No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.
Histone deacetylase inhibition and estrogen receptor alpha levels modulate the transcriptional activity of partial antiestrogens
Abstract
In this study, we have analysed the effects of histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibition on estrogen receptor (ER) expression and on its transcriptional activity in response to antiestrogens. In several breast cancer cell lines, trichostatin A (TSA), a potent HDAC inhibitor, strongly decreases ERalpha expression in a dose-dependent manner. This repression is observed independently of the presence of ligand and also occurs in ovarian and endometrial cell lines. In addition, we show that in MCF7 cells bearing a stably transfected reporter plasmid (MELN cells), partial antiestrogens such as 4-OH-tamoxifen (OHTam), raloxifen or LY117018, switch to an agonist activity upon HDAC inhibition. This effect is blocked by the pure antiestrogen ICI182780 and exhibits a half-maximal concentration of OHTam equivalent to its affinity for ERalpha. The TSA-dependent decrease of ERalpha expression is required to induce the agonist switch of OHTam properties as it is lost in cells constitutively expressing exogenous receptors (MELN-ERalpha or ERbeta). By contrast, the transrepression activity of OHTam is abolished by TSA independently of the decrease of ERalpha expression. Interestingly, in MELN-ERalpha, ICI182780 remains inhibitory suggesting the involvement of HDAC-independent mechanisms. Finally, in the absence of TSA, transcriptional activity in response to OHTam is significantly raised in MELN cells expressing low levels of ERalpha after transfection of antisense oligonucleotides. In conclusion, inhibition of HDAC enzymatic activity and modulation of ERalpha levels tightly control the relative agonist activity of partial antiestrogens on a stably integrated reporter transgene.
... Although this result suggests that ERα is strongly implicated in TNF-α-triggered apoptotic cell death in breast cancer cells, we could not conclusively infer that ERα is a positive regulator of the stimulation of caspase-dependent apoptosis in breast cancer, because our data obviously showed the dramatic decrease in ERα after TNF-α administration to MCF-7 cells, in accordance with a previous study [40]. About 75% of breast cancers are ERα-positive [41]; furthermore, cumulative data from clinical trials [42][43][44] and retrospective data analyses [42] suggest that ERα-positive breast cancer is more tolerant to some chemotherapeutic agents. On the basis of these facts, the downregulation of ERα expression by TNF-α treatment may contribute to overcoming the resistance to chemotherapy in patients with ERα-positive breast cancer; however, the molecular mechanism underlying this phenomenon remains unclear. ...
... This result suggests the involvement of HDAC3 in TNF-α-induced apoptotic cell death in ERα-positive breast cancer cells; moreover, other experiments performed in this study using either HDAC3 overexpression or knockdown also firmly supported this hypothesis. As mentioned briefly at the beginning of the Discussion section, there is accumulating evidence of the cross-talk between ERα and HDACs [43,44]. In breast cancer cells, trichostatin A (TSA) and suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA), which is a potent and reversible HDAC inhibitor (HDACi), inhibited ERα expression and transcriptional activity [44,45] via the disturbance of HDAC activity. ...
... As mentioned briefly at the beginning of the Discussion section, there is accumulating evidence of the cross-talk between ERα and HDACs [43,44]. In breast cancer cells, trichostatin A (TSA) and suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA), which is a potent and reversible HDAC inhibitor (HDACi), inhibited ERα expression and transcriptional activity [44,45] via the disturbance of HDAC activity. In contrast, the TNF-α-triggered ERα downregulation was attributed to the decline in HDAC3 activity because of its downregulation. ...
Tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) plays a significant role in inflammation and cancer-related apoptosis. We identified a TNF-α-mediated epigenetic mechanism of apoptotic cell death regulation in estrogen receptor-α (ERα)-positive human breast cancer cells. To assess the apoptotic effect of TNF-α, annexin V/ propidium iodide (PI) double staining, cell viability assays, and Western blotting were performed. To elucidate this mechanism, histone deacetylase (HDAC) activity assay and immunoprecipitation (IP) were conducted; the mechanism was subsequently confirmed through chromatin IP (ChIP) assays. Finally, we assessed HDAC3–ERα-mediated apoptotic cell death after TNF-α treatment in ERα-positive human breast cancer (MCF-7) cells via the transcriptional activation of p53 target genes using luciferase assay and quantitative reverse transcription PCR. The TNF-α-induced selective apoptosis in MCF-7 cells was negatively regulated by the HDAC3–ERα complex in a caspase-7-dependent manner. HDAC3 possessed a p53-binding element, thus suppressing the transcriptional activity of its target genes. In contrast, MCF-7 cell treatment with TNF-α led to dissociation of the HDAC3–ERα complex and substitution of the occupancy on the promoter by the p53–p300 complex, thus accelerating p53 target gene expression. In this process, p53 stabilization was accompanied by its acetylation. This study showed that p53-mediated apoptosis in ERα-positive human breast cancer cells was negatively regulated by HDAC3–ERα in a caspase-7-dependent manner. Therefore, these proteins have potential application in therapeutic strategies.
... However, other studies have failed to reproduce these observations [92]. On the other hand, treatment of ERα-expressing breast and uterine cancer cells with HDAC inhibitors leads to suppression of ESR1 expression [93][94][95][96]. Recently, treatment of triple negative breast tumor cells MDA-MB-231 LM2 with EZH2 inhibitors has been shown to induce GATA3 expression and, more modestly, ESR1 expression, and to sensitize these cells as well as another TNBC cell line (MDA-MB-468) to treatment with the antiestrogen fulvestrant [97]. ...
Estrogen receptor alpha (ERα, NR3A1) contributes through its expression in different tissues to a spectrum of physiological processes, including reproductive system development and physiology, bone mass maintenance, as well as cardiovascular and central nervous system functions. It is also one of the main drivers of tumorigenesis in breast and uterine cancer and can be targeted by several types of hormonal therapies. ERα is expressed in a subset of luminal cells corresponding to less than 10% of normal mammary epithelial cells and in over 70% of breast tumors (ER+ tumors), but the basis for its selective expression in normal or cancer tissues remains incompletely understood. The mapping of alternative promoters and regulatory elements has delineated the complex genomic structure of the ESR1 gene and shed light on the mechanistic basis for the tissue-specific regulation of ESR1 expression. However, much remains to be uncovered to better understand how ESR1 expression is regulated in breast cancer. This review recapitulates the current body of knowledge on the structure of the ESR1 gene and the complex mechanisms controlling its expression in breast tumors. In particular, we discuss the impact of genetic alterations, chromatin modifications, and enhanced expression of other luminal transcription regulators on ESR1 expression in tumor cells.
... Preclinically, HDAC inhibitors have been shown to increase the antitumour efficacy of, or reverse resistance to, hormone therapies in models of ERα-positive breast cancer [43][44][45] . HDAC inhibition interferes with ERα signalling pathway at multiple levels, including transcriptional suppression of ESR1 (which encodes ERα), reductions in ERα mRNA and protein stability and modulation of the transcription of ERα targets as well as other genes involved in cell proliferation and metastasis 46,47 (Fig. 3b). HDAC6 inhibition, specifically, leads to HSP90 hyperacetylation, which disrupts the HSP90-ERα association and favours ERα ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation 48 . ...
Epigenetic dysregulation has long been recognized as a key factor contributing to tumorigenesis and tumour maintenance that can influence all of the recognized hallmarks of cancer. Despite regulatory approvals for the treatment of certain haematological malignancies, the efficacy of the first generation of epigenetic drugs (epi-drugs) in patients with solid tumours has been disappointing; however, successes have now been achieved in selected solid tumour subtypes, thanks to the development of novel compounds and a better understanding of cancer biology that have enabled precision medicine approaches. Several lines of evidence support that, beyond their potential as monotherapies, epigenetic drugs could have important roles in synergy with other anticancer therapies or in reversing acquired therapy resistance. Herein, we review the mechanisms by which epi-drugs can modulate the sensitivity of cancer cells to other forms of anticancer therapy, including chemotherapy, radiation therapy, hormone therapy, molecularly targeted therapy and immunotherapy. We provide a critical appraisal of the preclinical rationale, completed clinical studies and ongoing clinical trials relating to combination therapies incorporating epi-drugs. Finally, we propose and discuss rational clinical trial designs and drug development strategies, considering key factors including patient selection, tumour biomarker evaluation, drug scheduling and response assessment and study end points, with the aim of optimizing the development of such combinations.
... In breast cancer cells, trichostatin A (TSA), a potent and reversible HDACi, produced a strong decrease in ERα accumulation independent of the presence or absence of ER ligands. The effect was dose dependent and was not restricted to TSA since a similar regulation was obtained with different HDACi, suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA), which is structurally similar to TSA [109]. Regulation by TSA takes place at the transcriptional level and therefore the use of different HDACi decreases the expression of ERα in ER-positive breast cancer cells. ...
Breast cancer is the most common malignancy in women worldwide. The risk of breast cancer in women increases with age, and this is partly attributable to the accumulation of genetic lesions. Growing evidence demonstrates the role played by epigenetic modifiers and the tumor microenvironment in contributing to the increased risk of breast cancer. This chapter provides a comprehensive overview of the epigenetic regulatory signatures that impact the well-studied signaling pathways in breast tissues. Additionally, we will also delve into the therapeutic and diagnostic potential of noncoding RNAs in breast cancer.
... We show here that SAFB action is specifically affected by four different HDAC inhibitors, depending on the receptor tested (FXR or PPAR). Although these results may appear confusing at first sight, they most probably reflect the recruitment of different types of HDACs by each receptor, as well as some specific interplay between HDACs on the one hand and promoters and ligands on the other hand, as recently exemplified with the estrogen receptor (ER), whose action is differently modulated by HDAC inhibitors, depending upon the cell line and the ligand tested (Margueron et al. 2004). It is also possible that these compounds have some side effects and modulate other cellular components which indirectly affect the transcription of the reporter construct. ...
Transcriptional activity relies on coregulators that modify the chromatin structure and serve as bridging factors between transcription factors and the basal transcription machinery. Using the DE domain of human peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPARgamma) as bait in a yeast two-hybrid screen of a human adipose tissue library, we isolated the scaffold attachment factor B1 (SAFB1/HET/HAP), which was previously shown to be a corepressor of estrogen receptor alpha. We show here that SAFB1 has a very broad tissue expression profile in human and is also expressed all along mouse embryogenesis. SAFB1 interacts in pull-down assays not only with PPARgamma but also with all nuclear receptors tested so far, albeit with different affinities. The association of SAFB1 and PPARgamma in vivo is further demonstrated by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments in living cells. We finally show that SAFB1 is a rather general corepressor for nuclear receptors. Its change in expression during the early phases of adipocyte and enterocyte differentiation suggests that SAFB1 potentially influences cell proliferation and differentiation decisions.
... In situations in which HDACs are inhibited, a decrease of EGFR mRNA in ER-negative MDA-MB-231 BC cells occurred [135] and re-sensitization in vivo of these cells to Tam, strengthening the potential usefulness of HDACis for BC treatment [136]. However, these data are difficult to reconcile with the switching to an agonist activity of tamoxifen by TSA in ERapositive BC cells observed previously [137]. ...
... However, C 10 (15), C 10 (16), and C 10 (19) did not induce any detectable transcriptional activity, similar to the SERDs ICI164,384, fulvestrant, and RU58,668. In addition, while SERMs also did not yield detectable transcriptional activity alone, treatment with the histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor TSA resulted in a gain of agonist activity with the SERMs OHT, Ral, and RU39,411 as previously reported (53). No gain of activity was observed with SERDs or with the compounds C 10 (15), C 10 (16), and C 10 (19), further demonstrating their SERD-like properties (see Fig. S5B in the supplemental material). ...
The selective estrogen receptor downregulator (SERD) fulvestrant can be used as second-line treatment for patients relapsing after treatment with tamoxifen, a selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM). Unlike tamoxifen, SERDs are devoid of partial agonist activity. While the full antiestrogenicity of SERDs may result in part from their capacity to downregulate levels of estrogen receptor alpha (ERα) through proteasome-mediated degradation, SERDs are also fully antiestrogenic in the absence of increased receptor turnover in HepG2 cells. Here we report that SERDs induce the rapid and strong SUMOylation of ERα in ERα-positive and -negative cell lines, including HepG2 cells. Four sites of SUMOylation were identified by mass spectrometry analysis. In derivatives of the SERD ICI164,384, SUMOylation was dependent on the length of the side chain and correlated with full antiestrogenicity. Preventing SUMOylation by the overexpression of a SUMO-specific protease (SENP) deSUMOylase partially derepressed transcription in the presence of full antiestrogens in HepG2 cells without a corresponding increase in activity in the presence of agonists or of the SERM tamoxifen. Mutations increasing transcriptional activity in the presence of full antiestrogens reduced SUMOylation levels and suppressed stimulation by SENP1. Our results indicate that ERα SUMOylation contributes to full antiestrogenicity in the absence of accelerated receptor turnover.
Endometrial carcinoma is the most common malignant tumor of the female genital tract in the United States. Epigenetic alterations are implicated in endometrial cancer development and progression. Histone deacetylase inhibitors are a novel class of anticancer drugs that increase the level of histone acetylation in many cell types, thereby inducing cell cycle arrest, differentiation, and apoptotic cell death. This review is aimed at determining the role of histone acetylation and examining the therapeutic potential of histone deacetylase inhibitors in endometrial cancer. In order to identify relevant studies, a literature review was conducted using the MEDLINE and LIVIVO databases. The search terms histone deacetylase, histone deacetylase inhibitor, and endometrial cancer were employed, and we were able to identify fifty-two studies focused on endometrial carcinoma and published between 2001 and 2021. Deregulation of histone acetylation is involved in the tumorigenesis of both endometrial carcinoma histological types and accounts for high-grade, aggressive carcinomas with worse prognosis and decreased overall survival. Histone deacetylase inhibitors inhibit tumor growth, enhance the transcription of silenced physiologic genes, and induce cell cycle arrest and apoptosis in endometrial carcinoma cells both in vitro and in vivo. The combination of histone deacetylase inhibitors with traditional chemotherapeutic agents shows synergistic cytotoxic effects in endometrial carcinoma cells. Histone acetylation plays an important role in endometrial carcinoma development and progression. Histone deacetylase inhibitors show potent antitumor effects in various endometrial cancer cell lines as well as tumor xenograft models. Additional clinical trials are however needed to verify the clinical utility and safety of these promising therapeutic agents in the treatment of patients with endometrial cancer.
Histone Deacetylases (HDACs) play an important role in regulating target gene expression. They have been highlighted as a novel category of anticancer targets, and their inhibition can induce apoptosis, differentiation, and growth arrest in cancer cells. In view of the fact that HDAC inhibitors and other antitumor agents, such as BET inhibitors, topoisomerase inhibitors, and RTK pathway inhibitors, exert a synergistic effect on cellular processes in cancer cells, the combined inhibition of both targets is regarded as a rational strategy to improve the effectiveness of these single-target drugs for cancer treatment. In this review, we discuss the theoretical basis for designing HDAC-involved dual-target drugs and provide insight into the structure-activity relationships of these dual-target agents.
In breast carcinoma cells, high levels of hyaluronan (HA) and its CD44 receptor are frequently associated with alteration in estrogen signaling. We demonstrate that stable hyaluronate synthase 2 (HAS2) overexpression in estrogen receptor α (ERα) -positive MCF7 cells oppositely altered estrogen dependence of cell growth and its sensitivity towards antiestrogens. Albeit without effect on ERα expression and estradiol binding properties, HAS2 overexpression increased ERα Ser118 phosphorylation as well as transcriptional activity of estrogen in an ERE-luciferase reporter gene assay. However, HAS2 overexpression induced partial silencing of E2 driven-genes without affecting the magnitude of regulation by estradiol. This effect was associated with half-reduction in the activity of nuclear histone deacetylases (HDACs) through a post-translational mechanism likely consecutive to the enhanced expression of the histone acetyl-transferase EP300. In conclusion, increase in HA/CD44 interactions may contribute, through an HDAC inhibitor-like and ER-independent mechanism, to the silencing of estrogen–driven genes in breast carcinoma.
Breast cancer, the most frequent cancer in women, is the second leading cause of cancer-related death. Estrogens and estrogen receptors are well recognized to play predominant roles in breast cancer development and growth. Neo-tanshinlactone is a natural product isolated from Salvia miltiorrhiza and showed selective growth inhibition of ER+ breast cancer cell lines as demonstrated by cell proliferation assay and colony formation assay. The selective anti-proliferative effect of neo-tanshinlactone was associated with the induction of apoptosis in ER+ breast cancer cells. We also found that neo-tanshinlactone decreased steady state ESR1 mRNA levels in ER+ breast cancer cells, which was further confirmed by analysis of ER protein levels as well as the mRNA levels of target genes of this transcription factor, such as ESR2, BRCA1, CCND1, GREB1, TFF1, SERPINB9 and ABCA3. Furthermore, analysis of heterogeneous nuclear RNA (hnRNA) demonstrated that neo-tanshinlactone inhibited ESR1 mRNA de novo synthesis. The decrease of steady state ESR1 mRNA upon neo-tanshinlactone treatment was not abolished by protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide. And inhibition of mRNA synthesis with actinomycin D revealed no significant effect of neo-tanshinlactone on ESR1 mRNA stability. These results indicated that transcriptional down-regulation of ESR1 mRNA could contribute to the selective activity of neo-tanshinlactone on ER+ breast cancer cells. And as expected, the combination of neo-tanshinlactone and antiestrogen reagent tamoxifen showed a synergistic effect on growth of ER+ MCF7 cells. Our results suggest that neo-tanshinlactone is a promising regimen for ER+ breast tumors.
Estrogens are critical mediators of multiple and diverse physiologic effects throughout the body in both sexes, including the reproductive, cardiovascular, endocrine, nervous, and immune systems. As such, alterations in estrogen function play important roles in many diseases and pathophysiological conditions (including cancer), exemplified by the lower prevalence of many diseases in premenopausal women. Estrogens mediate their effects through multiple cellular receptors, including the nuclear receptor family (ERα and ERβ) and the G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) family (GPR30/G protein-coupled estrogen receptor [GPER]). Although both receptor families can initiate rapid cell signaling and transcriptional regulation, the nuclear receptors are traditionally associated with regulating gene expression, whereas GPCRs are recognized as mediating rapid cellular signaling. Estrogen-activated pathways are not only the target of multiple therapeutic agents (e.g., tamoxifen, fulvestrant, raloxifene, and aromatase inhibitors) but are also affected by a plethora of phyto- and xeno-estrogens (e.g., genistein, coumestrol, bisphenol A, dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane). Because of the existence of multiple estrogen receptors with overlapping ligand specificities, expression patterns, and signaling pathways, the roles of the individual receptors with respect to the diverse array of endogenous and exogenous ligands have been challenging to ascertain. The identification of GPER-selective ligands however has led to a much greater understanding of the roles of this receptor in normal physiology and disease as well as its interactions with the classic estrogen receptors ERα and ERβ and their signaling pathways. In this review, we describe the history and characterization of GPER over the past 15 years focusing on the pharmacology of steroidal and nonsteroidal compounds that have been employed to unravel the biology of this most recently recognized estrogen receptor.
A strategy to develop chemotherapeutic agents by combining several active groups into a single molecule as a conjugate that can modulate multiple cellular pathways may produce compounds having higher efficacy compared to single-target drugs. In this paper, we describe the synthesis and evaluation of an array of dual-acting ER and histone deacetylase inhibitors. These novel hybrid compounds combine an indirect antagonism structure motif of ER (OBHS, oxabicycloheptene sulfonate) with the HDAC inhibitor suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA). These OBHS-HDACi conjugates exhibited good ER binding affinity and excellent ERα antagonistic activity, and they also exhibited potent inhibitory activities against HDACs. Compared with the approved drug tamoxifen, these conjugates exhibited higher antitumor potency in ERα-positive breast cancer cells (MCF-7). Moreover, these conjugates not only showed selective anticancer activity that was more potent against MCF-7 cells than DU 145 (prostate cancer), but they had no toxicity towards normal cells.
Breast cancer remains a significant cause of death in women, and few therapeutic options exist for estrogen receptor negative (ER (-)) cancers. Epigenetic reactivation of target genes using histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitors has been proposed in ER (-) cancers to resensitize to therapy using selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) that are effective in ER (+) cancer treatment. Based upon preliminary studies in ER (+) and ER (-) breast cancer cells treated with combinations of HDAC inhibitors and SERMs, hybrid drugs, termed SERMostats, were designed with computational guidance. Assay for inhibition of four type I HDAC isoforms and antagonism of estrogenic activity in two cell lines yielded a SERMostat with 1-3 μM potency across all targets. The superior hybrid caused significant cell death in ER (-) human breast cancer cells and elicited cell death at the same concentration as the parent SERM in combination treatment and at an earlier time point.
Estrogen receptor alpha (ERα) expression is a risk factor for breast cancer. HDAC inhibitors have been demonstrated to down-regulate ERα expression in ERα-positive breast cancer cell lines, but the molecular mechanisms are poorly understood. Here, we showed that HDAC inhibitors decrease the stability of ERα mRNA, and that knockdown of HDAC3 decreases the stability of ERα mRNA and suppresses estrogen-dependent proliferation of ERα-positive MCF-7 breast cancer cells. In the Oncomine database, expression levels of HDAC3 in ERα-positive tumors are higher than those in ERα-negative tumors, thus suggesting that HDAC3 is necessary for ERα mRNA stability, and is involved in the estrogen-dependent proliferation of ERα-positive tumors.
We recently found that tamoxifen suppresses l-glutamate transport activity of cultured astrocytes. Here, in an attempt to separate the l-glutamate transporter-inhibitory activity from the estrogen receptor-mediated genomic effects, we synthesized several compounds structurally related to tamoxifen. Among them, we identified two compounds, 1 (YAK01) and 3 (YAK037), which potently inhibited l-glutamate transporter activity. The inhibitory effect of 1 was found to be mediated through estrogen receptors and the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK)/phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) pathway, though 1 showed greatly reduced transactivation activity compared with that of 17β-estradiol. On the other hand, compound 3 exerted its inhibitory effect through an estrogen receptor-independent and MAPK-independent, but PI3K-dependent pathway, and showed no transactivation activity. Compound 3 may represent a new platform for developing novel l-glutamate transporter inhibitors with higher brain transfer rates and reduced adverse effects.
In the present study, effect of Na-Bu on the pRb phosphorylation was analysed in the primary cultures of 12 VS tumors. Primary cultures of VS tumors were established from the fresh tumor tissues removed surgically and were treated with Na-Bu. Na-Bu treatment for 48 h led to morphological changes and apoptotic cell death in VS tumor cells. Na-Bu treatment decreased level of total pRb and phosphorylated form of pRb and caused specific dephosphorylation at Ser 249/Thr 252 and Ser 567. In the untreated and Na-Bu treated cells (when present), pRb was localised in the nucleus. Moreover, in Na-Bu treated cells the nucleus appeared highly condensed as compared to untreated cells. Results of the present study indicated that Na-Bu treatment modulated pRb phosphorylation status and caused apoptotic cell death in VS tumors.
Estrogens play an essential role in the normal physiology of the breast as well as in mammary tumorigenesis. Their effects are mediated by two nuclear estrogen receptors, ERα and β, which regulate transcription of specific genes by interacting with multiprotein complexes, including histone deacetylases (HDACs). During the past few years, HDACs have raised great interest as therapeutic targets in the field of cancer therapy. In breast cancer, several experimental arguments suggest that HDACs are involved at multiple levels in mammary tumorigenesis: their expression is deregulated in breast tumors; they interfere with ER signaling in intricate ways, restoring hormone sensitivity in models of estrogen resistance, and they clinically represent new potential targets for HDACs inhibitors (HDIs) in combination with hormonal therapies. In this paper, we will describe these different aspects and underline the clinical interest of HDIs in the context of breast cancer resistance to hormone therapies (HTs).
Acetylation is an essential post-translational modification featuring an acetyl group that is covalently conjugated to a protein substrate. Histone acetylation was first proposed nearly half a century ago by Dr. Vincent Allfrey. Subsequent studies have shown that the acetylated core histones are often associated with transcriptionally active chromatin. Acetylation at lysine residues of histone tails neutralizes the positive charge, which decreases their binding ability to DNA and increases the accessibility of transcription factors and coactivators to the chromatin template. In addition to histones, a number of non-histone substrates are acetylated. Acetylation of non-histone proteins governs biological processes, such as cellular proliferation and survival, transcriptional activity, and intracellular trafficking. We demonstrated that acetylation of transcription factors can regulate cellular growth. Furthermore, we showed that nuclear receptors (NRs) are acetylated at a phylogenetically conserved motif. Since our initial observations with the estrogen and androgen receptors, more than a dozen NRs have been shown to function as substrates for acetyltransferases with diverse functional consequences. This review focuses on the acetylation of NRs and the effect of acetylation on NR function. We discuss the potential role of acetylation in disease initiation and progression with an emphasis on tumorigenesis.
A variety of post-translational protein modifications (PTMs) are known to be altered as a result of cancer development. Thus, these PTMs are potentially useful biomarkers for breast cancer. Mass spectrometry, antibody microarrays and immunohistochemistry techniques have shown promise for identifying changes in PTMs. In this review, we summarize the current literature on PTMs identified in the plasma and tumor tissue of breast-cancer patients or in breast cell lines. We also discuss some of the analytical techniques currently being used to evaluate PTMs.
Gender differences in cardiovascular disease have long been recognized and attributed to beneficial cardiovascular actions of estrogen. Class II histone deacetylases (HDACs) act as key modulators of heart disease by repressing the activity of the myocyte enhancer factor (MEF)2 transcription factor, which promotes pathological cardiac remodeling in response to stress. Although it is proposed that HDACs additionally influence nuclear receptor signaling, the effect of class II HDACs on gender differences in cardiovascular disease remains unstudied.
We aimed to examine the effect of class II HDACs on post-myocardial infarction remodeling in male and female mice.
Here we show that the absence of HDAC5 or -9 in female mice protects against maladaptive remodeling following myocardial infarction, during which there is an upregulation of estrogen-responsive genes in the heart. This genetic reprogramming coincides with a pronounced increase in expression of the estrogen receptor (ER)alpha gene, which we show to be a direct MEF2 target gene. ERalpha also directly interacts with class II HDACs. Cardioprotection resulting from the absence of HDAC5 or -9 in female mice can be attributed, at least in part, to enhanced neoangiogenesis in the infarcted region via upregulation of the ER target gene vascular endothelial growth factor-a.
Our results reveal a novel gender-specific pathway of cardioprotection mediated by ERalpha and its regulation by MEF2 and class II HDACs.
Endocrine disrupting chemicals are widely distributed in the environment and derive from many different human activities or can also be natural products synthesized by plants or microorganisms. The phytoestrogen, genistein (4', 5, 7-trihydroxy-isoflavone), is a naturally occurring compound found in soy products. Genistein has been the subject of numerous studies because of its known estrogenic activity.
We report that genistein exposure of zebrafish embryos induces apoptosis, mainly in the hindbrain and the anterior spinal cord. Timing experiments demonstrate that apoptosis is induced during a precise developmental window. Since adding ICI 182,780, an ER antagonist, does not rescue the genistein-induced apoptosis and since there is no synergistic effect between genistein and estradiol, we conclude that this apoptotic effect elicited by genistein is estrogen-receptors independent. However, we show in vitro, that genistein binds and activates the three zebrafish estrogen receptors ERalpha, ERbeta-A and ERbeta-B. Furthermore using transgenic ERE-Luciferase fish we show that genistein is able to activate the estrogen pathway in vivo during larval stages. Finally we show that genistein is able to induce ectopic expression of the aromatase-B gene in an ER-dependent manner in the anterior brain in pattern highly similar to the one resulting from estrogen treatment at low concentration.
TAKEN TOGETHER THESE RESULTS INDICATE THAT GENISTEIN ACTS THROUGH AT LEAST TWO DIFFERENT PATHWAYS IN ZEBRAFISH EMBRYOS: (i) it induces apoptosis in an ER-independent manner and (ii) it regulates aromatase-B expression in the brain in an ER-dependent manner. Our results thus highlight the multiplicity of possible actions of phytoestrogens, such as genistein. This suggests that the use of standardized endpoints to study the effect of a given compound, even when this compound has well known targets, may carry the risk of overlooking interesting effects of this compound.
Although numerous studies have underlined the role of histone deacetylases (HDAC) in breast physiology and tumorigenesis, little is known on the particular contribution of the various classes of HDACs in these processes. Using estrogen receptor-alpha (ERalpha)-positive MCF-7 breast cancer cells, the effects of MC1575 and MC1568, two novel class II-specific HDAC inhibitors, were analyzed on cell proliferation, apoptosis, and estrogen signaling. The specificity of these HDAC inhibitors was validated by measuring histone and alpha-tubulin acetylation and by the specific in vitro inhibition of recombinant HDAC4 using histone and nonhistone substrates, contrasting with the lack of inhibition of class I HDACs. In addition, MC1575 did not inhibit class I HDAC gene expression, thus confirming the specific targeting of class II enzymes. Similar to trichostatin A (TSA), MC1575 displayed a dose-dependent antiproliferative effect and induced cell cycle arrest although this blockade occurred at a different level than TSA. Moreover, and in contrast to TSA, MC1575 had no effect on MCF-7 cells apoptosis. Interestingly, MC1575 was able to increase p21(waf1/CIP1) mRNA levels but did not regulate the expression of other genes such as cyclin D1, p27, p14(ARF), Bcl2, Baxalpha, Trail-R1, and Trail-R2. Finally, MC1575 strongly induced ERbeta gene expression but did not decrease ERalpha expression, nor did it switch hydroxytamoxifen to an agonist activity. Altogether, these data suggest that the class II HDAC subfamily may exert specific roles in breast cancer progression and estrogen dependence.
Breast carcinogenesis involves genetic and epigenetic alterations that cause aberrant gene function. Recent progress in the knowledge of epigenomics has had a profound impact on the understanding of mechanisms leading to breast cancer, and consequently the development of new strategies for diagnosis and treatment of breast cancer. Epigenetic regulation has been known to involve three mutually interacting events--DNA methylation, histone modifications and nucleosomal remodeling. These processes modulate chromatin structure to form euchromatin or heterochromatin, and in turn activate or silence gene expression. Alteration in expression of key genes through aberrant epigenetic regulation in breast cells can lead to initiation, promotion and maintenance of carcinogenesis, and is even implicated in the generation of drug resistance. We currently review known roles of the epigenetic machinery in the development and recurrence of breast cancer. Furthermore, we highlight the significance of epigenetic alterations as predictive biomarkers and as new targets of anticancer therapy.
Estrogens are steroid hormones, which act through specific nuclear estrogen receptors (ERalpha and ERbeta) and are important regulators of breast cancer growth. These receptors control gene expression by recruiting transcriptional cofactors that exhibit various enzymatic activities such as histone acetyltransferase or histone deacetylase (HDAC) which target histone as well as non-histone substrates. The ERalpha itself and some of the transcriptional regulators have been shown to be acetylated proteins. Research performed over the last decade has highlighted the role of HDAC inhibitors (HDACi) as modulators of transcriptional activity and as a new class of therapeutic agents. In human cancer cells, inhibition of HDACs controls the expression of the ERalpha gene and the transcriptional activity in response to partial antiestrogens such as 4-hydroxytamoxifen. Various HDACi strongly inhibit breast cancer cell proliferation and ERalpha-negative (ER-) appear less sensitive than ERalpha-positive (ER+) cell lines. p21WAF1/CIP1 gene expression, in relation with ERalpha levels, could play a role in this differential response of breast cancer cells to hyperacetylating agents.
Transcriptional activation of estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) is regulated by the ligand-dependent activation function 2 and the constitutively active N-terminal activation function 1. To identify ERalpha N-terminal-specific coregulators, we screened a breast cDNA library by T7 phage display and isolated histone deacetylase 4 (HDAC4). HDAC4 interacts with the ERalpha N terminus both in vitro and in vivo. Presence of the ERalpha DNA binding domain and hinge region reduce HDAC4 recruitment whereas full-length ERalpha enhances recruitment. HDAC4 interaction is selective for the ERalpha and not ERbeta N terminus and occurs in the nucleus. We demonstrate in vivo that HDAC4 is recruited by the N terminus to the promoter of an endogenous estrogen responsive gene. HDAC4 suppresses transcriptional activation of ERalpha by estrogen and selective ER modulators (SERMs) such as tamoxifen in a cell type-dependent manner. Consistently, silencing of HDAC4 promotes the agonist effect of SERMs (tamoxifen and raloxifene) in a cell type-specific manner. These findings indicate a role for HDAC4 in regulating ERalpha activity as a novel N-terminal coregulator and uncover a mechanism by which certain cell types regulate SERM behavior.
Histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi), which have emerged as a new class of anticancer agents, act by modulating expression of genes controlling apoptosis or cell proliferation. Here, we compared the effect of HDACi on transcriptional activation by estrogen or glucocorticoid receptors (ER and GR, respectively), two members of the steroid receptor family with cell growth regulatory properties. Like other transcription factors, steroid receptors modulate histone acetylation on target promoters. Using episomal reporter vectors containing minimal promoters to avoid promoter-specific effects, we observed that long-term (24-h) incubation with HDACi strongly stimulated GR-dependent but markedly repressed ER-dependent signaling in ER+/GR+ human endometrial carcinoma Ishikawa cells. These effects were reproduced on endogenous target genes and required incubation periods with HDACi substantially longer than necessary to increase global histone acetylation. Repression of estrogen signaling was due to direct inhibition of transcription from multiple ERalpha promoters and correlated with decreased histone acetylation of these promoters. In contrast, the strong HDACi stimulation of GR-dependent gene regulation was not accounted for by increased GR expression, but it was mimicked by overexpression of the histone acetyltransferase complex component transcriptional intermediary factor 2. Together, our results demonstrate striking and opposite effects of HDACi on ER and GR signaling that involve regulatory events independent of histone hyperacetylation on receptor target promoters.
Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors are ligand-activated transcription factors with a potential role in cancer. We investigated peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha expression in breast cancer cell lines and showed a relationship between mean peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha and estrogen receptor alpha mRNA levels in estrogen receptor alpha positive breast cancer cells. Transfection of estrogen receptor alpha into the estrogen receptor alpha negative cell line, MDA-MB-231 decreased peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha mRNA and conversely inhibition of estrogen receptor alpha by ICI-182 780 in estrogen receptor alpha positive, MCF-7 cells increased peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha mRNA levels. Estrogen receptor alpha levels can be modulated by histone deacetylase inhibitors and such agents are in clinical trials for cancer treatment. We found the histone deacetylase inhibitor, sodium butyrate, increased peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha mRNA levels within 4h of treatment. Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha modulation was independent of estrogen receptor alpha, as a similar increase was observed in the estrogen receptor alpha negative MDA-MB-231 cells. To further investigate the relationship between sodium butyrate and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha expression, we created an MCF-7 cell line that conditionally over-expresses human peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha. Over-expression of the peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor protected MCF-7 cells from sodium butyrate-mediated inhibition of proliferation and attenuated sodium butyrate-mediated induction of histone deacetylase 3 mRNA, indicating that elevated levels of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha may reduce the sensitivity of cells to histone deacetylase inhibitors. The estrogen receptor alpha dependence of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha levels may be significant since estrogen receptor alpha negative breast cancer cells are associated with a more aggressive phenotype. Our studies also suggest that peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha levels may be a marker of breast cancer cell sensitivity to histone deacetylase inhibitors.
Using a variety of biochemical and cell-based approaches, we show that estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) is acetylated by the p300 acetylase in a ligand- and steroid receptor coactivator-dependent manner. Using mutagenesis and mass spectrometry, we identified two conserved lysine residues in ERalpha (Lys266 and Lys268) that are the primary targets of p300-mediated acetylation. These residues are acetylated in cells, as determined by immunoprecipitation-Western blotting experiments using an antibody that specifically recognizes ERalpha acetylated at Lys266 and Lys268. The acetylation of ERalpha by p300 is reversed by native cellular deacetylases, including trichostatin A-sensitive enzymes (i.e. class I and II deacetylases) and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide-dependent/nicotinamide-sensitive enzymes (i.e. class III deacetylases, such as sirtuin 1). Acetylation at Lys266 and Lys268, or substitution of the same residues with glutamine (i.e. K266/268Q), a residue that mimics acetylated lysine, enhances the DNA binding activity of ERalpha in EMSAs. Likewise, substitution of Lys266 and Lys268 with glutamine enhances the ligand-dependent activity of ERalpha in a cell-based reporter gene assay. Collectively, our results implicate acetylation as a modulator of the ligand-dependent gene regulatory activity of ERalpha. Such regulation is likely to play a role in estrogen-dependent signaling outcomes in a variety of estrogen target tissues in both normal and pathological states.
The INhibitor of Growth (ING) family of plant homeodomain (PHD) proteins induce apoptosis and regulate gene expression through stress-inducible binding of phospholipids with subsequent nuclear and nucleolar localization. Relocalization occurs concomitantly with interaction with a subset of nuclear proteins, including PCNA, p53 and several regulators of acetylation such as the p300/CBP and PCAF histone acetyltransferases (HATs), as well as the histone deacetylases HDAC1 and hSir2. These interactions alter the localized state of chromatin compaction, subsequently affecting the expression of subsets of genes, including those associated with the stress response (Hsp70), apoptosis (Bax, MDM2) and cell cycle regulation (p21WAF1, cyclin B) in a cell- and tissue-specific manner. The expression levels and subcellular localization of ING proteins are altered in a significant number of human cancer types, while the expression of ING isoforms changes during cellular aging, suggesting that ING proteins may play a role in linking cellular transformation and replicative senescence. The variety of functions attributed to ING proteins suggest that this tumor suppressor serves to link the disparate processes of cell cycle regulation, cell suicide and cellular aging through epigenetic regulation of gene expression. This review examines recent findings in the ING field with a focus on the functions of protein-protein interactions involving ING family members and the mechanisms by which these interactions facilitate the various roles that ING proteins play in tumorigenesis, apoptosis and senescence.
Induction of transcription requires an ordered recruitment of coregulators and specific combinations of histone modifications at the promoter. Occurrence of histone H4 arginine (Arg) 3 methylation by protein arginine methyltransferase 1 (PRMT1) represents an early promoter event in ER (estrogen receptor)-regulated gene activation. However, its in vivo significance in ER signaling and the prerequisites for PRMT1 recruitment to promoters have not been established yet. We show here that endogenous PRMT1 is a crucial and non-redundant coactivator of ER-mediated pS2 gene induction in MCF7 cells. By investigating promoter requirements for PRMT1 recruitment we find that the patient SE translocation (SET) protein, which was reported to protect histone tails from acetylation, associates with the uninduced pS2 gene promoter and dissociates early upon estrogen treatment. Knockdown of SET or trichostatin A (TSA) treatment causes premature acetylation of H4 and abrogation of H4 Arg3 methylation at the pS2 gene promoter resulting in diminished transcriptional induction. Thus, SET prevents promoter acetylation and is a prerequisite for the initial acetylation-sensitive steps of pS2 gene activation, namely PRMT1 function. Similar to pS2 we identify lactoferrin as a PRMT1-dependent and TSA-sensitive ER target gene. In contrast, we find that the C3 gene, another ER target, is activated in a PRMT1-independent manner and that SET is involved in C3 gene repression. These findings establish the existence of PRMT1-dependent and -independent ER target genes and show that proteins guarding promoter hypoacetylation, like SET, execute a key function in the coactivation process by PRMT1.
Steroid hormone receptors (estrogen receptor [ER] and progesterone receptor [PR]) play a critical role in the development of breast cancer. Most importantly, the expression of ER and/or PR by tumor cells provides important information that is critical for the selection of treatment. Recent studies on ER and PR have provided new insights into the pathogenesis of breast cancer and the mechanisms of resistance to antihormonal therapy. Better understanding of steroid receptors, their ligands, and the mechanisms through which they exert their effects will allow the correct treatment to be targeted to responsive tumors.
Here we report a novel potential therapeutic strategy using histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitors to enhance the action of hormonal therapy agents in estrogen receptor alpha (ER alpha)-positive breast cancer. HDAC inhibitors [trichostatin A (TSA), suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA) and valproic acid (VPA)], inhibited proliferation of MCF-7 breast cancer cells and, in combination with tamoxifen inhibited proliferation better than with either agent alone. VPA, an anti-convulsant drug with HDAC inhibitory activity, enhanced tamoxifen action at doses within the concentration range used for anti-convulsive therapy. VPA cooperated with tamoxifen in a variety of ER alpha-positive cell lines and was also effective when combined with other antiestrogens, and with aromatase inhibition. VPA enhanced antiestrogen action by promoting cell death via apoptosis without affecting cell cycling. Some of this action may be due to VPA's ability to induce the pro-apoptotic gene Bik, which is also induced by antiestrogens. Remarkably, VPA blocked the undesirable pro-proliferative action of tamoxifen on uterine endometrial cells. Our in vitro results suggest that VPA and other HDAC inhibitors have the potential to enhance hormonal therapy for ER alpha-positive breast cancer and simultaneously reverse the adverse effects of antiestrogens in the uterus.
The molecular chaperone heat shock protein (hsp)-90 maintains estrogen receptor (ER)-alpha in an active conformation, allowing it to bind 17beta-estradiol (E2) and transactivate genes, including progesterone receptor (PR)-beta and the class IIB histone deacetylase HDAC6. By inhibiting HDAC6, the hydroxamic acid analogue pan-HDAC inhibitors (HA-HDI; e.g., LAQ824, LBH589, and vorinostat) induce hyperacetylation of the HDAC6 substrates alpha-tubulin and hsp90. Hyperacetylation of hsp90 inhibits its chaperone function, thereby depleting hsp90 client proteins. Here, we determined the effect of HA-HDIs on the levels and activity of ERalpha, as well as on the survival of ERalpha-expressing, estrogen-responsive human breast cancer MCF-7 and BT-474 cells.
Following exposure to HA-HDIs, hsp90 binding, polyubiquitylation levels, and transcriptional activity of ERalpha, as well as apoptosis and loss of survival, were determined in MCF-7 and BT-474 cells.
Treatment with HA-HDI induced hsp90 hyperacetylation, decreased its binding to ERalpha, and increased polyubiquitylation and depletion of ERalpha levels. HA-HDI treatment abrogated E2-induced estrogen response element-luciferase expression and attenuated PRbeta and HDAC6 levels. Exposure to HA-HDI also depleted p-Akt, Akt, c-Raf, and phospho-extracellular signal-regulated kinase-1/2 levels, inhibited growth, and sensitized ERalpha-positive breast cancer cells to tamoxifen.
These findings show that treatment with HA-HDI abrogates ERalpha levels and activity and could sensitize ERalpha-positive breast cancers to E2 depletion or ERalpha antagonists.
Trichostatin A (TSA) and 5-Aza 2'deoxycytidine (AZA), two well characterized pharmacologic inhibitors of histone deacetylation and DNA methylation, affect estrogen receptor alpha (ER) levels differently in ER-positive versus ER-negative breast cancer cell lines. Whereas pharmacologic inhibition of these epigenetic mechanisms results in re-expression and increased estrogen receptor alpha (ER) levels in ER-negative cells, treatment in ER-positive MCF7 cells results in decreased ER mRNA and protein levels. This decrease is dependent upon protein interaction with the ER 3'UTR. Actinomycin D studies showed a 37.5% reduction in ER mRNA stability from 4 to 1.5 h in AZA/TSA treated MCF7 cell lines; an effect not seen in 231ER + cells transfected with the ER coding region but lacking incorporation of the 3'UTR. AZA/TSA do not appear to directly interact with the 3'UTR but rather decrease stability through altered subcellular localization of the RNA binding protein, HuR. siRNA inhibition of HuR expression reduces both the steady-state and stability of ER mRNA, suggesting that HuR plays a critical role in the control of ER mRNA stability. Our data suggest that epigenetic modulators can alter stability through modulation of HuR subcellular distribution. Taken together, these data provide a novel anti-estrogenic mechanism for AZA and TSA in ER positive human breast cancer cells.
Anti-estrogens are the current endocrine therapy of choice in the treatment of estrogen receptor (ER)-positive breast cancers. Histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi) also constitute a promising treatment for therapy, and combination of anti-estrogens with HDACi may improve efficacy while reducing side effects. We have examined the effect of the HDACi sodium butyrate and suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA), alone and in combination with 17beta-estradiol (E2) and the pure anti-estrogen ICI 182.780 (ICI) in human MCF-7 breast cancer cells. HDACi caused a sustained increase of histone H3 acetylation and caused cell death as shown by flow cytometry analysis. In surviving cells, both inhibitors were even stronger than ICI in depleting cyclin D1 levels, inducing expression of the cyclin kinase inhibitor p21Waf1/Cip1, blocking phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein, or inhibiting cell growth. No additive effects of ICI with either butyrate or SAHA were found. In addition, these drugs were able to antagonize the effects of E2 on expression of cell cycle proteins, cell growth, and transcription of ER-dependent genes. The anti-estrogenic effects of HDACi appear to be related to a strong downregulation of the expression of ERalpha that appears to be secondary to both transcriptional and post-transcriptional regulation. ERalpha phosphorylation is involved in estrogen signaling, and HDACi also prevented receptor phosphorylation in Ser-118 both in the absence and presence of ER ligands. These results provide further support for the use of deacetylase inhibitors as chemotherapeutic agents in the treatment of breast cancer tumors.
Estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) plays an important role in the development and progression of breast cancer, and recent studies showed that ERalpha expression is associated with resistance to hormonal therapy. Therefore, a number of studies have explored ways to deplete ERalpha from breast cancer cells as a new therapy especially for hormone-refractory breast cancer. We reported here that suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA), a histone deacetylase inhibitor, effectively depletes ERalpha in breast cancer MCF-7 cells. However, the intrinsic mechanisms by which SAHA decreases ERalpha levels are not clear. Our present data demonstrated that both inhibition of ERalpha mRNA level and promotion of ERalpha degradation by the proteasome contribute to SAHA-induced ERalpha depletion, indicating that SAHA may exert its effects through transcriptional and posttranslational mechanisms. Furthermore, the decrease of ERalpha protein level in MCF-7 cells after SAHA treatment is mainly the result of its rapid degradation by the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway rather than transcriptional inhibition. In addition, we showed that inactivation of the heat shock protein-90 (Hsp90) is involved in SAHA-induced ERalpha degradation, and ubiquitin ligase CHIP (C-terminal Hsc70 interacting protein) enhances SAHA-induced ERalpha degradation. SAHA-induced ERalpha depletion is paralleled with reduction of transcriptional activity of ERalpha and SAHA is able to effectively inhibit cell proliferation and induce apoptosis of MCF-7 cells. Taken together, our results revealed a mechanism for SAHA-induced ERalpha degradation and indicated that SAHA is a suitable pharmacological agent for depletion of ERalpha and a potential choice for breast cancer expressing high ERalpha.
Tamoxifen (Tam) decreased the clearance of L-glutamate (L-Glu) by cultured astrocytes at 1 pM, 1 nM, and 1 microM, but became toxic at 10 microM. When L-Glu transporters were mostly inhibited by threo-beta-benzyloxyaspartate (TBOA) (1 mM) or D,L-threo-beta-hydroxyaspartate (THA) (1 mM), Tam (1 nM) did not change extracellular L-Glu concentration, confirming that Tam attenuates L-Glu transport through L-Glu transporters. ICI182,780, LY294002, and U0126 inhibited the effect of Tam dose-dependently, suggesting the involvement of estrogen receptors (ERs), the phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) cascade, and the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) cascade in the effect of Tam.
Steroid receptors are ligand-regulated transcription factors that require coactivators for efficient activation of target gene expression. The binding protein of cAMP response element binding protein (CBP) appears to be a promiscuous coactivator for an increasing number of transcription factors and the ability of CBP to modulate estrogen receptor (ER)- and progesterone receptor (PR)-dependent transcription was therefore examined. Ectopic expression of CBP or the related coactivator, p300, enhanced ER transcriptional activity by up to 10-fold in a receptor- and DNA-dependent manner. Consistent with this, the 12S E1A adenoviral protein, which binds to and inactivates CBP, inhibited ER transcriptional activity, and exogenous CBP was able to partially overcome this effect. Furthermore, CBP was able to partially reverse the ability of active ER to squelch PR-dependent transcription, indicating that CBP is a common coactivator for both receptors and that CBP is limiting within these cells. To date, the only other coactivator able to significantly stimulate receptor-dependent transcription is steroid receptor coactivator-1 (SRC-1). Coexpression of CBP and SRC-1 stimulated ER and PR transcriptional activity in a synergistic manner and indicated that these two coactivators are not functional homologues. Taken together, these data suggest that both CBP and SRC-1 may function in a common pathway to efficiently activate target gene expression.
Repression of transcription by the classical nuclear receptors (e.g. TR, RAR), the orphan nuclear receptors (e.g. Rev-erbA alpha/beta), Mxi-1 and Mad bHLH-zip proteins and the oncoproteins PLZF and LAZ3/BCL6 is mediated by the corepressors N-CoR and SMRT. The interaction of the corepressors with the components involved in chromatin remodelling, such as the recruiting proteins Sin3A/B and the histone deacteylases HDAc-1 and RPD3, has been analysed in detail. The N-CoR/ Sin3/HDAc complexes have a key role in the regulation of cellular proliferation and differentiation. However, the interaction of these corepressors with the basal transcriptional machinery has remained obscure. In this study we demonstrated that the N-terminal repression domains and the receptor interaction domains (RID) of N-CoR and its splice variants, RIP13a and RIP13 Delta 1, directly interact with TAF(II)32 in vivo and in vitro. We show that interaction domain II within the N-CoR and RIP13a RID is required for the interaction with TAF(II)32. We also observed that N-CoR directly interacts with each of the basal factors, TFIIB and TAF(II)70, and can simultaneously interact with all three basal factors in a non-competitive manner. Furthermore, we provide evidence that suggests the RVR/Rev-erb beta-corepressor complex also interacts with the general transcriptional machinery, and that the physical association of TFIIB with N-CoR also occurs in the presence of Sin3B and HDAc-1. Interestingly, we observed that N-CoR expression ablated the functional interaction between TFIIB and TAF(II)32 that is critical to the initiation of transcription. In conclusion, this study demonstrates that the N-terminal repressor region and the C-terminal RIDs are part of the corepressor contact interface that mediates the interaction with the general transcription factors, and demonstrates that TAFs can also directly interact with corepressors to mediate signals from repressors to the basal machinery. We also suggest that N-CoR interacts with the central components of the transcriptional initiation process (TFIIB, TAFs) and locks them into a non-functional complex or conformation that is not conducive to transcription.
The tumor suppressor p53 is activated in response to many types of cellular and environmental insults via mechanisms involving post-translational modification. Here we demonstrate that, unlike phosphorylation, p53 invariably undergoes acetylation in cells exposed to a variety of stress-inducing agents including hypoxia, anti-metabolites, nuclear export inhibitor and actinomycin D treatment. In vivo, p53 acetylation is mediated by the p300 and CBP acetyltransferases. Overexpression of either p300 or CBP, but not an acetyltransferase-deficient mutant, efficiently induces specific p53 acetylation. In contrast, MDM2, a negative regulator of p53, actively suppresses p300/CBP-mediated p53 acetylation in vivo and in vitro. This inhibitory activity of MDM2 on p53 acetylation is in turn abrogated by tumor suppressor p19ARF, indicating that regulation of acetylation is a central target of the p53–MDM2–p19ARF feedback loop. Functionally, inhibition of deacetylation promotes p53 stability, suggesting that acetylation plays a positive role in the accumulation of p53 protein in stress response. Our results provide evidence that p300/CBP-mediated acetylation may be a universal and critical modifi cation for p53 function.
Regulation of nuclear receptor gene expression involves dynamic and coordinated interactions with histone acetyl transferase
(HAT) and deacetylase complexes. The estrogen receptor (ERα) contains two transactivation domains regulating ligand-independent
and -dependent gene transcription (AF-1 and AF-2 (activation functions 1 and 2)). ERα-regulated gene expression involves interactions
with cointegrators (e.g.p300/CBP, P/CAF) that have the capacity to modify core histone acetyl groups. Here we show that the ERα is acetylated in vivo.p300, but not P/CAF, selectively and directly acetylated the ERα at lysine residues within the ERα hinge/ligand binding domain.
Substitution of these residues with charged or polar residues dramatically enhanced ERα hormone sensitivity without affecting
induction by MAPK signaling, suggesting that direct ERα acetylation normally suppresses ligand sensitivity. These ERα lysine
residues also regulated transcriptional activation by histone deacetylase inhibitors and p300. The conservation of the ERα
acetylation motif in a phylogenetic subset of nuclear receptors suggests that direct acetylation of nuclear receptors may
contribute to additional signaling pathways involved in metabolism and development.
The androgen receptor (AR) is a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein that plays a key role in prostate cancer cellular proliferation
by dihydrotestosterone and the induction of secondary sexual characteristics. In this study we demonstrate that the AR can
be modified by acetylation in vitro and in vivo. p300 and p300/cAMP-response element-binding protein acetylated the AR at a highly conserved lysine-rich motif carboxyl-terminal
to the zinc finger DNA-binding domain. [14C]acetate-labeling experiments demonstrated that AR acetylation by p300 in cultured cells requires the same residues identified
in vitro. Point mutation of the AR acetylation site (K632A/K633A) abrogated dihydrotestosterone-dependent transactivation of the AR
in cultured cells. Mutation of the p300 CH3 region or the p300/cAMP-response element-binding protein histone acetylase domain
reduced ligand-dependent AR function. The identification of the AR as a direct target of histone acetyltransferase co-activators
has important implications for targeting inhibitors of AR function.
Estrogen receptor (ER) binding has been shown to decrease in breast cancer cell lines exposed to sodium butyrate; however, the underlying mechanisms are unknown. In MCF-7 breast cancer cells, butyrate caused a rapid time- and concentration-dependent decrease in ER mRNA levels, apparent by 3 h at 3 mM butyrate. ER gene transcription rate was decreased and cycloheximide co-treatment did not relieve this inhibitory effect, suggesting that the butyrate effect was not dependent on ongoing protein synthesis. In both MCF-7 and T-47D cells the decrease in ER mRNA was mirrored by an increase in the level of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGF-R) mRNA. A marked inverse relationship exists between ER and EGF-R in human breast cancer biopsies and cell lines, and the reciprocal modulation of these genes by butyrate suggests that the expression of ER and EGF-R may be co-regulated. This relationship was further investigated in lines expressing only one or the other receptor. In the ER-positive EGF-R-negative line, MDA-MB-134-VI, butyrate exposure decreased ER mRNA levels, implying that the regulation of ER mRNA by butyrate is independent of EGF-R expression. However, butyrate decreased EGF-R mRNA in two ER-negative lines, MDA-MB-231 and HBL-100. As this effect differed from that in ER-positive lines, the regulation of EGF-R may depend on the expression of ER. The possibility that ER and EGF-R gene expression are closely linked has implications in the understanding of progression of human breast cancers to a hormone-independent phenotype and for the use of ER and EGF-R levels as independent prognostic indicators.
Forty-three patients with large (greater than or equal to 4 cm) but operable carcinoma of the breast have been treated by endocrine manipulation before definitive local surgery. This has allowed the study of the relationship between response to therapy and pretreatment oestrogen receptor (ER) concentration, as measured by a dextran-coated charcoal adsorption method. Premenopausal patients (17) were treated by surgical (4) or medical (13) oophorectomy. Post-menopausal patients (26) received either tamoxifen (10) or an aromatase inhibitor (16). Response was assessed from statistical analysis of the changes in tumour size. On completion of 12 weeks of endocrine therapy, there was significant regression of tumour size in 18 of the 43 patients. All 18 patients had tumours with ER concentrations of greater than or equal to 20 fmol mg-1 cytosol protein. Conversely all patients except one progressing on treatment had tumours with ER concentrations of less than 20 fmol mg-1 cytosol protein. This relationship applied for both premenopausal and post-menopausal patients. The overall response rate of patients with tumours of ER concentration greater than or equal to 20 fmol mg-1 cytosol protein was 60%.
ER content of primary tumour tissue has been examined in 704 patients presenting with operable breast cancer. The median follow-up is now 84 months and no patient has received adjuvant therapy of any kind. ER status is related to histological grade, menopausal status, initial site of metastases and subsequent response to endocrine therapy. A significant advantage in terms of survival is found in ER positive patients which is confined to those lymph node positive at mastectomy. DFI is also significantly related to ER status in lymph node positive patients. Survival after the symptomatic presentation of metastases and the institution of endocrine therapy is prolonged in patients with ER positive tumours. The overall response rate to endocrine therapy in assessable patients with ER positive tumours is 32%. By combining the ER status and histological grade of tumour tissue, a group of patients comprising 28% of those assessable to endocrine therapy can be identified (ER positive, grade I and II) with a response rate of 46%.
We have used a series of human estrogen receptor (ER) mutants to evaluate the cell- and promoter-specific transcriptional activities of the TAF1 and TAF2 transactivation regions within the human ER. We show that the manifestation of TAF1 or TAF2 function depends strongly upon promoter context; on certain promoters, both the TAF1 and TAF2 activators are required for wild-type transcriptional activity, whereas on other promoters, the TAF1 and TAF2 activators function independently. Using these constructs, we show that the antagonist activity of the triphenylethylene-derived antiestrogens, e.g. tamoxifen, arises from their intrinsic inability to activate ER TAF2 function. However, on certain promoters, these antiestrogens efficiently activate gene transcription through ER. Consistent with this observation, the TAF2 function of the ER is not required on all promoters. In these TAF2-independent promoter contexts, TAF2 function may be provided by a separate transcription factor bound to the promoter. These data suggest that 1) TAF1 may be the major transcriptional activator of the ER; and 2) TAF2 functions as a transcriptional facilitator. On promoters where TAF2 function is provided independently of the ER, the TAF1 function of the ER can function independently of TAF2 activity, allowing triphenylethylene-derived antiestrogens to demonstrate partial agonist activity. These observations provide a possible molecular explanation for the tissue-specific partial agonist properties of tamoxifen and related triphenylethylene antiestrogens observed in vivo.
Nucleosome ordering on a variety of replicating plasmids, assembled into chromatin in transfected COS-1 cells, was studied by micrococcal nuclease digestion of isolated nuclei. Generally, no more than three well defined multiples of a unit nucleosome repeat, which resembled the first three bands of the (187 +/- 5 base pair (bp)) cellular chromatin ladder, could be detected in constructs that contained a near-minimal SV40 replication origin. In contrast, constructs that additionally contained the SV40 early region exhibited significantly more regular nucleosome arrangements. In some cases, eight to nine multiples of a 203 +/- 5-bp repeat could be resolved. The presence of the SV40 early region was necessary for physiological nucleosome alignment over the SV40 late and ori regions, or onto adjacent pBR327 DNA. In an in vitro chromatin assembly system, using purified chicken erythrocyte histones plus polyglutamic acid, a portion of SV40 DNA became packaged into a highly ordered 200 +/- 5-bp nucleosome array, which encompassed the early region and extended for about 2800 bp. The data suggest that in the cell nucleus, nucleosome ordering on SV40 DNA might spread from sequences in the early region, close to where transcription terminates, probably as a consequence of histone H1-nucleosome interactions.
The mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter is regulated by steroid hormones through a hormone-responsive region that is organized in a positioned nucleosome. Hormone induction leads to a structural change of this nucleosome which makes its DNA more sensitive to cleavage by DNase I and enables simultaneous binding of all relevant transcription factors. In cells carrying either episomal or chromosomally integrated MMTV promoters, moderate acetylation of core histones, generated by treatment with low concentrations of the histone deacetylase inhibitors sodium butyrate or trichostatin A, enhances transcription from the MMTV promoter in the absence of hormone and potentiates transactivation by either glucocorticoids or progestins. At higher concentrations, histone deacetylase inhibitors reduce basal and hormone induced MMTV transcription. Inducing inhibitor concentrations lead to the same type of nucleosomal DNase I hypersensitivity as hormone treatment, suggesting that moderate acetylation of core histone activates the MMTV promoter by mechanisms involving chromatin remodeling similar to that generated by the inducing hormones.
Steroid receptor antagonists, such as the antiestrogen tamoxifen or the antiprogestin RU486, can have inappropriate agonist-like effects in tissues and tumors. To explain this paradox we postulated that coactivators are inadvertently brought to the promoters of DNA-bound, antagonist-occupied receptors. The human (h) progesterone receptor (PR) hinge-hormone binding domain (H-HBD) was used as bait in a two-hybrid screen of a HeLa cDNA library, in which the yeast cells were treated with RU486. We have isolated and characterized two interesting steroid receptor-interacting proteins that regulate transcription in opposite directions. The first is L7/SPA, a previously described 27-kDa protein containing a basic region leucine zipper domain, having no known nuclear function. When coexpressed with tamoxifen-occupied estrogen receptors (hER) or RU486-occupied hPR or glucocorticoid receptors (hGR), L7/SPA increases the partial agonist activity of the antagonists by 3- to 10-fold, but it has no effect on agonist-mediated transcription. The interaction of L7/SPA with hPR maps to the hinge region, and indeed, the hPR hinge region squelches L7/SPA-dependent induction of antagonist-mediated transcription. Interestingly, pure antagonists that lack partial agonist effects, such as the antiestrogen ICI164,384 or the antiprogestin ZK98299, cannot be up-regulated by L7/SPA. We also isolated, cloned, and sequenced the human homolog (hN-CoR) of the 270-kDa mouse (m) thyroid/retinoic acid receptor corepressor. Binding of hN-CoR maps to the hPR-HBD. mN-CoR, and a related human corepressor, SMRT, suppress RU486 or tamoxifen-mediated partial agonist activity by more than 90%. This suppression is completely squelched by overexpression of the hPR H-HBD. Additionally, both corepressors reverse the antagonist-dependent transcriptional up-regulation produced by L7/SPA. Our data suggest that the direction of transcription by antagonist-occupied steroid receptors can be controlled by the ratio of coactivators to corepressors recruited to the transcription complex by promoter-bound receptors. In normal tissues and in hormone-resistant breast cancers in which the agonist activity of mixed antagonists predominates, steroid receptors may be preferentially bound by coactivators. This suggests a strategy by which such partial agonist activity can be eliminated and by which candidate receptor ligands can be screened for this activity.
Histone acetylation is thought to have a role in transcription. To gain insight into the role of histone acetylation in retinoid-dependent transcription, we studied the effects of trichostatin A (TSA), a specific inhibitor of histone deacetylase, on P19 embryonal carcinoma cells. We show that coaddition of TSA and retinoic acid (RA) markedly enhances neuronal differentiation in these cells, although TSA alone does not induce differentiation but causes extensive apoptosis. Consistent with the cooperative effect of TSA and RA, coaddition of the two agents synergistically enhanced transcription from stably integrated RA-responsive promoters. The transcriptional synergy by TSA and RA required the RA-responsive element and a functional retinoid X receptor (RXR)/retinoic acid receptor (RAR) heterodimer, both obligatory for RA-dependent transcription. Furthermore, TSA led to promoter activation by an RXR-selective ligand that was otherwise inactive in transcription. In addition, TSA enhanced transcription from a minimum basal promoter, independently of the RA-responsive element. Finally, we show that TSA alone or in combination with RA increases in vivo endonuclease sensitivity within the RA-responsive promoter, suggesting that TSA treatment might alter a local chromatin environment to enhance RXR/RAR heterodimer action. Thus, these results indicate that histone acetylation influences activity of the heterodimer, which is in line with the observed interaction between the RXR/RAR heterodimer and a histone acetylase presented elsewhere.
Anti-estrogens like hydroxytamoxifen (OHT) have mixed agonist/antagonist activities, leading to tissue-specific stimulation of cellular proliferation. Partial agonist activity of OHT can be observed in vitro in endometrial carcinoma cells like Ishikawa. Here, we have compared several anti-estrogens (including extensively characterized OHT and pure anti-estrogens such as ICI164, 384 and RU58,668, which are devoid of uterotrophic activity) for their capacity to stimulate promoters containing estrogen response elements (EREs) or AP1-binding sites (12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate response elements, TREs), the two types of DNA motifs known to mediate transcriptional stimulation by estrogen receptors. Assays were performed in Ishikawa cells either by transient transfection or by using cell lines with stably propagated reporter vectors. In transient transfection experiments, none of the anti-estrogens displayed agonist activity on the promoters tested. In contrast, significant transcriptional stimulation was observed with low concentrations of OHT and RU39,411 in Ishikawa cells stably propagating reporter constructs containing a minimal ERE3-TATA promoter. In addition, micromolar concentrations of OHT, but not of RU39,411, stimulated stably propagated AP1-responsive reporter constructs. No transcriptional stimulation of ERE- or TRE-containing promoters was observed with the pure anti-estrogens ICI164,384 and RU58,668. These results indicate that the presence of estrogen response elements in promoters is sufficient to mediate cell-specific agonism of anti-estrogens at the transcriptional level, and that stimulation of AP1 activity may be restricted to a subset of anti-estrogens possessing agonist activity on EREs. In addition, our results suggest that transient transfections do not fully recapitulate in vivo conditions required to observe agonist activity of anti-estrogens.
The p160 family of coactivators, SRC-1, GRIP1/TIF2, and p/CIP, mediate transcriptional activation by nuclear hormone receptors. Coactivator-associated arginine methyltransferase 1 (CARM1), a previously unidentified protein that binds to the carboxyl-terminal region of p160 coactivators, enhanced transcriptional activation by nuclear receptors, but only when GRIP1 or SRC-1a was coexpressed. Thus, CARM1 functions as a secondary coactivator through its association with p160 coactivators. CARM1 can methylate histone H3 in vitro, and a mutation in the putative S-adenosylmethionine binding domain of CARM1 substantially reduced both methyltransferase and coactivator activities. Thus, coactivator-mediated methylation of proteins in the transcription machinery may contribute to transcriptional regulation.
Transcriptional repression mediated by corepressors N-CoR and SMRT is a critical function of nuclear hormone receptors, and is dysregulated in human myeloid leukemias. At the present time, these corepressors are thought to act exclusively through an mSin3/HDAC1 complex. Surprisingly, however, numerous biochemical studies have not detected N-CoR or SMRT in mSin3- and HDAC1-containing complexes. Each corepressor contains multiple repression domains (RDs), the significance of which is unknown. Here we show that these RDs are nonredundant, and that one RD, which is conserved in N-CoR and SMRT, represses transcription by interacting directly with class II HDAC4 and HDAC5. Endogenous N-CoR and SMRT each associate with HDAC4 in a complex that does not contain mSin3A or HDAC1. This is the first example of a single corepressor utilizing distinct domains to engage multiple HDAC complexes. The alternative HDAC complexes may mediate specific repression pathways in normal as well as leukemic cells.
The human estrogen receptor alpha-isoform (ERalpha) is a nuclear transcription factor that displays a complex pharmacology. In addition to classical agonists and antagonists, the transcriptional activity of ERalpha can be regulated by selective estrogen receptor modulators, a new class of drugs whose relative agonist/antagonist activity is determined by cell context. It has been demonstrated that the binding of different ligands to ERalpha results in the formation of unique ERalpha-ligand conformations. These conformations have been shown to influence ERalpha-cofactor binding and, therefore, have a profound impact on ERalpha pharmacology. In this study, we demonstrate that the nature of the bound ligand also influences the stability of ERalpha, revealing an additional mechanism by which the pharmacological activity of a compound is determined. Of note we found that although all ERalpha-ligand complexes can be ubiquitinated and degraded by the 26 S proteasome in vivo, the mechanisms by which they are targeted for proteolysis appear to be different. Specifically, for agonist-activated ERalpha, an inverse relationship between transcriptional activity and receptor stability was observed. This relationship does not extend to selective estrogen receptor modulators and pure antagonists. Instead, it appears that with these compounds, the determinant of receptor stability is the ligand-induced conformation of ERalpha. We conclude that the different conformational states adopted by ERalpha in the presence of different ligands influence transcriptional activity directly by regulating cofactor binding and indirectly by modulating receptor stability.
Activated estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) modulates transcription triggered by the transcription factor activator protein-1 (AP-1), which consists of Jun-Jun homodimers and Jun-Fos heterodimers. Previous studies have demonstrated that the interference occurs without binding of ERalpha to DNA but probably results from protein.protein interactions. However, involvement of a direct interaction between ERalpha and AP-1 is still debated. Using glutathione S-transferase pull-down assays, we demonstrated that ERalpha bound directly to c-Jun and JunB but not to FOS family members, in a ligand-independent manner. The interaction could occur when c-Jun was bound onto DNA, as shown in a protein-protein-DNA assay. It implicated the C-terminal part of c-Jun and amino acids 259-302 present in the ERalpha hinge domain. ERalpha but not an ERalpha mutant deleted of amino acids 250-303 (ER241G), also associated with c-Jun in intact cells, in the presence of estradiol, as shown by two-hybrid and coimmunoprecipitation assays. We also show that ERalpha, c-Jun, and the p160 coactivator GRIP1 can form a multiprotein complex in vitro and in intact cells and that the ERalpha.c-Jun interaction could be crucial for the stability of this complex. VP16-ERalpha and c-Jun, which both interact with GRIP1, had synergistic effect on GAL4-GRIP1-induced transcription in the presence of estradiol, and this synergistic effect was not observed with the ERalpha mutant VP16-ER241G or when c-Fos, which bound GRIP1 but not ERalpha, was used instead of c-Jun. Finally, ER241G was inefficient for regulation of AP-1 activity, and an ERalpha truncation mutant encompassing the hinge domain had a dominant negative effect on ERalpha action. These results altogether demonstrate that ERalpha can bind to c-Jun in vitro and in intact cells and that this interaction, by stabilizing a multiprotein complex containing p160 coactivator, is likely to be involved in estradiol regulation of AP-1 responses.
Steroidogenic factor-1 (SF-1) is an orphan nuclear receptor that plays an essential role in the development of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis in both sexes. SF-1 belongs to the hormone nuclear receptor superfamily and possesses an N-terminal DNA binding domain and a C-terminal ligand binding domain. Activation function domain 2 is located C-terminal of the ligand binding domain of SF-1 and is important for the transactivation of target genes. Coactivators with histone acetyltransferase activity such as cAMP response element-binding protein-binding protein and steroid receptor coactivator 1 interact and increase SF-1-mediated transcriptional activity. In this study we demonstrate that SF-1 is acetylated in vivo. Histone acetyltransferase GCN5 acetylates SF-1 in vitro. Moreover, we found that SF-1 recruited a novel coactivator GCN5, which can be a newly identified coactivator for SF-1. Acetylation of SF-1 stimulates its transcriptional activity. Inhibition of deacetylation by trichostatin A, a histone deacetylase inhibitor, increased SF-1-mediated transactivation and stabilized and induced the nuclear export of the SF-1 protein.
CtBP (carboxyl-terminal binding protein) participates in regulating cellular development and differentiation by associating
with a diverse array of transcriptional repressors. Most of these interactions occur through a consensus CtBP-binding motif,
PXDLS, in the repressor proteins. We previously showed that the CtBP-binding motif in E1A is flanked by a Lys residue and
suggested that acetylation of this residue by the p300/CBP-associated factor P/CAF disrupts the CtBP interaction. In this
study, we show that the interaction between CtBP and the nuclear hormone receptor corepressor RIP140 is regulated similarly,
in this case by p300/CBP itself. CtBP was shown to interact with RIP140 in vitro and in vivo through a sequence, PIDLSCK,
in the amino-terminal third of the RIP140 protein. Acetylation of the Lys residue in this motif, demonstrated in vivo by using
an acetylated RIP140-specific antibody, dramatically reduced CtBP binding. Mutation of the Lys residue to Gln resulted in
a decrease in CtBP binding in vivo and a loss of transcriptional repression. We suggest that p300/CBP-mediated acetylation
disrupts the RIP140-CtBP complex and derepresses nuclear hormone receptor-regulated genes. Disruption of repressor-CtBP interactions
by acetylation may be a general mode of gene activation.
Post-translational modifications of histones play an important role in modulating gene transcription within chromatin. We used the mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter, which adopts an ordered nucleosomal structure, to investigate the impact of a specific inhibitor of histone deacetylase, trichostatin A (TSA), on progesterone receptor-activated transcription. TSA induced global histone hyperacetylation, and this effect occurred independently of the presence of hormone. Interestingly, chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis revealed no significant change in the level of acetylated histones associated with the MMTV promoter following high TSA treatment. In human breast cancer cells, in which the MMTV promoter adopts a constitutively "open" chromatin structure, treatment with TSA converted the MMTV promoter into a closed structure. Addition of hormone did not overcome this TSA-induced closure of the promoter chromatin. Furthermore, TSA treatment resulted in the eviction of the transcription factor nuclear factor-1 from the promoter and reduced progesterone receptor-induced transcription. Kinetic experiments revealed that a loss of chromatin-remodeling proteins was coincident with the decrease in MMTV transcriptional activity and the imposition of repressed chromatin architecture at the promoter. These results demonstrate that deacetylase inhibitor treatment at levels that induce global histone acetylation may leave specific regulatory regions relatively unaffected and that this treatment may lead to transcriptional inhibition by mechanisms that modify chromatin-remodeling proteins rather than by influencing histone acetylation of the local promoter chromatin structure.
Selective receptor modulators, such as the antiprogestin RU486, are known to exhibit partial agonist activities in a cell-type-dependent manner. Employing an in vitro chromatin transcription system that recapitulates progesterone receptor (PR)-mediated transcription in vivo, we have investigated the molecular basis by which the antiprogestin RU486 regulates transcription in a cell-type-specific manner. We have compared the effects of RU486 on PR-dependent transcription in vitro using T47D and HeLa cell nuclear extracts. RU486 exhibits a differential ability to activate transcription within these two cell types. The differential effect on transcription correlates with different ratios of endogenous coactivators/corepressors in these cells. Unlike agonist-bound PR that interacts only with coactivators such as steroid receptor coactivator-1 (SRC-1), RU486-bound PR binds to both coactivator SRC-1 and corepressor silencing mediator for retinoid and thyroid hormone receptor (SMRT) in vitro. Both SRC-1 and SMRT have the capacity to modulate RU486-dependent activity. Moreover, a change in the relative levels of SRC-1 and SMRT contained in our chromatin transcription system modulates agonist/antagonist effects of RU486 on transcription by PR. Our data indicate that the ability of RU486 to activate transcription is modulated by the ratio of coactivators to corepressors and substantiate the important roles of coregulators in the regulation of steroid receptor mediated transactivation in response to selective receptor modulators.
Several lines of evidence indicate that the nuclear receptor corepressor (N-CoR) complex imposes ligand dependence on transcriptional
activation by the retinoic acid receptor and mediates the inhibitory effects of estrogen receptor antagonists, such as tamoxifen,
suppressing a constitutive N-terminal, Creb-binding protein/coactivator complex-dependent activation domain. Functional interactions
between specific receptors and N-CoR or SMRT corepressor complexes are regulated, positively or negatively, by diverse signal
transduction pathways. Decreased levels of N-CoR correlate with the acquisition of tamoxifen resistance in a mouse model system
for human breast cancer. Our data suggest that N-CoR- and SMRT-containing complexes act as rate-limiting components in the
actions of specific nuclear receptors, and that their actions are regulated by multiple signal transduction pathways.
Here we report the use of fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) to examine the intranuclear dynamics of fluorescent oestrogen receptor- (ER). After bleaching, unliganded ER exhibits high mobility (recovery t1/2 < 1 s). Agonist (oestradiol; E2) or partial antagonist (4-hydroxytamoxifen) slows ER recovery (t1/2 5–6 s), whereas the pure antagonist (ICI 182,780) and, surprisingly, proteasome inhibitors each immobilize ER to the nuclear matrix. Dual FRAP experiments show that fluorescent ER and SRC-1 exhibit similar dynamics only in the presence of E2. In contrast to reports that several nuclear proteins show uniform dynamics, ER exhibits differential mobility depending upon several factors that are linked to its transcription function.
Screening for microbial metabolites that induce transcriptional activation of the SV40 promoter resulted in the identification of two known compounds, FR901228 and trichostatin A (TSA). FR901228 is a potent antitumor drug that is currently under clinical investigation. TSA is a specific inhibitor of histone deacetylase. Despite structural unrelatedness, both FR901228 and TSA greatly enhanced the transcriptional activity of the SV40 promoter in an enhancer-dependent manner. The effects of FR901228 on the cell cycle, chromatin structure, and histone acetylation were examined and compared with those of TSA. Both compounds caused arrest of the cell cycle at both G1and G2/M phases and induction of internucleosomal breakdown of chromatin. FR901228, like TSA, inhibited intracellular histone deacetylase activity, as a result of which marked amounts of acetylated histone species accumulated. FR901228 is therefore a new type of histone deacetylase inhibitor, whose chemical structure is unrelated to known inhibitors such as trichostatins and trapoxins.
The functional interplay between different domains of estrogen receptor-alpha (ERalpha, NR3A1) is responsible for the overall properties of the full-length protein. We previously identified an interaction between the N-terminal A and C-terminal domains, which we demonstrate here to repress ligand-independent transactivation and transrepression abilities of ERalpha. Using targeted mutations based on ERalpha structural models, we determine the basis for this interaction that defines a regulatory interplay between ERalpha A domain, corepressors, and ERalpha Helix 12 for binding to the same C-terminal surface. We propose a dynamic model where binding of different ligands influences the A/D-F domain interaction and results in specific functional outcomes. This model gives insights into the dynamic properties of full-length ERalpha and into the structure of unliganded ERalpha.
Synthetic steroid hormone antagonists are clinically important compounds that regulate physiological responses to steroid hormones. The antagonists bind to the hormone receptors, which are ligand-inducible transcription factors, and modulate their gene-regulatory activities. In most instances, a steroid receptor, such as progesterone receptor (PR) or estrogen receptor (ER), is transcriptionally inactive when complexed with an antagonist and competitively inhibits transactivation of a target steroid-responsive gene by the cognate hormone-occupied receptor. In certain cellular and promoter contexts, however, antagonist-occupied PR or ER acquires paradoxical agonist-like activity. The cellular mechanisms that determine the switch from the negative to the positive mode of transcriptional regulation by an antagonist-bound steroid receptor are unknown. We now provide strong evidence supporting the existence of a cellular inhibitory cofactor that interacts with the B form of human PR (PR-B) complexed with the antiprogestin RU486 to maintain it in a transcriptionally inactive state. In the presence of unliganded thyroid hormone receptor (TR) or ER complexed with the antiestrogen 4-hydroxytamoxifen, which presumably sequesters a limiting pool of the inhibitory cofactor, RU486-PR-B functions as a transcriptional activator of a progesterone-responsive gene even in the absence of hormone agonist. In contrast, hormone-occupied TR or ER fails to induce transactivation by RU486-PR-B. Recent studies revealed that a transcriptional corepressor, NCoR (nuclear receptor corepressor), interacts with unliganded TR but not with liganded TR. Interestingly, coexpression of NCoR efficiently suppresses the partial agonistic activity of antagonist-occupied PR-B but fails to affect transactivation by agonist-bound PR-B. We further demonstrate that RU486-PR-B interacts physically with NCoR in vitro. These novel observations suggest that the inhibitory cofactor that associates with RU486-PR-B and represses its transcriptional activity is either identical or structurally related to the corepressor NCoR. We propose that cellular mechanisms that determine the switch from the antagonistic to the agonistic activity of RU486-PR-B involve removal of the corepressor from the antagonist-bound receptor so that it can effect partial but significant gene activation.
ASTRACT
The effect of two anti-oestrogens, 4-OH tamoxifen and ICI 164,384, on growth and progesterone receptor (PR) concentration was investigated in the endometrial carcinoma cell line, Ishikawa. Growth stimulation in response to 4-OH tamoxifen was antagonized by ICI 164,384, the latter having no agonist effect when used as a single agent. Similarly, ICI 164,384 antagonized oestradiol-stimulated cell growth. PR was significantly increased following treatment with 4-OH tamoxifen, this response being antagonized in the presence of ICI 164,384. Oestradiol increased PR, although to a lesser extent than did 4-OH tamoxifen;the effect of oestradiol on PR was also antagonized by ICI 164,384. Used as a single agent, ICI 164,384 induced a moderate but statistically significant increase in PR, thus demonstrating partial agonist activity. This agonist property of ICI 164,384 may provide a mechanism of maintaining PR, which is down-regulated during conventional progestin therapy, without undesirable mitogenic activity.
Nuclear receptors regulate gene expression by direct activation of target genes and inhibition of AP-1. Here we report that, unexpectedly, activation by nuclear receptors requires the actions of CREB-binding protein (CBP) and that inhibition of AP-1 activity is the apparent result of competition for limiting amounts of CBP/p300 in cells. Utilizing distinct domains, CBP directly interacts with the ligand-binding domain of multiple nuclear receptors and with the p160 nuclear receptor coactivators, which upon cloning have proven to be variants of the SRC-1 protein. Because CBP represents a common factor, required in addition to distinct coactivators for function of nuclear receptors, CREB, and AP-1, we suggest that CBP/p300 serves as an integrator of multiple signal transduction pathways within the nucleus.
In order to characterize the estrogenic activity of chemicals, we established complementary in vitro recombinant receptor-reporter gene assays in stably transfected MCF-7 and HeLa cells. MCF-7 cells which express the endogenous estrogen receptor alpha (ER alpha) were stably transfected with only an estrogen-regulated luciferase gene. These cells enable the detection of compounds which bind to ER alpha or interfere with the induction of ER alpha mediated gene expression. Furthermore, HeLa cells, which do not express endogenous ERs, were transfected with an ER alpha or an ER beta construct together with an estrogen-regulated luciferase gene, or a chimeric GAL4-ER alpha receptor and the corresponding luciferase reporter gene. Finally, we tested these four cellular models as tools to check the estrogenic activities of several potential xenoestrogens and to detect estrogenic activity in wastewater sewage treatment effluents. In all of the models, nonylphenol mixture (NPm), 4n-nonylphenol (4nNP), 2,4'-DDE, 4,4'-DDE and wastewater sewage treatment effluent were active, while PCB mixture (Aroclor 1254), PCB 77, atrazine and lindane (gamma hexachlorocyclohexane) were inactive. Dioxin partially activates the estrogen receptor in MCF-7 cells while in HeLa-derived cell lines, it decreased the estrogenic-induced expression of luciferase.
Nuclear hormone receptors are ligand-dependent transcription factors that regulate genes critical to such biological processes as development, reproduction, and homeostasis. Interestingly, these receptors can function as molecular switches, alternating between states of transcriptional repression and activation, depending on the absence or presence of cognate hormone, respectively. In the absence of hormone, several nuclear receptors actively repress transcription of target genes via interactions with the nuclear receptor corepressors SMRT and NCoR. Upon binding of hormone, these corepressors dissociate away from the DNA-bound receptor, which subsequently recruits a nuclear receptor coactivator (NCoA) complex. Prominent among these coactivators is the SRC (steroid receptor coactivator) family, which consists of SRC-1, TIF2/GRIP1, and RAC3/ACTR/pCIP/AIB-1. These cofactors interact with nuclear receptors in a ligand-dependent manner and enhance transcriptional activation by the receptor via histone acetylation/methylation and recruitment of additional cofactors such as CBP/p300. This review focuses on the mechanism of action of SRC coactivators in terms of interactions with receptors and activation of transcription. Specifically, the roles of the highly conserved LXXLL motifs in mediating SRC function will be detailed. Additionally, potential diversity among SRC family members, as well as several recently cloned SRC-associated cofactors, will be discussed.
To compare the role of histone deactylation in estrogen activation of a transiently transfected vitellogenin (VIT) promoter and an integrated VIT promoter in the same cells, we produced three HepG2, human hepatoma, cell lines (HepG2ERV cells) stably expressing human estrogen receptor alpha (hERalpha) and containing an integrated VIT promoter-chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (VIT-CAT) reporter gene. The three ER-positive HepG2ERV cell lines and wild-type, ER-negative, HepG2 cells cotransfected with cytomegalovirus-hERalpha exhibited similar MOX-dependent inductions of 20- to 50-fold with a transiently transfected VIT-luciferase reporter and 15- to 50-fold with a transfected 4-estrogen response element-TATA-luciferase reporter gene. The histone deacetylase inhibitor, trichostatin A, did not enhance MOX induction of the transiently transfected VIT promoter in the HepG2ERV cells. In contrast, trichostatin A dramatically potentiated MOX induction of the stably integrated VIT-CAT reporter gene, resulting in MOX-ER-dependent increases in CAT activity of up to 600-fold. These data demonstrate that although liganded ER exhibits the capacity to fully activate a transiently transfected VIT promoter, under some circumstances the ability to reorganize a repressive chromatin structure may be limiting for steroid receptor action.
Nuclear receptors are members of a large family of ligand-inducible transcription factors that regulate gene programs underlying a plethora of (patho)physiological phenomena. The recent determination of the crystal structures of nuclear receptor ligand-binding domains has provided an extremely detailed insight into the intra- and intermolecular mechanisms that constitute the initial events of receptor activation and signal transduction. Here, a comprehensive mechanistic view of agonist and antagonist action will be presented. Furthermore, the novel class of partial agonists-antagonists will be described and the multiple challenges and novel perspectives for nuclear-receptor-based drug design will be discussed.
Many cofactors bind the hormone-activated estrogen receptor (ER), yet the specific regulators of endogenous ER-mediated gene transcription are unknown. Using chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP), we find that ER and a number of coactivators rapidly associate with estrogen responsive promoters following estrogen treatment in a cyclic fashion that is not predicted by current models of hormone activation. Cycles of ER complex assembly are followed by transcription. In contrast, the anti-estrogen tamoxifen (TAM) recruits corepressors but not coactivators. Using a genetic approach, we show that recruitment of the p160 class of coactivators is sufficient for gene activation and for the growth stimulatory actions of estrogen in breast cancer supporting a model in which ER cofactors play unique roles in estrogen signaling.
Estrogens exert their effects on target tissues by binding to a nuclear transcription factor termed the estrogen receptor (ER). Previous structural studies have demonstrated that each class of ER ligand (agonist, partial agonist, and SERM antagonist) induces distinctive orientations in the receptor's carboxy-terminal transactivation helix. The conformation of this portion of the receptor determines whether ER can recruit and interact with the components of the transcriptional machinery, thereby facilitating target gene expression.
We have determined the structure of rat ERbeta ligand binding domain (LBD) in complex with the pure antiestrogen ICI 164,384 at 2.3 A resolution. The binding of this compound to the receptor completely abolishes the association between the transactivation helix (H12) and the rest of the LBD. The structure reveals that the terminal portion of ICI's bulky side chain substituent protrudes from the hormone binding pocket, binds along the coactivator recruitment site, and physically prevents H12 from adopting either its characteristic agonist or AF2 antagonist orientation.
The binding mode adopted by the pure antiestrogen is similar to that seen for other ER antagonists. However, the size and resultant positioning of the ligand's side chain substituent produces a receptor conformation that is distinct from that adopted in the presence of other classes of ER ligands. The novel observation that binding of ICI results in the complete destabilization of H12 provides some indications as to a possible mechanism for pure receptor antagonism.
Nucleocytoplasmic shuttling of histone deacetylases is emerging as a major step in determining the composition, and hence the activity, of the corresponding nuclear regulatory complexes. This shuttling process is one of the distinctive characteristics of these enzymes, themselves belonging to structurally and functionally different classes. Considering the specific features of each class of deacetylases, it is possible to determine how each member can contribute to particular cellular functions.
To characterize the specificity of synthetic compounds for nuclear receptors, we established stable cell lines expressing the luciferase gene and different wild-type or chimaeric receptors. MCF-7 cells, which express the oestrogen receptor alpha (ER alpha), and HeLa cells, which do not express the oestrogen receptor, were transfected with a plasmid containing the luciferase gene downstream from a minimum promoter (beta-globin) and an oestrogen-responsive element, generating the MELN and the HELN cell lines, respectively. MELN cells enabled the detection of compounds that bind to the ER alpha or interfere with its pathway. HELN cells were used to establish stable transfectants expressing different nuclear receptors containing the DNA-binding domain of the oestrogen receptors. We thus established ER alpha or ER beta reporter cell lines by transfecting ER alpha or ER beta expression plasmids, and also retinoic acid receptor alpha, beta or gamma reporter cell lines by transfecting the chimaeric RAR gene, in which the DNA-binding domain was replaced by the ER alpha DNA-binding domain.
Transcriptional regulation in eukaryotes occurs within a chromatin setting and is strongly influenced by nucleosomal barriers imposed by histone proteins. Among the well-known covalent modifications of histones, the reversible acetylation of internal lysine residues in histone amino-terminal domains has long been positively linked to transcriptional activation. Recent biochemical and genetic studies have identified several large, multisubunit enzyme complexes responsible for bringing about the targeted acetylation of histones and other factors. This review discusses our current understanding of histone acetyltransferases (HATs) or acetyltransferases (ATs): their discovery, substrate specificity, catalytic mechanism, regulation, and functional links to transcription, as well as to other chromatin-modifying activities. Recent studies underscore unexpected connections to both cellular regulatory processes underlying normal development and differentiation, as well as abnormal processes that lead to oncogenesis. Although the functions of HATs and the mechanisms by which they are regulated are only beginning to be understood, these fundamental processes are likely to have far-reaching implications for human biology and disease.
Tamoxifen, the first clinically available SERM, was developed in 1966 and approved by the FDA (United States Food and Drug Administration) in 1978. It is the most prescribed antineoplastic drug in the world, with approximately 10 million women-use-years of experience. Tamoxifen has proved efficacious in all settings of breast cancer. However, in the mid-to-late 1980s, a series of letters to the editor and case reports announced an association between tamoxifen therapy in women with breast cancer and the development of endometrial carcinoma. Subsequently, in 1998, the observation of a significant 49% reduction in invasive breast cancer relative to placebo in a cohort of women at increased risk for the disease resulted in the early stopping of the National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project's (NSABP) P-1: Breast Cancer Prevention Trial (BCPT). Importantly, this was the first time that information became available about the effects of tamoxifen in healthy women, that is, women who did not already have breast cancer. In this healthy population, the relative risk of developing endometrial carcinoma in the tamoxifen arm was 2.54, although when stratified by age, in women over 50, the risk grew to 4.01. Thus, the risk appears to be confined to women over 50 because, in contrast, in women under 50 there was no statistically significant increase in the risk of endometrial carcinoma.
Selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) mimic estrogen action in certain tissues while opposing it in others. The therapeutic
effectiveness of SERMs such as tamoxifen and raloxifene in breast cancer depends on their antiestrogenic activity. In the
uterus, however, tamoxifen is estrogenic. Here, we show that both tamoxifen and raloxifene induce the recruitment of corepressors
to target gene promoters in mammary cells. In endometrial cells, tamoxifen, but not raloxifene, acts like estrogen by stimulating
the recruitment of coactivators to a subset of genes. The estrogen-like activity of tamoxifen in the uterus requires a high
level of steroid receptor coactivator 1 (SRC-1) expression. Thus cell type– and promoter-specific differences in coregulator
recruitment determine the cellular response to SERMs.
In the search for differences between ERalpha and ERbeta, we analyzed the interaction of both receptors with calmodulin (CaM) and demonstrated that ERalpha but not ERbeta directly interacts with CaM. Using transiently transfected HeLa cells, we examined the effect of the CaM antagonist N-(6-aminohexyl)-5-chloro-naphthalene sulfonilamide hydrochloride (W7) on the transactivation properties of ERalpha and ERbeta in promoters containing either estrogen response elements or activator protein 1 elements. Transactivation by ERalpha was dose-dependently inhibited by W7, whereas that of ERbeta was not inhibited or even activated at low W7 concentrations. In agreement with these results, transactivation of an estrogen response element containing promoter in MCF-7 cells (which express a high ERalpha/ERbeta ratio) was also inhibited by W7. In contrast, transactivation in T47D cells (which express a low ERalpha/ERbeta ratio) was not affected by this CaM antagonist. The sensitivity of MCF-7 cells to W7 was abolished when cells were transfected with increasing amounts of ERbeta, indicating that the sensitivity to CaM antagonists of estrogen-responsive tissues correlates with a high ERalpha/ERbeta ratio. Finally, substitution of lysine residues 302 and 303 of ERalpha for glycine rendered a mutant ERalpha unable to interact with CaM whose transactivation activity became insensitive to W7. Our results indicate that CaM antagonists are selective modulators of ER able to inhibit ERalpha-mediated activity, whereas ERbeta actions were not affected or even potentiated by W7.
The interactions of human estrogen receptor subtypes ERalpha and ERbeta with DNA and a 210 amino acid residue fragment of the coactivator protein SRC-1 bearing three nuclear receptor interaction motifs were investigated quantitatively using fluorescence anisotropy in the presence of agonist and antagonist ligands. ERalpha and ERbeta were found to bind in a similar manner to DNA, and both salt and temperature affected the affinity and/or stoichiometry of these interactions. The agonist ligands estradiol, estrone and estriol did not modify the binding of ERalpha to the fluorescein-labeled target estrogen response element. However, in the case of ERbeta, these ligands led to the formation of some higher-order protein-DNA complexes and a small decrease in affinity. The partial agonist 4-hydroxytamoxifen had little effect on either ER subtype, whereas the pure antagonist ICI 182,780 led to the cooperative formation of protein-DNA complexes of higher order than dimer, as further demonstrated by competition experiments and gel mobility-shift assays. In addition to DNA binding, the interaction of both ER subtypes with the Alexa488-labeled SRC-1 coactivator fragment was investigated by fluorescence anisotropy. The agonist ligands estrone, estradiol, estriol, genistein and ethynyl estradiol exhibited distinct capacities for inducing the recruitment of SRC-1 that were not correlated with their affinity for the receptor. Moreover, estrone and genistein exhibited subtype specificity in that they induced SRC-1 recruitment to ERbeta with much higher efficiency than in the case of ERalpha. The differential coactivator recruitment capacities of the ER agonists and their receptor subtype coactivator recruitment specificity may be linked to the molecular structure of the agonists with respect to their interactions with a specific histidine residue located at the back of the ligand-binding pocket. Altogether, these quantitative in vitro studies of ER interactions reveal the complex energetic and stoichiometric consequences of changes in the chemical structures of these proteins and their ligands.
- Sy Roth
- Jm Denu
- Cd Allis
Roth SY, Denu JM & Allis CD 2001 Histone acetyltransferases.
Annual Review of Biochemistry 70 81–120.
CBP-associated factor that competes with the adenoviral oncoprotein E1A
- Xj Yang
- Vv Ogryzko
- J Nishikawa
- Bh Howard
- Y Nakatani
Yang XJ, Ogryzko VV, Nishikawa J, Howard BH & Nakatani Y
1996 A p300/CBP-associated factor that competes with the
adenoviral oncoprotein E1A. Nature 382 319–324.
Acetylation of nuclear hormone receptor-interacting protein RIP140 regulates binding of Acetylation and antiestrogen activity · R MARGUERON and others 593 www
- N Vo
- C Fjeld
- Rh Goodman
Vo N, Fjeld C & Goodman RH 2001 Acetylation of nuclear
hormone receptor-interacting protein RIP140 regulates binding of
Acetylation and antiestrogen activity · R MARGUERON and others 593
www.endocrinology.org
Journal of Molecular Endocrinology (2004) 32, 583–594
The evolution of tamoxifen therapy in breast cancer: selective oestrogen-receptor modulators and downregulators
- O 'regan
- Rm Jordan
O'Regan RM & Jordan VC 2002 The evolution of tamoxifen
therapy in breast cancer: selective oestrogen-receptor modulators
and downregulators. Lancet Oncology 3 207–214.
Reactivation of silenced, virally transduced genes by inhibitors of histone deacetylase
- W Y Chen
- E C Bailey
- S L Mccune
- J Y Dong
- T M Townes
Chen WY, Bailey EC, McCune SL, Dong JY & Townes TM 1997
Reactivation of silenced, virally transduced genes by inhibitors of
histone deacetylase. PNAS 94 5798-5803.