ArticlePDF Available

Development of a national index for the purpose of forest fire risk assessments on the example of southern Serbia

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The paper presents the results on the study of the possible application of the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index and the Modified Angstrom Index in forest fire risk assessments. The daily values of these indices for the period 2005-2015 were related to the forest fire database. It was found that there is a relatively weak to moderate correlation between forest fires and the values of the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index. In order to improve the wildfire risk assessments (including forest fires), the index was modified. The modified index has a significantly greater correlation with the actual events of forest fires and consequently a much wider application in southern Serbia. The modified index can be of great importance in the future concepts of forest fire risk management.
Content may be subject to copyright.
1
DEVELOPMENT OF A NATIONAL INDEX FOR THE PURPOSE OF FOREST FIRE
RISK ASSESSMENTS ON THE EXAMPLE OF SOUTHERN SERBIA
by
Tatjana M. RATKNIĆ *1, Mihailo B. RATKNIĆ 1, Nikola Lj. RAKONJAC 2,
Ivana M. ŽIVANOVIĆ 1, Zoran B.
PODUŠKA
1
1 Institute of forestry, Belgrade, Serbia
2 Soil Physics and Land Management Group, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The
Nederlands
*Corresponding author; tatjanaratknic@yahoo.com
The paper presents the results on the study of the possible application
of the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) and the Modified
Angstrom Index (Mod Ang) in forest fire risk assessments. The daily values
of these indices for the period 2005-2015 were related to the forest fire
database. It was found that there is a relatively weak to moderate
correlation between forest fires and the values of the Canadian Forest
Fire Weather Index (FWI). In order to improve the wildfire risk assessments
(including forest fires), the index was modified. The modified index has a
significantly greater correlation with the actual events of forest fires and
consequently a much wider application in southern Serbia. The modified
index can be of great importance in the future concepts of forest fire risk
management.
Key words: forest fire, assessment, risk, modified index, Serbia
1. Introduction
Apart from their ecological role in the maintenance of important life cycles, forests have
other functions related to the economy, tourism, trade, recreation and health, etc. However, forests
used to cover much larger surface areas of the Earth than today.
Forest fires are a key element of the Earth's system that correlates with climate
characteristics, human activity, and type of vegetation [1]. With 200 - 500 million hectares of burned
area a year, forest fires damage larger areas and destroy more biomass around the world than any other
adverse factor affecting natural ecosystems [2,3].
Weather conditions have a dominant role in the outbreak of fires in a particular area [4]. High
temperatures and low relative air humidity are the basic factors in the fire triangle expressed through
the heat and moisture content in the fuel material.
The assessment of the risk of forest fire outbreak is one of the most important tasks
undertaken as preventive action of forest fire protection. In this way, fire damage can be minimized,
while a good fire detection system, pre-fire season preparation, good mobility and preparedness can
prevent the occurrence of forest fires. Forest fire risk assessments imply scenarios which include when
and where a fire will occur and how it will develop. The elements needed to predict the time of fire
2
occurrence are defined by the fire season, i.e., the dynamics of forest fire outbreak which is
determined by long-term monitoring.
The criteria applied when assessing where a fire will occur are determined by the area, the type
of fuels in the area, orographic and climatic conditions and the availability of fuels. These parameters
determine the way a fire will develop and measures to be taken for its suppression.
Some specific studies have determined the correlation between solar activity and forest fires [4-
10], but results of this study are still in the research phase.
In Portugal, the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) has shown great variability within
individual districts and relative applicability in the areas where no meteorological data are available
[11]. Since the data of daily measurements are presented in the Meteorological Yearbook of the
Republic Hydrometeorological Service of Serbia, the issue of the possible use of the Canadian Forest
Fire Weather Index (FWI) has become increasingly pronounced. Its application is hindered by distinct
orographic characteristics of the area of Serbia which require very extensive research in order to
develop correction parameters [12] and a different risk scale. Therefore, we have developed a
modified Angstrom index which provides a simpler way of determining the degree of forest fire
vulnerability [13].
The differences in the characteristics of these two indices also stem from the differences in the
characteristics of the areas in which they were created. The Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI)
was created in the conditions of a humid area with high sums of precipitation during the summer and
cold winters, thus representing a cumulative index complicated to measure. The Modified Angstrom
Index (Mod Ang) is adapted to the conditions of Serbia, i.e., dry and warm springs and summers and
autumns with low precipitation. This is a daily index easy to measure.
The method of determination and the simplicity of its application should be a parameter to
enable the creation of climate change scenarios and their impact on the increasing forest fire risk on
smaller territorial units within regions.
2. Research method
The study of climate characteristics and their effects on the occurrence of forest fires included
the following: air temperature, relative humidity, precipitation and wind. The daily values for the
period 2005 - 2015 were studied and correlated with the forest fire databases in this period. The
databases contain daily measurements and show the number of fires, the affected area and the location
of fires.
The analysis includes the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) and the Modified
Angstrom Index and their relationships with climate factors and the actually existing forest fire events.
A comparison of these two indices was made and the possibility of their application in the territory of
southern Serbia was assessed.
The Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) is based on the model of estimating the
flammability of forest fuels and its dependence on past and current weather conditions [13].
It consists of six components: three primary components (Fine Fuel Moisture Code - FFMC,
Duff Moisture Code - DMC and Drought code - DC) two indirect components (Initial spread index -
ISI and Buildup index BU) and one that denotes the intensity of an individual fire in the standard
type of fuel (The Fire Weather Index (FWI)).
3
The Fine Fuel Moisture Code (FFMC) is a numeric rating of the moisture content of forest litter
and other fine fuels in the forest. This code is an indicator of the relative ease of ignition and the
flammability of fine fuel. It typically refers to a 2-3 cm thick layer of dead organic forest litter,
weighing about 5 t/ha [14].
The calculation of the Fine Fuel Moisture Code is based on daily temperatures, relative
humidity and wind speed.
The precipitation over the past 24 hours greater than 0.6 mm points to the moisture of fuels by
the early afternoon in the hottest part of the day. This value is most adequate for the estimation of
inflammability. The wind is used to calculate the initial fire spread index in meters per minute.
The Fine Fuel Moisture Code - FFMC is calculated using the formula (1,2):
FFMC=59.5 (250-m)
(1)
m=147.2 (101-FFMC)/(59.5+FFMC)
(2)
where: m - fine fuel moisture content obtained as a function of air humidity.
Duff Moisture Code - DMC is a numeric rating of the average moisture content of loosely
compacted organic layers of moderate depth and the medium-size wood material. This code refers to
5-10 cm thick layer of dead organic forest litter, weighing about 50 t/ha. It is the primary source of
energy that ignites a fire in most types of fuels.
The calculation of this code is based on air temperature, relative humidity, 24-hour precipitation
greater than 1.5 mm and the day length.
DMC is an indicator of moisture at a depth of 5-10 cm obtained according to the following
formula (3,4):
DMC=DMCo (or DMCr) + 100 K
(3)
K=1.894 (T+1.1) (100-H) Le 10-6
(4)
where: DMCo = DMC of the previous day; DMCr = DMC if it is raining; T' = air temperature at 12
o`clock; H = relative air humidity at 12 o`clock; Le = the length of the visible part of the day; r = 24-
hour rainfall in mm.
The Drought Code - DC is a numeric rating of the average moisture content of deep, compact
organic layers and large wood material. In the coarse deep layer of dead forest litter, the layers can
contain up to 350-400% of water compared to the weight of dry fuels. In places where coarse
combustible material burns, the fire is difficult to extinguish and control.
The calculation of this code is based on air temperature, 24-hour rainfall greater than 2.9 mm,
the current month for the calculation of the value describing the moisture content in the layer 10-20
cm below the dead forest litter weighing 440 t/ha [14].
These moisture codes (modules of the meteorological fire indices) have the following meanings
regarding the inflammability and fire durability: FFMC - inflammable; DMC - durable and wind
power; DC difficult to extinguish and control.
The Drought Code - DC is derived from the following relationship (5):
DC = DCo (or DCt) + 0.18 (T + 2.8) + 0.5 Le
(5)
where: DCo = DC of the previous day; DCt = DC after rain; T = air temperature at 12 o'clock;
Le = the length of the visible part of the day; r = 24-hour rainfall in mm.
The DC value is a long-term indicator that is sensitive to seasonal drying that can last for 2, 3
and 4 months.
4
The Initial spread index ISI combines the effects of wind speed and the Fine Fuel Moisture
Code. It is used as a numeric rating of the expected rate of fire spread immediately after it has broken
out. To determine the Initial Spread Index, wind speed data at a height of 10 m are needed. The Initial
Spread index uses four classes of ROS (Rate of Spread).
The Buildup Index - BU combines the Duff Moisture Code DMC and the Drought Code - DC.
It is a numeric rating of the total amount of fuel available for combustion. The numeric value of this
index ranges from 0 to 400.
The Initial Spread Index ISI and The Buildup Index BU are represented by equations (6,7).
ISI = 0.208 f(W) f(F)
(6)
BUI = 0.8 DMC x DC/(P+0.4 DC)
(7)
where: f (W) = wind function; f (F) = fine fuel moisture function; DMC = The Duff Moisture Code;
DC = The Drought Code.
The Fire Weather Index (FWI) combines the Initial Spread Index with the Buildup Index. This
index is a numeric rating of the potential intensity of a fire in the standard fuel type and indicates the
degree of energy produced per unit of fire front length. The value of the Fire Weather index depends
only on meteorological elements and it is calculated on a daily basis. The values obtained point to the
risk of fire in a given area in the time interval around noon. This method allows temporal and spatial
comparisons of this index. It shows the range of localization, the size of spread, and the degree of the
damage that may occur. The Fire Weather Index, as the final index, is used in all planning activities.
Tab. 1. presents numeric values that determine the Fire Weather Index (FWI) on the basis of
which the degree of forest fire risk is determined.
Table 1.Forest fire risk according to FWI
Forest fire risk
VLR Very low risk
LR - Low risk
MR Moderate risk
HR High risk
VHR Very high risk
ER Extreme risk
In order to improve the wildfire risk assessment, the Angstrom index was modified [12] in the
following way:
1. the mean air temperature was replaced with the maximum air temperature in the formula
2. the mean relative air humidity was replaced with the minimum relative air humidity in the
(formula.
By incorporating these parameters, the formula has the following form:
Mod
𝐼
= 𝑅min /20 + (27−𝑇max)/10
(8)
Tab. 2. presents numeric values that determine the Modified Angstrom index (Mod Ang) on the
basis of which the degree of forest fire risk is determined
5
3. Research results
3.1 Climate characteristics
The explored area belongs to Climate Zone III, with pronounced continental characteristics and
subarea III d as the driest part of Zone III [15]. The hottest months are July and August at all stations
(Vranje climatological station), and the coldest are February (Vlasina, -3.20C) and January (Kukavica,
-3.10C).
Table 2. Forest fire risks according to Mod Ang
Mod Ang
Forest fire risk
<2.0
EC1 Extreme forest fire conditions1
2.0 2.5
EC2 - Extreme forest fire conditions 2
2.5 3.0
VH1 Very high risk 1
3.0 4.0
VH2 Very high risk 2
4.0 5.0
HR High Risk
5.0 6.0
MR Moderate Risk
6.0 - 7.0
LR Low risk
> 7.0
VLR Very low risk
The mean winter air temperatures range from -2.50C at Kukavica to 0.90C in Leskovac and
Vranje, while the summer temperatures range from 13.70C inVlasina to 20.40C in Vranje, spring
temperatures from 5.20C in Vlasina to 11.20C in Leskovac and autumn temperatures from 6.60C in
Vlasina to 11.40C in Vranje.
The mean monthly minimum air temperatures are the lowest in February (Vlasina and Kukavica
climatological stations). Mean monthly maximum air temperatures are the highest in July and August
and the lowest in January.
Precipitation of the research area is determined by the physical-geographical characteristics, the
character of atmospheric circulation during the year and local factors.
The annual precipitation totals in the research area range from 564.1 (Klenike) to 999.4 mm
(Kriva Feja). The highest amount of precipitation during the growing period was recorded at Kukavica
(547.6 mm or 58.6% of the total precipitation).
The wind is an important element of climate that affects temperature relationships and humidity.
It determines the precipitation and cloudiness. The distribution of wind depends mainly on the
distribution of air pressure. The direction and speed of wind are affected by the topography.
In the Vranje area, the most prevailing wind blows from the northeastern direction over the
whole year. Wind speed with Beaufort scale number 2.2 has been registered for this direction. The
winds blowing from the southeast, south and northwest are less frequent in the area. Southeastern
(Beaufort scale number 1.8) and southern (Beaufort scale number 2.1) winds have the lowest speed.
The highest speed with Beaufort scale number 2.5 was recorded in the winds blowing from the north,
and somewhat smaller (Beaufort scale number 2.4) from the east, west and northwest. The
northeastern and southwestern slopes are most affected by these winds. They are followed by the
6
northern, eastern, western and northwestern aspects, while the southern and southeastern aspects are
not endangered.
3.2 The number of fires and the burned area
Between 2005 and 2015, a total of 621 fires were recorded while the burned area amounted to
5662.5 ha. The mean fire burned area was 9.1 ha tab.3.
Table 3. The number of fires, burned area, mean fire burned area by years
of the study period
Year
Number of
fires
%
Burned area (ha)
%
Mean burned area
(ha)
2005
-
-
-
-
2006
1
0.2
108.0
1.9
108.0
2007
33
5.3
198.3
3.5
6.0
2008
12
1.9
4.5
0.1
0.4
2009
-
-
-
2010
11
1.8
317.6
5.6
28.9
2011
70
11.3
412
7.3
5.9
2012
483
77.8
4520.7
79.8
9.4
2013
-
-
-
2014
7
1.1
94.6
1.7
13.5
2015
4
0.6
6.8
0.1
1.7
Total
621
5662.5
9.1
Source: [13]
3.3 Correlation of the forest fire risk indices with the forest fire database
The daily values of the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) and the modified Angstrom
index for the period 2005-2015 were correlated to the actual forest fires that hit the area of southern
Serbia at the time. The values of these indices are shown in fig. 1 and 2.
3.4 Principal Component Analysis (PCA)
PCA was applied to determine the variability of data between and within the analyzed fire
indices in order to select the best variable for discrimination. The results of these analyses are
presented both numerically and graphically.
The principal component analysis (PCA) of the data related to meteorological stations for the
observation period from 2005 to 2015 distinguishes three components (fig. 3). The numeric results of
this analysis are shown in tab. 4. According to the obtained eigenvalue and percentage values, the first
three components (coordinates) are sufficient to explain 84.686% of the total variability of the data.
The value that each variable (climatic factor) contributes to the overall variability of data (according to
the first, second and third axis) are shown in tab. 5.
7
Figure 1. FWI for the research area
Figure 1. FWI for the research area
Figure 2. Mod Ang for the research area
8
Table 4. Eigenvalues and percentage values each coordinate contributes
to the overall variability of the investigated fire burned areas
and the data obtained
Figure 3. The number of derived components and their eigenvalues
Table 5. Values to which each variable (climatic characteristics) participates in describing the
total variability of the tested fire samples and the data obtained
The graph of scattering points (fig. 4) shows the geometric distance between the observed
climatic parameters as well as the variability that can be noticed between them.
Component
number
MS Vranje
Eigenvalue
Variance
percentage
Cummulative
percentage
1
3.87681
48.460
48.460
2
1.64824
20.603
69.063
3
1.24982
15.623
84.686
4
0.826939
10.337
95.023
5
0.259255
3.241
98.263
6
0.0842699
1.053
99.317
7
0.043637
0.545
99.862
8
0.0110306
0.138
100.000
Factor
MS Vranje
Components
1
2
3
T Max
0.4722
0.2469
0.0086
T Min
0.3977
0.4282
0.1120
T Mean
0.4566
0.3138
0.0334
MIN Humid
-0.3942
0.3379
0.2729
Mean Humid
-0.3692
0.3755
0.2887
Wind
0.0471
-0.3154
0.7726
Insolation
0.3393
-0.3805
0.3687
Precipitation
-0.0362
0.3973
0.3091
9
According to the first component, the investigated fields are divided into two groups. One
group is composed of the mean, the minimum and the maximum air temperatures. It also includes
precipitation. The second group consists of the minimum and the maximum relative humidity, while
the third group includes the wind and the insolation.
Figure 4. Two-dimensional presentation of data distribution (scattering points)
3.5 The correlation between the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) and the Modified
Angstrom Index (Mod Ang)
The correlation was established between the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) and
the Modified Angstrom Index of the potential danger of forest fire outbreaks. The results of this
analysis are shown in tab. 6 and in fig. 5.
The F-test value indicates a level of significance of 95% and amounts to 5417.47. The
coefficient of determination shows that the variability of the variables is explained with 57.42%. The
standard estimation error is 9.54. The Durbin-Watson test indicates that there is a possibility of serial
correlation between the analyzed indexes.
Table 6. Correlation between the FWI and the Modified Angstrom Index (original data)
Correlation equation
Regression parameters
Values
FWI = 33.3826 5.93719 ModAng
Standard regression error
9.53671
Coefficient of correlation
0.7577
Coefficient of determination
0.5742
F-test
5417.47
Durbin-Watson test
0.833663
Correlation coefficients point to a strong correlation between the Canadian Forest Fire
Weather Index (FWI) and the Modified Angstrom Index of the potential danger of forest fire
outbreaks.
10
The correlation between the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) and the Modified
Angstrom Index of potential dangers of forest fire outbreaks (categories) is shown in tab. 7 and in fig.
6. F-test value is 5667.56. The coefficient of determination shows that the variability of the
variables is explained with 58.52%. The standard error of estimation is 0.92. The Durbin-Watson test
indicates that there is a possibility of a serial correlation between the analyzed indices and it amounts
to 0.93. Regarding the number of days in the study period from 2005 to 2015 (a total of 4017 days),
according to the Canadian index there are 83 days of extreme fire risk1 (2.07% of the total), 238
(5.92%) of very high risk, 614 (15.29%) of high risk, 625 (15.56%) of moderate risk, 505 (12.57%) of
low risk and 1952 (48.59%) of very low risk.
Table 7. Correlation between the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI) and the Modified
Angstrom Index (Mod Ang) (categories)
Correlation equation
Regression parameters
Values
FWI cat = 2.79954 + 0.512418 ModArn cat
Standard regression error
0.924727
Coefficient of correlation
0.7649
Coefficient of
determination
0.5852
F-test
5667.56
Durbin-Watson test
0.925497
If we compare Canadian index data with the forest fire database for the study period, only
416 fires occurred (66.88% of the total) at the time of extreme fire risk, while 121 fires (19.45%) were
registered in the very high and 25 (4.02%) in the high-risk category. There were 20 fires (3.22%) in
the category of low fire risk and 16 fires (2.57%) in the category of very low risk. The number of fires
classified according to the forest fire risk based on the Canadian Weather Index is shown in tab. 8.
Figure 5. The correlation between the
Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index (FWI)
and the Modified Angstrom Index
Figure 6. Correlation between the degree of
the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index
(FWI) and the degree of the Modified
Angstrom Index
According to the Modified Angstrom Forest Fire Risk, extreme conditions for the occurrence
of forest fires 1 were recorded in 959 days (23.9% of the total), extreme conditions for the occurrence
11
of forest fires 2 were registered in 367 days (9.1% of the total number), while very high risk 1 was
observed in 365 days (9.1%), and very high risk 2 in 686 days (17.1%). High risk was recorded in 592
days (14.7%). The low risk of forest fires was recorded in 412 days (10.2%) and very low in 105 days
(2.6%). The comparison of the modified Angstrom Index with the forest fire database shows that 548
fires (88.1% of the total) were registered at the time of extreme fire risk 1, 14 fires (2.3% of the total)
were registered in the extreme fire risk 2. The category of very high risk 1 registered 24 fires (4.3%),
while the category of very high risk 2 registered 18 fires (2.9%). In the category of high risk, there
were 6 fires (0.9%). Only 1 fire (0.2%) was registered in the category of low risk of forest fires of the
Modified Angstrom index, while no fire was recorded in the very low-risk category.
The number of fires and the number of days according to the forest fire risk based on the
Modified Angstrom is shown in tab. 9.
Table 8. The number of days and the number of
fires according to the forest fire risk based on
the Canadian Fire Weather Index (FWI)
Table 9. The number of days and the
number of fires according to the forest fire
risk based on the Modified Angstrom
index (Mod Ang).
Fire risk
Number of days
Number of fires
Fire risk
Number of days
Number of fires
N
%
N
%
N
%
N
%
ER
83
2.07
416
66.88
EC1
959
23,9
548
88.1
VH
238
5.92
121
19.45
EC2
367
9.1
14
2.3
HR
614
15.29
25
4.02
VH1
365
9.1
27
4.3
MR
625
15.56
24
3.86
VH2
686
17.1
18
2.9
LR
505
12.57
20
3.22
HR
592
14.7
6
0.9
VLR
1952
48.59
16
2.57
MR
531
13.2
8
1.3
LR
412
10.2
1
0.2
VLR
105
2.6
4. Conclusion
This study shows that the analysis of forest fires in the period from 2005 to 2015 provided a
more efficient way of predicting forest fires in southern Serbia. The Modified Angstrom Index has a
significantly greater correlation with the actual events of forest fires. Therefore it can be recommended
for its further application.
The Modified Angstrom Index can be used in the creation of climate change scenarios when
data on the amount of fuel for combustion and microclimate conditions that can cause a forest fire are
not available, which is the case in most underdeveloped countries, including Serbia.
Acknowledgment
This paper was realized as a part of the project LODE (Loss Data Enhancement for DRR and
CCA management). LODE is funded by the European Commission- DG-ECHO Directorate General
for European Civil protection and Humanitarian Aid Operations under the Program: Union Civil
Protection Mechanism Prevention and Preparedness Projects in Civil Protection and Marine Pollution
2018-2020.
12
References
[1] Ichoku, C., et al., MODIS Observation of Aerosols and Estimation of Aerosol Radiative
Forcing Over Southern Africa During SAFARI 2000, Journal of Geophysical Research, 108
(2003), 13, pp. 1-13
[2] Lavorel, S., et al., Vulnerability of Land Systems to Fire: Interactions Among Humans, Climate,
the Atmosphere and Ecosystems, Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change, 12
(2007), pp. 33-53
[3] Ichoku, C., et al., Global Characterization of Biomass-Burning Patterns Using Satellite
Measurements of Fire Radiative Energy, Remote Sensing of Environment, 112 (2008), pp. 2950-
2962
[4] Pyne, J., Indroduction to Wildland Fire, John Wiley and Sons Inc., New York, 1996
[5] Radovanovic, M. M, et al., Application of Adaptive Neuro Fuzzy Interference System Models
for Prediction of Forest Fires in the USA on the Basis of Solar Activity, Thermal Science,19
(2015), 5, pp. 1649-1661
[6] Radovanovic, M. M, et al., Forest Fires in Portugal Case Study, June 18, 2017, Thermal
Science,23 (2019), 1, pp. 73-86
[7] Velasco, G. H., et al., Mexican Forest Fires and Their Decadal Variations, Advances in Space
Research, 58 (2016), 10, pp. 2104-2115
[8] Sun, R., et al., The Importance of Fire Atmosphere Coupling and Boundary Layer
Turbulence to Wildfire Spread, International Journal of Wildland Fire, 18 (2009), 1, pp. 50-60
[9] Kuznetsov, G. V., Baranovskiy, N. V., Focused Sunʼs Rays and Forest Fire Danger,
Proceedings, SPIE, Remote Sensing of Clouds and the Atmosphere XVIII; and Optics in
Atmospheric Propagation and Adaptive Systems XVI, International Society for Optics and
Photonics, San Francisco, Cal., USA, 2013
[10] Milenkovic, M., et al., Forest Fires in Finland the Influence of Atmospheric Oscillations, J.
Geogr. Inst. Cvijic, 69 (2019), pp. 75-82.
[11] Carvalho, A., et al., Fire Activity in Portugal and its Relationship to Weather and the Canadian
Fire Weather Index System, International Journal of Wildland Fire, 17 (2008), pp. 328-338.
[12] De Jong, C. M., et al., Calibration and evaluation of the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index
(FWI) System for Improved Wildland Fire Danger Rating in the United Kingdom, Natural
Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 16 (2016), pp. 1217-1237
[13] Ratknić, M. T., An Integral Model of Protection and the Management of Forest Risk in the
Republic of Serbia, Ph. D. thesis, Singidunum University, 2018
[14] Van Wagner, C. E, Development and Structure of the Canadian Forest Fire Weather Index
System, Technical Report No. 35, Canadian Forestry Service, Ottawa, ON, 1987
[15] Ducić, V., Radovanovic, M., Klima Srbije, Zavod za udzbenike i nastavna sredstva, Beograd,
2005
... As droughts have been observed to increase in frequency, intensity and duration in Serbia, more frequent wildfires are expected, especially in south-eastern and eastern Serbia. The Modified Angstrom and Nesterov indices can be used to assess the risk of fire, including Serbia (Ratknić et al., 2019;Živanović and Tošić, 2020). Wildfires affect sustainable forest management and incur a substantial loss to forestry. ...
Article
Full-text available
Wildfires caused by climate change in Europe have numerous and long-lasting ecological, economic, and social implications for sustainable development (natural environment, economy, and society as a whole). Artificial revitalization of sessile oak forests destroyed by wildfires in Serbia is feasible, but it is quite expensive compared to the spontaneous regeneration. Cost-benefit analysis (an economic approach to comparing and estimating the benefits and shortcomings of a particular business plan, i.e., an investment project by analyzing its costs and benefits) is aimed at finding the best solutions and making the best decisions about the desirability of a project. It was concluded that the investment in the restitution of sessile oak forests could be profitable only if it was based on wood production. Wood production may bear slightly higher interest rates compared to previous estimates which ranged mainly around 3%. This primarily applies to better site classes, while poor quality sites require lower rates. At lower discount rates, it takes more time to reach the break-even point, while the period of time needed to reach the break-even point shortens with higher discount rates. The length of the production cycle plays an important role in determining the investment profitability, especially regarding the relationship between the length of the production cycle and production targets (the type and the quality of wood assortments produced). According to the results of the analysis of intangible benefits and costs, the costs outweigh the benefits, which makes the restitution of sessile oak forests destroyed by fires unacceptable.
... Studies [10,12] showed that the relationship between forest fires and fire indices existed in different regions of Serbia. In order to improve the wildfire risk assessment, the Angstrom index was modified, and a significant correlation with the forest fires is found in southern Serbia [25]. Beside the fire indices, the raw climate data can be used to estimate fire occurrence. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstract: The Djerdap National Park in Serbia is vulnerable to fires. The variability of a fire in the Djerdap National Park is studied depending on the impact of climatic conditions. The influence was investigated on a yearly, monthly and daily basis using data recorded at the meteorological station Veliko Gradište. Data were analysed for two periods: 1961-1990 and 1991-2017, and for the year of 2011. Special attention is devoted to the conditions for the emergence of the largest forest fire in the Djerdap National Park in September 2011. In this study, the Angström index, the Nesterov index, and method of deficit and surplus of precipitation are used to predict the risk of fire. There was an increased danger of fire in the forests in the period of 1991-2017 compared to the period of 1961-1990. Indices showing fire risk are increased for the months of June, July and August. September 2011 is characterized by an increase of average monthly air temperature by 3.7 °C and a reduction of the total monthly rainfall of 32.3 mm compared to a long-term average value which favorable influenced to the occurrence of large forest fires. Key words: climate change; risk; fire; forestry; The Djerdap National Park; Serbia
... The FWI system is an important part of the Canadian Forest Fire Danger Rating System (CFFDRS) and was initially developed for conditions of boreal forests in Canada (Wotton, 2009). Later, the FWI system has been adapted to a number of countries with different climates to Canada, such as Indonesia and Malaysia (Groot et al., 2006), or countries of the Mediterranean region, i.e., Spain (Padilla and Vega-García, 2011), Portugal (Carvalho et al., 2008), France (Cloppet and Regimbeau, 2010), Serbia (Ratknić et al., 2019) and Greece (Dimitrakopoulos et al., 2011, Karali et al., 2014. Another fire danger rating system is the National Fire Danger Rating System (NFDRS), which is used in the United States (Deeming et al., 1977). ...
Article
Full-text available
The performance of fire indices based on weather variables was analyzed with a special focus on the Czech Republic. Three fire weather danger indices that are the basis of fire danger rating systems used in different parts of the world were assessed: the Canadian Fire Weather Index (FWI), Australian Forest Fire Danger Index (FFDI) and Finnish Forest Fire Index (FFI). The performance of the three fire danger indices was investigated at different scales and compared with actual fire events. First, the fire danger indices were analyzed for different land use types during the period 1956–2015. In addition, in the analysis, the three fire danger indices were compared with wildfire events during the period 2001–2015. The fire danger indices were also analyzed for the specific locality of the Bzenec area where a large forest fire event occurred in May 2012. The study also focused on the relationship between fire danger indices and forest fires during 2018 across the area of the Jihomoravský region. Comparison of the index values with real fires showed that the index values corresponded well with the occurrence of forest fires. The analysis of the year 2018 showed that the highest index values were reached on days with the greater fire occurrence. On days with 5 or 7 reported fires per day, the fire danger indices reached values between 3 and 4.
Chapter
Full-text available
This chapter aims to show the phenomenon of forest fires from socioeconomic aspects to present the readers with a new perspective. We start from the assumption that fire in forest ecosystems has a positive and negative impact, which can be represented by an appropriate valuation system. The basis for such an assumption was found in the paradox of fire (in natural ecosystems), which has had human attention from the very beginning of the human population. From early views on social dependence on fire to a modern perspective, that fire is a catastrophic phenomenon in nature. Today, it can be assumed that our valuation system is set at a point where fire harms nature. This tacit acceptance has become commonplace in fire reporting where the importance of fire in removing biomass especially coniferous stands, maintaining open spaces for grazing and hunting, reducing catastrophic wildfires, in carbon balance and water regulation or scientific knowledge is almost completely omitted. Contemporary streams in nature and forest science and practice point out that fire is an ecosystem service providing many services with trade-offs between fire prevention and the provision of ecosystem services. Here, we explain why fire in natural ecosystems become relevant for science after the eighties. We present that the extent of fire damage is more than 0.012% of Worlds GDP in this decade. Major socioeconomic driving factors of forest fires are presented too. The chapter presents examples of ecosystem services and economic impacts provided by wildfires.
Article
Full-text available
In Finland, in the period 1996–2017, 28,434 forest fires were recorded (an average of 1,292.5 per year), and the total burned area was 11,922 ha (an average of 541.9 ha per year). In both cases, a statistically nonsignificant downward trend was recorded. Forest fires in Finland do not represent a particularly significant problem, primarily due to climatic characteristics, well-organized fire protection, and low density of population. The research of climate influence included the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO), the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), and the Arctic Oscillation (AO). The statistically significant values (p ≤ .05) of Pearson correlation coefficient were recorded for the August values of NAO and the surface area of burned forest (−0.44), the June values of NAO and the average surface area of forest burned per fire (−0.51) and the May AO values and the average surface area of forest burned per fire (−0.45). For the June values of NAO and the average surface area of forest burned per fire, the Lomb periodogram shows four significant peaks, and the match is at two, at 2.4 and 3.4 years, which supports the hypothesis of the connection between NAO and forest fires in Finland.
Article
Full-text available
Forest fires that occurred in Portugal on 18 June 2017 caused several tens of human casualties. The cause of their emergence, as well as many others that occurred in Western Europe at the same time remained unknown. Taking into account consequences, including loss of human lives and endangerment of ecosystem sustainability, discovering of the forest fires causes is the very significant question. The heliocentric hypothesis has indirectly been tested, according to which charged particles are a possible cause of forest fires. We must point out that it was not possible to verify whether in this specific case the particles by reaching the ground and burning the plant mass create the initial phase of the formation of the flame. Therefore, we have tried to determine whether during the critical period, i.e. from 15–19 June there is a certain statistical connection between certain parameters of the solar wind and meteorological elements. Based on the hourly values of the charged particles flow, a correlation analysis was performed with hourly values of individual meteorological elements including time lag at Monte Real station. The application of the Adaptive Neuro Fuzzy Inference System models has shown that there is a high degree of connection between the flow of protons and the analysed meteorological elements in Portugal. However, further verification of this hypothesis requires further laboratory testing.
Article
Full-text available
Wildfires in the United Kingdom (UK) pose a threat to people, infrastructure and the natural environment. During periods of particularly fire-prone weather, wildfires can occur simultaneously across large areas, placing considerable stress upon the resources of fire and rescue services. Fire danger rating systems (FDRSs) attempt to anticipate periods of heightened fire risk, primarily for early-warning and preparedness purposes. The UK FDRS, termed the Met Office Fire Severity Index (MOFSI), is based on the Fire Weather Index (FWI) component of the Canadian Forest FWI System. The MOFSI currently provides daily operational mapping of landscape fire danger across England and Wales using a simple thresholding of the final FWI component of the Canadian FWI System. However, it is known that the system has scope for improvement. Here we explore a climatology of the six FWI System components across the UK (i.e. extending to Scotland and Northern Ireland), calculated from daily 2km × 2km gridded numerical weather prediction data and supplemented by long-term meteorological station observations. We used this climatology to develop a percentile-based calibration of the FWI System, optimised for UK conditions. We find this approach to be well justified, as the values of the "raw" uncalibrated FWI components corresponding to a very "extreme" (99th percentile) fire danger situation vary by more than an order of magnitude across the country. Therefore, a simple thresholding of the uncalibrated component values (as is currently applied in the MOFSI) may incur large errors of omission and commission with respect to the identification of periods of significantly elevated fire danger. We evaluate our approach to enhancing UK fire danger rating using records of wildfire occurrence and find that the Fine Fuel Moisture Code (FFMC), Initial Spread Index (ISI) and FWI components of the FWI System generally have the greatest predictive skill for landscape fire activity across Great Britain, with performance varying seasonally and by land cover type. At the height of the most recent severe wildfire period in the UK (2 May 2011), 50 % of all wildfires occurred in areas where the FWI component exceeded the 99th percentile. When all wildfire events during the 2010–2012 period are considered, the 75th, 90th and 99th percentiles of at least one FWI component were exceeded during 85, 61 and 18 % of all wildfires respectively. Overall, we demonstrate the significant advantages of using a percentile-based calibration approach for classifying UK fire danger, and believe that our findings provide useful insights for future development of the current operational MOFSI UK FDRS.
Article
Full-text available
MODIS provides almost complete global coverage daily. Aerosol optical thickness (AOT or taualambda) and other aerosol parameters are retrieved over land and ocean at a spatial scale of 10 km (level 2), then aggregated to a global grid of 1° spatial resolution on daily, weekly, and monthly time scales (level 3). The SAFARI 2000 ground-based measurements of AOT from the Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET) group of Sun photometers were used to compare MODIS over-land AOT based on a spatiotemporal statistical technique. At low aerosol loading (when taua470 < 0.6), MODIS taualambda values agree with those of AERONET at the blue wavelength (lambda = 440, 470 nm). But, at higher wavelengths and with increasing aerosol loading, MODIS AOT values underestimate those of AERONET. There are also regional variations in validation accuracy. This AOT underestimation by MODIS during SAFARI 2000 is attributed to the application of a constant single-scattering-albedo (SSA or omega0) value of 0.90 globally for smoke aerosol retrieval. Recent studies based on long-term observations with AERONET Sun photometers suggest that lower omega0 values of 0.88 and 0.84 at 440 nm and 670 nm wavelengths respectively would be more applicable over southern Africa (particularly over Zambia, where most of the measurements were based). A column climate model, with MODIS aerosol information as input, is used to calculate aerosol radiative forcing over the (southern Atlantic) Ocean part of the SAFARI 2000 region. For September 2000, the results show a forcing of -10 W/m2 at the top of the atmosphere and approximately -26 W/m2 at the terrestrial surface.
Article
Full-text available
The relationships among the weather, the Canadian Fire Weather Index (FWI) System components, the monthly area burned, and the number of fire occurrences from 1980 to 2004 were investigated in 11 Portuguese districts that represent respectively 66% and 61% of the total area burned,and number,of fires in Portugal. A statistical approach was used to estimate the monthly area burned and the monthly number of fires per district, using meteorological variables and FWI System components,as predictors. The approach,succeeded,in explaining from 60.9 to 80.4% of the variance for area burned,and between,47.9 and 77.0% of the variance for the number,of fires; all regressions were highly significant (P < 0.0001). The monthly,mean,and the monthly,maximum,of daily maximum,temperatures,and the monthly,mean,and extremes (maximum and 90th percentile) of the daily FWI were selected for all districts, except for Bragança and Porto, in the forward stepwise regression for area burned. For all districts combined, the variance explained was 80.9 and 63.0% for area burned and number of fires, respectively. Our results point to highly significant relationships among forest fires in Portugal and the weather and the Canadian FWI System. The present analysis provides baseline information,for predicting the area burned,and number,of fires under future climate scenarios and the subsequent,impacts on air quality. Additional keywords: area burned, fire occurrence, forest fires, FWI System.
Article
Full-text available
Fires are critical elements in the Earth System, linking climate, humans, and vegetation. With 200–500 Mha burnt annually, fire disturbs a greater area over a wider variety of biomes than any other natural disturbance. Fire ignition, propagation, and impacts depend on the interactions among climate, vegetation structure, and land use on local to regional scales. Therefore, fires and their effects on terrestrial ecosystems are highly sensitive to global change. Fires can cause dramatic changes in the structure and functioning of ecosystems. They have significant impacts on the atmosphere and biogeochemical cycles. By contributing significantly to greenhouse gas (e.g., with the release of 1.7–4.1 Pg of carbon per year) and aerosol emissions, and modifying surface properties, they affect not only vegetation but also climate. Fires also modify the provision of a variety of ecosystem services such as carbon sequestration, soil fertility, grazing value, biodiversity, and tourism, and can hence trigger land use change. Fires must therefore be included in global and regional assessments of vulnerability to global change. Fundamental understanding of vulnerability of land systems to fire is required to advise management and policy. Assessing regional vulnerabilities resulting from biophysical and human consequences of changed fire regimes under global change scenarios requires an integrated approach. Here we present a generic conceptual framework for such integrated, multidisciplinary studies. The framework is structured around three interacting (partially nested) subsystems whose contribute to vulnerability. The first subsystem describes the controls on fire regimes (exposure). A first feedback subsystem links fire regimes to atmospheric and climate dynamics within the Earth System (sensitivity), while the second feedback subsystem links changes in fire regimes to changes in the provision of ecological services and to their consequences for human systems (adaptability). We then briefly illustrate how the framework can be applied to two regional cases with contrasting ecological and human context: boreal forests of northern America and African savannahs.
Article
A high forest fire season of two to three years is regularly observed each decade in Mexican forests. This seems to be related to the presence of the El Niño phenomenon and to the amount of total solar irradiance. In this study, the results of a multi-cross wavelet analysis are reported based on the occurrence of Mexican forest fires, El Niño and the total solar irradiance for the period 1970–2014. The analysis shows that Mexican forest fires and the strongest El Niño phenomena occur mostly around the minima of the solar cycle. This suggests that the total solar irradiance minima provide the appropriate climatological conditions for the occurrence of these forest fires. The next high season for Mexican forest fires could start in the next solar minimum, which will take place between the years 2017 and 2019. A complementary space analysis based on MODIS active fire data for Mexican forest fires from 2005 to 2014 shows that most of these fires occur in cedar and pine forests, on savannas and pasturelands, and in the central jungles of the Atlantic and Pacific coasts.
Article
Remote sensing is the most practical means of measuring energy release from large open-air biomass burning. Satellite measurement of fire radiative energy (FRE) release rate or power (FRP) enables distinction between fires of different strengths. Based on a 1-km resolution fire data acquired globally by the MODerate-resolution Imaging Spectro-radiometer (MODIS) sensor aboard the Terra and Aqua satellites from 2000 to 2006, instantaneous FRP values ranged between 0.02 MW and 1866 MW, with global daily means ranging between 20 and 40 MW. Regionally, at the Aqua-MODIS afternoon overpass, the mean FRP values for Alaska, Western US, Western Australia, Quebec and the rest of Canada are significantly higher than these global means, with Quebec having the overall highest value of 85 MW. Analysis of regional mean FRP per unit area of land (FRP flux) shows that at peak fire season in certain regions, fires can be responsible for up to 0.2 W/m2 at peak time of day. Zambia has the highest regional monthly mean FRP flux of ~ 0.045 W/m2 at peak time of day and season, while the Middle East has the lowest value of ~ 0.0005 W/m2. A simple scheme based on FRP has been devised to classify fires into five categories, to facilitate fire rating by strength, similar to earthquakes and hurricanes. The scheme uses MODIS measurements of FRP at 1-km resolution as follows: category 1 (< 100 MW), category 2 (100 to < 500 MW), category 3 (500 to < 1000 MW), category 4 (1000 to < 1500 MW), category 5 (≥ 1500 MW). In most regions of the world, over 90% of fires fall into category 1, while only less than 1% fall into each of categories 3 to 5, although these proportions may differ significantly from day to day and by season. The frequency of occurrence of the larger fires is region specific, and could not be explained by ecosystem type alone. Time-series analysis of the proportions of higher category fires based on MODIS-measured FRP from 2002 to 2006 does not show any noticeable trend because of the short time period.