Greater percentages of rare and highly restricted cacti are found in the Chihuahuan Desert than in any other desert in the Americas, with as many as 35 species confined to areas no larger than 2,500 square kilometers in the CDE in Mexico (Hernández and Bárcenas 1995, 1996). Mexico, home to more cacti species than any other country in the Americas, covers about 80 percent of the Chihuahuan Desert, with Arizona, New Mexico, and Texas making up the remaining 20 percent of the desert’s total area (Bravo Hollis 1978; Bravo Hollis and Sánchez Mejorada 1992a, 1992b; Hunt 1999; Hernández and Godínez 1994; Hernández and Bárcenas 1995, 1996).
Mexico’s cactus diversity attracts the interest of international markets and collectors who employ illegal tactics to obtain wild-collected specimens of desirable species, some of which may be newly named to science, rare, or threatened with extinction. Even though collecting wild plants in Mexico for the sole purpose of resale or export is strictly prohibited, cactus specimens, such as seeds and live plants, are the target of unscrupulous collectors, uninformed tourists, and impoverished villagers. Additional threats such as habitat loss and grazing exist for many species, especially those whose wild populations are limited to only a few locations.
A survey of nurseries in more than 100 Mexican establishments in 13 states reveals 94 cactus species native or endemic to the Chihuahuan Desert in domestic trade, with three genera (Mammillaria, Turbinicarpus, and Ferocactus) accounting for 53 percent of the total species traded. Approximately 300 cactus species native to the Chihuahuan Desert of Mexico were also documented in the international marketplace, with the maximum number of species offered in the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, and Sweden. More than half of the species documented in international trade are listed in CITES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora) Appendix I and, therefore, cannot be commercially traded unless artificially propagated; are included in the list of threatened species recognized by the World Conservation Union (IUCN); or receive special status under Mexican law.
Regrettably, many of the species now commercially available as artificially propagated plants in foreign markets are descendants of seeds or live plants that were illegally exported from Mexico by private collectors. Illegal trade continues to threaten many cactus species of limited distribution and of conservation concern in the Chihuahuan Desert in Mexico, as is evident from the number of seizures involving several endemic taxa: Astrophytum myrisotigma, Ariocarpus retusus, Aztekium hintonii, Cephalocereus senilis, Geohintonia mexicana, and Lophophora williamsii.
The illegal trade in cactus species of the Chihuahuan Desert is a symptom of a combination of problems, including a lack of nurseries propagating rare species to meet international demand, confusing and often contradictory Mexican laws posing a barrier to establishing commercial plant breeding operations, and insufficient outreach efforts to rural villages to communicate the economic benefits of sustainable cactus harvest. Stronger enforcement of existing Mexican laws is also needed to deter individuals, particularly foreign private collectors, from collecting and bringing into their countries protected cactus plants. These issues require a multifaceted approach, ranging from investing in commercial propagation to improving monitoring and law enforcement. Unless these issues are addressed, they will continue to undermine the conservation of Mexico’s outstanding, yet dwindling cactus populations.