Content uploaded by Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Zamira Hyseni Duraku on Aug 02, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
17
Chapter 1
The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-
being of teachers, parents, and students: Challenges
related to remote (online) learning and opportunities
for advancing the quality of education
Zamira Hyseni Duraku*
Linda Hoxha
Chapter Summary: The closure of educational institutions as a preventive
measure against the spread of COVID-19 has aected the educational systems in the
world. While the process of shifting learning to an online format has already become
common to many educational institutions worldwide, several factors are assumed to
aect the quality of remote or online learning, teachers’ performance, and students’
knowledge and skills. This chapter presents the research ndings on the impact of
COVID-19 on education and the well-being of teachers, parents, and students by
listing the challenges relating to remote online learning. Semi-structured interviews
were conducted with (n=13) parents and (n=11) teachers from pre-university public
institutions within 14 municipalities, from seven regions of Kosovo. Findings from
the study show that the circumstances created by COVID-19 have caused a great deal
of concern among students, parents and teachers about assessment, distance learning
inadequacy, and student overload., Opportunities to advance the quality of education,
the support of teachers, parents, and families, coupled with practical suggestions for
parties involved in the eld of education are also included.
Keywords: COVID-19, Remote learning, Challenges, Opportunities
Introduction
More than 1 billion and 575 million students in approximately 188 countries around
the world are reported to have been aected by the closure of schools and universities
due to preventive measures taken by countries against the spread of COVID-19
(UNESCO, 2020a). Due to isolation, the use of technology has been considered the
most appropriate (if not the only) alternative to keep educational systems functional in
* Corresponding author: Zamira Hyseni Duraku, Associate Professor, Department of Psychology, Faculty of Philosophy,
University of Prishtina, Hasan Prishtina. Address: Eqrem Çabej # 21, 10000, Prishtinë, Kosovë, email: zamira.
hyseni@uni-pr.edu, ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8268-3962
18
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
many parts of the world during this period. Despite the challenges in implementation,
several advantages have been acknowledged in the need to shift to remote or online
learning, among which stands out the opportunity for rapid progress in the eld of
digital education, which, in other circumstances, would take years (UNESCO, 2020b).
The shift to the remote learning format has also been assessed as a good opportunity
for teachers and students to become more creative (UNESCO, 2020b).
The spread of COVID-19 has also caused fear, anxiety and other concerns to
citizens in dierent parts of the world, including groups engaged in the educational
process, such as children, teachers and parents (NCIRD, 2020). Parents’ concerns,
apart from circumstances created due to physical distancing and other personal factors,
are presumed to have been inuenced by: an unwillingness to support their children
in distance/online learning or home learning; the lack of access to technology and
the Internet or the inadequacy of the technological formats used for children with
special educational needs; economic hardship (UNESCO, 2020b). It was noted that
the concerns of teachers engaged in the learning process were related to opportunities
to conduct remote/online learning due to their level of knowledge and skills in the
use of technology, access to technology and isolation at home (UNESCO, 2020a).
Such concerns have been reported in particular by countries in which, prior to the
circumstances created by the preventive measures against the spread of COVID-19, the
level of use of technology by teachers in the classroom has been declared extremely
low (UNESCO, 2020b). In addition, the demands to shift teaching to the online format
have also been reported to have increased the level of stress and anxiety of teachers
in dierent parts of the world (UNESCO, 2020).
Factors inuencing the quality of teaching and online learning
Although the shift to online learning has already become part of many education
systems in the world, the level of use and the way technology is used to achieve the
quality of distance or online learning is considered to vary. This level depends on many
factors, related to the various parties involved in the implementation of this learning
format and the integration of technology in education systems before the school closure
period as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. For years, numerous studies around the
world have focused on identifying factors that make technology integration successful
in classroom teaching and learning. The same factors are assumed to inuence the level
of use of technology in the processes of shifting learning from school to a distance or
online format, and the quality of learning in both formats. According to the ndings
of studies conducted so far, through which it was intended to identify the factors
inuencing the ability of educational systems to integrate technology in teaching, it
is suggested that to achieve positive results in the integration of teaching technology,
19
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
it is required to understand the types of interchanges between teachers, students, and
technology (Honey et al., 2000). In the group of factors inuencing opportunities to
successfully integrate technology into the classroom and make it part of the learning
process, it has been suggested that the teachers’ perspective on teaching has an impact.
This means that it depends on whether the teachers consider the learning process:
- as a process of information transfer, or use the teacher-centered approach, within
which the teacher communicates information to students and uses various assessment
techniques to assess the memorization of data;
- as a process through which conceptual change is achieved (e.g. change of attitudes,
knowledge, way of thinking) and/or see learning as a process that facilitates conceptual
change, and therefore use the student-centered approach, where independence in
learning is driven through discussions, debates, and questions among students, and
by the forms of assessment through which conceptual change is assessed (Prosser &
Trigwell, 1999).
The same factors related to teachers’ perspectives on teaching methodology, which
have proven to inuence the level of technology integration in the classroom, are
also expected to have an impact on the successful implementation of online learning,
since the shift from school to the online format incorporates the concept of “exible
learning.” According to this concept, regardless of whether they are online, the
applied teaching methodologies should aim to stimulate learning and independence
among the students, and the courses should be designed with the aim of supporting
their individual needs (Huang et al. 2020). Therefore the student-centered approach
is considered the main component of exible learning (Lundin, 1999).
It has been proven that changes in education can be associated with a number of
other factors, both when this change occurs due to preventive measures against the
spread of pandemics, as well as when it is part of reforms within the educational
system. Therefore, until change is dened as the creation of something unusual and
involves everything that is dierent from the norm (Flamholtz & Randle, 2008), the
request for change may not be readily accepted by the parties seeking the change,
and may be meet with resistance. Studies in the eld of education have proven that
the highest level of resistance to change occurs within groups that lack interest in
change, abstain from cooperation, and wish to maintain their status quo (Ibrahim et al.,
2013). These studies analyzed the group of factors that can aect the implementation
of educational changes and, in particular, when it was required to develop the skills
and knowledge of educational leaders, teachers, and students (Ibrahim et al., 2013).
Meanwhile, researchers such as Palmer et al. (2009) have pointed out several other
factors that can encourage or discourage people to adapt to changes, such as: security,
economic conditions, authority, status, responsibility, working conditions, level of
self-satisfaction, or the time and dedication needed to implement the change.
20
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Other studies link factors inuencing teachers’ resistance to change to psychological,
personal, school-related, and organizational factors. According to a study that analyzed
the psychological factors that can aect teachers’ ability to be part of the change,
teachers report discomfort, feeling lost, and experiencing doubt and worry when
they depart from what they know and what makes them feel comfortable, and move
toward something that is unusual and uncomfortable (Flamholtz & Randle, 2008;
Ibrahim et al., 2013). Other group factors that have been found to inuence teachers’
resistance to change are teachers’ stress, accumulated fatigue, and mental exhaustion,
which, in addition to making them resistant to change, can also negatively aect their
performance and level of job satisfaction (Margolis & Nagel, 2006).
Regarding the group of personal factors (in particular, factors identied as inuencing
the level of rejection or acceptance of changes in the educational system), the following
are mentioned in the literature: attitudes of the educational sta toward changes, level
of adaptation opportunities and trust in change of the educational sta, age of teachers
and appropriate time to incorporate new approaches into their work methodologies
(Flamholtz and Randle 2008), and the discrepancies teachers have in relation to the
proposed strategies of change (Van Veen and Sleegers 2006). The level of commitment
that teachers have with children/students and parents, has also been identied as a
contributing factor to the level of rejection or acceptance of change (McKenzie and
Scheurich, 2008). Factors related to school, or school culture, include: how norms
and values are formed, how work is organized, how interpersonal relationships are,
and how the need for change is interpreted by the school. These are other factors that
are supposed to inuence teachers’ perceptions of change, adaptation, or rejection
(Per & Kitson, 2004). Moreover, the success of distance or online learning has been
proven to be inuenced by the way instruction is provided and the level of clarication,
access and appropriateness of technological equipment, time, motivation and support
to participate in online learning (Ibrahim et al., 2013).
Positive eects of technology on learning processes
The eects of the use of technology in educational institutions have been researched
many years ago by researchers in the eld of education, through which it has been
proven and promoted that technology can help in various educational processes (Hung
& Yyen, 2010), it can have a positive impact on supporting learning in students (Dyson
et al., 2015), it can assist teachers, and aid them in professional advancement and
development (Donelan, 2016; Manca & Raineri, 2017). Therefore, the integration
of technology in the classroom has been promoted and supported for many years
now in dierent countries of the world (Cope & Ward, 2002). The development of
information and communications technology (ICT) and its utilization in learning
processes has enabled learning to become more open and teaching methodologies to
21
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
become more exible, thus making students more independent and self-determined,
becoming responsible for learning (Goode et al., 2007), gaining self-regulating
abilities in relation to goal setting, and becoming self-monitoring and adaptable.
Such opportunities also allow teachers to promote active learning so that learning is
engaging and eective (Collis 1998), which makes them facilitators of the learning
process (Huang et al. 2020;) and exempts them from the responsibilities of teaching
alone by giving students responsibilities as well (Goode, 2007).
The closure of schools and the organization of distance (online)
learning in Kosovo
The preventive measures announced by the Government of Kosovo against the
spread of COVID-19 on March 11, 2020, have aected the lives and education of
approximately 450, 146 students and 30, 528 teachers/professors in the country
(Kosovo Agency of Statistics 2017, 2019; MESTI, 2020c). Days later, the Ministry of
Education, Science, Technology and Innovation (MESTI) in cooperation with other
actors, including education directorates at the municipal level and non-governmental
organizations, began planning distance learning for children of certain age groups,
and for particular subjects (language and mathematics). Weeks later, distance learning
for public pre-university education began with video recordings broadcasted on the
national television, through which selected teachers, for the subjects of Albanian
language and mathematics, presented lessons for students in grades 1-5. Furthermore,
in the framework of the plans of the Ministry of Education, Science, Technology and
Innovation, for the further planning of distance learning, the tasks and responsibilities
for the realization of learning were published, through which the role of each party
engaged in educational institutions in the country was specied (MESTI, 2020b)
The organization of the pre-university system, quality of
education, and integration of technology in teaching
The public pre-university system in Kosovo is organized into 1,094 public pre-university
educational institutions, of which 44 are preschool institutions, 921 are primary/lower
secondary schools, 123 are upper secondary schools, and six are special schools/resource
centers. The total number of students in public pre-university education is reported to be
approximately 345,540, while the total number of educational sta is 28,150, of whom
23,234 are regular teachers, while 3,350 are support sta (MESTI, 2020).
According to data from the strategic plans of the Ministry of Education, Science,
Technology and Innovation, the quality of education in Kosovo has been accompanied by
a number of obstacles, which may be even more apparent and hinder distance or online
22
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
learning, including the performance of teachers and students during the realization of
teaching in this format. According to the ndings from the evaluation of the strategic
education plan for 2011-2016, it is emphasized that despite the developments for teacher
retraining, work still needs to be done to ensure that teachers reach the minimum
qualication standards. Furthermore, within the same assessment, it is noted that
only 40% of teachers engaged in the education system in Kosovo have the necessary
qualications according to the administrative instructions in force for teaching, and that
only 57% of teachers currently engaged in the education system have attended training
in the use of technology (ECDL). In addition, schools have little access to information
and communication technology (ICT) and technology was not suciently and adequately
incorporated into the curriculum, teaching or management of education, although this
was planned to happen during the period of 2011-2016. However, although in this report
there is no assessment that documents the level of achievement after this period, it is
emphasized that the integration of information and communication technology in the
education system will continue to be a priority within future education strategies. On
the contrary, the lack of technology inclusion in the classroom will aect the future of
students (MESTI, 2015). The low level of ICT integration into the teaching process in
pre-university education in Kosovo has also been reported in other studies conducted
in the country. For example, the report by the Kosovo Pedagogical Institute reported
that 38.9% of teachers participating in this study have a sucient level of computer
literacy (Mexhuani, KPI, 2015). Among the participants who use technology in their
classes, 25.6% reported using it to illustrate or shape teaching content, 17.1% to consult
scholastic literature, 13.4% to prepare and present various teaching topics using pictures
and tables, and 6% to convey new methods in the eld of teaching and drafting various
projects, for providing additional information. Nevertheless, it was also observed that
a very large percentage of teachers participating in this study do not use technology to
stimulate learning in their students, due to: their negative attitudes about the importance
of classroom technology; doubts about students’ ability to use technology, emphasizing
that students do not have a computer at home; considering that a book is sucient to
achieve the desired results; students’ economic conditions; and due to students’ lack of
knowledge of computer use for learning purposes. In addition, among the total number
of participants, the group of teachers who teach English language and mathematics
reported higher levels of technological literacy (Mexhuani, 2015).
Opportunities to advance the integration of technology in teaching
Although the insucient inclusion of technology in the learning processes is
documented by the evaluation of the strategic education plan for the period of 2011-
2016 and the ndings of previous studies, within the strategic education plan for the
period of 2017-2021, there are objectives through which the aim is to advance of the
23
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
quality of education, which can contribute to the advancement of online learning or
the integration of technology in teaching, and the further professional development
of teachers. Participation and inclusion aims to increase, include and provide equal
opportunities for development, training, and education of all individuals within pre-
university education; Teacher professional development, which aims to improve
the quality of teaching, and contribute to the implementation of reforms, which are
expected to aect the improvement of learning outcomes in students. Furthermore,
another objective of this strategic plan is teaching and learning, through which it
aims to maximize the quality of teaching and implementation of curriculum-based
competencies. Within the same objective, among others, is specied the necessity for
the creation of electronic teaching materials, which are in line with the curriculum
(MESTI, 2016). In the same strategy it is assumed that the development of technology
over the next ve years will take on other dimensions and, although they cannot be
predicted, the strategic education plan may change in order to make the integration
more rapid information and communication technology in school (MESTI, 2016).
Another contributing factor to the successful implementation of distance or online
learning in Kosovo is the relatively high number of citizens in Kosovo who use
technology. According to the ndings from previous studies conducted in recent years,
about 76.6% of citizens in Kosovo are Internet users. However, the use of the Internet
has been reported to be primarily for entertainment purposes (social media). These
same ndings report that the largest number of Internet users comes from rural areas,
low-income families (whose income is less than 200 euros per month), and citizens
with secondary education. As for the age group, the highest levels of use have been
reported by young people aged 10 to 19 and 20 to 29, while the lowest levels were
found in the age group of over 30 years of age. In addition, 65.14% of participants
reported having Internet at home, while 94.21% reported that they use the Internet
the most at home. Participants who declared themselves unemployed also reported
having more technological devices (smartphones) in possession than the employed
population (STIKK, 2013).
Existing ndings from previous research within the eld of psychology and
education conrm that factors related to education quality and technology use can
inuence the switching of the educational system from traditional to remote/online
learning. Therefore, the quality of pre-university education in Kosovo and the
insucient level of technology integration in the teaching processes are expected
to aect the implementation and process of distance/online learning in the country.
However, there is no scientic evidence to measure the impact of COVID-19 on
the circumstances of education and well-being of Kosovar citizens. Therefore, to
ll this gap, the purpose of this study was to explore and describe the concerns of
parents and teachers regarding the circumstances caused by quarantine, physical
24
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
distancing and the perspective of teachers and parents regarding distance or online
learning. The ndings from this study, which present the perspectives of teachers
and parents, together with the ndings from the studies of other countries that
analyze the factors inuencing the quality of educational systems and the use of
technology, are foreseen to assist in the advancement of educational systems, the
adaptation of education strategies, and the further organization of online learning
so that the methods implemented have positive and long-term eects on all the
parties and beneciaries of the educational institutions involved. Therefore, these
ndings can be of great value to policymakers, educational leaders, and teachers.
The ndings and practical implications of this study can also greatly benet mental
health professionals and school psychologists, who can provide emotional support,
increase motivation, improve attitudes toward change, and support the advancement
of knowledge of sustainable educational skills of each beneciary of the education
system. Furthermore, the ndings of this study can serve as a starting point for future
studies that can assist other educational systems, in particular those of countries
with low and medium economic development (which Kosovo is also a part of), in
overcoming diculties in reforming education systems.
Methodology
Research approach: This study used a qualitative research design. To explore the
impact of COVID-19 circumstances (eg: physical distance and school closure) on
teachers, parents and children, a descriptive phenomenological research approach
has been used1.
Participants: Participants: Semi-structured interviews were used for data collection,
with n=13 parents, and n=11 teachers. Participants for this study were selected using
convenience sampling. All teachers and parents who at the time of the interview were
involved or had children within the public pre-university education institutions, grades
1-9, in dierent cities of Kosovo had the right to participate in the study. Throughout
the contact period, participants were informed of the purpose of the study, that their
participation was voluntary and that they could withdraw from the process at any
time. No participants withdrew from the interview process. To protect the participants’
condentiality, all data through which their identities could be revealed were removed.
The data collection process lasted from March 20 to April 1, 2020. In addition to the
areas explored, the general characteristics of the participants were collected during
the initial part of the interviews.
1 Descriptive phenomenology is based on the philosophical work of Husserl (Husserl, 1970), an approach, which
explores the effects of a new phenomenon (eg: COVID-19). It is very important to study the experiences (in this
case of teachers, parents and children) to reach an essential understanding of the phenomenon (Dowling, 2007).
25
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
Of the total number of teachers (n = 11): nine were women, two men, with work
experience of 15.4 years on average (see Table 1.1).
Table 1.1 Data on participants – Teachers
n %
Gender Women 9 81.81
Men 2 18.18
Level of Education Associate’s Degree 1 9.09
Bachelor’s Degree 9 81.81
Master’s Degree 1 9.09
Average number of students in class N11
Average 25.4
Years of work experience as a teacher N11
Average 15.4
Age N11
Average 41.9
All participants in the capacity of parents (n = 13) were women with an average age of 36 years. Of the total
number of parents, ve held a bachelor’s degree. The majority were unemployed (n=8), while the average number
of children in their families was 2.5 (see Table 1.2).
Table 1.2 Data on participants – Parents
n %
Gender Women 13 100
Men 0 0
Level of education High school 4 30.7
Associate’s Degree 1 7.6
Bachelor’s Degree 5 38.46
Master’s Degree 3 23.07
26
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Average number of children in the family N 13
Average 2.5
Employment situation Employed 5 36.4
Unemployed 8 61.5
Age N 13
Average 36
Geographical distribution of participants: The participating teachers are currently
engaged in public pre-university institutions from grades 1 through 8, in dierent
cities of Kosovo: (n = 3) in Prishtinë and the others in Fushë Kosova, Lipjan, Ferizaj,
Mitrovica, Peja, Deçan, Gjakova, and Prizren (see Table 1.3). Participating parents
had children in public pre-university institutions from grades 1 through 8 in dierent
cities of Kosovo: (n = 4) in Prishtinë, (n = 2) in Ferizaj, (n = 2) in Suhareka, and others
in Gjilan, Istog, Peja, Fushë Kosovë, Podujevë, and Suharekë.
Procedure: Interviews were conducted by students in the Department of Psychology
of the University of Prishtina “Hasan Prishtina”: Master’s Program in School
Psychology and Counseling, within the course of “Learning and Motivation”. The
students engaged in data collection had prior knowledge and skills related to interview
procedures, ethical principles, and the subject researched. Prior to the data collection
process, students were informed in detail, by the course supervisor, about the interview
format, purpose, research areas, procedures to be followed, data transcription, and
the research design. As physical contact with the interviewees was impossible due to
isolation, interviews were conducted online. Each individual interview lasted between
45 minutes to one hour.
Semi-structured interviews with teachers: The interviews cover 7 areas 1) the
level of technology use by teachers before the COVID-19 pandemic; 2) methods of
implementing classroom learning before the COVID-19 pandemic; 3) the level of
teachers’ concerns; 4) methods of implementing online learning and student assessment;
5) assessment of distance learning, challenges and opportunities in Kosovo; 6) attitudes
towards distance or online learning; and 7) the level of motivation of teachers to
implement online learning.
Semi-structured interviews with parents: These interviews covered eight main
topics: 1) changes and concerns observed in children during isolation; 2) the impact
of change on family concerns; 3) mastery of technological equipment (students); 4)
27
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
learning methods followed by children; parent-teacher communication; 5) children’s
reactions to distance or online learning; 6) the type of parental engagement with
children while they stayed at home and during children’s online learning; and 7) the
impact of parental engagement on online learning and isolation.
Data processing: Data was analyzed through the Atlas.it software. The data were
collected through semi-structured interviews. The data were analyzed through classical
content analysis2, which is based on content analysis and coding of certain parts of
the material, continuing with the collection of similar codes in clusters. The coding
process for the responses was done with in-vivo coding, through which categories
and codes for each category were generated. During the coding, it was ensured that
the codes result in all interviews, substantive dierentiation was made between the
codes, and the frequency of each code was quantied (quantitative information). In
order to better understand, descriptive memos were also used for certain codes, which
claried how to code. The process of data analysis, coding, was done individually
by two coders. After nalization, the categories of responses and dierences were
discussed in detail, and after reaching agreement, a randomly selected a third coder,
who was generally informed on the main topic and areas of study, coded interviews.
The reliability rate for this study turned out to be acceptable (81.0%).
Results
The following results reect ndings from the perspectives of teachers and parents,
by areas explored. In addition to the narrative description, the ndings are accompanied
by excerpts from the interviews, and processed data, presented in tabular form. The
ndings listed within the codes and subcodes are derived from the classical analysis of
the content of the interviews, and are ranked according to the frequency of information
identied among the interviews.
Level of use of technology by teachers before the COVID-19
period
Teachers, participants in the study, stated that they did not have any previous
experience in conducting distance or online learning. Most of the participants
also stated that until the precautionary measures against the spread of COVID-19,
communication with colleagues on school issues and conveyance of information
from the school was done via verbal communication or by phone (including Viber).
2 Content analysis is “any technique used, which results in conclusions, objectively and systematically identifying
the specied characteristics of messages/texts” (Holsti, 1969 in Stemler, 2000).
28
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
A relatively small number of them have stated that they possess ocial emails and
that they use them for school matters. They also stated that they communicated with
parents through daily meetings, parent-teacher conferences, individual meetings or
via telephone communication.
“All information from the school was transmitted verbally while in school-hours, in some
cases through phone calls, but never via electronic mail, emails. Also, communication
with parents was done through joint meetings with them, before or after school hours,
or by phone (including communication on Viber). (# 1, teacher).
Of the total number of teachers, a small number of them (n = 4) stated that they
have attended technology training. Among the most frequent trainings is ECDL,
which is also considered helpful during the implementation of online learning. The
use of technology is considered to be a problem for teachers, parents and students.
“Teachers, parents, and students have signicant problems with the use of ICT.” (#4, Teacher).
“The online technology training, ECDL, helped me implement online lessons.” (#10,
Teacher).
Prior to the COVID-19 period, technology for teaching matters was used by a relatively
small number of teachers. However, the use of technology is stated to have been made
solely for the purpose of retaining information or researching teaching materials:
“In addition to textbooks, I also use information from the Internet.” (#7, teacher).
Methods of lesson implementation before the COVID-19
pandemic
The teachers participating in the study stated that they use a certain format for the
implementation of lessons following a similar structure of the implementation of the
online format through which students have an active role during learning. They also
reported that, as part of their commitments, they have individualized education plans
for students with special educational needs.
“Before the COVID-19 pandemic, I based my lessons on three main phases: introduction,
realization of understanding, and reection. In addition, interaction with students was a
essential criterion of the lessons.” (#4, teacher)
“Evocation, realization of understanding, and reection.” (#9, teacher)
“Each student has their own individualized education plans along with relevant commitments
and activities, as well as comments that follow their implementation.” (#12, teacher)
29
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
Level of teachers’ concerns
The participating teachers stated that the circumstances created by COVID-19, at-
home isolation, and the changes associated with the organization of the lessons made
them feel anxious, uncomfortable, confused, insecure, and overloaded (see Table 1.3).
Table 1.3 Level of teachers’ concerns
Codes Subcodes
Level of concerns Worry, discomfort regarding lesson implementation or student
assessment through online classes
Increased confusion regarding student assessment
Uncertainty
Overload of information related to online learning
Methods of implementing online learning and student
assessment
According to this study’s ndings, teachers use a variety of alternatives to conduct
remote or online learning, including virtual learning (Google Meet and Zoom), task
compilation, and placement of materials in Google Classroom. Teachers stated that
they use Viber and WhatsApp to communicate with students and parents. In fact,
these applications are especially used for the delivery and assessment of students’
learning tasks.
While in relation to assessment methods, dierent alternatives which have been
used by teachers were presented. According to statements from teachers, the most
frequent assessment of student performance was done through homework assessment.
However, in the context of planning for ongoing assessments, teachers emphasize that
they had combined assessment methods planned (see Table 1.4).
Table 1.4 Methods of online learning implementation and student assessment
Codes Subcodes
Method of conducting remote/
online learning by teachers Compilation of tasks from the curriculum in
combination with virtual learning (Zoom and
Google Meet)
Google Classroom Platform
Giving homework to students every work day
Making classroom groups (on Viber)
Communication for homework is carried out
through parents (Viber and WhatsApp)
30
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Method of student assessment
during remote/online learning At present
Homework assessment (submission of homework on
Viber)
Assessment – through homework
Homework assessment for every lesson (by e-mail)
Assessment of homework with stickers (rst grade)
Assessment with a grade in the basis of percentage
per homework submitted
Planned for the future
Assessment will be made through communication,
online homework, and tests (presentations,
homework, and online tests)
Creating online tests
Assessment of students through a dossier that will
compile their work throughout this period
Individual assessment throughout the
implementation of lessons on an online platform
(Zoom)
Teachers’ evaluation of remote or online learning, challenges,
and opportunities
According to the teachers, the factors that may have aected the quality of the
implementation of online education, namely planning for the learning process, relate
to organizational factors, including inadequate level of cooperation from the school
management and precarious organization in the distribution of information to teachers.
However, they also stressed that, during this period, there has been proper cooperation
between teachers. Regarding the lessons broadcast by public television, they express
skepticism, consider the format short and vague, and state that the lessons presented
are not in accordance with the curriculum oered by them at schools.
Furthermore, in the context of potential concerns about remote or online learning,
the teachers express doubts about the technical issues that can hinder the process,
show concern about whether this form will be accepted by students, and point out
that student participation is low. Other concerns refer to their confusion about how
students will be assessed.
Meanwhile, for teachers, an ongoing challenge for remote or online learning will
be the large number of students, frequent communication with parents, and students’
diculty in using technological devices. However, they suggest that, in order to
advance online learning, teachers need to raise the level of their knowledge and skills
31
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
in technology, and the level of interactions with students should also increase over
the course of online learning (see Table 1.5).
Table 1.5 Teachers’ evaluation of remote (or online) learning
Codes Subcodes
Organizational factors:
Evaluation of school planning
and collaboration in regards to
distance or online learning
Inadequate level of cooperation with school
management
Proper cooperation between teachers
Weak organization of information distribution to
teachers
Good organization
Assessment of lessons
broadcasted on public television Skepticism about lessons compiled from MESTI
Lessons from MESTI are short and unclear
Units broadcast on TV are not in accordance with the
curricula previously implemented
Concerns related to future
remote or online learning Technical issues
Concerns about whether the format will be accepted by
students
Low student participation
With regard to assessment:
Confusion about student assessment at the end of the
semester
Added confusion with regard to student assessment
Challenges Large number of students
Frequent communication with parents
Online learning as a challenge
Students have diculties using ICT
Opportunities and
recommendations Need for technology training
More frequent interaction with students
Attitudes toward remote or online learning
Teachers consider remote or online learning as an advantage that enables them to
be more exible, as well as a process that will distract students from the pandemic
and keep them engaged with the ow of lessons. However, they see it as useless for
students with special educational needs (see Table 1.6).
32
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Table 1.6 Attitudes toward remote or online learning
Codes Subcodes
Attitudes towards online
learning Schedule exibility is an advantage of online learning
Online learning is child-friendly
Online learning helps to distract students from the
pandemic
Online learning helps students to engage with lessons
Online learning is useless for children with special
educational needs
“… such a form of online learning is not useful for learning new study units. This form of learning only helps
to reinforce retention of previous study units, but not in understanding a new study unit. Given the fact that
children in my class need more supervision, online learning does not give me complete condence of their proper
engagement.” (#12, teacher)
Teachers’ motivation level to implement remote or online
learning
The largest number of teachers have stated that they are motivated to continue
with the realization of distance or online learning, and as a contributing factor to have
inuenced this motivation is the expression of gratitude and thanks from the students’
families. However, in the group of risk factors, which have been observed to have
inuenced their lack of motivation, is the lack of physical presence of students and
the suspicions that the results from learning in this format will not be the same as
from in-school learning (see table 1.7).,
Table 1.7 Level of motivation of teachers and inuential factors
Codes Subcodes
Teachers’ motivation in
implementing remote/online
learning and contributing
factors
Motivated
Unmotivated
Risk Factors
Absence of physical presence of students
Results from lessons will not be the same
Supporting Factors
Gratitude and acknowledgments from the students’
families
Support from schools
“The part that inuences demotivation the most is the fact that, no matter how hard I try, the learning outcomes
will not be the same as they would be in school settings. I am afraid that teachers’ shortcomings will negatively
aect students.” (#3, teacher).
“Support from the school principal and school management, in parallel with the provision of clear guidelines for
teachers, results in increased levels of job satisfaction and willingness to contribute to online teaching.” (#5, teacher).
33
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
Students’ (children’s) concerns per the perspective of parents
The results of the study highlight the level of concerns and other changes in students
(children) and families. From the parents’ perspective, during the period of isolation,
it was observed that children had changes in behavior, were scared (showed signs
of panic), desperate, stressed, frightened, anxious, confused and passive. Various
changes and levels of anxiety have also been observed within the family, including
increased burden and worry levels, increased fear, pressure, and changes in sleep
rhythms (see Table 1.8).
Table 1.8 Concerns of children (students) and family (parents)
Codes Subcodes
Changes and concerns observed in
children during isolation Frustrated
In panic
Passive
Stressed
Distressed
Scared
Concerned
Confused
Changes and concerns in families Worried about children because of the halt of
other activities
Insomnia
Overload
Fear
Pressure
Parents also report an increased burden on children and their coping with this
situation, where they are expected to do their best in lessons, while everything around
them has changed – and fear, frustration and insecurity for the near future prevail. In
addition, a large part of the impact on children is the impossibility of personal space
and activities that are only theirs, where in normal conditions going to school and
contact with peers made this possible.
“…my daughters have been showing feelings of fear …” ( #8, mother).
“…children on the other hand are very frustrated that they can’t go out and that they
have to do homework all the time.” (Interview #1, mother).
“The emotional state of the child is impacted a lot by the quarantine, and this causes
pressure on parenting and presents as an impossibility to calm the children about the
current situation.” (Interview #11, mother).
34
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Possession of technological equipment
According to the study ndings, students possess sucient technological equipment
to attend online school. In most cases, parents have stated that their children have more
than 1 (one) technological device, which they can use to participate in online learning.
“…Children have special (technological) devices that they can use to complete school
tasks, such as phones, iPads, computers, or laptops…” (#5, mother).
“…Children own technological devices – phones, laptops and iPads.” (#1, mother).
Methods of participation in distance or online classes and
reactions of students and parents
According to parents, most children have participated in remote learning through
lessons broadcast on public television. Some of them have also followed online lessons
with teachers, on online platforms, and/or on Viber, in addition to watching classes on
television. Meanwhile, parents’ communication with teachers has been done mainly
through Viber, email, or Skype.
From the parents’ perspective, carrying out remote and online learning and staying
at home has had a positive eect, as they have become able to distract themselves
from the pandemic situation, and spend quality time with their children. However,
parents have perceived that their children (students) do not see online learning as an
obligation and are dissatised. In addition, the change in learning has led to additional
commitments for parents, both in monitoring children during online learning and in
communicating with teachers. They also stressed that commitments to their children’s
lessons and homework have become a burden for them (see Table 1.9).
Table 1.9 Methods of participation in online learning, parents’ engagement, and
reactions toward learning
Codes Subcodes
Learning method followed by
children Remote learning, study units on public television
Online learning with teacher on dierent platforms
(Zoom, Google Meet, Skype)
Communication with teachers on Viber
Method of communication
between parents and teachers Smartphone apps (Viber, WhatsApp)
Email
Skype
35
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
Children’s reactions in
regards to remote/online
learning
Children are dissatised
Children do not consider lesson attendance as an
obligation
The type of parental
engagement throughout
children’s online learning and
at-home stay
Dierent activities with children including their
preferences
Communication with teachers (for children’s homework)
Psychological and emotional support for children
Eects of parental
engagement throughout the
implementation of online
learning and isolation
Positive:
Distract from the pandemic situation
Spent quality time with their children
Negative:
Overburden from the educational process, homework aid,
and arrangements in regards to their children’s learning
Another important factor that has resulted from the analysis of interviews is the
level of diculty of homework with regard to dealing with online learning and the
work of parents with their children at home.
“If the homework is not in my eld of expertise and my daughter is stuck with it, I seek
help from another family member (e.g., the girl’s grandmother).”( #1, mother).
Parents’ assessment and recommendations for the
implementation of remote or online learning
Parents claimed that several challenges and advantages accompany the process
of conducting remote or online learning. According to them, the short duration of the
class, the ambiguity of the homework, the asynchrony of the teaching units broadcast
on television with the classes attended by students at school, the lack of other subjects
besides basic ones, the home environment, the level of parental education, and the lack
of physical conditions (separate rooms) are factors that have hindered the quality of
teaching. However, they also considered the organization of remote learning and the
speed of its implementation an advantage, and recommend that, during the development
of online learning, it would be important to improve the interaction between teachers
and parents, improve online learning, provide better explanations for assignments,
and clarify student assessment methods (see Table 1.10).
36
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Table 1.10 Parents’ assessment and recommendations for the implementation of
remote/online learning
Codes Subcodes
Parents assessment in regards to
methods of implementation for
remote/online learning
Challenges:
Duration (short) of classes on TV
Classes on RTK are not clear, the homework is not
seen clearly enough
TV broadcast lessons are not synchronized with
children’s learning up until now
Other classes are missing
Home environment has sometimes hindered the
attendance of remote or online learning
Parents’ level of education
Physical conditions – absence of separate rooms for
children
Tools for work
Advantages
Online/Virtual learning was welcome
The rapid response of MESTI and schools - to be
appreciated
Recommendations to improve
quality of remote (online)
learning
Better interaction between teachers and parents
Online learning needs to be improved
Clarication of homework
Explanation of how assessment will be done
Common ndings between the two groups – teachers and
parents
During the execution of the classical content analysis of the two target groups,
some common ndings have resulted which are indicative of the strong presence of
these factors in this situation. Assessment of children’s learning during this semester,
concern and overload, and assessment of learning achieved so far are three factors
that result in greater frequency in both target groups.
“…what will be done in regard to assessment?”(#4, mother).
“One aspect that I am confused about is the assessment of students at the end of the
semester. Although I keep notes on student engagement, I need to meet with a few other
teachers to decide on how to evaluate them.” (#1, teacher).
“Responsibilities and commitment to children are ongoing; however, in the current
situation, the responsibility is even greater, especially in supporting them psychologically
and emotionally.” (#6, parent).
37
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
“…all teachers are facing their own uncertainties, perhaps because they were not prepared
and had never imagined themselves under these circumstances.” (#3, teacher).
“The broadcast on RTK is far behind what was taught to children at school or vice versa:
lessons from RTK are further along and children have not yet reached these lessons.”
(#3, parent).
“…The lessons presented on national television are in a much shorter format and there
is a lack of teacher-student interactivity.” (#2, parent).
“The units that are being presented on television by MESTI are not in accordance with
the curriculum previously implemented by the school.” (#3, teacher).
Conclusions
The ndings of this study conrm that social isolation and the new circumstances
created against the spread of COVID-19, including changes in education, have caused
a number of concerns for children, parents, and teachers in Kosovo. These changes
are in line with expectations that the spread of COVID-19 would cause fear, anxiety,
and other concerns among citizens around the world (International Federation of Red
Cross and Red Crescent Societies, 2020).
Furthermore, these circumstances, which have inuenced the changes in the
engagement of teachers, parents, and students are conrmed to have inuenced both
parents’ and teachers’ overburden. However, as highlighted by other countries, these
concerns have also been aected by other changes, including the impact of COVID-19
in the eld of education and inexperience or lack of preparation of teachers and parents
to support students or their children in remote or online learning – also inuenced by the
inadequacy of the methods used for online learning to the individual needs of students
(UNESCO, 2020a). In addition, these results conrm that, as in other countries of the
world, knowledge of the use of technology and the demand for change, in conjunction
with the circumstances caused by COVID-19, can bring on a number of concerns,
including increased stress and teacher anxiety (UNESCO, 2020b).
However, despite the declared changes and concerns, the early implementation
of remote and online learning has been conrmed to have been positively assessed
during this period, keeping students engaged and distracting them from the pandemic.
In addition, while increasing parental responsibilities, home isolation is considered
valuable and inuential in raising the level of quality and productive time among
family members.
The ndings of this study conrm the implementation of remote and online
learning and demonstrate the eorts of teachers and students to engage in the learning
processes. The ndings also show that most students have no problems with possessing
the technological equipment needed for online learning (including smartphones,
computers, laptops, and iPads) that can negatively inuence their participation in
38
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
online educational processes. In addition to indicating the possibility of eective
implementation of online learning and the integration of technology into teaching,
this fact also reconrms the ndings of previous studies that emphasize that about
76.6% of citizens in Kosovo are Internet users and that families in Kosovo, despite
their income, housing area, level of education, and other socioeconomic factors, have
sucient technological equipment (STIKK, 2013).
Similar to previous studies, which measured personal, psychological and organizational
factors inuencing the successful participation of teachers in change, in this case in the
implementation of online learning, in Kosovar teachers too, the demand for change is
observed to be accompanied by a range of personal, psychological, and organizational
factors (Flamholtz & Randle, 2008 in Ibrahim et al., 2013). According to the results,
teachers’ attitudes towards change are inuenced by lack of experience in distance or
online learning, insucient level of skills and knowledge related to the use of technology,
lack of clear instructions for putting online teaching into practice and lack of cooperation.
These factors have been shown to bring anxiety, overload, and insecurity to teachers,
in addition to further raising their stress levels, making them feel tired or mentally
exhausted, increasing their level of resistance to change, hindering their performance
and reducing their level of job satisfaction (Margolis & Nagal, 2006).
Alternatives used by teachers to communicate with students and parents about school
issues (e.g. via Viber, WhatsApp), lack of knowledge and skills for the integration
of technology in teaching, are considered factors inuencing attitudes of teachers in
regards to technology and online learning. Furthermore, these may be issues that will
aect the further development or advancement of the quality of teaching and education
in general. This set of ndings also conrms the existing data from the evaluation of
educational policies and the ndings of previous studies, which state the low level
of skills and knowledge of teachers for the integration of technology in learning and
their attitudes that technology is not considered as a tool through which learning can
be stimulated or an important tool for advancing the quality of education (MESTI,
2017; Mexhuani, 2015).
In addition, according to the ndings from this study, it is pointed out that teachers
within the school have used pedagogical approaches through which they have
encouraged the active participation of students in lessons. However, in the context of
the approaches that teachers have stated to be using during online learning, elements
from interacting with students, through which their engagement and active participation
in dierent subjects is assessed, are missing. In addition, the assessments and attitudes
for distance learning realized during the pandemic period highlight the inadequacy of
the alternatives adopted during the pandemic, with special emphasis on the teaching
units broadcast through public television in relation to schools’ curricula, of school
lesson implementation and their unsuitability to the individual needs of students.
39
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
Nevertheless, the ndings of this study conrm the willingness of teachers and their
motivation to advance the level of knowledge and skills needed to advance the quality
of education, a contributing fact that can facilitate the creation of opportunities for the
development of digital education, empowerment of teachers and students, and raising
the level of creativity and opportunities to become more innovative. Similar factors have
been found to contribute to the advancement of the online learning format, as well as
to the improvement of learning in general, as they imply the importance of increased
encouragement and support for the individual needs of students (UNESCO, 2020b).
Practical implications and suggestions for future research
The ndings of both groups of study participants – teachers and parents – conrm
the need to further advance remote and online learning, to increase interaction between
teachers, parents and students, to improve the way in which students are instructed
to performing tasks, and to clarify assessment methods. Previous studies conrm the
impact of all of these factors on the quality of online learning, learning stimulation,
motivation and improvement of teachers’ attitudes toward technology, and integration
of technology into learning processes (Huang et al., 2020).
School principals can have a positive impact on supporting teachers to change
when they believe in change. They promote change, address teachers’ concerns,
helping them feel less anxious and irritated by change-related concerns (Ibrahim, et
al., 2013; de la Varre et al., 2010). Reminding teachers of the benets of change and
increasing their professional development, skills and knowledge needed for change
are other factors that can facilitate change. Also, ndings from studies recommend
that teachers should be part of the change, because this will help them feel involved
in planning professional developments and give their perspective on what can be most
eective in the development of any kind of reform within the school (Kise, 2005;
MacNeill et al., 2005). Teacher support and motivation to be part of the change are
also other organizational factors that have been proven to have an impact and are
suggested to be considered by school principals when implementing change (Rayan
and Ackerman, 2005). During the development of distance or online learning and
or during the implementation of learning on school premises, educational policy
makers, responsible educational institutions and other actors involved in the school
process, including school psychologists, are recommended to create programs to
support teachers, parents and students to overcome concerns that aect well-being
and performance in the learning processes. The data from this study revealed dierent
types of concerns present in groups of students, which have been proven to have an
impact on deteriorating mental health and even behavioral changes in children (NCIRD,
2020). Also, creating appropriate educational programs based on the individual needs
40
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
of students, supporting welfare and mental health, and raising the level of support for
families, teachers and guardians should be considered necessary (Covid-19 Educational
Disruption and Response: UNESCO, 2020b). Moreover, despite the circumstances,
COVID-19-related concerns and commitments about their children’s learning can
be overwhelming for parents. The situation created during the pandemic can be
considered as a priority in increasing the cooperation of the school with the parents,
their support to overcome the challenges related to the school, and at the same time
to advance their level of knowledge and skills for appropriate support practices in
regards to their children, in order to improve behaviors, foster learning, and create a
positive approach to school.
The lack of sucient skills and knowledge of the teachers participating in the
study to integrate technology and identify appropriate approaches to promote learning,
whether they are technological or pedagogical, and the inadequacy of distance
learning programs for the individual needs of students, conrms the need to advance
online learning, the quality of pre-university education, the knowledge and skills
of teachers and the integration of technology into learning processes. Therefore, as
in other countries, the circumstances created can be considered as an advantage in
improving the quality of education, the performance of students and teachers, while
helping to achieve the objectives of the education strategy, through which the aim is
to provide equal opportunities for education of all individuals within pre-university
programs, improving the quality of teachers, and maximizing the quality of teachers
(MESTI, 2016).
Studies conducted in the eld of education and technology also suggest that having
the opportunity to integrate technology into the classroom requires an understanding
of teachers’level of knowledge in relation to technology3, the knowledge of course
content4, pedagogical knowledge5, knowledge of pedagogical content6, knowledge
of technological content7, technological pedagogical knowledge8 and technological
3 Technology knowledge refers to a variety of technological knowledge that ranges from low-tech technologies,
such as pencils and paper, to digital technologies, such as the Internet, digital videos, interactive whiteboards,
and various computer programs.
4 Knowledge of course content refers to the knowledge of current subjects that the teacher must implement or
already implements.
5 Pedagogical knowledge refers to teaching methods and includes the knowledge of teachers in managing the
classroom, planning the lesson and evaluating students’ achievements.
6 Knowledge of pedagogical content refers to teachers’ knowledge on how to transfer knowledge to students.
7 Knowledge of technological content refers to teachers’ knowledge of how certain content can be presented through
technology and how much teachers understand that by using specic forms of technology they can change the
way students understand specic concepts in certain areas.
8 Technological pedagogical knowledge refers to the level of knowledge that teachers possess about how different
technologies can be used in teaching and understand that the use of technology can change the way teachers
teach students.
41
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
knowledge of content9(Mishra & Koehler, 2006; Shulman, 1986). One of the theoretical
perspectives present in the educational eld research by which the abovementioned
factors can be assessed is Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK;
Mishra and Koehler 2006). Through this perceptive, which was developed based on
Shulman’s construction of Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK), three areas for teacher
knowledge are addressed: technology, pedagogy, and content (Thompson and Mishra
2007). According to this perspective, the interplay among these three components is
necessary to enable the association of learning content with the appropriate pedagogical
methods and technology (Schmidt et al. 2009).
Throughout the development of online learning and in the eorts to integrate
technology into the learning processes, teaching sta should also be supported when it
comes to enhancing their knowledge and skills on improving teaching methodologies
with a student-centered approach. As emphasized by previous studies, technological and
communications developments, their use in teaching processes, and teacher approaches
in which the student is at the center promote active learning, remove teachers from
traditional lecturing shaping their roles as facilitators, increase students’ responsibilities,
make learning more open, and stimulate students to be more independent, have the
opportunity to self-determine, gain self-regulatory skills, be self-monitoring, and
adapt (Goode et al., 2007; Huang et al., 2020).
Inuenced by the same circumstances, due to preventive measures against the
spread of COVID-19, practices from other countries of the world promote the exible
learning approach during the implementation of learning and assessment of students.
According to the exible approach, students are given the opportunity to master the
subject materials in dierent forms, specifying the time when they want to interact
with others or to learn, and the format of their evaluation. In addition to providing
students with the opportunity to access teaching materials in a variety of ways, exible
teaching also enables teachers to oer students various learning activities in dierent
online applications. Furthermore, assessment methods can also be exible, including
presentations, group projects, peer/student assessment, standard forms of online
testing, and e-portfolios (Casey & Wilson, 2005; Gordon, 2014; Huang et al., 2020).
Isolation at home and engagement of students for longer periods of time in
technological equipment while they carry out school activities and/or are in contact
with peers, in the absence of monitoring and lack of information about factors that
may harm them, will increase the likelihood of their involvement in violent behavior
or victimization from cyber-bullying. Therefore, during the development of further
9 Technological knowledge of content refers to the knowledge that teachers are required to have to integrate
technology into their teaching in any eld in accordance with the content. Through this component, the teacher’s
knowledge is evaluated in integrating the three components: learning the content, using appropriate pedagogical
methods, and implementing technologies (Schmidt et al. 2009).
42
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
online programs, the parties involved are encouraged to take preventive measures,
increase student monitoring, and raise awareness of teachers and students to prevent risk
factors, while building a suitable environment for online learning and the establishment
of healthy relationships between peers.
Findings of previous studies through which the multidimensional factors of violence
in Kosovo’s public schools have been explored report that online violence is present
among students from grades 6 through 9 in public schools in Kosovo, including
harassment/threats through the Internet/phone (13.8%), gossip about students via the
Internet/e-mail/Facebook/other social media (10.8%), and threats/shaming through
photo sharing (5.9%) (Arënliu et al., 2020).
The ndings of this study represent the changes, concerns, and factors inuencing
teachers, children, and parents’ participation in and benefiting from the online
education processes. However, these elements reect the initial eects of shifting the
classroom-based education system to an online format and the eects of the changes
caused by the new circumstances. Therefore, while these ndings may serve as a basis
for supporting parents, teachers, and other actors involved in the lives and education
of children for improving the quality of education, further research may be needed
to measure other eventual changes in the subsequent stages of social isolation and
the current circumstances created against the spread of COVID-19, as well as the
further impact of changes in education during the following stages of the academic
year. Ongoing research on the issues addressed in this chapter, and other factors
inuencing the education and mental health of children, parents and teachers, can
help educational institutions in carrying out possible interventions to support students,
teachers, parents, school psychologists and others engaged in the education system,
in advancing their learning and well-being, both during the COVID-19 period and
after returning to school.
Acknowledgement: To all the students of the Master of School Psychology
and Counseling program in the Department of Psychology, Faculty of Philosophy,
University of Prishtina “Hasan Prishtina”, from the course “Learning and motivation”,
who have contributed to data collection, and all teachers and parents, who voluntarily
contributed by participating in this study.
References
Almutairi, A. (2009). Teachers’ perceptions of technology and technology education, years 7 to 10 (Doctoral
dissertation, Auckland University of Technology).
Arënliu, A., Kelmendi, K., Hyseni-Duraku, Z., & Konjufca, J. (in press).Multilevel determination of school
violence in pre-university educational institutions in Kosovo. Prishtinë, Kosovë: University of Prishtina.
Interviewy, J., & Wilson, P. (2005).A practical guide to providing exible learning in further and higher
education. Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education Scotland, Glasgow.
43
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
Collis, B. (1998). New didactics for university instruction: Why and how? Computers & Education, 31(4),
373–393. doi:10.1016/s0360-1315(98)00040-2
Collis, D. J. (2004). The paradox of scope: A challenge to the governance of higher education. Competing
conceptions of academic governance: Negotiating the perfect storm, 33-76.
Cope, C., & Ward, P. (2002). Integrating learning technology into classrooms: The importance of teachers’
perceptions. Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 5(1), 67–74.
de la Varre, C., Keane, J., & Irvin, M. J. (2010). Enhancing online distance education in small rural US schools:
A hybrid, learner-centred model. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 26(8).
Donelan, H. (2016). Social media for professional development and networking opportunities in academia. Journal
of Further and Higher Education, 40(5), 706–729. doi:10.1080/0309877x.2015.1014321
Dowling, M. (2007).From Husserl to van Manen.A review of dierent phenomenological approaches. International
journal of nursing studies, 44(1), 131-142.
Dyson, B., Vickers, K., Turtle, J., Cowan, S., & Tassone, A. (2015). Evaluating the use of Facebook to increase
student engagement and understanding in lecture-based classes. Higher Education, 69(2), 303–313.
doi:10.1007/s10734-014-9776-3
Flamholtz, E. G., & Randle, Y. (2008). Leading strategic change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Freeman, M. (2011).Validity in dialogic encounters with hermeneutic truths. Qualitative Inquiry, 17(6), 543-551.
Goode, J. (2007). Empowering or disempowering the international Ph. D. student? Constructions of the
dependent and independent learner. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 28(5), 589–603.
doi:10.1080/01425690701505409
Goode, S., Willis, R. A., Wolf, J. R., & Harris, A. L. (2007). Enhancing IS education with exible teaching
and learning. Journal of Information Systems Education, 18(3), 297–302.
Heidegger, M. (1988). The basic problems of phenomenology (Vol. 478).Indiana University Press.
Holsti, (1969).In, Stemler, S. (2000).An overview of content analysis. Practical assessment, research, and
evaluation, 7(1), 17.
Honey, M., Culp, K. M. M., & Carrigg, F. (2000). Perspectives on technology and education research: Lessons
from the past and present. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 23(1), 5–14. doi:10.2190/7vv9-
4g08-u0bx-reej
Huang, R.H., Liu, D.J., Tlili, A., Yang, J.F., Wang, H.H., et al. (2020). Handbook on facilitating exible
learning during educational disruption: The Chinese experience in maintaining undisrupted learning
in COVID-19 outbreak. Beijing: Smart Learning Institute of Beijing Normal University.
Hung, H. T., & Yuen, S. C. Y. (2010).Educational use of social networking technology in higher education. Teaching
in Higher Education, 15(6), 703–714. doi:10.1080/13562517.2010.507307
Husserl, E. (1970). The crisis of European sciences and transcendental phenomenology: An introduction to
phenomenological philosophy. Northwestern University Press.
Ibrahim, A., Al-Kaabi, A., & El-Zaatari, W. (2013).Teacher resistance to educational change in the United
Arab Emirates. International Journal of Research Studies in Education, 2(3), 25–36. doi:10.5861/
ijrse.2013.254
International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies.(2020). Remote psychological rst aid during
the COVID-19 outbreak interim guidance - March 2020.Psychosocial Centre.https://reliefweb.int/sites/
reliefweb.int/les/resources/IFRC-PS-Centre-Remote-Psychological-First-Aid-during-a-COVID-19-
outbreak-Interim-guidance.pdf.
Irvin, J. B. (2010). A Case of teachers’ perceptions of change and change implementation at a rural public
school.ProQuest LLC.
Kise, J. A. G. (2005). Coaching teachers for change: Using the concepts of psychological type to reframe
teacher resistance. Journal of Psychological Type, 65(6), 47–58.
44
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Education and Wellbeing
Zamira Hyseni Duraku
Kosovo Agency of Statistics. (2017). Kosovo Education Statistics for 2016-2017. https://ask.rks-gov.net/
media/3439/statistikat-e-arsimit-n%C3%AB-kosov%C3%AB-shqip.pdf.
Kosovo Agency of Statistics. (2019). Kosovo Education Statistics for 2018-2019. https://ask.rks-gov.net/
media/5055/statistikat-e-arsimit-2018-2019.pdf.
Lundin, R. (1999). Flexible teaching and learning: Perspectives and practices. Proceedings of Tools for Flexible
Learning Workshop.
MacNeill, N., Cavanagh, R. F., & Silcox, S. (2005). Pedagogic leadership: Refocusing on learning and
teaching. International Electronic Journal for Leadership in Learning, 9(2), n2.
Manca, S., & Ranieri, M. (2017).Exploring digital scholarship: A study on use of social media for scholarly
communication among Italian academics.In Research 2.0 and the impact of digital technologies on
scholarly inquiry (pp. 117–142). Pennsylvania: IGI Global.
Margolis, J., & Nagel, L. (2006). Education reform and the role of administrators in mediating teacher
stress. Teacher Education Quarterly, 33(4), 143–159.
McKenzie, K. B., & Scheurich, J. J. (2008).Teacher resistance to improvement of schools with
diverse students. International Journal of Leadership in Education, 11(2), 117–133.
doi:10.1080/13603120801950122
Mexhuani, A. (2015). Integration of information and communication technology in teaching and learning.
Prishtinë: Kosovo Pedagogical Institute. https://masht.rks-gov.net/uploads/2015/06/a-mexhuani-
integrimi-i-tik-ut-ne-mesimdhenie-dhe-nxenie-1.pdf.
Ministry of Education Science and Technology.(2015). Evaluation report: Kosovo Education Strategic Plan,
2011-2016. https://masht.rks-gov.net/uploads/2016/02/raport-vleresimi-psak-2011-2016-eng-web.pdf.
Ministry of Education Science and Technology. (2016). Kosovo Education Strategic Plan 2017-2021. http://
www.kryeministri-ks.net/repository/docs/KOSOVO_EDUCATION_STRATEGIC_PLAN.pdf.
Ministry of Education Science and Technology.(2020a). Ministry of Education Science Technology and
Innovation information regarding e-learning.https://masht.rks-gov.net/e-mesimi.
Ministry of Education Science and Technology.(2020b). Duties and responsibilities for the implementation of
distance learning.https://masht.rks-gov.net/uploads/2018/02/lib04-udhezuesi-per-mesimdhenes-nali.pdf.
Ministry of Education Science and Technology. (2020c). Statistical notes. Data on pre-university education.
Education Information Management System.Kosovo.https://masht.rks-gov.net/uploads/2020/02/
shenime-statistikore-2019-2020-arsimi-parauniversitar-2.pdf.
Mishra, P., & Koehler, M. J. (2006). Technological pedagogical content knowledge: A framework for teacher
knowledge. Teachers College Record, 108(6), 1017–1054. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9620.2006.00684.x
National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases.(2020). Coronavirus disease 2019.https://www.
cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/daily-life-coping/managing-stress-anxiety.html.
Palmer, I., Dunford, R., & Akin, G. (2009). Managing organizational change: A multiple perspective
approach(2nd ed.). London: McGraw-Hill.
Per, D., & Kitson, K. (2004).School development: Theories and strategies. New York: Bloomsbury.
Prosser, M., & Trigwell, K. (1999). Understanding learning and teaching: The experience in higher education.
London: McGraw-Hill Education.
Racher, F. E., & Robinson, S. (2003). Are phenomenology and postpositivism strange bedfellows?. Western
journal of nursing research, 25(5), 464-481.
Ryan, S., & Ackerman, D. J. (2005).Using pressure and support to create a qualied workforce. Education
Policy Analysis Archives/Archivos Analíticos de Políticas Educativas, 13, 1–17. doi:10.14507/epaa.
v13n23.2005
45
Chapter 1 - The impact of COVID-19 on education and on the well-being of teachers, parents, and students |
Schmidt, D. A., Baran, E., Thompson, A. D., Mishra, P., Koehler, M. J., & Shin, T. S. (2009). Technological
pedagogical content knowledge (TPACK) the development and validation of an assessment instrument
for preservice teachers. Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 42(2), 123–149. doi:10.10
80/15391523.2009.10782544
Shulman, L. S. (1986). Those who understand: Knowledge growth in teaching. Educational Researcher, 15(2),
4–14. doi:10.3102/0013189x015002004
STIKK Kosovo ICT Association. (2013). Internet penetration and use in Kosovo. https://stikk.org/wp-content/
uploads/2018/11/Publications_2013_-_Internet_Penetration_SQ.pdf.
Thompson, A. D., & Mishra, P. (2007). Breaking news: TPCK becomes TPACK!. Journal of Computing in
Teacher Education, 24(2), 38.
United Nations Educational, Scientic and Cultural Organization.(2020a). COVID-19 impact on education
data.COVID-19 education disruption and response.Paris, France: The United Nations Educational,
Scientic and Cultural Organization, UNESCO.
United Nations Educational, Scientic and Cultural Organization.(Producer). (2020b). COVID-19 Webinar:
A new world for teachers, education’s frontline workers [Video]. https://en.unesco.org/news/covid-
19-webinar-new-world-teachers-educations-frontline-workers.
Van Veen, K., & Sleegers, P. (2006). How does it feel? Teachers’ emotions in a context of change. Journal of
Curriculum Studies, 38(1), 85–111. doi:10.1080/00220270500109304
