Content uploaded by Teresa Lebel
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Teresa Lebel on Oct 07, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
Sequestrate species of
Agaricus
and
Macrolepiota
from Australia:
new species and combinations and their position in a calibrated phylogeny
Teresa Lebel
1
Anna Syme
2
National Herbarium of Victoria, Royal Botanic Gardens
Melbourne, Private Bag 2000, Victoria, 3141 Australia
Abstract
: Australian collections of sequestrate Agar-
icaceae were examined with morphological and
molecular data (nuclear DNA from ITS and LSU),
and the majority were found to belong to the genera
Agaricus
and
Macrolepiota
. Previously described Aus-
tralian species of
Endoptychum
are transferred to the
appropriate agaricoid genera and several new combi-
nations proposed. Descriptions and illustrations are
provided for these and eight new species:
Agaricus
eburneocanus
sp. nov.,
A. chartaceus
sp. nov.,
A.
erythrosarx
sp. nov.,
A. inilleasper
sp. nov.,
A.
pachydermus
sp. nov.,
Macrolepiota gasteroidea
sp.
nov.,
M. vinaceofibrillosa
sp. nov. and
M. turbinata
sp. nov. The sequestrate genus
Barcheria
is retained as
a distinct taxon. Timing of evolution of sequestrate
sporocarp forms in
Macrolepiota
,
Chlorophyllum
and
Agaricus
seems to have occurred in the past
15 000 000 y, and a stem age is approximately
65 000 000 y for
Barcheria
.
Key words:
Agaricaceae,
Endoptychum
, nomencla-
ture, taxonomy, timing of evolution
INTRODUCTION
The Agaricaceae as currently understood includes
taxa with considerable diversity in sporocarp form,
from agaricoid to sequestrate (hypogeal or emergent,
hymenophore remaining enclosed, and lacking active
spore dispersal, and now pulverant gastroid (Singer
1986, Candusso and Lanzoni 1990, Redhead et al.
2001, Kruger et al. 2001, Kirk et al. 2008). Studies
have shown that sequestrate sporocarp forms have
evolved relatively recently, with up to 10 independant
gastromycetization or sequestration events scattered
throughout the family (Kru¨ger et al. 2001, Moncalvo
et al. 2002, Vellinga 2004, Lebel et al. 2004, Matheny
et al. 2007, Gube 2009). Historically sequestrate taxa
were placed in morphologically distinct genera, such
as
Endoptychum
(Czernajew 1845),
Gyrophragmium
(Montagne 1843),
Montagnea
(Fries 1836) or
Barcheria
(Lebel et al. 2004) and until fairly recently were treated
in unique families (e.g. Julich 1982:
Podaxaceae
,
Montagnaceae
,
Secotiaceae
).
The genera
Agaricus
,
Chlorophyllum
and
Macro-
lepiota
are easily recognized based on sporocarp
morphology and a few microscopic characters, how-
ever species differentiation can be problematic
(Vellinga 2003, Geml et al. 2004, Kerrigan et al.
2006, Ge et al. 2010). All three genera are important
saprotrophs in many habitats from the tropics to the
arctic, and several edible and toxic species can be
found in each genus (Ding and Huang 2003, Kirk
et al. 2008).
Agaricus
is the most species rich with more
than 300 known worldwide, then
Macrolepiota
with 30
species and
Chlorophyllum
with 16 species (Bas 1991,
Kirk et al. 2008). The Australian taxa in these lineages
are generally understudied and poorly known. Of the
37 currently known species of
Agaricus
, more than half
are introduced taxa (Grgurinovic 1997, May et al.
2006). Neither
Macrolepiota
nor
Chlorophyllum
are
particularly diverse in Australia, with three and four
species respectively (Vellinga 2003).
Of the sequestrate taxa with affinities to
Agaricus
,
the North American species
Longula texensis
(Berk.
& M.A. Curtis) Zeller (5
A. deserticola
G. Moreno,
Esqueda & Liza´rraga),
Gyrophragmium dunalii
Zeller
(5
A. aridicola
Geml, Geiser & Royse) and
Endopty-
chum depressum
Singer & A.H. Sm.(5
A. inapertus
Vellinga) are members of
Agaricus
section
Arvenses
(Moncalvo et al. 2000; Geml 2004, 2004; Gube 2009).
The relationships of Australian taxa
Secotium coarcta-
tum
Berk.,
Endoptychum wariatodes
Grgur.,
E. moon-
gum
Grgur. and
E. melanosporum
(Berk.) Singer &
A.H. Sm. also are likely to be with
Agaricus
, based on
morphology. The rare taxon
Smithiogaster volvoagar-
icus
J.E. Wright appears to be an aborted
Agaricus
(Wright 1975). Finally
Endoptychum agaricoides
Czern. was found to belong to
Chlorophyllum
(5
C.
agaricoides
[Czern.] Vellinga), but the position of
E.
arizonicum
is unresolved, being sister to
Agaricus
and
Chlorophyllum
(Vellinga 2002, Gube 2009). No se-
questrate taxa related to
Macrolepiot a
have been
described thus far.
Based on extensive morphological examination
and molecular phylogenetic analyses, we present
species diversity and descriptions of novel sequestrate
Agaricus
and
Macrolepiota
from Australia and their
affinities to other species in these lineages. In
addition we conducted a trial calibrated phylogenetic
Submitted 23 Mar 2011; accepted for publication 13 Aug 2011.
1
Corresponding author. E-mail: teresa.lebel@rbg.vic.gov.au
2
E-mail: anna.syme@rbg.vic.gov.au
Mycologia,
104(2), 2012, pp. 496–520. DOI: 10.3852/11-092
#
2012 by The Mycological Society of America, Lawrence, KS 66044-8897
496
analysis, using existing hypotheses of estimated taxon
divergences to provide preliminary evidence of the
timing of evolution of sequestrate sporocarp forms in
the three lineages of
Agaricus
,
Chlorophyllum
and
Macrolepiota
(Geml et al. 2004).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Taxon sampling.—
The regions of nuclear rDNA data used
for analyses included the internal transcribed spacers ITS1–
5.8S–ITS2 (ITS) and the 59 end of the large subunit (LSU).
Sequences representing 127 species within Agaricaceae
were derived from fresh or herbarium material or were
retrieved from GenBank. Novel sequences representing
Australian species of
Agaricus
(40),
Barcheria
(seven) and
Macrolepiota
(11), and three of
Chlorophyllum agaricoides
were generated for this study (SUPPLEMENTARY TABLE I).
Unfortunatelywewereunabletoobtainmaterialor
sequences of
E. arizonicum
for our analyses. Type material
of
Endoptychum melanosporum
,
Secotium coarctatum
and
E.
wariatodes
is fragmentary and has been stored in an
unknown chemical; no useable DNA was obtained.
Nucleic acid preparation, amplification and sequencing.—
Genomic DNA was isolated with the QIAGEN DNeasy Plant
Mini Kit, following the manufacturer’s protocol. The
targeted regions were amplified from purified DNA with
standard fungal primer pairs ITS1/ITS4 (White et al. 1990,
Gardes and Bruns 1993) or LROR/LR5 (http://www.
biology.duke.edu/fungi/mycolab/primers.htm).
PCR protocols followed standard methods (Lebel et al.
2004, Lebel and Tonkin 2007, Danks and Lebel 2010).
Purified DNA (Concert Rapid PCR Purification System, Life
Technologies) was directly sequenced with the ABI Prism
BigDye Terminator Cycle Sequencing Kit with primers ITS1
and ITS4 and LROR and LR5. Sequencing was carried out
with an ABI model Automated 377 DNA Sequencer.
Assembly and manual editing of sequences for each region
were performed with Sequencher 4.3 (Gene Codes Corp.).
Sequences were aligned with default settings in MUSCLE
(Edgar 2004) with some manual editing. Previously unpub-
lished sequences are deposited in GenBank (S
UPPLEMENTA-
RY TABLE
I).
Alignments and phylogenetic analyses.—
A preliminary align-
ment consisting of 72 LSU sequences and 965 characters
was generated to investigate broad patterns of relationships
between genera. Subsequently two alignments were gener-
ated to investigate positions and relationships within (a)
Agaricus
, consisting of 102 ITS sequences and 854
characters and (b)
Macrolepiota
and
Chlorophyllum
, consist-
ing of 87 ITS sequences and 896 characters. Gaps in
alignments were treated as missing data.
Tulostoma
squamosum
was included as outgroup in all alignments
based on work showing it as a potential sister taxa to these
lineages (Vellinga et al. 2003, Vellinga 2004, Matheny et al.
2007, Gube 2009). A combined ITS-LSU analysis was not
undertaken because LSU data was not available for the
majority of taxa. All alignments and trees are available
in TreeBase (http://purl.org/phylo/treebase/phylows/
study/TB2:S11712; temporary reviewer access http://purl.org/
phylo/treebase/phylows/study/TB2:S11712?x-access-code5
6280681c731f036e5967bd14672529b8&format5html).
Phylogenetic analyses were performed with Bayesian
likelihood with the Metropolis coupled Markov chain
Monte Carlo (MCMC) search algorithm implemented in
MrBayes 3.1.2 (Ronquist and Huelsenbeck 2003). PAUP*
4.0b10 (Swofford 2002) and Modeltest (Posada and
Crandall 1998) were used to determine appropriate
evolutionary models for the Bayesian analyses. Under the
Akaike information criterion (AIC) the best-fit models for
each alignment had six substitution types (nst 5 6), gamma-
shaped rate variation and a proportion of invariable sites
(rates 5 invgamma). Each search involved four chains
(three heated to 0.2 and one cold) sampled every 1000
generations. The search ran until convergence between
runs was achieved, measured by a standard deviation of split
frequencies below 0.05 and observing when this was no
longer decreasing. For ITS
Agaricus
this was 0.02 after
5 000 000 generations; for ITS
Chlorophyllum
/
Macrolepiota
,
0.01 after 5 000 000 generations. To confirm that the
topologies had converged we visualized split posteriors with
AWTY (Wilgenbusch et al. 2004). After discarding burn-in,
consensus trees were imported to FigTree (Rambaut 2009)
and are presented with posterior probabilities at clades.
Calibration of phylogeny.—
We used a combined subset of
the ITS alignments, with a focus on lineages with both
sequestrate and agaricoid sporocarp forms within the three
lineages of interest to decrease computational time (taxa
included are annotated by asterisk in S
UPPLEMENTARY TABLE
I). To construct the calibrated phylogeny we used the
program BEAST (Drummond and Rambaut 2007). An XML
input file was created with the ancillary program BEAUTi.
The substitution model was general time reversible (GTR)
with + I + G as found by Modeltest as described earlier. We
used the uncorrelated lognormal (UCLN) relaxed clock
model for nucleotide evolution, which permits among-
lineage rate heterogeneity to be uncorrelated and performs
well whether the data are clock-like or not (Drummond
et al. 2006). A random starting tree was used and a Yule
model for the tree prior, a model that is useful for species-
level analyses (Drummond and Rambaut 2007).
For the most recent common ancestor (MRCA) of
Agaricus
and
Chlorophyllum
we placed a prior distribution
on the divergence time of
A. xanthodermus
and
C. molybdites
of 73 000 000 y ago (Geml et al. 2004), based on a multigene
study of Heckman et al. (2001). Several distributions can be
chosen to model the prior, but a normal distribution is
useful for modelling the uncertainty around secondary
calibration points such as this one (Ho 2007). We therefore
used a normal prior on this divergence time and set the
value of the mean at 73 and a standard deviation of 1.0
(making 95% of the probability 71 000 000–75 000 000 y).
Two independent runs of 20 000 000 generations were set,
sampling every 2000 steps. The program Tracer was used to
check that the effective sample size (ESS) was greater than
or close to 200 for the posterior, prior and likelihood,
indicating that samples are independent (Drummond and
Rambaut 2007). A burn-in of 10% was found to be adequate
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
497
as stationarity had been achieved, and the distributions
across the separate runs were congruent. The two runs were
combined with LogCombiner, each with a 10% burn-in
(1000 trees) and the parameters and topology summarized
in TreeAnnotator (Drummond and Rambaut 2007). The
maximum credibility tree (MCC) with node heights set to
mean heights was imported to FigTree (Rambaut 2009) and
plotted against a time scale.
We also constructed a binary character matrix for
morphology of sequestrate forms as absent (0) or present
(1) (S
UPPLEMENTARY TABLE II). With Mesquite (Maddison
and Maddison 2010) this character was mapped onto the
calibrated phylogeny with the Markov k-state 1-parameter
model (MK1), which assumes equal probabilites for change
between states.
Morphology.—
Macroscopic characters were described di-
rectly from fresh material and based on examination of,
and field notes on, dried collections. Colors are described
in general terms. Habitat, associated plant communities
and fruiting season are based on collection notes. Hand-
cut sections of fresh and dried material were mounted
either in 5% aqueous solution of KOH then stained with
ammoniacal Congo red or cotton blue or directly stained
with Melzer’s reagent. Measurements were made at 4003
or 10003 with a calibrated ocular micrometer. Spore
dimensions are given as length range 3 width range (n 5
20). The length : width ratio (Q) of individual spores is
presented as the range of Q values. Measurements do not
include the apiculus. Dimensions of basidia and cystidia
are given as length range 3 width range (n 5 15). All
drawings and illustrations are based on type material unless
otherwise stated. Informal taxon names are standardized
according to Barker (2005) and names of herbaria are
abbreviated according to Thiers (http://sweetgum.nybg.
org/ih/ continuously updated).
RESULTS
Phylogenetic analyses.—Agaricus ITS dataset. Microp-
salliota
(including
Allopsalliota geesteranii
)and
Chloro-
phyllum
both form well supported clades (FIG.1).If
PPs of , 0.95 are collapsed,
Heinemannomyces
,
Clarkeinda
,
Eriocybe
and
Coniolepiota
are in an unre-
solved polytomy, sister to a well supported clade of
Barcheria
and a monophyletic
Agaricus
.
Agaricus
wariatodes
and
A. chartaceus
are sister taxa in a well
supported sect.
Minores
,and
A. eburneocanus
and
A.
inapertus
are in a weakly supported sect.
Arvenses
but
with affinities to different species.
Agaricus inilleasper
is
in a weakly supported clade with
A. campestris
(sect.
Agaricus
)and
A. langei
and
A. silvaticus
(sect.
Sanguinolenti
).
Agaricus erythrosarx
is in a strongly
supported clade of taxa belonging to sect.
Sanguino-
lenti
.Finally
A. melanosporus
is sister to all remaining
species of
Agaricus
but without strong support or
affinities to any previously described section of
Agaricus
.
Macrolepiota/Chlorophyllum ITS dataset.
Species of
Macrolepiota
are grouped in a clade with a high PP (0.97).
Both
Micropsalliota
(PP 1.0) and
Leucoagaricus
(PP 1.0)
form a clade sister to a paraphyletic
Chlorophyllum
and a
strongly supported (PP 1.0) polytomy that groups
Barcheria
and
Agaricus
with
Heinemannomyces
,
Clar-
keinda
,
Coniolepiota
and
Eriocybe
(FIG.2).
Multiple accessions of
Chlorophyllum agaricoides
clustered together but some genetic heterogeneity is
apparent (F
IG. 2). Three subclades were recovered
within
Macrolepiota
matching currently recognized
sections
Volvatae
,
Macrosporae
and
Macrolepiota
(Vel-
linga 2003, Ge et al. 2010). Two of the new Australian
sequestrate species,
M. turbinata
and
M. vinaceofibril-
losa
, grouped within sect.
Macrolepiota
but do not form a
monophyletic group. The position of the third species,
M. gasteroidea
, is currently unresolved but morpholog-
ically appears to be related to this same group of taxa.
Calibrated phylogeny: the evolutionary origin of the
sequestrate sporocarp form.—
Based on a divergence
time between
Agaricus
and
Chlorophyllum
of
73 000 000 y (F
IG.3, SUPPLEMENTARY FIG.2),the
following divergence times are estimated (million
years ago 5 Ma):
Macrolepiota
+
Chlorophyllum
/
Agaricus
: 83 Ma [95% CI 72–98];
Barcheria
:65Ma
[95% CI 57–72];
Agaricus
: 34 Ma [95% CI 26–43].
Substitution rates were 0.0012–0.0101 substitutions
per site per million years. Character mapping based
on maximum likelihood (one rate) reconstructed
most nodes as the agaricoid form; the only exceptions
being the ancestors to clades of solely sequestrate
forms 2
Agaricus chartaceus
+
A. wariatodes
;
Barch-
eria
; and
Macrolepiota turbinata
(matrix in SUPPLE-
MENTARY TABLE
II). Width of branches are displayed
as thick or thin, according to the most likely recon-
structed state. A pattern seen in this character mapp-
ing is that sequestrate forms in these three lineages
tend to have evolved recently and since the mid-
Miocene (, 15–0 Ma). Stem lineages of
Agaricus
melanosporus
and
Barcheria
date back approximately
, 34 Ma and , 65 Ma respectively.
TAXONOMY
Barcheria willisiana
T. Lebel, in Lebel, Thompson &
Udovicic, Mycol. Res. 108(2):211 (2004)
F
IG.4A,B
Additional specimens examined
: WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
Kellerberrin, Site 17B, Higginson Road, 16 km along
Bencubbin-Kellerberrin Road, 29 Jun 1998,
I.C. Tommerup
H7518
[PERTH 07626886]; north of Kellerberrin, Site 17
(near Tree 22), Higginson Road, 16 km along Bencubbin-
Kellerberrin Road, 5 Sep 1995,
I.C. Tommerup H7306
[PERTH 07584407]; Corrigin Shire, Grylls Road, Valem
Farm, Paddock 12 (Todd’s Lounge), 13 Aug 1999,
J.
Catchpole & S. Bolsen broek H7564
[PERTH].
498 MYCOLOGIA
Notes
:
Barcheria willisiana
is known only from a few
sites within drier woodlands of Western Australia,
associated with
Eucalyptus wandoo
,
E. salmonophloia
and
E. kondineninsis
. Additional specimens cited here
are of material collected more than 500 km west of the
type locality.
Barcheria
is supported as a sister taxon to
a monophyletic
Agaricus
in analyses of the ITS (FIG.1)
and in a strongly supported clade with species of
Agaricus
but with no resolution of generic boundaries
in analyses of LSU (S
UPPLEMENTARY FIG. 1).
Barcheria
is
retained here as a distinct genus, due to the distinctive
appearance of the sporocarp, characters of the spores
and strong support in the ITS phylogeny.
Agaricus chartaceus
T. Lebel sp. nov. FIGS. 4C, 5
Mycobank MB519924
Etymology: (L). papery 5 chartaceus, in reference to the
papery texture of dry sporocarps.
FIG. 1. Bayesian phylogram of
Agaricus
based on ITS data. Thick branches indicate support by posterior probabilities of
. 0.95. All sequestrate taxa are in boldface.
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
499
Sporocarpum 12–38 mm altum, 12–27 mm diametro,
subglobosum vel elongatum apice convexo, albidum vel
cremeum, sericeum laevigatum, nitidum; contextus
non mutabilis. Hymenophorum pallido-flavidum dein
fumeum, ad initium minute labyrinthium-loculatum,
cellulis dein pulverescentibus. Stipes uterque basalis 8–
10 3 2–5 mm vel robustus percurrens 18–42 3 2–6 mm,
cremeus vel pallido-cinereus. Odor curcuma simulans.
Sporae 7.0–8.0 3 5.0–6.0(–7.0)
mm, subglobosae vel
obovatae, valde dextrinoideae.
Holotypus
: Western Australia. 86.2 km E of Broome
along the Great Northern Highway, 10 Feb 1993,
N.L.
Bougher H6271
[PERTH07582757].
Sporocarps hypogeous to emergent, gregarious to
solitary. Pileus 12–38 mm high 3 12–27 mm diam,
irregularly subglobose to elongate, apex convex,
white to pale cream, silky smooth, shiny, thin, papery
when dry, sometimes finely cracked; margin fused to
stipe by veil remnants, concolorous with pileus.
Context fleshy, thick, white to cream, not changing
color. Hymenophore pale yellowish becoming grayish
tan but not darkening further, initially minutely
labyrinthine-loculate; becoming powdery. Stipe either
an inserted basal pad, 8–10 3 2–5 mm, or robust,
percurrent, 18–42 3 2–6 mm diam, projecting well
beyond margin with slightly bulbous base, cream to
pale grayish cream, fibrous; context cream, no color
change. Odor of curry; flavor mild. Spores 7.0–8.0 3
5.0–6.0(–7.0)
mm, mean 7.2 3 5.9 mm, Q 5 1.0–1.3,
subglobose to obvate, mostly symmetric, pale yellow-
brown in KOH, dextrinoid. Basidia 7–16 3 8–12
mm,
clavate to broadly clavate; sterigmata two. Pileipellis a
cutis, 5–35
mm wide, of compact subparallel hyaline
hyphae 2–5
mm diam, overlying a broad context, 70–
250
mm wide, of slightly inflated hyphae 5–8 mm diam.
Clamps absent in all tissues.
Additional specimens examined
: WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
Gibson Desert, Patience Well, 6 Jun 2001,
C.P. Campbell
[PERTH05848261]; Coolgardie, Newman Rocks 50 km W of
Balladonia, 1 km N of Eyre Highway, 27 May 2003,
K. Symes
FIG. 2. Bayesian phylogram of
Chlorophyllum
and
Macrolepiota
based on ITS data. Thick branches indicate support by
posterior probabilities of . 0.95. All sequestrate taxa are in boldface.
500 MYCOLOGIA
1234/03
[MEL2231690]. SOUTH AUSTRALIA. Flinders
Ranges, Oraparinna Station, North of Wilpena Pound near
Blinman, 3 Sep 2000,
Catcheside 758
[AD]. NORTHERN
TERRITORY. 61 km N of Alice Springs, 28 Jun 1968,
H.A.
Morrison 6
[MEL202451]; 15 miles W of Ayers Rock, 30 Jun
1967,
A.C. Beauglehole 22929
[MEL260729]; George Gill
Range, west of Farrers Spring, 26 miles NW of Wallara
Ranch, 3 Jul 1967,
A.C. Beaglehole
[MEL260703].
Distribution and habitat
: Found in the drier regions
of central Western Australia, South Australia and
northern Australia. Associated with
Allocasuarina
and
Callitris
woodland.
Notes
:
Agaricus chartaceus
resembles
A. wariatodes
both macro- and microscopically, however the pileus
is papery not silky when dry, the fragrence is of curry
FIG. 3. Calibrated phylogeny of Agaricaceae species based on ITS data. The maximum clade credibility tree with posterior
probabilities is shown. Character trace of sequestrate form using a one-rate model under maximum likelihood. The best
supported state on each branch is represented by width; sequestrate lineages are shown by wide/bold branches and agaricoid
lineages by narrow branches.
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
501
rather than marzipan, and the basidia are two- rather
than four-spored. Affinities lie with a strongly
supported sect.
Minores
(FIG. 1).
Agaricus eburneocanus
T. Lebel sp. nov. FIG. 4D, 6
MycoBank MB519925
Etymology
: (L) cream or ivory 5
eburneus
, gray 5
canus
(light) in reference to the sporocarp pellis and stipe.
Sporocarpum 15–20 mm altum, 25–28 mm diam,
late convexum apice plano, ad centrum eburneum vel
in margine late pallido-cinereum, margo tenuis
appendiculatus; contextus non mutabilis. Hymeno-
phorum brunneum trama argento-cinerea, ad initium
minute loculata vel labyrinthina, cellulis pulverescen-
tibus. Stipes 25–30 mm altus, 5–10 mm diam,
percurrens, tomentosus, cinereo-cremeus basi luteo;
contextus cremeus dein armeniacus. Sporae 8.0–
13.5(–16) 3 6.0–8.0
mm, variabiles amygdalinae vel
angulato-ovoideaea, plerumque elongatae ellipsoi-
deae vel ovoideae, infirme dextrinoideae.
Holotypus
: Western Australia. Site 17b, Higginson
Road (north), 16 km along Bencubbin-Kellerberin
Road, 29 Jun 1998,
I.C. Tommerup and S. Bolsenbroek
H7528
[PERTH07626789].
Sporocarp solitary to gregarious, hypogeous to
emergent. Pileus 15–20 mm high 3 25–28 mm diam,
broadly convex with convex to plane apex, white to
cream centrally to pale gray in broad marginal zone,
overlain by fine brown fibrils; margin initially
attached to stipe by cream partial veil, becoming free
in small sections as pileus expands. Context not
changing color. Hymenophore dark rich brown with
white to silvery gray trama, loculate to labyrinthiform
with minute chambers; becoming pulverant. Stipe-
columella 25–30 mm long 3 5–10 mm diam,
percurrent, cylindrical, appressed matted fibrillose,
white to cream with grayish tinge, with yellowish stains
basally; context white to cream becoming gradually
pale apricot. Odor not distinctive. Spores 8.0–13.5
(–16) 3 6.0–8.0
mm, mean 5 10.2 3 6.8 mmQ5 1.3–
1.7, variable shape, amygdaliform or angular-ovoid,
predominantly long ellipsoid or ovoid, brown in
KOH, weakly dextrinoid. Basidia 35.5–45.0 3 16.0–
20.5
mm, broadly clavate; sterigmata short, four rarely
FIG. 4. Sporocarps of taxa. A.
Barcheria willisiana
(MEL2151446; photo B. Archer). B.
Barcheria willisiana
(H7518; photo
N. Bougher). C.
Agaricus chartaceus
(holotype H6271; photo T. Lebel). D.
Agaricus eburneocanus
(photo N. Bougher; holotype
H7528). E.
Agaricus erythrosarx
(photo W. Dunstan MURU6080).
502 MYCOLOGIA
FIG.5.
Agaricus chartaceus
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and subhymenium, D. spores.
Bar 5 10
mm.
FIG.6.
Agaricus eburneocanus
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. basidia and subhymenium, C. spores. Bar 5 10 mm.
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
503
two. Pileipellis a cutis of hyaline interwoven hyphae 3–
7
mm diam, overlying a broad context 100–230 mm
wide, of hyaline regular to somewhat interwoven
hyphae 3–8
mm diam and abundant inflated elements
15–47 3 5–26
mm. Clamps absent from all tissues.
Additional specimens examined
: WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
Seven km NE of Dowerin, approximately 200 m SW of refuse
dump at AMERY, 11 Jul 2002,
W.A. Dunstan
[MURU5927].
Distribution and habitat
:Foundin
Eucalyptus
wandoo
and
E. salmonophloia
woodland, in leaf litter
at the base of trees.
Notes
:
Agaricus eburneocanus
is characterized by the
agaricoid sporocarps, dark brown hymenophore with
silvery gray trama, and grayish cap. Affinities lie within
a weakly supported sect
Arvenses
, in a subclade with
an undescribed Australian epigeous species,
Agaricus
sp. ‘‘B’’ (FIG. 1).
Agaricus erythrosarx
T.Lebel sp. nov. FIGS. 4E, 7
Mycobank MB519926
Etymology
: (Gk)
erythrosarx
5 red flesh, for the reddening
reaction of the flesh when cut or exposed.
Sporocarpum (20–)30–60 mm altum, (40–)65–
120 mm diam, convexum vel plano-convexum, apice
depresso initio ad maturationem ellipsoideum irre-
gulariter apice plano vel depresso, albidum vel
cremeum, nitidum sericeum radiale fibrillosum,
superato squamato vinaceo sparso, velum partiale,
albidum sericeum; contextus albidus mutabilis
erubescens. Hymenophorum sublamellatum, cellulis
grandis cassis labyrinthinis compostium, pallido-hin-
nuleum dein brunneum, in siccitate leviter pulver-
atum trama cremeum dein aurantiaco-ruber. Stipes
(24–)30–60(–80) mm altus, 15–25 mm diam, percur-
rens cremeus; contextus cremeus tarde rubescens.
Sporae 7.0–9.0 3 5.0–7.0
mm, subglobosae vel late
ellipsoideae, non dextrinoideae.
Holotypus
: Western Australia. Elyra Brook, Bolgart
(off Blood Road), 25 Jul 2004, W.A. Dunstan
[MURU6080].
Sporocarp solitary or gregarious, hypogeous to
emergent. Pileus (20–)30–60 mm high 3 (40–)65–
120 mm diam, convex to planoconvex, apically
depressed when young, usually irregularly ellipsoid
with flat apex or slightly depressed at center when
mature, white to cream, shiny silky radially fibrillose,
overlain with scattered vinaceous fibrils that may
aggregateintofinescales,moreabundantnear
center; margin remaining attached to stipe by veil of
dense white silky fibrils. Context fleshy, compact, 2–
6 mm thick, white, reddening when cut. Hymenophore
pale faun maturing to dark brown, trama cream but
slowly and irregularly reddening (to orange-red) when
exposed, sublamellate to labyrinthine, of large, disor-
ganized empty chambers; moist initially becoming
slightly pulverant. Stipe (25–)30–60(–80) mm long 3
15–25 mm diam, percurrent, cylindrical or tapering
slightly toward base, solid initially often becoming
FIG.7.
Agaricus erythrosarx
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and hymenophoral trama,
D. spores. Bar 5 10
mm.
504 MYCOLOGIA
slightly hollow at maturity, cream with reddish tints,
with scattered vinaceous fibrils in lower section;
context cream then slowly reddening, smooth, dry.
Odor and flavor mildly spicy. Spores 7.0–9.0 3 5.0–
7.0
mm, mean 8.1 3 6.3 mm, Q 5 1.1–1.4, subglobose to
broadly ellipsoid, slightly asymmetric, brown in KOH,
not dextrinoid. Basidia 20.0–28.5 3 9.5–14.0
mm,
clavate; four-spored. Pileipellis a cutis, 45–110
mm wide,
of hyaline, interwoven to periclinal hyphae, 5–10
mm
diam. Clamps absent in all tissues.
Additional specimens examined
: WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
Paddock 53 (remnant opposite farmhouse), Grylls Road,
Valerma Farm, west of Corrigin, 19 Jul 2000,
N. Bougher
,
I.
Tommerup
,
R. Campbell H7638
[PERTH].
Distribution and habitat
: Found at the base of trees
in
Eucalyptus eremophila
and
E. loxophleba
subsp
loxophleba
woodland.
Notes
:
Agaricus erythro sarx
resembles
A. melanos-
porus
both macro- and microscopically. Both species
have large pale sporocarps with scattered vinaceous
fibrils on the surface, a sublamellate hymenophore
that becomes pulverant, reddening pileal flesh and
small spores. Differences include the red-orange
staining reaction of the hymenophoral trama and
reddening of the stipe context in
A. erythrosarx
and
lack of color changes in
A. melanosporus
(some dingy
brown stains at base of stipe), and narrower basidia
(5–9
mm vs. 9.5–14 mm) and slightly larger spores in
A. melanosporus
.
Agaricus erythrosarx
has strong
affinities to section
Sanguinolenti
, including an
undescribed agaricoid Australian taxon,
Agaricus
sp. ‘‘C’’ (FIG.1).
Agaricus inilleasper
T. Lebel sp.nov. FIGS. 8, 10A
Mycobank MB519927
Etymology
: (L)
in
5 in,
ille
5 the (usually not used),
asper
5 rough, is in reference to the location of the type
collection on a golf course.
Sporocarpum 25 mm altum, 30 mm diam, con-
vexum, albidum vel pallido-cremeum maculatum
ferrugineum et lutescens, laevigatum vel areolatum;
contextus non mutabilis. Hymenophorum fumeum,
sublamellatum vel labyrintho-loculatum irregulariter,
pulverescens. Stipes 20 mm altus, 5 mm diam,
percurrens, albidus; contextus pallido-cremeus.
Sporae 6.0–8.0 3 5.0–6.0 (–7.0)
mm, ellipsoideae vel
subglobosae, infirme dextrinoideae.
Holotypus
: Queensland. Townsville, Willows golf
course, fairway 9th hole, 9 Apr 1989,
M. Castellano
H4452
(holotype PERTH; isotype DAR).
Sporocarp solitary, emergent. Pileus 25 mm high 3
30 mm diam, convex, white to pale cream with some
tan patches, staining yellowish where handled,
FIG.8.
Agaricus inilleasper
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and subhymenium, D. spores.
Bar 5 10
mm.
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
505
smooth or obscurely wrinkled or areolate; margin
remaining fused to stipe. Context 1–3 mm thick, firm,
white in section with no color change. Hymenophore
brownish gray, sublamellate to irregularly labyrin-
thine-loculate; becoming powdery. Stipe 20 mm long
3 5 mm diam, percurrent, with some small chambers,
white; context pale cream, no staining reactions.
Odor and flavor not recorded. Spores 6.0–8.0 3 5.0–
6.0(–7.0)
mm, mean 7.3 3 5.6 mm, Q 5 1.2–1.4,
ellipsoid to subglobose, sometimes obvate, symmetri-
cal, hyaline initially then pale brown in KOH, weakly
dextrinoid. Basidia 22–29 3 6–8
mm, cylindrical to
narrowly clavate; sterigmata four, rarely two. Pileipel-
lis a narrow cutis of compact subparallel hyaline
hyphae 2–7
mm diam, overlying a context of hyaline
hyphae 3–8
mm diam and irregular inflated elements
3–42 3 7–28
mm. Clamps absent in all tissues.
Distribution and habitat
: Known only from the
holotype collection, from northern Queensland.
Found among grass.
Note
:
Agaricus inilleasper
may be distinguished from
other species by the pale sporocarp staining yellowish,
brownish gray sublamellate to irregularly labyrinthine
hymenophore, small spores. Although it is preferable
to not describe taxa from single collections (known
only from the type), this species is distinctive. At first
glance it resembles
Agaricus bisporus
in sect.
Duploan-
nulati
, however analysis of ITS places it in a weakly
supported clade with some species from sect.
Sanguinolenti
and sect.
Agaricus
.
FIG.9.
Agaricus melanosporus
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. spores. Bar 5 10 mm.
506 MYCOLOGIA
Agaricus melanosporus
(Berk.) T. Lebel comb. nov.
F
IGS. 9, 10B, C
Mycobank MB297191
T: Western Australia. Swan River,
Drummond 180
(K;
BPI704933)
;
Endoptychum melanosporum
(Berk.) Singer & A.H. Sm.,
Brittonia
10:220 (1958)
;
Secotium melanosporum
Berk.,
London J. Bot
. 4:62
(1845)
5
Endoptychum kolya
Grgur.,
Larger Fungi of South
Australia
437 (1997). T: South Australia: 7 Jul 1923,
Kinchina,
JBCleland
[AD9767]
Additional illustration s
: Griffiths (1985) A field guide to
the larger fungi of the Darling Scarp and south west of
Western Australia. p 59 (figures lower right).
Sporocarps solitary to gregarious, hypogeous to
emergent. Pileus (18–)25–45 mm high 3 (20–) 35–
72 mm diam, subglobose to turbinate, planoconvex
FIG. 10. Sporocarps of taxa. A.
Agaricus inilleasper
(Holotype H4452). B.
Agaricus melanosporus
(Type K,
Secotium
melanosporum
, Swan River 180). C.
Agaricus melanosporus
(Corda
Icones fungorum
, Pl VI fig. 19–24). D.
Agaricus wariatodes
(Type K,
Secotium coarctatum
, Swan River 181). E.
Agaricus wariatodes
(Corda
Icones fungorum
, Pl VI fig. 25–30). F.
Agaricus
wariatodes
(TWM 1589; photo TW May).
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
507
with somewhat squarish edges, sometimes with
depressed center, pale tan to cinnamon drab or
warm brown, smooth to very finely fibrillose with
slightly darker fibrils scattered over surface; margin
incurved to stipe with fibrillose veil remnants
appendiculate, pale concolorous with pileus, en-
closing hymenophore. Context fleshy, white turning
pale brownish with pale reddish tint on exposure.
Hymenophore initially pallid olive brown then dark
brown to purple brown, sublamellate to labyrin-
thine loculate; becoming slightly powdery. Stipe
(35–)50–120 mm long 3 6–16(–21) diam, percur-
rent, robust, equal, pale tan with dingy brown tints,
particularly toward base, silky. Odor and flavor not
recorded. Spores 8.0–10.0(–11) 3 6–7.5(–8)
mm,
mean 8.9 3 6.8
mm, Q 5 1.2–1.4, subglobose to
broadly ellipsoid or obovate, many asymmetric, pale
yellowish brown to brown in KOH, weakly dextri-
noid. Basidia 17–28 3 5–9
mm, cylindrical to clavate;
sterigmata four. Pileipellis a cutis of subparallel,
interwoven, hyaline hyphae 2–7
mmdiamand
scattered inflated elements 10–18 3 7–12
mm,
overlying a broad context, 170–350
mmwide,of
loosely interwoven hyaline hyphae, 3–6
mmdiam.
Clamps at base of basidia, but not observed in pileal
or hymenophoral trama.
Specimens examined
: SOUTH AUSTRALIA.
J.B. Cleland
[AD9763]; Monarto South, Sep 1920,
J.B. Cleland
[AD2971
5 AD48433; MELU6252F]; region 9, Murray, Halidon,
J.B.
Cleland
[AD22633];
J.B. Cleland
[AD9765]; Monarto South,
27 May 1921,
J.B. Cleland
[AD20223; PDD8396; looks like
photo in Cunningham]; Karoonda, 30 Jun 1946,
J.B.Cleland
[AD22628]; Kinchina, Adelaide, 8 Jun 1925,
J.B. Cleland
[AD22621; PDD8388];
J.B. Cleland
[BPI718210; CG. Lloyd
#734]. VICTORIA. Mallee Research Station, Walpeup,
Jun 1955,
E.M. Packe & A. Mann
[MELU6253F]; 4 km
from Inglewood, Green Hills, 25 May 1988,
F. Watts
[MEL2032783]. WESTERN AUSTRALIA. Toodyay, 20 Aug
1983,
K. Griffiths
[PERTH00962007].
Material held in US National Fungus Collections
(BPI): AUSTRALIA. BPI704932 (packet labeled ex-
Massee; fragments only), BPI704934 (packet labeled
ex-Paris; fragments only).
Distribution and habitat
: Found in open disturbed
ground and compacted rocky soil.
Note
:
Agaricus melanosporus
is characterized by the
large sporocarps with dark brown hymenophore at
maturity and broadly ellipsoid to obovate spores. The
only difference between earlier descriptions in
Berkeley (1845) and Cunningham (1935) was the
shape of the spores—obovate to elliptical in the
former rather than subglobose to ovate in the latter.
No observable morphological differences were found
on comparison of type material of
S. melanosporum
(Drummond 180) and
E. kolya
(AD9767) or other
more recent collections. Although no sequence was
obtained from type material of
S. melanosporum
(K),
the collections examined here fit nicely with Berke-
ley’s original concept and the illustration of type
material in Corda (1854) (F
IG. 10C).
Agaricus melanosporus
lacks a spore hilar cap and
has a cuticular pileipellis, characters of
Agaricus
rather than other lineages within the Agaricaceae.
Analysis of molecular data places this taxon at the
base of a strongly supported
Agaricus
, but relation-
ship to a particular section remains unresolved.
This species is a priority for recollection because the
most recent specimens are more than 25 y old (1983).
New material would be useful to add morphological
characters and also to obtain more sequence data.
Agaricus pachydermus
T. Lebel sp. nov. FIG.11
Mycobank MB519928
Etymology:
(L)
pachy
5 thick; -
derma
5 skin, in reference
to the thick pellis.
Sporocarpum 15–28 mm altum, 10–23(–28) mm
diam, subglosum apice planoconvexum, pallido-cre-
meum vel pallido-brunneum, laevigatum vel subtiliter
fibrillosum siccum; contextus non mutabilis. Hyme-
nophorum pallido-brunneum vel purpureo-brun-
neum, sublamellatum vel labyrinthinum, pulveres-
cens. Stipes 5–16 mm altus, 3–6 mm diam, percurrens
vel truncatus, cremeus; contextus cremeus non
mutabilis. Sporae (6–)7–8 3 (5–)6–7
mm, globosae
vel subglobosae, non dextrinoideae.
Holotypus
: South Australia. Flinders Ranges, within
Wilpena Pound (ca. 40 km NE of Hawker), 21 Sep
1971,
G.A. Crichton P11
[MEL2059965].
Sporocarps emergent, solitary to gregarious. Pileus
15–28 mm high 3 10–23(–28) mm diam, subglobose
to planoconvex, light cream to pale brown, smooth to
finely fibrillose, becoming brittle when dried. Context
fleshy when fresh, compact, white, no color change.
Hymenophore pale brown to dark purple-brown,
sublamellate to elongated labyrinthine; moist becom-
ing powdery. Stipe 5–16 mm long 3 3–6 mm diam,
percurrent or truncated, pale cream, fibrous, context
pale with no staining reactions, protruding shortly
below excavated hymenophore. Odor not recorded.
Spores (6–)7–8 3 (5–)6–7
mm, mean 7.4 3 6.7 mm,
Q 5 1.0–1.3, globose to subglobose, some slightly
asymmetric, pale yellowish brown to brown in KOH,
non-dextrinoid. Basidia 15–22 3 5–9
mm, elongate
clavate to cylindrical; sterigmata four. Pileipellis a
cutis, 24–42
mm wide, of subparallel, interwoven,
hyaline hyphae 2–5
mm diam and scattered inflated
elements 7–14 3 5–10
mm, overlying a context, 45–
80
mm wide, of loosely interwoven hyaline hyphae, 2–
5
mm diam. Clamps not observed.
Specimens examined
: NORTHERN TERRITORY. Raggatts
Creek, Glen Helen Station west of Mount Zeil, 22 Jul 1966,
508 MYCOLOGIA
J.H. Willis
[MEL269764]. NEW SOUTH WALES. Southern
Tablelands, paddock in Yass District, on the way to fossil
banks, 22 May 1968,
G.A. Crichton L39
[MEL2058665; K;
DAR 26446]; Haddens Corner, Yass, 20 May 1968,
G.A.
Crichton L65
[MEL 2058669]. WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
Carnarvon, 18 May 1971,
A.M. Young 134
[BRIP24660].
Distribution and habitat
: Found in arid regions, in
open grassy areas or claypans in flat mulga country in
NT, NSW, SA and WA.
Notes
:
Agaricus pachydermus
is similar to
A. war-
iatodes
and
A. chartaceus
, however the overall sporo-
carp shape differs, being more agaricoid. The pileus is
brittle and fragile when dried, often cracking to expose
the powdery spore mass, the hymenophore is dark
brown to purplish brown fresh versus pale tan to ocher,
lacks strong odors, and the spores are non-dextrinoid.
Unfortunately it proved difficult to obtain sequences
from any of the collections examined. Affinities of this
taxon to sections within
Agaricus
remain unresolved.
Agaricus wariatodes
(Grgur.) T. Lebel comb. nov.
F
IGS. 10D–F, 12
Mycobank MB443370
T: Western Australia. Swan River, Drummond 181 K;
BPI704922.
;
Endoptychum wariatodes
Grgur., Larger Fungi of South
Australia 436 (1997). T: South Australia. Adelaide,
Eagle on Hill, 26 Apr 1943,
J.B. Cleland
[AD9773].
5
Secotium coarctatum
Berk.,
London J. Bot
. 4:63 (1845).
non
Agaricus coarctatus
Cooke & Massee in Cooke
Grevillea
18:2 (1889).
5
Endoptychum moongum
Grgur.,
The larger fungi of South
Australia
435 (1997) T: South Australia. Greenhill
Road, 9 Apr 1932,
J.B.Cleland
[AD9759].
Nom
.
dubium Gautieria tasmanica
Rodway
Pap. & Proc.
Roy. Soc. Tasmania
1928:72 (1929). T: Tas. Rodway. non
G.Cunn. (1938); non
Agaricus tasmanicus
Berk. In Hook. F.
Fl. Tasman
. 2:245 (1859).
Additional illustrations
: McCann (2003 as gastroid
Agar-
icus
)
Australian fungi illustrated
p 69 (top left).
Sporocarps hypogeous to emergent, gregarious to
solitary. Pileus 8–18(–35) mm high 3 8–23(–34) mm
diam, irregularly subglobose to elongate or turbinate,
apex convex to planoconvex, cream to pinkish buff,
especially in creases, rarely pale dingy brown, silky
smooth to finely fibrillose, rarely drying faintly
tessellated; margin generally fused to stipe, veil
remnants appendiculate on some sporocarps, cream,
persistent. Context fleshy, firm texture, white to
cream, not changing color. Hymenophore initially
pinkish buff to yellowish buff, maturing to grayish
brown or rich olive-brown, minutely labyrinthine-
loculate; moist initially, becoming powdery. Stipe
(8–)17–40 mm long 3 2–6 mm diam, percurrent,
either barely projecting beyond margin with slightly
bulbous base or long, well developed, equal, cream to
pale grayish cream, fibrillose; context cream, no
bruising reactions. Odor weak to strong marzipan,
less fragrant in younger specimens, apparent even
after drying; flavor mild. Spores (5.5)7.0–8.0(9.0) 3
(5)6.0–7.5(8.5)
mm, mean 7.2 3 6.4 mm, Q 5 1.0–1.3,
globose to subglobose or sometimes obvate, mostly
FIG. 11.
Agaricus pachydermus
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and subhymenium, D. spores.
Bar 5 10
mm.
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
509
symmetric, hyaline initially then pale yellow-brown to
pale brown in KOH, dextrinoid. Basidia (8)11–18 3
7–15
mm, clavate to broadly clavate, sterigmata two or
four. Pileipellis a cutis, 5–25
mm wide, of compact
subparallel hyphae 2–5
mm diam, hyaline to pale
yellowish in KOH, overlying a broad context of
slightly inflated hyphae 5–12
mm diam. Clamps absent
in all tissues.
Specimens examined
: VICTORIA. Wimmera, Vectis, Quan-
tong Cemetary Road, B. Maraoske property, 10 Jun 2003,
TWM 1589 [MEL2326250]; Grampians, Mount Arapiles,
road to summit, 1.6 km from Wimmera Highway, 8 Jun
2003, TWM 1584 [MEL2326251]; Arnold West, 1 Jun 1938,
J.H.Willis [MEL1052387]; near Tarnagulla, Arnold West,
Apr 1938, C.L. Barrett [MEL1052366]; 12 km SE of Stawell,
6 Jun 1987, I.R. McCann GAC B109 [MEL2058458,
MEL2292966]; about 12 km SE of Stawell, 10 Jun 1987,
I.R. McCann [MEL2292963; K]; Stawell, in Three Jacks
Wildflower Reserve, 15 Apr 2001, I.R. McCann & T.H. Argyll
[MEL2292032]; near junction of Germanio and Mosquito
Creek roads, N of Stawell, 31 Mar 2001, I.R. McCann & T.H.
Argyll [MEL2292031, MEL2292033]; Arnold West near
Rheola, May 1939, H. Watts [MELU6249F]; Near Ingle-
wood, Green Hills, 13 Apr 1983, F. Watts [MEL2032782];
Riverina, Mitiamo Cemetary, Terrick Terrick State Park, 25
Apr 1996, J. Eichler 16 [MEL2096554]; Riverina, Boort area,
P. Weavers Road approx. 4.5 km SSW of Boort, 5 Apr 1999,
J. Eichler 109 [MEL2096555]; far NW District, Meridian
Road ca. 20 miles SW of Red Cliffs, 1 Aug 1968, J.H. Willis
[MEL695342]; 3.2 km north of Deep Lead, near Ararat, 5,
16 May 1968, I.R. McCann 16 [MELU E0617F (L38), DAR
26447, MEL2058664]. SOUTH AUSTRALIA. Flinders Rang-
es, Wilpena Pound, 19 Jun 2000, Catcheside 540 [AD];
Flinders Ranges, Wilpena Pound near Quorn, 11 Aug 2000,
Catcheside 681 [AD]; Flinders Ranges, Wilpena pound, 19
Jun 2000, Catcheside 528 [AD]; Beaumont, near Adelaide,
17, 24 May 1925, J.B. Cleland [AD22620]; Beaumont,
Adelaide, 20 May 1923, J.B. Cleland [AD20224]; Kinchina,
8 Jun 1925, J.B. Cleland [AD20215]; Beaumont, Adelaide,
Apr 1935, J.B. Cleland [AD22622]; 13 km south of Mount
Davies, Aug 1962, D.E. Symon [AD15829]; WARI, May 1960,
J.H. Warcup [AD10572]; Waite Arboretum, 13 May 1953,
J.H. Warcup [WAITE 3353]; 1935, J.B. Cleland [AD9769];
Highfield, Adelaide, 10 Jan. 1934, J.B. Cleland [AD9771];
Adelaide, J.B. Cleland [MELU6250F]; Dry Creek, 25 Jul
1934, Prof Johnston [AD20208]. NEW SOUTH WALES.
Narrabri, 2 Jun 1919, J.B. Cleland [AD20217]; Sydney, J.B.
Cleland [BPI718213; CG. Lloyd #528]; Riverina, Savernake
Station, Lifeboat, 20.5 km E of Berrigan. SANDS site 6, 4
Jun 2000, J. Trappe 25186; Abbotsford Bridge over Murray
River, near Wentworth, 26 Aug 1955, J.H. Willis 157
[MEL1053064]; Riverina, Kilpa farm, 17.5 km SE of
Berrigan. SANDS site 5, 6 Nov 2000, J.M. Trappe 26601
[MEL2276058]; Trentham Station North of Mildura, 11
Aug 1986, I. McCann B108 & T.H. Argyll [MEL2292967];
Riverina Highway, W of SANDS Plot 23, 23 Jun 2003, J.M.
Trappe 28630. WESTERN AUSTRALIA. Dryandra State
Forest, Tomingley Road, 15 Jun 1999, M. Brundrett & T.
Lebel 43 [MEL2063323]; Dryandra State Forest, Tomingley
Road, 13 Aug 2000, K. Syme & M. Hart [MEL2219013];
Toodyay, 20 Aug 1983, K. Griffiths [PERTH963062];
FIG. 12.
Agaricus wariatodes
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and subhymenium, D. spores.
Bar 5 10
mm.
510 MYCOLOGIA
[BPI704923; packet labeled ex-Paris, small fragments only].
AUSTRALIA. Herb Hookeriana 1867 (K).
Distribution and habitat
: Found in arid areas among
moss, lichens, small herbaceous plants and scattered
litter, or in bare ground or fine gravel, in woodlands
of
Allocasuarina
sp.,
Callitris
sp.,
Eucalyptus leucox-
ylon
,
E. microcarpa
,
E. drummondii
,
E. tectifica
or
Acacia armata
.
Notes
:
Agaricus wariatodes
is characterized by the
subglobose spores, pallid color and minute cells of
the hymenophore, mostly four-spored basidia, and in
most collections, a pleasant, strong fragrence of
marzipan in fresh specimens (also noticeable in many
dried collections).
Agaricus wariatodes
is a widespread
species, found in dry woodlands in all states except
Queensland and Tasmania. Affinities lie within a
strongly supported sect.
Minores
with sister taxon
A.
chartaceus
and two undescribed Australian taxa (
A
.
aff.
semotus
‘‘spH’’; and
Agaricus
sp. ‘‘D’’) (FIG. 1). It
is possible there are a couple of cryptic taxa because
of some variation in the ITS. However no morpho-
logical characters have been found to support
distinguishing varieties at this stage.
On examination of type material of
S. coarctatum
(Drummond 181, K & BPI) no observable difference
was found in spore shape to the type of
E. wariatodes
(AD9773) or more recent collections. The holotype
packet of
E. moongum
(AD9759) contains only pulver-
ized fragments, but the spore size range and shape and
note of strong odor are typical of
Agaricus wariatodes
.A
paratype of
E. moongum
(AD22638) has an organized,
lamellate hymenophore, a membranous annulus on the
saccate stipe, and dark brown, asymmetric spores. All of
these characters point to an agaricoid rather than a
sequestrate form of
Agaricus
, and this collection
therefore is excluded from this taxon.
Although no DNA sequence was obtained from
type material of
S. coarctatum
(FIG. 10D), the collec-
tions examined here fit Berkeley’s original concept
and the illustration of type material in Corda (1854)
(F
IG. 10E). Two collections of
Gautieria tasmanica
are
listed in HO; however one is a species of
Austrogau-
tieria
and the second collection could not be found.
Notes suggest both of these collections were made
after the type collection date (Chang and Kantvilas
1993). Therefore we are calling
G. tasmanica
nom.
dubium and not proposing formal synonymy with
A.
wariatodes
. The specific epithets ‘‘
coarctatus
’’ and
‘‘
tasmanicus
’’ are preoccupied in the genus
Agaricus
and as such are not available for this species (Berkeley
1859, Cooke 1889). The next available names are
‘‘
wariatodes
’’ and ‘‘
moongum
’’, which were published
at the same time (Grgurinovic 1997). Accordingly we
have chosen
A. wariatodes
as the new combination for
this taxon (Art.11.5).
Macrolepiota gasteroidea
T. Lebel sp. nov.
F
IGS. 13, 14A
Mycobank MB519929
Etymology
: (L)
gasteroidea
5 sac-like, in reference to the
gasteroid nature of the sporocarp.
Sporocarpum (30) 35–45 mm altum, (25) 50–65 mm
diam, subglosum vel elongatum ad basim decrescens
apice planum vel convexum, cremeum vel pallido-
brunneum squamatae latae vel angustaeleviter fuscatae
in pagina dispersae; contextus non mutabilis. Hymeno-
phorum initio pallido-brunneum maturita atroluteo-
brunneum, sublamellatum, cellulis grandis elongatis
labyrinthinis, pulverescentibus compositis. Stipes 25–
37 mm altus, (9)16–18 mm diam, percurrens robustis
ad basim decrescens, cremeus; contextus cremeus non
mutabilis. Sporae 14.0–17.5(–19) 3 10.0–12.0(–13.0)
mm, ellipsoideae, dextrinoideae; poris germinationum
praesentis, operculis hili praesentis.
Holotypus
: Western Australia. Ludlow State Forest,
10 Jun 1980,
N. Malajczuk H0052
[PERTH].
Sporocarps solitary or gregarious, hypogeous to
emergent. Pileus (30)35–45 mm high 3 (25)50–
65 mm diam, subglobose to elongate, tapering slightly
toward base, convex or plane at apex, cream to pale
tan, with slightly darker, broad to narrow scales
scattered over surface, giving areolate appearance in
dried specimens; margin incurved to stipe abruptly or
gradually, remaining fused to stipe. Context fleshy,
compact, 2–5 mm wide, white with no change in
color. Hymenophore pale tan initially becoming dark
yellowish brown, sublamellateto labyrinthine, cham-
bers large, empty; becoming powdery. Stipe 25–37 mm
long 3 (9)16–18 mm diam (broken off in larger
speciman), percurrent, robust, tapering slightly to-
ward base, not bulbous, pale tan, smooth to finely
fibrillose, context white to pale tan. Odor and flavor
not recorded. Spores 14.0–17.5(–19) 3 10.0–12.0
(–13)
mm, mean 15.9 3 10.9, Q 5 1.3–1.6, ellipsoid,
asymmetric, yellowish brown in KOH, dextrinoid;
germ pore present, small hilar cap present. Basidia
12.0–22.5 3 7.5–13.0
mm, clavate to broadly clavate;
sterigmata two. Pileipellis a weak trichoderm of
cylindrical interwoven pale brown, thick-walled hy-
phae 35–155
mm long 3 4–10 mm diam with terminal
cells slightly inflated 14–37 3 6–10
mm, obtuse or
occasionally tapered, overlying a broad context of
hyaline, thin-walled hyphae, mostly 2–3.5
mm diam
with scattered inflated hyphae 5–11
mm diam. Clamps
present at base of basidia, not common.
Additional specimens examined
: WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
Coastal Plain, 14 Apr 1983,
N. Malajczuk H0326
[PERTH];
Leederville,
Stoward
[BPI704142; cited by C.G. Lloyd (1918)
and Cunningham (1979) as
S. acuminatum
].
Distribution and habitat
:Foundin
Eucalyptus
gomphocephala
woodland.
L
EBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
511
Note
:
Macrolepiota gasteroidea
resembles
M. vina-
ceofibrillosa
; the main macroscopic difference is the
lack of color change of the flesh and overlying
vinaceous fibrillose squamules on the pileus of
M.
gastero idea
. Both are rare taxa associated with a
restricted species of eucalyptus,
E. gomphocephala
,
native to a small region of southern Western
Australia. Analysis of LSU sequences place this taxon
within an unsupported
Macrolepiota
(SUPPLEMENTARY
FIG
. 1).
Macrolepiota turbinata
T. Lebel sp. nov.
F
IGS. 14B, 15
Mycobank MB519930
Etymology
: (L)
turbinatus
5 turbinate; in reference to the
sporocarp shape.
Sporocarpum (30–)50–110 mm altum, (30–)50–
90 mm diam, elongatum conicum vel subglobulosum
apice convexo vel planoconvexo, basim decrescentem
abrupte vel gradatim, pallido-cremeobrunneum sicca-
tate argenteum interdum vinaceum, laevigatum vel
squamatum concolorum; contextus non mutabilis.
Hymenophorum initio albidum maturita brunneum,
sublamellatum, cellulis grandis elongatis labyrinthi-
nis, pulverescentibus compositum. Stipes (37–)48–
90 mm altus, (8–)20–35 mm diam, percurrens
robustis ad basim bulbosus vel turbinatus, cremeus;
contextus cremeus. Sporae (12–)14(–17) 3 (8–)10
(–11)
mm, late ellipsoideae vel obovatae, dextrinoi-
deae; poris germinationum praesentis, operculis hili
praesentis.
Holotypus
: Western Australia. Agroforestry site. 30
Sep 1981,
N. Malajczuk
H0219 [PERTH].
Sporocarps partly or almost wholly epigean, sessile,
with few basal rhizomorphs. Pileus (30–)50–110 mm
high 3 (30–)50–90 mm diam, elongate conical or
squat and spherical, sometimes turbinate when
young, apex convex or planoconvex, tapering abrupt-
ly or gradually to short stipe, pale creamy tan, drying
silvery white, with a purplish tint on some sporocarps,
smooth overall or with scattered to dense, fine
fibrillose scales, concolorous or slightly darker than
FIG. 13.
Macrolepiota gasteroidea
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and subhymenium,
D. spores. Bar 5 10
mm.
512 MYCOLOGIA
pellis; margin remaining attached to robust stipe,
enclosing hymenophore. Hymenophore off-white to
tan initially, becoming dingy grayish brown to dark
brown at maturity, sublamellate to labyrinthine;
becoming powdery. Stipe-columella (37–)48–90 3
(8–)20–35 mm diam, percurrent, bulbous at base,
tapering slightly or abruptly, pale cream, minute
fibrillose scales scattered over surface, context cream;
persistent fibrillose veil remnants, concolorous with
pellis or slightly paler. Odor and flavor sweet,
pleasant. Spores (12–)14(–17) 3 (8–)10(–11)
mm,
mean 14.3 3 9.9
mm, Q 5 1.2–1.6, broadly ellipsoid to
slightly obvate, some pedicillate, pale yellowish brown
to brown in KOH, dextrinoid; germ pore present,
distinct, hyaline cap present. Basidia 9.0–14.5 3 16.0–
24.5
mm diam, spherical or broadly clavate; sterigmata
two or four. Pileipellis a patchy trichoderm of
cylindrical interwoven, thick-walled hyphae 70–
200
mm long 3 3–7 mm diam with terminal cells
slightly inflated 14–30 3 5–8
mm, obtuse or occasion-
ally tapered, with scattered brown pigmentation,
overlying a broad context of hyaline, thin-walled
hyphae, mostly 2–3.5
mm diam with scattered inflated
hyphae 5–9
mm diam. Clamps present at base of
basidia, not common.
Additional spec imens examined
: WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
Ludlow State Forest near Busselton, 17 Jun 2002,
B.
Bradshaw
[MURUL055]; Murdoch University Campus, 22
Apr 1982,
R. Watling 14576
; Margaret River, 15 Apr 1963,
L.E. Souef 27
[PERTH00952516]; Yanchep, Aug 1963,
L.
Newhouse 3
[PERTH00953571]; Margaret River, 24 Jun
1962,
L.E. Souef 18
, [PERTH00952036]; Murdoch University
carpark, 1975,
R.N. Hilton
[PERTH00959359]; Margaret
River,414SussexStreet,2May1964,
L.E. Souef
[PERTH00954624]; Jurien Bay, Mountt Benia, 18 May
1971,
R.N. Hilton
[PERTH00956295]; Yanchep, Aug 1963,
O.K. Miller
[PERTH00952591]; Margaret River, 12 May 1963,
L.E. Souef 28
[PERTH00951951]; Margaret River, 15 Apr
1963,
L.E. Souef 27
[PERTH00952060]; Ashdale, Coomal-
bidgup, near Esperance, 7 Apr 1974,
G. Bowen
[PERTH00958832]; Guildford, May 1967,
T.C..Daniell 29
[PERTH00955159]; Edgewater, 27 Apr 1982,
M. Daams
[PERTH00960934]; Waneroo, Apr 1982,
J. Daams Y624
[BRIP25269]; Margaret River, 414 Sussex Street, 30 May
1964,
L.E. Souef
[PERTH00954136]; Margaret River, 17 Jun
1962,
L.E. Soeuf 31
[PERTH00951501]; Esperance, 7 May
1971,
M.S. Daniell 143
[PERTH00958387]; Esperance, 20
May 1972,
T.C. Daniell
[PERTH00957771];
W. Stewart
[BPI704148 under the name
Secotium acuminatum
].
Distribution and habitat
: Emergent in sandy soils
under leaf litter, in mixed open, mostly coastal,
Eucalypt forest, including
Eucalyptus gomphocephala
,
E. marginata
,
E. calophylla
and
Agonis flexuosa
.
Note
:
Macrolepiota turbinata
is distinguished by the
overall shape of the sporocarp, with its tapering base
FIG. 14. Sporocarps. A.
Macrolepiota gasteroidea
(photo N. Malajczuk; holotype H0052). B.
Macrolepiota turbinata
(photo
W. Dunstan MURUL055). C.
Macrolepiota vinaceofibrillosa
(photo N. Bougher 0546).
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
513
to the stipe, smooth pale pileus and dark brown
hymenophore. The species appears to be restricted to
Western Australia but is fairly widespread in the
southern coastal region. Affinities to sect.
Macro-
lepiota
are supported by ITS analyses, with the closest
taxa
M. dolichaula
and
M. detersa
(FIG. 2).
Macrolepiota vinaceofibrillosa
T. Lebel sp. nov.
F
IGS. 14C, 16
Mycobank MB519931
Etymology
: (L)
vinaceo
5 vinaceous; -
fibrillosa
5 fibrillose,
in reference to the vinaceous fibrils on the pileus.
Sporocarpum 65 mm altum, 45 mm diam, tur-
binatum vel elongatum apice convexum, pallido-
brunneum squamatae latae concolores in pagina
despersae; contextus albidus roseolescens. Hymeno-
phorum initio pallido-brunneum maturita brunneum,
sublamellatum, cellulis grandis elongatis labyrinthinis,
pulverescentibus compositum. Stipes 90 mm altus, 18–
26 mm diam, percurrens robustis ad basim bulbosus,
albidus vel pallido-brunneus; contextus albidus roseo-
lescens. Sporae 12.5–15.0 3 10.0–12.0
mm, ellipsoideae
vel late ellipsoideae, dextrinoideae; poris germinatio-
num praesentis, operculis hili praesentis.
Holotypus
: Western Australia. Bold Park, Floreat
Park, 2 Jun 1980,
N. Malajczuk H0047
[PERTH].
Sporocarp solitary, hypogeous to emergent.
Pileus 50–65(–95) mm high 3 45–60(–70) mm
diam, turbinate-elongate with convex apex and
tapering slightly toward base, pale tan with scat-
tered to abundant vinaceous, mainly appressed
fibrillose-agglutinated scales; margin remaining
fused to stipe. Context fleshy, 2–5 mm thick, white
turning pale pinkish brown. Hymenophore pale
greenishbrownbecomingdulltodarkbrown,
sublamellate to labyrinthine, chambers large; be-
coming powdery. Stipe 75–90 mm long 3 18–26
FIG. 15.
Macrolepiota turbinata
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and hymenophoral trama,
D. spores. Bar 5 10
mm.
514 MYCOLOGIA
(–32) mm diam, percurrent, slightly bulbous then
tapering slightly toward base, fleshy when fresh,
white to pale tan, protruding below pileus 20–
30 mm; context white turning pale pinkish brown.
Odor and flavor not recorded. Spores 12.5–15.0 3
10.0–12.0
mm, mean 14.0 3 10.6, Q 5 1.2–1.4,
ellipsoid to broadly ellipsoid-ovoid, variable shape
and size, asymmetrical, yellowish brown in KOH,
dextrinoid; small germ pore present, hilar cap
present. Basidia 12.0–14.5 3 20.5–28.0
mm, clavate
to cylindrical; sterigmata four. Pileipellis a patchy
trichoderm of cylindrical interwoven brown pig-
mented, thick-walled hyphae 32–190
mmlong3 3–
7
mm diam with terminal cells slightly inflated 14–37
3 6–10
mm, obtuse or occasionally tapered, overly-
ing a broad context of hyaline, thin-walled hyphae,
septate, mostly 2–3.5
mmdiamwithscattered
inflated hyphae 5–11
mm diam. Clamps present at
base of basidia, not common.
Additional specimen examined
: WESTERN AUSTRALIA.
City Beach, Bold Park, in front of Ecology Centre, 9 Jul
2009,
N. Bougher 00546
[PERTH].
Distribution and habitat
:Foundin
Eucalyptus
gomphocephala
woodland.
Note
:
Macrolepiota vinaceofibrillosa
resembles
M.
gasteroidea
. Microscopically
M. vinaceofibrillosa
spores
are slightly shorter and more broadly ellipsoid than
those of
M. gasteroidea
, the pellis hyphae are slightly
narrower with longer terminal cells, and the basidia
have four rather than two sterigmata. Affinities with
sect.
Macrolepiota
are supported by both morphology
and DNA (F
IG. 2). Unlike
Macrolepiota procera
and
allies,
Macrolepiota vinaceofibrillosa
and sister taxa
M.
dolichaula
,
M. turbinata
,
M. gastroidea
and
M. detersa
generally have a pileus with slightly inflated terminal
elements that are not thick-walled, clamp connections
at the base of basidia, and lack big patches of velar
material on the pileus.
K
EY TO AUSTRALIAN SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
,
B
ARCHERIA
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
SPECIES
1a. Sporocarps astipitate, soft, globose; flesh staining
orange reddish ............
Barcheria willisiana
1b. Sporocarps stipitate, firm, subglobose, or turbi-
nate; flesh may or may not change color ....... 2
2a. Spores with a germ pore and hilar cap present;
pellis a trichodermium; clamp connections
present at the base of basidia . .......... 3.
FIG. 16.
Macrolepiota vinaceofibrillosa
. Illustrations of A. sporocarps, B. pileipellis hyphae, C. basidia and hymenophoral
trama, D. spores. Bar 5 10
mm.
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
515
2b. Spores with or without a germ pore, but hilar
cap lacking; pellis a cutis; clamp connections
almost always absent at the base of basidia . . . 5
3a. Flesh staining pinkish; pileus covered in fine
vinaceous squamules . . .
Macrolepiota vinaceofibrillosa
3b. Flesh not changing color; pileus smooth or with
broad, flat concolorous squamules . . .......... 4
4a. Pileus scaly, areolate in dried specimens; basidia
two-spored; spores 14.0–17.5(–19) 3 10.0–12.0(–13)
mm, ellipsoid .............
Macrolepiota gasteroidea
4b. Pileus smooth; basidia four-spored; spores (12–)
14.0(–17) 3 (8–)10.0(–11)
mm, broadly ellipsoid
toslightlyobvate ........
Macrolepiota turbinata
5a. Sporocarps with a strong fragence of almonds,
marzipan or anise ........................ 6
5b. Sporocarps without odor or with a different odor . . . 7
6a. Pileus thin, remaining fleshy; basidia four-
spored ...............
Agaricus wariatodes
6b. Pileus thin, becoming papery; basidia two-
spored ...............
Agaricus chartaceus
7a. Sporocarps large, generally . 40 mm diam (up to
120mm) .............................. 8
7b. Sporocarps smaller, generally , 25 mm diam (up
to30mm) ............................. 9
8a. Hymenophoral trama staining reddish orange
and stipe-context reddening
Agaricus erythrosarx
8b. Hymenophoral trama and stipe-context not
changing color .......
Agaricus melanosporus
9a. Pileus or hymenophore staining yellow when
bruised ..................
Agaricus inilleasper
9b. Pileus or hymenophore not staining or becoming
reddish ............................... 10
10a. Spores globose to subglobose 6–8 3 6–7.5
mm;
stipe flesh not changing color
..........
...................
Agaricus pachydermus
10b. Spores predominantly ellipsoid or ovoid
8–13.5 (–16) 3 6–8
mm; stipe flesh yellowish
then apricot at base . . .
Agaricus eburneocanus
DISCUSSION
Several studies have shown that the sequestrate
sporocarp form has arisen multiple times within the
Agaricaceae, with much of the diversification occur-
ring in
Agaricus
(Hopple and Vilgalys 1999, Vellinga
et al. 2003, Vellinga 2004, Gube 2009). The species of
Macrolepiota
reported here are an indication that the
sequestrate sporocarp form is more widely distributed
than initially thought. The three novel taxa are
derived from within sect.
Macrolepiota
and all are
currently known only from southern Western Austra-
lia. Given the similarities in appearance both macro-
and microscopically, overlap in distributions, it is
possible that
Macrolepiota gastroidea
is a two-spored
variant of
M. vinaceofibrillosa
, although analysis of
DNA data is inconclusive (S
UPPLEMENTARY FIG.1,
F
IG. 2). The sister taxa to
M. turbinata
and
M.
vinaceofibrillosa
appear to be
M. dolichaula
(Austra-
lian/Asian) and
M. deters
, a recently described species
from Japan and China (Ge et al. 2010), rather than
either of the other Australian species,
M. clelandii
or
M. eucharis
(FIG. 2). Both
M. dolichaula
and
M.
detersa
have medium to large, whitish sporocarps with
a long stipe, however
M. dolichaula
has small uplifted
pale squamules while
M. detersa
has large patch-like
brownish squamules (Ge et al. 2010). Intriguingly
mapping the distributions of Australian
Macrolepiota
species shows no overlap (Western Australia) in
sequestrate and sister agaricoid species (northeastern
Australia), the most likely explanation for current
distributions and relationships are that related taxa
are now extinct and/or documentation of taxa is
incomplete.
As with the epigeous taxa, spores of sequestrate
Macrolepiota
tend to be on the larger side (8–20 mm
long) and taxa also tend to have fairly large and fleshy
sporocarps; although in the case of the sequestrate
taxa the hymenophore becomes pulverant at maturi-
ty. Clamps are present at the base of basidia, but not
common, in the sequestrate forms, but this is variable
in both
Macrolepiota
and
Chlorophyllum
. Instead the
presence of a hilar cap covering the germ pore and
trichoderm versus a hymeniderm pellis are consid-
ered good characters differentiating
Macrolepiota
from
Chlorophyllum
. Without these characters it
would be difficult to differentiate sequestrate
Macro-
lepiota
species from
Chlorophyllum agaricoides
solely
on macromorphology.
No Australian sequestrate species of
Chlorophyllum
were discovered in this study, and Australian speci-
mens of
C. agaricoides
cited in Cunningham (1979)
are of
Agaricus wariatodes
‘‘Green Hill Rd, SA 9 April
1932’’, and
Macrolepiota gasteroidea
‘‘Leederville, WA,
F.W. Stoward’’.
Chlorophyllum
is paraphyletic in
analyses of both LSU and ITS, however the ‘‘
C.
molybdites
’’group (
C. globosum
,
C. neomastoideum
,
C.
agaricoides
) is well supported (SUPPLEMENTARY FIG.1,
F
IG. 2). The strong molecular support for
C. agar-
icoides
as a distinct taxon and lack of morphological
differences between specimens from a broad geo-
graphic area including much of Europe and North
America suggests that this is a stable, widespread
species undergoing little selection pressure for
speciation or that there has been a fairly recent
dispersal of the species across continents.
Our results and others show that the majority of
taxa once placed in the genus
Endoptychum
belong in
other genera. The only species remaining,
E.
arizonicum
, cannot be placed with any certainty.
Endoptychum arizonicum
has extremely thick-walled,
white to pale yellow spores that lack a germ pore, a
non-percurrent stipe, no color changes on exposure
to air and a pileus that is a cutis rather than a
516 M
YCOLOGIA
hymeniderm (Shear 1902, Singer and Smith 1958,
Moreno et al. 2007). These characters would tend to
point to a closer affinity to
Agaricus
and
Barcheria
rather than
Chlorophyllum
. Gube’s (2009) combined
phylogenetic analyses of ITS and LSU were inconclu-
sive, showing
E. arizonicum
to be sister to
Agaricus
and
Chlorophyllum
. Of the other taxa that are
apparently sister to
Chlorophyllum
,
Barcheria
and
Agaricus
, both
Coniolepiota
and
Eriocybe
also have
pale or white spores but
Eriocybe
spores display an
immediate and strong dextrinoid reaction that is
lacking in
E. arizonicum
.
Endoptychum arizonicum
sporocarps lack the dense velar covering of pileus and
stipe and strong odors but do have scattered clamp
connections in the hymenophoral trama and at the
base of basidia such as
Coniolepiota
and
Eriocybe
(Vellinga et al. 2011).
Endoptychum arizonicum
remains somewhat in limbo, being retained as a
species of
Endoptychum
until further data is available.
In our analyses
Barcheria willisiana
also appears as
sister to
Agaricus
rather than within as suggested by
Gube (2009). Morphologically there is little resem-
blance to
Endoptychum arizonicum
, although both
have gastroid sporocarps, with a thin, fragile pileus, a
cuticular pellis and spores lacking a germ pore.
The diversity of native
Agaricus
species in Australia
is poorly known (May et al. 2006); thus putative sister
taxa to sequestrate species may be missing from
analyses. Our analyses indicated that the nine
sequestrate species in
Agaricus
are a result of at least
six transitions from agaricoid to sequestrate form,
with the highest diversity apparent in sections
Arvenses
and
Minores
. In various analyses by other
authors
Agaricus deserticola
[5
Longula texensis
]isin
sect.
Arvenses
, which includes
A. eburneocanus
and
A.
inapertus
[5
Endoptychum depressum
], while
A.
aridicola
[5
Gyrophragmium dunalii
],
A. wariatodes
and
A. chartaceus
have affinities to taxa in sect.
Minores
(Mitchell and Bresinksy 1999, Geml 2004,
Gube 2009). The majority of taxa in these two groups
can be characterized by the yellow color change and
almond-like fragrance of the sporocarp (Moncalvo
et al. 2000, Geml 2004, Geml et al. 2004). Section
Arvenses
is known to be dominant in high-latitude
habitats, seemingly well adapted to harsh climates,
such as the subantarctic islands of New Zealand and
now the drier regions of Australia (Geml et al. 2007,
2008).
The position of
Agaricus melanosporus
and
Agaricus
inilleasper
are unresolved in DNA analyses (SUPPLE-
MENTARY FIG
.1,FIG. 1), and morphological characters
are not sufficiently distinct to place these taxa within
any particular section. Section
Sanguinolenti
includes
the sequestrate
A. erythrosarx
and agaricoid
A. lilaceps
,
A. pattersonae
,
A. fuscovelatus
and an undescribed
Australian species ‘‘C’’. All taxa in this clade have a
brownish pileus (
A. erythrosarx
is pale), rufescent
context and a fruity or spicy odor (Geml et al. 2004).
Thiers (1984) suggested that gastroid forms evolved
from an agaricoid ancestor via secotioid intermedi-
ates, considering the process to be sequential (i.e.
Cortinarius
to
Thaxterogaster
to
Hymenoga ster
)al-
though sometimes incomplete (i.e.
Agaricus
to
Endoptychum
). Under that hypothesis none of the
series examined here, in three different lineages
(
Macrolepiota
,
Chlorophyllum
,
Agaricus
), are complete
to the gastroid form, ending instead with the
secotioid taxa. However the more gastroid forms of
Barcheria
and
Endoptychum arizonicum
are unique
with no apparent extant secotioid or agaricoid sister
taxa. This may be due to extinction of related
sporocarp forms/taxa or reflect our incomplete
knowledge of local fungal diversity.
Timing of sequestration.—
Calibrating fungal phyloge-
nies is difficult due to lack of well preserved fossil
material (Matheny et al. 2009), so we incorporated an
existing hypothesis for a divergence time between
known species of
Agaricus
and
Chlorophyllum
from
Geml et al. (2004), which is derived from Heckman
et al. (2001). Divergence times of other taxa then are
calibrated based on this node, and our conclusions
about patterns of evolution of sequestrate forms
therefore are tentative at this stage. It should be
noted in particular that conclusions of Heckman et al.
(2001) may be overestimates of node ages (Nagy et al.
2011), such that our estimates here are possibly
conservative with respect to the dated origin of
sequestrate forms. New information about other
divergence times and/or fossil taxa will improve the
accuracy and interpretation of future calibrations.
An unexpected result from the calibrated phylog-
eny (F
IG. 3) is the relatively old sequestrate
Barcheria
clade, , 65 Ma, and
Agaricus melansporous
, , 34 Ma.
One possibility is that their ancestors also were
sequestrate, although this was not indicated by the
ancestral state reconstruction (F
IG.3,SUPPLEMENTARY
FIG
. 2). This then would have suggested that most
Agaricus
species have transitioned from sequestrate to
agaricoid forms, which is unlikely, but the evolution
of the gastroid form could be reversible (Hibbet
2004). More likely is that the lack of agaricoid forms
on the branches to
Barcheria
and
A. melanosporous
is a
result of incomplete taxon sampling and/or extinc-
tion of non-sequestrate forms.
Gastroid forms may have higher net rates of
diversification (Wilson et al. 2011), and their relative
taxonomic rarity may stem from recent origins.
Adaptation to xeric environments is often suggested
as the major selection pressure for fungal sporocarps
L
EBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
517
with an enclosed hymenium and eventually loss of the
stipe, and our calibrated phylogeny (F
IG. 3) suggests
that climatic events in Australia could be correlated
with the evolution of sequestrate forms. For taxa in this
study the evolution of sequestrate forms is estimated to
have occurred predominantly during the mid-Miocene
onward, during the past 15 000 000 y. Interestingly, a
recently calibrated phylogeny that includes one Aus-
tralian sequestrate form (
Auritella geoaustralis
) dates
the origin of its branch at a similar time frame, 20 Ma
(Matheny et al. 2009). This time frame matches
environmental and geological events, particularly for
Australia where the continent was subject to increased
cooling and drying as it moved northward (Martin
2006). Species radiations also occurred in the Miocene
for many important Australian sclerophyll flora, such
as
Eucalyptus
,
Banksia
and
Allocasuarina
(Crisp et al.
2004). Further study of Agaricaceae from xeric habitats
in Australia will be relevant for research into adaptive
evolutionary changes, particularly those that might be
driven by climatic shifts.
A
CKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank the staff of PERTH, BRI, MEL and BPI for
providing access to specimens and aid in locating
collection data. Thank-you to Christopher Dunk (research
assistant) who aided with DNA extraction and sequencing,
and Tom May and the RBG Melbourne fungal studies
group for comment on the draft manuscript. Part of this
research was supported by the Australasian Biological
Resources Study research grant program. Finally many
thanks to reviewers who provided insightful commentary
and for suggesting a variation of a new taxon name
(erythrosarx).
LITERATURE CITED
Barker WR. 2005. Standardizing informal names in Austra-
lian publications. Aust Syst Bot Newslett 122:11.
Bas C. 1991. A short introduction to the ecology, taxonomy
and nomenclature of the genus Agaricus. In: van
Griensven LJLD, ed. Genetics and breeding of
Agaricus
. Proceedings of the 1st International Seminar
on Mushroom Science, Pudoc Wageningen. p 21–24.
Berkeley MJ. 1845. Decades of fungi. Dec III–VII. Australian
fungi. London J Bot 4:42–73.
———. 1859. Fungi. In: Hooker JD. The botany of the
Antarctic voyage of H.M. discovery ships Erebus and
Terror, in the years 1839–1843 Part III. Flora Tasmaniae.
Vol. 2 Monocotyledones and Acotyledones. London:
Lovell Reeve, 241–282.
Candusso M, Lanzoni G. 1990.
Lepiota
s.l. Fungi Europaei 4.
Sareno, Italy: Giovanna Biella. 743 p.
Chang Y-S, Kantvilas G. 1993. A catalogue of Leonard
Rodway’s collection of fungi I. Hymenomycetes and
Gasteromycetes. Tasmanian Herbarium Occasional
Publication No. 4. Hobart: Tasmanian Museum and
Art Gallery. 43 p.
Cooke MC. 1889. New Australian fungi. Grevillea 18:1–8.
Corda ACJ. 1854. Icones fungorum. Vol. 6. Prague: Libraria
Friderici Ehrlich. 91 p.
Crisp M, Cook L, Steane D. 2004. Radiation of the
Australian flora: What can comparisons of molecular
phylogenies across multiple taxa tell us about the
evolution of diversity in present-day communities?
Philos Trans Roy Soc London B 359:1551–1571,
doi:10.1098/rstb.2004.1528
Cunningham GH. 1935. The Gasteromycetes of Australasia
XVII, Some new species of Hymenogastraceae. Proc
Linn Soc New South Wales 60:119–120.
———. 1979. The Gasteromycetes of Australia and New
Zealand. Band 67. Vaduz: Cramer. 236 p.
Czernajew BM. 1845. Nouveaux cryptogames de l’Ukraine
et quelques mots sur la flore de ce pays. Bull Soc Imp
Natl Moscou 18(2, III):148.
Danks M, Lebel T, Vernes K. 2010. Cort short on a
mountaintop—Eight new species of sequestrate Corti-
narius from sub-alpine Australia and affinities to
sections within the genus. Persoonia 24:106–126,
doi:10.3767/003158510X512711
Ding ZQ, Huang SZ. 2003. Characteristics and high-yield
culture technique of
Macrolepiota procera
. Edible Fungi
4:33.
Drummond AJ, Ho SYW, Phillips MJ, Rambaut A. 2006.
Relaxed phylogenetics and dating with confidence.
PLoS biology 4:e88, doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0040088
———, Rambaut A. 2007. BEAST: bayesian evolutionary
analysis by sampling trees. BMC Evol Biol 7:214,
doi:10.1186/1471-2148-7-214
Edgar RC. 2004. MUSCLE: multiple sequence alignment
with high accuracy and high throughput. Nucleic Acids
Res 32:1792–1797, doi:10.1093/nar/gkh340
Fries EM. 1836–1838. Epicrisis systematis mycologici.
Uppsala, Sweden: Typographia Academica. 610 p.
Gardes M, Bruns TD. 1993. ITS primers with enhanced
specificity of basidiomycetes: application to the identi-
fication of mycorrhizae and rusts. Mol Ecol 2:113–118,
doi:10.1111/j.1365-294X.1993.tb00005.x
Ge ZW, Yang ZL, Vellinga EC. 2010. The genus
Macrolepiota
(Agaricaceae, Basidiomycota) in China. Fungal Divers
45:81–98, doi:10.1007/s13225-010-0062-0
Geml J. 2004. Evolution in action: molecular evidence for
recent emergence of secotioid genera
Endoptychum
,
Gyrophragmium
and
Longula
from
Agaricus
ancestors.
Acta Microbio Immunol Hungarica 51:97–108,
doi:10.1556/AMicr.51.2004.1-2.7
———, Geiser DM, Royse DJ. 2004. Molecular evolution of
Agaricus
species based on ITS and LSU rDNA
sequences. Mycol Prog 3:157–176, doi:10.1007/
s11557-006-0086-8
———, Laursen GA, Nusbaum HC, Taylor DL. 2007. Two
new species of
Agaricus
from the Subantarctic. Myco-
taxon 100:193–208.
———, ———, Taylor DL. 2008. Molecular diversity
assessment of arctic and boreal
Agaricus
taxa. Mycolo-
gia 100:577–589, doi:10.3852/07-042R1
518 MYCOLOGIA
Grgurinovic CA. 1997. Larger fungi of South Australia.
Adekaude: Botanic Gardens and State Herbarium.
725 p.
Gube M. 2009. Ontogeny and phylogeny of gasteroid
members of Agaricaceae (Basidiomycetes). [doctoral
dissertation]. Jena, Germany: Friedrich-Schiller-Univer-
sitat. 145 p.
Heckman DS, Geiser DM, Eidell BR, Stauffer RL, Kardos
NL, Hedges SB. 2001. Molecular evidence for the early
colonization of land by fungi and plants. Science 293:
1129–1133, doi:10.1126/science.1061457
Hibbett DS. 2004. Trends in morphological evolution in
Homobasidiomycetes inferred using maximum likeli-
hood: a comparison of binary and multistate approaches.
Syst Biol 53:889–903, doi:10.1080/10635150490522610
Ho SYM. 2007. Calibrating molecular estimates of substitu-
tion rates and divergence times in birds. J Avian Biol 38:
409–414.
Hollos L. 1903. Magyarorsza´g Gasteromyceta´i (Gasteromy-
cetes Hungariae). Franklin Ta´rsulat, Budapest. 248 p.
Hopple JS, Vilgalys R. 1999. Phylogenetic relationshjps
among coprinoid taxa and dark-spored allies based on
sequence data from the nuclear gene coding for the
large ribosomal subunit RNA: divergent domains,
outgroups and monophyly. Mol Phylog Evol 13:1–19,
doi:10.1006/mpev.1999.0634
Ju¨lich W. 1982. Higher taxa of Basidiomycetes. Bibliotheca
Mycol 85:1–485.
Kerrigan RW, Callac P, Guinberteau J, Challen MP, Parra
LA. 2006.
Agaricus
section
Xanthodermatei
: a phyloge-
netic reconstruction with commentary on taxa. Myco-
logia 97:1318–1341.
Kirk PM, Cannon PF, Minter DW, Stalpers JA. 2008. Dictionary
of the Fungi. 10th ed. Wallingford, UK: CABI. 771 p.
Kru¨ger D, Binder M, Fischer M, Kreisel H. 2001. The
Lycoperdales. A molecular approach to the systematics
of some gasteroid mushrooms. Mycologia 93:947–957,
doi:10.2307/3761759
Lebel T, Thompson D, Udovicic F. 2004. Descriptions and
affinities of a new sequestrate fungus,
Barcheria will-
isiana
gen. et
s
p. nov. (Agaricales) from Australia. Mycol
Res 108:206–213, doi:10.1017/S0953756203008736
———, Tonkin JE. 2007. Australasian species of
Macowa-
nites
are sequestrate species of
Russula
(Russulaceae,
Basidiomycota). Aust Syst Bot 20:355–381, doi:10.1071/
SB07007
Lloyd CG. 1918. Mycological notes 55 [Mycol Writings
5:781–796].
Maddison WP, Maddison DR. 2010. Mesquite 2.73: a
modular system for evolutionary analysis. http://
mesquiteproject.org
Martin HA. 2006. Cenozoic climatic change and the
development of the arid vegetation in Australia. J Arid
Environ 66:533–563, doi:10.1016/j.jaridenv.2006.01.009
Matheny PB, Aime MC, Bougher NL, Buyck B, Desjardin D,
Horak E, Kropp BR, Lodge DJ, Soyton K, Trappe JM,
Hibbett DS. 2009. Out of the Palaeotropics? Historical
biogeography and diversification of the cosmopolitan
ectomycorrhizal mushroom family Inocybaceae. J Bio-
geogr 36:577–592, doi:10.1111/j.1365-2699.2008.02055.x
———, Curtis JM, Hofstetter V, Aime MC, Moncalvo J-M, Ge
Z-W, Yang Z-L, Slot JC, Ammirati JF, Baroni TJ,
Bougher NL, Hughes KW, Lodge DJ, Kerrigan RW,
Seidl MT, Aanen DK, DeNitis M, Daniele GM,
Desjardin DE, Kropp BR, Norvell LL, Parker A,
Vellinga EC, Vilgalys R, Hibbett DS. 2007. Major
clades of Agaricales: a multilocus phylogenetic over-
view. Mycologia 98:982–995, doi:10.3852/mycologia.98.
6.982
May TW, Milne J, Wood AE, Shingles S, Jones RH, Neish P.
2006. Interactive catalogue of Australian fungi. Version
3.0. Australian Biological Resources Study, Canberra/
Royal Botanic Gardens Melbourne. http://www.rbg.vic.
gov.au/dbpages/cat/index.php/fungicatalogue
Mitchell AD, Bresinsky A. 1999. Phylogenetic relationships
of
Agaricus
species based on ITS–2 and 28S ribosomal
DNA sequences. Mycologia 91:811–819, doi:10.2307/
3761534
Moncalvo J-M, Lutzoni FM, Rehner SA, Johnson J, Vilgalys R.
2000. Phylogenetic relationships of agaric fungi based
on nuclear large subunit ribosomal DNA sequences. Syst
Biol 49:278–305, doi:10.1093/sysbio/49.2.278
———, Vilgalys R, Redhead SA, Johnson JE, James TY, Aime
MC, Hofstetter V, Verduin SJW, Larsson E, Baroni TJ,
Thorn RG, Jacobsson S, Clemencon H, Miller OK Jr.
2002. One hundred seventeen clades of euagarics. Mol
Phylogenet Evol 23:357–400, doi:10.1016/S1055-7903
(02)00027-1
Montagne C. 1843. Conside´rations ge´ne´rales sur la tribu des
Podaxine´es et fondation du nouveau genre
Gyrophrag-
mium
, appartenant a` cette tribu. Ann Sci Nat, Bot 20
ser. II:69–91.
Moreno G, Esqueda M, Pe´rez-Silva E, Herrera T, Alte´s A.
2007. Some interesting gasteroid and secotioid fungi
from Sonora, Mexico. Persoonia 19:265–280.
Nagy LG, Walther G, Hazi J, Vagvolgyi C, Papp T. 2011.
Understanding the evolutionary processes of fungal
fruiting bodies: correlated evolution and divergence
times in the Psathyrellaceae. Syst Biol 60:303–317,
doi:10.1093/sysbio/syr005
Posada D, Crandall KA. 1998. Modeltest: testing the model
of DNA substitution. Bioinformatics 14:817–818,
doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/14.9.817
Rambaut A. 2009. FigTree 1.3.1 http://tree.bio.ed.ac.uk/
software/figtree
Redhead SA, Vilgalys R, Moncalvo J-M, Johnson J, Hopple
JS. 2001.
Coprinus
Persoon and the disposition of
Coprinus
species sensu lato. Taxon 50:203–241,
doi:10.2307/1224525
Ronquist F, Huelsenbeck JP. 2003. MrBayes 3: Bayesian
phylogenetic inference under mixed models. Bioinfor-
matics 19:1572–1574, doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/
btg180
Shear CL. 1902. Mycological notes and new species. Bull
Torrey Bot Club 29:449–457, doi:10.2307/2478544
Singer R. 1986. The Agaricales in modern taxonomy. 4th
ed. Konigstein, Germany: Koeltz Scientific Books. 912 p.
———, Smith AH. 1958. Studies on secotiaceous fungi II.
Endoptychum depressum
. Brittonia 10:216–221, doi:10.
2307/2804952
LEBEL AND SYME:SEQUESTRATE
A
GARICUS
AND
M
ACROLEPIOTA
519
Swofford DL. 2002. PAUP* 4.0: phylogenetic analysis using
parsimony (*and other methods). Sunderland, Massa-
chusetts: Sinauer Associates.
Thiers B. [continuously updated]. Index herbariorum: a
global directory of public herbaria and associated staff.
New York Botanical Garden’s Virtual Herbarium.
http://sweetgum.nybg.org/ih/
———. 1984. The secotioid syndrome. Mycologia 76:1–8,
doi:10.2307/3792830
Vellinga EC. 2002. New combinations in
Chlorophyllum
.
Mycotaxon 83:415–417.
———. 2003. Notes on
Chlorophyllum
and
Macrolepiota
(Agaricaceae) in Australia. Aust Syst Bot 16:361–370,
doi:10.1071/SB02013
———. 2004. Genera in the family Agaricaceae—evidence
from nrITS and nrLSU sequences. Mycol Res 108:354–
377, doi:10.1017/S0953756204009700
———, de Kok RPJ, Bruns TD. 2003. Phylogeny and
taxonomy of
Macrolepiota
(Agaricaceae). Mycologia
95:442–456, doi:10.2307/3761886
———, Sysouphanthong P, Hyde KE. 2011. The family
Agaricaceae: phylogenies and two new white-spored
genera. Mycologia 103:510–524, doi:10.3852/10-204
White TJ, Bruns T, Lee S, Taylor J. 1990. Amplification and
direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for
phylogenetics. In: Innis MA, Gelfand DH, Shinsky JJ,
White TJ, eds. PCR protocols: a guide to methods
and applications. San Diego: Academic Press. p 315–
322.
Wilgenbusch JC, Warren DL, Swofford D. 2004. AWTY: A
system for graphical exploration of MCMC conver-
gence in Bayesian phylogenetic inference. http://ceb.
csit.fsu.edu/awty
Wilson AW, Binder M, Hibbett DS. 2011. Effects of gasteroid
fruiting body morphology on diversification rates in
three independent clades of fungi estimated using
binary state speciation and extinction analysis. Evolution
65:1305–1322, doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.2010.01214.x
Wright JE. 1975.
Smithiogaster
, a new genus of agaricoid
Gasteromycetes. Nova Hedwigia 51:359–364.
520 MYCOLOGIA