Conference PaperPDF Available

An overview of vertebrate collecting in the Permian System of North-Central Texas

Authors:
Pages 40-46 in Permo-Carboniferous Vertebrate Paleontolo gy,
Lithostratigraphy, and Depositional Environments of North-Central Texas,
edited by R.W. Hook. Field Trip Guidebook No. 2, 49th Annual Meeting of the
Sociery of Vertebrate Paleontology. Austin, Texas, 1989.
AN OVERVIEW OF VERTEBRATE COLLECTING IN THE
PERMIAN SYSTEM OF NORTH-CENTRAL TEXAS
Kenneth W. Craddockl and Robert W. Hook2
t711 Emery Street, Denton, Texas 76201
2Vertebrate Paleontology Laboratory, Balcones Research Center
10100 Burnett Road, Austin, Texas 78756
ABSTRACT --Since the late 1870s, when the fossil vertebrate collections of naturalist Jacob Boll attracted
the attention of E. D. Cope, the collecting of vertebrate fossils in the Permian of North-Central Texas has
contributed greatly to our understanding of Late Paleozoic terrestrial faunas. The pioneering efforts of Boll,
W. F. Cummins, and C. H. Sternberg resulted in the description of distinct Wichita and Clear Fork
assemblages by Cope and Broili. During the early 1900s, E. C. Case and S. W. Williston conducted
extensive field work in these beds and combined revisions of previously collected taxa with descriptions of
new forms. Case reported also on paleoenvironmental settings and sought to integrate the Texas
assemblages with other Permo-Carboniferous faunas in a comprehensive view of Late Paleozoic vertebrate
evolution. In the 1930s and 1940s, the collecting effors of A. S. Romer and of field crews sponsored by
the Work hojecs Administration extended the range of several Wichita-Clear Fork taxa into the older
deposits of the lowermost Permian and uppermost Carboniferous of the Bowie Group. Subsequent work by
E. C. Olson established the taxonomic composition of the upper Clear Fork Group and revealed a
dramatically different vertebrate assemblage in the overlying Pease River Group. Continued field
investigations have resulted in reports on marine to freshwater vertebrate assemblages in the upper Wichita
Group and on the paleoenvironmental conditions responsible for the preservation of vertebrate remains in the
lower Wichita and upper Bowie Groups.
INTRODUCTION
The vertebrate-bearing Lower Permian
beds of North-Central Texas have attracted
fossil collectors for over 100 years. Although
colorful n:uratives recount some of the efforts
of early workers, field activities have gener-
ally not been considered in a broader context
of their notable scientific contributions. In
summarizing the history of vertebrate collect-
ing, the following review traces the growth of
paleontologic knowledge that resulted directly
from field work in this region.
EARLY WORKERS
Jacob Boll was the first collector of
Permian vefiebrates in North-Central Texas.
Born and educated in Switzerland, Boll ar-
rived in Dallas in 1869 and, within a year,
collected a wide variety of extant zoological
specimens for his friend and countryman
Louis Agassiz of the Museum of Comparative
Zoology (MCZ) at Harvard College (Geiser,
1948). During this period, he also collected
vertebrate fossils and forwarded at least one
specimen to Harvard, where it languished for
over 50 years (Romer, L945).
Boll's fossil-collecting talents were recog-
nized in 1877 when E. D. Cope visited
Dallas and acquired a skull of the
then-unknown temnospondyl Eryops that
Boll had collected from eastern Archer
County. Impressed with the new material,
Cope hired Boll to explore for additional
remains during the winter of 1877-1878.
With the assistance of J. C. Isaac, who had
worked for Cope in South Dakota the
previous year, Boll prospected south of the
Wichita River in Wichita County and along the
drainage of the Little Wichita River in Archer
County. Boll continued to collect for Cope
during the next two years but died of
peritonitis while camped in northern Wilbarger
County near the Red River in September,
1880.
Boll's germinal collections were described
by Cope in a series of papers that documented
a diverse veftebrate assemblage (Cope, 1877,
1878, 1880, 1888). These collections, which
40
CRADDOCK AND HOOK --
are held by the American Museum of Natural
History, include the first-known specimens of
many Wichita genera, such as
Ectosteorhachis, Spermatodus, Pantylus,
Eryops, P ariory s, Trimerorhac his, Diadectes,
B o lo s aurus, and D imetro do n.
Soon after Boll's death, Cope employed
W. F. Cummins to continue the search for
Permian vertebrates. Cummins" a Methodist
minister who later became the State Geologist
of Texas, spent much of his 1881 field season
in western Archer County where he obtained
numerous specimens from an area referred to
as Headquarters. These very productive mid-
dle Wichita exposures included localities that
are known today as Rattlesnake Canyon. His
major contribution, however, ctune a year later
when he discovered the richly fossiliferous
deposits of the lower Clear Fork Group in
western Baylor County. From 1882 to 1884,
he collected extensively in the drainage area of
Coffee Creek and of other tributaries of the
Wichita River north of Seymour. These col-
lections, which are also part of the Cope Col-
lection in New York. introduced the distinc-
tive Clear Fork assemblage and include sig-
nificant specimens of G nat hor hiza, I sode cte s,
Acheloma, Captorhinus, and Edaphosaurus
(Cope, 1882, 1883, 1884). Of comparable
importance was a subsequent effort by
Cummins to provide localiry and stratigraphic
data for vertebrate specimens of the Cope
Collection from the Texas Permian deposits
(Cummins, 1908).
In t 882, the IN{CZ engaged
C. H. Sternberg to collect in North-Central
Texas. After failing to obtain directions from
Cummins on where to collect, Sternberg spent
several unsuccessful weeks in nonproductive
Clear Fork exposures (Sternberg, 1909). He
eventually assembled a small but significant
collection that included a suite of Seymouria
specimens and a nearly complete Diadectes
from the lower Clear Fork of the Coffee Creek
area (White, 1939; Romer, 1944). Upon his
return to Baylor County in 1895 for the first
of three consecutive seasons of collecting for
Cope, Sternberg located several highly pro-
ductive sites in the lower Clear Fork. This
material, which was the last to be added to
Cope's Texas collection before his death in
1897, includes the type specimens of
D is s orop hus multicinc tus and Labidosaurus
hamatus (Cope, 1895, 1896a, 1896b, 1896c).
Sternberg continued to exploit the Clear
Fork deposits of Baylor County in 1901 when
VERTEBRATE COLLECTING 41
he was hired to collect for the Alte Akademie
of Munich. The resulting collections, as well
as specimens purchased previously from
Sternberg in 1895, were described by
Ferdinand Broili (1899, l9OZ, 1904a, 1904b,
1903). Of particular note are the types of
Seymouria bay lorensis and V aranos aurus
acutirostris, both of which are represented by
less complete specimens in Sternberg's
previously acquired American Museum
collections. In comparison to Cope's brief
descriptions that often lacked adequate
specimen illustrations, the lavishly illustrated,
comprehensive work of Broili established a
new standard for the study of Permian
vertebrates from Texas.
E. C. CASE AND S. W. WILLISTON:
COLLECTING IN THE 19OOS
With the exception of Broili's brief 1901
visit to Baylor County with the Sternberg field
pilty, E, C" Case was the first field worker
in North-Central Texas to be affrliated with an
academic institution. Case completed a field
season in 1895 before receiving his Ph.D.
from the University of Chicago and returned
in 1901 and 1903 to obtain additional verte-
brates from both the Wichita and Clear Fork
Groups for the Walker Museum. These col-
lections were transfered later to the Field
Museum of Natural History. While collecting
for the American Museum in 1906 and 1908,
Case found important specimens in middle
Wichita exposures in the vicinity of the
Archer-Baylor county line. The results of
these efforts, along with findings based on
study of type specimens from the Cope
Collection and with exhaustive review of
Cope's work, were presented in a series of
papers from 1899 to 1910 and were summa-
rized in three monographs published by the
Carnegie Institution of Washington (Case,
1907b, 1911a, 1911b).
Beyond a prodigious output during his
first decade of work in Texas, Case's most
significant contribution was the discovery in
I9I2 of a remarkably rich deposit that he
named the Brier (or Briar) Creek bonebed
(Case, 1915). This deposit, located in middle
Wichita exposures of western Archer County,
has yielded more than 2000 specimens of
aquatic to terrestrial tetrapods but virtually no
fishes or sharks. Through the next 28 years
of his career at the University of Michigan,
Case and his students returned routinely to
A1 N O RT H -C ENTRAL T EXAS GU I D EB O O K
Texas, and he continued to report on signifi-
cant finds (Case, 1929,1935a, 1935b).
In addition to his description of new
materials, Case addressed the occurrence of
Permian vertebrates in paleoenvironmental and
paleoecological contexts. His field observa-
tions, augmented by published geological in-
formation, formed the basis of a series of pa-
pers that suggests that the global development
of vertebrate faunas during the Permo-Car-
boniferous was controlled by climatically
influenced environmental factors (Case,
1907a,1915). Case was also the fust to trace
convincingly the antiquity of the Texas
Permian vertebrate complex to its roots in
Upper Carboniferous faunas and to compare
the Texas assemblages with other Permian
records in North America, Europe, and Africa
(Case, 1908, 1918, 1926).
The collections that Case provided the
Walker Museum attracted S. W. Williston to
the Texas Permian. From his first trip to the
region in 1908 until his last in 1918, Williston
was joined by Paul Miller, preparator and
vertebrate curator at the Walker Museum.
Besides important discoveries in the upper
Wichita near Mitchell Creek in Baylor County,
Miller found a unique concenration of gener-
ally articulated tetrapods in lower Clear Fork
exposures near Indian Creek during the 1909
season. This small deposit, known as the
Cacops bonebed, yielded nearly all the known
specimens of Cacops, Casea, and Varanops
(Williston, 1910a, 1911). In the same year,
another member of Williston's party discov-
ered a second prolific Clear Fork site, the
Craddock bonebed (Williston, 1910b, 1911).
This channel-fill deposit has produced
hundreds of specimens, including important
materials of Dimetrodon, Secodontosaurus,
and Araeoscelis (Romer, 1927; Romer and
Price, 1940: Vaughn, 1955). Following
Miller's 1910 excavation of the Craddock
bonebed, a l9l7 Sternberg field party blasted
additional overburden and obtained specimens
that were acquired by the U. S. National
Museum (Gilmore, 1919).
LOWER WTCTUTE AND BOWIE
COLLECTIONS: A. S. ROMER
AND THE WPA
In the late 1920s, Paul Miller accompanied
A. S. Romer on the latter's first of many
collecting trips to North-Central Texas. After
four seasons of rather modest returns in
Bavlor and western Archer counties, Romer
distovered an exceptional concentration of
well-preserved tetrapods in the lower Wichita
exposures of central Archer County during the
1932 season. Named the Geraldine bonebed,
this deposit was excavated by several field
parties over a ten-year period and produced
virtually complete specimens of Archeria,
Eryops, and Edaphosaurus (Sander, 1987).
Early in his career, Romer also provided an
invaluable synopsis of locality and taxonomic
data culled from collections and the first-hand
recollections of early collectors (Romer,
1928).
Because Romer recognized a need for the
collection and study of older fossils that
would span the interval between known
Permian and Carboniferous tetrapod assem-
blages, he turned his attention in 1934 to the
lowermost Texas Permian sequence. Starting
from the lowest sections collected by
Cummins and Boll in eastern and southern
Archer County, Romer and L. I. Price
worked into nearby areas of Clay, Jack, and
Young Counties and located some 20 verte-
brate-bearing deposits (Romer, 1935) in what
is regarded now as the upperrnost Bowie
Group (see Hentz, 1988, 1989). Aithough
the oldest beds produced little more than frag-
mentary remains of xenacanth sharks, Eryops,
Archeria, Diadectes, Edaphosaurus,
Ophiacodon, and Dimetrodon, Price was
especially successful in finding skulls of small
protorothyridid and captorhinid reptiles in the
uppermost Bowie beds of Archer County
(Price, 1937; Clark and Carroll, 1973). A
very fossiliferous, roughly coeval deposit that
came to be known as the Archer Ciry bonebed
was discovered two years later by
R. V. Witter, who collected for the MCZ
from 1936 to 1942 and, later, for the
American Museum of Natural History and the
Princeton Museum of Natural History (col-
lection now at the Peabody Museum of
Natural History, Yale University).
Exploration of the Bowie Group continued
during 1940 and 1941 under the auspices of
the Work Projects Administration, or WPA.
Headed in the field by Henrietta resident
A. H. Witte, crews of about a dozen workers
opened quarries at two Clay County sites. In
less than ayear, Witte found new vertebrate
deposits in Clay, Montague, Archer, and Jack
Counties. The WPA collections, which in-
clude specimens of rarely occurring taxa, such
as Panrylw, Seymouria, and Stereophallodon,
CRADDOCK AND HOOK -- VERTEBRATE COLLECTING 43
are part of the Texas Memorial Museum
holdings reposited at the Vertebrate Paleon-
tology Laboratory of the Balcones Research
Center in Austin.
Romer returned to Texas after World
War II and resumed his nearly annual recon-
noitering of previously collected Wichita ex-
posures and, aided by Witte, his exploration
of older deposits to the southeast. Usually
accompanied by R. H. Romer, N" E.
Wright, S. J. Olsen, A. D. Lewis, and
various graduate students from Harvard,
Romer's parties collected hundreds of speci-
mens for the N4CZ- During his last two field
seasons (1972,1973), Romer's crew quarried
the Briar Creek bonebed, which had received
only cursory attention since Case's time.
E. C. OLSON AND TTM, UPPER CLEAR
FORK AND LOWER PEASE RTVER
COLLECTIONS
Aside form Sternberg's unproductive ef-
forts in northwestern Baylor County, no early
collectors are known to have prospected above
the extraordinarily fossiliferous deposits of the
lower Clear Fork in the region of present-day
Lake Kemp. E. C. Olson, a student of
Romer at the University of Chicago in the
1930s, initiated the first systematic search for
vertebrates in the middle to upper Clear Fork
beds of Baylor, Knox, and Wilbarger
Counties. Like Romer's efforts to acquire
materials from the lowermost Permian,
Olson's work during the 1940s in these
uppernost l.ower Permian deposits produced
assemblages of generally fragmentary but
identifiable vertebrate remains that extended
the range of several common tetrapod taxa
(Olson, 1958). R. J. Seltin, who was
introduced to the Texas Permian as an Olson
graduate student in the middle 1950s,
continued to collect in the middle Clear Fork
during the late 1950s and early 1960s for
Michigan S tate University.
In 1949, Olson and his field crew of
Chicago graduate students prospected the
overlying lower Pease River Group of
Hardeman and Foard Counties. The Late
Permian fossils collected during this and
following years revealed a vertebrate
assembiage that contrasted sharply with the
well-known assemblages of the Clear Fork
(Olson, 1962). As the single most important
Pease River locality, the Kahn Quarry in
western Knox County produced remains of
nearly 100 individual tetrapods, the most
common being the huge caseid pelycosaur
C oty lor hy nc hus hanc o c ki.
Olson also collected data on the preserva-
tional circumstances and sedimentary condi-
tions associated with fossil occulrences in the
Clear Fork and Pease River Groups.
Combined with his analysis of vertebrate dis-
tributions, this paleoenvironmental informa-
tion formed the basis of paleoecological inter-
pretations and the chronofauna concept
(Olson, 1952,1976).
RECENT WORK
A fairly comprehensive understanding of
tetrapod assemblages from the Bowie,
Wichita, Clear Fork, and Pease River Groups
had emerged by the early 1960s (Romer,
1958; Olson, 1962)" Conspicuously absent,
however, was a complementary knowledge of
fish remains that occur less frequently in
various deposits of Archer and Baylor Coun-
ties. As if to fill this gap, W. W. Dalquest
and D. S Berman investigated the upperrnost
Wichita exposures of the Lake Kemp area and
acquired significant fish and tetrapod remains
(Berman, L97A; Dalquest and Kocurko, 1986,
1988). More recently, Dalquest and
M. J. Kocurko have amassed large col-
lections dominated by marine acanthodians
from carbonate-rich upper Wichita sequences
in southern Baylor County (Dalquest et al.,
1988). G. D. Johnson and P. A. Murry
have also provided details of aquatic as-
semblages within the region by employing
bulk-sampling techniques (Johnson, 1981,
1987; Murry and Johnson, 1987).
Several recent field studies have addressed
paleoenvironmental factors responsible for
particular fossil deposits in the Wichita and
Bowie Groups (Parrish, 1978; Sander, 1987,
1989). During the past 13 years, Nicholas
Hotton, III, and A. D. Lewis of the U. S.
National Museum have maintained a collecting
program primarily in the middle Wichita and
lower Clear Fork exposures of Archer and
Baylor Counties. In addition to numerous
vertebrate specimens, this work has yielded
paleoenvironmen tally significant invertebrate
fossils and sedimentologic data .
As paleontologists continue to find im-
portant specimens of known taxa or an occa-
sional new genus within drawers of incom-
pletely prepared or overlooked Texas material,
field workers today similarly find outstanding
44
specimens or remains of novel forms at classic
sites (e.g. Langston and Olson, 1986).
Although several bonebeds have been ex-
hausted and some gently sloping, fos-
sil-bearing localities have become gtassed
over, many productive areas have not been
prospected in recent years. Given the success
of past efforts and a tradition of cooperation
from generous land owners, we anticipate fu-
ture discoveries that will augment the existing
wealth of Permian vertebrates from
North-Central Texas.
LITERATURE CITED
Berman, D.S. t970. Vertebrate fossils from
the Lueders Formation, Lower Permian of
North-Central Texas. University of
California Publications in Geological
Sciences 86:1-61.
Broili, F. 1899. Ein Beitra1 zur Kenntniss
von Eryops megacephalus (Cope).
Palaeontographica 46:61 -84.
1902. Ein Beitrag zur Kenntniss von
Diplocaulus, Cope. Centralblatt ftir
Mineralogie, Geologie und Palaeontologie
1902:536-541.
1904a. Permische
N O RT H - C ENT RAL T EXAS GU I D EB O O K
Stegocephalen und
Palaeontographica
Carnegie Institution of Washington
Publication 146:l-17 9.
1915. The Permo-Carboniferous red
beds of North America and their vertebrate
fauna. Carnegie lnstitution of Washington
Publication 207 :l-17 6.
1918. Permo-Carboniferous condi-
tions versus Permo-Carboniferous time.
Journal of Geology 26:500-506.
1926. Environment of tetrapod life in
the Late Paleozoic of regions other than
North America. Carnegie Institution of
Washin gton Publicati on 37 5 :1 -21 l.
1929. Description of a nearly com-
plete skeleton of Ostodolepis brevispinnttu
Williston. Contributions from the
Museum of Paleontology, University of
Michigan 3:81-107.
1935a. Description of a collection of
associated skeletons of Trimerorhachis.
Contributions from the Museum of
Paleontology, University of Michigan
4:227-274.
1935b. A new paleoniscid fish,
Eurylepidoides socialis, from the
Permo-Carboniferou s of Texas.
Contributions from the Museum of
Paleontology, University of Michigan
4:275-277.
Clark, J., and R.L. Carroll. 1973. Romeriid
reptiles of the Permian. Harvard
University, Museum of Comparative
Tnology, Bulletin IM3 53 -407 .
Cope, E.D. 1877. Descriptions of extinct
Vertebrata from the Permian and Triassic
formations of the United States.
Proceedings of the American
Philosophical Society 17 :182-193.
1878. Descriptions of extinct
Batrachia and Reptilia from the Permian
formation of Texas. Proceedings of the
American Philosophical Society
17:505-530.
1880. Second contribution to the his-
tory of the Vertebrata of the Permian for-
mation of Texas. Proceedings of the
American Philosophical Society 19:38-58.
1882. Third contribution to the his-
tory of the Vertebrata of the Permian for-
mation of Texas. Proceedings of the
American Philosophical Society
20:447 -461.
1883. Fourth contribution to the his-
tory of the Permian formation of Texas.
Proceedings of the American
Philosophical Sociery 20:628- 636.
Reptilien aus Texas.
5 1:1- 120.
1904b. Ueber Diacranodus texensis
Cope (= Didymodus? compressus Cope).
Neues Jahrbuch ftr Mineralogie, Geologie
und Palaeontologie 1 9 :467 -484.
1908. Ein montiertes Skelett von
Labidosaurus hamatus Cope, einem
Cotylosaurier aus dem Perm von Texas.
Zeitschrift der deutschen geologischen
Gesellschaft 60 :63 - 67 .
Case, E.C. 1907a. The character of the
Wichita and Clear Fork divisions of the
Permian red beds of Texas. Bulletin of
the American Museum of Natural History
23:659-664.
1907b. Revision of the Pelycosauria
of North America. Carnegie Institution of
Washington Publication 55 : 1 - 176.
1908. On the value of the evidence
furnished by vertebrate fossils of age of
certain so-called Permian beds in America.
Journal of Geology 16:572-580.
1911a. A revision of the Cotylosauria
of North America. Carnegie Institution of
Washington Publicati on L45 :l - L22.
1911b. Revision of the Amphibia and
Pisces of the Permian of North America.
CRADDOCK AND HOOK .- VERTEBRATE COLLECTING
1884. Fifth contribution to the 1989. Permo-Carboniferous litho-
45
knowledge of the fauna of the Permian
formation of Texas and the Indian
Teritory. Proceedings of the American
Philosophical Society 22:28-47 .
1888. On the shoulder-eirdle and ex-
tremities of Eryops. Transactions of the
American Philosophical Society
16:362-367.
1895. A batrachian armadillo.
American Naturalist 29 :998.
1896a. Permian land Vertebrata with
carapaces. American Naturalist
30:936-937.
1896b. The reptilian order
Cotylosauria. Proceedings of the
American Philosophical Society
34:436-457.
1896c. Second contribution to the
history of the Cotylosauria. American
Philosophical Society 35 :122- 139 "
Cummins. W.F. 1908. The localities and
horizons of Permian vertebrate fossils in
Texas. Journal of Geology 16:737 -7 45.
Dalquest, W.W., and M.J. Kocurko. 1986.
Geology and vertebrate paleontology of a
Lower Permian delta margin in Baylor
County, Texas. The Southwestern
Naturalist 3 I :47 7 - 492.
and _ 1988. Notes on Permian
fishes from Lake Kemp, Baylor County,
Texas, with a synopsis of Texas
palaeonisciform fishes. The Southwestern
Naturalist 33 :263 -27 4.
and J.V. Grimes. 1988.
Geology and vertebrate paleontology of a
Lower Permian deposit on the Brazos
River, Baylor County, Texas, with the
description of a new genus and species of
acanthodian fish. Tulane Studies in
Geology and Paleontology 21 :85- 104.
Geiser, S.W. 1948. Naturalists of the
Frontier (2nd edition). Southern
Methodist University, Dallas:296pp.
Gilmore, C.W. 1919. A mounted skeleton of
Dimetrodon gigas in the United States
National Museum, with notes on the
skeletal anatomy. Proceedings of the
U.S. National Museum 56:525-540.
Hentz, T.F. 1988. Lithostratigraphy and pa-
leoenvironments of upper Paleozoic conti-
nental red beds, North-Central Texas:
Bowie (new) and Wichita (revised)
Groups. The University of Texas at
Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology
Report of Investigations 170: 1-55.
stratigraphy of the vertebrate-bearing
Bowie and Wichita Groups, North-Centrai
Texas; pp. I-21 in Permo-Carboniferous
Vertebrate Paleontology, Lithostratigra-
phy, and Depositional Environments of
North-Centrai Texas, R.W. Hook (ed.).
Field Trip Guidebook No. 2, 49th Annual
Meeting of the Society of Vertebrate
Paleontology.
Johnson, G.D. 1981. Hybodontoidei (Chon-
drichthyes) from the Wichita-Albany
Group (Early Permian) of Texas. Journal
of Vertebrate Paleontology 1 : i-4i.
1987. Deformed xenacanthodiid shark
teeth from the Permian of Texas.
Dakoterra 3:22-27.
Langston, W., Jr., and E.C. Olson. 1986.
Carrolla craddocki a new genus and
species of microsaur from the Lower
Permian of Texas. Texas Memorial
Museum, University of Texas at Austin,
Pearce- Sellards Serie s 43 : L -20.
Murry, P.A., and G.D. Johnson. 1987.
Clear Fork vertebrates and environments
from the l,ower Permian of North-Cenu'al
Texas. Texas Journal of Science
39:253-266.
Olson, E.C. 1952. The evolution of a
Permian vertebrate chronofauna.
Evolution 6:181-196.
1958. Fauna of the Vale and Choza:
14. Summary, review, and integration of
the geology and the faunas. Fieldiana,
Geology lO:397-448.
1962. Late Permian terrestrial verte-
brates. U.S.A. and U.S.S.R.
Transactions of the American
Philosophical Society 52:I -224.
1976. The exploitation of land by
early tetrapods; pp. 1-30 in Morphology
and Biology of Reptiles, A. d'A. Bellairs
and C.B. Cox (eds.). Linnean Society
Symposium Series 3.
Parrish, W.C. I978. Paleoenvironmental
analysis of a Lower Permian bone bed and
adjacent sediments, Wichita County,
Texas. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimato-
logy, Palaeoecology 24:209 -237 .
Price, L.I. 1937. Two new cotylosaurs from
the Permian of Texas. Proceedings of the
New England Zoological Club 16:97-102"
Romer, A.S. 1927. Notes on the
Permo-Carboniferous reptile D ime tr o do n.
Journal of Geology 35:673-689.
46 N O RT H - C ENTRAL T EXAS G U
I D EB O O K
1928. Vertebrate faunal horizons in
the Texas Permo-Carboniferous red beds.
University of Texas Bulletin 2801:67-108.
1935. Early history of Texas redbeds
vertebrates. Bulletin of the Geological
Society of America 46:1597-1658.
1944. The Permian cotylosaur
D iade ctes tenuite ctus. American Journal
of Science 242:139-lM.
1945. Texas redbeds collecting.
Society of Vertebrate Paleontology News
Bulletin 16:25-77.
1958. The Texas Permian redbeds
and their vertebrate fauna.; pp. 155-179 in
Studies on Fossil Vertebrates, T.S.
Westoll (ed.). Athlone Press, University
of London, London.
and L.I. Price. 1940. Review of the
Pelycosauria. Geological Society of
America Special Papers 28:1-538.
Sander, P.M. 1987. Taphonomy of the
Lower Permian Geraldine Bonebed in
Archer County, Texas. Palaeogeography,
Paiaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology
61:221-236.
1989. Early Permian depositional en-
vironments and pond bonebeds in central
Archer County, Texas. Palaeogeography,
Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology
69:l-21.
Sternberg, C.H. 1909. The Life of a Fossil
Hunter. Holt, New York, xiii + 286pp.
Vaughn, P.P. 1955. The Permian reptile
Araeoscelis restudied. Harvard Uni-
versity, Museum of Comparative
Tnology, Bulletin tB 343-467 .
White, T.E. 1939. Osteology of Seymouria
baylorensis Broili. Harvard University,
Museum of Comparative Zoology,
Bulletin 85:323-410.
Williston, S.W. 1910a. Cacops,
Desmospondylus: new genera of Permian
vertebrates. Bulletin of the Geological
Society of America 2I:249-284.
1910b. New Permian reptiles: rha-
chitomous vertebrae. Journal of Geology
18:585-600.
191 1. American Permian Vertebrates.
University of Chicago Press, Chicago,
v +145pp.
... Since their initial description by W.F. Cummins in 1890, Lower Permian rocks of north-central Texas called Clear Fork have been inextricably linked to terrestrial vertebrate fossils. Cummins, who provided collections to the prolific paleontologist E.D. Cope, established the "Clear Fork beds" as a thick sequence of mainly nonmarine rocks, and Cope established the Clear Fork as a rich source of amphibian and reptile remains (Cummins, 1908;Craddock and Hook, 1989). Late in his life, the remarkable Cummins (1840Cummins ( -1931 also saw the name Clear Fork applied to major oil discoveries in Permian rocks of West Texas. ...
... The resulting collections, now held by the Non-vertebrate Paleontology Laboratory (NPL), Jackson School of Geoscience, The University of Texas at Austin, total over 2600 catalogued specimens (Ann M. Molineux, 2017, personal communication). Concurrently with collecting plant deposits, Witte discovered numerous important lower Permian vertebrate localities, two of which developed into sizeable quarries (collections at the VPL, Craddock and Hook, 1989 The fossiliferous matrix of the USGS and USNM collections is similar to most of the NPL specimens. However, the sandy plant-bearing beds mentioned earlier appear to have been collected from higher in the coarsening-upward section, an interval largely covered today by fallen sandstone blocks that mark the former WPA excavation. ...
Chapter
The Sanzenbacher flora is one of the few early Wolfcampian (Asselian) floras to be reported from north central Texas, an area well known for its Permian vertebrate fossils. As such, it serves as a point of comparison to other floras from the early Permian of western Pangea. Comparison with several described floras indicates considerable variation in space and time. However, similarities also are revealed, including the consistent mixture of plants interpreted to have grown in wetter and more water-stressed substrates. Drought-tolerant taxa, including conifers, callipterids, taeniopterids, and certain of the medullosan pteridosperm groups (particularly Neurodontopteris and Neurocallipteris), occur widely among these floras intermixed with more mesomorphic to hygromorphic plant groups, such as marattialean tree ferns and calamitaleans.
... The most extensive lower Permian tetrapod record from the western United States is from north-central Texas (e.g., Romer 1928Romer , 1935Romer , 1958Romer , 1974Hook, 1989;Sander et al., 2007). Fossil vertebrates have been collected from the nonmarine Permian redbeds in north-central Texas since the 1870s and have been studied in great detail (see historical review by Craddock and Hook, 1989). In the Texas section, Plummer and Moore (1921), Hentz (1988) and Lucas (2006). ...
Article
Four substantial tetrapod extinctions have been identified during the Permian, but only one of these is an apparent mass extinction. Analyses of global compilations of the family-level diversity of Permian tetrapods have been confounded by incorrect and compiled correlations. Instead, analyzing diversity patterns at the genus level in “best sections” identifies only one apparent mass extinction of Permian tetrapods. Much evolutionary turnover took place among tetrapods during the latter part of the early Permian and had been identified as a single mass extinction at the Artinskian-Kungurian boundary. However, the only stratigraphically dense tetrapod record of the late early Permian, from the southwestern USA, indicates a succession of extinctions spread out from Redtankian through Littlecrontonian (Kungurian) time, not a single mass extinction. Olson's gap remains a hiatus in the global record of Permian tetrapods equivalent to part of the Kungurian-Roadian. Across the gap, eupelycosaur-dominated assemblages were replaced by therapsid-dominated assemblages, but the claim that this is associated with a mass extinction (“Olson's extinction”) has been based on compressing all of the extinctions of the Redtankian-Littlecrotonian and Olson's gap into one event. Recognition of Olson's gap does not preclude the possibility of an extinction at the early-middle Permian boundary (“Olson's extinction”). However, the gap in the tetrapod fossil record makes it impossible to establish the magnitude, precise timing and structure of the extinctions that took place across Olson's gap.
... Romer 1928Romer , 1935Romer , 1958Romer , 1974Hook 1989;Sander et al. 2007). Fossil vertebrates have been collected from the non-marine Permian red beds in north-central Texas since the 1870s and have been extensively published (see historical review by Craddock & Hook 1989). ...
Article
The most extensive Permian tetrapod (amphibian and reptile) fossil records from the western USA (New Mexico to Texas) and South Africa have been used to define 11 land vertebrate faunachrons (LVFs). These are, in ascending order, the Coyotean, Seymouran, Mitchellcreekian, Redtankian, Littlecrotonian, Kapteinskraalian, Gamkan, Hoedemakeran, Steilkransian, Platbergian and Lootsbergian. These faunachrons provide a biochronological framework with which to assign ages to, and correlate, Permian tetrapod fossil assemblages. Intercalated marine strata, radioisotopic ages and magnetostratigraphy were used to correlate the Permian LVFs to the standard global chronostratigraphic scale with varying degrees of precision. Such correlations identified the following significant events in Permian tetrapod evolution: a Coyotean chronofaunal event (end Coyotean); Redtankian events (Mitchellcreekian–Littlecrotonian); Olson's gap (late Littlecrotonian); a therapsid event (Kapteinskraalian); a dinocephalian extinction event (end Gamkan); and a latest Permian extinction event (Platbergian–Lootsbergian boundary). Problems of incompleteness, endemism and taxonomy, and the relative lack of non-biochronological age control continue to hinder the refinement and correlation of a Permian timescale based on tetrapod biochronology. Nevertheless, the global Permian timescale based on tetrapod biochronology is a robust tool for both global and regional age assignment and correlation. Advances in Permian tetrapod biochronology will come from new fossil discoveries, more detailed biostratigraphy and additional alpha taxonomic studies based on sound evolutionary taxonomic principles.
... Records at the American Museum of Natural History show Jacob Boll and his assistant J.C. Isaac collected this specimen in February of 1878 in Wichita County, Texas. These men collected south of the Wichita River in Wichita County during the winter of 1877-1878(Craddock and Hook 1989 placing the undetermined locality most likely in the Petrolia Formation of the Wichita Group (Hentz 1988). The articulated crus and pes of Eryops MCZ 7555 was collected in 1953 three miles south of Black Flat, Archer County in the Nocona Formation (Wichita Group). ...
Article
Full-text available
The carpus of Eryops megacephalus and tarsus of Acheloma cumminsi known from complete and articulated individuals have provided the standard anatomy of these skeletal regions for temnospondyls. Restudy of the carpus of Eryops confirms the presence of only four digits, but refutes evidence for a prepollex, postminimus, and distal carpal 5. The supposed contact surface on centrale 1 for a prepollex is reinterpreted as part of the articulation for metacarpal 1 that includes distal carpal 1. Contrary to previous interpretations, a notch on the intermedium does not fit against the lateral corner of the radius. An articular surface on the distal end of the ulna thought previously to contact an absent postminimus fits against the ulnare. Preparation of the tarsus of the type specimen of Trematops milleri (junior synonym of Acheloma cumminsi) and a previously undescribed crus and pes of Eryops finds no evidence for a pretarsale in either genus. Centrale 4 of the tarsus shares a similar rectangular shape with a wide contact for the tibiale among several temnospondyls whether terrestrial or aquatic. Limited flexibility of the carpus of Eryops and a strong palmar arch are probably weight-bearing features. A proximal-distal line of flexibility is present along the tibial side of the tarsus between the tibiale and centrale 4 and between centrale 2 and centrale 1. A phylogenetic analysis of Temnospondyli including new characters of the carpus and tarsus reveals considerable instability, highlighting the significance of Dendrerpeton acadianum, Balanerpeton woodi, Capetus palustris, and Iberospondylus schultzei.
... Fossil vertebrates have been collected from the non-marine Permian red beds in northcentral Texas since the 1870s (see historical review by Craddock & Hook 1989). The collected vertebrate fossils have been published on extensively by E. D. Cope, E. C. Case, S. W. Williston, A. S. Romer and E. C. Olson, among others, and they provide the basis for much of what is known about the Early Permian evolution of tetrapods. ...
Article
The most extensive Permian tetrapod (amphibian and reptile) fossil records from the western United States (New Mexico-Texas) and South Africa provide the basis for definition of 10 land-vertebrate faunachrons that encompass Permian time. These are (in ascending order): the Coyotean, Seymouran, Mitchellcreekian, Redtankian, Littlecrotonian, Kapteinskraalian, Gamkan, Hoedemakeran, Steilkransian and Platbergian. These fauna- chrons provide a biochronological framework with which to determine and discuss the age relationships of Permian tetrapod faunas. Their correlation to the marine time scale and its numerical calibrations indicate that the Coyotean is a relatively long time interval of about 20 Ma, whereas most of the other faunachrons are much shorter, about 1-2 Ma long each. The Platbergian may also be relatively long, 14 Ma, although this is not certain. This suggests slow rates of terrestrial tetrapod faunal turnover during most of the Early Permian and late Middle to Late Permian, but more rapid rates of turnover during the latest Early and most of the Middle Permian, especially during the explosive initial diversification of therapsids.
... This fossil site is in the classic Clear Fork Group/Formation of the Lower Permian section of north-central Texas. The Texas Lower Permian section has yielded one of the world's greatest assemblages of fossil vertebrates, beginning with the work of E.D. Cope in the late 1870s (Craddock and Hook, 1989 provide an overview of the history of vertebrate fossil collecting). Olson (1958) wrote an overview of the geology and extensive vertebrate fauna of the Clear Fork. ...
Article
Continental trace fossils of Early Permian age are well known in the western United States from Wolfcampian (~Asselian to Artinskian) strata, but few examples are known from Leonardian (~Kungurian) deposits. A substantial ichnofauna from strata of the lower part of the Clear Fork Formation at Lake Kemp, Baylor County, Texas, augments the meager North American record of Leonardian continental trace fossil assemblages. Ichnofossils at Lake Kemp occur in the informally-named Craddock dolomite member of the Clear Fork Formation, which is 12–15m above the local base of the Clear Fork. The trace-bearing stratum is an up-to-0.3m thick, laminated to flaser-bedded, dolomitic siltstone that also contains mud cracks, raindrop impressions, microbially induced mat structures, and some land-plant impressions. We interpret the Craddock dolomite member as the feather-edge of a marine transgressive carbonate deposit of an irregular coastline marked by shallow bays or estuaries on the eastern shelf of the Midland basin, and the trace-fossil-bearing stratum at Lake Kemp is an unchannelized flow deposit on a muddy coastal plain. The fossil site at Lake Kemp yields a low to moderately diverse fauna of invertebrate and vertebrate traces. A sparse invertebrate ichnofauna consists of arthropod feeding and locomotion traces assigned to Walpia cf. W. hermitensis White, 1929 and Diplichnites gouldi Gevers in Gevers et al., 1971. Tetrapod footprints are most common and assigned to Batrachichnus salamandroides (Geinitz, 1861), cf. Amphisauropus kablikae (Geinitz and Deichmüller, 1882), and Dromopus lacertoides (Geinitz, 1861), which represent small temnospondyl, seymouriamorph, and basal sauropsid trackmakers. Both the traces and sedimentary features of the fossil horizon indicate a freshwater setting at the time of track formation, and the trace assemblage represents the Scoyenia ichnofacies and the Batrachichnus ichnofacies in an overbank environment with sheet flooding and shallow ephemeral pools on an extensive coastal plain. The Lake Kemp tetrapod track assemblage is characteristic of the global Early Permian tetrapod ichnofauna found in red beds, which is dominated by a handful of ichnogenera that include Batrachichnus, Limnopus, Amphisauropus, Dromopus, Varanopus, Hyloidichnus, Ichniotherium and Dimetropus, which are the tracks of temnospondyls, seymouriamorphs, diadectomorphs, “pelycosaurs”, “captorhinomorphs”, and araeoscelids. The Lake Kemp tracks also further document the continuity of the ichnogenera Batrachichnus, Amphisauropus and Dromopus from Wolfcampian into Leonardian time and thus support the concept that Wolfcampian and Leonardian red-bed tetrapod footprints represent a single biostratigraphic assemblage.
Article
Lower Permian Admiral Formation redbeds in north Texas are famous for their vertebrate fauna. This paper provides a detailed taphonomic analysis of the Geraldine Bonebed in central Archer County, Texas, one of the most important fossil vertebrate occurrences in the region.The Geraldine Bonebed is situated in the floodbasin facies (red and gray mudstones with abundant Psaronius roots) of a small meandering river system. Such basins were covered with a dense swamp forest with a high diversity of vertebrates. The Geraldine Bonebed has yielded, from an area of 30 m2, 44 partly articulated skeletons of four genera of tetrapods and the remains of another eight vertebrate taxa. The bones lie on a layer of fern, and conifer foliage and wood intermingled with fossil charcoal. The sediment, the occurrence of “Wasserleichen”, and the skeleton orientation indicate post-mortem transportation and deposition in water.A single mass death event, which could have been a forest fire, drove the animals into a pond where they perished. Carcasses floating in water together with plant debris were concentrated by wind-induced drift into this exceptional fossil deposit. A recent example of this process of bonebed formation after mass death was described by Weigelt (1927) from the Texas Gulf Coast.
A new paleoniscid fish, Eurylepidoides socialis, from the Permo-Carboniferou s of Texas
  • Paleontology
Paleontology, University of Michigan 4:227-274. 1935b. A new paleoniscid fish, Eurylepidoides socialis, from the Permo-Carboniferou s of Texas. Contributions from the Museum of
  • J Clark
  • R L Carroll
Clark, J., and R.L. Carroll. 1973. Romeriid reptiles of the Permian. Harvard University, Museum of Comparative Tnology, Bulletin IM3 53 -407.
On the value of the evidence furnished by vertebrate fossils of age of certain so-called Permian beds in America
1907b. Revision of the Pelycosauria of North America. Carnegie Institution of Washington Publication 55 : 1 -176. 1908. On the value of the evidence furnished by vertebrate fossils of age of certain so-called Permian beds in America. Journal of Geology 16:572-580. 1911a. A revision of the Cotylosauria of North America. Carnegie Institution of
Early Permian depositional environments and pond bonebeds in central Archer County
1989. Early Permian depositional environments and pond bonebeds in central Archer County, Texas. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 69:l-21.
New Permian reptiles: rhachitomous vertebrae
1910b. New Permian reptiles: rhachitomous vertebrae. Journal of Geology 18:585-600.