ArticlePDF Available

Municipal isomorphism: testing the effects of vertical and horizontal collaboration

Authors:
Gabriel Piña
Gabriel Piña
Gabriel Piña
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Claudia Nancy Avellaneda at Indiana University Bloomington
Claudia Nancy Avellaneda
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

This study tests whether vertical and horizontal collaborative arrangements generate organizational isomorphic pressures. Using neo-institutional theory, we explore whether local governments emulate their peers when they are (1) bound through collaborative agreements/associations (mimetic pressures), and/or (2) scrutinized by central government through a vertical agreement (coercive pressures). Municipal isomorphism is measured by municipality-dyad convergence across time based on: (1) the number of central-government grant applications submitted by municipalities and (2) use of information technologies. We test for changes in divergence between dyads on these measures using data from all possible dyads generated from 207 Chilean municipalities over 10 years (2005–2014). After controlling for potential confounding factors, findings show mimetic and coercive pressures, from horizontal and vertical forms of governance, reduce a municipal dyad’s divergence in terms of grant applications and use of information technologies. However, collaboration effects on municipal isomorphism are contingent on the type of collaboration. While formal municipal agreements increase a municipal dyad’s convergence, municipal associations unexpectedly seem to decrease it.
Content uploaded by Claudia Nancy Avellaneda
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Claudia Nancy Avellaneda on Jan 22, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
Municipal isomorphism: testing the effects of vertical and horizontal col... http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14719037.2017.1412116?s...
1 of 6 1/22/2018, 9:39 AM
Municipal isomorphism: testing the effects of vertical and horizontal col... http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14719037.2017.1412116?s...
2 of 6 1/22/2018, 9:39 AM
Municipal isomorphism: testing the effects of vertical and horizontal col... http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14719037.2017.1412116?s...
3 of 6 1/22/2018, 9:39 AM
Municipal isomorphism: testing the effects of vertical and horizontal col... http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14719037.2017.1412116?s...
4 of 6 1/22/2018, 9:39 AM
Municipal isomorphism: testing the effects of vertical and horizontal col... http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14719037.2017.1412116?s...
5 of 6 1/22/2018, 9:39 AM
Municipal isomorphism: testing the effects of vertical and horizontal col... http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14719037.2017.1412116?s...
6 of 6 1/22/2018, 9:39 AM
... Haken, H. first defined "synergy" as a composite system that contains multiple subsystems and generates synergistic effects through non-linear interactions [53]. Later, this concept was applied in the innovation system theory, and the SR usually appeared in two ways: HS and VS [54][55][56]. HS refers to inter-organizational synergy within the same link of the industry chain [51], whereas VS refers to organizational synergy in different links of the industry chain [52]. Synergistic innovation is typically described as a process in which two or more industry chain members, such as raw material suppliers, builders, sellers, and customers, jointly plan and implement knowledge-related activities in the industry chain network [57][58][59]. ...
Synergistic Relationship, Agent Interaction, and Knowledge Coupling: Driving Innovation in Intelligent Construction Technology
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2024
The core driving force behind innovation in intelligent construction technology is synergistic relationships. It has become common practice to promote synergistic innovation through agent interaction and knowledge coupling in the development of intelligent construction technology. Drawing upon synergetics, social network theory, and the knowledge base view as theoretical frameworks, this research examines the impact of synergistic relationship, agent interaction, and knowledge coupling on innovation in intelligent construction technology. An empirical analysis of 186 questionnaires revealed the following: (1) regarding synergistic relationships, both horizontal synergy and vertical synergy significantly positively impact innovation in intelligent construction technology. (2) Concerning agent interaction, strong interaction serves as a mediator between horizontal synergy and innovation in intelligent construction technology, while weak interaction serves as a mediator between vertical synergy and innovation in intelligent construction technology. (3) Knowledge coupling has a positive moderating effect on innovation in intelligent construction technology under a strong interaction and a negative moderating effect on innovation in intelligent construction technology under a weak interaction. This study contributes to expanding the theory of synergistic relationships and its application in the context of intelligent construction technology. Furthermore, it provides practical insights and guidance for construction companies seeking to enhance innovation in intelligent construction technology through the utilization of agent interaction and knowledge coupling.
View
... In this study, we argue that isomorphic pressures provide one possible explanation for why local governments decide to experiment innovative ideas. Previous studies have shown that institutional theory is relevant to public organizations; they also pursue legitimacy by conforming to isomorphic pressures (Ashworth et al., 2009;Frumkin and Galaskiewicz, 2004;Jun and Weare, 2011;Piña and Avellaneda, 2018). In the context of our study, coercive isomorphism may have played some roles, as local governments are influenced by the reform program initiated by the central government. ...
Determinants of Digital Innovation in the Public Sector
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2022
  • GOV INFORM Q
This study explores the determinants of digital innovation in the public sector. Focusing specifically on new digital technologies, such as big data, artificial intelligence, Internet of things, and augmented reality, we explained the wide variation in how Korean local governments used these technologies to transform their services. We found support for four theoretical mechanisms. First, our findings support the existence of demand-pull innovation in the public sector: public organizations respond to citizen demands or needs for innovation. Second, we also find support for an electoral incentive hypothesis, which posits that local governments' motivation for digital innovation is influenced by local politicians' electoral incentives. Third, our results show the existence of isomorphic pressure as a driver for public sector innovation: public organizations emulate their neighbors in adopting innovative practices. Fourth, the results support the upper echelons theory, as younger policymakers are more active innovators.
View
View
Decoupled accounting in a non-profit context: An explanation for stable management accounting?
Article
  • Feb 2024
  • Crit Perspect Account
While extant literature on decoupling tends to focus on for-profit organizations, this paper examines the non-profit context, where donors are the most salient stakeholders and accountability to donors is paramount. Specifically, this research explores why management accounting in some non-profit contexts may be both decoupled and coupled from other accounting in the same context. Based on data from three large case study organizations, the findings indicate that donors’ demands for compliance-based financial accounting information, rather than for performance information, limits the availability and use of management accounting information; in essence, leaving it decoupled and coupled in different aspects. This is potentially to the detriment of organizational performance, and by association to beneficiaries and donors.
View
Collaborators, supplementers, purchasers and privatizers - profiling the social and health care delivery forms of finnish municipalities through cluster analysis
Article
  • Nov 2022
Municipalities´ service delivery choices are under constant public debate. To better understand the configurations of service delivery forms across different municipalities, we analyse all 309 Finnish municipalities’ delivery of 10 social and healthcare services. Five clusters emerge: Collaborators, Supplementers, Purchasers, Privatizers and Decentralizers (likely representing municipalities in transition). Overall, mixed delivery dominates. While the clusters present differences in municipal characteristics, surprisingly few statistically significant cost differences emerge, suggesting different configurations of efficient service delivery choices exist. Smaller municipalities can achieve economies of scale by collaboration, while large municipalities seem to ‘get away’ with going against transaction cost economics theory recommendations.
View
Inter-municipal vs. Inter-governmental Cooperation: Their Impact on International Aid
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2022
  • Publ Organ Rev
This study combines the type of partners and the number of partnerships’ purposes to assess municipal partnerships’ effectiveness in bringing international aid. First, the study test whether inter-municipal cooperation (homogenous partners) is more effective than inter-governmental cooperation (heterogeneous partners) in increasing international aid at the local level. Second, the study tests whether partnerships with the sole purpose of raising international aid (single purpose) are more effective than partnerships with additional purposes (multiple purposes). Using panel data with 2,431 municipal-year observations, results confirm that inter-governmental partnerships with multiple purposes are the most effective partnership to increase international aid.
View
Roles of policy brokers in collaborative governance: Evidence from Khon Kaen and Bueng Kan cities in Thailand
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2022
This article examines the roles of policy brokers in different settings of collaboration in Khon Kaen and Bueng Kan Cities in Thailand. It integrates the advocacy coalition and multiple stream frameworks to view how a policy broker in different collaborative settings would manage their preferred urban transport initiatives by conducting qualitative research methodology based on an embedded multiple case study approach. The results showed Khon Kaen City revealed a horizontal setting of local collaboration where the Khon Kaen Think Tank and Khon Kaen Transit System were key policy brokers that strategized light rail transit initiatives. These policy brokers were proficient in negotiating, financing, and locally-allied strategies. Bueng Kan City displayed a vertical collaboration where the Deputy Minister of Interior of Thailand was a crucial policy broker who held potential administrative and political powers to manage the desired policies. This study showed that several joint actors, as backing resources to policy brokers, were essential to horizontal collaboration, but they were less critical than the resources of the policy brokers in vertical collaboration.
View
Les déterminants de la qualité de la gestion des communes béninoises
Thesis
  • Dec 2021
Le Bénin, à l’instar de la plupart des pays africains, s’est engagé dans le processus de décentralisation suite à la conférence nationale des forces vives de la nation de février 1990. Les nouvelles communes, créées à la place des anciennes sous-préfectures, sont appelées à mettre en œuvre des compétences à elles dévolues avec pour finalité la démocratie locale et le développement à la base. Mais pour certains auteurs comme Vigoda-Gadot et al (2018) et Chitou (2013), les administrations publiques (Etat, entreprises publiques) sont généralement mal gérées et affichent des contre-performances récurrentes. La question qui se pose est de savoir si les nouvelles communes béninoises qui sont aussi des structures publiques peuvent faire exception à ce constat général de mauvaise qualité de la gestion des administrations publiques.L’objectif principal de cette étude est d’identifier les principaux déterminants de la qualité de la gestion des communes au Bénin. La démarche méthodologique est basée sur les modèles économétriques avec des données en panel à travers le logiciel STATA d’une part et la méthode d’évaluation des performances dénommée Data Enveloppement Analysis (DEA) d’autre part. En particulier, le modèle DEA a permis de mesurer les efficiences techniques globale, pure et d’échelle afin d’en faire un lien avec la qualité de la gestion des communes. Aux termes de l’étude, les résultats obtenus se présentent comme suit :- l’efficacité dans le fonctionnement des organes de gouvernance, la qualité des outils de gestion et la qualité du système d’information influencent positivement et significativement la qualité de la gestion;- les résultats montrent qu’il existe une relation entre l’efficience et la qualité de la gestion. Le score d’efficience technique globale influence positivement et significativement la qualité de la gestion lorsqu’il est dessus des seuils qui varient de 76,4% à 82,9% en fonction des modèles estimés. En dessous de ces seuils, l’efficience technique globale influence négativement la qualité de la gestion
View
Interagency Collaboration/Coordination in the Context of Pakistan: Case of Polio Eradication Program
Chapter
  • Jun 2022
The chapter takes a close look at the reforms and strategies that have been adopted for the eradication of polio in Pakistan. It digs deep into the changes that have taken place in the approach of how the government and the varied interlinked departments are dealing with this pressing concern. The chapter explains the functioning of all collaborative departments which include the government, international and third-party organizations. It provides a holistic view as to how the system has been put into place. It is a concern that despite initiatives and efforts being made, the task is not yet accomplished. Therefore, the possible reasons for not achieving the goal along with certain suggestions are also noted in the analysis.
View
Explaining interstate military friendly policy diffusion across U.S. universities: uncovering vertical-diagonal diffusion
Article
  • Aug 2021
This article examines the diffusion of diversity management policies across large state bureaucracies that operate in a national marketplace of ideas. We analyze organizational antecedents and horizontal, vertical, and vertical-diagonal diffusion mechanisms associated with the degree of diversity management convergence among research universities from 2008-2016. Findings suggest the long-theorized, but rarely measured, non-linear pattern of diffusion explains organizational adoptions and the degree of policy convergence across the system. We also show a vertical-diagonal process whereby policy spills over to influence policy choices in other lower-level governance systems. This spillover may explain how organizations make policy decisions in complex governance arrangements.
View
Developing and Testing an Integrative Framework for Open Government Adoption in Local Governments
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2016
  • PUBLIC ADMIN REV
Open government is an important innovation to foster trustworthy and inclusive governments. The authors develop and test an integrative theoretical framework drawing from theories on policy diffusion and innovation adoption. Based on this, they investigate how structural, cultural, and environmental variables explain three dimensions of open government: accessibility, transparency, and participation. The framework is tested by combining 2014 survey data and observational data from 500 local U.S. government websites. Organizational structure, including technological and organizational capacity, is a determinant shared by all dimensions of open government. Furthermore, accessibility is affected by a mixture of an innovative and participative culture and external pressures. A flexible and innovative culture positively relates to higher levels of transparency, whereas capacity is a strong predictor of adopting participatory features. The main conclusion is that there is no one-size-fits-all solution to fostering the three dimensions of open government, as each dimension is subject to a unique combination of determinants.
View
Linking Network Structure to Collaborative Governance
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2017
How do social networks differ between highly collaborative and less collaborative forms of governance? Drawing on a prior study that characterized the level of collaboration for three federal hydropower relicensing processes, we develop exponential random graph models of meeting attendance and participation networks. We find that the highly collaborative relicensing process had lower overall density and a propensity for relatively fewer and stronger interactions. Reciprocity is highest in the high-collaboration process, indicating that it is characterized by mutual interactions. In the low-collaboration process, patterns of connections between any three members of the network displayed a more unidirectional structure, suggesting asymmetrical interactions between active versus passive members of the network. By linking network structure to collaborative dynamics, this study helps elaborate potential mechanisms of successful collaboration.
View
Innovation and Change in the Chilean Health System
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2016
  • NEW ENGL J MED
Chile has had a two-tiered health system since the 1980s, though successive governments have worked to strengthen the public tier. Despite improvements in some health indicators, satisfaction with the system has declined, and the need for reform is widely acknowledged.
View
View
The collaborative public manager: New ideas for the twenty-first century
Book
  • Jan 2009
Today's public managers not only have to function as leaders within their agencies, they must also establish and coordinate multi-organizational networks of other public agencies, private contractors, and the public. This important transformation has been.
View
Does Benchmarking Encourage Improvement or Convergence? Evaluating North Carolina’s Fiscal Benchmarking Tool
Article
  • Oct 2017
Several states monitor the fiscal health of their local governments by "benchmarking" them-using a suite of financial indicators to track performance over time. Benchmarking of public organizations can facilitate performance management, leading to the spread of best practices and improved organizational performance. It is also possible that benchmarking, absent other performance routines, could create isomorphic pressures that encourage local governments to adopt policies that converge performance or financial indicators towards the group mean. This article tests these hypotheses using the introduction of North Carolina's financial benchmarking tool in 2010. We construct a panel of the 14 indicators used to assess and compare the financial positions of North Carolina county and municipal governments from fiscal year 2008 to 2014. We find support for isomorphism as the dispersion of several indicators declined in the post-implementation period without offsetting beneficial changes in the mean indicator value. These findings pose a dilemma for the quantitative evaluation of both benchmarking and performance management systems ; could offsetting changes result in null findings at the mean of the distribution?
View
Digital government and public management research: finding the crossroads
Article
  • May 2017
Information and information technologies have become ubiquitous in the public sector and it is difficult to think of a public problem or government service that does not involve them in some substantial way. Public management (PM) research now incorporates the effects of the availability and quality of data as well as the technologies used in the public sector. From a PM perspective, digital government (DG) could be considered an essential aspect of innovation, co-production, transparency, and the generation of public value. However, studies that attempt to understand the role that DG research plays in PM theory and practice are scarce. As a research field, DG emerged from multiple disciplines, including public administration, information science, management information systems, computer science, communication, and political science. There have been numerous efforts in the last decade to delineate this emergent academic community by assessing the growing body of research represented by hundreds of new peer-reviewed publications every year. This paper reviews these prior studies about the DG community, along with a systematic review of recent articles in top public administration journals from the United States and Europe, to begin to identify and compare key characteristics of these academic communities, including their core researchers, theories, topics, and methods. We argue that their similarities and differences present opportunities for more dialogue between DG and PM scholars that could produce synergies to enhance the production and dissemination of knowledge, yielding greater influence on practice.
View
Diffusion of Responsibility: An Interorganizational Analysis 1)
Chapter
  • Jan 1985
Three topics of scholarship that are insufficiently studied in conjunction with one another are moral philosophy, public administration, and interorganizational relations.
View
Designing and Implementing Cross-Sector Collaborations: Needed and Challenging
Article
  • Aug 2015
  • PUBLIC ADMIN REV
Theoretical and empirical work on collaboration has proliferated in the last decade. The authors’ 2006 article on designing and implementing cross-sector collaborations was a part of, and helped stimulate, this growth. This article reviews the authors’ and others’ important theoretical frameworks from the last decade, along with key empirical results. Research indicates how complicated and challenging collaboration can be, even though it may be needed now more than ever. The article concludes with a summary of areas in which scholarship offers reasonably settled conclusions and an extensive list of recommendations for future research. The authors favor research that takes a dynamic, multilevel systems view and makes use of both quantitative and qualitative methods, especially using longitudinal comparative case studies.
View
Assessing Freedom of Information in Latin America a Decade Later: Illuminating a Transparency Causal Mechanism
Article
  • Jul 2015
  • LAT AM POLIT SOC
More than 100 freedom of information (FOI) laws have been enacted worldwide, nearly half within the last 10 years. Yet these cross-domain, lynchpin transparency measures have received little scholarly attention. This article assesses the 16 FOI measures adopted across Latin America. Is secrecy being surrendered in a region marked by legacies of opacity? Why are some laws fulfilling their de jure potential in practice while others are not? This article aims to achieve 3 general objectives. It analyzes the de jure and de facto strength of Latin American FOI regimes; it exposes critical data-based and methodological challenges in evaluating and comparing transparency laws; and it illustrates how a causal mechanism, driven by the interactive dynamics of legislative balances of power and cabinet compositions, has had a determinate influence in shaping the strength of FOI regimes from adoption to implementation and reform.
View