ArticlePublisher preview available

"A Home of My Own": The Experience of Children of International Migrants

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

There is a lack of research on children’s acculturation processes following international migration. As such, this article presents a study conducted among 10 latency-age children (10–11 years old), living in Israel, whose parents were work migrants/refugees/asylum seekers, via their artwork and through the lens of Bronfenbrenner’s ecological model. The findings revealed that the migrant children expressed their acculturation and sense of belonging to the host country through three main themes: (1) a longing to have a room of their own; (2) a wish to separate and individuate, as is typical of pre-adolescents and adolescents universally; and (3) the need to rely on their youth movement as an alternative to the family and as a bridge to Israeli society. An examination of the weaknesses of the children’s microsystems and mesosystems highlights the need for continued efforts to strengthen their connection with the macrosystem, which provides them with a sense of home. Findings suggest that art is a useful mode of expression that can help migrant children explore their past, present, and future lives. They also highlight the importance of changing existing exclusionist policies in order to improve migrant children's sense of belonging and security.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
1 3
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10615-021-00811-1
ORIGINAL PAPER
"A Home ofMy Own": The Experience ofChildren ofInternational
Migrants
NoaWiner1· OritNuttman‑Shwartz2 · EphratHuss1
Accepted: 6 June 2021
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2021
Abstract
There is a lack of research on childrens acculturation processes following international migration. As such, this article
presents a study conducted among 10 latency-age children (10–11years old), living in Israel, whose parents were work
migrants/refugees/asylum seekers, via their artwork and through the lens of Bronfenbrenner’s ecological model. The findings
revealed that the migrant children expressed their acculturation and sense of belonging to the host country through three main
themes: (1) a longing to have a room of their own; (2) a wish to separate and individuate, as is typical of pre-adolescents and
adolescents universally; and (3) the need to rely on their youth movement as an alternative to the family and as a bridge to
Israeli society. An examination of the weaknesses of the children’s microsystems and mesosystems highlights the need for
continued efforts to strengthen their connection with the macrosystem, which provides them with a sense of home. Findings
suggest that art is a useful mode of expression that can help migrant children explore their past, present, and future lives.
They also highlight the importance of changing existing exclusionist policies in order to improve migrant childrens sense
of belonging and security.
Keywords Acculturation· Art therapy· International migration· Latency-age children
Introduction
Today, approximately 31 million children live outside of
their country of origin. Of these children, 10 million are
refugees, including approximately one million children liv-
ing without supervision, and orphans who have been defined
as asylum seekers (Donato, 2018). Findings indicate that
the challenges for children of migrants include having to
deal with new learning environments as well as with pres-
sure from parents to succeed in school. They also have to
internalize new rules that require them to change their pre-
viously held social and cultural perspectives. Moreover, as
children generally adjust to their new cultures more rapidly
than do their parents, and because parents often miss and
long for their country of origin (Spiegler etal., 2019), the
parent–child relationship is marked by a new complexity.
This complexity creates a variety of problems including par-
ent–child conflicts, parent–child communication problems,
and problems in the children’s adjustment both to the new
culture and to the host country (Kim & Park, 2011). Addi-
tionally, many parents become dependent on their children,
a phenomenon that poses a threat to the parental role, and
changes the traditional, accepted, and long-held division of
roles (Edison & Curtis, 2007).
Within this context of being so deeply and traumatically
uprooted from their homes, how do children of international
migrants gain an attachment to their host homes, communi-
ties, and places? In an attempt to conceptualize the com-
plexity of coping with migration, Berry (1997) developed
the acculturation theory. This theory characterizes migra-
tion processes as resulting from migrants’ encounters with
new cultures that challenge their value systems, identities,
and behaviors, as well as their culture and lifestyle (Berry
etal., 2006). According to Berry, cultural and psychological
changes—such as changes in language and eating habits,
and changes in social and cultural activities—naturally take
place in the process of migration. At the same time, changes
are also taking place in the individual’s sense of belong-
ing and identity. Essentially, the encounter of the old and
* Orit Nuttman-Shwartz
orits@sapir.ac.il
1 Spitzer Department ofSocial Work atBen-Gurion
University oftheNegev, BeerSheva, Israel
2 School ofSocial Work, Sapir College, Sderot, Israel
/ Published online: 14 June 2021
Clinical Social Work Journal (2021) 49:325–335
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Twenty studies (McBrien, 2011;Jessup-Anger and Aragones, 2013;Elliot et al., 2016a,b;Li and Que, 2016;Taylor and Ali, 2017;Vardanyan et al., 2018;Zhang, 2018;Emery et al., 2020;Merchant et al., 2020;Porter and Porter, 2020;Conceição et al., 2021;Winer et al., 2021;Chkaif et al., 2022;Ngo et al., 2022a,b;Tong et al., 2022;Xu and Tran, 2022;Marangell, 2023;Rokita-Jaśkow et al., 2023) are based on the early version, that is, the EST model, although some of them cite Bronfenbrenner's later work and use the term "bioecological." Three sub-categories can be identified: partial adoption, full adoption, and extended adoption of EST. ...
... Vardanyan et al. (2018) employ Bronfenbrenner's EST concepts in their data analysis, emphasizing the micro-and mesosystems, with limited focus on the chronosystem. In contrast, Winer et al. (2021) explore immigrants' children's sense of belonging within the microsystem (their rooms in their homes), mesosystem (a shared living building), and macrosystem (their neighborhood). However, they do not introduce or investigate the exo-and chronosystems. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Russian-born American psychologist Bronfenbrenner's bioecological perspective on human development is an ideal framework for understanding how individuals negotiate the dynamic environment and their own identities in international and intercultural education settings. However, a review of the current literature shows that most studies either adopted the earlier version of the theory (i.e., the ecological systems theory) or inadequately presented the most recent developments of the bioecological model (i.e., the process-person-context-time model). The construct of proximal processes—the primary mechanisms producing human development according to Bronfenbrenner—has seldom been explored in depth, which means the true value of bioecological theory is largely underrepresented in international and intercultural education research. This article first presents a review of studies that adopt Bronfenbrenner's theory and then offers future directions for the scope and design of international and intercultural education research.
... Although they had no civic status, they are eligible to enter the Israeli educational system and do enjoy some social rights. Yet, despite growing up and studying in Israeli schools, absorbing its culture and speaking fluent Hebrew (Eliyahu-Levi and Ganz-Meishar, 2016; Winer et al., 2021;Tannenbaum and Stern, 2022), their children are pushed to the margins of society. They suffer from various forms Frontiers in Psychology 04 frontiersin.org of formal and informal discrimination, are not eligible for civic status and become candidates for deportation (Willen, 2005;Sabar and Gez, 2009). ...
Article
Full-text available
This article explores how non-citizen minorities experience military service, focusing on children of international labor migrants who served in the Israel Defense Forces. During the 1990’s, Israel witnessed an influx of migrant workers, primarily from the Philippines, Latin America and Africa. However, due to Israeli immigration policies, neither they nor their Israeli-born children were eligible for citizenship. Consequently, upon reaching the age of 18, unlike their Israeli peers, these children were not recruited into the army. Furthermore, they lived under constant threat of deportation. Due to advocacy by civil society organizations, in 2006 and 2010 the government granted civic status (permanent residency) to approximately 1,500 children. This made them eligible for military service, a somewhat unique situation globally. Upon completion of their first year of military service, they were eligible for Israeli citizenship and their immediate family members were eligible for permanent residency. Through qualitative and quantitative research, we examine inclusion and belonging amongst children of migrant workers who served in the military. Our findings suggest that military service enabled them to overcome the exclusionary boundaries they experienced as children in three ways. Firstly, they achieved formal belonging by receiving citizenship. Secondly, they achieved informal belonging through the cultural and social capital this service accrued within Israeli society. Finally, for some, military service deepened their knowledge of Judaism and, in certain cases, led to conversion, thus fostering religious belonging. These three aspects facilitated inclusion and a sense of belonging for these formerly marginalized children while also enhancing their legitimacy within Israeli society. This unique case study contributes to ongoing global debates about the experiences of minority groups in the military.
... Migrants engage in practices that foster place attachment, such as sharing of cultural histories, ideologies, using technology to connect with those abroad, consuming media associated with the place, having social relationships, and possessing objects tied to places (Lewis, 2009;Li et al., 2014;Meijering & Lager, 2014;Palladino, 2019). However, place attachments can also be challenged by language barriers and citizenship status (Meijering & Lager, 2014;Palladino, 2019), proximity to family members, and the ability to enact autonomy (Almevall et al., 2022;Mackenzie et al., 2015;Wiles et al., 2009;Winer et al., 2021;Zhan et al., 2017). As such, migrants' attachment to places can be established via inclusionary and exclusionary factors. ...
... Migrant adolescents are more vulnerable to peer exclusion and discrimination, and it is difficult for them to integrate into new groups, which reduces their positive emotions and self-esteem (Hu et al., 2021;Zhou & Zhong, 2022;Zhuang & Wong, 2016). Facing a new school and social environment, migrant adolescents have weaker connections with their school and community, and a lower sense of belonging (Winer et al., 2021). Furthermore, migrant parents are busy making a living, and the quality of the parent-child relationship is low (Guo et al., 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
The rural-to-urban migration of adolescents influences their positive development. Existing research has focused on the various aspects of the positive development of migrant adolescents in isolation while ignoring the natural development patterns of positive development. In the present study, the positive development profiles of migrant adolescents (indexed by character, competence, self-worth, and connection) were identified using a person-centered approach, and direct and interactive associations of resilience and family capital with positive development profiles were examined. This study included 1279 migrant adolescents in junior high schools who were instructed to complete a series of questionnaires. The results revealed three positive development profiles, namely low, moderate, and high positive development. A multinomial logistic regression analysis revealed that female migrant adolescents were more likely than their male counterparts to be assigned to the high positive development profile than to the low positive development profile. Moreover, migrant adolescents with higher resilience and family economic capital were more likely to be assigned to the high positive development profile than to the low and moderate positive development profiles. Migrant adolescents with higher family cultural capital were more likely to be assigned to the moderate positive development profile than to the high positive development profile. The interaction term between resilience and family cultural capital was found to be significant. This study expands prior research by focusing on natural positive development patterns and examining the compensatory interplay of resilience and family capital on positive development profiles.
Article
Full-text available
רקע: עבודה סוציאלית עם מבקשי מקלט מאריתריאה, החיים בישראל למעלה מעשור ללא מעמד וזכויות, הינה תחום חדש בפרקטיקה המקצועית. על רקע היעדר נגישותם של שירותי הרווחה הציבוריים למבקשי המקלט, התפתח התחום בעיקר מחוץ לממסד. מטרת המאמר: לבחון ולתאר את המאפיינים והאתגרים הייחודיים לפרקטיקת העבודה הסוציאלית עם מבקשי מקלט מאריתריאה. שיטת המחקר: מחקר איכותני שנערך בגישת התאוריה המעוגנת בשדה ההבנייתית, וכלל 12 ראיונות עומק חצי-מובנים עם עובדות סוציאליות העובדות בשירותים ייעודיים למבקשי מקלט. ממצאים: פרקטיקת העבודה הסוציאלית עם מבקשי מקלט בישראל עודנה נמצאת בתהליכי התהוות, הכוללים פעולות "חלוציות" של פיתוח וביסוס מענים "יש מאין" על רקע משאבים מועטים. ניתוח הראיונות העלה חמישה מאפיינים ואתגרים מרכזיים בעבודה עם מבקשי המקלט: ארעיות קבועה, טראומה מתמשכת והשלכותיה, העצמת יחסי הכוח, תחום פוליטי במיוחד ובלתי פורמליות. מסקנות והשלכות לפרקטיקה: לצד קווי דמיון בין פרקטיקת העבודה עם מבקשי המקלט ופרקטיקת העבודה עם אוכלוסיות נוספות במצבי הדרה, הממצאים מציגים אתגרים ייחודיים בסיוע למבקשי המקלט. אתגרים אלה נובעים מהממד הפוליטי בתפיסת אוכלוסייה זו וביחס אליה, הכולל מדיניות שמדירה את הפונים מנגישות לזכויות, לצד חוויית טראומה מתמשכת שלהם במהלך החיים בישראל, ולאור יחס חברתי שלילי כלפי מבקשי המקלט והמסייעים להם. בהתבסס על עבודה סוציאלית אנטי- דכאנית מוצעות השלכות להכשרה, להדרכה ולפרקטיקה עם מבקשי המקלט בישראל, תוך הדגשת חשיבות השילוב בין רמות המיקרו והמקרו
Chapter
Full-text available
This chapter deals with Eritrean refugees and social workers’ perceptions about Israel’s policies and their implications for the well-being of refugee families, parents and children. The concept of “permanent temporariness” is used to encapsulate the legal and psycho-social aspects of refugees’ lives in continuing instability, which is caused by their temporary legal status, lack of human rights and access to services, and the ongoing threat of deportation. Based on the narratives of Eritrean refugee service users and social workers who work with them, this chapter focuses on the context of policies in the construction of well-being. The findings suggest that Israel’s policies and the permanent temporariness they enforce hindered families’ mental health and recovery from trauma, children’s processes of identity formation, and enhanced the role shifts between parents and children. Furthermore, restrictive policies and xenophobic discourse had driven families to poverty and increased their exposure to violence and racism. The threat of deportation had put families’ physical and psychological well-being at risk. Refugees’ temporariness also impacted the relationship between social workers and service users: it increased power imbalances, parents’ mistrust, and hindered the creation of partnerships. Still, despite the permanent temporariness and other post migration challenges, refugee families’ resilience is discussed. The chapter concludes with implications for social work practice and a call for policy advocacy for the protection of refugee children and families’ rights.
Article
Full-text available
La compréhension et la gestion de la diversité culturelle grandissante découlant de l’immigration constituent désormais une question d’intérêt public majeure au Canada et dans d’autres pays de réinstallation d’immigrants. Un des aspects discutés est le niveau selon lequel les immigrants s’orientent à l’égard de la nouvelle société et selon leur culture et leur religion respectives. Un autre aspect est le succès qu’atteignent les immigrants dans le pays d’accueil, en particulier en ce qui a trait à leur bien-être psychologique. Une des préoccupations centrales est la relation possible entre la façon dont les immigrants s’orientent à l’égard de leurs groupes culturels et religieux et leur bien-être : y a-t-il une façon de vivre de manière interculturelle associée à de meilleurs résultats? Cet article examine ces questions au moyen de grands échantillons d’immigrants et de leurs descendants au Canada, en utilisant des concepts et des mesures concernant le sentiment d’appartenance, l’identité religieuse, la satisfaction de vivre et la santé mentale. Les résultats révèlent qu’avoir des identités multiples est associé à des niveaux plus élevés de satisfaction de vivre et de santé mentale. Toutefois, ce résultat général varie selon lesquelles des identités sont fortes et selon le groupe religieux. Les résultats laissent croire que, parmi les immigrants, la promotion des identités à la fois canadienne et d’origine et d’une identité religieuse est la meilleure voie pour atteindre de hauts niveaux de bien-être psychologique dans la société multiculturelle du Canada.
Article
Full-text available
To date, more than 11 million Syrians have been forced from their homes due to the civil war in that country. However, little research has been done on adolescent Syrian refugees. This study aimed to fill that gap in the research literature by examining how adolescent Syrian refugees cope with the harsh situation of having fled from their homes. We explored how personal capital factors, sense of coherence (SOC), wishes, and expectations, as well as socio-demographic and situational factors, contribute to a variety of mental health and psychological problems, namely, internalizing and externalizing problems and post-traumatic stress symptoms. Data were gathered from 110 adolescents aged 13–18 of whom 50.9% were boys. Participants filled out self-report questionnaires that asked about demographics, exposure to war, appraisal of danger, receiving aid, SOC, wishes, and expectations. They also completed the Achenbach Youth Form. The results show that girls appraised their situation as more dangerous and reported more internalizing, externalizing, and post-traumatic stress symptoms. By contrast, boys reported more exposure to war experiences and stronger SOC. Younger adolescents reported stronger SOC, while older adolescents reported more psychological problems. The adolescents who had more recently arrived in the refugee camp were in better condition, thereby reporting stronger SOC, higher expectations, and fewer psychological problems. The amount of time spent in the refugee camp, gender, exposure to war situations, and appraisal of danger all contributed to the explained variance in the different psychological problems. However, once the personal resource SOC was entered into the model, it mediated the relationships between all of the socio-demographic and situational variables, on the one hand, and the examined psychological problems, on the other. The results are discussed based on the personal-capital model of salutogenesis and its relations with traumatic stress.
Article
Full-text available
Turkish immigrant-origin youth in Western Europe often develop strong ethnic and weaker national identities. To advance our understanding of this pattern, we investigated the concurrent development and intergenerational transmission of both identities over time in conjunction with maternal homesickness. Our study was based on a sample of 176 Turkish mother-child dyads from Germany, Norway, and the Netherlands. Mothers (Mt1 = 38 years) reported on their identities and homesickness at T1 and children (Mt1 = 12 years) on their identities at T1 and T2. Our results showed that children’s ethnic and national identities became more incompatible over time, mother’s homesickness strengthened children’s ethnic identities, and mother’s ethnic identities in combination with high levels of homesickness weakened children’s national identities. We conclude that early adolescence is a critical time for Turkish immigrant youth’s identity development and that a focus on parental acculturative stressors can advance ethnic socialization and cultural transmission research.
Article
The challenges facing social workers in addressing the migration crisis are myriad and complex. Against this background, the current article presents a case study on the response of Israeli social work to the asylum seekers, which allows us to identify gaps between the social work profession’s global agenda and its implementation. The article examines how recent immigration policies have impacted Israeli social workers’ responses to these challenges. Following a brief description of Israel’s policies for controlling and limiting the entrance of asylum seekers to the country, the article offers insights into social workers’ involvement in some of the main social services that aim to assist asylum seekers in Israel. Insights are also offered into the response of Israeli social workers to the community of asylum seekers, which focuses on individual needs and on urgent needs. Several explanations for these emphases was offers, noting that they may reflect a more general gap between repeated statements about the significance of human rights for the social work profession on the one hand and the professional reality on the other. Finally, several strategies for social work in the community of asylum seekers and in society as a whole are recommended.
Article
Relocation to a new culture has significant impacts on individuals’ “self” and identity. This qualitative study examines the perspectives of Japanese temporary resident and immigrant parents on their children’s acculturation to U.S. local schools and its impact on self. Japanese people, generally, are sensitive to others’ responses to their struggles. Reluctance to seek formal support that can label them as “failures” may increase their vulnerability to acculturative stress. Individual interviews with 14 Japanese parents from 11 families in a southern state described the experiences of 23 children. Parents reported that language barriers and differences in school systems, particularly, have affected their children’s self and identity, including a sense of inferiority and reluctance to participate in activities to protect themselves. Yet participation in non-academic activities such as sports, which do not require extensive English communication skills, helps their children develop friendships with local children and regain a positive understanding of self. Further, the time they spend with other Japanese children can relieve acculturative stress, and motivate them to participate at their local schools. The Japanese case study can broaden our perspectives on the self and acculturation of immigrant and foreign-born children, and provide insights into how we might better support them.
Article
Research continues to superficially address the social and cultural factors that influence young refugees’ resilience. Expressive therapies have been found to promote resilience in at-risk youth, but empirical research is lacking with refugee children and adolescents. In this paper, we provide an integrative review of the literature on young refugees about expressive therapy and resilience presented through an ecological framework. The review suggests that expressive therapies can enhance young refugees’ resilience by mediating factors across various levels of their ecology. The importance of considering environmental and cultural factors during program development is emphasized.
Article
Human trafficking results in tragedy, trauma, and devastation. Sex trafficking has become a universal dilemma demanding awareness, education, and restorative treatment for the survivors of its illegal and wide ranging crimes. Art therapy is an effective, engaging, and non-verbal treatment to provide healing support to sex trafficking survivors, and for the advocates who work with them. Art therapy facilitates emotional catharsis and empowerment, connection to others and strengthens concepts of the inner self to enhance resilience. Art therapy addresses trauma, and provides hope for the future. This article presents the application of art therapy to enhance resilience within a trauma-informed approach and provides recommendations for victim and advocate programming.
Article
This article sets out to explore the use of art therapy with refugee children, from the perspective of art therapists and their experiences. Three semi-structured interviews were conducted to gain insights by capturing experiences and stories. Using thematic analysis, five themes were identified: (1) giving voice; (2) rebuilding trust, opening wounds; (3) sharing stories, healing pain; (4) exploring identity, discovering new-self; and (5) understanding art therapy. Upon reflection, two key aspects of art therapy were established, these were identified as: (1) providing refugee children with a safe space to heal and discover new-self, and (2) giving refugee children a voice to express and share stories. Despite the last of the five themes (understanding art therapy) being established as a factor that limits the use of art therapy, this has created an avenue for further research. From the findings, it was concluded that art therapy can be a useful form of psychotherapy for refugee children. Art therapy can provide these children with a safe space to heal, and give them a voice to be heard. Plain-language summary This research explores the use of art therapy with refugee children from the art therapist’s perspective. Three semi-structured interviews were carried out with art therapists who had experience of working with refugee children. Once interviews were collected, these were then analysed using a method of analysis which enables common themes to be found amongst the unique set of experiences and stories collected. The analysis generated five themes, which were: (1) Giving Voice, (2) Rebuilding Trust, Opening Wounds, (3) Sharing Stories, Healing Pain, (4) Exploring Identity, Discovering New-self, and (5) Understanding Art Therapy. The first four themes suggested that art therapy is a useful form of therapy for refugee children. However, theme 5 (understanding art therapy) could be a limitation for art therapy with this client group, as art therapy is often unknown to them. Taking this research forward, it will be important to explore the use of art therapy with refugee children by carrying out further research with the children themselves. In conclusion, art therapy can be a useful form of therapy for refugee children. Art therapy provides these children with a safe space to heal, and gives them a voice to be heard.
Article
The study reported in this paper focuses on the narratives of six adult Third Culture Kids (TCKs) who lived in multiple countries during developmental years. It explores their childhood experiences with mobility and the impact that multiple shifts in location, culture, and language have had on their adult lives. The results indicate that they come to terms with their identities, which are closely connected to multiple cultures and countries. Participants reported a desire to maintain nomadic lives, which may have been impacted by the multilingual competence and nuanced cultural understanding they gained through mobile upbringings. They also commonly expressed a desire to build social relationships with other individuals with migrant backgrounds. The results demonstrate the necessity of supporting the growing community of TCKs in maximizing the potential benefits of cross-cultural experiences while helping them navigate the challenges of identity, transition, and relocation.