Content uploaded by Matthew Vincent Flinders
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Matthew Vincent Flinders on Sep 23, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
>>> Draft Paper – Please do not quote without permission <<<
!" #
$#%&''''
'('
)()(')'*+,
'''
'-' *,
.'/'&,
* 0 '
',
' (')'1&*2
'' //'
**34% 3-.-1&
$ 5 6 $ 7 8 $
65&* 9 ,'
'
.* '
: /' '' '
'''
* 0 / / '
,+*
;<=2>?',
'@.
'AB2C0D
;<=>?:(')
@.AB2C00D
;<1=3'>2/'@
'(')()(')A
B2C000D
;<E=4+>8'
'-'AB2C0FD
2 ' ' + = *&
! C , ''
(! C ;) ' ;<& *&
' ,' , ;<& 1*&
' ', 11
3' ; 4 ;<1& : E*&
+ + (
') ' ';<E&* C
: : /'
'
'111
', G
:* ! C
!C&HI():
('')+**
4$ ; 5 $ % # $# %&* 0
'
''
+*4
'
.*?'
/' '
'':'
':,
:,)')*
2 ' ' ''
(')
' '* 2 / '
'
'**;<&*2
/!C !C&
& ' & @ &
+@.
/ ' * 2
/'(')()(')
' ' ' !C,
* ?
'#'
' # 1
+ # E*&
..-.
'4 $ 8 7& /'
''.*?
.'
!C /' * 0 !C
''''>
.- '
' ''
'>/(!C;)'
'*
/ '
!C@@'
,'
'.*J
.K'!C
''* #'',
!C '
' '
@@*8!C(.)
? L/" #C"&
'.
( .) ' '*2()
'' G ': (
) '
'':'
:
+ @ * J '
&
(')''
/' ' ',/ '
*
J !C'
'
('')
'* 8 ',
!C,
*C @ .21&
','(@')!C''
' , '
'+'*&
. 4' M
"&'
'
. . ,/ /
(): '
' * 8 .
' /(')',
''(!C
;)* 2 (!) K
,(C);*&
0!C;!C
,'
' ,
* 8 K
'' K
'''*
,''.''
!C* 4 / ''
( ) >
( @)A > / ' 'G
''.,
' ?NN&*2 . (,
),'':>'
@*0
' / '
,',
' ' &*
2>>
'* !C &
'-()#'NN%& '
/'
' ' ' * 2 !C; ,
(')>,'
''''
' '
*
0 ,' '
,',',,
/ ('
)''/'*
!C G ( .) '
*.
61&;8%%&
',/
' /' * 8
(')()(')'
: +
'
'*2'#23'
** &
()
C. & ) ;,? %& '
' ' 3 E&* 2
'
'' ' ' @
? M $ # N&*
'@'.
' ' @
L!$85 8N%%&*?
/''**'
--)'&
/*
2,':
.* 0 !C () C
2E&()?.1&!C;
'()()'
''' +
',()**&*2'
( ') . (,,
,,,') '
. 4 $ ; 5&* 2
+
!C !C;*2
',
!C :
' '
( ) .
*2HI
> . () () ' !C; ,
' /'
' ( ')
HI& ' &
8$65&*
!"#$%$&
"''()*"+
#1&(!C;)
'
:/''*
/' +
/'. ' . '
,/' /'*2
, / &=#
,
' # ':
' # 1 / &
' ' '
' # E /,' '
'+*#
0 HI : ' ' . N N1
'8 C';JC*##3
2*2#=&
/' & '' /''* 2
.: . :'()
', **
*&* 2 M ; ,H 4 1
+ # 0 0. E,E& (.
)./'*0'
,''
' K ', '*
','G*2
' ' HI
' ' ''
'''''*0
' ; 4 % > . 8 ;'& /'
/''
''*2 + (C 0')
: E ( ')
:, +
.& /' / '&' '
' *2'
(0' 4 #) )
' + "'
;3/.*
+ * 3 /'
,'HI'
/' G'
''*2+'
. ' ' ,
( ') /' /
''*2
/*
,-.
2 '
. ',
/'!C*2'(!C;)
@ ' '
/''*2
' ' '' '
'(')C1&,
' ' /'
' C E&* 0
/,'/,.'2
&''3'4'#2
4J#2&*8@.@
'(')
**;<&*
/",$.
#23
C
32?J
L8?3! L320M
L.
;
%,
5
4
',
)
4
#O
#'*
%,
5
0.
#'*%I.HM*
153'
1
6'0 ,5
4M*
E4'
'*<
E
6'00 #',5
4#G
74'
''*<
"
3/'
.
N
L
K'*
2'
.'I.H
M#'%*2;<1;<E
& + 15
4J#2 .* L ' 11 * 2
'''':.
**
'' ' ' *&* 2.
' .
': ' +
' * 2 &
'
/*
8#'=&('
) : G &
' &'
,': ''* 0.
:'
' #' 5 **
#'1E 2&*! :
': ':
' ' '
' * 2 : '
: ' N
'' ' = & :
' ' & .
&'
.* 2 /
' '
''**;<1&*2:
@ .
**;<E&*
,.
2'(')
' ''* 2 :
''=
*Spread=3/',(')'
3'*J
11 1 /
(')*
*Pace=2:''
' '
** 0 !& ' ** # #& / '
**HI&*
1* Genesis= 2 H I) /' (')
' E ;
3/ . '' : ', @ '
**!3';4&
2:
/'','
*2'
' ' , '
'/*2''
'&*
0".$$-.12&
)*"'
I39 3!0!6 !2H;3
#
?,'
'* 6
#
0',,
* 3
#
1
0''
''B/D ;+
#
E
!.
+,
(')'
C
.
' '
/:
*2'.'
'G/':,+=
#<* ?('):A
#<* 8(')'''A
#<1* 8 (') '
+A
#<E* ?(')A
#<"* 8(')A
SQ1. How is ‘impact’ de!ned?
2:(')''/'8**6
N"7&&(')
''''.
:* 2 / ' '
' K/ '
''C. 4
7&* ! ' :
:' K .
(')*
0 : >
+ (') > ' ,
'. '
K/,*2
: '
. :
*J.:/
G ' @:
'''
: :* J' :
:':/''2
&'@
M &* 2: '
>>+*0'
(-) & (
)0&(')M&(
)#M/&(./)?&(.
-) !&*# :'
(, ) & (
'') , C !&
()C&*
2 : , (') '
* 2
':+''
'*?
:::&
'
' '
:* / : '
' @ ,
* 2 K '
3-C'' &
'* 0 '
/'
'.* /'
K '- ' (:)
@&*2
'-'/'HI!M
3' ; 4* # / :
' '& '
> +>
/''.
& '> K
''*
2 ' . ' ' HI
/=#$#%&>'''*
#./:''
'
'''*
/)-34!-/
4JH!2;
9
L30!020J! #JH;43
H
I
(@
:
'
'
+
*)
P;3/.=
.
Q
'=RR***.RER'R,R
2
!
(I
'.
:.
R
:
'*)
PIH-#
#Q
'=RR**RRRR.
,R,.,
,,,,,,
! (@
:
'
'
+
*)
P''
#3FMQ
'=RR*.*RR
0 (J',
/
/'
.*)
P2-0'#
3;Q
'=RR**RRR
3;4 (@:
''
*)
P0''C
4'654Q
'=RR*'*RR
M/
P0'
:
@
'**
*
'=
:'
',
''
'*Q
P0'2!;
C4J;30!23;22;42!L
C3;MQ
'=RR**
' '
.' *2
K.('),
''(')#N%&>(')
: ' ' ,
K .*
J',/''#)'
6)'-->@(')()
()/
'@'
1&*2K::'
* / & /' HI ()
(/) () '
:'
#23,'
'/
K * ':
: (') HI (
') ' 8 ;'
'*2
K ' +:
' ;3*8
'.'
*
SQ2. What role does ‘impact’ play in relation to research grant
applications?
0'K'
' ':
* 2 '' 'G
' 2' 0&
+
'''2'00&.
>/,*2
-''''2'0
'
/' /','* 2
'G, 2' 0 : 1 ''
3';4&*2':
2'0*2
()G''
+/',:''
' ** HI ! 3;4) ?- &
/' (') ' @
'' : / '
''':.
**C0&*
0 ' :
(')
2' 0 * 2 K = :
/' ' : (:
/)'' ''
., ** (: )& '
' . . .
- .*2K
', (,') $
87&',
''
'* 2 ,
''
2'00+*2
/,*
SQ3. What role does ‘impact’ play in relation to national assessments of
research quality?
(')
K
.*02'00'
(')(',)
''2'0'
'
(')*2:
'')'
,. '/ / '
:,S,
''''*22',00'
. /,' '
G'**
(')()(./)&*0'
2' 00 *
? ' ' ' '
*00/'''
@ (') '
'*0!
(')#3
C/*2
',K*0;
+'&
, * 0
(') '
+'':
'*2HI);3''''
! ' * # M ;
?34J#2&M
; 4
/' '*
0 :
'!;L'!;L&*
'34
; ;' , !
<3;:,
'*
SQ4. How is ‘impact’ weighted?
8 2'02'00 '
/()()'*0
'','
/' > G
'*0 /'
''.,
'>'
: +* 8 ' 'G
'
()
()&* 8
'G('
)''G
() '' * J 11 /
'G ' : () '
'.21&*
/(02
L
#'2.2HI!
0M2!
&
?-M6
L.0C
M/#
?6
4;#C
3#.0
!&
0 '
'
'
&*>:'
'>''2'0
2' 00 ' :
*2''/'
',=
8 ''' ' '
'')'' * 0'
' * 0'
'G ' *2
' . ** )
&').'.
7&*
' ,
()
: ,'''
'*C@(,
')/'' ',. .
/'
'
/'* 2 ' '
' ** & G ,
' * 2
' : +
/'.,'
. L &* 2 2 ' 0 2' 00
,**
()()&,'
''','G*
-"5
#4M3J0C42##3##3!2
2'0
BCGR'
D
2'00
B!
;<D
29C3J
0C42
##3##3!2
?
B
'
D
?0
#'2.
03;4
?00HI
!
M
#
BL
D
#0
?-
6
M/
CC
3
#00
2!
&0
M?
;0
#.6
2 ' (')** ?0 ?00#0 #00& '
''
' &
' /' ' '
'*2K
##*0#
'
'
: # ; 4 "&* #
# '
! N&*
' >
'
*
0'G
( ')
'/'*2'
K'
'
'''
;3HI&*2:
*
SQ5. What incentives and sanctions are attached to the ‘impact agenda’?
H .
' / /'*
J
@ > >
'(')*(0')
& ) 6 ! HI*0
; @ '
, 'G* 9
' :
2E&*00/'
':,
'.'*&*J'
'
@/,'G&R/,'
. &* 2 ' -
'= & '' ' & 2' 00> ,
& 2' 0, ''+('
') . & ', .,
'G*2'''2E*
/6
0
&
2'00
&
2'0
&
1&
2'0
#'
0'
6&E&
43/'
/ / / / HI
/ / / !;
/ / !
M
/ / M0
/ /
/
4##
/ 0#.6
/
M/
?-2.
C6
3
?
/ / #'
// 3;40
/C
&0/'
:*
&0'R
/'HI;3!)#3FM*
1&':'
*3/'HIC0'*
E&6':'
'*3/'
(0')HI':
3#;4I3/'*
2E'(')
': ('
@)'=
&(').
&()
' '' ' ':
(')'&
' ,
''
**'' ' *&,
' ,: ('' )
' *&* 2
+(')*
0F*.7#.
2 ' /
' , (' )
> (!C;) ,
''''*
2'
. '
',:
* 0
' .
.
:'*'=
/' ,
()(:)'*2
: /' :'
'-'**;<E&
' /'
' ' # 2 &* 2
*
2:
: ' '
()(') *2,/
* 2: '
=(')'
' @ ()
''
' ,* (0'
') '' (
' )*
''
()
(')* J ' / '
.,.
' (. )
(. .,')*& 0 ,
( )
'''*
6'=
0 ''
'T
(') ()T
'' ()
*
2 K : ,
'= ' +
': ' '
+'
.:*J'
,' =(2
) )
G)*0'
(')
' . . ! C
#0&*
( ' ) ' ,
''
'
( ' ) '
' ( '
')*(!')'',
''
':*''
0 . ) B + D
A#0''
* '' 0 .
G
*
' '
- ' /'
'G
'(')*2(,,
,,,')G
/ / '
/*
2 ' '
: ,. '* J '' /'
''@
,:''*
8:/''G
'G''*
.. T 0 '
5.0:/
0 '.' 'TBD0.
)G'G.
' BD*#) .
'
''
/:'*')''
G''/':/*
'''
'') ' . '
'
,' ,
('') ()''* C
,:.
'(')*
+ ;3 HI
''&'4
$ ; 5 8 L ;G. * 7 ?343 7
6*" $% #$#%&*2
'''
(+-') #&.'
'''
/ ' '*2
'./':=
' ' '
' '
(') ',
/
@ * 2
' '' '
.,'
'*#''=
0.'G)
) * '
..
'':.'
'*#*8)
0).'''
)''*
(0.')!'''
(0'''* ! ( ' )
T*#'
, T) * '' .
' *) 3 HI '
.
G'.*2
'''
> 4 L H>
'
+* 2 '
:*
7&*0'
BD*Academy of Finland*=
'=RR*.*:RR,,,'R@,,',,
R',,,,,,:,,R
3*C*&*4.=
*C=CHC
4*7&*8)'AScience, Technology &
Human Values*1&NN>
4*;*#*5&*2''=
'''+*
British Politics*11&N">1*='=RR*R*"%REN1,
5,%%,N
4*$8;*7&*:.-
'A0'&'
''HI*Studies
in Higher Education*&>1*=
'=RR*R*5R1%"%N*7*EE5
4'*$MC*"&*2'!C
'=''*Financial
Accountability & Management*31&%,N
4#*%&*#'.*!9.=F.
L?*!#*80*5&*8P.Q
''*Journal of Health Services Research &
Policy*11&55>N*='=RR*R*"5RG'*5*5""
#*C*M*;*5&*8:/
'3'A,'
''*Research
Evaluation*17>*='=RR*R*N1RR17
L;G.#*8C**;*L*2*C*?
*7&*3'@,*
Research Evaluation*"&7>7N*=
'=RR*R*N1RR15
3L*E&*(2)/=;K
'*
06I*8!*$8#**The Science-Industry Nexus:
History, Policy, Implications*#=#?
C,17*
3-.-?*1&*;'(+,:)=
'*Research policy*1&N,
3U?*$4V#**%&*H=
''*!9.=#'
*&*#''*0?6*6
4*$**Edward Elgar International Handbook on Public–
Private Partnerships*4=33C
*1&*2*Political
Studies Review*&EN>7%*='=RR*R*RE%5,
N1*
*8*$4*7&*2',
'=.'*Evidence & Policy: A Journal of Research,
Debate and Practice*&7,%N
68**N"7&*'*The Philosophical
Quarterly71&N%,E*
62*!*8I*L?*6-C*L*
4*"&*;',=
7EHI;3/.*
BMC Medicine*11&>*='=RR*R*57RN7,",
E7%,E
6**7&*?'3'=
'*European Education*E5E&
E>"%*='=RR*R*5R"7EN1E*7*1%%1
?343*7&*C'''
;3E*'?343L#*M=?343
?M*I*M?*#;*N&*0=2
*Science and Public Policy*
17"&15%>E*='=RR*R*1"R11ENWEE1E
?4*NN&*A2'!C&*Public
Administration*7N&1>N*=
'=RR*R'=RR**RR*RG*E7%,
NNN*NN*%%N*/R'
?4*$L/;*"&*.A=
3HI6*
J/=J/HC
?M*$.6*1&*HA2'
,*0?#'*American Political Science
Review*N%&11>E
XL!*2X*N&*#.Y
GBD*Nature*N*
='=RR**RRE"57,5,%5%,
6*1&*2*M=C
M*;*H*%&*#=2/
'*Research Evaluation*7&">%*=
'=RR*R*N1RRE
C.;*&*'*Minerva*"1&11N>17*
='=RR*R*%RE,,N%,"
C4*$24**E&*H=
+*=
;
;,?!*%&*''
''*Journal for General Philosophy of Science*E5E&
"1">""*='=RR*R*%R515,%,N17,1
#6*N%&*4'''*American
Political Science Review*MW0FE&11>"1
#'*8*NN%&*6'*
'*=8C
#I*&*;',
+-'*British Journal of Sociology*7&%7>N"*
='=RR*R*RG*E75,EEE7*N*1%*/
#I*3*#3*%&*8.'=
'.)'*Journal
of Social Policy*E7&N>%*=
'=RR*R*%R#E%%NE751
#L*C4*"&*!C.*Public Management Review*
%N&1",11
#;4"&*;+#*
#.=#;4*=
'=RR**RR5*E"17E%71""R"NE5""7N15R;
,<,3,#ZJIH#ZF;Z"*'
2**1&*2@''3
=()(')(,)
'>;3*Public Management Review*"E&"%1,"51
8;*&*#(
')='HI(')
*Studies in Higher Education*1N&1"N>1%%*=
'=RR*R*5R1%"%N**%NEN
84*N%%&*;').=
*Policy Analysis*1&"1>"E"
8I*6*5&*''
''HI*
Research Evaluation*&>1*=
'=RR*R*N1RR/E
8;*%&*C
*M=C