ArticlePDF Available

Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment in marmoset ( Callithrix jacchus ) monkeys

Authors:
  • Covance Preclinical Services, Germany

Abstract and Figures

To safeguard patients, regulatory authorities require that new drugs that are to be given by the intravitreal (IVT) route are assessed for their safety in a laboratory species using the same route of administration. Due to the high similarity of ocular morphology and physiology between humans and nonhuman primates (NHPs) and due to the species specificity of many biotherapeutics, the monkey is often the only appropriate model. To this end, intravitreal administration and assessment of ocular toxicity are well established in cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicularis). In contrast, the common marmoset monkey (Callithrix jacchus) is not a standard model for ocular toxicity studies due to its general sensitivity to laboratory investigations and small eye size. It was the purpose of the present work to study whether the marmoset is a useful alternative to the cynomolgus monkey for use in intravitreal toxicological studies. Six marmoset monkeys received repeated (every 2 weeks for a total of four doses) intravitreal injections of 10 or 20 µ L of a placebo. The animals were assessed for measurements of intraocular pressure (IOP), standard ophthalmological investigations and electroretinography (ERG). At the end of the dosing period, the animals were sacrificed and the eyes were evaluated histologically. ERG revealed similar results when comparing predose to end-of-study data, and there was no difference between the two dose volumes. A transient increase in the IOP was seen immediately after dosing, which was more pronounced after dosing of 20 µ L compared to 10 µ L. Ophthalmologic and microscopic observations did not show any significant changes. Therefore, it can be concluded that 10 µ L as well as 20 µ L intravitreal injections of a placebo are well tolerated in the marmoset. These results demonstrate that the common marmoset is an alternative to the cynomolgus monkey for intravitreal toxicity testing.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017
www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/
doi:10.5194/pb-4-93-2017
© Author(s) 2017. CC Attribution 3.0 License.
Research article
Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety
assessment in marmoset (Callithrix jacchus) monkeys
Birgit Korbmacher1, Jenny Atorf2, Stephanie Fridrichs-Gromoll1, Marilyn Hill3, Sven Korte1,
Jan Kremers2, Keith Mansfield3, Lars Mecklenburg1, Andrew Pilling3, and Andreas Wiederhold1
1Covance Preclinical Services GmbH, Kesselfeld 29, 48163 Münster, Germany
2Department of Ophthalmology, University Hospital Erlangen, Maximiliansplatz 2, 91054 Erlangen, Germany
3Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Klybeckstraße, 4002 Basel, Switzerland
Correspondence to: Birgit Korbmacher (birgit.korbmacher@covance.com, birgit.niggemann@covance.com)
Received: 16 November 2016 – Revised: 4 April 2017 – Accepted: 4 April 2017 – Published: 28 April 2017
Abstract. To safeguard patients, regulatory authorities require that new drugs that are to be given by the intrav-
itreal (IVT) route are assessed for their safety in a laboratory species using the same route of administration. Due
to the high similarity of ocular morphology and physiology between humans and nonhuman primates (NHPs) and
due to the species specificity of many biotherapeutics, the monkey is often the only appropriate model. To this
end, intravitreal administration and assessment of ocular toxicity are well established in cynomolgus monkeys
(Macaca fascicularis). In contrast, the common marmoset monkey (Callithrix jacchus) is not a standard model
for ocular toxicity studies due to its general sensitivity to laboratory investigations and small eye size. It was the
purpose of the present work to study whether the marmoset is a useful alternative to the cynomolgus monkey
for use in intravitreal toxicological studies. Six marmoset monkeys received repeated (every 2 weeks for a total
of four doses) intravitreal injections of 10 or 20 µL of a placebo. The animals were assessed for measurements
of intraocular pressure (IOP), standard ophthalmological investigations and electroretinography (ERG). At the
end of the dosing period, the animals were sacrificed and the eyes were evaluated histologically. ERG revealed
similar results when comparing predose to end-of-study data, and there was no difference between the two dose
volumes. A transient increase in the IOP was seen immediately after dosing, which was more pronounced after
dosing of 20 µL compared to 10 µL. Ophthalmologic and microscopic observations did not show any signifi-
cant changes. Therefore, it can be concluded that 10 µL as well as 20 µL intravitreal injections of a placebo are
well tolerated in the marmoset. These results demonstrate that the common marmoset is an alternative to the
cynomolgus monkey for intravitreal toxicity testing.
1 Introduction
To support clinical trials of new drugs to be given by the in-
travitreal (IVT) route, it is required to assess the safety after
IVT administration to a laboratory species. Due to the high
similarity of ocular morphology and physiology between hu-
mans and nonhuman primates (NHPs) and given the species
specificity of many biotherapeutics, the monkey often is the
only appropriate species for preclinical safety testing. To this
end, intravitreal administration procedures and assessments
of ocular toxicity in cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fasci-
cularis) are well established (Niggemann et al., 2006). In
contrast, the common marmoset monkey (Callithrix jacchus;
Fig. 1) is not a standard model for ocular toxicity studies
due to its general sensitivity to laboratory investigations and
small eye size.
However, apart from a polymorphism in red–green color
vision (Mollon et al., 1984 and Travis et al., 1988), only mi-
nor structural and functional differences in the retina were
described in comparison to macaques. In addition, recordings
from single neurons in the lateral geniculate nucleus showed
that the functional properties of visually responsive cells in
marmosets are very similar to those in the macaque (Kremers
et al., 1999). It was the purpose of the present work to study
whether the marmoset is a useful alternative to the cynomol-
Published by Copernicus Publications on behalf of the Deutsches Primatenzentrum GmbH (DPZ).
94 B. Korbmacher et al.: Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment
Figure 1. Common marmoset monkey (Callithrix jacchus).
gus monkey for use in intravitreal toxicological studies and
whether injecting a volume of 10 or even 20µL would be
tolerated.
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Pre-study test
To determine various weight and anatomical measurements,
seven eyes from four adult common marmosets, that were
sacrificed for reasons unrelated to this study, were obtained
at necropsy, and following removal of periorbital muscle
and fat, the eyes were snap-frozen at 70 C. Eyes were
thawed and weighed. Transverse and sagittal measurements
were performed. Volumetric measurements were made by
recording fluid displacement in a 10.0 mL graduated cylin-
der. The eye was then dissected and similar measurements
were recorded for the vitreous and lens.
2.2 Housing, ethical and regulatory guideline
considerations
During the development of a specific biotechnology-derived
compound, it was shown that the marmoset was the only
pharmacologically relevant species for nonclinical safety
testing. Due to the very limited experience with IVT adminis-
tration in marmosets (Ivanova et al., 2010; Melo et al., 2012;
Neitz et al., 2013), this feasibility study was conducted in or-
der to prepare for a good laboratory practice (GLP) toxicity
study with this specific compound.
The test facility Covance Preclinical Services GmbH (Ger-
many) is fully accredited by AAALAC International. All pro-
cedures in this study were in compliance with the German
Animal Welfare Act and were approved by the local Institu-
tional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC). Further-
more, the procedures were performed in consideration of the
Directive 2010/63/EU of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 22 September 2010 on the protection of animals
used for scientific purposes.
The standard social housing for marmosets at Covance,
Münster (Germany), is according to the “Commission Rec-
ommendation 2007/526/EC on guidelines for the accommo-
dation and care of animals used for experimental and other
scientific purposes (Appendix A of Convention ETS 123)”.
The standard cage allows three-dimensional movements by
this highly agile primate species in groups of two or three
individuals.
The animals received a variety of food, which was pre-
pared freshly each day and given twice a day according to a
meal plan. The room temperature was between 22 and 28 C,
with a relative humidity between 40 and 70 %, and artifi-
cial lighting was in 12 h dark/light cycle. The cages were en-
riched with sleeping boxes, wooden chips, plastic balls and
wooden bars.
2.3 Feasibility study
The animals were 1 to 10 years old and weighed between
349 and 501 g. One group of three male marmoset monkeys
received repeated bilateral intravitreal injections of 10µL of
a placebo (70 mM mannitol, 20 mM histidine pH 6.5, and
0.04 % polysorbate) every second week (days 1, 15, 29,
and 43). The second group of three male animals received
20 µL of a placebo on the same days. Ophthalmic exami-
nations and intraocular pressure (IOP) measurements were
performed once before there start of dosing (predose), on
days 1 (directly after dosing), 3, 15 (directly after dosing), 17,
29 (directly after dosing), 31, 43 (directly after dosing) and
45 (before the animals were sacrificed as scheduled). Elec-
troretinography (ERG) was performed twice before the start
of dosing and at week 6 of the study (after the last adminis-
tration of the placebo).
2.3.1 Intravitreal dosing
The animals were fasted before they were anesthetized by
intramuscular injection of ketamine and medetomidine. My-
driasis was induced by using 1 % tropicamide eye drops, and
an antiseptic (povidone-iodine 5 %) solution was instilled in
the area of the injection. A local ophthalmic anesthetic was
instilled into both eyes prior to insertion of a lid speculum. A
microscope was used for dose administration with the aim to
observe any reflux (see Fig. 2). The distance from the corneal
limbus was measured (approx. 1.5 to 2.0 mm) and marked
on the conjunctiva. The needle was inserted approximately
3 mm into the vitreous body in the direction to the posterior
pole. The needle stayed in that position for 3–5 s after dos-
ing so that the vehicle could distribute in the vitreous body.
Before the needle was removed it was clasped with a Col-
ibri forceps to avoid reflux. Reflux could not be completely
avoided but was only seen on few occasions.
Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017 www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/
B. Korbmacher et al.: Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment 95
Figure 2. Intravitreal administration in the Marmoset eye.
Ointment containing dexpanthenol was instilled onto each
eye following the dosing, and atipamezole was used as an
anesthetic antidote at the end of the procedure (intramuscular
injection).
2.3.2 Ophthalmic examinations
Ophthalmic examinations were conducted following seda-
tion using ketamine. Mydriasis was induced by using 1 %
tropicamide eye drops. The eye and the connecting tissues
were evaluated during the macroscopic investigations. The
ocular fundus with the macula lutea, papilla, ocular vessels
and retina was assessed funduscopically. Slit lamp examina-
tions including fluorescein staining were performed to evalu-
ate the anterior and medium segment of the eye with conjunc-
tiva, cornea, anterior chamber, iris, lens and vitreous body. In
addition, the intraocular pressure was determined using the
TonoVet®tonometer.
2.3.3 Electroretinography
The animals were dark adapted for at least 30 min prior to
anesthesia using ketamine and medetomidine. The pupils
were dilated with 1 % tropicamide eye drops and 0.5 % at-
ropine eye drops. Further preparation of the animals was per-
formed under dimmed red light to ensure that rod sensitivity
was preserved.
For the first measurement, ERGs were only measured in
the right eyes using DTL (Dawson–Trick–Litzkow) elec-
trodes that were placed over the lower conjunctiva of each
eye, serving as active electrodes. The eyes were covered by
methylcellulose and a custom-made contact lens (radius of
curvature: 3.5 mm; 5 mm diameter; 0 diopter; Cantor & Nis-
sel, UK) to avoid desiccation of the eye. During the second
measurement and the dosing phase, the left and right eyes
were measured simultaneously and the DTL electrodes and
contact lenses were replaced by contact lens electrodes (same
properties as above; Mayo Corporation, Japan). The contact
lens electrodes were easier to handle and gave nearly iden-
tical results as the DTL electrodes. The data obtained with
both techniques were considered comparable. Needle elec-
trodes that were placed subcutaneously at the base of the ip-
silateral ears served as references. Ground needle electrodes
were placed at the base of the tail. The animals were placed
on a platform that could be slid into the full-field stimulator.
Each recording lasted approximately 30 min.
The animals underwent ERG measurements to the follow-
ing five stimulus protocols:
1. Scotopic flash ERGs were recorded with a dark back-
ground. The responses to six flash strengths (0.0095,
0.03, 0.095, 0.3, 0.95 and 3.0 cd·s m2) were recorded.
The flash frequency was 0.3 Hz. The recordings to six
flashes were averaged. The a-waves were measured
only at the highest flash strength (i.e., 3.0 cd m2) from
baseline to the trough of the a-wave. The b-waves were
measured at all flash strengths. The amplitudes were de-
fined as the voltage difference between the trough of the
a-wave to the peak of the b-wave.
2. Oscillatory potentials (OPs) were measured for four
flashes on a dark background at a rate of 0.1 Hz. The
flash strength was 3.0 cd·s m2. Representative for all
OPs, the OP amplitude between the peak of OP2 and
the following trough was measured. The latency was de-
fined as the time to the trough following OP2.
3. Photopic flicker ERGs were recorded for a train of
3.0 cd·s m2flashes on a 100 cd m2background at a
rate of 30.1 Hz. The responses to 50 flashes were mea-
sured and averaged. The measurements were performed
directly after the background was switched on and were
repeated after 10 min of adaptation. A general increase
in the ERG responses was observed during this time.
Therefore, only the second measurement was used for
further analysis. The response amplitude was defined as
a trough-to-peak amplitude.
4. The responses to red flashes on a 100 cd m2white
background were recorded. Two flash strengths were
used: 0.3 and 0.95 cd·s m2. The flash rate was 1.5 Hz
and the responses to 30 flashes were averaged. White
backgrounds were chosen instead of blue backgrounds
to be able to compare the data with previous data ob-
tained from cynomolgus monkeys. The white back-
grounds were photopic and thus sufficiently suppressed
rod-driven signals. The b-wave amplitudes and implicit
times were measured.
5. The photopic flashes were repeated with white flashes.
The responses to 20 flashes of 3.0 cd·s m2strength
were averaged. The flash rate was 1.5 Hz. The a- and
b-wave amplitudes and latencies were measured.
www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/ Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017
96 B. Korbmacher et al.: Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment
Table 1. Ocular weight and linear and volumetric measurements from adult common marmoset eyes.
Animal 1 Animal 2 Animal 2 Animal 3 Animal 3 Animal 4 Animal 4 Mean SD
Eye 1 Eye 1 Eye 2 Eye 1 Eye 2 Eye 1 Eye 2
Eye weight (g) 0.59 0.749 0.7412 0.6489 0.6618 0.7472 0.7366 0.70 0.058
Lens weight (g) 0.019 0.027 0.026 0.030 0.041 0.026 0.051 0.03 0.010
Lens wt / eye wt 0.03 0.04 0.03 0.03 0.07 0.03 0.07 0.04 0.017
Circumference (A) 3.3 3.8 3.8 3.4 3.4 3.9 3.9 3.6 0.244
Transverse (cm)
Circumference (B) 3.5 3.9 3.9 3.6 3.5 3.8 3.8 3.7 0.164
Sagittal (cm)
Lens volume (mL) n/a 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.04 0.01 0.025 0.03 0.009
Vitreous weight (g) n/a 0.558 0.552 0.424 0.487 0.483 0.587 0.52 0.056
Vitreal wt / total eye wt n/a 0.74 0.74 0.65 0.8 0.65 0.80 0.73 0.062
Vitreous volume (mL) 0.4 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.54 0.073
Total volume (mL) 0.6 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.8 0.76 0.073
Vitreal vol / total vol 0.67 0.75 0.75 0.71 0.63 0.71 0.63 0.69 0.049
2.3.4 Necropsy and histopathology of the eye
Animals were sedated by intramuscular injection of ketamine
followed by an intravenous sodium pentobarbitone overdose
prior to exsanguination. Both eyes including the optic nerve
were fixed in Davidson’s fluid. The eye was bisected in a hor-
izontal plane, just below the equator, and embedded in paraf-
fin wax. Sections were prepared at a nominal thickness of
5 µm. Three serial sections were taken through each block at
1 mm spacing, yielding a total of six sagittal sections per eye
(Fig. 3). These sections included the optic disc and the fovea.
Sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E).
3 Results
3.1 Pre-study test
Weights and linear and volumetric measurements are pro-
vided in Table 1. Total mean vitreal volume was determined
at 0.54 mL and mean vitreal weight at 0.52 g. The mean vit-
real wt / total eye weight ratio was 0.73 and is comparable to
the ratio of 0.65 reported for cynomolgus monkey eyes using
a frozen dissection method (Struble et al., 2014).
3.2 Feasibility study
3.2.1 ERGs
Representative for all ERG parameters, Fig. 4a and b show
the b-wave amplitudes and latencies of the scotopic elec-
troretinograms, respectively, of the right eyes of both treated
groups measured twice before injections (predose 1 and 2)
and 6 weeks after injections. The ERG assessment revealed
similar results when comparing predose to end-of-study data,
and there was no difference between the two dose volumes.
Figure 3. Trimming and sectioning of the eye.
None of the measured parameters showed any difference
between data obtained from the left and right eyes. The vari-
ability in the data was satisfactory (see Fig. 4). We averaged
all amplitude and latency data for each stimulus condition
(i.e., obtained from the two eyes, from the three experimental
sessions and from all animals in the two groups). The sco-
topic b-wave amplitudes deviated from the averages up to
about 30 % from these averages for low-intensity flashes. At
high intensities the deviation was maximally 15 %. The de-
viation in all other parameters was generally less than 10 %,
except for the OP amplitudes and the b-wave amplitude ob-
tained with the dimmer (0.3 cd·s m2) red flash, where the
deviations could be larger probably due to the smaller ampli-
tudes and thus less favorable signal-to-noise ratio (similar to
the scotopic b-wave amplitude at low flash strengths).
In agreement with macaque and human data, the ampli-
tudes increase with increasing flash strength. Furthermore,
the implicit times decrease with increasing stimulus strength.
The absolute values of the scotopic a- and b-wave amplitudes
measured with 3 cd·s m2flashes agree with those measured
in humans at the same conditions (Hamilton et al., 2015).
The implicit time of the a-wave at the same flash strength
was also similar to those measured in human subjects. The la-
tency of the b-wave was, however, shorter (35 ms) than those
Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017 www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/
B. Korbmacher et al.: Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment 97
Figure 4. (a) Scotopic b-wave amplitudes. (b) Scotopic b-wave latencies.
Table 2. ERG reference data from 46 cynomolgus monkeys (right eye) in comparison to the mean of the three marmosets (right eye) from
group 1 before dosing.
Standard response Species b-wave b-wave peak a-wave a-wave peak Flash Adaptation
amplitude latency amplitude latency intensity status
(µV) (ms) (µV) (ms) (mcds m2)
rod response cyno 119 [29] 50 [4] 95 dark
marmoset 78 [23] 41 [3] (30 min)
maximal response cyno 194 [41] 38 [2] 95 [24] 17 [2] 3000 dark
marmoset 244 [62] 34 [3] 123 [9] 15 [0.4]
oscillatory potential cyno 18 [6] 25 [1] 3000 dark
marmoset 16 [11] 24 [1]
30 Hz flicker cyno 77 [20] 57 [0.9] 3000 light
marmoset 145 [5] 58 [0.5] (10 min)
red flash cone response cyno 41 [13] 24 [2] 950 light
marmoset 116 [5] 22 [0.5]
white flash cone response cyno 88 [25] 24 [0.8] 16 [3] 14 [0.9] 3000 light
marmoset 177 [17] 26 [0.7] 48 [10] 15 [0.4]
[ ] =standard deviation.
www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/ Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017
98 B. Korbmacher et al.: Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment
Figure 5. (a) Intraocular pressure of group 1 (10 µLeye1). (b) Intraocular pressure of group 2 (20µLeye1).
measured by Hamilton et al. (2015) in human subjects (about
50 ms).
In general, the responses to the different flash intensities
are comparable to those measured in cynomolgus monkeys
(Table 2). However, the cone-driven response appears to be
stronger than in cynomolgus monkeys. This is likely to be re-
lated to the higher cone density found in marmosets in com-
parison with macaques (Goodchild et al., 1996).
Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017 www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/
B. Korbmacher et al.: Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment 99
3.2.2 Ophthalmic examinations
Slit lamp examination and funduscopy did not show any
changes in ocular structures which could be due to manip-
ulation.
3.2.3 Intraocular pressure
A transient increase in the intraocular pressure was seen im-
mediately after dosing which was more pronounced after
dosing of 20 µL compared to 10 µL (see Fig. 5a and b) in-
dicating the influence of the volume to the intraocular pres-
sure immediately following dosing. Pressure increase indi-
cates that 20 µL is about the maximum volume injectable
without damage to the intraocular structures.
3.2.4 Histology
Microscopic findings were limited to the site of injection
(Fig. 6a) and were characterized by minimal focal disorga-
nization of stromal layers mainly affecting the muscle of
the ciliary body (Fig. 6b) and a subepithelial infiltrate of in-
flammatory cells of the conjunctiva at the corneoscleral lim-
bus. The cell infiltrate was composed of neutrophils and/or
mononuclear cells, was minimal in magnitude, and was focal
or multifocal in distribution. Disorganization of stromal lay-
ers and inflammatory cell infiltrates occurred to the same ex-
tent in animals from the 10 and the 20 µL dose volume group.
There was no difference in magnitude between the groups, no
morphological evidence of occlusion of the iridocorneal an-
gle, and no evidence of optic nerve or retinal damage from
increased intraocular pressure (Fig. 6c).
4 Discussion
During pretest evaluation of marmoset eyes, the volume of
the vitreous body was determined at 0.54 mL. In cynomol-
gus monkeys the volume was determined at 2mL (Struble at
al., 2014) using the same technique. Since the standard injec-
tion volume in cynomolgus monkey is 50µL per eye, the vol-
ume of 10 and 20 µL was selected for this study. It could be
shown that this is a feasible volume for injection into the vit-
reous body of the eye from a marmoset. A transient effect to
the intraocular pressure immediately after dosing was seen at
10 and 20 µL doses. However, this increased intraocular pres-
sure did not result in any changes in the morphology of the
eye that was evaluated microscopically. Therefore, both vol-
umes could be used for future study. The electroretinogram
showed that there were no changes during the study due to
the intravitreal dosing of a placebo. In addition, a comparison
to reference data from the cynomolgus monkeys (Table 2)
shows that the cone-driven response appears to be stronger
than in cynomolgus monkeys, which is likely to be related to
the higher cone density found in marmosets.
Figure 6. (a) H&E-stained section from the eye of a marmoset
monkey treated intravitreally (10 µL). The image shows the ciliary
body and portions of the iris, sclera and lens. Note the needle track
lesion in the sclera (arrow) and the disorganization of collagen fibers
in the pars plana of the ciliary body, accompanied by few inflam-
matory cell infiltrates. (b) H&E-stained section from the eye of a
marmoset monkey treated intravitreally (10 µL). This picture shows
the disorganization of the stromal layers and minimal inflammatory
cell infiltrates. (c) H&E-stained section from the eye of a marmoset
monkey treated intravitreally (20 µL). This picture shows the nor-
mally structured papilla of the optic nerve with no microscopical
changes induced by transiently increased intraocular pressure.
5 Conclusion
It is concluded that, based on IOP measurements, ERG
recording, and ophthalmologic and microscopic observa-
tions, up to 20 µL intravitreal injections of a placebo were
well tolerated in the marmoset. Therefore, the common mar-
moset provides a potential alternative to the cynomolgus
monkey for ocular toxicity testing.
www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/ Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017
100 B. Korbmacher et al.: Feasibility of intravitreal injections and ophthalmic safety assessment
Data availability. All measured ERG results are available in the
Supplement.
The Supplement related to this article is available online
at doi:10.5194/pb-4-93-2017-supplement.
Author contributions. B. Korbmacher wrote this paper as the
first author. J. Atorf and J. Kremers were responsible for estab-
lishing and analyzing the electroretinograms. S. Friderichs-Gromoll
performed the pathology and A. Pilling reviewed the slides and the
pathology evaluation. K. Mansfield supplied the pre-study data re-
garding the weight and volume of the marmoset eyes. A. Wieder-
hold performed the ophthalmic examinations. M. Hill planned this
project and was responsible for the design together with S. Korte.
L. Mecklenburg reviewed the manuscript.
Competing interests. The authors declare that they have no con-
flict of interest.
Acknowledgements. The authors would like to thank the
operational and administrative staff for their support.
Edited by: G. Weinbauer
Reviewed by: A. Wegener and one anonymous referee
References
Goodchild, A. K., Ghosh, K. K., and Martin, P. R.: Comparison of
photoreceptor spatial density and ganglion cell morphology in
the retina of human, macaque monkey, cat, and the marmoset
Callithrix jacchus, J. Comp. Neurol., 366, 55–75, 1996.
Hamilton, R., Al Abdlseaed, A., Healey, J., Neveu, M. M., Brown,
L., Keating, D., McBain, V. A., Sculfor, D., and Thompson, D.
A.: Multi-centre variability of ISCEV standard ERGs in two nor-
mal adults, Doc. Ophthalmol., 130, 83–101, 2015.
Ivanova, E., Hwang, G. S., Pan, Z. H., and Troilo, D.: Evaluation
of AAV-Mediated Expression of Chop2-GFP in the Marmoset
Retina, Invest. Ophth. Vis. Sci., 51, 5288–5296, 2010.
Kremers, J., Silveira, L. C. L., Yamada, E. S., and Lee, B. B.: The
ecology and evolution of primate vision, in: Color Vision from
Genes to Perception, edited by: Gegenfurtner, K. R. and Sharpe,
L. T., Cambridge University Press, New York, USA, 123–142,
1999.
Melo, G. B., Moraes Filho, M. N., Rodrigues, E. B., Regatieri, C.
V., Dreyfuss, J. L., Penha, F. M., Pinheiro, M. M., Coimbra, R.
C., Haapalainen, E. F., and Farah, M. E.: Toxicity and retinal
penetration of infliximab in primates, Retina, 32, 606–612, 2012.
Mollon, J. D., Bowmaker, J. K., and Jacobs, G. H.: Variations of
colour vision in a new world primate can be explained by poly-
morphism of retinal photopigments, P. Roy. Soc. B-Biol. Sci.,
222, 373–399, 1984.
Neitz, M., Hendrickson, A., Lukason, M., Neitz, J., Possin, D.,
Abedi, G., Huang, J., Scaria, A., and Wadsworth, A.: Accessibil-
ity of Retinal Cells to Different AAV Serotypes After Intravitreal
Injection in Old Versus New World Primates, Invest. Ophth. Vis.
Sci., 54, p. 2733, 2013.
Niggemann, B., Korte, S. H., and Srivastav, S.: Ocular Toxicity
Testing in Nonhuman Primates, in: Novel Approaches Towards
Primate Toxicology, edited by: Weinbauer, G. F. and Vogel, F.,
Waxmann Verlag GmbH, Münster, Germany, 202–217, 2006.
Struble, C., Howard, S., and Relph, J.: Comparison of ocular tissue
weights (volumes) and tissue collection techniques in commonly
used preclinical animal species, Acta Ophthalmol., 92, 2014.
Travis, D. S., Bowmaker, J. K., and Mollon, J. D.: Polymorphism of
visual pigments in a callitrichid monkey, Vision Res., 28, 481–
490, 1988.
Primate Biol., 4, 93–100, 2017 www.primate-biol.net/4/93/2017/
... For example, species with large eyes relative to the brain size (e.g., marmosets) tend to have a large or positive pitch (frontal downward direction) of the stereotactic coordinate relative to AC-PC plane, whereas species (e.g., human and macaque) with relatively smaller eyes tend to have a smaller or negative pitch (frontal upward direction). Indeed, the volume ratio of eyeball to brain is substantially larger in marmoset (10%) (Korbmacher et al., 2017) in comparison to macaque monkeys (3%) (Atsumi et al., 2013) and humans (0.4%) (Heymsfield et al., 2016). ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Localising accurate brain regions needs careful evaluation in each experimental species due to their individual variability. However, the function and connectivity of brain areas is commonly studied using a single-subject cranial landmark-based stereotactic atlas in animal neuroscience. Here, we address this issue in a small primate, the common marmoset, which is increasingly widely used in systems neuroscience. We developed a non-invasive multi-modal neuroimaging-based targeting pipeline, which accounts for intersubject anatomical variability in cranial and cortical landmarks in marmosets. This methodology allowed creation of multi-modal templates (MarmosetRIKEN20) including head CT and brain MR images, embedded in coordinate systems of anterior and posterior commissures (AC-PC) and CIFTI grayordinates. We found that the horizontal plane of the stereotactic coordinate was significantly rotated in pitch relative to the AC-PC coordinate system (10 degrees, frontal downwards), and had a significant bias and uncertainty due to positioning procedures. We also found that many common cranial and brain landmarks (e.g., bregma, intraparietal sulcus) vary in location across subjects and are substantial relative to average marmoset cortical area dimensions. Combining the neuroimaging-based targeting pipeline with robot-guided surgery enabled proof-of-concept targeting of deep brain structures with an accuracy of 0.2 mm. Altogether, our findings demonstrate substantial intersubject variability in marmoset brain and cranial landmarks, implying that subject-specific neuroimaging-based localization is needed for precision targeting in marmosets. The population-based templates and atlases in grayordinates, created for the first time in marmoset monkeys, should help bridging between macroscale and microscale analyses. Highlights Achieved sub-millimeter localization accuracy of subject-wise brain region Propose a dedicated non-invasive multi-modal subject-specific registration pipeline Construct brain coordinate system in AC-PC and grayordinate spaces Establish multi-modal MRI and CT brain and cortical templates, MarmosetRIKEN20 Quantify intersubject variabilities in marmoset brain Significant bias and uncertainty exist in marmoset stereotactic positioning
Article
Humans and nonhuman primates (NHPs) share numerous anatomical and physiological characteristics, thereby explaining the importance of NHPs as essential animal models for translational medicine and nonclinical toxicity testing. Researchers, toxicologic pathologists, toxicologists, and regulatory reviewers must be familiar with normal and abnormal NHP biological traits when designing, performing, and interpreting data sets from NHP studies. The current compilation presents a list of essential books, journal articles, and websites that provide context to safety assessment and research scientists working with NHP models. The resources used most frequently by the authors have been briefly annotated to permit readers to rapidly ascertain their applicability to particular research endeavors. The references are aimed primarily for toxicologic pathologists working with cynomolgus and rhesus macaques and common marmosets in efficacy and safety assessment studies.
Article
Localising accurate brain regions needs careful evaluation in each experimental species due to their individual variability. However, the function and connectivity of brain areas is commonly studied using a single-subject cranial landmark-based stereotactic atlas in animal neuroscience. Here, we address this issue in a small primate, the common marmoset, which is increasingly widely used in systems neuroscience. We developed a non-invasive multi-modal neuroimaging-based targeting pipeline, which accounts for intersubject anatomical variability in cranial and cortical landmarks in marmosets. This methodology allowed creation of multi-modal templates (MarmosetRIKEN20) including head CT and brain MR images, embedded in coordinate systems of anterior and posterior commissures (AC-PC) and CIFTI grayordinates. We found that the horizontal plane of the stereotactic coordinate was significantly rotated in pitch relative to the AC-PC coordinate system (10 degrees, frontal downwards), and had a significant bias and uncertainty due to positioning procedures. We also found that many common cranial and brain landmarks (e.g., bregma, intraparietal sulcus) vary in location across subjects and are substantial relative to average marmoset cortical area dimensions. Combining the neuroimaging-based targeting pipeline with robot-guided surgery enabled proof-of-concept targeting of deep brain structures with an accuracy of 0.2 mm. Altogether, our findings demonstrate substantial intersubject variability in marmoset brain and cranial landmarks, implying that subject-specific neuroimaging-based localization is needed for precision targeting in marmosets. The population-based templates and atlases in grayordinates, created for the first time in marmoset monkeys, should help bridging between macroscale and microscale analyses.
Article
Full-text available
The reproducibility of an individual's full-field ERG between centres has not previously been investigated. ERGs were recorded using both silver thread and skin electrodes from the same two normal adult subjects at 15 UK centres using routine, local protocols and a highly standardised, 'ISCEV-specified' protocol matching the values specified in the ISCEV standard; where the ISCEV standard allows options, a single value was chosen. Inter-ocular differences were small, and amplitudes were smaller for skin than silver thread electrodes. No centre produced outlying data points, and ERGs across all 15 centres were remarkably similar. Amplitude variability was less for local protocols (using LED flashes) than for the ISCEV-specified protocol using xenon flashes (22 vs. 24 %, p = 0.01), but peak time variability was less for the ISCEV-specified protocol (6.1 vs. 7.4 %, p = 0.001). Only the DA 0.01 ERG correlated with photometric variability. The bifidity of the DA 3 a-wave doubled its peak time variability compared with the DA 10 a-wave. Inter-centre amplitude variability was typically within clinically significant thresholds, suggesting that inter-centre variability with suitable standardisation may not add more to total variability than inter-subject variability. Variability improvements gained by the tighter specifications of the ISCEV-specified protocol were possibly more than lost due to imprecisions of xenon flashtubes. Peak time variability was far lower than amplitude variability, corresponding with acceptable variability of biochemical assays. These results represent a vindication of the existence of an ERG standard and suggest that further standardisation would lend itself to greater reproducibility of ERGs worldwide.
Article
Full-text available
Converting inner retinal neurons to photosensitive cells by expressing channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) offers a novel approach for treating blindness caused by retinal degenerative diseases. In the present study, the recombinant adeno-associated virus serotype 2 (rAAV2)-mediated expression and function of a fusion construct of channelopsin-2 (Chop2) and green fluorescent protein (GFP) (Chop2-GFP) were evaluated in the inner retinal neurons in the common marmoset Callithrix jacchus. rAAV2 vectors carrying ubiquitous promoters were injected into the vitreous chamber. Expression of Chop2-GFP and functional properties of ChR2 were examined by immunocytochemical and electrophysiological methods 3 months after injection. The percentage of Chop2-GFP-expressing cells in the ganglion cell layer was found to be retinal region- and animal age-dependent. The highest percentage was observed in the far-peripheral region. Chop2-GFP expression was also found in the foveal and parafoveal region. In the peripheral retina in young animals with high viral concentrations, the expression of Chop2-GFP was observed in all major classes of retinal neurons, including all major types of ganglion cells. The morphologic properties of Chop2-GFP-positive cells were normal for at least 3 months, and ChR2-mediated light responses were demonstrated by electrophysiological recordings. The rAAV2-mediated expression of ChR2 was observed in the inner retinal neurons in the marmoset retina through intravitreal delivery. The marmoset could be a valuable nonhuman primate model for developing ChR2-based gene therapy for treating blinding retinal degenerative diseases.
Article
Full-text available
Microspectrophotometric measurements of visual pigments have been obtained for a large sample of New World monkeys of the species Callithrix jacchus jacchus. These animals exhibit a polymorphism of visual pigments. The rods (Lmax 499 nm) and the short-wave receptors (Lmax 423 nm) appear to be common to all animals but individuals differ in the number and spectral position of pigments in the green-yellow spectral region. The latter pigments cluster near 545, 559 and 567 nm. Male monkeys draw one pigment from this set and female monkeys may draw one or two. The results are generally consistent with a genetic theory that postulates in Callithrix three possible alleles for a single locus in the X-chromosome. It appears that polymorphisms of cone pigments may be widespread among neotropical primates.
Article
Full-text available
The squirrel monkey (Saimiri sciureus) exhibits a polymorphism of colour vision: some animals are dichromatic, some trichromatic, and within each of these classes there are subtypes that resemble the protan and deutan variants of human colour vision. For each of ten individual monkeys we have obtained (i) behavioural measurements of colour vision and (ii) microspectrophotometric measurements of retinal photopigments. The behavioural tests, carried out in Santa Barbara, included wavelength discrimination, Rayleigh matches, and increment sensitivity at 540 and 640 nm. The microspectrophotometric measurements were made in London, using samples of fresh retinal tissue and a modified Liebman microspectrophotometer: the absorbance spectra for single retinal cells were obtained by passing a monochromatic measuring beam through the outer segments of individual rods and cones. The two types of data, behavioural and microspectrophotometric, were obtained independently and were handed to a third party before being interchanged between experimenters. From all ten animals, a rod pigment was recorded with lambda max (wavelength of peak absorbance) close to 500 nm. In several animals, receptors were found that contained a short-wave pigment (mean lambda max = 433.5 nm): these violet-sensitive receptors were rare, as in man and other primate species. In the middle- to long-wave part of the spectrum, there appear to be at least three possible Saimiri photopigments (with lambda max values at about 537,550 and 565 nm) and individual animals draw either one or two pigments from this set, giving dichromatic or trichromatic colour vision. Thus, those animals that behaviourally resembled human protanopes exhibited only one pigment in the red-green range, with lambda max = 537 nm; other behaviourally dichromatic animals had single pigments lying at longer wavelengths and these were the animals that behaviourally had higher sensitivity to long wavelengths. Four of the monkeys were behaviourally judged to be trichromatic. None of the latter animals exhibited the two widely separated pigments (close to 535 and 567 nm) that are found in the middle- and long-wave cones of macaque monkeys.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
Article
Purpose Ocular pharmacokinetic and distribution studies are key elements for the development of ophthalmic drugs and are used to correlate drug levels in preclinical species with human dosages and exposures. The purpose of this study was to compare ocular tissue weights for five commonly used preclinical species using two collection techniques. Methods Standard ocular tissues were collected from five males and five females of each species; New Zealand white (NZW) and Dutch Belted (DB) rabbits, beagle dogs, Gottingen minipigs, and Cynomolgus monkeys. Two collection techniques were used; a collection from fresh eyes (OS, immediately following enucleation) or a collection from frozen eyes (OD, following flash freezing). A specific procedure and collection sequence was followed for each technique. Results Aqueous and vitreous humor, cornea, lens, iris‐ciliary body, retina, choroid, and sclera were collected from each species; these tissues represented mean values of 70.0‐82.0% and 84.3‐88.9% of the total eye weight, respectively, for fresh and frozen collection. Tissue recovery levels were consistently higher using the frozen collection technique. Mean combined male & female vitreous humor weights using the frozen collection were 1.41, 1.31, 2.22, 2.34, and 2.04 g for NZW & DB rabbits, dogs, minipigs, and monkeys, respectively. Other tissue weights will be compared. Conclusion Comparative ocular tissue weights are presented for common preclinical species using fresh or frozen collection techniques. Vitreous humor and other tissue weights collected by the frozen technique accurately represent the weight (and volume assuming a VH density of 1) of the total tissue for comparative purposes to human vitreous volumes.
Article
To evaluate the retinal penetration and toxicity of two doses of intravitreal infliximab in primates. Ten marmosets (Callithrix jacchus) were given intravitreal injection of 100 μg or 400 μg of infliximab, and balanced salt solution served as control. At baseline and after 24 hours (5 animals) and 7 days (the other 5), the eyes were examined by electroretinography. They were then killed (at 24 hours and 7 days) and assessed by light microscopy and transmission electron microscopy for toxicity and immunohistochemistry, using a biotinylated anti-human immunoglobulin G, to evaluate retinal penetration. There was no difference over 50% of the electroretinography b-wave between baseline and the time points studied in all animals. Light and electron microscopy, and electroretinography analysis, showed no signs of toxicity in any of the animals. Strong presence of infliximab was observed in all retinal layers 7 days after intravitreal injection at both doses (100 and 400 μg). Infliximab at doses of 100 and 400 μg seemed to cause no damage to the retina 24 hours and 7 days after its intravitreal injection, and deeply penetrated all its layers, in primates. These results encourage future perspectives for the treatment of chronic inflammatory diseases of the retina in humans.
Article
We studied the relationship between the morphology of ganglion cells and the spatial density of photoreceptors in the retina of two Old World primates, human and macaque monkey; the diurnal New World marmoset Callithrix jacchus; and the cat. Ganglion cells in macaque and marmoset were labelled by intracellular injection with Neurobiotin or by DiI diffusion labelling in fixed tissue. Cone photoreceptor densities were measured from the same retinas. Supplemental data for macaque and data for human and cat were taken from published studies. For the primates studied, the central retina is characterised by a constant numerical convergence of cones to ganglion cells. Midget ganglion cells derive their input, via a midget bipolar cell, from a single cone. Parasol cells derive their input from 40-140 cones. Outside the central retina, the convergence increases with eccentricity. The convergence to beta cells in the cat retina is very close to that for parasol cells in primate retina. The convergence of rod photoreceptors to ganglion cells is similar in human, macaque, and marmoset, with parasol cells receiving input from 10-15 times more rods than midget cells. The low convergence of cones to midget cells in human and macaque retinas is associated with distinctive dendritic "clusters" in midget cells' dendritic fields. Convergence in marmoset is higher, and the clusters are absent. We conclude that the complementary changes in photoreceptor density and ganglion cell morphology should be considered when forming linking hypotheses between dendritic field, receptive field, and psychophysical properties of primate vision.
The ecology and evolution of primate vision
  • J Kremers
  • L C L Silveira
  • E S Yamada
  • B B Lee
  • K R Gegenfurtner
  • L T Sharpe
Kremers, J., Silveira, L. C. L., Yamada, E. S., and Lee, B. B.: The ecology and evolution of primate vision, in: Color Vision from Genes to Perception, edited by: Gegenfurtner, K. R. and Sharpe, L. T., Cambridge University Press, New York, USA, 123-142, 1999.
Accessibility of Retinal Cells to Different AAV Serotypes After Intravitreal Injection in Old Versus New World Primates
  • M Neitz
  • A Hendrickson
  • M Lukason
  • J Neitz
  • D Possin
  • G Abedi
  • J Huang
  • A Scaria
Neitz, M., Hendrickson, A., Lukason, M., Neitz, J., Possin, D., Abedi, G., Huang, J., Scaria, A., and Wadsworth, A.: Accessibility of Retinal Cells to Different AAV Serotypes After Intravitreal Injection in Old Versus New World Primates, Invest. Ophth. Vis. Sci., 54, p. 2733, 2013.
The ecology and evolution of primate vision, in: Color Vision from Genes to Perception
  • E Ivanova
  • G S Hwang
  • Z H Pan
  • D Troilo
  • J Kremers
  • L C L Silveira
  • E S Yamada
  • B B Lee
  • K R Gegenfurtner
  • L T Sharpe
Ivanova, E., Hwang, G. S., Pan, Z. H., and Troilo, D.: Evaluation of AAV-Mediated Expression of Chop2-GFP in the Marmoset Retina, Invest. Ophth. Vis. Sci., 51, 5288-5296, 2010. Kremers, J., Silveira, L. C. L., Yamada, E. S., and Lee, B. B.: The ecology and evolution of primate vision, in: Color Vision from Genes to Perception, edited by: Gegenfurtner, K. R. and Sharpe, L. T., Cambridge University Press, New York, USA, 123-142, 1999.