Content uploaded by James F White
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by James F White
Content may be subject to copyright.
APPLIED AND ENVIRONMENTAL MICROBIOLOGY,
0099-2240/00/$04.00⫹0Jan. 2000, p. 425–427 Vol. 66, No. 1
Copyright © 2000, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Phoma glomerata as a Mycoparasite of Powdery Mildew
RAYMOND F. SULLIVAN AND JAMES F. WHITE, JR.*
Department of Plant Pathology, Cook College, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey 08901
Received 26 July 1999/Accepted 2 November 1999
Ampelomyces and Phoma species are frequently confused with each other. Isolates previously attributed to the
genus Ampelomyces were shown to be Phoma isolates through studies of their morphology and life cycle and
ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer region 1 sequence analysis. Phoma glomerata can colonize and
suppress development of powdery mildew on oak and may have utility as a mycoparasitic agent.
Powdery mildews are widespread plant pathogens that are
conspicuous by their white mycelia and powder-like conidia
(20). The fungus Ampelomyces quisqualis Ces. is the only fun-
gus that has been demonstrated to be generally effective as a
biocontrol agent of powdery mildew (4, 9, 16). Many morpho-
logically similar species may be confused with A. quisqualis
(10). To evaluate this possibility, we examined and identified
Ampelomyces-like fungi isolated from powdery mildew and
compared these cultures with isolates identified as Ampelomy-
ces in culture collections.
Isolation and growth. Leaves of sycamore trees (Platanus
occidentalis L.) bearing infections of powdery mildew (Mi-
crosphaera penicillata (Wallr.:Fr.) Le`v.) were located in South
River, New Jersey, in July 1998. Microscopic examination of
the leaves revealed two types of pycnidia: stipitate pycnidia,
typical of A. quisqualis, and sessile pycnidia, typical of the
genus Phoma (Fig. 1) (17). Both types of pycnidia were re-
moved from leaves with fine needles and placed on potato
dextrose agar (Difco, Inc., Detroit, Mich.) containing the an-
tibiotics gentamicin (40 mg/liter), streptomycin (40 mg/liter),
and penicillin (20 mg/liter) (PDA ⫹3). Two different fungi
were consistently recovered. The stipitate pycnidia developed
into slow-growing colonies whose characteristics corresponded
to those expected for A. quisqualis (5, 11). The sessile pycnidia
developed into rapidly growing colonies whose characteristics
corresponded to those of Phoma glomerata (Cda) Wollenw. (2,
19).
Agar plugs (6 mm in diameter) of mycelia cut from the
margins of rapidly growing colonies of both the South River
Ampelomyces and South River P. glomerata isolates were trans-
ferred to five plates each of PDA⫹3 and incubated at room
temperature (21 to 22°C) for 3 weeks to measure growth rates.
We measured an average growth of 8 ⫾1 mm/day for the P.
glomerata isolates and an average growth of 0.8 ⫾0.1 mm/day
for the Ampelomyces isolates. With age, cultures of P.
FIG. 1. (A) Stipitate pycnidium of A. quisqualis (arrow). (B) Section of sessile pycnidium of P. glomerata on oak leaf (arrow). Scale bar ⫽20 m.
* Corresponding author. Mailing address: Department of Plant Pa-
thology, 386 Foran Hall, Cook College, Rutgers University, New
Brunswick, NJ 08901. Phone: (732) 932-9375, ext. 357. Fax: (732)
932-9377. E-mail: jwhite@aesop.rutgers.edu.
425
glomerata produced alternarioid dictyochlamydospores mea-
suring 41 ⫾7.5 ⫻12 ⫾1.4 m.
Inoculation experiments. Koch’s postulates (1, 3) were used
to establish the pathogenicity of P. glomerata to powdery mil-
dew. A suspension of P. glomerata conidia from cultures grown
on PDA⫹3 was made in sterile water (⬃8⫻10
6
conidia/ml).
The conidial suspension was used to inoculate epiphyllous
mycelia of the powdery mildew Phyllactinia guttata (Wallr.:Fr.)
Le`v. on intact (left on the tree) leaves of oak (Quercus coccinea
Mu¨nch.) by moistening an approximately 15-mm
2
region on
the upper surface of the leaves. Controls were repeats of this
process with sterile water. Ten replicates of both the treatment
and control were made, and the sites of inoculation were
marked by placing white tape on the reverse of the leaves at the
inoculation sites. The leaves were monitored for 30 days. Dur-
ing this time, control leaves developed powdery mildew cleis-
tothecia while all leaves treated with P. glomerata conidia de-
veloped abundant pycnidia in and around the inoculation sites
but did not produce powdery mildew cleistothecia. None of the
control leaves showed development of P. glomerata pycnidia,
and cleistothecia developed normally. To fulfill Koch’s postu-
lates, pycnidia were removed from treated leaves with fine
needles and plated on PDA⫹3 medium to recover P.
glomerata. Colonies that developed were confirmed to be P.
glomerata by observation of dictyochlamydospores, pycnidia,
and subsequent sequence analysis.
Phylogenetic analysis. The nuclear ribosomal DNA internal
transcribed spacer region 1 (ITS1) from P. glomerata, several
Ampelomyces spp., and several Phoma spp. were sequenced.
The South River P. glomerata and A. quisqualis, as well as
American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) cultures of Ampe-
lomyces heraclei (Dejeva) Rudakov (ATCC 36804) and A. quis-
FIG. 2. Maximum likelihood phylogram based on ITS region sequences between the 18S and 5.8S ribosomal DNA (ITS1). Bootstrap confidence levels (percent)
of branches are shown. The scale bar is based on a total tree length of 204. Taxa included in the analysis, GenBank numbers (if known), and their sources are as follows:
LM,L. microscopica (LMU04234); PAV,P. avenaria (PAU77357); AQ1, A. quisqualis (AQU82451, DSM [Deutsche Sammlung von Mikrooganismen und Zellkulturen
GmbH, Braunschweig, Germany] 2223); AQ2, A. quisqualis (AF126818, South River); AQ3, A. quisqualis (AF126817, ATCC 200245); AQ4, A. quisqualis (AF035782);
AQ5, A. quisqualis (AQU82449, CBS [Centraalbureau voor Schimmelcultures, Baarn, The Netherlands] 130.79); AQ6, A. quisqualis (AF035783, Ecogen AQ10); AQ7,
A. quisqualis (AF035781, CBS 131.31); AQS,A. quercinus (AF035778, ATCC 36786); PG,P. glomerata (AF126816, South River); AHE,A. heraclei (AF126819, ATCC
36804); AHU,A. humuli (AF035779, ATCC 38616); PAM,P. americana Morgan-Jones et White (AF046016); PM,P. macrostoma Mont. (AF046020); PS,P. sorghina
(Sacc.) Boerema (AF046022); DL,D. lycopersici Klebahn (AF046015); and DB,D. bryoniae (Auersw.) Rehm (AF046014).
426 SULLIVAN AND WHITE APPL.ENVIRON.MICROBIOL.
qualis (ATCC 200245), were grown on PDA⫹3. DNA extrac-
tion, amplification, and sequencing were accomplished as
described previously (14).
Several additional ITS1 sequences identified as Ampelomy-
ces spp., including Ampelomyces humuli (Fautr.) Rudakov,
Ampelomyces quercinus (Syd.) Rudakov, Phaeosphaeria avena-
ria (Weber) Eriksson, and Leptosphaeria microscopica P. Karst.
were obtained from GenBank (Fig. 2).
The SeqLab interface for the Wisconsin Package Version 9.1
(Genetics Computer Group, Madison, Wis.) was used to gen-
erate alignments and make manual adjustments. PAUP ver-
sion 4.0b2 for Macintosh (17) was used for phylogenetic anal-
ysis. Heuristic searches were performed by using maximum
parsimony (14). Bootstrapping, using the same criteria with
400 replicates, was performed to determine the confidence
levels of the inferred phylogenies. Trees found by maximum
parsimony were subjected to heuristic searches by using max-
imum likelihood criteria by the Hasegawa-Kishino-Yano
model (6) to find the most likely tree (See Treebase [http:
//herbaria.harvard.edu/treebase] submission no. SN145 for
alignment and tree construction details).
Maximum parsimony analysis resulted in ten trees. Maxi-
mum likelihood analysis of these trees resulted in one tree
(⫺lnL⫽1200, tree length ⫽204, consistency index ⫽0.78,
homoplasy index ⫽0.22, retention index ⫽0.79). The South
River P. glomerata is identical to A. heraclei and A. humuli, and
they group together with A. quercinus in the Didymella/Phoma
clade (Fig. 2). Our South River A. quisqualis isolate grouped in
the Ampelomyces clade with Ecogen’s A. quisqualis AQ10.
There was strong bootstrap support for the Ampelomyces
(90%) and Phoma (100%) clades.
Distinguishing Phoma from Ampelomyces. Stipitate pycnidia
developing into slow-growing colonies characterize A. quisqua-
lis (5, 11). Sessile pycnidia developing into rapidly growing
colonies characterize P. glomerata (2, 19). The cultures identi-
fied as A. heraclei,A. humuli, and A. quercinus are typical
representatives of their species.
The process of pycnidium formation in association with the
powdery mildew is also different between the two genera. Am-
pelomyces spp. infect conidiogenous cells of powdery mildew,
internally colonizing and forming pycnidia within the conidio-
phore; the pycnidia appear stipitate (Fig. 1). Phoma sp. does
not appear to internally infect conidiogenous cells, and pyc-
nidia are formed directly on the leaf surface; they are sessile
(Fig. 1). While many species of Phoma are plant pathogens
(17), P. glomerata is not. However, Phoma can grow saprophyt-
ically in tissues of plants and is known to be a secondary
invader of diseased tissues, perhaps feeding on fungal sapro-
phytes or pathogens of diseased tissues (12, 17, 19). P.
glomerata has been isolated from species of the powdery mil-
dew genus Microsphaera in the United States (this study) and
Russia (as A. quercinus) and from species of the genus Spha-
erotheca (as A. humuli) in Russia (15). It also has been isolated
from the downy mildew of grapes (Plasmopara viticola (Berk.
et Curt.) Berl. et De Toni) in Russia (as A. heraclei) (15). It is
apparent that P. glomerata has a widespread distribution.
Potential new mycoparasitic agent. Currently a single strain
of fungus, A. quisqualis AQ10 Biofungicide, is in commercial
use for biocontrol of powdery mildew on grapes and other
crops (7). This strain grouped within the divergent Ampelomy-
ces clade and appears to correctly represent a species of that
genus. A few reports have identified Phoma species that are
antagonistic to fungal plant pathogens. A Phoma sp. (P66A)
significantly reduced conidial germination of an apple scab
(Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) Wint.) (13), and Phoma etheridgei
Hutch. & Hirat. produced antifungal compounds inhibitory to
the tree pathogen Phellinus tremulae (Bond) Bond et Borisov
(8).
Our results suggest that P. glomerata is frequently misiden-
tified as A. quisqualis or other species of Ampelomyces. Addi-
tionally, P. glomerata often may inhabit powdery mildew infec-
tions and may be an important component of a hyperparasitic
guild of fungi that naturally infect powdery mildews. Further
study is warranted to evaluate the effectiveness of P. glomerata
in the hyperparasitic control of fungal plant pathogens.
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers. The following se-
quences were deposited in GenBank: A. quisqualis ATCC
200245 and South River, P. glomerata South River, A. heraclei
ATCC 36804. Their accession numbers are listed in the legend
for Fig. 2.
REFERENCES
1. Agrios, G. N. 1988. Plant Pathology, 3rd ed. Academic Press, Inc., San Diego,
Calif.
2. Boerema, G. H., M. M. J. Dorenbosch, and H. A. van Kesteren. 1965.
Remarks on species of Phoma referred to Peyronellaea. Persoonia 4:47–68.
3. Brock, T. D. 1988. Robert Koch, a life in medicine and bacteriology. Science
Tech Publishers, Madison, Wis.
4. Falk, S. P., D. M. Gadoury, P. Cortesi, R. C. Pearson, and R. C. Seem. 1995.
Partial control of grape powdery mildew by the mycoparasite Ampelomyces
quisqualis. Plant Dis. 79:483–490.
5. Galper, S., A. Sztejnberg, and N. Lisker. 1985. Scanning electron microscopy
of the ontogeny of Ampelomyces quisqualis pycnidia. Can. J. Microbiol.
31:961–964.
6. Hasegawa, M., H. Kishino, and T. Yano. 1985. Dating of the human-ape
splitting by a molecular clock of mitochondrial DNA. J. Mol. Evol. 21:160–
174.
7. Hofstein, R., and B. Fridlender. 1994. Development of production, formu-
lation and delivery systems, p. 1273–1280. In Brighton Crop Protection
Conference—pests and diseases, vol. 3. British Crop Protection Council,
Farnham, United Kingdom.
8. Hutchinson, L. J., P. Chakravarty, L. M. Kawchuck, and Y. Hirasuka. 1994.
Phoma etheridgei sp. nov. from black galls and cankers of trembling aspen
(Populus tremuloides) and its potential role as a bioprotectant against the
aspen decay pathogen Phellinus tremulae. Can. J. Bot. 72:1424–1431.
9. Jarvis, W. R., and K. Slingsby. 1977. The control of powdery mildew of
greenhouse cucumber by water spray and Ampelomyces quisqualis. Plant Dis.
Rep. 61:728–730.
10. Kiss, L. 1997. Genetic diversity in Ampelomyces isolates, hyperparasites of
powdery mildew fungi, inferred from RFLP analysis of the rDNA ITS re-
gion. Mycol. Res. 101:1073–1080.
11. Kiss, L., and K. K. Nakasone. 1998. Ribosomal DNA internal transcribed
spacer sequences do not support the species status of Ampelomyces quisqua-
lis, a hyperparasite of powdery mildew fungi. Curr. Genet. 33:362–367.
12. Morgan-Jones, G. 1967. Phoma glomerata.In CMI descriptions of patho-
genic fungi and bacteria no. 134. Commonwealth Mycological Institute, Kew,
United Kingdom.
13. Ouimet, A., O. Carisse, and P. Neumann. 1997. Environmental and nutri-
tional factors affecting the in vitro inhibition of the vegetative growth of
Venturia inaequalis by five antagonistic fungi. Can. J. Bot. 75:632–639.
14. Reddy, P. V., R. Patel, and J. F. White, Jr. 1998. Phylogenetic and develop-
mental evidence supporting reclassification of cruciferous pathogens Phoma
lingham and P. wasabiae in genus Plenodomus. Can. J. Bot. 76:1916–1922.
15. Rudakov, O. L. 1979. Fungi of the genus Ampelomyces Ces. Ex. Schlect.
Mikologiya i Fitopatologiya 13:104–110.
16. Sundheim, L., and A. Tronsmo. 1988. Hyperparasites in biological control, p.
53–70. In K. G. Mukerji and K. L. Garg (ed.), Biocontrol of plant diseases.
CRC Press, Boca Raton, Fla.
17. Sutton, B. C. 1980. The coelomycetes. Commonwealth Mycological Institute,
Kew, United Kingdom.
18. Swofford, D. L. 1999. PAUP*. Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and
other methods). Version 4. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Mass.
19. White, J. F., Jr., and G. Morgan-Jones. 1987. Studies in the genus Phoma.
VII. Concerning Phoma glomerata. Mycotaxon 28:437–445.
20. Yarwood, C. E. 1978. History and taxonomy of powdery mildews. In D. M.
Spencer (ed.), The powdery mildews. Academic Press, Inc., London, United
Kingdom.
VOL. 66, 2000 P. GLOMERATA AS A MYCOPARASITE OF POWDERY MILDEW 427