ArticlePDF Available

Correlation between Fitness Parameters and An Occupational Rescue Simulation among Emergency Care Providers in North West Province, South Africa: A Pilot Study

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Objective: The purpose of the study was to examine the relationship between validated fitness parameters and an emergency rescue simulation (RS) circuit performed by emergency care providers (ECPs). Methods: A cross-sectional study was selected to determine the relationship between the fitness tests and the RS. Twenty ECPs in the North West province of South Africa participated in the study. Demographic data were collected, followed by testing of anthropometric characteristics and field fitness tests measuring muscular strength, muscular endurance, aerobic capacity, anaerobic capacity and flexibility. Thereafter, participants had to complete a RS circuit. Pearson's correlation coefficient was used to assess the relationship between variables. Differences in age, gender and body mass index formed part of the descriptive statistics. A test-retest reliability method was applied to evaluate the reliability of the RS. Results: Significant correlations were found between the RS and the 250 m shuttle run (r=0.83; p<0.01), flexed-arm hang test (r=-0.59; p<0.01), Cooper 12-minute test (r=-0.56; p<0.01), and the maximum push-up test (r=-0.51; p<0.05). Conclusion: Findings demonstrate a possible association between aerobic capacity, anaerobic capacity, muscular strength, muscular endurance and ECP performance in an occupational task-related RS. Improved performance in these specific fitness areas may enable ECPs to be better prepared for the physical demands of their occupation. The RS may also be used as a tool to assess job (physical) preparedness of qualified ECPs during their recruitment, but this requires further validation.
Content may be subject to copyright.
01
Research
Correlation between tness parameters and an occupational
rescue simulation among emergency care providers in North
West province, South Africa: A pilot study
Solomon Mthombeni MPhil, is Researcher1; Yoga Coopoo PhD, FACSM; Habib Noorbhai PhD, is Associate Professor2
Afliation:
1National Assembly, Parliament of the Republic of South Africa
2Department of Sport and Movement Studies, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Johannesburg, South Africa
https://doi.org/10.33151/ajp.18.862
Abstract
Objective
The purpose of the study was to examine the relationship between validated tness parameters and an emergency rescue
simulation (RS) circuit performed by emergency care providers (ECPs).
Methods
A cross-sectional study was selected to determine the relationship between the tness tests and the RS. Twenty ECPs in the North
West province of South Africa participated in the study. Demographic data were collected, followed by testing of anthropometric
characteristics and eld tness tests measuring muscular strength, muscular endurance, aerobic capacity, anaerobic capacity and
exibility. Thereafter, participants had to complete a RS circuit. Pearson’s correlation coefcient was used to assess the relationship
between variables. Differences in age, gender and body mass index formed part of the descriptive statistics. A test-retest reliability
method was applied to evaluate the reliability of the RS.
Results
Signicant correlations were found between the RS and the 250 m shuttle run (r=0.83; p<0.01), exed-arm hang test (r=-0.59;
p<0.01), Cooper 12-minute test (r=-0.56; p<0.01), and the maximum push-up test (r=-0.51; p<0.05).
Conclusion
Findings demonstrate a possible association between aerobic capacity, anaerobic capacity, muscular strength, muscular endurance
and ECP performance in an occupational task-related RS. Improved performance in these specic tness areas may enable ECPs
to be better prepared for the physical demands of their occupation. The RS may also be used as a tool to assess job (physical)
preparedness of qualied ECPs during their recruitment, but this requires further validation.
Keywords:
emergency medical care; physical tness; occupational demands; rescue simulation; physical preparedness
Corresponding Author: Habib Noorbhai, habibn@uj.ac.za
02
Mthombeni: Fitness parameters and an occupational rescue simulation
Australasian Journal of Paramedicine: 2021;18
Introduction
Emergency care providers (ECPs) work in a pre-hospital
setting with a specic mandate to provide patient care
during emergencies. Activities in their mandate include, but
are not limited to, patient positioning and immobilisation,
cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), uid therapy and lifting
and moving of patients (1). At times, ECPs are also required
to perform duties such as removal of injured patients from
dangers such as vehicle wreckage through patient extrication
using rescue equipment (2). Hunter et al (3) suggested that the
duties of paramedics responsible for frequent injuries include
manual handling and awkward tasks, combined with periods
of sedentary behaviours during shifts. Therefore, due to the
occupation of ECPs, it requires them to rescue casualties as
rapidly and efciently as possible (4), which places mental and
physical demands on the body (Figure 1).
Studies investigating the relationship between physical tness
components of ECPs and their occupational tasks in South
Africa and globally are uninitiated. Only a few studies have
investigated the tness levels and physical health measures
among ECPs (5,6), despite the literature detailing the
demonstration of the physical demands in the profession. For
example, Russo et al (7) examined the impact of physical tness
on the quality of external chest compressions during CPR and
found that rescuers of superior physical tness were able to
sustain high quality chest compressions and lower rescuer
fatigue. Furthermore, Coffey et al (1) assessed the physical
demands of the paramedic occupation in Canada. They found
that loading and unloading of ill/injured patients, pushing and
pulling of patient loaded stretchers, as well as the carrying of
medical and rescue equipment were among the most physically
demanding tasks of paramedics.
There is no pre-employment physical tness testing of ECPs,
nor is there policy advocating for such in South Africa when
compared to other emergency care professions such as
reghting, law enforcement and trafc ofcers (which conduct
pre-employment tness testing). In the rural areas of South
Africa, ECPs not only work in an ambulance setting but are also
formally trained to perform rescue operations in conjunction with
other rescue organisations (ie. re department). Therefore, the
purpose of the study was to determine the relationship between
physical tness parameters of ECPs and an occupation specic
rescue simulation (RS), designed in accordance with their
intensied job-related tasks (ie. performing CPR, lifting, carrying
and loading of patients and equipment, vehicle extrication).
Methods
Participants
A cross-sectional study was designed to assess the relationship
between the tness test battery and the RS parameters of
ECPs. For the study, ECPs were dened as basic ambulance
assistants, emergency care assistants, ambulance emergency
assistants, emergency care technicians, critical care assistants,
as well as emergency care practitioners, as recognised by the
professional board of emergency care at the Health Professions
Council of South Africa (8). Twenty male ECPs between the
ages of 30 and 48 years with a minimum of 2 years of work
experience as operational ECPs volunteered for the study. The
**HR = heart rate; MSD = musculoskeletal disorders; RF = risk factors; RPE = resting perceived exertion
Figure 1. Job related risk factors for ECPs
03
participants were free from any musculoskeletal injuries and
were qualied and recruited via email contact throughout the
32 emergency medical services (EMS) stations in the North
West province of South Africa. They responded by reading and
completing a participant information and consent form provided.
Standardised testing methods were used based on the American
College of Sports Medicine criteria (9). Principles of the Helsinki
agreement was followed with respect to the testing of human
subjects. Ethical clearance was obtained from the Faculty of
Health Sciences Research Ethics Committee at the University of
Johannesburg (REC-01-159-2016). Permission was also granted
by the North West Department of Health to conduct the study on
their personnel.
Data collection and procedures
On signing the informed consent form, the participants met
with the researcher on three occasions at the testing venue.
The rst visit was to conduct the tness test; the second and
third visits was for the completion of two attempts at the RS
circuit. Participants required a minimum of 48 hours lapse
time between attempts at the RS. During the collection of
anthropometric measurements, the participants had to be in a
fasted state. Participants were also requested not to participate
in any exercise for 48 hours before the tness testing and the
RS simulation and were asked to have a light breakfast on the
morning of testing. All tests were administered by a qualied
biokineticist (specialised exercise therapist) also trained as a
basic ambulance assistant. All 20 participants were tested over a
period of 10 days.
Anthropometric measurements
In a fasted state, participants weight and height were measured
and calculated [body weight (kg) x height (cm) squared] to
determine their body mass index (BMI). The subcutaneous body
fat percentage of participants was measured using a skinfold
calliper (Harpenden skinfold Body Calliper C-136, USA) on four
areas of the body (subscapular, suprailliac, bicep, tricep) as
described by Miller (10). Before the tness testing, participants
were only allowed to have a light meal or energy drink after the
anthropometric measurements.
Fitness parameters
The following nine eld tests were used to measure ve
components of tness – aerobic capacity, anaerobic capacity,
muscular strength, muscular endurance and exibility:
12 minute cooper test
maximal push-up test
60 seconds sit-up test
isometric torso lift
isometric leg lift
modied sit-and-reach test
hand grip test
exed arm hang test
250 m shuttle run.
Participants were taken through light warm-ups and dynamic
stretching by a qualied exercise therapist before the tests.
Rescue simulation
The RS was designed from ve different physical ability tests
(tasks commonly performed by ECPs in their line of duty)
derived from other related studies (11-15). The RS tests were
then formulated into a system of ve different stations whereby
the participant could perform one test after the other, moving
from one station to the next in a sequential form. The tests in
the RS were also organised in such a way that they imitated a
typical rescue scenario. The RS required participants to have
adequate recovery from the tness test. Thereafter, 48 hours
after the tness tests, the participants were required to complete
an RS consisting of ve stations with no rest period in between
the stations, organised in a time-trial format. Before the RS,
the participants were required to wear personal protective
equipment consisting of a jumpsuit, protective boots, helmet and
gloves. Participants were taken through a session to familiarise
themselves with the content of the simulation and were then
given an opportunity to ask questions or seek clarity before
beginning the RS. Once participants were familiar and condent
with the RS, they could start the circuit. The tness components
tested in the RS included aerobic and anaerobic capacity as
well as muscular strength and muscular endurance. The RS
was conducted in a temperature-controlled environment ranging
between 15ºC and 20ºC. The participants had to complete the
RS on two different occasions (after 48 hours) in order to do a
test-retest reliability of the RS.
Rescue simulation sequence
The RS circuit was designed in a manner that allowed
participants to move from station-to-station in sequence (ie. in
alphabetical order, from the start line to station A, B, C, D, E and
then to the nish line) (Figure 2).
Station A: Ascending stair test carrying a 16.5 kg medical/
rescue bag, electrocardiogram and a suction unit
The purpose of the test was to test the ability and efciency
of the ECPs to carry their medical equipment up four ights
of stairs in order to reach the patient (13). The apparatus that
the participant had to carry was a medical/rescue bag, medical
suction unit and ECG. The participants had to ascend then
descend four ights of stairs (step height of 0.17 m) with a total
vertical rise of 13 m (estimated to be four oors) while carrying
a medical bag, suction unit and ECG with a combined weight
of 16.5 kg. The test was scored by the ability of participants
to ascend and descend stairs carrying equipment within the
shortest time possible. The faster person was awarded a higher
score, which implied that in an emergency situation, the faster
person may attend to a patient rst, for various rescue tasks.
Station B: Vehicle extrication using a spreader
The purpose of the test was to determine the ability of ECPs to
lift and utilise heavy vehicle hydraulic extrication tools during
vehicle collisions in order to remove trapped casualties (13). A
19.6 kg ‘jaws of life’ hydraulic extrication spreader (Hurst ML-28)
Mthombeni: Fitness parameters and an occupational rescue simulation
Australasian Journal of Paramedicine: 2021;18
04
was used for the test. The participants had to hold the vehicle
extrication spreader ve times at three different heights (0.9
m, 1.2 m, 1.5 m) for at least 15 seconds at each height. The
test was scored according to the participants’ ability to hold the
spreader with the correct form in all three different positions
without rest breaks.
Station C: 30 m simulated victim drag with a 120 kg manikin
The purpose of the test was to determine the ECPs’ ability
to drag the patient out of dangerous situations at the scene
(11). A 120 kg Life Tec adult rescue training manikin and 2 m
kernmantle rope was used and due to the difculty in gripping
the manikin during the drag, a kernmantle rope was tied around
the manikin’s armpits, making it easier to grip and drag the
manikin. However, in a real-world setting, ECPs have to victim
drag under the armpits using their forearms or by using a rescue
blanket. The participants then had to reverse drag the manikin
for a 30 m distance. The test was scored by the shortest time the
participant covered the 30 m distance during the drag.
Station D: Five minutes of continuous chest compressions
The purpose of the test was to determine the ECPs’ ability
to perform adequate continuous chest compressions for ve
minutes without rest (14). A Laerdal CPR manikin was used
for the test. The participants had to complete ve minutes
of continuous chest compressions of at least 100 bpm. The
CPR manikin used had a clicking mechanism during each
compression which was used to measure the effectiveness
of the compressions. The test was scored according to the
participants’ ability to complete ve-minute chest compressions
without rest.
Station E: Imitation of carrying of the patient on a spine
board
The purpose of the test was to determine the ability of the
ECPs to lift and carry a patient with a scoop stretcher or spine
board off the ground towards an ambulance (12,15). Two 24 kg
kettlebells were used for the test as the scoop stretcher or spine
board stretchers would require more than one person to carry.
Therefore, kettlebells served as an alternative to stretchers.
The participants had to squat lift a pair of 48 kg (24 kg each)
kettlebells (26) and carry them for a distance of 20 m (12). The
test was scored by the ability of the ECP to safely squat lift and
carry kettlebells in the shortest time possible (without running)
for a 20 m distance.
Data analysis
Morphological measurements (height, weight, anthropometry),
tness test and RS results were recorded on a Microsoft Excel
spreadsheet. Inferential and descriptive statistical analyses
were computed on the obtained data and used to describe the
demographics, health and tness parameters of ECPs. Central
tendency was measured via means and standard deviations.
A correlation coefcient was used to determine the relationship
between two variables and to ascertain the strength of the
relationship.
A test-retest was conducted to evaluate the reliability of the RS
whereby participants had to complete two RS with a minimum
of 48 hours rest between them. A two-tailed t-test method was
used to determine the reliability of the RS. Pearson’s correlation
coefcient was used to assess the correlation between
the anthropometric measurements, tness test and the RS
Mthombeni: Fitness parameters and an occupational rescue simulation
Australasian Journal of Paramedicine: 2021;18
Figure 2. Rescue simulation sequence
05
Mthombeni: Fitness parameters and an occupational rescue simulation
Australasian Journal of Paramedicine: 2021;18
completion time. SPSS (version 26) (IBM, Amronk, NY) was used
for the statistical analysis. Signicance was set at the level of
p≤0.05.
Results
Anthropometric characteristics
The anthropometric characteristics of participants are presented
in Table 1. The mean age of the participants was 37 ± 4.4 years,
with a BMI of 28.4 ± 5.5 kg/m2, and body fat percentage of 24.2
± 6.8. A total of 30% of participants were classied as overweight
(BMI ≥25) and 45% as clinically obese (BMI ≥30). More
participants with an elevated subcutaneous body fat percentage
than in the normal range (5% lean, 25% average vs. 55% high
and 15% very high) was found.
Table 1. Anthropometric characteristics of participants
Participant characteristics n Mean SD
Age (years) 20 37.0 4.4
Mean height (cm) 20 169.6 6.0
Mean weight (kg) 20 81.5 15.4
Mean BMI (kg/m2) 20 28.4 5.5
Mean body fat % 20 24.2 6.8
Fitness test results
The maximum push-up test produced a mean of 21 ± 14 and
one-minute sit-up at 26 ± 8 repetitions; the isometric torso lift
produced a mean of 105 ± 20.9 kg and the isometric leg lift at
115.1 ± 23.5 kg. In addition, the exed-arm hang text (FAHT)
produced a mean at 29 ± 18 seconds and the modied sit-and-
reach test 36 cm ± 6.6 (Table 2).
Rescue simulation results
The mean RS completion time was 8.42 ± 0.4 minutes. The
relationship between the RS and the tness tests are illustrated
in Table 3. The most signicant relationship was found between
the RS and 250 m shuttle runs, FAHT, Cooper 12-minute test and
the maximum push-up test. The results, therefore, indicated that
the better the participant performed in the various tness tests,
the faster they completed the RS.
Table 2. Fitness test results for participants
Test Values
Mean SD
Maximum push-up (repetitions) 21 14
One-minute sit-up (repetitions) 26 8
Isometric torso lift (kg) 105 20.9
Isometric leg lift (kg) 115.1 23.5
Flexed-arm hang test (seconds) 29 18
Grip strength (kg) 43.1 6.6
Modied sit-and-reach test (cm) 36 6.6
Cooper 12-minute test (m) 1866.5 416
250 m shuttle run test (seconds) 70 17
Table 3. Relationship between the rescue simulation (trial 2) and
tness parameters
Variables Rescue simulation (n=20)
R statistic p-value
250 m shuttles 0.83 0.000*
Flexed-arm hang test -0.59 0.006
Cooper 12-minute test -0.56 0.010
Maximum push-up test -0.51 0.020
One-minute sit-up test -0.43 0.060
Isometric leg lift -0.39 0.080
Isometric torso lift -0.05 0.840
Grip strength -0.16 0.510
Modied sit-and-reach test 0.12 0.600
*p<0.05
Discussion
The RS in the study was designed to determine the relationship
between the physical tness of ECPs and their ability to complete
job-specic physical tasks such as performing CPR, vehicle
extrication, lifting and carrying of patients among others as
quickly and efciently as possible. Their tasks are supported by
Coffey et al (1) who suggested that paramedics are routinely
exposed to physically demanding tasks while on duty, especially
those that require loading, unloading, pushing, pulling and
carrying of patients and rescue equipment. Tests that formed
part of the RS were extracted from different published studies
that included job tasks pertinent to ECPs and reghters (11-
14). However, it must be highlighted that the RS has not been
a scientically validated test to assess job task analysis within
EMS, but was composed of selected activities commonly
performed by ECPs in their line of duty.
The study found a moderate but statistically signicant
relationship between the RS and various tness tests (250 m
shuttle runs [p=0.000], FAHT [p=0.006], Cooper 12-minute run
[p=0.010], and maximum push-up [p=0.020]) indicating that those
participants who performed poorer during these tness tests
were likely to take longer to complete the RS. These ndings
were consistent with those of Williford et al (16) who investigated
the relationship between physical tness (pull-ups, push-ups, sit-
ups, 1.5-mile run) and reghting suppression tasks (stair climb,
hoist, forcible entry, hose advance, victim rescue), whereby
signicant correlations were also found. The ndings were also
consistent with those of Michaelides et al (17) who examined the
relationship between physical tness aspects of reghters and
their job abilities through the reghter ability test. They found
that the reghter ability test completion time was correlated with
upper-body muscular endurance (push-ups and sit-ups), upper
body strength and relative power. Both reghters and ECPs
occupations are physically demanding and have similarities in
terms of physically handling (lifting, carrying, loading) patients as
indicated by Poplin et al (18). Therefore, the results of the study
had to be compared to those of studies related to reghters as
06
Mthombeni: Fitness parameters and an occupational rescue simulation
Australasian Journal of Paramedicine: 2021;18
there are limited studies on physical tness standards of ECPs
globally (19).
The study found a correlation between the RS and muscular
(upper body) strength (FAHT). This indicates that ECPs with
higher levels of muscular strength completed the RS faster
than those with lower levels. Similar results were demonstrated
by Rhea et al (11) who examined the relationship between
physical tness and job performance of reghters, and found a
signicant relationship between upper-body strength levels and
pulling activities (hose pull and victim drag) in reghters. This
is important because victim drag formed part of the RS. Ock et
al (14) examined the inuence of physical tness on 5 minutes
of continuous chest compressions and found strong correlations
between higher muscular strength and prolonged effective chest
compressions during CPR. This indicates that good muscular
strength is necessary for effective chest compressions during
prolonged CPR (>5 minutes).
Signicant correlations were found between the RS and
muscular endurance (maximum push-ups and FAHT). Rhea et
al (11) found that upper-body muscular endurance correlated
with reghters’ job task activities such as stair climbing,
equipment hoist, victim drag and overall job performance. In
addition, Michaelides et al (17) found that upper-body muscular
endurance (push-ups) signicantly contributed to the predictive
power of a reghter’s test performance ability. Therefore,
aerobic and anaerobic capacity remains paramount for the
occupation-specic activities of ECPs.
Signicant relationships were also found between aerobic
(Cooper 12-minute run), anaerobic (250 m shuttle run test)
capacity and the RS. Lindberg et al (13) conducted a study
on eld tests useful for evaluating aerobic work capacity of
reghters. Correlations were found between maximal aerobic
capacity (VO2 max) and a range of reghting tasks (stair
climbing carrying hose baskets, demolition, cutting, victim
rescue, vehicle extrication, hose pulling and carrying hose
baskets over terrain).
These results suggest that these components of physical
tness may be important in the performance of the RS. Hansen
et al (20) investigated the impact of physical tness on CPR
quality among healthcare professionals and found that there
was early rescuer physical fatigue which resulted in declined
compression depth, indicative of poor cardiorespiratory
endurance and muscular strength. Similar ndings by Rhea
et al (11) demonstrated a signicant relationship between
anaerobic capacity (400 m run) and the overall job performance
of reghters during a simulated reghting job task. This further
highlights the importance of aerobic and anaerobic capacity for
the occupation-specic activities of ECPs.
Lastly, the study found an insignicant relationship between
the RS and one-minute sit-up test, isometric torso-lift, isometric
leg lift, grip strength and modied sit-and-reach test. It is
acknowledged that having a good level of overall tness is
useful, but these elements may not be useful in predicting RS
performance.
Historically, there has been limited research on scientically
designed occupation-specic tness testing such as the RS
to test the physical preparedness of ECPs. One of the main
challenges is that qualied ECPs in the North West province are
not tested for physical tness during recruitment for employment
due to limited research in the area to advise policy. The ECPs
are tested for physical tness only when enrolling for rescue
training or emergency medical care qualication at the local
provincial colleges and other institutions of higher learning. The
current system of physical tness testing of ECPs makes use
of the generic tness test battery (ie. eld tests such as 2.4 km
run, push-ups, hang-test and sit-ups, shuttle runs), which are
time-consuming and do not assess the actual job-specic tasks
of ECPs, hence, the designing of the RS.
Limitations
It is assumed that a larger sample would have yielded higher
correlations, and hence, the trends indicate that a further study
with larger numbers is required to achieve better results. The
eld tests pose an inherent limitation in that they cannot provide
a more accurate reection of strength such as the one-repetition
maximum test. The results of the study equated the success of
adequate physical tness with a faster RS completion time. This
is a limitation because other factors (ie. safe execution of a task
instead of the speed of performance of occupation-related tasks)
were not taken into consideration. During the RS, a rope was
tied around the manikin as an aide during victim drag in Station
C as it was difcult to grip when pulling. In a real-world setting,
the ECP would drag a victim with arms bent under the victim’s
armpits, or by using a rescue sling. The participants were not
randomly sampled and the researcher had to rely on participants
volunteering to complete the RS which limits the generalisability
of the ndings. Furthermore, the study was only composed
of male participants, which is not indicative of the workforce
composition. The RS was designed using job-related activities
from other research papers and, therefore, no job task analysis
was conducted.
Conclusion
These ndings demonstrate a possible association between eld
tness parameters of testing, namely aerobic capacity, anaerobic
capacity, muscular strength, muscular endurance and ECP
performance in an occupational task-related RS. These results
are encouraging as they show trends in the RS test and eld
tness testing components, which may enable ECPs to be better
prepared for the physical demands of their occupation. The RS
may be used as a tool to assess job (physical) preparedness of
qualied ECPs during their recruitment, but this requires further
validation of these results on a larger population study.
07
Mthombeni: Fitness parameters and an occupational rescue simulation
Australasian Journal of Paramedicine: 2021;18
Competing interests
The authors declate no competing interests. Each author of this
paper has completed the ICMJE conict of interest statement.
Author contributions
Conception and design of the study: YC. Data acquisition:
YC, SM. Data analysis and interpretation of the data: all
authors. Drafting and critical revisions of the paper: all authors.
Accountability for all aspects of the work: all authors.
References
1. Coffey B, MacPhee R, Socha D, Fischer SL. Physical
demands description of paramedic work in Canada. Int J
Indus Erg 2016;53:355-62.
2. Bucher J, Dos Santos F, Frazier D, Merlin MA. Rapid
extrication versus the Kendrick Extrication Device (KED):
comparison of techniques used after motor vehicle
collisions. West J Emerg Med 2015;16:453-8. doi:10.5811/
westjem.2015.1.21851
3. Hunter J, MacQuarrie A, Sheridan S, et al. Health and
tness status of Australian paramedics: a cause for concern.
Abstract from Health, Wellness & Society Conference; 2018
Sep 20-21; London, UK. Available at: https://researchoutput.
csu.edu.au/en/publications/health-and-tness-status-of-
australian-paramedics-a-cause-for-co
4. Hegg-Deloye S, Corbeil P, Brassard P, et al. Work-related
and dietary factors associated with weight gain over the
period of employment in paramedics. Occup Med Health Aff
2014;2. doi:10.4172/2329-6879.1000173
5. Mthombeni S, Coopoo Y, Noorbhai H. Physical health status
of emergency care providers in South Africa. Asian J Sports
Med 2020;11:1-8.
6. Mthombeni SK, Coopoo Y, Noorbhai H. Fitness levels of
rural emergency medical and rescue service providers in the
North West province, South Africa. Occup Health Southern
Afr 2020;26:111-6.
7. Russo SG, Neumann P, Reinhardt S, et al. Impact of physical
tness and biometric data on the quality of external chest
compression: A randomised, crossover trial. BMC Emerg
Med 2011;11:20. doi:10.1186/1471-227X-11-20.
8. Sobuwa S, Christopher LD. Emergency care education in
South Africa: past, present and future. Australasian Journal
of Paramedicine 2019;16. doi: https://doi.org/10.33151/
ajp.16.647Hoffman R, Collingwood TT. Fit for Duty. 3rd edn.
Champaign, Illinois: Human Kinetics Inc, 2015; p.54.
9. Swain DP, editor. ACSM’s resource manual for guidelines for
exercise testing and prescription. 7th edn. Human Kinetics
Inc, 2013; p.110-6.
10. Miller TA, editor. NSCA’s guide to tests and assessments.
Champaign: Human Kinetics Inc, 2012.
11. Rhea RM, Alvar BA, Gray R. Physical tness and job
performance of re ghters. J Str Cond Res 2004;18:348-52.
12. Coopoo Y, Govender AN. An analysis of the tness demands
and the establishment of norms for U-21 South African
provincial rugby players. Afr J Phys Act Health Sci 2002;8:61-
74.
13. Lindberg A, Oksa J, Gavhed D, Malm C. Field tests for
evaluating the aerobic capacity of reghters. PLoS One
2013;8:1-8.
14. Ock S, Kim Y, Chung J, Kim S. Inuence of physical
tness on the performance of 5-minute continuous chest
compression. Eur J Emerg Med 2011;18:251.
15. Larsson H, Tergern M, Monnier A, et al. Content validity index
and intra and interrater reliability of a new muscle strength/
endurance test battery for Swedish soldiers. PLoS One
2015;10:1-13.
16. Williford HN, Duey WJ, Olson MS, Howard R, Wang N.
Relationship between reghting suppression tasks and
physical tness. Ergonomics 2010;42:1179-86.
17. Michaelides AM, Parpa MP, Henry LJ, Thompson GB,
Brown BS. Assessment of physical tness aspects and
their relationship to reghters’ job abilities. J Str Cond Res
2010;25:956-65.
18. Poplin G, Harris RB, Pollack KM, Peate WF, Burgess JL.
Beyond the reground: injuries in the re service. Inj Prev
2012;18:228-33. doi:10.1136/injuryprev-2011-040149
19. Fischer SL, Sinden KE, MacPhee RS: Ottawa Paramedic
Service Research Team. Identifying the critical physical
demanding tasks of paramedic work: towards the
development of a physical employment standard. Appl Ergon
2017;65:233-9. doi:10.1016/j.apergo.2017.06.021 Epub 2017
Jul 12. PMID: 28802444.
20. Hansen D, Vranckx P, Broekmans T, et al. Physical tness
affects the quality of single operator cardiocerebral
resuscitation in healthcare professionals. Eur J Emerg Med
2012;19:28-34.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Background: Studies investigating the physical fitness levels of emergency care providers (ECPs) in relation to their occupational demands in South Africa are limited, despite the importance of physical fitness for the occupation. There are no fitness guidelines available, nor are periodic fitness assessments of ECPs performed in the workplace. Objective: The objective of the study was to measure the physical fitness of ECPs in the North West province of South Africa, using a validated motor fitness test battery. Methods: Ninety-one volunteers completed nine field tests (fitness, sit-and-reach, push-ups, sit-ups, "exed-arm hang, hand grip-strength, isometric leg and torso lift, 250 m shuttle run, and a 12-minute run/walk). Anthropometric measurements were recorded. The Student’s t-test was used to determine any signi!cant di#erences in test scores between male and female ECPs. Results: Sixty-four male and 27 female ECPs participated in the study. The mean ages of the male and female ECPs were 36.5 years and 37.0 years, respectively. There was a high prevalence of overweight/obesity, as defined by body mass index, for both male (71.9%) and female (77.7%) ECPs. Male ECPs demonstrated superior muscular strength, muscular endurance, and aerobic and anaerobic capacity, compared to female ECPs. Most participants had poor aerobic capacity (62.7%), grip-strength (57.1%), lower body strength (95.6%) and muscular endurance measured by the push-up test (32.9%), one-minute sit-up test (67.0%) and "exed-arm hang test (53.8%). Conclusion: Many of the ECP study participants were not physically fit for duty. Measured fitness levels indicate that they may not be able to perform their occupational duties to the level required. The job requires much physical effort, and poor fitness may result in personal injury and risk patients’ lives. The ECPs would bene!t from exercise training to improve fitness and lower the risk of musculoskeletal injuries.
Article
Full-text available
Background: Emergency care providers (ECPs) have a physically, mentally, and emotionally demanding profession. Therefore, they are predisposed to cardiovascular and other non-communicable disease risk factors. Objectives: The objective of the study was to determine the physical health status of ECPs in the NorthWest province of South Africa through a selected anthropometric and other health parameter test battery. Methods: Ninety-one ECPs (64 males, 27 females) took part in the study voluntarily for health screening tests including body mass index (BMI), lean body mass (LBM), resting heart rate (RHR), blood pressure (BP), skinfold measurement, waist circumference (WC), waist-to-hip ratio (WHR), fasting blood glucose (FBG), and total cholesterol (TC). The collected data were subjected to statistical analysis using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 25 (IBM). Results: The participants demonstrated a mean BMI of 28.2+5.5 kg/m2, body fat of 26+7.6 %, and LBM of 58.6+10 kg. Significant differences were seen in height (170.5�6.2 vs. 160.7�5.3 cm), BF% (22.5+5.3 vs. 34.2+6.2 %), and LBM (62.3+8 vs. 49.2+8.2 kg) between males and females (P�0.05). Mean systolic BP was 122+15 mmHg, and diastolic BP was 81+10 mmHg. Mean WC was 90.8+11.4 cm. Other health parameters included mean FBG of 5.1+2.4 mmol/L and mean TC of 4.9+0.7 mmol/L. Significant differences were seen in WHR (0.88+0.04 vs. 0.79+0.06) between males and females (P<0.05). Conclusions: A significant number of ECPs presented with cardiovascular and other NCD risk factors such as hypertension, obesity, high WC, elevated FBG, and abnormal levels of TC. This can be attributed to the nature of their occupation such as working irregular shifts leading to sleep deprivation, being exposed to psychological trauma, poor nutrition during shifts, and/or lack of exercise. Stress management is an important part of these workers’ rehabilitation program. A well-formulated employee wellness program is required to set remedial measures in place.
Article
Full-text available
The objective of this study was to examine the content validity of commonly used muscle performance tests in military personnel and to investigate the reliability of a proposed test battery. For the content validity investigation, thirty selected tests were those described in the literature and/or commonly used in the Nordic and North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) countries. Nine selected experts rated, on a four-point Likert scale, the relevance of these tests in relation to five different work tasks: lifting, carrying equipment on the body or in the hands, climbing, and digging. Thereafter, a content validity index (CVI) was calculated for each work task. The result showed excellent CVI (≥0.78) for sixteen tests, which comprised of one or more of the military work tasks. Three of the tests; the functional lower-limb loading test (the Ranger test), dead-lift with kettlebells, and back extension, showed excellent content validity for four of the work tasks. For the development of a new muscle strength/endurance test battery, these three tests were further supplemented with two other tests, namely, the chins and side-bridge test. The inter-rater reliability was high (intraclass correlation coefficient, ICC2,1 0.99) for all five tests. The intra-rater reliability was good to high (ICC3,1 0.82-0.96) with an acceptable standard error of mean (SEM), except for the side-bridge test (SEM%>15). Thus, the final suggested test battery for a valid and reliable evaluation of soldiers' muscle performance comprised the following four tests; the Ranger test, dead-lift with kettlebells, chins, and back extension test. The criterion-related validity of the test battery should be further evaluated for soldiers exposed to varying physical workload.
Article
Full-text available
The goal of this study was to compare application of the Kendrick Extrication Device (KED) versus rapid extrication (RE) by emergency medical service personnel. Our primary endpoints were movement of head, time to extrication and patient comfort by a visual analogue scale. We used 23 subjects in two scenarios for this study. The emergency medical services (EMS) providers were composed of one basic emergency medical technician (EMT), one advanced EMT. Each subject underwent two scenarios, one using RE and the other using extrication involving a commercial KED. Time was significantly shorter using rapid extraction for all patients. Angles of head turning were all significantly larger when using RE. Weight marginally modified the effect of KED versus RE on the "angle to right after patient moved to backboard (p= 0.029) and on subjective movement on patient questionnaire (p=0.011). No statistical differences were noted on patient discomfort or pain. This is a small experiment that showed decreased patient neck movement using a KED versus RE but resulted in increased patient movement in obese patients. Further studies are needed to determine if the KED improves any meaningful patient outcomes in the era of increased evidence-based medicine in emergency medical services.
Article
Full-text available
Most sports loving countries in the world value test and measurements in sport science as the primary route to success in any code of sport. Empirical studies in sport, in the field of fitness evaluation, impact on coaching and development through the application of anthropometrical and physiological testing. This study was aimed at obtaining data on fitness levels of the U-21 South African provincial rugby players so that normative tables could be compiled for the forwards, backs and combined team. This study also provides an insight into the fitness demands of U-21 provincial rugby players on the basis of the two major playing units in a rugby game, namely the forwards and the backs. The test battery evaluated body composition, flexibility, explosive strength, dynamic strength, cardio-respiratory endurance, anaerobic capacity and agility at the beginning of a season. Data from one hundred and twelve players were categorized in three groups: forwards (57), backs (55) and the combined team (112). Means and standard deviations were computed for all tests. The t-test was applied to the means of both the forwards and backs for each test to establish the level of difference. Normative tables have been established for the forwards, backs and the combined team. No significant difference was found between backs, and forwards, except percent body fat, lean body mass and grip strength (p£ 0.05). The fitness demands for backs and forwards appear to be similar suggesting that a single set of norms will suffice for the whole team. The comparison of the two sets of norms for three similar tests indicate that the U-21 provincial norms compare favourably with senior club norms. The implications of the findings on a descriptive basis indicate that the U-21 provincial player is physiologically ready to participate at senior level. With careful guidance and mentoring, and of course, effective training,, the potential lies for participation at national level. Key words: Field testing, fitness, norms, rugby players. (Af. J. Physical, Health Education, Recreation and Dance: 2002 8(1): 61-74)
Article
Full-text available
Working as a firefighter is physically strenuous, and a high level of physical fitness increases a firefighter's ability to cope with the physical stress of their profession. Direct measurements of aerobic capacity, however, are often complicated, time consuming, and expensive. The first aim of the present study was to evaluate the correlations between direct (laboratory) and indirect (field) aerobic capacity tests with common and physically demanding firefighting tasks. The second aim was to give recommendations as to which field tests may be the most useful for evaluating firefighters' aerobic work capacity. A total of 38 subjects (26 men and 12 women) were included. Two aerobic capacity tests, six field tests, and seven firefighting tasks were performed. Lactate threshold and onset of blood lactate accumulation were found to be correlated to the performance of one work task (rs = -0.65 and -0.63, p<0.01, respectively). Absolute (mL·min(-1)) and relative (mL·kg(-1)·min(-1)) maximal aerobic capacity was correlated to all but one of the work tasks (rs = -0.79 to 0.55 and -0.74 to 0.47, p<0.01, respectively). Aerobic capacity is important for firefighters' work performance, and we have concluded that the time to row 500 m, the time to run 3000 m relative to body weight (s·kg(-1)), and the percent of maximal heart rate achieved during treadmill walking are the most valid field tests for evaluating a firefighter's aerobic work capacity.
Article
Public safety related occupations including police, fire and military commonly apply physical employment standard (PES) to facilitate job matching, an approach to evaluate if candidates demonstrate acceptable physical capabilities as required to perform the job safely and effectively. In Canada, paramedics remain as one of the few public safety occupations without an evidence-based, validated PES. The purpose of this study was to document and describe the physical demands of paramedic work and to identify the most physically demanding tasks. These outcomes are essential to inform the design and development of an evidence-based PES for the paramedic sector.
Article
Paramedics perform physically demanding job tasks related to patient care and transport; however, no data exists describing the physical demands exposure profile for a shift. The purpose of this research was to address this knowledge gap by characterizing the physical demands of paramedic work by gathering data from seven different services across Canada. Further, this investigation was extended to compare physical demand exposure frequencies between High-Populous (HP) and Low-Populous (LP) paramedic services. Using a participatory model, two paramedics from each of the seven services were trained how to conduct a physical demands description (PDD). Each trained paramedic observer then conducted PDDs while completing two ride-outs each, where they observed and recorded the physical demand exposures of their colleagues. Results support the belief that paramedics are routinely exposed to physical demands such as lifting, lowering, carrying, pushing, and pulling. In fact, attending paramedics identified stretcher loading and unloading (25.6% of respondents), carrying equipment (19.5%), and pushing and pulling the stretcher (13.4%) as the most physically demanding tasks. When considering differences in task frequency between services, the empty stretcher was loaded and unloaded more frequently in HP services (10.0 ± 4.1) than in LP services (5.6 ± 3.4). Additionally, medication bags were handled more frequently in HP services (21.4 ± 7.5) than in LP services (5.1 ± 3.6). These data confirm that paramedic work is a mix of prolonged sedentary time (on alert waiting for a call), interspersed with bouts of high physical demand exposures (when attending to a call).
Article
Background: Recent studies reported high body mass index values in paramedic, with a high percentage of workers being considered overweight or obese. However, little evidence exists regarding which factors explained weight gain over time in paramedics. Objective: This study evaluated whether occupational stress, tobacco consumption, sleeping problems or emotional food disinhibition were associated with weight gain over time in paramedics compared to a control group. Method: A retrospective study was performed. The study consisted in a self-report questionnaire composed of 84 questions related to sleeping problems, emotional food disinhibition, tobacco consumption and occupational stress. Occupational stress was evaluated through lack of social support and effort-reward imbalance. A repeated measures regression model was used to explore relationships between body mass index (BMI) and characteristics related to employment. Results: Questionnaires from 283 controls and 295 paramedics were analyzed. Paramedics, but not controls, gained BMI over the period of employment, as shown by a significant interaction between Time and Occupation (F(2, 568)=6.28; p=.002). Men were more likely to gain BMI over the period of employment (F(1,568)=42.95; p<. 0001). Among all covariates tested, tobacco consumption (F(1,568)=5.68; p=.02), supervisor support (F(1,568)=5.25; p=.02) and emotional disinhibition of eating (F(3,568)=7.51; p<.0001) had a significant effect on BMI for both groups. Conclusion: Paramedics experienced a greater increase in BMI over their years of employment than controls, often leading to obesity. These findings suggest that both work environment and organizational factors influence weight gain among paramedics and other workers.