Content uploaded by Miriam Benita
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Miriam Benita on Jul 12, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
Acta Hortic. 1130. ISHS 2016. DOI 10.17660/ActaHortic.2016.1130.53
XXIX IHC – Proc. Int. Symposia on the Physiology of Perennial Fruit Crops and
Production Systems and Mechanisation, Precision Horticulture and Robotics
Eds.: D.S. Tustin et al.
351
Fertilization and fruit setting in date palm: biological
and technological challenges
Y.Cohen1,F.Slavkovic1,2,D.Birger1,2,A.Greenberg3,A.Sadowsky3,M.Ish‐Shalom1,M.Benita1,
T. T i c u c h i n s k i 3,Y.Avnat4andR.Kamenetsky5
1Departmentof FruitTreeSciences, VolcaniResearchCenter,P.O.Box6, BetDagan, Israel;2TheRobertH.Smith
FacultyofAgriculture,FoodandEnvironment,The HebrewUniversityof Jerusalem,Israel;3SouthernAravaR&
D, Yotvata, Israel; 4Crystal Vision, Kibbutz Samar, Israel; 5Department of Ornamental Horticulture, Volcani
ResearchCenter,P.O.Box6,BetDagan,Israel.
Abstract
Control of pollination and fertilization in date palms is essential for
development of high quality fruits. The female flower has three separate carpels. Only
a single carpel develops into a fruit, while the others degenerate. When pollination is
inefficient, non-fertilized flowers may develop into parthenocarpic fruits, which have
no commercial value. The main aim of our research is characterization of fertilization
and fruit setting in date palms and assessment of the effect of temperature on these
processes. Since date is a very large tree, it is practically impossible to study its
reproductive biology under completely controlled conditions, in a greenhouse or
phytotron. Therefore, two alternative research approaches have been applied. In vitro
assay was developed for culturing of isolated pollinated spikelets in liquid media
under fully controlled conditions. Alternatively, the controlled environmental
conditions were applied in planta, using specially designed units, assembled on
pollinated inflorescences of whole date trees in the orchard. Each technique had
specific advantages, as well as technical and biological limitations. Taken together,
they complement as an efficient research tool.
Relatively low temperatures (from 8 to 20°C) enhanced formation of
parthenocarpic fruits and reduced normal fruit development. Temperatures also
affected the rate of fruitlet development. Stages of pollen tube growth, fertilization,
carpel development and/or degeneration, and early development of normal and
parthenocarpic fruits were defined and characterized by macro- and microscopic
analyses.
Keywords:Phoenix dactilifera, temperature, controlled environmental conditions, pollen
tubegrowth
INTRODUCTION
Datepalm (Phoenix dactyliferaL.)isaveryimportantfruitcropinaridregionsofthe
MiddleEastandNorthAfrica(ChaoandKrueger,2007;ZaidandDeWet,2002a).Datepalm
isalargedioecioustree,havingfemaleandmaleflowersseparated on different trees. In
order to fertilize female flowers, pollen from male trees must reach the stigma. Under
natural conditions, wind‐mediated pollination occurs in date palms. In commercial
plantations,pollenisharvestedfrommaletreesandthenactivelydistributedonthefemale
treeinflorescences.Overlyhighrateoffruitsetmaycauseexcessive fruit load. Thus,
expensivefruitthinningisrequiredtopreventreductioninfruitsizeandmarketability.On
the other hand, sub‐optimal pollination conditions (usually occurring at cooler
temperatures) may result in non‐efficient fertilization and in low fruit yields. Therefore,
controlofpollinationandfertilizationindatepalmsisessentialforthedevelopmentofhigh
qualityfruitandyield.
Thedatefemaleflowerhasthreeseparatecarpels,eachcontainingasingleovule.After
fertilizationonlyoneofthethreecarpelsdevelopsintoafruitwhiletwoothersdegenerate.
Whenpollinationisinefficient,non‐fertilizedflowersmaydevelopintoparthenocarpicfruits
thathavenocommercialvalue(Reuveni,1986).
352
Pollination and fertilization processes are limited by various environmental factors.
Foremost,datepalmsflowerwhentheshadetemperatureincreasesto18°C,andfruitset
occurswhentemperatureishigherthan 25°C. Theeffectivetemperatureduringtheperiod
frompollinationtofruitripeningofthedatepalmrangesfrom21to27°C(ZaidandDeWet,
2002b).However,temperaturesin some arid regions vary drasticallyonadailybasis with
amplitudereachingmorethan20°C;asaresult,theefficiencyofpollination,fertilizationand
consequentfruitsetisoftenbelowoptimum.
Studyoffloweringandpollinationmechanismsandtheirregulationbyenvironmental
conditions (especially temperature) will provide tools for the optimization of fertilization
and fruit setting in date palms. However, the date is a very largetreeandthestudyofits
reproductivebiologyundercontrolledconditionsisachallengingtask.Inthisresearch,two
alternative approaches have been applied. First, an in vitro assay was developed for
culturingisolatedpollinatedspikeletsin liquidmediaunderfullycontrolledenvironmental
conditions. Second, the controlled environmental conditions were applied in planta, using
speciallydesignedunits,assembledon pollinated inflorescencesofwholedatetreesin the
orchard.Eachtechniquehasspecificadvantages,aswellastechnicalandbiological
limitations.Takentogether,theycomplementas efficientresearchtoolsthatallowin‐depth
studiesofthereproductiveprocessindatepalm.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Plant material
Date palm (Phoenix dactylifera)‘Medjoul’,grownattheexperimentalorchardsof
SouthernAravaR&D,Yotvata,andCanarypalm(Phoenix canariensis)growninthecampusof
Agricultural Research Organization, the Volcani Center in Bet Dagan,wereusedinthis
research.Bothspeciesarecloserelativesandpossesssimilarreproductivemechanismsbut
varyintheirannual cycleandfloweringseason. Datepalmsflowerduring arelativelyshort
season in March‐April, while canary palms flower in October. Therefore, we used canary
palmtocompsecondlementour main researchtoobtainplantmaterialbeyondthedateof
floweringseason.Forthelaboratoryinvitrostudiestheinflorescences of date palm and
canarypalm,enclosedinthespathe,weredeliveredtothelaboratoryinFebruary‐Aprilof
2013andOctober2013,respectively.Forinplantastudies,weusedtenyearoldintactdate
palmtrees(‘Medjoul’),growninanorchardatSouthernAravaR&D,Yotvata,Israel.
In vitro pollination assay
Singlespikeletscarryingflowerswerecuttoapproximately15cm,pollinated with a
small paintbrush with pollen collected during the previous season and stored at ‐20°C.
Spikeletswerethenplacedintubeswith10mLofliquidmediaorinagarmedia.Toprolong
“vaselife”andtoincreasesurvivalperiodoftheflowers,severalchemicalswereaddedtothe
media:TOG6(GADOTAgro),TOG6+2%sucrose,“Longlife”(GADOTAgro)wereaddedto
theliquidmedia.Additionallysurvivalwastestedonsolidagar plates supplemented with
3%sucrose,Murashige&Skoog(MS)medium(GetterM0222),casein hydrolysate (Getter
YB‐C1301), plant agar (0.8%, Getter YM‐P1001) and active charcoal (0.25%, Getter YB‐
C1302).pHwassetto5.7(Table1).
To delaysenescence, spikeletsweretreatedwith ethylene inhibitors: incubated with
500 ppb 1‐methylcyclopropene (1‐MCP) in sealed glass chambers at 20°C, or with 0.2%
silverthiosulfate(STS)pulse‐treatedfor4hat20°C.
Sampleswereincubatedatgrowthchamberswithconstanttemperatureof15,20,25
and30°C,and12‐hphotoperiod.Viabilityofspikeletsandindividual flowers was visually
evaluated, using a six‐point scale, where 5 is completely viable and 0 being dead/most
contaminated. To assess the viability we used the following parameters: (a) stigma
browning, (b) spikelet browning, (c) flower browning, (d) spikelet drying, (e) flower
abscissionand(f)senescence,Inparallel,sampleswerecollectedformicroscopicanalysisat
severaltimepointsduring14dayspostpollination.
353
Table1. Effectofculturemediaandtemperatureonisolatedspikeletsviability andflower
abscission. Spikelet sections were incubated at different temperatures, there
viabilityandflowerabscission wasestimatedat1, 5 and9daysaftersetup(DAS)
usingasix‐pointscale,where5iscompletelyviableand0being dead/most
contaminated. Means with different letters in columns are significantly different
(P≤0.05)accordingtotheTukey‐KramerHSDtest.
Culture media Overall vitality Abscission
1 DAS 5 DAS 9 DAS 1 DAS 5 DAS 9 DAS
TOG 5 a 4.8 a 1.5 ab 5 a 4.8 ab 2.8 abc
TOG + 2% sucrose 5 a 5 a 4.5 cd 5 a 4.5 ab 4.6 bc
LongLife 3.8 b 2 bc 0 a 5 a 2.6 a 0 a
DDW 4.3 ab 3.5 abc 0 a 4.9 a 4.6 ab 0 a
MS agar + 3% sucrose 4.9 a 3.5 abc 0 a 5 a 3.8 ab 2.3 abc
In planta pollination and fruit setting assay in temperature-controlled units
Controlledenvironmentalconditionswereappliedinplanta, usingspeciallydesigned
units,assembledonpollinatedinflorescencesofwholedatetreesintheorchardofSouthern
Arava R&D, Yotvata. Temperature was controlled by Peltier elements, capable of rapid
heating or cooling the environment. Ventilators were employed to remove excessive heat
within the units. Three sinusoidal temperature regimes were applied with a
maximal/minimaltemperaturesof20/8°C,25/12°Cand 32/18°C, mimickingextremecool,
average,andextremewarmconditionsatSouthernArava,Israelduringtheflowering
season.Thehighesttemperaturelevelwassettoapproximately2:00pm,andtheminimum
level at 5:00 am. Pollinated bunches, exposed to open‐air temperatures, were used as
control.Inflorescences/bunchesweresampledapproximatelytentimesinMarch‐May2013,
withinfirstsixweeksfrompollination.
Pollen tube elongation in vitro and on the stigma
DatepalmpollengrainswerecollectedfromYotvataorchardin2012and2013.Pollen
wasgerminatedinvitroatdifferenttemperaturesfor3hinasolutionof 10%sucroseand
500mgL‐1boricacid(Bernestein,2004).Pollengrainswerevisualizedunderamicroscope
(MZFLIII,LEICA),photographed(Nikon DS‐Fi1) and theirtubelengthwasmeasuredusing
theNIS‐ElementsBR3.1Program.
Analysisof pollentubeelongationin stigmaswasadapted fromReuvenietal.(1986)
and Cohen et al. (2004). Prior to histological evaluation, FAA fixed flowers were washed
three times in double distilled water (DDW): 100% ethanol (1:1), and then five times in
DDW.Usingstereoscope,stigmaswereseparatedandclearedwith10MNaOHfor2hand
washed in DDW fivetimes. Stigmas were stained with aniline blue (0.4% in 0.35% K3PO4
solution) and examined under fluorescence microscope (MZFLIII, LEICA) with a UV
excitationfilterset(340‐380/400/425nm).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Pollen germination in vitro
Pollen germination in vitro was significantly affected by temperature. At lower
temperaturesitwasslowerandpollen tubeelongationwasretardedascomparedwith 25‐
30°C(datanotshown).Wearguethatthisassaydidnotfullyrepresenttheeventsoccurring
within the stigma and carpel of the flower in vivo. Therefore, for the further study of the
effect of environmental conditions on fertilization and fruit setting in date palm two
additionalapproacheswere used: (1)invitropollinationof flowersoncutspikeletsunder
controlled conditions and (2) in planta pollination, fertilization and fruit setting in
temperature‐controlledunits,placedontheintactinflorescencesofthewholetree.
354
In vitro pollination and fertilization on isolated spikelets
Creating controlled environment conditions for fruit bearing indatepalmsisa
challengingtask.Wecalibratedaninvitroassay,inwhichisolatedspikeletswillhavealong
enough “vase life”, thus enabling fertilization and fruit settinginvitro.Severalparameters
werecalibratedtoreachthebestconditions.Fivegrowthmediaweretestedtoprolong“vase
life”andtoincreasesurvivalperiodoftheflowers.Thelongest“vase‐life”ofinflorescences
wasrecordedatTOG6andTOG6+2%sucrosegrowthmedia(Table1).Furtherexperiments
werelaterperformedusingthisgrowthmedia.
InOctober2013,cutspikeletsofCanarypalm,weretreatedwithethyleneinhibitors,
1‐MCPorSTS.Bothtreatmentsextended“vaselife”oftheflowersandspikelets.Theflowers
werehealthierandlessflowershaddropped3‐10DAP(Figure1), and lower fungal
contamination was observed (data not shown). Pollinated spikeletstreatedby1‐MCPand
STSremainedviable13DAP,whilethecontrolflowershaddried(Figure1).However,these
treatmentswerenotabletosupport invitrodevelopment oftheflowersandfruitsetafter
pollination.
0
1
2
3
4
5
024681012
Grades
Days after setup
MCP
STS
Control
0
1
2
3
4
5
024681012
Grades
Days after setup
1-MCP
control
1-MCP
control
STS
ABC
D
Figure1. Effectofethyleneinhibitorssilverthiosulfate(STS)(A)and1‐methylcyclopropene
(1‐MCP) (B) on viability (C) and flower abscission (D) on isolated spikelets.
Pollinatedspikeletsectionswereincubatedtwoweeksat25°C.Theirviabilityand
flower abscission was estimated using a six‐point scale, where 5 is completely
viableand0beingdead/sheddedflower.Datarepresentmeans±standarderrors.
Weconcludedthatunderourexperimentalconditionsfastflowersenescencemightbe
caused by fungal or bacterial contamination, ethylene emission, hormonal imbalance or
otherfactors.Inanyevent,flowersenescencewasfasterthanfruitletdevelopment,andeven
ifthepollinationwassuccessful, wewerenotableto followtheprocessoffertilizationand
fruitletdevelopment.
Temperature effect on pollen tube growth on stigma of in vitro pollinated flowers
Pollen tube elongation was estimated on stigmas of the flowers, pollinated on cut
spikelets and cultured in vitro (Table 2). Pollen tube elongation was observed under all
temperatureregimesinthefirstdayafterpollination.Thehighestpollengerminationrate
was observed at 30°C, followed by 25 and 20°C. Even at 15°C moderate germination on
355
stigmawasobserved.However,pollentubeelongationandpenetrationtotheupperpart of
thecarpelwasmuchslowerat15°Ccomparedwithhighertemperatures. Although no
morphological damage was observedwithinthefirstdaysaftergermination, under our
experimentalconditionsfurthergrowth of thepollentubeswasrestricted andfertilization
didnotoccurunderanytemperatureregime.Inasimilarexperiment, performed with
isolatedspikeletsofadifferentdatecultivar,‘Barhee’,pollentubeelongationwasdetected
withinthecarpelanduptotheovulewithin3‐7daysafterpollination(Cohenetal.,2004).
Wesuggestthatinvitrothe‘Medjuol’flowerswiltrelativelyfastduetointensesenescence
andcontaminationprocesses,andthatfurthercalibrationisrequiredfortheoptimizationof
invitroconditionsforfertilizationexperiments.
Table2. Effectsoftemperature onpollengerminationon stigmaofflowersofcutspikelets
pollinatedinvitro.Pollengerminationwasestimatedonafive‐pointscale,where0
=nogermination;4= high germination. Analysiswasperformed on atleasteight
stigmas per treatment. Statistical analysis includes samples from different
temperaturetreatmentsandDAPs.Meansaresignificantlydifferent (P≤0.05)
accordingtotheTukey‐KramerHSDtest.
Temperature, day/night 1 DAP 3 DAP 7 DAP
15°C 1.95±0.29 bcd 1.45±0.29 c 1.62±0.29 d
20°C 1.37±0.29 d 1.75±0.29 bcd 1.68±0.36 bcd
25°C 1.5±0.29 d 1.91±0.29 bcd 1.35±0.38 d
30°C 3.41±0.29 a 3.08±0.29 ab 3.00±0.29 abc
Effect of environmental conditions on fertilization and fruit setting in date palm in
planta
Inordertostudythetemperatureeffectsonthefertilizationandfruitsettinginplanta,
temperature controlled units were designed (Figure 2). Following pollination, date
inflorescenceswereenclosedinthetemperaturecontrolled units on the treesunderthree
temperatureregimes,forfiveweeksinMarch‐May2013.Warmerconditions resulted in
much bigger fruitlets. However, temperaturedid not affect the spikelet elongation and the
distancesbetweenthefruitletsonthespikeletsdidnotvarysignificantly.Atfiveweeksafter
pollination (WAP) there was no significant difference in fruitlet abscission. Under cooler
conditions(20/8°C)increasedlevelsofparthenocarpicfruitsweredetectedcomparedtothe
warmtemperatureregimes(32/18°C)andthecontrol(datanotshown). The fruitlet
developmentandweightat5WAPwashigherastemperatureincreased(Table3).
Figure2. Schematic representation (A) and picture (B) of temperature controlled units
assembledoninflorescencesoffruitbearingdatepalmsintheorchard.
356
Table3. Effect of temperature on fruitlet weight and density in pollinated date palm
bunches, incubated in temperature‐controlled units, 5 and 10 weeks after
pollination(WAP).Experimentswereperformedonfourdifferent bunches per
treatment. Analysis was performed on at least 10 representativefruitsfrom5
spikeletsfrom each bunch.Meansaresignificantly different(P≤0.05)accordingto
theTukey‐KramerHSDtest.
Temperature,
day/night
Fruitlet density 5 WAP
(cm-1 spikelet)
Single fruitlet weight
5 WAP (g)
Single fruitlet weight
10 WAP (g)
20/8°C 1.5 0.91 c 1.48±0.14 c
25/12°C 1.9 1.22 bc 1.78±0.12 c
32/18°C 1.6 3.12 a 3.76±0.14 a
Control 1.5 1.89 b 2.98±0.12 b
Temperature effect on pollen tube growth in planta
Pollengrainsgerminated in planta in all temperatureregimes(Tab le 4). H owever, a t
lowertemperatures(20/8°C)pollengerminationwasnotdetectedat16h afterpollination
andwasalsodelayedat3DAPcomparedwith 25/12,32/18andcontrolplants.Additional
differences in pollen tube elongation rate have been recorded. At moderate temperatures
(25/12°C),pollentubesweresignificantlyshorterat16hafter pollination than at higher
temperatures(32/18°C).At7DAPgrowthofpollentubeswasobservedinallstigmas.Since
thetemperatureconditionswerechangingduringthe daywithineachtreatment,weargue
thatinthelowertemperaturetreatments,activepollen growthhadprobablyoccurredonly
atthehoursofhighesttemperatureduringtheday.Forfertilization, pollen tubes have to
extendfromthestigmathroughthecarpelstotheovules.Wesuggest that under lower
temperaturesaconsiderablefractionofthepollentubesdidnot reach the ovule, thus
preventing an efficient fertilization.In this experiment, large amo untso fpollen have been
applied. However, the increased occurrence of parthenocarpic fruitsunderlower
temperatures (20/8°C) implies that the reduced elongation of pollen tubes eliminated
efficientfertilization.Thisfactmightalsoexplainreducedfruit settingandyields occurring
incommercialplantationsundercoolerconditions.
Table4. Effect of temperature on pollen germination on stigma in pollinated date palm
bunches, incubated in temperature‐controlled units 1‐7 days after pollination
(DAP). Pollen germination was estimated on a five‐point scale, where 0 = no
germination; 4 = high germination. Analysis was performed on atleasteight
stigmas per treatment. Statistical analysis included samples from different
temperaturesandDAPs.Meansaresignificantlydifferent(P≤0.05)accordingtothe
Tukey‐KramerHSDtest.
Temperature, day/night 0.6 DAP 3 DAP 7 DAP
20/8°C 0 b 0.79 b 2.06 a
25/12°C 0.15 b 2.58 ab 1.80 a
32/18°C 1.33 a 2.88 a 2.06 a
Control 1.33 a 1.88 ab 1.80 a
The presented study demonstrates that temperature regime significantly affects
pollination, fertilization and fruit setting in palms. When temperatures are relatively low,
reductioninfruitsettingmightbecausedbyslowelongationof pollen tubes. Microscopic
analyses are currently being performed to elucidate the environmental effects at different
stages of fertilization and early fruit development in date palms.Wehopethatfurther
calibration of environmental conditions in vitro will allow for betterunderstanding of the
mechanismsoffruitsettingsindatepalms.
Two systems for evaluation of the fertilization process in palms were developed to
complement each other. Each system had specific advantages, as well as technical and
357
biologicallimitations.Theinvitroapproachfacilitatedadirectstudyoftheinflorescencesat
constanttemperaturesinartificialconditions.However, major limitations in this approach
weretheshort“vaselife”ofthecutinflorescences,contamination, absence of leaves and
hencedisturbanceofhormonalandenvironmentalstimuli,aswellasfastflowersenescence,
probablyduetoethylenereleaseincutinflorescences.Nevertheless,thisapproachallowed
ustofocusonindividualflowersandcarefullyexaminethestigmasandcarpelsinvitro.
Thesizeofmaturedatepalmtreespreventsstudiesincompletely controlled
conditions,i.e.,inaphytotron.Ourstudyofthepalmsinvivo in controlled temperature
units, actually presents a beneficial “modular phytotron” approach.Inthiscase,the
inflorescenceremainsthe integral partofthewhole tree, and itshormonalandnutritional
balance is intact. However, in these experiments, environmental conditions were modified
only in the inflorescences, while temperature effects on the other plant organs were not
modified. We areaware of the limitations of this approach: by enclosing inflorescences in
environmentalcontrolled units,thetreetrunk, leavesand rootsystemsarestillexposedto
the outdoor temperatures and are not controlled. Hence, one of the drawbacks is the
disregardofanyhormonalandotherenvironmentalsignalssuch aslightandhumiditythat
affecttheplantandcanbetransportedfromorgantoorgan.
CONCLUSIONS
Theexperimentsperformedinthecontrolledenvironmentunitspresentthebeneficial
potentialofthisapproachforothersystemsinhorticulture.Theyareapplicablenotonlyto
study fertilization of date palms, but to study the effects of environmental conditions
(temperature,humidity,light) onanylarge tree. Thecontrolledunits can providemodified
conditionsaroundanytreeorgan‐ aninflorescence,fruitbunch,leafortreesection.Useof
severalunitscanalsocreatevariousenvironmentalconditionson thesameindividualtree.
Such units can function as “modular phytotron” to facilitate studies on the whole‐plant
physiologyinfruittrees.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
ThestudywasfundedbygrantsfromtheIsraeliministryofagriculture,byIsraeliDate
Grower’sBoardandbytheJCACharitableFoundation.Wewishto thank Dr.S. Philosoph‐
HadasandDr.S.Meirforhelpfulsuggestions.
Literature cited
Bernestein,Z.(2004).TheDatePalm(TelAviv:IsraeliFruitBoard)(inHebrew).
Chao, C.T., and Krueger, R.R. (2007). The date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.): overview of biology, uses, and
cultivation.HortScience42,1077–1082.
Cohen, Y., Korchinsky, R., and Tripler, E. (2004). Flower abnormalities cause abnormal fruit setting in tissue
culture propagated date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.). J. Hortic. Sci. Biotechnol. 79(6), 1007–1013
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14620316.2004.11511853.
Reuveni,O. (1986).Date.In CRC HandbookofFruit Set andDevelopment,S.P.Monselise,ed.(BocaRaton:CRC
Press),p.119–144.
Reuveni,O., Abu, S., and Golobovitz, S. (1986). Date palm pollen germination and tube elongation on pistillate
flowers cultured at different temperatures. Acta Hortic. 175, 91–96
http://dx.doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.1986.175.13.
Zaid,A.,andDeWet,P.F.(2002a).Botanicalandsystematicdescriptionofthedatepalm.InDatePalmCultivation,
Vol.156,A.Zaid,ed.(Rome:FAO),p.29–44.
Zaid, A., and De Wet, P.F. (2002b). Climatic requirements of datepalm.InDatePalmCultivation,A.Zaid,ed.
(Rome:FAO)p.58–73.
358