ArticlePDF Available

A Human Skeleton of the Early Phase of the Okhotsk Culture Unearthed at the Hamanaka-2 Site, Rebun Island, Hokkaido

Authors:

Abstract

A burial site of the early phase of the Okhotsk culture was found at the Hamanaka-2 site, Rebun Island, Hokkaido, from which an adult female human skeleton was unearthed. This is the oldest extant human remains from the Okhotsk culture. Both measurements and nonmetric traits of the skeleton showed that she has common physical characteristics with the Northern Mongoloid populations. Because her skeletal morphology shows a contrast to those of the Jomon, Epi-Jomon and Ainu peoples, we reconfirmed the earlier conclusion that the Okhotsk people were originated in the northern area including the Sakhalin and Amur region and then migrated into the northern Hokkaido with their culture. Severe dental wear had caused apical periodontitis around the left lower first molar, secondarily resulting in tooth fracture. Compression fractures affected the first and third lumbar vertebrae, probably because of osteoporosis. © 1994, The Anthropological Society of Nippon. All rights reserved.
Anthropol. Sci. 102(4), 363-378, 1994
A Human Skeleton of the Early Phase of the Okhotsk Culture
Unearthed at the Hamanaka-2 Site, Rebun Island, Hokkaido
HAJIME ISHIDA1, TSUNEHIKO HANIHARA2,
OSAMU KONDO1, AND NAOYUKI OHSHIMA1
1 Department of Anatomy, Sapporo Medical University School of
Medicine, S-1, W-17, Chuo-ku, Sapporo, 060 Japan
2 Department of Anatomy, Tohoku University School of Medicine,
2-1 Seiryo-cho, Aoba-sku, Sendai 980-77, Japan
Received February 16, 1994
•ôGH•ô Abstract•ôGS•ô A burial site of the early phase of the Okhotsk culture was found at
the Hamanaka-2 site, Rebun Island, Hokkaido, from which an adult female human
skeleton was unearthed. This is the oldest extant human remains from the Okhotsk
culture. Both measurements and nonmetric traits of the skeleton showed that she
has common physical characteristics with the Northern Mongoloid populations.
Because her skeletal morphology shows a contrast to those of the Jomon, Epi-
Jomon and Ainu peoples, we reconfirmed the earlier conclusion that the Okhotsk
people were originated in the northern area including the Sakhalin and Amur
region and then migrated into the northern Hokkaido with their culture. Severe
dental wear had caused apical periodontitis around the left lower first molar,
secondarily resulting in tooth fracture. Compression fractures affected the first and
third lumbar vertebrae, probably because of osteoporosis.
•ôGH•ô Key Words•ôGS•ô: skeletal morphology, Okhotsk culture, Rebun, dental pathology,
compression fracture
INTRODUCTION
Many archaeological sites of the Okhotsk culture are located in Hamanaka
district, in the northern part of Rebun Island, Hokkaido Prefecture. These have
revealed some human skeletal remains of the Okhotsk culture. Professor Sakuzaemon
Kodama of Hokkaido University unearthed about 20 human skeletal remains at the
Funadomari site in 1949 (Ito and Kodama, 1963), and Professor Tadahiko Matsuno
of Hokkaido University recovered four human skeletal remains at the Kanzaki site
in 1967 (Matsuno et al., 1968); however, those anthropological data have never been
published.
Recently, the Hamanaka-2 site was excavated by Professor Ushio Maeda of
University of Tsukuba and Professor Kiyoshi Yamaura of Rikkyo University in
1990, who found the remains of eight infants and children in a shell mound (Maeda
and Yamaura, 1992). The physical characteristics of those skeletons were reported
364 ISHIDA et at.
by the present authors (Ishida and Hanihara, 1992). These four and other researchers
have continued excavations at the Hamanaka-2 site since 1991 in the hope of
elucidating the origin, affinity and life style of the Okhotsk culture (Yamaura and
Maeda, 1994). In 1992, a burial of the early phase of the Okhotsk culture (hereafter
called "the Towada phase," in keeping with Japanese nomenclature) was found,
from which an adult skeleton was unearthed in good preservation. The Towada
phase is now defined as the second earliest phase of the Okhotsk culture, following
the Susuya phase (Maeda, 1987). The adult skeleton from the Hamanaka-2 site was
the first discovery for the Towada phase and is the oldest human remains of the
Okhotsk culture at the present. Seven other human skeletal remains of the Okhotsk
culture have been recovered there. The authors investigated all these materials for
a report in an excavation monograph edited by Maeda and Yamaura (1994).
Since the recovery of many human skeletal remains from the Moyoro shell
mound, Omisaki site and others in Hokkaido, morphological studies of the skeletons
have provided a number of hints as to the origin of the Okhotsk people. They have
been found to show much closer affinities with the Northern Mongoloid populations
than with the Jomon or Ainu peoples (Kodama, 1948; Suzuki, 1958; Yamaguchi,
1974, 1981; Ishida, 1988a, 1994; Kozintsev, 1990, 1992). However, because the
human skeletal remains described in earlier reports were not from early phases of
the Okhotsk culture, we could not eliminate the possibility that some of them
intermarried with the people already living in Hokkaido at that time, that is, the Ainu
ancestors (Ishida, 1988a, 1988b; Kozintsev, 1990, 1992). That is the reason for the
interest in the present findings.
The subjects of this study are to present skeletal metric and nonmetric charac
teristicsof the material, to evaluate affinities with the neighboring populations, and
to show life activity-induced pathology seen in this individual.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The material, numbered HM2 I-3, was derived from the Towada phase level of
the Okhotsk culture on August, 1992 (Yamaura and Maeda, 1994). It is associated
with one complete Towada type pot. I-3 is a nearly complete skeleton of an adult
female of mature age. The sex determination is based on the morphology of its great
sciatic notch, pubic ramus, cranium and long bones. The estimate of age at death
is based on its symphyseal surface morphology and dental wear.
Thirty-five cranial measurements, including facial flatness ones, were taken
(Brauer, 1988; Yamaguchi, 1973). Next, upper facial height was also measured
following Howell's method (1973). The cranium was examined for the presence or
absence of thirty-three nonmetric cranial traits, as defined by Dodo (1972, 1974,
1986a) and Kozintsev (1990, 1992, 1993). Long bones were measured following
Martin's methods (Brauer, 1988). In addition, maximum and minimum shaft
An Early Human Skeleton of Okhotsk Culture 365
diameters of ulnae were also measured. When subtrochanteric diameters of femur
were measured, in place of sagittal and transverse ones, the maximum and minimum
ones were taken. Transverse diameters of tibial shaft were measured according to
the definition given by Vallois (Olivier, 1960). Pathological findings were diagnosed
by both macroscopic and radiological examinations.
Biological distances based on cranial measurements were estimated by Penrose's
shape distances (Penrose, 1954). The likelihood of allocation of the HM2 I-3 was
calculated by Sjovold's method (1975) in terms of nonmetric cranial traits.
DESCRIPTION AND MEASUREMENTS
Cranial measurements and indices are listed in Table 1. Nonmetric cranial traits
and limb bone measurements and indices are given in Tables 2 and 3, respectively.
Figures 1 and 2 show the cranium and limb bones of the HM2 I-3, respectively.
Length-breadth index is mesocranic (76.3). The temporal lines developed in the
frontal region wind acutely inward (minimum frontal breadth: 88). The mastoid
process is rather large with a distinct supramastoid ridge and mastoid crest, while
the nuchal lines or external occipital protuberance are obtuse. The sagittal parieto-
occipital index is slightly low (91.1). The occipito-mastoid wormian and precondylar
tubercle are recognizable on the left side. The glabella and superciliary arches are
not developed and the nasion is not engraved. Supraorbital foramina are bilateral;
the left consists of two supraorbital nerve grooves in the frontal bone. The high and
wide face is mainly caused by large maxillae and zygomatic bones. The infraorbital
suture is not intersected by the zygomatic bone, whose form was classified into type
I defined by Kozintsev (1993). The piriform orifice is narrow and high. The canine
fossa of the maxilla is very shallow with a large alveolar process. The frontal flatness
index is low, while the zygomaxillary portion shows some prognatism. The palatine
and mandibular tori are visible. The mandibular condyle as well as the temporal
components of the temporo-mandibular joint shows osteoarthrotic changes.
All thirty-two teeth are preserved in the alveolar processes. While the third molars
show moderate occlusal attrition, all other teeth exhibit pronounced wear with their
dentine or even pulps exposed. Abrasion and pathological changes of the teeth were
discussed in a later section. Because of the severe wear, it was impossible to measure
the crown diameters or examine nonmetric crown characters.
The mid-shaft of the humerus is flattened. The crest of the greater tubercle is
distinct and elongated. Femoral length is almost equal to the average of the Omisaki
female (Mitsuhashi and Yamaguchi, 1962a). The mid-shaft of femur forms a weak
pilaster and the subtrochanteric shaft is platymeric. The degree of medio-lateral shaft
flatness of the tibia is in the platycnemic range. The cross section of the tibial shaft
was classified into Hrdlicka's type II or VI (Stewart, 1952); i.e., it did not form a
vertical line in the posterior surface. The tibio-femoral index based on the maximum
366 ISHIDA et al.
length shows the relative shortness of the tibia, while the radio-Numeral index is
not very low. The talocrural joint surfaces of tibia and talus have additional articular
surfaces or tubercles, which are called squatting facets; these are common in the
Okhotsk people (Mitsuhashi and Yamaguchi, 1962b).
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
The biological distances from the HM2 I-3 were estimated by Penrose's shape
distances (Penrose, 1954), based on the 17 cranial and facial flatness measurements
listed in Table 4. The available comparison samples consist of the Okhotsk people
from the Omisaki site at the northern part of Hokkaido (Ishida, 1988a), Hokkaido
Table 1. Cranial measurements and indices of the HM2 I-3 human skeleton at the Towada phase of
the Okhotsk culture from the Hamanaka-2 site, Rebun Island, Hokkaido
An Early Human Skeleton of Okhotsk Culture 367
Ainu (Koganei, 1893; Yamaguchi, 1973), Jomon (Dodo, 1986b; Yamaguchi, 1980),
and the Ulch in the lower Amur basin (Ishida, unpublished data). The HM2 I-3 is
the closest to the Okhotsk, and the next closest to the Ulch.
On the basis of the 17 available nonmetric cranial traits, we calculated average
probabilities of likelihood for allocating the HM2 I-3 using Sjovold's method
(1975). The comparison samples contain the Aleut, Asian Eskimo, Ekven (the Iron
Age), Evenki, Buryat, Neolithic Baikalian, Hokkaido Ainu (Ishida and Dodo, 1992),
Amur (Ishida, 1990) and Sakhalin Ainu (Ishida and Kida, 1991). Table 5 shows that
the HM2 I-3 is more probably allocated to the Buryat, Neolithic Baikalian, or
Sakhalin Ainu than to the Hokkaido Ainu or the Arctic peoples.
Mitsuhashi and Yamaguchi (1962a, 1962b), investigating the Omisaki samples
of the Okhotsk culture, pointed out that the Okhotsk people had a short tibia in
comparison with the femur, while their forearm bones were relatively long as
compared with the humerus. The HM2 I-3 also has those characteristics. In addition,
the HM2 I-3 has the following shaft morphology of limb bones, which is consistent
with those of Omisaki Okhotsk people: flattened shaft of the humerus; platymeria
of the femoral upper shaft; and platycnemia of the tibial shaft. The Hokkaido Ainu
have different proportions of limb bones, while their shaft shapes are rather similar
to those of the Okhotsk people (Koganei, 1893; Yamaguchi, 1983).
All these results indicated that the HM2 I-3 shows closer affinities with the
Okhotsk people and the Northern Mongoloid populations than with the Hokkaido
Table 2. Nonmetric cranial variations of the HM2 I-3 skeleton from the Hamanaka-2 site
+: present, -: absent, /: unknown
368 ISHIDA et al.
Table 3. Limb bone measurements and indices of the HM2 I-3 skeleton from the Hamanaka-2 site
An Early Human Skeleton of Okhotsk Culture 369
Fig. 1. Cranium of the HM2 I-3 from the Hamanaka-2 site, Rebun, Hokkaido.
370 ISHIDA et al.
Fig. 2. Frontal and back views of right limb bones of the HM2 I-3 from the Hamanaka-2 site, Rebun,
Hokkaido.
An Early Human Skeleton of Okhotsk Culture 371
Ainu. That confirms the earlier conclusion that the people of the Okhotsk culture
were derived from the Northern Mongoloid, not Jomon or Ainu, stock (Yamaguchi,
1974; Ishida, 1988). The human skeletal remains of the late phase of the Epi-Jomon
period, that is, just before the Okhotsk culture, were recovered at the Onkoromanai
shell mound in Wakkanai, Hokkaido in 1959. They have many common character
isticswith the Ainu and Jomon peoples and are quite different in morphology from
Table 4. Comparisons of cranial and facial flatness measurements
1 Ishida (1988); 2 Koganei (1893) , partly supplemented by B. Yamaguchi (Yamaguchi, 1973);
3 Dodo (1986) , Yamaguchi (1980); 4 Ishida (unpublished data).
Table 5. Average probabilities of likelihood for allocating the
HM2 I-3
372 ISHIDA et al.
the Okhotsk people (Yamaguchi, 1963). The morphological contrast between the
Onkoromanai and Hamanaka remains seems to strongly confirm that the Okhotsk
people were originated in the northern area including Sakhalin and suddenly
appeared in northern Hokkaido and that the Ainu ancestors did not participate in
the Okhotsk people's formation.
As mentioned above, Maeda (1987) considered the Susuya type pottery to be the
marker of the earliest phase of the Okhotsk culture. However, some archaeologists
argue that the Towada phase was the beginning of the Okhotsk culture and that the
Susuya phase preceded the Okhotsk culture (Ohyi, 1982). It is certain that the
Towada phase was included in the Okhotsk culture based on the results of not only
archaeological investigations but also this osteological study. The present lack of
human skeletal remains of the Susuya phase prevents definite statement whether the
Susuya phase belonged to the Okhotsk culture.
LIFE ACTIVITY-INDUCED PATHOLOGY
Occupational stress, habitat, nutritional status, disease and trauma sometimes
result in structural modifications of bones and teeth (Iscan and Kennedy, 1989).
There has been little osteoarchaeological or paleopathological research on the
Okhotsk people; Kodama (1948) noted severe dental wear in the Moyoro Okhotsk
people, and Yamaguchi (1967) reported that a male from the Omisaki site had been
wounded by a stone arrowhead in his right hip bone. Although much investigation
must be done on life activity-induced pathology in the Okhotsk people for a clear
picture of their lives and epidemiology of diseases, the following data from the HM2
I-3 is a step in that investigation.
Dental wear and pathology (Fig. 3)
The left lower incisors and canine exhibited the distinct pattern of labial rounding
ascribed to the use of the teeth for skin-working, which is typical among hunter-
gatherer peoples (Scott, 1991). The HM2 I-3 had developed an oblique wear plane,
sloping upward to lingual in the upper molars and downward to buccal in the lower
molars, at an angle of about 30 degrees against the horizontal occlusal plane. Smith
(1984) suggested that agriculturalists tended to exhibit a steeper angle of molar wear
while hunter-gatherers developed flatter molar wear, probably due to differences in
the toughness of the food consumed in the two life styles. However, according to
stable isotope and zooarchaeological analyses (Koike et al., 1992; Nishimoto, 1985),
the Okhotsk people most likely developed a considerable maritime infrastructure
and used sea mammals and fish for food mainly. In this individual, the steep angle
of molar wear might be produced not only by attrition but also by abrasion, such
as that caused by working pelts. Light and electron microscopic surveys will be
necessary for refining our understanding of the cause of that abrasion.
An Early Human Skeleton of Okhotsk Culture 373
Accompanied with the considerable wear, apical periodontitis and tooth fracture
were seen in the left lower first molar. The bone cavity around the root of the left
lower first molar is probably caused by chronic apical periodontitis and radicular
cyst (Shafer et al., 1963; Ishikawa and Akiyoshi, 1978). The bone cavity is
surrounded by clearly sclerotic bone tissue diagnosed as condensing osteitis.
Excessive amounts of secondary cementum were deposited on the root surface as
a result of radicular granuloma. A small bone cavity opening to the labial surface
Fig. 3. Pronounced crown wear in the upper and lower dentition, exhibiting a steeper angle of wear
on the posterior teeth. Chronic apical periodontitis and radicular cyst affected the lower left
first molar and its socket, resulting in the tooth fracture.
374 ISHIDA et al.
was also seen in the left lower lateral incisor. X-ray diagnosis confirmed that the
other teeth were not affected. We can easily imagine that pulp exposure through
extreme wear resulted in bacterial infection of dental pulp and periapical tissue. In
addition, even if dentin tissue remained on the pulp, the dentin does not seem to
have prevented infection of the pulp (Tronstad and Langelland, 1971). Tooth
fracture seems to have occurred secondarily due to severe wear and apical
periodontitis under the stress of mastication (Shafer et al., 1963).
Fractures of lumbar vertebrae (Fig. 4)
Compression fractures affected the first and third lumbar vertebrae. Anterior
wedge fracture with 52% loss of vertebral body height occurred in the first lumbar
vertebra, and central compression fracture in the third one showed a so-called fish
vertebra. X-rays revealed moderate loss of trabecular marking in the vertebral
bodies, indicating osteoporosis. Osteoporosis is likely to occur in mature and senile
aged females and weakens their bones, resulting in fractures of the vertebral body,
femoral neck and distal radius (Apley and Solomon, 1993).
As a result of compression fractures, the normal convex-forward curve of the
lumbar region had disappeared in this skeleton. Compression fracture is by far the
most common vertebral fracture, usually affecting the anterior part of the vertebral
body (Apley and Solomon, 1993). This is caused by forward flexion or axial
compression (Leventhal, 1992). Merbs (1983) guessed that a high incidence of the
vertebral compression fracture in a Canadian Inuit population, Sadlermiuts, was due
to sledding and tobogganing over rough and icy terrain. This individual might have
engaged in such activities in her lifetime, though it seems quite probable that
osteoporosis triggered the fracture of the lumbar vertebrae.
CONCLUSION
The HM2 I-3 remains from the Towada phase of the Okhotsk culture has a close
affinity with the Northern Mongoloid population in terms of cranial measurements,
nonmetric cranial variations and limb bone morphology. The skeletal morphology
of the HM2 I-3 is well contrasted with that of the Onkoromanai people of the late
phase of Epi-Jomon period in many respects, who are similar to the Jomon and Ainu.
These data confirmed the earlier hypothesis that the Okhotsk people were originated
in the northern area, perhaps, the Amur basin and Sakhalin, and that they came to
the Hokkaido with their culture.
The teeth exhibit pronounced wear with dentine exposed. Chronic apical
periodontitis and radicular cyst affected the lower left first molar and its socket,
resulting in fracture of the tooth. In addition, this individual suffered from
compression fracture of the lumbar vertebrae, probably due to osteoporosis.
An Early Human Skeleton of Okhotsk Culture 375
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We wish to thank Professor Ushio Maeda, University of Tsukuba and Professor
Kiyoshi Yamaura, Rikkyo University, for their collaboration with us to recover
human skeletal remains of the Okhotsk culture. We are also grateful to Professor
Hajime Sakura, Sapporo Gakuin University, and Dr. Tetsuo Masuda, Sapporo
Medical University, for their valuable suggestions, and to Mrs. Mikako Higuchi for
her technical work.
This study was supported in part by Grant-in-aid for Scientific Research from the
Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Japan (No. 04740463), and a Grant
in-aid for Scientific Research from the Toyota Foundation (No. 92-II-085).
Fig. 4. Lumbar vertebrae of the HM2 I-3. Compression fractures affected the bodies of first and third
lumbar vertebrae. X-ray revealed moderate loss of trabecular marking in the vertebral bodies,
indicating osteoporosis (right).
376 ISHIDA et al.
REFERENCES
Apley A.G., and Solomon, L. (1993) Apley's System of Orthopaedics and Fractures, 7th Ed.,
Butterworth-Heinemann Ltd., Oxford.
Br_??_uer, G. (1988) Osteometry. In Anthropologie (Martin, R., and Knussman, K., ed.), Gustav Fischer,
Stuttgart, pp. 160-232.
Dodo, Y. (1972) Aural exostosis in the human skeletal remains excavated in Hokkaido. J. Anthrop.
Soc. Nippon 80, 11-22. (In Japanese with English summary)
Dodo, Y. (1974) Non-metrical cranial traits in the Hokkaido Ainu and the northern Japanese of recent
times. J. Anthrop. Soc. Nippon 82, 31-51.
Dodo, Y. (1986a) A population study of the jugular foramen bridging of the human cranium. Am. J.
Phys. Anthropol. 69, 15-19.
Dodo, Y. (1986b) Metrical and non-metrical analyses of Jomon crania from eastern Japan. In
Prehistoric Hunter-Gatherers in Japan (Akazawa, T., and Aikens, C.M., ed.), Univ. of Tokyo
Press, Tokyo, pp. 137-161.
Howells, W.W. (1973) Cranial Variation in Man: A Study by Multivariate Analysis of Patterns of
Difference among Recent Human Populations. Papers of the Peabody Museum of Archaeology
and Ethnology, 67. Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge.
Ican, M.Y., and Kennedy, K.A.R., ed. (1989) Reconstrution of Life from the Skeleton, Alan R. Liss,
New York.
Ishida, H. (1988a) Morphological studies of Okhotsk crania from Omisaki, Hokkaido. J. Anthrop. Soc.
Nippon 96, 17-45.
Ishida, H. (1988b) An Ainu-like cranium from the Okhotsk cultural burial of the Menashidomari site,
Esashi-cho, Hokkaido. J. Anthrop. Soc. Nippon 96, 371-374. (In Japanese with English summary)
Ishida, H. (1990) Cranial morphology of several ethnic groups from the Amur basin and Sakhalin.
J. Anthrop. Soc. Nippon 98, 137-148.
Ishida, H. (1994) Skeletal morphology of the Okhotsk people on Sakhalin Island. Anthropol. Sci. 102,
257-269.
Ishida, H., and Kida, M. (1991) An anthropological investigation of the Sakhalin Ainu with special
reference to nonmetric cranial traits. J. Anthrop. Soc. Nippon 98, 403-409.
Ishida, H., and Dodo, Y. (1992) Differentiation of the northern Mongoloid: The evidence of cranial
nonmetric traits. In Japan in the World IV: Japanese as a Member of the Asian and Pacific
Populations (Hanihara, K., ed.), International Research Center for Japanese Studies Press, Kyoto,
pp. 79-94.
Ishida, H., and Hanihara, T. (1992) Analysis of the human skeletal remains. In Archaeological
Investigation in Hamanaka II, Island of Rebun, Hokkaido (Maeda, U., and Yamaura, K., ed.),
Rebun Board of Education, Rebun, pp. 89-107. (In Japanese)
Ishikawa, G., and Akiyoshi, M. (1978) Oral Pathology, Nagasue-shoten, Kyoto. (In Japanese)
Ito, S., and Kodama, G. (1963) On the human skulls from the sites at Funadomari in Rebun Island,
Hokkaido, Acta Anat. Nippon. 38, 29. (In Japanese)
Kodama, S. (1948) Moyoro Shell Heap, Hokkaido Genshi Bunka Kenkyukai, Sapporo. (In Japanese)
Koganei, Y. (1893) Beitr_??_ge zur physischen Anthropologie der Aino. I. Untersuchungen am Skelet.
Mittheil. med. Fak. Univ. Tokyo 2, 1-249.
Koike, H., Chisholm, B., and Sakazume, K. (1992) ƒÂ•ôUH•ô13•ôUS•ôC measurements for the human skeletal
collections (2). ƒÂ•ôUH•ô13•ôUS•ôC values for Hokkaido prehistoric people using collections at the Department
of Anatomy, Sapporo Medical College. J. College Liberal Arts, Saitama Univ. 27, 33-44.
(In Japanese with English summary)
An Early Human Skeleton of Okhotsk Culture 377
Kozintsev, A.G. (1990) Ainu, Japanese, their ancestors and neighbours: Cranioscopic data. J. Anthrop.
Soc. Nippon 98, 247-267.
Kozintsev, A.G. (1992) Prehistoric and recent populations of Japan: Multivariate analysis of
cranioscopic data. Arctic Anthropol. 29, 104-111.
Kozintsev, A.G. (1993) Ethnic epigenetics: A new approach. Homo 43, 213-244.
Leventhal, M.R. (1992) Fractures, dislocations, and fracture-dislocation of spine. In Campbell's
Operative Orthopaedics. Vol. 5, 8th Ed. (Crenshaw, A.H., ed.), Mosby Year Book, St. Louis, pp.
3517-3582.
Maeda, U. (1987) Archaeology of the Northern Hunters, Dosei-sha, Tokyo. (In Japanese)
Maeda, U., and Yamaura, K., ed. (1992) Archaeological Investigation in Hamanaka II, Island of
Rebun, Hokkaido, Rebun Board of Education, Rebun. (In Japanese with English summary)
Maeda, U., and Yamaura, K., ed. (1994) Archaeological Investigation in Hamanaka II, Island of
Rebun, Hokkaido, No. 2, Univ. of Tsukuba, Tsukuba. (in press)
Matsuno, T., Suenaga, Y., Sato T., and Kaneshige, T. (1968) On the chronological position of the
human skeletal remains (Uen-nai-po Man) from Kanzaki, Rebun Island. Acta Anat. Nippon 43
(Suppl.), 1-2. (In Japanese)
Merbs, C.F. (1983) Patterns of Activity-induced Pathology in a Canadian Inuit Population: National
Museum of Man Mercury Series, Archaeological Survey of Canada, No. 119, National Museums
of Canada, Ottawa.
Mitsuhashi, K., and Yamaguchi, B. (1962a) Anthropological studies on the human remains from
Omisaki, Hokkaido. II. Femur, tibia, and fibula. Sapporo Med. J. 21, 23-32. (In Japanese with
English summary)
Mitsuhashi, K., and Yamaguchi, B. (1962b) Anthropological studies on the human remains from
Omisaki, Hokkaido. III. Talus, calcaneus, and articular surface variation of the lower extremity
bones. Sapporo Med. J. 21, 106-114. (In Japanese with English summary)
Nishimoto, T. (1985) The transition of hunting and fishing activities in Hokkaido. Bull. Natn. Mus.
Jpn. Hist. 6, 53-74, 274. (In Japanese with English summary)
Ohyi, H., ed. (1982) Symposium on Problems of the Okhotsk Culture, Gakusei-sha, Tokyo. (In
Japanese)
Olivier, G. (1960) Pratique Anthropologique, Vigot Fr_??_res, Paris.
Penrose, L.S. (1954) Distance, size and shape. Ann. Eugen. 18, 337-343.
Scott, G.R. (1991) Dental anthropology. In Encyclopedia of Human Biology, Vol. 2, Academic Press,
San Diego, pp. 789-804.
Shafer, W.G., Hine, M.K., and Levy, B.M. (1963) A Textbook of Oral Pathology, W.B. Saunders
Company, Philadelphia.
Sjovold, T. (1975) Allocation of single or some few individuals to one of two or more groups by means
of non-metrical variants in the skeleton. Ossa 2, 41-46.
Smith, B.H. (1984) Patterns of molar wear in hunter-gatherers and agriculturalists. Am. J. Phys.
Anthropol. 63, 39-56.
Stewart, T.D., ed. (1952) Hrdlicka's Practical Anthropometry, 4th Ed., The Wister Institute of
Anatomy and Biology, Philadelphia.
Suzuki, H. (1958) Physische Anthropologie in Japan. Homo 9, 37-47.
Tronstad, L., and Langeland, K. (1971) Effect of attrition on subjacent dentin and pulp. J. Dent. Res.
50, 17-30.
Yamaguchi, B. (1963) The human skeletal remains from the Onkoromanai shell-mound in northern
Hokkaido. J. Anthrop. Soc. Nippon 70, 131-146. (In Japanese with English summary)
378 ISHIDA et al.
Yamaguchi, B. (1967) A human skeleton penetrated by a stone arrowhead. Culture of Hokkaido 12,
32-34. (In Japanese)
Yamaguchi, B. (1973) Facial flatness measurements of the Ainu and Japanese crania. Bull. Natn. Sci.
Mus., Tokyo 16, 161-171.
Yamaguchi, B. (1974) Paleoanthropology in Hokkaido. The Quaternary Research 12, 257-264. (In
Japanese)
Yamaguchi, B. (1980) A study on the facial flatness of the Jomon crania. Bull. Natn. Sci. Mus., Tokyo
Ser. D 6, 21-28.
Yamaguchi, B. (1981) Human skeletal remains in Hokkaido. In Nihonjin. I. Jinruigaku-koza 5 (Ogata,
T., ed.), Yuzankaku, Tokyo, pp. 137-156. (In Japanese)
Yamaguchi, B. (1983) Postcranial bones of the human skeletal remains of the Jomon period from the
Ebishima (Kaitori) shell mound in Hanaizumi, Iwate Prefecture. Mem. Natn. Sci. Mus. Tokyo 16,
201-222. (In Japanese with English summary)
Yamaura, K., and Maeda, U. (1994) Investigation in Hamanaka-2 site, Rebun Island. Archaeol. J. 371,
10-12. (In Japanese)
... There has been little bioarcheological research on the Okhotsk people; Kodama (1948) mentioned severe dental wear and Yamaguchi (1995) identified a wound caused by a stone arrowhead in the right hip bone of a male specimen. Recently, oral health has attracted attention (Ishida et al., 1994;Hudson, 2004;Fukumoto et al., 2007;Oxenham and Matsumura, 2008;Hoover and Matsumura, 2008). However, only vertebral compression fractures were reported with regard to the skeletal system of the Okhotsk people (Ishida et al., 1994;Ishida and Matsumura, 2000). ...
... Recently, oral health has attracted attention (Ishida et al., 1994;Hudson, 2004;Fukumoto et al., 2007;Oxenham and Matsumura, 2008;Hoover and Matsumura, 2008). However, only vertebral compression fractures were reported with regard to the skeletal system of the Okhotsk people (Ishida et al., 1994;Ishida and Matsumura, 2000). ...
Article
Full-text available
Degenerative changes of the spine in people of the Okhotsk culture were investigated in adult human skeletal remains from 38 males and 34 females. These findings were then compared with those in materials obtained from the medieval Kamakura period and early-modern peasants on Kumejima, Ryukyu Islands. The three samples clearly showed different patterns. In the Okhotsk series, the cervical spine of each sex had most osteophytes on the vertebral body, while the Kumejima samples had the highest frequency on the lumbar vertebrae. In the Kamakura series, males were most affected on the lower thoracic vertebrae. Moreover, severe osteophytes on the body of the lumbar vertebrae were more frequently seen in the Okhotsk males. Degenerative changes of the articular process of the Okhotsk series were most frequently seen in the lumbar vertebrae and least frequently seen in the cervical vertebrae. This is well contrasted with a high frequency of degenerative changes of cervical apophyseal joint in early-modern Kumejima peasants. The Kamakura series of each sex had generally low frequencies. Severe degenerative changes of apophyseal joint dominantly affected the Okhotsk series. It is inferred that different dynamic loads caused a high frequency of degenerative changes in the corresponding articular parts. For example, because the Okhotsk culture developed a considerable maritime infrastructure, the lifestyle required for sea-mammal hunting and fishing seems to have particularly affected the incidence of severe degenerative changes of the lumbar vertebrae.
... From 2011 to 2013, the remains of three human skeletons of the Okhotsk culture were recovered in the area, one of which (NAT002) was affected by severe hyperostotic changes, or abnormal excessive growth of bone, suggesting SAPHO syndrome (synovitis, acne, pustulosis, hyperostosis, osteitis) or sternoclavicular hyperostosis . This is the first case of such pathological changes among the Hamanaka-2 remains, although severe dental calculus deposits or vertebral compression fracture were found in other skeletons Ishida et al., 1994). In the current study, we present this pathological finding and consider its cause. ...
Article
Full-text available
We present the oldest human skeletal case yet identified with possible SAPHO syndrome (synovitis, acne, pustulosis, hyperostosis, osteitis), a chronic disease involving the skin, bone, and joints. A human skeleton with a severe pathological condition was recovered from a shell mound of the prehistoric Okhotsk culture at the Hamanaka 2 site, Rebun Island, Hokkaido, Japan in 2013. Morphological and Amelogenin gene analyses determined the sex as female, and the age at time of death was estimated to be in the forties using analysis of the auricular surface of the ilium. The stable isotope ratios of this individual (NAT002) and other Hamanaka 2 samples indicated a heavy dependence on marine mammals and fish for dietary protein intake. Radiocarbon age on collagen from the bone of NAT002 was 1689 ± 20 BP, or 1060–1155 (68.2%) calAD. Macroscopic and computed tomography (CT) findings indicated diffuse hyperostosis in the axial and appendicular skeleton, including the mandible, vertebrae, clavicles, sternum, scapulae, humeri, radii, ulnae, and ilium, caused by osteitis and synovitis. The bilateral clavicles were most affected, in which CT imaging revealed irregular cortical thickening, termed ‘grotesque periostitis.’ The case was diagnosed as most likely having SAPHO syndrome, although dermatological findings could not be detected. Although SAPHO syndrome is a fairly new concept in autoimmune diseases, this case suggests the syndrome originated much earlier in human history.
... To obtain food, these people concentrated primarily on fishing and hunting for sea mammals such as fur seals, whales, and sea lions. Severe degenerative changes and compression fractures were found in the spines of these remains, probably due to the heavy loads associated with marine mammal hunting and fishing (Ishida et al., 1994;Shimoda et al., 2012). : 1-Otomo, 2-Neshiko, 3-Ukumatsubara, 4-Miyanomoto, 5-Hamago, 6-Fukahori. ...
Article
Degenerative changes in six major limb joints were investigated to compare their prevalence among five ancient skeletal populations from the Japan Islands. The populations assessed in this study consisted of the farmers in the northern Kyushu/Yamaguchi area and the foragers from the northwestern Kyushu area from the Yayoi period (5th century BC to 3rd century AD); the Okhotsk (5th to 12th centuries AD) foragers from Hokkaido and Sakhalin; the common people from medieval Kamakura (12th to 14th centuries AD) in Kanto, central Japan; and the early-modern farmers (17th to 19th centuries AD) from Kumejima, in the southernmost island chain (Ryukyu Islands). Crude prevalence comparisons showed that the shoulder and hip joints were principally affected in early-modern Kumejima and medieval Kamakura, which contrasted with the high prevalence of elbow and knee joint changes in the Okhotsk people. The heavy dependence on marine mammals and fish for dietary protein intake probably required flexion and extension movements of the most severely degenerated joints in the Okhotsk people. The northern Kyushu/Yamaguchi and northwestern Kyushu Yayoi peoples were more affected by degeneration in the wrist joints than others, possibly due to their use of innovative tools such as stone or shell knives and harpoons. A multivariate logistic regression analysis, adjusted for age, region, and sex as the predictor variables for degenerative changes in joints, was applied to only the two samples from Kumejima and Kamakura (including previously reported spine data) because of their better preservation. This revealed differences in the prevalence of changes in some joints; for example, age-related changes were recognized. The Kumejima people were more commonly affected by hip and knee joint changes, whereas the Kamakura people were more commonly affected by changes to apophyseal joints. Because a stable isotope analysis indicated that the trophic levels of the two populations were almost the same, the pattern of degenerative changes would have reflected differences in their specific workloads, such as wet rice cultivation using a peculiar hoe by the Kumejima people. This study, combining multivariate logistic regression analysis of degenerative joint changes and stable isotope analyses, uses large skeletal populations to add clarity to the actual rigors of ancient life.
... On Hokkaido, the pre-agricultural period extends beyond the Later J omon periods into the Epi-J omon (2000e1000 BP), a period paralleling the wet-rice agricultural period (Yayoi) on Honshu, and the Okhotsk (1000e600 BP), which resembles the Honshu protohistoric period and is named for immigrants from the land bridge between Sakhalin and Hokkaido (Mitsuhashi and Yamaguchi, 1961;Aikens and Higuchi, 1982;Ishida, 1988Ishida, , 1991Ishida, , 1994Ishida, , 1996Yamaguchi, 1991;Ishida et al., 1993Ishida et al., , 1994Imamura, 1996;Habu, 2004;Hudson, 2004;Sato et al., 2007Sato et al., , 2009Naito et al., 2010;Tsutaya et al., 2014). ...
Article
Previous research has identified a relationship between mandibular morphology and diet (e.g., coarse diets result in more robust mandibles). Prehistoric Japan is an excellent place to explore the significance of this relationship in shaping mandibular morphology due to the pronounced regional dietary variation. South/West Honshu Jōmon engaged in broad spectrum foraging, Northeastern Honshu Jōmon were fisher-gatherers, Hokkaido Jōmon were maritime (sea mammal) foragers. We test the hypothesis that diet variation across temporal and spatial zones will be reflected in mandibular morphological traits. Metric measurements were utilized to test for regional differences with both archaeological time period and biological sex as covariants. ANOVA results for region with time period as a covariate indicated all variables except corpus height and breadth are significantly different among regions but for the time period covariate, significance is only present for corpus breadth and the dimensions of the ascending ramus. ANOVA for region with biological sex as a covariate indicates all variables except corpus height are significantly different. Biological sex as a covariate demonstrates significant p-values for chin height, bicondylar breadth and minimum ascending ramus breadth. Generally, North Hokkaido, followed by Southwest Hokkaido, exhibits the largest mandibular ascending rami and tallest anterior mandibles, whereas Northeast and South/West Honshu have the smallest. Multivariate analysis indicates a separation between North and Southwest Hokkaido and South/West Honshu, whereas Northeast Honshu partially overlaps these dietary zones. Differences in mandibular morphology are better explained by regional diets than by temporal trends and biological sex.
... On Hokkaido, the pre-agricultural period extends beyond the Later J omon periods into the Epi-J omon (2000e1000 BP), a period paralleling the wet-rice agricultural period (Yayoi) on Honshu, and the Okhotsk (1000e600 BP), which resembles the Honshu protohistoric period and is named for immigrants from the land bridge between Sakhalin and Hokkaido (Mitsuhashi and Yamaguchi, 1961;Aikens and Higuchi, 1982;Ishida, 1988Ishida, , 1991Ishida, , 1994Ishida, , 1996Yamaguchi, 1991;Ishida et al., 1993Ishida et al., , 1994Imamura, 1996;Habu, 2004;Hudson, 2004;Sato et al., 2007Sato et al., , 2009Naito et al., 2010;Tsutaya et al., 2014). ...
Article
Previous research has identified a relationship between mandibular morphology and diet (e.g., coarse or tough diets result in more robust mandibles). Prehistoric Japan is an excellent place to explore the significance of this relationship in shaping mandibular morphology due to the pronounced regional dietary variation. South/West Honshu Jōmon engaged in broad spectrum foraging, Northeastern Honshu Jōmon were fisher–gatherers, Hokkaido Jōmon were maritime (sea mammal) foragers. We test the hypothesis that diet variation across temporal and spatial zones will be reflected in mandibular morphological traits. Metric measurements were utilized to test for regional differences with both archaeological time period and biological sex as covariants. ANOVA results for region with time period as a covariate indicates all variables except corpus height and breadth are significantly different among regions but for the time period covariate, only corpus breadth and dimensions of ascending ramus are significant. ANOVA for region with biological sex as a covariate indicates all variables except corpus height are significantly different. Biological sex as a covariate demonstrates significant p-values for chin height, bicondylar breadth and minimum ascending ramus breadth. Generally, North Hokkaido and Southwest Hokkaido, exhibit the largest mandibular ascending rami and tallest anterior mandibles, whereas Northeast and South/West Honshu have smaller mandibles. Multivariate analysis indicates a separation between North and Southwest Hokkaido and South/West Honshu, whereas Northeast Honshu partially overlaps these dietary zones. Differences in mandibular morphology are better explained by regional diets than by temporal trends and biological sex.
... The Okhotsk sample is represented by five sites in northern/eastern Hokkaido and single site on Sakhalin Island (Table 1, Figure 1). From northern Hokkaido, 40 skeletal individuals came from the Hamanaka and Hamanaka 2 sites on the island of Rebun (Ito and Kodama, 1963;Ishida et al., 1994aIshida et al., , 2002Maeda and Yamaura, 1994;Ishida and Matsumura, 2000) and from the Omisaki site in the city of Wakkanai Yamaguchi, 1961, 1962a, b, c;Ishida, 1988;Yamaguchi, 1995). From adjacent Sakhalin Island, the Susuya site produced eight skeletal specimens be-longing to the early Okhotsk cultural phase (Kiyono, 1925). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper examines the population affinity of the Okhotsk-culture people who settled along the northeastern coastal areas of the islands of Hokkaido and Sakhalin during the 5th and 11th centuries, on the bases of dental metric and nonmetric features. Based on neighbor-joining analyses of both metric and nonmetric data, the Okhostk people, eastern Siberians, and subarctic American natives were linked more closely to each other than to other East Asian and Pacific samples. In particular, the nonmetric data analysis demonstrated the close linkage between the Okhotsk people and tribes in the Amur River Basin, suggesting that the Okhotsk people were descended from eastern Siberians who might share common ancestry with the present-day Amur people and subarctic Americans. Beside the above demonstration of Okhotsk affinities among the populations settling along the Circum Sea of the Okhotsk rim, as far as the metric dental traits are concerned, close resemblances were found between the Okhotsk, Neolithic Jomon, and Hokkaido Ainu. However, with regard to their overall dental characteristics, it is not clear whether such odontmetric similarities indicate the evidence of substantial genetic interaction between the Okhotsk and Jomon-Ainu lineages, because their nonmetric traits data indicate a quite distant relationship from each other.
Article
Following the method of Yamaguchi (1973), a series of facial flatness measurements were taken from crania from the islands of Amami, Okinawa and Sakishima of the Ryukyu Islands. These measurements were compared with each other and with measurements of cranial series from other Japanese Islands, insular and continental Northeast Asia and Europe. Among the three Ryukyuan samples, the facial skeletons of Sakishima are least flattened. Nevertheless, the Ryukyuans as a whole show far flatter faces than Ainu. The extent of Ryukyuan facial flatness is comparable to that of the so-called "Northern Mongoloid". In addition to the previous cranial nonmetric study (Dodo and others, 1998) the present study of facial flatness also does not give any indication of a close affinity between the Ainu and Ryukyuans.
Article
Full-text available
Population affinities and biological variation in human skeletal series associated with the Okhotsk culture from Hokkaido and Sakhalin Islands from the 5th to 12th centuries AD are investigated using 19 nonmetric cranial traits. The Okhotsk crania have a higher frequency of the supraorbital foramen than the Hokkaido Ainu and Jomon, while the frequency of the transverse zygomatic suture vestige in the Okhotsk is as high as in the Jomon. The mean measure of divergence between the northern and eastern Okhotsk cranial assemblages is small and insignificant. The method of Relethford and Blangero [Relethford J.H. and Blangero J. (1990) Human Biology, 62: 5-25] suggests that the eastern Okhotsk had a larger Rii value (distance from the centroid) and a lower observed variation than the northern Okhotsk, indicating that the eastern Okhotsk lost phenotypic variability. These results further reaffirm the affinity between the Okhotsk skeletal series and Northeast Asian series such as the Neolithic Baikalian and Amur. Finally, the results of analyses of nonmetric cranial variation demonstrate a close relationship between the Okhotsk, Ainu, and Jomon series that suggests that the Jomon and Ainu were closer to the Okhotsk than to other Northeast Asian series prior to any admixture.
Article
Full-text available
Frequencies of several highly informative nonmetric traits in four prehistoric and six recent cranial samples from Japan are analysed with the principal components method. The observed pattern may be explained by a hybridisation process in which Mongoloid characteristics were added to the Jomonese substratum. Their proportions in various populations are estimated. -Author
Article
Full-text available
Morphological data of human skeletal remains of the prehistoric Okhotsk culture in Sakhalin were presented. The Okhotsk people in Sakhalin are quite similar to the Okhotsk people in Hokkaido in terms of not only cranial metric and nonmetric data but also limb bone measurements. The Sakhalin Okhotsk people show a close affinity in morphology with peoples in the northern Sakhalin and Amur Basin and differ from the Ainu in Hokkaido and Sakhalin. © 1994, The Anthropological Society of Nippon. All rights reserved.
Article
Six human skeletal remains, excavated by the late Prof. H. KONO from Eneolithic pit-graves at Bozuyama in Ebetsu (about 20km northeast of Sapporo), were measur-ed (Tables 1-3) and described. All the skeletons were found in extremely flexed position, with their heads turned to the south or southeast, and lying on their backs. The graves contained potsherds of the Kohoku and Hokudai types, which represent the epi-Jomon culture of northeast half of Hokkaido in early and middle parts of the first millennium A. D.Measurements of the best preserved adult male skull from burial No. VI-2 (Fig. 1-3, Table 1) were compared with those of adjacent racial groups of Hokkaido, Sakhalin, and Japan proper. The Bozuyama VI-2 skull showed the closest resem-blance to the contemporary Onkoromanai remains (YAMAGUCHI, 1963) from northern Hokkaido (Table 4 and Fig. 5 and 6). The author gave a common provisional des-ignation "the Onkoromanai type" to these two Eneolithic groups from central and northern parts of Hokkaido.The Onkoromanai type, which was tentatively represented by the average of three male skulls of Bozuyama and Onkoromanai (Table 4), was compared with the various recent and prehistoric races of Oceania, Far East, Northern Asia and Europe, by means of the shape distance of L. S. PENROSE (1954). The closest distances from the Onkoromanai type were found in the northern and eastern groups of Hokkaido Ainu, Kuril Ainu, Neolithic populations of Japanese mainland, and cromagnonoid types of Bronze Age southwestern Siberia and Neolithic Ukraina. On the other hand, the remotest distances were shown by the Mongoloid races of northeastern Asia, including the Sakhalin Gilyak. The Ainu of Sakhalin and southern Hokkaido, the recent Japanese, and many Oceanian groups showed intermediate distances (Table 5).In addition, reciprocal distances among eight representative groups were calcula-ted and illustrated (Table 6, Fig. 7). Remarkable mutual resemblances were found among four of them, i. e. the Onkoromanai type, the Kitami Ainu (northeast Hok-kaido), the Yoshiko (Neolithic shellmound of Japan), and the Andronovo (Bronze Age Minusinsk basin).
Article
Five skeletal remains of epi-Jomon and pre-Okhotsk period (approx. earlier half of the first millennium A. D.), excavated in 1959 from the Onkoromanai shell-mound near the Cape of Soya by Prof. S. Izumi and his staff of Tokyo University, were measured (see Table) and described.The major anthropological characteristics of these remains were : 1) mesocrany, with indices higher than the recent Hokkaido Ainu, 2) hypsicrany, in contrast to the orthocrany of recent Ainu, 3) longer frontal arc than the Ainu, 4) strongly bulging glabella, deeply subsiding nasion, and projecting nasal bones, as are common in the Ainu, 5) extremely low and wide face, 6) rectangular and very low orbit, 7) narrow nose compared to the breadth of the face, 8) coincidence of straight (nonainoid) and rounded (ainoid) lower margins of the mandible, 9) broad ramus and everting angle, 10) relatively long radius and tibia, and 11) flatness of long bones, with the exception of the femur, of which upper part of the shaft showed no flattening and middle part showed pilaster formation, as is usual among Japanese Jomon period femora.In these features, especially in 4, 5, 6 and 10, the Onkoromanai type was quite distinct from the Okhotsk-type such as found in Moyoro and Omisaki. On the other hand, it had much in common with the Ainu and the Japanese Jomon-type. The ainoid (4, 5, 6 and 10) and Jomon-type (1, 3, 4, 5, 10, 11) features were compounded in these skeletons. But the former was stronger rather than the latter. These results of comparisons seemed to suggest that the Onkoromanai type represented at least one of the ancestral forms of the Ainu race.When compared with the three major local types of the recent Ainu, i. e. of Hokkaido, Sakhalin, and Kuril, the closest resemblance was found to the Kuril Ainu of Shumshu Island. In order to illustrate the relative degree of affinity, the craniometric deviations of the Onkoromanai (2 males and 1 female) from the means of the Hokkaido Ainu (Yakumo cemetery in Southern Hokkaido, by WATANABE, 1938) were shown in Fig. 2, together with those of the Kuril Ainu (from Shumshu by KODAMA, 1940), Tsukumo (shell-mound of Jomon period in Japan by KIMONO & MIYAMOTO, 1926), Sakhalin Ainu (from Rorei cemetery of eastern coast by HIRAI, 1927), and Moyoro I (typical Okhotsk type from Moyoro shell-mound in Eastern Hokkaido by ITO, 1948).The remarkable resemblance between the Onkoromanai and the Kuril Ainu, as seen in Fig. 2, led the author to assume that the marginal Northern Kuril Islanders might be a survival of the ancestral form of the Ainu.
Article
Deciduous and permanent teeth from swine, monkeys, and humans, with dentin exposed by attrition, were studied histologically. Bacteria were present in exposed dentinal tubules, in cracks in dentin, and in necrotic pulp tissue. Remaining primary dentin and secondarily formed irritation dentin did not seem to protect the pulp entirely from exogenous irritants, and microscopic changes were observed in the pulp.