ArticlePDF Available

Application of Electrical Resistivity Imaging in Investigating Groundwater Pollution in Sapele Area, Nigeria

Authors:
Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 2014, 6, 1369-1379
Published Online October 2014 in SciRes. http://www.scirp.org/journal/jwarp
http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/jwarp.2014.614126
How to cite this paper: Uchegbulam, O. and Ayolabi, E.A. (2014) Application of Electrical Resistivity Imaging in Investigating
Groundwater Pollution in Sapele Area, Nigeria. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 6, 1369-1379.
http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/jwarp.2014.614126
Application of Electrical Resistivity Imaging
in Investigating Groundwater Pollution in
Sapele Area, Nigeria
Okezie Uchegbulam, Elijah A. Ayolabi
Department of Geosciences, University of Lagos, Lagos, Nigeria
Email: okezie_uchegbulam@yahoo.com, eojelabi@yahoo.com
Received 13 August 2014; revised 8 September 2014; accepted 2 October 2014
Copyright © 2014 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY).
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Abstract
Sixty-four multi-electrode Lund imaging system coupled with ABEM SAS 4000 Terrameter was
used for the electrical imaging of the study area. Wenner and Gradient arrays with 2 m minimum
electrode spacing were employed which revealed resistivity changes in the vertical and horizontal
directions along the survey lines. Earth imager software was employed for the processing and the
iteration of the 2-D resistivity data. The subsurface is characterized with soil material with resis-
tivity ranging from 42 - 15,000 Ohm-m, reflective of varying degree of conductivity associated with
changing lithology and fluid type. Correlation with borehole data shows that the first 10 m is
composed of laterite. While sand materials occupy 10 to about 60 m beneath the surface, with
anomalously high resistivity 15,000 Ohm-m in most parts. These high resistivity formations can
be attributed to the presence of hydrocarbon within the subsurface, which is an indication that
shallow aquifer in the study area has been polluted. The water level in the study area is close to
the surface, between 4 - 5 m. As a result of the high resistivity formations in most parts, deep wells
of about 45 m are recommended after geophysical investigations.
Keywords
Electrical Resistivity, Imaging, Pollution, Traverse Lines
1. Introduction
A groundwater pollutant is any substance that makes the water unclean or otherwise unsuitable for a particular
purpose when it reaches an aquifer. Sometimes, the substance is a manufactured chemical, but it might be mi-
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1370
crobial contamination just as often. Contamination also can occur naturally from occurring mineral and metallic
deposits in rock and soil [1].
Hydrocarbon pollution and contaminants constitute serious problems wherever exploration and exploitation
activities are carried out [2]. Sources of contaminants include field brines and oil spillage. Reference [3] re-
ported over ten oil producing communities in the Niger Delta region that have experienced major oil spills and
its negative environmental consequences such as fire, destruction of aquatic lives, water pollution, soil pollution
and devastation of the ecosystem. According to a report by the Directorate of Petroleum Resources [4], over
6000 spills had been recorded in the 40 years of oil exploitation in Nigeria, with an average of 150 per year. In
the period 1976-1996, 647 incidents occurred resulting in the spillage of 2369407.04 barrels of crude oil. With
only 549060.38 barrels recovered. 1820410.50 barrels were lost to the ecosystem. Other human activities such
as felling of trees, indiscriminate disposal of chemicals and refuse, flooding caused by the blockage of water
ways, etc. have equally led to the devastation of the ecosystem in the study area.
Geophysical methods have been shown to be useful to the study of contaminated zones. These methods are
based on the contrasts in several physical properties that typically make up the different constituents of the af-
fected zone. In general, hydrocarbons have much lower electrical conductivity than water. This fact makes the
resistivity method especially suitable for hydrocarbon contamination delineation [5] [6]. Hence, 2-D Electrical
Resistivity Tomography (ERT) which provides a relatively low cost, noninvasive and rapid means of generating
spatial models of physical properties of the subsurface is employed in this study.
Electrical Resistivity Tomography has been successfully applied by several researchers in the detection of
pollution [7] [8].
A serious environmental concern is the movement of pollutants to the water table and subsequent contamina-
tion of drinking water resources.
The behavior of the electrical resistivity of contaminants, with respect to the host environment, depends on
several factors, such as the host lithology, the moisture and the solubility of the contaminants in the groundwater.
They make the 2-D ERT effective in delineating the contaminated zones due to resistivity contrasts. Fresh or-
ganic compounds in the water saturated soils usually have high electrical resistivity values.
1.1. Background of the Study Area.
Sapele, located in Delta State (Figure 1), Western Niger Delta, Nigeria, lies between longitude 5˚E - 5˚45'E and
latitude 5˚30'N - 6˚N in geographic coordinate. The city hosts a flow station and an oil rig owned by one of the
oil and gas companies. Figure 1 shows the map of Delta State while Figure 2 shows the picture of a fared gas
taken during the survey.
Figure 1. Map of Delta state, showing Urhboland and major Rivers of Western Niger Delta: (map drawn by
Prof. Francis Odermerho, Southern Illinois University, Edwardsville; USA. Copyright: Urhobo Historical So-
ciety, 2008).
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1371
Figure 2. View of gas being flared at a flow station near the survey site in Sapele
(Field Survey, October 2012).
Oil and gas production is usually accompanied by substantial discharge of wastewater in the form of brines.
Constituents of brines include sodium, calcium, ammonia, boron, trace metals, and high total dissolved solids
(TDS). Oil spillage is a result of leakages of hydrocarbon from the pipes, and to an extent, poor maintenance of
oil pipelines and poor monitoring of pressure regimes of the fluids with respect to the strength of the pipe,
equipment failure, operators error, corrosion, pigging operations, flow line replacement, flow station upgrade
and the activities of vandals in search of crude and refined petroleum products [9].
As a consequent of the environmental problems highlighted above, 2-dimensional electrical resistivity imag-
ing was carried out in a residential area close to the flow station to see if contaminants have actually infiltrated
into the groundwater resources in the study area.
1.2. Site Geology and Hydrogeology
The Niger Delta is a large curve shaped delta which is located in Southern Nigeria like some other deltaic envi-
ronments in the world. It occupies an area lying between longitude 4˚E - 9˚E and latitude 4˚N - 6˚N. It is
bounded in the west by the Calabar flank, in the north by the Anambra platform and in the south by the Atlantic
Ocean under which it extends Figure 1 and Figure 3. Both marine and mixed continental depositional environ-
ment characterize the Niger Delta of Nigeria [10]. The Niger Delta covers an area of about 75,000 km2 (28,957
mi2) in southern Nigeria, where the Niger Delta discharges its water into the Atlantic Ocean through a series of
distributaries.
From the Eocene to the present, the Delta has prograded Southwest ward, forming depobelts that represent the
most active portion of the Delta at each stage of its development [11]. These depobelts form one of the largest
regressive deltas in the world with an area of some 300,000 km2 [12] a sediment volume of 500,000 km3 [13]
and a sediment thickness of over 10 km in the basin depocenter.
The Niger Delta consists of three main tertiary stratigraphic units overlain by Quaternary deposit [14] shown
in Table 1. These three subsurface stratigraphic units in the Niger Delta are Benin, Agbada and Akata forma-
tions. The base is the Akata formation comprising mainly of marine shale and sand beds consisting of dark grey
sandy, silty shale with plant remains at the top. It is over 4000 ft thick. The underlying Agbada formation is a
sequence of sandstones and shales [15]. It consists of an upper predominantly sandy unit with minor shale inter-
calations and a lower shale unit which is thicker than the upper sandy unit. It is over 10,000 ft thick. The aquifer
in the Benin formation is largely phreatic. These formations are overlain by various types of Quaternary deposits
[15]. These areas are made up of top soil, red laterite, clay, fine sand, medium sand and coarse sand in form of
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1372
Figure 3. The Niger Delta coastline of West Africa (Short and Stauble, 1967).
Table 1. Geologic units of the Niger Delta (Short and Stauble, 1967).
Geologic Unit Lithology Age
Alluvium (general) Gravel, sand, clay, silt
Quaternary
Freshwater backswamp and meander belt Sand, clay, some silt and gravel
Mangrove and salt water/backswamps Medium-fine sand, clay and some silt
Sombreiro-warri deltaic plain Sand, clay and some silt
Benin formation (coastal plain sand) Coarse to medium sand with subordinate silt and clay lenses Miocene
Agbada formation Mixture of sand, clay and silt Eocene
Akata formation Clay Paleocene
pebbles. The thickness is variable but generally exceeds 6000 ft [16].
The deposits of the Freshwater Swamps and the Sombreiro-Warri Deltaic Plain are universally considered to
be recent expressions of and a continuation of the Benin Formation. They result from the sediment laden dis-
charges of the River Niger that is spread on the delta by its various tributaries. The sediment is generally an ad-
mixture of medium to coarse-grained sands, sandy clays, silts and clays that eventually settle in fluvial/tidal
channel, tidal flat and mangrove swamp environments, a process that has been ongoing since the late Quaternary
and is related to interglacial marine transgressions [17]-[19]. The Niger Delta is one of the most hydrocar-
bon-rich regions in the world. Exploration and exploitation of hydrocarbons has been going on in the region
since 1956, when oil was discovered there [20]. The oil and gas production and a rapidly growing population
have resulted in environmental degradation of the Delta [21].
The study area consists of Fresh water swamp, Coastal Plain Sands, Mangrove swamps, and Sombreiro-Warri
plains [22]. The water table in the study area is approximately 4 to 5 m beneath the surface, and the direction of
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1373
flow is towards River Ethiope which drains into the Atlantic ocean through the Benin River (Figure 1).
1.3. Electrical Resistivity and Hydrocarbon Pollution
2-dimensional model, where the resistivity changes in the vertical direction, as well as in the horizontal direction
along the survey line was employed in the study area to image the subsurface. In this case, it is assumed that re-
sistivity does not change in the direction that is perpendicular to the survey line.
Geophysical methods are frequently used to study subsoil contamination caused by industrial residues of dif-
ferent nature. The effectiveness of electrical methods for the characterization of oil contaminated subsoil has
been reported by several researchers [23]-[26].
Geoelectric method (Resistivity method) has been used by several researchers to study environmental prob-
lems and groundwater studies. Reference [27] used Geoelectric method in the evaluation of Olushosun landfill
site Southwest Nigeria and its implication on Groundwater. Geophysical and hydrochemical assessment of
groundwater pollution due to a dumpsite in Lagos State was also conducted by [28].
References [9] [29] also found out that high hydrocarbon content of soils has been known to affect soil phy-
siochemical properties, which in turn affect the agricultural potentials of such soils. Hence, this work attempts to
find out if hydrocarbon has infiltrated into the groundwater in the study area.
Hydrocarbon pollution is very complex. Fresh spilled hydrocarbon gives different result from aged spills. The
following results from some researchers give clue on what to expect from the investigation in the study area.
Reference [30] in their work on “Two-dimensional electrical imaging for detection of hydrocarbon contami-
nants” pointed out the usefulness and the pitfalls of electrical tomography in the characterization of underground
leakage of hydrocarbons. Experimental evidence, obtained from a joint geochemical and geophysical investiga-
tion approach, indicated that subsoil which has been saturated with diesel oil for a long period (>20 years) exhi-
bits an increased conductivity. It suggests that electrical tomography could be useful for monitoring the effects
of induced biodegradation (bioremediation) through the repetition of the survey at different times, in order to
observe any changes in the resistivity due to the increase of free ions resulting from hydrocarbon degradation.
Electrical resistivity models for oil contamination in some area showed high resistivity [31] and low resistivi-
ty [32] [33]. Recent oil pollution shows a high resistivity anomaly, while mature oil pollution produces a low re-
sistivity anomaly [32]. Months after spill, a low resistivity anomaly is developed in the contaminated zone, with
a strength that depends on the geological characteristics of the subsoil [32] [34]. The formation processes of
such low resistivity anomaly are related to chemical reactions and to variations in the physical characteristics of
the oil contaminated zone. The low resistivity anomaly is caused by an increase in the total dissolved solids
(TDS), due to bacterial degradation of hydrocarbons in the lower part of the vadose zone. Reference [32] found
that aged contamination appears as a low resistivity horizon slightly above groundwater table (GWT).
2. Materials and Method
64 multi-electrode Terrameter was used for the electrical imaging with 2 m minimum electrode spacing. Each
traverse covered a lateral distance of 126 m. Three traverses were taken proximal to the oil rig, flow station and
oil pipelines (Figure 4). We could not get too close to the pipelines and other installations due to restrictions by
the oil companies and the presence of security forces monitoring the installations. The areas we took the tra-
verses were the only allowed areas.
Environmental geophysical surveys are concerned with near surface, typically to depths of less than 30 m. So
a small electrode spacing of 2 m was adopted, in order to be able to provide considerable details of any plumes
related to leakages from the underground pipes and flow stations. It is well known that the Wenner array is rela-
tively sensitive to vertical changes of resistivity below the centre of the array, and Gradient array exploit the ad-
vantages of Schlumberger and Wenner arrays. So, Wenner array and Gradient methods were chosen in the ac-
quisition of data because of good vertical resolution, less sensitivity to noise and better lateral coverage.
Computer iteration was carried out on the data obtained, using the Earth Imager software. This software si-
mulates the values of the apparent resistivity and that of the current electrode spacing to obtain a two dimen-
sional (2D) layered model. Consequently, resistivities and the depths of the layers were estimated. Borehole logs
(Figure 5 and Figure 6) of the study area collected from The Federal Ministry of Water Resources, Asaba were
used as an aid in the interpretation of the electrical resistivity tomography results. The elevation of the study area
is about 3 - 4 m.
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1374
Figure 4. Map of Sapele showing the traverse lines.
Figure 5. Borehole 1: lithologic description of the study area (Courtesy: Federal Ministry of Water Resources, Asaba).
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1375
Figure 6. Borehole 2: lithologic description of the study area (Courtesy: Federal Ministry of Water Resources, Asaba).
3. Results and Discussion
The results and discussion of the Electrical Resistivity Tomography of the study area is given below.
3.1. Traverse 1
Traverse 1 reveals the resistivity image along the profile. Figure 7(a) and Figure 7(b) show the Gradient and
Wenner array maps respectively.
Integration of the two 2-D ERT array results show that subsurface is characterized with soil material with re-
sistivity ranging from 42 - 15,000 Ω∙m reflective of varying degree of conductivity associated with varying li-
thology and fluid type. Figure 5 and Figure 6 are the borehole data used for comparing the interpretation of the
2-D ERT section.
The ERT result shows that the subsurface is composed predominantly of sand material from the surface to a
depth of about 60 m beneath the surface. The 2-D electrical resistivity imaging result (Figure 7(A)) show the
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1376
Figure 7. (a) Sapele (traverse 1) Gradient array; (b) Sapele (traverse 1) Wenner array.
resistivity distribution over a lateral distance of 126 m from the surface to a depth of about 21 m beneath the
surface. The 2-D section revealed an anomalously high resistivity (1500 - 15,000 Ω∙m) structure within a lateral
distance of 2 - 32 m; 36 - 40 m; 40 - 52 m; 58 - 63 m; 76 - 86 m; and 114 - 118 m at a depth of 0.5 - 9 m; 0.1 - 1
m; 5 - 18 m; 7 - 11 m; 8 - 10 m; and 0 - 2 m respectively. These anomalously high resistivity structures are at-
tributed to the presence of hydrocarbon within the subsurface which may be due to leakages from various pipe-
lines within the study area or possible activity of the vandals.
Correlation with the borehole data (Figure 5 and Figure 6) shows that the subsurface is characterized predo-
minantly with sand, and may compose of clayey sand/clay in some locations. The 2-D ERT result shows that the
resistivity within the depth of investigation ranges from 45 - 15,000 Ohm-m. Since the formation in the study
area is compose of sand with water table between 4 - 5 m beneath the surface, the high resistivity (1500 Ω∙m)
is a possible indication that the aquifer within this area may have been polluted by hydrocarbon.
3.2. Traverse 2
Figure 8(a) and Figure 8(b) show the Gradient and Wenner array 2D resistivity structures. The two resistivity
structures also show that the subsurface is equally compose of varying degrees of resistivity as can be seen from
the resistivity values (43 - 15,000 Ω∙m), revealing varying degree of conductivity associated with lithology and
fluid type.
The 2-D section also revealed an anomalously high resistivity (2000 - 15,000 Ω∙m) structure within a varying
lateral and vertical location distributed over the entire traverse. At a lateral distance of 2 - 58 m, possible hydro-
carbon pollution were noticed at a depth of 0.5 - 6 m, while at a lateral distance of 60 - 126 m the depth of pollu-
tion vary from 0.5 - 21 m beneath the surface.
Integration of the two array maps and correlation with the borehole data (Figure 5 and Figure 6) show that
the resistivity of the sand layer within the depth of investigation of the 2-D ERT ranges from 45 - 15,000 Ω∙m
and may compose of fine to coarse sand/clay in some location.
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1377
Figure 8. (a) Sapele (traverse 2) Gradient array; (b) Sapele (traverse 2) Wenner array.
3.3. Traverse 3
Traverse three reveal the resistivity image along the survey line. Figure 9(a) and Figure 9(b) show the Gradient
and Wenner array structures respectively.
Integration of the 2-D ERT array results show that the subsurface has soil materials with resistivity ranging
from 42.5 - 15,000 Ω∙m indicative of changing degree of resistivity associated with varying lithology and fluid
type. The 2-D section revealed an anomalously high resistivity (1500 - 15,000 Ω∙m) structure within a lateral
distance 2 - 16 m within a depth of 0.1 - 6 m reflective of near surface hydrocarbon pollution. Similar occur-
rence was noticed within a lateral distance of 62 - 126 at a depth of 0.1 to 4 m; however within a lateral distance
of 20 - 70 m and within 86 - 100 m the hydrocarbon pollution seems to have migrated to a depth of about 21 m
beneath the surface. This may be a clear evidence of groundwater pollution by the hydrocarbon since the water
table lies within 4 - 5 m within the study area.
4. Conclusion
The 2-D Electrical Resistivity Tomography results of the study area show that the subsurface is characterized
with soil material with resistivity ranging from 42 - 15,000 Ω∙m, reflective of varying degree of conductivity
associated with changing lithology and fluid type. Correlation with borehole data shows that the subsurface is
predominantly composed of sand material from the surface to a depth of about 60 m beneath the surface, with
anomalously high resistivity 1500 Ω∙m in most parts. This low conductivity formations can be attributed to hy-
drocarbon which is an indication that shallow aquifer in the study area has been polluted. It is recommended that
water from hand dug well should not be used for drinking and certain domestic work. Moreover, geophysical
investigation should be carried out in the study area before sinking boreholes.
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1378
Figure 9. (a) Sapele (traverse 3) Gradient array; (b) Sapele (traverse 2) Wenner array.
Acknowledgements
We thank the Federal Ministry of Water Resources, Asaba for providing us the borehole data of the study area.
References
[1] Boulding, J.R. (1995) Practical Handbook of Soil, Vadose Zone, and Ground-water Contamination: Assessment, Pre-
vention, and Remediation. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton.
[2] Atakpo, E.A. and Ayolabi, E.A. (2008) Evaluation of Aquifer Vulnerability and the Protective Capacity in Some Oil
Producing Communities of Western Niger Delta, Nigeria. The Environmentalist.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10669-008-9191-3
[3] Ekoriko, M. and Egwu, E. (1995) Neglect of Oil Communities Rage of the People. Newswatch Magazine, 18 Decem-
ber 1995, 13.
[4] DPR (1997) Department of Petroleum Resources. Annual Reports, Abuja, 191 p.
[5] Fetter, C.W. (1993) Contaminant Hydrogeology. Prentice-Hall, Inc., Upper Saddle River.
[6] Reynolds, J. (1998) An Introduction to Applied and Environmental Geophysics. John Wiley & Sons Ed., New York.
[7] Daily, W., Ramirez, A. and Johnson, R. (1998) Electrical Impedance Tomography of a Perchloroethelyne Release.
Journal of Environmental and Engineering Geophysics, 2, 189-201.
[8] Goes, B.J.M. and Meekes, J.A.C. (2004) An Effective Electrode Configuration for the Detection of DNAPLs with
Electrical Resistivity Tomography. Journal of Environmental and Engineering Geophysics, 9, 127-141.
http://dx.doi.org/10.4133/JEEG9.3.127
[9] Ezebuiro, P.E. (2004) A Review of Effect of Oil Pollution in West African Environment. Science and Nature, 5, 14-18.
[10] Uko, E.D., Ekine, A.S., Ebeniro, J.O. and Ofoegbu, C.O. (1992) Weathering Structure of the East-Central Niger Delta,
Nigeria. Geophysics, 57, 1228-1233. http://dx.doi.org/10.1190/1.1443338
[11] Doust, H. and Omatsola, E. (1990) Niger-Delta. In: Edwards, J.D. and Santogrossi, P.A., Eds., Divergent/Passive Mar-
gin Basins, AAPG Memoir 48, American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, 239-248.
[12] Kulke, H. (1995) Nigeria. In: Kulke, H., Ed., Regional Petroleum Geology of the World, Part II, Africa, America, Aus-
O. Uchegbulam, E. A. Ayolabi
1379
tralia and Antarctica, Gebruder Borntraeger, Berlin, 143-172.
[13] Hospers, J. (1965) Gravity Field and Structure of the Niger-Delta, Nigeria, West Africa. Geological Society of America
Bulletin, 76, 407-422. http://dx.doi.org/10.1130/0016-7606(1965)76[407:GFASOT]2.0.CO;2
[14] Short, K.C. and Stauble, A.J. (1967) Outline of the Geology of Niger Delta. American Association of Petroleum Geol-
ogists Bulletin, 51, 761-779.
[15] Merki, P.J. (1970) Structural Geology of the Cenozoic Niger Delta. African Geology, University of Ibadan Press, Iba-
dan, 251-268.
[16] Egbai, J.C. (2011) Resistivity Method: A Tool for Identification of Areas of Corrosive Groundwater in Agbor, Delta
State, Nigeria. Journal of Emerging Trends in Engineering and Applied Sciences (JETEAS), 2, 226-230.
[17] Allen, J.R.L. (1965) Late Quaternary Niger Delta and Adjacent Areas: Sedimentary Environments and Lithofacies.
American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, 49, 547-600.
[18] Oomkens, E. (1974) Lithofacies Relations in the Late Quaternary Niger Delta Complex. Sedimentology, 21, 195-222.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3091.1974.tb02056.x
[19] Durotoye, B. (1975) Quaternary Sediments in Nigeria. In: Kogbe, C.A., Ed., Geology of Nigeria, Rockview, Jos,
431-444.
[20] Oloibiri (2014) The Community that Hosted Nigeria’s First Oil Well in 1956. http://www.premiumtimesng.com
[21] Obasi, R.A. and Balogun, O. (2001) Water Quality and Environmental Impact Assessment of Water Resources in Ni-
geria. African Journal of Environment Studies, 2, 228-231.
[22] Omo-Irabor, O.O. and Oduyemi, K. (2006) A Hybrid Image Classification Approach for the Systematic Analysis of
Land Cover (LC) Changes in the Niger Delta Region. Proceedings of the 6th Intl Conference on Earth Observation
and Geoinformation Sciences in Support of Africas Development, Cairo, 30 October-2 November 2006.
[23] Vanhala, H., Soininen, H. and Kukkonen, I. (1992) Detecting Organic Chemical Contaminants by Spectral Induced
Polarization Method in Glacial Till Environment. Geophysics, 57, 1014-1017. http://dx.doi.org/10.1190/1.1443312
[24] Atekwana, E.A., Sauck, W.A. and Werkemer, D.D. (2000) Investigations of Geophysical Signatures at a Hydrocarbon
Contaminated Sites. Journal of Applied Geophysics, 44, 167-180. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0926-9851(98)00033-0
[25] Atekwana, E.A., Sauck, W.A., Abdel Aal, G.Z. and Werkema Jr., D.D. (2002) Geophysical Investigation of Vadose
Zone Conductivity Anomalies at a Hydrocarbon Contaminated Site: Implications for the Assessment of Intrinsic Bio-
remediation. Journal of Environmental & Engineering Geophysics, 7, 103-110. http://dx.doi.org/10.4133/JEEG7.3.103
[26] Osella, A., de la Vega, M. and Lascano, E. (2002) Characterization of a Contaminant Plume Due to a Hydrocarbon
Spill Using Geoelectrical Methods. Journal of Environmental & Engineering Geophysics, 7, 78-87.
[27] Ayolabi, E.A. (2005) Geoelectric Evaluation of Olushosun Landfill Site Southwest Nigeria and Its Implication on
Groundwater. Journal of Geological Society of India, 66, 318-322.
[28] Ayolabi, E.A. and Folashade, J.O. (2005) Geophysical and Hydrochemical Assessment of Groundwater Pollution Due
to Dumpsite in Lagos State, Nigeria. Journal of Geological Society of India, 66, 617-622.
[29] Amadi, A., Dickson, A. and Maate, G.O. (1993) Effect of Organic and Inorganic Nutrient Supplements on the Perfor-
mance of Maize (Zea may L). Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 66, 59-76.
[30] Godio, A. and Naldi, M. (2003) Two-Dimensional Electrical Imaging for Detection of Hydrocarbon Contaminants.
Near Surface Geophysics, 2003, 131-137.
[31] Osella, A., de la Vega, M. and Lascano, E. (2002) Characterization of a Contaminant Plume Due to a Hydrocarbon
Spill Using Geoelectrical Methods. Journal of Environmental & Engineering Geophysics, 7, 78-87.
http://dx.doi.org/10.4133/JEEG7.2.78
[32] Sauck, W.A. (2000) A Model for the Resistivity Structure of LNAPL Plumes and Their Environs in Sandy Sediments.
Journal of Applied Geophysics, 44, 151-165. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0926-9851(99)00021-X
[33] Cassidy, D.P., Werkema, D.D., Sauck, W.A., Atekwana, E.A., Rossbach, S. and Duris, J. (2001) The Effects of
LNAPL Biodegradation Products on Electrical Conductivity Measurements. Journal of Environmental & Engineering
Geophysics, 6, 47-52. http://dx.doi.org/10.4133/JEEG6.1.47
[34] Omar, D.R., Vladimir, S., Jesús, O.V. and Albert, R. (2006) Using Electrical Techniques for Planning the Remediation
Process in a Hydrocarbon Contaminated Site. Revista Internacional de Contaminación Ambiental, 22, 157-163.
... with Aquifer transmisivity of 429m /day 2 and 373m /day respectively ( Fig. 12 and Fig. 14). High resistivities values in contaminated areas also denote that only shallow water (Perched aquifer) has been polluted in the study areas (Uchegbulam and Ayolabi, 2014). The resistivity method is useful in determining areas that are prone to groundwater pollution. ...
... The resistivity method is useful in determining areas that are prone to groundwater pollution. Recent (shallow) pollution can also show high resistivity value while matured (ageing) pollution indicates a lower resistivity value than fresh pollution (Sauck, 2000;Uchegbulam and Ayolabi, 2014). show the contour map for transmissivity for aquifer layer, aquifer depth and resistivity of aquifer in the study areas. ...
Article
Geophysical electrical resistivity method (Vertical Electrical Sounding) using Schlumberger configuration was employed to investigate subsurface formations and aquifer transmisivity in Agbarotor, Agbarha-Otor and Edoiede Agbarha-Otor in Ughelli North Local Government Area in Delta State, Southern Nigeria with VES evenly carried out in the aforementioned study areas. ABEM Signal averaging system (SAS) 1000 Terrameter, was one of the major equipments used in obtaining the resistivity field data with a maximum current electrodes spreading of 500m done with the aid of a tape. The interpretation of the data gotten from the field was done using WINRESIST software coupled with the qualitative and quantitative curve matching to obtain modelize parameters and curves type for various VES points. The model parameters displayed up to six formations layers which include topsoil, laterite, clay and sand (fine, medium and coarse) formation. The resistivity of the confined aquifer ranges from 1037.6-4986.5Ωm with thickness varying interval of 16.3m and 42.9m. The investigation denote that VES 1 of Agbarotor, VES 6 for Agbarha-Otor and VES 7,9,10 of Edoiede Agbarha-Otor are the best locations for citing boreholes in the studied areas since they are characterize with higher resistivity (low corrosivity) and moderate or higher transmisivity. Thus aquifer transmisivity in the cited areas are of good quality and the produce can sustain the people of the areas and neighboring environs for long period of time. I recommend that the samples of VES water locations should be tested from time to time to ascertain its Level of contaminations for future remedial measure and a water system for the general public should be drilled in the aforementioned VES points.
... Oil pollution is also widespread and arises at all stages of the petroleum industry: extraction, transportation, refining and distribution (Shevninet al., 2003). A serious environmental concern is the movement of pollutants to the water table and subsequent contamination of drinking water resources (Okezie and Elijah, 2014). When oil leakages and spills happen, both surface and underground water are affected negatively resulting in the need to ascertain the extent to which subsurface water has been affected by hydrocarbon leakage (Nwankwo and Emujakporue, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
The effectiveness of geophysical and geochemical methods in delineating hydrocarbon contamination in a spill site is carried out around theErhoike flow station in Kokori, Ethiope East LGA, Delta State. Wenner array was used for the transverse in acquiring the data which spanned a transverse of 200m and 3D model resistivity images were obtained from the inversion and presented in horizontal depth slices. Well water samples were also taken for Total Petroleum Hydrocarbon (TPH) content while soil samples from the location were also taken for Porosity and coefficient of permeability. The result of the 3D horizontal depth slices in the location reveals that Erhoike is impacted with hydrocarbon plume to a depth of 31.7m. The concentration of TPHCs from the water analysis shows that the wells around the suspected zones are affected by hydrocarbon. The laboratory tests for porosity (Փ ) and coefficient of permeability (k) for the soil samples are indicative of sand/silty sand which thus allows the flow of PHCs plume to the soil and groundwater in the study area. The results of the study have shown that the soil is permeable and porous which would allow the passage of the leaked and spilled PHCs through the soil to groundwater where the PHCs could mix, float and sink into groundwater. The 3D analysis revealed the presence of PHCs up to a depth of 33.7m but prominent at a depth of 10m which indicates the presence of PHCs in the wells. The hydrochemical analysis also proved the same results as that of the 3D which authenticated the reliability of the method used in the study.
... Although we have presented only two examples of LNAPL spills and biodegradation in saline aquifers in coastal regions, another good example is a spill in the Niger Delta area of Nigeria. A resistive response was the dominant response observed in the electrical resistivity profiles (Raji et al. 2018;Uchegbulam and Ayolabi 2014). The resistive response probably resulted from the fact that this is an area of active oil exploration with repeated spills from pipeline breakage. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Oil spills are common occurrences on land and in coastal environments. To remediate oil spills, the contaminated volume has to be defined, appropriate remedial measures should be undertaken, and evidence must be provided for the successful remediation. Geophysical techniques can aid site investigation and remediation efforts. The insulating properties of hydrocarbons make them ideal targets for employing a variety of geophysical techniques for their characterization. Nonetheless, the geophysical response of hydrocarbon-contaminated sites is non-unique and depends on factors such as: (1) the release history, (2) hydrocarbon distribution and partitioning into different phases (vapor, free, dissolved, entrapped, and residual phases) in the unsaturated and saturated zones, (3) seasonal hydrologic processes, (4) extent of biodegradation and (5) aquifer salinity and host lithology. Where the contaminants have been biodegraded, the geophysical response depends on the by-products of different terminal electron acceptor processes (TEAPs). In this chapter, we review the different pathways by which TEAPs mediate geophysical property changes. We provide select field case studies from hydrocarbon-contaminated sites across the globe, including different climatic regimes and water salinity conditions. We show that the geophysical response can be transient, hence, data interpretation should be guided by an understanding of the hydrobiogeochemical processes at each site.
... The detailed profiles in Fig. 14 provide insights into the distribution and severity of oil contaminations across Lines 1 to 5, mapping and characterizing the spills into high and low contaminations and delineating the boundaries between contaminated and uncontaminated soils for efficient remediation site zoning and bioremediation planning. This aligns with the successful applications of ERT reported by Uchegbulam and Ayolabi (2014) and . ...
... These chemical substances in elevated concentration in both soil and groundwater could cause kidney infections, lung damage, cancer, liver and bladder complications (ASTDR, 2000). The impacts of leachate derived from solid waste on groundwater have attracted the attention of so many researchers (Mor et al., 2006;Talalaj and Dzienis, 2007;Suresh and Kottureshwara, 2009;Akudo et al., 2010;Rajkumar et al., 2010;Uchegbulam and Ayolabi, 2014). Geophysical study of the impact of solid waste on groundwater has not been carried out in Damaturu, despite the prevailing groundwater quality challenges in the area. ...
Article
Full-text available
Groundwater quality monitoring is very important in cities and towns where there were poor solid waste management. In this study, the effects of solid waste on groundwater in Damaturu Metropolis along Potiskum road was investigated using both electrical resistivity survey and hydro-chemical methods. The results of the study showed that the solid waste at the dump sites generate leachate which percolate into the subsurface to pollute the groundwater. Two aquifers were delineated in the study area and the ERT survey results showed that the groundwater in the first aquifer was contaminated. The contaminants were characterized by very low resistivity which distinguished them from their host rocks. The contaminants are highly conductive which indicate that they were inorganic and possibly of metallic origin. The results of the analyzed water samples from the study area revealed that heavy metals such as Cadmium, Arsenic, Iron, Chromium, and Lead were in elevated concentration in the groundwater of the study area. The first aquifer in the study area is semi-confined and its proximity to the earth surface made it much vulnerably to pollution. The second aquifer is confined by a very thick sandy-clay formation which protects it from pollution by contaminant plumes. It is the most appropriate for groundwater abstraction in the study area. Considering the health hazards associated with the consumption of polluted groundwater, we therefore recommend that all the hand dug wells and shallow boreholes in the study area should be closed down for safety and the solid waste dump sites should be...
... The dominant aquifer entity in the area falls inside the sands of the upper deltaic top lithofacies [25] . The water table in the study area (the first occurrence of groundwater) is estimated to lie between 4 m to 5 m beneath [26] . ...
Article
Full-text available
In the design of building structures, joint efforts must be decided to resolve the depth to competent layers across the intended site, and periodic subsidence monitoring and deformation assessment of all buildings, specifically high-rise buildings, should be a regular practice, to safeguard the durability of civil engineering structures, to avert the disastrous consequences of structural failure and collapse prevalent of late. It was this extremity that necessitated the adoption of an integrated methodology which employed DC resistivity tomography involving 2-D and 3-D techniques and geotechnical-soil analysis to evaluate subsoil properties for engineering site investigation at Okerenkoko primary school, in Warri-southwest area of Delta State, to adduce the phenomena responsible for the visible cracks/structural failure observed in the school buildings. Rectilinear set of 2-D resistivity data consisting of five (5) parallel and five (5) perpendicular lines were obtained in a 100 x 80 m2 rectangular grid using the Wenner array. Thirteen (13) Schlumberger soundings were also obtained on the site with half-current electrode separation of 200 m. The results brought to light the geological structure beneath the subsurface, which consists of four geoelectric layers identified as top soil, dry/lithified upper sandy layer, wet sand (water-saturated) and peat/clay/sandy clayey soil (highly water-saturated). The deeply-seated peat/clay materials (ρ ≤ 20 Ωm) were delineated in the study area to depths of 17.1 m and 19.8 m from 2-D and 3-D imaging respectively. The dominance of mechanically unstable peat/clay/sandy clay layers beneath the subsurface, which are highly mobile in response to volumetric changes, is responsible for the noticeable cracks/failure/subsidence detected on structures within the study site. The DC resistivity result was validated using geotechnical test of soil samples collected from boreholes covering the first 8.0 m on three of the profiles. Atterberg’s limits of the soil samples revealed plasticity indices of zero for all samples. Thus, the soil samples within the depth analyzed were representatives of sandy soil which does not possess any plasticity and their plasticity index is taken as zero. These findings apparently justify the subsoil conditions defined in the interpretation of 2-D and 3-D resistivity imaging data. 3-D images presented as horizontal depth slices revealed the dominance of very low resistivity materials i.e. peat/clay/sandy clay within the third, fourth and fifth layers at depths ranging from 5.38-8.68 m, 8.68-12.5 m and 12.5-16.9 m respectively. Hence, 3-D tomography amplified the degree of accuracy of the geoelectrical resistivity imaging. Resistivity contour maps of second, third and fourth layers for VES 1 to 13, displayed low resistivity direction predominantly towards the northeastern part of the site, and signifies that rocks within the northeastern part have low resistivity values, which connotes high porosity and establishes the groundwater flow trend in the study area. The methods employed in this study justifiably gave relevant information on the subsurface geology beneath the study site and its suitability for engineering practice. Thus, it is suggested that these methods should be appropriated as major tools for engineering site assessment projects and groundwater future studies.
... Currently, geophysical methods have been progressively popular in engineering and environmental studies. This technique provides useful subsurface information based on the contrast in physical properties (Uchegbulam and Ayolabi, 2014). The geoelectrical resistivity method is a non-invasive and cost-effective alternative for obtaining subsurface geological information. ...
Article
Full-text available
The impacts of leachate on the soil count as one of the main environmental issues, especially near waste dump areas. The Kwashe dumpsite is located in the Semel district, west of Duhok City. Different types of waste had accumulated from medical, construction, and household materials without any barrier or control of the contamination. Wastewater flows on the surface and percolates downward all over the area. Geophysical methods provide high-resolution data to investigate subsurface environmental conditions with no disturbance in the materials. In this study, the 2D resistivity technique by Ohm-Mapper device (G-858G) with a dipole-dipole arrangement was utilized along six resistivity profiles. the system uses one Transmitter to couple an active current signal to the ground and the voltage difference is recorded by one Receiver with separation distances of 2.5, 5.0, 10.0, and 15.0 m. The resistivity data from MagMapper software was transferred to Res2dinvx32 software to create an inversion model for the subsurface. The results showed two main parts: The upper part consists of soil material mixed with recent deposits and fill materials formed of alluvium deposits with resistivity values of 15-50 Ohm.m at a depth between 0.25-3.0 m. The bottom section represents leachate of bowl-shaped anomalies of very low resistivity values of less than 1.0 Ohm.m at various depths. The type of materials in the left and right edges of each of the models represent the main weak zone for leachate infiltration.
... Electrical resistivity imaging has successfully been employed to delineate contaminated zones in a dump site in the Olushosun area of Lagos (Ayolabi, 2005). The method was equally used by Uchegbulam and Ayolabi (2014) to investigate groundwater pollution by hydrocarbons in the Sapele area of the Western Niger Delta. Induced polarization, which measures chargeability, will complement the resistivity results and, therefore, be incorporated. ...
Article
Underground water resources and soil are increasingly under threat due to refining activities near a residential area. Hydrocarbon contamination of groundwater and soil near the refinery in the Western part of the Niger Delta was carried out using the integrated techniques of electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), induced polarization, geotechnics, and geochemistry. Electrical imaging of the subsurface along the traverses in the site was taken through the use of an earth resistivity meter. Permeability of the soil was determined using a variable head permeameter and geochemical parameters of groundwater were deduced in an analytical laboratory. The resistivity imaging range is 10–2568 Ohm m, reflecting varying resistivity levels associated with lithology and liquid type. Low chargeability of 1–15 ms recorded in most parts implies that the sand has been infiltrated by a high-resistive plume. This low conductivity contaminant may be caused by hydrocarbon intrusion. The typical permeability of the soil is 6.00 × 10–5 m/s, indicating fairly good drainage conditions. Groundwater sample analysis shows slight acidity with a pH value of 5.3–6.6. Conductivity ranges from 74.50 to 119.60 µS/cm, while Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) is 51920 to 69,350 µg/L. Iron content is slightly high (645–977 g/L). Gas chromatography (GC) examination reveals that oil and grease as total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) is > 31 µg/L. The impermeable clay before the confined aquifer filters the TPH, which accounts for its low quantity in the water samples. The results have shown that the area has been degraded. It could be recommended that periodic integrated methods be carried out in the area.
Article
Full-text available
The challenge of data availability for accurately assessing a location's level of corrosivity has lingered for so long and as such, researchers are constantly seeking factors with great influence that can assist in describing how corrosive a location will be toward buried oil and gas infrastructure. Alternative measures are required for making rapid and realistic investment decisions because accumulating these factors to make perfect sense is sometimes time-consuming and expensive. Using MATLAB mathematical computational analysis, this study capitalizes on this gap to build a 3D corrosivity signature and model for Delta state in Nigeria to aid in rapid and realistic investment decision-making. The soil pH and resistivity were identified as key variables that determine the extent of corrosion in this investigation. Vertical Electrical Soundings were utilized to collect soil resistivity data, which was then combined with the soil pH to create a 3D corrosivity signature and model with a 98% R-square factor. During the study, potential limitations were found, and recommendations were made.
Article
Groundwater is a reservoir of fresh water located beneath the ground surface in soil pore spaces and the fractures of lithology formations. Groundwater contained in the aquifer layer has a certain depth. Aquifer layer measurement was conducted with five tracks using the AGI Super Sting R1 IP tool with a spacing of 25 m and a track length of 675 m in Balangan County. This study aims to determine the 2D cross-sectional model, analyze lithology types, and determine the depth, thickness, and aquifer type in the study area based on the resistivity value. The results showed that the study area includes two rock formations – the Dahor and Warukin formations. The Dahor formation is clay with a resistivity value of 1–28.284 m, sandy clay 28.284–99.055 m, and sand 99.055–800 m. The Warukin formation is clay with a resistivity value of 1–10 m, sandy clay 10–31.623 m, and sand 31.623–100 m. Aquifer layer estimation shows that track 1 has a free aquifer and contains aquitard rock. Next, track 2 has a confined aquifer and contains rocks that are both aquifer and aquitard. Then, track 3 has a free aquifer type and contains rocks that are aquifer and aquitard. Track 4 has two measurements with a depressed aquifer and contains rocks that are aquifer. Finally, Track 5 has a depressed aquifer and contains aquitard rock. This study shows the existence of groundwater deposits in the thickness of the aquifer layer in Balangan County, Indonesia.
Article
Full-text available
Refraction experiments were conducted over parts of the east-central Niger Delta in an attempt to provide an interpretation of the region's weathering structure. The velocity and depth of the weathered layer and the velocity of the refractor were calculated from critically refracted arrivals using flat-layer models. An interpretation of the data, carried out using the time-intercept method, shows that the thickness of the low velocity weathered layer in the region is highly variable, from between about 2.9 m and 45.5 m, with a regional average of about 20.0 m. The weathered layer and the refractor beneath it have an average compressional-wave velocity of about 500.0 m/s and 1732.0 m/s, respectively. The knowledge of this weathering structure can be applied in oil and ground water exploration in the area of the study. It is also expected that this structure could be used by groups interested in civil engineering.
Article
Geoelectric resistivity technique of geophysical investigation have been used to evaluate the effect of leachate generated from Olushosun landfill on the groundwater in the area. The result shows that the first aquifer has been greatly polluted by the leachate generated from the decomposed heap of refuse materials at the landfill site. A total depth of up to 73 m has been delineated as polluted area with resistivity ranging from 16 to 361 Ωm as compared to resistivity values ranging between 2167-3714 Ωm for the unpolluted area. The results of the evaluation of the protective capacity of the overburden material within the unpolluted zone shows that the overburden material has a weak protective capacity and this may have largely been responsible for the high level of pollution observed in this area.
Article
The impact of the buried refuse at the abandoned Achakpo refuse dumpsite in Ajeromi-Ifelodun Local Government area of Lagos State on the groundwater has been carried out using geophysical and hydrochemical methods. The geophysical method involved vertical electrical soundings while the hydrochemical analysis carried out on the samples of groundwater from four hand dug wells in the vicinity of refuse dumpsite and one sample of surface water. Three geoelectric layers were delineated from the interpretation of vertical electrical sounding data and the map of the depth to the top of resistive bed was produced to show the extent of pollution. Supporting evidence was provided by the hydrochemical analysis of samples from groundwater and surface water which show very high value of conductivity, total dissolved solids, total suspended solids, Alkalinity, Total hardness, Ca2+, Fe2+ and PO43-.
Article
The Late Quaternary Niger delta in the Gulf of Guinea is a large, arcuate "classical" delta associated with marginal estuary and barrier island-lagoon complexes. The Late Quaternary deltaic lens (minimum volume 900 cubic kilometers) is the latest accretion within the Nigerian Coastal Plain geosyncline. Sediment originating in a vast and geologically complex hinterland is dispersed through the delta by river, tidal, wave, and ocean currents. Delta growth began during the Late Wisconsin lowstand of the sea when the rivers entrenched the continental shelf to reach mouths above submarine canyons at the shelf edge. The oldest stratigraphical unit of the Late Quaternary deltaic pile is a strand plain sand (Older Sands) representing a marine transgression into the hinterland. Later, in the Holocene, when sea-level became relatively stable, regressive advance across the sands of concentrically arranged delta environments gave rise to the Younger Suite, the uppermost stratigraphical formation in the deltaic lens. Lithofacies of this suite grade upward from open shelf clays, through pro-delta slope layered clays, silts, and sands, to well-bedded sands formed on the delta-front platform, river mouth bars, and beaches. Behind beach idge barrier islands fringing the visible part of the delta occur tidal mangrove swamps in which organic-rich sands and silts are being deposited. Cross-stratified river bar sands are accumulating in association with top-stratum silts and clays in the delta floodplain environment. The sedimentary framework of the Late Quaternary Niger delta is based on essentially concentric facies elements, as in many other "classical" deltas, rather than on radial elements as in the Mississippi birdfoot delta.
Article
This paper describes one of the world's major hydrocarbon provinces, the Niger delta. An introduction describes the regional setting of the delta, the deltaic framework and morphology, and the present morphology. Major sections within the paper consider the stratigraphy, basin architecture and tectonics, as well as oil and gas systems and a review of exploration activity. There are a number of interpreted regional seismic profiles. The paper is concluded with a reference list. -D.J.Sanderson