Content uploaded by Shweta Singh
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Shweta Singh on Nov 12, 2022
Content may be subject to copyright.
ROLE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT
SOFTWARE IN THE MANUFACTURING
SECTOR
Table of Contents
!""#
$%&
$"' &
()'*
!+"""*
!+""
,
- './-.0
1)2""+""#
2)#
!)**&
$3$44+""
3$4+""'
4.454+""'
6
$7*
8+)
9*
$1:
,:
."#
.".;#
."7&
617
6!"*1
6.*1
"' <
"'
1<
)/<0
)
1)/*0
:%1
#4*
&47=>4*
$"6
$:
1).:
4
?2@
2.A@:
'*458<4#&
@#
$*#
$#
Table of Figures
$"'
@- '&
@"' 6
Table of Charts
@,
@4
@=
@- =>
@,45*)'>+""
6@B,")""6
@,;";
:@,)")'*
'":
#@,">"#
&@"*&
@;+C"'
+
@+C"'
+
@+"C"
@"+"C"
"+
@"*+)'
++)
6@"*+)' +
+)6
@"*+)' +
+)
:@! "")
*+:
#@ "*) #
&@-.*)'>+""6&
@-."*"+""
+6
@-.)**6
@-.*)
) 6
@-.">")"""
6
@42+""'.7=6
6@72'+""66
@4 '""6
:@* "*'26:
#@B"*" +6#
&@42+""')D.7=D
"&
@=+""')
@="* +' '""
@="; )"
@B))""
@) ,45C-."'""
+""
6@!+""'' "6
@+"""")*"
:@2*"+"":
#@3$4C4.454*"*#
Table of tables
@,
@4
@=
@- =>
@,45*)'>+""
6@B,")""6
@,;";6
:@,)")'*
'"
#@,">":
&@"*#
@;+C"'
+&
@+C"'
+
@+"C"
@"+"C"
"+
@"*+)'
++)
6@"*+)' +
+)
6
@"*+)' +
+)6
:@! "")
*+
#@ "*) :
&@-.*)'>+.6&
@-."*"+""
+6
@-.)**6
@-.*)
) 6
@-.">")"""
6
@42+""'.7=6
6@72'+""66
@4 '""6
:@* "*'26:
#@B"*" +6#
&@42+""')D.7=D
"&
@=+""')
@="* +' '""
@="; )"
@B))""
@) ,45C-."'""
+""
6@!+""'' "6
@+"""")*"
:@2*"+"":
#@3$4C4.454*"*#
Chapter 1 – Introduction
1.1 Background
*'2+""'>)*
'*>*"D'+
""""">'")"
/EFC,GD&0 =)""
"")" #&D''"'A'
"H"+""/<+IDD&0!+
""'+*B.)"2'
""D*
D D) """ '' +
""/"CJ"D&&01)+'"
' """ " +) + "" KD
) "* + > " /J!7,D&0 !+
""""D '
')"DA )"+) '
+D'+''
" D "" *
""+'D*)
''*+""5D*D">*
+7+)")*D' "*
+DA*)*D"")'
DA")*D"'/<;D&0D
"" ") " > '
:
"4*D")*D)2
2)"
) ) ) )" +
""*""""*/0
' * '* ) + ""
"* " ' + "" 4 !+
7" /4!70 " * "
" >" /,FD � J " "
" ,- '.'
" 34D")*
"*D
"'""
" + "" " D
>'+""))D"*
+""4D'+""
)"*""'2
34
4""+"""
+""**D*
+"' )
)"/1D&0 A*D"
+ "" " ) " ) /. C !D
&0) " +
"" ) A" "
" * /KD D &09')D ) '*
"*')") ')
4!7'*D)*D)D""*
+"" ')* *+""
*')"D>"""
D 3 4 ), - '.
#
*""*D "> "" '
)"4*D **"
) " " " ) " "
)*
D * ' " " '2 " +
""
1.2 Problem statement
+ " * ")
)"")+
* )"D"
+""D+""+)"
""*"+/DD�
8"*""""
")" )>D>4!7*)"
' 2'
)"4* )'*'
)D')')"))
4!7 " ) "
+D)"
)2*"
2D 34>"D'
")>")*>
)'
* * " " )
* D * ' )' ' >
''>+""
).D"*DD)
"*')"H*'"*""
+"""*'" 3
&
44)*D"))
))' "
4!7 )" + ""
"'2>*D'
+"'"*)
'4!7 +"'
*" *""
2 " D 3 4 ) + ""@ *
) " " * ' '
A@
Research Question
'A'"+)@
-*"*)
,' '""
";L
-)""2+
""'"*LM
-"+""'L
9'"2+"""'
34)*"L
Research Framework
'$"' @
!"
#
$
"
%
"
$"'
Chapter 2 – Literature review and hypothesis testing
2.1 Introduction
;"D)'
"")" !+""""
"")*' "
)* * ; ' "2
D" ")"
+ "D ) ) " + "" ' "
"" + "" " ' D
D"D+' '*
'')"4*D))
+""' D2""
8 ' + "" "* "
)+'""")""'
" ) -D *" "
+ ;D "* * 2
'+""2+ """
)*'D"";
+D"""2'
/D&0D"""
+""''N"
" " 2 + "" '
)'D)"')
+""
2.2 Project management in the manufacturing industry
7)*"*
"" " 9')D
"""">"
+""'+""D*"D
'DA"D"A"+
"*D'' D*""
"**"" D""*D
''"")'*
""''*+D'
+"
"+'"
'* ")."*D*
' )*""4D + """
' 'D'" '
")/(D&0
4 "D D 'D > )
+) + ' )" ' +
+ "" /.'D&� *"D 'D
"+*"+
"" " D * " *
*DD > 7 /&&0)
+"" """
* '2'* "" ' * " *
""4<OP /�D >+)
" " "* &Q
)*+)
)"'*A*DA
))+>*A"
!+"""*" '+'
DA*DD")*/*D0D'
"")4!,/&0D "
*+ *
+ *'7)D+
""">''
+'' D"*'2"
) ) ) "" ) *
' D "" "' /$D D &0 4*D
)'D ' " "
' "+"")
2.2 Project management tools
!+ "" " R"N " )
" ' ; '* ' + " .'
/&� " + '* * )
+)"D*+"
A""""'
;D*""*4
4"D /&&60D ' )
"D*+"""D>)*
)'2
2.2.1 Gantt charts
,*
"+""D'*/C9D&&:0
*D)*'&+"&A
')),""
+""=),')*&&*
- /&&0D"'") D
))*D"*)/(+C7*D&04
" A !" =) $)' A /!=$0
!7/!70) +""
, * ' * ) D
*' -D
*/,C(D&09')D
-/&&0),D
* ) ,"
)" +"" * ""
" ) D
+""
*D+2,'"**J
/#0 ) , '
' -"D)
+)/,C(D&05D77/&0
')',*"+'
*D*)+'
+"&)=);,)
A*D'"*7)D,(/&0
) " "+ ,
*),>'+
+ " 2
D4/&0-*",+
"");)>D'*,'
)*'*)*>"
"D* +
+
2.2.2 Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)
-.+"" '""+
"** +"D")D-.
""* SD )T'
=) " -. ) * S2T
/8CD&0" *-.D')*
' 2 D S+
*"T 2 " )
) ) D -.
" 4"))-.
6
)*
" )** +D)
" 7)D "")*
""" D"
+')""5D
' -.)+D
DST>""D'
)*") /,!+7"D&0
- "D . D /&&:0 )
"'"
" /&:0 "
"')-.A)
") D -. " "
" * ' ' "
D D " " /, C
$D&04'D-."**"
'/!.0"'"
7)D !U /&0 !.
+'"*V)'
""D*
" ' *"*"
+"""*/. DD&&:0-*
-.)-."+"")
@- '
> -. '* D .D
/&:0) " ' " "+ D -.
" !.D -. *
7)D+""
-4/&&0"' -.!.
*"")'
+")) '-.
* " ' . /.0D 8 ' .
/8.0D!+(*.D './.0( '
./$DD&0
-.*)+""*+"
' "*'>"D
))+D""')'
"") ' *D *' *
""'*S-.>
"+"D*"T
:
/8 C D &0 4*D , +
"" '* '" + "" )"
,)"**
""D-."'"' .8.
)'+""
'')' )/9C
( D&07)D,"'"
+'+""'
7.!+!"),"+*
"/5*C(D""
'*@
!
.""'""+@D
" " + A" D +
"D '>+.D""''
" > * "" ' + """
/4>.D &60+"""""
+D" +
""+""
+ "" "
""+"D*""
*'' D*"
"+""4*D+""">
) D"*)*A*+')
D)*+/?.D&0D
""'*@
"#$
%$
#
)>DJD/&02"
' + " ) * D
""R'N*)
+"*"+4*!-/�D
'Q "")"
***"
2*"*+"D"*"
"*'8*D2" ""
2+"")"' ; /C
D&04*D ""*
D* +D*'
>D) A"*D)
*)+"" *"
D+">"
+)+*+)*
""+"
) /W; C 7D� +
"" ""'"" *
4D )"D ") D
)D)"
)*D"
+")"""D*
'+)"/1D&0")'
'"
2.3 Drivers of cloud-based and automated tools in manufacturing project
management
2.3.1 Cost-saving
+ * D
"+""'
&
"* ) '+"
*" ' /.D &&0
"+ + "" ' * *
).*DS)".' .) /..0
*")' )+"D
*""*'D'"2"*T
/!'D &#D 60 + "" '" * '
" " + "" ' "
)4" ' " *
"* '*"""
" ) * " * + " *
*)' "*"")
" ' * ") D
" " + "" " " /D
&0
" + "" D D ) *
* * + A "*
' ' ) 4D "
AD)A4"
+""''")
")/D&0
D!-/�+""""
" "'+D
*)"D")*
+* " D*
+")+
2.3.3 Privacy and security
!)**D'*
=D#:&##&'"*"'"D
*'"+4D*2)"
)*D " "" " "
"D*)'"*
)/$"*DD&&09')D&
' 8 *
*"'))>4D
")**)**)
'*,""*"*
+""")
* /.D D
&09D*)*+*''
D*""D )"DD 4 +
"" "* " " " D /0
+)"*'++)
'D /0 * + * D"
* " H/0"*
)*+/=DD&60
)D)'***
+ " " * A*D
)''""*
' ) + "" " "D
)**A*")**
+/9";DD�)2
) ' " ) "
!)* * )** * ,1!$
/,1!$0"*'
R1).8N')"D*-D1)8
' )" D 1).8 '
"""*'")"
4 D ' ' *
)" /(D &0
) * " ) " ; "" '
; "" "D * " " *
' D D A*
"+/7=D	D"
' ) *D *
"*+""D*"
) " + ""D
""'*@
&'$$(
8)"""
+""D '"+
""'@ 3$44.454 "
*
2.4 Role of JIRA and Asana in project management
2.4.1 JIRA an agile project management tool and software
3$4'')*4&+""
"* +""
''*D2-
"2D'
"")D*
)"'"" "
)"".$B73$4' ' /7C7D
&0 4 " +"" ' A
3$4* )"
* + "" ' D D
A-3$4D+"*
"""*'
'"* D
")) 4D"*
'9')D"
>*"*A"
/W; C7DD"
)*3$4'""
3$4 *"*+""
'*) D+""
'"*)")"4*"+
" 3$4 " ' 'D " " "
" ) " + "" '
S)"J222> ""D'
" "; ' ' " 2"
" /2V' D D )* 0 "
*")*)"T/4D&0
3$4)*'""")"
'"*'5D3$4'
"D' S7,9T
)"*;'*D
'4.454""/-C-D&0D)"
2
2.4.2 ASANA an agile project management tool and software
4 + "" )' " ""
"2 D17 );'
&&:+"" " "
'*)"*"'"'
"+" ""1
''D""""*
+*"""+D')*
D""')V> /DD&:04
*" ' "
"* * 4"
+""D4"''DD
1> 5'* "* 1>
"9D'
1>D* .")''4
@S. D?D,"D9D8 D,1)T/7A
CD� 4"
48.D'2+""
)" " "* + " "
""" )
+/27C2"XD&04.454
""""""+" "
'")"
""+""' 3$44.454
2D')''
A*$"/&60')'"'"
"2"D"
+ "" "*'>
+4D)'2
"*D""
+"D ''>D*
*4 '*"""
"*""'")";D"
' D >) "* / C .'D &&0
"D=* /&0 " 2 D 3$4
4""**)
;1D" "*'2
)>D")""'
A"D"N)*- +
D" *
'-"D' "*'"
A* ) + 5 * + "
>)" "" "2"
/7D &0 4D ))" )* 2 +
"" " 7)D ">
+D D2"+
"*D"*
/4;D D &0 $* D )* )" '
D)+YD2"
' " /D &0 "D 3$4 4.454 )
+""'&D
* /&0 " ' ' "* ' D A*
'*@
)(%$*(+
-"D">*+' +"
"**' "*4D
'*"+'D">*D
D'*"")"
>''" /.ZDD&:0A*D '
'+D)D
' " * /,D &0 5)D
> +D ' *
; ")D"'""
; /J C -';D &0*D ."
'';A"*/0D
) *' DA*"4""
';)$1)"
/$C10)/.DD&02"
">"" D +
""!D '+"
*"*'')"*".'.)/..0
6
'";"2"*4D2)"
;")*"*"' "
+ ""D * ") '
' ; /4"D D &&0 )' '
*@
, ' ( $ % $
(($(
2.5 Research gap
)+""+"
A"""""'
")"D ,-.
' D D ") )" ' *
!*3$44.454)"""D+
") )* * ' '
"" ' " "" 1D *
+"""+
)>)* D '
' '* * /W; C 7D
*D>D"'
H ) '* " " '
" " "D 3$4 4.454 + ""
'N*>"
&$'
3.1 Introduction
S$+""'"T
+""''' /03/4D&60
/0 4 /4 D &0 ) + ""
>*'))
'+""> "*
"* D,45D5' A!=$!7D
) 9')D " *
;'"*'
))'''+""
D$7*A"
**'*
*"
**'2"A"*
"+)
3.2 Objectives
* " ) " ) + ""
""
.;)*'>
+"")A
B ' ) " +
""
:
''34)>
* + "" "
3.2.1 Hypothesis
9@)")"!7 ,45
C-.
9@)'")
"+""
9$)"
9@"!+7"*34
9@$4"!+"""
3.3 Research Design
"+'
4/,D&0'
* D S=>"$ 1TD
;*'""
+""DD3/7D&04
'' "
' '*
>"")
"*'
>"))
' A)
"DA
*- "
' A " '*
#
* ' /8=1D &&0
)*
3.4 Target Group
*A"')'
" *
* - * ' "
+""
*"''34
+""/4D&0*+
)/7*4D&0
"D )*" "") 'D
))""*B"' *
**')")A"*
+ "" /1[ C 7\D &&0
,"*")+""
,"*)"'*=$!D>"
.4!","*D,"*
*"''"A"*
'
3.5 Sample
4"/7+D&:0
'"D/0;"
D*;"
"'>
/0"*'"D
&
3.5.1 Sample Size
)";&&'""*)"
*'")D*)'"/%D
&0)";
.@*";?.
.@B";"'
!"#$%&#"$%&'(
"""' *
D
.@.A"
/0)@) ) #Q ?2. #Q
)#6
/0 .1)@ ) * &
)&'""")'*''
))
/07)@"*'
*'"
*' " ' D
''34'>+""
')]V2:Q')9)#Q
)':Q"
:Q"*'&
):Q')&&:*'
)
.@4*""
$A.".;^!"#$%&#"$%&'(
^/#60_/&_/2&00V/&`0
^#_&V&&
^&#:V&&^#:
^&&
D' &&";*A"
)+*
" *D D
""A)'>+""
);
3.5.2 Sampling Method
" A " '* ' " ;
.";'
"**&&""")""
')" "
''9)""'
"* * ) * ' 2*
"+)+*
"'
' + "" '
"D/0' 'D/0
'")/0' '"
'AD ))
2
3.6 Data Collection Method
"";8D*
"*D/0 !"*1 /0.*1
".* "
)' ) "
)'*1)+)''
)')"
))DR($)'N
3.6.1 Primary Data
R!"* 1N D
" * " "* ' * '
A"'+""'
" ) " "* ")
" /0 B % " ' ))
"*+""D/08)7
))"' 7'
))*D/0 ""
""*""
'"*))
A*)"")*''
*""9')D"*
*)
)"A)
")*">'
A
3.6.2 Secondary Data
*;*')
"*'*"
)+)
)"""
*"*""*'
""*'*
*
3.7 Conceptual Framework and Variables
*+)'*
)+)
3.7.1 Conceptual Framework
"' D"'
' ""+
""'') D/0
,45D /0" "D /0 ) * '*
)"D/)0+""*D
/)0-.- './ C4D&&0)
;4")'
' 3 4 ' + "" '
)+""B"*"'"
")'""+""
""' )*"
" ) 3 4 )
)KA
)
()
()
*
/>0
+%
/>0
#
/>0
,-#
/>0
!$"
"#"."
'
'
()
*-./0/"0/&0/)1
@"'
3.7.2 Defining Variables
*'"*'"
+) ) $ 7 /!) C
J D &0 ' " ) * '
9')D ) )
'')*')"
A ) */01 </0
</0<
3.7.3 Indirect variables (IV)
' ) ) " )
"' 4) *"
")') ,/>0D
C"/>0D.*/>0D-./>0
/0,45 />0@ )
"+"")')
'"""
"+""""
'*
/0 C " />0@ " ' )* "
"+"")
9')D**D
/0.* />0@ " "
+ "" .* "" '
""D')
)"">+""
*''
/)0-./>0@) )*"
"'+""
3.7.4 Control variables
) ")
"9')')
))D/03D/04D'N'
;+""'")
+"")"*
9'"''"
)+""D)
3.7.5 Direct variable (y)
D S=) !+ 7" 7 */*0T
)D")
*+""*'''
"* " " '
* RKN
A
)
3.8 Questionnaire Design
*;"**D"*"
"AA/*"C
D&0'"+H/01""
/0"))
)" +) A * *
A'"A)*9')D
" " " A) "+*
A)A)"A)"
A'A')
''"))
")"' DD
)4))A"'
6
A'
')*A)(
;*
3.9 The application of tools for Analysis
> " " ; *
A " * * /5 4"
.D&0 'A*"
))/01)
'>D
*D/04@
/0?2H/02.AH/0'*458<4H/0
'')
+*''
! " ) "' /0
$*@$*/,C$D
&:0''
)4
)>R4*N'
')'*"*
3.10 Application of Ms Excel for Analysis
"*'
"***
)')'
"*"*)*7=>
"')
7=>'*
*"
''*+*H/0
* ) ' ' "
'D/0A
">")D/0
'*D/)0
)*>*A" *"'
"'""*D'*
A*D/)0*D*D
*A" *
D*7=>*
3.11 Research limitation
"*D')D'
"'D'
' "
">"*
*' /,C$D&:0*
A"D)
)))>
"'"*"*)A*>
" ) *"D )*
'')"
*'')
')"**"
""")"*)'
)*"
'')"*
*
8D)"")>
') ' '
:
'>'
'"*)*
" "* " " ) '*'
>
/$
A) ) "* " &&
" " ' M '
A" ')')*.4*
""D'.2( *"
* )
* ' *M' "
")''>D
#
' " ) ' '
)D'@
01
,DC"D.*D-.
01
=)!+7"7*
)A))
4.1 Descriptive Statistics
=A )"D"
""M)*+""'
"
"")YD
*D)
"A**
@,
* $
' :
&
2@,
8D"'"':
&'D*&"
@4
" $
2345/ 6
564&6
&64/6 :
"/6 #
514
4D&
'2"D*6&'
#2
@=
- $
-7 &
" &
6
8
' :
!"#$"%!
$&' ( ( )*#+"#
,!- - -"
&@=
*:&')"
9')D*&')
@- =>
,9 $
:45;
&46;
<43;
"2:; #
.% /0)"
12 2 2 12
/@- =>
8)D&'
)2*>D'*#&'>
&*)
7=
@,45*)'>+""
*".%%
9
>
$
#" &
" 6
.
6
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
455)6)67"#&6)/"!#608"
9
6@,45*)'>+""
":'",45*
)'>+""8*D*
'"
6@B,")""
8*
>
$
#" #
"
. 6
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
,"6:7"#0"9
<@B,")""
6'6&'"B,"
)""8D*'"
@,;";
*
??>
$
#"
" :
. 6
#
6
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
"6!66!"!#);#)0#);9
@@,;";
D&'
",;";)*D*
''""
:@,)")'*
'"
*
>
$
#" :
"
. &
&
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
"60)<&66
!")6"")&)6!"!)9
A@,)")'*
'"
:&'",)"
)'*'"9')D*
'""
#@,">"
*9
>
$
#"
" #
. #
# #
:
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
"6"0/""!)#9
3@,">"
#"*'",
">"9')D*#*'
"
&@"*
>
$
#" #
" &
. &
:
#
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
*#)"00#"669
*#)"00#"669
2:@"*
&#*
'""*8D
*'*'""
@;+C"'
+
%?
+
>
$
#"
" 6
. 6
#
&
3 4 ! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
56)")6);608")"6"=#
")&)608 "9
22@;+C"'
+
4:'"
; + C " ' +
9')D**'""
@+C"'
+
%
+
>
$
#" #
" :
. #
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
56)")6!#608"6"6"
=#")&)608"9
25@+C"'
+
)+C"
'+7''"D6&
'*''"
@+"C"
%
+>
$
#"
"
.
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
5608"00)"")"=#9
2&@+"C"
+"C"7
'"D:&'*
''"
@"+"C"
"+
%
+
>
$
#" 6
"
.
:
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
56#)608"!#!"6)"
)0""=#600608"9
2/@"+"C"
"+
')"+"
C""+))**
AS4T'H'':
'"D*
@"*+)'
++)
>
$
#" #
"
. #
&
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
>#"!)8"#")&6)
!%))"!)08"8"#9
26@"*+)'
++)
" 6 ' " "
*+)' ++)8
D*&&*'"
6@"*+)' +
+)
>
$
#" :
" 66
.
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
>#"!)8"#"!"&6)
!%))"!)08"8"#9
2<1"*+)'
++)
"'""*
+)' ++)D*
&*'""
@"*+)' +
+)
>
$
#" #
" 66
.
#
6
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
>#"!)8"#)"!&6)
!%))"!)08"8"#9
2@@"*+)' +
+)
)"*+)'
++)))**D
S4T'66'D'
)"D*
:@! "")
*+
>
$
#" 6
" 6
. &
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
#)%)0#)!
06"+#)08"!"9
2A@! "")
*+
A ! ""
)*+'
)6&>'&&
:D'**'6&
)"*:
#@ "*)
%
>
$
#"
" 6
.
:
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
56)%)0)#6
!600?"%9
23@ "*)
"')
D:&)'"#
9')D*''"
&@-.*)'>+.
,-#
9
>
$
#" 6
" 6
. #
#
&
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
.$3)6)67"#&6)/"!#608"
9
5:@-.*)'>+""
&&)
-.'*)'>+""'&&
''"4*D#'
"
@-."*"+""
+
,-#
>
$
#"
" 6#
.
&
6&
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1
.$3)0!)608"#""
0608"9
52@-."*"+""
+
4D:&'"-.
"*"+""+8
D*"
@-.)**
,-#
>
$
#" &
"
.
6
6
# 6
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
.$3)"0!"#)0"9
55@-.)**
4"D&'"-.
)**'*6'
"
@-.*)
)
,-#
>
$
#" :
"
.
6
&
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
.$3)06""!))0)
?))60)!%9
5&@-.*)
)
4D&'
"-.*)
) )*D&'"
@-.">")"""
,-#9
>
$
#" :
"
6
.
:
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
.$3)"0/)6"!)
6)0#6"!0"9
5/@-.">")"""
4D&'''
"-.">")"
""D'"
@42+""'.7=
"4
#'>
$
#" #
" 6
.
6
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
*!08"@&!)3 9
56@42+""'.7=
4D:&'
"42+""'.7=8
D''"
6@72'+""
'4
>
$
#"
"
.
6
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
))")#"@&!08"9
5<@72'+""
46D:&'
"72'+""4)*D6
'"
@4 '""
"
>
$
#" :
"
.
#
66
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
06%&0!"9
5@@4 '""
4D:&'
"3$4 '""')D
'"
:@* "*'2
4
>
$
#" &
"
.
6
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
*00)%)!)60&
+0"9
:@* "*'2
4:D:&'
"3$4* "*'2
')D'"
#@B"*" +
8
>
$
#" #
" 6
.
6:
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
,"#)"%)
08"9
53@B"*" +
4#D&'
"3$4"*" +)
D'"
&@42+""')D.7=D
"
"4
B
#'B>
$
#" &
" #
. :
6#
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
*!08"@&!)
)))!A3$A"0)9
&:@42+""')D.7=D
"
4&D6#&'"42
+""')D.7=D"*D
''"
@=+""')
>
$
#"
"
.
# &
&
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0)08"@&!)!
0)9
&2@=+""')
4D6&'
"+""')
D'"
@="* +' '""
>
$
#"
" 6&
. 6
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0"%)08"&%<&9
&5@="* +' '""
4D6&&'"4.454
"* +' '""D'
'"
@="; )"
?
>
$
#"
"
. :
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
06)0))#;#%0)
"#)69
&&@="; )"
4D:&'
"4.454"; )
"D'"
@B))""
8
>
$
#"
"
. :
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
,60))!)0"
0B)9
&/@B))""
4D&'
"4.454))
""D'"
@) ,45C-."'""
+""
*".%%
+,-#
>
$
#"
"
.
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
*#)%455=.$3!"6"
#&6))0#08"9
&6@) ,45C-."'""
+""
4D&'
",45C-."'""+
""8D'"
6@!+""'' "
>
$
#"
" &
. &
#
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
8"@&!"6&%)6
"!#9
&<@!+""'' "
4*6D:&
'"!+""''
"D'"
@+"""")*"
%
>
$
#" :
"
.
#
6
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
5608"!!0)
9
&@@+"""")*"
8D:&
'"+"""")*"
D'"
:@2*"+""
%4
>
$
#"
"
.
# &
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
56"!!0008"?9
)*+$",$-,
4:D:6&'"
2*"+""D'
"
#@3$4C4.454*"*
!$"+"#"."
>
$
#" &
"
.
#
:
3 4! -) 3-)
1
1
1
1
1
1
C>D=346)600)"6!"!)
)!9
&3@3$4C4.454*"*
4*#D:&'
"3$4C4.454*"*D
'"
4.2 Test of Association
*D)'
'B"D
)'*"D?2D2.AD458<4D'
*D')*'
4.2.1 Z-test:
;2'''""
)'"*
#/*
?4%1%#'
#
2.) /00/)+12/34
' #:
C0 :66
7 && &&
D?' & M
?6&&# M
(EFG?)4 &6=2& M
?4 6:6 M
(EFG?)4 &:=2&# M
?4 ###6#: M
4Q)D9"?)
)D 6&a##D
)D',))+
""'"
)9@
#/"*
?4%1%#'
2)5+6+14/ /00/)+12/34
' && #:
C0 ::#
7 && &&
:&
D?' & M
?&#&& M
(EFG?)4 &66 M
?4 6:6 M
(EFG?)4  M
?4 ###6#: M
4Q)D9+"?)
)D &b###D ' )
D ' " ) ) 2
""+
"'*+@
&'$$(
#/&*
?4%1%#'
2/)71+8 /00/)+12/34
' & #:
C0 6
7 ## &&
D?' & M
?# M
(EFG?)4 &&&& M
?4 6:6 M
(EFG?)4 &&& M
:
?4 ###6#: M
4Q)D9"?)
)Da###D'
)D'*))2
""+
)'*@
&'$$(
#/)*
?4%1%#'
29: /00/)+12/34
' 6: #:
C0 :#66
7 && &&
D?' & M
?:6: M
(EFG?)4 6#&6=2& M
?4 6:6 M
(EFG?)4 :=2&6 M
?4 ###6#: M
4Q)D9"?)
)D :a###D '
:
) D ' -. ) ) +
""'"
)'*@
"#$
%$
#+3'
?4%1%#'
2;1< /00/)+12/34
' ## #:
C0 #
7 ## &&
D?' & M
?2&# M
(EFG?)4 &:#&# M
?4 6:6 M
(EFG?)4 &##:&# M
?4 ###6#: M
4Q)D9+")
)D2&&b###D')
D'"!+7")*
*3
)9+@
)(%$*(+
#
:
?4%1%#'
2<<< /00/)+12/34
' &# #:
C0 6:666
7 && &&
D?' & M
?6:::# M
(EFG?)4 &&66 M
?4 6:6 M
(EFG?)4 &:: M
?4 ###6#: M
4Q)D9+"?)
)b###D')
D'"!+7")*
*4
)9+@
)(%$*(
4.2.2 Chi-Square test:
2A"'))'>
)*'*
:
#/*
1 9 191
1 9 9 1
9 191
91 9
9 9
91 9
9 9 1
91 9
1 91 9
91 9
9 91 1
9 19 1
9 9 1
1 91 91
1 9 91
1 91 911 1
1 9 191
1 91 911 1
1221 980 2201 1221 980 2201
Chi square 911 E11
:
4#=092G&&=]&&
")D2)"&&=]&&D
')"
*',)"
""
:6
"95
9 9
91 9
1 19 19
1 19 19
1 19 9 1
1 19 19
1 91 9 1
9 191
1 19 19
91 9
9 9
9 9
911 9
1 1 1 19 9 1
1 19 9 1
1007 980 1987 1007 980 1987
Chi square 911 E11
:
4#=095G2>::H::
")D2)"&&=]&&D
')"
*'"D)
"""
::
"9&
19 191
91 19
1 1 1 19 9 1
91 91
19 191
91 91
1 91 19
1 19 191
911 19
1 19 191
91 19
1 19 191
1 19 191
1 19 9 1
1 19 191
1 9 9 1
9 9
911 19
911 9
9 91
19 191
1 91 91
1 1 1 19 9 1
9 9
1071 980 2051 1071 980 2051
Chi square 911 E11
:#
2.A<>*^&&=]&&
)D2)"&&=]&&D
')"
*'.*
"M""
#&
"9/
9 1 91
1 9 9 1
9 9 11
9 9 11
911 9
1 9 191
9 9 11
91 1 9
9 9 11
1 911 19
1 91 19
911 19
911 19
9 9
91 19
91 19
911 19
1 9 191
9 9
91 91
91 91
91 9
91 9
1 19 9 1
1 19 9 1
1 91 9
91 91
1168 980 2148 1168 980 2148
Chi square 911 E11
2.A<>*^&&=]&&
#
42)&&=]&&D')
"M4)M'-.
"""M
4.2.3 one way ANOVA
4*)/458<40A"
")""*")
>))D"
)"D'"
"1#
#8''"$; M M M M
( ) <& 2
* && :666
7#%+%' && && && ::##
#8$%; ## & & 6
,-# && 6: 6: :#666
!$" ## ## ## #
"#"." && &# &# 6:6666
%0' && #:& #:
".70"
(4 $( 4 0 3"& 0
-* 6 6 :## #: =2 6
,* #: 6# M M M
IM M M M M M
% #& 6## M M M M
#
D:1J2GJ5
D"1J2KJ5
458<4'""')"!+
""'""'2
))#aD'+9&
94
4.2.4 Correlation:
=>"''*
A)"*
'''*')
2
5
56
37
758'3
9
+3'
7::7534
7
*
7#%+
%'
&#&:
&
#8$%; &##
&:6
:
,-# &&&
:
&&:
::
&&
##
!$" &&6&6
&##
::
&&&
:6
&:
:
"#"." &&:
##
&#:
&6&
6:
&66
6
:
%0
'
&:&
:
&6#
#
&6#
6
&#
#
&:
#
&#:
&
#
,
',+""7)D
"&#&'"D
"""4'D.*&#
''*""""D
-.&''-.
"""
4.3 Regression analysis
$)")
')
#8''"$;78%8%
'$
7$ &:&
$.A &&&#
4+$.A &&#:6
.= #:
8) &&
".70"
= $( 4 0 (0
$ 6 6& #& 6:##6 #:=2
$
#
::# ##6 M M
#
# & M M M
=
)((
$
$/
3"
&
>?
@A
7
@A
>?
@A
7
@A
2
&:
::&
:
2

:
&
#
2
:66:
&&
6
2
:66:
&&
6
#
,
&&
&#:
&&#
6::
&
&&&
6
&&&
&:#
&#
&6
&&&
&:#
&#
&6
8.
C
7=
&&:6
&&#:
&:#
6:
&
:6
2
&&
##
&6&#
2
&&
##
&6&#
.=B$
K
2
&&&6
6
&&#:
6
2
&&:
&#
2
&##
:
&:6
##
2
&##
:
&:6
##
-.
&&#:
&&:6
&#
6#
&
##
2
&6
&&
##
2
&6
&&
##
3$4
&#
&6:
&&
6
:
&&&
#
&
#::
&&
#:
&
#::
&&
#:
4.45
4
&#&
6:
&&:6
:
6
#6
6#=
2&
&::
:#
&6&66
#
&::
:#
&6&66
#
4D$.A)*''&&_)
KD)"&&D'
'D')'
)/,D"D*D-.0)
/"""0
)'*@
B+,&(&$$(34C.<++69:
B+$(((&$?$(&$
-
B*(((&
BD+3-4,(;$<
B(<$((3-(
$
#
References
4DJD&35;/)+4<<./4/+B<%:55E<D@(
B)*4.
7=D&#F7(3-4+$+Gc8d
4)@@VV'''""V+2""V+2""22
2A
c43*&d
4"D$DD3C!D$D&&6)""""@4
)'1-(&?:/0D2
4"D7D4D4D.DJC."D1!D&&28
"' =!+7"!1;(
<$&$)$</#0D26
4>.D4D&6<3-4:3$4$
D4@4>.
6 4D3D&B?7.)(3-4H9/I
c8d
4)@@VV)"VV22+2""V
c43*&d
4D$1D&&4"$-
9 D5'3*@3-*C.
: 4;DKD5;D4D9;D7$C7D.49D&!;
+""""+
1;()4/0D6:26:#
# 4D&43-<$H5Jc8d
4)@4)@
@VV"VV>"V+2""V+2""
c464&d
& 4D&67$(;1<(?&K@4
4D4D&9;$(Lc8d
4)@@VV'''"V'V+VV2V'22+22
#6
e322A"2C222""
c43*&d
27D7$C2"XD74D&4
>' 2@14C7
<D14(I(&&I
7@"B)*7!*B)*
7D6#2
DC9DD&&:!+""D>@4
* 3--#/0D62
D7CD7D&4""+
"""*"'>1;
(3-4/0D:2#
D3D&B?7+C</I6+c8d
4)@@VV'''+""VV 2"222"2
c43"*&d
6 *"D4CD=D&:4$-.D8>@
8>B)*!
DJD&<3-42+$3-4c8d
4)@@VV''' '"VVV2+2""2)2
2+2""
c43*&d
: D-C7D$D&69'*-
8;<&?(53$5
:&/0D#2
# )D7.D.)D=C'D1D&:4"
'2;"*+@
$D<C.?D%+$5)"@
.DD2
#
& D77C.'D4D&&1C*+""
"349$+$/0D2#
EFD1C,GD1D&<-,$(?$1
$(M2(($5)
.D.DB)*5).D2
D1D)+""@.D
3$4(<"#D
&2
D=D&:99C:C$?9:3-4L
c8d
4)@@VV'''' "+"VV' 2 '22'
c43*&d
1D1D&<3-43426+
c8d
4)@@VV'''+""VV2+2""222
"
c43*&d
1D.D&4@N""">*
6>$/0D&2
6 1[D3C7\D5D&&9(
.($4,c8d
4)@@VVV'2222*2222
"*V
c44&d
=*D94,D4D45D45"D9C.DD&$
"*+"""";:
+&/0D::2#
: =DDD4D7DCDJJ$D&6"@
*D)*D1///)$)/0D62
# 7*4D&01-K@(
/)/)0$01$$D(0<5
#:
/0)$"DD7*4
& DD,f;24D3CD3D&:03-
($$-19$)(
1($+"D.D
"D%-CJ"D37D&&/$23-4
=5''.AD!*)@!+7"
DD&5-(?c8d
4)@@VV'''"V2+2""2
'2" 2&##
c43&d
,D.D&+C$&$&
(,3$341N.,)(D
=D=7=4D
,D.C$D4D&:-7$"21L4
72$4*;(/&/0D6&2:
,D3C(DD&,)@4*
"""+*1;(4
3-:/0D:2#
6 ,D.D&$7*$7@.,D
)$)@$,!
,FDD&#)+"")
/3-4;#/0D26
: ,DC$D3D&E31$O<$1
%F"3$(1)(/%
1)/%1/%2%3
D1" D(**
# ,!+7"D&9C:C$?c8d
4)@@VV'''+""V"V' 2 '2
"
c463&d
##
& 9";D7D&#!)*.*$
@4=")&?()/6/0D
2
9DC( D1D&<$&$-$
(@$
D.C4D$4D&&1.".*"!
7*7*9(11(
6/0D2
JD7D<)D5C,;D1D&+$$1
19C)1(1(D
9D.D
J D4D#3$@-*
J!7,D&3-4&*c8d
4)@@VV "VV"V "VV&V&VJ!7,2!+2
7"2.)*2&
c43*&d
6 J D-C-';D4D&))E?$$
53(+/P3&D.D
B)*
(D&B?+1$1(13-4c8d
4)@@VV'''"V&V&V"2*2'2222
+2""
c4&3&d
: (+D4C7*D4D&+"/$3(>
33$+5'K @$
# (D<D&3-44(1$c8d
4)@@VV''' "V"2+2""
c43&d
& 7+D9JD&:<(4/)$.
+@B)*
&&
7AD3CD3D&#/&(<5$$3->,
3-4+54$13$(
1;)(E?$%&E?$/$
E?$41)*E@.UD!D.=!$=...
*!
7D4C7D1D&.'!+7"@4
")<'<)41.50+(?/:/0D2
7D.D&9B8B57>%<7+54<+15:/7/%135;/)+
4<<./4/+50+9</Lc8d
4)@@VV'''VV-*2.24"2222
!+27"2.'2
c43*&d
7D9D&;1<+'D8@JB)*
72."D.C$;D3D&&)"@
)'</<D2
6 54".D=7D&01
-D1@9=54854(441=7=.!$=..
5*D7JC(D3D&#<(3-4
1($113-53$(
1)(1$/$547D
=87.*
: 8=1D&&/&.-@8=1!
# 8DCDD&9C:C$?9:13-
4c8d
4)@@VV'''"V)VV'22' 2 '2
V
c463&d
6& W; D1C7D4D!+7"@4")
<'),$1(+#/0D2
6 !)D,CJ D5D&$7*@$)'4
1+/<+15<>;57<>50152<+12///<)B6%/2/>534/+/0D
&
6:2
6 !UD4D&9 '3<"D
2
6 !DKC,D!D&4);
+D)*+2
;1;(3-4/:0D2#
6 !'D&#<23LB?<(1?$3-
4$(3-@
@VV''''"V"VVV"V)222
22+2""222+2"2
6 $DD$DC("D$D&B?-""$
:($?,C$13$(
1%,/6<5'K 5KD
4"7*
66 $"D7D&6.'*A""""
")1;(1(46/0D
:&2#&
6 $"*D.D *D$D$D.C$D9$D&&3&$
3<()$)"<3@47.
6: $D5D1 D3$D(DKC$D49D&$)' '
'">"1;(
4(+$4://2600D&&26
6# .ZD3$D&:">*!+7"@4,
8))')I<"&:D2&
& .D<D.D4C)D3D&J'.">
$1)"!+@4=>*.*!!+
7E59>/%./<%35)/4<<./4/+@#/0D2
.D3$D$2.D1C!27AfD1D&=)*
)*' "*"*&/
1(/0D2
&
.'DJD&$-@@*
(
.DD&&1435+<)/5035;/)+)B/%7>/<%)5+)5+5>1
35;/)+4<<./4/+c8d
4)@
@VV''' '"V2VV2*VV"2
2+222222+2""Ve
c43*&d
.D!C!D3JD&14' Lg4A)*
+1-(-/0D&&2&
. D4D$D(CJ7*D3.D&&:1"
"" '*
+-($&$(/0D2
6 .D7D$"* D1C,D3.D&:1)' '
">"+<
$$/0D:2#
<+ID3D"2!D$C.)D9D&.8&&@&!7J
"*"+"")$$6
1(<"&D62
: <;D=D&+((?$4:<-5'
3*DB.@3-*C.
# <D3COPD!D&#!+"")"
*;$3$)<"6D26
:& -D3C-D$D&<2;))c8d
4)@@VV'''"V)VV'V2)2+2
"Veh)h+hhhh
c43*&d
: -D37D&&,@4*/;(
5#/0D&2
&
: KD(D,*D4CD3<D&3-
-&3$<1)((
<(/4O<4/,
)$7/4<DB.4D
: ?.D&F</((&3-4c8d
4)@@VV;"V$V2&V62.22=)2!+2
7""
c463*&d