Content uploaded by Md. Atiar Rahman
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Md. Atiar Rahman on Feb 15, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
ResearchArticle
ANTINOCICEPTIVEANDANTIINFLAMMATORYEFFECTOFCRINUMASIATICUMBULB
EXTRACT
MD.ATIARRAHMAN1*,RUMANASHARMIN2,MD.NAZIMUDDIN3,MAHBUBUZZAMAN4,SOHELRANA5NAZIM
UDDINAHMED6
1,2,3,5DepartmentofBiochemistryandMolecularBiology,UniversityofChittagong,Chittagong4331,Bangladesh
4,6BangladeshCouncilforScientificandIndustrialResearch(BCSIR),Chittagong,Bangladesh
Email: atiarh@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Themethanol extract ofCrinumasiaticumbulb wasevaluatedfor itsantinociceptive propertiesonthe paininducedbyaceticacidandformalinin
Swissalbinomice.Thebulbextractatadoseof1,1.5and2g/kgproducedaninhibitionof40.71,56.42and68.57%on painindu cedby acetic acid
andatadoseof1.5g/kg&2g/kgproducedaninhibitionof60.0and67.0%onthatinducedbyformalin.Theanti‐inflammatoryactivityofthesame
extractwasestimatedvolumetricallybymeasuringthemeanincreaseinhindpawvolumeofcarrageenan‐inducedWistaralbinoratwiththehelpof
plethysmometer.Oraladministrationofbulbextractatadose of 1.5g/kg& 2g/kg showedthe highestinhibition 52.56%and 47.3 7%,respectively,
atthe3rdhourofadministration whereasat adose of1g/kg showed37.5%inhibitionatthe4thhour.Diclofenacsodium atadoseof40mg/kgwas
usedasastandarddrugintheinhibitionofaceticacidandformalininducedpainaswellasincarrageenan‐inducedpawedema.
Keywords:Crinumasiaticum,antinociceptive,anti‐inflammatory,pawedema,carrageenan.
INTRODUCTION
CrinumasiaticumisanevergreenherblocallyknownasBara
kanurinBangladesh.ItiswidelydistributedtoChina,Hongkong,
India, Srilanka, Myanmar, Thailand,Malayasia, Ryukyu Islands &
Mainland Japan1,2,3.ChittagongHilltractsofBangladesharethe
mainhabitatofthisherb.
TribesofChittagongHillyareasusethisplantasaremedyofpain,
swelling carbuncle, piles, earache, arthritis, skin disease (leprosy),
cold and cough disorders, vomiting, worms infestation, disuria,
polyuria, bowel complains, throat disorder, colic, flautulance,and
fever1,2,3. Crinumasiaticum(C.asiaticum) is used traditionally for
variouspurposes. Leaves and root of this plant are used as emetic,
diaphoreticandpurgative.
Leavesof this herb smeared with castor oilandwarmedis a useful
remedyfor repellinginflammationsandswellingsat theend of toes
andfingers.Alternatively,bruisedleavesoftheherbmixedwith
castoroilcanbeusedforthispurpose.Theherbisalsouseful to
treatinflammedjointsandsprains.Slightlywarmedjuiceofthe
leaveswitha littlesalt isused forearache andother earcomplaints.
Roasted bulb is used as rubefacient in rheumatism. The bulbs are
powerfully emetic and are used to produce vomiting in poisoni ng
especially antiaries. Bruised leaves act as an efficient insect
repellent1,2,3.Juice of t he fresh bulb at a dose of 2 to 4 drachms is
veryeffectiveinemeticforchildren.
Despiteal lthese traditional uses of C.asiaticum, very few scientific
evaluationsofthisplanthavebeendocumentedsofar.Presentstudy
targetstoevaluate a fewofthepharmacological properties namely
anti‐inflammatoryand antinociceptiveactivities of C.asiaticumbulb
extractinanimalmodel.
MATERIALANDMETHODS:
Thebulbs ofC.asiaticumwerecollectedfromChittagongHilltracts,
Bangladesh,in the month ofJanuary2009. The plantwasidentif ied
and authenticated taxonomically by Dr. Shaikh Boktear Uddin,
AssistantProfessor,DepartmentofBotany,UniversityofChittagong.
A specimen of the plant was preserved in Bangladesh National
HerbariumunderthePlantAccessionNo.34545.
PreparationofPlantExtract
Thefresh bulbs ofC.asiaticum(Syn:Crinumamabile) were washed
withdistilledwaterimmediatelyaftercollection.Thecollecte dbulbs
were chopped into small pieces, air dried at room temperature f or
about10daysandgroundintopowder(536.46gm)tostoreinan
airtightcontainer. The resultingpowder was macerated in3 L pure
methanol(99%Anal‐R,Aldrich,Germany)for7daysatroom
temperaturewithoccasionalstirring.Methanolextract,after7days,
wasfilteredthroughacottonplugandfinallywithaWhatmanNo.1
filter paper. The extract was concentrated under reduced pressure
below 500Cthroughrotatoryvaccumevaporator.Theconcentrated
extractswerecollectedinanEggplantFlaskandallowtoairdryfor
completeevaporation ofmethanol.Thewhole processwasrepeate d
three times and finally, 35 gm of brownish colored, con centrated
bulbextractwasobtained(yield6.5%w/w)whichwaskeptin
refrigeratorat40C.
ExperimentalAnimalsandDiets
Swissalbino miceofboth sexesweighingbetween 25 to30 gm and
WistarAlbinoratsoftheeithersexweighingbetween150‐200gm
obtainedfromanimalhouse ofBangladeshCouncil forScientificand
Industrial Research (BCSIR) laboratories, Chittagong were used for
presentstudy. The animals wereacclimatizedtoroom temperature
(28±5)0Cwitharelativehumidityof55±5%inastandardwire
meshedplasticcagesfor4to5dayspriortocommencementofthe
experiment. During the entire period of study the animals were
supplied standard pellet diet and water adlibitum.All animal
experimentations were carried out with the guidelines of
InstitutionalAnimalEthicsCommittee(IAEC).
Assayforantinociceptiveactivity
Aceticacidinducedwrithingtest
Forwrithing test, 1%(v/v)acetic acid solution (2.3ml/kg body
weight)wasinjectedintraperitoneallytomice(weighing25‐30
gm) and the number of writhing and stretching was counted
over 20 minutes4. The methanol extract of C.asiaticum
(2gm/kg), reference analgesic drug diclofenac sodium (40
mg/kg)anddistilledwaterwereadministered orally 30minute
beforeaceticacidinjection.
Formalintest
The procedure was similar to that described previously by
Gaertner etal.5 (1999). 20 μL of 2.5% formalin (0.92%
formaldehyde)madeinphosphatebufferwasinjectedunderthe
righthindpawsurfaceofexperimentalmice.Eachmousewas
placedindividuallyinacageandobservedfrom0to5min
followedbytheinjectionofformalintoanalyzethefirstphaseof
formalininducedpain(neurogenicpain).Thelengthoftimethe
animalspentlickingtheinjectedpawwastimedwitha
chronometerandwasconsideredasindicativeofpain.
Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical and Clinical Research
Vol. 4, Issue 3, 2011 ISSN - 0974-2441
Rahmanetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,3437
35
Assayforantiinflammatoryactivity
Anti‐inflammatoryactivityof C.asiaticumbulbextractwas assessed
usingcarrageenaninducedpawedemamodelinthehindpawofrat
by the reported method6.AccordingtoWinter,acuteinflammation
wasinduced in albino rats by subplantar injection of0.1mlof 1%
(w/v)carrageenanaftermeasuringtheinitialrighthindpawvolume
ofeachrat.Thevolumeofrighthindpawwasmeasuredat1st,2nd,
3rdand4thhouraftercarrageenan injectionand thepaw edemawas
determined using plethysmometer (7150 UCG Basil, Italy). C.
asiaticumbulbextract(1.0,1.5and2g/kg),standardanti‐
inflammatory drug diclofenac sodium (40 mg/kg), and distilled
water were administered orally to treated, positive control and
control groups one hour before the subplantar injection of
carrageenan.
Statisticalanalysis
Valuesfor analgesic activity wereexpressed as "mean increasein
latency after drug administration ±SEM" in terms of seconds
whereas values for anti‐inflammatory activity were expressed as
"meanincreaseinpawvolume±SEM".Thesignificance ofdifference
betweenmeanswasdeterminedby student'st‐testvaluesofp<0.05
were considered significant and p<0.01 and P<0.001 as highly
significant.
RESULTANDDISCUSSION
Analgesic activity of C.asiaticumbulb extract was assessed using
aceticacidinducedwrithingresponsemodel.Table4showsthepain
behaviorofwrithingresponseofmice,whichwaspresentedas
cumulativeabdominalstretchingresponse.
When1%(v/v)aceticacidsolution(2.3ml/kgbodyweight)was
injected intraperitoneally in mice, the control animal showed 79.3
writhing count / 20 minutes. But, administration of diclofenac
sodium caused significant reduction of writhing count, from 70 to
16.5. On the other hand, C.asiaticumbulb extract reduced the
writhingcountfrom70to22.Theeffectofbulbextractand
diclofenacsodiumwas analyzedstatisticallyby Student’s t test. The
treatment of animals with methanol bulb extract of C.asiaticum
(2gm/kg)anddiclofenacsodiumwasfoundsignificant(P<0.001)
comparedwithcontrolgroup(Table4).Thepercentageinhibitionof
analgesicactivitywascalculatedbyusingfollowingformula‐
Meanwrithingcount
(Controlgroup‐Treatedgroup)x100
%Analgesicactivity=
Meanwrithingcountofcontrolgroup
Thedegreeofinhibition,atadose2g/kg,ofbulbextractwasfound
68.57%whichwasalmostnearertotheeffectshowedbystandard
analgesic drug diclofenac sodium (76.43 %) (Fig.1). The methanol
extract at a dose of 1.5 g/kg and 2.0g/kg inhibited the effect of
formalin by 55% and 63%, respectively (Fig.2). Morphine did not
exertanysignificanteffect.
Carrageenan induced paw edema model indicated that subplantar
injectionofcarrageenaninexperimentalratsshowedatime‐
dependent increase in paw thickness (Table 1). This increase was
observed at 1sthandwasmaximalat4hafteradministrationof
carrageenaninjectionin thecontrolgroup. Methanolicbulb ext ract
ofC.asiaticum(2g/kg) produced33.06%,50.55%,52.56%,51.02%
inhibition of paw edema at 1st, 2nd, 3rdand4
th h after carrageenan
injectionrespectively(Table2andFig.3).Thepercentofinhibition
forotherconcentrationarealso delineated(Table 2andFig.3).The
effectwasfoundstatisticallynon‐significant,comparedtocontrol,at
1sth(P> 0.05),significantat 2ndh(P<0.05) &4h(P<0.05) andvery
significantat3h(P<0.01)aftercarrageenaninjection.
On the other hand, carrageenan‐induced inflammation was
significantly (P<0.05) reduced in all phases of the experiment by
treatmentwith referenceanti‐inflammatory drugdiclofenacsodium
(40mg/kg).Diclofenac sodium produced 38.70%,45.67%,58.32%,
60.88%anti‐inflammatory effect at 1st, 2nd, 3rdand4th,respectively,
aftercarrageenaninjection(Table2).
Medicinalplantsindeedhavebeenanindispensablearmin
ameliorating common inflammation, pain sensation as well as
nonciception7.Thebulb of C.asiaticumhad been used tra ditionally
intherheumatoidarthritisandcoldsincelongbutnoworkhasbeen
done to confirm its analgesic and anti‐inflammatory activity albeit
the antipyretic effect of petroleum ether and chloroform soluble
fractionsofethanolextractofitsrootshasbeenobservedrecently8.
Aceticacidinducedabdominalconstrictionsareusefulexperimental
toolsinthetestingofnewanalgesicdrugs9 because the abdominal
injectionofacetic acid in micehasbeenattributed to the release of
arachidonicacid,whichresultsthesynthesisofprostaglandinviathe
cyclooxygenase (COX) enzyme10. The special nerve endings that
sensepainis verysensitive toprostaglandin. Whenprostaglandinis
released,the nerve endings respond to itthroughprostaglandinE2
(PGE2)receptorbypickingupandtransmittingthepainandinjury
messagestothebrainandcausevisceralwrithingstimuliin
mice11,12,13.
Therefore,ithas beensuggested thattheinhibitionofprostaglandin
synthesis is remarkably an efficient antinociceptive mechanism in
visceral pain14.Sincemethanolextractinthisstudyshowedvery
significantinhibition(P<0.001)(Table4)inaceticacidinducedpain,
itmaybepredictedastheanalgesiceffectofextract.Theextractwas
thentestedagainstothermodelofexperimentalpain.Itwasassayed
on the first phase of formalin induced pain known as neur ogenic
pain.Themethanolextractexhibitedasignificantanalgesicactivity
against neurogenic pain (Fig. 2). The activity of the extract in this
modelsuggeststheactivationofopioidreceptorsintheiraction
mechanism5.
Theanalgesiceffectoftheextract,therefore,maybeduetoitsaction
on visceral nociceptors sensitive to acid, to the inhibition ofthe
synthesis of the arachidonic acid metabolite15. Anti‐inflammatory
activity through carrageenan induced paw edema is a suitable test
for evaluating anti‐inflammatory properties for natural drugs
becauseitshowsverypromisingsensitivity,particularlyintheacute
phaseofinflammation,indetectingorallyactiveanti‐inflammatory
agents16.Developmentofedemainthepawofratafterinjectionof
carrageenenisindeedabiphasicevent17, of which the initial phase
observed during the first hour is attributed to the release of
histamineandserotonin whereasthe secondone ofedemaisdueto
thereleaseofprostaglandins,protease,andlysosome
18,19,20. This
leadsto a dilationofthe arterioles andvenulesand to anincreased
vascularpermeability.Asaconsequence,fluidandplasmaprote ins
areextravagated,andedemaforms21.
The mediators, including histamine, 5‐HT, the kinins and their
complements,havebecometherecentfocusofattentionasthe
metabolites of arachidonic acid (AA). Alone or in appropriate
combination,AA productsof COX pathwayare capableofproducin g
thecharacteristicsignsofinflammationwhichsubsequently
produces vasodilatation, hyperemia, pain, edema, and cellular
filtration. The COX products, particularly prostaglandin E2 (PGE2),
contribute to increased blood flow throug h a vasodilatation action,
but the lipoxygenase (LOX) pathway is necessary for vascular
leakageandedemaconsequentlyoncellularinfiltration.
Itispossiblethatthemethanolextractofbulbcontainstheactive
constituents that exhibit its anti‐inflammatory action probably by
means of either inhibiting the synthesis, release or action of
inflammatory mediators like histamine, serotonin, prostaglandin,
protease,andlysosome.
From our observation we assume that different active secondary
metabolites are present in crude extracts of C.asiaticumbulb and
perhaps some of these compounds may operate in a synergistic
manner. Moreover, the anti‐inflammatory effect of the C.asiaticum
crude extract is almost near to the effect of standard anti‐
inflammatorydrug diclofenac sodium.Fromthis observation, it can
besuggestedthatifthecompoundresponsibleforanti‐
inflammatoryeffectcouldbeisolatedfromcrudeextract,itmight
show very potent anti‐inflammatory effect even better than
diclofenacsodium.
Rahmanetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,3437
36
Table1:EvaluationofantiinflammatoryactivityofCrinumasiaticumbulbextractbycarrageenaninducedpawedemamodel
Here,Allvaluesareexpressedasmean±SEM(n=5)NS=Notsignificant(P>0.05)comparedwithcontrol.**P<0.01compared
withcontrol(Student’st‐test).*P<0.05significantcomparedwithcontrol(Student’st‐test).
Table2:%AntiinflammatoryactivityofCrinumasiaticumbulbextractandDiclofenacSodium
Here,Coisthepawthicknessvolume(inmm 3)beforecarrageenaninjection,Ctisthepawthicknessvolume(inmm3)attimet,
(Ct‐Co)ispawedema.
Table3:EffectofCrinumasiaticumbulbextractonaceticacidinducedwrithingresponse
Table4:EffectofCrinumasiaticumbulbextractonaceticacidinducedwrithingresponse(Student’sttest,***P<0.001significant
comparedtocontrol)
WreathingCounts/20min
Treatment ControlDistilledwater DiclofenacSodium Stemextrac
t
Dose 2ml 40(mg/kg) 1.00(gm/kg) 1.5(gm/kg) 2(gm/kg)
Mean±SEM 70±1.87 16.5±1.71 41.5±2.5 30.5±1.96 22±4.02
Student’s
ttest
t
‐calculated
t‐tabulated
Deg.offred.
p‐value
21.1
5.96
6
<0.001
9.13
5.96
6
<0.001
14.58
5.96
6
<0.001
10.82
5.96
6.0
<0.001
Here,allvaluesareexpressedasMean±SEM(n=4),P<0.001significantcomparedtocontrol
Group
Treatmen
t
Dose
Pawedema(mm3)(Ct‐Co)
1st
hr
2nd
hr
3rd
hr
4th
hr
Control Distilledwater 2ml 0.37±0.05 0.64±0.06 0.76±0.07 0.88±0.11
Positivecontrol DiclofenacSodium 40mg/kg *0.23±0.04 *0.35±0.07 **0.32±0.03 **0.35±0.04
Sampletreated CrinumasiaticumBulbextract 2gm/kg NS0.25±0.05 **0.31±0.06 *0.36±0.10 **0.43±0.07
1.5gm/kg *0.27±0.007 *0.36±0.012 *0.4±.01 *0.48±.01
1gm/kg *0.29±.017 *0.44±.028 *0.49±.02 *0.55±.015
Group
Treatment
Dose
%InhibitionofPawedema
1sthr2ndhr3rdhr4thhr
Control Distilledwater 2ml ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐
Positivecontrol DiclofenacSodium 40mg/kg 38.70% 45.67% 58.32%60.88%
Sampletreated
C.asiaticumbulbextract
2gm/kg 33.06% 50.55% 52.56% 51.02%
1.5gm/kg 27.02% 43.75% 47.37% 45.45%
1.0gm/kg 21.62% 31.25% 35.52% 37.5%
RatNo.
WrithingCount/20minutes
Control DiclofenacSodium(40mg/kg) BulbExtract
2(gm/kg) 1.5(gm/kg) 1.00(gm/kg)
1 70 12 26 36 48
2 69 16 27 29 36
3 66 20 10 30 40
4 75 18 25 27 42
MEAN 70 16.5 22 30.5 41.5
SEM 1.87 1.71 4.02 1.93 2.5
%Analgesicactivity ‐ 76.43% 68.57% 56.42% 40.71%
Rahmanetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,3437
37
Fig.1:Comparative%analgesicactivityofC.asiaticumbulb
extractandcommerciallyavailableanalgesicdrugDiclofenac
Sodium
CONCLUSION
Theresults ofthe studydemonstratethatthemethanol extract ofC.
asiaticumbulb exerts potential analgesic and anti‐inflammatory
effectinexperimentalanimalmodelswhichsupporttheclaimsby
traditionalmedicine practitioners. Onthe basis oftheresults, itcan
beusedasagoodsourceofanalgesicdrugs.However,
pharmacodynamic studies should be undertaken to establish the
mechanism of action of the plant extracts contributing in
nonciception andinflammation. Phytochemical investigation is also
proposedinordertoisolatetheactivefractionandeventuallythe
purecompound.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
TheauthorswishtopaythankfulgratitudetoBangladesh Council
for Scientific and Industrial Research (BCSIR) Laboratories,
Chittagongfortheircontinuoussupportinprogressofthisstudy.
REFERENCES
1. GhaniA.MedicinalPlantsofBangladesh:ChemicalConstituents
andUses.AsiaticSocietyofBangladesh;1998.
2. ZhanheJi,AlanWM.Amaryllidaceae.In:FloraofChina.Science
Press(Beijing)andMissouriBotanicalGardenPress;2000.p.
264.
3. WalterCH.Crinumasiaticum.In:FloraofNorthAmerica.Oxford
UniversityPress;1998.p.278‐279..
4. Koster R, Anderson M, de Beer EJ. Acetic acid for analgesic
screening.FederationProceeds1959;18:412‐416.
5. Gaertner M, Müller L, Roos JF. Analgesic triterpenes from
Sebastianiaschottianaroots.Phytomedicine1999;6:41–44.
6. WinterCA, RisleyEA, NussGW. Carrageenin‐inducededema in
hind paw of the rat as an assay for antiinflammatory drugs.
ProcSocExpBiolMed1962,111:544‐547.
7. Ahmad F, Khan RA, Rasheed S. Study of analgesic and anti‐
inflammatory activity from plant extracts of Lactucascariola
andArtemisiaabsinthium.JIslamAcaSci1992;5:111‐114.
8. Awatef MS, Asmawi MZ, Jagdish NS, Ahmad PMY. Anti‐
inflammatory activity of Crinumasiaticumplantanditseffect
on bradykinin‐induced contractions on isolated uterus.
Immunopharmacology1999;43(2‐3):311‐316
9. Otterness I, Bliven M. (1985). Laboratory models for testing
nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs. In Nonsteroidal
antiinflammatorydrugs.J.Lombardino,editor.JohnWiley&
SonsInc.NewYork,USA.112–251.ISBN:18444720
10. DaviesP, BaileyP,Goldenberg M, Ford‐HutchinsonA. The role
ofarachidonicacidoxygenationproductsinpainand
inflammation.AnnuRevImmunol1984;2:335‐357.
11. Hosoi M. Prostaglandin E(2) has antinociceptive effects
through EP(1) receptor in the ventromedial hypothalamus in
rats.Pain1999;83:221‐227.
12. Seibert K. Pharmacological and biochemical demonstration of
the role of cyclooxygenase 2 in inflammation and pain. Proc
NatlAcadSciUSA1994;91:12013‐12017.
13. Ferreira S, Nakamura M, AbreuCastro M. The hyperalgesic
effectsof prostacyclin and PGE2. Prostaglandins 1978; 16:31‐
38.
14. FranzottiEM, Santos CV, Rodrigues HM,Mourão RH, Andrade
MRand Antoniolli AR.. Anti‐inflammatory, analgesic andacute
toxicity of SidacadifoliaL. JEthnopharmacol2002;72: 273‐
278.
15. VaneJ.Theevolution ofnon‐steroidalanti‐inflammatorydrugs
andtheirmechanismsofaction.Drug1987;1:18‐27.
16. DiRosa M, Giroud JP, Willoughby DA. Studies of the acute
inflammatory response induced in rats in different sites by
carrageenan and turpentine.Journal of Pathology 1971;
104:15–29.
17. VinegarR,SchreiberW,HugoR.Biphasicdevelopmentof
carrageenan edema in rats.J pharmacol Exp Ther1969;
166:96‐103.
18. CrunkhonP,MeacockSER.Mediatorsofinflammationinduced
intheratpawbycarrageenan.BritJPharmacol1971,42:392‐
402.
19. AsongalemEA, Foyet HS, Ekoo S, Dimo T and Kamtchouing P.
Anti‐inflammatory,lackofcentralanalgesiaandantipyretic
properties of Acanthusmontanus(Ness) T. Anderson. J
Ethnopharmacol2004;95:63‐68.
20. Silva GN, Martins FR, Matheus ME. Investigation of anti‐
inflammatoryand antinociceptive activities ofLantanatrifolia.
JEthnopharmacol2005;100:254‐259.
21. 21.OzakiY.Anti‐inflammatoryeffectsofCurcumaxanthorrhiza
Roxbanditsactiveprinciple.ChemPharmBull1990;
38:1045‐1048.
Fig.
2:Effectofethanolextractof
C.asiaticumandmorphineon
formalininducedpaininmice.n=5,P<0.05comparedwith
control
Fig.
3:
Comparative%antiinflammatoryactivityof
C.asiaticumbulbextractanddiclofenacsodium