ArticlePublisher preview available

Earthquake Genesis and Earthquake Early Warning Systems: Challenges and a Way Forward

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Several natural hazards, including earthquakes, may trigger disasters and the presence of disaster drivers further lead to the massive loss of life and property, every year around the world. The earthquakes are unavoidable, as exact earthquake prediction in terms of date, and time is difficult. However, with the advancement in technology, earthquake early warning (EEW) has emerged as a life-saving guard in many earthquake-prone countries. Unlike other warning systems (where hours of warning are possible), only a few seconds of warning is possible in the EEW system, but this warning may be very helpful in saving human lives by taking the proper action. The concept of EEW relies on using the initial few seconds of information from nearby instruments, performing basic calculations, and issuing the warning to the farther areas. A dense network or enough network coverage is the backbone of an EEW system. Because of insufficient station coverage, the estimated earthquake location is error-prone, which in turn may cause problems for EEW in terms of estimating strong shaking for the affected areas. Seismic instrumentation for EEW has improved significantly in the last few years considering the station coverage, data quality, and related applications. Many countries including the USA, Mexico, Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea have developed EEW systems and are issuing a warning to the public and authorities. Several other countries, namely China, Turkey, Italy, and India are in process of developing and testing the EEW system. This article discusses the challenges and future EEW systems developed around the world along with different parameters used for EEW. Article Highlights This article aims to provide a comprehensive review related to the development The explicit emphasis is on the scientific development of EEW parameters The challenges and future scopes for the effective implementation of EEWS are discussed in terms of the correct location, the magnitude estimation, the region-specific use of ground motion prediction equations, communication technologies, and general public awareness
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
Surveys in Geophysics (2022) 43:1143–1168
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10712-022-09710-7
1 3
Keywords Earthquake early warning· Regional warning· On-site warning· Earthquakes·
Earthquake early warning parameters
REVIEW PAPER
Earthquake Genesis andEarthquake Early Warning Systems:
Challenges andaWay Forward
RoshanKumar1· HimanshuMittal2 · Sandeep3· BabitaSharma2
Received: 15 November 2021 / Accepted: 12 April 2022 / Published online: 16 May 2022
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature B.V. 2022
Abstract
Several natural hazards, including earthquakes, may trigger disasters and the presence of
disaster drivers further lead to the massive loss of life and property, every year around
the world. The earthquakes are unavoidable, as exact earthquake prediction in terms of
date, and time is difficult. However, with the advancement in technology, earthquake early
warning (EEW) has emerged as a life-saving guard in many earthquake-prone countries.
Unlike other warning systems (where hours of warning are possible), only a few seconds
of warning is possible in the EEW system, but this warning may be very helpful in saving
human lives by taking the proper action. The concept of EEW relies on using the initial
few seconds of information from nearby instruments, performing basic calculations, and
issuing the warning to the farther areas. A dense network or enough network coverage is
the backbone of an EEW system. Because of insufficient station coverage, the estimated
earthquake location is error-prone, which in turn may cause problems for EEW in terms
of estimating strong shaking for the affected areas. Seismic instrumentation for EEW has
improved significantly in the last few years considering the station coverage, data quality,
and related applications. Many countries including the USA, Mexico, Japan, Taiwan, and
South Korea have developed EEW systems and are issuing a warning to the public and
authorities. Several other countries, namely China, Turkey, Italy, and India are in process
of developing and testing the EEW system. This article discusses the challenges and future
EEW systems developed around the world along with different parameters used for EEW.
* Himanshu Mittal
himanshumitt10@gmail.com
Extended author information available on the last page of the article
Article Highlights
This article aims to provide a comprehensive review related to the development
The explicit emphasis is on the scientific development of EEW parameters
The challenges and future scopes for the effective implementation of EEWS are dis-
cussed in terms of the correct location, the magnitude estimation, the region-specific
use of ground motion prediction equations, communication technologies, and general
public awareness
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... These systems are engineered to swiftly alert the populace upon the initial detection of seismic P-waves, preceding the emergence of more intense tremors. They are instrumental in diminishing the risks associated with earthquakes [1][2][3]. EEW systems demand both technical robustness and a thorough grasp of operational and management facets, thereby necessitating context-specific approaches tailored to the unique needs of different countries [3][4][5][6]. The customization of EEW systems takes into account the unique seismic characteristics and technological capacities of each region. ...
... They are instrumental in diminishing the risks associated with earthquakes [1][2][3]. EEW systems demand both technical robustness and a thorough grasp of operational and management facets, thereby necessitating context-specific approaches tailored to the unique needs of different countries [3][4][5][6]. The customization of EEW systems takes into account the unique seismic characteristics and technological capacities of each region. ...
Article
Full-text available
The recent advancements in Internet of Things (IoT) technology have played a pivotal role in the development and implementation of an integrated disaster management system aimed at enhancing public safety and refining disaster mitigation strategies through a technologically sophisticated framework. This study explores the application of earthquake early warning systems in conjunction with ShakeMap data, utilizing these tools to swiftly identify regions at the highest risk of seismic damage and thereby optimize emergency response efforts in the most critical areas. The research involves designing and conducting a pilot test to validate the efficacy of an IoT-based service platform, ensuring its alignment with international standards. The pilot test not only encompassed earthquake scenarios and response models but also evaluated the platform’s capability to tailor response functions based on regional intensity measures. The outcomes of this study demonstrate the categorization of response types into "automatic opening/closing," "response guidance," and "automation system linkage," highlighting the potential of IoT devices to react rapidly and effectively in seismic events. This underscores the significant role that IoT technology can play in enhancing public safety measures in the face of seismic disaster.
... With the continuous development of earthquake early warning technology, the earthquake early warning system has gradually evolved from Tao et al. Geoenvironmental Disasters (2024) 11:9 simple seismic instruments in the early days to highly automated, intelligent, and networked (Ide 2019;Allen 2017;Kumar et al. 2022). The physical quantities monitored have also evolved from surface displacements and seismic waves to parameters such as acceleration and geomagnetic fields (Cremen et al. 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Earthquakes and landslides pose significant threats to human safety and property, necessitating early warning systems. However, the high construction costs of earthquake early warning systems present a challenge. Purpose Landslide warnings are more prevalent, so linking them to earthquake warnings could address cost concerns. Hence, it is crucial to validate the feasibility of utilizing GNSS landslide monitoring as assistance for earthquake early warning systems. Methods This paper analyzes acceleration anomaly data from 31 GNSS landslide monitoring points near the epicenter of the May 2, 2023, MW = 5.2 Baoshan earthquake in Yunnan. The response time was determined as the time difference between an earthquake's occurrence and GNSS's acceleration anomalies. This calculation helps measure the time delay and sensitivity between these two events. Data were obtained from the geological disaster monitoring and early warning management system. Results GNSS landslide monitoring showed high sensitivity to nearby earthquakes. The fastest response time among the 31 data points was 8 seconds, while the slowest was 56 seconds, all falling within the one-minute mark. A linear correlation was found between acceleration anomaly response time and distance from the epicenter, indicating the feasibility of GNSS landslide monitoring-assisted earthquake monitoring. Conclusion A proposal is made for a GNSS landslide monitoring cluster to establish a multi-dimensional landslideearthquake disaster warning system. This approach offers new methods for combining earthquake and landslide early warning systems, leveraging existing infrastructure for cost-effectiveness and enhancing disaster preparedness.
Chapter
The emergence of internet of things (IoT) based smart sensors has brought a revolution in disaster management to create early warning systems and to quickly respond to natural disasters. This chapter explores the vital function that these sensors serve, emphasizing how they might improve preparedness and lessen the destructive effects of disasters. It provides vital information that helps communities and authorities to anticipate any flooding events using smart sensors, flood sensors, atmospheric sensors. It emphasizes the necessity of developments in IoT-based smart sensors through case studies and real-world examples. Through an examination of the application of advanced technologies like artificial intelligence and machine learning, the chapter highlights how these sensors can sense on changing environmental conditions, improving the precision of early warning systems and response plans. The chapter ends with a discussion of the applications of internet of things-based smart sensors that can successfully address the difficulties brought on by natural catastrophes.
Article
Full-text available
The Garhwal region, situated in the central segment of the Himalayas, stands as one of the most seismically active areas in the Uttarakhand Himalaya. The newly established earthquake early warning (EEW) system in the Garhwal region emphasizes the critical need for magnitude scaling relations to enable real-time estimation of earthquake size. This study employs P-wave onset data from both observed and simulated records to develop magnitude scaling relations specific to the Garhwal region. Initially, we modified the semi-empirical technique (SET) for P-wave simulation and validated this modification using the 1991 Uttarkashi (Mw6.8) and 1999 Chamoli (Mw6.4) earthquakes in the Garhwal region. The modified semi-empirical technique (MSET) demonstrates its reliability, as evidenced by the comparatively low root mean square error (RMSE) between observed and simulated records for both earthquakes. Subsequently, we apply MSET to simulate seven additional future earthquakes (Mw7.0–8.5) at the hypocentral locations of the 1991 Uttarkashi and 1999 Chamoli earthquakes. Moreover, conventional EEW parameters, such as average period (τc) and peak amplitude displacement (Pd), are extracted from 107 observed and 63 simulated P-wave onsets, utilizing a 3 s time window. Using this combined dataset of observed and simulated data, we introduce magnitude scaling relations based on the τc and Pd parameters. Subsequently, the developed scaling relations are tested to predict earthquake magnitude using the average values of estimated EEW parameters. The relatively small errors, measuring at 4.47–0.75%, and 2.45–0.60% for τc–Mw and 5.71–1.60% and 4.90–1.57% for Pd–Mw scaling relations, respectively for the Uttarkashi and Chamoli earthquakes suggest the applicability of these proposed relations. However, the scaling relations developed tend to underestimate the magnitude of earthquakes larger than 7.5, potentially attributed to the saturation observed in these relations for big earthquakes. Additionally, the calculated lead time for future earthquakes will range from 4 to 60 s for the sites situated within epicentral distances of 56–200 km. This lead time has the potential to play a substantial role in disaster mitigation in the Garhwal region, especially in the Indo-Gangetic plains and Himalayan foothills. Hence, the development of scaling relations specific to the region is imperative for effective disaster mitigation and risk reduction in the Garhwal region.
Chapter
Earthquakes have long pose a vast danger to human existence and infrastructure. Over time, sizeable studies have been performed in the field of earthquake prediction, mainly on the improvement of an early warning machine. This essay aims to discover the background of earthquake prediction, the want for an early warning system, and the advancements made in this vicinity to mitigate the impact of seismic occasions. This chapter offers the development of a complicated and reliable early warning machine that utilizes a combination of seismic information analysis and device learning techniques. The goals of an early warning system for predicting earthquakes are to offer timely statistics to permit suitable actions, reduce the lack of existence and assets, and foster resilience in affected groups. The advancements in era and studies have provided us with the gear and expertise essential to construct a robust and reliable system that can save limitless lives and limit harm to infrastructure.
Article
An efficient, robust, reliable Earthquake Early Warning (EEW) can play a vital role in hazard mitigation by reducing false and missed alarms. This study represents a comparative analysis of state-of-the-art real-time event detection techniques for the EEW. In real-time event detection, a trade-off between detection reliability and delay in detection exists dominantly. This trade-off is the motivation behind the implementation and performance optimization of event detection techniques, namely Short-time-average over Long-time-average (STA/LTA), Multi-window Algorithm (MWA), and Modified Energy Ratio (MER) for EEW applicability. Earthquake data from the Kyoshin Network (K-NET), Japan along with noise events recorded by the Seismic Sensing Nodes (SSN) at the NCR, India is used for analysis and validation of detection techniques for the EEW system. The critical parameters such as signal window duration and threshold for event declaration are optimized for the detection techniques. An introspection of their performance measures in terms of delay in detection and detection accuracy for optimized parameters is presented. The median delay in detection is best for STA/LTA (0.53[Formula: see text]s) followed by MER (0.55[Formula: see text]s) and MWA (3.23[Formula: see text]s). The comparative analysis shows that MER provides the best results among the candidate techniques with a normalized balanced accuracy of 0.98 followed by STA/LTA (0.97) and MWA (0.82).
Article
Earthquakes have become a popular research area because they have recently caused numerous problems in many countries. Also, they significantly impact preschool children. Children in the preschool age group, which is a critical period, are at risk from earthquakes, as they are a vulnerable group. Specifically, investigating the effects of the earthquake on preschool children is crucial in solving the problems they experience and putting forward policy recommendations, but there is no review study specific to this age group in the literature. Therefore, this study aims to examine the effects of the earthquake on preschool children. The effects of the earthquake, which takes place in a wide range, on preschool children are gathered, especially in the fields of social, psychological, health, and education. Challenges experienced by parents, difficulties in meeting basic needs, complex psychological problems, and changes such as migration are some of the critical issues preschool children experience after earthquakes.
Chapter
Undoubtedly one of the most destructive natural catastrophes is an earthquake. Around the world, they frequently result in significant losses in terms of people, structures, economies, and societies. It is still impossible to accurately anticipate the location and timing of catastrophic occurrences, despite the fact that analytical and measuring techniques have advanced steadily over the previous few decades. The chapter provides an overview of applications of machine learning (ML) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) in seismology so that above mentioned problems in this field can be resolved. The ML Model helps to identify unseen signals and patterns to extract features that might improve our physical understanding of earthquakes. The modeling capabilities of the ML-based methods have resulted in their extensive applications in science and engineering. Herein, the role of ML as an effective approach for solving some problems in geosciences will be highlighted. ML algorithms in seismology address various problems like earthquake detection, phase picking, EEW, ground-motion prediction, seismic tomography, and earthquake geodesy. AI-based algorithms are used for earthquake analysis and prediction, deciphering complex stress development patterns, and developing fully automatic seismic event detection using SVM. ML techniques, such as ANN and GA, estimate earthquake source parameters, while classification algorithms like Artificial Neural Network (ANN) and Support Vector Machine (SVM) have been used to study to identify shallow focus (depth < 70 km) tsunami genic earthquakes at a regional distance. Also, a lot of ML and AI models can be used in seismology to resolve various key problems of seismology from detection to prediction tasks.KeywordsMachine learningArtificial intelligenceSeismologyEarly warningClassification
Chapter
The Earthquake Early Warning System Laboratory, Centre of Excellence in Disaster Mitigation & Management, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee has developed India's first Earthquake Early Warning System (EEWS). For this, Uttarakhand, a Himalayan state of the Republic of India, was selected for setting up the regional EEWS. Seismic sensors have been installed in the central seismic gap region, an area where strong and higher magnitude earthquakes are predicted and likely to occur in the future. A total of 169 sensors have been installed in this seismically active region. The control room has been set up in the Earthquake Early Warning System Laboratory. The data is streamed to the laboratory through dedicated VPNoBB network of BSNL and SWAN. The server does the processing of the data in real time. Warning of the earthquakes that occurred in the instrumented region is issued through two modes. Under first mode, sirens have been installed in the Government-owned buildings of Dehradun, Haldwani, and District Emergency Operation Center in all 13 districts of Uttarakhand. In the second mode, earthquake warning are issued through the mobile app ‘Uttarakhand Bhookamp Alert’, which has now been renamed now as ‘Bhukamp Disaster Early Vigilante (BhuDEV)’. This app was launched to the public on 4th August, 2021 by the honorable Chief Minister of Uttarakhand. In this article, site classification for the instrumented field sites is performed. It is vital for analyzing the seismic hazard of an area and understanding the damage patterns caused by earthquakes. In the present study, 169 sites of the seismic network array of EEWS for Uttarakhand are classified on the basis of geological settlement at the locations of the stations.KeywordsEarthquake early warning systemSite classificationGeological conditionsUttarakhandSeismic gap
Article
Full-text available
Seismic instrumentation for earthquake early warnings (EEWs) has improved significantly in the last few years, considering the station coverage, data quality, and the related applications. The official EEW system in Taiwan is operated by the Central Weather Bureau (CWB) and is responsible for issuing the regional warning for moderate-to-large earthquakes occurring in and around Taiwan. The low-cost micro-electro-mechanical system (MEMS)-based P-Alert EEW system is operational in Taiwan for on-site warnings and for producing shakemaps. Since 2010, this P-Alert system, installed by the National Taiwan University (NTU), has shown its importance during various earthquakes that caused damage in Taiwan. Although the system is capable of acting as a regional as well as an on-site warning system, it is particularly useful for on-site warning. Using real-time seismic signals, each P-Alert system can provide a 2-8 s-long warning time for the locations situated in the blind zone of the CWB regional warning system. The shakemaps plotted using this instrumentation help to assess the damage pattern and rupture directivity, a key feature in the risk mitigation process. These shakemaps are delivered to the intended users, including the disaster mitigation authorities, for possible relief purposes. Earlier, the network provided only peak ground acceleration (PGA) shakemaps, but has now been updated to include peak ground velocity (PGV), spectral acceleration (S a) at different periods, and CWB intensity maps. The PGA and PGV shakemaps plotted using this network have proven helpful in establishing the fact that PGV is a better indicator of damage detection than PGA. This instrumentation is also useful in structural health-monitoring and estimating co-seismic deformations. Encouraged by the performance of the P-Alert network, more instruments are installed in Asia-Pacific countries.
Article
Full-text available
Many nations face challenges in assessing, understanding, and responding to the time-dependent nature of disaster risk. Changes in the intensity of occurrences of extreme events coupled with changes in vulnerability and exposure alter the impacts of natural hazards on society in mostly negative ways. Here an interrelationship between natural hazard (NH), climate change (CC), vulnerability (V), exposure (E), and decisionmaking (DM) is considered. While NHs trigger disasters and CC is likely to intensify occurrences of disasters, V and E present major drivers of disasters. Informed DM on disaster risk reduction should be based on scientific evidence from NH and CC, knowledge of V and E, and relevant options for actions on preventive disaster measures as a part of preparedness and public awareness.
Article
Full-text available
The earthquake early warning systems (EEWSs) in China have achieved great progress, with warning alerts being successfully delivered to the public in some regions. We examined the performance of the EEWS in China's Sichuan Province during the 2019 Changning earthquake. Although its technical effectiveness was tested with the first alert released 10 s after the earthquake, we found that a big gap existed between the EEWS's message and the public's response. We highlight the importance of EEWS alert effectiveness and public participation for long-term resiliency, such as delivering useful alert messages through appropriate communication channels and training people to understand and properly respond.
Article
Full-text available
Using low-cost sensors to build a seismic network for earthquake early warning (EEW) and to generate shakemaps is a cost-effective way in the field of seismology. National Taiwan University (NTU) network employing 748 P-Alert sensors based on micro-electro-mechanical systems (MEMS) technology is operational for almost the last 10 years. This instrumentation is capable of recording the strong ground motions of up to ± 2g and is dense enough to record the near-field ground motion. It has proven effective in generating EEW warnings and delivering real-time shake-maps to the concerned disaster relief agencies to mitigate the earthquake-affected regions. Before 2020, this instrumentation was used to plot peak ground acceleration (PGA) shakemaps only; however , recently it has been upgraded to generate the peak ground velocity (PGV), Central Weather Bureau (CWB) Intensity scale, and spectral acceleration (Sa) shakemaps at different periods as value-added products. After upgradation, the performance of the network was observed using the latest recorded earthquakes in the country. The experimental results in the present work demonstrate that the new parameters shakemaps added in the current work provide promising outputs, and are comparable with the shakemaps given by the official agency CWB. These shakemaps are helpful to delineate the earthquake-hit regions which in turn is required to assist the needy well in time to mitigate the seismic risk.
Article
Full-text available
The November 23rd, 1980 Irpinia-Basilicata (Southern Italy) earthquake is one of the strongest earthquakes ever occurred in Italy. The earthquake was a natural laboratory for the scientific community, which was engaged highly and promptly in investigating the event, thus publishing a flood of papers in different research areas over time. Just these research outputs are the focus of the article, which examines, with a tailored methodological approach, the international and national (Italian) studies started and advanced since the occurrence of the earthquake. First, we built and analyzed statistically two bibliographic databanks regarding the earthquake studies: (a) the international version of IRpinia Bibliographic databASE (IR_BASE_ENG), selecting and standardizing the pertinent scientific documents extracted from Scopus, Web of Science, and other databases and (b) the national version of the database (IR_BASE_IT) using the Google Scholar search engine to search for the most relevant papers in Italian. Second, IR_BASE_ENG was analyzed in a bibliometric perspective through the data mining VOSviewer software (Waltman et al., 2010) that builds co-occurrence term maps useful in perspective of investigating the wide-ranging studies on the earthquake. Third, taking a cue from this network analysis, we recognized the main research topics and performed a minireview of the related international studies, integrating in it a quick reference to the literature in Italian. Finally, we associated the scientific outputs to each cluster/topic, also performing the frequency analysis of the published documents for each subject, thus gaining information on the temporal trends of studies and getting a more exhaustive evidence of the scientific landscape on the earthquake over the last 40 years.
Article
Full-text available
The Sichuan–Yunnan region is one of the most seismically vulnerable areas in China. Accordingly, an earthquake early warning (EEW) system for the region is essential to reduce future earthquake hazards. This research analyses the utility of two early warning parameters (τc and Pd) for magnitude estimation using 273 events that occurred in the Sichuan–Yunnan region during 2007–2015. We find that τc can more reliably predict high-magnitude events during a short P-wave time window (PTW) but produces greater uncertainty in the low-magnitude range, whereas Pd is highly correlated with the event magnitude depending on the selection of an appropriate PTW. Here, we propose a threshold-based evolutionary magnitude estimation method based on a specific combination of τc and Pd that both offers more robust advance magnitude estimates for large earthquakes and ensures the estimation accuracy for low-magnitude events. The advantages of the proposed approach are validated using data from 2016–2017 and the Ms 8.0 Wenchuan earthquake in an offline simulation. The proposed concept provides a useful basis for the future implementation of an EEW system in the Sichuan–Yunnan region.
Article
The earthquake early warning (EEW) system in Taiwan is the outcome of rigorous research work carried out at various levels after the occurrence of the 1986 Hualien earthquake that caused destruction. After more than 25 years of development, three different EEW systems exist in Taiwan. Currently, the nationwide regional EEW system is operated by the Central Weather Bureau (CWB), whereas, a hybrid (regional & onsite) system based on Micro-Electro-Mechanical System sensors is run by National Taiwan University (NTU). The third EEW (onsite system) is run by the National Center for Research on Earthquake Engineering (NCREE). Both CWB and NTU systems are capable of reporting the EEW warnings within 20 s of earthquake occurrence. The CWB system is in charge of providing earthquake alerts in Taiwan via text message through mobile phone, TV, and directly broadcasting system to schools and is providing earthquake alarms to the general public since 2016. During recently damaging earthquakes in Taiwan, the NTU system provided 2-8 s onsite warning (lead time) in the blind zone around the epicenter. The NTU system also can generate near real-time shakemaps for rapid response purposes. The NCREE system consists of about 98 stations and can provide several seconds lead time in the area near the epicenter. The NCREE system also can receive CWB regional EEW messages for warning the regions away from the epicenter. Individually every system has its advantage, however, the hybrid approach will be one of the future systems for real operation.
Article
Two earthquakes having almost the same magnitude occurred in the Hualien area of Taiwan in 2018 and 2019. The 2018 earthquake had a magnitude ML 6.2 produced severe destruction; however, the 2019 earthquake (ML=6.3) did not cause any severe damage. The P-Alert Strong Motion Network provides real-time shakemaps, in addition, to earthquake early warning (EEW) in terms of lead-time. Each instrument provides a different lead-time using peak ground acceleration (PGA) and peak ground velocity (PGV). During both the events, the instruments reported a lead-time of 1.5 to 8.0 s in the epicentral region. This network system also generated high-quality shakemaps during both earthquakes. The shakemaps showed that the higher PGAs are concentrated in the epicentral region for the 2018 and 2019 earthquakes. The lower PGA contour (≥ 25 gals) extended to a broader area, including Taipei, during the 2019 earthquake compared to the 2018 earthquake. However, PGV shakemaps display a different pattern. The higher PGV values (more than 17 cm/s) are observed in the epicentral region during the 2018 earthquake (locations suffering building collapse) compared to the 2019 earthquake, suggesting that PGV correlates better with damage distribution as compared to the PGA. The PGV shakemap, currently only available for the P-Alert network, provides crucial information that complements the PGA issued by the official agency in Taiwan.