ArticlePDF Available

The Tongan Maritime Expansion: A Case in the Evolutionary Ecology of Social Complexity

Authors:
Shankar Aswani Canela at Rhodes University
Shankar Aswani Canela
Michael W Graves at University of New Mexico
Michael W Graves
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

The evolution of the Tongan maritime empire, involving both the development of social complexity and geographic expansion through conquest and trading, are examined by means of evolutionary ecology. This Darwinian evolutionary framework provides the mechanism and identifies the environmental structure, processes, and behavioral strategies by which to account for the geographic and temporal pattern of change in Tonga and related islands. Both ethnohistorical and archaeological data are employed in this analysis, showing how both may reveal overlapping aspects of historical change. The results of this research highlight the importance not only of competition but also of cooperative strategies in the evolution of social complexity and the process of geographic expansion. Key to explaining the evolution of Tongan social complexity are the productive but uncertain environment of Tongatapu, the location of Tongatapu in relation to other islands and prevailing winds, the smail landmass of the island, the relatively early integration of the island into a single polity, the creation of collateral ruling lineages, the appropriation of voyaging technology to redirect competition from within Tongatapu to other islands through colonization, aggression, staple and wealth goods trade, and the exchange of spouses. KEYWORDS: evolution of social complexity, evolutionary ecology, Tongan maritime complex, Polynesian archaeology, ethnohistory.
Content uploaded by Michael W Graves
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Michael W Graves on Jan 31, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
The Tongan maritime expansion: A case in the evolutionary ecology of social complexity
Aswani, Shankar;Graves, Michael W
Asian Perspectives; Fall 1998; 37, 2; Ethnic NewsWatch
pg. 135
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... The Paci c is a region where archaic states and complex chiefdoms developed outside of continental in uences (Hommon, 2014;Kirch, 1984; and the island of Tongatapu, rst occupied by people from 900 b.c. (Burley et al. 2012), was the seat of power for a dynastic polity whose in uence extended across the south west Paci c ( Fig. 1) (Aswani & Graves, 1998;Clark, 2017). Archaeological evidence and vernacular literature indicate that the Tongan polity ourished from a.d. ...
... From a.d. 1300, the island was home to the Tu'i Tonga dynasty whose territorial political institutions spread to other Paci c islands(Aswani & Graves, 1998;Clark, 2017). The high accuracy lidar data provides unprecedented data on the built environment of Tongatapu that permits a new analysis of the built environment. ...
Low-Density Urbanisation: Prestate Settlement Growth in a Pacific Society
Preprint
Full-text available
  • Oct 2023
The recognition of low-density urbanisation has been important in documenting how diverse human settlements generated enduring social and economic change. In tropical regions, the key challenges to studying low-density urbanisation have been the difficulty in acquiring past built environment data and integrating the frameworks that illuminate the social behaviours intrinsic to urbanisation. The introduction of lidar mapping and urban science methods has proven revolutionary in our understanding of low-density urbanisation as demonstrated by emerging research on settlements and states in Mesoamerica and Southeast Asia. These studies draw on urban theory to highlight patterns in the built environment associated with profound societal changes including the rise of social institutions, agglomeration effects and ongoing settlement growth. Here, we present an approach that combines lidar survey and archaeological fieldwork with recent developments in urban science to understand the built environment of Tongatapu; the location of an archaic state whose influence spread across the southwest Pacific Ocean between the thirteenth and nineteenth centuries a.d. Quantitative results show—for the first time—that settlements on a Pacific island were urbanised in a distinct low-density form, and that the processes of urbanisation began prior to state development. This study highlights the contribution of Pacific landscapes to urban science and the low-density settlement phenomena given the presence of large populations, hierarchical societies, and vast distributions of archaeological built remains on many island groups.
View
... 85; 154; 272; 296). Other authors (Aswani et al. 1998following Loeb 1926Goldman 1970) However, as all three components are interrelated under this model, I will analyze each instance of place in the context of ritual and/or symbology. ...
... In addressing my thesis directly, I have demonstrated that the Cook Islands' sphere of influence is much wider than previously thought spanning at least from Tonga to the Austral Islands to the Marquesas Islands with possible connections to Fiji, the Line Islands, and Rawiki (the Phoenix Islands). Additionally, my research into this topic has suggested that Tongan political influence reached and impacted the Cook Islands as suggested by other authors (Aswani et al. 1998following Loeb 1926Goldman 1970). This is substantiated through Oral Histories in the Cook Islands (Gill 1977(Gill [1876; Nicholas 1892). ...
Songs, Storytellers, and Science: An Examination of Long-Distance Interaction in the Cook Islands
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Mar 2020
It is widely accepted in Polynesian archaeology that contact between island groups persisted after first peopling but declined over time. However, there is not a clear sense of how the dynamics and directionality of interaction change over time. Archaeological discussions of interaction in the Cook Islands often focus on quantitative materialist data. While this is certainly valuable and critical to archaeology as a scientific discipline, I see this discussion as an opportunity to incorporate more fully more qualitative or ontologically driven data from other fields of anthropology. I intend to explore the geography, chronology, and ontology of long-distance interaction between the Cook Islands and the rest of Polynesia through materialist and ontological perspectives. One of the key factors in discussing interaction between these island groups is to examine anthropological, ethnohistoric, and oral accounts of past interactions. Incorporating the social dynamics of trade and interaction through anthropological records may provide some unique perspectives that may not be apparent in materialist data. I will use these sources to provide context and discussion about an emic understanding of interaction over space in tandem with documented material evidence that serve as proxies for these ancient interactions. The synthesis of archaeological models and traditional understanding of voyaging over space and time is the ultimate focus of this thesis. As such, the anthropological, archaeological, and predictive sides will each provide a narrative that may contradict narratives from other perspectives. However, this should not be understood as an attempt to test the truthfulness of oral traditions with archaeological evidence but rather an examination of the interaction between these different spheres providing an aggregate narrative.
View
... comm. 2011), all of which reinforce social relations [61,63]. ...
... Moreover, it is clear that environmental management has little impact on the sustainability of the agrifood chain in these societies. Although all people we met recognised that good land was important for food production, and our survey demonstrated an understanding of the need to manage 'God's resources', land access itself is utterly determined by social rules and kinship relationships both in Tonga [60,61,63] and in Solomon Islands [66,67,69,70,72,76]. In both countries, land degradation is met with movement to new kinship-based lands rather than improvements to current plots. ...
Agrifood Chains as Complex Systems and the Role of Informality in Their Sustainability in Small Scale Societies
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 2020
Agrifood chains are complex systems; they encompass biological, economic, social, health and political variables at different scales (e.g., on-farm, local, regional, national and global). Consequently, what enables a food system to achieve ‘sustainability’ is also complex. This is particularly the case in small-scale societies in developing nations which are socially constituted. In this paper we posit that a habitus of informality underpins food systems’ sustainability in these societies. We argue that conventional applications of approaches like the Triple Bottom Line (TBL) and Circles of Sustainability (CoS) frameworks fail to assist understanding of sustainability in informal socio-economic systems because they either place too much emphasis on economic growth (TBL) or underplay the strength of socio–cultural obligations and responsibilities (CoS). This is seen in international aid programs that encourage economic growth in the agrifood sector, which is challenging for villages in such societies. We review data from two Pacific Island countries—Tonga and Solomon Islands—to demonstrate the need for a more holistic way to think about sustainability in informal agrifood systems in small-scale developing nations. We demonstrate the value of employing a Hybrid Value Chain Framework for collecting information necessary to understanding how sustainability is constituted in the food systems of small-scale societies.
View
... An alternative strategy adopted by some Pacific archaeologists is to categorise explanations according to evolutionary biologist Ernst Mayr's (1961) distinction between proximate and ultimate causes (Aswani and Graves, 1998;Kirch, 2010, p. 178;Cochrane, 2018, p. 524). Mayr considered these to be fundamentally different, rather than competing, explanatory targets. ...
... But inasmuch as the prestige of chiefs derived from the deeds of voyaging ancestors, canoes and seafaring retained an association with power and the work of the gods. They would again have symbolic and practical political importance during episodes of polity expansion, naval raiding and trade network dominance during later periods (Kirch, 2010;Aswani and Graves, 1998). This, then, was not a one-way move towards landed sessility: as demonstrated elsewhere in the Pacific it was entirely possible for communities to transition away from inland regions and a political emphasis on agricultural production to form coastal chiefdoms whose politics centred on networks of maritime exchange and raiding Walter and Sheppard, 2006). ...
Pacific colonisation as process and practice
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Jul 2020
The human colonisation of the Pacific hemisphere is an enduring topic of enquiry in the archaeology of the region. Archaeologists have employed a wide variety of theoretical perspectives and evidence to gain insight into the problem, combining data from the archaeological record with computer simulation, experimental replication and ethnography, and deploying explanatory models ranging from simple culture history, to biogeographic theory, behavioural ecology and evolutionary perspectives. Here I review the dominant explanatory strategies in Pacific colonisation research, and advocate for a multi-scalar approach. Rather than being simply a history of population dispersal, I argue that colonisation is a long-term phenomenon encompassing most aspects of human-environment interactions. Colonisation is, at root, the process by which historical relationships are established between people and landscapes, and consequently involves the interaction of ecological, demographic, social, political and cultural dynamics through time. I develop a ‘marginal island network sorting’ model of Pacific colonisation, which seeks to integrate long-term causal process with changing forms of sociocultural practice.
View
... What emerges is a picture of multiple and consequential long-distance voyages between the twelfth and early fifteenth centuries, particularly on the part of Marquesans. These voyages appear to precede significant expansion of the Tongan maritime empire, which from the fifteenth century AD greatly extended its sphere of influence and increasingly engaged in expansionist warfare on an inter-archipelago scale (Aswani & Graves 1998;Clark et al. 2014). These East Polynesian transports may also pre-date significant exportation of high quality fine-grained basalt tools from Samoan quarries in the fourteenth to seventeenth centuries, which were distributed to Fiji, Tonga, Tokelau, Tuvalu, southern Cook Islands, and elsewhere (Clark et al. 2014; see also Allen & Johnson 1997;Best et al. 1992;Clark et al. 1997;Di Piazza & Pearthree 2001;Leach 1993;Walter & Sheppard 1996;Weisler et al. 2016b). ...
Marquesan ceramics, palaeotsunami, and megalithic architecture: Ho‘oumi Beach site (NHo‐3) in regional perspective
Article
  • May 2021
  • ARCHAEOL OCEAN
The iconic Ho‘oumi Beach site (NHo‐3), Nuku Hiva Island (Marquesas), was excavated by Robert Suggs in the late 1950s. It figured importantly in his island‐wide reconstruction of settlement patterns, socio‐political organisation, material culture and subsistence change – a cultural historical framework that has guided Marquesan archaeology for six decades. Ho‘oumi is also one of four Marquesan localities where prehistoric ceramics have been found. We revisited Ho‘oumi to acquire chronological and palaeoenvironmental context for two cultural occupations reported by Suggs. Eight ¹⁴ C determinations on short‐lived materials and new marine reservoir corrections are reported, and the overall series evaluated using Bayesian modelling. A single ceramic sherd, previously assigned to a Fijian source, is attributed to the thirteenth to fourteenth centuries AD – a period when Marquesans engaged in long‐distance voyaging. A significant marine inundation disrupted the associated occupation, leading to sustained coastal abandonment. Stratigraphic and historical evidence suggests this was a palaeotsunami, which may also be represented at Hane (Ua Huka Island). House pavements of the early occupation were replaced by raised megalithic house foundations, probably around the late seventeenth to mid‐eighteenth centuries AD, but material culture changes were modest. By late prehistory, mature native forest was largely replaced by secondary species and Polynesian introductions.
View
... Archaeological data indicate that while people living on Futuna consistently managed to repel aggressive Tongan maritime expansions from the S (Fig. 10a), those on Wallis were successfully occupied in the early 15th century (Aswani and Graves, 1998;Frimigacci, 2000). Goff et al. (2012d) surmised that the catalyst for this invasion was most likely related to the large Tonga-Kermadec Trench earthquake and palaeotsunami that led to widespread destruction of coastal settlements, an increase in warfare, the rise of chiefdoms and a significant resource crisis throughout the SW Pacific. ...
Palaeotsunamis in the Sino-Pacific region
Article
  • Sep 2020
  • EARTH-SCI REV
Palaeotsunami research in the Sino-Pacific region has increased markedly following the 2011 Tōhoku-oki tsunami. Recent studies encompass a variety of potential sources and cover a full range of research activities from detailed studies at individual sites through to region-wide data collation for the purposes of database development. We synthesise palaeotsunami data from around the region drawing on key examples to highlight the progress made since 2011. We focus on a wide range of spatial and temporal scales, from region-wide to local events, from multi-millennial site records to estimates of magnitude and frequency along national coastlines. The review is based on sub-regions but in reviewing the combined records highlights common events and anomalies. In doing so we identify future research opportunities and notable findings arising from our review.
View
Low-Density Urbanisation: Prestate Settlement Growth in a Pacific Society
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2024
  • J ARCHAEOL METHOD TH
The recognition of low-density urbanisation has been important in documenting how diverse human settlements generated enduring social and economic change. In tropical regions, the key challenges to studying low-density urbanisation have been the difficulty in acquiring past built environment data and integrating the frameworks that illuminate the social behaviours intrinsic to urbanisation. The introduction of lidar mapping and urban science methods has proven revolutionary in our understanding of low-density urbanisation as demonstrated by emerging research on settlements and states in Mesoamerica and Southeast Asia. These studies draw on urban theory to highlight patterns in the built environment associated with profound societal changes including the rise of social institutions, agglomeration effects, and ongoing settlement growth. Here, we present an approach that combines lidar survey and archaeological fieldwork with recent developments in urban science to understand the built environment of Tongatapu; the location of an archaic state whose influence spread across the southwest Pacific Ocean between the thirteenth and nineteenth centuries a.d. Quantitative results show—for the first time—that settlements on a Pacific island were urbanised in a distinct low-density form and that the processes of urbanisation began prior to state development. This study highlights the potential contribution of Pacific landscapes to urban science and the low-density settlement phenomena given the presence of large populations, hierarchical societies, and vast distributions of archaeological built remains on many island groups.
View
Using lidar and Bayesian inference to reconstruct archaeological populations in the Kingdom of Tonga
Article
  • Oct 2022
  • JASR
The islands of Polynesia are often seen as “natural laboratories” where population size and growth are core components of models which examine the development of Oceanic societies. As in many parts of the world, the population of Pacific Islands suffered severe declines after contact when Europeans introduced new pathogens. These rapid population declines and a historical record weighted heavily to later missionary accounts complicate estimates of population size and distribution. Here, we use lidar derived settlement data to estimate the population of the island of Tongatapu, the seat of power of the Tu‘i Tonga polity between the 13th and 19th centuries. We use a Bayesian approach to adapt the house count method and estimate population based on information from: the number and spatial distribution of households from lidar survey, archaeological transect data to determine structure function, and ethnographic records of household composition. Results indicate the population of Tongatapu was probably between 50,000 and 60,000 people, suggesting a total population living in the archipelago of between 100,000 to 120,000 people. Population estimates were compared to population retrodictions calculated with previously unanalysed historical sources to show the Tongan archipelago suffered a population decline at all island groups of approximately 70% to 86%. These results highlight the contribution lidar derived settlement data to our understanding of demography and social development.
View
UTU: Sāmoa archaeology and cultural heritage database
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2022
The Sāmoa Archaeology and Cultural Heritage Database was begun in 2016 as an ongoing means of encouraging and assisting more archaeological research in Sāmoa. It is also building a stronger engagement between the Archaeology and Cultural Heritage research and teaching programme at the Centre for Sāmoan Studies at the National University with government agencies here, and is contributing to the still incomplete processes of preparing heritage protection legislation. Known as “Utu” (meaning “a container for treasures”). The Sāmoa Archaeology and Cultural Heritage Database maps known archaeological sites and previously undocumented sites identified by surveys and analysis of LiDAR images using a global information system (GIS) program. Mapped sites are linked to information about them, including archaeological analysis, historical sources, and oral traditions and any other available information. The work so far has provided new evidence for Sāmoa's prehistory in relation to population size and distribution, settlement patterns and land use.
View
Theory in the Pacific, the Pacific in Theory: Archaeological Perspectives
Book
  • Aug 2020
Theory in the Pacific, the Pacific in Theory explores the role of theory in Pacific archaeology and its interplay with archaeological theory worldwide. The contributors assess how the practice of archaeology in Pacific contexts has led to particular types of theoretical enquiry and interest, and, more broadly, how the Pacific is conceptualised in the archaeological imagination. Long seen as a laboratory environment for the testing and refinement of social theory, the Pacific islands occupy a central place in global theoretical discourse. This volume highlights this role through an exploration of how Pacific models and exemplars have shaped, and continue to shape, approaches to the archaeological past. The authors evaluate key theoretical perspectives and explore current and future directions in Pacific archaeology. In doing so, attention is paid to the influence of Pacific people and environments in motivating and shaping theory-building. Theory in the Pacific, the Pacific in Theory makes a significant contribution to our understanding of how theory develops attuned to the affordances and needs of specific contexts, and how those contexts promote reformulation and development of theory elsewhere. It will be fascinating to scholars and archaeologists interested in the Pacific region, as well as students of wider archaeological theory.
View
Burial structures and societal ranking in Vava'u, Tonga
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 1980
  • J POLYNESIAN SOC
View
History, Phylogeny, and Evolution in Polynesia
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 1992
In the study of evolution, biological or cultural, a critical element is a methodology for distinguishing homologous from analogous characters. The historical knowledge this requires must be sought in the phylogeny of the modern groups under study and their common ancestors. Applying the methods for determining the phylogenetic relationships among cultural groups defined some years ago by Romney and Vogt to the results of recent archacological and historical linguistic work, we examine Polynesia as a well-defined case of cultural "radiation" and divergence for which the specific shared ancestral traits can be distinguished from convergent developments in response to common selection pressures. We go on to present a series of hypotheses regarding some major factors underlying divergence and convergence in Polynesia in the hope that others will be stimulated to test them and thereby advance our understanding of this region.
View
View
View
View
Trade and Its Origins on the Botletli River, Botswana
Article
  • Jul 1987
This paper discusses the causes of trade and evaluates the roles played by habitat diversity, mobility, and competition. Ethnographic and ethnohistorical evidence from the Botletli River, Botswana, is used to evaluate some general arguments. The Botletli trade is shown to be based on locational advantages, due to the habitat diversity of the region, and on other comparative advantages arising from differential access to important resources. These factors appear to have become important with increases in population density, which increased the effective habitat diversity of the region and created competition for a limited zone of valuable land.
View
View
View
View
The Evolutionary Ecology of Rotuman Political Integration
Article
  • Dec 1995
On the basis of the constructs of evolutionary ecology, this article presents an explanation for political integration during the prehistoric-protohistoric period on Rotuma, Fiji. Archaeological, ethnohistorical, and environmental data are analyzed with a geographic information system (GIS) to define the natural and social constraints according to which specific behavioral strategies conferred benefits to the people who employed them. The analysis suggests that during the prehistoric-protohistoric period chiefs from the relatively less productive, eastern side of Rotuma dominated the political arena. The integration of the island into a single, loose polity provided the eastern chiefs with social and material benefits. Because of these benefits, the eastern chiefs sought to perpetuate the political structure. Individuals from other districts participated in the hegemonic political structure because they reaped long-term benefits, suffered minimal costs, and perceived relatively fewer advantages in obtaining pan-Rotuman positions. Given the specific environmental context of this relatively isolated island, the formation of an island-wide polity provided selective advantages to its members.
View