ArticlePublisher preview available

Stop the Stigma: TED Talk Reduces Negative Attitudes About Mental Health Treatment

Authors:
Lindsay C Morton at Marywood University
Lindsay C Morton
Giavanna Villano
Giavanna Villano
Giavanna Villano
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Emily Faltings
Emily Faltings
Emily Faltings
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Nicole Coccodrilli at Marywood University
Nicole Coccodrilli
Read publisher preview
Download citation
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Mental health stigma contributes to failure to seek professional psychological treatment, yet evidence suggests that video interventions may be effective in reducing such stigma. The current study hypothesized that a brief TED Talk on mental illness would result in more positive attitudes toward mental health treatment seeking compared to a control TED Talk. American adults (N = 141) were randomly assigned to video conditions and then were asked to evaluate the videos and provide a self-report of their attitudes toward seeking professional psychological treatment. It was found that, compared to the control video condition, the mental health video condition displayed more positive attitudes toward mental health treatment seeking. Exploratory analysis investigated the video factors related to these attitudes. These findings provide additional evidence that video interventions are effective in reducing stigma related to mental illness and that brief TED Talk videos may be a free, easy-to-access, and publicly available source for future interventions to reduce mental health stigma.
A preview of this full-text is provided by American Psychological Association.
Learn more
Content available from Psychology of Popular Media
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Psychology of Popular Media
Stop the Stigma: TED Talk Reduces Negative Attitudes About Mental Health
Treatment
Lindsay C. Morton, Giavanna Villano, Emily Faltings, and Nicole Coccodrilli
Online First Publication, January 8, 2024. https://dx.doi.org/10.1037/ppm0000518
CITATION
Morton, L. C., Villano, G., Faltings, E., & Coccodrilli, N. (2024, January 8). Stop the Stigma: TED Talk Reduces Negative
Attitudes About Mental Health Treatment. Psychology of Popular Media. Advance online publication.
https://dx.doi.org/10.1037/ppm0000518
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
How many participants do I need to test an interaction? Conducting an appropriate power analysis and achieving sufficient power to detect an interaction
Preprint
Full-text available
  • Sep 2022
Power analysis for first-order interactions poses two challenges: (i) Conducting an appropriate power analysis is difficult, because the required sample size depends on the shape of the interaction and the size of the simple slopes; (ii) Achieving sufficient power is difficult, because interactions tend to be modest in size. This paper consists of three parts. PART 1 addresses the first challenge. We first describe a fictional study to illustrate in a simple way how power analyses differ between interactions and main effects. Then, we introduce an intuitive taxonomy of 12 types of interactions based on the shape of the interaction (reversed, fully attenuated, partially attenuated) and the size of the simple effects (small, medium, large), and we offer mathematically-derived sample size recommendations to detect each interaction with a power of .80/.90. PART 2 addresses the second challenge. We first describe a preregistered meta-study (159 studies from recent articles in influential psychology journals) showing that the median power to detect medium-sized interactions in the literature is .18. Then, we use simulations (887M simulated datasets) to generate power curves for the 12 types of interactions, and test three strategies to increase power without increasing sample size: (i) preregistering one-tailed tests (+21% gain), (ii) using a mixed design (+75% gain), and (ii) preregistering contrast analysis for a fully attenuated interaction (+63% gain). PART 3 introduces INT×Power, a web-application that enables users to draw their interaction and determine the sample size needed to reach a power of .80 with and without using these strategies: www.intxpower.com.
View
Engaging the online audience in the digital era: A multimodal analysis of engagement strategies in TED talk videos
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2021
Scientific popularization genres have attracted the attention of researchers in esp. Authors of such genres have been found to employ a variety of strategies to engage the readers. However, most studies of engagement in scientific popularization tend to focus on written genres. For this reason, they have mostly examined only the linguistic mode and rarely gone beyond this to take multimodal resources into consideration. the present study investigates how multimodal semiotic resources are combined in digital media to engage the online audience in an influential online scientific popularization genre, that is, TED talks. drawing on a corpus of 28 highly viewed TED talks from the area of biology, this study provides an in-depth analysis of multimodal engagement strategies in one of those talks. the analysis shows that the engagement of online viewers in a digitally mediated scientific popularization genre like TED talks tends to be achieved by the combination of multiple semiotic resources afforded by digital technologies, such as speech, gestures, gaze, visuals, distance of shot, perspective of shot and angle of shot. the study also reveals five strategic multimodal configurations employed to achieve viewer engagement, with the focus variously on engagement through visual aids, a long shot, gaze, questions and reference to personal emotions.
View
TED Talks: A genre analysis
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2021
This research aims at investigating TED Talks as a genre. The analysis focuses on its rhetorical structure, characterized by moves and steps and the communicative purposes of the genre. The corpus comprises 10 talks selected from the website TED Talks. The data are discussed in the light of Bhatia’s (1996/2004) and Swales’ (1990/2004) theories of genre. Results demonstrate that, in terms of the analysis of the rhetorical structure, it reveals a constant pattern of moves and steps along the corpus, since every talk contained the five moves identified by the analysis. These cyclical and more frequent moves are: topic introduction, speaker presentation, topic development, concluding messages, and acknowledgments/gratitude. In terms of its communicative purpose, TED aims to celebrate ideas to a diverse audience worldwide, due to the variety of topics encompassed. This study also allowed us to develop a deeper view of this spoken genre, its features, and the way individuals may benefit from it in their lives.
View
Reducing depression‐related stigma and increasing treatment seeking among adolescents: randomized controlled trial of a brief video intervention
Article
Full-text available
Background Confronting stigma early in life could enhance receptivity to seeking treatment. We evaluated the efficacy of social contact interventions to reduce stigma toward depression and to enhance treatment‐seeking intentions among adolescents. We hypothesized that the brief video‐based interventions would be more effective than their matched controls. Method Using crowdsourcing, we recruited and randomly assigned 1,183 participants aged 14–18 to one of four video‐based stimuli on a 4:4:1:1 ratio: (a) adolescent girl with depression; (b) adolescent boy with depression; (c) same girl, without depression; or (d) same boy, without depression. In each of the ~100‐second‐long videos, two simulated patients (SPs) depicted empowered presenters sharing their personal stories. In the depression conditions, SPs described how social support from family, friends, and professionals helped them overcome their symptoms and recover. Results We found a significant effect for the Depression Stigma Scale (DSS) between active and control groups (F = 27.4, p < .001). We found a significant increase in treatment‐seeking intentions, as measured by the General Help‐Seeking Questionnaire (GHSQ; p < .001). Secondary analyses revealed that racial (but not gender) congruence between protagonists and participants resulted in greater stigma reduction and treatment seeking, as compared to racially incongruent pairings (t = 2.9, p = .004). Conclusion A brief video‐based intervention effectively reduced stigma toward depression and increased treatment seeking among adolescents. Favorable changes were greater when race (but not gender) was congruent between protagonists and participants. Future studies should explore how to optimize brief contact‐based interventions according to adolescents’ race and ethnicity and how to scale such interventions to novel online platforms of dissemination.
View
Socioeconomic status and mental illness stigma: the impact of mental illness controllability attributions and personal responsibility judgments
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2021
Background Prior research has suggested that higher levels of socioeconomic status (SES) may be linked with heightened mental illness stigma (MIS). It has been posited that this link is due to the resource-rich environment high-SES individuals live in, which predisposes them to seeing the certain phenomena as being more controllable in nature than low-SES individuals. Aims The current study intended to address the attributional mechanisms behind the SES-MIS link. Methods In a sample of 932 participants, we collected self-reported SES along with the controllability attributions and personal responsibility judgments participants make for individuals with mental illnesses. Results Analyses indicated that SES was significantly associated with greater MIS levels, and that this link was significantly mediated by controllability attributions and personal responsibility judgments. Conclusions Findings suggest that high-SES individuals are more likely to see mental illness as due to internal, controllable factors, which leads to blaming the individual for mental illness onset and, ultimately, greater mental illness stigma. These results provide support for more socioeconomically diverse committees and panels where mental health funding decisions are made due to inherent attributional biases which may be present along the SES spectrum.
View
Mental Health and Well-Being of University Students: A Bibliometric Mapping of the Literature
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2020
The purpose of this study is to map the literature on mental health and well-being of university students using metadata extracted from 5,561 journal articles indexed in the Web of Science database for the period 1975–2020. More specifically, this study uses bibliometric procedures to describe and visually represent the available literature on mental health and well-being in university students in terms of the growth trajectory, productivity, social structure, intellectual structure, and conceptual structure of the field over 45 years. Key findings of the study are that research on mental health and well-being in university students: (a) has experienced a steady growth over the last decades, especially since 2010; (b) is disseminated in a wide range of journals, mainly in the fields of psychology, psychiatry, and education research; (c) is published by scholars with diverse geographical background, although more than half of the publications are produced in the United States; (d) lies on a fragmented research community composed by multiple research groups with little interactions between them; (e) is relatively interdisciplinary and emerges from the convergence of research conducted in the behavioral and biomedical sciences; (f) tends to emphasize pathogenic approaches to mental health (i.e., mental illness); and (g) has mainly addressed seven research topics over the last 45 years: positive mental health, mental disorders, substance abuse, counseling, stigma, stress, and mental health measurement. The findings are discussed, and the implications for the future development of the field are highlighted.
View
Use of an Educational Video to Reduce Barriers to Military Mental Health Care
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2019
Objective: Although there is significant need for mental health care among service members, stigma surrounding these services, along with myths associated with behavioral health treatment, discourages care seeking. This study evaluated the effect of a video designed to demystify mental health treatment on barriers to seeking care among military personnel. Methods: Participants were 294 active duty U.S. Marine Corps personnel who were randomly assigned to the intervention video only, the intervention video with discussion, or an attentional control video. Participants completed questionnaires that assessed social stigma regarding mental health treatment and willingness to seek help at pretest, posttest, and 6-week follow-up; personal desire for mental health care was assessed at pretest and 6-week follow-up. Results: Participants who viewed the intervention video in either condition showed significant and similar decreases in social stigma and increases in willingness to seek help at posttest (p<.001), whereas participants in the control group showed no change at posttest in either variable. Although social stigma did not differ by intervention group at the 6-week follow-up, participants in either intervention were 2.56 times more likely than participants in the control group to report a personal desire for mental health care at the 6-week follow-up (p=.05). There were no significant differences between the two interventions on the main outcomes. Conclusions: A video in which mental health care providers explain the treatment process may be effective as an initial stand-alone social stigma reduction intervention. Additional efforts are likely needed to sustain effects and to realize increases in help-seeking behavior.
View
“Maybe No One Is Really Crazy, but Everyone Is Just a Little Bit Mad”: Framing Experiences of Living with Madness in the TED Talk
Article
  • Oct 2021
  • Can J Community Ment Health
This article explores the victimizing experiences of individuals with mental illness using grounded inductive qualitative research methods, by extracting themes from 15 first-hand accounts of living with mental illness delivered on the TED Talks media platform. Emergent themes included (1) victimizing effects of the illness including the effects of medication and the effects of stigma, (2) normalcy, (3) the importance of help-seeking in the process of overcoming obstacles presented by mental health issues, and (4) victimization by others. We conclude that the speakers in our sample, even though they reflect an extraordinary level of functioning, still view themselves as what Becker (1991 [1963]) describes as outsiders, acting as moral entrepreneurs, crusading to normalize madness through a variety of strategies.
View
Measuring The Lifetime Costs Of Serious Mental Illness And The Mitigating Effects Of Educational Attainment
Article
  • Apr 2019
Serious mental illness (SMI) is a disabling condition that develops early in life and imposes substantial economic burden. There is a growing belief that early intervention for SMI has lifelong benefits for patients. However, assessing the cost-effectiveness of early intervention efforts is hampered by a lack of evidence on the long-term benefits. We addressed this by using a dynamic microsimulation model to estimate the lifetime burden of SMI for those diagnosed by age twenty-five. We estimated that the per patient lifetime burden of SMI is $1.85 million. We also found that a policy intervention focused on improving the educational attainment of people with SMI reduces the average per person burden of SMI by $73,600 (4.0 percent)-a change driven primarily by higher lifetime earnings-or over $8.9 billion in reduced burden per cohort of SMI patients. These findings provide a benchmark for the potential value of improving educational attainment for people with SMI.
View
Student Reflections on Vulnerability and Self-awareness in a Social Work Skills Course
Article
  • Oct 2018
  • Aust Soc Work
Self-awareness is generally considered core to effective social work education and professional practice. This paper examines student reflections on personal vulnerability and self-awareness in social, educational, and professional contexts. Ethics approval and student consent was obtained to analyse entries from the online learning component of a second year interpersonal skills course. The week 7 workshop, which focused on the concept of self-awareness, was contextualised and triggered by an online viewing of a relevant TED talk on the power of vulnerability. Qualitative analysis of student entries from this week revealed three core themes: (a) a provocative stimulus, which emphasised the usefulness and challenging nature of the TED talk in the context of workshop learning; (b) vulnerability, scarcity, and blame, which highlighted student identification with stimuli material and their emerging self-awareness; and (c) the importance of self-awareness and connection, which illuminated the students’ beginning applications of theory to practice. IMPLICATIONS • Interpersonal skills courses can be well supported by a diverse range of online and classroom stimuli. • The intentional scaffolding of self-reflective activities can support early skills development and promote self-awareness. • The analysis of student reflections can contribute to effective and responsive curriculum design.
View