ArticlePublisher preview available

Transurethral ventral buccal mucosa graft inlay urethroplasty for reconstruction of fossa navicularis and distal urethral strictures: surgical technique and preliminary results

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Objectives: To introduce a novel surgical technique for the reconstruction of distal urethral strictures using buccal mucosal graft (BMG) through a transurethral approach. Methods: A retrospective institution chart review was conducted of all the patients who underwent a transurethral ventral BMG inlay urethroplasty from March 2014 to March 2016. Patients with greater than one-year follow-up were included. Steps of the procedure: transurethral ventral wedge resection of the stenosed segment and transurethral delivery and spread fixation of appropriate BMG inlay into the resultant urethrotomy. The patients were followed for post-operative complications and stricture recurrence with uroflow, PVR, cystoscopy and outcome questionnaires. Results: Three patients with a minimum of 12-month follow-up are included in this case series. The mean age of the patients was 42 years (35-53); mean stricture length was 2.1 cm (1-4). All patients had at least 2 previous failed procedures. Mean follow-up was 18 months (12-24). There were no stricture recurrences or fistula. Mean pre- and post-operative uroflow values were 4.3 (0-8) and 19 (16-26), respectively. Neither penile chordee nor changes in sexual function were noted in patients on follow-up. Conclusion: Transurethral ventral BMG inlay urethroplasty is a feasible option for treatment of fossa navicularis strictures. This single-stage technique allows for avoiding skin incision or urethral mobilization. It helps to prevent glans dehiscence, fistula formation and avoids the use of genital skin flaps in all patients, especially those affected with LS. This novel surgical technique is an effective treatment alternative for men with distal urethral strictures.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
1 3
Int Urol Nephrol (2016) 48:1823–1829
DOI 10.1007/s11255-016-1381-1
UROLOGY - ORIGINAL PAPER
Transurethral ventral buccal mucosa graft inlay urethroplasty
for reconstruction of fossa navicularis and distal urethral
strictures: surgical technique and preliminary results
Dmitriy Nikolavsky1 · Mourad Abouelleil1 · Michael Daneshvar1
Received: 13 June 2016 / Accepted: 19 July 2016 / Published online: 28 July 2016
© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2016
skin flaps in all patients, especially those affected with LS.
This novel surgical technique is an effective treatment
alternative for men with distal urethral strictures.
Keywords Urethral stricture · Fossa navicularis ·
Meatoplasty · Lichen sclerosus · Urethroplasty · Buccal
mucosa graft
Introduction
Reconstructive urologic surgery has vastly changed in the
past three decades with the introduction of BMG for ure-
thral reconstruction [1, 2]. Subsequently, a variety of new
surgical techniques to treat urethral stricture disease have
been developed [3, 4]. Surgical repair of distal penile and
fossa navicularis strictures (FNS) however remains a chal-
lenging issue within reconstructive urology due to the
nature of the strictures, their underlying pathology and ana-
tomical considerations. Herein, we propose a novel surgical
technique that may help to avoid inherent technical difficul-
ties and surgical complications.
Most of the previously described options for the man-
agement of FNS include either a ventral or a circumfer-
ential skin incision to access the urethra for a ventral ure-
throtomy. Through these incisions a buccal mucosa graft,
a fasciocutaneous flap or a combination of both are used to
reconstruct the affected urethral lumen [57]. All of these
techniques require external skin incisions in an area that is
less forgiving than the perineum, therefore often leading
to less than desirable cosmetic and functional outcomes.
Additionally, some of the techniques employ the use of
local genital skin for urethral reconstruction. Since this area
is frequently affected by lichen sclerosis (LS), genital skin
use is discouraged due to a high risk of disease recurrence
Abstract
Objectives To introduce a novel surgical technique for
the reconstruction of distal urethral strictures using buccal
mucosal graft (BMG) through a transurethral approach.
Methods A retrospective institution chart review was con-
ducted of all the patients who underwent a transurethral
ventral BMG inlay urethroplasty from March 2014 to
March 2016. Patients with greater than one-year follow-
up were included. Steps of the procedure: transurethral
ventral wedge resection of the stenosed segment and tran-
surethral delivery and spread fixation of appropriate BMG
inlay into the resultant urethrotomy. The patients were
followed for post-operative complications and stricture
recurrence with uroflow, PVR, cystoscopy and outcome
questionnaires.
Results Three patients with a minimum of 12-month fol-
low-up are included in this case series. The mean age of
the patients was 42 years (35–53); mean stricture length
was 2.1 cm (1–4). All patients had at least 2 previous failed
procedures. Mean follow-up was 18 months (12–24). There
were no stricture recurrences or fistula. Mean pre- and post-
operative uroflow values were 4.3 (0–8) and 19 (16–26),
respectively. Neither penile chordee nor changes in sexual
function were noted in patients on follow-up.
Conclusion Transurethral ventral BMG inlay urethroplasty
is a feasible option for treatment of fossa navicularis stric-
tures. This single-stage technique allows for avoiding skin
incision or urethral mobilization. It helps to prevent glans
dehiscence, fistula formation and avoids the use of genital
* Dmitriy Nikolavsky
Nikolavd@upstate.edu
1 Department of Urology, SUNY Upstate Medical University,
750 East Adams Street, Syracuse, NY 13210, USA
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... This has traditionally funnelled patients with FNS to high-volume centres that are able to minimise fistula formation, flap necrosis and glandular dehiscence, and patients who are unable to get to these highvolume centres would be subjected to repeated dilatations to maintain patency [5]. The transurethral ventral inlay BMG approach described by Nikolavsky et al. [6] has been shown to avoid the inherent technical difficulties and complications generally associated with FNS repair. Here, we present a stepby-step description of this surgical procedure and intermediate-term patient outcomes. ...
... The median (interquartile range [IQR]) Q max improved from 5 (3)(4)(5)(6)(7)(8) to 19 (13-24) mL/s (P < 0.001), while the median (IQR) PVR decreased from 39.5 (8.25-156.75) to 28 (2.5-68.25) mL (P = 0.02). ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective To outline our step‐by‐step surgical technique for a transurethral ventral buccal mucosa graft inlay urethroplasty to treat fossa navicularis and distal urethral strictures. Methods The transurethral ventral inlay urethroplasty is accomplished in four steps. First, after obtaining proper exposure the cicatrice is excised via a transurethral ventral urethrotomy until the lumen is at least 24fr. Second, double arm 6‐0 polydioxanone suture is used to deliver the triangular buccal mucosal graft to the proximal extent of the urethrotomy and secured externally. Third, the graft is secured to the meatus with 5‐0 polyglactin sutures and additional 6‐0 double arm polydioxanone sutures are used to quilt the graft for spread fixation. Finally, a 16fr silicone catheter is placed. Patients are discharged the same day and return for void trial after one week. A retrospective, single institution review was conducted to include all patients who underwent this procedure with a minimum of 1 year follow‐up. Patients were analyzed for recurrences, and pre‐ and post‐operative urine flow rates, post void residuals, and patient questionnaires were also reviewed. Results 44 patients met our inclusion criteria. Median surgical time was 120 minutes. At a mean follow up of 36 months (IQR 22‐50) 95% of patients are patent without additional interventions. The 2 patients that did have stricture recurrence were found to have urethral stenosis that extended more proximally, and both were successfully treated with a dorsal onlay buccal urethroplasty. There were significant improvements in urine flow rate, post void residuals, international prostate symptom score and quality of life scores post operatively. There was no difference in post operative sexual function scores. Conclusion This minimally invasive transurethral ventral urethroplasty has excellent intermediate term outcomes in terms of traditional objective measures of urethroplasty success and patient reported outcomes.
... Nikolavsky et al. first described a transurethral placement of BMG as an inlay following wedge resection of the narrowed segment. They reported no recurrences, no fistula formations, and improved flow in 3 out of 3 patients with at least 1 year follow up (range 12-24 months) (17). The procedure was studied again but at a multi-institutional level (15 sites total), finding 3 recurrences in 57 patients with a median follow up of 17 months (IQR 13-22) (17). ...
... They reported no recurrences, no fistula formations, and improved flow in 3 out of 3 patients with at least 1 year follow up (range 12-24 months) (17). The procedure was studied again but at a multi-institutional level (15 sites total), finding 3 recurrences in 57 patients with a median follow up of 17 months (IQR 13-22) (17). Others have even successfully adapted transurethral circular graft placement through a circum-meatal incision and careful dissection of the urethra from the glans. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose: Management of fossa navicularis (FN) strictures balances restoring urethral patency with adequate cosmesis. Historically, FN strictures are managed via glans cap or glans wings, and in severe cases, multi-stage procedures. Ventral onlay glanuloplasty (VOG) is an easily reproducible technique that involves a single-stage augmentation with buccal mucosal graft. We have been applying this technique for several years and present early promising outcomes of this novel approach. Materials and methods: We retrospectively reviewed all patients with FN strictures who underwent VOG at our institution. Treatment success was designated by the absence of extravasation on voiding cystourethrogram and no need for further urethral instrumentation on follow up. Glans cosmesis was assessed by patients providing binary (yes/no) response to the satisfaction in their appearance. We also noted stricture length, stricture etiology, demographic characteristics and any post-operative complications and reported median, interquartile range (IQR) and count, frequency (%), accordingly. Results: Ten patients underwent VOG and fit our inclusion criteria. Median stricture length was 2.0 cm (IQR 1.6 -2). Success rate was 90% (9/10) with a median follow up of 30 months (IQR 24.3 - 36.8). The one recurrence was treated by dilation combined with triamcinolone injection at 419 days post-op. Stricture etiology included primarily iatrogenic causes such as transurethral prostate resection (4/10), greenlight laser vaporization (2/10), cystolitholapaxy (1/10), and traumatic catheterization (3/10). All patients were satisfied with penile cosmesis. Conclusion: VOG is a simple technique for treating FN strictures. Based on our preliminary series, VOG provides sustained distal urethral patency and patients are pleased with the appearance.
... In 1998, Naudé [27] initiated the concept of endoscopic graft urethroplasty. A few modifications were published later [28][29] . Unfortunately, these procedures did not gain popularity due to intrinsic technical complexity and problems with surgical reconstruction of distal penile strictures. ...
... Open procedures are intrinsically associated with cosmetic and functional complications, including infection, dehiscence, and fistula. In 2008, Seth et al. [29] reported a hybrid technique of intraurethral approach to distal urethral stricture combining a transurethral graft placement with a ventral subcoronal incision to promote better scar removal and proximal graft anastomosis. At a mean follow-up of 38 months, an 84% success rate was reported. ...
Article
Full-text available
Although urethral strictures have been known since antiquity, the surgical management of urethral strictures has undergone a great (re)evolution over the last six decades, both in the perception of the disease and in the surgical repair techniques, always presenting itself as a challenge for the surgeon and patient. Reconstruction of urethral stricture disease involving a combination of grafts and flaps consists of a group of complex procedures with specific clinical indications. The knowledge of these procedures by reconstructive urologists is both necessary and relevant. A thorough understanding of the anatomy, including blood supply, is a crucial proviso for the correct evaluation and successful management of urethral stricture disease. We discuss the main techniques and indications in combined graft and flap urethroplasties.
... A technique with ventral wedge resection and external suture tying of a meatal buccal mucosa graft by Nikolavsky works glans sparing but is difficult for longer strictures. 6 There is a shift toward an increased use of single-stage procedures even in patients with multiple previous interventions that led to fibrotic and atrophic scarring of the urethral plate. 7,8,10 This is possible due to the advancements and refinements in operative techniques and often arises because patients are hesitant to accept staged treatment. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: To describe a step-by-step approach for glans preserving urethroplasty with a dorsal inlay graft used for distal urethral strictures. Description of the Technique: The reconstruction was performed through a keyhole incision in the urethra. In this way, we achieve maximal exposure by a minimal incision and saving of the glans. After incision of the diseased dorsal urethral mucosa through the keyhole and the meatus, a buccal mucosa graft pull-through resulting in a dorsal inlay is done. Patient(s) and Methods: We treated 10 patients in different clinical settings with success by using the newly described technique below. We highlight and illustrate 1 case of a 34-year-circumcised male. Antegrade urethrogram showed a distal penile and fossa navicularis stricture with a total estimated length of 3.5 cm. Results: In this specific case the glans sparing approach had a surgical duration of 115 minutes. After 3 weeks the urinary catheter was removed. At 12 months, the patient reported no remaining urinary tract symptoms. Examination showed a fully healed lesion and an adequate uroflowmetry with a Qmax of 24 mL/s coming from 4 mL/s pre-operatively. In our 10-patient case series, all treated patients had complete resolution of their complaints, significant improvement in flow rates and excellent cosmetic results without complications. Conclusion: In selected cases, the described technique is feasible, safe, and effective with excellent functional outcomes and better cosmetic results especially due to the glans preservation.
Article
Objective: To determine which patient-reported symptoms are associated with satisfaction after urethroplasty. Methods: From 2011-2018, patients were offered enrollment in a prospective study assessing patient-reported outcomes after urethroplasty. Outcomes were assessed pre-operatively and 6-months postoperatively including patient satisfaction, voiding function (IPSS), erectile function (IIEF-5) and ejaculatory function (ejaculatory component of brief sexual function inventory). Additionally, penile curvature/appearance, genitourinary pain, post-void dribbling, and standing voiding function were also evaluated using either 3 or 5 point Likert scales. Stricture recurrence was defined as the inability to easily pass a 16Fr flexible videocystoscope. Multivariable binary logistic regression was used to examine the associations between outcomes and patient satisfaction. Results: 387 patients completed the study with a mean age of 49.5 years and a mean stricture length of 4.5cm. Location was bulbar (59.4%), penile (19.6%), posterior (13.7%) and pan-urethral (7.2%). At 6-months, 96.1% of patients were stricture-free, 81.6% reported being satisfied with surgery and 8.0% were unsatisfied. On multivariable binary logistic regression, improvement in IPSS (O.R.1.1, 95%CI 1.1-1.2, p=0.04), new erectile dysfunction (O.R.0.5, 95%CI 0.2-0.9, p=0.04), new penile curvature (O.R. 0.4, 95%CI 0.2-0.9, p=0.03) and improved standing voiding function (O.R.1.3, 95%CI 1.1-1.5, p=0.004) were associated with patient satisfaction. Cystoscopic success (p=0.60), change in pain score (p=0.14), post-void dribbling (p=0.69), change in penile length (p=0.44) and ejaculatory dysfunction (p=0.51) were not. Conclusion: Improved voiding function, patient-reported penile curvature, new erectile dysfunction and improved standing voiding are independently associated with patient satisfaction after urethroplasty and should be incorporated into any patient-centered approach to urethral stricture management.
Article
Aims: Transmasculine genital reconstructive surgery involves the creation of a neourethra by way of metoidioplasty or phalloplasty. We aim to describe approaches in identifying complications associated with these procedures as well as the various reparative techniques that can be utilized to reestablish the neourethral tract. Methods: We prepared a guide to diagnostic and procedural interventions for urologic complications following transmasculine genital reconstructive surgery based on our clinical experience as well as those of our colleagues. We reviewed all current peer-reviewed publications based on this topic. Results: These procedures have a considerable revision rate for urologic complications, which include urethrocutaneous fistulae, persistent vaginal remnant, and urethral strictures. These complications often present simultaneously and require appropriate workup and treatment. Conclusions: Several reconstructive techniques can be employed to restore the neourethral tract, as we describe in detail.
Article
Full-text available
The correction of fossa navicularis strictures poses a distinct reconstructive challenge as it requires attention to cosmesis, in addition to urethral patency. Different graft and flap based repairs have been described with variable success rates. However, the ideal management remains unclear. The feasibility and efficacy of a single stage ventral onlay buccal mucosa graft urethroplasty (VOBMGU) for navicular fossa strictures (NFS) was evaluated in the present study. All patients with NFS attending urology out-patient department from March, 2009 onward accepting VOBMGU were evaluated prospectively. Patients with minimum 1 year of follow-up were included for analysis. The technique involves opening the diseased stenosed meatus ventrally up to the corona. The diseased mucosa is excised leaving a midline strip of native urethral mucosa on the dorsal side. The buccal mucosal graft (BMG) is fixed on either side of this strip over a 24 Fr. silicone catheter. The glans wings are apposed in midline taking anchoring bites on the mucosal graft ventrally. Post-operatively patients were reviewed at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months and annually thereafter. Cosmetic acceptance and splaying of the urinary stream was assessed with individual questionnaires. A total of six patients underwent VOBMGU. Average flow rate at 3 months post-operatively was 12 ml/s. The end result was cosmetically highly acceptable. There was no fistula in any of the cases. With a median follow-up of 37 months, only one patient had a recurrence of stricture in a proximal site. VOBMGU is a viable technique for reconstruction of NFS with promising short term results. However, long-term follow-up is necessary.
Article
Fossa navicularis strictures have troubled urologists for years. Although several flap procedures have been described none truly leaves a normal-appearing penis postoperatively. A new technique is described of the reconstruction of the fossa navicularis with a ventral transverse island flap on a broad, dependable pedicle. All 5 patients who have undergone the procedure have excellent cosmetic and functional results. The appearance of the penis postoperatively is normal, with a median followup of 17 months. Early reconstruction of fossa strictures may avoid the sequelae of more conservative attempts at management, thus, correcting the fossa stricture itself before the occurrence of penourethral stricture disease secondary to repeated dilations, meatotomy and internal urethrotomy.
Article
Distal urethral strictures involving the fossa navicularis and meatus represent a unique subset of urethral strictures that are particularly challenging to reconstructive urologists. Management of distal urethral strictures must take into account not only maintenance of urethral patency but also glans cosmesis. A variety of therapeutic approaches exist for the management of distal urethral strictures, including dilation, meatotomy, extended meatotomy, flap urethroplasty, and substitution grafting. Common etiologies for distal urethral strictures include lichen sclerosus, instrumentation, and prior hypospadias repair. Proper patient selection is paramount to the ultimate success and durability of the treatment, which should be individualized and include an assessment of the stricture etiology, location, and burden, and patient-centered goals of care.
Article
Purpose: We evaluate the long-term efficacy of an integrated 1-stage approach for the reconstruction of resistant strictures of the fossa navicularis and meatus. Materials and Methods: In 19 men with resistant glanular urethral strictures of varied origin reconstruction was tailored to the individual characteristics of the urethral stricture and glans, Urethral reconstruction was performed with a ventral transverse island fasciocutaneous penile flap in 16 cases, resection and primary end-to-end anastomosis in 2, and a buccal mucosal graft in 1. The glanuloplasty was completed as a glans cap in 15 patients and as glans wings in 4, In the latter group the glans was significantly scarred from the causative process and previous failed procedures. Results: The patients were followed for a mean of 42.7 months. Transient urinary splaying and mild glans torsion were observed postoperatively but resolved within 8 weeks. Overall, a durable, functional and cosmetic result was achieved in 18 patients (94.7%), and only 1 had an anastomotic stricture that required reoperation. Conclusions: Although the management of resistant glanular urethral strictures can be difficult, the appropriate reconstructive techniques can permanently correct these strictures. We describe a logical 1-stage approach to reconstructing the fossa navicularis and meatus, allowing a functionally successful and cosmetically appealing long-term outcome.
Article
In this systematic review of the literature, a search of the PubMed database was conducted to identify articles dealing with augmentation/substitution urethral reconstruction of the anterior urethral stricture. The evidence was categorized by stricture site, surgical technique, and the type of tissue used. The committee appointed by the International Consultation on Urological Disease reviewed this data and produced a consensus statement relating to the augmentation and substitution of the anterior urethra. In this review article, the background pathophysiology is discussed. Most cases of urethral stricture disease in the anterior urethra are consequent on an ischemic spongiofibrosis. The choice of technique and the surgical approach are discussed along with the potential pros and cons of the use of a graft vs a flap. There is research potential for tissue engineering. The efficacy of the surgical approach to the urethra is reviewed. Whenever possible, a 1-stage approach is preferable from the patient's perspective. In some cases, with complex penile urethral strictures, a 2-stage procedure might be appropriate, and there is an important potential role for the use of a perineal urethrostomy in cases where there is an extensive anterior urethral stricture or where the patient does not wish to undergo complex surgery, or medical contraindications make this hazardous. It is important to have accurate outcome measures for the follow-up of patients, and in this context, a full account needs to be taken of patients' perspectives by the use of appropriate patient-reported outcome measures. The use of symptoms and a flow rate can be misleading. It is well established that with a normally functioning bladder, the flow rate does not diminish until the caliber of the urethra falls below 10F. The most accurate means of following up patients after stricture surgery are by the use of endoscopy or visualization by urethrography. Careful consideration needs to be made of the outcomes reported in the world literature, bearing in mind these aforementioned points. The article concludes with an overview of the key recommendations provided by the committee.
Article
To describe our minimally invasive hybrid technique for treating pan-anterior urethral stricture. From February 2009 through November 2011, 12 patients with pan-anterior urethral stricture were operated on in our unit. The bulbospongiosus muscle was mobilized on one side, and a 2.5-cm dorsolateral bulbar urethrotomy was made. A full-thickness cold knife optical internal urethrotomy was made to reach the corpus cavernosum as graft bed. A 14- to 16-cm-long, 15- to 16-mm-wide buccal/lingual mucosa graft was harvested and sutured dorsally at the site of urethrotomy, and then distally at the meatus along with meatoplasty. The mean operating time was 91.66 min. The average hospital stay was 2.4 days. The Foley catheter was removed after 3 weeks. The mean Q(max) preoperatively and postoperatively was 5.5 ± 1.87 and 18.83 ± 2.04 ml/s, respectively. Our mean follow-up was 18.5 ± 6.92 (6-32) months. Our hybrid technique provides good short-term results while promoting minimal urethral mobilization and graft vascularity.
Article
To report our results with 1-stage reconstruction in short distal urethral strictures using circular buccal mucosa graft (cBMG). The data of 19 patients (median age 41.8 years, range 25-58) operated between 2001 and 2010 were reviewed. Patients were evaluated with American Urological Association (AUA) symptom score, uroflowmetry, voiding cystourethrography (VCUG), and intraoperative urethroscopy. Stricture was limited to the glanular urethra (≤ 2 cm.) in all cases and 16 patients had lichen sclerosus. Strictured urethra was resected 0.5 cm proximal to the healthy urethra and a rectangular BMG with 4-cm length and 1.5- to 2.5-cm width (depending on the length of the defect) was rolled on a 24-Fr sound that calibrated the urethra. Proximal and distal edges of the cBMG were anastomosed circumferentially to the healthy mucosa and meatus, respectively. Foley catheter was removed within 10-14 days. Voiding symptoms, uroflowmetric parameters, and cosmesis were assessed at 1, 3, and 6 months, and yearly thereafter. With a median follow-up of 38 months (range 12-96), 16 (84.2%) patients were cured. One patient developed early graft loss, and 2 patients developed stricture at proximal anastomotic site. Mean Q(max) (mL/s) increased from 7.8 ± 5.4 preoperatively to 21.8 ± 9.2 postoperatively (P = .001), and mean AUA score decreased from 26.7 ± 3.9 preoperatively to 7.3 ± 3.8 postoperatively (P < .001). Our results suggest cBMG as a feasible alternative in 1-stage reconstruction of distal strictures confined to the glanular urethra because the glans penis has a good blood supply, providing an efficient circumferential graft take.
Article
When penile skin is available, onlay flap reconstruction is an excellent choice for 1-stage repair of complex hypospadias and strictures involving the glans, fossa navicularis and penile urethra. When the urethra is deficient circumferentially, tube flaps are an option but there is a high failure rate. We report our 8-year experience with 1-stage reconstruction using a dorsal buccal mucosa graft to reconstruct the deficient urethral plate with repair completed using an onlay penile skin flap. A total of 12 patients with a mean age of 42.8 years (range 16 to 77) underwent dorsal buccal grafting with ventral skin flap repair. Buccal mucosa was quilted to the penile ventral corpora to reconstruct the dorsal urethral aspect. Most surgeries included buccal graft reconstruction of the glans and fossa navicularis. Onlay penile skin flap repair was then performed to complete the reconstruction. All 12 patients were free of disabling chordee or urethral stricture disease at a mean 39-month followup (range 7 to 96). In 1 patient a small urethrocutaneous fistula developed, which was repaired. In another patient a fistula and medium caliber fossa navicularis narrowing developed with associated chordee, which were successfully repaired. Dorsal buccal grafting with ventral flap reconstruction appears to be an excellent option to repair circumferential urethral deficiency when penile skin is available, especially when chordee correction with distal urethral plate reconstruction is required.