ArticlePDF Available

The corallimorpharian Paracorynactis hoplites feeds on the sea star Choriaster granulatus in the western Indian ocean

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Paracorynactis hoplites is a highly efficient predator of various echinoderms and other invertebrates, including large individuals of Acanthaster planci (Bos et al. 2008, 2011). Although this corallimorpharian is usually hiding underneath ledges and inside crevices, individuals have been found in scattered groups on shallow reefs (Bos et al. 2011), suggesting that more individuals may be found in Nacala Bay. The present observation constitutes the first accurate record of P. hoplites from Mozambique and the western Indian Ocean.
Content may be subject to copyright.
OCEANARIUM
The corallimorpharian Paracorynactis hoplites feeds on the sea
star Choriaster granulatus in the western Indian ocean
Julien Wickel
1
&Mathieu Pinault
1,2
&Remi Garnier
3
&Arthur R. Bos
4,5
Received: 30 November 2015 / Revised: 8 February 2016 /Accepted: 10 February 2016
#Senckenberg Gesellschaft für Naturforschung and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2016
Paracorynactis hoplites (Haddon and Shackleton 1893)
(Anthozoa: Corallimorphidae) was recently assigned to the
new monotypic genus Paracorynactis based on specimens
from Indonesia and observations in the Philippines (Ocaña
et al. 2010). Shortly after, this species was reported from the
western Indian Ocean without locality data (Den Hartog and
Ocaña 2011), whereas earlier a resembling species,
Pseudocorynactis globulifera (Ehrenberg, 1834), was ob-
served on coral reefs off the Seychelles, also in the western
Indian Ocean (Den Hartog 1994).
Paracorynactis can be separated from Pseudocorynactis
by the presence of prominent acrospheres containing unusual-
ly large nematocysts, tentacles with limited extension capabil-
ity, and a highly protractible column (Ocaña et al. 2010;Bos
et al. 2011). The maximum number of tentacles in adults may
provide an additional diagnostic character (Ocaña et al. 2010):
<180 in Paracorynactis and <115 in Pseudocorynactis.In
contrast to most other corallimorpharians that occur in aggre-
gations and apply camouflage or mimicry (e.g. Waheed and
Hoeksema 2012), P. hoplites individuals usually hide in crev-
ices as solitary predators lurking for prey (Bos et al. 2011).
An individual of P. hoplites was observed feeding on a sea
star, Choriaster granulatus Lütken 1869, during a survey in
Nacala Bay (14°2709S; 40°4039E), Mozambique in
June 2014 (Fig. 1a). The corallimorpharian was attached un-
derneath a ledge at 4 m depth and had protracted its column in
order to connect its acrospheres to the sea stars upper surface.
Once one of the preysarmswasengulfedbythe
corallimorpharians mouth, the acrospheres released the prey
while uncovering whitened skin (Fig. 1b). A consolidated
substrate may have provided traction to the sea star, allowing
it to escape.
Paracorynactis hoplites is a highly efficient predator of
various echinoderms and other invertebrates, including large
individuals of Acanthaster planci (Bos et al. 2008,2011).
Although this corallimorpharian is usually hiding underneath
ledges and inside crevices, individuals have been found in
scattered groups on shallow reefs (Bos et al. 2011), suggesting
Communicated by B. W. Hoeksema
*Julien Wickel
julien.wickel@gmail.com
1
Marex -Marine Expertise Company, 13 Chemin Camille Roche,
97425 Les Avirons, Reunion Island, France
2
UMR 9220 UR-CNRS-IRD - Entropie, University of Reunion,
Saint-Denis, Reunion Island, France
3
Pareto, Saint-Denis, Reunion Island, France
4
Department of Biology, American University in Cairo, Cairo, Egypt
5
Naturalis Biodiversity Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands
Mar Biodiv
DOI 10.1007/s12526-016-0461-x
that more individuals may be found in Nacala Bay. The
present observation constitutes the first accurate record
of P. hoplites from Mozambique and the western Indian
Ocean.
References
Bos AR, Gumanao GS, Salac FN (2008) A newly discovered predator of
the crown-of-thorns starfish. Coral Reefs 27:581
Bos AR, Mueller B, Gumanao GS (2011) Feeding biology and symbiotic
relationships of the corallimorpharian Paracorynactis hoplites
(Anthozoa: Hexacorallia). Raffles Bull Zool 59:245250
Den Hartog JC (1994) Sea anemones of the Seychelles. In: Van der Land
J (ed) Oceanic reefs of the Seychelles. National Museum of Natural
History, Leiden, pp 7579
Den Hartog JC, Ocaña OV (2011) Sea anemones. In: Richmond MD (ed)
A field guide to the seashores of eastern Africa and the western
Indian ocean islands, 3rd edn. SIDA, Stockholm, pp 144149
Ocaña O, Den Hartog JC, Brito A, Bos AR (2010) On Pseudocorynactis
species and another related genus from the Indo-Pacific (Anthozoa:
Corallimorphidae). Rev Acad Canar Cienc 21:934
Waheed Z, Hoeksema BW (2012) Coral-mimicking corallimorpharians
on the reefs of Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia. Coral Reefs 31:519
Fig. 1 Paracorynactis hoplites in Nacala Bay, Mozambique. aPolyp
extending from underneath a reef ledge capturing a seastar, Choriaster
granulatus. bTraces of the predators acrospheres remaining on the
preysuppersurface
Mar Biodiv
... The first author in this paper has enough experience working on Actiniaria and Corallimorpharia from New Zealand waters (see CAIRNS et al., 2009) but, obviously, he was not one of the reviewers in charge of the mentioned Fautin's paper. Since 2011 nothing has been published to void the new genus Paracorynactis, a very eloquent silence along several years because Paracorynactis hoplites is now days a well-known species with a particular predatory behaviour and ecology (BOS et al., 2011;WICKEL et al., 2016). Some other wrong interpretations and concepts have been noticed in Fautin's paper (2011): A) A not very accurate affirmation about den Hartog work as "only dealt with shallow waters corallimorpharians", as the deep water genera Corallimorphus, Sideractis and Nectactis were searched by him (see den HARTOG et al., 1993). ...
... Paracorynactis is an active diurnal predator with moderate extendible tentacles but with a high capacity to elongate the body wall in order to catch the prey. Echinoderms are the main pray of Paracorynactis and the moderate extendible tentacles can approach to the prey thanks to the highly extendible column (BOS et al., 2011;WICKEL et al., 2016). P. hoplites specimens are highly efficient predators usually found in crevices (BOS et al., 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
The genus Pseudocorynactis den Hartog, 1980 was synonymized in 2011 (see FAUTIN, 2011: 39) because its taxonomic weakness and merged into Corynactis Allman, 1846. In the same paper Fautin merge automatically Pseudocorynactis caboverdensis and Pseudocorynactis globulifera into Corynactis without appropriate discussion otherwise the paper printed one year ago (see OCAÑA et al., 2010) would had been referenced in Fautin's paper and indeed the new genus Paracorynactis Ocaña, den Hartog, Brito and Bos, 2010 would had not been overlooked by the North American author. Along this paper we reestab-lished the genus Pseudocorynactis and confirming the taxonomic status of Paracorynac-tis as separated genera from Corynactis. In addition, there are also enmended diagnosis of the genera Pseudocorynactis, Paracorynactis and Corynactis in order to prevent future er-roneus taxonomic interpretations.
... Most species are distributed across the reef zones of subtidal and intertidal reefs in the Indo-Pacific and Caribbean seas (Chadwick & Adams, 1991;Waheed & Hoeksema, 2012;Work et al., 2018), but there are also a handful of deep-sea species (Fautin et al., 2002;Fautin, 2016). Polyps are solitary and often found attached to coral rock by their pedal disc or body column (Wickel et al., 2017). ...
Article
Full-text available
Corallimorpharia is an order of benthic cnidarians with a known global richness of 51 species, most of which are tropical and found in shallow-water habitats. These solitary organisms, which may occur in aggregations, are often overlooked compared to its more well-known sister group, Scleractinia (stony corals), as well as the closely-related Actiniaria (sea anemones) with which they are usually confused. Data on corallimorpharians in Singapore are sparse, though there are anecdotal photographic reports of various morphotypes at intertidal localities collated by citizen scientists. Combining these citizen-science observations and field collections, this study used both morphological and DNA sequencing approaches to establish the diversity and distribution of Corallimorpharia in Singapore. Based on a collection of 31 specimens and observational data from 23 coastal sites, examination of field photographs and gross morphology yielded nine distinct morphotypes. To infer their identities based on molecular data, three DNA loci were sequenced-mitochondrial intergenic region (IGR) between the cytochrome c oxidase subunits 1 (COX1) and 3 (COX3), part of the ATP synthase F0 subunit 6 gene (ATP6), and nuclear internal transcribed spacers (ITS). Phylogenetic analysis, supported by detailed examination of the internal and external morphology, recovered six morphospecies placed within four genus-level clades, including two species from Corynactis and Discosoma that are possibly new to science. The molecular phylogeny is nearly concordant with the morphological taxonomy and distinction between the Rhodactis species is equivocal, likely because of recent divergence and the limited number of molecular markers used. This study represents the first comprehensive inventory and phylogenetic analysis of corallimorpharians in Singapore that would facilitate further research on this understudied order.
... . Only recently, this polyp was reported to feed on another sea star in a coral reef in Mozambique(Wickel, Pinault, Garnier, & Bos, 2017). The above, in addition to new species descriptions and records, underline the unique ecological conditions in the Davao Gulf. ...
Article
Full-text available
Selected fish were measured on markets along the Davao Gulf, Philippines between 2009 and 2016, augmenting the number of Length-Weight relationships (LWR) published earlier for the same area. LWRs were calculated for 28 fishes including those of 12 firstly reported, rare species. SL-TL and SL-FL relationships were determined for 28 and 25 species (also including 8 and 12 newly reported relationships, respectively). Minimum size at which individuals start developing forked tails are provided for Cheilinus fasciatus (SL = 15.0 cm), Plectorhinchus polytaenia (SL = 27.0 cm), Pseudobalistes flavimarginatus (SL = 18.0 cm) and Thalassoma hardwicke (SL = 11.5 cm). The flatfish Psettodes erumei had a right-left eyed ratio of 0.55.
Article
Full-text available
The feeding upon large animals—even larger than the predator—by benthic cnidarians has been reported from many ecosystems but never exhaustively studied to date. By reviewing 38 papers on this topic, this review aims to recap the observations on the predatory behaviour of polyps, to establish feeding plasticity boundaries and to understand the contribute of this trophic strategy to the benthic–pelagic coupling. The reviewed documents published increasingly during the last two decades mostly reported observations on heterotrophic Anthozoa in shallow ecosystems collected through photo/video records. The main prey items are represented by gelatinous zooplankton and echinoderms. The lexical discordance in the considered papers highlights the need to standardize the terminology to describe the feeding behaviour of benthic Cnidaria, opportunistic and characterized by a strong plasticity. Given the importance of large prey in cnidarian trophism, we proposed an unambiguous terminology that will help the online search of literature and address future studies. We suggest identifying micro-predation (predator/prey size ratio ≥ 5:1) and macro-predation (predator/prey size ratio is ≤ 1:1) as distinct feeding modalities, because the capture of large prey involves peculiar movements of polyps, such as stretching and retracting of column and tentacles to pull the prey towards the mouth.
Article
Full-text available
Tentacles development is important for the Corallimorphidae in terms of speciation and different evolutionary levels in tentacle anatomy. We studied three species of Corallimorpharia: two belonging to Pseudocorynactis and the third belonging to the new genus Paracorynactis. Highly extendable tentacles are proposed to differentiate between the above mentioned genera. The species Pseudocorynactis globulifera from the Red Sea was newly added to this genus; we also described the new species Pseudocorynactis tuberculata from Indonesia and Maldives. On an ecological note, Paracorynactis hoplites feeds on the crown of thorns sea star (Acanthaster spp.) and may help controlling its populations.
Article
Full-text available
Polyps of the corallimorpharian Paracorynactis hoplites were studied in coral reefs of the Davao Gulf, the Philippines, between October 2007 and January 2009. Polyps of Paracorynactis hoplites preyed mainly on echinoderms. Predation on seven species of echinoderms was observed in the fi eld (four asteroids, two echinoids and one holothurian); an additional ten species were accepted during feeding trials (four asteroids, four echinoids and two holothurians). The echinoids Diadema setosum, Diadema savignyi and Echinotrix calamaris, and the ophiuriod Ophiomastix sp. were not adversely affected by the polyps. The opisthobranch Phyllidiella pustulosa (Mollusca) was accepted during feeding trials, whereas the gastropod Cypraea tigris was not adversely affected. In a feeding experiment, polyps of Paracorynactis hoplites (maximum diameter 170 mm) completely ingested crown-of-thorns sea stars (Acanthaster planci) of up to 340 mm diameter. The polyps had a mean daily biomass uptake of 24.5 g d-1 when having a single-species asteroid diet. Fishes of several species of families Apogonidae, Gobiidae, Labridae, Pomacentridae, and Pseudochromidae as well as the shrimps (Periclimenes holthuisi, Periclimenes lacerate, Stenopus hispidus and Thor amboinensis) lived near or among the tentacles of the polyps.
Article
Full-text available
A large solitary polyp of the genus Pseudocorynactis (Corallimorpharia) was observed to prey on the crown-of-thorns starfish (Acanthaster planci), which itself has destroyed large areas of coral reefs by solely feeding on the polyps of reef-building corals. We observed Pseudocorynactis sp. to prey on echinoderms and to completely ingest starfishes, including the crown-of-thorns starfish, up to 25 cm in diameter. This newly discovered predator may play a key role in the ecology of crown-of-thorns outbreaks by controlling the juvenile and sub-adult populations of this starfish.
Article
Tentacles development is important for the Corallimorphidae in terms of speciation, being interesting to discuss about the presence of different evolutionary levels in tentacle anatomy. We studied three species of Corallimorpharia belonging two of them to Pseudo-corynactis and one to the new genus Paracorynactis. The extendible capability of the tentacles is proposed to make difference among the above mentioned genera. The species Pseudo-corynactis globulifera from the Red Sea is include in this genus for the first time, we also have described the new species Pseudocorynactis tuberculata from Indonesia and Maldives. The help control of Paracorynactis hoplites on the crown of thorns sea stars population is exposed. RESUMEN El desarrollo tentacular es importante para comprender los procesos de especiación en la familia Corallimorphidae y poder discutir acerca de la existencia de niveles evolutivos relacionados con la anatomía de los tentáculos. En este artículo estudiamos tres especies de Corallimorpharia pertenecientes dos al género Pseudocorynactis y una al nuevo género Paracorynactis. La capacidad de extensión de los tentáculos es una característica que proponemos para diferenciar los géneros. Incluimos a la especie Pseudocorynactis globulifera en este género por primera vez y también se describe una nueva especie, Pseudocorynactis tuberculata, a partir de material procedente de Indonesia y las Maldivas. Es interesante destacar la capacidad de la especie Paracorynactis hoplites para ejercer cierto control sobre las poblaciones de la Rev. Acad. Canar. Cienc., XXI (Núms. 3-4), 9-34 (2009) (publicado en septiembre de 2010) maqueta.qxp 23/08/2010 23:40 PAEgina 9 10 estrella de mar corona de pinchos que tantos estragos causa a los madreporarios en el Indo-Pacífico. Palabras claves: Corallimorpharia, capacidad de extensión de los tentáculos, nuevo género, nueva especie, nueva combinación, región Indopacífica.
Sea anemones of the Seychelles
  • Den Hartog
  • JC Hartog Den
Den Hartog JC (1994) Sea anemones of the Seychelles. In: Van der Land J (ed) Oceanic reefs of the Seychelles. National Museum of Natural History, Leiden, pp 75-79
Sea anemones. In: Richmond MD (ed) A field guide to the seashores of eastern Africa and the western Indian ocean islands
  • Den Hartog
  • J C Ocaña
  • JC Hartog Den
Den Hartog JC, Ocaña OV (2011) Sea anemones. In: Richmond MD (ed) A field guide to the seashores of eastern Africa and the western Indian ocean islands, 3rd edn. SIDA, Stockholm, pp 144-149