ArticlePDF Available

Femoral Stem Placement for Total Hip Arthroplasty Using Three-Dimensional Custom Surgical Guides in Dogs: A Cadaveric Study

Georg Thieme Verlag KG
VCOT Open
Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Objective The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility and accuracy of femoral stem placement for total hip arthroplasty (THA) using three-dimensional (3D)-printed custom surgical guides (CSGs). Study Design Computed tomography (CT) scans of 7 cadaveric adult medium-sized (23.2–30.0 kg) dog femurs were acquired. A virtual plan was made using 3D models, and CSGs were designed to aid in optimal femoral stem positioning. Two surgeons with limited experience in THA performed stem implantation with CSGs for each limb. Following stem implantation, CT scans were repeated, and final stem alignment was measured and then compared with the preoperative virtual plan. Results The median difference between planned and postoperative stem alignment with CSGs was –6.2 degrees (interquartile [IQR] –15.2 to 2.1 degrees) for stem version, 2.3 degrees (IQR –0.6 to 3.9 degrees) for varus/valgus angulation, and 1.8 degrees (IQR –0.1 to 2.9 degrees) for cranial/caudal stem angulation. The median difference in stem depth was 1.5 mm (IQR –1.2 to 3.1). Mean surgical procedure time for CSG surgeries was 44.1 ± 20.5 minutes for femoral stem implantation. Conclusion The use of CSGs resulted in successful femoral stem placement by two novice THA surgeons. Novice THA surgeons may benefit from CSGs in the learning stages of THA, but further investigation is recommended prior to clinical implementation.
This content is subject to copyright.
Femoral Stem Placement for Total Hip
Arthroplasty Using Three-Dimensional Custom
Surgical Guides in Dogs: A Cadaveric Study
Jose Carvajal1Sarah Timko1Stanley E. Kim1Daniel D. Lewis1Hae Beom Lee2
1DepartmentofSmallAnimalClinicalSciences,UniversityofFlorida,
College of Veterinary Medicine, Gainesville, Florida, United States
2Department of Veterinary Surgery, Chungnam National University,
Yuseong-gu, Daejeon, The Republic of Korea
VCOT Open 2024;7:e80e86.
Address for correspondence Jose Carvajal, DVM, MS, DACVS-SA,
Department of Small Animal Clinical Sciences, University of Florida,
College of Veterinary Medicine, Gainesville, FL 32611, United States
(e-mail: josecarvajal@u.edu).
Introduction
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a well-accepted treatment
option for a variety of hip disorders in dogs.1While the overall
success rates range from 80 to 98% and can lead to excellent
surgical outcomes, major complications requiring additional
surgery are common.24Many of these complications are
related to imprecise execution of the procedure, particularly
for the femoral component (stem).5Accurate stem orientation
and the level of the femoral head ostectomy (FHO) are impor-
tant factors for the reduction of complication rates,3as poor
stem alignment can increase the risk of intraoperative com-
plications such as ssuring or fracture, or placement of an
undersized stem predisposing to subsidence with subsequent
luxation or ssuring/fracture.16
Surgical prociency in THA in dogs is associated with a
steep learning cur ve.7,8 Consequently, inexperienced sur-
geons or low-volume surgeons have an increased chance of
encountering complications. Interestingly, evidence that re-
duction in complication rates may not be directly correlated to
increasing individual surgeons experience has also been
published.9Furthermore, the known challenges associated
Keywords
total hip arthroplasty
total hip replacement
total joint
replacement
3D-printed guides
dog
Abstract Objective The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility and accuracy of femoral
stem placement for total hip arthroplasty (THA) using three-dimensional (3D)-printed
custom surgical guides (CSGs).
Study Design Computed tomography (CT) scans of 7 cadaveric adult medium-sized
(23.230.0 kg) dog femurs were acquired. A virtual plan was made using 3D models,
and CSGs were designed to aid in optimal femoral stem positioning. Two surgeons with
limited experience in THA performed stem implantation with CSGs for each limb.
Following stem implantation, CT scans were repeated, and nal stem alignment was
measured and then compared with the preoperative virtual plan.
Results The median difference between planned and postoperative stem alignment
with CSGs was 6.2 degrees (interquartile [IQR] 15.2 to 2.1 degrees) for stem version,
2.3 degrees (IQR 0.6 to 3.9 degrees) for varus/valgus angulation, and 1.8 degrees (IQR
0.1 to 2.9 degrees) for cranial/caudal stem angulation. The median difference in stem
depth was 1.5 mm (IQR 1.2 to 3.1). Mean surgical procedure time for CSG surgeries
was 44.1 20.5 minutes for femoral stem implantation.
Conclusion The use of CSGs resulted in successful femoralstem placement by two novice
THA surgeons. Novice THA surgeons may benet from CSGs in the learning stages of THA,
but further investigation is recommended prior to clinical implementation.
received
April 8, 2024
accepted after revision
May 15, 2024
DOI https://doi.org/
10.1055/s-0044-1787746.
ISSN 2625-2325.
© 2024. The Author(s).
This is an open access article published by Thieme under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License, permitting unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction so long as the original work is properly cited.
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
Georg Thieme Verlag KG, digerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart,
Germany
Original Article
THIEME
e80
Article published online: 2024-06-25
with press-t THA have led to the implementation of adapta-
tions such as prophylactic cerclage and/or plating, use of
hybrid components, as well as proprietary system adaptations
such as collars and interlocking lateral bolts to minimize the
incidence of some common complications.10,11
The role of computer-assisted design (CAD) software in
surgical planning, surgeon training, custom surgical guide
(CSG) development, and robotic-assisted surgery is quickly
expanding in human arthroplasty.1215 CSGs have been used
in veterinary medicine and have showed improved surgical
accuracy in a wide variety of applications,1620 but to our
knowledge, no study has assessed virtual arthroplasty plan-
ning or CSGs for THA in dogs.
The purpose of this cadaveric study was to determine
whether CAD software could be used for virtual femoral
stem templating and to assess the feasibility and accuracy of
three-dimensional (3D) CSGs for stem placement by inexperi-
enced THA surgeons in cadaveric dogs. We hypothesized that
CAD software could be used to successfully plan femoral stem
size, that stem alignment would be within acceptable ranges.5
Materials and Methods
Preoperative Planning
Seven medium to large mixed breed dogs that were eutha-
nized for reasons unrelated to the study were used. This study
was approved by the institutional animal care and use
committee (#201910714). Following euthanasia, Computed
tomographic (CT) scans of the pelvis and hindlimbs were
acquired, dogs werethen kept fresh in a cooler at 4°C following
imaging prior to surgery during CSG development. Digital
Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) les
were segmented, volume rendered, and exported as stereo-
lithography les to the CAD software (3-Matic, Materialize N.
V., Leuven, Belgium) for virtual planning. In addition, concur-
rent 3D models of press-t cementless femoral stems (BFX,
Biomedtrix, Boston, Massachusetts, United States) were avail-
able for templating using the same software. A modied
femoral stem virtual plan using CAD software was executed
following current published guidelines.21 Once the virtual
surgical plan was determined satisfactory by an experienced
THA surgeon (Stanley Kim) (Fig. 1), the virtual ostectomy
and virtual femoral broaching guides were designed.
Virtual Guide Design and Printing
The ostectomy guide was created with features that would
help ensure secure attachment to the femur and precise
ostectomy location (Fig. 2). The broaching guide was
designed to assist in canal preparation starting with initial
entry point drilling of the trochanteric fossa, reaming,
broaching, and nal stem placement (Fig. 3).
All components were fabricated in ABS-M30i (Stratasys,
Eden Prairie, Minnesota, United States) using a Fortus 450MC
printer (Stratasys) using a biocompatible, production-grade
thermoplastic (ABS M30i, Stratasys Inc).
Surgical Procedure
The surgical procedures were performed by a rst-year small
animal surgery resident (Jose Carvajal) and a board-certied
surgeon (Daniel Lewis). Neither individual had previous ex-
perience as a primary surgeon with cementless THA. Each
surgeon operated on femurs for each dog at random using the
CSGs thereby modifying the traditional technique as previ-
ously described.21 Surgical assistance was provided by one
Fig. 1 Virtual plan. Modied vir tual templating plan using three-dimensional rendered models of cadaveric femur and press-t femoral stem in
the coronal (A), sagittal (B), and axial (C)plane.
VCOT Open Vol. 7 No. 1/2024 © 2024. The Author(s).
3D-Printed Subject-Specific Guides for Canine Total Hip Arthroplasty Carvajal et al. e81
veterinary student (Sarah Timko) who had no prior experi-
ence with THA, and a small animal surgeon (Hae Lee) who had
signicant experience with Zurich Cementless THA system
(Kyon Veterinary Surgical Products, Boston, Massachusetts,
United States). For each procedure, dogs were placed in lateral
recumbency, the surgical leg was clipped with a number 40
blade and draped, and a routine craniolateral approach to the
hip was performed.21 Craniocaudal and lateromedial views of
the 3D digital bone model and virtually implanted stem
(including size of the stem) were available to the surgeon
intraoperatively. The pelvic muscularity of each cadaveric dog
was determined on a scale from 1 (severe atrophy), 2 (mild
atrophy), 3 (normal), to 4 (very muscular).
For the modied CSGs procedures, the ostectomy guide
was placed on the cranioproximal femoral head and neck. A
partial take-downof the vastus lateralis along the cranial
aspect of the greater trochanter was performed to allow
proper placement of the CSGs. The guidest was conrmed
to be ush with the femoral head and neck at the proximal,
distal, medial, and lateral aspects of the guide and was
secured into place with Kirschner wires. The ostectomy
was created by keeping the saw blade in contact with the
cutting shelf (Fig. 4A). Once completed, the two trochan-
teric Kirschner wires were left in situ for placement of the
broaching guide. The broaching guide was placed over the
trochanteric Kirschner wires and secured in place with an
additional trochanteric post. Proper t was conrmed when
the guides safety shelf sat ush with the osteotomy surface.
After initial drilling with a 5-mm drill bit, the drill post was
cut and removed for subsequent reaming and broaching. The
femoral broach was aligned by the surgeon using the broach-
ing guides alignment posts as a reference in the coronal,
sagittal, and axial planes (Fig. 4B). Placement of both
guides was subjectively graded by each surgeon as easy,
moderate, or difcult. Procedural advice during the ostec-
tomy, reaming, or broaching by either assistant during CSGs
procedures was not permitted. Final stem size was planned
Fig. 2 Virtual ostectomy guide and plan. The guide was contoured to
the femoral head and neck and designed to be secured into place with
two converging Kirschner wire (k-wire) slots (adjacent to white
asterisk), and two parallel trochanteric slots for added stability
(adjacent to black asterisk). The cutting shelf has a 1-mm slot at an
equivalent plane to the preplanned ostectomy (white arrowhead),
with an trochanteric overhangcutting shelf when indicated (black
arrowhead). (B) The ostectomy plane (green) is ush to the shoulder
of the press-t stem (blue) ensuring adequate room between the
stem and cortical bone in the craniomedial plane.
Fig. 3 Virtual femoral broaching guide. (A) The guide is contoured to the calcar region following ostectomy of the femoral head and neck.
It features the same two parallel trochanteric posts (adjacent to black asterisk) in (Fig. 2A) with a single converging post (white asterisk)
for added stability. A drill post was designed for guiding of the initial entr y point into the trochanteric fossa (black arrow), an aiming post
intended to provide the surgeon with the ideal sagittal and coronal stem axiality (white arrowhead), a shorter versionshaft positioned
on the aiming post (black arrowhead), and a broaching safety shelf(white arrow) resting on the ostectomy surface (green) with a
crescent-shaped component corresponding to the idealcentralpositionoftheterminalbroachandstem.(B) The aiming post is coaxial to the
stem (blue) in the coronal plane. (C) The aiming post is coaxial to the stem in the sagittal plane. (D) The version shaft is 90 degrees to the stem
orientation in the axial plane, and the drill post marks the ideal drilling location based on the center of the stem.
VCOT Open Vol. 7 No. 1/2024 © 2024. The Author(s).
3D-Printed Subject-Specific Guides for Canine Total Hip Arthroplasty Carvajal et al.e82
based on preoperative template or when contact was made
between broach and medial aspect of the safety shelf
(Fig. 4C). After the stem placement was completed, the
femur was dissected from the surrounding tissue for post-
operative CT imaging.
The time was recorded for each component of the proce-
dures including: the approach (skin incision to the exposure
of the femoral head and neck), guide placement (placement
of the guides on the femur until they were secured with
Kirschner wires), the ostectomy, canal preparation (initial
drilling to terminal broaching), and stem placement (stem
placement until press-t is achieved).
CT Analysis and Data Collection
CT scans of the femurs with implanted stems were acquired,
and the DICOM images were exported to the CAD software
3-Matic. The postoperative CT images were measured and
compared with the preoperative plan by superimposing
the pre- and postoperative femurs using a translational
function and calculating the degree of difference between
the two implants in the x,y,andzplanes (Fig. 5). The
variables assessed included stem angulation in the coronal
(Stem
cor
) plane with negative values indicating varus, in the
sagittal (Stem
sag
) plane with negative values indicating
cranial angulation, and in the axial (Stem
ax
)planewith
negative values indicating normo-version or retro-version
(>15 degrees). Additionally, s tem depth and the Hausdor ff
distance (HD), which is dened as the degree of mismatch
between two data sets, were used to assess the degree of
positioning error between the preoperative and postopera-
tive models.
Statistics
For continuous numeric data, normality was evaluated using
the ShapiroWilk test. Continuous, numeric nonparametric
data sets were summarized as median and range. Differences
between surgeons were not investigated.
Results
Surgical Procedure
Seven BFX femoral stem implants were placed in seven
medium to large mix breed cadavers, with average body-
weight o f 25.6 kg (3.6). Five stems of the correct size were
inserted, while two were undersized compared with preop-
erative planning. Results of individual dogs muscularity,
difculty of guide placement, total surgical time (minutes),
maximum HD, vir tual stem size, and nal stem size are l isted
in Table 1. Mean surgical procedure time for CSG surgeries
was 44.1 20.5 minutes.
CT Analysis
Results for stem alignment are available in Fig. 6.The
median difference between planned and postoperative
stem alignment with CSGs was 6.2 degr ees (interquartile
[IQR] 15.2 to 2.1 degrees) for stem version, 2.3 degrees (IQR
0.6 to 3.9 degrees) for varus/valgus angulation, and
1.8 degrees (IQR 0.1 to 2.9 degrees) for cranial/ caudal
stem angulation. The median difference in stem depth was
1.5 mm (IQR 1.2 to 3.1). The mean HD difference was 0.68.
Discussion
The implementation of a virtual plan and use of CSGs was
feasible for femoral stem implantation in all cadavers. Fur-
ther investigation should be considered for the use of CSGs as
they may be useful for inexperienced TH A surgeons. The nal
stem position was acceptable in all cases, and no major
intraoperative complications occurred during the femoral
preparation process.
Fig. 4 Intraoperative images. (A) The sagittal saw blade is sitting ush to the cutting shelf while performing the ostectomy. (B)Thefemoral
broach is coaxial to the aiming post, and the version shaft is coaxial to the cemented stem impactor. (C) Final stem implantation with the
femoral broaching guide on. Note the drill post is removed following initial drilling.
VCOT Open Vol. 7 No. 1/2024 © 2024. The Author(s).
3D-Printed Subject-Specific Guides for Canine Total Hip Arthroplasty Carvajal et al. e83
The ability to accurately predict implant size for THA is of
paramount importance.112 In this study, the implanted
stem size matched the virtual plan exactly in 5/7 femurs,
and was within one size in the remaining 2 femurs. In the two
procedures in which the nal stem size was one size smaller
than the virtual plan, the smaller stem was selected intra-
operatively because the broach met with the safety shelf of
the broaching guide. Additionally, these two stems were
malaligned in the frontal and sagittal planes. Therefore, the
down-sized stems in the two cases reect issues with canal-
prep execution, rather than inconsistent preoperative plan-
ning. In addition to predicting stem size, this 3D virtual plan
allowed for assessment of coronal, sagittal, and axial posi-
tioning of the femur for each case. This approach therefore
overcomes the limitations of radiography, which can lead to
variability associ ated with positioning of the femur.5Altering
stem anteversion changes the concurrent two-dimensional
geometry of the stem in the coronal and sagittal plane, and
this is not accounted for with traditional radiographic tem-
plating. Although the pur pose of the present study was not to
compare the accuracy of the CAD virtual plan in predicting
implant size to an accepted method of templating, such a
comparison study may be warranted.
This study aimed to explore the feasibility of CSGs for THA,
with the long-term goal of determining realistic applications
and capabilities of CSGs in the clinical setting. The ostectomy
guide was designed to ensure a smooth and controlled ostec-
tomy height and orientation. In this study, characteristics of
the ostectomy were not able to be adequately assessed due to
image scatter artifact from the impacted stems in the postop-
erative models. The attempt to interpret variablessuch as stem
height and HD distances to assess the ostectomy were
Fig. 5 Postoperative stem alignment assessment. Superimposed virtual plan (blue) and postoperative (red) stem models over the preoperative cadaveric
femur model. Using a translational feature, The Hausdorff distance (HD) between the two implants in the coronal (A), sagittal (B), and axial (C)
orientations was assessed. Note that the red stem is smaller (one size) due to the degree of varus and caudal malalignment.
Table 1 Resultsofindividualdogsmuscularity
Dog Muscularity Guide placement (ostectomy/broaching) Surgical time (min) Virtual stem size Final stem size
14 Easy/difcult 52.7 9 9
22 Easy/easy 33.5 8 8
3 3 Easy/moderate 40.8 7 7
44 Moderate/difcult 50.4 8 7
53 Easy/difcult 47.7 9 9
61 Easy/easy 32.1 8 8
74 Easy/difcult 51.6 10 9
Note: Results of individual dogsmuscularity(1¼severe atrophy, 2¼mild atrophy, 3 ¼normal, 4 ¼very muscular), difculty of guide placement,
total surgical time, virtual stem size and nal st em size. ( mm) ¼millimeter.
VCOT Open Vol. 7 No. 1/2024 © 2024. The Author(s).
3D-Printed Subject-Specific Guides for Canine Total Hip Arthroplasty Carvajal et al.e84
ultimately not pursued due to the low number of cases, type 2
error, and the variability in virtual and nal stem sizes in two
cases. However, the use of the ostectomy guide was easy, fast
when compared with the broaching guide, and subjectively
added a signicantdegree of condence. In the clinical setting,
CSGs may be especially useful in cases with severe secondary
changes and distorted anatomical landmarks.
The broaching guide was designedto give the surgeonvisual
references for controlling stem alignment in all three planes,
rather than relying on assistants visual references (in the
sagittal plane). In our postoperative analysis, Stem
ax
had the
greatest degree of error, where there was a tendency to place
the stems in normo-version rather than the planned ante-
version, which may predispose to changes in gait and medial
patellar luxation in clinical patients. The potential reason why
version was most inaccurate despite the availability of a
version shaft is that normo-version is generally the path of
least resistance during broaching, and small deviations from
the plan are difcult to observe intraoperatively.
One potential benet of the design explored in this study
was the ability for the surgeon to rely solely on the broaching
guide for alignment in all three planes. Clinical cases with
excessive femoral procurvatum may benet from CSGs as an
alternative to relying on an assistant to determine sagittal
alignment. Another feature of the broaching guide, its safety
shelf, was created with the intention to help preserve
craniomedial bone stock by giving a visual warningto
the surgeon to lateralize broaching/rasping. However, canal
preparation still requires an active effort that requires haptic
feedback and early recognition of malalignment currently
only gained through experience, something that was not able
to be overcome by the safety shelf, as evident in two guided
cases that required implantation of a smaller stem due to
interference with the safety shelf.
The rationale for including an experienced board-certied
surgeon and a resident was an attempt to demonstrate the
accuracy of the guides in a representative spectrum of
potential novice THA surgeons, rather than to distinguish
differences between the two surgeons. A conicting factor is
that the resident (Jose Carvajal) was the primary designer of
the guides and gained substantial familiarity with the press-
t system and procedure through the design process. Possi-
ble alternative study designs may demonstrate notable
differences between surgeons, or between guided or free-
handed procedures, especially if an independent guide de-
signer is excluded from the surgical procedure.
The wide range in surgical time can be contributed to the
additional t ime for soft tissue disse ction and ensuring proper
t of the guides, especially the broaching guide. The longest
surgeries were docu mented in the heavily muscled dogs with
prominent quadriceps and gluteal musculature, which re-
quired a relatively more extensive vastus take-down, and
imposed challenges by interferi ng with the drill post pos ition
of the broaching guide. In the clinical setting, patients with
notable pelvic limb muscular atrophy may be better candi-
dates for CSGs given the subjective easier t and shorter
Fig. 6 Degree of error between pre- and postoperative implant placement. Each data point represents the degree of error measured for an
individual dog (yellow ¼dog 1, red ¼dog 2, blue ¼dog 3, purple ¼dog 4, black ¼dog 5, green ¼dog 6, gray ¼dog 7).
VCOT Open Vol. 7 No. 1/2024 © 2024. The Author(s).
3D-Printed Subject-Specific Guides for Canine Total Hip Arthroplasty Carvajal et al. e85
surgical times of dogs with low muscularity scores in this
study.
There are several limitations to our study: Cadaveric dogs
do not adequately replicate many factors affecting femoral
preparation and stem implantation that may be encountered
in clinical cases. Additionally, only one guide design (one
ostectomy and one broaching guide) was tested. Further-
more, the study was not sufciently powered to nd indi-
vidual differences between surgeons, and despite surgery
being performed by novice surgeons, the planning was
veried by an experienced arthroplasty surgeon, likely af-
fecting outcomes. Finally, potential benets of 3D-printed
guides should be weighted against the increased nancial
costs and the possibility of potential complications associat-
ed with increased surgical times, such as periprosthetic joint
infections.22 It should be mentioned that CSGs may give the
false idea that the surgery is more accessible and can be
performed without prior experience. Instead, the perfor-
mance of these surgeries with CSGs requires considerable
expertise, familiarity with the multiple anatomical, patho-
logical, and CSG variables, as well as the ability to make
unplanned intraoperative decisions. Ultimately, it is likely
that this cohort is not reective of some of the challenges
encountered in clinical cases as the use of cadavers allows for
less soft tissue resistance, better exposure and elevation of
the femur, and lack of bony/periarticular pathology that
affects stem implantation in clinical cases.
In summary, CT-based virtual templating may be a prom-
ising preoperative tool for THA in dogs, and implementation
of CSGs resulted in acceptable accuracy of femoral stem
placement without the occurrence of major intraoperative
complications. Further investigation in the use of 3D model
templating and the application of 3D CSGs by novice THA
surgeons is encouraged prior to clinical application.
Funding
None of the authors of this article has a nancial or
personal relationship with other people or organizations
that could inappropriately inuence or bias the content of
the paper.
Conict of Interest
None declared.
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by the Edward DeBartolo Gift to
the University of Florida.
References
1Olmstead ML. Total hip replacement. Vet Clin North Am Small
Anim Pract 1987;17(04):943955
2Ganz SM, Jackson J, VanEnkevort B. Risk factors for femoral
fracture after canine press-t cementless total hip arthroplasty.
Vet Surg 2010;39(06):688695
3Nelson LL, Dyce J, Shott S. Risk factors for ventral luxation in
canine total hip replacement. Vet Surg 2007;36(07):644653
4Dyce J, Wisner ER, Wang Q, Olmstead ML. Evaluation of risk factors
for luxation after total hip replacement in dogs. Vet Surg 2000;29
(06):524532
5Townsend S, Kim SE, Pozzi A. Effect of stem sizing and position on
short-term complications with canine press t cementless total
hip arthroplasty. Vet Surg 2017;46(06):803811
6Pernell RT, Gross RS, Milton JL, et al. Femoral strain distribution
and subsidence after physiological loading of a cemen tless canine
femoral prosthesis: the effects of implant orientation, canal ll,
and implant t. Vet Surg 1994;23(06):503518
7Hayes GM, Ramirez J, Langley Hobbs SJ. Use of the cumulative
summation technique to quantitatively assess a surgical learning
curve: canine total hip replacement. Vet Surg 2011;40(01):15
8Franklin SP, Miller NA, Riecks T. Complications with the Zurich
canine total hip replacement system in an initial series of cases
performed by a single surgeon. Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2021;
34(05):346351
9Kidd SW, Preston CA, Moore GE. Complications of porous-coated
press-t cementless total hip replacement in dogs. Vet Comp
Orthop Traumatol 2016;29(05):402408
10 Israel SK, Liska WD. Outcome of canine cementless collared stem
totalhip replacementwith proximal femoral periprosthetic cerclage
application: 184 consecutive cases. Vet Surg 2022;51(02):270278
11 Buks Y, Wendelburg KL, Stover SM, Garcia-Nolen TC. The effects of
interlocking a universal hip cementless stem on implant subsi-
dence and mechanical properties of cadaveric canine femora. Vet
Surg 2016;45(02):155164
12 Schneider AK, Pierrepont JW, Hawdon G, McMahon S. Clinical
accuracy of a patient-specic femoral osteotomy guide in minimal-
ly-invasive posterior hip arthroplasty. Hip Int 2018;28(06):636641
13 Chang JD, Kim IS, Bhardwaj AM, Badami RN. The evolution of
computer-assisted total hip arthroplasty and relevant applica-
tions. Hip Pelvis 2017;29(01):114
14 Kumar P, Vatsya P.R ajnish RK, Hooda A , Dhillon MS. Application of
3D printing in hip and knee arthroplasty: a narrative review.
Indian J Orthop 2021;55(Suppl 1):S14S26
15 Pelliccia L, Lorenz M, Heyde CE, et al. A cadaver-based biomechan-
ical model of acetabulum reaming for surgical virtual reality
training simulators. Sci Rep 2020;10(01):14545
16 Hall EL, Baines S, Bilmont A, Oxley B. Accuracy of patient-specic
three-dimensional-printed osteotomy and reduction guides for
distal femoral osteotomy in dogs with medial patella lu xation. Vet
Surg 2019;48(04):584591
17 Hamilton-Bennett SE, Oxley B, Behr S. Accuracy of a patient-
specic 3D printed drill guide for placement of cervical trans-
pedicular screws. Vet Surg 2018;47(02):236242
18 Lynch AC, Davies JA. Percutaneous tibial fracture reduction using
computed tomography imaging, computer modelling and 3D
printed alignment constructs: a cadaveric study. Vet Comp
Orthop Traumatol 2019;32(02):139148
19 Worth AJ, Crosse KR, Kersley A. Computer-assisted surgery using
3D printed saw guides for acute correction of antebrachial angu lar
limb deformities in dogs. Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2019;32
(03):241249
20 Roh YH, Cho CW, Ryu CH, Lee JH, Jeong SM, Lee HB. Comparison
between novice and experienced surgeons performing corrective
osteotomy with patient-specic guides in dogs based on res ulting
position accuracy. Vet Sci 2021;8(03):40
21 BioMedtrix Inc. Canine Modular Total Hip Replacement System,
Surgical Protocol for BFX. Cementless Application. Boonton, NJ:
BioMedtrix Inc.; 2008
22 Scigliano NM, Carender CN, Glass NA, Deberg J, Bedard NA.
Operative time and risk of surgical site infection and peripros-
thetic joint infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Iowa Orthop J 2022;42(01):155161
VCOT Open Vol. 7 No. 1/2024 © 2024. The Author(s).
3D-Printed Subject-Specific Guides for Canine Total Hip Arthroplasty Carvajal et al.e86
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Corrective osteotomy has been applied to realign and stabilize the bones of dogs with lameness. However, corrective osteotomy for angular deformities requires substantial surgical experience for planning and performing accurate osteotomy. Three-dimensional printed patient-specific guides (3D-PSGs) were developed to overcome perioperative difficulties. In addition, novices can easily use these guides for performing accurate corrective osteotomy. We compared the postoperative results of corrective osteotomy accuracy when using 3D-PSGs in dogs between novice and experienced surgeons. We included eight dogs who underwent corrective osteotomy: three angular deformities of the radius and ulna, three distal femoral osteotomies, one center of rotational angle-based leveling osteotomy, and one corrective osteotomy with stifle arthrodesis. All processes, including 3D bone modeling, production of PSGs, and rehearsal surgery were carried out with computer-aided design software and a 3D-printed bone model. Pre- and postoperative positions following 3D reconstruction were evaluated by radiographs using the 2D/3D registration technique. All patients showed clinical improvement with satisfactory alignment and position. Postoperative accuracy evaluation revealed no significant difference between novice and experienced surgeons. PSGs are thought to be useful for novice surgeons to accurately perform corrective osteotomy in dogs without complications.
Article
Full-text available
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a highly successful surgical procedure, but complications remain, including aseptic loosening, early dislocation and misalignment. These may partly be related to lacking training opportunities for novices or those performing THA less frequently. A standardized training setting with realistic haptic feedback for THA does not exist to date. Virtual Reality (VR) may help establish THA training scenarios under standardized settings, morphology and material properties. This work summarizes the development and acquisition of mechanical properties on hip reaming, resulting in a tissue-based material model of the acetabulum for force feedback VR hip reaming simulators. With the given forces and torques occurring during the reaming, Cubic Hermite Spline interpolation seemed the most suitable approach to represent the nonlinear force–displacement behavior of the acetabular tissues over Cubic Splines. Further, Cubic Hermite Splines allowed for a rapid force feedback computation below the 1 ms hallmark. The Cubic Hermite Spline material model was implemented using a three-dimensional-sphere packing model. The resulting forces were delivered via a human–machine-interaction certified KUKA iiwa robotic arm used as a force feedback device. Consequently, this novel approach presents a concept to obtain mechanical data from high-force surgical interventions as baseline data for material models and biomechanical considerations; this will allow THA surgeons to train with a variety of machining hardness levels of acetabula for haptic VR acetabulum reaming.
Article
Background: The purpose of this study was to perform a systematic review and meta-analysis on the association between operative time and peri-prosthetic joint infection (PJI) after primary total hip arthroplasty (THA) and total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Methods: PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane CENTRAL databases were searched for relevant articles dating 2000-2020. Relationship of operative time and PJI rate in primary total joint arthroplasty (TJA) was evaluated by pooled odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals. Results: Six studies were identified for meta-analysis. TJA lasting greater than 120 minutes had greater odds of PJI (OR, 1.63 [1.00-2.66], p=0.048). Similarly, there were greater odds of PJI for TJA procedures lasting greater than 90 minutes (OR, 1.65 [1.27-2.14]; p<0.001). Separate analyses of TKA (OR, 2.01 [0.76-5.30]) and THA (OR, 1.06 [0.80-1.39]) demonstrated no difference in rates of PJI in cases of operative time ≥ 120 minutes versus cases < 120 minutes (p>0.05 for all). Using any surgical site infection (SSI) as an endpoint, both TJA (OR, 1.47 [1.181.83], p<0.001) and TKA (OR, 1.50 [1.08-2.08]; p=0.016) procedures lasting more versus less than 120 minutes demonstrated significantly higher odds of SSI. Conclusion: Following TJA, rates of SSI and PJI are significantly greater in procedures ≥120 minutes in duration relative to those < 120 minutes. When analyzing TKA separately, higher rates of SSI were observed in procedures ≥ 120 minutes in duration relative to those <120 minutes. Rates of PJI in TKA or THA procedures alone were not significantly impacted by operative time. Level of Evidence: V.
Article
Objective To report outcomes of cementless collared stem total hip replacement (THR) with proximal femoral periprosthetic cerclage application in dogs. Study design Retrospective case series. Animals Client-owned dogs (n = 150) with THR (n = 184). Methods Serial postoperative radiographs and medical records of dogs that underwent consecutive index cementless THR, with a single full cerclage wire placed distal to the femoral neck osteotomy line and proximal to the lesser trochanter, were reviewed for intraoperative and postoperative complications. Results No proximal femoral fractures occurred. No complications associated with the use of the cerclage wire were encountered. A fissure (n = 1) or fractures (n = 2) occurred near the tip of the femoral stem in three cases postoperatively. All three cases required plate and screw fixation. All dogs returned to subjectively normal function at home and all owners were satisfied with the outcome. Conclusion A single full cerclage wire may minimize the risk of a proximal femur fracture following cementless collared stem total hip replacement in dogs. No complications were encountered with the cerclage wire. Clinical significance Application of a cerclage wire is a simple and economically feasible procedure that requires minimal additional instrumentation, takes little time, and may decrease the risk of proximal femur fractures after cementless press-fit THR.
Article
Objective The aim of this study was to quantify the complications using the Zurich total hip replacement system in an initial series of cases performed by a single surgeon who had experience with other total hip replacement systems. Materials and Methods This was a retrospective study in which complications were classified as major if any treatment was needed or if the outcome was less than near-normal function. Complications that did not warrant treatment and that did not result in function that was inferior to near-normal were considered minor. Outcomes were assessed by radiographic review, physical examination, subjective gait evaluation or, in one case, by objective gait analysis. Bilateral total hip replacements were considered separate procedures. Results The first 21 procedures in 19 dogs performed by a single surgeon were included. The mean time to follow-up was 48 weeks (range: 8–120 weeks; standard deviation: 36 weeks). Two cases (of 21) experienced major complications including one dog with excess internal femoral rotation during weight bearing and one dog having luxation. One case (of 21) had a minor complication; femoral fracture in the presence of an intact bone plate that maintained alignment and healed without treatment. Clinical Significance A high rate of successful outcomes with few major complications can be obtained in the initial cases treated using the Zurich total hip replacement system for surgeons with prior experience with other total hip replacement systems.
Article
Introduction Ideal surgical positioning and placement of implants during arthroplasty are crucial for long-term survival and optimal functional outcomes. Inadequate bone stock or defects, and anatomical variations can influence the outcomes. Three-dimensional printing (3DP) is an evolving technology that could provide patient-specific instrumentation and implants for arthroplasty, taking into account anatomical variations and defects. However, its application in this field is still not adequately studied and described. The present review was conceptualised to assess the practicality, the pros and cons and the current status of usage of 3DP in the field of hip and knee arthroplasties and joint reconstruction surgeries. Methods A PubMed database search was conducted and a total number of 135 hits were obtained, out of which only 30 articles were relevant. These 30 studies were assessed to obtain the qualitative evidence of the applicability and the current status of 3D printing in arthroplasty. Results Currently, 3DP is used for preoperative planning with 3D models, to assess bone defects and anatomy, to determine the appropriate cuts and to develop patient-specific instrumentation and implants (cages, liners, tibial base plates, femoral stem). Its models can be used for teaching and training young surgeons, as well as patient education regarding the surgical complexities. The outcomes of using customised instrumentations and implants have been promising and 3D printing can evolve into routine practice in the years to come. Conclusion 3D printing in arthroplasty is an evolving field with promising results; however, current evidence is insufficient to determine significant advantages that can be termed cost effective and readily available.
Article
Objective The aim of this study was to report the use of custom saw guides produced using computed tomographic imaging (CT), computer simulation and three-dimensional (3D) printing to aid surgical correction of antebrachial deformities in six dogs. Materials and Methods Antebrachial limb deformities in four small, and two large, breed dogs (seven limbs) were surgically corrected by a radial closing wedge ostectomy and ulnar osteotomy. The location and orientation of the wedge ostectomy were determined using CT data, computer-assisted planning and production of a saw guide in plastic using a 3D printer. At surgery, the guide was clamped to the surface of the radius and used to direct the oscillating saw blade. The resultant ostectomy was closed and stabilized with a bone plate. Results Five limbs healed without complications. One limb was re-operated due to a poorly resolved rotational component of the deformity. One limb required additional stabilisation with external fixation due to screw loosening. The owners of five dogs completed a Canine Orthopedic Index survey at a follow-up period of 37 to 81 months. The median preoperative score was 3.5 and the median postoperative score was 1, representing an overall positive effect of surgery. Radiographically, 5/7 limbs were corrected in the frontal plane (2/7 were under-corrected). Similarly, 5/7 limbs were corrected in the sagittal plane, and 2/7 were over-corrected in the sagittal place. Conclusions Computer-aided design and rapid prototyping technologies can be used to create saw guides to simplify one-stage corrective osteotomies of the antebrachium using internal fixation in dogs. Despite the encouraging results, accurate correction of rotational deformity was problematic and this aspect requires further development.
Article
Objective The main aim of this study was to evaluate a percutaneous method of bone alignment using a diaphyseal tibial fracture model. Materials and Methods Mid-shaft diaphyseal fractures were created in 12 large-breed canine tibiae. Interaction pins were inserted into the proximal and distal bone segments. Computed tomography scans of the fractured tibiae and pins were imported into three-dimensional (3D) modelling software and the fractures were virtually reduced. A multi-component 3D printed alignment jig was created that encompassed the pins in their aligned configuration. Orthogonal radiographs were taken after alignment jig application. Intact and post-alignment tibial lengths and joint angles were compared. Rotational alignment was subjectively evaluated. Results Post-alignment tibial lengths differed on the mediolateral and craniocaudal radiographs by an average of 1.55 and 1.43% respectively. Post-alignment mechanical medial proximal tibial angle, mechanical medial distal tibial angle and mechanical caudal proximal tibial angle had an average difference of 1.67°, 1.92° and 2.17° respectively. Differences in tibial length and joint angles were not significant (p > 0.05). Clinical Significance While in vivo evaluation is necessary, this technique to align diaphyseal fractures percutaneously using computer modelling and 3D printing is technically feasible and may facilitate the clinical use of minimally invasive osteosynthesis techniques.
Article
Objective To compare precorrectional and postcorrectional femoral alignment following distal femoral osteotomy using patient‐specific 3‐dimensional (3D)‐printed osteotomy and reduction guides in vivo and ex vivo. Study design Prospective study. Sample population Ten client‐owned dogs and matching 3D‐printed plastic bone models. Methods Distal femoral osteotomy was performed via a standard approach using osteotomy and reduction guides developed with computer‐aided design software prior to 3D‐printing. Femoral osteotomy and reduction was also performed on 3D‐printed models of each femur with identical reprinted guides. Femoral varus angle (FVA) and femoral torsion angle (FTA) were measured on postoperative computed tomographic images by 3 observers. Results In vivo, the mean difference between target and achieved postoperative was 2.29° (±2.29°, P = .0076) for the FVA, and 1.67° (±2.08°, P = .300) for the FTA. Ex vivo, the mean difference between target and achieved postoperative was 0.29° (±1.50°, P = .813) for the FVA, and −2.33° (±3.21°, P = .336) for the FTA. Intraobserver intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC; 0.736‐0.998) and interobserver ICC (0.829 to 0.996) were consistent with an excellent agreement. Conclusion Use of 3D‐printed osteotomy and reduction guides allowed accurate correction of FTA in vivo and both FVA and FTA ex vivo. Clinical significance Use of 3D‐printed osteotomy and reduction guides may improve the accuracy of correction of femoral alignment but warrant further evaluation of surgical time, perioperative complications, and patient outcomes compared with conventional techniques.
Article
Introduction: Patient specific guides can be a valuable tool in improving the precision of planned femoral neck osteotomies, especially in minimally invasive hip surgery, where bony landmarks are often inaccessible. The aim of our study was to validate the accuracy of a novel patient specific femoral osteotomy guide for THR through a minimally invasive posterior approach, the direct superior approach (DSA). Methods: As part of our routine preoperative planning 30 patients underwent low dose CT scans of their arthritic hip. 3D printed patient specific femoral neck osteotomy guides were then produced. Intraoperatively, having cleared all soft tissue from the postero-lateral neck of the enlocated hip, the guide was placed and pinned onto the posterolateral femoral neck. The osteotomy was performed using an oscillating saw and the uncemented hip components were implanted as per routine. Postoperatively, the achieved level of the osteotomy at the medial calcar was compared with the planned level of resection using a 3D/2D matching analysis (Mimics X-ray module, Materialise, Belgium). Results: A total of 30 patients undergoing uncemented Trinity™ acetabular and TriFit TS™ femoral component arthroplasty (Corin, UK) were included in our analysis. All but one of our analysed osteotomies were found to be within 3 mm from the planned height of osteotomy. In one patient the level of osteotomy deviated 5 mm below the planned level of resection. Conclusion: Preoperative planning and the use of patient specific osteotomy guides provides an accurate method of performing femoral neck osteotomies in minimally invasive hip arthroplasty using the direct superior approach. Level of evidence: IV (Case series).