ArticlePublisher preview available

A Pilot Study of the Tongue Pull-Back Exercise for Improving Tongue-Base Retraction and Two Novel Methods to Add Resistance to the Tongue Pull-Back

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

This pilot study investigated the tongue pull-back (TPB) exercise to improve tongue-base retraction as well as two methods to add resistance to the TPB. Surface electromyography (sEMG) to the submental triangle was used as an indication of tongue-base activity on 13 healthy adults during: (1) saliva swallow, (2) 15 mL water swallow, (3) effortful swallow, (4) unassisted TPB, (5) TPB with added resistance by holding the tongue with gauze (finger-resisted TPB), and (6) TPB with the tongue clipped to a spring-loaded tension resistance device (device-resisted TPB). Order of the exercises was randomized. The exercises fell into two groups-weak and intense. Weak exercises included saliva swallow, water swallow, and unassisted TPB (mean sEMG = 19.07 μV, p = .593). Intense exercises included effortful swallow, finger-resisted TPB, and device-resisted TPB (mean sEMG = 36.44 μV, p = .315). Each intense exercise resulted in significantly higher mean sEMG peak amplitude than each weak exercise (p < .05), with one exception; the effortful swallow was not significantly different than the unassisted TPB (p = .171). This study provides preliminary evidence that the unassisted TPB may not be any more helpful for improving tongue-base retraction than normal swallowing. Adding resistance to the TPB by holding the tongue with gauze may be an effective alternative. This study also demonstrates proof-of-concept for creating a device to attach to the tongue and provide tension resistance during the TPB exercise. Further research with a more sophisticated design is needed before such a device can be fully developed and implemented clinically.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
A Pilot Study of the Tongue Pull-Back Exercise for Improving
Tongue-Base Retraction and Two Novel Methods to Add
Resistance to the Tongue Pull-Back
Laurie Slovarp
1
Lauren King
1
Catherine Off
1
Julie Liss
2
Received: 25 June 2015 / Accepted: 20 January 2016 / Published online: 9 February 2016
ÓSpringer Science+Business Media New York 2016
Abstract This pilot study investigated the tongue pull-
back (TPB) exercise to improve tongue-base retraction as
well as two methods to add resistance to the TPB. Surface
electromyography (sEMG) to the submental triangle was
used as an indication of tongue-base activity on 13 healthy
adults during: (1) saliva swallow, (2) 15 mL water swal-
low, (3) effortful swallow, (4) unassisted TPB, (5) TPB
with added resistance by holding the tongue with gauze
(finger-resisted TPB), and (6) TPB with the tongue clipped
to a spring-loaded tension resistance device (device-re-
sisted TPB). Order of the exercises was randomized. The
exercises fell into two groups—weak and intense.Weak
exercises included saliva swallow, water swallow, and
unassisted TPB (mean sEMG =19.07 lV, p=.593). In-
tense exercises included effortful swallow, finger-resisted
TPB, and device-resisted TPB (mean sEMG =36.44 lV,
p=.315). Each intense exercise resulted in significantly
higher mean sEMG peak amplitude than each weak exer-
cise (p\.05), with one exception; the effortful swallow
was not significantly different than the unassisted TPB
(p=.171). This study provides preliminary evidence that
the unassisted TPB may not be any more helpful for
improving tongue-base retraction than normal swallowing.
Adding resistance to the TPB by holding the tongue with
gauze may be an effective alternative. This study also
demonstrates proof-of-concept for creating a device to
attach to the tongue and provide tension resistance during
the TPB exercise. Further research with a more sophisti-
cated design is needed before such a device can be fully
developed and implemented clinically.
Keywords Deglutition Deglutition disorders
Dysphagia Tongue-base retraction Electromyography
Effortful swallow Tongue pull-back Strength training
The pharyngeal swallow consists of a series of multiple
complex sensory-motor events that occur in a coordinated
fashion to efficiently and effectively move a bolus through
the pharynx and into the esophagus, while simultaneously
protecting the airway from aspiration [1,2]. Motor events
that contribute to the pharyngeal swallow include tongue-
base retraction, hyolaryngeal elevation and excursion,
sequential contraction of the pharyngeal constrictors, and
opening of the upper esophageal sphincter (UES) [14].
The role of tongue-base retraction during the swallow is to
move the base of the tongue posteriorly to meet the pos-
terior pharyngeal wall, which moves superiorly and ante-
riorly during the swallow [1,36]. Collectively, posterior
movement of the tongue base and superior-anterior
movement of the posterior pharyngeal wall increase pha-
ryngeal pressure during the swallow to push the bolus
through the pharynx and into the esophagus [3,5,7].
Impairment in tongue-base retraction results in post-swal-
low residue within the pharynx, particularly the valleculae,
and is common in patients suffering from dysphagia due to
various etiologies [2,811].
The literature is inconsistent regarding the exact muscles
responsible for tongue-base retraction. Most sources describe
the intrinsic and extrinsic lingual muscles when discussing
anatomy but then generally refer to the ‘‘tongue base’’ or
&Laurie Slovarp
laurie.slovarp@umontana.edu
1
Communicative Sciences and Disorders, The University of
Montana, 32 Campus Drive, Missoula, MT 59812-9968, USA
2
Speech and Hearing Science, Arizona State University, 975
S. Myrtle Ave, P.O. Box 870102, Tempe, AZ 85287-0102,
USA
123
Dysphagia (2016) 31:416–423
DOI 10.1007/s00455-016-9693-y
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... They noted that repeated ESs cause the pharyngeal muscles to contract more strongly, which increases overall strength over time. Regarding the principles of exercise, ES has excellent specificity [3]. Specificity is an exercise principle that is most effective when the training task is similar to the end goal of the exercise. ...
... The researchers noted the limitations of ES as an exercise program. Slovarp et al. reported that the suprahyoid muscle activation level varied significantly among people during ES performance [3]. This indicates that the performance level may be inconsistent in patients with dysphagia performing ES. ...
... They also pointed out limitations in terms of resistive load and gradual resistance provision. In addition, ES is difficult to be performed by patients with severe dysphagia because it requires repeated swallowing by participants for exercise [3]. According to Kim et al., ES exercise is limited in that exercise intensity cannot be quantified [9]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this study was to confirm the effect of effortful swallowing (ES) exercise programs applied to increase the swallowing-related muscle strength in the elderly. In this study, 20 healthy elderly people (76.65 ± 5.87 years; 10 women and 10 men) participated and exercised for 7 weeks. The experimental group performed ES exercise combined with external resistance using Iowa Oral Performance Instrument (IOPI), and the control group performed pure ES without external resistance. The exercises were performed for 20 min a day, 2 days a week for 7 weeks in both groups. ES was repeated 60 times in weeks 1 and 2, 80 times in week 3 and 4, and 120 times in weeks 5–7. In the experimental group, the isometric and swallowing tongue pressures at week 8 were significantly improved compared to baseline. At week 8, the anterior and swallowing tongue pressures and anterior tongue endurance were significantly higher than those of the control group. In the control group, no significant change in tongue pressure-related variables was observed after 7 weeks of exercise. ES exercise combined with IOPI resistance for 7 weeks tended to increase the suprahyoid muscle activation level without statistical significance. For clinical application of this exercise protocol, further studies including more elderly people and patients with dysphagia are required.
... When introducing a new rehabilitative exercise, establishing its effects on healthy subjects is an important first step before applying it to patient populations [4]. Generally, pilot studies of newly developed rehabilitative exercises verify the physiological effects of these exercises on healthy individuals using sEMG [4,11,12]. ...
... These pressures may provide additional information about the therapeutic mechanism underlying training effects. Both the measurements used in this study have been used in previous studies to represent the changes generated during long-term swallowing-related exercises in healthy subjects [4,11,18]. This study hypothesized that long-term HESE would enhance swallowing-related submental muscle activation and tongue pressure. ...
Article
Full-text available
This pilot study examined the effect of a new head extension swallowing exercise (HESE) on submental muscle activity and tongue strength in healthy volunteers. Fifteen young adults (10 females and 5 males) were instructed to extend their head backwards as much as possible, and while watching the ceiling, swallowed their saliva every 10 s for a duration of 20 min. Twenty-four treatments were performed over 8 weeks. The outcome variables evaluated at baseline, 4 and 8 weeks of training, and 12-week follow-up included mean and peak submental muscle activation amplitudes during normal and effortful swallowing measured via surface electromyography, and anterior and posterior isometric tongue pressures were measured with the Iowa Oral Performance Instrument. Results indicated that the muscle activation amplitudes during effortful swallowing increased significantly at 4 and 8 weeks compared to baseline (p < 0.025). However, the increases in amplitudes during normal swallowing were minor (nonsignificant) after 8 weeks compared to baseline. The isometric pressures of the tongue tip and the posterior part of the oral tongue were significantly higher at 8 weeks compared to baseline (p < 0.025). Thus, the 8-week HESE protocol significantly improved suprahyoid muscle activity during effortful swallowing as well as the isometric tongue pressures. The HESE appears effective in exercising and strengthening the suprahyoid muscles and tongue muscles in healthy participants. Although encouraging, these results need to be replicated in clinical trials for testing the therapeutic effects of the HESE in older adults and patients with dysphagia who present with decreased hyolaryngeal elevation.
... However, in the case of muscle strengthening exercises, when the primary cause of a swallowing disorder is muscle weakness or muscle tension, various exercise methods comprising tasks that induce higher loading than the level of muscle activity required for typical swallowing may be used [5,8,9]. Nevertheless, it is difficult to objectively and systematically monitor and control the resistance applied to the swallowing muscles when performing skill-based or strength training to improve swallowing function [5,10,11]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The suprahyoid muscles play an important role in protecting the airway by elevating both the hyoid bone and larynx superior-anteriorly during swallowing. However, providing systematic external resistance when performing exercises to improve suprahyoid muscle strength is practically difficult. This study attempted to confirm whether systematic resistance can be provided to the suprahyoid muscles using the Iowa Oral Performance Instrument (IOPI)—a representative tongue pressure measurement device. Thirty-one healthy adults participated in this study (20.6 ± 0.96 y, 19 females). The participants performed 16 exercise tasks using the IOPI three times each in random order (Anterior/posterior tongue × pressing/swallowing task × 40/60/80/100% maximum tongue pressure). Furthermore, the floor of the mouth (FOM) muscle activity during exercise was simultaneously measured using surface electromyography. During the pressing task, there were significant differences in FOM maximal muscle activity among the four exercise intensities for both the anterior and posterior oral tongue. For the swallowing task, a significant difference was found in FOM muscle activity among the four exercise intensities for the anterior tongue. For the posterior tongue, significant differences were identified among all conditions except for the comparison between 80% and 100% maximum tongue pressure. Significant correlations between the degree of tongue pressure and maximal FOM muscle activity were found in both the pressing and swallowing tasks at the anterior and posterior oral tongue. Overall, these results indicate that objective and systematic external resistance can be applied using the IOPI—a standard tongue pressure measurement device—during the program to improve suprahyoid muscle function.
... Slovarp et al. noted that providing gradual resistance during ES is difficult. In addition, participants who had difficulty in swallowing repeatedly because of severe impairment of swallowing function could have limited participation in this exercise [35]. Kim et al. noted another limitation, which is that accurately quantifying the exercise intensity when applying ES as an exercise program is challenging [11]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Effortful swallow (ES) is a maneuver intended to increase pressure on a bolus by swallowing and pushing with sufficient force to facilitate clearance. Although ES is mainly known for its immediate effects, the long-term effects of applying ES as an exercise program remain unclear. This study investigated the effects of a 7-week systematic ES exercise regime on swallowing-related muscle strength in individuals aged 65 years and over. In total, 30 healthy older adults participated in this study (16 women and 14 men, aged 67–90 years). The subjects participated in the exercise program for 20 min a day, twice a week, for 7 weeks. To gradually increase exercise intensity, the number of exercises per session was increased from the initial 60 repetitions (weeks 1–2) to 120 repetitions (weeks 5–7). To measure the effect of the strengthening exercise program, the activation level of suprahyoid muscles was measured using surface electromyography, and a tongue pressure measurement system was used to measure variables related to tongue strength (isometric tongue pressure, swallowing tongue pressure, and tongue endurance). Although the effect of ES exercise on muscle strength through gradual adjustment of exercise frequency was not confirmed, ES remains valuable as an exercise for strengthening the muscles involved in swallowing. Future studies are warranted to determine the effects of ES exercise after adjusting for other variables of exercise intensity.
... These factors are known to modulate the effect of exercise on directly involved (targeted) as well as indirectly involved (nontargeted) skeletal muscles, including exercise-related changes in strength and endurance (Tew et al. 2009;Karavirta et al. 2011a;Wilson et al. 2012b). Although the effect of some of these factors has been examined when the exercise was designed to directly target tongue muscles (Clark 2012;Van Nuffelen et al. 2015;Slovarp et al. 2016), it is currently unknown if these factors also impact tongue muscle performance when exercise targets skeletal muscles and only indirectly involves tongue muscles. Such information would be valuable to better understand how to promote healthy tongue muscle performance throughout the aging process. ...
Article
Full-text available
Exercise mode (i.e., resistance training, endurance training) is known to yield mode‐specific effects on strength and endurance of muscles that are directly targeted during the exercise. Such mode‐specific effects can also be observed in indirectly involved (i.e., nontargeted) muscles. Mode‐specific muscle performance changes of nontargeted muscles, however, have only been investigated within the skeletal system. Therefore, as a first step, this study aimed to determine if bulbar muscle performance (tongue strength [TS], tongue endurance [TE]) differs between weightlifters and runners and if group differences are tongue region‐specific. The Iowa Oral Performance Instrument (IOPI) was used to measure TS and TE of the anterior and posterior tongue regions in 21 weightlifters and 23 runners. In weightlifters anterior TS was significantly greater than posterior TS (P = 0.008), whereas in runners anterior and posterior TS were comparable. Furthermore, weightlifters produced significantly greater anterior TS than runners (P = 0.001). Finally, TE was overall significantly greater in runners than in weightlifters (P = 0.001). Findings suggest that exercise mode may differentially impact performance patterns of nontargeted bulbar muscles. More research is warranted to better understand the mechanisms underlying tongue muscle performance differences between weightlifters and runners. This study aimed to determine if bulbar muscle performance (tongue strength, tongue endurance) differs between weightlifters and runners and if group differences are tongue region‐specific. The findings suggest that exercise mode may differentially impact performance patterns of nontargeted bulbar muscles. More research is warranted to better understand the mechanisms underlying tongue muscle performance differences between weightlifters and runners.
... However, this is an invasive method, which can cause considerable inconvenience to the subject. Thus, this study used sEMG, which is commonly used in exploratory research [26,27], to identify the feasibility and physiological changes of relative THS in the elderly population. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study investigated differences in suprahyoid muscle activity in elderly adults during tongue-hold swallowing (THS) according to tongue protrusion length to determine the most effective tongue protrusion length during THS. A total of 52 healthy participants (34 females and 18 males) aged 69–92 years were included. Changes in suprahyoid muscle activation during normal swallowing and THS with 1/3rd and 2/3rd tongue protrusions using surface electromyography were observed. Suprahyoid muscle activation significantly increased with the increasing tongue protrusion length (p < 0.05). Depending on the responses of the participants based on tongue protrusion length, participants were categorized into the increase group [increased suprahyoid muscle activity with tongue protrusion, n = 36 (1/3rd THS compared to normal swallowing) or 38 (2/3rd THS compared to normal swallowing)] or decrease group [decreased suprahyoid muscle activity with tongue protrusion, n = 16 (1/3rd THS compared to normal swallowing) or 14 (2/3rd THS compared to normal swallowing)]. The functional reserve of the increase group was significantly higher than that of the decrease group (p < 0.05). Many elderly people were found to have increased activation of the suprahyoid muscle during THS; however, others showed the opposite. Therefore, it is necessary to confirm the degree of suprahyoid muscle activation during THS so that the patient can perform the exercise at the tongue protrusion length that can maximize the effect of the exercise. For individuals who cannot overcome even a small amount of tongue protrusion (e.g., 1/3rd MTPL), replacing THS with another exercise may be considered.
... The tongue pull back maneuver targets tongue base retraction, as well; but only recently have data been published regarding its measured utility. A novel resistance device (Slovarp, King, Off, & Liss, 2016) holds the anterior tongue in place while the subject attempts to pull the tongue back. This was compared to a finger hold resistance and no resistance using sEMG. ...
Article
The act of swallowing is “multidimensional” and involves contributions from several neuroanatomical structures. A stroke affecting any of these areas is likely to cause some amount of physiologic impairment in deglutition. This paper explores current and emerging evidence for rehabilitative exercises for physiological impairments in deglutition due to stroke. Evidence is more emerging than current. However, focus on task specificity and muscle load, along with the use of resistance that can be measured in an increasing number of ways, is encouraging. Results are supporting exercises at specific increments of maximum values using exercises that are as task-specific as possible. Clinical trials on patients post-stroke are challenging and require scrutiny toward diagnosis, age, severity, and type of dysphagia, as well as judicious use of controls. More research is needed to define effective exercise programs for swallowing impairments post-stroke.
Article
Background: Evidence suggests that prophylactic swallowing exercises improve swallowing-related outcomes after chemoradiation therapy (CRT) for head and neck cancer (HNC). However, low patient adherence undermines the potential effectiveness of the training. Purpose: This study aimed to examine whether a self-training booklet improves adherence to prophylactic swallowing exercises in patients with HNC undergoing CRT. Methods: Multiple disciplines jointly created a self-training booklet for prophylactic swallowing exercises that incorporated behavior change techniques. In this case-control study, 15 patients were instructed to perform six swallowing exercises using the booklet during CRT (the booklet group). The control group included 15 patients who had previously completed the same training before introducing the booklet, and thus did not use the booklet. All patients underwent clinical evaluation and videofluoroscopy before and after CRT. Adherence was determined from patient records on log sheets. Patients who completed more than 80% of the training sessions were considered highly adherent. Results: Although the grade of oral mucositis at the end of CRT was significantly higher in the booklet group than in the control group, there were no significant differences in the level of adherence between the two groups. This suggests that the booklet group had a more significant barrier to adhering to the training than the control group. Nevertheless, the patients in the booklet group continued their self-training to the same extent as the control group. Conclusion: The booklet may help patients with HNC undergoing CRT to maintain their motivation and continue self-training under challenging conditions
Article
Full-text available
Oropharyngeal dysphagia is a frequent occurrence following stroke. The length of acute care hospitalization, however, has decreased over time with many individuals weak and frail upon admission for rehabilitation and possibly with continued dysphagia upon discharge. It is imperative that the swallowing therapist have a thorough understanding of evidence-based compensatory and exercise management strategies at all stages of recovery for patients with dysphagia following stroke.
Article
Get all the information you need to confidently manage dysphagia in professional practice with Dysphagia: Clinical Management in Adults and Children, 2nd Edition! This logically organized, evidence-based resource reflects the latest advancements in dysphagia in an approachable and user-friendly manner to help you master the clinical evaluation and diagnostic decision-making processes. New coverage of the latest insights and research along with expanded information on infant and child swallowing will help prepare you for the conditions you'll face in the clinical setting. Plus, the realistic case scenarios and detailed review questions threaded throughout the book will help you develop the clinical reasoning skills needed for professional success.
Article
Surface electromyographic (sEMG) biofeedback has been used to enhance behavioral treatment interventions in a variety of movement disorders involving the head and neck musculature. These include, but are not limited to, voice disorders (Andrews, Warner, & Stewart, 1986), dysarthria (Gentil, Aucouturier, Delong, & Sambuis, 1994), hemifacial spasm (Rubow, Rosenbek, Collins, & Celesia, 1984), mandibular closure (Nemec & Cohen, 1984), and dysphagia (Bryant, 1991; Crary, 1995). Despite the potential for widespread application of sEMG biofeedback-assisted treatments in motor disorders of the head and neck musculature, speech-language pathologists generally are not aware of these techniques or of their potential application to speech, voice, or swallowing disorders. The intent of this tutorial is to provide a general introduction to surface electromyographic biofeedback techniques as they may apply to the rehabilitation of dysphagia in adults. Specific examples are provided based on clinical management of patients with dysphagia following brainstem stroke.
Article
The effortful swallow achieves overload through high effort. It was predicted that both immediate effects on biomechanics and long-term neuromuscular adaptations would be facilitated by maximal overload during this exercise. This study examined how high-effort sips from small-diameter straws influenced linguapalatal swallow pressures. Additionally, training effects of effortful swallows preceded by high-effort sips were compared to two other exercise conditions: effortful swallows preceded by maximum effort lingual elevation and effortful swallows performed in isolation. Training outcomes included linguapalatal pressures produced during effortful and noneffortful swallows, and maximum isometric pressure (MIP) produced during tongue elevation and interlabial compression. Forty healthy adults participated in the experiment. Lingual-palatal swallowing pressure during non effortful and effortful swallows and MIPs were measured prior to and after 4 weeks of training. Prior to training, anterior linguapalatal pressures were significantly higher during effortful compared to noneffortful swallows. Anterior linguapalatal pressures did not significantly differ during swallows preceded by sips from high-resistance straws. Weak correlations were observed between tongue MIP and linguapalatal pressures during effortful swallows. After training, anterior linguapalatal pressures significantly increased, with training effects more dramatic for effortful swallows. Anterior tongue MIP also significantly increased. Gains in anterior linguapalatal pressure were not correlated with gains in tongue MIP. Training effects did not vary across exercise condition. The study failed to find a training advantage of pairing the effortful swallow with a precursor movement. The results demonstrated specificity of training, with more dramatic benefits observed for effortful swallows relative to noneffortful swallows. Further investigation is needed to characterize training effects in older adults and patients with dysphagia.
Article
We tested the effects of surface electrical stimulation on hyoid elevation during swallowing in healthy volunteers. Sixteen people were recruited and randomly divided into two groups. Electrical stimulation was applied to the skin above the infrahyoid muscle in the experimental group. The stimulation current was adjusted until muscle contraction occurred and the hyoid bone became depressed. Participants were asked to swallow forcefully so as to elevate the hyolaryngeal complex when the stimulation began. The same experiment was performed in the control group except the intensity of stimulation was adjusted to just above the sensory threshold. The two groups received ten 20-min treatments over 2weeks. We recorded the myoelectrical activity of the submental muscles and the amount of hyoid bone movement at three time points (pretreatment, immediately post-treatment, and 2weeks after treatment). In the experimental group, the amount of y-axis hyoid bone excursion was increased immediately post-treatment, but this effect faded within 2weeks following the treatment. Myoelectrical activity was not affected by either treatment regimen. We concluded that effortful swallowing coupled with electrical stimulation increases the degree of hyoid elevation in healthy volunteers. It needs to be evaluated for its long-term effectiveness in increasing the elevation of hyolaryngeal complex.
Article
The influence of bolus volume and viscosity on the distribution of anterior lingual force during the oral stage of swallowing was investigated using a new force transducer technology. The maximum force amplitudes from 5 normal adults were measured simultaneously at the mid-anterior, right, and left lateral tongue margins during 10 volitional swallows of 5-, 10-, and 20-ml volumes of water, applesauce, and pudding. Results indicated significant increases in peak force amplitude as viscosity increased. Volume did not significantly influence maximum lingual force amplitudes. Individual subjects demonstrated consistent patterns of asymmetrical force distribution across the lingual margins tested. The results suggest that bolus-specific properties influence the mechanics of oral stage lingual swallowing. This finding has important clinical implications in the assessment and treatment of dysphagic individuals.
Article
The neurophysiological control of swallowing involves three functionally distinct divisions: the oral preparatory phase, a pharyngolaryngeal phase and an esophageal phase. Both the pharyngeal and esophageal phases involve control by interneurons in different regions of the reticular formation of the medulla within the brain stem. The central neural control of the brain stem is triggered by specific patterns of sensory or descending cortical input. The threshold that will elicit swallowing depends upon the type of stimuli (i.e., specific fluids, touch, pressure). The threshold is higher if much of the pharyngeal mucosa is anesthetized and if salivation is inhibited. Sensory feedback does change the threshold and intensity of sequential muscle recruitment. Descending pathways that modify swallowing include the prefrontal cortex, the limbic-hypothalamic system, and specific regions of the pons.