ArticlePDF Available

Spiritually Integrated Cognitive Processing Therapy: A New Treatment for Post-traumatic Stress Disorder That Targets Moral Injury

Authors:
  • South Texas VA

Abstract

Background Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a debilitating disorder, and current treatments leave the majority of patients with unresolved symptoms. Moral injury (MI) may be one of the barriers that interfere with recovery from PTSD, particularly among current or former military service members. Objective Given the psychological and spiritual aspects of MI, an intervention that addresses MI using spiritual resources in addition to psychological resources may be particularly effective in treating PTSD. To date, there are no existing empirically based individual treatments for PTSD and MI that make explicit use of a patient’s spiritual resources, despite the evidence that spiritual beliefs/activities predict faster recovery from PTSD. Method To address this gap, we adapted Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT), an empirically validated treatment for PTSD, to integrate clients’ spiritual beliefs, practices, values, and motivations. We call this treatment Spiritually Integrated CPT (SICPT). Results This article describes this novel manualized therapeutic approach for treating MI in the setting of PTSD for spiritual/religious clients. We provide a description of SICPT and a brief summary of the 12 sessions. Then, we describe a case study in which the therapist helps a client use his spiritual resources to resolve MI and assist in the recovery from PTSD. Conclusion SICPT may be a helpful way to reduce PTSD by targeting MI, addressing spiritual distress, and using a client’s spiritual resources. In addition to the spiritual version (applicable for those of any religion and those who do not identify as religious), we have also developed 5 religion-specific manuals (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, and Hinduism) for clients who desire a more religion-specific approach.
Original Article
Spiritually Integrated Cognitive
Processing Therapy: A New Treatment
for Post-traumatic Stress Disorder
That Targets Moral Injury
Michelle Pearce, PhD
1
, Kerry Haynes, DMin, BCC
2
, Natalia R Rivera,
LCSW, CADCT
3
, and Harold G. Koenig, MD
4,5
Abstract
Background: Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a debilitating disorder, and current treatments leave the majority of
patients with unresolved symptoms. Moral injury (MI) may be one of the barriers that interfere with recovery from PTSD,
particularly among current or former military service members.
Objective: Given the psychological and spiritual aspects of MI, an intervention that addresses MI using spiritual resources in
addition to psychological resources may be particularly effective in treating PTSD. To date, there are no existing empirically
based individual treatments for PTSD and MI that make explicit use of a patient’s spiritual resources, despite the evidence
that spiritual beliefs/activities predict faster recovery from PTSD.
Method: To address this gap, we adapted Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT), an empirically validated treatment for PTSD,
to integrate clients’ spiritual beliefs, practices, values, and motivations. We call this treatment Spiritually Integrated CPT
(SICPT).
Results: This article describes this novel manualized therapeutic approach for treating MI in the setting of PTSD for spiritual/
religious clients. We provide a description of SICPTand a brief summary of the 12 sessions. Then, we describe a case study in
which the therapist helps a client use his spiritual resources to resolve MI and assist in the recovery from PTSD.
Conclusion: SICPT may be a helpful way to reduce PTSD by targeting MI, addressing spiritual distress, and using a client’s
spiritual resources. In addition to the spiritual version (applicable for those of any religion and those who do not identify as
religious), we have also developed 5 religion-specific manuals (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, and Hinduism) for
clients who desire a more religion-specific approach.
Keywords
post-traumatic stress disorder, moral injury, religion, spirituality, psychotherapy
Received November 9, 2017. Received revised January 16, 2018. Accepted for publication January 23, 2018
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is one of the most
debilitating disorders affecting military service members
and is a precipitating factor for suicide.
1
Of those that
seek treatment from PTSD, only 20% to 30% fully
recover,
2
making the development of more effective
interventions a research and public health priority. One
of the factors that seems to impede the effectiveness of
current PTSD treatments is moral injury. Moral injury
(MI) has been defined as ‘‘perpetrating, failing to pre-
vent, bearing witness to, or learning about acts that
transgress deeply held moral beliefs,’’
3
and experiencing
1
Department of Family and Community Medicine, Center for Integrative
Medicine, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2
South Texas Veterans Health Care System, San Antonio, Texas
3
254th MED DET (COSC), 332d Expeditionary Medical Group Clinic,
MSAB
4
Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, Duke University Medical
Center, Durham, North Carolina
5
Department of Psychiatry, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Corresponding Author:
Michelle Pearce, Center for Integrative Medicine, University of Maryland
School of Medicine, 520 W. Lombard Street, East Hall, Baltimore, MD
21201, USA.
Email: mpearce@som.umaryland.edu
Global Advances in Health and Medicine
Volume 7: 1–7
!The Author(s) 2018
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/2164956118759939
journals.sagepub.com/home/gam
Creative Commons Non Commercial CC BY-NC: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-
NonCommercial 4.0 License (http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial use, reproduction and
distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://
us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
‘‘a deep sense of transgression including feelings of
shame, grief, meaninglessness, and remorse from
having violated core moral beliefs,’’
4
and ‘‘betrayal of
what’s right, by someone who holds legitimate authority,
in a high-stakes situation.’’
5
Notably, MI can result in
psychological symptoms (eg, shame, guilt, rage) and spir-
itual symptoms (eg, spiritual struggles, moral concerns,
loss of meaning, self-condemnation, difficulty forgiving,
loss of faith, loss of hope).
6
MI appears to be a barrier to
recovery from PTSD
5
and is positively correlated with
PTSD among Veterans.
7–10
In a recent study with 427
Veterans, 90% had at least 1 symptom of moral injury
that was rated 9 or 10 on a scale from 1 to 10, and 50%
had 5 or more symptoms at this level.
11
Spirituality is an important and complex phenomenon
that needs to be considered in the conceptualization and
treatment of PTSD. Spirituality has the potential to be a
positive and protective resource or an exacerbating
factor for PTSD or both. Active duty soldiers and
Veterans report high rates of spirituality/religiosity
(S/R),
12,13
and many reports relying on their faith to
cope.
14
Service members who reported higher S/R also
reported less substance use, risky behaviors, and better
affect.
12
On the other hand, individuals with spiritual
struggles report lower recovery rates from PTSD and a
greater need for VA (Veterans Affairs)-approved mental
health services.
15,16
Given that MI and spiritual struggles
are common among those with combat-related
PTSD,
9,17,18
a PTSD intervention that specifically
addresses a patient’s spirituality and MI may be particu-
larly effective in reducing PTSD symptoms.
6,19
Over the last decade, several interventions have been
developed to address MI in the context of PTSD, includ-
ing Adaptive Disclosure,
3
Trauma Informed Guilt
Reduction Therapy,
20
and ACT for moral injury.
21
These treatments are advances in the treatment of
PTSD and have shown promising results; however,
none of these MI interventions have specifically included
spiritual resources or targeted spiritual distress, which as
discussed are important components of MI. In contrast,
a few interventions have used spiritual resources and
these have shown promise for reducing PTSD, including
Mantra Meditation,
22
Mindfulness Meditation,
23
and
Building Spiritual Strengths.
24,25
Although these inter-
ventions included spiritual resources, they did not
target or measure MI. In addition, Building Spiritual
Strengths is a group intervention delivered by chaplains.
Notably, Resick et al. recently found that 1-on-1
Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT) for PTSD was
more effective than group CPT.
26
In summary, although moral injury is intimately con-
nected with spiritual beliefs and values, these are typic-
ally not addressed in secular approaches, not to mention
spiritual struggles and loss of religious faith due to
trauma, which are typically not addressed at all.
Instead, secular approaches focus on thinking errors,
dysfunctional cognitions, erroneous underlying assump-
tions, and rational justifications, not on spiritual
resources, spiritual struggles, and the spiritual ramifica-
tions of trauma and their interconnection with symptoms
of PTSD. In addition, among the approaches that do
address spirituality in the treatment of PTSD, moral
injury is typically not addressed, particularly for individ-
ual treatment. Therefore, there is a need for empirically
based individual treatments for PTSD that target MI
that make explicit use of a patient’s spiritual resources,
particularly given the evidence that such resources pre-
dict faster resolution of PTSD.
9,27
Spiritually Integrated Cognitive
Processing Therapy
To address this gap, we (a clinical psychologist, an active
duty military psychologist, a psychiatrist, and a VA
chaplain, all with expertise in developing and/or
researching spiritually integrated treatments) have devel-
oped Spiritually Integrated Cognitive Processing
Therapy (SICPT). This novel treatment is an adaptation
of CPT,
28
one of the primary empirically validated treat-
ments for PTSD and one of the three treatments used by
the VA for Veterans with PTSD.
29
In addition to CPT’s
large evidence based for reducing PTSD, we chose to
adapt CPT because of the overlap between MI and
PSTD and the fact that many aspects of MI can be
addressed by the same approach used for PTSD.
CPT is designed to target inaccurate or maladaptive
beliefs—called stuck points—that result in guilt, shame,
and self-blame, rendering individuals stuck in their
trauma recovery. CPT uses cognitive restructuring and
behavioral exercises to help individuals change the way
they think about the trauma. These cognitive changes
allow individuals to better process their emotions, con-
textualize the event, and integrate the experience in a
more positive or adaptive way into their lives. Similar
to CPT, SICPT is designed for individuals experiencing
PTSD across the spectrum of severity, from mild to
severe symptom presentations.
SICPT differs from CPT in 5 major ways. First,
SCIPT specifically targets MI as a major barrier to
achieving recovery from PTSD, whereas CPT directly
targets PTSD. Second, SICPT targets MI by challenging
erroneous interpretations of trauma by focusing on cog-
nitive restructuring using clients’ spiritual/religious
resources (ie, spiritual beliefs, practices, sacred writings,
values, and motivations) to challenge maladaptive think-
ing patterns. Third, given that MI does not always reflect
erroneous interpretations—accurate and legitimate self-
blame and guilt can result from intentional perpetration
or an intentional lack of action—cognitive restructuring
may not be sufficient for the resolution of MI.
30
2Global Advances in Health and Medicine
To address the need for moral repair, SICPT employs
spiritual tools to help resolve moral injury and its dama-
ging sequelae, such as shame, guilt, rage, demoralization,
and self-handicapping behaviors. Specifically, SICPT
uses the spiritual concepts and rituals of compassion,
grace, spiritual guided imagery, repentance, confession,
forgiveness, atonement, blessing, restitution, and making
amends.
Fourth, SICPT also encourages patients to access sup-
port from or emersion in a faith community, which can
help with recovery and reintegration. Finally, in addition
to identifying spiritual resources to aid in recovery, spir-
itual struggles, which are part of MI, are specifically
normalized and addressed in treatment. Spiritual strug-
gles might include feeling angry at God for allowing this
to happen, feeling punished by God, questioning God’s
love and one’s religious faith, feeling abandoned by God
or one’s faith community, or a complete loss of faith as a
result of severely traumatic experiences. (‘‘God’’ is used
here to represent the person’s understanding of a tran-
scendent power or higher being, which may widely vary.)
Given that SICPT makes explicit use of a patient’s
spiritual/religious beliefs, this intervention is only appro-
priate for individuals who identify as spiritual or reli-
gious. In a recent multisite study, nearly three-quarters
of 427 Veterans indicated that religion was important or
very important in their lives, over 80% indicated this for
spirituality, and more than two-thirds indicated that they
would definitely engage in or be open to engaging in a
spiritually integrated treatment such as SICPT.
11
Thus,
at least among U.S. Veterans, the vast majority finds
religion/spirituality important and would be receptive
to and eligible for such a treatment.
Session Content
Similar to CPT, SICPT is delivered in 12 sessions over 6
to 12 weeks.
31
Each session is 50 to 60 min in length and
follows a similar format.
Session 1: Moral Injury and Rationale for SICPT
focuses on rapport building, education on PTSD and
MI, and the rationale for spiritually integrated cognitive
processing treatment that targets MI to reduce PTSD.
The patients’ most traumatic event to be targeted in
treatment is defined. For homework, patients write a
statement describing the impact of the trauma on their
beliefs about God, self, others, and the world; their spir-
itual belief, practices, and well-being; and how the
trauma may have violated their conscience or created
moral distress.
Session 2: Meaning of the Event and Spirituality begins
with patients reading their impact statement and discuss-
ing its meaning, particularly that of the MI and the trau-
ma’s impact on their spiritual beliefs and practices.
‘‘Stuck points’’ (ie, erroneous or unhelpful beliefs driving
the experience of negative emotions) are then added to
the stuck point log. Patients state how they define and
practice their spirituality and what spiritual resources
they have available to them. The relationship between
thoughts, feelings, and behavior are introduced using
the A–B–C (Antecedent, Belief, and Consequence) work-
sheet. For homework, patients complete A–B–C work-
sheets and the My Spiritual Resources worksheet, which
includes identifying someone in their spiritual commu-
nity that might provide support during SICPT.
Session 3: Spiritual Resources and Moral Injury begins
with a review of the worksheets completed for home-
work. Stuck points are discussed, particularly as they
relate to MI, self-blame, and spiritual struggles.
Patients are encouraged to make use of their spiritual
resources and have regular contact with their support
person. The spiritual values of cultivating kind attention
and compassion are introduced as a lens through which
to view the trauma and MI, in order to combat self-
blame and condemnation. For homework, patients com-
plete A–B–C worksheets on MI stuck points and read a
short story on compassion.
Session 4: Kind Attention and Compassion begins by
reviewing the A–B–C worksheets on MI stuck points and
by discussing story on compassion. The impact that
trauma and MI can have on one’s spiritual well-being
is explained and spiritual distress is normalized.
Lament is introduced as a formal expression of sorrow
and spiritual grief. The Spiritually Integrated
Challenging Questions worksheet is introduced to help
patients challenge stuck points using their spiritual
beliefs and values. For homework, patients complete
the Spiritually Integrated Challenging Questions work-
sheets, read the Spiritual Reactions to Trauma and MI
worksheet, and write a lament.
Session 5: Challenging Questions and Spiritual Distress
begins by reviewing the Spiritually Integrated
Challenging Questions worksheet, discussing identified
spiritual distress, and reading aloud and processing the
patient’s lament. The spiritual ritual of confession/
acknowledgement is introduced as a tool for dealing
with guilt resulting from violating one’s moral code
(eg, self-induced MI or rage/revenge for other-induced
MI); if applicable, a confession ritual is chosen by the
patient (eg, acknowledging in prayer the moral violation
to a moral authority or confession to a priest, depending
on client’s faith tradition). The Patterns of Problematic
Thinking worksheet is introduced, which is completed
for homework, along with a daily confession ritual.
Session 6: Confession Ritual and Problematic Thinking
begins by reviewing the Patterns of Problematic
Thinking worksheet and the impact of emotions and
thoughts that resulted from the spiritual ritual of confes-
sion. The spiritual tool of forgiveness is introduced as a
tool for healing MI. Discussion includes the stages of the
Pearce et al. 3
REACH model of forgiveness (Recall, Empathize,
Altruism, Committing, and Holding on)
32
and possible
targets of forgiveness (ie, self, others, God). Patients
identify someone they want to forgive for the MI. The
Spiritually Integrated Challenging Beliefs worksheet is
introduced, and the first 2 steps of forgiveness are
assigned for homework. Patients also read a short
story on forgiveness.
Session 7: Forgiveness I and Challenging Beliefs begins
with reviewing the Spiritually Integrated Challenging
Beliefs worksheet and patients’ success with and impact
of the first 2 steps of forgiveness. The last 3 steps in the
REACH forgiveness model are introduced. The theme of
trust for self, others, and God are discussed, including
how their ability to trust may have changed as a result of
the trauma and MI. For homework, patients read a
module on trust and complete the REACH forgiveness
worksheet. They also complete Spiritually Integrated
Challenging Beliefs worksheets, particularly targeting
stuck points related to forgiveness.
Session 8: Forgiveness II and Trust begins with a
review of the REACH forgiveness worksheets and the
Spiritually Integrated Challenging Beliefs worksheets,
focusing on stuck points related to trust and forgiveness.
Making amends (or restitution) is introduced as a spir-
itual tool for dealing with MI. If this is applicable,
patients choose one action to complete over the next
week to help another person, with the goal of neutraliz-
ing feelings of shame and guilt. The spiritual tool of ver-
bally blessing others is introduced, and patients are
asked to choose someone to bless. The theme of esteem
for self, others, and God/divine being is also presented.
For homework, patients read a module on esteem and
complete Spiritually Integrated Challenging Belief work-
sheets on esteem-related stuck points, engage in the
making amends action, and create and daily say a
verbal blessing for someone.
Session 9: Making Amends and Esteem begins with a
review of the completion and impact of the making
amends and verbal blessing exercises, as well as the
esteem-related Spiritually Integrated Challenging
Beliefs worksheets. The theme of power/control related
to self, others, and God/divine being is introduced next.
Spiritual discrepancies related to power and control (ie,
how one’s lived experiences may differ from one’s spir-
itual beliefs) are discussed and the emotions and stuck
points that may have risen from these discrepancies. For
homework, patients read a module on power/control and
complete Spiritually Integrated Challenging Beliefs
worksheets on this theme, particularly those related to
spiritual discrepancies.
Session 10: Power, Control, and Spiritual
Discrepancies begins with a review of the Spiritually
Integrated Challenging Beliefs worksheets related to
power/control. Spiritual discrepancies and spiritual
issues related to power, such as anger at God, the limited
nature of human perspective, free will, and active surren-
der, are discussed. The theme of intimacy related to self,
others, and God is introduced. Spiritual partnerships are
discussed, both in terms of how trauma and MI can
impact these relationships and how deepening or reenga-
ging in spiritual partnerships/community can help with
the healing process. For homework, patients choose one
way to develop greater intimacy with God or someone in
their spiritual community. They also read a module on
intimacy and complete Spiritually Integrated
Challenging Beliefs worksheets on stuck points related
to intimacy.
Session 11: Spiritual Partnerships and Intimacy begins
with a review of the Spiritually Integrated Challenging
Beliefs worksheets on intimacy and the completion and
impact of the action to deepen intimacy. The theme of
safety related to self, others, and God/divine being is
introduced. The session concludes with the concept of
post-traumatic growth (PTG; experiencing growth and
benefits as a result of going through challenges and
trauma) and how patients might be able to experience
this, if they have not already. For homework, patients
read a module on safety and complete Spiritually
Integrated Challenging Beliefs worksheets on safety-
related stuck points. They also write another trauma
impact statement, state their current level of moral dis-
tress, and describe possible PTG they may have experi-
enced or could imagine experiencing in the future.
Session 12: Post-Traumatic Growth and Safety begins
by reviewing the Spiritually Integrated Challenging
Beliefs worksheets on safety. Patients read the new
impact statement and compare it to the original impact
statement. Changes and growth are discussed, particu-
larly as they relate to MI, spiritual well-being, and PTG.
The rest of the session is spent reviewing the course of
treatment and the major concepts and skills they learned,
including their spiritual tools and resources (eg, compas-
sion, kind attention, lament, confession/acknowledg-
ment, forgiveness, making amends, verbal blessing,
spiritual partnerships). Any remaining issues that need
attention are identified, and future goals are set. Finally,
patients are asked to ‘‘pay it forward’’ to other people,
including those with similar issues, family members, their
spiritual community, and those in need.
Religion-specific SICPT Supplements
The manual-based sessions described above were
designed to be applicable for patients with spiritual
and religious beliefs, with particular care given to make
the therapy appropriate for patients who identify as spir-
itual, but not necessarily religious. We have also devel-
oped brief religion-specific SICPT supplements that
cover each of the 12 sessions. These supplements are
4Global Advances in Health and Medicine
available for 5 major world religions: Christianity,
Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism. For each ses-
sion, the supplements describe specific religious con-
cepts, teachings, principles, and stories about religious
figures that might inform treatment. Sacred scriptures,
prayers, and rituals that relate to the content of each
session are also provided. These religion-specific supple-
ments are designed to aid therapists in deepening the
work with their religious clients and providing back-
ground information about the various faith traditions
that might be helpful in addressing trauma and MI.
Note that given space limitations, we are limited in
how much detail we can provide on the content of the
sessions in this article. For those who would like more
detail, we would be happy to provide the full treatment
manual and religions-specific supplements that are cur-
rently being refined through field testing and a future
randomized controlled trial.
SICPT Case Study
This case is a compilation of several patients to protect
confidentiality.
James is a 39-year-old Hispanic man and Iraq War
Veteran who was diagnosed with PTSD. He presented at
the VA for treatment, and upon evaluation, he scored 57
on the PTSD Checklist—DSM-5—Military Version
(PCL-5) and described various war-related traumatic
experiences on the Life Events Checklist-DSM-5. He
reported experiencing flashbacks and nightmares,
among other symptoms, since returning to the United
States 1 year ago. The traumatic experience he named
as most troublesome for him was ‘‘doing something bad’’
on a convoy he commanded. James also shared that his
Christian faith was important to him, although he found
it hard to practice as actively as before his deployment.
Upon learning of the option of engaging in SICPT,
James chose this treatment approach.
In session 1 of SICPT, James became teary-eyed when
learning about the concept of moral injury and agreed to
write about the convoy memory that plagued him for his
impact statement that week. In session 2, James read
his impact statement. He described the power inherent
in his position as Convoy Commander and the presence,
on that day, of a visiting dignitary, an attractive female
who was assigned to travel in his vehicle. He stated that a
civilian vehicle was repeatedly attempting to pass his
convoy. At his orders, the vehicle was temporarily
deterred by other military vehicles, but the civilian
driver did not give up. Finally, as the vehicle approached
James’ vehicle, he ordered his driver to force it off the
road. Right before the vehicle crashed, he saw a man and
a woman in the front seat, with 2 small children in the
back seat. He expressed much anger at the civilian driver
for not standing down. He described the far-reaching
implications of that experience, including losing trust in
himself, others, and God, and feeling distant in his rela-
tionships. Regarding moral distress, he wrote, ‘‘Some
actions are too bad to be forgiven.’’
In session 3, during the introduction of the spiritual
values of kind attention and compassion for self, James
again became teary-eyed. He remarked that he did not
have a supportive community, and that he knew his
church would reject him if they knew what he had
done. He chose his uncle as his support person. In ses-
sion 4, he reported a great deal of spiritual distress,
which he wrote about in his lament that week.
During the review of ABC worksheets in session 5, the
therapist remarked on James’ tendency to be self-
condemning. James began to open up about why the
convoy experience bothered him so much. He said,
There is that moment of decision when you must act and
do what is right for the safety of all. But there is also that
little voice inside that knows the truth. One small part of
me forced that vehicle off the road into the overpass
embankment—not to ensure our safety—but to show
off for my VIP. What kind of person does that? I
wasn’t raised that way. I know God doesn’t approve of
that. What if those people all died in that car?
The therapist sought to convey understanding, but did
not offer any quick answers. Instead, after a few minutes,
the therapist introduced the spiritual ritual of confession/
acknowledgment, a tool for resolving justified guilt.
After discussion, James indicated he would be open to
talking with a clergy person. Instead of his pastor, he
opted for a referral to a mental health chaplain at
his VA.
In session 6, James said he had not yet met with the
chaplain, but had confessed his action to God in prayer.
He was still struggling with guilt and shame from the
event and said he wanted to work on forgiving himself.
In sessions 7 and 8, they worked through the REACH
forgiveness steps and he was able to forgive himself for
his action motivated by wanting to impress the VIP.
During this time, he also described a ‘‘great’’ visit with
the chaplain, who told him that no act is beyond the
reach of God’s grace and forgiveness.
In session 9, for his making amends activity, James
chose to volunteer with a local nonprofit that provides
clothes and furniture to impoverished families. He
wanted to dedicate his work there to the memory of
the family in Iraq that was involved in the car accident.
In session 10, he discussed his fear of returning to
church, but also his longing to have those kinds of rela-
tionships in his life again. He e-mailed the therapist on
Monday morning to say that he had gone to the Sunday
morning worship service and was pleasantly surprised
that people did not stare at him. He said that he even
Pearce et al. 5
had a nice conversation with a parishioner and that he
intended to return next Sunday. In session 11, they went
through the concept of PTG, and after the session, he
noted that maybe his deepening intimacy with his wife
was the start of this kind of growth.
In his second impact statement, which he read aloud in
session 12, James said he had learned a valuable lesson from
the convoy command on that day of the accident. He
quoted the adage of ‘‘absolute power corrupting abso-
lutely,’’ and decided that he, along with the rest of the
human community, was susceptible to temptation. He
was also able to describe the sadness he felt for the
family, but seemed to have made peace with the guilt. His
PCL score registered at 31, indicating comparably reduced
symptoms from his initial 57 score, and which fell under the
cutoff of 35 for a probable diagnosis of PTSD. He also told
the therapist that he hoped to help other Veterans like him-
self who were stuck in guilt and shame and that using the
resources of his Christian faith would help him in finding
healing from this traumatic event.
Conclusion
The recognition and treatment of PTSD has come a long
way over the last few decades. We believe one of the next
important steps for improving PTSD treatment effective-
ness is to address specific barriers to recovery. One of
these barriers is moral injury. Given that moral injury is
composed of both psychological and spiritual symptoms,
it follows that the most effective treatments for MI in the
context of PTSD will be those that address both types of
symptoms. As such, a spiritually integrated treatment
that targets moral injury may reduce one of the barriers
to full recovery from PTSD and may provide much
needed relief for those who are suffering, particularly
those who serve our country and protect our freedom.
We offer SICPT as one such intervention that has the
potential to fill this treatment gap. Research is needed to
determine the empirical effectiveness of this approach for
individuals who desire a spiritually or religiously inte-
grated treatment for trauma.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with
respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
article.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research,
authorship, and/or publication of this article.
References
1. Sareen J, Cox BJ, Stein MB, Afifi TO, Fleet C, Asmundson
GJG. Physical and mental comorbidity, disability, and
suicidal behavior associated with posttraumatic stress dis-
order in a large community sample. Psychosom Med. 2007;
69:242–248.
2. Marmar CR, Schlenger W, Henn-Haase C, et al. Course of
posttraumatic stress disorders 40 years after the Vietnam
War. JAMA Psychiatry. 2015;72(9):875–881.
3. Litz BT, Lebowitz L, Gray MJ, Nash WP. Adaptive
Disclosure: A New Treatment for Military Trauma, Loss,
and Moral Injury. New York, NY: Guilford Press, 2015.
4. Brock RN, Lettini G. Soul Repair: Recovering From Moral
Injury After War. Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 2012.
5. Shay J. Moral injury. Psychoanal Psychol. 2014;
31(2):182–191.
6. Koenig HG, Boucher NA, Youssef N, Oliver JP, Currier
JM, Pearce MJ. Spiritually-oriented cognitive processing
therapy for moral injury in active duty military and
Veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder. J Nerv Ment
Dis. 2017;205(2):147–153.
7. Dokoupil T. A new theory of PTSD and veterans: moral
injury. Newsweek.com. 2012. http://www.newsweek.com/
new-theory-ptsd-and-veterans-moral-injury-63539.
Accessed November 2, 2017.
8. Nash WP, Marino Carper TL, Mills MA, Au T, Goldsmith
A, Litz BT. Psychometric evaluation of the moral injury
events scale. Mil Med. 2013;178(6):646–652.
9. Currier JM, Holland JM, Drescher KD. Spirituality fac-
tors in the prediction of outcomes of PTSD treatment
for U.S. military veterans. J Trauma Stress. 2015;
28(1):57–64.
10. Youssef NA, Boswell, E, Fiedler S, et al. Moral injury,
posttraumatic stress disorder, and religious involvement
in U.S. Veterans. Ann Clin Psychiatry. 2018. In press.
11. Koenig HG, Currier JM, McDermott RC, et al. The Moral
Injury Symptom Scale-military version. J Relig Health.
2017. Published online. DOI 10.1007/s10943-017-0531-9.
12. Barlas FM, Higgins WB, Pflieger JC, Diecker K. 2011
Health Related Behaviors Survey of Active Duty Military
Personnel: Executive Summary (Department of Defense).
2013. Contract No. GS-23F-8182H.
13. Maxfield B. FY13 Army Religious Affiliations. Source:
Chief, Office of Army Demographics (DMDC West); 2014.
14. Koenig HG, Cohen HJ, Blazer DG, et al. Religious coping
and depression in elderly hospitalized medically ill men.
Am J Psychiatry. 1992;149:1693–1700.
15. Fontana A, Rosenheck R. Trauma, change in strength of
religious faith, and mental health service use among vet-
erans treated for PTSD. J Nerv Ment Dis. 2004;
192(9):579–584.
16. Currier JM, Holland JM, Drescher K, Foy D. Initial psy-
chometric evaluation of the moral injury question-
naire—military version. Clin Psychol Psychother. 2015;
22(1):54–63.
17. Currier JM, Drescher KD, Harris JI. Spiritual functioning
among veterans seeking residential treatment for PTSD: a
matched control group study. Spiritual Clin Pract. 2014;
1(1):3–15.
18. Ogden H, Harris JI, Erbes C, et al. Religious functioning
and trauma outcomes among combat veterans. Couns
Spiritual. 2011;30:71–89.
6Global Advances in Health and Medicine
19. Wade N. Integrating cognitive processing therapy and spir-
ituality for the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder
in the military. Soc Work Christian. 2017;43(3):59–72.
20. Norman SB, Wilkins KC, Myers US, Allard CB. Trauma
informed guilt reduction therapy with combat veterans.
Cogn Behav Pract. 2014;21(1):78–88.
21. Nieuwsma JA, Walser RD, Farnsworth JK, Drescher KD,
Meador KG, Nash WP. Possibilities within acceptance and
commitment therapy for approaching moral injury. Curr
Psychiatry Rev. 2015;11:193–206.
22. Bormann JE, Thorp S, Wetherell JL, Golshan S. A spir-
itually based group intervention for combat veterans with
posttraumatic stress disorder: feasibility study. J Holist
Nurs. 2008;26(2):109–116.
23. Kearney DJ, McDermott K, Malte C, Martinez M,
Simpson TL. Association of participation in a mindfulness
program with measures of PTSD, depression and quality
of life in a veteran sample. J Clin Psychol. 2012;
68(1):101–116.
24. Harris JI, Erbes CR, Engdahl BE, et al. The effectiveness
of a trauma focused spiritually integrated intervention for
veterans exposed to trauma. J Clin Psychol. 2011;
67(4):425–438.
25. Harris I, Usset T, Voeck C, Thuras P, Currier J, Erbes C.
Spiritually integrated care for PTSD: a randomized con-
trolled trial of ‘‘Building Spiritual Strength.’’ J Affect
Disord. Under review.
26. Resick PA, Wachen JS, Dondanville KA, et al. Effect of
group vs individual cognitive processing therapy in active-
duty military seeking treatment for posttraumatic stress
disorder: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Psychiatry.
2017;74(1):28–36.
27. Tsai J, El-Gabalawy R, Sledge WH, Southwick SM,
Pietrzak RH. Post-traumatic growth among veterans in
the USA: results from the National Health and
Resilience in Veterans Study. Psychol Med. 2015;45:
165–179.
28. Resick PA, Nishith P, Weaver TL, Astin MC, Feuer CA. A
comparison of cognitive-processing therapy with pro-
longed exposure and a waiting condition for the treatment
of chronic posttraumatic stress disorder in female rape vic-
tims. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2002;70:867–879.
29. McHugh RK, Barlow DH. The dissemination and imple-
mentation of evidence-based psychological treatments: a
review of current efforts. Am Psychol. 2010;65:73–84.
30. Gray MJ, Schorr Y, Nash W, et al. Adaptive disclosure.
Behav Ther. 2012;43(2):407–415.
31. Resick PA, Monson CM, Chard KM. Cognitive Processing
Therapy: Veteran/Military Version: Therapist’s Manual.
Washington, DC: Veterans Administration, 2014.
32. Wade N, Hoyt W, Kidwell J, Worthington E. Efficacy of
psychotherapeutic interventions to promote forgiveness: a
meta-analysis. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2014;82:154–170.
Pearce et al. 7
... As chaplaincy has evolved over the last two decades to incorporate belief systems extending beyond the original Christian model of chaplaincy, so too has research exploring the range of activities conducted by chaplains. Programs conducted by individual chaplains and/or in collaboration with healthcare professionals such as psychologists, have been shown to better equip soldiers and promote wellbeing in advance of deployment Thomas et al., 2018), as well as support them in the theatre of war (Roberts et al., 2018), help them to recover after diagnosis of MI and/or PTSD (Ames et al., 2021;Hodgson et al., 2022;Pearce et al., 2018), and reduce veteran and service member suicide rates (Davis, 2022). ...
Article
Full-text available
A module to explore perspectives on chaplaincy services was included in an online enterprise survey randomly distributed to members of the Australian Defence Force (ADF) during 2021. Up to eight questions were answered by 2783 active military personnel relating to their perception of chaplain activities and the impact of chaplaincy services. Of those military participants answering the question on religious status (n = 1116), a total of 71.6% (n = 799) of respondents identified as non-religious while 28.4% (n = 317) identified as holding a religious affiliation. Approximately 44.2% (n = 1230) of participants had sought support from a chaplain, of which 85.3% (n = 1049) found chaplaincy care to be satisfactory or very satisfactory. While the data suggest there is a lack of clarity around the multiple roles undertaken by chaplaincy, nevertheless respondents were just as likely to prefer chaplains for personal support (24.0%), as they were to seek help from non-chaplaincy personnel such as a non-ADF counsellor (23.2%), their workplace supervisor (23.1%) or a psychologist (21.8%). This evidence affirms that the spiritual care provided by military chaplaincy remains one of several preferred choices and thus a valued part of the holistic care provided by the ADF to support the health and wellbeing of its members.
... Rebuilding religious meaning after war trauma is not uncommon (MacDermott, 2010;Owens et al., 2009;Steger et al., 2015) since old meanings no longer provide comfort and solace (Drescher & Foy, 2008;Kopacz et al., 2019). Spiritual support is important for the mental health of veterans (Kopacz et al., 2017;Pearce et al., 2018;Smith-MacDonald et al., 2017), and when such support is unavailable, mounting guilt (Fontana & Rosenheck, 2004) has been found to be associated with early death in veterans (see also Drescher & Foy, 1995). ...
Article
Full-text available
There is growing evidence that the spiritual/religious (S/R) beliefs of war veterans change, even years after the war. Researchers need to explore these changes in different cultures and religions. This study therefore identified S/R changes in Iranian war veterans after three decades of war between Iran and Iraq. The participants were veterans (n = 14), their relatives (n = 5: wives [3] and children [2]), and service providers and decision and policymakers (n = 12) at the Foundation for Martyrs and Veterans’ Affairs (N = 31) in Iran. We collected data with semistructured interviews and used an inductive approach to carry out thematic content analysis (Graneheim et al. in Nurse Education Today, 56, 29–34 2017). Two key themes emerged, namely, questioning S/R values and finding new S/R beliefs and concepts. Qualitative assessment of S/R status in Iranian war veterans should assist service providers in making referrals, evaluations, and interventions, which could include spiritual and culture-based care.
... Bryan et al.'s study among military personnel identified that the construct of moral injury and PTSD are distinct [3] and reinforced by Sun et al.'s study evaluating brain-imagery response patterns [4]. Since these are two distinct constructs, it is important to identify whether someone is experiencing PTSD or moral injury because it is known that moral injury can impede the effectiveness for PTSD treatment and recovery [45]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Opinion statement Moral injury is extensively studied among trauma-exposed veterans. Two measurement scales are available to screen for symptoms of moral injury among trauma-exposed veterans; however, no measurement scale exists screening for symptoms of moral injury among trauma-exposed firefighters. The objective of this study aims to address the gap in available instruments by developing a moral injury assessment scale for firefighters. Through this project, a psychometrically accepted moral injury scale will be available to researchers, clinicians, and fire organizations to assess moral injury in trauma-exposed firefighters. Military studies found that moral injury and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are distinct constructs and can co-exist. PTSD is prevalent in firefighters and despite subject experts expressing the need to expand research efforts to first responders (e.g., firefighters), no moral injury scale is available assessing these symptoms. Exploratory themes are recently emerging in these occupations. The EMIS-F yielded almost perfect interrater reliability across raters (.97). Psychometric properties of the EMIS-F were comparable to the military version, yielding excellent internal consistency (ω = 0.94), in addition to the self-directed (ω = 0.92) and others-directed (ω = 0.89) moral injury subscales. Inter-item and item-total correlations are within acceptable ranges (ρ = 0.30–0.73) to empirically conclude the EMIS-F measures a unidimensional construct. Item-total correlations did not detract from the consistency of the overall scale and independently demonstrated positive correlations with the EMIS-F (ρ = .62–79). The EMIS-F demonstrated strong convergent validity with validated measures of PTSD (ρ = .61), depression (ρ = .50), and suicide ideation (ρ = .38), and evidence of divergent validity with strong support systems (ρ = − .14).
... None of these assessed suicide-related outcomes. Spiritually-Integrated CPT purports to target moral injury, as is demonstrated in a case study, but no data is reported on suiciderelated outcomes [80]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose of Review This review summarizes empirical studies investigating the associations between moral injury and suicide-related outcomes. Recent Findings A total of 47 studies met inclusion criteria and were reviewed. Samples included military, veteran, and civilian populations. Overall, more exposure to potentially morally injurious events (PMIE) and greater morally injurious symptom severity were both related to increased risk for suicide-related outcomes, including suicidal ideation and suicide attempt[s], and composite suicide-related variables. The strength of the association depended on the population, assessments used to measure moral injury and suicide-related outcomes, and covariates included in the model. Mediators and moderators of the association were identified including depression, posttraumatic stress, hopelessness, guilt, shame, social support, and resilience. Summary Moral injury confers a unique risk for suicide-related outcomes even after accounting for formalized psychiatric diagnosis. Suicide prevention programs for military service members, veterans, and civilians working in high-stress environments may benefit from targeted interventions to address moral injury. While suicide-related outcomes have not been included in efficacy trials of moral injury interventions, mediators and moderators of the association between moral injury and suicide-related outcomes are potential targets for therapeutic change, including disclosure, self-forgiveness, and meaning-making.
... Emerging research has found that veterans are often interested in incorporating religious and spiritual considerations into treatment, and research on religiously integrated psychotherapy has shown potential in the veteran community (Currier et al., 2018;Pearce et al., 2018). Thus, it may be important to consider the role of religion and spirituality in mental health care, and incorporate religious and spiritual concerns into mental health treatment, including a possible referral to a chaplaincy if necessary (Koenig, 2000). ...
Article
Background: Rising suicide rates in the U.S. veteran population are a growing concern. Combat exposure has been identified as a potential predictor of suicide risk, but factors that may mediate the relation between combat exposure and suicide risk, and the role of potential coping mechanisms remain largely understudied. To address this gap, this study examined the association between lifetime combat exposure and current suicide risk; whether this association is mediated by posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms; and whether direct and/or indirect associations with combat exposure are moderated by organizational, non-organizational, and intrinsic religiosity. Methods: Data were analyzed from the National Health and Resilience in Veterans Study (2019-2020; n = 3843). Ordinary least squares and conditional process analyses were conducted to evaluate the conditional direct and indirect predictors of suicide risk. Results: PTSD symptoms significantly mediated the association between combat exposure and suicide risk. Intrinsic religiosity showed significant moderation and reduced the coefficient of PTSD symptoms predicting suicide risk but increased the coefficient of combat exposure predicting PTSD symptoms. Limitations: In this cross-sectional, observational study, no conclusions can be made regarding causality. Conclusions: Results of this study suggest a multifaceted relationship between combat exposure, PTSD, religiosity/spirituality, and suicide risk in U.S. veterans, and underscore the importance of PTSD and religious coping as part of ongoing suicide prevention efforts in this population.
... 13 Other developed treatments focus on MI-disrupted spiritual beliefs using spiritually integrated cognitive processing therapy. 14 However, these treatments are developed from samples of US military persons, and significant differences between deployment experiences and mental health difficulties has been found between US and other militaries. 15 Given the subjective and sensitive nature of PMIEs and the intense distress that individuals can experience, it is important to consider the needs and experiences of patients in development of MI treatment. ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction Moral injury (MI) significantly impacts the lives of many UK military veterans however, there is a lack of manualised treatment to address the needs of this population. To develop future treatments that are acceptable and well tolerated, veterans should be consulted on their experiences of existing psychological treatments and suggestions for future treatments. Methods 10 UK military veterans were interviewed about their experiences of receiving treatment for psychological difficulties after MI, and beliefs about core components of future treatments. Thematic analysis of these interviews were conducted. Results 2 superordinate themes were identified: experiences of previous mental health treatment and perceptions of the proposed treatments. Reflections on cognitive behavioural therapy were mixed, with some describing that it did not ameliorate their guilt or shame. In future treatments, focusing on values, using written letters and including therapy sessions with close companions were considered beneficial. Veterans reported that a strong rapport with therapist was key for MI treatment. Conclusion Findings provide a useful account of how current post-trauma treatments may be experienced by patients with MI. Although limited by sample size, the results highlight therapeutic approaches that may be helpful in future and provide important considerations for therapists treating MI.
... Older adults have a high coping mechanism according to socio-cultural structure (potential spiritual, religious beliefs), which is consistent with a study done by Palgi. Y. [59,60]. Moreover, older people were reported to learn coping mechanisms from experience; also, older age was associated with less sensitivity, fewer negative beliefs, and decreased mood symptoms [61]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstract Background Natural disasters cause long term psychological consequences, especially post-traumatic stress disorders. It has been regarded as the most prevalent of psychiatric disorders after a natural disaster. The purpose of this study is to estimate the prevalence of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and determine its associated factors in adult survivors three years after the 2015 Nepal earthquake. Methods A cross-sectional descriptive design was used where 1076 adults within the age range of 19–65 were randomly selected and interviewed from four adversely affected districts due to the 2015 earthquake. Instruments included a demographic questionnaire, an earthquake exposure questionnaire, the Oslo Social Support Scale (OSSS), and the Post-traumatic Stress Disorder Checklist-Civilian Version (PCL-C). Descriptive and inferential statistics were applied using Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) Version 16 for data analysis. Results The prevalence of PTSD among earthquake survivors was 18.9%. The multivariate logistic regression showed that gender, ethnicity, education, occupation, social support and severity of damage to house and property were significantly associated with PTSD. Odds of having PTSD was 1.6 times higher among females (AOR = 1.6, 95% CI: 1.1–2.3) and nearly 2 times higher amongst illiterate survivors (AOR = 1.9, 95% CI: 1.2–2.8). Participants from the Janajati ethnic group and those who had a business occupation had a 50% lower risk of having PTSD. Around 39% of the participants had moderate social support and had 60% lower odds of having PTSD compared to those with poor social support (AOR = 0.4, 95%CI: 0.2–0.5, p
Thesis
Full-text available
This mixed-methods Doctor of Ministry Research Project examined peers' roles during crisis management situations and sought to improve their knowledge, skills, readiness, and confidence during crises. Peers are often the first to see precursors of a crisis or are the first present when a crisis ensues. This was true in the ministry context of a United States Army Reserve unit. A training program was developed to equip participants on crisis precursor identification, prevention, intervention, stabilization, post-intervention, and normalization concepts and techniques. Additionally, ethical consideration, professional resources, and resiliency concepts were trained. The concepts were delivered via an online web-based platform for asynchronous participation. The twelve participants reported improved confidence and knowledge of the presented topics. The participants reported that they better understood how to manage the crisis management cycle and were more confident aiding peers in crisis. The research results improved the local ministry context's crisis management support and can be applied in other contexts.
Chapter
Moral injury is a syndrome that has been observed in healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. It is manifested as a group of symptoms that, if not well managed, can lead toward adverse physical and mental health consequences. Moral injury results when personal beliefs, ethical and moral principles have been trespassed by omission, commission, or while witnessing such actions committed by others. This chapter describes the ways in which the principles of Viktor Frankl’s logotherapy and existential analysis can be applied to manage moral injury in healthcare professionals.
Article
Full-text available
Background: Traumatic experiences can cause ethical conflicts. "Moral injury" (MI) has been used to describe this emotional/cognitive state, and could contribute to the development of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) or block its recovery. We examine the relationship between MI and PTSD, and the impact of religious involvement (RI) on that relationship. Methods: We conducted a study of 120 veterans enrolled at the Charlie Norwood VA Medical Center in Augusta, Georgia. Standard measures of PTSD symptoms, MI, and RI were administered. Regression models were used to examine correlates of PTSD symptoms and the moderating or mediating effects of RI. Results: A strong relationship was found between MI and PTSD symptoms (r = 0.54, P ≤ .0001), and between MI and RI (r = -.41, P ≤ .0001), but only a weak relationship was found between RI and PTSD symptoms (r = -.17, P = .058). RI did not mediate or moderate the relationship between MI and PTSD symptoms in the overall sample. However, among non-Middle Eastern war theater veterans, a significant buffering effect of religiosity was found. Conclusions: MI has a strong positive relationship with PTSD symptoms and an inverse relationship with RI. RI did not mediate or moderate the relationship between MI and PTSD in the overall sample, but it moderated this relationship in non-Middle Eastern war theater veterans.
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this study was to develop a multi-dimensional measure of moral injury symptoms that can be used as a primary outcome measure in intervention studies that target moral injury (MI) in Veterans and Active Duty Military with PTSD. This was a multi-center study of 427 Veterans and Active Duty Military with PTSD symptoms recruited from VA Medical Centers in Augusta, Los Angeles, Durham, Houston, and San Antonio, and from Liberty University in Lynchburg. Internal reliability of the Moral Injury Symptom Scale-Military Version (MISS-M) was examined along with factor analytic, discriminant, and convergent validity. Participants were randomly split into two equal samples, with exploratory factor analysis conducted in the first sample and confirmatory factor analysis in the second. Test–retest reliability was assessed in a subsample of 64 Veterans. The 45-item MISS-M consists of 10 theoretically grounded subscales assessing guilt, shame, moral concerns, religious struggles, loss of religious faith/hope, loss of meaning/purpose, difficulty forgiving, loss of trust, and self-condemnation. The Cronbach’s alpha of the overall scale was .92 and of individual subscales ranged from .56 to .91. The test–retest reliability was .91 for the total scale and ranged from .78 to .90 for subscales. Discriminant validity was demonstrated by relatively weak correlations with other psychosocial, religious, and physical health constructs, and convergent validity was indicated by strong correlations with PTSD, depression, and anxiety symptoms. The MISS-M is a reliable and valid multi-dimensional symptom measure of moral injury that can be used in studies targeting MI in Veterans and Active Duty Military with PTSD symptoms and may also be used by clinicians to identify those at risk.
Article
Full-text available
Moral injury and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) are both topics that have only quite recently been introduced into the mental health literature. Although inquiries into these two domains have been advanced independent from one another, both challenge various aspects of the traditional medical model for diagnosing, understanding, and treating psychiatric problems. This article explores complementary possibilities for using ACT to approach the care of persons with moral injury. Descriptions of moral injury and ACT are provided along with an overview of the developmental histories and relevant research literature in each of these domains. Specific possibilities for attending to moral injury are explored via examination of each of the six core processes in ACT: acceptance; cognitive defusion; contact with the present moment; self-as-context; values; and committed action. It is suggested that ACT has unique potential as an evidence-based psychotherapy for approaching numerous moral injury related issues. These include: understanding human suffering as normative, expectable, and potentially meaningful; balancing both verbal and experiential understandings of morality; fostering forgiveness in a manner that is not dismissive of guilt but employs it to orient towards values; holding and honoring morally injurious experiences in a way that respects and empathizes with ongoing suffering; identifying a sense of self from which to behaviorally enact valued actions; and inviting engagement from care providers and communities outside of the traditional mental health care system. Future conceptual and empirical work is needed, including studies examining the efficacy and effectiveness of ACT for moral injury.
Article
Full-text available
Spirituality is a multifaceted construct that might affect Veterans’ recovery from posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in adaptive and maladaptive ways. Drawing on a cross-lagged panel design, this study examined longitudinal associations between spirituality and PTSD symptom severity among Veterans in a residential treatment program for combat-related PTSD. Results indicated that spirituality factors at the start of treatment were uniquely predictive of PTSD symptom severity at discharge, when accounting for combat exposure and both synchronous and autoregressive associations between these variables, βs = 0.10 to 0.16. Specifically, Veterans who scored higher on adaptive dimensions of spirituality (daily spiritual experiences, forgiveness, spiritual practices, positive religious coping, and organizational religiousness) at intake fared significantly better in this program. In addition, possible spiritual struggles (operationalized as negative religious coping) at baseline were predictive of poorer PTSD outcomes. In contrast to these results, PTSD symptomatology at baseline did not predict any of the spirituality variables at post-treatment. In keeping with a spiritually-integrative approach to treating combat-related PTSD, these results suggest that understanding the possible spiritual context of Veterans’ trauma-related concerns might add prognostic value and equip clinicians to alleviate PTSD symptomatology among those Veterans who possess spiritual resources and/or are somehow struggling in this domain.
Article
Full-text available
The term moral injury has recently begun to circulate in the literature on psychological trauma. It has been used in two related, but distinct, senses; differing mainly in the “who” of moral agency. Moral injury is present when there has been (a) a betrayal of “what’s right”; (b) either by a person in legitimate authority (my definition), or by one’s self—“I did it” (Litz, Maguen, Nash, et al.); (c) in a high stakes situation. Both forms of moral injury impair the capacity for trust and elevate despair, suicidality, and interpersonal violence. They deteriorate character. Clinical challenges in working with moral injury include coping with [1] being made witness to atrocities and depravity through repeated exposure to trauma narratives, [2] characteristic assignment of survivor’s transference roles to clinicians, and [3] the clinicians’ countertransference emotions and judgments of self and others. A trustworthy clinical community and, particularly, a well-functioning clinical team provide protection for clinicians and are a major factor in successful outcomes with morally injured combat veterans. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2014 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Full-text available
Background There is increasing recognition that, in addition to negative psychological consequences of trauma such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), some individuals may develop post-traumatic growth (PTG) following such experiences. To date, however, data regarding the prevalence, correlates and functional significance of PTG in population-based samples are lacking. Method Data were analysed from the National Health and Resilience in Veterans Study, a contemporary, nationally representative survey of 3157 US veterans. Veterans completed a survey containing measures of sociodemographic, military, health and psychosocial characteristics, and the Posttraumatic Growth Inventory-Short Form. Results We found that 50.1% of all veterans and 72.0% of veterans who screened positive for PTSD reported at least ‘moderate’ PTG in relation to their worst traumatic event. An inverted U-shaped relationship was found to best explain the relationship between PTSD symptoms and PTG. Among veterans with PTSD, those with PTSD reported better mental functioning and general health than those without PTG. Experiencing a life-threatening illness or injury and re-experiencing symptoms were most strongly associated with PTG. In multivariable analysis, greater social connectedness, intrinsic religiosity and purpose in life were independently associated with greater PTG. Conclusions PTG is prevalent among US veterans, particularly among those who screen positive for PTSD. These results suggest that there may be a ‘positive legacy’ of trauma that has functional significance for veterans. They further suggest that interventions geared toward helping trauma-exposed US veterans process their re-experiencing symptoms, and to develop greater social connections, sense of purpose and intrinsic religiosity may help promote PTG in this population.
Article
Wartime experiences have long been known to cause ethical conflict, guilt, self-condemnation, difficulty forgiving, loss of trust, lack of meaning and purpose, and spiritual struggles. "Moral injury" (MI) (also sometimes called "inner conflict") is the term used to capture this emotional, cognitive, and behavioral state. In this article, we provide rationale for developing and testing Spiritually Oriented Cognitive Processing Therapy, a version of standard cognitive processing therapy for the treatment of MI in active duty and veteran service members (SMs) with posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms who are spiritual or religious (S/R). Many SMs have S/R beliefs that could increase vulnerability to MI. Because the injury is to deeply held moral standards and ethical values and often adversely affects spiritual beliefs and worldview, we believe that those who are S/R will respond more favorably to a therapy that directly targets this injury from a spiritually oriented perspective. An evidence-based treatment for MI in posttraumatic stress disorder that not only respects but also utilizes SMs' spiritual beliefs/behaviors may open the door to treatment for many S/R military personnel.
Article
Importance: Cognitive processing therapy (CPT), an evidence-based treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), has not been tested as an individual treatment among active-duty military. Group CPT may be an efficient way to deliver treatment. Objective: To determine the effects of CPT on PTSD and co-occurring symptoms and whether they differ when administered in an individual or a group format. Design, setting, and participants: In this randomized clinical trial, 268 active-duty servicemembers consented to assessment at an army medical center from March 8, 2012, to September 23, 2014, and were randomized to group or individual CPT. Inclusion criteria were PTSD after military deployment and stable medication therapy. Exclusion criteria consisted of suicidal or homicidal intent or psychosis. Data collection was completed on June 15, 2015. Analysis was based on intention to treat. Interventions: Participants received CPT (the version excluding written accounts) in 90-minute group sessions of 8 to 10 participants (15 cohorts total; 133 participants) or 60-minute individual sessions (135 participants) twice weekly for 6 weeks. The 12 group and individual sessions were conducted concurrently. Main outcomes and measures: Primary measures were scores on the Posttraumatic Symptom Scale-Interview Version (PSS-I) and the stressor-specific Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist (PCL-S); secondary measures were scores on the Beck Depression Inventory-II (BDI-II) and the Beck Scale for Suicidal Ideation (BSSI). Assessments were completed by independent evaluators masked to treatment condition at baseline and 2 weeks and 6 months after treatment. Results: Among the 268 participants (244 men [91.0%]; 24 women [9.0%]; mean [SD] age, 33.2 [7.4] years), improvement in PTSD severity at posttreatment was greater when CPT was administered individually compared with the group format (mean [SE] difference on the PSS-I, -3.7 [1.4]; Cohen d = 0.6; P = .006). Significant improvements were maintained with the individual (mean [SE] PSS-I, -7.8 [1.0]; Cohen d = 1.3; mean [SE] PCL-S, -12.6 [1.4]; Cohen d = 1.2) and group (mean [SE] PSS-I, -4.0 [0.97]; Cohen d = 0.7; mean [SE] PCL-S, -6.3 [1.4]; Cohen d = 0.6) formats, with no differences in remission or severity of PTSD at the 6-month follow-up. Symptoms of depression and suicidal ideation did not differ significantly between formats. Conclusions and relevance: Individual treatment resulted in greater improvement in PTSD severity than group treatment. Depression and suicidal ideation improved equally with both formats. However, even among those receiving individual CPT, approximately 50% still had PTSD and clinically significant symptoms. In the military population, improving existing treatments such as CPT or developing new treatments is needed. Trial registration: clinicaltrials.gov identifier: NCT02173561.
Article
The long-term course of readjustment problems in military personnel has not been evaluated in a nationally representative sample. The National Vietnam Veterans Longitudinal Study (NVVLS) is a congressionally mandated assessment of Vietnam veterans who underwent previous assessment in the National Vietnam Veterans Readjustment Study (NVVRS). To determine the prevalence, course, and comorbidities of war-zone posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) across a 25-year interval. The NVVLS survey consisted of a self-report health questionnaire (n = 1409), a computer-assisted telephone survey health interview (n = 1279), and a telephone clinical interview (n = 400) in a representative national sample of veterans who served in the Vietnam theater of operations (theater veterans) from July 3, 2012, through May 17, 2013. Of 2348 NVVRS participants, 1920 were alive at the outset of the NVVLS, and 81 died during recruitment; 1450 of the remaining 1839 (78.8%) participated in at least 1 NVVLS study phase. Data analysis was performed from May 18, 2013, through January 9, 2015, with further analyses continued through April 13, 2015. Study instruments included the Mississippi Scale for Combat-Related PTSD, PTSD Checklist for DSM-IV supplemented with PTSD Checklist for DSM-5 items (PCL-5+), Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale for DSM-5 (CAPS-5), and Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV, Nonpatient Version. Among male theater veterans, we estimated a prevalence (95% CI) of 4.5% (1.7%-7.3%) based on CAPS-5 criteria for a current PTSD diagnosis; 10.8% (6.5%-15.1%) based on CAPS-5 full plus subthreshold PTSD; and 11.2% (8.3%-14.2%) based on PCL-5+ criteria for current war-zone PTSD. Among female veterans, estimates were 6.1% (1.8%-10.3%), 8.7% (3.8%-13.6%), and 6.6% (3.5%-9.6%), respectively. The PCL-5+ prevalence (95% CI) of current non-war-zone PTSD was 4.6% (2.6%-6.6%) in male and 5.1% (2.3%-8.0%) in female theater veterans. Comorbid major depression occurred in 36.7% (95% CI, 6.2%-67.2%) of veterans with current war-zone PTSD. With regard to the course of PTSD, 16.0% of theater veterans reported an increase and 7.6% reported a decrease of greater than 20 points in Mississippi Scale for Combat-Related PTSD symptoms. The prevalence (95% CI) of current PCL-5+-derived PTSD in study respondents was 1.2% (0.0%-3.0%) for male and 3.9% (0.0%-8.1%) for female Vietnam veterans. Approximately 271 000 Vietnam theater veterans have current full PTSD plus subthreshold war-zone PTSD, one-third of whom have current major depressive disorder, 40 or more years after the war. These findings underscore the need for mental health services for many decades for veterans with PTSD symptoms.