Available via license: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
Case Study
Reversing thoracic hyperkyphosis:
a case report featuring mirror image®
thoracic extension rehabilitation
Jason E. MillEr1), Paul a. oaklEy2)*, scott B. lEvi n1), DEED E. Harrison3)
1) Private Practice, USA
2) Private Practice: Newmarket, ON, L3Y 8Y8, Canada
3)CBPNonprotInc.,USA
Abstract. [Pur pose] To present a case of non-surgical reduction of thoracic hyperkyphosis utilizing a multi-
modal rehabilitation program emphasizing the mirror image® concept. [Subject and Methods] A 15-year-old female
presented to a rehabilitation ofce suffering from back and neck pains and headaches. The patient was treated
sporadically over a period of 13-months. Treatment consisted of anterior thoracic translation and thoracic extension
exercises, spinal traction and spinal manipulation. [Results] After 13-months of treatment the patient displayed a
signicant reduction in hyperkyphosis and a dramatic correction of her overall posture and spine alignment cor-
responding to the reduction in back /neck pains, headaches and the simultaneous improvement of var ious other
health issues. [Conclusion] Thoracic hyperkyphosis can be reduced through a multimodal rehabilitation program
emphasizing mir ror image thoracic extension procedures.
Key words: Hyperkyphosis, Posture, Rehabilitation
(ThisarticlewassubmittedMar.17,2017,andwasacceptedApr.5,2017)
INTRODUCTION
Thoracic hyperkyphosis is associated with the incidence of compression fractures1, 2), reduced mobility1, 2), reduced qual-
ity of life3, 4), as well as decreased longevity5–10). In younger adolescent patients it has been determined the greater the
kyphosis curvature, the stronger the negative association to total pain, general self-image, general function, and overall level
of activity11).
Thoracic hyperkyphosis is difcult to treat clinically, and has unique considerations regarding its treatment12). Harrison et
al.13) demonstrated that one cause of thoracic hyperkyphosis is the normal spinal coupling pattern resulting from a posterior
thoracic translation postural shift. They also demonstrated that an anterior thoracic translation postural shift produces the
opposite postural pattern, a attening of the thoracic kyphosis13).
The logical treatment for those with thoracic hyperkyphosis with accompanying posterior thoracic translation posture is
the so-called ‘mirror image®’ approach, a term coined by Dr. Don Harrison14). Examples of the mirror image approach can
include the prescription of thoracic extension postural exercises and spinal traction.
Because of its serious potential/future health impact, the diagnosis of thoracic hyperkyphosis in younger patients deserves
serious attention and treatment aimed at reducing the deformity to prevent future undesirable consequences15). This case
presents the successful reduction of a hyperkyphotic thoracic posture in a 15-year-old suffering from back pains as well as
several other health issues.
J. Phys. Ther. Sci. 2 9: 1264–1267, 2017
*Corresponding author. Paul A. Oakley (E-mail: docoakley.icc@gmail.com)
©2017 The Societ y of Physical Therapy Science. Published by IPEC Inc.
This is an open-access ar ticle distributed under the ter ms of the Creative Commons Attr ibution Non-Commercial No Derivatives ( by-nc-nd)
License. (CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
The Journal of Physical Therapy Science The Journal of Physical Therapy Science
1265
SUBJECT AND METHODS
A 15-year-old female was brought by her parents to one of our rehabilitation clinics suffering from back and neck pains as
well as headaches. Upon visual inspection, it was obvious she had a pronounced thoracic hyperkyphosis.
The patient reported her pains were rated as 3–5/10 for her neck (0= no pain; 10= worst pain ever), 5–10/10 for migraine
headaches, 4–8/10 for chronic low back pain, 2–5/10 for mid back pain, and 2–4/10 for pain into the ribs and chest. She also
reported to suffer from dizziness, visual disturbances, numbness and tingling into the hands, weakness and coldness in the
left hand, heartburn, heart palpitations, shortness of breath, involuntary breathing patterns, as well as muscle cramps in the
hips, thighs and calves bilaterally.
Full spine radiographs were taken and biomechanically analyzed using the PostureRay® Software (Posture Co. Inc.,
Trinity, FL, USA). This system uses the Harrison posterior tangent method for lateral spine images16, 17) and the modied
Riser-Ferguson method for AP spine images17). These measurement methods are repeatable and reliable16–18).
The patient had several postural faults, the larger and notable ones included a forward head posture (35.6 mm vs. <15 mm
normal19), Fig. 1), thoracic hyperkyphosis (T1–T12= 71.3° vs. 43.7° normal20), Fig. 2), and posterior thoracic translation
posture (−59.2 mm vs. 0 mm normal13), Fig. 3).
The patient was treated with a multimodal rehabilitation program14, 21, 22) including mirror image corrective exercises,
spinal traction, and spinal manipulation. Since the patient had a large posterior thoracic translation, the prescribed mirror
image corrective exercises included an anterior thoracic translation exercise as well as a prone back extension exercise on a
PowerPlate® (Northbrook, IL, USA) which intensies the muscular demand23).
The spinal traction was an anterior thoracic position performed for up to 20 minutes in both a supine position (for rst 20
treatments) and then progressed to a standing position utilizing the SRBraceTM (Circular traction, Huntington Beach, CA,
USA) on the PowerPlate (Fig. 4). This positions the thoracic spine into its mirror image (hypo-kyphosis), as well as positions
the posterior thoracic posture into its mirror image (anterior translation). Spinal manipulation was also applied for pain relief.
The patient received 94 treatments over a period of 13-months. The patient and parents consented to the publication of these
results.
RESU LTS
Upon radiographic re-assessment, the patient’s forward head posture reduced (28.8 mm vs. 35.6 mm), the thoracic hyper-
kyphosis reduced (54.3° vs. 71.3°), and the posterior thoracic translation posture corrected (−59.2 mm vs. +4.9 mm). The
patient reported to be 80–100% improved in all of the initial health complaints. The low back pain improved and was rated
as 2–4/10, and the mid back and rib and chest pains a 1–2/10.
DISCUSSION
This case illustrates the successful application of Harrison’s mirror image approach to reduce thoracic hyperkyphosis
deformity and improve posture in a 15 year old with back pains and various other health issues.
There is limited clinical evidence within the manual therapies literature of successful non-surgical treatments for the
reduction of pathologic thoracic hyperkyphosis1, 24). Although many non-surgical approaches may show promise includ-
ing exercise, manual therapy, spinal orthosis, ‘practiced normal posture,’ and taping, the clinical trials used to study these
Fig. 1. Cervical spine radiographs
Left: Initial taken 9/30/2011; Right: Follow-up taken 10/30/2012.
Patient has visible anterior head translation (35.6 mm vs. normal
<15mm19)).
Fig. 2. Thoracic spine radiographs
Left: Initial taken 9/30/2011; Right: Follow-up taken 10/30/2012.
Patient has visible hyper-kyphosis (T1–T12 = 71.3° vs. normal =
43.7°20)).
J. Phys. Ther. Sci. Vol. 29, No. 7, 2017
1266
procedures have been criticized by being small in scale and short in duration24).
The only other documentation of using thoracic mirror image, extension traction in the treatment of thoracic hyperky-
phosis is a case by Jaeger et al.15) This case reported a 23° reduction in thoracic hyperkyphosis in a 24-year-old receiving 48
posture-based treatments (mirror image traction and exercises) over a 7-month period. The patient also performed the two
exercises as described in our case. An 8.5-month follow-up showed the patients spine had remained stable and the patient
had remained well.
Postural fault is frequently found in the adolescent population25). In screening 2,075 pupils aged 10–17 years, Nitzschke
and Hildenbrand26) determined the rate of hyperkyphosis to be 15% and 12% for males and females, respectively. Poor
posture alignment in the sagittal plane creates a non-ergonomic disequilibrium about the gravity line27) that in turn, changes
trunk muscle length-tension relationships28) that eventually lead to stress-strain nociceptive tendencies in the associated
tissues (i.e. muscles, discs, facet joints etc.) that can be reversed with the correction of posture29).
We believe that recognition of the coupled posterior translation posture and thoracic hyperkyphosis is essential to success-
fully treat patients presenting with this pattern of postural fault. Thoracic hyperkyphosis can be reduced through a multimodal
rehabilitation program emphasizing mirror image thoracic extension procedures.
REFERENCES
1) Hall SE, Cr iddle RA , Comito TL , et al.: A case-c ontrol st udy of qualit y of life and fu nctiona l impairment in women with long-s tandi ng vertebral osteoporot ic
fracture. O steopo ros Int, 1999, 9: 508 –515. [Med li ne] [C ros sRe f ]
2) Lyles KW, Gold DT, Shipp KM, et al.: Asso ciation of osteoporotic vertebral compression fra ctur es with impai red functional status. Am J Med, 1993, 94:
595 –601. [ Me dl ine] [Cro ssRef ]
3) Lonner B, Yoo A, Terra n JS, et al.: Effe ct of spinal d eformit y on adolescent qua lity of li fe: compar ison of oper ative scheuerma nn ky phosis, a dolescent idio-
pathic scoliosis, a nd norm al contr ols. Spine, 2013, 38: 1049–1055. [Medli ne] [Cro ssR ef ]
4) Takahash i T, Ishida K, Hi rose D, et al.: Tru nk defor mity is associated with a re duction in outdoor activit ies of daily l iving and life sati sfaction in commu nity-
dwelling old er people. O steoporos Int, 20 05, 16: 273–279. [Med li ne] [Cro ssR ef ]
5) Kado DM, Browner WS, Paler mo L, et a l. Study of Osteoporotic Fr actu res Research G roup: Verteb ral fr actu res an d mort ality i n older women: a pros pective
study. Arch Inter n Med, 1999, 159: 1215–1220. [Med li ne] [Cro ssR ef ]
6) Kado DM, Duong T, Stone K L, et al.: I ncident vertebral fractu res and mortality in older women: a prospective study. Oste oporos Int, 2003, 14: 589 –594.
[Me dl in e] [Cr oss Ref ]
7) Kado DM, Huang MH, Ka rlama ngla AS, et al.: Hy perky photic postur e predict s mort ality i n older commu nity-dwelling men and women: a prospect ive study.
J Am Ger iatr Soc , 2004, 52: 1662–1667. [Med li ne] [C ros sRe f ]
8) Milne JS , Williamson J: A longit udinal study of k yphosi s in older pe ople. Age Agein g, 1983, 12: 225–233. [Me dl in e] [Cr oss Ref ]
9) Ander son F, Cowan NR: Su rviva l of healthy olde r people. Br J P rev Soc Med , 1976, 30: 231–232. [Med li ne]
10) Cutler W B, Fried mann E , Genovese -Stone E: Pr evalence of k yphosi s in a healt hy sample of pre - and postmenopausal wome n. Am J Phys Med Re habil, 1993,
72: 219–225. [Medline] [Cro ssRef ]
11) Petchar aporn M, Pawelek J, Bastro m T, et al.: T he relation ship betwe en thoracic hy perk yphosis and th e Sc oliosis Research Society outcomes inst rument.
Spine, 20 07, 32: 2226–2231. [Med li ne] [Cro ssR ef ]
12) de Mauroy J, Weiss H, Au lisa A, et al.: 7th SOSORT cons ensus paper: con servative tre atment of id iopathic & Scheuer mann’s kyphosis. Scol iosis, 2010, 5: 9.
[Me dl in e] [Cr oss Ref ]
Fig. 3. Lumbar spine radiograph
Left: Initial taken 9/30/2011; Right: Follow-up taken 10/30/2012.
Patient has visible posterior translation of thoracic cage (−59.2 mm
vs. normal = 0mm13)).
Fig. 4. Patient in simultaneous anterior thoracic translation and
thoracic extension traction
Left: Standing anterior thoracic translation traction in the ‘spi-
nal remodeling brace’ (Circular traction Supply, Inc., Huntington
Beach, CA, USA). Right: Supine anterior thoracic translation trac-
tion.
1267
13) Harr ison DE, Caill iet R, Harr ison DD, et al.: How do anterior/ poster ior tran slations of the thora cic cage affect the sagit tal lumba r spine, pelvic tilt , and thoracic
kypho sis? Eur Spin e J, 2002, 11: 287–293. [Me dl in e] [Cross Ref ]
14) Harris on DD, Janik TJ, Harr ison GR, et a l.: Chiropractic biophysics te chnique: a linea r algebra ap proach to p ostu re in chi ropractic. J Man ipulat ive Physiol
Ther, 1996, 19: 525–535. [Me dl in e]
15) Jaeger JO, Oak ley PA, Colloca CJ, et al.: Non-surgical red uction of th oracic hy per-ky phosis in a 2 4-year-old mu sic teache r utili zing ch iropr actic BioPhysics®
techn ique. Br J Med Med Res, 2016, 11: 1–9. [Cros sRe f ]
16) Harr ison DE , Har rison DD, Cail liet R, et al.: C obb meth od or Ha rri son pos terior tange nt metho d: which to choo se for la teral cerv ical ra diographic analysis.
Spine, 20 00, 25: 2072–2078. [ Me dline] [Cro ssRef ]
17) Harr ison DE, Hollan d B, Harris on DD, et al.: Further relia bility an alysis of the Harr ison radiograph ic line- drawi ng methods: crossed ICCs for later al poster ior
tangents and mod ied Ri sser-Ferguson meth od on AP vie ws. J Manipulative Physiol Ther, 2002, 25: 93–98. [ Med li ne] [Cro ssR ef ]
18) Harr ison DE, Harr ison DD, C olloca CJ, et al .: Rep eatability over time of postu re, radiog raph positioning, and rad iograph line d rawing: an analysis of si x
control g roups. J Ma nipulative Physiol Ther, 2003, 26: 87–98. [ Medli ne] [Cro ssR ef ]
19) Harr ison DD, Har rison DE, Jani k TJ, et al.: Modeli ng of the sagittal cervic al spine a s a method to discr imin ate hypolordosis: res ults of elliptical and circu lar
modelin g in 72 asymptomat ic subject s, 52 acute ne ck pain subjects, a nd 70 chron ic neck pai n subject s. Spine, 20 04, 29: 2485–2492. [M edli ne] [C ros sRef]
20) Harr ison DE, Janik TJ, Harr ison DD, et al.: Can the thorac ic kyphosis be modeled wit h a simple geometric shape? The result s of circular and ellipt ical modeling
in 80 asy mptomatic patie nts. J Spinal Disord Tech, 20 02, 15: 213–220. [Me dl in e] [Cr oss Ref ]
21) Oak ley PA, Harrison DD, Harrison DE, et al.: Evidence-based protocol for str uctural rehabilit ation of the spine and posture: review of clinical biomechanics
of postu re (CBP) publicat ions. J Can C hiropr Assoc, 20 05, 49: 270–296. [ Med li ne]
22) Harr ison DE, Betz JW, Har rison DD, et al.: CBP Structur al Rehabilitation of the Lumba r Spine: Har rison Chiropractic Biophysics Sem inar s, Inc., 20 07.
23) Lee DY: Analysi s of muscle activatio n i n each body segment in response to the stimulation intensity of whole- body vibration. J Phys Ther Sci, 2017, 29:
270–273. [M ed li ne] [C ros sRe f ]
24) Kado DM: The rehabil itation of hy perkyphotic postu re in the elderly. Eur J Phys Reha bil Med, 20 09, 45: 583–593. [Med li ne]
25) Salmi nen JJ: The ad olescent ba ck. A eld sur vey of 370 Finnish schoolchi ldren. Acta Paed iatr Sca nd Suppl, 1984, 315: 1–122. [Me dline] [Cro ssRef ]
26) Nitzsch ke E, Hildenbrand M: [Epidem iology of ky phosis in s chool child ren]. Z Orthop Ih re Gren zgeb, 1990, 128: 477–481. [M edli ne] [C ros sRef]
27) Le Huec JC, Sa ddik i R, Fran ke J, et al.: Equi librium of the hum an body a nd the gr avity line: the basics. Eur Spi ne J, 2011, 20: 558–563. [Me dl in e] [Cr os sRef ]
28) Roy AL, Kel ler TS, Collo ca CJ: Postur e-de pendent t runk exte nsor EMG activity d uri ng maxi mum isome trics exertion s in nor mal male a nd female subjects. J
Electromyogr Ki nesiol, 2003, 13: 469–476. [M edli ne] [Cros sRef]
29) Troyanovich SJ, Har rison DE, Har rison DD: St ruct ural rehabilitation of t he spine and postu re: ratio nale for treatment beyond the resolution of sy mptoms. J
Manipu lative Physiol T her, 1998, 21: 37–50. [Med li ne]