No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.
Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability
Abstract
Lateral ligament attenuation may occur after repetitive ankle sprains, creating instability. Management of chronic ankle instability requires a comprehensive approach to mechanical and functional instability. Surgical treatment, however, is indicated when conservative treatment is not effective. Ankle ligament reconstruction is the most common surgical procedure to resolve mechanical instability. Anatomic open Broström-Gould reconstruction is the gold standard for repairing affected lateral ligaments and returning athletes to sports. Arthroscopy may also be beneficial for identifying associated injuries. In severe and long-standing instability, reconstruction with tendon augmentation could be necessary.
Background
Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability (CLAI) is a common condition treated using either Anterior Talofibular and Calcaneofibular Ligament (ATFL and CFL) reconstruction or Modified Brostrom Procedure (MBP). However, the comparative efficacy of these approaches is not well-studied.
Methods
In this study, clinical data were retrospectively collected from 101 patients diagnosed with CLAI who underwent either ATFL and CFL reconstruction (n = 51) or the MBP (n = 50). Patients were comparable in terms of age, sex, Body Mass Index (BMI), post-injury duration, preoperative American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Karlsson score, Visual Analog Score (VAS), Anterior Talar Translation, and Talar Tilt Angle.
Results
The post-operative measures showed no significant differences in AOFAS Score, Karlsson Score, and VAS between both treatment groups. However, patients who underwent ATFL and CFL reconstruction showed significantly lower follow-up Anterior Talar Translation (mean = 4.1667 ± 1.3991 mm) and Talar Tilt Angle (mean = 5.0549 ± 1.6173°) compared to those who underwent MBP. Further, patients treated with ATFL and CFL reconstruction experienced a significantly longer postoperative recovery time (median = 6 weeks) compared to MBP (median = 3 weeks).
Conclusions
Although both therapeutic techniques were generally effective in treating CLAI, the ATFL and CFL reconstruction approach delivered superior control of Anterior Talar Translation and Talar Tilt Angle. However, its longer recovery time merits further study to optimize the balance between therapeutic efficacy and recovery speed.
Introdução: As lesões ligamentares do tornozelo são frequentes e podem resultar em instabilidade crônica, afetando a qualidade de vida dos pacientes. Uma abordagem eficaz de reabilitação é essencial para prevenir complicações a longo prazo e promover a recuperação completa. Objetivo: Discorrer sobre as lesões do tornozelo, investigação diagnóstica e abordagens de reabilitação, com foco na identificação de diretrizes atuais e práticas recomendadas. Metodologia: Foi conduzida uma revisão narrativa utilizando descritores MeSH “("Ankle Injuries") AND (“Ankle instability" OR "sprains") AND "ankle" AND ("rehabilitation" OR "Ankle reconstruction" OR "comparative effectiveness") AND ("Fractures" OR "avulsion" OR "Ligaments/injuries" OR "Sprains and strains"e selecionando artigos de revisão sistemática, com ou sem meta-análise, publicados nos últimos 20 anos em inglês, português e espanhol. Foram consultadas plataformas de pesquisa e diretrizes relevantes, resultando na análise de um total de 24 artigos. Além disso, foi utilizada a plataforma ResearchRabbit para facilitar o acesso à literatura cinzenta. Resultados: A eficácia da abordagem conservadora, especialmente no que diz respeito à fisioterapia e ao acompanhamento clínico individualizado, no tratamento das lesões ligamentares do tornozelo, considerando que 60% a 70% dos pacientes respondem bem a essa vertente de tratamento. A personalização do cuidado com base em diretrizes atualizadas e evidências científicas demonstrou ser fundamental para otimizar a recuperação dos pacientes e prevenir a instabilidade crônica. É visto que a implementação de protocolos de reabilitação bem estruturados e adaptados às necessidades específicas de cada indivíduo foi identificada como um fator determinante para alcançar resultados clínicos satisfatórios e melhorar a qualidade de vida a longo prazo. Conclusão: A reabilitação adequada das lesões ligamentares do tornozelo desempenha um papel crucial na prevenção da instabilidade crônica e na melhoria dos desfechos clínicos. A abordagem conservadora, aliada a diretrizes baseadas em evidências, é fundamental para garantir uma recuperação completa e a retomada das atividades diárias dos pacientes afetados por essas lesões.
Purpose
To determine whether a double anchor is more effective than a single anchor in the surgical repair of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) in patients with ankle instability.
Methods
This study searched PubMed, Embase and the Cochrane Library to identify potential studies that compared the clinical outcomes of double anchors and single anchors for ATFL repair from inception to July 31st, 2023. The study aligned with the 2020 Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews (PRISMA) guidelines and checklist. The Risk of Bias in Nonrandomized Studies-of Interventions (ROBINS-I) tool was used to evaluate methodologic quality and risk of bias. The meta-analysis was performed with random effects. Outcomes, including American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society Score (AOFAS), Karlsson Ankle Functional Score (KAFS), Tegner activity score, return to sport rate, complications and revision surgery events, were recorded.
Results
A total of 845 articles were identified after an initial search of the three databases. Four retrospective studies involving 231 individuals were included for further analysis. There was no significant difference between the single-anchor group and the two-anchor group in terms of the AOFAS (risk ratio, −0.44, [−2.22; 1.34]) or KAFS (mean difference, −2.81, [−6.87; 1.25]). However, in terms of the Tegner activity score and the return to sport rate, the single-anchor group had significantly lower scores and longer times than the double-anchor group. No complications or revision surgery events were reported.
Conclusions
In patients with chronic ankle instability, both single anchors and double anchors can provide good functional outcomes. For patients who participate in physically demanding sports, double anchors may be a superior option.
Level of Evidence
Level Ⅲ, meta-analysis of Level
To evaluate the clinical outcomes of anatomic repair procedure for chronic anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) injury at the talar side, and to compare the outcomes between patients with and without concomitant avulsion fractures. It was hypothesized that anatomic repair procedure could produce similarly satisfactory outcomes for those two groups.
Thirty-nine consecutive patients with chronic ATFL injuries at the talar side who underwent anatomic repair procedure at the department of sports medicine at Peking University Third Hospital between 2013 and 2018, were retrospectively evaluated. The pain visual analogue scale (VAS), American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Tegner score, and Foot & Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS) were recorded as the primary outcomes. Time to return to sports (RTS), surgical satisfaction, deficiency of ankle range of motion (ROM), recurrent sprain, and postoperative complications were recorded as the secondary outcomes. Outcomes were compared between patients with (Group A, 16 cases) and without (Group B, 23 cases) concomitant avulsion fractures.
The mean follow-up time was 79.4 ± 17.0 and 76.6 ± 18.5 months for Group A and B, respectively. VAS, AOFAS, Tegner, FAOS, and all subscale scores of FAOS were significantly improved in both groups at the final follow up. Patients in group A had inferior postoperative VAS, AOFAS, FAOS, and pain score of FAOS compared to group B (1.1 ± 1.1 vs. 0.4 ± 0.5, 89.1 ± 10.1 vs. 95.2 ± 5.2, 87.2 ± 7.2 vs. 91.5 ± 4.1, and 88.4 ± 11.3 vs. 96.7 ± 3.5, respectively).The mean time to RTS, rate of satisfaction and recurrent sprain had no significant differences between group A and B (6.1 ± 2.8, 93.8%, and 18.8% vs. 5.2 ± 2.2, 100.0%, and 13.0%, respectively), and the rate of ROM deficiency was significantly higher in group A (37.5 vs. 8.7%). Avulsion fracture was identified as an independent risk factor for inferior pain score of FAOS.
Anatomic repair procedure for chronic ATFL injuries at the talar side produces favourable results for patients with and without avulsion fractures at 5 to 10 years follow-up, however, avulsion fracture is associated with more pain.
III.
Background
There is still some controversy about the augmentation of the inferior extensor retinaculum after arthroscopic anterior talofibular ligament repair. The aim of this study was to evaluate the novel arthro-Broström procedure with endoscopic retinaculum augmentation using all-inside lasso-loop stitch techniques for chronic lateral ankle instability.
Methods
Thirty-four cases with grade-2 or grade-3 chronic anterior talofibular ligament lesions who underwent the novel arthro-Broström procedure with endoscopic retinaculum augmentation using all-inside lasso-loop stitch techniques were assessed retrospectively. A total of 30 cases (30 ankles) were followed up for a mean of 26.67 ± 4.19 months (range, 24—36 months). four cases were excluded due to insufficient medical records or loss of follow-up reports. The Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool scores, The Karlsson-Peterson scores and Visual Analogue Scale scores were evaluated before surgery and at the final follow-up time. Also, the results of stress fluoroscopic tests and complications were recorded.
Results
At the final follow-up, the average of the Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool scores, The Karlsson-Peterson scores and Visual Analogue Scale scores were 86.63 ± 6.69 (range, 77—100), 90.17 ± 4.64 (range, 85—100) and 0.53 ± 0.63 (range, 0—2), respectively. Moreover, the results of stress fluoroscopic tests were improved significantly after surgery. Mild keloid formation and/or knot irritation were observed in four cases. No wound infections, nerve injuries and recurrent instability were recorded. Also, no stiffness or arthritis of the subtalar joint was encountered.
Conclusions
The arthro-Broström procedure combined with endoscopic retinaculum augmentation using all-inside lasso-loop techniques is reliable and safe due to the advantage of direct endoscopic visualization.
Objective:
To specify indications and contraindications of the modified percutaneous inferior extensor retinaculum augmentation (PIERA) technique for chronic ankle instability cases, and to introduce technique details and report surgical outcomes and complications.
Methods:
The PIERA technique was performed on seven patients with chronic ankle instability (four females and three males, 36.4 ± 15.1 years of age, and course of symptoms of 33.7 ± 8.8 months) from June to October 2018 in this retrospective study of case series. All patients demonstrated attenuated ligamentous tissue quality, which was confirmed using preoperative ankle MRI. IER were drew up to the distal fibula using suture anchors with the ankle in neutral position for all cases, to engage the entire IER in reconstructing the stability of the ankle. Patients were assessed using American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Ankle-Hindfoot (AOFAS) score and Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool (CAIT) scores pre- and postoperatively at the last follow-up examination. Preoperative and postoperative outcome scores of patients were compared using paired t-test. A p value of less than 0.05 was regarded statistically significant.
Results:
Mean follow-up duration was 16.7 ± 1.6 months. The mean AOFAS score significantly improved from 66.9 ± 11.2 preoperatively to 93.7 ± 8.5 postoperatively (P = 0.001). Mean CAIT score significantly improved from 13.1 ± 4.7 preoperatively to 26.3 ± 1.8 postoperatively (P = 0.001). Patients did not report any wound healing problem, numbness, swelling, or instability at the last follow-up examination, except for one patient who reported pain and minimal stiffness, and presented an AOFAS score of less than 80 and a CAIT score below 24. All patients returned to at least recreational sport activity level.
Conclusion:
The PIERA technique can improve the functional outcomes of patients with chronic ankle instability with few complications.
Background: Nearly 20% of acute ankle sprains progress to chronic lateral ankle instability that requires surgical intervention. In recent years, there has been a growing interest in arthroscopic Brostro ̈ m techniques as an alternative to open surgery.
Purpose: To review the most up-to-date evidence comparing the outcomes of open and arthroscopic Brostro ̈ m procedures for chronic lateral ankle instability.
Study Design: Systematic review; Level of evidence, 3.
Methods: This review was performed following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. Relevant comparative studies in English up to May 2020 were identified. The primary outcomes were (1) functional scores (Karlsson Ankle Function Score and American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society [AOFAS] score) and (2) the 10-point visual analog scale (VAS) score for pain. The secondary outcomes were differences in (1) postoperative anterior drawer and talar tilt, (2) surgical time and complication rate, and (3) time to return to sports and weightbearing.
Results: A total of 408 patients in 8 studies met the inclusion criteria. Of these, 193 (47.3%) patients underwent open surgery, while 215 (52.7%) patients underwent arthroscopic surgery. There were significant differences between the open and arthroscopic repair groups in mean 6-month AOFAS scores (82.4 vs 92.25, respectively; mean difference [MD], 11.36; 95% CI, 0.14-2.56; I2 1⁄4 90%; P 1⁄4 .03), 1-year AOFAS scores (80.05 vs 88.6; MD, –11.96; 95% CI, –21.26 to –2.76; I2 1⁄4 82%; P 1⁄4 .01), 6-month VAS scores (1.7 vs 1.4; MD, –0.38; 95% CI, –0.54 to –0.21; I2 1⁄4 78%; P < .001), and 1-year VAS scores (2.05 vs 1.45; MD, 0.31; 95% CI, 0.09-0.54; I2 1⁄4 0%; P < .001). The mean time to weightbearing was 14.25 and 9.0 weeks in the open and arthroscopic repair groups, respectively (MD, 1.89; 95% CI, 1.24-2.54; I2 1⁄4 99%; P < .001). There were no statistically significant differences in the remaining outcomes evaluated.
Conclusion: While technically more demanding, arthroscopic Brostro ̈ m was superior to open Brostro ̈ m-Gould surgery in post- operative AOFAS scores, VAS pain scores, and time to return to weightbearing. The operative time, complication rate, talar tilt, and anterior drawer tests were excellent and statistically comparable. Long-term clinical trials are required before recommending arthroscopic Brostro ̈ m as the new gold standard.
Keywords: lateral ankle instability; open; arthroscopic; Brostro ̈ m-Gould; repair
Purpose
The aim of this study was to determine whether the use of suture tape augmentation would lead to improved clinical outcomes, increased stability, shorter postoperative immobilization and earlier return to activity and sports compared to Broström repair in surgical treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI).
Materials and Methods
A systematic literature search was performed using Pubmed and Embase according to the PRISMA guidelines. The following search keywords were used: ankle instability, suture tape, fiber tape and internal brace. Full-text articles in English language that directly compared a Broström (BR) and a suture tape augmentation (ST) cohort were included, with a minimum cohort size of 40 patients. Exclusion criteria were former systematic reviews, biomechanical studies and case reports.
Results
Ultimately, seven clinical trials were included in this systematic review. Regarding the clinical and radiologic outcomes and complication rates, no major differences were detected between both groups. Recurrence of instability and revision surgeries tended to occur more often after Broström repair, while irritation of the peroneal nerve and tendons seemed to occur more frequently after suture tape augmentation. Postoperative rehabilitation protocols were either the same for both groups or more aggressive in the ST groups. When both techniques were performed with arthroscopic assistance, return to sports was significantly faster in the ST groups.
Conclusions
In conclusion, suture tape augmentation showed excellent results and is a safe technique comparable to traditional Broström repair. No major differences regarding clinical and radiologic outcomes and complications were found.
Chronic ankle instability can result from untreated or badly managed acute lateral ankle ligament injuries. Conservative management is the modality of choice for acute lateral ankle ligament injuries, and operative treatment is reserved for special cases. Failure after strict rehabilitation may be an indication for surgery. Several operative options are vailable, including anatomic repair, anatomic reconstruction, and tenodesis procedures. Anatomic repair can be performed when the quality of the damaged ligaments permits. Anatomic reconstruction with an autograft or allograft should be considered when the torn ligaments are not adequate. Ankle arthroscopy is a useful adjunct to ligamentous procedures, performed at the time of repair to identify and treat intra-articular conditions that may be associated with chronic ankle instability.
Tenodesis techniques are not recommended because of their suboptimal long-term results related to the modification of ankle and hindfoot biomechanics.
Background: No reported study has compared clinical and radiologic outcomes between an all-inside arthroscopic
modified Broström operation (MBO) and an open MBO. The purpose of this study was to compare clinical and radiologic
outcomes of all-inside arthroscopic and open MBOs.
Methods: From August 2012 to July 2014, 48 patients were included. They were divided into 2 groups: all-inside arthroscopic
MBO (25 patients) and open MBO (23 patients). The American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle–hindfoot
score, visual analog scale (VAS) score, and Karlsson score were used to evaluate clinical outcomes. Anterior talar translation
and talar tilt were used to evaluate radiologic outcomes. All patients had lateral ankle instability. MBO was performed in 87
patients. Of these, 50 patients met the inclusion criteria. All patients had giving way, persistent pain, and an inability to resume
their preinjury activity level for more than 6 months. Patients were randomized into 2 groups, all-inside arthroscopic MBO
and open MBO, using a permuted block randomization method. Clinical outcome evaluations were performed preoperatively,
at 6 weeks and 6 months postoperatively, and at a final follow-up at a minimum of 12 months postoperatively using the
Karlsson score, the AOFAS ankle-hindfoot score, and pain VAS scores. Radiologic outcome evaluations were performed
preoperatively and at 1 year postoperatively at final follow-up using anterior talar translation, and talar tilt angle.
Results: After randomization, 25 ankles were allocated to the all-inside arthroscopic MBO group and 25 to the open
MBO group. Two ankles in the open MBO group were excluded from the analysis because they were lost to follow-up.
Thus, evaluations were performed for 25 ankles in the all-inside arthroscopic MBO group and 23 in the open MBO group.
There was no difference in age, gender, symptom duration, preoperative AOFAS, VAS, Karlsson scores, anterior talar
translation, or talar tilt between the 2 groups (all P > .05). At the final follow-up, the AOFAS, VAS, and the Karlsson scores
had improved significantly in both groups (P < .001). There was no difference in the Karlsson, AOFAS, or VAS scores,
anterior talar translation, or talar tilt between the 2 groups at final follow-up (all P > .05).
Conclusions: There was no difference in the clinical or radiologic outcome between the all-inside arthroscopic MBO and
open MBO for the treatment of lateral ankle instability at up to 1 year after surgery. An all-inside arthroscopic MBO should
be considered carefully in patients who have lateral ankle instability.
Level of Evidence: Level I, randomized controlled trial.
Background:
The open Brostrom-Gould procedure for the repair of lateral ankle ligament remains the gold standard in operative management of chronic ankle instability. Nevertheless, the arthroscopic technique has been gaining attention among foot and ankle surgeons in the past decade. Our study aimed to compare the clinical outcomes of patients who underwent the arthroscopic and open Brostom-Gould technique over a 12-month follow-up period.
Methods:
We retrospectively reviewed the database in a tertiary hospital foot and ankle registry from 2015 to 2019. We then performed a 1:1 matching of 26 ankles that underwent the arthroscopic Brostrom-Gould technique to 26 ankles with the open technique, all performed by a fellowship-trained foot and ankle surgeon, for age, sex, and body mass index. To assess clinical outcomes, visual analog scale scores, American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) Ankle-Hindfoot Scores, and Short Form 36 Health Survey scores were collected at the preoperative and 6- and 12-month follow-up visits, respectively.
Results:
The arthroscopic group demonstrated significantly less pain in the perioperative period (arthroscopic, 1.0 ± 1.2; open, 2.4 ± 2.2; P = .015) and had higher AOFAS scores at 6 months (arthroscopic, 87.2 ± 11.1; open, 73.5 ± 21.9; P = .028) and 12 months (arthroscopic, 94.2 ± 10.0; open, 70.9 ± 33.1; P = .020). No complications were reported in either group. Twenty patients (76.9%) in the arthroscopic group had preoperative intra-articular abnormalities compared with 24 patients (92.3%) in the open group.
Conclusion:
The arthroscopic Brostrum-Gould technique produced better clinical outcomes than the open technique at 12 months of follow-up.
Level of Evidence:
Level III, retrospective comparative series
Objective:
To evaluate the functional outcomes of arthroscopic anatomical repair of anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) in the treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) during medium- and long-term follow-up.
Methods:
From September 2014 to August 2017, the data of 37 patients (23 males, 14 females; 12 left ankles, 25 right ankles) aged between 21 and 56 years, with an average age of 32.17 ± 6.35 years, presenting with CLAI, was retrospectively analyzed. Among them, 32 injuries were caused by sprain and five injuries were caused by car accidents. The course of the disease lasted for 12 to 60 months, with an average of 26.07 ± 13.29 months. All patients had intact skin around the ankle and no skin lesions. All patients underwent arthroscopic anatomical repair of ATFL, with the fixation of one to two anchors. Pre- and post-operative visual analogue scales (VAS), the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Ankle-Hindfoot Score (AOFAS), and the Karlsson Ankle Functional Score (KAFS) were compared to evaluate the curative effect of the operation.
Results:
The operation was successful in all 37 cases. The operation time ranged from 40 to 75 min, with an average of 51.25 ± 11.49 min. After surgery, all incisions healed in stage I and there were no complications such as nerve, blood vessel and tendon injury, implant rejection, or suture rejection. Hospital stays of postoperative patients were 3 to 5 days, with an average of 3.77 ± 1.36 days. All patients were followed for 24 to 45 months, averaging 33.16 ± 10.58 months. For three patients with CLAI combined with mild limitation of subjective ankle movement, joint activity was normal after rehabilitation function exercise and proprioceptive function training for 2 months. At the final follow-up, ankle pain had disappeared completely. The ankle varus stress test and ankle anterior drawer test were both negative. Range of joint motion was good. There was no lateral instability of the ankle and all patients returned to normal gait. The mean VAS score decreased to 1.12 ± 0.13, the AOFAS score increased to 92.53 ± 4.87, and the KAFS score increased to 93.36 ± 6.15. All the follow-up indexes were significantly different from those before surgery.
Conclusion:
Arthroscopic anatomical repair of ATFL for CLAI is precise, with less surgical trauma and reliable medium- and long-term effect.
Purpose
Anatomic reconstruction of the anterior talofibular ligament and calcaneofibular ligament is a valid treatment of chronic hindfoot instability. The purpose of this study was to investigate the outcomes of this procedure performed by an all-inside endoscopic technique.
Methods
This study is a retrospective evaluation of a prospective database. Subjects were all patients who underwent an endoscopic lateral ligament reconstruction between 2013 and 2016. All patients had symptoms of ankle instability with positive manual stress testing and failed nonoperative treatment during at least 6 months. At final follow-up the outcome was assessed using the visual analogue score (VAS), American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score and Karlsson–Peterson scores.
Results
After an average follow-up of 31.5 ± 6.9 months, all patients reported significant improvement compared to their preoperative status. The preoperative AOFAS score improved from 76.4 ± 15 to 94.7 ± 11.7 postoperatively (p = 0.0001). The preoperative Karlsson–Peterson score increased from 73.0 ± 16.0 to 93.7 ± 10.6 postoperatively (p = 0.0001). The VAS score improved from 1.9 ± 2.5 to 0.8 ± 1.7 (p < 0.001). Two patients had complaints of recurrent instability.
Conclusion
Endoscopic ligament reconstruction for chronic lateral ankle instability is a safe procedure and produces good clinical results with minimal complications. In addition, the endoscopic approach allows an assessment of the ankle joint and treatment of associated intra-articular lesions.
Level of evidence
II.
Background:
A key point to surgical treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability is choosing a suitable surgical procedure. The purpose of this meta-analysis was to compare different surgical techniques for management of chronic lateral ankle instability.
Methods:
We searched the Cochrane Library, MEDLINE, and EMBASE. All identified randomized and quasi-randomized controlled trials of operative treatment for chronic lateral ankle instability were included. Two review authors independently extracted data from each study and assessed risk of bias. Where appropriate, results of comparable studies were pooled.
Results:
Seven randomized controlled trials were included for analysis. They fell in five clearly distinct groups. One study comparing two different kinds of non-anatomic reconstruction procedures (dynamic and static tenodesis) found two clinical outcomes favoring static tenodesis: better clinical satisfaction and fewer subsequent sprains. Two studies compared non-anatomic reconstruction versus anatomic repairment. In one study, nerve damage was more frequent in non-anatomic reconstruction group; the other one reported that radiological measurement of ankle laxity showed that non-anatomic reconstruction provided higher reduction of talar tilt angle. Two studies comparing two anatomic repairment surgical techniques (transosseous suture versus imbrication) showed no significant difference in any clinical outcome at the follow-up except operation time. One study compared two different anatomic repairment techniques. They found that the double anchor technique was superior with respect to the reduction of talar tilt than single anchor technique. One study compared an anatomic reconstruction procedure with a modified Brostrom technique. Primary reconstruction combined with ligament advanced reinforcement system results in better patient-scored clinical outcome, at 2 years post-surgery, than the modified Brostrom procedure.
Conclusions:
There is limited evidence to support any one surgical technique over another surgical technique for chronic lateral ankle instability, but based on the evidence, we could still get some conclusions: (1) There are limitations to the use of dynamic tenodesis, which obtained poor clinical satisfaction and more subsequent sprains. (2) Non-anatomic reconstruction abnormally increased inversion stiffness at the subtalar level as compare with anatomic repairment. (3) Multiple types of modified Brostrom procedures could acquire good clinical results. (4) Anatomic reconstruction is a better procedure for some specific patients.
Background:
The arthroscopic modified Broström operation (MBO) has been frequently used to treat chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI). However, no reports comparing the clinical outcomes between patients with or without generalized ligamentous laxity (laxity or no laxity, respectively) currently exist. The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical outcomes of the 2 groups with CLAI.
Methods:
Between January 2013 and November 2015, arthroscopic MBO was performed on 99 patients with CLAI. Patients were divided into 2 groups: the laxity group (24 ankles) and no laxity group (75 ankles). Generalized ligamentous laxity was defined as a Beighton score of 4 or more points. Evaluation tools included the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) hindfoot ankle score, a pain visual analog scale (VAS), and talar tilt angle.
Results:
The change in talar tilt angle from preoperative to 12 months postoperative was significantly greater in the laxity group (-6.9 ± 5.2) compared with the no-laxity group (-4.2 ± 4.2) ( P = .03). The final follow-up AOFAS hindfoot ankle score and pain VAS in both groups showed improvement compared with the preoperative values.
Conclusion:
All groups achieved successful clinical and radiological final follow-up outcomes. Arthroscopic MBO should be considered a reasonable method in patients who have chronic lateral ankle instability, regardless of generalized ligamentous laxity.
Level of evidence:
III, comparative study.
Background:
No reported study has compared clinical and radiologic outcomes between an all-inside arthroscopic modified Broström operation (MBO) and an open MBO. The purpose of this study was to compare clinical and radiologic outcomes of all-inside arthroscopic and open MBOs.
Methods:
From August 2012 to July 2014, 48 patients were included. They were divided into 2 groups: all-inside arthroscopic MBO (25 patients) and open MBO (23 patients). The American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot score, visual analog scale (VAS) score, and Karlsson score were used to evaluate clinical outcomes. Anterior talar translation and talar tilt were used to evaluate radiologic outcomes. All patients had lateral ankle instability. MBO was performed in 87 patients. Of these, 50 patients met the inclusion criteria. All patients had giving way, persistent pain, and an inability to resume their preinjury activity level for more than 6 months. Patients were randomized into 2 groups, all-inside arthroscopic MBO and open MBO, using a permuted block randomization method. Clinical outcome evaluations were performed preoperatively, at 6 weeks and 6 months postoperatively, and at a final follow-up at a minimum of 12 months postoperatively using the Karlsson score, the AOFAS ankle-hindfoot score, and pain VAS scores. Radiologic outcome evaluations were performed preoperatively and at 1 year postoperatively at final follow-up using anterior talar translation, and talar tilt angle.
Results:
After randomization, 25 ankles were allocated to the all-inside arthroscopic MBO group and 25 to the open MBO group. Two ankles in the open MBO group were excluded from the analysis because they were lost to follow-up. Thus, evaluations were performed for 25 ankles in the all-inside arthroscopic MBO group and 23 in the open MBO group. There was no difference in age, gender, symptom duration, preoperative AOFAS, VAS, Karlsson scores, anterior talar translation, or talar tilt between the 2 groups (all P > .05). At the final follow-up, the AOFAS, VAS, and the Karlsson scores had improved significantly in both groups (P < .001). There was no difference in the Karlsson, AOFAS, or VAS scores, anterior talar translation, or talar tilt between the 2 groups at final follow-up (all P > .05).
Conclusions:
There was no difference in the clinical or radiologic outcome between the all-inside arthroscopic MBO and open MBO for the treatment of lateral ankle instability at up to 1 year after surgery. An all-inside arthroscopic MBO should be considered carefully in patients who have lateral ankle instability.
Level of evidence:
Level I, randomized controlled trial.
Background:
Chronic ankle instability is defined by an instability lasting more than 6 months, in those cases where a comprehensive conservative treatment fails a surgical stabilization is required. Several surgical techniques have been proposed for the management of the chronic lateral instability of the ankle and even after 50 years, the Broström-Gould technique is still considered the gold standard for the treatment of this pathology. Recently, many authors have developed completely arthroscopic lateral ligament repair and the use of these procedures is rapidly increasing. The aim of this review is to provide an updated overview of open and new arthroscopic lateral ligament repair techniques in order to summarize and compare the effectiveness of these strategies.
Methods:
A systematic literature review using PubMed/Medline databases was performed (July 1972-July 2015). Clinical results, satisfaction rate and complications of both patient populations were recorded and statistically analyzed.
Results:
The total ankles treated with an open Broström ATFL repair in the 13 studies was 505 with a mean follow up of 73.4 months (range 9 months-27.9 years). Postoperative AOFAS score was reported in 11 studies, with a mean value of 90.1 (range, 60-100), patient's satisfaction rate was 91.7%. Surgery-related complications occurred in 40 (7.92%) out of 505 treated ankles. The total number of ankles treated within the 6 arthroscopic studies was 216 with a mean follow up of 37.2 months (range 6 months-14 years). Five studies reported a mean postoperative AOFAS score of 92.48 (range, 44-100) with a patient's satisfaction rate of 96.4%. Surgery-related complications were observed in 33 (15.27%) cases.
Conclusions:
The results of this review show the excellent efficacy of open and arthroscopic surgical procedures in the treatment of the chronic ankle instability. The higher complication rate of arthroscopic procedures respect to the open ones represents the major issue: however, this does not seem to affect the patient's satisfaction. Because of statistical heterogeneity observed no definitive conclusions can be statistically drawn. Finally, to definitively validate the effectiveness of arthroscopic procedures prospective and comparative studies are needed.
Background
The concept of utilizing nonabsorbable suture tape fixed directly to bone to augment Brostrom repairs of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) has been proposed. However, no clinical data are currently available regarding the arthroscopic modified Brostrom operation with an internal brace. Materials and methodsThis study involved 85 consecutive patients (22 in the with internal brace group; 63 in the without internal brace group) who could be followed up for >6 months after undergoing an arthroscopic modified Brostrom operation. The American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score was administered to assess the functional status. At preoperation and at 24 weeks after surgery, the anterior drawer test was examined clinically. ResultsImprovement of mean AOFAS score in the internal brace group from before surgery to two weeks after surgery was statistically significant (p < 0.05). At 24-week follow-up, the anterior drawer test showed grade 0 laxity in 19 patients (86.4 %) and grade 1 in three patients (13.6 %). Improvement of AOFAS score in the group without an internal brace from before surgery to 6 weeks after surgery was not statistically significant (p = 0.001). At 24-week follow-up, the anterior drawer test showed grade 0 laxity in 54 patients (85.7 %) and grade 1 in nine patients (14.3 %). Conclusion
Patients in the internal brace group were able to quickly return to activity and sports. We believe this technique could be a viable option for surgically treating chronic lateral ankle instability in patients who need an early return to activity and sports. Level of evidenceIII.
Context:
Individuals with chronic ankle instability (CAI) have reported decreased global and regional function. Despite the identification of functional deficits in those with CAI, more research is required to determine the extent to which CAI influences the multidimensional profile of health-related quality of life.
Objective:
To determine whether global, regional, and psychological health-related outcomes differ between individuals with and without CAI.
Design:
Case-control study.
Setting:
Laboratory.
Patients or other participants:
Twenty-five participants with CAI (age = 21.9 ± 2.5 years, height = 170.8 ± 8.6 cm, mass = 69.8.0 ± 11.7 kg) were sex- and limb-matched to 25 healthy participants (age = 22.0 ± 2.1 years, height = 167.4 ± 9.1 cm, mass = 64.8 ± 11.2 kg).
Main outcome measure(s):
Both groups completed the Disablement in the Physically Active Scale, the Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM), the FAAM-Sport, the Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia-11, and the Fear-Avoidance Beliefs Questionnaire. Dependent variables were scores on these instruments, and the independent variable was group.
Results:
Compared with healthy individuals, those with CAI reported decreased function on the Disablement in the Physically Active Scale, FAAM, and FAAM-Sport (P < .001) and increased fear of reinjury on the Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia-11 and Fear-Avoidance Beliefs Questionnaire (P < .001). In the CAI group, the FAAM and FAAM-Sport demonstrated a significant relationship (r = 0.774, P < .01).
Conclusions:
Individuals with CAI reported decreased function and increased fear of reinjury compared with healthy control participants. Also, within the CAI group, there was a strong relationship between FAAM and FAAM-Sport scores but not between any other instruments. These findings suggest that health-related quality of life should be examined during the rehabilitation process of individuals with CAI.
Lateral ankle sprains are common; if conservative treatment fails and chronic instability develops, stabilization surgery is indicated. Numerous surgical procedures have been described, but those that most closely reproduce normal ankle lateral ligament anatomy and kinematics have been shown to have the best outcomes. Arthroscopy is a common adjunct to open ligament surgery, but it is traditionally only used to improve the diagnosis and the management of any associated intra-articular lesions. The stabilization itself is performed open because standard anterior ankle arthroscopy provides only partial visualization of the anterior talofibular ligament from above and the calcaneofibular ligament attachments cannot be seen at all. However, lateral ankle endoscopy can provide a view of this area that is superior to open surgery. We have developed a technique of ankle endoscopy that enables anatomic positioning of the repair or fixation of the graft. In this article we describe a safe and reproducible arthroscopic anatomic reconstruction of the lateral ligaments of the ankle using a gracilis autograft. The aim of this procedure is to obtain a more physiological reconstruction while maintaining all the advantages of an arthroscopic approach.
Background:
Lateral ankle sprains may result in pain and disability in the short term, decreased sport activity and early retirement from sports in the mid term, and secondary injuries and development of early osteoarthritis to the ankle in the long term.
Hypothesis:
This combined approach to chronic lateral instability and intra-articular lesions of the ankle is safe and in the long term maintains mechanical stability, functional ability, and a good level of sport activity.
Study design:
Case series; Level of evidence, 4.
Methods:
We present the long-term outcomes of 42 athletes who underwent ankle arthroscopy and anterior talofibular Broström repair for management of chronic lateral ankle instability. We assessed in all patients preoperative and postoperative anterior drawer test and side-to-side differences, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, and Kaikkonen grading scales. Patients were asked about return to sport and level of activity. Patients were also assessed for development of degenerative changes to the ankle, and preoperative versus postoperative findings were compared.
Results:
Thirty-eight patients were reviewed at an average of 8.7 years (range, 5-13 years) after surgery; 4 patients were lost to follow-up. At the last follow-up, patients were significantly improved for ankle laxity, AOFAS scores, and Kaikkonen scales. The mean AOFAS score improved from 51 (range, 32-71) to 90 (range, 67-100), and the mean Kaikkonen score improved from 45 (range, 30-70) to 90 (range, 65-100). According to outcome criteria set preoperatively, there were 8 failures by the AOFAS score and 9 by the Kaikkonen score. Twenty-two (58%) patients practiced sport at the preinjury level, 6 (16%) had changed to lower levels but were still active in less demanding sports (cycling and tennis), and 10 (26%) had abandoned active sport participation although they still were physically active. Six of these patients did not feel safe with their ankle because of the occurrence of new episodes of ankle instability. Of the 27 patients who had no evidence of degenerative changes preoperatively, 8 patients (30%) had radiographic signs of degenerative changes (5 grade I and 3 grade II) of the ankle; 4 of the 11 patients (11%) with preexisting grade I changes remained unchanged, and 7 patients (18%) had progressed to grade II. No correlation was found between osteoarthritis and status of sport activity (P = .72).
Conclusion:
Combined Broström repair and ankle arthroscopy are safe and allow most patients to return to preinjury daily and sport activities.
The majority of lateral ankle instability can be treated successfully with conservative method. However, if such treatments fail, surgical treatment should be considered. A wide variety of procedures have been introduced to treat chronic lateral ankle instability. The percutaneous method avoids dissection which is associated with open surgery and can lead to excessive morbidity. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical and radiological outcomes of percutaneous lateral ligament reconstruction with an allograft in the treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability.
Between October 2006 and April 2009, percutaneous lateral ligament reconstruction using an allograft was performed on 15 ankles in 13 patients for chronic lateral ankle instability. The patients included in this study satisfied at least one of the following criteria: a previously failed reconstruction of the ligament, severe ankle instability (more than 15 degrees of talar tilt, more than 10 mm of anterior drawer), general laxity of ligaments, body mass index (BMI) higher than 25. The mean followup period was 18.1 (range, 12 to 40) months. The grafted tendon was secured by double tenodeses at both the talus and calcaneus or triple tenodeses which included a fibular tenodesis. The clinical outcomes were evaluated with Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain, Karlsson-Peterson ankle score, and patients' subjective satisfaction. The radiological results were evaluated using the varus tilting angle and the anterior displacement distance.
The VAS improved from preoperative 3.7 ±2.2 to 1.6 ±1.3 at the last followup (p = 0.002). The Karlsson-Peterson ankle score increased from 54.2 ±8.8 to 80.9 ±7.2 (p = 0.001). Patients were satisfied in 13 cases (86.7%) with excellent or good results. Radiologically, the mean varus tilting angle was 15.5 ±4.4 degrees preoperatively and 7.3 ±3.6 at the last followup (p = 0.001). The anterior drawer distance was 10.1 ±3.3 mm preoperatively and 7.2 ±2.7 mm at last followup (p = 0.001).
We believe percutaneous lateral ligament reconstruction with allograft to be a useful method as a salvage procedure for the treatment of severe and complicated types of chronic lateral ankle instability. Furthermore, the minimal invasiveness of this technique provides a good cosmetic outcome and we found it to be a technically easy and fast procedure.
Ankle sprains are a common injury among physically active populations and occur with an incidence of around 2.15 per 1000 person-years. This article discusses various surgical procedures used to treat chronic lateral ankle instability, including direct ligament repair, anatomic reconstruction, and nonanatomic reconstruction. We focus our discussion on the most common and challenging complications of ankle stabilization, both in our experience and as supported by the existing literature, including recurrent instability, superficial peroneal nerve injury, and unaddressed pathology that continues to cause symptoms and limit function. We offer possible methods to manage these conditions as well as available outcome data.
Many operative procedures have been reported for the management of chronic lateral ankle instability, and anatomical reconstructions are an excellent option. However, if the remnants of the ligaments are considerably damaged, anatomical reconstructions using such remnants can be difficult. In cases such as these, tenodesis stabilization may be required. However, tenodesis stabilization often restricts the range of ankle movement. The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of a new procedure that we developed to mitigate the problems associated with tenodesis stabilization procedures. We installed grafts in the original anatomical position by devising a system for positioning the drill holes in the bones so that our procedure did not restrict the range of ankle movement. A retrospective review of 37 patients (13 men, 24 women) with a mean age of 30.2 (range, 16–66) years was performed at an average of 69 (range, 47–77) months after the surgery. The average American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society ankle–hindfoot score improved significantly from 65.6 (range, 47–77) points preoperatively to 98.0 (range, 87–100) points postoperatively (P < 0.001). With the number of subjects available, no significant differences were detected between the postoperative mean ranges of movement of the ankle and subtalar joints and those of the preoperative ankle. Patients who underwent anatomical tenodesis reconstructions with a free split peroneal brevis tendon showed good outcomes after a 69-month follow-up period.
Chronic lateral ankle instability is the sensation of the ankle giving way along with recurrent sprains, chronic pain and swelling of the ankle for 1 year. The lateral ankle complex comprises the anterior talofibular ligament, calcaneofibular ligament, and posterior talofibular ligament. The anterior talofibular ligament is the most commonly injured ligament of the lateral ankle. Evaluation comprises a history and physical with concomitant imaging to confirm the diagnosis and can be used to evaluate for concurrent pathology. The most popular treatment is a direct anatomic repair; however, additional options can be used in specific patient populations.
Background:
Immediately following a lateral ligament reconstruction of the ankle, the strength of the repair is far less than that of the native anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL). Additionally, early functional rehabilitation has been shown to increase laxity of the repair. We hypothesized that a Broström procedure augmented with a suture-tape construct would allow early functional rehabilitation while maintaining patient reported outcomes within a military population.
Methods:
This study is a retrospective study of 93 consecutive patients with chronic lateral ankle instability that were treated with a Broström procedure augmented with a suture-tape construct. Subjects were evaluated at 2, 6, and 12 weeks postoperatively, with yearly satisfaction reviews. Demographics and functional outcomes including Foot and Ankle Disability Index (FADI), visual analog scale (VAS), satisfaction score, and clinical measures including single-leg hop and single-leg heel raise were recorded. Our patients included 75 males and 18 females with a mean age of 30 ± 7 (range, 19-51) years; our mean follow-up was 19 (range, 3-48) months.
Results:
The mean FADI score improved from 67 preoperatively to 87 and 90 at 6 and 12 weeks (P < .001), with 60 patients (65%) obtaining a score greater than 90. The mean VAS scores improved from 4.8 preoperatively to 1.4 and 1.3 at 6 and 12 weeks (P < .001). Eighty-two (96%) of the patients asked were able to complete a single-leg hop and single-leg heel raise at 6 weeks. The 12-, 24-, 36-, and 48-month satisfaction scores were 8.5, 9.8, 9.2, and 8.9, respectively. Demographics collected did not impact results.
Conclusion:
This study suggests that a Broström procedure augmented with suture tape enabled early safe functional rehabilitation without subsequent failure. Our data also demonstrated a sustained high level of patient satisfaction while preventing reoccurrence within a high-demand military population.
Level of evidence:
Level IV, retrospective case series.
Surgical management for chronic lateral ankle ligament instability is useful when patients have failed nonoperative modalities. Open anatomic reconstruction is an effective method of stabilization. Ankle arthroscopy is a recommended to address intra-articular disorder before stabilization. An anatomic approach provides full range of motion, stability, and return to sport and activity. Allograft or suture tape augmentation can be useful for patients with generalized ligamentous laxity, patients with high body mass index, and elite athletes. Allograft reconstruction may be especially useful in revision procedures. Arthroscopic approach to lateral ankle ligament stabilization may provide good outcomes, with long-term data still limited.
Chronic ankle instability predominantly occurs due to multiple exercise-related diseases. Conservative treatment methods regarding this condition have not effectively improved in recent years, which is why more focus has been put on exploring different novel reconstruction procedures of the lateral ankle ligament for the treatment of chronic ankle instability.
Objectives
This study aims to obtain the overall effectiveness of various lateral ankle ligament reconstruction methods for chronic ankle ligament instability.
Methods
We gathered data from PubMed and EMBASE databases using the keywords: ankle, malleolar, and reconstruction. Newcastle - Ottawa quality assessment was carried out for the obtained studies; effect volume combination and image drawing were performed by Stata14, and Excel was used for data statistics.
Results
A total of 12 articles were included in the quantitative analysis by performing full-text reading and data inclusion. Among them, 476 patients (485 ankle joints) were treated. The results showed that the overall valid efficiency of “excellent” was 59% and “good” lateral ligament reconstruction was 26%, I²=87.3%, P=0.000; the subgroup analysis anatomic reconstruction group I²=0.0%, P=0.993; the autograft group I²=0.0%, P=1.000; allograft group I²=0.0%, P=0.993.
Conclusion
Reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligament is a relatively stable treatment for chronic ankle instability.
Purpose
. In chronic lateral ankle instability, primary ligament repair is not always possible because of poor quality of the local tissues. A free autologous or allograft tendon graft or synthetic grafts are suitable alternative. We describe middle term results of arthroscopic reconstruction of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL)using a free autologous ipsilateral gracilis graft in patients with chronic ankle instability.
Methods
. Eleven patients with chronic lateral ankle instability with imaging evidence of isolated ATFL tear underwent arthroscopic reconstruction of the ATFL using a free ipsilateral gracilis graft. Functional and subjective assessment were performed after an average of 24 months following the index procedure.
Results
. At 24 months, all patients showed objective improvements. One patient reported transient dysaesthesiae on the dorsolateral aspect of the foot and heel.
Conclusions
. Arthroscopic isolated reconstruction of the ATFL with a free ipsilateral gracilis grafts is safe, allowing restoration of joint stability and low surgical morbidity.
Study design
. Case series
Surgeons should understand the anatomic, vascular, biomechanical, and predisposing factors related to lateral ankle instability and peroneal tendon injuries, including peroneal tendinitis and tenosynovitis, peroneal tendon tears and ruptures, as well as peroneal tendon subluxation and dislocation. Surgeons should understand the treatment options and recommendations for patients who have lateral ankle instability and peroneal tendon injuries from the perspective of a sports medicine foot and ankle specialist. In addition, surgeons should be aware of arthroscopic approaches and an algorithm for the treatment of patients who have lateral ankle instability and peroneal tendon injuries.
Open surgical reconstruction for chronic lateral ankle instability is a proven and effective means of providing renewed stability. Ankle arthroscopy is recommended before reconstruction to address intra-articular pathology. The open procedure discussed is well researched and proven to restore stability and the ability to return to sport and daily activity. Anatomic shortening with reattachment into a bony trough allows return to full motion, reliable stability, and return to an active lifestyle without sacrificing any tendons or requiring a tenodesis. The authors’ aggressive rehabilitation protocol is provided; the approach to athletes/patients with ligament laxity or cavovarus alignment is also addressed.
Purpose:
The purpose of this meta-analysis was to analyze the current comparative studies of arthroscopic and open techniques for lateral ankle ligament repair to treat chronic lateral ankle instability.
Methods:
A systematic search of MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane Library databases was performed during February 2018. Included studies were evaluated with regard to level of evidence and quality of evidence using the Modified Coleman Methodology Score. Total number of patients, patient age, follow-up time, gender ratio, surgical technique, surgical complications, complication rate, recurrent instability or revision rate, clinical outcome measures and percentage of patients who returned to sport at previous level were also evaluated. Statistical analysis was performed using RevMan, and a p value of < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant.
Results:
Four comparative studies for a total of 207 ankles were included. There was a significant difference in favor of arthroscopic repair with regard to AOFAS score, and there was no significant difference with regard to Karlsson score. There was a statistically significant difference in AOFAS score in favor of the arthroscopic repair (MD; 1.41, 95% CI 0.29-2.52, I2 = 0%, p < 0.05). There was no statistically significant difference in Karlsson score (MD; 0.00, 95% CI - 3.51 to 3.51, I2 = 0%, n.s.). There was no statistically significant difference in total, nerve, or wound complications.
Conclusions:
The current meta-analysis found that short-term AOFAS functional outcome scores were significantly improved with arthroscopic lateral ankle repair compared to open repair. There was no significant difference between arthroscopic and open repair with regards to Karlsson functional outcome score, total complication rate, or the nerve and wound complication subsets with the included studies with at least 12 months of follow-up. However, the current evidence is still limited, and further prospective trials with longer follow-up are needed.
Level of evidence:
III.
In this retrospective study, we assessed the outcome in 99 patients who underwent reconstruction of the lateral ligaments of the ankle for chronic anterolateral instability with a minimum follow-up of 15 years.
Two techniques were compared: 54 patients had an anatomical reconstruction (AR group) and 45 had an Evans tenodesis (ET group). They were followed up for 19.9 ± 3.6 years and 21.8 ± 4.6 years, respectively. During follow-up, seven patients in the AR group and 17 in the ET group required a further operation (p = 0.004). At follow-up, significantly more patients (n = 15) in the ET group had limited dorsiflexion than in the AR group (n = 6, p = 0.007) and 18 in the ET group had a positive anterior drawer test compared with seven in the AR group (p = 0002). In the ET group 27 had tenderness on palpation of the ankle compared with 15 in the AR group (p = 0.001). Stress radiographs showed ligamentous laxity significantly more often in the ET group (n = 30) than in the AR group (n = 13, p < 0.001). The mean values for talar tilt and anterior talar translation were significantly higher in the ET group than in the AR group (p < 0.001, p = 0.007, respectively). There were degenerative changes on standard radiographs in 32 patients in the AR group and 35 in the ET group (p = 0.05). Four patients in the ET group had developed severe osteoarthritis compared with none in the AR group (p = 0.025). Assessment of functional stability revealed a mean Karlsson score of 83.7 ± 10.4 points in the AR group and 67.0 ± 15.8 points in the ET group (p < 0.001). According to the Good rating system, 43 patients in the AR group had good or excellent results compared with 15 in the ET group (p < 0.001).
Compared with anatomical reconstruction, the Evans tenodesis does not prevent laxity in a large number of patients. Long-standing ligamentous laxity leads to degenerative change in the ankle, resulting in chronic pain, limited dorsiflexion and further operations. The functional result deteriorates more rapidly after the Evans tenodesis than after anatomical reconstruction.
Background:
Anatomic graft reconstruction of the anterior talo-fibular ligament is an alternative for patients who are bad candidates for standard procedures such as a Broström-Gould reconstruction (high-demand athletes, obesity, hyperlaxity or collagen disorders, capsular insufficiency or talar avulsions). The purpose of this study is to describe an all-inside arthroscopic technique for ATFL reconstruction, and the results in a series of patients with chronic ankle instability.
Methods:
We reviewed patients with chronic ATFL ruptures treated with an all-inside arthroscopic allograft reconstruction of the ATFL, with a minimum 2-year follow-up. Twenty-two patients with lateral ankle instability were included. Mean follow-up was 34±2.5 months.
Results:
The mean AOFAS score improved from 62.3±6.7 points preoperatively to 97.2±3.2 points at final follow-up. Three patients suffered complications: one case each of ankle rigidity, superficial peroneal nerve injury and fibular fracture.
Conclusions:
Chronic ATFL injuries are amenable to all-inside arthroscopic allograft reconstruction fixed with tenodesis screws. This procedure simplifies other reported techniques in that it facilitates identification and bone tunnel placement of the talar ATFL insertion.
Background
Although various minimally invasive procedures for chronic ankle instability are increasingly being used, a question regarding whether these procedures can be a viable alternative of the modified Broström procedure remains controversial. This study was conducted to compare the intermediate-term clinical outcomes between lateral ligaments augmentation using suture-tape and modified Broström repair in a selected cohort of patients.
Methods
Sixty female patients with chronic lateral ankle instability were randomly assigned and underwent surgical treatments by one surgeon. Twenty-eight patients with suture-tape augmentation and 27 modified Broström procedures were followed ≥2 years and analysed in this comparative study. The clinical evaluation included the Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS), Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM), and stress radiographs. Medical expense related with operation was analysed to evaluate the cost-effectiveness.
Results
There were no statistically significant differences in the clinical outcomes between two procedures based on FAOS, FAAM, recurrence rate of instability, and stress radiographs. Total medical expense was approximately 1.3 times more in the suture-tape group (P < 0.001), despite shorter operation time.
Conclusions
Lateral ankle ligaments augmentation using suture-tape showed the similar clinical outcomes but low cost-effectiveness, as compared to modified Broström repair for young female patients with chronic ankle instability.
Background:
The modified Broström procedure (MBP) is widely accepted as the primary operative treatment for chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI). However, the MBP does not produce good clinical results in all patients, and anatomic reconstruction using a free tendon graft may be considered in those patients. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of the MBP using distal fibular periosteal flap augmentation for CLAI in patients who were not candidates for standard repair.
Methods:
Thirty-eight patients (39 ankles) who underwent surgery for CLAI were retrospectively analyzed. The patients were divided into 2 groups: an anatomic lateral ligament reconstruction group (reconstruction group) consisting of 17 ankles and an MBP group using distal fibular periosteal flap augmentation (augmentation group) consisting of 22 ankles. Preoperative and postoperative clinical evaluations were performed using the visual analog scale (VAS), American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS), and Karlsson-Peterson (Karlsson) scores.
Results:
The mean VAS, AOFAS, and Karlsson scores significantly improved from 4.0 to 1.8, 54.7 to 92.9, and 46.4 to 92.7, respectively, in the reconstruction group ( P < .001, P < .001, P < .001), and from 4.1 to 1.5, 60.1 to 94.9, and 52.6 to 94.1, respectively, in the augmentation group ( P < .001, P < .001, P < .001). There were no significant differences in the mean postoperative AOFAS and Karlsson scores between the groups ( P = .214, P = .299).
Conclusion:
The MBP using distal fibular periosteal flap augmentation was also an effective option for CLAI in cases of generalized ligament laxity, severe attenuation of the soft tissue, previous failed surgery, high demand activity, and obesity.
Level of evidence:
Level III, comparative series.
Background:
Few studies have compared outcomes of Broström-Gould repair and allograft reconstruction.
Hypothesis/purpose:
The purpose of this study was to compare outcomes and revision rates after Broström-Gould lateral ankle ligament repair versus anatomic allograft reconstruction in patients with lateral ankle instability. The hypothesis was that patients who underwent lateral ankle ligament repair would have outcomes and revision rates similar to those of patients who underwent anatomic allograft reconstruction.
Study design:
Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.
Methods:
All patients who underwent surgical repair or reconstruction of the anterior talofibular ligament and/or the calcaneofibular ligament by a single surgeon between September 2009 and February 2013 were included in this study. Patients completed a subjective questionnaire at minimum 2 years after ankle surgery. Outcomes measures included the Foot and Ankle Disability Index (FADI), American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) Ankle-Hindfoot Score, Lysholm score, Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index (WOMAC), Short Form-12 Physical Component Summary (PCS) and Mental Component Summary (MCS) scores, Tegner activity scale, and patient satisfaction with outcome. Detailed surgical data and intraoperative findings were documented at the time of surgery. All data were collected prospectively and reviewed retrospectively.
Results:
A total of 86 patients were included in this study: 45 men and 41 women (mean age, 38 years; range, 19-68 years) with a mean body mass index of 26.5 (range, 17.5-47.1). There were 61 (71%) patients in the repair cohort and 25 (29%) in the reconstruction cohort. There was no significant difference in age or sex between cohorts. Seventy-six (88%) patients had minimum 2-year follow-up (mean follow-up, 3.0 years; range, 2.0-5.3 years). There was no significant difference in FADI (87 vs 91; P = .553), AOFAS (77 vs 82; P = .372), Lysholm score (83 vs 87; P = .110), Tegner activity scale (6 vs 4; P = .271), patient satisfaction (9 vs 10; P = .058), WOMAC (8 vs 5; P = .264), or Short Form-12 PCS (51.3 vs 54.6; P = .169) or MCS (54.8 vs 51.5; P = .239) score between the repair cohort and the reconstruction cohort, respectively. No patient in either cohort underwent revision lateral ligament surgery.
Conclusion:
When compared with lateral ankle repair, anatomic allograft reconstruction produced similarly favorable outcomes, including high patient satisfaction, high function and activity levels, and no revision surgeries in either cohort.
Background:
This case series evaluated the clinical and functional outcomes of patients with lateral ankle instability treated with a primary modified Brostrom-Evans.
Methods:
Nineteen patients who underwent the modified Brostrom-Evans procedure for lateral ankle instability with a minimum follow-up of 5 years were reviewed. Physical exams were performed and weight-bearing ankle radiographs taken at final follow-up. Clinical outcomes were evaluated using Short Form Health Survey (SF-36), Foot Function Index (FFI), and Visual Analog Scale (VAS) scores. Functional outcomes were assessed using a goniometer for ankle range of motion (ROM) and dynamometer for ankle strength compared to the non-operative extremity.
Results:
Average age at time of surgery was 34 ± 11 years (range 17-58 years) and average follow-up was 8.7 ± 2.8 years (range 5.1-15.4 years). At final follow-up, average total SF-36 and FFI scores were 83 ± 18 and 11% ± 18%, respectively. Average VAS at rest was 1 ± 1 and during activities 2 ± 2. There were no significant differences in ankle eversion ROM or strength between operative and non-operative extremities. Ankle eversion strength in operative extremities was 91 ± 12% of non-operative ankles. Ankle ROM was similar in all planes except for a 41% decrease in ankle inversion in surgically treated extremities compared to the contralateral side (p = .01).
Conclusions:
Patients treated with the modified Brostrom-Evans procedure for lateral ankle ligament reconstruction have minimal loss of peroneal strength, decreased inversion ROM, and no recurrent instability or progressive symptomatic subtalar arthritis requiring re-operation at long-term follow-up.
Levels of evidence:
Level IV: Retrospective case series.
The modified Broström procedure is commonly used for anatomic repair of chronic lateral ankle instability. However, no studies have compared outcomes of gender-based differences after the modified Broström procedure. We compared outcomes of the modified Broström procedure in men and women.
A total of 155 patients (155 ankles) treated with the modified Broström procedure for chronic lateral ankle instability constituted the study cohort. The 155 ankles were divided into 2 groups: a men's group (94 ankles) and a women's group (61 ankles). The Karlsson score, American Orthopedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot score, talar tilt, and anterior talar translation were used to evaluate clinical and radiographic outcomes. The mean follow-up duration was 42.8 months (range, 24-101).
Mean preoperative Karlsson scores were 53.6 points (39-65) in the men's group and 54.9 points (39-65) in the women's group, and these improved to 93.2 (72-100) and 92.2 (80-100), respectively, at the final follow-up. Mean preoperative AOFAS ankle-hindfoot scores were 62.4 points (44-79) in men and 63.6 points (49-77) in women and 93.7 (72-100) and 92.3 (79-100), respectively, at the final follow-up. Mean preoperative talar tilt angles decreased from 11.9 degrees (2.5-27.5) in men and 11.4 degrees (0.9-24.7) in women to 6.0 (1.0-11.5) and 6.0 (2.3-11.9), respectively, at the final follow-up. Mean preoperative anterior talar translation in men and women improved from 8.6 mm (5.1-14.6) and 8.7 mm (2.3-11.9) to 6.0 (4.3-8.7) and 5.8 (3.3-9.9), respectively, at the final follow-up. No significant differences were found between men and women in terms of Karlsson scores, AOFAS scores, talar tilt angle, and anterior talar translation.
The modified Broström procedure showed similar good functional and radiographic outcomes in men and women. These results suggest that the modified Broström procedure is effective and reliable for treating chronic lateral ankle instability regardless of gender.
Level III, retrospective comparative cohort study.
© The Author(s) 2015.
Although the modified Brostrom procedure has had excellent clinical results, postoperative complications such as skin irritation by suture material and problematic scar formation occur. This prospective study was performed to evaluate the clinical outcomes of mini-open ligament augmentation (internal brace technique) using suture tape for chronic ankle instability in a select cohort of patients.
Thirty-four young female patients with less than 70 kg of body weight were followed for more than 2 years after suture tape augmentation for lateral ankle instability. The clinical evaluation consisted of the Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS), Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM) score, Sefton grading system, and the period to return to various activities. Measurement of talar tilt angle and anterior talar translation was obtained from stress radiographs to evaluate the longevity of mechanical ankle stability.
FAOS and FAAM scores had significantly improved to 92.5 points at final follow-up (P < .001). According to the Sefton grading, 31 cases (91.2%) achieved satisfactory functional results. The period to return to exercise was on average 10.2 weeks for jogging and 9.6 weeks for walking on uneven ground. The average subjective satisfaction score of patients was 93.8 points, and satisfaction with the scar was 98.5 points. Talar tilt angle and anterior talar translation had significantly improved to an average of 4.5 degrees and 4.1 mm, respectively, at final follow-up (P < .001). There were no complications such as skin irritation and wound infection, except for 1 case of chronic inflammation.
Minimally invasive suture tape augmentation seems to be an effective alternative for young women with chronic ankle instability. Because there is a possibility of progressive elongation over time, the longevity of mechanical ankle stability and the proper indication for using the internal brace technique should be addressed in future studies.
Level IV, case series study.
© The Author(s) 2015.
Lateral ankle instability is one of the most common musculoskeletal disorders and can result in ankle damage. This study reports on the results of the anatomical reconstruction of ligaments using semitendinosus tendon allograft and bioabsorbable tenodesis screws for chronic lateral ankle instability, as well as the functional and radiological results of this procedure.
From February 2007 to January 2013, 70 patients (72 ankles) underwent this procedure. Six patients were lost to follow-up, and ultimately 64 patients (66 ankles) were evaluated. Visual Analog Scale (VAS) pain scores, American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) scores, Karlsson-Peterson ankle scores, and patient satisfaction were evaluated at a mean of 22.1 months (range, 12-68 months) postoperatively. The talar tilt angle and anterior translation were assessed radiographically in pre- and postoperative ankle stress views. The mean patient age at surgery was 30.1 years (range, 16-59 years).
The mean VAS pain score decreased from 5.5 to 1.3 (P < .05), and the mean AOFAS improved from 71.0 to 90.9 (P < .05). The mean Karlsson-Peterson score improved from 55.1 to 90.3, whereas talar tilt decreased from 14.8 degrees to 3.9 degrees. There was no significant difference in clinical outcomes between the pretensioned and nonpretensioned groups.
This procedure yielded successful results, including satisfactory ankle stability and clinical outcomes, in ankles with poor lateral ligament tissues.
Level IV, case series.
© The Author(s) 2015.
Surgical strategy regarding chronic lateral ankle instability is undergoing an evolution from traditional open procedures to minimally invasive and arthroscopic techniques. The development of arthroscopic techniques for the ankle mirrors the processes witnessed for the shoulder and knee over the last 30 years. The arthroscopic Brostrom is a novel technique that allows the surgeon to use an arthroscope to perform a lateral ankle ligament reconstruction that was previously thought possible only through open surgical technique. Indications and contraindications for the arthroscopic technique are essentially the same as those for an open Brostrom type of procedure. The arthroscopic Brostrom procedure is easy to remember and relatively simple to perform for the surgeon who has mastered basic ankle arthroscopy. The authors' results discussed in this article reveal that the arthroscopic Brostrom is a safe and effective procedure with outcomes at least equal to published results for traditional open techniques.
Level V, expert opinion.
© The Author(s) 2015.
Background
There are various ligament reattachment techniques for the modified Brostrom procedure. There have been few comparative studies on recently developed techniques. This prospective study was performed to compare the functional outcomes of 2 different ligament reattachment techniques using suture anchors. We furthermore evaluated the cost-effectiveness of the suture bridge technique.
Methods
Forty-five amateur athletes under 30 years of age were followed for more than 2 years. Twenty-four procedures with the suture anchor technique and 21 procedures with the suture bridge technique were performed by one surgeon. The functional evaluation consisted of the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS), Karlsson score, Sefton grading system, and the period to return to various forms of exercise (jogging, spurt running, jumping, one leg standing for >1 minute, walking on uneven ground, and going down stairs). Measurement of talar tilt angle and anterior talar translation was obtained from stress radiographs to evaluate mechanical stability.
Results
There were no significant differences on AOFAS score, FAOS, Karlsson score, Sefton grade, and stress radiographs. There were no significant differences on the return to exercises, except for jumping. As the most common complication, there were 3 cases of skin irritation by suture materials in the suture anchor group and 2 cases of intraoperative breakage of the suture anchor in suture bridge group.
Conclusions
Both ligament reattachment techniques using suture anchors showed similar functional outcomes. Considering the additional medical expenses incurred by more suture anchors, the modified Brostrom procedure using the suture bridge technique had low cost-effectiveness. Proper indication and clinical usefulness of suture bridge technique for chronic ankle instability will be addressed in further studies.
Level of Evidence
Level II, prospective comparative study.
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to assess the incidence of iatrogenic articular cartilage injuries during ankle arthroscopy and to determine the factors that caused them. The hypothesis of this study was that the incidence of iatrogenic cartilage injuries produced during ankle arthroscopic procedures is high and directly related to the arthroscopic technique.
Methods
All consecutive records from ankle arthroscopies performed between 2008 and 2010 were reviewed. Arthroscopic arthrodesis of the ankle was excluded from the study. Iatrogenic articular cartilage injury was defined as any cartilage injury that occurred during the arthroscopic procedure.
Results
The final number of ankle arthroscopic procedures reviewed was 74. There were a total of 23 iatrogenic lesions of the cartilage, for an overall complication rate of 31 %. The two most common injury locations were the anterolateral and central area of the talus. The cartilage lesion was superficial in 78.2 % of injuries (24.3 % of all patients), and deep in 21.8 % of injuries (6.7 % of all patients). Of the 23 injuries found, 65 % of them were sustained during the therapeutic portion of the arthroscopic procedure and the remaining 35 % occurred during the portal creation portion of the procedure.
Conclusion
The incidence of cartilage injury during ankle arthroscopy is high. However, severe damage was found in only 6.7 % of ankle arthroscopies.
Level of evidence
Retrospective case series, Level IV.
Background:
The purpose of this study was to assess the feasibility of inferior extensor retinaculum (IER) reinforcement and analyze differences in clinical and radiographic outcomes based on whether or not IER reinforcement was performed in modified Broström procedures.
Methods:
Forty-one patients (41 ankles) who underwent ankle reconstruction with either a Broström procedure or modified Broström with IER reinforcement were included in this prospective study. During Broström procedures, feasibility of IER reinforcement was recorded. Clinical and radiographic outcomes were analyzed between modified Broström procedures (MBP group) in which IER reinforcement was feasible and Broström procedures (BP group) in which IER reinforcement was not feasible.
Results:
IER reinforcement was feasible in 31 cases (75.6%) and not feasible in 10 cases (24.4%) due to anatomic variations. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society ankle-hindfoot score improved in the MBP group from a preoperative mean of 66.3 to a postoperative mean of 89.4. In the BP group, the score increased from 71.3 to 89.8. The radiographic outcomes assessed by stress radiographs demonstrated that talar anterior translation and talar tilt improved from 6.3 mm to 4.6 mm and from 9.0 degrees to 5.0 degrees, respectively, in the MBP group. In the BP group, talar anterior translation improved from 6.9 mm to 4.9 mm and talar tilt, from 9.5 degrees to 4.9 degrees. No statistically significant difference was observed between the 2 groups.
Conclusion:
IER reinforcement was feasible in 75.6% of patients in whom modified Broström procedures had been planned. Postoperative clinical and radiographic outcomes were not significantly different based on whether or not IER reinforcement was performed. These findings suggest that isolated ligament reconstruction without IER may be sufficient to restore ankle stability.
Level of evidence:
Level II, cohort study.
Background:
The purpose of the study was to retrospectively compare the therapeutic effect between semitendinosus autograft and tendon allograft for lateral ankle ligaments reconstruction.
Methods:
From September 2006 to June 2011, 68 patients (41 males, 27 females) with chronic ankle instability underwent anatomical reconstruction of the lateral ligaments using semitendinosus autograft (autograft group, 32 patients) or tendon allograft (allograft group, 36 patients) via a minimally invasive approach. All patients were followed up for at least 12 months. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Ankle-Hindfoot Scale score (AOFAS score) and stress tests were used to evaluate the clinical outcomes. Operation time, time to heal and complications were also recorded.
Results:
Compared with allograft group, the average operation time was significantly increased (85.5 ± 11.5 minutes vs 58.1 ± 10.2 minutes, P < .0001), but the mean time to heal was significantly shorter (11.2 ± 4.1 months vs 13.5 ± 5.2 months, P = .0458) in the autograft group. Although the mean AOFAS score was significantly increased at the final follow-up in the autograft group (95.1 ± 7.5 vs 62.3 ± 8.2, P = .0001) and allograft group (94.8 ± 5.5 vs 60.2 ± 8.4, P < .0001), no significant difference in AOFAS was found between these 2 groups. Similarly, there was no significant difference in talar tilt or shift between autograft and allograft groups. In addition, no patients complained of weakness or disability at the donor site in the autograft group, while incisional swelling was observed in 4 patients in the allograft group, which was resolved via dressing change, oral use of indomethacin or dexamethasone.
Conclusion:
Reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments using a semitendinosus tendon autograft and a minimally invasive approach was safe and effective for ankle instability with a relatively short time for healing and minimal donor site problems.
Level of evidence:
Level III, comparative case series.
Repair of acute Achilles tendon rupture is a common procedure. There are many accepted surgical techniques; suture selection is largely due to surgeon preference. We present a case report of a granulomatous reaction to suture material following Achilles tendon repair. 'Fiberwire(®)' is an increasingly popular suture material for the repair of tendons and ligamentous structures; the polyethelene braided structure with silicone and polyester coating provides high tensile strengths and good handling characteristics. Eight months following uneventful Achilles tendon repair surgery in an otherwise fit and well patient, pain, swelling and loss of function was noted. She required revision surgery with debridement and reconstruction of the tendo Achillis with flexor hallucis longus tendon transfer. Histology revealed a granulomatous reaction with giant cell response surrounding sections of the suture. Both the silicone coating of Fiberwire(®) and polyethylene core have the potential to cause a severe granulomatous reaction. We would advise caution in the use of this suture for tendo Achillis repair, and use the readily available alternatives.
Recently, arthroscopic-assisted techniques have been described to treat lateral ankle instability with excellent results. However, complications including neuritis of the superficial peroneal or sural nerve, and pain or discomfort due to a prominent anchor or suture knot have been reported. The aim of this study was to describe a novel technique, the "all-inside arthroscopic lateral collateral ankle ligament repair," and its results for treating patients with ankle instability.
Sixteen patients (10 men and 6 women, mean age 29.3 years, 17-46) with lateral ankle instability were treated with an arthroscopic procedure. Using a suture passer and a knotless anchor, the ligaments were repaired with an all-inside technique. The right ankle was affected in 10 cases. Mean follow-up was 22.3 (12-35) months.
On arthroscopic examination, 13 patients had an isolated anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) injury, and in 3 patients, both the ATFL and calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) were affected. All-inside arthroscopic anatomic repair of the lateral collateral ligament complex was performed in all cases. All patients reported subjective improvement of their ankle instability. The mean AOFAS score increased from 67 preoperatively to 97 at final follow-up. No major complications were reported.
The all-inside arthroscopic ligament repair was a safe, reliable, and reproducible technique that both provided an anatomic repair of the lateral collateral ligament complex and restored ankle stability while preserving all the advantages of an arthroscopic technique.
Level IV, retrospective case series.
Background:
Current operative treatment options for chronic lateral ankle instability include anatomic repairs utilizing existing local tissue and nonanatomic reconstructions sacrificing the peroneus brevis tendon to mechanically stabilize the ankle. Recent studies have modified these techniques to create an anatomic reconstruction utilizing allograft tendons. The purpose of this study was to retrospectively examine the clinical outcomes of a near-anatomic ligament reconstruction utilizing an allograft tendon for recurrent or complex lateral ankle instability.
Methods:
Twenty-eight patients underwent a near-anatomic allograft lateral ankle ligament reconstruction with a semitendinosis allograft for severe or recurrent lateral ankle ligamentous instability, and all of them were available for follow-up at an average 32 months. Twelve patients had previously undergone lateral ankle ligament stabilizing surgery, 4 had Ehlers Danlos syndrome with poor local tissue, 5 had greater than 30 degrees of varus angulation of talar tilt, while 12 had associated hindfoot varus requiring concomitant reconstruction. Patients were assessed pre- and postoperatively for Visual Analog Scores (VAS) for pain, Foot and Ankle Ability Measures (FAAM), patient satisfaction, radiographic correction, and complications.
Results:
Median VAS of pain decreased from 8 before surgery to 1 after surgery (P < .001). Median FAAM score increased from 41.7 to 95.2 after surgery (P < .001). Radiographic comparison demonstrated correction of preoperative varus malalignment in all but 1 patient. No patients developed subsequent subtalar arthritis or pain. Three patients had mild persistent instability, all of which was managed nonoperatively. One of the patients with persistent instability also developed chronic regional pain syndrome following surgery. At final follow-up, 25 of 28 patients rated their satisfaction as good or excellent and 3 as fair. No patients required revision surgery.
Conclusion:
Lateral ligament reconstruction utilizing a near-anatomically placed and tensioned allograft tendon was a viable option in treating recurrent and complex lateral instability. Not sacrificing the peroneal tendons avoided loss of eversion strength. Near-anatomic placement of the allograft provided good ankle stability without sacrificing subtalar motion or predisposition to subtalar arthritis in short-term follow-up.
Level of evidence:
Level IV, retrospective case series.
Background:
The modified Broström procedure is frequently used to treat chronic lateral ankle instability. There are 2 common methods of the modified Broström procedure, which are the bone tunnel and suture anchor techniques.
Purpose:
To compare the clinical outcomes of the modified Broström procedure using the bone tunnel and suture anchor techniques.
Study design:
Cohort study; Level of evidence, 2.
Methods:
Eighty-one patients (81 ankles) treated with the modified Broström procedure for chronic lateral ankle instability constituted the study cohort. The 81 ankles were divided into 2 groups, namely, a bone tunnel technique (BT group; 40 ankles) and a suture anchor technique (SA group; 41 ankles). The Karlsson score, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot score, anterior talar translation, and talar tilt angle were used to evaluate clinical and radiographic outcomes. The BT group consisted of 32 men and 8 women with a mean age of 34.8 years at surgery and a mean follow-up duration of 34.2 months. The SA group consisted of 33 men and 8 women with a mean age of 33.3 years at surgery and a mean follow-up duration of 32.8 months.
Results:
Mean Karlsson scores improved significantly from 57.0 points preoperatively to 94.9 points at final follow-up in the BT group and from 59.9 points preoperatively to 96.4 points at final follow-up in the SA group. Mean AOFAS scores also improved from 64.2 points preoperatively to 97.8 points at final follow-up in the BT group and from 70.3 points preoperatively to 97.4 points at final follow-up in the SA group. Mean anterior talar translations in the BT group and SA group improved from 9.0 mm and 9.2 mm preoperatively to 6.5 mm and 6.8 mm at final follow-up, respectively. Mean talar tilt angles were 12.0° in the BT group and 12.5° in the SA group preoperatively and 8.8° at final follow-up for both groups. No significant differences were found between the 2 groups in terms of the Karlsson score, AOFAS score, anterior talar translation, and talar tilt angle.
Conclusion:
The bone tunnel and suture anchor techniques of the modified Broström procedure showed similar good functional and radiographic outcomes. Both techniques appear to be effective and reliable methods for the treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability.
Background:
Multiple techniques have been described for reconstruction of the lateral ligaments of the ankle. Most require extensive exposure and dissection, which may lead to potential problems with wound healing, higher risk of nerve injury, fibrosis, and stiffness. This study reports on the results of a minimally invasive method to reconstruct the ligaments using a semitendinosus tendon autograft and achieve a stable ankle while avoiding these problems.
Materials and methods:
From September 2006 to May 2010, 25 patients (14 males, 11 females) with chronic ankle instability underwent lateral ligament reconstruction. The average age was 32.4 (range, 17 to 62) years old. A semitendinosus autograft was harvested through 2 small knee incisions. For the ankle reconstruction, 4 small incisions of 5 mm each were made at the medial and lateral side of the fibular tip, the talar neck, and the middle of the calcaneus. Anatomical reconstruction of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) and calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) was then performed through these small incisions. The mean final follow-up was 32.3 (range, 12 to 56) months. AOFAS questionnaires were used to measure clinical outcomes and donor site morbidity and patient satisfaction are also reported. Preoperative and postoperative stress tests were performed and radiographic parameters were measured.
Results:
The mean AOFAS score increased on average from 71.1 to 95.1 (P < .001). Two patients reported residual instability on uneven ground. No patient reported weakness or disability from the donor site. The satisfaction level was excellent in 20 patients and good in 5 patients. Significant improvement in stress radiographic parameters was noted for the talar tilt angle, with reduction from a mean of 14.0 to 3.8 degrees (P < .001); anterior talar displacement reduced from a mean of 12.3 to 4.6 mm (P < .001).
Conclusion:
Reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments using a semitendinosus tendon autograft and a minimally invasive approach can achieve a stable ankle while avoiding extensive exposure and risk of nerve injury.
Level of evidence:
Level IV, retrospective case series.
Chronic instability is a common complication of lateral ankle sprains. Furthermore, patients often have unrecognized associated lesions affecting the ankle and subtalar joints. Many stabilizing surgical techniques have been described, each with variable results. This article reports the long-term results of ligamentous retensioning combined with reinforcement using an extensor retinaculum flap.
This is a retrospective, multicenter study. One hundred fifty cases were reviewed at a mean follow-up of 11 years. Functional results were assessed using the Karlsson score. Pre- and postoperative radiological assessment employed stress x-rays to measure varus tilt and anterior drawer and the Van Dijk classification to grade osteoarthrosis. The Stata 10 program was used for statistical analysis.
A thorough preoperative workup identified ligamentous lesions of the subtalar joint in 30% of cases. At review, 93% of patients were satisfied. Residual instability was present in only 4.8%. Radiographic analysis of both ankles revealed a differential in varus tilt of only 0.12° and in anterior drawer of 0.17~mm. There was no deterioration of the articular surfaces after 11 years of follow-up.
To the authors' knowledge, this is the largest series reported with such a follow-up. This technique addressed both lateral ankle and subtalar instability without sacrificing the peroneal tendons. It protected against progression of posttraumatic arthrosis and provided superior results to other reported techniques in terms of patient satisfaction and residual instability.
The career of Reginald Watson-Jones (1902-1972) was associated chiefly with Liverpool where Hugh Owen Thomas and Robert Jones were among his ancestral kinsmen. During and after World War II he was among the leading teachers and activists in the area of fracture therapy. His book FRACTURES AND JOINT INJURIES remained a standard reference for several decades. He was a powerful individual towering high above his contemporaries. At a dinner tended to him by some of his peers in New York City, Dr. Robert Kennedy introduced him as "Sir Reginald Watson-Jones, always positive, never in doubt, and by the grace of God usually right."
(C) Lippincott-Raven Publishers.