ArticlePublisher preview available

Insights on Multistage Rock Avalanche Behavior From Runout Modeling Constrained by Seismic Inversions

Wiley
Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Inversion of low‐frequency regional seismic records to solve for a time series of bulk forces exerted on the earth by a landslide (a force‐time function) is increasingly being used to infer volumes and dynamics of large, highly energetic landslides, such as rock avalanches and flowslides, and to provide calibration information on event dynamics and volumes for numerical landslide runout models. Much of the work to date using landslide runout modeling constrained by seismic data has focused on using single‐phase models with frictional or velocity‐weakening rheologies. Awareness of multistage landslide initiations is increasing, with discrete failures separated in time contributing to the final impact of an event. Our work utilizes a method for incorporating seismic data as a calibration constraint for landslide runout models, considering variable rheologies and different initiation conditions. This study presents a systematic examination of multiple rheologies and initiation conditions, and shows how these factors affect the force‐time function derived from the landslide runout model. Our work confirms that, while rheology and fragmenting or initially coherent initiations affect the force‐time function, multiple collapses separated by tens of seconds have the greatest impact on the shape and amplitude. We apply this method to the analysis of three real rock avalanches to better constrain plausible initiation conditions and rheology parameters using both seismic and field data. This study provides insights on how assumptions about the initiation dynamics of the source zone and the runout model definition can aid in the interpretation of seismic inversions for multistage rock avalanches.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
1. Introduction
Extremely rapid, large, flow-like landslides (as defined by Hungr etal.,2014) are among the most catastrophic
natural hazards on Earth. These landslides are characterized by a deficit between driving and resisting stresses
at the initiation of motion, which results in rapid acceleration. This deficit is gradually reduced during motion
through traction stresses, plastic deformations, heat, and sound, among other forms of energy dissipation, until
the potential energy of the landslide has been fully consumed (Knapp & Krautblatter,2020). If a landslide is
sufficiently large and rapid, the vibrational energy imparted on the earth can be measured by seismographs, with
different landslide types having distinct signal characteristics (e.g., review papers by Allstadt etal., 2018 and
Provost etal.,2018, and references therein). Many of the most seismically energetic landslides are classified as
Abstract Inversion of low-frequency regional seismic records to solve for a time series of bulk forces
exerted on the earth by a landslide (a force-time function) is increasingly being used to infer volumes and
dynamics of large, highly energetic landslides, such as rock avalanches and flowslides, and to provide
calibration information on event dynamics and volumes for numerical landslide runout models. Much of the
work to date using landslide runout modeling constrained by seismic data has focused on using single-phase
models with frictional or velocity-weakening rheologies. Awareness of multistage landslide initiations is
increasing, with discrete failures separated in time contributing to the final impact of an event. Our work
utilizes a method for incorporating seismic data as a calibration constraint for landslide runout models,
considering variable rheologies and different initiation conditions. This study presents a systematic examination
of multiple rheologies and initiation conditions, and shows how these factors affect the force-time function
derived from the landslide runout model. Our work confirms that, while rheology and fragmenting or initially
coherent initiations affect the force-time function, multiple collapses separated by tens of seconds have the
greatest impact on the shape and amplitude. We apply this method to the analysis of three real rock avalanches
to better constrain plausible initiation conditions and rheology parameters using both seismic and field data.
This study provides insights on how assumptions about the initiation dynamics of the source zone and the
runout model definition can aid in the interpretation of seismic inversions for multistage rock avalanches.
Plain Language Summary Understanding how large, rapid landslides move is important to
estimate the dangers posed by these events. Large, rapid landslides impart forces on the surface of the earth
when they accelerate during their initial movement, when they change direction as they follow the terrain along
their runout path, and as they come to rest. These forces generate seismic waves that can be used to estimate
the characteristics of the motion of a landslide. We present an approach for simulating the motion of rapid,
flowing landslides that considers different ways for the material to transition from being at rest to flowing, and
different landslide material representations that affect how the simulated landslide moves once it is in motion.
We then compare the forces estimated from the model of landslide motion with the forces estimated from the
seismic data. Using simulations with simple, idealized terrain and real events with complex terrain, we show
how terrain and different assumptions in the model for landslide motion affect the force estimation. We provide
additional insight on how seismic data can aid in interpreting the way in which motion begins and how a
landslide moves.
MITCHELL ETAL.
© 2022. American Geophysical Union.
All Rights Reserved.
Insights on Multistage Rock Avalanche Behavior From Runout
Modeling Constrained by Seismic Inversions
A. Mitchell1,2 , K. E. Allstadt3 , D. George3 , J. Aaron4, S. McDougall1 , J. Moore5 , and
B. Menounos6
1Department of Earth, Ocean and Atmsopheric Sciences, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada,
2Now at BGC Engineering Inc., Vancouver, BC, Canada, 3U. S. Geological Survey, Golden, CO, USA, 4Swiss Federal
Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research, Birmensdorf, Switzerland, 5Department of Geology & Geophysics,
University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA, 6Department of Earth and Environmental Science, University of Northern
British Columbia, Prince George, BC, Canada
Key Points:
Different runout model material
representations and initial conditions
were tested to determine their
influence on seismic force estimates
Real event simulations confirmed
the interplay between material
representation, topography, multistage
failures, and modeled seismic forces
The magnitude of the simulated peak
forces was most sensitive to failures
separated by tens of seconds
Supporting Information:
Supporting Information may be found in
the online version of this article.
Correspondence to:
A. Mitchell,
AMitchell@bgcengineering.ca
Citation:
Mitchell, A., Allstadt, K. E., George,
D., Aaron, J., McDougall, S., Moore,
J., & Menounos, B. (2022). Insights
on multistage rock avalanche behavior
from runout modeling constrained
by seismic inversions. Journal of
Geophysical Research: Solid Earth,
127, e2021JB023444. https://doi.
org/10.1029/2021JB023444
Received 16 OCT 2021
Accepted 19 SEP 2022
Author Contributions:
Conceptualization: A. Mitchell, K. E.
Allstadt, D. George, S. McDougall
Formal analysis: A. Mitchell, K. E.
Allstadt, D. George, J. Aaron
Investigation: A. Mitchell
Methodology: A. Mitchell, K. E.
Allstadt, D. George, J. Aaron, S.
McDougall
Resources: J. Aaron, S. McDougall, J.
Moore, B. Menounos
Software: A. Mitchell, K. E. Allstadt
Visualization: A. Mitchell
Writing – original draft: A. Mitchell
Writing – review & editing: K.
E. Allstadt, D. George, J. Aaron, S.
McDougall, J. Moore, B. Menounos
10.1029/2021JB023444
RESEARCH ARTICLE
1 of 29
... These force-time functions have provided insight into the timing, duration, and dynamics of landslide events (e.g. Mitchell et al. 2022, and the references therein) and for a limited number of tailings dam breach events (e.g. Takahashi 2014). ...
Article
Full-text available
Numerical models are used for detailed and site-specific tailings dam breach analyses (TDBAs) to estimate the downstream inundation and deposition resulting from a potential breach at a tailings dam. The results of TDBAs are key inputs into risk assessments, consequence classification, and emergency planning. This paper describes the research and development of a database of 12 tailings dam breach events with a specific focus on observations that are needed for numerical modelling, in conjunction with an assessment of existing dam breach conventions to improve consistency in reporting. The characteristics relevant to modelling include outflow volumes, breach processes, breach geometries, and runout observations local to the downstream area. This study and the new database shed light on the diversity of outflow materials, facility arrangements, breach processes, and downstream environments that affect the breach development and tailings runout. Familiarity with case studies is a crucial element of expert judgement for forward-analysis TDBAs, which this database supports. The database can also be used to define model inputs for back-analysis of additional tailings dam breach events, and simultaneously provides calibration or validation constraints with the runout observations. Continued review and critical assessments are needed to reduce uncertainties and to enhance case history data availability and quality in this database.
... Most research interest in earthquake-induced rock avalanches has focused on the trigger mechanisms, the initiation failure characteristics, the movement dynamics, and the material properties of rock avalanches Guo et al., 2020a;Liu et al., 2020;. In particular, larger geological hazards derived from the process of rockfall occurrence or dynamic propagation, such as rock falls or debris flows, have attracted the attention of many researchers (Matasci et al., 2018;Zhang et al., 2018;Singeisen et al., 2020;Mitchell et al., 2022). However, both the analysis of dynamic propagation (Chen et al., 2006;Baggio et al., 2021; and the assessment of the rockfall movement distance (Chen et al., 2010;Zhu et al., 2020;Donati et al., 2021;Ma et al., 2021) were closely related to the influence of initiating damage factors on the triggering mechanism in rockfalls. ...
Article
Full-text available
Rock avalanches are a significant threat to transportation or hydraulic infrastructure, as they can also cause catastrophic secondary destruction in large practical engineering or to nearby residents. Earthquake-induced rock avalanches have been the most common and prominent natural hazard phenomena among geological hazards in recent years. Earthquake-induced rock avalanche events usually begin when a massive rock mass or multiple rock masses separate from a rock slope, progressively fragmenting and transforming into fast-moving, cohesionless rock falls. Earthquake-induced sequential collapse often occurs on weathered and fractured rock cliffs in horizontal strata, and its kinematic dynamics and destabilization mechanism are significantly different from those of isolated collapse due to weathering. In this study, the failure characteristics of the initiation and movement process of the avalanche are revealed in detail, through physical model experiments and analytical solutions, thereby obtaining an earthquake-controlled mechanical model equation. Our methods use the inflection points of the displacement time curve at the top of the rock wall and the digital images acquired by the shaking test bench to quantify the critical damage time point and to characterize the critical morphology of continuous collapse. A mathematical model of analytical solution is proposed, which aims to address the kinematic mechanics mechanism of sequential collapse under translational and rotational motion models. The comparative analysis results of the experiment and analytical solutions reveal that the transformed motion pattern is controlled by the ratio between the model stacking height, the rock block size, and the seismic acceleration. Whereas the rotational motion pattern is mainly influenced by the nodal dip angle, model stacking height, and seismic acceleration. The results of the study are of great scientific importance to elucidate the destruction mechanism of the earthquake-induced sequential collapse of rock avalanches and to determine the evolution characteristic of subsequent rockfalls motion of dangerous rocks. The proposed framework for the analysis of rock avalanches can be applied to understand the critical topographic features and mechanical mechanism behavior of analogous geological hazards.
Article
Full-text available
Rock avalanches can be a significant hazard to communities located in mountainous areas. Probabilistic predictions of the 3D impact area of these events are crucial for assessing rock avalanche risk. Semi-empirical, calibration-based numerical runout models are one tool that can be used to make these predictions. When doing so, uncertainties resulting from both noisy calibration data and uncertain governing movement mechanism(s) must be accounted for. In this paper, a back-analysis of a database of 31 rock avalanche case histories is used to assess both of these sources of uncertainty. It is found that forecasting results are dominated by uncertainties associated with the bulk basal resistance of the path material. A method to account for both calibration and mechanistic uncertainty is provided, and this method is evaluated using pseudo-forecasts of two case histories. These pseudo-forecasts show that inclusion of expert judgement when assessing the bulk basal resistance along the path can reduce mechanistic uncertainty and result in more precise predictions of rock avalanche runout. Supplementary information: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10346-022-01939-y.
Article
Full-text available
Debris flows affect people and infrastructure around the world, and as a result, many numerical models and modelling approaches have been developed to simulate their impacts. Observations from instrumented debris-flow channels show that variability in inflow depth, velocity, and discharge in real debris flows is much higher than what is typically used in numerical simulations. However, the effect of this natural variability on numerical model outputs is not well known. In this study, we examine the effects of using complex inflow time series within a single-phase runout model utilizing a Voellmy flow-resistance model. The interactions between model topography and flow resistance were studied first using a simple triangular hydrograph, which showed that simulated discharges change because of local slopes and Voellmy parameters. Next, more complex inflows were tested using time series based on 24 real debris-flow hydrographs initiated from three locations. We described a simple method to scale inflow hydrographs by defining a target event volume and maximum allowable peak discharge. The results showed a large variation in simulated flow depths and velocities arising from the variable inflow. The effects of variable-inflow conditions were demonstrated in simulations of two case histories of real debris flows, where the variation in inflow leads to significant variations in the simulation outputs. The real debris-flow hydrographs were used to provide an indication of the range of impacts that may result from the natural variability in inflow conditions. These results demonstrate that variation in inflow conditions can lead to reasonable estimates of the potential variation in impacts.
Article
Full-text available
Seismic instruments are highly sensitive and capable of recording a large range of different Earth signals. The high sensitivity of these instruments also makes them prone to various failures. Although many failures are very obvious, such as a dead channel, there are other more subtle failures that easily go unnoticed by both network operators and data users. This work documents several different types of failure modes in which the instrument is no longer faithfully recording ground-motion data. Although some of these failure modes make the data completely unusable, there are also a number of failures in which the data can still be used for certain applications. Of course, the ideal situation is to identify as soon as possible when data become compromised and to have the network operator fix the station. However, knowing how the data became compromised can also help data users to identify if the data can still be used for their particular application. This work in no way attempts to exhaustively document recording failures but rather to communicate examples and equip the reader with ways of identifying failure modes.
Article
Full-text available
In April 2013, Rio Tinto Kennecott Copper’s (RTKC) Bingham Canyon Mine experienced what is arguably the world’s largest ever in-pit slope failure. The failure initiated on the east wall of the mine, along major, continuous, low-strength bedding faults, which were the upper and lower contact of the Manefay hornfels bed. The failure comprised approximately 145 million tonnes of rock and waste dump material. East wall slope deformations were detected some months prior to the catastrophic slope collapse by RTKC’s ground-based slope monitoring systems. Use of existing terrestrial radar and prism monitoring systems provided excellent data to manage the response to the slope collapse. The failure resulted in no injuries/loss of life, although the failure runout distance was longer than expected, resulting in the loss of mining equipment and significant production interruption. Post-failure investigations identified an RTKC-sponsored, university research project, which detected a zone of sporadic ground deformation at the crest of the Manefay failure using satellite-based Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar (InSAR) monitoring. When the outcomes of this research study were received in 2010, RTKC responded by conducting detailed field inspections, installing prisms in the area of concern and monitoring the area closely in the years before the event. Interferometric methods for calculating ground displacement from satellite-based synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data have improved significantly since the time leading up to the Manefay failure. These updated methods have been used in this study of the available historic SAR data with results indicating that significant ground movements were occurring over a number of years prior to failure. Detailed knowledge of these movements could potentially have led to a different interpretation of failure mechanisms and magnitude and, in hindsight, different slope management and mine development plans in the years preceding slope failure. From a business and mine operations perspective, the ability to identify subtle signs of slope failure before a catastrophic slope collapse is essential for appropriate management of such events. The use of InSAR monitoring, as discussed in this paper, provides an increased capability for further improved slope management at RTKC, and at other mining operations.
Article
Full-text available
Landslides are a major natural hazard and act as a primary driver of erosion, chemical weathering and organic carbon transfer in mountain ranges. Evaluating the impact of landslides on Earth systems requires knowledge about the controls on their size, which are not well understood. Here we show that topographic stress, resulting from the interaction between tectonic stress and topography, influences bedrock landslide size at landscape scales by modulating the subsurface material strength through fracturing and weathering. Using a three-dimensional topographic stress model, we characterize the spatial pattern of subsurface open-fracture zones in a crystalline-rock terrain of the eastern Tibetan mountains. Then, we compare the predicted open-fracture zones with 982 mapped bedrock landslides. The results show that areas with deeper subsurface open-fracture zones tend to accommodate larger landslides. This is probably due to the influences of topographically induced fractures on the material strength and groundwater flow paths and rates. We conclude that the extent of hillslope failure depends on both distant tectonic forces and local topography, which has implications for hazard mitigation, landscape evolution and the global carbon cycle.
Article
Full-text available
Surficial mass wasting events are a hazard worldwide. Seismic and acoustic signals from these often remote processes, combined with other geophysical observations, can provide key information for monitoring and rapid response efforts and enhance our understanding of event dynamics. Here, we present seismoacoustic data and analyses for two very large ice–rock avalanches occurring on Iliamna Volcano, Alaska (USA), on 22 May 2016 and 21 June 2019. Iliamna is a glacier-mantled stratovolcano located in the Cook Inlet, ∼200 km from Anchorage, Alaska. The volcano experiences massive, quasi-annual slope failures due to glacial instabilities and hydrothermal alteration of volcanic rocks near its summit. The May 2016 and June 2019 avalanches were particularly large and generated energetic seismic and infrasound signals which were recorded at numerous stations at ranges from ∼9 to over 600 km. Both avalanches initiated in the same location near the head of Iliamna's east-facing Red Glacier, and their ∼8 km long runout shapes are nearly identical. This repeatability – which is rare for large and rapid mass movements – provides an excellent opportunity for comparison and validation of seismoacoustic source characteristics. For both events, we invert long-period (15–80 s) seismic signals to obtain a force-time representation of the source. We model the avalanche as a sliding block which exerts a spatially static point force on the Earth. We use this force-time function to derive constraints on avalanche acceleration, velocity, and directionality, which are compatible with satellite imagery and observed terrain features. Our inversion results suggest that the avalanches reached speeds exceeding 70 m s−1, consistent with numerical modeling from previous Iliamna studies. We lack sufficient local infrasound data to test an acoustic source model for these processes. However, the acoustic data suggest that infrasound from these avalanches is produced after the mass movement regime transitions from cohesive block-type failure to granular and turbulent flow – little to no infrasound is generated by the initial failure. At Iliamna, synthesis of advanced numerical flow models and more detailed ground observations combined with increased geophysical station coverage could yield significant gains in our understanding of these events.
Article
Full-text available
Depth‐averaged thin‐layer models are commonly used to model rapid gravity‐driven flows such as debris flows or debris avalanches. However, the formal derivation of thin‐layer equations for general topographies is not straightforward. The curvature of the topography results in a force that maintains the velocity tangent to the topography. Another curvature term appears in the bottom friction force with frictional rheologies. In this work, we present the main lines of the mathematical derivation for these curvature terms that are proportional to the square velocity. With the SHALTOP numerical model, we quantify their influence on flow dynamics and deposits over synthetic and real topographies. This is done by comparing simulations in which these terms are exact, disregarded or approximated. With the Coulomb rheology, for slopes θ = 10 and for friction coefficients below μ = tan (5°), neglecting the curvature force increases the simulated travel times by up to 10% and 30%, for synthetic and real topographies respectively. When the curvature in the friction force is neglected, the travel distance may be increased by several hundred meters on real topographies, whatever the topography slopes and friction coefficients. We observe similar effects on a synthetic channel with slope θ = 25° and μ = 15°, with a 50% increase of the kinetic energy. Finally, approximations of curvature in the friction force can break the noninvariance of the equations and decelerate the flow. With the Voellmy rheology, these discrepancies are less significant. Curvature effects can thus have significant impact for model calibration and for overflows prediction, both being critical for hazard assessment.
Article
Full-text available
In this study, based on the frictional velocity-weakening law used in continuum modeling, an adapted Hertz-Mindlin contact model between particles and the ground surface is established to accurately simulate the landslide dynamics process. Moreover, the long-period seismic waves indicating the dynamic characteristics of large landslides are adopted to determine the computational parameters for the discrete element method (DEM). By combining the force-time functions obtained from the long-period seismic waves and numerical modeling, the dynamic parameters and reasonableness of the simulation results of the first Baige landslide on October 11, 2018, in eastern Tibet, China, have been validated. The friction coefficient obtained in this study is also in agreement with the relationship between the volume and friction coefficients reported in the literature. Taking the same model and parameters, the dynamic process leading to the second Baige landslide on November 3, 2018, is analyzed. The modeled profile and position of the maximum thickness of the deposits arising from the two landslides both match the observations well. It is demonstrated that this combination procedure is feasible for the prediction and identification of areas susceptible to large landslides.
Article
Validation and benchmarking of pyroclastic current (PC) models is required to evaluate their performance and their reliability for hazard assessment. Here, we present results of a benchmarking initiative built to evaluate four models commonly used to assess concentrated PC hazard: SHALTOP, TITAN2D, VolcFlow, and IMEX_SfloW2D. The benchmark focuses on the simulation of channelized flows with similar source conditions over five different synthetic channel geometries: (1) a flat incline plane, (2) a channel with a sharp 45° bend, (3) a straight channel with a break-in-slope, (4) a straight channel with an obstacle, and (5) a straight channel with a constriction. Several outputs from 60 simulations using three different initial volume fluxes were investigated to evaluate the performance of the four models when simulating valley-confined PC kinematics, including overflows induced by topographic changes. Quantification of the differences obtained between model outputs at t = 100 s allowed us to identify (1) issues with the Voellmy-Salm implementation of TITAN2D and (2) small discrepancies between the three other codes that are either due to various curvature and velocity formulations and/or numerical frameworks. Benchmark results were also in agreement with field observations of natural PCs: a sudden change in channel geometries combined with a high-volume flux is key to generate overflows. The synthetic benchmarks proved to be useful for evaluating model performance, needed for PC hazard assessment. The overarching goal is to provide an interpretation framework for volcanic mass flow hazard assessment studies to the geoscience community.
Article
We present an open-source Python package, lsforce, for performing single-force source inversions of long-period (tens to hundreds of seconds) seismic signals. Although the software is designed primarily for landslides, it can be used for any single-force seismic source. The package allows users to produce estimates of the three-component time series of forces exerted on the Earth by a landslide with postprocessing options to estimate the trajectory of its center of mass. Green’s functions for a user-selected 1D Earth model are obtained automatically from the Incorporated Research Institutions for Seismology Synthetics Engine webservice or can be computed for custom 1D Earth models using Computer Programs in Seismology. lsforce implements the two most commonly used source parameterizations: a fully flexible, high-resolution approach and a more stable but lower-resolution method of overlapping triangle sources. Regularization options include a blended zeroth-, first-, and second-order semiautomated Tikhonov regularization scheme, as well as additional optional constraints on start times, end times, and on the sum of forces. Uncertainty due to data selection can be assessed using either a leave-one-out approach or a modified jackknife technique that randomly excludes subsets of the data for multiple re-inversions. Numerous built-in plotting methods allow for easy quality control and assessment of results. In this article, we briefly outline the theory and methodology, describe our implementation, and demonstrate the usage of lsforce using the well-studied 28 June 2016 Lamplugh rock avalanche in Alaska. Despite the rapidly increasing prevalence of landslide single-force inversions in the landslide and seismology literature over the past decade, to our knowledge this is the first open-source code for performing such inversions.