ArticlePDF AvailableLiterature Review

Team Development Interventions: Evidence-Based Approaches for Improving Teamwork

Authors:
Christina Lacerenza at University of Colorado Boulder
Christina Lacerenza
Shannon L. Marlow at University of Texas at San Antonio
Shannon L. Marlow
Scott I. Tannenbaum
Scott I. Tannenbaum
Scott I. Tannenbaum
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Eduardo Salas at University of Central Florida
Eduardo Salas
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

The rate of teamwork and collaboration within the workforce has burgeoned over the years, and the use of teams is projected to continue increasing. With the rise of teamwork comes the need for interventions designed to enhance teamwork effectiveness. Successful teams produce desired outcomes; however, it is critical that team members demonstrate effective processes to achieve these outcomes. Team development interventions (TDIs) increase effective team competencies and processes, thereby leading to improvements in proximal and distal outcomes. The effectiveness of TDIs is evident across domains (e.g., education, health care, military, aviation), and they are applicable in a wide range of settings. To stimulate the adoption and effective use of TDIs, the current article provides a review of four types of evidence-based TDIs including team training, leadership training, team building, and team debriefing. In doing so, we aim to provide psychologists with an understanding of the scientific principles underlying TDIs and their impact on team dynamics. Moreover, we provide evidence-based recommendations regarding how to increase the effectiveness of TDIs as well as a discussion on future research needed within this domain.
Figures - uploaded by Christina Lacerenza
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Christina Lacerenza
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Christina Lacerenza
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Christina Lacerenza on Jun 20, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
A preview of this full-text is provided by American Psychological Association.
Learn more
Content available from American Psychologist
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
... The overarching aim was to collect suggestions to inform the subsequent design, development, and implementation of multilevel interventions, actions, and initiatives addressing healthcare workers' outcomes. However, for the purposes of the present dissertation's main topic, only job demands and job resources at the group level of analysis are reported, consistent with Lacerenza et al.'s (2018) indication that, when interventions are delivered to teams, needs of the teams are to be exhaustively understood first. The ultimate aim was to verify the organisation-intervention fit (Andersen et al., 2021;Peters et al., 2020) and ensure the relevance of the subsequent implementation of team-level digital-based interventions in the targeted workplace settings. ...
... In the last decades, considering the importance of teamwork in the workplace, a number of interventions have been developed and tested with the aim of promoting teamwork quality and effectiveness. Traditional evidence-based approaches to team development and improvement (Grote & Kozlowski, 2023;Lacerenza et al., 2018) have primarily focused on in-presence team training, team building, and team debriefing. Team training refers to a structured approach to improving the teamwork skills, with a focus on the shared understanding of roles, responsibilities, and goals. ...
... On the other hand, the project has a number of strengths too, that contribute to its academic and practical value. First and foremost, in line with mainstream literature in the field of workplace interventions (e.g., Nielsen & Noblet, 2018;von Thiele Schwarz et al., 2021), the project followed a stepwise framework for team interventions (i.e., Lacerenza et al., 2018), going from the review of previous evidence to the assessment of team needs, and from the tailored implementation of interventions to the evaluation of implemented actions. This approach ensures a structured, well-organised and methodical exploration of team-level digital interventions, addressing unique needs and challenges faced by organisations nowadays. ...
Digital-based interventions for teams in the workplace
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Apr 2024
This research project investigated a digital workplace intervention based on team coaching and social network visualisation. The investigation was carried out through four studies. Study 1 was a systematic literature review with a realist synthesis approach about workplace digital interventions at multiple levels, highlighting the need for more research about group-level digital workplace interventions. Study 2 was a qualitative needs assessment exercise that verified the fit between the targeted organisations and the selected intervention. Following the tailored implementation of the intervention, Study 3 analysed recipients’ positive perceptions of intervention characteristics, with usability and integrity being appreciated the most, and acceptability being appreciated the least. While the intervention was considered usable and recipients felt valued during sessions, training did not fully meet their expectations. Also, recipients’ perceptions did not change from second to fourth session, suggesting they remained stably satisfied with the intervention over time. Finally, Study 4 tested two relevant Context-Mechanism-Outcome (CMO) configurations and suggested that teams implementing action plans developed during training might need less support from immediate managers to coordinate collective efforts and accomplish collective performance. Moreover, peer support towards training transfer was confirmed as a relevant contextual factor contributing to intervention effectiveness. Overall, this multifaceted and complex research project offers a nuanced examination of team-level digital interventions within the contemporary workplace, unveiling valuable insights and opportunities for further refinement and application.
View
... Nevertheless, the leader-behavioral approach is well positioned because it inevitably involves three streams of research: leadership, team science, and team coaching literature. The leadership training literature has decades of empirical support and a plethora of metaanalytic evidence suggesting that leadership training works (see [20]). The team training literature is also heavily supported by empirical (e.g., [21]) and meta-analytic evidence (e.g., [22]). ...
... Given that the team coaching literature is nascent compared to the other two, we undertake an integrative approach, where we systematically review these three streams of literature to put forward the core competencies an effective internal team coach should have. In this review, we define a competency in alignment with prior team research, which are the knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs) "critical for team [leaders] to interdependently interact with [their team] in such a way that leads to positive team-based outcomes" [20] (p. 518). ...
... Nevertheless, it is important to note that team coaching is an approach, and not the approach. Different team developmental interventions (TDIs, see [20]) can also be helpful, depending on the issue that an organization is facing. Team coaching can be both a formal training intervention and a process intervention where an individual simply chooses to engage in certain behaviors [2]. ...
How to make an internal team coach: An integration of training research.
Article
Full-text available
  • May 2024
Team coaching has been found to increase group effort, improve interpersonal processes, and increase team knowledge and learning. However, the team coaching literature is renowned for its inability to define team coaching itself—making it difficult to solidify its place in the world of team science. So far, there is no consensus on what specific training would serve internal leaders best, and how they would connect to the team coaching literature. We know leadership and team training are effective in improving organizational outcomes, but the gap in the literature lies in identifying what specific competencies internal team coaches need, and what training could fulfill these. In this piece, we seek to (1) identify what competencies internal team leaders need based on the outcomes we know team coaching yields, (2) identify specific behaviors that can fulfill these competencies, and (3) integrate the literature to form an evidence-based guide on what training to provide to internal team coaches. By doing so, we hope to provide a definitive understanding of what internal team coaches need to be successful.
View
... Basketball is a multi-player sports program, which has certain requirements on students' individual physical quality and basketball skills and needs to ensure that all participants have a strong teamwork spirit and ability [11][12]. The use of sports basketball teaches students various skills and qualities of training, the need for scientific and skillful introduction of basketball games, so as to further enhance the effect of teamwork spirit of college students [13][14]. ...
A study on the modeling of shooting probability in basketball sports competition sport
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2024
In basketball sports competition sports, shooting percentage is an important indicator of basketball players. In this paper, the trajectory of basketball sports shooting is solved by mathematical modeling and simulation. In the first step, the hyperparameter estimation of the variance is obtained by using the SURE-Type Double shrinkage estimation method. In the second step, the variance of the SUREDSC method is determined by sampling from the hyperparametric distribution using the Bootstrap method. In the third step, the covariates were taken into account and combined with the Ghoreishi bi-level shrinkage estimation method to obtain the optimal shrinkage estimate of the probability of hitting a basketball shot. The results of the study yielded that α differs from β when α ≤ 75°. When α >75°, α and β are very close. When the angle of incidence is certain, the angle of the ball shot is negatively correlated with the height of the athlete, and the degree of reduction decreases with the increase of the angle of incidence. The prediction success rate of the shot probability model was 87.98%, and the overall error rate was small, and the prediction results of the seven games were basically consistent with the prediction results of the constructed shot probability model. The study offers a guide for basketball managers to weigh the pros and cons of player transfers.
View
... The bulk of aviation accidents, medical mishaps, and industrial disasters have well-established root causes that include deficiencies in team leadership, coordination, and communication. Additionally, they have been connected to several military and political tragedies [16]. ...
Agent Based Intelligent System for Enhanced Teamwork Performance
Article
Full-text available
  • May 2024
It is impossible to overstate the necessity of a strategic and practical approach in the workplace in order to maximize productivity these days. Teamwork is one of the best ways to adapt to the changes that have occurred in today's environment throughout time. In every industry, the optimum performance arrangement for realizing visions, carrying out plans, and accomplishing objectives is teamwork. It is also one of the most crucial components of systems for continuous improvement since it makes information exchange, issue resolution, and the growth of employee accountability easier. Teams function as a grouping of people with complementary talents who work together rather than against one another. They are held accountable for their strategic methods and use them to achieve a shared objective. The Supervised Learning technique was used in this work to simulate team performance utilizing an intelligent coaching agent. Through the use of an automated performance assessment and weighted scores for each task, this study was able to create a system that will remove biases from performance evaluation. As soon as a worker does the task, they will obtain a score. The purpose of this study was to demonstrate an event-based performance approach by developing and utilizing an intelligent coaching agent in a supervised learning team training framework. The goal was successfully met, and the result shows positive impacts on the team's performance.
View
View
Enhancing team dynamics through digital coaching: the role of managerial and peer support
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2024
Purpose Although the literature on the effectiveness of team interventions is constantly expanding, there has been a strong focus on the process mechanisms that could explain their success, often overlooking the contextual aspects in which these interventions are carried out. Based on the Context-Mechanism-Outcome framework, this study aims to investigate the influence of contextual factors on the effectiveness of digital team coaching interventions that use social network visualisation to enhance team coordination and reduce interpersonal conflicts. Design/methodology/approach Using a multi-wave, longitudinal design, this research analysed 38 work teams from three organisations over three-time points. Data collection focused on manager and peer support, the mechanisms of training transfer and action plan implementation and the outcomes of these interventions. Surveys were administered in three organisations, involving 317 respondents across different phases. The intervention spanned six to eight months, incorporating three to four structured online group sessions. Each session involved a multi-stage process, concluding with a result-oriented action plan about work-related goals. The intervention included social network visualisation, discussions, coaching and continuous refinement of action plans. Findings The analysis highlights how manager support significantly correlates with team coordination and performance, mainly when teams are less engaged in implementing action plans. Peer support did not show a mediating effect on training transfer or outcomes but had direct positive impacts on team coordination and performance. Practical implications Teams actively implementing action plans may require less immediate managerial support for effective coordination and high performance. The manager’s role becomes crucial, particularly in the early stages of the intervention or in those teams where online coordination alone may not be adequate for action plan implementation. Peer support for training transfer could enhance the effectiveness of the intervention in achieving desired team outcomes; therefore, cultivating a supportive peer environment is crucial for the success of such interventions. Monitoring and assessing team dynamics are vital to maximise the benefits of digital team coaching interventions. Originality/value This study stands out for its innovative exploration of the interplay between managerial and peer support in the context of digital team coaching, using social network visualisation as a novel approach to enhancing team dynamics.
View
Networks and Leadership Development
Chapter
  • Jun 2024
Social network analysis is the application of network science to groups of people (or other entities) linked together through some common purpose (e.g., shared work). Social networks comprise links or ties among nodes (i.e., individuals or actors, broader collectives, or other entities) in a bounded but permeable space. Much as an organizational chart represents the formal organization in terms of reporting relationships, a social network is a way to understand the informal organizing structure among any group of people. It is argued that through interactions and appropriate interventions that a collective capacity for leadership emerges in a network of actors (i.e., individuals) involved in shared work. Network theory and social network analyses offer a useful lens and methodological/analytical approach to understand leadership capacity at a collective level of analysis. A related concept is that of social capital, or the value inherent in the relationships developed among people in a network. In this way, leadership resides between people in their links or ties rather than the leader-centric assumption that a leader is the sole cause of leadership in a system.
View
Developing a Collective Capacity for Leadership
Chapter
  • Jun 2024
This chapter takes a more collective level of analysis (e.g., group, team, organization) with a focus on leadership development rather than individual leader development. Although the focus is different in terms of level and scope, the development of leaders and the development of collective capacity for leadership are not mutually exclusive endeavors. Whereas leader development is mainly about human capital development, leadership development focuses on social capital as the relevant outcome. Instead of focusing on the intrapersonal development of an individual leader as enhancing the potential for leadership, a collective focus recognizes that leadership is found in the interpersonal connections among individuals engaged in shared work. Rather than a systems input, leadership is conceptualized as an output shaped by systems structure and processes. Much less is known about collective forms of leadership development than those pertaining to individual leader development; however, there has been some notable work in recent years that will be summarized in this chapter. As with leader development, time is an important consideration. Proximal and distal outcomes of leadership development—leading and lagging indicators—are presented and explained.
View
Advancing the Science of Developing Leaders and Leadership
Chapter
  • Jun 2024
This volume offered a scholarly perspective on the emerging science of developing leaders and leadership. Where available, scientific evidence is summarized to support the choice of appropriate developmental pathways (i.e., processes and practices) that enhance the likelihood of effective leader and leadership development occurring. This chapter concludes with a focused summary of key points to consider for future research and practice, but especially for research. A set of research questions is posed to help guide further advances in the nascent science of leader and leadership development. A mandate going forward is to encourage the scientific study of developing leaders and leadership, elevating the field to something on par but different from what is found in the leadership literature. It is also a counterweight to the voluminous marketplace of self-help books that promise to make someone a great leader, preferably right away.
View
Physical Challenge Interventions and the Development of Transferable Skills for the Workplace: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Article
  • Apr 2024
This study presents a systematic review and meta-analysis synthesising the existing research on the effectiveness of interventions featuring physical challenges for developing transferable skills and psychological health outcomes. Results from 47 independent samples across 44 studies revealed that the overall proximal effects of the interventions were medium ( g = 0.51) and that effects gradually diminished over time ( g = 0.39). Analyses across individual outcomes revealed interventions positively influenced interpersonal ( g = 0.55), intrapersonal ( g = 0.53), and cognitive skills ( g = 0.53), as well as psychological health outcomes ( g = 0.56). Moderator analyses indicate interventions can be potentially beneficial irrespective of design and participants involved. However, the current state of the literature does not truly allow for thorough conclusions to be made regarding the appropriateness and effectiveness of physical challenge interventions for organizational settings.
View
The Effects of Team Reflexivity on Psychological Well-Being in Manufacturing Teams
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2017
While the impact of team reflexivity (a.k.a. after-event-reviews, team debriefs) on team performance has been widely examined, we know little about its implications on other team outcomes such as member well-being. Drawing from prior team reflexivity research, we propose that reflexivity-related team processes reduce demands, and enhance control and support. Given the centrality of these factors to work-based strain, we posit that team reflexivity, by affecting these factors, may have beneficial implications on 3 core dimensions of employee burnout, namely exhaustion, cynicism, and inefficacy (reduced personal accomplishment). Using a sample of 469 unskilled manufacturing workers employed in 73 production teams in a Southern Chinese factory, we implemented a time lagged, quasi-field experiment, with half of the teams trained in and executing an end-of-shift team debriefing, and the other half assigned to a control condition and undergoing periodic postshift team-building exercises. Our findings largely supported our hypotheses, demonstrating that relative to team members assigned to the control condition, those assigned to the reflexivity condition experienced a significant improvement in all 3 burnout dimensions over time. These effects were mediated by control and support (but not demands) and amplified as a function of team longevity.
View
Leadership Training Design, Delivery, and Implementation: A Meta-Analysis
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2017
Recent estimates suggest that although a majority of funds in organizational training budgets tend to be allocated to leadership training (Ho, 2016; O'Leonard, 2014), only a small minority of organizations believe their leadership training programs are highly effective (Schwartz, Bersin, & Pelster, 2014), calling into question the effectiveness of current leadership development initiatives. To help address this issue, this meta-analysis estimates the extent to which leadership training is effective and identifies the conditions under which these programs are most effective. In doing so, we estimate the effectiveness of leadership training across four criteria (reactions, learning, transfer, and results; Kirkpatrick, 1959) using only employee data and we examine 15 moderators of training design and delivery to determine which elements are associated with the most effective leadership training interventions. Data from 335 independent samples suggest that leadership training is substantially more effective than previously thought, leading to improvements in reactions (δ = .63), learning (δ = .73), transfer (δ = .82), and results (δ = .72), the strength of these effects differs based on various design, delivery, and implementation characteristics. Moderator analyses support the use of needs analysis, feedback, multiple delivery methods (especially practice), spaced training sessions, a location that is on-site, and face-to-face delivery that is not self-administered. Results also suggest that the content of training, attendance policy, and duration influence the effectiveness of the training program. Practical implications for training development and theoretical implications for leadership and training literatures are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record
View
Saving Lives: A Meta-Analysis of Team Training in Healthcare
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2016
As the nature of work becomes more complex, teams have become necessary to ensure effective functioning within organizations. The healthcare industry is no exception. As such, the prevalence of training interventions designed to optimize teamwork in this industry has increased substantially over the last 10 years (Weaver, Dy, & Rosen, 2014). Using Kirkpatrick’s (1956, 1996) training evaluation framework, we conducted a meta-analytic examination of healthcare team training to quantify its effectiveness and understand the conditions under which it is most successful. Results demonstrate that healthcare team training improves each of Kirkpatrick’s criteria (reactions, learning, transfer, results; d = .37 to .89). Second, findings indicate that healthcare team training is largely robust to trainee composition, training strategy, and characteristics of the work environment, with the only exception being the reduced effectiveness of team training programs that involve feedback. As a tertiary goal, we proposed and found empirical support for a sequential model of healthcare team training where team training affects results via learning, which leads to transfer, which increases results. We find support for this sequential model in the healthcare industry (i.e., the current meta-analysis) and in training across all industries (i.e., using meta-analytic estimates from Arthur, Bennett, Edens, & Bell, 2003), suggesting the sequential benefits of training are not unique to medical teams. Ultimately, this meta-analysis supports the expanded use of team training and points toward recommendations for optimizing its effectiveness within healthcare settings.
View
Trust and Team Performance: A Meta-Analysis of Main Effects, Moderators and Covariates
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2016
Cumulating evidence from 112 independent studies (N = 7,763 teams), we meta-analytically examine the fundamental questions of whether intrateam trust is positively related to team performance, and the conditions under which it is particularly important. We address these questions by analyzing the overall trust-performance relationship, assessing the robustness of this relationship by controlling for other relevant predictors and covariates, and examining how the strength of this relationship varies as a function of several moderating factors. Our findings confirm that intrateam trust is positively related to team performance, and has an above-average impact (ρ = .30). The covariate analyses show that this relationship holds after controlling for team trust in leader and past team performance, and across dimensions of trust (i.e., cognitive and affective). The moderator analyses indicate that the trust-performance relationship is contingent upon the level of task interdependence, authority differentiation, and skill differentiation in teams. Finally, we conducted preliminary analyses on several emerging issues in the literature regarding the conceptualization and measurement of trust and team performance (i.e., referent of intrateam trust, dimension of performance, performance objectivity). Together, our findings contribute to the literature by helping to (a) integrate the field of intrateam trust research, (b) resolve mixed findings regarding the trust-performance relationship, (c) overcome scholarly skepticism regarding the main effect of trust on team performance, and (d) identify the conditions under which trust is most important for team performance. (PsycINFO Database Record
View
Leading Teams: Past, Present, and Future Perspectives
Chapter
  • Dec 2012
The study of leadership is a rapidly evolving, multi-faceted field. Leadership is conceptualized as a social and cultural phenomenon, which cannot be fully understood from a single perspective. The leader, the follower, the context, and the interactions amongst these elements must all be considered. The Oxford Handbook of Leadership explores the complex relationship between leader, led, and the environment that constitutes leadership. Divided into five parts, it provides comprehensive coverage of the field, exploring the roles individual attributes, training, and development play in generating a leader who is capable of performing effectively. The book also examines the relationship between leadership and contextual factors in terms of an organizational role, one's culture, and a specific setting (e.g. military, higher education, and presidential). It furthermore takes a critical look at the extent to which leader and follower behavior in a social and/or organizational context are tied. The book also gives a consideration of what leader effectiveness means (i.e., what differentiates effective from ineffective leadership, including insights and scholarship that have emerged regarding this issue). A concluding chapter provides some overall comments concerning the current state of leadership research and some thoughts about potentially fruitful directions. Leadership research has come a long way, but the inherent dimensionality of the field leaves room for new insights and new directions.
View
View
View
View
View
View