ArticlePDF Available

Multiple senses influencing healthy food preference

Authors:

Abstract

The worldwide prevalence of obesity and lifestyle diseases has increased the importance of healthy eating. Understanding consumer preferences for healthy food could lead to healthier food consumption and help mitigate public health concerns. Continued research in food science, marketing, and consumer psychology has demonstrated that healthy food preferences can be shaped by multiple senses. We review recent research on the effects of visual, auditory, olfactory, and tactile cues on consumers’ evaluations, choices, and intake of healthy foods. Our review also highlights the promising role of multisensory virtual environments and educational interventions in fostering healthy food preferences. Finally, based on this review, we discuss directions for future research.
1
Multiple senses influencing healthy food preference
Kosuke Motoki1* & Taku Togawa2
This is an accepted version of a paper published in
Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences
1 Department of Management, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
2 Faculty of Economics, Department of Management, Sophia University, Tokyo, Japan
*Correspondence should be addressed to Kosuke Motoki, Department of Management,
The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
E-mail: motoki@e.u-tokyo.ac.jp
2
Abstract
The worldwide prevalence of obesity and lifestyle diseases has increased the importance
of healthy eating. Understanding consumer preferences for healthy food could lead to
healthier food consumption and help mitigate public health concerns. Continued
research in food science, marketing, and consumer psychology has demonstrated that
healthy food preferences can be shaped by multiple senses. We review recent research
on the effects of visual, auditory, olfactory, and tactile cues on consumers’ evaluations,
choices, and intake of healthy foods. Our review also highlights the promising role of
multisensory virtual environments and educational interventions in fostering healthy
food preferences. Finally, based on this review, we discuss directions for future
research.
3
Introduction
With the exacerbation of health-related issues, such as obesity and lifestyle diseases
caused by eating habits, research aiming to enhance healthy eating behavior has become
increasingly vital [1]. In this review, we define healthy food as food that is high in
nutrients and low in calories/fat/sugar (e.g., [2,3]). Previous studies have shown that
behavioral decisions on food (e.g., purchasing or intake) can be determined in relation
to all five senses [4]*. For instance, while purchasing, visual elements, such as package
color and advertisement images, influence food product choices [5,6]. During
consumption, tactile experiences, including mouthfeel and food temperature, affect the
amount of food intake [7]. While studies have comprehensively reviewed marketing and
nutrition literature on food, few studies have focused on sensory influences on healthy
eating behavior. Considering the social and academic significance of healthy eating, it is
crucial to review and organize existing knowledge on the influence of multisensory
experiences on healthy eating behaviors [6,8]. Thus, the present cross-disciplinary paper
reviews recent food studies and outlines existing findings on how sensory inputs affect
healthy eating behavior, such as food choice and intake. A graphical illustration of this
review is presented in Figure 1.
Vision
4
Vision is the most widely studied sense among the five senses [9]. Previous research
has investigated the relationship between visual (e.g., color, shape) and food attributes
(e.g., perceived healthfulness) [10,11]. More relevant to the present review, increasing
evidence has revealed that visual attributes extending from more basic levels (e.g.,
color, shape) [12–17] to more sophisticated levels (e.g., artistic design) influence
preference for healthy food [2,18,19*].
Color
Color research on marketing and consumer behavior has attracted attention for many
years [9]. Lighting has been considered as a key factor of color perception. Recent
studies have investigated the effects of brightness in lighting on healthy food
preferences [12,13], and they have consistently shown that participants in a brightly lit
room tend to choose a healthy snack (e.g., banana) compared to those in a dimly lit
room. In addition to ambient factors such as lighting, verbal or visual elements of
communications can also influence healthy eating decisions. For instance, Wang et al.
showed that health-focused advertising messages with black and white colors positively
influenced consumer attitudes (including advertisements, restaurants, purchasing
intention, and willingness to pay) [14] (also see [20]). Additionally, some researchers
have focused on the role of traffic light colors on labels in food choices. Kunz et al.
5
showed that a label colored green (vs. a colorless label) increased purchase intention
toward products with low sugar levels [18].
Not surprisingly, the colors of food itself also determine consumers’ eating decisions.
Recent research has applied digital image analysis to explore color parameters
influencing consumer preferences [19*, 21]. Paakki et al. showed that the color
parameters of food images influenced healthy food preferences [19]*. The color
parameters (L*, a*, b*) of salad images were calculated using digital image analyses.
Colorful salads were preferred over pale salads. Moreover, salads with great variation in
red-green (a*) and dark-light colors (L*) were rated as higher in terms of preferences
than those with less variation in red-green and dark-light colors. Digital image analyses
may help explore the color parameters of real-world visual elements (e.g.,
advertisements, interior, packaging, and logos) that influence consumer preferences for
healthy food.
Shape
Specific properties of shape, such as roundness and slimness, influence healthy food
preferences [11,17,22,23]. For example, Wang et al. showed that angular shapes were
more associated with healthy food, whereas round shapes were more linked to
unhealthy food. Moreover, consumers tended to prefer healthy foods with angular
6
shapes (i.e., angular wholegrain bread) compared to healthy foods with round shapes
(i.e., circular wholegrain bread). However, other studies have not found significant
effects of angular shape on healthy food preferences [11,22,23]. One study showed that
round-shaped packages or typefaces were preferred over angular-shaped packages or
typefaces regardless of whether the food was healthy or not [11,23]. It has also been
shown that round (vs. angular) shapes increase preferences for indulgent foods, while
the effects of angular versus round shapes on healthy food preferences were non-
significant [22].
Additionally, the perception of healthiness can be engendered by the slim design of
packages. Yarar et al. investigated how the slimness of a package influenced the
evaluation of food healthfulness [24]. Packaging mimicking a slim humanoid was
perceived as healthier than packaging resembling a less slim humanoid. Moreover, the
effects of package slimness were more pronounced in women and those with higher
body mass index. Although this study did not test the downstream effects on
preferences, slim packaging may have increased healthy food preferences, and the
effects were more pronounced in women and those with higher body mass
index. Moreover, given that there are exceptions in the marketplace where slim
packaging is not associated with healthiness (e.g., Coca-Cola bottles and other
7
carbonated juices), future research is needed to identify boundary conditions or
moderators determining the effect of slim packaging on healthiness perception.
Position
Healthy eating behavior can be driven by the vertical or horizontal position of food
imagery on a display or package façade. For example, Togawa et al. hypothesized that a
food image placed at the bottom (vs. top) of the package façade would enhance flavor
richness and perceived satiety, resulting in healthy eating decisions (e.g., decreasing
consumption and choosing a healthy option) [25]. In an experiment, participants were
asked to watch a short film while eating popcorn. To manipulate the position of the
imagery, a picture of popcorn was placed at the bottom or top of the package façade. As
hypothesized, participants in the bottom (vs. top) condition perceived the flavor as
richer and ate less popcorn. Wang and Basso also documented a metaphorical
association between vertical representation and healthiness [26], in that that people
associated healthy foods with a higher (vs. lower) vertical position. Specifically, people
perceived a food product as healthier when it was pictured from a low (vs. high) camera
angle such that the viewer would seem to be looking up (vs. looking down) at
it. However, these two studies provided mixed results. In the former study, the lower
8
(vs. higher) location of packaging imagery promoted healthy eating (e.g., reducing
consumption) [25], whereas the latter study showed that higher (vs. lower) vertical
position was associated with healthiness [26]. This suggests that the association between
vertical positions and food healthiness can lead to different results depending on two
stages of food consumption: the point-of-purchase (i.e., judgment of healthiness) [26]
and the consumption stage (i.e., health-conscious eating) [25]. Moreover, given that
food positioning is also associated with specific food taste (i.e., a higher position is
associated with sweetness) [27], the effects of vertical positioning on healthy food
preferences may differ depending on what kind of taste consumers associate with that
positioning.
There is also a mental association between horizontal positions and food healthiness.
To investigate this association, Manippa et al. conducted four experiments wherein data
were collected and assessed using multiple methods, such as Likert scales and the
Visual Analogue Scale [28]. The results showed that when a “Healthy” label was
displayed on the left (right) side of a screen, participants were more likely to categorize
foods as healthier (higher calorie). Moreover, low-calorie (high-calorie) foods were
preferred when presented on the left (right) side of the screen. Another study focusing
on both vertical and horizontal positions replicated these findings [29]; that is,
9
participants preferred low-calorie (vs. high-calorie) foods and indicated a more intense
desire to eat when food imagery was displayed on the top or left (vs. bottom or right)
side of the screen. Moreover, one study investigated the role of the position of
transparent windows on packaging designs on food preferences [30]. The results
demonstrated that the top- and bottom-right (vs. top- and bottom-left) windows
enhanced preferences for healthy food (e.g., granola) [30].
Visual aspects of materials
Consumers infer food healthfulness from visual aspects of materials [31,32].
Recent research has investigated the visual perception effects of materials on healthy
food preferences [32]. Consumers tended to perceive food with matte (vs. glossy)
packages as healthier. Furthermore, consumers motivated to engage in healthy eating
were more likely to choose food products with matte (vs. glossy) packages. These
findings suggest that the visual aspects of materials (e.g., matte) influence cues of food
healthfulness and nudge consumers to healthier food choices.
Visual aesthetic elements
Aesthetic elements can help enhance preferences for healthy foods [2,8]. Research has
shown that the visual aesthetic presentation of food increases healthy food preferences
10
[8]. Kandinsky-inspired artistic plating increased the liking, willingness to pay, and
perceived palatability of salads in comparison with regular and neat presentations [8].
Moreover, visual aesthetic elements such as symmetry and balance in a dish affected
food preferences [33,34]. For example, across a series of experiments, Hagan
investigated how and when the aesthetics of foods, manipulated by balance and
symmetry, influenced perceived healthfulness and choice of (healthy) foods [2] (see also
[15,35]). Specifically, aesthetic appearance (symmetry + balance) increased the
willingness to pay for healthy food (bell pepper) via increased perceived healthfulness.
Furthermore, an intervention to capitalize on the aesthetic elements of food increased
children’s preference for healthy foods [36]*. Children participated in a workshop on
creating artistic plating of foods or an unrelated creativity workshop. The artistic
workshop conditions enhanced children’s preference for healthy sweets (e.g., Spinach
sponge cake) previously used in the workshop when compared with the results from the
unrelated creativity workshop condition.
Audition
People’s healthy food preferences can be affected by auditory experience through
background music or brand names.
Background music/noise
11
Previous studies have investigated the effects of background music on healthy food
preferences [37–40]. Their focus can be classified broadly into two subcategories:
musical attributes and types. In terms of the first subcategory, two studies demonstrated
that playing music or noise with a higher (vs. lower) pitch [41] and lower (vs. higher)
volume [37] increased the choices for and sales of healthy food.
Research in the latter category has found that music genres influence consumers’
healthy food preferences [38–40]. For example, classical and jazz music increased
preferences for healthy foods (e.g., vegetable sandwiches) more than rock or heavy
metal music [38]. Similarly, soft nature sounds (e.g., the sound of ocean waves)
increased preferences for healthy foods rather than unhealthy foods [40]. Interestingly, it
has also been suggested that white noise decreases sweetness and saltiness intensity, that
is, consumers prefer sweeter and saltier foods when they are in a noisy environment
[42,43], which might affect consumers’ healthy food preferences.
Sound branding
Research has shown that particular sounds in brand names or sonic logos are
associated with healthy foods [44,45]. For example, Motoki et al. tested whether sounds
embedded in fictitious brand names modulated the perceived appropriateness of healthy
food names. The results demonstrated that higher-frequency sounds (i, e, f, s) in
12
fictitious brand names were rated as more appropriate for healthy food names than
lower-frequency sounds (b, d, g, u, o) in fictitious brand names. This suggests that
sounds in brand names might influence preferences for healthy foods.
Olfaction
Olfactory cues play a significant role in eating decisions [46]. Specifically, recent
studies have examined the role of ambient odors in food selection, intake, and appetite
[47]. The effects of ambient odors seem to be specific to congruent food (i.e., similar
types of food from which the odor originates) [48]. For example, ambient healthy food
odors (e.g., fruit odors) increased the selection of fruits and vegetables [48]. However,
contradictory findings have also been reported [48]. Perceiving healthy food odors (i.e.,
cucumber and melon) did not increase healthy (or low-calorie) food preferences [48].
Differing exposure times to odors (i.e., longer or shorter exposure durations) may
explain these contradictory findings [48]. Recent research has revealed that the exposure
time to odors modulates how odors influence healthy food preferences [49].
Specifically, people were more likely to choose healthy foods when exposed to an
ambient scent of indulgent versus non-indulgent foods (i.e., chocolate chip cookies vs.
strawberries) for a long time (more than two minutes) [49].
13
Other characteristics of odors (the temperature dimension of odor) also influence
healthy food preferences [50]. Lefebvre and Biswas examined the role of ambient scent
temperature in healthy food preferences. The presence of a metaphorically warm
ambient odor (e.g., cedarwood) increased the choice of healthy (lower-calorie) food
options more than the presence of a metaphorically cool ambient odor (e.g., eucalyptus)
[50].
Touch
Healthy food preferences can be affected by specific attributes of touch, such as
temperature, weight, and texture. For example, warm foods are perceived as having
more calories and satiation than cold foods [7,51]. Baskentli et al. demonstrated that
purchasing cold (vs. warm) foods was more likely to lead to ordering more
complementary items (e.g., a bag of chips, cookies) [51]. In contrast, ambient
temperature does not influence healthy food preferences [52].
One study found that a food’s weight influenced evaluation of the food as healthy [53].
Consumers tended to associate physical weight with greater perceived healthiness of
food because physically lighter food was regarded as having fewer calories. Given
consumers’ intuition in this regard, consumers may prefer lightweight, healthy foods.
Furthermore, the weight of bowls in which food was served influenced the perceived
14
density of food [54], which possibly leads to faster satiation and, thus, healthy eating
behavior.
Van Rompay et al. investigated the effects of 3D-printed surface textures on healthy
food preferences [55]*. A between-participant experiment was conducted using three
surface textures (smooth, rough, and rough or irregular) and three salt contents (low,
medium, and high). Significant interactions were found for healthy food preferences
(indexed by a willingness to try healthy product variants). In medium and high salt
conditions, a smooth texture resulted in a lower willingness to try than a rough or
irregular texture. Conversely, in the low salt condition, a smooth texture led to a higher
willingness to try than a rough or irregular texture.
Multiple senses
Multisensory virtual environments
Some recent studies have focused on multisensory virtual environments to facilitate
healthy food preferences [56*–59]. For example, Pennanen et al. designed three
conditions: a peaceful nature VR environment (sunny day picnic), an uncomfortable VR
environment (sudden rain shower picnic), and a control (blank canvas) [56]*. In the
peaceful nature VR environment, participants viewed a mountain valley with natural
15
sounds (birds, wind, and rain) and subtle background music (Figure 2). Among the
various environments presented, participants rated healthy (rye nacho) and unhealthy
(milk chocolate) snacks. The results demonstrated that the peaceful nature VR
environment increased the liking of and desire for a healthy snack more than the control
condition. Although an alternative account whereby participants associated situational
factors (e.g., birdsong and mountain views reminiscent of breakfast) with specific foods
(e.g., chocolate) was considered plausible, the results of the study suggest the possibility
of using multisensory virtual environments to enhance consumers’ acceptance of
healthy foods.
Multisensory educational intervention
Multisensory exposure intervention in preschool children (three- to four-years-old)
increases healthy food preference [60]* (see also [61]). Children in intervention groups
participated in activities involving unisensory (visual) or multisensory (smell/visual or
smell/touch/visual) exposure to vegetables. The two multisensory exposure
interventions increased the preference for the exposed vegetables more than the
unisensory intervention. These findings suggest that multisensory activities provide a
promising avenue to increase the acceptance of healthy foods.
16
Conclusions
We reviewed recent research on the multisensory influences on healthy food
preferences. This review identified that multisensory cues, including visual, auditory,
olfactory, and tactile cues, can enhance consumers’ food evaluations, choices, and intake
of healthy foods. Furthermore, it highlighted the promising role of multisensory virtual
environments and educational interventions to foster healthy food preferences.
This review provides an avenue for future research. In the current literature, less
attention has been paid to touch than other sensations, such as vision and audition.
Future research should broadly investigate how haptic information on food, plates, and
cutlery affects healthy eating decisions. Moreover, only a limited number of studies
have focused on multisensory effects; however, given the complexity of the interplay
between human sensations, further extensive research needs to be conducted to examine
how, when, and why multisensory experiences affect healthy eating behaviors.
Acknowledgments
Funding
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public,
commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Conflict of interest statement
17
None declared.
References and recommended reading
Papers of particular interest published within the period of review have been highlighted
as follows:
• of special interest
References
[1] Swinburn BA, Kraak VI, Allender S, Atkins VJ, Baker PI, Bogard JR, Brinsden H,
Calvillo. A, De Schutter O, Devarajan R, et al.: The global syndemic of obesity,
undernutrition, and climate change: The Lancet Commission report. Lancet 2019,
393:791–846.
[2] Hagen L: Pretty healthy food: How and when aesthetics enhance perceived
healthiness. J Mark 2021, 85:129–145.
[3] Gill T, Lei J, Kim HJ: Adding more portion-size options to a menu: A means to
nudge consumers to choose larger portions of healthy food items. Appetite 2022,
169:105830.
[4]* Spence C: Sensehacking: How to Use the Power of Your Senses for Happier,
Healthier Living. Penguin UK; 2021.
[5] Velasco C, Spence C (Eds.): Multisensory Packaging: Designing New Product
Experiences. Springer; 2019.
[6] Spence C: Gastrophysics: Nudging consumers toward eating more leafy (salad)
greens. Food Qual Prefer 2020, 80:103800.
[7] Yamim AP, Mai R, Werle COC: Make it hot? How food temperature (mis)guides
product judgments. J Consum Res 2020, 47:523–543.
18
[8] Michel C, Velasco C, Gatti E, Spence C: A taste of Kandinsky: assessing the
influence of the artistic visual presentation of food on the dining experience. Flavour
2014, 3:1–11.
[9] Sample KL, Hagtvedt H, Brasel SA: Components of visual perception in marketing
contexts: A conceptual framework and review. J Acad Mark Sci 2020, 48:405–421.
[10] Reinoso-Carvalho F, Campo R, De Luca M, Velasco C: Toward Healthier Cookie
Habits: Assessing the role of packaging visual appearance in the expectations for dietary
Cookies in Digital Environments. Front Psychol 2021, 12:679443.
[11] Marques da Rosa V, Spence C, Miletto Tonetto L: Influences of visual attributes of
food packaging on consumer preference and associations with taste and healthiness. Int
J Consum Stud 2019, 43:210–217.
[12] Chan EY: Brightness motivates healthy behaviors: The role of self-accountability.
Environ Behav 2021, 54:363–382.
[13] Biswas D, Szocs C, Chacko R, Wansink B: Shining light on atmospherics: How
ambient light influences food choices. J Mark Res 2017, 54:111–123.
[14] Wang B, Liu SQ, Kandampully J, Bujisic M: How color affects the effectiveness of
taste- versus health-focused restaurant advertising messages. J Advert 2020, 49:557–
574.
[15] Schifferstein HNJ, Wehrle T, Carbon C-C: Consumer expectations for vegetables
with typical and atypical colors: The case of carrots. Food Qual Prefer 2019, 72:98–
108.
[16] Howell BF, Schifferstein HNJ: How neutral coloured backgrounds affect the
attractiveness and expensiveness of fresh produce. Food Qual Prefer 2019, 78:103718.
[17] Wang J, Zhang X, Jiang J: Healthy-angular, unhealthy-circular: Effects of the fit
between shapes and healthiness on consumer food preferences. J Bus Res 2022,
139:740–750.
[18] Kunz S, Haasova S, Rieß J, Florack A: Beyond healthiness: The impact of traffic
light labels on taste expectations and purchase intentions. Foods 2020, 9:34.
19
[19]* Paakki M, Sandell M, Hopia A: Visual attractiveness depends on colorfulness and
color contrasts in mixed salads. Food Qual Prefer 2019, 76:81–90.
[20] Del Gatto C, Indraccolo A, Imperatori C, Brunetti R: Hungry for colours?
Attentional bias for food crucially depends on perceptual information. Cogn Process
2021, 22:159–169.
[21] Motoki K, Takahashi A, Spence C: Tasting atmospherics: Taste associations with
colour parameters of coffee shop interiors. Food Qual Prefer 2021, 94:104315.
[22] Zhou S, Chen S, Li S: The shape effect: Round shapes increase consumers’
preference for hedonic foods. Psychol Mark 2021, 38:2051–2072.
[23] Wang L, Yu Y, Li O: The typeface curvature effect: The role of typeface curvature
in increasing preference toward hedonic products. Psychol Mark 2020, 37:1118–1137.
[24] Yarar N, Machiels CJA, Orth UR: Shaping up: How package shape and consumer
body conspire to affect food healthiness evaluation. Food Qual Prefer 2019, 75:209–
219.
[25] Togawa T, Park J, Ishii H, Deng X: A packaging visual-gustatory correspondence
effect: Using visual packaging design to influence flavor perception and healthy eating
decisions. J Retail 2019, 95:204–218.
[26] Wang F, Basso F: The peak of health: The vertical representation of healthy food.
Appetite 2021, 167:105587.
[27] Velasco C, Adams C, Petit O, Spence C: On the localization of tastes and tasty
products in 2D space. Food Qual Prefer 2019, 71:438–446.
[28] Manippa V, Giuliani F, Brancucci A: Healthiness or calories? Side biases in food
perception and preference. Appetite 2020, 147:104552.
[29] Manippa V, Ferracci S, Pietroni D, Brancucci A: Can the position on the screen of
an image influence its judgment? The case of high- and low-calorie foods. Food Qual
Prefer 2022, 96:104407.
[30] Simmonds G, Woods AT, Spence C: “Seeing what’s left”: The effect of position of
transparent windows on product evaluation. Foods 2018, 7:151.
20
[31] Kerpel LD, De Kerpel L, Volles BK, Van Kerckhove A: Fats are glossy but does
glossiness imply fatness? The influence of packaging glossiness on food perceptions.
Foods 2020, 9:90.
[32] Ye N, Morrin M, Kampfer K: From glossy to greasy: The impact of learned
associations on perceptions of food healthfulness. J Consum Psychol 2019, 32:1.
[33] Rowley J, Spence C: Does the visual composition of a dish influence the
perception of portion size and hedonic preference? Appetite 2018, 128:79–86.
[34] Velasco C, Michel C, Woods AT, Spence C: On the importance of balance to
aesthetic plating. Int J Gastron Food Sci 2016, 5-6:10–16.
[35] Bolos LA, Lagerkvist C-J, Normann A, Wendin K: In the eye of the beholder:
Expected and actual liking for apples with visual imperfections. Food Qual Prefer 2021,
87:104065.
[36]* Maiz E, Urkia I, Bereciartu A, Urdaneta E, Allirot X: Introducing novel fruits and
vegetables: Effects of involving children in artistic plating of food. Food Qual Prefer
2019, 77:172–183.
[37] Biswas D, Lund K, Szocs C: Sounds like a healthy retail atmospheric strategy:
Effects of ambient music and background noise on food sales. J Acad Mark Sci 2019,
47:37–55.
[38] Motoki K, Takahashi N, Velasco C, Spence C: Is classical music sweeter than jazz?
Crossmodal influences of background music and taste/flavour on healthy and indulgent
food preferences. Food Qual Prefer 2022, 96:104380.
[39] Peng-Li D, Mathiesen SL, Chan RCK, Byrne DV, Wang QJ: Sounds healthy:
Modelling sound-evoked consumer food choice through visual attention. Appetite 2021,
164:105264.
[40] Peng-Li D, Andersen T, Finlayson G, Byrne DV, Wang QJ: The impact of
environmental sounds on food reward. Physiol Behav 2021, 245:113689.
[41] Huang X (I), Labroo AA: Cueing morality: The effect of high-pitched music on
healthy choice. J Mark 2020, 84:130–143.
21
[42] Woods AT, Poliakoff E, Lloyd DM, Kuenzel J, Hodson R, Gonda H, Batchelor J,
Dijksterhuis GB, Thomas A: Effect of background noise on food perception. Food Qual
Prefer 2010, 22:42–47.
[43] Spence C: Tasting in the air: A review. Int J Gastron Food Sci 2017, 9:10–15.
[44] Techawachirakul M, Pathak A, Calvert GA: That sounds healthy!: Audio and visual
frequency differences in brand sound logos modify the perception of food healthfulness.
Food Qual Prefer 2022, 99:104544
[45] Motoki K, Park J, Pathak A, Spence C: Constructing healthy food names: On the
sound symbolism of healthy food. Food Qual Prefer 2021, 90:104157.
[46] Spence C: Leading the consumer by the nose: On the commercialization of
olfactory design for the food and beverage sector. Flavour 2015, 4:31.
[47] Morrin M, Tepper BJ: Multisensory marketing: Effects of environmental aroma
cues on perception, appetite, and consumption of foods and drinks. Curr Opin Food Sci
2021, 40:204–210.
[48] Morquecho-Campos P, de Graaf K, Boesveldt S: Smelling our appetite? The
influence of food odors on congruent appetite, food preferences and intake. Food Qual
Prefer 2020, 85:103959.
[49] Biswas D, Szocs C: The smell of healthy choices: Cross-modal sensory
compensation effects of ambient scent on food purchases. J Mark Res 2019, 56:123–
141.
[50] Lefebvre S, Biswas D: The influence of ambient scent temperature on food
consumption behavior. J Exp Psychol Appl 2019, 25:753–764.
[51] Baskentli S, Block L, Morrin M: The serving temperature effect: Food temperature,
expected satiety, and complementary food purchases. Appetite 2021, 160:105069.
[52] Motoki K, Saito T, Nouchi R, Kawashima R, Sugiura M: The paradox of warmth:
Ambient warm temperature decreases preference for savory foods. Food Qual Prefer
2018, 69:1–9.
[53] Li Y, Heuvinck N, Pandelaere M: The light = healthy intuition. J Consum Psychol
2022, 32:326–335.
22
[54] Piqueras-Fiszman B, Harrar V, Alcaide J, Spence C: Does the weight of the dish
influence our perception of food? Food Qual Prefer 2011, 22:753–756.
[55]* van Rompay T, van Ooijen I, Groothedde S, Saakes D: (Not to be taken) with a
grain of salt: Enhancing perceived saltiness by 3D-printed surface textures. Food Qual
Prefer 2021, 93:104279.
[56]* Pennanen K, Närväinen J, Vanhatalo S, Raisamo R, Sozer N: Effect of virtual
eating environment on consumers’ evaluations of healthy and unhealthy snacks. Food
Qual Prefer 2020, 82:103871.
[57] Hoppu U, Puputti S, Mattila S, Puurtinen M, Sandell M: Food consumption and
emotions at a salad lunch buffet in a multisensory environment. Foods 2020, 9:1349.
[58] Sinesio F, Saba A, Peparaio M, Saggia Civitelli E, Paoletti F, Moneta E: Capturing
consumer perception of vegetable freshness in a simulated real-life taste situation. Food
Res Int 2018, 105:764–771.
[59] van Bergen G, Zandstra EH, Kaneko D, Dijksterhuis GB, de Wijk RA: Sushi at the
beach: Effects of congruent and incongruent immersive contexts on food evaluations.
Food Qual Prefer 2021, 91:104193.
[60]* Roberts AP, Cross L, Hale A, Houston-Price C: VeggieSense: A non-taste
multisensory exposure technique for increasing vegetable acceptance in young children.
Appetite 2022, 168:105784.
[61] Youssef J, Mora M, Maiz E, Spence C: Sensory exploration of vegetables
combined with a cookery class increases willingness to choose/eat plant-based food and
drink. Int J Gastron Food Sci 2022, 28:100515.
23
Figure Captions
Figure 1. A graphical illustration summarizing the review
Figure 2*. The multisensory virtual environment used in Pennanen et al. [52].
*Reprinted from Pennanen et al. [52] with permission from Elsevier.
24
Figures
Figure 1
25
Figure 2
... These researchers remarked the importance of improving the culinary quality of meals to engage more consumers in future experiences. Gastronomy has been suggested as a driver of change on consumer habits (Allirot et al., 2016;Mora et al., 2020;Motoki and Togawa 2022). Allirot et al. (2016) studied how involving children in cooking healthy foods reduced neophobia in kids and favored these foods choices. ...
... Mora et al. (2020) showed that menus of a "calorie control diet" were more accepted when designed including chefs' gastronomic knowledge (flavor and texture enhancement by using specific culinary techniques) than when designed in a conventional manner (conventional cooking techniques). Also, Motoki and Togawa (2022) explored the impact of different senses (olfactory, tactile, auditory, and visual signals) on consumers' assessments, selections, and consumption of food, indicating the potential of multimodal strategies on improving the election of healthy meals. In the present research, using a tasting experience in which a chef enhanced the flavor properties of a seasonal product using a zero-waste approach, seemed to properly exemplify to citizens the potential of culinary knowledge for reaching a more sustainable city. ...
Article
Reaching a sustainable future in which cities characteristics meet all needs and expectations of citizens is an ambitious challenge at a global level. The present study aimed to identify appropriate ways to transform cities into “greener-cities” using a citizen science approach. In a three phases-project, co-design dynamics were conducted with different citizens' groups: consumers, chefs, producers/suppliers, and experts in different scientific disciplines. First, four focus groups were carried out for diagnosing the food system of the city (Donostia-San Sebastián) and identify potential solutions. Then, two workshops with mixed participants from different stakeholders' groups were carried out to co-design suitable initiatives previously identified in the first phase. Finally, the co-designed initiative was presented and tested: an immersive experience where participants could taste a local and seasonal dish presented by a Chef in a 360° video room with projections of an organic farm. Results showed that innovative educational activities or programs, such as the developed “Gastronomic Journey”, could be used to engage citizens and move forward to a greener city. The experience was considered as an opportunity to discover the city's flavor and culture, and to bring awareness to citizens about challenges of the food system through the chef's speech.
... Consumers generally rely on their intuition or lay beliefs when determining whether a food is healthy (Chan & Zhang, 2022;Motoki & Togawa, 2022) rather than just the food's nutritional information (such as calories). Lay beliefs are acquired from individual experiences and/or the environment (Chan & Zhang, 2022;Nisbett & Ross, 1980). ...
Article
Full-text available
Across five studies (including one supplementary study), we demonstrated that the length of brand names influences the expectations of healthiness in foods and preference for healthy foods. Specifically, foods with shorter (versus longer) brand names are perceived as healthier, and consumers prefer such foods. The perceived potency of names and expectations of healthfulness partially mediate the effect. Shorter (vs. longer) names are perceived as less potent; therefore, foods with such names are expected to be healthier, leading to a greater preference. Furthermore, the boundary condition (perceived potency of the brand names) ise identified, where a positive effect of name length is not observed when the name includes more potent phonemes. Our findings contribute to the literature on healthy food branding and provide managerial implications for practitioners who are interested in promoting healthy foods.
Article
Purpose As humans are influenced by their environment, this study explores how different construal levels of ambient scent temperature affect consumers’ food choices. Design/methodology/approach This study employed a series of experimental methods from three studies, totalling five experiments. The experiments involved both laboratory and field settings, as well as neuroscientific techniques, thus generating empirical evidence. Findings Three studies were conducted to investigate how construal levels of both ambient scent temperature and tasks influenced food choice. Study 1 found that the construal level of ambient scent temperature significantly affected the type of food consumed. Study 2 included the task’s construal level as another factor to examine whether it interacted with the ambient scent temperature construal level. Both factors were significant, but only when perceived by the participants simultaneously. If the task’s construal level was manipulated before exposure to the ambient scent temperature, the latter did not have a significant effect. Study 3 employed a neuroscientific method to explore the mechanism behind the match between ambient scent temperature and food choices based on construal levels. The congruence of ambient scent temperature and food choice based on construal level enhanced positive emotions. Research limitations/implications The sample size, although in line with other neuroscientific studies, was not sufficiently large for robust generalizability. This limitation can encourage future research to increase the number of participants and thus enhance the accountability of the findings. Another limitation is the participants’ cultural background. Practical implications This study’s practical implications are twofold. First, odour intensity was perceived to be the strongest in hot samples (Kähkönen et al. , 1995), and we confirmed how ambient scent temperature can influence one’s food choice. Thus, food business operators can use warm ambient scent temperatures to promote hedonic food or snacks. Second, participants’ positive emotions were enhanced by the congruence of ambient scent temperature and food choice. Social implications The association between ambient scent temperature and food choice has been extensively researched. However, this study provides an empirical explanation for the application of CLT. Accordingly, we performed a series of laboratory and field experiments using behavioural and neuroscientific approaches. The results confirmed that the construal level of ambient scent temperature significantly affected food choice. Moreover, the FAA revealed that one’s positive emotions would be prompted if there was congruence in the construal levels of ambient scent temperature and food choice. Originality/value This study has theoretical and managerial value because people’s poor understanding of food selection is affected by ambient scent temperature. Moreover, its novelty lies in the application of a neuroscientific approach to one experiment.
Article
Multisensorisches Marketing kann die Bindung zwischen Konsumenten und gesunden Lebensmitteln durch visuelle, auditive, gustatorische, olfaktorische und haptische Elemente stärken, um positive Auswirkungen auf Gesundheitswahrnehmung, bewusstes Essen und langfristige Verhaltensänderungen zu erzielen. Trotz Präventionspotenzial für multiple Erkrankungen erfordert dies weitere Langzeitstudien.
Article
Full-text available
Sonic brand logos, also termed “sogos”, are a marketing communication tool that brands use to signify brand or product benefits to consumers in catchy, non-visual ways. Given the considerable utility of brand lsogos, it is surprising that there has been scant research into the nature of the specific acoustic features that can be modulated to connote certain traits, such as the healthfulness of products within the food category. Our findings revealed that sogos created with higher (vs. lower) frequency were significantly matched with healthy food products (vs. less healthy), while the effect of tempo was neutral. This effect generalizes to high (vs. low) spatial frequency visual stimuli too. The current study contributes to the literature on the crossmodal correspondence between acoustic sound clips and expectations of healthfulness. It also advances the theoretical insights into business applications using optimal sogos congruent with visual cues on packaging to connote food healthfulness to consumers implicitly.
Article
Full-text available
Wanting and liking are both components of food reward, but they manifest in fundamentally different neural substrates. While wanting denotes anticipatory and motivational behaviors, liking is associated with consummatory and hedonic experiences. These distinct constructs have also been quantitatively dissociated in behavioral paradigms. Indeed, internal, physiological, and interoceptive states affect the degree to which the food presented is valued. However, how contextual sensory cues might impact these appetitive and rewarding responses to food remains unexplored. In light of the increasing empirical focus on sound in food research, we investigated the influence of environmental soundscapes on explicit liking, explicit wanting, implicit wanting, choice frequency, and reaction time of healthy/unhealthy food using an online version of the Leeds Food Preference Questionnaire (LFPQ). Soft nature sounds and loud restaurant noises were employed to induce emotional relaxation and arousal respectively. One hundred and one healthy university students completed a repeated-measure design of the LFPQ; once with each soundscape playing in the background. Generalized linear mixed model analyses detected a significant interaction effect between soundscape and food type on choice frequency, yet the post hoc analyses did not reach significance. While hypothesis-driven analyses found that only nature sounds increased explicit liking of healthy (vs. unhealthy) foods, no effect of soundscape on any wanting measures (explicit or implicit) were observed. Finally, exploratory analyses indicated that restaurant noise (vs. nature sound) induced faster response times for both healthy and unhealthy foods. The study exemplifies that in an online setting, contextual auditory manipulation of certain food reward measures and decision processes is feasible.
Article
Full-text available
Store atmospheres are inherently multisensory and constitute an important driver of consumer behaviour. The research suggests that background music (as one element of the multisensory atmosphere) can influence consumer preference and choice. However, the findings have been inconsistent as far as how background music influences people’s preferences for healthy vs. indulgent foods is concerned. By considering different music genres, food types, and tastes/flavours, we aimed to disentangle the mixed results that have been reported previously. Across two experiments (including one pre-registered replication), the participants rated their preferences for each of several options (healthy savoury, indulgent savoury, healthy sweet, indulgent sweet) while listening to one of four music genres (Jazz, Classical, Rock/Metal, and Hip-hop). The results of the two experiments consistently demonstrated that the effects of background music on food preferences were dependent on the interaction between music genre, food type (healthy vs. indulgent), and taste/flavour (sweet vs. savoury). Crucially, listening to Jazz and Classical music increased people’s preferences for healthy savoury foods (e.g., vegetable sandwich) as compared with Rock/Metal music. Listening to Rock/Metal, Hip-hop, and Jazz music increased people’s preferences for indulgent savoury foods (e.g., a beef sandwich) as compared with Classical music. Additionally, listening to Classical music increased people’s preferences for both healthier (e.g., low-fat milk) and indulgent (e.g., milk chocolate) sweet foods as compared with the other musical genres. The mediating role of emotions was also documented in these experiments. Specifically, positive valence mediated the relationship between music genre and sweet as well as healthier savoury foods, while the feeling of arousal mediated the relationship between music genre and indulgent savoury foods. These findings suggest that auditory atmospherics may influence consumers’ food preferences. Practical implications for store managers concerning when to select and use specific types of background music are made.
Article
Full-text available
Despite being a fundamental food feature, the effect of food shapes has been underexplored. This study demonstrates that giving hedonic foods a round shape increases their desirability, choice probability, and consumption. However, this effect does not apply to utilitarian foods. Such asymmetric effects are attributed to the positive affect elicited by a round shape and not to the food's shape typicality, food knowledge, vividness, or fragility. The positive affect provides affective information and influences consumers' judgments and decisions. Moreover, the effectiveness of giving hedonic foods a round shape is attenuated by consumers' health motivations; that is, the effect holds only for those with low health motivation. Applying statistical methods to data from seven independent studies provided consistent evidence that supports our hypotheses, thereby advancing knowledge of the shape effect, susceptibility of hedonic products, and the affect-as-information framework, while also revealing how food shapes affect food consumption.
Article
We report a study conducted at Underhill School in North London designed to assess the immediate impact of a culinary class with a chef on the students' willingness to choose and to eat unfamiliar vegetable-based food and beverage options. A total of 98 school children were randomly assigned to take part in either a 40-minute sensory exploration and cooking class with chef Jozef Youssef and the Kitchen Theory team (the experimental condition) or else to take part in a creative origami class (the control condition) instead. The results demonstrate that Year 2 children (aged 6–7 years) were significantly more willing to choose unfamiliar vegetable-based food and drink offerings after having taken part in the sensory exploration and cooking class than after taking part in the control origami class. These results therefore highlight the potential relevance of sensory exploration and a brief chef-based cooking lesson on young children's willingness to choose and eat plant-based food.
Article
We propose and find that the extremeness aversion bias when choosing portion-sizes is stronger for healthy food as compared to unhealthy food items. In two studies (and a follow-up) we find that adding an extra-large option to a standard menu of small, medium, and large portions increases the choice share of the larger portion-sizes; but more so for healthy food than for unhealthy food. Furthermore, we find evidence for the lay belief that larger portions of healthy food do not have incremental health costs. When health costs of the larger portions of healthy food were made salient by providing calorie information, the above effects disappeared. These findings show (1) a boundary condition to the extremeness aversion effect when choosing portion sizes, and (2) imply that this bias can act as a nudge to increase the consumption of healthy food.
Article
Vegetable consumption falls well below recommended levels for children in the UK. Previous research has found that repeated non-taste sensory exposure over the course of several days increases young children's willingness to touch and taste vegetables. The current study examined the impact of a one-off multisensory non-taste exposure intervention that took place on a single day on children's willingness to taste and intake of the exposed vegetables. Children (N = 110) aged 3- to 4-years-old were assigned to one of three intervention groups or to a control group. Children in all groups participated individually in a single activity session delivered in their nursery. Children in the intervention conditions took part in fun activities that provided either (a) visual exposure, (b) smell and visual exposure, or (c) smell, touch and visual exposure to six raw and prepared vegetables. Children in the control group engaged in a visual exposure activity with non-food items. After the exposure activities, all children were offered the prepared vegetables to eat; their willingness to taste and intake of the vegetables were measured. Results confirmed previous findings of sensory exposure activities increasing children's willingness to taste and intake of vegetables and revealed linear trends in both measures of acceptance with the number of senses engaged; children who took part in smell, touch and visual activities showed the highest level of acceptance. Findings suggest that multisensory exposures are effective in increasing consumption of vegetables in young children and that the effect of sensory exposure to healthy foods may be cumulative, with the more senses engaged prior to offering a food, the better.
Article
Although many previous researchers have examined how visual cues (e.g., colors, typefaces, numbers) influence consumers’ judgments of food products, little is known about whether and how shapes affect food judgments and preferences. This research examined the healthy-angular, unhealthy-circular association in consumers’ memory and its implications for consumer behavior. Using six studies, we demonstrated that consumers tend to associate angular (vs. circular) shapes with healthy (vs. unhealthy) products and such association leads to a fit effect on consumers’ food preferences. Specifically, the awareness of healthy food (vs. unhealthy food) increases consumers’ preferences for the product option with an angular shape (vs. circular shape); Meanwhile, the awareness of angular shapes (vs. circular shapes) increases preferences for the healthier food option. We also identified the sense of feeling right as the mechanism underlying the fit effect. The findings suggest innovative visual marketing strategies for retailers, manufactures, and policymakers.
Article
If a food product is not perceived positively in its appearance, it is unlikely eaten. However, there are several subtle spatial cues able to bias attitudes towards food, such as the position where it is displayed. To date, no-one has investigated how the placement of high-calorie food (HcFd) or low-calorie food (LcFd) on a screen, influences them evaluations. Thus, we asked 57 participants to rate food images that appeared on the center, on the top, on the bottom, on the left or on the right side of the screen. For each item participants evaluated on a 100 mm VAS the liking, the desire to eat and buy, and the willingness to pay. We found that HcFd liking and desire to eat were higher when images were shown on the bottom side and lower when shown on the left side of the screen; LcFd liking scores were lower when shown on the bottom side and higher when shown on the left side of the screen. Such results were consistent with the literature reporting a peculiar perceptual/preference bias determined by the placement of high- and low-calorie products. Both policy makers and sellers can use such knowledge respectively to prevent unhealthy food intake or to improve the effectiveness of the advertisements.
Article
As expressed by the “Healthy is Up” metaphor, conceptual metaphor theory argues that the representation of health is commonly associated with high verticality because, typically, people stay upright when they are healthy whereas illness may force them to lie down. Along this line of argument, this research is the first to empirically explore the metaphorical representation of healthy food in terms of verticality. Across five experiments (N = 714), this article first demonstrates that people are faster to pair healthy food with up than down in an implicit association test (Study 1, supporting a metaphorical congruency effect). Then, it shows that people associate healthy food with high verticality and unhealthy food with low verticality by placing healthy food up high and unhealthy food low down along the vertical axis, and by preferring a food pyramid that depicts healthy food at the top rather than at the bottom (Studies 2a, 2b and 3, supporting an abstract-to-concrete effect). Last, this research finds that people judge a food product as healthier when it is pictured from an upward-looking angle than when it is pictured from a downward-looking angle (Study 4, supporting a concrete-to-abstract effect). Further analyses test the interaction between individual differences in self-control and the effects of the “Healthy is Up” metaphor in Studies 2a, 2b, 3 and 4. The article concludes with a discussion of the theoretical and practical implications of this research.