Naga City Case Studies: Risk Sensitive Land-Use Planning & Incentives for Disaster Risk Reduction

Full text

!"#"!"#$"
"
%

!"#"!"#$"
"
%"
&'()*+,-)'*.%
"
$!%&"'()*+,-*,%"(."/010"
%
/'(0%1'2(%3'(#")4%5"6'*%
/'(0%7$8.'(%9$#":+'(4%;+:$%5"6'*%
/'(0%1'.$%<-".'(4%&'-(:+8'*%
5*0%=+8>*$?'%!*+88$.4%1*04%&+)6%!8"((+(#%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%&''*?+(")'*%
5.0%D*$#'*+"%7+8?"%E,'("84%&+)6%<*$".-*$*%
F(#*0%G'8"(?'%&"CB+88'.4%H*,"(%!''*%E>>"+*.%&2+$>%
5*0%1'.$8+)'%@$8%G'."*+'4%!-,8+:%I">$)6%J>>+:$*%
5.0%5"8'-%@$8%&".)+88'4%E..+.)"()%3-?#$)%J>>+:$*%
5*0%E(.$8C'%5"K'4%L(>'*C")+'(%I6.)$C.%E("86.)%LLL4%F8$:)*'(+:%@")"%!*':$..+(#%J>>+:$%
5*0%9"M*$(:$%7'#*"4%I5I%!*'#*"CC$*4%+NI$*A$%!*'#*"C%
5*0%G$-$8%J8+A$*4%5$)*'%7"#"%!-,8+:%FCB8'6C$()%I$*A+:$.%J>>+:$%/$"?%
F(#*0%9$'(%!"8C+"('4%&+)6%F(#+($$*%
"
2+!)0%*"3*4%(+"0,5"$!)!6"3(4!*%&"7+10,!80%!(,9"
5$)*'%7"#"%&2"C,$*%'>%&'CC$*:$%"(?%L(?-.)*6%
!2+8+BB+($%G$?%&*'..%O%7"#"%&+)6%&2"B)$*%
2+04%!4*":*05*+9"
%
@*0%G$("(%5"0%<0%<"(2-$:'4%G+.P%I$(.+)+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%FQB$*)%
E))60%;+'8$)"%I'C$*"NI$A"4%H*,"(%@+.".)$*%G+.P%5"("#$C$()%RL(:$()+A$.S%FQB$*)%
"
;<="2+(>*4%"<0,01*-*,%"?*0-"
%
@*0%F(#0%T'-"?%3$(?+C$*"?4%!*'U$:)%<$"C%9$"?$*%
5*0%1'.$%5"*+%@":8"(4%!*'U$:)%5"("#$*%
5*0%5+:2"$8%E?*+"(%!"?+88"4%E..+.)"()%!*'U$:)%5"("#$*%
5.0%E62$(%9'+..$%@"8$("4%!*'U$:)%&''*?+(")'*%
E))60%E(($%G'($88$%I+?$*.4%G$.$"*:2%T$88'M%
5*0%G',+(%&*'V+$*4%G$.$"*:2%E..+.)"()% %

!!"#"!"#$"
"
E:*'(6C.%
%
E@3% % E.+"(%@$A$8'BC$()%3"(P%
EIF!% % E..':+")+'(%'>%I)*-:)-*"8%F(#+($$*.%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%
E-.EL@% % E-.)*"8+"(%E#$(:6%>'*%L()$*(")+'("8%@$A$8'BC$()%
&3@% % &$()*"8%3-.+($..%@+.)*+:)%
&35I% % &'CC-(+)6%3".$?%5'(+)'*+(#%I6.)$C%
&&E% % &8+C")$%&2"(#$%E?"B)")+'(%
&&I% % &'(.)*-:)+'(%&'?$.%"(?%I)"(?"*?.%
&&<.% % &'(?+)+'("8%&".2%<*"(.>$*.%
&9H!% % &'CB*$2$(.+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"(%
&!@%% % &+)6%!8"((+(#%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%
&!@J% % &+)6%!8"((+(#%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%J>>+:$%
@35% % @$B"*)C$()%'>%3-?#$)%"(?%5"("#$C$()%
@L9D% % @$B"*)C$()%'>%)2$%L()$*+'*%"(?%9':"8%D'A$*(C$()%
@!=/% % @$B"*)C$()%'>%!-,8+:%='*P.%"(?%/+#2M"6.%
@GL;F% % @+.".)$*%G$.+8+$(:6%L(+)+")+A$%>'*%;-8($*",8$%F(:8"A$%
@G5% % @+.".)$*%G+.P%5"("#$C$()%
@GG% % @+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%
@GG5% % @+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%
@GG5J% % @+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%J>>+:$%
F@!J% % F8$:)*'(+:%@")"%!*':$..+(#%J>>+:$%
DLI% % D$'#*"B2+:%L(>'*C")+'(%I6.)$C%
DLW% % D$*C"(%&'*B'*")+'(%>'*%L()$*(")+'("8%@$A$8'BC$()%
DJ9@% % D'A$*("(:$%"(?%9':"8%@$C':*":6%
/9HG3% % /'-.+(#%"(?%9"(?%H.$%G$#-8")'*6%3'"*?%
/;GE% % /"V"*?4%;-8($*",+8+)6%"(?%G+.P%E..$..C$()%
+7GG!% % L()$#*")$?%7"#"%G+A$*%G$A+)"8+V")+'(%!*'U$:)%
LGE% % L()$*("8%G$A$(-$%E88')C$()%
XE9EIED% % XE8"C+?"?%")%I"P-("%9E,"("(4%IE*+8+(#%D"8+(#%"(#%X"8+#)"."(%
XLL.% % X$6%L(>'*C"()%L()$*A+$M.%
9@GG5T% % 9':"8%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%T-(?%
9FG&% % 9$".)%F:'('C+:"886%G$.+8+$()%&'CC-(+)+$.%
9DH% % 9':"8%D'A$*(C$()%H(+)%
9L@EG% % 9+#2)%@$)$:)+'(%"(?%G"(#+(#%
9H5% % 9"(?%H.$%5"("#$C$()%
9H!% % 9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%
53E.% % 5-)-"8%3$($>+)%E..':+")+'(.%
5D3% % 5+($.%"(?%D$'.:+$(:$.%3-*$"-%
7E!&% % 7")+'("8%E()+N!'A$*)6%&'CC+..+'(%
7&D% % 7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%
7&@GG5T% % 7"#"%&+)6%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%T-(?%
7@GG5&% % 7")+'("8%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%&'-(:+8%
7F@E% % 7")+'("8%F:'('C+:%@$A$8'BC$()%E-)2'*+)6%
7FYHI% % L()$#*")$?%H*,"(%@$A$8'BC$()%!*'U$:)%
7DJ% % 7'(ND'A$*(C$()%J*#"(+V")+'(%

!!!"#"!"#$"
"
7/E% % 7")+'("8%/'-.+(#%E-)2'*+)6%
J3J% % J>>+:$%'>%)2$%3-+8?+(#%'>>+:+"8%
J&@% % J>>+:$%'>%&+A+8%@$>$(.$%
JF&@% % J*#"(+V")+'(%>'*%F:'('C+:%&'N'B$*")+'(%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%
!EDEIE% % !2+8+BB+($%E)C'.B2$*+:4%D$'B26.+:"8%"(?%E.)*'('C+:"8%I$*A+:$.%E?C+(+.)*")+'(%
!&T% % !$*>'*C"(:$%&2"88$(#$%T-(?%
!&TLH% % !$*>'*C"(:$%&2"88$(#$%T-(?%LCB8$C$()")+'(%H(+)%
!IT% % !$'B8$Z.%I-*A+A"8%T-(?%
!/L;J9&I% % !2+8+BB+($%L(.)+)-)$%'>%;'8:"('8'#6%"(?%I$+.C'8'#6%
!2!% % !2+8+BB+($%!$.'%
!L&F% % !2+8+BB+($%L(.)+)-)$%'>%&+A+8%F(#+($$*.%
!!E.% % !*'#*"C.4%!*'U$:).%"(?%E:)+A+)+$.%
[GT% % [-+:P%G$.B'(.$%T-(?%
[HFF7% % [-"8+)6%H(+A$*."8%F8$C$()"*6%"(?%/+#2%I:2''8%F?-:")+'(%
GF@EI% % G"B+?%F"*)2\-"P$%@"C"#$%E..$..C$()%I6.)$C%
GI9H!% % G+.P%I$(.+)+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%
ITG% % IC"88%T"*C%G$.$*A'+*.%
ID/% % I$"8%'>%D''?%/'-.$P$$B+(#%
I=LI% % IC"88%=")$*%LCB'-(?+(#%I6.)$C%
I=J&% % I)*$(#)2.4%=$"P($..$.4%JBB'*)-(+)+$.%"(?%&2"88$(#$.%
<E% % <$:2(+:"8%E..+.)"(:$%
<@G% % <*"(.>$*%'>%@$A$8'BC$()%G+#2).%
<'!% % <$:2('8'#6%'>%!"*)+:+B")+'(%
H&!3% % H(+)$?%&':'(-)%!8"()$*.%3"(P%
H7% % H(+)$?%7")+'(.%
WJ% % W'(+(#%J*?+("(:$%
%

?0@6*"(."$(,%*,%9%
&'()*+,-)'*.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %%%
+%
E:*'(6C.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%++%
!*'U$:)%3":P#*'-(?%%%%%%%%%%%%]%
&".$%I)-?6%9':")+'(^%7"#"%&+)64%!2+8+BB+($.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%_%
&".$%I)-?6%`a^%G+.P%I$(.+)+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%b%
L()*'?-:)+'(%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
c%
5"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG%+()'%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%+(%7"#"%&+)6^%L..-$.%"(?%&2"88$(#$.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%c%
="6%T'*M"*?%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
aa%
&".$%I)-?6%`]^%L(:$()+A$.%>'*%@GG%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%ab%
7")+'("8%@GG%L(:$()+A$.%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%ac%
9':"8%@GG%L(:$()+A$.%+(%7"#"%&+)6%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%]]%
@$.+#(+(#%L(:$()+A$.%>'*%@GG%+(%7"#"%&+)6^%&2"88$(#$.%"(?%!*+'*+)+$.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%]b%
&'(:8-.+'(.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
]d%
G$>$*$(:$.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% % % %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%_e%
E(($Q$.%%%%%%%%%%%%% %%_f%

A"#"!"#$"
"
2+(>*4%"B04C1+(D,5""
%
<2$%E.+"(%@$A$8'BC$()%3"(P%RE@3S%+.%+CB8$C$()+(#%"%*$#+'("8%)$:2(+:"8%"..+.)"(:$%R<ES%B*'U$:)%)'%
.)*$(#)2$(%"::$..%)'%)''8.%"(?%#-+?$8+($.%'(%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%"(?%-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()%
B*':$..$.%+(%)2$%E.+"N!":+>+:%G$#+'(0%<2$%<E%+.%$QB$:)$?%)'%B*'?-:$%)M'%*$#+'("8%'-)B-).^%RaS%E%
#-+?$,''P%'(%+()$#*")+(#%?+.".)$*%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%R@GGS%+()'%-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()%B*':$..$.4%M+)2%.$:)'*%
(')$.%'(%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#4%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%-*,"(%*$?$A$8'BC$()4%"(?%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%M")$*4%
M".)$M")$*4%"(?%.)'*C%M")$*%?*"+("#$%.6.)$C%?$A$8'BC$()g%"(?%R]S%E%?+.:-..+'(%B"B$*%'(%
+(:$()+A$.h?+.+(:$()+A$.%>'*%+(A$.)+(#%+(%@GG0%
<2*$$%.)-?6%.+)$.%2"A$%,$$(%.$8$:)$?%>'*%)2$%B*'U$:)4%("C$86%7"#"%&+)6%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%X")2C"(?-%
;"88$6%+(%7$B"84%"(?%@"%7"(#%+(%;+$)("C0%L(%)2+.%:'()$Q)4%E@3%2".%$(#"#$?%)M'%$QB$*).OG+.P%9"(?%H.$%
!8"((+(#%"(?%H*,"(%@+.".)$*%G+.P%5"("#$C$()%RL(:$()+A$.S%IB$:+"8+.).i>*'C%)2$%F"*)2\-"P$%"(?%
5$#":+)+$.%L(+)+")+A$.%)'%M'*P%:8'.$86%M+)2%)2$%'>>+:+"8.%>*'C%7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%)'%?$A$8'B%)M'%:".$%
.)-?+$.%'(%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%"(?%+(:$()+A$.%>'*%+(A$.)+(#%+(%-*,"(%@GG0%
L(%)2$%:".$%.)-?+$.4%)2$%(")+'("8%$QB$*).%2"A$%"::'CB8+.2$?%)2$%>'88'M+(#%)".P.^%
a0!@':-C$()$?%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%B*":)+:$.%+(%7"#"%&+)6%"(?%*$A+$M$?%?$A$8'BC$()%B*":)+:$.%
)2")%"+C%)'%.)*$(#)2$(%*$.+8+$(:$0%
]0!&'88$:)$?%+(>'*C")+'(%'(%?+>>$*$()%)6B$.%'>%+(:$()+A$.%B*'A+?$?%,6%)2$%(")+'("8%"(?%:+)6%
#'A$*(C$().%)'%B*'C')$%+(:8-.+A$%"(?%.-.)"+(",8$%-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()g%
_0!L?$()+>+$?%*$8$A"()%+(:$()+A$.%)2")%?+*$:)86%'*%+(?+*$:)86%:'()*+,-)$%)'M"*?.%.)*$(#)2$(+(#%
?+.".)$*%"(?%:8+C")$%*$.+8+$(:$g%
f0!L?$()+>+$?%?+>>$*$()%'B)+'(.%>'*%+(:$()+A$.%)2")%:'-8?%2$8B%*$C'A$%+CB8$C$()")+'(%
,'))8$($:P.%"(?%>*"C$?%)2$.$%+(%)2$%8':"84%(")+'("8%"(?%#8',"8%:'()$Q).g%%
b0!!*'A+?$?%*$:'CC$(?")+'(.%'(%?+>>$*$()%)6B$.%'>%+(:$()+A$.%*$8$A"()%)'%7"#"%&+)64%"(?%%
c0!T'*C-8")$?%.-##$.)+'(.%'(%>'88'MN-B%":)+'(.%*$\-+*$?%>'*%>-*)2$*%?$A$8'BC$()%'>%.B$:+>+:%
+(:$()+A$.0%%%
L)%+.%2'B$?%)2")%)2$%>+(?+(#.4%'-)B-).%"(?%*$:'CC$(?")+'(.%'>%)2$.$%:".$%.)-?+$.%M+88%:'()*+,-)$%)'%
+(+)+")+(#%?+"8'#-$.%"(?%:'(.-8)")+'(.%M+)2%.)"P$2'8?$*.%)2")%M+88%2$8B%)2$C%)'%-(?$*.)"(?%)2$%+..-$.%
)2")%8+C+)%+(A$.)C$().%+(%@GG4%"(?%)2$%)6B$%'>%+(:$()+A$.%)2")%:'-8?%B*'C')$%*$.+8+$()%"(?%.-.)"+(",8$%
-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()0%
"
%

E"#"!"#$"
"
$09*"3%D5&":(40%!(,F"/010"$!%&G"2H!6!II!,*9"
%
7"#"%&+)6%2".%"%2+.)'*6%'>%#''?%#'A$*("(:$0%L)%+.%)2$%2+#2$.)%*"(P$?%:+)6%,".$?%'(%#'A$*(C$()%$>>+:+$(:6%
"(?%:'CB$)+)+A$($..%R7")+'("8%&'CB$)+)+A$($..%&'-(:+84%]eafSg% .'%+)%*$B*$.$().%"%,$.)%:".$% .:$("*+'% +(%
)2$% !2+8+BB+($.0% % &2"88$(#$.% $QB$*+$(:$?% +(% 7 "#"% &+)6% "*$% 8+P$86% )'% ,$% >'-(?4% "(?% B'..+,86% )'% ,$% $A$(%
C'*$%B*'C+($()4%+(%')2$*%!2+8+BB+($.%:+)+$.0%%
%
7"#"%&+)6%+.%8':")$?%+(%)2$%:$()$*%'>%)2$%3+:'8%*$#+'(4%'(%)2$%.'-)2$".)$*(%)+B%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($%+.8"(?%'>%
9-V'(4%8':")$?%_jj%PC%.'-)2%'>%5$)*'%5"(+8"0%<2$%:+)6%2".%"%B'B-8")+'(%'>%ajf4kfj%R!2+8+BB+($%I)")+.)+:"8%
E-)2'*+)64%]ea_S%M+)2+(%"%#$'#*"B2+:%"*$"%'>%df0b%.\0%PC4%C"P+(#%+)%'($%'>% )2$%C'.)%?$(.$86%B'B-8")$?%
:+)+$.%+(% )2$% *$#+'(% R7"#"%&+)6%@$A$8'BC$()%!8"(4%]eaaS0%%7"#"%&+)6%+.%"%C"U'*%$CB8'6C$()% ,".$% +(% )2$%
*$#+'(% "(?% .$*A$.% ".% "% P$6% 2-,% >'*% ,-.+($..% "(?% $?-:")+'(% +(% .'-)2$*(% 9-V'(% R&+)+$.% @$A$8'BC$()%
L(+)+")+A$% >'*% E.+"4% ]eaaS0%L)% +.% :8"..+>+$?% ,6% )2$% !2+8+BB+($% @$B"*)C$()% '>% T+("(:$% ".% "% ](?%:8"..% :+)64%
C$"(+(#%)2")%+)%2".%"(%"((-"8%"A$*"#$%+(:'C$%'>%,$)M$$(%HIl%c0d%5%)'%d0b%50%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
Source:
http://www.zamboanga.com/z/index.php?title=
Naga_City,_Camarines_Sur,_Philippines
J!1D+*9"K"L"AM":(40%!(,"(."/010"!,"+*60%!(,"%("%H*"
*,%!+*"2H!6!II!,*9G"0,5"6(40%!(,"(."/010"N!%H!,"!%9"
+*1!(,"

O"#"!"#$"
"
%
%
7"#"%&+)6%+.%"8.'%'($%'>%)2$%:+)+$.%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%)2")%+.%A-8($*",8$%)'%(")-*"8%?+.".)$*.0%L)%2".%"(%
"((-"8%*"+(>"88%'>%]4]af%CC%"(?%+.%2+)%,6%"(%"A$*"#$%'>%]%)'%_%)6B2''(.%$A$*6%6$"*0a%<2$%:+)6%:'-8?%"8.'%
,$%+CB":)$?%,6%"%B'..+,8$%C"#(+)-?$%d%$"*)2\-"P$%'*+#+(")+(#%>*'C%)2$%!2+8+BB+($%<*$(:24%M2+:2%:'-8?%
">>$:)%)2$%3+:'8%G$#+'(0]%<2$.$%:'(?+)+'(.4%:'C,+($?%M+)2%)2$%:+)6Z.%8':")+'(%+(%)2$%3+:'8%G+A$*%3".+(4%
$QB'.$%)2$%:+)6%)'%>8''?+(#%*+.P0%<2+.%*+.P%+.%$Q":$*,")$?%,6%B26.+:"8%:2"(#$.%M+)2+(%7"#"%"(?%+).%
.-**'-(?+(#%"*$"%?-$%)'%B'B-8")+'(%#*'M)2%"(?%-*,"(+V")+'(0%%<2$%M")$*.2$?%"*$".%'>%5)0%L."*'#4%$".)%
'>%)2$%:+)64%2"A$%,$$(%#*$")86%*$?-:$?%?-$%)'%-(*$#-8")$?%8'##+(#%'-).+?$%)2$%:+)6%)$**+)'*6%"(?%)2$%
:'(A$*.+'(%'>%>'*$.)%8"(?%>'*%>"*C+(#4%.$))8$C$().4%"(?%')2$*%-.$.0%G"B+?%-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()%2".%"8.'%
*$?-:$?%)2$%",.'*B)+A$%:"B":+)6%'>%(")-*"8%:"):2C$()%"*$".%"8'(#%)2$%7"#"%"(?%3+:'8%G+A$*.0_%
%
<'%.-BB'*)%:'()+(-$?%B'B-8")+'(%#*'M)24%-*,"(+V")+'(4%"(?%$:'('C+:%?$A$8'BC$()%M2+8$%.)+88%*$?-:+(#%
?+.".)$*%*+.P4%7"#"%&+)6%C-.)%+()$#*")$%@GG%+()'%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%".%M$88%".%+CB8$C$()%B'8+:6%
C$:2"(+.C.%)2")%$(:'-*"#$%-*,"(%*$.+?$().%)'%:'CB86%M+)2%@GG%*$#-8")+'(.%"(?%A'8-()"*+86%B-*.-$%
>-*)2$*%@GG%":)+'(.0%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
a%7"#"%&+)6%!*'>+8$%R2))B^hhMMM0("#"0#'A0B2h:+)6B*'>+8$h)'B'02)C8S4%"::$..$?%]a%I$B)$C,$*%]eab0%
]%5"(+8"%3-88$)+(4%f%T$,*-"*6%]eab%
_%F0%F8:"C$84%]ee]0%

P"#"!"#$"
"
"
$09*"3%D5&"QKF"R!9C"3*,9!%!)*"
:0,5"S9*"260,,!,1"

T"#"!"#$"
"
=,%+(5D4%!(,%
%
5"+(.)*$"C+(#%?+.".)$*%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%R@GGS%+()'%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#4%.+CB86%P('M(%".%mRisk%sensitive*
Land*Use*Planning*(RSLUPS4n%+.%)2$%:'(:$B)%"(?%B*":)+:$%'>%+()$#*")+(#%*+.P%+(>'*C")+'(%+()'%)2$%:'()$()%
'>%8"(?%-.$%B8"(.4%".%M$88%".%+(%)2$%+CB8$C$()+(#%)''8.4%.-:2%".%)2$%V'(+(#%'*?+("(:$4%,-+8?+(#%
*$#-8")+'(.%"(?%+(A$.)C$()%B*'#*"C.4%+(%'*?$*%)'%+(>8-$(:$%8"(?%-)+8+V")+'(%"(?%C"("#$C$()4%
+(>*".)*-:)-*$%?$.+#(%"(?%:'(.)*-:)+'(4%"(?%.':+"8%"(?%$:'('C+:%?$A$8'BC$()0%GI9H!%+.%"%($M%"BB*'":2%
+(%B*')$:)+(#%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%#"+(.%'>%:+)+$.4%,6%*$?-:+(#%$QB'.-*$%"(?%A-8($*",+8+)6%)'%2"V"*?.%)2*'-#2%
8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%)2")%:'(.+?$*.%?+.".)$*%*+.P0%
5'.)%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%+(%)2$%E.+"N!":+>+:%*$#+'(%2"A$%8+C+)$?%P('M8$?#$%"(?%$QB$*+$(:$%+(%+()$#*")+(#%
@GG%+()'%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%"(?%"*$%'(86%>"C+8+"*%M+)2%:'(A$()+'("8%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"((+(#%B*':$..$.0%
EA"+8",+8+)6%"(?%-.$%'>%*+.P%+(>'*C")+'(%+.%"8*$"?6%"%:2"88$(#$%)'%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%-(+).4%2$(:$%>+(?+(#%+).%
+()$#*")+'(%+()'%8"(?%-.$%"(?%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"(.%+.%#$($*"886%"%?"-()+(#%)".P0%FA$(%M+)2%)2$%$Q+.)$(:$%'>%
B-,8+.2$?%GI9H!%#-+?$8+($.%)2")%+?$()+>6%$()*6%B'+().%>'*%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG%+()'%:'(A$()+'("8%8"(?%-.$%
B8"((+(#%)2$'*6%"(?%B*":)+:$4%)2$%"?'B)+'(%'>%GI9H!%+()'%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"((+(#%2".%(')%,$$(%"%
.)*"+#2)>'*M"*?%B*':$..%>'*%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%+(%)2$%E.+"N!":+>+:4%".%2".%,$$(%)2$%$QB$*+$(:$%'>%)2$%
7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%R7&DS%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.0%
<2+.%:".$%.)-?6%M".%B*$B"*$?%)'%?':-C$()%)2$%:2"88$(#$.%"..':+")$?%M+)2%"?'B)+(#%GI9H!%".%"%($M%
?$A$8'BC$()%B8"((+(#%"BB*'":2%>'*%7&D4%)'%+?$()+>6%)2$%*'"?,8':P.4%"(?%)'%?':-C$()%)2$%B*'#*$..%"(?%
B$*>'*C"(:$%'>%)2$%:+)6%+(%+()$#*")+(#%@GG%"(?%:8+C")$%:2"(#$%"?"B)")+'(%R&&ES%+()'%-*,"(%8"(?%-.$%
B8"((+(#0%
%
<0!,9%+*0-!,1"URR"!,%(":0,5"S9*"260,,!,1"!,"/010"$!%&F"=99D*9"0,5"$H066*,1*9""
"
3$+(#%'($%'>%)2$%C'.)%?+.".)$*NB*'($%:'-()*+$.%+(%)2$%M'*8?4%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%2".%$(":)$?%)2$%&8+C")$%
&2"(#$%E:)%'>%]eek%"(?%@+.".)$*%G+.P%5"("#$C$()%E:)%'>%]eae4%M2+:2%:"88%>'*%)2$%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%'>%@GG%
+(%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"((+(#%B*':$..$.4%+(:8-?+(#%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#4%")%)2$%(")+'("8%"(?%.-,N(")+'("8%
#'A$*(C$()%8$A$8.0%/'M$A$*4%.+(:$%)2$.$%($M%*$\-+*$C$().%)'%C"P$%:'CB*$2$(.+A$%8"(?%-.$%B8"(.%
R&9H!S%"(?%*$8")$?%+CB8$C$()")+'(%+(.)*-C$().%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%M$*$%C"(?")$?4%'(86%"%8+C+)$?%(-C,$*%'>%
8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%-(+).%2"A$%,$$(%",8$%)'%:'CB8$)$%"(?%+CB8$C$()%"(%GI9H!0%<2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%
2".%B*'A+?$?%@GG%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%#-+?$8+($.%>'*%)2$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%>'88'M%+(%&9H!%?$A$8'BC$()f0%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
f%I-:2%".%)2$^%D-+?$8+($.%'(%5"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG%+(%I-,(")+'("8%@$A$8'BC$()%9"(?%H.$h!26.+:"8%
!8"((+(#%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%,6%7F@Eg%G$>$*$(:$%5"(-"8%'(%5"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG%"(?%&&E%+()'%)2$%&9H!%
,6%)2$%/'-.+(#%"(?%9"(?%H.$%G$#-8")'*6%3'"*?%R/9HG3S%"(?%7F@Eg%I-BB8$C$()"8%D-+?$8+($.%'(%
5"+(.)*$"C+(#%&8+C")$%"(?%@+.".)$*%G+.P.%+(%)2$%&'CB*$2$(.+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"(%,6%)2$%/'-.+(#%"(?%9"(?%
H.$%G$#-8")'*6%3'"*?%"(?%&&&%R]eafSg%D-+?$8+($.%'(%5"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG5h&&E%+(%9':"8%!8"((+(#%
I6.)$C%"(?%D-+?$8+($.%'(%5"+(.)*$"C+(#%@+.".)$*%G+.P.%"(?%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%+(%9':"8%@$A$8'BC$()%!8"(.%
,6%)2$%@$B"*)C$()%'>%)2$%L()$*+'*%"(?%9':"8%D'A$*(C$()0%

V"#"!"#$"
"
/'M$A$*4%A"*+'-.%+..-$.%"(?%:'(:$*(.%2"A$%B*$A$()$?%)2$%"?'B)+'(%'>%$>>$:)+A$%*+.PN,".$?%?$A$8'BC$()%
B8"((+(#4%".%+(?+:")$?%+(%)2+.%.)-?60%%
%
SI50%!,1"%H*"$:S2"%("0"R!9CW9*,9!%!)*":0,5"S9*"260,"
"
The*2002*Naga*City*CLUP*is*outdated*and*
unresponsive*to*Naga*City’s*existing*
development*requirements,*especially*in*
terms*of*reducing*risks*from*disasters.5%9"(?%
-.$%+(%7"#"%&+)6%2".%"8*$"?6%?$A+")$?%>*'C%
M2")%M".%$(A+.+'($?%+(%)2$%'*+#+("8%akjd%
<'M(%!8"(%RJ!1D+*"ES0%!*$.$()%:2"88$(#$.%
+(:8-?$%:'()+(-'-.%8"(?%-.$%:'(A$*.+'(%
>*'C%"#*+:-8)-*"8%)'%:'CC$*:+"8%"(?h'*%
*$.+?$()+"8%i%M+)2+(%)2$%:+)6%:$()$*%"(?%+).%
>*+(#$.4%*+A$*%%$".$C$()%$(:*'":2C$().4%
B''*%?*"+("#$%?-$%)'%,8':P"#$.%>*'C%
#"*,"#$%"(?%*$8")$?%."(+)")+'(%B*',8$C.%
"(?%2+#2%+(:+?$(:$%'>%>8''?+(#0%
H(?'-,)$?864%.-:2%":)+'(.%+(:*$".$%)2$%
+CB":).%'>%2"V"*?.%.-:2%".%>8''?.%"(?%$"*)2\-"P$.0%%
*
The*need*to*integrate*the*latest*requirements*from*the*Housing*and*Land*Use*Regulatory*Board*(HLURB)*
has*delayed*the*updating*of*the*CLUP.**L(%]ea_4%7&D%+(+)+")$?%)2$%-B?")+(#%'>%+).%&9H!%-.+(#%)2$%7FYHI%
"BB*'":20c%3$>'*$%)2$%-B?")+(#%M".%:'CB8$)$?4%)2$%/9HG3%*$8$".$?%+).%($M%&9H!%#-+?$,''P%"(?%
+()$#*")$?%C'?$8%V'(+(#%'*?+("(:$4%M+)2%"??+)+'("8%*$\-+*$C$().%>'*%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG%+()'%)2$%&9H!0%
7&D%2".%$Q)$(?$?%)2$%-B?")+(#%'>%)2$%&9H!%)'%:'CB86%M+)2%)2$%($M%#-+?$8+($.0*
*
NCG*has*restarted*the*updating*of*the*Naga*City*CLUP,*but*it*is*being*hampered*by*limited*internal*
knowledge*and*experience*in*DRR.*7&D%+.%\-+)$%"?$B)%")%)2$%.)"(?"*?%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%B*':$..4%".%
B*'A$(%,6%)2$%&+)6%!8"((+(#%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%J>>+:$%R&!@JS%2"A+(#%?$A$8'B$?%)2$%]ee]%&9H!%)'#$)2$*%
M+)2%')2$*%:+)6%?$B"*)C$().0%/'M$A$*4%)2$%'(#'+(#%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%'>%@GG%+()'%)2$%&9H!%2".%,$$(%.8'M%
C'A+(#4%".%)2$%)$:2(+:"8%M'*P+(#%#*'-B.%)".P$?%M+)2%)2$%-B?")+(#%2"A$%8+C+)$?%"::$..%)'%+(>'*C")+'(%'(%
:+)6N.B$:+>+:%?+.".)$*%*+.P.%"(?%"*$%-(>"C+8+"*%M+)2%"BB*'":2$.%'(%+()$#*")+(#%*+.P%B"*"C$)$*.%"::'*?+(#%
)'%)2$%($M%&9H!%D-+?$8+($.%RI$$%&9H!%B*$B"*")+'(%B*':$..%+(%J!1D+*"OS0%
%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
b%=0%!*+88$.4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%c4%]eab0%
c%<2$%7FYHI%"BB*'":24%B*'C')$?%,6%DLW%"(?%L&9FL%IFE4%>':-.$.%'(%>''?4%M")$*%"(?%$($*#6%".%)2$%C$"(.%
'>%8+(P+(#%)2$%?+>>$*$()%.$:)'*"8%B*+'*+)+$.%+(%"%8"(?%-.$%B8"(0%
T+#-*$%_0%akjd%7"#"%<'M(%!8"(0%%

X"#"!"#$"
"
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%T+#-*$%f0%<2$%7$M%a]NI)$B%&'CB*$2$(.+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%!*':$..%R/9HG34%]eafS0%
%
NCG*lacks*the*internal*capacity*to*collect*and*process*spatial*data*and*information*on*local*hazards,*
exposure*and*vulnerabilities,*that*can*be*used*to*incorporate*risk*parameters*in*the*formulation*and*
implementation*of*development*programs,*projects*and*activities*(PPAs).*E%.+#(+>+:"()%+..-$%>'*%)2$%7"#"%
&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%+.%)2$%"::$..%'>%:+)6%?$B"*)C$().%)'%-B?")$?%.B")+"8%*+.P%+(>'*C")+'(4%M2+:2%:"(%2$8B%
+(>'*C%)2$%B*$B"*")+'(%"(?%+CB8$C$()")+'(%'>%)2$%!!E.%)2")%M+88%.-BB'*)%)2$%GI9H!0%7&DZ.%F8$:)*'(+:%
@")"%!*':$..+(#%J>>+:$%RF@!JSj%'(86%2".%'($%.)">>%C$C,$*%)*"+($?%'(%D$'#*"B2+:%L(>'*C")+'(%I6.)$C.%
RDLIS4%"(?%)2$%'>>+:$%2".%(')%6$)%":\-+*$?%"::-*")$%)$**"+(%$8$A")+'(%?")"%"(?%2+#2N*$.'8-)+'(%2"V"*?%
C"B.0%<2$*$%+.%"8.'%('%+(A$()'*6%"(?%?+#+)"8%?")",".$%'>%B-,8+:%,-+8?+(#.%"(?%>":+8+)+$.4%M2+:2%:"(%,$%-.$?%
)'%C"B%$QB'.-*$.%)'%2"V"*?.0%7&D%:-**$()86%*$8+$.%'(%2"V"*?%+(>'*C")+'(%?*"M(%>*'C%$QB$*+$(:$.%.-:2%
".%>*'C%.)*'(#%>8''?%$A$().0%<2$%8+C+)$?%?':-C$()")+'(%C"P$.%)2$%+(>'*C")+'(%8$..%*$8+",8$%"(?%
'-)?")$?%>'*%+(>'*C+(#%GI9H!%"(?%*$8")$?%!!E.0d%
%
Limitations*in*the*availability*of*science%based*flood*hazard*information*has*resulted*in*NCG’s*using*
anecdotal*community*knowledge*and*empirical*experience*from*past*floods*in*identifying*flood%prone*
areas.k%/'M$A$*4%)2+.%B*':$..%+.%-(*$8+",8$%,$:"-.$%'>%)2$%8":P%'>%?':-C$()")+'(%'(%)2$%A"*+'-.%>8''?%
$A$().%R$0#04%$Q)$()%'>%">>$:)$?%"*$"4%?$B)24%.B$$?S%"(?%+("::-*")$%+(%?$>+(+(#%>8''?%'A$*8"6%V'($%
B*'A+.+'(.0%D+A$(%)2$.$%8+C+)")+'(.4%7&D%C-.)%+?$()+>6%)2$%B')$()+"8%+CB":).%)'%8"(?%-.$%"(?%?$:+?$%'(%
C+)+#")+'(%'B)+'(.%"A"+8",8$%)'%)2$%:+)6%-.+(#%M2")%:'-8?%,$%+("::-*")$%"(?%-(*$8+",8$%2"V"*?%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
j% <2$% F@!J% C"("#$.% )2$% ?")",".$% .6.)$C% '>% 7&D4% M2+:2% .)'*$.% +(>'*C")+'(% '(% ,-.+($..$.4% *$"8%
B*'B$*)64%B"6*'884%"(?%2-C"(%*$.'-*:$.4%$):0%+(%7"#"%&+)60%<2+.%?")",".$%.6.)$C4%")%)2$%C'C$()4%M2+8$%
.$*A+(#%')2$*%7&D%?$B"*)C$().4%.-:2%".%)2$%&+)6%E..$..'*Z.%J>>+:$4%"(?%&+)6%/$"8)2%J>>+:$4%M2+:2%-B?")$.%
)2$+*% ?")"% $A$*6% .+Q% C'()2.4% ?'$.% (')% .$*A$% )2$% &!@J0% T-*)2$*C'*$4% )2$*$% +.% ('% ?")"% \-"8+)6% *$A+$M%
B*':$..% B-)% +(% B8":$% 6$)% >'*% )2+.% ?")",".$% .6.)$C0% &-**$()864% )2$*$% "*$% a]% .)">>% +(% )2$% F!@J^% a%
B*'#*"CC$*4%]%?")",".$%2"(?8$*.4%"(?%k%:'CB-)$*%*$B"+*%)$:2(+:+"(.0%
d%F0%F8:"C$84%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%c4%]eab%
k%=0%!*+88$.4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%1-86%]e4%]eab%

Y"#"!"#$"
"
+(>'*C")+'(0%<2$%8":P%'>%:"B":+)6%)'%B*$B"*$%"%.:+$()+>+:%*+.P%"..$..C$()%C"P$.%+)%A$*6%:2"88$(#+(#%>'*%)2$%
&+)6%)'%:'CB8$)$%)2$%&9H!%-B?")+(#%,6%)2$%$(?%'>%]eab%".%C"(?")$?%,6%)2$%&+)6%&'-(:+80%
%
=-I6*-*,%!,1"0"R!9CW9*,9!%!)*":0,5"S9*"260,"
*
The*Zoning*Ordinance,*which*is*the*primary*implementation*tool*of*the*CLUP,*is*similarly*outdated*and*
does*not*contain*zoning*provisions*to*mitigate*nor*avoid*hazards.*<2$%W'(+(#%E?C+(+.)*")+'(%I$:)+'(ae%'>%
)2$%&!@J4%M2+:2%+.%+(%:2"*#$%'>%)2$%*$A+$M%"(?%"BB*'A"8%'>%8':")+'("8%:8$"*"(:$.4%2".%6$)%)'%:'CB86%M+)2%
]eaf%#-+?$8+($.%'(%L()$#*")$?%W'(+(#%.$)%,6%)2$%/9HG34%"(?%)'%$(.-*$%)2")%2"V"*?%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%R$Q0%
>8''?4%.$+.C+:%"(?%>+*$S%B*'A+.+'(.%"*$%>'-(?%+(%)2$%($M%7"#"%&+)6%W'(+(#%J*?+("(:$%)'%B*')$:)%$Q+.)+(#%
"(?%($M%?$A$8'BC$().%+(%7"#"%&+)60%I+C+8"*864%8"(?%-.$%:'(>8+:).%"(?%V'(+(#%A+'8")+'(.%.-:2%".%%
$(:*'":2C$().%+(%)2$%)2*$$NC$)$*%8$#"8%$".$C$()%.$)%>'*%-*,"(%"*$".%.B$:+>+$?%,6%)2$%=")$*%&'?$%'>%
)2$%!2+8+BB+($.aa%($$?%)'%,$%"??*$..$?4%"8'(#%M+)2%')2$*%+..-$.%'>%?$8+($")+(#%>8''?M"6.%R('%,-+8?%V'($.S%
"(?%>8''?%>*+(#$.%RB'..+,8$%,-+8?",8$%"*$".S%"(?%"..+#(+(#%)2$C%M+)2%:8$"*%>8''?%2"V"*?%'A$*8"6%V'($.%
B*'A+.+'(.0*
*
Lack*of*manpower*and*technical*capacity*within*city*departments*in*implementing*the*Zoning*Ordinance*
and*Building*Regulations*limit*the*responsiveness*of*relevant*departments*to*effectively*carry*out*safe*
and*risk%sensitive*development*in*Naga*City.a]%<2$%J>>+:$%'>%)2$%3-+8?+(#%J>>+:+"8%RJ3JS%+.%*$.B'(.+,8$%>'*%
+..-+(#%)2$%($:$.."*6%?$A$8'BC$()%B$*C+).%)'%$(.-*$%:'CB8+"(:$%M+)2%)2$%,-+8?+(#%:'(.)*-:)+'(%
*$\-+*$C$().a_%+(%7"#"%&+)64%>'88'M+(#%)2$%8")$.)%7")+'("8%3-+8?+(#%&'?$%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.0%F(.-*+(#%
:'CB8+"(:$%)'%)2$%3-+8?+(#%&'?$%"(?%W'(+(#%J*?+("(:$%2".%,$$(%"%:2"88$(#$%>'*%)2$%J3J%"(?%)2$%&+)6%
F(#+($$*+(#%J>>+:$%,$:"-.$%'>%)2$%8+C+)$?%(-C,$*%'>%$(#+($$*.%"(?%.B$:+"8+.)%.)">>af4%M2'%:'-8?%+CB*'A$%
)2$%B*':$..%'>%*$A+$M+(#%,-+8?+(#%:'(.)*-:)+'(%"BB8+:")+'(.%"(?%)2$%+CB8$C$()")+'(%'>%*$#-8")+'(.%
*$8")$?%)'%,-+8?+(#%:'(.)*-:)+'(%"(?%8"(?%?$A$8'BC$()%R$0#0%?':-C$()+(#%)2$%(-C,$*%'>%B*+A")$86%
'M($?%,-+8?+(#.%+(%7"#"%&+)64%:2$:P+(#%:'CB8+"(:$%M+)2%:'(.)*-:)+'(%*$#-8")+'(.S0%&-**$()864%)2$%J3J%
'(86%2".%>'-*%$(#+($$*.%'(%.)">>4%8+C+)+(#%+).%",+8+)6%)'%:"**6%'-)%+).%C"(?")$.0%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
ae%E.+?$%>*'C%)2$%&!@J%&''*?+(")'*4%)2$*$%"*$%af%.)">>hB$*.'(($8%+(%)2$%&!@J4%M2'%"*$%"..+#($?%+(%)2$%
>'88'M+(#%.$:)+'(.^%!8"((+(#4%!*'#*"CC+(#%"(?%!*'U$:)%@$A$8'BC$()%J>>+:$4%W'(+(#%E?C+(+.)*")+'(4%
G$.$"*:2%"(?%I)")+.)+:.4%"(?%E?C+(+.)*")+A$%T-(:)+'(.0%
aa%L)%2".%(')%,$$(%A$*+>+$?%2'M%7&D%+CB8$C$().%)2$%*-8+(#%'(%$".$C$().4%"(?%+>%')2$*%8$#"8%$".$C$().%*$\-+*$?%+(%
"#*+:-8)-*"8%"(?%>'*$.)%"*$".%"*$%"8.'%,$+(#%-(+>'*C86%:'CB8+$?%M+)2%+(%7"#"%&+)60%
a]%90%!"8C+"('4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%b4%]eab0%
a_%J3J%B$*C+))+(#%*$\-+*$C$().%"*$%$(-C$*")$?%+(%"%:2$:P8+.)4%M2+:2%+(:8-?$.%*$C+(?$*.%)'%"BB8+:"().%
)'%:'CB86%M+)2%)2$%,-+8?+(#%:'(.)*-:)+'(N*$8")$?%:'?$.%R,-+8?+(#4%.)*-:)-*"84%C$:2"(+:"8%$(#+($$*+(#4%
"*:2+)$:)-*"84%$8$:)*+:"84%B8-C,+(#S4%"(?%')2$*%8"M.%"(?%'*?+("(:$.%">>$:)+(#%)2$%?$.+#(%"(?%:'(.)*-:)+'(%
'>%,-+8?+(#.4%.-:2%".%$(A+*'(C$()"8%:8$"*"(:$%:$*)+>+:")+'(i>*'C%)2$%F(A+*'(C$()"8%G$.'-*:$%J>>+:$i
>'*%:'CC$*:+"8%"(?%+(?-.)*+"8%,-+8?+(#.0%E??+)+'("8%B$*C+))+(#%*$\-+*$C$().%+(%)2$%:2$:P8+.)%"*$%.'+8%
,$"*+(#%"(?%B8")$%8'"?%)$.)%*$.-8).%>'*%)2*$$N.)'*$6%"(?%>'-*N.)'*$6%,-+8?+(#.%M+)2%"))+:.4%C$VV"(+($.4%
"(?%*''>%?$:P.0%%
af%IB$:+>+:"886^%C")$*+"8.4%.)*-:)-*"84%#$')$:2(+:"8%"(?%."(+)"*6%$(#+($$*.0%%

KZ"#"!"#$"
"
<2$%C+Q%'>%,-+8?+(#%.)':P%+(%)2$%:+)6%"8.'%B'.$.%"%:2"88$(#$%)'%)2$%J3J0%=2+8$%($M86%:'(.)*-:)$?%
,-+8?+(#.%+(%7"#"%&+)6%:"(%,$%"..-C$?%)'%2"A$%.")+.>+$?%)2$%*$\-+*$C$().%'>%)2$%3-+8?+(#%&'?$4%"%
.-,.)"()+"8%(-C,$*%'>%,-+8?+(#.%'A$*%_e%6$"*.%'8?%"*$%+(%($$?%'>%.)*-:)-*"8%"(?%,-+8?+(#%"..$..C$().%)'%
B*+'*+)+V$%.)*-:)-*$.%)2")%($$?%)'%-(?$*#'%*$)*'>+))+(#%C$".-*$.%R$0#0%>8''?%*$)*'>+)4%.$+.C+:%*$)*'>+).S%)'%
$(.-*$%*$.+.)"(:$%)'%"(?%>-(:)+'("8+)6%-(?$*%.)*'(#%(")-*"8%2"V"*?.0ab%<2+.%+(:8-?$.%2$*+)"#$%.+)$.%"(?%
')2$*%.)*-:)-*$.%M2+:2%:'()*+,-)$%)'%)2$%:-8)-*"8%"(?%$:'('C+:%A"8-$%'>%)2$%:+)60%
%
Similar*to*the*situation*with*the*Zoning*and*Building*Regulations,*Naga*City*also*faces*challenges*in*the*
enforcement*of*Environmental*and*Sanitation*Regulations*in*the*city.*EC'(#%)2$%:2"88$(#$.%
$(:'-()$*$?%,6%)2$%:+)6Z.%F(A+*'(C$()%"(?%7")-*"8%G$.'-*:$.%J>>+:$%RF7GJS%+.%)2$%A+'8")+'(%'>%
$(A+*'(C$()"8%"(?%."(+)")+'(%*$#-8")+'(.%+(%7"#"%&+)60%H()*$")$?%$>>8-$().%R$0#0%.$M"#$hM".)$M")$*S%
2"A$%.+#(+>+:"()86%B'88-)$?%)2$%7"#"%G+A$*4%)-*(+(#%+)%$>>$:)+A$86%+()'%"%M".)$%:'88$:)'*0%<2$%F7GJ%2".%
:'(.+?$*$?%.$A$*"8%)$:2('8'#+$.%)'%?$"8%M+)2%)2$%8+\-+?%M".)$%#$($*")$?%+(%)2$%:+)64%.-:2%".%)2$%
:'(.)*-:)+'(%'>%"%.$B)"#$%)*$")C$()%>":+8+)6%".%B"*)%'>%)2$%+7GG!%,$+(#%+CB8$C$()$?%,6%)2$%@$B"*)C$()%
'>%!-,8+:%='*P.%"(?%/+#2M"6.%"(?%)2$%5$)*'%7"#"%=")$*%@+.)*+:)4%"(?%"%B*$A+'-.%B*'U$:)%)'%?$A$8'Bac%"%
M".)$N)'N$($*#6%B8"()0aj%I+C+8"*864%)2$%8"*#$%A'8-C$%'>%.'8+?%M".)$%B*'?-:$?%+(%)2$%:+)6%2".%*$(?$*$?%
?-CB.+)$.%)'%,$%($"*%:"B":+)6%"(?%.:2$?-8$?%>'*%:8'.-*$4%:8$"(N-B%"(?%*$2",+8+)")+'(0%%%
%
<(,!%(+!,1"0,5";)06D0%!(,"(."0"R!9CW9*,9!%!)*":0,5"S9*"260,"
%
There*is*a*lack*of*monitoring*and*evaluation*mechanisms*in*NCG’s*development*planning*system.*<2$%
:+)6Z.%&'CB*$2$(.+A$%@$A$8'BC$()%!8"(%>'*%]eaaN]e]e%"(?%)2$%]ee]%&9H!%8":P%"%>*"C$M'*P%"(?%
C$)2'?'8'#6%>'*%C'(+)'*+(#%"(?%$A"8-")+(#%)2$%+CB8$C$()")+'(%'>%?$A$8'BC$()%!!E.%.-:2%".%)2$%
L()$#*")$?%7"#"%G+A$*%G$A+)"8+V")+'(%!*'U$:)%R+7GG!S4%)2$%D+(2"M"(#%7"#-$K'h9$".)%F:'('C+:"886%
G$.+8+$()%&'CC-(+)+$.%R9FG&S%!*'#*"C4%"(?%)2$%X""()","6%."%X"-.M"#"(h!"*)($*.%+(%@$A$8'BC$()%
!*'#*"C0*=+)2'-)%"%>$$?,":P%C$:2"(+.C%'*%B*':$..%)'%)*":P%"(?%"..$..%)2$%+CB8$C$()")+'(%'>%
?$A$8'BC$()%+()$*A$()+'(.4%+)%+.%?+>>+:-8)%>'*%7&D%)'%$A"8-")$%M2$)2$*%)2$%!!E.%"*$%":2+$A+(#%)2$%
+()$(?$?%*$.-8).4%"(?%+>%)2$*$%+.%"%($$?%)'%"8)$*%'*%+CB*'A$%.B$:+>+:%".B$:).%'>%!!E%+CB8$C$()")+'(0%*
%
Similarly,*the*lack*of*monitoring*and*evaluation*mechanisms*for*DRR*and*CCA*in*Naga*City*also*makes*it*
difficult*to*assess*the*impact*on*DRR*of*national*government%supported*programs.*7&D%2".%C"?$%-.$%'>%
$Q+.)+(#%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C.%>*'C%)2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%)'%>-(?%?$A$8'BC$()%!!E.%+(%'*?$*%)'%*$?-:$%
?+.".)$*%*+.P.%"(?%,-+8?%*$.+8+$(:$%+(%7"#"%&+)60%EC'(#%)2$.$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%B*'#*"C.%)2")%B*'A+?$%
+(:$()+A$.%>'*%+(A$.)C$().%+(%@GG%"*$%)2$%9':"8%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%T-(?%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
ab%E::'*?+(#%)'%)2$%*$.$"*:2%.)-?64%mG"B+?%;+.-"8%I:*$$(+(#%'>%!-,8+:%I:2''8%3-+8?+(#.%M+)2+(%7"#"%&+)6%
RT'*%!')$()+"8%I$+.C+:%/"V"*?S4n%'>%)2$%E)$($'%@$%7"#"%H(+A$*.+)64%?")$?%5"*:2%]eaf4%)2$*$%"*$%]_d%R'-)%
'>%fdeS%,-+8?+(#.%+(%"*$".%'>%C'?$*")$%.$+.C+:+)6%)2")%2"A$%,$$(%.-,U$:)$?%)'%?$)"+8$?%+(A$.)+#")+'(.0%
ac%3$:"-.$%'>%)2$%+(",+8+)6%'>%)2$%)$:2('8'#6%B*'A+?$*.%)'%?$8+A$*%)2$%.'8+?%M".)$%)*$")C$()%$\-+BC$()4%
)2$%B8"()%M".%?*'BB$?%,6%7&D0%&'**$.B'(?+(#864%)2$%B8"(($?%:'(A$*.+'(%'>%"%>+A$N2$:)"*$%"*$"%'>%B-,8+:%
8"(?4%($"*%)2$%>'')%'>%5)0%L."*'#4%+()'%"(%+(?-.)*+"8%.+)$%>'*%)2$%B8"()%,6%7&D%M".%"8.'%2"8)$?0%%
aj%=0%!*+88$.4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%f4%]eab%

KK"#"!"#$"
"
R9@GG5TS4%!$*>'*C"(:$%&2"88$(#$%T-(?%R!&TS4%"(?%I$"8%'>%D''?%D'A$*("(:$0%/'M$A$*4%+(%)2$%",.$(:$%
'>%C'(+)'*+(#%"(?%$A"8-")+'(%+(%)2$%7&D%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"((+(#%.6.)$C4%+)%+.%(')%:8$"*86%P('M(%M2$)2$*%
)2$.$%(")+'("8%@GG%+(:$()+A$%+(A$.)C$()%B*'#*"C.%2"A$%:'()*+,-)$?%.-,.)"()+"886%)'%?+.".)$*%*$.+8+$(:$%
+(%7"#"%&+)60% %
*
[0&"J(+N0+5"
%
J(+"%H*"/010"$!%&"'()*+,-*,%"
%
=2+8$%)2$%7&D%2".%:'CB8+$?%M+)2%)2$%@GG5%E:)%"(?%)2$%7")+'("8%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%E:)+'(%!8"(%+(%)$*C.%
'>% )2$% "A"+8",+8+)6% '>% B8"(.% R$0#0% @GG5% B8"(4% &&E% B8"(S4% "(?% 2".% B*'A+?$?% >'*% )2$% '*#"(+V")+'(% "(?%
'B$*")+'(.%'>%+).%8':"8%@GG5% J>>+:$4%*+.P%C"("#$C$()%"(?% *+.P%"..$..C$()%*$C"+(%P$6% B*':$..$.%M2+:2%
($$?%)'%,$%>-*)2$*%?$A$8'B$?%"(?%+(.)+)-)+'("8+V$?%)'%>":+8+)")$%)2$%+()$#*")+'(%'>%@GG%"(?%&&E%+()'%8"(?%
-.$%B8"((+(#%"(?%')2$*%?$A$8'BC$()%B*':$..$.0%%
%
L(.)+)-)+'("8+V$%/"V"*?4%;-8($*",+8+)6%"(?%G+.P%E..$..C$()%R/;GES%)'%I-BB'*)%)2$%@$A$8'BC$()%
!8"((+(#%"(?%@$:+.+'(N5"P+(#%!*':$..$.%
"
a0!E(%-B?")$?%>8''?%*+.P% "..$..C$()% .2'-8?% ,$% C"?$%"A"+8",8$%)'%#-+?$% .)*")$#+:% "(?% B*'U$:)%
B8"((+(#4%"(?%+(>'*C%"(?%-B?")$%(')%'(86%)2$%:+)6Z.%B8"(.4%,-)%"8.'%')2$*%B8"(.%B*$B"*$?%,6%
('(N7&D%"#$(:+$.%R$0#0%M")$*%?+.)*+:)4%7"#"%G+A$*%G$A+)"8+V")+'(%!*'U$:)%:'CB'($().S0%%
]0!7&D%.2'-8?%.)"*)%:'88$:)+(#4%B*':$..+(#%"(?%+()$#*")+(#%*+.P%+(>'*C")+'(%)'% ,$%-.$?%>'*%8"(?%
-.$%B8"(%>'*C-8")+'(%"(?%>'*%?$A$8'B+(#%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%.)*")$#+$.%"(?%!!E.0% <2$% :+)6% .2'-8?%
":\-+*$% #''?% *$.'8-)+'(% 2"V"*?% C"B.4% ".% M$88% ".4% 9+@EGN,".$?% ?+#+)"8% $8$A")+'(% C'?$8.%
?$A$8'B$?% ,6% (")+'("8% #'A$*(C$()% "#$(:+$.4% "(?% A"8+?")$% "(?% B*':$..% )2$.$% >'*% -.$% +(%
-B?")+(#%)2$%:+)6Z.%8"(?%-.$%B8"(.0%
_0!&''B$*")+'(4%P('M8$?#$%.2"*+(#4%$.)",8+.2+(#%B*')':'8.%>'*%?")"%.2"*+(#%'>%?")"4%)*"+(+(#.4%
:'(.-8)")+'(.%"(?%)$:2(+:"8%"?A+:$%>*'C%A"*+'-.%#'A$*(C$()%-(+).%.-:2%".%)2$%/9HG34%
!2+8+BB+($%L(.)+)-)$%'>%;'8:"('8'#6%"(?%I$+.C'8'#6%R!/L;J9&IS4%!2+8+BB+($%E)C'.B2$*+:4%
D$'B26.+:"8%"(?%E.)*'('C+:"8%I$*A+:$.%E?C+(+.)*")+'(4%@L9D4%"(?%5+($.%"(?%D$'.:+$(:$.%
3-*$"-%"*$%:*+)+:"8%)'%)2$%7&DZ.%B*$B"*")+'(%'>%2"V"*?4%A-8($*",+8+)6%"(?%*+.P%"..$..C$().4%
"(?%+()$#*")+'(%'>%)2$%"..$..C$()%'-)B-).%+()'%)2$%8"(?%-.$%B8"(.0%
f0!<*"+(+(#%M'*P.2'B.%R$Q0%G"B+?%F"*)2\-"P$%@"C"#$%E..$..C$()%I6.)$C%C"BB+(#4%:8+C")$%
B*'U$:)+'(.S%.2'-8?%,$%:'(?-:)$?%.'%)2")%7&D%)$:2(+:"8%.)">>%:"(%,$))$*%-(?$*.)"(?%)2$%
>8''?%"(?%.$+.C+:%2"V"*?%:2"*":)$*+.)+:.%"(?%)2*$").%+(%7"#"%&+)64%)'%2$8B%)2$C%+()$*B*$)%
2"V"*?%+(>'*C")+'(%"(?%?$>+($%2"V"*?%+CB":).%"(?%)2$+*%+CB8+:")+'(.%)'%)2$%:+)6Z.%.$:)'*"8%
"(?%.B")+"8%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"(.0%
%
HB?")$%)2$%&'CB*$2$(.+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"(%"(?%W'(+(#%J*?+("(:$%,6%5"P+(#%<2$C%G+.PNI$(.+)+A$%'*%
L()$#*")+(#%@GG%+()'%)2$%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%!*':$..%

KA"#"!"#$"
"
"
a0!J(:$%)2$%>8''?%*+.P%"..$..C$()%"(?%"%.$+.C+:%*+.P%"..$..C$()%2"A$%,$$(%B*$B"*$?%R.$$%J!1D+*"
PS4%.':+'N$:'('C+:%B*'>+8$.%"(?%.$:)'*"8%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"(.%B*$B"*$?%+(%]eaa%,6%)2$%7&D%
($$?%)'%,$%*$A+$M$?h-B?")$?%+(%M+)2%)2$.$%"..$..C$().0%%
]0!9"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%.2'-8?%,$%:'(?-:)$?%>'88'M+(#%)2$%($M%/9HG3%#-+?$8+($.%"(?%M+)2%
#-+?"(:$%>*'C%)2+.%"#$(:6%"(?%*+.P%"..$..C$()%$QB$*).0%<2$%/9HG3%"(?%)2$%!*'A+(:+"8%
D'A$*(C$()%'>%&"C"*+($.%I-*%:"(%B8"6%+CB'*)"()%*'8$.%+(%B*'A+?+(#%)*"+(+(#.%"(?%M'*P.2'B.%
'(%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG%%%+(%)2$%8"(?%-.$%
B8"((+(#%B*':$..0%%
_0!L(%>'88'M+(#%/9HG3Z.%($M%a]N.)$B%8"(?%-.$%
B8"((+(#%B*':$..4%:"*$>-8%)2'-#2)%.2'-8?%
,$%#+A$(%)'%)2$%+(:8-.+'(%'>%)2$%*+.P%
"..$..C$()%*$.-8).%+()'%)2$%.+)-")+'("8%
"("86.+.%.)$B.%+(%'*?$*%)'%"BB*'B*+")$86%
.)*")$#+V$%8"(?%-.$%C"("#$C$()0%
='*P.2'B%.$..+'(.%'(%2'M%)'%:'(.+?$*%
2"V"*?%+CB":).%"(?%)2$+*%+CB8+:")+'(.%)'%
.)*")$#+:%B8"((+(#%.2'-8?%,$%:'(?-:)$?%
M+)2%*+.P%"..$..C$()%$QB$*).0%
f0!<2$%B"*)+:+B")+'(%'>%)2$%@L9D%"(?%/9HG3%+(%
C"+(.)*$"C+(#%B*'U$:).%.2'-8?%,$%.)*'(#86%
$(:'-*"#$?4%"(?%)2$%7&D%.2'-8?%$(#"#$%
)2$.$%'*#"(+V")+'(.%+(%>-)-*$%B*'U$:).%)'%
$(.-*$%2"*C'(+V")+'(%'>%)2$%B*':$..$.%'(%
B*'>+8$%B*$B"*")+'(4%.$:)'*"8%"(?%.B")+"8%
?$A$8'BC$()%B8"(%B*$B"*")+'(%"(?%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%'>%@GGh&&E%B*'#*"C.4%B*'U$:).%"(?%
":)+A+)+$.0%%
b0!HB?")$?%8"(?%-.$%"(?%V'(+(#%#-+?$8+($.%B*$B"*$?%,6%)2$%/9HG3%)2")%)"P$%2"V"*?.4%$QB'.-*$4%
A-8($*",+8+)+$.4%"(?%*+.P%+()'%:'(.+?$*")+'(%"*$%"A"+8",8$0%<*"+(+(#.%"(?%.2"*+(#%'>%')2$*%:+)+$.Z%
$QB$*+$(:$.%+(%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%:"(%*$+(>'*:$%)2$%7&DZ.%P('M8$?#$%"(?%-(?$*.)"(?+(#%'>%2'M%
)'%?$A$8'B%.)*")$#+$.4%B'8+:+$.4%"(?%!!E.%)2")%.-BB'*)%@GG0%%
c0!7&D%.2'-8?%B-*.-$%>-*)2$*%$(#"#$C$()%M+)2%8':"8%:2"B)$*.%'>%B*'>$..+'("8%'*#"(+V")+'(.%
.-:2%".%)2$%E..':+")+'(%'>%I)*-:)-*"8%F(#+($$*.%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%REIF!S%"(?%)2$%!2+8+BB+($%
L(.)+)-)$%'>%&+A+8%F(#+($$*.%R!L&FS4%"(?%":"?$C+:%+(.)+)-)+'(.%8+P$%)2$%H(+A$*.+)6%'>%7-$A"%
&":$*$.%"(?%E)$($'%?$%7"#"%)'%+CB*'A$%)2$%:'88$:)+'(%"(?%-.$%'>%2"V"*?%"(?%$QB'.-*$%
+(>'*C")+'(0%
j0!E%>'*C"8%*$A+$M%'>%V'(+(#%A+'8")+'(.%"(?%$Q+.)+(#%*$.'8-)+'(.%+(%7"#"%&+)6%.2'-8?%,$%
:'(?-:)$?4%M2+:2%.2'-8?%+(:8-?$%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%'>%"%B8"(%>'*%:'CC-(+:")+(#%)2$%*")+'("8$%
T+#-*$%b0%9+\-$>":)+'(%!')$()+"8%5"B%"(?%T8''?%
/"V"*?%I-.:$B)+,+8+)6%5"B%'>%7"#"%&+)6%[-"?*"(#8$0%
RI'-*:$^%?'.)0#'A0B2S

KE"#"!"#$"
"
>'*%2"V"*?%V'(+(#4%+(%'*?$*%)'%,-+8?%:'(.$(.-.%>'*%>+(?+(#%"::$B)",8$%C+)+#")+'(%'B)+'(.%"(?%
+(:$()+A$.0%<2$%8"(?%-.$%B8"(%"(?%V'(+(#%'*?+("(:$%2"A$%)'%,$%-B?")$?%M+)2%)2+.%+(%C+(?0%
%
@$A$8'B%"%5'(+)'*+(#%"(?%FA"8-")+'(%T*"C$M'*P%)'%!*'A+?$%"%T$$?,":P%!*':$..%>'*%G+.PN3".$?%
9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%"(?%LCB8$C$()")+'(%
"
a0!<2$%&+)6%!8"((+(#%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%J>>+:$%'>% 7"#"%($$?.% "??+)+'("8%B$*.'(($8%"(?%)"*#$)$?%
)$:2(+:"8% :"B":+)6% ,-+8?+(#% )'% C"("#$% )2$% C"+(.)*$"C+(#% B*':$..% +(% 8"(?% -.$% B8"(%
>'*C-8")+'(%"(?%+CB8$C$()")+'(4%"(?%)'%C'(+)'*%"(?%$A"8-")$%)2$%*$.-8).%'>%)2$%B*':$..0%
]0!7&D%2".%.$A$*"8%!!E.4%.-:2%".%)2$%D+(2"M"(#%7"#-$K'%B*'#*"C4%)2")%"??*$..%.':+"8%
A-8($*",+8+)6%*$?-:)+'(0%<2$.$%($$?%)'%,$%*$A+$M$?4%C'(+)'*$?%"(?%$A"8-")$?%)'%?$)$*C+($%
)2$+*%+CB":)%'(%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(0%
_0!I+C+8"*864%)2$%:"B":+)6%,-+8?+(#%:'CB'($()R%$0#0%?+.".)$*%*+.P%"..$..C$()%"(?%C"("#$C$()4%
>8''?%?")",".$%.6.)$C4%.':+"8%B*$B"*")+'(4%M".)$%C"("#$C$()4%.B")+"8%B8"((+(#S%'>%)2$%+7GG!%
2".%)'%,$%B-*.-$?%)'%C"("#$%)2$%?+>>$*$()%.'8-)+'(.%B*'B'.$?%+(%)2$%"*$".%'>%$(A+*'(C$()"8%
C"("#$C$()4%>8''?%"88$A+")+'(%"(?%?*"+("#$4%"(?%*+A$*.+?$%*$A+)"8+V")+'(4%"C'(#%')2$*.0%
%
J(+"%H*"\9!0,"U*)*6(I-*,%"B0,C""
%
a0!<2$% .)-?6% 8''P$?% +()'% )2$% B')$()+"8% '>% 7"#"% &+)6% )'% C"+(.)*$"C% @GG% +()'% +).% #'A$*("(:$%
>-(:)+'(.%"(?%B*':$..$.0% % <2$%.)-?6%>'-(?%)2")% )2$% :+)6% 2".%)2$%"M"*$($..%"(?% *$"?+($..%)'%
B-*.-$% *+.PN.$(.+)+A$% ?$A$8'BC$()4% "(?% ".B+*$.% )'% 2"A$% )2$+*% -B?")$?% 8"(?% -.$% B8"(.% "(?%
V'(+(#% '*?+("(:$% "BB*'A$?4% "(?% 2$8?% -B% ".% $Q"CB8$.% '>% *+.PN.$(.+)+A$% ?$A$8'BC$()0%%
/'M$A$*4%.-:2%".B+*")+'(.%"*$%2+(?$*$?%,6%.$A$*"8%+CB$?+C$().%".%+(?+:")$?%B*$A+'-.860%%
]0!<2$% :*+)$*+"% "(?% B*':$..% -.$?% >'*% "..$..+(#% )2$% *+.PN.$(.+)+A+)6%'>% B8"(.4% B*' #*"C.4% B*'U$:).%
"(?%":)+A+)+$.% +(% )2+.% .)-?6% :"(%,$% :2"88$(#$?4%.+(:$% +)% +.%?+>>+:-8)% )'% #")2$*% $A+?$(:$% '(% )2$%
B$*>'*C"(:$% '>% !!E.% +?$()+>+$?% +(% $Q+.)+(#% 7&D% B8"(.%)2")% +CB8$C$()% @GG4% ".% )2$*$% +.% ('%
C'(+)'*+(#% "(?% $A"8-")+'(% >*"C$M'*P% )'% #-+?$% .-:2% "% *$A+$M0% <2+.% +.% "% .6.)$C+:% B*',8$C%
M+)2+(%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().0%%5'(+)'*+(#%"(?%$A"8-")+'(%:*+)$*+"%)2")%$.)",8+.2%,$(:2C"*P.%"(?%
$(",8$%',U$:)+A$%$A"8-")+'(.%.2'-8?%,$%?$A$8'B$?%"(?%)$.)$?0%
_0!J($%.+(#8$%:".$%.)-?6% :"((')% *$>8$:)% )2$% .)")$N'>N)2$NB*":)+:$%'>% GI9H!%"C'(#% 9DH.%+(% )2$%
!2+8+BB+($.4%('*%:"(%+)% *$>8$:)% "88% )2$%*$8$A"()%+..-$.0%% L)% +.% .-##$.)$?%)2")%C'*$% :".$% .)-?+$.%
.2'-8?% ,$% 8''P$?% +()'% )'% *$A+$M% )2$% $QB$*+$(:$% "(?% B$*>'*C"(:$% '>% !2+8+BB+($% :+)+$.% )2")%
2"A$%:'CB8$)$?%'*%"*$%$(#"#$?%+(%-(?$*)"P+(#%)2$+*%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%8"(?%-.$%B8"(.0%I-:2%8':"8%
#'A$*(C$().%+(:8-?$%I-*+#"'%&+)64%&"#"6"(%@$%J*'%&+)64%L8'+8'%&+)64%%"(?%)2$%C-(+:+B"8+)+$.%'>%
3":-"#4%I-*+#"'%@$8%7'*)$%"(?%%JB'84%5+."C+.%J*+$()"84%)'%("C$%"%>$M0%
f0!=2")%+.%$A+?$()%2'M$A$*%+.% )2")%:+)+$.%M2+:2% M$*$% ",8$%)'% :'CB8$)$%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$% 8"(?% -.$%
B8"(.% *$:$+A$?% C"U'*% .-BB'*)% >*'C% ?$A$8'BC$()% B"*)($*.% "(?h'*% #'A$*(C$()% +(.)+)-)+'(.4%

KO"#"!"#$"
"
*$>8$:)+(#%)2$%.6.)$C+:% ?+>>+:-8)+$.% 8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%"*$%$QB$*+$(:+(#%+(%C"P+(#%B*'#*$..%+(%
)2+.% B"*)+:-8"*% .$:)'*0%%=+)2'-)% $Q)$*("8% .-BB'*)4% +)% "BB$"*.% )'% ,$% ?+>>+:-8)% >'*% 9DH.% )'%
:'CB8$)$%"%:'CB$)$()%GI9H!0%%
b0!FA$(%)2'-#2%)2$*$%"*$%"%>$M%8':"8%:".$.%"A"+8",8$%'(%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%?$A$8'BC$()4%)2$%:*+)$*+"4%
+(?+:")'*.% "(?% C$".-*$.% '(% M2")% C"P$.% "% 8"(?% -.$% B8"(% *+.PN.$(.+)+A$% .)+88% ($$?% )'% ,$%
$.)",8+.2$?% )'% B*'A+?$% #-+?"(:$4% "(?% "88'M% >'*% :'CB"*+.'(.% "(?% .2"*+(#% '>% $QB$*+$(:$.%
"C'(#%:+)+$.%"(?%C-(+:+B"8+)+$.0%
% %

KP"#"!"#$"
"
%
%
%
%
%
"
"
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
$09*"3%D5&"QAF"=,4*,%!)*9".(+"
URR"
% %

KT"#"!"#$"
"
"=,%+(5D4%!(,"
%
L(:$()+A$.%>'*%?+.".)$*%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%R@GGS%"*$%B'8+:6%C$:2"(+.C.%)2")%$(:'-*"#$%+(?+A+?-"8.4%
,-.+($..$.4%'*%#'A$*(C$().%)'%)"P$%":)+'(.%)2")%*$?-:$%?+.".)$*%*+.P.0ad%H(8+P$%*$#-8")+'(.4%M2+:2%+CB'.$%
."(:)+'(.%>'*%('(N:'CB8+"(:$4%+(:$()+A$.%*$M"*?%"?'B)+'(%"(?%+CB8$C$()")+'(%'>%*+.PN*$?-:+(#%":)+'(.ak%
)'%:*$")$%M+(NM+(%.+)-")+'(.0]e%%<2+.%*$B'*)%+.%'($%'>%"%.$*+$.%'>%:".$%.)-?+$.%'(%)2$%-.$%'>%+(:$()+A$.%>'*%
@GG%,6%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().0%%
%
L(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%".%+(%C"(6%?$A$8'B+(#%(")+'(.4%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%"*$%-(>"C+8+"*%M+)2%)2$%-.$%'>%
+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C.%>'*%@GG0%G$.$"*:2%+(?+:")$.%)2")%)'%?")$4%+(:$()+A$.%>'*%@GG%2".%B*+C"*+86%>':-.$?%
'(%?$A$8'B$?%(")+'(.g%>-*)2$*C'*$4%)2$*$%+.%"%8":P%'>%B*":)+:"8%"BB8+$?%:".$%.)-?+$.%)'%+(>'*C%8':"8%
#'A$*(C$().%'(%)2$%)'B+:0%FQ"CB8$.%>'*%)2$%7"#"%&+)6%:".$%.)-?6%"*$%*$B*'?-:$?%+(%)2$%>'88'M+(#%
.$:)+'(.0%%
%
/0%!(,06"URR"=,4*,%!)*9"!,"%H*"2H!6!II!,*9"
%
E.%'($%'>%)2$%:'-()*+$.%+(%)2$%M'*8?%C'.)%A-8($*",8$%)'%(")-*"8%2"V"*?.%"(?%:8+C")$%:2"(#$4%)2$%
!2+8+BB+($%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%2".%)"P$(%.$A$*"8%.)$B.%)'%B*'C')$%:8+C")$%:2"(#$%"?"B)")+'(%R&&ES%
"(?%@GG%B'8+:+$.%")%)2$%8':"8%8$A$80%%<2$%!2+8+BB+($%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%E:)%'>%]eek%"(?%!2+8+BB+($%@+.".)$*%
G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%R@GG5S%E:)%'>%]eae%,')2%$.)",8+.2%C$:2"(+.C.%)'%?$?+:")$%>-(?+(#%>'*%
@GG0%%<2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%"8.'%+(:$()+A+V$.%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%,$%C'*$%)*"(.B"*$()%"(?%>':-.$?%
'(%@GG%)2*'-#2%.$A$*"8%#''?%#'A$*("(:$%+(+)+")+A$.4%M2+8$%+(.-*"(:$%"(?%C+:*'N+(.-*"(:$%+(+)+")+A$.%
.B*$"?%*+.P%"(?%:"(4%)2*'-#2%*+.PN,".$?%B*$C+-C.4%+(:$()+A+V$%@GG%,$2"A+'*0%%
%
J!,0,4!06"?+0,9.*+9"0,5"<0,50%*9""
%
J($%'>%)2$%C"U'*%:2"88$(#$.%B*$A$()+(#%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%>*'C%+(A$.)+(#%+(%@GG%+.%"%8":P%'>%>-(?.0%9":P%
'>%>-(?+(#%:"(%"*+.$%,$:"-.$%)2$%:+)6%2".%+(.->>+:+$()%*$A$(-$g%,-)%+)%:"(%"8.'%'::-*%+(%:+)+$.%M+)2%
.-,.)"()+"8%*$A$(-$%,$:"-.$%)2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%?'$.%(')%B*+'*+)+V$%@GG0%%L(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%)2$%@GG5%
E:)%]eae%*$\-+*$.%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%?$?+:")$%"%:$*)"+(%"C'-()%'>%)2$+*%8':"8%*$A$(-$%)'%@GG0%<2$%
(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%"8.'%B*'A+?$.%"??+)+'("8%>-(?+(#%>'*%&&E%"(?%@GG0%%
%
?H*":(406"U!909%*+"R!9C"R*5D4%!(,"0,5"<0,01*-*,%"JD,5"]:URR<J^""
%
<2$%@GG5%E:)%]eae%*$\-+*$.%:+)+$.%)'%-.$%)2$+*%$Q+.)+(#%>-(?.%>'*%@GG%B-*B'.$.0%IB$:+>+:"8864%+)%*$\-+*$.%
8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%.$)%".+?$%>+A$%B$*:$()%RboS%'>%)2$+*%$.)+C")$?%*$A$(-$%+(%"%?$?+:")$?%9@GG5T0%
9':"8%#'A$*(C$().%:"(%:'()*+,-)$%C'*$4%+>%)2$6%:2''.$0%HB%)'%jeo%'>%)2$%9@GG5T%:"(%,$%-.$?%)'%
>+("(:$%@GG4%M2+8$%_eo%#'$.%)'%"%[-+:P%G$.B'(.$%T-(?%R[GTS%?$.+#($?%)'%>+("(:$%?+.".)$*%*$8+$>0%9':"8%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
ad%EF&J54%]eaf%
ak%D$4%!$":':P4%p%9+(?$884%]eaa%
]e%T-U+C+%p%<")"('4%]ea_%

KV"#"!"#$"
"
#'A$*(C$().%2"A$%?+.:*$)+'(%'(%2'M%)'%.B$(?%)2$%>-(?+(#4%".%8'(#%".%)2$6%>'88'M%)2$.$%"88':")+'(%
\-')".%"(?%2"A$%"%@GG5%B8"(%)2")%+(?+:")$.%B*'#*"C.4%B*'U$:).%"(?%":)+A+)+$.0%%
%
<2$%9@GG5T%+.%(')%"%)*"?+)+'("8%+(:$()+A$4%".%+)%*$\-+*$.%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%+(A$.)%+(%@GG4%*")2$*%)2"(%
C$*$86%$(:'-*"#+(#%)2$C0%/'M$A$*4%)2$%>-(?%"8.'%B*'A+?$.%:+)+$.%M+)2%>8$Q+,+8+)6%)'%+(A$.)%+(%:"B+)"8%
B*'U$:).%"(?%$(:'-*"#$.%'M($*.2+B%'>%@GG%,6%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().0%%H.$%'>%)2$%9@GG5T%+.%'A$*.$$(%,6%"%
9':"8%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%&'-(:+8%R9@GG5&S0%%
%
<2$%7"#"%&+)6%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%T-(?%2".%"%]eab%,-?#$)%'>%HI@%kcj4eee0ee0]a%L)%
+.%,$+(#%-.$?%>'*%.)*-:)-*"8%"(?%('(N.)*-:)-*"8%+(A$.)C$().4%.-:2%".%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%"(?%$Q)$(.+'(%'>%
)2$%.)'*C%?*"+("#$%.6.)$C%+(%C-8)+B8$%,"*"(#"6.]]4%$C$*#$(:6%C"("#$C$()%)*"+(+(#.4%"(?%)2$%B-*:2".$%
'>%$C$*#$(:6%'B$*")+'(.%$\-+BC$()%R*-,,$*%,'").4%*$.:-$%)*-:P.4%:2"+(."M.4%L<%$\-+BC$()S0%I'C$%'>%
)2$%>-(?.%2"A$%"8.'%,$$(%"88':")$?%)'%,-6%:"8"C+)6%+(.-*"(:$%B*$C+-C.%>'*%B-,8+:%,-+8?+(#.%"(?%
+(>*".)*-:)-*$0]_%
"
?H*"U!909%*+"<0,01*-*,%"\99!9%0,4*"JD,5"]U<\J^"
%
<2$%@+.".)$*%5"("#$C$()%E..+.)"(:$%T-(?%R@5ETS%$.)",8+.2$?%,6%)2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()4%B*'A+?$.%
:'(:$..+'("8%8'"(.%)'%.-BB'*)%)2$%@GG%',U$:)+A$.%'>%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%")%+()$*$.)%*")$.%)2")%"*$%8'M$*%
)2"(%)2'.$%+(%)2$%C"*P$)0%<2$%>-(?%B*'A+?$.%:'(:$..+'("8%8'"(.%M+)2%e%)'%a0bo%+()$*$.)%*")$%)'%B*'A+(:$.4%
:+)+$.%"(?%C-(+:+B"8+)+$.%>'*%m.'>)n%+(A$.)C$().%+(%?+.".)$*%B*$B"*$?($..%.-:2%".%:"B":+)6%,-+8?+(#%
":)+A+)+$.%"(?%2"V"*?%"(?%A-8($*",+8+)6%"..$..C$().4%".%M$88%".%>-(?+(#%>'*%+(>*".)*-:)-*$%B*'U$:).%
+()$(?$?%>'*%?+.".)$*%C+)+#")+'(0%<2$%*$\-+*$C$().%>'*%*$B"6C$()%.B$:+>6%)2")%8'"(.%C-.)%,$%*$B"+?%
M+)2+(%)2$%)$*C%'>%)2$%8':"8%:2+$>%$Q$:-)+A$4%)2-.%B*'A+?+(#%"??+)+'("8%C')+A")+'(%>'*%8':"8%'>>+:+"8.%)'%
:'CB8$)$%)2$%>-(?$?%B*'U$:).%'(%)+C$0%7"#"%&+)6%2".%(')%"A"+8$?%'>%)2+.%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C0%
%
FA$(%M+)2%)2$.$%>-(?+(#%"88':")+'(%*$\-+*$C$().%"(?%"??+)+'("8%>-(?+(#%.'-*:$.4%)2$%*$.'-*:$.%"A"+8",8$%
>'*%@GG%+(%8':"8%"*$".%8+P$%7"#"%&+)6%C"6%,$%+(.->>+:+$()0%%L(%"??+)+'(4%>-(?+(#%+.%($:$.."*6%(')%'(86%)'%
>-(?%":)-"8%@GG%B*'U$:).%,-)%"8.'%)'%,-+8?%)$:2(+:"8%:"B":+)6%"(?%":\-+*$%2"V"*?%"(?%$QB'.-*$%?")"0%
FQB$*+$(:$%>*'C%')2$*%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%+(?+:")$%)2")%.+#(+>+:"()%"C'-().%'>%>-(?+(#%"(?%)$:2(+:"8%
"..+.)"(:$%"*$%($$?$?%)'%'A$*:'C$%,"**+$*.%.-:2%".%?$A$8'B+(#%2+#2%*$.'8-)+'(%2"V"*?%"(?%*+.P%C"B.4%
":\-+*+(#%:'CB8$)$%$QB'.-*$%?")",".$.4%"(?%.$))+(#%-B%C'?$*(%)$:2('8'#+$.%.-:2%".%DLI0%%
% %
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
]a%7"#"%&+)64%]eab%
]]%<2$%,"*"(#"6%+.%)2$%.C"88$.)%B'8+)+:"8%-(+)%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%")%)2$%:'CC-(+)6%'*%A+88"#$%8$A$8g%
"8)2'-#2%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%"%:'CC-(+)6%:"(%,$%:'CB'.$?%'>%.$A$*"8%)2'-."(?%'*%$A$(%)$(.%'>%
)2'-."(?.%'>%B$'B8$0%E%:+)6%'*%C-(+:+B"8+)6%+.%)6B+:"886%.-,?+A+?$?%+()'%.$A$*"8%,"*"(#"6.0%<2$%,"*"(#"6%
+.%2$"?$?%"?C+(+.)*")+A$86%,6%"%:2"+*B$*.'(%'*%:"B)"+(4%M2'%+.%$8$:)$?%>*'C%M+)2+(%)2$%:'CC-(+)64%"(?%
.$*A$.%M+)2%)2$%.-BB'*)%'>%"%,"*"(#"6%:'-(:+84%M2'.$%C$C,$*.%"*$%"8.'%$8$:)$?%,6%)2$%*$.+?$().%>*'C%
)2$+*%'M(%*"(P.0%
]_%7"#"%&+)64%]eaf%

KX"#"!"#$"
"
L(%7"#"%&+)64%>-(?+(#%@GG%+(:$()+A$.%+.%B"*)+:-8"*86%:'()*'A$*.+"8%,$:"-.$%)2$%&+)6%<*$".-*$*Z.%J>>+:$%>$"*.%
)2")%@GG%C$:2"(+.C.%)2")%-.$%)"Q%*$?-:)+'(.%".%"(%+(:$()+A$%C+#2)%C$"(%"%?$:*$".$%+(%)')"8%*$A$(-$%
:'88$:)+'(%"(?%",+8+)6%)'%.-BB'*)%')2$*%B*'#*"C.0]f%<2$*$%+.%"8.'%)2$%B$*:$B)+'(%)2")%7"#"%.2'-8?%>+*.)%
8''P%")%B*'A+?+(#%+(:$()+A$.%+(%)2$%>'*C%'>%)*"+(+(#%"(?%:"B":+)6%,-+8?+(#4%M2+:2%"*$%.)+88%8":P+(#0]b%<2+.%
C"6%B'+()%)'%"(')2$*%:2"88$(#$4%M2+:2%+.%"(%+(.->>+:+$()%-(?$*.)"(?+(#%'>%>+.:"8%*+.P.%B'.$?%,6%?+.".)$*.%
)'%)2$%:+)60%E::'*?+(#864%)2$%&+)6%<*$".-*$*Z.%J>>+:$%C"6%,$%'A$*8''P+(#%)2$%"?A$*.$%>+.:"8%:'(.$\-$(:$.%
'>%"%?+.".)$*%$A$()4%".%M$88%".%)2$%8'(#N)$*C%."A+(#.%8$A$*"#$?%,6%?+.".)$*%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%+(%)2+.%:".$%
RM+)2%B*$?+:)",86%8'M$*%2-C"(%"(?%B26.+:"8%8'..$.S0%
%
?H*"2*(I6*_9"3D+)!)06"JD,5"]23J^"
%
<2$%!$'B8$Z.%I-*A+A"8%T-(?%M".%+()*'?-:$?%+(%]ea]%".%"(%"C$(?C$()%)'%)2$%!2+8+BB+($%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%
E:)4%)2*'-#2%G$B-,8+:%E:)%7'0%aeajf0%%L)%+.%?$.+#($?%)'%B*'A+?$%.-BB8$C$()"*6%>-(?+(#%>'*%8':"8%
"?"B)")+'(%B*'U$:).%)2")%.-BB'*)%)2$%7")+'("8%I)*")$#+:%T*"C$M'*P%>'*%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%"(?%)2$%7")+'("8%
&8+C")$%&2"(#$%E:)+'(%!8"(0%<2$%>':-.%M+88%,$%'(%B*'U$:).%"??*$..+(#%,')2%$(A+*'(C$()"8%"(?%
?$A$8'BC$()%:2"88$(#$.4%".%M$88%".%*+.P.%"..':+")$?%M+)2%:8+C")$N+(?-:$?%?+.".)$*.0%%/'M$A$*4%>+("8%
#-+?$8+($.%>'*%)2$%!IT%2"A$%6$)%)'%,$%+..-$?4%.'%)2$%!IT%+.%(')%:-**$()86%":)+A$0%%
%
\5-!,!9%+0%!)*"=,4*,%!)*9"
%
D'A$*("(:$%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%+.%"%:'()+(-+(#%:2"88$(#$4%"(?%)2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%2".%:*$")$?%
.$A$*"8%B*'#*"C.%)'%$(:'-*"#$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%+CB*'A$%)*"(.B"*$(:64%*$?-:$%:'**-B)+'(4%"(?%
+(A$.)%+(%8'(#N)$*C%B8"((+(#0%<2$.$%#''?%#'A$*("(:$%B*'#*"C.4%M2$(%)+$?%)'%@GG4%:"(%"8.'%,$%-.$?%".%
+(:$()+A$.%>'*%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()0%%
%
'+099+((%9"20+%!4!I0%(+&"BD51*%!,1"2+(4*99"
%
<2$%D*"..*'').%!*':$..%+.%+CB8$C$()$?%")%"%(")+'("8%.:"8$%-(?$*%)2$%:'CC'(%'A$*.+#2)%'>%)2$%
@$B"*)C$()%'>%3-?#$)%"(?%5"("#$C$()%R@35S4%@$B"*)C$()%'>%)2$%L()$*+'*%"(?%9':"8%D'A$*(C$()%
R@L9DS4%@$B"*)C$()%'>%I':+"8%=$8>"*$%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%R@I=@S4%"(?%)2$%7")+'("8%E()+N!'A$*)6%
&'CC+..+'(%R7E!&S0%%L).%',U$:)+A$%+.%)'%2$8B%"))"+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($%@$A$8'BC$()%!8"(Z.%#'"8%'>%+(:8-.+A$%
#*'M)2%"(?%B'A$*)6%*$?-:)+'(%)2*'-#2%$(2"(:$?%8':"8%B"*)+:+B")+'(%"(?%#''?%#'A$*("(:$%B*':$..$.0%%E88%
B*'U$:).%.-,C+))$?%)'%)2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%>'*%>-(?+(#%C-.)%:'()*+,-)$%)'%)2$%:8+C")$%:2"(#$%
"?"B)")+'(%hC+)+#")+'(%"(?%?+.".)$*%B*$B"*$?($..%#'"8.%'>%)2$%#'A$*(C$()4%"8'(#.+?$%*$#-8"*%B'A$*)6%
*$?-:)+'(%',U$:)+A$.0%/$(:$4%)2$%B*'#*"C%:'-8?%.$*A$%".%"%A$(-$%>'*%:+A+8%.':+$)6%)'%B"*)+:+B")$%+(%
.$8$:)+(#%B*'U$:).%"(?%>'*C-8")+(#%B*'B'."8.%)2")%*$?-:$%?+.".)$*%*+.P.4%"(?%>"A'*.%'M($*.2+B%'>%8':"8%
.)"P$2'8?$*.%+(%B*'NB''*%@GGN*$8")$?%":)+A+)+$.0%<2+.%+(%)-*(4%+(:*$".$.%)2$%"M"*$($..%"(?%P('M8$?#$%'>%
.)"P$2'8?$*.%+(%?+.".)$*%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(4%"(?%:'()*+,-)$.%)'%>'*#+(#%"%m:-8)-*$%'>%*$.+8+$(:$n%M+)2+(%:+A+8%
.':+$)64%M2+8$%B*'C')+(#%B*'U$:).%)2")%M+88%*$?-:$%?+.".)$*%*+.P.%'(%)2$%#*'-(?0%L(%7"#"%&+)64%)2$%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
]f%D0%E,'("84%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%c4%]eab%
]b%D0%E,'("84%5"*:2%c4%]eab%

KY"#"!"#$"
"
#*"..*'').%B"*)+:+B")'*6%,-?#$)+(#%B*':$..%2".%,$$(%-.$?%>'*%#*$$(+(#%"(?%>8''?%C+)+#")+'(%C$".-*$.%
"8'(#%)2$%*+A$*,"(P.0%
"
'0N05"`\:\3\'"\N0+5"
%
<2$%D"M"?%XE9EIED]c%+.%+CB8$C$()$?%(")+'("886%,6%)2$%7")+'("8%@GG5%&'-(:+8%"(?%)2$%J>>+:$%'>%&+A+8%
@$>$(.$0%<2$%B*'#*"C%M".%'*+#+("886%+()$(?$?%)'%*$:'#(+V$%'-).)"(?+(#%B$*>'*C"(:$%'>%'*#"(+V")+'(.%+(%
B*'A+?+(#%2-C"(+)"*+"(%"..+.)"(:$%?-*+(#%?+.".)$*.0%/'M$A$*4%.+(:$%]eed%+)%2".%"8.'%>':-.$?%'(%8':"8N
8$A$8%@GG0%<2$%C"+(%+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C%+.%)2$%*$:'#(+)+'(%B*'A+?$?%,6%)2$%"M"*?4%M2+:2%+.%,')2%
>+("(:+"8%"(?%.6C,'8+:4%,6%2+#28+#2)+(#%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%M2'%:"(%.$*A$%".%C'?$8.%>'*%#''?%#'A$*("(:$%
+(%@GG0%<2+.%*$:'#(+)+'(%+.%(')%8+C+)$?%)'%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%.-:2%".%+(%)2$%:".$%'>%)2$%B*'A+(:$%'>%E8,"64%
M2+:2%M".%:'(.+.)$()86%"M"*?$?%)2$%D"M"?%X"8"."#%>'*%,$.)%!*'A+(:+"8%@GG5%&'-(:+8%,$)M$$(%]eek%"(?%
]eaa4%"(?%M".%.-,.$\-$()86%:2'.$(%".%"%H7%D8',"8%5'?$8%+(%@GG%"(?%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%E?"B)")+'(0]j%
%
7"#"%&+)6%M'(%)2$%D"M"?%XE9EIED%"M"*?%+(%]eef%"(?%M".%"M"*?$?%"%HI@a4eee0ee%#*"()0%%=2+8$%)2$%
8':"8%.)"P$2'8?$*.%A"8-$%)2$%+CB'*)"(:$%'>%D"M"?%XE9EIED%+(%)$*C.%'>%*$:'#(+V+(#%"(?%*$M"*?+(#%)2$%
$>>'*).%'>%)2$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().4%)2$%.C"88%"C'-()%'>%)2$%#*"()%"M"*?$?%?'$.%(')%*$"886%B*'A+?$%?+*$:)%
.-BB'*)%>'*%*$?-:+(#%?+.".)$*%*+.P.0%%
%
3*06"(."'((5":(406"'()*+,0,4*""
%
<2$%@L9DZ.%I$"8%'>%D''?%D'A$*("(:$%R>'*C$*86%)2$%I$"8%'>%D''?%
/'-.$P$$B+(#S% M".% "?'B)$?% +(% ]eaf% ".% "% C$".-*$% )'% *$M"*?%
8':"8% $>>'*).% +(% #''?% #'A$*("(:$0% % L)% +(:'*B'*")$.% ?+.".)$*%
B*$B"*$?($..% ".% '($% '>% )2$% .+Q% :'*$% :*+)$*+"% )'% "..$..% )2$%
B$*>'*C"(:$% '>% 8':"8% #'A$*(C$()% -(+).4% "8'(#.+?$% #''?%
>+("(:+"8% C"("#$C$()4%$:'('C+:% :'CB$)+)+A$($..4% .':+"8%
B*')$:)+'(4%$(A+*'(C$()"8%C"("#$C$()4%"(?%B$":$%p%'*?$*0%
%
36% +(:'*B'*")+(#% @GG% ".% "(% $8$C$()% '>% #''?% #'A$*("(:$4%"(?%
)6+(#% >-(?+(#% C$:2"(+.C.% )'% #''?% #'A$*("(:$% ":2+$A$C$().4%
)2$% (")+'("8% #'A$*(C$()% :"(% B*'C ')$% @GG0% <2$% I$"8% '>% D''?% 9':"8% D'A$*("(:$% +.% "% *$\-+*$C$( )% >'*%
8':"8% #'A$*(C$().% )2")% M"()% )'% "A"+8% '>% 8'"(.% >*'C% )2$% 9"(?% 3"(P% '*% )2$% @$A$8'BC$()% 3"(P% '>% )2$%
!2+8+BB+($.0%% L)% +.% "8.'% "% *$\-+*$C$()%>'*%$8+#+,+8+)6% >'*%.$A$*"8%>-(?+(#% B*'#*"C.%R.$$% !&T%,$8'MS0% % 7"#"%
&+)6%M".%"M"*?$?%)2$%I$"8%'>%D''?%/'-.$P$$B+(#%+(%]ea]0%%%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
]c%X"8"."#%+.%)2$%T+8+B+('%M'*?%>'*%m.2+$8?n0%<2$%XE9EIED%":*'(6C%+(%)2$%"M"*?%.)"(?.%>'*%X"8"C+?"?%")%
I"P-("%9","("(4%I"*+8+(#%D"8+(#%"(#% X"8+#)"."(4% M2+:2% :"(%,$%)*"(.8")$?%)'% C$"(% m'-*%'M(%$>>'*).%"*$%
M2")%M+88%."A$%-.%>*'C%?+.".)$*.0n%
]j%5"(+8"%I)"(?"*?%<'?"64%]k%5"*:2%]eab%
T+#-*$%c0%I+Q%&'*$%&*+)$*+"%)'%E..$..%>'*%)2$%
I$"8%'>%D''?%9':"8%D'A$*("(:$0%

AZ"#"!"#$"
"
?H*"2*+.(+-0,4*"$H066*,1*"JD,5"]2$J^"
%
<2$%!&T%M".%?$.+#($?%".%"(%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C%)'%B*'C')$%#''?%#'A$*("(:$4%,-)%)2$%B*'#*"C%2".%,$$(%
-.$?%)'%$(:'-*"#$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%+(A$.)%+(%@GG%,$:"-.$%'($%'>%)2$%C$".-*$.%'>%#''?%#'A$*("(:$%
+(:8-?$.%"(%$CB2".+.%'(%@GG0%%<'%,$%$8+#+,8$%>'*%!&T%>-(?+(#4%)2$%9DH%C-.)%2"A$%,$$(%"M"*?$?%"%I$"8%'>%
D''?%D'A$*("(:$0%%%
%
<2$%!&T%+.%"?C+(+.)$*$?%,6%)2$%@L9D4%M2+:2%"BB*'A$.%)2*$$%)6B$.%'>%B*'U$:).%>'*%>-(?+(#^%%
-!!*'#*"C.%#$"*$?%)'M"*?%)2$%"))"+(C$()%'>%)2$%5+88$((+-C%@$A$8'BC$()%D'"8.g%%
-!E:)+A+)+$.%)2")%B*'C')$%8':"8%$:'('C+:%?$A$8'BC$()4%"(?%%
-!&8+C")$%:2"(#$%"?"B)")+'(%"(?%@GG%B*'U$:).0%
%
7"#"%&+)6%M".%"M"*?$?%)2$%I$"8%'>%D''?%/'-.$P$$B+(#%,6%)2$%@L9D%+(%]eaa4%"(?%M".%B*'A+?$?%M+)2%"%
#*"()%'>%HI@%cf4eee0ee%)'%,$%.B$()%'(%"%B*'U$:)%$()+)8$?!“9+($?%&"("8%!*'U$:)%")%&'(:$B:+'(%!$\-$("4%
7"#"%&+)6.”!<2$%:+)6%:'(.)+)-)$?%"%q)".P%>'*:$Z%)'%C$$)%)2$%"?C+(+.)*")+A$%"(?%C'(+)'*+(#%*$\-+*$C$().%
-(?$*%)2$%!&T0%7"#"%&+)6%FQ$:-)+A$%J*?$*%]eafNa]%:*$")$?%)2$%!$*>'*C"(:$%&2"88$(#$%T-(?%
LCB8$C$()")+'(%H(+)%R!&TLHS%)'%+()$#*")$4%:''*?+(")$4%>":+8+)")$4%C'(+)'*%"(?%.-B$*A+.$%)2$%
'-)B-).h":)+A+)+$.%'>%)2$%8':"8%?$B"*)C$().%+(A'8A$?%+(%)2$%B*'U$:)0%
%
<2$%!&T%+.%(')%"?$\-")$%)'%>-(?%8"*#$N.:"8$%+(>*".)*-:)-*$%B*'U$:).%'*%')2$*%*$.'-*:$N+()$(.+A$%
B*'#*"C.0%T'*%.-:2%":)+A+)+$.4%)2$%!&T%.-,.+?6%.$*A$.%C'*$%".%"%.-BB8$C$()"84%*")2$*%)2"(%"%B*+C"*6%
.'-*:$%'>%>-(?+(#0%E8.'4%"%.)*+(#$()%"(?%.8'M%"?C+(+.)*")+'(%'>%)2$%>-(?%C"P$.%+CB8$C$()")+'(%?+>>+:-8)0%%%
%
=,9D+0,4*"0,5"<!4+(W=,9D+0,4*"2+(5D4%9"
%
L(.-*"(:$%+.%8''P$?%")%2$*$%".%"%*+.P%)*"(.>$*%C$:2"(+.C0%%L>%M$%)"P$%
)2$%.)"(?B'+()% '>% +(?+A+?-"8.4%)2$%+(:$()+A$% $Q+.).% '(86%+>%)2$% B*+:+(#%
*$:'#(+V$.% B'.+)+A$% ":)+'(.% )"P$(% ,6% )2$% B'8+:6% 2'8?$*% )'% *$?-:$%
B')$()+"8%8'..0%/'M$A$*4%+>%M$%)"P$%)2$%:+)6Z.%B$*.B$:)+A$4%)2$*$%+.%"(%
+(:$()+A$% >'*% #'A$*(C$()% )'% B*'C')$% ('(N8+>$% "(?% :"8"C+)6%
+(.-*"(:$% B*'?-:).4% M+)2% '*% M+)2'-)% *+.PN,".$?% B*+:+(#% .)*")$#+$.4%
.+(:$%+)%"88'M.%>'*%)2$%)*"(.>$*%'>%*+.P%)'%)2$%B*+A")$%.$:)'*%"(?%2$(:$%
*$?-:$.% )2$% 'A$*"88% .2"*$% '>% *+.P% )"P$(% '(% ,6% #'A$*(C$()% R+0$04%
:'()+(#$()%8+",+8+)6S%+>%"%?+.".)$*%M".%)'%2"BB$(0%% 7')$%2'M$A$*%)2")%
+(.-*"(:$% +.%*$#-8")$?% ,6% )2$% (")+'("8% #'A$*(C$()4% 8':"8%
#'A$*(C$()%:"(%,-6%+(.-*"(:$% )'% B*')$:)%+).%'M(%"..$).%,-)%2".%('%
"-)2'*+)6%'A$*%)2$%B*+:+(#%'*%')2$*%*$#-8")'*6%C"))$*.0%
%
L(.-*"(:$%:'A$*+(#%B$*+8.%>*'C%(")-*"8%2"V"*?.4%.-:2%".%)6B2''(.4%
$"*)2\-"P$.%'*%>8''?.%"*$%B*'A+?$?%,6%+(.-*"(:$%:'CB"(+$.%+(%7"#"%
&+)64%,-)%)2$.$%B*'?-:).%"*$%#$($*"886%-(B'B-8"*%"(?%.$8?'C%
T+#-*$%j0%D$($*"8%<6B$.%'>%L(.-*"(:$0

AK"#"!"#$"
"
.-,.:*+,$?%)'0]d%9+C+)$?%-B)"P$%'>%+(.-*"(:$%:'A$*"#$%+.%*'')$?%+(%*+.+(#%B'A$*)6%+(:+?$(:$%"C'(#%
T+8+B+('%>"C+8+$.4%+(:*$".+(#%:'.)%'>%8+A+(#%"(?%8'M%8$A$8.%'>%"M"*$($..%"(?%-(?$*.)"(?+(#%'>%+(.-*"(:$%
B*'?-:).0]k%%<2$%7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%2".%('%B*'#*"C%)'%B*'C')$%+(.-*"(:$%$+)2$*%"C'(#%+).%:+)+V$(.%
'*%+()$*("886%M+)2+(%)2$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()0%%
%
<2$%!2+8+BB+($%@$B"*)C$()%'>%T+("(:$%*$:$()86%B*$B"*$?%"%?*">)%@+.".)$*%G+.P%T+("(:+(#%"(?%L(.-*"(:$%
I)*")$#6%M+)2%.-BB'*)%>*'C%)2$%='*8?%3"(P0%/'M$A$*4%+)%+.%(')%6$)%B-,8+:86%"::$..+,8$%")%)2$%)+C$%'>%
M*+)+(#0%%7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%+.%(')%B*+A6%)'%'*%"M"*$%'>%.-:2%"(%+(+)+")+A$0%%
%
G$#"*?+(#%"#*+:-8)-*"8%+(.-*"(:$4%)2$%!2+8+BB+($%&*'B%L(.-*"(:$%&'*B'*")+'(%R!&L&S%:'A$*.%+(.-*"(:$%>'*%
8+A$.)':P4%2+#2%A"8-$%:*'B.4%:'*(4%*+:$%"(?%>"*C%+CB8$C$().0%T"*C$*.%2"A$%)2$%8+,$*)6%)'%:2''.$%)2$%
$Q)$()%'>%:'A$*"#$%'>%2"V"*?.%.-:2%".%)6B2''(.%'*%$"*)2\-"P$.4%M+)2%?+>>$*$()%:'.).%"..':+")$?%M+)2%
$":2%)6B$%'>%2"V"*?%:'A$*"#$0%%
"
5+:*'N+(.-*"(:$%B*'?-:).%O%?$>+($?%".%+(.-*"(:$%C$:2"(+.C.%M+)2%B*$C+-C.%,$8'M%bo%'>%?"+86%M"#$%
"(?%M+)2%"%C"Q+C-C%,$($>+)%'>%bee%)+C$.%)2$%?"+86%M"#$_e*O%"*$%"8.'%"A"+8",8$%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%"(?%"*$%
+()$(?$?%)'%B*')$:)%)2$%B''*%>*'C%A"*+'-.%*+.P.4%+(:8-?+(#%(")-*"8%?+.".)$*%*+.P0%E.%+)%2".%"%8'M$*%:'.)%"(?%
C'*$%>8$Q+,8$%B"6C$()%)$*C.%:'CB"*$?%)'%)*"?+)+'("8%+(.-*"(:$4%+)%B*'A+?$.%8'M%+(:'C$%+(?+A+?-"8.%"(?%
>"C+8+$.%"(%"::$..+,8$%'B)+'(%>'*%B*')$:)+(#%)2$+*%"..$).%>*'C%?+.".)$*.0%<2$*$%+.%"8.'%"(%+(:$()+A$%>'*%
8':"8%"(?%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$().%)'%B*'C')$%C+:*'N+(.-*"(:$%B*'?-:).%".%)2$6%"88'M%)*"(.>$**+(#%?+.".)$*%
*+.P.%)'%B*+A")$%+(.)+)-)+'(.4%"(?%2$(:$%8+#2)$(%)2$%>+("(:+"8%,-*?$(%>*'C%)2$%#'A$*(C$()Z.%.2'-8?$*.%+(%
:".$%"%?+.".)$*%2"BB$(.0%%/'M$A$*4%C+:*'N+(.-*"(:$%B$($)*")+'(%*")$%+.%8'M4%?-$%B*+C"*+86%)'%"%8":P%'>%
>+("(:+"8%$?-:")+'(%"(?%"M"*$($..0_a%7"#"%&+)6%?'$.%(')%2"A$%"%.)*")$#6%)'%.-BB'*)%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%'>%
C+:*'N+(.-*"(:$%B*'?-:).4%('*%)'%+CB*'A$%>+("(:+"8%8+)$*":60%9':"8%.)"P$2'8?$*.%"*$%(')%P('M8$?#$",8$%
",'-)%C+:*'N+(.-*"(:$%B*'?-:).%"(?%)2$%,$($>+).%)2")%)2$6%:"(%,*+(#%)'%:'CC-(+)+$.0%%
%
?+0!,!,1"0,5"`,(N6*51*"?+0,9.*+"=,4*,%!)*9"
%
<2$% !2+8+BB+($.%(")+'("8% #'A$*(C$()% "8.'% .$$P.% )'% B*'C')$% @GG% +(% 8':"8% #'A$*(C$().% ,6% B*'A+?+(#%
)*"+(+(#.%"(?%+(>'*C")+'(%*$#"*?+(#%)2$%,$($>+).%'>%@GG%"(?%@G50%%
%
?+0!,!,1""
%
E.%B"*)%'>%+).%8$#"8%C"(?")$4%)2$%J>>+:$%'>%&+A+8%@$>$(.$%RJ&@S%B*'A+?$.%)*"+(+(#.%+(%?+.".)$*%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%
"(?% C"("#$C$()% )'% 8':"8% #'A$*(C$()% .)">>0% % <2$% /9HG3% 2".% "8.'% B*'?-:$?% #-+?$8+($.% '(% 2'M% )'%
+()$#*")$%@GG%+()'%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#4%".%M$88%".%?$A$8'B$?%"%C$)2'?%2".%)'%8$"?%2"V"*?%"(?%A-8($*",+8+)6%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
]d%@$%D-VC"(4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"6%b4%]eab%
]k%5"(+8"%3-88$)+(4%]ea_%
_e%5+:*'+(.-*"(:$%!2+8+BB+($.4%]eaa%
_a%@$%D-VC"(4%]eab%

AA"#"!"#$"
"
"..$..C$().%>'*%"% :'CB*$2$(.+A$% *"(#$% '>%*+.P.4%"(?% +()$#*")$% )2$% *$.-8).% '>% )2$.$%"("86.$.%+()'% &9H!%
>'*C-8")+'(0%%%
%
E.% "% B"*)% '>% )2$% 9':"8% &8+C")$% &2"(#$% E:)+'(% !8"(.4% )2$%
&8+C")$% &2"(#$% &'CC+..+'(% B*'A+?$.% )*"+(+(#.% )'% 8':"8%
#'A$*(C$().% '(% 2'M% )'% 8$"?% :8+C")$N+(?-:$?% *+.P%
A-8($*",+8+)6%"..$..C$().0%<2$%:-**$()% )"*#$)% >'*% )2+.%6$"*%+.%
)'% )*"+(% abe% 8':"8% #'A$*(C$().% '(% 2'M% )'% :'(?-:)% )2$.$%
"..$..C$().0%%
%
BD!65!,19"0,5"$(,9%+D4%!(,"R*1D60%!(,9EA"
%
7"#"%&+)6%+.% C"(?")$?% )'% $(>'*:$%)2$% 3-+8?+(#% &'?$%'>% )2$%
!2+8+BB+($.4% +(:8-?+(#% )2$% 7")+'("8% I)*-:)-*"8% &'?$% .$:)+'(0%%
L(% B*":)+:$4% 'A$*.+#2)% '(% :'(.)*-:)+'(% +.% $(.-*$?% ,6% )2$%
J>>+:$% '>% )2$% &+)6% F(#+($$*% >'*% B-,8+:% ,-+8?+(#.4% M2+8$% )2$%
J>>+:$%'>%)2$%3-+8?+(#%J>>+:+"8%$(>'*:$.%)2$%B*'A+.+'(.%'>%)2$%
7")+'("8% 3-+8?+(#% &'?$% "(?% ')2$*% ,-+8?+(#% *$#-8")+'(.% '(% ,')2% )2$% B-,8+:% "(?% B*+A")$% .$:)'*.0% &+)6%
$(#+($$*.% -.-"886% ?+A+?$% )2$+*% )+C$% ,$)M$$(% :'(.)*-:)+'(% B$*C+)% "BB*'A"8.% +(% )2$% C'*(+(#% "(?%
+(.B$:)+'(% '>% :'(.)*-:)+'(% .+)$.% "(?% 2'C$.% +(%)2$% ">)$*(''(0__%E.% B'+()$?% '-)% ?-*+(#% +()$*A+$M.4% )2$%
J>>+:$% '>% )2$% 3-+8?+(#% J>>+:+"8%"(?% )2$% J>>+:$% '>% )2$% &+)6% F(#+($$*% >":$% "% 8":P% '>% 2-C"(% "(?% )$:2(+:"8%
*$.'-*:$.%)'% $(.-*$%*'-)+($% )".P.%+(:8-?+(#% )2$% C'(+)'*+(#% 'B$*")+'(.0%E.% .-:24% $A$(%,$>'*$% B*'A+?+(#%
.)"P$2'8?$*.%M+)2% +(:$()+A$.% )'% -(?$*)"P$% A'8-()"*6% @GG% ":)+'(.4% '($% '>% )2$% C"U'*% :2"88$(#$.% >":+(#%
7"#"%&+)6%+.%$(>'*:+(#%:'CB8+"(:$%M+)2%$Q+.)+(#%8"M.%"(?%'*?+("(:$.0%%
%
:(406"URR"=,4*,%!)*9"!,"/010"$!%&""
%
7")+'("8%+(:$()+A$.%"*$%?$.+#($?%)'%$(:'-*"#$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%-(+).%)'%$(#"#$%+(%@GG4%,-)%8':"8%
#'A$*(C$().%:"(%"8.'%-.$%@GG%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C.%)'%$(:'-*"#$%'*#"(+V")+'(.4%,-.+($..$.4%"(?%
+(?+A+?-"8.%M+)2+(%)2$+*%U-*+.?+:)+'(%)'%$(#"#$%+(%@GG%":)+A+)+$.0%%E)%)2+.%8':"8%8$A$84%$>>$:)+A$%+(:$()+A$%
B*'#*"C.%($$?%)'%,$%)"*#$)$?%M+)2%"%:8$"*%A+.+'(%'>%)2$%#'"8%'>%@GG%":)+A+)+$.0%%7"#"%&+)6%?'$.%(')%
:-**$()86%2"A$%?+*$:)%@GG%+(:$()+A$.4%,-)%)2$%:+)6%?'$.%"?C+(+.)$*%"%.$*+$.%'>%B*'#*"C.%)2")%B*'A+?$%
+(:$()+A$.%>'*%?$A$8'BC$()%"(?%B'A$*)6%*$?-:)+'(%)2")%:'-8?%,$%2"*($..$?%)'%B*'C')$%@GG0%%
"
=,)*9%-*,%"=,4*,%!)*9"$(5*"(."%H*"$!%&"(."/010"]7+5!,0,4*"/(MYVWKKO^%%
%
<2$%7"#"%&+)6%L(:$()+A$.%&'?$%'>%akkj"+.%"(%'*?+("(:$%B"..$?%,6%)2$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%)'%.-BB8$C$()%
)2$%+(A$.)C$()%+(:$()+A$.%B*'A+?$?%,6%)2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()0%<2+.%'*?+("(:$%M".%B-*B'.$86%$(":)$?%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
_]%FA$(%)2'-#2% ,-+8?+(#%"(?%:'(.)*-:)+'(%*$#-8")+'(.%"*$%(')%+(:$()+A$.%B$*%.$4% )2$6%"*$%+(:8-?$?%2$*$%
>'*%)2$+*%*$8$A"(:$%)'%7"#"%&+)6Z.%:2"88$(#$.%"(?%+CB'*)"(:$%>'*%,-+8?+(#%@GG%+(%#$($*"80%%
__%F0%&"C,'4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"6%b4%]eab%
Source:!Naga*City*Smiles*at*the*World,*Naga*City*
Facebook*(2015)%
T+#-*$%d0%7"#"%&+)6%/'8?.%[-"*)$*86%
7")+'(M+?$%I+C-8)"($'-.%F"*)2\-"P$%@*+880

AE"#"!"#$"
"
)'%$(:'-*"#$%($M%+(A$.)'*.%+(%)2$%:+)6%)2*'-#2%)2$%-.$%'>%>+.:"8%"(?%('(N>+.:"8%+(:$()+A$.0%T+.:"8%
+(:$()+A$.%+(:8-?$%$Q$CB)+'(%>*'C%:+)6%)"Q$.4%:2"*#$.%"(?%>$$.0%7'(N>+.:"8%+(:$()+A$.%+(:8-?$%"..+.)"(:$%
+(%.$:-*+(#%B$*C+).%"(?%8+:$(.$.4%"..+.)"(:$%+(%+?$()+>6+(#%,-.+($..%8':")+'(.4%"::$..%)'%>+("(:+"8%"(?%
)$:2(+:"8%"..+.)"(:$%B*'#*"C.4%>":+8+)")+(#%.$*A+:$%:'(($:)+'(.%M+)2%8':"8%-)+8+)+$.4%"(?%')2$*%('(N>+.:"8%
+(:$()+A$.%($$?$?%,6%+(A$.)'*.%"(?%>+*C.0%<2$%:'?$%+.%(')%:-**$()86%-.$?%)'%$(:'-*"#$%@GG%,6%+(A$.)'*.4%
,-)%+)%:'-8?%,$%C'?+>+$?%O%$+)2$*%+(%+).%8"(#-"#$%'*%+).%+CB8$C$()")+'(%O%)'%B*'C')$%@GG0%%
%
T'*%$Q"CB8$4%"%B'*)+'(%'>%)2$%L(:$()+A$.%&'?$%+.%?$?+:")$?%)'%D*$$(%L(A$.)C$().0%<2$%C"+(%+(:$()+A$%
C$:2"(+.C.%-.$?%"*$%)"Q%?+.:'-().%>'*%*$B"+()+(#%R:+)6%,$"-)+>+:")+'(S4%)*$$%B8"()+(#%'*%8"(?.:"B+(#%
C$".-*$.0%I'C$%'>%)2$.$%+(:$()+A$.%C"6%:'()*+,-)$%)'%@GG4%.-:2%".%)*$$%B8"()+(#%)'%:*$")$%#*$$(%,->>$*%
V'($.%+(%$(A+*'(C$()"886%.$(.+)+A$%"*$".0%%/'M$A$*4%('%'($%2".%"A"+8$?%'>%)2$%*$N#*$$(+(#%+(:$()+A$.%.'%
>"*0_f%J($%B'..+,8$%$QB8"(")+'(%+.%)2")%)2$*$%+.%"%8":P%'>%:'CC-(+:")+'(%'(%)2$%B'8+:64%#$($*")+(#%"(%
+(>'*C")+'(%#"B%"(?%"%8":P%'>%P('M8$?#$%'>%)2$%"A"+8",+8+)6%'>%)2$%+(:$()+A$0_b%
%
`00,%0@0&"90"`0D9N010,"(+"20+%,*+9"!,"U*)*6(I-*,%"
2+(1+0-"]7+5!,0,4*"/(M"YXWZEE^""
%
<2$%X""()","6%."%X"-.M"#"(%RX.XS%'*%!"*)($*.%+(%
@$A$8'BC$()%!*'#*"C%+.%"%.':+"8%"C$8+'*")+'(%B*'#*"C%)2")%
"+C.%)'%"??*$..%)M'%:'*$%+..-$.%>":$?%,6%)2$%-*,"(%B''*^%RaS%
)2$%",.$(:$%'>%.$:-*$%8"(?%)$(-*$g%"(?%R]S%)2$%8":P%'>%,".+:%
+(>*".)*-:)-*$%"(?%>":+8+)+$.%+(%)2$+*%:'CC-(+)+$.0%L)%"8.'%"+C.%
)'%*$?-:$%)2$%"?A$*.$%$>>$:).%'>%-*,"(%#*'M)2%+(%B-,8+:%
2$"8)24%.">$)6%"(?%$(A+*'(C$()0_c%<2$%B*'#*"C%+.%>+("(:$?%
-.+(#%aeo%'>%)2$%"((-"8%7&D%H*,"(%!''*%<*-.)%T-(?0%%
%
=2+8$%)2$%X.X%!*'#*"C%?'$.%(')%B*+C"*+86%"+C%)'%*$?-:$%
?+.".)$*%*+.P.4%.'C$%+(:$()+A$.%+)%2".%+()*'?-:$?%:'()*+,-)$%+(?+*$:)86%)'%*$?-:+(#%,$($>+:+"*+$.Z%$QB'.-*$%
"(?%A-8($*",+8+)6%)'%?+.".)$*%*+.P.0%E.%"(%$Q"CB8$4%)2$%7&D%B*'A+?$.%\-"8+>+$?%,$($>+:+"*+$.%M+)2%8"(?%>'*%
2'-.+(#%"(?%*$8':")+'(%)2*'-#2%'(N.+)$%"(?%'>>N.+)$%*$?$A$8'BC$()4%-.-"886%+(%"*$".%)2")%"*$%(')%2"V"*?N
B*'($0%G$.$))8$C$()%+(%8'MN*+.P%"*$".%+.%(')%)2$%*$.-8)%'>%"%>'*C"8%#-+?$8+($%-(?$*%X.X%,-)%*")2$*%"%
:'(.$\-$(:$%'>%:-**$()%-*,"(+V")+'(%B"))$*(.%+(%2+#2N#*'-(?%"*$".4%M2+:2%2"A$%8+))8$%$QB'.-*$%)'%>8''?%
*+.P0_j%%%
%
<2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%"8.'%#+A$.%"88'M"(:$.%>'*%2'-.+(#%C")$*+"8.4%M2+8$%)2$%,$($>+:+"*+$.%2"A$%)'%
.2'-8?$*%)2$%:'.)%'>%:'(.)*-:)+'(0%L(%"??+)+'(4%)2$%7&D%:"(%$(?'*.$%)2$%,$($>+:+"*+$.%)'%7DJ.%8+P$%
D"M"?%X"8+(#"%"(?%/",+)")%>'*%/-C"(+)64%M2+:2%B*'A+?$%"??+)+'("8%2'-.+(#%:'(.)*-:)+'(%"..+.)"(:$0%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
_f%G0%J8+A$*4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%c4%]eab%
_b%=0%!*+88$.4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%1-86%c4%]eab%
_c%G0%&"CB+88'.4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%c4%]eab%
_j%=0%!*+88$.4%1-86%c4%]eab%
T+#-*$%k0%<2$%X.X%!*'#*"C%!-*.-$.%<$(-*$%
I$:-*+)6%!'8+:6%R1'($.%p%9"(#4%]eejS0%

AO"#"!"#$"
"
E??+)+'("8864%B*'#*"C%,$($>+:+"*+$.%"*$%B*'A+?$?%M+)2%#-+?$8+($.%,6%)2$%/'-.+(#%"(?%I$))8$C$().%J>>+:$%
'(%2'M%)'%,-+8?%2'-.$.%M+)2%)2$%,".+:%.)*-:)-*"8%"(?%>+*$%.">$)6%>$")-*$.4%M2+:2%:'-8?%"8.'%,$%C'?+>+$?%
)'%C'*$%>'*C"886%.-BB'*)%@GG0%%
%
X.X%+.%.-BB8$C$()$?%,6%3"6"?(+2"(4%"%:".2N>'*NM'*P%B*'#*"C%)2")%B*'A+?$.%)$CB'*"*6%$CB8'6C$()%
'BB'*)-(+)+$.%)'%X.X%,$($>+:+"*+$.0%.-:2%".%+(%)2$%:'(.)*-:)+'(%'>%:+)6%+(>*".)*-:)-*$%B*'U$:).4%
C"+()$("(:$%'>%$Q+.)+(#%B-,8+:%+(>*".)*-:)-*$4%"(?%')2$*%B*'U$:).%.-:2%".%)2$%,$"-)+>+:")+'(%'>%B-,8+:%
B8"V".4%C'(-C$().%"(?%>":+8+)+$.0%%
%
<2$%B*'#*"C%2".%"%(-C,$*%'>%8+C+)")+'(.0%<2$%X.X%B*'U$:)%2".%'(86%*$":2$?%c4eee%'>%)2$%+(+)+"8%ae4eee%
)"*#$)$?%,$($>+:+"*6%>"C+8+$.0_d%E8.'4%.-BB'*)%B*'#*"C.%.-:2%".%8+A$8+2''?%B*'U$:).%+(%)2$%*$8':")+'(%.+)$.%
"*$%(')%"8M"6.%"A"+8",8$0%L)%2".%,$$(%*$B'*)$?%+(%)2$%B".)%)2")%)2$%3"6"?(+2"(%B*'#*"C%M".%-(?$*N
*$.'-*:$?4%C'.)86%?-$%)'%"%8+C+)$?%(-C,$*%'>%'BB'*)-(+)+$.%+(%#'A$*(C$()%'*%B*+A")$N.$:)'*%B*'U$:).0%
<2$%?+>>+:-8)6%)'%.-.)"+(%8+A$8+2''?%+.%C"?$%$A$(%C'*$%?+>>+:-8)%+(%'>>N.+)$%?$A$8'BC$().4%M2$*$%
)*"(.B'*)")+'(%"(?%')2$*%8+A+(#%:'.).%"*$%#$($*"886%2+#2$*%>'*%*$.+?$().0%<2+.%2".%2"?%-(?$.+*$?%
:'(.$\-$(:$.4%.-:2%".%?$8"6$?%"C'*)+V")+'(%B"6C$().%"(?%*$.$88+(#%'>%8').0_k%
%
@-$%)'%)2$%&+)6Z.%*$.'-*:$%8+C+)")+'(.%)'%C'(+)'*%)2$%:'CB8+"(:$%M+)2%,-+8?+(#%.)"(?"*?.4%+)%+.%-(:8$"*%)'%
M2")%$Q)$()%?+.B8":$?%>"C+8+$.%"*$%",8$%)'%,-+8?%,":P%,$))$*%+(%)2$+*%($M%.$))8$C$().0%
%
'!,H0N0,1"/01D*a(b:*09%";4(,(-!4066&"R*9!6!*,%"$(--D,!%!*9"]:;R$^"2+(1+0-"
%
9FG&%+.%"%($M%B*'#*"C%)2")%+.%B*+C"*+86%"+C$?%")%$*"?+:")+(#%B'A$*)6%)2*'-#2%A"8-$.%>'*C")+'(4%".%M$88%
".%)2*'-#2%)2$%B*'A+.+'(%'>%8'MN:'.)%,-)%*$.+8+$()%2'-.+(#4%U',.4%"(?%"::$..%)'%,".+:%*$.'-*:$.%.-:2%".%
B')",8$%M")$*%"(?%$8$:)*+:+)60%<2$%B*'#*"C%+.%,$+(#%+CB8$C$()$?%,6%A+*)-$%'>%"(%$Q$:-)+A$%'*?$*%.+#($?%
,6%)2$%5"6'*0%
%
<2$%B*'#*"C%B*+'*+)+V$.%'(N.+)$%?$A$8'BC$()4%"(?%C"P$.%-.$%'>%B"*)+:+B")'*6%B8"((+(#%)'%?+*$:)86%$(#"#$%
)2$%B*'#*"C%,$($>+:+"*+$.%+(%)2$%:'(:$B)-"8+V")+'(%"(?%+CB8$C$()")+'(%'>%B*'#*"C%:'CB'($().4%".%"%
C$"(.%)'%,-+8?%:'CC-(+)6%"M"*$($..%"(?%$CB'M$*%:'CC-(+)6%C$C,$*.0%J(N.+)$%?$A$8'BC$()%+.%)2$%
B*$>$**$?%'B)+'(4%"8)2'-#2%)"*#$)$?%,$($>+:+"*+$.%8+A+(#%+(%2"V"*?NB*'($%"*$".%M+88%,$%*$8':")$?%)'%.">$*%
8':")+'(.0fe%L(%B"*"88$8%M+)2%.)*-:)-*"8%+CB*'A$C$().%"(?%8+A$8+2''?%B*'#*"C.%M+)2+(%)2$%:'CC-(+)+$.4%
)2$%9FG&%B*'#*"C%M+88%"8.'%+(:8-?$%)*"+(+(#%'(%?+.".)$*%*+.P%C"("#$C$()%B*'A+?$?%,6%)2$%7"#"%&+)6%
@GG5%J>>+:$4%+(%'*?$*%>'*%B$'B8$%)'%,$))$*%-(?$*.)"(?%)2$%*+.P.%)2")%)2$6%>":$%"(?%+(A$.)%C'*$%+(%)2$+*%
'M(%.">$)6%".%)2$+*%$:'('C+:%'BB'*)-(+)+$.%$QB"(?0%%E%B+8')%B*'U$:)%+.%:-**$()86%,$+(#%:"**+$?%'-)%+(%
3"*"(#"6%3"8")".%>'*%fj%>"C+8+$.0fa%
"
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
_d%G0%&"CB+88'.4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"*:2%c4%]eab%
_k%1'($.%p%9"(#4%]eej%
fe%F0%I"8A+('4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"6%b4%]eab%
fa%F0%I"8A+('4%]eab%

AP"#"!"#$"
"
=,%*1+0%*5"/010"R!)*+"R*)!%06!80%!(,"2+(>*4%OA"
%
<2$%G$A+)"8+V")+'(%!*'U$:)%+(:8-?$.%"%*$.$))8$C$()%:'CB'($()%)2")%B8":$.%>"C+8+$.%+(%.">$*%"*$".%"(?%
B*'A+?$.%)2$%*$.$))8$C$()%"*$".%M+)2%+(>*".)*-:)-*$%"(?%8+A$8+2''?%'BB'*)-(+)+$.0%E*'-(?%abe%>"C+8+$.%
>*'C%3"*"(#"6%I"(%T*"(:+.:'%"8'(#%)2$%7"#"%G+A$*%"*$%,$+(#%*$8':")$?%-(?$*%)2$%B*'U$:)0%<2$6%M$*$%
*$.$))8$?%+(%"%8$..%2"V"*?NB*'($%"*$"%B*$A+'-.86%'M($?%,6%"%B*+A")$%:'CB"(64%M2+:2%)2$%8':"8%
#'A$*(C$()%":\-+*$?%)2*'-#2%$C+($()%?'C"+(0%<2$%*$.$))8$?%>"C+8+$.%M$*$%B*'A+?$?%M+)2%8').%>'*%)2$+*%
2'-.$.4%"(?%,".+:%.$*A+:$.%.-:2%".%M")$*%"(?%$8$:)*+:+)60f_%<2$%*$.$))8$C$()%"*$"%+.%"8.'%8':")$?%*$8")+A$86%
:8'.$%)'%)2$%"*$"%)2$6%-.$?%)'%*$.+?$%+(0%L(%'*?$*%)'%$(.-*$%)2$%:'()+(-+)6%'>%8+A$8+2''?.4%$":2%'>%)2$%
*$.$))8$?%>"C+8+$.%M+88%,$%B*'A+?$?%M+)2%:6:8$%*+:P.2"M.%)2")%:"(%.$*A$%".%"%C$"(.%'>%8+A$8+2''?%"(?%
)*"(.B'*)")+'(0%%3$($>+:+"*+$.%.$88+(#%)2$%8').%'*%2'-.$.%":\-+*$?%)2*'-#2%)2$%*$8':")+'(%B*'#*"C%>":$%
>+($.%'*%B*+.'(%:2"*#$.4%"(?%"*$%,8":P8+.)$?%>*'C%')2$*%:+)6%B*'#*"C.0%%
%
U*9!1,!,1"=,4*,%!)*9".(+"URR"!,"/010"$!%&F"$H066*,1*9"0,5"2+!(+!%!*9"
%
$0I04!%&".(+"5*9!1,!,1"0,5"!-I6*-*,%!,1"!,4*,%!)*"-*4H0,!9-9"
%
9':"8%#'A$*(C$()%'>>+:+"8.%"(?%.)">>%+(%7"#"%&+)6%"*$%(')%P('M8$?#$",8$%",'-)%@GG%+(:$()+A$%
C$:2"(+.C.4%$+)2$*%>+("(:+"8%'*%('(N>+("(:+"80%%<2$+*%$QB$*+$(:$%M+)2%+(:$()+A$.%2".%,$$(%8+C+)$?%)'%
B*'#*"C.%>':-.$?%'(%$:'('C+:%?$A$8'BC$()%"(?%B'A$*)6%"88$A+")+'(4%"(?%'>>+:+"8.%?'%(')%.$$%)2$%
B')$()+"8%>'*%+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C.%)'%B*$A$()%>-)-*$%B*',8$C.%O%'(86%)'%"??*$..%$Q+.)+(#%:2"88$(#$.0%%
T'*%$Q"CB8$4%'>>+:+"8.%+(%7"#"%&+)6%"*$%(')%+()$*$.)$?%+(%B-*.-+(#%?$(.+)6%,'(-.$.%'*%)*"(.>$*%'>%
?$A$8'BC$()%*+#2).%,$:"-.$%?$(.+)6%2".%(')%6$)%,$:'C$%"%B*',8$C%+(%7"#"%&+)60%%<2$6%?'%(')%.$$%)2$%
B')$()+"8%>'*%)2$.$%C$:2"(+.C.%)'%B*$A$()%?$(.+)6%>*'C%,$:'C+(#%"%B*',8$C4%'*%)'%-.$%>-)-*$%#*'M)2%".%
"%M"6%)'%$(:'-*"#$%@GG0%RG$>$*%)'%)2$%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%&".$%I)-?6%>'*%C'*$%+(N?$B)2%?+.:-..+'(%'(%
)2+.%)'B+:0S%%
%
L(%"??+)+'(4%7"#"%&+)6%#'A$*(C$()%+.%.2'*)N.)">>$?%"(?%2".%8+C+)$?%)$:2(+:"8%:"B",+8+)60%&+)6%.)">>%8":P%
)$:2(+:"8%)*"+(+(#%+(%GI9H!4%*+.P%"..$..C$()4%DLI4%"(?%')2$*%)''8.%)2")%:'-8?%.-BB'*)%@GG4%"(?%"%
C"(B'M$*%.2'*)"#$%C"P$.%,')2%B8"((+(#%"(?%$(>'*:$C$()%?+>>+:-8)0%%T'*%$Q"CB8$4%)2$%&+)6%+.%,$2+(?%
.:2$?-8$%+(%-B?")+(#%+).%&9H!%+(%B"*)%,$:"-.$%+).%-*,"(%B8"((+(#%'>>+:$%2".%)''%>$M%.)">>%C$C,$*.0%%E(?4%
".%C$()+'($?%+(%)2$%GI9H!%:".$%.)-?64%)2$%:+)6%$(#+($$*+(#%'>>+:$%2".%)''%>$M%B$*.'(($8%)'%$>>$:)+A$86%
C'(+)'*%"(?%$(>'*:$%,-+8?+(#%:'?$.%"(?%)2$%W'(+(#%J*?+("(:$0%7"#"%&+)6%2".%('%$(>'*:$C$()%
C$:2"(+.C%)'%C'(+)'*%)2$%$>>$:)+A$($..%'>%+).%B8"((+(#%$>>'*).4%"(?%$A$(%8$..%+(>'*C")+'(%)'%$A"8-")$%
+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C.0%%
%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
f]%T'*%C'*$%?$)"+8.%'(%)2+.%B*'U$:)4%B8$".$%.$$%)2$%F5L%&".$%I)-?6%'(%G+.P%I$(.+)+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"((+(#%+(%
7"#"%&+)64%!2+8+BB+($.0%%
f_%@0%9-?'A+:$4%B$*.'("8%:'CC-(+:")+'(4%5"6%b4%]eab%

AT"#"!"#$"
"
E)%)2$%8':"8%8$A$84%7"#"%&+)6%:'-8?%+CB*'A$%+).%:"B":+)6%,6%+(:*$".+(#%+).%@GG%":)+A+)+$.%"(?%B8"((+(#%.)">>4%
,6%+(A$.)+(#%+(%)$:2(+:"8%)*"+(+(#%R:'-B8$?%M+)2%*$)$()+'(%C$:2"(+.C.%)'%$(.-*$%)2")%)*"+($?%.)">>%
C$C,$*.%.)"6%+(%)2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()S4%"(?%,6%?$A$8'B+(#%>*"C$M'*P.%)'%+(:*$".$%"M"*$($..%"(?%
P('M8$?#$%'>%@GG%+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C.0%<2+.%:'-8?%+(:8-?$%-(?$*)"P+(#%"%.)-?6%'>%+(:$()+A$%
C$:2"(+.C.g%$.)",8+.2+(#%B"*)($*.2+B.%M+)2%":"?$C+"4%?$A$8'BC$()%B"*)($*.4%'*%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%
"#$(:+$.g%"(?%:*$")+(#%"%:+)6N)'N:+)6%.2"*+(#%B8")>'*C%"C'(#%:+)+$.%)2")%2"A$%$QB$*+$(:$%M+)2%@GG%
+(:$()+A$.0%T-(?+(#%>*'C%)2$%8':"8%@GG5%T-(?%:"(%,$%-.$?%)'%>-(?%.'C$%'>%)2$.$%":)+A+)+$.0%%
7"#"%&+)6%:'-8?%"8.'%*$\-$.)%"..+.)"(:$%>*'C%L()$*(")+'("8%?'('*%'*#"(+V")+'(.%+(%)2$%:'()$Q)%'>%)2$+*%
@GG%B*'#*"C.%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%"+C$?%")%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().0%%/'M$A$*4%+)%+.%,$.)%)'%$(#"#$%+()'%
"#*$$C$().%$(A+.+'(+(#%8'(#N)$*C%"(?%8"*#$N.:"8$%)$:2(+:"8%"..+.)"(:$%B*'#*"C.%)2")%:"(%*$"886%C"P$%"%
?+>>$*$(:$0%E.%"(%$Q"CB8$4%)2$%C-(+:+B"8+)6%'>%JB'8%*$"8+V$?%+).%/;GE%)2*'-#2%!*'U$:)%&8+C")$%<M+(%
!2'$(+Qff4%M+)2%>+("(:+"8h)$:2(+:"8%.-BB'*)%>*'C%/9HG3%"(?%+()$*(")+'("8%?'('*%'*#"(+V")+'(.%.-:2%".%
E-.EL@0%%L(%)2+.%:'()$Q)4%)2+.%.)-?6%.2'M.%)2")%)2$*$%:'-8?%,$%,$($>+).%>'*%L()$*(")+'("8%?'('*.%)'%"..+.)%
M+)2%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%'>%"(%+()$*(")+'("8%:+)6N)'N:+)6%P('M8$?#$%.2"*+(#%B8")>'*C4%)'%"88'M%8':"8%
#'A$*(C$().%)'%8$"*(%>*'C%)2$+*%B$$*.%*")2$*%)2"(%)'%.)*-##8$%'(%)2$+*%'M(%+()'%-(:2"*)$*$?%)$**+)'*60%%
L()$*(")+'("8%?'('*.%:'-8?%>":+8+)")$%)2$%P('M8$?#$%.2"*+(#%B*':$..%"(?%B*'A+?$%)$:2(+:"8%"..+.)"(:$%)'%
?$C'(.)*")$%2'M%@GG%+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C.%"*$%$.)",8+.2$?%"(?%:'-8?%,$%-.$?%)'%$A"8-")$%)2$+*%
$>>$:)+A$($..0%%<2$*$%+.%:-**$()86%A$*6%8+))8$%$QB$*+$(:$%+(%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%"(?%I'-)2$".)%E.+"%M+)2%
:'CB*$2$(.+A$%@GG%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C.0%%!+8')%B*'U$:).%M+)2%:+)+$.%8+P$%7"#"%&+)6%M'-8?%,-+8?%)2$%:"B":+)6%
'>%)2$%)$.)%:+)6%M2+8$%"8.'%:'(:*$)$86%)$.)+(#%)2$%B')$()+"8%"BB8+:",+8+)6%'>%)2$%+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C%)'%)2$%
*$#+'(0%%
%
=,4(+I(+0%!,1"URR"!,"*c!9%!,1"60,5"D9*"I60,9G"(+5!,0,4*9G"0,5"!,4*,%!)*"I+(1+0-9".(+"*4(,(-!4"
5*)*6(I-*,%"0,5"I()*+%&"066*)!0%!(,"
"
@GG%+.%(')%"(%$QB8+:+)%'*%:$()*"8%:'CB'($()%'>%)2$%$Q+.)+(#%&'CB*$2$(.+A$%9"(?%H.$%!8"(%R&9H!S4%W'(+(#%
J*?+("(:$4%L(A$.)C$()%L(:$()+A$.%&'?$4%'*%B'A$*)6%"88$A+")+'(%B*'#*"C.%.-:2%".%X.X%'*%9FG&%+(%7"#"%
&+)60%/'M$A$*4%?+.".)$*%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%+.%$..$()+"8%+(%,-+8?+(#%*$.+8+$()%8'MN+(:'C$%:'CC-(+)+$.4%,6%
>-*)2$*%*$?-:+(#%)2$+*%A-8($*",+8+)6%"(?%O%".%+CB'*)"()%>'*%7"#"%O%.$:-*+(#%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%#"+(.%
":2+$A$?%+(%)2$%B".)0%I)*$(#)2$(+(#%)2$%@GG%:'CB'($()%'>%)2$.$%$Q+.)+(#%*$#-8")+'(.%"(?%B*'#*"C.%
:'-8?%#*$")86%$(2"(:$%)2$%'A$*"*:2+(#%.':+"8%?$A$8'BC$()%#'"8.%'>%7"#"%"(?%:'()*+,-)$%)'%)2$%8'(#N
)$*C%+CB*'A$C$()%'>%8'MN+(:'C$%:'CC-(+)+$.Z%:'(?+)+'(.0%L)%M'-8?%"8.'%8$A$*"#$%7"#"%&+)6Z.%
$QB$*+$(:$%"(?%.-::$..%+(%$Q$:-)+(#%)2$.$%B*'#*"C.0%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
ff%LCB8$C$()$?%,6%)2$%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%&'CC+..+'(%!2+8+BB+($.%M+)2%.-BB'*)%>*'C%)2$%H(+)$?%7")+'(.%
@$A$8'BC$()%!*'#*"CC$%"(?%)2$%E-.)*"8+"(%D'A$*(C$()4%!*'U$:)%&8+C")$%<M+(%!2'$(+Q%+.%"%8'(#%)$*C%
:"B":+)6%?$A$8'BC$()%B*'#*"C%>'*%:+)+$.%"(?%C-(+:+B"8+)+$.4%"??*$..+(#%,')2%*+.P.%>*'C%:8+C")$%:2"(#$%
"(?%')2$*%*$8")$?%(")-*"8%2"V"*?.0%<2$%B*'U$:)%B*'C')$.%+(>'*C$?%?$:+.+'(NC"P+(#%"(?%B'8+:6%:2"(#$%")%
)2$%8':"8%8$A$8.4%$CB'M$*+(#%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%"(?%:'CC-(+)+$.%+(%:'C+(#%-B%M+)2%,$))$*%B8"(.4%
B'8+:+$.4%"(?%*$#-8")'*6%C$".-*$.%)2")%M+88%$(",8$%)2$C%)'%:'B$%M+)2%:8+C")$N*$8")$?%(")-*"8%?+.".)$*.0%

AV"#"!"#$"
"
E??+)+'("8%'*%$(2"(:$?%+(:$()+A$.%>'*%@GG%:"(%B8"6%"%*'8$%+(%"-#C$()+(#%)2$%*$.-8).%"(?%.-::$..%'>%
B'A$*)6%"88$A+")+'(%B*'#*"C.%,6%.)*$(#)2$(+(#%:'CC-(+)6%'M($*.2+B%"(?%:'CC-(+)6%,-+8?+(#%
C$".-*$.0%E.%"(%$Q"CB8$%'>%M'*P",8$%+(:$()+A$.%)'%,-+8?%:'CC-(+)6%'M($*.2+B4%8+A$8+2''?%
'BB'*)-(+)+$.%:"(%,$%>-*)2$*%2"*($..$?%)'%.$*A$%@GG%#'"8.4%.-:2%".%$.)",8+.2+(#%:".2N>'*NM'*P%B*'#*"C.%
R3"6"?(+2"(S%>'*%2'C$%+CB*'A$C$().%"(?%.">$*%.)*-:)-*$.0%E??+)+'("8%)*"+(+(#%:'-8?%,$%B*'A+?$?%+(%
2'C$%:'(.)*-:)+'(%B*'U$:).%'(%.">$%:'(.)*-:)+'(%B*":)+:$.%"(?%@GG%#'"8.0%%
I+C+8"*864%)2$%L(A$.)C$()%L(:$()+A$.%&'?$%+.%.'%>"*%"(%-()"BB$?%*$.'-*:$%>'*%@GG0%L)%+.%"(%+(.)*-C$()%
M2$*$%>+.:"8%"(?%('(N>+.:"8%+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C.%:"(%,$%+()*'?-:$?%)'%B*'C')$%@GG%',U$:)+A$.0%I'C$%
'>%)2$.$%$Q+.)+(#%+(:$()+A$.%:'-8?%,$%-.$?%C'*$%B*'":)+A$86%)'%":2+$A$%@GG%+>%)2$%L(A$.)C$().%L(:$()+A$.%
&'?$%M".%*$A+.$?%)'%+(:8-?$%@GG%".%"%#'"80%%&-**$()864%)2$%L(A$.)C$()%L(:$()+A$.%&'?$%+.%>':-.$?%'(%
:*$")+(#%U',.4%B*$.$*A+(#%(")-*"8%*$.'-*:$.%)'%B*'A+?$%>'*%>-)-*$%#$($*")+'(.4%?$)$*C+(+(#%?$(.+)6%"(?%
.B")+"8%?+.)*+,-)+'(%'>%B*+A")$%+(A$.)C$().%>'*%,"8"(:$?%#*'M)24%"(?%$(:'-*"#+(#%:'CC$*:+"8%$()$*B*+.$.%
"(?%>"*C$*.Z%"..':+")+'(.h:''B$*")+A$.%)'%C'?$*(+V$%)2$%"#*+:-8)-*"8%.$:)'*%"(?%+CB*'A$%'A$*"88%
:'CB$)+)+A$($..0%%/'M$A$*4%)2$%&'?$%:'-8?%,$%*$A+.$?%)'%+(:8-?$%@GG%".%"(%$QB8+:+)%',U$:)+A$0%%
LCB8$C$()")+'(%M'-8?%*$\-+*$%$(2"(:$?%:''*?+(")+'(%,$)M$$(%:+)6%?$B"*)C$().%"(?%)2$%L(A$.)C$().%
3'"*?4%.'%)2")%)2$%3'"*?%M'-8?%,$%"M"*$%'>%"(?%:'-8?%.-BB'*)%@GG%',U$:)+A$.0%%L)%C"6%"8.'%*$\-+*$%)2$%
?$A$8'BC$()%'>%"(%"M"*$($..%:"CB"+#(%)'%$?-:")$%8':"8%,-.+($..$.%",'-)%)2$%B*'A+.+'(.%'>%)2$%&'?$%
"(?%2'M%)2$6%:"(%,$($>+)%$:'('C+:%#*'M)20%%
E(%-B?")$?%"(?%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%&9H!%"(?%W'(+(#%J*?+("(:$%:'-8?%.$*A$%".%"%:'*$%)'%7"#"%&+)6Z.%@GG%
.)*")$#60%%<2$.$%B'8+:+$.%M+88%+(>'*C%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%'>%>-*)2$*%+(:$()+A$%C$:2"(+.C.%,64%>'*%$Q"CB8$4%
+?$()+>6+(#%8$..%2"V"*?NB*'($%"*$".%>'*%X.X%)'%>':-.%*$N.$))8$C$()%'*%>'*%)2$%L(A$.)C$()%L(:$()+A$.%&'?$%
)'%B*+'*+)+V$%($M%:'CC$*:+"8%?$A$8'BC$()0%%7"#"%&+)6Z.%.-::$..%+(%C"("#+(#%)2$.$%$Q+.)+(#%B*'#*"C.%
.-##$.).%)2")%C'?+>6+(#%)2$.$%B*'#*"C.%)'%+(:8-?$%@GG%:'-8?%,$%"%A$*6%$>>$:)+A$%M"6%'>%B*'C')+(#%*+.P%
*$?-:)+'(%+(%)2$%:+)60%%
3$6'(?%7"#"%&+)64%+()$*(")+'("8%?'('*.%"(?%8':"8%'>>+:+"8.%.2'-8?%,$%"M"*$%'>%M2")%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C.%O%
$A$(%('(N@GG%B*'#*"C.%O%$Q+.)%M+)2+(%"%:+)64%".%)2$.$%$Q+.)+(#%B*'#*"C.%'>>$*%)2$%'BB'*)-(+)6%)'%
8$A$*"#$%$Q+.)+(#%C"("#$C$()%.)*-:)-*$.%"(?%,-+8?%'(%B".)%.-::$..0%%
"
U0%0"04dD!9!%!(,G"-0,01*-*,%G"0,5"D9*"(."+!9C"!,.(+-0%!(,"
"
7"#"%&+)6%?'$.%(')%:-**$()86%2"A$%"%:'CB*$2$(.+A$4%C-8)+N*+.P%2"V"*?%"(?%A-8($*",+8+)6%"..$..C$()%'>%+).%
)$**+)'*60%<2+.%.2'-8?%,$%C"?$%"%B*+'*+)6%+(%'*?$*%)'%?$A$8'B%+(:$()+A$.%)2")%M+88%$(",8$%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%
-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()0%%L(?$$?4%2"A+(#%"%:8$"*%C"BB+(#%'>%*+.P.%O%M2")%"*$%)2$%2"V"*?.%"(?%2'M%>*$\-$()86%
)2$6%'::-*4%M2")%V'($.%"(?%M2+:2%B'B-8")+'(.%"*$%C'.)%A-8($*",8$%"(?%M2")%+.%)2$%*+.P%O%+.%($$?$?%)'%
?$.+#(%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C.%)2")%M+88%.2+>)%?$A$8'BC$()%>*'C%*+.PNB*'($%)'%('(N?"(#$*%V'($.%+(%)2$%:+)60%
E??+)+'("8%?")"%:"(%"8.'%,$%-.$?%)'%+(:*$".$%"M"*$($..%"(?%B-,8+:%.-BB'*)%>'*%@GG%$>>'*).0%%T'*%$Q"CB8$4%
+(?+A+?-"8.%M2'%>+(?%)2$+*%2'C$4%.:2''84%'*%,-.+($..%'(%"%2"V"*?%C"B%C"6%,$))$*%-(?$*.)"(?%)2$%*+.P.%
)2$6%>":$%"(?%.-BB'*)%#*$")$*%$>>'*).%)'%*$?-:$%>-)-*$%*+.P0%%
%

AX"#"!"#$"
"
E:\-+*+(#%"(?%-.+(#%*+.P%+(>'*C")+'(%+.%"%*$.'-*:$N+()$(.+A$%B*':$..%)2")%.2'-8?%(')%,$%.$$(%".%"%'($N
.2')%?$"8%,-)%*")2$*%".%"%8'(#N)$*C%M'*P%*$\-+*+(#%-B?")$.%)2*'-#2%)+C$0%5"("#+(#%"(?%"?C+(+.)$*+(#%
+(:$()+A$.%B*'#*"C.%+.%"8.'%?+>>+:-8)%"(?%#$($*"886%*$\-+*$%.-,.)"()+"8%*$.'-*:$.%+(%'*?$*%)'%>-(:)+'(4%.-:2%
".%"%2+#2%)$:2(+:"8%8$A$8%"C'(#%.)">>0%L(%)2+.%*$#"*?4%"%:2"88$(#$%>":+(#%7"#"%&+)6%+.%)2")%:-**$()%
"88':")+'(.%'>%*$.'-*:$.%>'*%@GG%O%.-:2%".%)2'.$%B*'A+?$?%-(?$*%)2$%9@GG5T%O%"*$%>':-.$?%'(%.)*-:)-*"8%
B*'U$:).%*")2$*%)2"(%'(%B'8+:6%.$))+(#4%:"B":+)6%,-+8?+(#4%?")"%C"("#$C$()%"(?%2-C"(%*$.'-*:$.0%
%
/'M$A$*4%7"#"%&+)6%:'-8?%+CB*'A$%+).%?")"%":\-+.+)+'(%,6%"88':")+(#%"%?$?+:")$?%,-?#$)%+)$C%R.-:2%".%+(%
)2$%9@GG5TS%>'*%?")"%:'88$:)+'(%"(?%2"V"*?%"(?%*+.P%"..$..C$()4%"(?%,6%,-+8?+(#%)2$%.)*$(#)2%'>%+).%
$Q+.)+(#%8':"8%"..$).4%.-:2%".%)2$%DLI%-(+)%'>%)2$%F8$:)*'(+:%@")"%!*':$..+(#%J>>+:$4%&!@J4%@GG5%J>>+:$4%
F(#+($$*+(#%J>>+:$4%J>>+:$%'>%3-+8?+(#%J>>+:+"84%"(?%')2$*.0%%7"#"%&+)6%:'-8?%"8.'%B"*)($*%M+)2%(")+'("8%
"#$(:+$.%R$0#04%J&@4%7F@E4%/9HG34%!/L;J9&IS4%":"?$C+:.4%7DJ.4%'*%?$A$8'BC$()%B"*)($*.%)'%:'CB8$)$%
"%*+.P%"..$..C$()%'>%)2$%:+)6%"(?%)'%"..+.)%M+)2%)$:2(+:"8%:"B":+)6%,-+8?+(#%"(?%?")"%C"("#$C$()0%%%
%%
L()$*(")+'("8%?'('*%'*#"(+V")+'(.%:'-8?%"..+.)%7"#"%&+)64%"(?%')2$*%.+C+8"*%8':"8+)+$.4%,6%$(:'-*"#+(#%'*%
*$\-+*+(#%:+)+$.%)'%C"P$%)2$+*%*+.P%?")"%"(?%"..$..C$().%'B$(%"::$..%"(?%,6%.-BB'*)+(#%)2$%?$A$8'BC$()%
'>%"(%'B$(%"::$..%?")"%.2"*+(#%B8")>'*C0%G+.P%"..$..C$().%.2'-8?%(')%C$*$86%,$%B*'?-:$?%+(%)2$%:'()$Q)%
'>%"%.B$:+>+:%B*'U$:)%,-)%".%B"*)%'>%"%8'(#$*N)$*C%B*':$..%M2$*$+(%+(>'*C")+'(%:"(%,$%-.$?%M+?$86%"(?%+.%
"::$..+,8$%)'%B*'>$..+'("8.4%B*":)+)+'($*.%"(?%)2$%#$($*"8%B-,8+:%+(%>'*C").%)2")%"*$%$".+86%
-(?$*.)"(?",8$0%%G+.P%"..$..C$()%'-)B-).%"*$%'>)$(%C"?$%,6%$QB$*).%>'*%$QB$*).%"(?%*$C"+(%.$A$*$86%
-(?$*-)+8+V$?0%%%
%
<2$%?$A$8'BC$()%'>%"(%'B$(%"::$..%?")"%.2"*+(#%B8")>'*C%M'-8?%$(",8$%9DH.%)'%B*'A+?$%)2$+*%?")"%"(?%
*+.P%"..$..C$().%+(%"%B-,8+:%"(?%)*"(.B"*$()%>'*C")0%%L()$*(")+'("8%?'('*.%:'-8?%C"P$%'B$(%"::$..%?")"%
.2"*+(#%"%*$\-+*$C$()%+(%)2$+*%#*"().%"(?%"+?%B":P"#$.4%'*%)2$6%:'-8?%B*'A+?$%,'(-.%>+("(:+(#%)'%:+)+$.%
M2'%C"P$%)2$+*%"..$..C$().%'B$(%"::$..%".%"(%+(:$()+A$0%%
"
$(,46D9!(,9""
%
L(%7"#"%&+)64%!2+8+BB+($.4%+(:$()+A$.%>'*%@GG%":)+A+)6%"*$%B*$.$()%,')2%>*'C%)2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%O%)'%
$(:'-*"#$%":)+'(%,6%)2$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%O%"(?%>*'C%)2$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%O%)'%$(:'-*"#$%":)+'(%,6%
+(?+A+?-"8%2'C$'M($*.%"(?%,-.+($..$.0%%E)%)2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%8$A$84%+(:$()+A$.%2"A$%>':-.$?%
B*+C"*+86%'(%B*'A+?+(#%?$?+:")$?%>-(?+(#%)'%8':"8%#'A$*(C$().%>'*%@GG%'*%B*'A+?+(#%"??+)+'("8%>-(?+(#%+(%
$Q:2"(#$%>'*%#''?%#'A$*("(:$%B$*>'*C"(:$4%'*%>'*%B'A$*)6%"88$A+")+'(0%%E)%)2$%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%8$A$84%
C$:2"(+.C.%$Q+.)%)'%$(:'-*"#$%+(A$.)C$()%,6%B*+A")$%:'CB"(+$.%"(?%)'%:2"(#$%,$2"A+'*%'>%8':"8%
2'C$'M($*.0%4%<2$.$%C$:2"(+.C.%2"A$%,$$(%C'?$.)86%-.$?%+(%B*":)+:$%)'%$(:'-*"#$%@GG%,-)%:'-8?%,$%
C"?$%$A$(%C'*$%$>>$:)+A$%,6%>'*C"886%*$:'#(+V+(#%@GG%".%"%B*+'*+)6%#'"80%%%
%
I+#(+>+:"()%:"B":+)6%,-+8?+(#%M+88%,$%($:$.."*6%)'%*"+.$%"M"*$($..%"(?%:'CB$)$(:6%"C'(#%8':"8%
.)"P$2'8?$*.%"(?%8':"8%#'A$*(C$()%'>>+:+"8.%'(%)2$%($$?%>'*%+(:$()+A$.%"(?%)2$%M"6.%+(%M2+:2%$Q+.)+(#%
B*'#*"C.%:"(%,$%"?"B)$?%)'%B*'C')$%@GG0%%7"#"%&+)6%:"(%+CB*'A$%+).%@GG%$>>'*).%,6%+(A$.)+(#%+(%

AY"#"!"#$"
"
:"B":+)6%,-+8?+(#4%?")"%":\-+.+)+'(%"(?%-.$4%"(?%,6%C'?+>6+(#%+).%$Q+.)+(#%.-::$..>-8%+(:$()+A$%B*'#*"C.%
)'%+(:'*B'*")$%@GG0%L()$*(")+'("8%?'('*.%:"(%.-BB'*)%)2$.$%$>>'*).%,6%B*'C')+(#%8'(#N)$*C%:"B":+)6%
,-+8?+(#%B*'U$:).4%+(A$.)+(#%+(%B+8')%B*'U$:).4%$.)",8+.2+(#%"%:+)6N)'N:+)6%P('M8$?#$%B8")>'*C4%"(?%
$(:'-*"#+(#%'B$(%"::$..%?")"%.2"*+(#0%<2$%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%>'*%+).%B"*)%:"(%B*'C-8#")$%.-BB'*)+(#%
B'8+:+$.%"(?%#-+?$8+($.%)'%+(:$()+A+V$%@GG0%
%
=+)2%)2$.$%$>>'*).4%7"#"%&+)6%"(?%.+C+8"*%8':"8+)+$.4%M+88%,$%,$))$*%B*$B"*$?%)'%B*'C')$%@GG%")%"88%8$A$8.%
'>%)2$+*%:+)6%B8"((+(#0%%
%%
% %

EZ"#"!"#$"
"
R*.*+*,4*9"
%
EF&J50%R]eafS0%Incentive*for*Disaster*Risk*Management—Discussion*Paper0%%I2"(#2"+4%&2+("^%EF&J5%
%9)?0%%
%
E8,"6%@'C+(")$.%D"M"?%X"8"."#%R]eab4%5"*:2%]kS0%Manila*Standard*Today0%G$)*+$A$?%T*'C^%
2))B^hhC"(+8".)"(?"*?)'?"60:'Ch]eabhe_h]kh"8,"6N?'C+(")$.N#"M"?NP"8"."#h%%
%
%
E)$($'%I':+"8%I:+$(:$%G$.$"*:2%&$()$*%REIIG&S0%R]eekS0%Naga*City:*A*Profile0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
%2))B^hhMMM0"?(-0$?-0B2h&$()$*.hIIG&h("#"B*'>+8$02)C8%%
%
3"2"?-*4%E04%X+*,6.2+*$4%E04%X2"(4%@0%p%32"))4%50%R]eafS0%What*does*it*take*to*mainstream*disaster*risk**
management*in*key*sectors?0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hh:?P(0'*#hMBN%
:'()$()h-B8'"?.h]eafhefh&@X7rD-+?$r5"+(.)*$"C+(#r?*rC"("#$C$()r>+("8r*$ArM$,N*$.0B?>%%
%
3"*,")4%E0/04%X2"V"+4%304%3-*)'(4%&0D04%3$(?+C$*"?4%T04%&"**$K'4%90%p%&"*?'("4%J0@0%R]eabS0%A*Guide*to*
Measuring*Urban*Risk*Resilience:*Principles,*Tools*and*Practice*of*Urban*Indicators0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hh$C+NC$#":+)+$.0'*#hMBN:'()$()h-B8'"?.h]eabhe_hG$.+8+$(:$L(?+:")'*.r!*$N
*$8$".$r5"*:2]eaba0B?>%%
%
3"*:+"4%G0%30%R]eab4%T$,*-"*6%bS0%!2+A'8:.%M"*(.%3+:'8%9DH.%)'%,*":$%>'*%C"#(+)-?$%d%\-"P$.0%Philippines*
News*Agency4%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hhB(",+:'80,8'#.B')0:'Ch]eabhe]hB2+A'8:.NM"*(.N,+:'8N8#-.N)'N
,*":$N>'*02)C8%%
%
3"6"?(+2"(%J*?+("(:$4%ss%aN]e%R]eeaS%
%
3$(?+C$*"?4%T04%I$A"4%;0%p%A'(%F+(.+$?$84%70%R]eae4%J:)',$*S0%%Disaster*Risk*Reduction*of*Highly**
Vulnerable*Urban*Areas*through*Urban*Re%Development*Case*Study*of*Barangay*Rizal,*Makati,*
Philippines0%!"B$*%B*$.$()$?%")%)2$%k)2%I6CB'.+-C%'(%7$M%<$:2('8'#+$.%>'*%H*,"(%I">$)6%'>%
5$#"%&+)+$.4%X',$4%1"B"(0%
%
3$(.'(4%&0%R]eekS0%Mainstreaming*Disaster*Risk*reduction*into*Development:*Challenges*and*Experiences**
in*the*Philippines0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hh+B::NM#]0#'Ah(U8+)$r?'M(8'"?0B2Bt+?uckkc%
%
&"8+>'*(+"%G$.+?$()+"8%5+)+#")+'(%!*'#*"C0%R(0?0S0%F"*)2\-"P$%3*":$%v%3'8)%RF33S0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%%
2))B^hhMMM0$"*)2\-"P$,*":$,'8)0:'Ch%
%
&+)+$.%@$A$8'BC$()%L(+)+")+A$%>'*%E.+"%R&@LES.*R]eaaS0%Project*Overview:*Naga*City,*The*Philippines0%%
G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hh:?+"0".+"h]eaahekh]dhB*'U$:)N'A$*A+$MN)2$NB2+8+BB+($.N("#"N:+)6h%%
%
&+)6%"(?%&'-()6%'>%I"(%T*"(:+.:'0%Earthquake*Safety*Implementation*Program0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%%
2))B^hhMMM0.>#."0'*#h+(?$Q0".BQtB"#$ucefd%
%
@$8"%&*-V4%E04%/$*("(?$V4%G0%p%3'(+>":+'4%90%R]ea_S0%Accessing*the*People's*Survival*Fund:*Finding*the**

EK"#"!"#$"
"
Right*Balance*With*Access*Modalities*and*Institutional*Arrangements*for*the*PSF0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hhMMM0$U$$B($60'*#hMBN:'()$()h-B8'"?.h]ea_hekhE::$..+(#N)2$N!$'B8$.NI-*A+A"8N
T-(?r+&I&0B?>%%
%
F"*)2\-"P$.%"(?%5$#":+)+$.%L(+)+")+A$%RF5LS0%R]eabS0%Urban*Resilience*Master*Planning:*A*Guidebook*for*
Practitioners*and*Policymakers0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hh$C+NC$#":+)+$.0'*#hMBN
:'()$()h-B8'"?.h]eabhe_hHG5!r!*$N*$8$".$r5"*:2]eaba0B?>%%
%
F8:"C$84%F0%R]ee]4%I$B)$C,$*%]fN]cS0%Managing*Urban*Disasters:*The*Naga*City*Experience*on*Mitigation**
and*Planning0%L(%!*':$$?+(#.%'>%)2$%G$#+'("8%='*P.2'B%'(%3$.)%!*":)+:$.%+(%@+.".)$*%5+)+#")+'(%
RBB0%]eeN]e_S0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hhB?>0-."+?0#'AhB?>r?':.hB("?Pjjc0B?>%%
%
T+#-$*'"4%G010%p%/-)"#"'84%50%R]eafS0%Empowering*the*Urban*Poor:*The*Case*of*‘Kaantabay*sa*
Kauswagan’*Program%w!*$V+%>*"C$.%R.8+?$.Sx0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B.^hhB*$V+0:'ChC,*UB"+,2(PehB"*)($*.N>'*N
?$A$8'BC$()ht-)Cr:"CB"+#(u.2"*$p-)CrC$?+-Cu:'B6%*
%
T-U+C+4%<0%p%<")"('4%/0%R]ea_S0%!*'C')+(#%I$+.C+:%G$)*'>+)%LCB8$C$()")+'(%<2*'-#2%m7-?#$n^%="**"()6%
".%"%%
@*+A$*0%Risk*Analysis4%33%RaeS4%adbdNadd_0%
%
D"884%504%&-))$*4%I090%p%7#-6$(4%X0%R]eafS0%Incentives*for*Disaster*Risk*Management%RLG@G%ELG@G%%
!-,8+:")+'(%7'0%]S0%3$+U+(#4%&2+("^%L()$#*")$?%G$.$"*:2%'(%@+.".)$*%G+.P%
%
D$4%y04%!$":':P4%=0D0%p%9+(?$884%50X0%R]eaaS0%T8'*+?"%/'-.$2'8?.Z%FQB$:)$?%G$.B'(.$.%)'%/-**+:"($%%
/"V"*?%5+)+#")+'(%L(:$()+A$.0%Risk*Analysis4%_aRaeS4%acjcNacka0%%
%
L(.-*"(:$%&'CC+..+'(%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.%RL&S0%R(0?0S0%Magpaseguro*Para*Protektado:*A*Roadmap*to**
Financial*Literacy*on*Micro*Insurance0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hhMMM0+(.-*"(:$0#'A0B2hC+:*'h2)C8h00ob&00ob&rz?C+(ob&-B8'"?ob&C+:*'ob&*'"?C"B0
B?>%%
%
1'($.4%E0%p%9"(#4%90%R]eejS0%Sustaining*the*Kaantabay*Sa*Kauswagan*in*Naga*City:*Strenghts,*Challenges**
and*Recommendations%w!'M$*!'+()%.8+?$.x0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hhMMM0.8+?$.2"*$0($)hU":P*6"(cdh.-.)"+(+(#N)2$NP""()","6N."NP"-.M"#"(NB*'#*"C%%
%
9$#":+'(4%70I0%R]ea_4%@$:$C,$*%bS0%I!%/LD/9LD/<I^%7"#"%*+A$*%*$2",+8+)")+'(%"(?%?$A$8'BC$()%>-(?0%%
Bicol*Mail.%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hhMMM0,+:'8C"+80:'Ch]ea]htBua]dfc%%
%
5"(+8"%3-88$)+(0%R]eabS0%Phivolcs*warns*of*magnitude%8*quake*in*Bicol.*G$)*+$A$?%>*'C*
2))B^hhMMM0C,0:'C0B2hB2+A'8:.NM"*(.N'>NC"#(+)-?$NdN\-"P$N+(N,+:'8h%
%
5+:*'+(.-*"(:$%!*+C$*0%R]eaaS0%Microinsurance*Philippines.%@$-).:2$%D$.$88.:2">)%>-*%L()$*(")+'("8$%
RDLWS0%G$)*+$A$?%T*'C^%2))B^hhC+:*'+(.-*"(:$0B2h+(?$Q0B2Bt+?u",'-)NC+:*'+(.-*"(:$`Ba\a0%%%
%

EA"#"!"#$"
"
Naga*City,*Camarines*Sur,*Philippines4%
2))B^hhMMM0V"C,'"(#"0:'ChVh+(?$Q0B2Bt)+)8$u7"#"r&+)64r&"C"*+($.rI-*4r!2+8+BB+($.%R8".)%C'?+>+$?%
aa%I$B%]ea_S0%
%
7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%R7&DS0%R]eafS0%Exec.*Order*No.*2014%019,*§§*1%12*(2014)0%
%
7&D0%R(0?0S0%Incentives0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hhMMM0("#"0#'A0B2h+(A$.)C$().h+(:$()+A$.02)C8%%
%
7&D0%R]eaaS0%Comprehensive*Development*Plan*2011%20200%
%
7&D0%R]ee]S0%Comprehensive*Land*Use*Plan*20020%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hhMMM0("#"0#'A0B2h:+)6B*'>+8$h(:8-B0B?>%%
%
7&D0%R]eafS0%Local*Disaster*Risk*Reduction*and*Management*Fund%Annual*Investment*Plan0%w7"#"%&+)64%
!2+8+BB+($.x0%
%
7&D0%R]eabS0%Local*Disaster*Risk*Reduction*and*Management*Fund%Annual*Investment*Plan0%w7"#"%&+)64%
!2+8+BB+($.x0%
%
7&D0%RakkjS0%<2$%X""()","6%."%X"-.M"#"(%J*?+("(:$4%LNYLL%ss%aNfe%RakkjS0%
%
7&D0%R]eafS0%Local*Disaster*Risk*Reduction*and*Management*Fund%Annual*Investment*Plan0%w7"#"%&+)64%%
!2+8+BB+($.x^%E-)2'*%
%
7"#"%&+)6%IC+8$.%")%)2$%='*8?4%7"#"%&+)6%T":$,''P%R]eabS4%
2))B.^hhMMM0>":$,''P0:'ChC$?+"h.$)ht.$)u"0k_acj]j_cdd_fjd0aej_jf]e_d0a]]bkjfaaa]f_b]p)6B$
u_S%%
%
7&D%p%7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*("(:$%L(.)+)-)$%R7&DLS0%R(0?0S0%X""()","6%."%X"-.M"#"(%!*'U$:)^%FCB'M$*+(#%)2$%
H*,"(%!''*%+(%7"#"%&+)64%!2+8+BB+($.%w!'M$*!'+()%.8+?$.x0%w7"#"%&+)64%!2+8+BB+($.x^%E-)2'*%
%
7"#"%&+)6%L(A$.)C$()%L(:$()+A$.%&'?$4%LNYLL%ss%aNcb%RakkjS%
%
7")+'("8%&'CB$)+)+A$($..%&'-(:+8%R7&&S0%R]eafS0%Naga*City*(CS)0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%%
2))B^hhMMM0:'CB$)+)+A$0'*#0B2h:C:+(?$Qh:+)6B*'>+8$0B2Bt:+)6u7"#"o]e&+)6o]eo]d&Io]k%%
%
7")+'("8%I)*-:)-*"8%&'?$%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%L%ss%aeaNaek%R]eaeS%
%
!2+8+BB+($%I)")+.)+:.%E-)2'*+)6%R!IES0%Population*of*Camarines*Sur*reached*1.8*Million*(Results*from*the**
2010*Census*of*Population*and*Housing)0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hhM$,e0B."0#'A0B2h:'()$()hB'B-8")+'(N:"C"*+($.N.-*N*$":2$?NadNC+88+'(N*$.-8).N]eaeN
:$(.-.NB'B-8")+'(N"(?N2'-.+(#%%
%
!2+8+BB+($.%/".%<2$%9$".)%L(.-*"(:$%!$($)*")+'(%L(%E.+"%O%!2+8"C%I-*A$60%R]ea_4%1"(-"*6%_S0%Manila**
Bulletin0%G$)*+$A$?%T*'C^%2))B.^hhB20($M.06"2''0:'ChB2+8+BB+($.N8$".)N+(.-*"(:$NB$($)*")+'(N
".+"NB2+8"CN.-*A$6Nekejbb]]bNN>+("(:$02)C8%
%

EE"#"!"#$"
"
!2+8+BB+($.%&8+C")$%&2"(#$%E:)%'>%]eek%RG$B-,8+:%E:)%7'0%aeajfS%
%
!2+8+BB+($.%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%E:)%'>%]eae%RG$B-,8+:%E:)%7'0%aea]aS%
%
!2+8+BB+($.%/".%<2$%9$".)%L(.-*"(:$%!$($)*")+'(%L(%E.+"%O%!2+8"C%I-*A$60%R]ea_4%1"(-"*6%_S0%Manila*
Bulletin0%G$)*+$A$?%T*'C^%2))B.^hhB20($M.06"2''0:'ChB2+8+BB+($.N8$".)N+(.-*"(:$NB$($)*")+'(N".+"N
B2+8"CN.-*A$6Nekejbb]]bNN>+("(:$02)C8*
%
!2+8+BB+($%I)")+.)+:.%E-)2'*+)6%R!IES0%Population*of*Camarines*Sur*reached*1.8*Million*(Results*from*the*
2010*Census*of*Population*and*Housing)0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hhM$,e0B."0#'A0B2h:'()$()hB'B-8")+'(N
:"C"*+($.N.-*N*$":2$?NadNC+88+'(N*$.-8).N]eaeN:$(.-.NB'B-8")+'(N"(?N2'-.+(#%%
%
G$B-,8+:%E:)%7'0%cbfa4%LNYYL%ss%aN]a%RakjjS%
%
G$B-,8+:%E:)%7'0%aea]a4%ss%aN_e%R]eaeS%
%
G$B-,8+:%E:)%7'0%kj]k4%ss%aN]c%R]eekS%
%
G$B-,8+:%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($.4%@$B"*)C$()%'>%T+("(:$%p%L(.-*"(:$%&'CC+..+'(0%R]eafS0%X$6%I)")+.)+:"8%@")"4%%
]eek%N%]ea_0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hhMMM0+(.-*"(:$0#'A0B2hrz?C+(h-B8'"?h.)")+.)+:.hX$6r@")"r]ea_0B?>%
%
I-{*$V4%@0&0%%R]eaaS0%Disaster*Risk*Reduction*in*Latin*America,*Improving*Tools*and*Methods*Regarding**
Climate*Change:*The*Case*Study*of*Colombia*and*the*City*of*Manizales0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hh+?$"0C"(+V"8$.0-("80$?-0:'h#$.)+'(r*+$.#'.h?$.:"*#".h@GG+(9")+(EC$*+:"0B?>%%
%
I-?C$+$*NG+$-Q4%X04%T*"%!"8$'4%H04%D"*.:2"#$(4%504%F.)*$88"4%504%G$("-?4%T0D0%p%1",'6$?'>>4%50%R]eafS0%%
Opportunities,*Incentives*and*Challenges*to*Risk*Sensitive*Land*Use*Planning:*Lessons*from*Nepal,*
Spain*and*Vietnam0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hhMMM0B*$A$()+'(M$,0($)h$(#8+.2h26'#'h#"*h]ea_h$(%
h,#?':.hI-?C$+$*NG+$-Qo]e$)0"80o]e]ea]0B?>%
%
H(+)$?%7")+'(.%/-C"(%I$))8$C$().%!*'#*"CC$%RH7N/",+)")S0%R]eabS0%Government*of*India*Supports**
Housing*Efforts*in*Sri*Lanka0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C^%2))B^hh-(2",+)")0'*#h#'A$*(C$()N'>N+(?+"N.-BB'*).N
2'-.+(#N$>>'*).N+(N.*+N8"(P"h%
%
='*8?%3"(P0%R]eafS0%Philippines*%*Disaster*Risk*Management*Development*Loan*with*a*Catastrophe**
Deferred*Drawdown*Option*(CAT*DDO):*P125943*%*Implementation*Status*Results*Report:*
Sequence*060%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%2))B^hhMMMN
M?.0M'*8?,"(P0'*#h$Q)$*("8h?$>"-8)h=@I&'()$()I$*A$*h=@I!hFE!h]eafhaah]fheke]]f,ed]dd"
k$dharehG$(?$*$?h!@Th!2+8+BB+($.eeeeG$B'*)eeeI$\-$(:$eec0B?>%
%
='*8?%3"(P%"(?%F5L0%R]eafS0%Legal*and*Institutional*Arrangements*Framework*Guidebook0%w[-$V'(%&+)64%
!2+8+BB+($.x^%F5L0%
%
='*8?%3"(P%"(?%F5L0%R]eafS0%Risk*Sensitive*Land*Use*Planning*Guidebook0%w[-$V'(%&+)64%!2+8+BB+($.x^%
F5L0%%
%

EO"#"!"#$"
"
='*8?%=+?$%T-(?%>'*%7")-*$%R==TS%!2+8+BB+($.%p%3"(P%'>%)2$%!2+8+BB+($%L.8"(?.%R3!LS%T'-(?")+'(0%
R]ea_S0%%
Business*Risk*Assessment*and*the*Management*of*Climate*Change*Impacts0%G$)*+$A$?%>*'C%
2))B^hhMM>0'*#0B2hMM>_h?'M(8'"?.hB-,8+:")+'(.h3-.+($..o]eG+.Po]eE..$..C$()o]e"(?o]e)2
$o]e5"("#$C$()o]e'>o]e&8+C")$o]e&2"(#$o]eLCB":).o]eNo]ea]o]e&+)+$.0B?>%%
\,,*c"\F"\99!9%0,4*"%("%H*"/010"$!%&"'()*+,-*,%"!,"%H*"SI50%!,1"(."%H*!+"$:S2"
%
Rationale!for!assisting!Naga!City!with!their!CLUP!updating!
L(%)2$%:'-*.$%'>%?$A$8'B+(#%)2$%:".$%.)-?+$.%'(%GI9H!%"(?%+(:$()+A$.%>'*%-*,"(%@GG%+(%7"#"%&+)64%)2$%
F5L%.)-?6%)$"C%+?$()+>+$?%>'-*%P$6%:2"88$(#$.%B*$A$()+(#%)2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%>*'C%-B?")+(#%)2$%&9H!4%
("C$86^%
KM!<2$%)$:2(+:"8%M'*P+(#%#*'-B.%)".P$?%M+)2%&9H!%-B?")+(#%"*$%(')%>"C+8+"*%M+)2%"BB*'":2$.%>'*%
+()$#*")+(#%*+.P%B"*"C$)$*.%+()'%)2$%&9H!%".%B*$.:*+,$?%+(%)2$%($M%/9HG3%#-+?$8+($.0%
AM!<2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%2".%C"?$%8+C+)$?%-.$%'>%"::$..+,8$%.:+$(:$N,".$?%>8''?%2"V"*?%+(>'*C")+'(0%
EM!<2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%8":P.%)2$%+()$*("8%:"B":+)6%)'%:'88$:)%"(?%B*':$..%.B")+"8%?")"%"(?%
+(>'*C")+'(%'(%8':"8%2"V"*?.4%$QB'.-*$%"(?%A-8($*",+8+)+$.0%
OM!<2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%?$B"*)C$().%"8.'%8":P%)2$%:"B":+)6%)'%-B?")$%$Q+.)+(#%.B")+"8%*+.P%
+(>'*C")+'(%)2")%)2$6%2"A$%'(%2"(?0%
<2*$$%":)+A+)+$.%M$*$%:"**+$?%'-)%)'%"??*$..%)2$.$%:2"88$(#$.%"(?%.-BB'*)%)2$%7&D%+(%+(:'*B'*")+(#%
2"V"*?%"(?%*+.P%+(>'*C")+'(%+()'%)2$+*%&9H!0%<2$.$%+(:8-?$?^%
KM!L?$()+>6+(#%($:$.."*6%?")"%"(?%')2$*%+(>'*C")+'(%*$8$A"()%)'%(")-*"8%2"V"*?.%+(%7"#"%&+)64%"(?%
"..+.)"(:$%+(%)2$%":\-+.+)+'(%'>%)2$%($$?$?%?")"g%
AM!!*'A+?+(#%,".+:%DLI%)*"+(+(#%)'%.$8$:)$?%7&D%.)">>%)'%.-BB'*)%)2$%C"BB+(#%*$\-+*$C$().%'>%)2$%
&9H!%-B?")+(#g%
EM!G$A+$M+(#%)2$%?*">)%-B?")$?%7"#"%&+)6%&9H!%"(?%B*'A+?+(#%#-+?"(:$%'(%($Q)%.)$B.%+(%)2$%
-B?")+(#%B*':$..0%
T+#-*$%Ea%+88-.)*")$.%2'M%$":2%'>%)2$%":)+A+)+$.%C$()+'($?%",'A$%"??*$..$?%7"#"%&+)6Z.%:2"88$(#$.%+(%
-B?")+(#%+).%&9H!0%%
%
Overview!of!the!support!activities!
H(?$*%)2$%>+*.)%":)+A+)64%"%:2$:P8+.)%M".%?$A$8'B$?%)'%.$*A$%".%"%#-+?$%>'*%)2$%7&D%'(%)2$%.B$:+>+:%2"V"*?%
"(?%.':+'N$:'('C+:%?")"%*$\-+*$?%)'%-B?")$%)2$+*%&9H!%,".$?%'(%)2$%]eaf%/9HG3%I-BB8$C$()"8%
D-+?$8+($.fb0%<2$%:2$:P8+.)%:'()"+(.%"%8+.)+(#%'>%2"V"*?%C"B.%"(?%)2$%?+>>$*$()%)6B$.%'>%?")"%($:$.."*6%>'*%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
fb%&'B+$.%'>%)2$%]eaf%/9HG3%I-BB8$C$()"8%D-+?$8+($.%:"(%,$%?'M(8'"?$?%>*'C%)2+.%8+(P^%2))B^hh28-*,0#'A0B2hMBN
:'()$()h-B8'"?.h.$*A+:$.h8#-h&9H!h/9HG3rI-BB8$C$()"8rD-+?$8+($.0B?>%

EP"#"!"#$"
"
$QB'.-*$%"("86.+.%"(?%A-8($*",+8+)6%C"BB+(#%)2")%:"(%,$%":\-+*$?%>*'C%(")+'("8%#'A$*(C$()%"#$(:+$.%
"(?%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%?$B"*)C$().0%<'%:'CB8$C$()%)2$%:2$:P8+.)4%"..+.)"(:$%M".%"8.'%B*'A+?$?%)'%)2$%
7&D%+(%?*">)+(#%8$))$*%*$\-$.).%>'*%2"V"*?%?")"%>*'C%)2$%5+($.%"(?%D$'.:+$(:$.%3-*$"-%"(?%)2$%
!2+8+BB+($%L(.)+)-)$%>'*%;'8:"('8'#6%"(?%I$+.C'8'#60%<2$%:2$:P8+.)%"(?%."CB8$%8$))$*.%"*$%+(%)2$%"))":2$?%
E(($Q$.%3%"(?%&4%*$.B$:)+A$860%
T'*%)2$%.$:'(?%":)+A+)64%"%)*"+(+(#%M'*P.2'B%'(%)2$%-.$%'>%DLI%+(%*+.PN.$(.+)+A$%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%M".%
:'(?-:)$?%")%)2$%3+:'8%I:+$(:$%"(?%<$:2('8'#6%&$()*-C%+(%7"#"%&+)6%>*'C%J:)0%jNk4%]eab0%%<2$%+()$()%'>%
)2$%M'*P.2'B%M".%,-+8?+(#%)2$%:"B":+)6%'>%.$8$:)$?%7&D%.)">>%'(%)2$%>'88'M+(#^%%
a0%H.$%'>%DLI%+(%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"((+(#4%%
]0%3".+:%DLI%)''8.%"(?%"BB8+:")+'(.4%%
_0%5"B%B*$B"*")+'(4%%
f0%D$($*"8%:'(:$B).%'>%2"V"*?4%A-8($*",+8+)6%"(?%*+.P%"..$..C$()4%%
b0%L?$()+>+:")+'(%"(?%A+.-"8+V")+'(%'>%2"V"*?.%"(?%$QB'.-*$4%"(?%%
c0%L?$()+>+:")+'(%'>%2+#2%*+.P%"*$".%R+0$04%2').B').S0%
=99D*9"+*60%*5"%("$:S2"DI50%!,1"!,"/010"$!%&%
% %
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
"
9+C+)$?%"::$..%)'%
+(>'*C")+'(%'(%
:+)6N.B$:+>+:%
?+.".)$*%*+.P.%
9":P%'>%>"C+8+"*+)6%
+(%+()$#*")+(#%*+.P%
B"*"C$)$*.%+()'%
)2$%&9H!%
9":P%'>%+()$*("8%:"B":+)6%
)'%:'88$:)%"(?%B*':$..%
.B")+"8%?")"%"(?%
+(>'*C")+'(%'(%8':"8%
2"V"*?.4%$QB'.-*$%"(?%
A-8($*",+8+)+$.%
9+C+)$?%"A"+8",+8+)6%
'>%.:+$(:$N,".$?%
>8''?%2"V"*?%"(?%
*+.P%+(>'*C")+'(%
@$A$8'B%"%:2$:P8+.)%'>%2"V"*?%"(?%
.':+'N$:'('C+:%?")"%($$?.%
*$\-+*$?%>'*%+()$#*")+(#%*+.P%
B"*"C$)$*.%+()'%)2$%&9H!%
%
!*'A+?$%,".+:%DLI%)*"+(+(#%)'%
.$8$:)$?%7&D%.)">>%)'%.-BB'*)%)2$%
C"BB+(#%*$\-+*$C$().%'>%&9H!%
-B?")+(#%
!*'A+?$%$QB$*)%#-+?"(:$%'(%($Q)%
.)$B.%+(%+()$#*")+(#%*+.P%
B"*"C$)$*.%+()'%)2$%-B?")$?%&9H!%

ET"#"!"#$"
"
3DII(+%"I+()!5*5"%("/010"$!%&".(+"$:S2"DI50%!,1%
""""""""""""
J!1D+*"\KM"\4%!)!%!*9"055+*99!,1"/010"$!%&_9"4H066*,1*9"!,"DI50%!,1"!%9"$:S2

ET"#"!"#$"
"
<2$%DLI%M'*P.2'B%:'A$*$?%)2$%>'88'M+(#%)'B+:.^%
%
a0!@")",".$%5"("#$C$()%%
d0!<",8$%\-$*6+(#%
]0!@+#+)+V+(#%
k0!IB")+"8%\-$*6+(#%
_0!<",8$%C"(+B-8")+'(%R!'B-8")+(#%
>$")-*$.%M+)2%"))*+,-)$.S%
ae0!<",8$%C"(+B-8")+'(%R1'+(+(#%)",8$.%>*'C%
$Q:$8%>+8$.%"(?%&I;%>+8$.S%
f0!G$.'-*:$%C"BB+(#%
aa0!3->>$*%"("86.+.%
b0!5"(+B-8")+(#%.6C,'8'#6%
%
a]0!D$'B*':$..+(#%)''8.%R1'+(+(#%"))*+,-)$.%
'>%?+>>$*$()%.2"B$>+8$.h8"6$*.S%
c0!/"V"*?%'A$*8"6%
a_0!<",8$%C"(+B-8")+'(%RH.+(#%)2$%>+$8?%
:"8:-8")'*S%
j0!;+.-"8+V+(#%$QB'.-*$%
%
%
<2$%M'*P.2'B%M".%"))$(?$?%,6%]_%B"*)+:+B"().%>*'C%)2$%>'88'M+(#%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%?$B"*)C$().^%%%
a0%!8"((+(#%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%J>>+:$%R_%*$B*$.$()")+A$.S4%%
]0%F(#+($$*+(#%J>>+:$%Ra%*$B*$.$()")+A$S4%%
_0%E..$..'*Z.%J>>+:$%R]%*$B*$.$()")+A$.S4%%
f0%@+.".)$*%G+.P%G$?-:)+'(%"(?%5"("#$C$()%J>>+:$%R_%*$B*$.$()")+A$.S4%%
b0%F(A+*'(C$()%"(?%7")-*"8%G$.'-*:$.%J>>+:$%R_%*$B*$.$()")+A$.S4%%
c0%L(>'*C")+'(%<$:2('8'#6%J>>+:$%Ra%*$B*$.$()")+A$S4%%
j0%%&'CC-(+)6N3".$?%5'(+)'*+(#%I6.)$C%Rf%*$B*$.$()")+A$.S4%%
d0%7"#"%&+)6%!'8+:$%J>>+:$%Rc%*$B*$.$()")+A$.S0%%
I"CB8$.%'>%)2$%B"*)+:+B"().Z%'-)B-).%>*'C%)2$%M'*P.2'B%"*$%B*'A+?$?%,$8'M0%

EV"#"!"#$"
"
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
""""""""""""""""""""""""""J!1D+*"\AM"?(%06"0..*4%*5"H(D9*H(659"6(40%*5"N!%H!,"KZZ-".+(-"%H*"+!)*+"
"
%
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""J!1D+*"\EM"J6((5W0..*4%*5"H(D9*H(659"N!%H"6!-!%*5"044*99"%("H(9I!%069%

EX"#"!"#$"
"
<2$*$%M".%.'C$%?+>>+:-8)6%+(%:"**6+(#%'-)%)2$%)2+*?%":)+A+)64%".%)2$%7&D%2"?%(')%6$)%:'CB8$)$?%)2$%?*">)%A$*.+'(%
'>%+).%-B?")$?%&9H!%")%)2$%)+C$%'>%)2$%.-,C+..+'(%'>%)2+.%*$B'*)0%L(%B8":$%'>%"%*$A+$M%'>%)2$%-B?")$?%&9H!4%
.$A$*"8%.$..+'(.%M$*$%:'(?-:)$?%?-*+(#%)2$%DLI%)*"+(+(#%M'*P.2'B%>':-.$?%'(%B*'A+?+(#%"??+)+'("8%
*$:'CC$(?")+'(.%)'%"..+.)%)2$%7&D%+(%C"+(.)*$"C+(#%@GG%+()'%)2$+*%8"(?%-.$%B8"(0%<2$.$%.$..+'(.%>':-.$?%'(%
)2$%>'88'M+(#^%
•!7$$?%>'*%+()$#*")+(#%@GG%+(%)2$%&9H!%
•!L?$()+>6+(#%@GG%$()*6%B'+().%+(%)2$%&9H!%%
•!L?$()+>6+(#%:'(?+)+'(.%)2")%+(:*$".$%*+.P.%+(%-*,"(%"*$".%
•!&2''.+(#%*+.P%*$?-:)+'(%.)*")$#+$.%
•!LCB8+:")+'(.%'>%2"V"*?%"(?%*+.P%C"BB+(#%'(%7"#"%&+)6%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%"(?%-*,"(%?$A$8'BC$()0%
%
Next!steps%
<2$%)2*$$%":)+A+)+$.%"::'CB8+.2$?%)2$%>'88'M+(#^%
a0!I$(.+)+V$?%)2$%?$B"*)C$()%2$"?.%"(?%)$:2(+:"8%.)">>%>*'C%)2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%'(%)2$%:'(:$B).%'>%
2"V"*?4%A-8($*",+8+)6%"(?%*+.P4%"(?%)2$%+CB'*)"(:$%'>%:'(.+?$*+(#%)2$.$%:'(:$B).%+(%)2$%:'()$Q)%'>%)2$+*%
&9H!%-B?")+(#g%
]0!!*'A+?$?%)2$%&+)6%!8"((+(#%"(?%@$A$8'BC$()%J>>+:$%M+)2%"%:8$"*%+?$"%'>%)2$%.B$:+>+:%)6B$.%'>%
+(>'*C")+'(%R2"V"*?%C"B.%"(?%.':+'N$:'('C+:%?")"S%*$\-+*$?%>'*%+()$#*")+(#%?+.".)$*%*+.P%+()'%)2$+*%
&9H!4%".%M$88%".%)2$%.'-*:$.%>*'C%M2$*$%.-:2%?")"%:"(%,$%*$\-$.)$?g%
_0!FQB"(?$?%)2$%(-C,$*%'>%)$:2(+:"8%.)">>%:"B",8$%'>%:"**6+(#%'-)%,".+:%2"V"*?4%$QB'.-*$%"(?%*+.P%
C"BB+(#%>-(:)+'(.%)'%.-BB'*)%)2$%+()$#*")+'(%'>%*+.P%B"*"C$)$*.%+()'%)2$%&9H!g%
f0!L?$()+>+$?%$()*6%B'+().%M2$*$%($M86%":\-+*$?%2"V"*?4%A-8($*",+8+)6%"(?%*+.P%R/;GS%+(>'*C")+'(%:"(%,$%
+()$#*")$?%+()'%)2$%&9H!%B*':$..4%"(?%B*'A+?$?%#-+?$%\-$.)+'(.%'(%2'M%)'%$A"8-")$%)2$%+CB8+:")+'(.%'>%
.-:2%+(>'*C")+'(%'(%8"(?%-.$%B8"((+(#%+(%7"#"%&+)60%
=2+8$%)2$.$%":)+A+)+$.%2"A$%B*'A+?$?%"??+)+'("8%:"B":+)6%"(?%:'(>+?$(:$%)'%)2$%7"#"%&+)6%D'A$*(C$()%>'*%
-B?")+(#%+).%&9H!4%.$A$*"8%P$6%"(?%:'CB8$Q%)".P.%.)+88%($$?%)'%,$%:"**+$?%'-)%,6%)2$%:+)6%#'A$*(C$()%+(%'*?$*%)'%
:'CB8$)$%+).%8"(?%-.$%B8"(%-B?")+(#4%.B$:+>+:"886^%
a0!E:\-+*$%)2$%*$\-+*$?%2"V"*?%C"B.%"(?%.':+'N$:'('C+:%?")"g%%
]0!L()$#*")$%)2$%/;G%+(>'*C")+'(%+()'%)2$%.+)-")+'("8%"("86.+.%"(?%?$A$8'B%2"V"*?%'A$*8"6.4%"::'*?+(#%)'%
)2$%]eaf%/9HG3%D-+?$8+($.g%
_0!L()$*B*$)%)2$%/;G%+(>'*C")+'(%"(?%+?$()+>6%+).%+CB8+:")+'(.%)'%)2$%&9H!%"(?%')2$*%?$A$8'BC$()%B8"(.g%
f0!G$A+$M%"(?%*$A+.$%)2$%>'88'M+(#%+)$C.4%+(%8+#2)%'>%)2$%($M%/;G%+(>'*C")+'(%"(?%+?$()+>+$?%+CB8+:")+'(.^%
%
%

EY"#"!"#$"
"
"0!;+.+'(%.)")$C$()%
,0!5"U'*%B*',8$C.4%+..-$.%"(?%'BB'*)-(+)+$.%+(%)2$%.$:)'*"8%"("86.+.%
:0!L?$()+>+$?%8"(?%-.$%+..-$.%
?0!9"(?%-.$%+..-$%C")*+Q%
$0!L(A$()'*6%'>%8"(?%-.$.%
>0!9"(?%-.$%"(?%V'(+(#%B8"(%B*'B'."8.%
#0!@$A$8'BC$()%.)*")$#+$.4%"8)$*(")+A$%.B")+"8%.)*")$#+$.4%"(?%?$A$8'BC$()%:'()*'8.g%
%
b0!!*$B"*$%"%($M%.)*-:)-*$%B8"(g%
c0!@$)"+8%)2$%#$($*"8h-*,"(%8"(?%-.$%B8"(g%
j0!@$A$8'B%)2$%B'8+:+$.4%.)*")$#+$.4%V'(+(#%"(?%')2$*%+CB8$C$()+(#%)''8.%R$0#0%*$#-8")+'(.4%+(:$()+A$.S%>'*%
)2$%B*$>$**$?%B8"(g%
d0!@*">)%)2$%W'(+(#%J*?+("(:$g%"(?%
k0!&'CB8$)$%)2$%&'CB*$2$(.+A$%@$A$8'BC$()%!8"(%>'*%)2$%:+)60%
%
=2+8$%7&D%.2'M.%+(.)+)-)+'("8%M+88+(#($..%)'%:'CB8$)$%+).%G+.PN.$(.+)+A$%&9H!4%)2$*$%"*$%.)+88%.6.)$C+:%
M$"P($..$.%+(%)2$%)$:2(+:"8%:"B":+)6%)2")%:'-8?%2+(?$*%"%.")+.>":)'*6%'-):'C$0%%5'*$%.-.)"+($?%)$:2(+:"8%
.-.)"+($?%.-BB'*)%M+88%,$%*$\-+*$?%)'%B*'?-:$%"%:'CB$)$()%GI9H!%"(?%$(.-*$%$(>'*:$C$()%"(?%C'(+)'*+(#%
B*':$..$.%"*$%+(%B8":$0%%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
% %

!
!"#$#"#$%#
#
%&&'(#)*#+,'-./012#34#567689#:6;1#6&9#<626#=3>8-'1#?:39040'9#483@#=>;;/'@'&26/#A>09'/0&'1#B"C!D#5EFG)H#
567689#
:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
=-6/'!J#
G'@68.1!K#
%L60/6M/'#
N38@62!O#
<62>@*#
G'4'8'&-'*#
=-6/'*#
%-P>08'9#
&'(()!
*+,-%./010'0/2!
304%,!#4)!
5%(,-0%4-%,!
6+7%#+!
89:;<;;;=>!
!!
!!
?%.0-/,!#7%#,!,+,-%./01'%!
/(!@'((),<!-'#,,0@0%)!#,!
A0$A<!B()%7#/%!#4)!'(C!
C0/A!,+..'%B%4/#'!
04@(7B#/0(4!(4!@'(()!
A%0$A/,D!EF#0'#1'%!@(7!
,%'%-/%)!7%$0(4,<!
.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,D!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!
F0%C%)!/A7(+$A!
A//.9GG$)0,D)%47D$(FD.AG
H%,!
89!:;<;;;!
!
!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
=I!3#J%!,+7%!$%($7#.A0-!7%@%7%4-%!#4)!)#/+B!0,!.7(F0)%)!#4)!.7%@%7#1'2!7%K+%,/!@(7!,A#.%@0'%,!(7!A0$A!7%,('+/0(4!)0$0/#'!B#.,!
=L!E'C#2,!#,J!@(7!#--(B.#4204$!/%-A40-#'!7%.(7/!M0@!#42N!
=O!E,J!2(+7!5P*!,.%-0#'0,/!@(7!/A%!)%/#0',!
=>!89:;<;;;QQ!P4)0-#/0F%!B#.,!+,%@+'!@(7!!!$%4%7#'!.'#4404$!.+7.(,%,R!%F#'+#/0(4!(@!04@7#!#4)!A(+,04$!.7(S%-/,R!!/A7%#/%4%)!B+40-0.#'0/0%,!#4)!-0/0%,!!!
!!898;<;;;!#4)!A0$A%7!QQ?%@040/0F%!B#.,!@(7!$%4%7#'!.'#4404$<!%4$04%%704$!C(7J,<!'(-#/04$!%F#-+#/0(4!T7%'(-#/0(4!,0/%,<!)%/#0'%)!'#4)!+,%!.'#4404$<!#,,%,,04$!
%,-#.%!7(+/%,!#4)!@(7!'#4)!U(404$!
!

!
!C#$#"#$%#
#
567689#
:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
=-6/'!J#
G'@68.1!K#
%L60/6M/'#
N38@62!O#
<62>@*#
G'4'8'&-'*#
=-6/'*#
%-P>08'9#
B$1F0%C%7G!
!
"A0'0..04%!
E/B(,.A%70-<!
5%(.A2,0-#'!#4)!
E,/7(4(B0-#'!*%7F0-%,!
E)B040,/7#/0(4!
M"E5E*E:;N<!V@@0-%!(@!
W0F0'!?%@%4,%!MXYE?H!
"7(S%-/N!
89:;<;;;<!
898;<;;;!
P)%4/0@0%,!#7%#,!.7(4%!/(!
@'((),!7%.7%,%4/04$!#!
C(7,/!-#,%!,-%4#70(D!
*%'%-/%)!.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,!
$%4%7#/%)!/A7(+$A!/A%!
XYE?H!"7(S%-/D!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!
F0%C%)!
/A7(+$A!
A//.9GGCCCD4)77B-D$(FD
.AG!
Z(!
!
!
!
?%.#7/B%4/!(@!*-0%4-%!
#4)![%-A4('($2Q!
Z#/0(4C0)%!
V.%7#/0(4#'!
E,,%,,B%4/!(@!\#U#7),!
"7(S%-/!M?V*[QZVE\N<!
]#70(+,!
3#.!
*-#'%,!
&'(()!A#U#7)!B#.,!(@!
,%'%-/%)!#7%#,!C0/A04!8O!
B#S(7!70F%7!1#,04,D!
"7(F0)%,!@'(()!04+4)#/0(4!
U(4%,!#7%!1#,%)!@7(B!:Q<!
8;Q<!^:Q<!:;Q<!#4)!8;;Q
H%,!
!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:;!X%K+%,/!@(7!/7#0404$QC(7J,A(.,!#1(+/!A(C!/(!.7%.#7%!-'0B#/%!-A#4$%!.7(S%-/0(4,!@(7!W#B#704%,!*+7D!

!
!B#$#"#$%#
#
567689#
:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
=-6/'!J#
G'@68.1!K#
%L60/6M/'#
N38@62!O#
<62>@*#
G'4'8'&-'*#
=-6/'*#
%-P>08'9#
?XXYE3!"7(S%-/!
2%#7!7#04@#''!7%-+77%4-%!
04/%7F#'<!C0/A!04)0-#/0F%!
@'(()!A%0$A/,D!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!@(7!
,%'%-/%)!#7%#,!-#4!1%!
F%70@0%)!/A7(+$A!
A//.9GG4(#AD)(,/D$(FD.AG!
!
X#04Q04)+-%)!
_#4),'0)%!
304%,!#4)!
5%(,-0%4-%,!
6+7%#+!
89:;<;;;!
8R8;<;;;!
M04K+07%!0@!
#F#0'#1'%N!
?%.0-/,!#7%#,!,+,-%./01'%!
/(!7#04Q04)+-%)!'#4),'0)%<!
-'#,,0@0%)!#,!A0$A<!
B()%7#/%!#4)!'(CD!
EF#0'#1'%!@(7!,%'%-/%)!
7%$0(4,<!.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,D!!
!
EF#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!F0%C%)!
/A7(+$A!
A//.9GG$)0,D)%47D$(FD.AG
B$1F0%C%7G!
H%,!M.#7/0#'!
-(F%7#$%!(@!
Z#$#!W0/2N!
89:;<;;;!
898;<;;;!
!
!
!
V@@0-%!(@!W0F0'!
!
?%.0-/,!#7%#,!,+,-%./01'%!
Z(!MVW?N!
!
!

!
!Q#$#"#$%#
#
567689#
:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
=-6/'!J#
G'@68.1!K#
%L60/6M/'#
N38@62!O#
<62>@*#
G'4'8'&-'*#
=-6/'*#
%-P>08'9#
?%@%4,%!MXYE?H!
"7(S%-/N!
/(!7#04Q04)+-%)!'#4),'0)%<!
-'#,,0@0%)!#,!A0$A<!
B()%7#/%!#4)!'(CD!
EF#0'#1'%!@(7!,%'%-/%)!
.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,!
$%4%7#/%)!/A7(+$A!/A%!
XYE?H!"7(S%-/D!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!
F0%C%)!/A7(+$A!
A//.9GGCCCD4)77B-D$(FD
.AG!
57(+4)!
X+./+7%!
"A0'0..04%!P4,/0/+/%!(@!
]('-#4('($2!#4)!
*%0,B('($2!
M"\P]V_W*N:8<!V@@0-%!(@!
W0F0'!?%@%4,%!MXYE?H!
"7(S%-/N!
89:;<;;;!
?%.0-/,!#7%#,!C0/A!J4(C4!
#4)!04@%77%)!@#+'/,D!
*%'%-/%)!.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,!
$%4%7#/%)!/A7(+$A!/A%!
XYE?H!"7(S%-/D!!
!
3#.!
H%,!
M"\P]V_W*N!
!
Z(!MVW?N!
!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:8!X%K+%,/!/7#0404$!C(7J,A(.,!@(7!+/0'0U#/0(4!(@!XY?E*![(('D![7#0404$!(@!`+#4/+B!5P*!M(.%4Q,(+7-%N!0,!#',(!4%-%,,#72!/(!/7#4,@%7!XY?E*!(+/.+/,!/(!5P*!@(7B#/D!

!
!!#$#"#$%#
#
567689#
:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
=-6/'!J#
G'@68.1!K#
%L60/6M/'#
N38@62!O#
<62>@*#
G'4'8'&-'*#
=-6/'*#
%-P>08'9#
#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!F0%C%)!
/A7(+$A!
A//.9GGCCCD4)77B-D$(FD
.AG!
57(+4)!
*A#J04$!
"A0'0..04%!P4,/0/+/%!(@!
]('-#4('($2!#4)!
*%0,B('($2M"\P]V_W*<!!
V@@0-%!(@!W0F0'!?%@%4,%!
MXYE?H!"7(S%-/N!
89:;<;;;!
W(B.(,0/%!$7(+4)!
,A#J04$!'%F%',!1#,%)!(4!
A2.(/A%/0-#'!B#a0B+B!
-7%)01'%!%#7/AK+#J%!
,-%4#70(,D!*%'%-/%)!
.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,!
$%4%7#/%)!/A7(+$A!/A%!
XYE?H!"7(S%-/D!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!
F0%C%)!#/!
A//.9GGCCCD4)77B-D$(FD
.AG!#4)!
A//.9GGCCCD.A0F('-,D)(,/
D$(FD.AG!
H%,!
M"\P]V_W*N!
!
Z(!MVW?N!
!
!
_0K+%@#-/0(4!
"A0'0..04%!P4,/0/+/%!(@!
]('-#4('($2!#4)!
89:;<;;;!
W(B.(,0/%!'0K+%@#-/0(4!
,+,-%./010'0/2!B#.!1#,%)!
H%,!
M"\P]V_W*N!
!
!

!
!R#$#"#$%#
#
567689#
:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
=-6/'!J#
G'@68.1!K#
%L60/6M/'#
N38@62!O#
<62>@*#
G'4'8'&-'*#
=-6/'*#
%-P>08'9#
*%0,B('($2!
M"\P]V_W*N<!V@@0-%!(@!
W0F0'!?%@%4,%!MXYE?H!
"7(S%-/N!
(4!A2.(/A%/0-#'!
B#a0B+B!-7%)01'%!
%#7/AK+#J%!,-%4#70(,D!
*%'%-/%)!.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,!
$%4%7#/%)!/A7(+$A!/A%!
XYE?H!"7(S%-/D!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!
F0%C%)!#/!
A//.9GGCCCD4)77B-D$(FD
.AG!#4)!
A//.9GGCCCD.A0F('-,D)(,/
D$(FD.AG!
!
Z(!MVW?N!
Y#7/AK+#J%Q
04)+-%)!
_#4),'0)%!
"A0'0..04%!P4,/0/+/%!(@!
]('-#4('($2!#4)!
*%0,B('($2!
M"\P]V_W*N<!V@@0-%!(@!
W0F0'!?%@%4,%!MXYE?H!
"7(S%-/N!
89:;<;;;!
W(B.(,0/%!%#7/AK+#J%!
04)+-%)!'#4),'0)%!B#.!
1#,%)!(4!A2.(/A%/0-#'!
B#a0B+B!-7%)01'%!
%#7/AK+#J%!,-%4#70(,D!
*%'%-/%)!.7(F04-%,!#4)!
B+40-0.#'0/0%,G-0/0%,!
$%4%7#/%)!/A7(+$A!/A%!
H%,!
M"\P]V_W*N!
!
Z(!MVW?N!
!
!

!
!J#$#"#$%#
#
567689#
:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
=-6/'!J#
G'@68.1!K#
%L60/6M/'#
N38@62!O#
<62>@*#
G'4'8'&-'*#
=-6/'*#
%-P>08'9#
XYE?H!"7(S%-/D!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!1%!
F0%C%)!#/!
A//.9GGCCCD4)77B-D$(FD
.AG!#4)!
A//.9GGCCCD.A0F('-,D)(,/
D$(FD.AG!
]('-#40-!
\#U#7),!
"A0'0..04%!P4,/0/+/%!(@!
]('-#4('($2!#4)!
*%0,B('($2!
M"\P]V_W*N<!V@@0-%!(@!
W0F0'!?%@%4,%!MXYE?H!
"7(S%-/N!
!
89:;<;;;!
E7%#,!)%.0-/04$!F('-#40-!
#,,(-0#/%)!A#U#7),!
M0D%D!'#A#7!#4)!.27(-'#,/0-!
@'(CND!EF#0'#1'%!@(7!
,%'%-/%)!#-/0F%!F('-#4(%,<!!
!
3#.!#F#0'#10'0/2!-#4!
1%!F0%C%)!#/!
A//.9GGCCCD4)77B-D$(FD
.AG!#4)!
A//.9GGCCCD.A0F('-,D)(,/
D$(FD.AG!
!
H%,!
M"\P]V_W*N!
!
Z(!MVW?N!
!
!
!

!
!K#$#"#$%#
#
<626#438#S(;31>8'#%&6/T101#6&9#U>/&'86M0/02T#:6;;0&V#
"7%.#7%!#4!04F%4/(72!(@!%'%B%4/,!#@@%-/%)!#4)!-(4)+-/!,+7F%2,!/(!.7(F0)%!)%/#0'!(4!/A%07!'(-#/0(4<!-(4)0/0(4!(7!
,0/+#/0(4D!*%%!E44%a!W!/#1'%,!04!/A%!^;8=!\_bX6!5+0)%'04%,!@(7!B(7%!04@(7B#/0(4!(4!#//701+/%,!(@!%'%B%4/,D!
='-238#:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
G'@68.1RB#
%-P>08'9#
E)B040,/7#/0F%!
1(+4)#70%,!M%aD!1#7#4$#2<!
B+40-0.#'G-0/2!
#)B040,/7#/0F%!
1(+4)#70%,<!'#4)!-(F%7!
0B#$%N!
•!\_bX6!!!
•!ZE3XPE!
•!6+7%#+!(@!*(0',!#4)!c#/%7!
3#4#$%B%4/Q6*c3!M!@(7!
'#4)!-(F%7N!
•!?YZX!
•!5(($'%!3#.,<!5(($'%!
Y#7/A<!V.%4Q,/7%%/B#.!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
7%,0)%4/0#'!1+0')04$,!
#4)!'(-#/04$!
1(+4)#70%,!
!
5%4%7#'!.(.+'#/0(4M%D$D!
1#7#4$#2!A(+,04$<!
.(.+'#/0(4<!)%4,0/2<!
04@(7B#'!,%//'%B%4/,<!
7%,0)%4/0#'!,+1)0F0,0(4,NR!
•!Z#/0(4#'!*/#/0,/0-,!V@@0-%!
•!b,%!(@!5"*!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
7%,0)%4/0#'!1+0')04$,!
#4)!'(-#/04$!
1(+4)#70%,!
!
5%4%7#'!.(.+'#/0(4M%D$D!
1#7#4$#2!A(+,04$<!
•!Z*V<!!
•!W(BB+40/2!1#,%)!
B(40/(704$!,2,/%B!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:^!WA%-J!/A%!P4F%4/(72%'04%,!M*%-/(7#'!E4#'2,0,!#4)![((',!@(7!*0/+#/0(4#'!E4#'2,0,N#
!

!
!O#$#"#$%#
#
='-238#:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
G'@68.1RB#
%-P>08'9#
.(.+'#/0(4<!)%4,0/2<!
04@(7B#'!,%//'%B%4/,<!
7%,0)%4/0#'!,+1)0F0,0(4,NR!
!
MW63*N!
•!"A0'0..04%!X%)!W7(,,!)#/#!
04!Z#$#!W0/2!
•!\_bX6!7%$0(4#'!(@@0-%!
•!Z#$#!W0/2!W"?V!
•!?%.#7/B%4/!(@!*(-0#'!
c%'@#7%!#4)!!
?%F%'(.B%4/!M?*c?N!
•!!
!
,/7+-/+7%,!#4)!
'(-#/04$!1(+4)#70%,!
]+'4%7#1'%!"(.+'#/0(4!
M%D$D!%')%7'2<!C(B%4!#4)!
2(+/A<!04)0$%4(+,!
.%(.'%,<!.%7,(4,!C0/A!
)0,#10'0/0%,NR!
!
•!Z#$#!W0/2!!!Y')%7'2!(7!
*%40(7!W0/0U%4d,!V@@0-%!
•!?*c?!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
'(-#/0(4,!(@!/A%07!
1+0')04$,!
!
Y)+-#/0(4!,%-/(7M%D$D!
.70B#72<!,%-(4)#72<!
/%7/0#72<!,.%-0#'!,-A((',NR!
!
•!?%.QY)!?0,/70-/!V@@0-%<!
•!!W\Y?!
•!!!5(($'%!B#.,!!@(7!
'(-#/0(4!(@!,/7+-/+7%,!
•!b,%!(@!$'(1#'!.(,0/0(404$!
,2,/%B!)%F0-%!!@(7!
$%(/#$$04$!,/7+-/+7%,!
?%.#7/B%4/!(@!
Y)+-#/0(4!-(4)+-/,!
#,,%,,B%4/!(4!/A%!
%@@%-/,!(4!/A%!
%)+-#/0(4!,%-/(7<!
,-A(('!
@#-0'0/0%,G1+0')04$,!#4)!
!

!
!W#$#"#$%#
#
='-238#:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
G'@68.1RB#
%-P>08'9#
.7(F0)%!#4!04F%4/(72!
(@!,-A(('!1+0')04$,!
+,%)!#,!%F#-+#/0(4!
-%4/%7D![A%!(@@0-0#'!
C%1,0/%!
A//.9GGCCCD%)+D$(FD.
A!-#4!1%!+,%)!/(!$%/!
/A%!4%%)!04@(7B#/0(4!
#4)!)07%-/(72!(@!/A%!
J%2!.%7,(44%'!/(!$%/!
.%7/04%4/!)#/#!@(7!
%,/0B#/0(4D!
\(,.0/#'<!A%#'/A-#7%!T!
,#40/#/0(4!@#-0'0/0%,!M%aD!
7%$0(4#'!T!'(-#'!A(,.0/#',<!
1+70#'!,0/%,!T!-%B%/%70%,<!
)+B.04$!,0/%,!#4)!
'#4)@0'',<!\%#'/A!-#7%!
+40/,<!7+7#'!A%#'/A!+40/,!
MX\b,NNR!
•!Z#$#!W0/2!\%#'/A!#4)!
*#40/#/0(4!V@@0-%<!!
•!Y4F07(4B%4/!V@@0-%!
?%.#7/B%4/!(@!\%#'/A!
#,,%,,%,!)#B#$%!(4!
A%#'/A!@#-0'0/0%,!#4)!
,/#/+,!(@!A%#'/A!
,%7F0-%,!04-'+)04$!
C#/%7!#4)!,#40/#/0(4D!
[A%!(@@0-0#'!C%1,0/%!
A//.9GGCCCD)(AD$(FD
.A!-#4!1%!-(4,+'/%)!
/(!$%/!/A%!)07%-/(72!(@!
/A%!J%2!.%7,(44%'!/(!
!

!
R"#$#"#$%#
#
='-238#:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
G'@68.1RB#
%-P>08'9#
$%/!.%7/04%4/!)#/#!@(7!
%,/0B#/0(4D:e!
!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
7%,0)%4/0#'!1+0')04$,!
"7(/%-/0(4!,%7F0-%,!M%D$D!
.('0-%<!@07%@0$A/04$<!
)0,#,/%7!70,J!7%)+-/0(4!
#4)!B#4#$%B%4/!+40/NR!
•!Z#$#!W0/2!"Z"!
•!6+7%#+!(@!&07%!"7(/%-/0(4!
•!?XX3V!)0,#,/%7!7%.(7/,!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
7%,0)%4/0#'!1+0')04$,!
!
Y-(4(B0-!#-/0F0/0%,!M%D$D!
#$70-+'/+7#'!'#4)<!@(7%,/!
'#4)<!B0404$!,0/%,<!
1+,04%,,!T!-(BB%7-0#'!
%,/#1'0,AB%4/,<!*E&?f!
#7%#,NR!
•!W0/2!E,,%,,(7,!V@@0-%!
•!?YZX!M!&(7%,/!'#4)!b,%N!
•!?%.#7/B%4/!(@!E$70-+'/+7%!
•!6+7%#+!(@!304%,!#4)!5%(Q
*-0%4-%,!M30404$!,0/%,<!
.%7B0//%)!#7%#,N!
•!Z#$#!W0/2!?%.#7/B%4/,!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
1(+4)#70%,!#4)!
,/7+-/+7%,!
!
P4@7#,/7+-/+7%<!'0@%'04%,!M!
%D$D<!C#/%7<!7(#),<!
7#0'C#2,<!.(7/,N!#4)!
1+0')04$,<!A0,/(70-!,0/%,<!
•!W0/2!Y4$04%%7d,!V@@0-%!
•!?%.#7/B%4/!(@!"+1'0-!
c(7J,!#4)!\0$AC#2,!
•!?%.#7/B%4/!(@!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!!!
1+0')04$,!#4)!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:e!"#$%&'(!)*+,!-./012%'.3/04!5$/6'7/0'18!9::;!

!
RC#$#"#$%#
#
='-238#:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
G'@68.1RB#
%-P>08'9#
A#U#7)!-(4/7('!,/7+-/+7%,!
#4)!(/A%7!,2,/%B,R!
/%'%-(BB+40-#/0(4,!
•!Z#/0(4#'!P770$#/0(4!
E+/A(70/2!
•!?%.#7/B%4/!(@!Y4%7$2!!
04@7#,/7+-/+7%,<!
@#-0'0/0%,D!
!
W(4,+'/!?%.#7/B%4/!
(@!"+1'0-!c(7J,!#4)!
\0$AC#2,!7%$0(4#'!(7!
)0,/70-/!(@@0-%,D!E,,%,,!
)#B#$%,!(4!
04@7#,/7+-/+7%!#4)!
.+1'0-!C(7J,!,+-A!#,!
@'(()!-(4/7('<!
04/%74#/0(4#'!#4)!'(-#'!
7(#),!#4)!170)$%,!#4)!
(/A%7!F0/#'!04,/#''#/0(4!
#4)!@#-0'0/0%,D![A%!
(@@0-0#'!C%1,0/%!
A//.9GGCCCD).CAD$(F
D.A!-#4!1%!+,%)!/(!$%/!
/A%!)07%-/(72!(@!J%2!
.%7,(44%'!@7(B!
7%$0(4#'!#4)!)0,/70-/!
(@@0-%,!@(7!#-K+0704$!
7%K+07%)!04@(7B#/0(4!
!
?%.#7/B%4/!(@!Y4%7$2!

!
RB#$#"#$%#
#
='-238#:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
G'@68.1RB#
%-P>08'9#
-(4)+-/,!)#B#$%!
#,,%,,B%4/!(4!.(C%7!
$%4%7#/04$!@#-0'0/0%,D!
[A%!7%$0(4#'!(@@0-%,!
-#4!1%!-(4,+'/%)!/(!
%,/0B#/%!/A%!-(,/!(@!
/A%!.(C%7!.'#4/,<!
/7#4,B0,,0(4!'04%,!#4)!
$70)!,/#/0(4D!
!
?%./!(@!
[7#4,.(7/#/0(4!#4)!
W(BB+40-#/0(4,!
-(4)+-/,!)#B#$%!
#,,%,,B%4/!(4!
-(BB+40-#/0(4!#4)!
/7#4,.(7/!@#-0'0/0%,!
Y4F07(4B%4/!M!%D$D!
.7(/%-/%)!#7%#,<!'#4)!+,%!
U(404$<!-(#,/#'!#7%#,<!
C%/'#4)<!!#4)!@0,A%72!
#7%#,!
?YZX!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
1(+4)#70%,!(@!/A%,%!
#7%#,!
!
_#4)!b,%!M!%D$D!
7%,0)%4/0#'<!-(BB%7-0#'<!
04)+,/70#'<!B0a%)!+,%<!
•!\_bX6!
•!?YZX!
•!Z#$#!W0/2!!"'#4404$!#4)!
b,%!(@!$'(1#'!
.(,0/0(404$!,2,/%B!
)%F0-%!!@(7!$%(/#$$04$!
!

!
RQ#$#"#$%#
#
='-238#:6;1#
<626#=3>8-'I1#
G'@68.1RB#
%-P>08'9#
04@(7B#'!#7%#,N!
?%F%'(.B%4/!V@@0-%!
1(+4)#70%,!#4)!
-(4@'0-/!#7%#,!
!
#
NXEEXY#ZF[#=FGUS\#]FS=^_X``%_GS#NXG#`%A%#+_^\#+%[%+_^\#`SS<=#%==S==:S`^#
`6@'#34#<';682@'&2*#
<62'*###
`6@'#34#G'1;3&9'&2*#
+>88'&2#[310203&*#
##
\'681#='8L'9#0&#+>88'&2#;310203&*#
!
V4-%!2(+!A#F%!-(B.'%/%)!/A%!-A%-J'0,/,<!#4,C%7!/A%!@(''(C04$!K+%,/0(4,D!!!!##
H(+!B#2!+,%!#))0/0(4#'!,A%%/,!(@!.#.%7!0@!2(+!C0,A!/(!%'#1(7#/%!(4!2(+7!#4,C%7,D!
#
[%G^#Ca#X`#5%b%G<=D#UFE`SG%)_E_^_S=#%`<#G_=c=#XN#`%A%#+_^\#
%a#5%b%G<=#D#<_=%=^SG=#%`<#[E%``_`A##
%`=YSG=#(After'completing'the'hazard'inventory,'check'on'the'space'if'it'applies)#
8DN!cA#/! 4#/+7#'! A#U#7),! A#F%! -7%#/%)! #! &62>86/!
901612'8# 04! 2(+7! #7%#g! "'%#,%! -A%-J! #..7(.70#/%!
,.#-%,D!!
!
?0,#,/%7! 0,! )%@04%)! #,! #4! %F%4/! CA%7%! %a/%74#'!
#,,0,/#4-%!0,! ,(+$A/! 12!/A%! -0/2! (7!B+40-0.#'0/2! @7(B!
/A%!"7(F04-%!(7!X%$0(4!)+%!/(!/A%!0B.#-/!(@!#!4#/+7#'!
A#U#7)D!
!
!
!
Climate'and'Water''related'Hazards'
1!6%#$4<21====!2!%./0!/06$&'6!7.0617/6'1=====!!
3!%/>'%!?7##61!====4!12%#04!@/061A!&B&7#0'1=====!!
5'C2<'%18!D71E1D'&/?B====================================!
'
Earthquake'induced'hazards'
6!"'>'%'! 4%#$06F1<.G/04======! 7!4%#$06! %$D2$%'A1$%?.&'! H%'.G1=====! 8!
I/J$'?.&2/#0=====!9'4%#$06!'KD.01/#0========!
10!7.0617/6'======!11!I.06!3.11!3#>'3'02======'!
12!C2<'%18D71E!1D'&/?B(===================================!
'
Volcanic'Hazards'

!
R!#$#"#$%#
#
'
13'I.>.!?7#@======14'*KD7#1/>'!*%$D2/#01AL'D<%.!?.771======!
15'MB%#&7.12/&!N7#@1=====16'I.<.%1======!17!+'H%/1!,>.7.0&<'!
18!C2<'%18!D71E!1D'&/?B(====================================!
Erosion'
19!"#/7!*%#1/#0===20!O/>'%!*%#1/#0===!21!P#.12.7!*%#1/#0===!
12!C2<'%18!D71E!"D'&/?B=========================!
^N! P4)0-#/%! /A%! )%$7%%! 04! CA0-A! Z#$#! W0/2! "'#4404$!
#4)!W((7)04#/0(4!V@@0-%G?XX3V!A#,! +4)%7/#J%4! /A%!
@(''(C04$! .A2,0-#'! .'#4404$! B%#,+7%,D! "'%#,%! -A%-J!
/A%! ,.#-%! -(77%,.(4)04$! /(! /A%! 4+B1%7! (@! 2(+7!
#4,C%7D!
!!!
#
#:'6&0&V1*#
!
Cd!Y'#,6L'#M68'/T#6--3@;/01,'9#2,01#
Bd!Y'#,6L'#6--3@;/01,'9#6M3>2###BRe#34#&''9'9#6-203&#
Qd!Y'# ,6L'# # 6--3@;/01,'9# 6M3>2# R"e# # 34# 2,'# &''9'9#
6-203&#
!d!%--3@;/01,@'&2##01#1>M126&206/#?#6M3>2#KRe#38###
#########@38'H#
#
#
#
:S%=FGS=#
ESUSE#C#
ESUSE#B#
ESUSEQ#
ESUSE#!#
?%'04%#/%! )#4$%7! U(4%,! 2(+! A#F%!
0)%4/0@0%)!#,!/A7%#/%4%)!12!4#/+7#'!
A#U#7),!M04!B#.!@(7BN!
#
#
#
#
P)%4/0@2! %#,%B%4/,! #4)!
1(+4)#70%,! @(7! )#4$%7! U(4%,! (4!
/A%!$7(+4)!!
#
#
#
#
P)%4/0@2!/A%!%B%7$%4-2!7(+/%,!#4)!
/%B.(7#72! 7%'(-#/0(4! ,0/%,! #4)!
%F#-+#/0(4!U(4%,! M04! B#.!@(7B! (7!
0)%4/0@0%)!,0/%,N!
!
#
#
#
#
P)%4/0@2! ! ,+0/#1'%! #7%#,! CA%7%!
,%//'%B%4/! $7(C/A! (7! CA%7%!
)%F%'(.B%4/! ! ,A(+')! 1%! #''(C%)!
(7!%4-(+7#$%)!
C#
B#
Q#
!#
#
#
#
#
]%70@0%)!#4)!'0,/%)!#7%#,!!(7!
1+0')04$,!/A#/!7%K+07%!,/7+-/+7#'!
04/%7F%4/0(4!M!%4$04%%704$!
7%/7(@0/,N!(7!4(4Q,/7+-/+7#'!
04/%7F%4/0(4,M!4(Q)%F%'(.B%4/!
U(4%,<!%#,%B%4/N!#$#04,/!@'((),<!
%#7/AK+#J%,<!@07%!A#U#7),!#4)!
(/A%7,D!!!!
#
#
#
#

!
RR#$#"#$%#
#
Z#$#! W0/2! A#,! '%$0,'#/0(4! 04! #0)! (@!
)0,#,/%7!B0/0$#/0(4!!!
#
#
#
#
X2,'8# ;,T10-6/# ;/6&&0&V# 6-203&1I@'61>8'1# \3># ,6L'# 93&'# 0&# 2,'# +02T# ;/1a#
1;'-04T#,'8'#38#0&#6&32,'8#1,''2*#
#
#
#
#
!

!
56#|#"#$%#
#
Annex#C:#Sample#Data#Request#Letters#to#National#Agencies!
!
!
&%'(%)*%+!,-.!/-,0!
!
!
DR.#RENATO#U.#SOLIDUM,#JR.#
Director#
Philippine#Institute#of#Volcanology#and#Seismology#
C.P.#Garcia#Ave.,#U.P.#Campus,#Diliman,#Quezon#City#
! !
Request'for'Datasets'on'Exposure'to'Natural'Hazards'
!
Dear#Dir.#Solidum1!!
!
2#$#!34(5!46!47!(8%!'+9:%66!9;!<'=#(47$!4(6!39)'+%8%764>%!?#7=!@6%!"A#7!B3?@"C.!(9!47:A<=%!
47;9+)#(497!97!(8%!=4;;%+%7(!7#(<+#A!8#D#+=6!(8#(!)#5!#;;%:(!(8%!34(5E!F7!(8#(!+%$#+=.!(8%!8#D#+=!
)#'6!'+9=<:%=!*5!(8%!"84A4''47%!F76(4(<(%!9;!G9A:#79A9$5!#7=!&%46)9A9$5!B"HFGI?3&C!J4AA!
'+9>4=%!>#A<#*A%!47'<(6!97!(8%!%K'96<+%!9;!2#$#!34(5!(9!=4;;%+%7(!(5'%6!9;!7#(<+#A!8#D#+=6E!L%!
#+%!(8%+%;9+%!+%M<%6(47$!;9+!(8%!;9AA9J47$!=#(#6%(6!+%A%>#7(!(9!2#$#!34(5.!;9+!<6%!47!9<+!3?@"!
<'=#(47$1!
!
,E!N+9<7=!+<'(<+%!)#'6!B,10-.---!6:#A%C!#7=!NF&!68#'%;4A%6!
/E!N+9<7=!68#O47$!)#'6!B,10-.---!6:#A%C!#7=!NF&!68#'%;4A%6!
PE!?4M<%;#:(497!)#'6!B,10-.---!6:#A%C!#7=!NF&!68#'%;4A%6!
QE!R#+(8M<#O%S47=<:%=!A#7=6A4=%!)#'6!B,10-.---!#7=!9(8%+!6:#A%6C!#7=!NF&!68#'%;4A%6!
0E!G9A:#74:!8#D#+=!)#'6!B,10-.---!#7=!9(8%+!6:#A%6C!#7=!NF&!68#'%;4A%6E!
!
T8%6%!=#(#6%(6!J4AA!6<''9+(!(8%!47(%$+#(497!9;!+46O!'#+#)%(%+6!47(9!2#$#!34(5U6!A#7=!<6%!'A#7747$!
#7=!%76<+%!(8#(!;<(<+%!=%>%A9')%7(!47!(8%!:4(5!46!+46OS6%764(4>%E!V%6(!#66<+%=!(8#(!"HFGI?3&!J4AA!
+%:%4>%!=<%!:+%=4(!#7=!#:O79JA%=$)%7(!;9+!4(6!:97(+4*<(497!(9!(8%!3?@"!<'=#(47$E!
!
W+EXW6E!YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!9;!(8%!34(5!"A#7747$!#7=!Z%>%A9')%7(!I;;4:%!B:97(#:(!=%(#4A6C!
J4AA!*%!;9AA9J47$!<'!9<+!+%M<%6(!J4(8!59<+!9;;4:%E!
!
T8#7O!59<!>%+5!)<:8!;9+!8%A'47$!<6!97!(846!4)'9+(#7(!)#((%+!#7=!J%!A99O!;9+J#+=!(9!59<+!
;#>9+#*A%!#:(497!97!9<+!+%M<%6(E!
! !
&47:%+%A5.!!
!!
!
Hon.#John#G.#Bongat#
W#59+!
&%'(%)*%+!,-.!/-,0!

!
57#|#"#$%#
#
!
!
HON.#RAMON#J.P.#PAJE#
Secretary#
Department#of#Environment#and#Natural#Resources#
Visasyas#Avenue,#Diliman,#Quezon#City!
! !
Request'for'Datasets'on'Exposure'to'Natural'Hazards'
!
Dear#Sec.#Paje1!!
!
2#$#!34(5!46!47!(8%!'+9:%66!9;!<'=#(47$!4(6!39)'+%8%764>%!?#7=!@6%!"A#7!B3?@"C.!(9!47:A<=%!
47;9+)#(497!97!(8%!=4;;%+%7(!7#(<+#A!8#D#+=6!(8#(!)#5!#;;%:(!(8%!34(5E!F7!(8#(!+%$#+=.!(8%!8#D#+=!
)#'6!'+9=<:%=!*5!(8%!W47%6!#7=!N%96:4%7:%6![<+%#<!J4AA!'+9>4=%!>#A<#*A%!47'<(6!97!(8%!
%K'96<+%!9;!2#$#!34(5!(9!=4;;%+%7(!(5'%6!9;!7#(<+#A!8#D#+=6E!L%!#+%!(8%+%;9+%!+%M<%6(47$!;9+!(8%!
;9AA9J47$!=#(#6%(6!+%A%>#7(!(9!2#$#!34(5.!;9+!<6%!47!9<+!3?@"!<'=#(47$1!
!
,E!\A99=!6<6:%'(4*4A4(5!)#'6!B,1,-.---!#7=!,10-.---!6:#A%C!#7=!NF&!68#'%;4A%6!
/E!V#47S47=<:%=!A#7=6A4=%!6<6:%'(4*4A4(5!)#'6B,1,-.---!#7=!,10-.---!6:#A%C!#7=!NF&!
68#'%;4A%6!
!
T8%6%!=#(#6%(6!J4AA!6<''9+(!(8%!47(%$+#(497!9;!+46O!'#+#)%(%+6!47(9!2#$#!34(5U6!A#7=!<6%!'A#7747$!
#7=!%76<+%!(8#(!;<(<+%!=%>%A9')%7(!47!(8%!:4(5!46!+46OS6%764(4>%E!V%6(!#66<+%=!(8#(!(8%!ZR2V!#7=!
WN[!J4AA!+%:%4>%!=<%!:+%=4(!#7=!#:O79JA%=$)%7(!;9+!4(6!:97(+4*<(497!(9!(8%!3?@"!<'=#(47$E!
!
W+EXW6E!YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!9;!(8%!34(5!"A#7747$!#7=!Z%>%A9')%7(!I;;4:%!B:97(#:(!=%(#4A6C!
J4AA!*%!;9AA9J47$!<'!9<+!+%M<%6(!J4(8!59<+!9;;4:%E!
!
T8#7O!59<!>%+5!)<:8!;9+!8%A'47$!<6!97!(846!4)'9+(#7(!)#((%+!#7=!J%!A99O!;9+J#+=!(9!59<+!
;#>9+#*A%!#:(497!97!9<+!+%M<%6(E!
! !
&47:%+%A5.!!
!!
!
Hon.#John#G.#Bongat#
W#59+!
!
!
3:1!!!!!!!!R7$+E!?%9!?E!]#6#+%79!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Z4+%:(9+.!W47%6!#7=!N%96:4%7:%6![<+%#<!