ArticlePDF Available

Vetiver grass ( Vetiveria zizanioides (L.) Nash) as trap plant for Chilo partellus (Swinhoe) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) and Busseola fusca (Fuller) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

Authors:

Abstract

The preference of lepidopterous stem borer moths to oviposit on certain wild host plants can be exploited in habitat management systems by using those hosts as trap crops. Vetiver grass (Vetiveria zizanioides (L.) Nash) was evaluated for its attractiveness and suitability to the pyralid Chilo partellus (Swinhoe) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) and the noctuid Busseola fusca (Fuller) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Two choice tests were conducted in the laboratory and in the greenhouse to determine oviposition choice of C. partellus for maize, Vetiver and rice (Oryza sativa L.), and of B. fusca for Vetiver and maize. C. partellus larval survival was evaluated in green house studies. Results indicated that C. partellus chose Vetiver grass over maize though larval survival on Vetiver was extremely low. B. fusca did not show any host preference.
Ann. soc. entomol. Fr. (n.s.), 2006, 42 (3-4) : 449-454
449
ARTICLE
Vetiver grass (Vetiveria zizanioides (L.) Nash) as trap plant for
Chilo partellus (Swinhoe) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) and Busseola
fusca (Fuller) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)
Abstract. The preference of lepidopterous stem borer moths to oviposit on certain wild host plants
can be exploited in habitat management systems by using those hosts as trap crops. Vetiver grass
(Vetiveria zizanioides (L.) Nash) was evaluated for its attractiveness and suitability to the pyralid Chilo
partellus (Swinhoe) (Lepidoptera: P yralidae) and the noctuid Busseola fusca (Fuller) (Lepidoptera:
Noctuidae). Two choice tests were conducted in the laboratory and in the greenhouse to determine
oviposition choice of C. partellus for maize, Vetiver and rice (Oryza sativa L.), and of B. fusca for Vetiver
and maize. C. partellus larval survival was evaluated in green house studies. Results indicated that C.
partellus chose Vetiver grass over maize though larval survival on Vetiver was extremely low. B. fusca
did not show any host preference.
Résumé. L e Vetiver (Ve tiveria zizan ioides (L . ) N as h) , p l an te pi èg e p ou r Chilo pa rtellus (Swinhoe)
(Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) et Busseola fusca (Fuller) (Lepidoptera : Noctuidae). La préférence
des lépidoptères foreurs de graminées à pondre sur certaines gaminées sauvages plutôt que sur
celles cultivées peut être exploitée dans un système de pratique culturale en utilisant ces graminées
sauvages comme plantes-pièges autour des cultures. L’attractivité du Vétiver (Vetiveria zizanioides
(L.) Nash) sur la ponte de Chilo partellus (Swinhoe) de Busseola fusca (Fuller) a été testée, de même
que sa faculté à permettre le développement de ces deux espèces. Des tests de choix binaire ont été
menés en laboratoire et en serre pour déterminer la préférence de ponte de C. partellus pour le maïs, le
Vétiver et le riz (Oryza sativa L.), et celle de B . fusca pour le Vétiver et le maïs. Les taux de survie des
larves de C. partellus ont été évalués en serre. Les résultats ont montré que les femelles de C. partellus
choisissent plutôt le Vétiver au maïs alors que le taux de survie larvaire y est extrêmement faible. B.
fusca n’a montré aucune préférence de ponte vis-à-vis du Vétiver.
Keywords: habitat management, host plant selection, preference-performance hypothesis, rice, trap crops.
J   B
School of Environmental Sciences and Development, North-West University, Private Bag X 6001, Potchefstroom, 2520, South Africa
E-mail: drkjvdb@puk.ac.za
Accepté le 29 juin 2006
The principle of trap cropping rests on the fact that
virtually all insects show a distinct preference for
certain plant species, cultivars or a certain crop stage
(Hokkanen 1991). Preferences of lepidopterous stem
borers for graminaceous plants have been reported for
Chilo partellus (Swinhoe) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) (van
den Berg et al. 2001; van den Berg 2006; Khan et al.
in press) and for Busseola fusca (Fuller) (Lepidoptera:
Noctuidae) (van den Berg et al. in press). Napier grass
(Pennisetum purpureum L.) and sorghum (Sorghum
spp.) were recommended as trap plants around maize
elds in habitat management systems for stem borers
in East and Southern Africa. While the attractiveness
of Napier grass for especially C. partellus have been
shown, its eff ect as trap crop could possibly also be
partly ascribed to its role as a barrier to moths infesting
elds outside (van den Berg et al. in press). Reduction
in stem borer infestation in maize fi elds surrounded
by wild grasses have also been reported by Khan et
al. (1997), Ndemah et al. (2002) and Midega et al.
(2005). Napier grass and forage sorghum are however
not always suitable to farming conditions in low
rainfall areas, or in farming systems where forages are
not important and where free grazing is practised.
Alternative trap crops need to be identifi ed that could
be used in systems where the use of Napier grasses and
forage sorghums is not feasible.
Vetiver grass (Chrysopogon zizanioides (L.) Roberty
=Vetiveria zizanioides (L.) Nash) is a species that is
used globally as soil erosion management tool and in
sustaining agricultural productivity (Grimshaw 2003).
Vetiver grass technology, in its most common form, is
the establishment of a narrow (less than 1 m wide) live,
stiff grass barrier, in the form of a hedge across the slope
of the land (Grimshaw 2003).  e easy availability of
Vetiver grass and its presence on contours between
crop fi elds in many African countries prompted
investigation into the possibility of using this grass as a
trap plant for stem borers in maize production systems.
Stem borers have been reported to damage Vetiver grass
in China where this grass is indigenous (Xinbao 1992).
450
J.   B
Paddy stem borers (Chilo spp.) have been reported to
infest culms and midribs of leaves wherever Vetiver was
planted in Southern China. An interesting observation
was that the levels of mortality amongst stem borer
larvae was high and in the worst case, approximately
39 % of Vetiver stems were damaged by the borer
but no pupae were found (Xinbao 1992), indicating
that larval survival in Vetiver is low. If the oviposition
choice of stem borer moths for Vetiver grass is high,
which seems to be suggested by these observations, the
possibility exists that it could be used as trap plants
around crops on which stem borers are a problem.
e aim of this study was to determine the oviposition
choice of B. fusca and C. partellus moths for Vetiver
grass and maize and to determine the survival of larvae
on this plant species.
Materials and methods
Laboratory trials: Two-choice bioassays
Oviposition choice tests were done in muslin cloth cages (50
x 55 x 75 cm). Each test was replicated three times. Cages
(replicates) were placed in the centre of a dark room with two
pots placed inside each cage. One pot contained a Vetiver plant
with 4–6 tillers and the other one 4-week old maize plant. Maize
of this age was used because B. fusca was previously observed to
prefer four to fi ve week old plants for oviposition (van Rensburg
et al. 1989) while C. partellus infest plants of any age (Seshu
Reddy et al. 1990; Singh & Sandhu 1978). Five pairs of adult
moths were released into the centre of each cage and allowed to
oviposit overnight before they were removed. Although this is
a high number of moths, not all of them were expected to be
of egg laying age since their mating status was not determined
before collection. Moths were collected in cages on the evening
of emergence from sorghum stalks collected from the fi eld.
Moths were therefore naive and had no oviposition experience.
Since C. partellus is known to attack rice (Seshu Reddy 1990),
a test was also conducted to determine the oviposition choice
of moths when presented with rice and Vetiver plants. One
rice variety (accession number 966) was used in this study.  e
procedure was identical to that described in the two-choice
test with maize.  e number of egg batches per plant, eggs per
batch and mean numbers of eggs per plant on the diff erent
plant species were recorded and subjected to Student t-tests to
determine if there were signifi cant diff erences.
Greenhouse trials: Larval survival on potted plants
In this experiment larval survival of C. partellus was determined
on Napier grass, Vetiver grass and maize plants growing in pots.
e objective was to compare larval survival on maize with that
on Vetiver and Napier grass, which is currently used in habitat
management for control of maize stem borers (Midega et al.
2005; van den Berg et al. 2001). Pots were kept in a greenhouse.
Each plant species was replicated ten times (10 pots) with one
plant per pot in a completely randomised design. Each plant
was infested with one egg batch in the black head stage when
maize plants were four weeks old. Each egg batch contained 30
eggs. Eggs were produced by wild moths that were collected
in cages in which sorghum stalks, collected from the fi eld,
were kept. Plants were kept in a greenhouse at 25 (±2) °C and
50–60 % relative humidity for 28 days after which they were
dissected to recover surviving larvae.  e number of surviving
larvae was calculated from the number of eggs put on plants.
e assumption was made that egg hatch was 100% and the
numbers of eggs was then taken to represent the number of
rst-instar larvae that there was on each plant after egg hatch.
Larval survival was expressed as a percentage of larvae recovered
after 28 days in relation to the number of fi rst- instar larvae
(number of eggs).
Data on mean percentage survival, calculated in terms of
number of eggs put on each plant were subjected to ANOVA
and means separated by means of the Tukey test.
Greenhouse trials: Two-choice bioassay
A two-choice experiment that involved more plants and larger
cages was subsequently conducted in a commercial green house
where plants were growing in the soil.  e aim was to determine
C. partellus oviposition choice and subsequent larval survival on
plants. Two rows of maize were planted on one side of a row of
established Vetiver grasswhile one row was planted on the other
side.  e inter-row spacing was 0.75 m with 30 cm between
plants and one plant per hill.  e Vetiver grass row was one
year old and had a dense stand of tillers. Six muslin cloth cages
(3.0 x 1.5 m x 1.5 m) were placed transversely over the three
rows of maize and one row of Vetiver grass when the maize
plants were fi ve weeks old.  e maize and Vetiver plants were
approximately 0.7 m and 1.0 m high respectively. Each cage
formed a replicate and enclosed within it an average of 14 maize
plants and a dense 1.2 m long row of Vetiver grass.  e surface
area inside the cage planted to maize and Vetiver was 2.25 and
0.60 m2 respectively. Twenty male and twenty female moths
were released into each cage and allowed to oviposit on plants
for two nights after which cages were removed.  e number of
egg batches and eggs per batch on maize was determined by
carefully inspecting the foliage of each maize plant. One half of
the Vetiver row in each cage was removed from the soil in order
to inspect each leaf for egg batches.  is was done to facilitate
nding of eggs which is diffi cult in the dense foliage of the
grass.  ere were approximately 54 tillers (splits) of Vetiver in
the half-row in each replicate. Leaves were removed from tillers
and checked for eggs.  e assumption was made that there
would be a similar number of eggs on the section of the row
that was not removed from the cage. All the maize plants were
left in each replicate. Data on mean number of egg batches and
mean numbers of eggs on maize and Vetiver was standardized
to numbers/m2 to facilitate comparison between the two plant
species. Data on mean numbers of egg batches, eggs per batch,
total number of eggs and larval survival were subjected to
Student t-tests to determine if diff erences were signifi cant.
Results
Moth oviposition preference and larval survival
Laboratory two-choice bioassays
Results from the two-choice experiment with B.
fusca indicated that there was no signifi cant diff erence
(t = 0.152; P = 0.886) between the number of egg
Vetiver grass as trap plant for Chilo partellus
451
batches per plant with 3.3 (S.E. ± 0.66) and 3.0 (S.E.
± 2.08) batches per plant recorded from maize and
Vetiver respectively. However, the number of eggs per
batch recovered from Vetiver were signifi cantly lower
than those on maize (t = 4.176; P = 0.013). Of the total
number of B. fusca eggs recorded in this experiment
92% was from maize. Results from the fi rst two-choice
experiment with C. partellus indicated that there were
signifi cantly more egg batches per plant on Vetiver (t =
–3.528; P = 0.024) (fi g.1) while egg batch size did not
diff er between maize and Vetiver plants (t = –0.231; P
= 0.828).  e average number of eggs per batch was 33
(S.E. ± 2.2) on maize and 34 (S.E. ± 3.2) on Vetiver.  e
numbers of eggs per plant was therefore signifi cantly
higher on Vetiver (t = 4.294; P = 0.012) with only 18
% of the eggs recorded on maize (fi g. 2).  e number of
C. partellus egg batches on rice was signifi cantly higher
(t = 3.283; P = 0.030) than on Vetiver. Rice plants
received an average of 16 (S.E. ± 3.7) egg batches per
plant while maize plants received only 4 (S.E. ± 0.6).
e total number of eggs per plant was also signifi cantly
lower on Vetiver (t = 3.752; P = 0.019) with 690 (S.E.
± 101.8) and 264 (S.E. ± 50.1) eggs per plant on rice
and Vetiver, respectively. However, egg batches were
signifi cantly larger on Vetiver (t = 2.893; P = 0.044)
with 65 (S.E. ± 3.5) and 44 (S.E. ± 6.1) eggs per batch
on Vetiver and rice, respectively.  e percentage larval
survival of C. partellus on potted plants 28 days after
infestation (DAI) diff ered signifi cantly (F = 572.1; P =
0.00001) among plant species (fi g. 3). On average 63.0
% and 2.8 % of larvae survived on maize and Napier
grass, respectively. No larvae survived on Vetiver grass.
Greenhouse bioassay: Oviposition data
Signifi cantly higher numbers of egg batches (t =
3.932; P = 0.002) were again recorded on Vetiver grass.
Only 4.3 % of the total number of egg batches was
laid on maize. In this experiment an average of 1.92
(S.E. ± 0.58) egg batches/m2 was laid on maize while
155.7 (S.E. ± 37.8) egg batches/m2 was laid on Vetiver.
e size of egg batches recovered on Vetiver was also
signifi cantly larger than those on maize (t = 3.449; P =
0.006), with 34 (S.E. ± 3.8) and 16 (S.E. ± 3.6) eggs
per batch for Vetiver and maize respectively. Of the
total number of eggs recorded in this experiment 96.3
% were laid on Vetiver which was signifi cantly higher
than that on maize plants (t = 2.600; P = 0.026) with
2716.8/m2 (S.E. ± 903.6) and 101.3/m2 (S.E. ±10.6)
being recorded on Vetiver and maize, respectively.
Greenhouse bioassay: Larval survival
e percentage of larval recovery from maize in
the greenhouse was signifi cantly higher (t = 6.098;
P = 0.0001) than on Vetiver.  e number of larvae
recovered 28 days after oviposition was 132 % (S.E. ±
21.6) on maize versus 0.56 % (S.E. ± 0.08) on Vetiver.
e recovery rate on maize was therefore 32 % higher
than the number of eggs recorded on maize plants.
Figure 3
Mean numbers of larvae recovered from maize and vetiver plants in a
greenhouse, 28 days after oviposition by Chilo partellus. (Bars indicate
Standard Error).
Figure 1
Mean number of egg batches per pot laid by Chilo partellus moths on maize
and vetiver in two-choice tests. (Bars indicate Standard Error).
Figure 2
Total number of eggs per pot laid by Chilo partellus moths on maize and
vetiver in two-choice tests. (Bars indicate Standard Error).
452
J.   B
Discussion
Busseola fusca moths chose to lay their eggs on maize
rather than on Vetiver.  e poor status of Vetiver as
ovipositional host is ascribed to the physical properties
of the plant and B. fusca oviposition behaviour. B. fusca
moths position egg batches between leaf sheaths and the
stem of host plants. Since Vetiver “stems” are composed
of a large number of tight-fi tting leaves with no real
stem, no suitable oviposition sites exist. Vetiver grass only
produce fl ower-bearing stems in more tropical areas.
Due to the low numbers of eggs recovered on Vetiver no
further studies were conducted with B. fusca. Both the
laboratory and green house experiments showed that C.
partellus moths chose to lay eggs on Vetiver grass and not
on maize.  e numbers of larvae recovered from Vetiver
plants in all the experiments were low. In the greenhouse
experiment more larvae were recovered from maize than
the number of eggs actually laid on plants. On maize
132 % of larvae was recovered and on Vetiver grass 0.56
%.  e high larval numbers on maize can be ascribed
to the unsuitability of Vetiver for fi rst instar larvae and
subsequent emigration of larvae from these plants to
maize.  is is probably due to high levels of larval spin-
off and mortality on this plant. After egg hatching many
rst-instar larvae were observed hanging on silk threads
from leaves.  e total number of larvae that could have
been recovered collectively from maize and Vetiver in
the experiment, if 100 % of larvae survived emigration
off Vetiver to maize, would have been 5778, but a total
of only 986 larvae were recovered from maize.  is
indicated that in spite of having a suitable host plant
(maize) next to the Vetiver plants, larval mortality was
still very high with 83 % of larvae not accounted for
at the end of the experiment.  e high preference and
low larval survival of C. partellus on Vetiver grass cannot
easily be explained.  ese observations do not support
the “preference-performance hypothesis” which states
that oviposition preference should correlate with host
suitability for off spring development, because females
get maximum fi tness by ovipositing on the optimal host
(Jaenike 1978). It has also been hypothesized that C.
partellus selects oviposition sites most suitable for egg
survival since larvae are mobile and could fi nd a suitable
host plant if eggs were laid in close proximity to host
plants (van den Berg & van der Westhuizen 1997).
Renswick & Chew (1994), in a review of oviposition
behaviour in Lepidoptera however observed that larvae
are relatively immobile and that the judicious choice
of a food plant and the oviposition step is of particular
importance in the Lepidoptera. Host specifi city may
however also play a role in these observed insect/
plant interactions.  e nature of oviposition choice
in Lepidoptera has been shown to be highly adaptive
with females choosing hosts on which larval survival is
superior to that on hosts rejected by females ( ompson
1988). Observations on C. partellus host selection
and off spring performance on sorghum lines with
diff erent levels of antibiosis resistance do not support
this (van den Berg & van der Westhuizen 1997).  e
latter authors reported C. partellus moth preference for
sorghum varieties with high levels of larval antibiosis. If
the host plants used in this study for C. partellus were
put in a preference hierarchy for oviposition it would be
rice << Vetiver << maize. Larval survival on rice was not
determined but survival rates on Vetiver approached
what is referred to by  ompson (1988) as one of the
extreme relationships between oviposition preference
and off spring performance where females oviposit on a
host that is fatal to the immatures.  e causes of good
or poor performance on a plant species in natural or
managed communities does not always result directly
from interactions between an insect and plant but
could be due to interactions with, amongst others,
abiotic diff erences in microhabitats in which the host
plant species grow ( ompson 1988).  e relationship
between preference and performance can vary under
diff erent ecological conditions and is infl uenced by
geographic variation in host use ( ompson 1988).  e
most feasible explanation for C. partellus behaviour on
Vetiver in this study is the eff ect of geography on the
growth pattern of the host plant which seldom fl owers
outside tropical areas. Vetiver produces fl owering stems
in its area of origin in which Chilo sp. is able to survive
in very low levels once they enter these stems.  is
aspect was however not addressed in this study. Low
levels of survival of Chilo spp. have been reported to
infest culms and midribs of leaves wherever Vetiver
was planted in Southern China (Xinbao 1992). Field
observations made by Shangwen (1999) and Zisong
(1991) in China showed high numbers of infested
Vetiver plants but low larval recovery.  e occurrence
of fully grown larvae of another Chilo sp., C. polychysus
(Meyrick), although in low numbers was reported on
Vetiver in Vietnam (Truong 2005a & b). Chilo partellus
is an alien invasive species in Africa. Chilo partellus is
from the Old World tropics, from where it dispersed
to East and Southern Africa during the fi rst half of the
twentieth century (Maes 1998). Similarly, Vetiver grass
originated in South Asia. India was most probably the
primary centre from where it may have dispersed to
other areas (Lavania 2000).  e strong preference of
C. partellus for Vetiver grass could therefore possibly be
ascribed to an old association between this insect and
Vetiver during the period before its current primary host
plants (maize, sorghum and rice) were domesticated.
Vetiver grass as trap plant for Chilo partellus
453
Although this study did not show that C. partellus
prefers Vetiver to rice the possibility exists that it and
also other Chilo spp. may choose Vetiver grass to other
rice varieties. Many Chilo spp., including the notorious
C. partellus attack rice in many parts of the world
(Seshu Reddy 1990). If Chilo spp. prefer Vetiver grass
it could have a potential as a trap crop around paddy
rice fi elds where it is used as fi eld boundaries and as
a soil conservation measure to protect rice from fl ood
damage during the rainy season (Huq 2000).
Vetiver grass has the most important characteristics
of a trap crop for C. partellus, i.e. it is highly attractive to
the target pest (Hokkanen 1991). Once oviposition has
taken place, the suitability of the host plant for larval
feeding and development is one of the most important
aspects of a plant’s potential as a trap crop (Hokkanen
1991). Poor larval survival and/or development are also
essential for a successful trap crop (Shelton & Nault
2004). If the trap crop has the additional quality that it
allows no or very low larval survival, it could be termed a
dead-end trap crop (Shelton & Nault 2004).  e overall
acceptability of the trap plant for feeding is therefore
also important (Potting et al. 2005) since it prevents the
possibility of larval emigration to neighbouring plants,
which may be the target food crop, as was observed in
the greenhouse study. Infestation levels in this study
were however abnormally high and natural enemies
that could have a huge impact on survival of migrating
larvae were absent from the study.
Conclusions
is study showed that the preference of
Lepidopterous stem borer moths to oviposit on
certain wild host plants can be exploited in habitat
management systems by using these preferred hosts
as trap crops in integrated management strategies for
stem borers. It also highlighted the phenomenon of
lack of correlation between moth preference for host
plants and performance of off spring that is sometimes
observed in the Lepidoptera.  e eff ect of Vetiver grass
as trap crop should be evaluated further and in fi eld
experiments under diff erent agro-ecological zones.
Furthermore, future studies should be conducted to
determined the potential of Vetiver as trap crop for
other Chilo spp., especially those that attack rice in
areas where Vetiver is indigenous.
Acknowledgements. e Gatsby Charitable Foundation
provided funding for this study.  e technical assistance of
Charles Midega is highly appreciated. Hanalene du Plessis and
Ursula du Plessis participated in conducting experiments and
data analyses.  e National Plant Genetic Resources Centre
of the National Department of Agriculture, Pretoria, provided
seed of rice.
References
Grimshaw R.G. 2003. e role of Vetiver grass in sustaining agricultural
productivity. (http://www.vet .org) (accessed on 24/04/2003).
Hokkanen H.M.T. 1991. Trap cropping in pest management. Annual
Review of Entomology 36: 119-138.
Huq F. 2000. Primary and secondary centres of origin of Vetiver and its
dispersion. Proceedings of the  ird International Vetiver Conference,
ailand – January 2000. (http://www.vetiver.com/TVN_IVC2/
ICV2_index.htm. accessed on 30 April 2003).
Jaenike J. 1978. On optimal oviposition behaviour in phytophagous
insects. eoretical Population Biolog y 14: 350-356.
Khan Z.R., Chiliswa P., Ampong-Nyarko K., Smart L.E., Polaszek A.,
Wandera J., Mulaa M.A. 1997. Utilization of wild graminaceous
plants for the management of cereal stem borers in Africa. Insect Science
and its Application 17: 143-150.
Khan Z.R., Midega C.A.O., Hutter N.J., Wilkins R.M., Wadhams L.J.
Assessment of the potential of Napier grass (Pennisetum purpureum)
varieties as trap plants for management of Chilo partellus. Entomologia
Experimentalis et Applicata (in press).
Lavania U.C. 2000. Primary and secondary centres of origin of Vetiver and its
dispersion. Proceedings of the  ird International Vetiver Conference,
ailand January 2000 (http://www.vetiver.com/TVN_IVC2/
ICV2_index.htm. accessed on 30 April 2003).
Maes K.V.N. 1998. Pyraloidea: Crambidae, Pyralidae, p. 87–98 in:
Polaszek A. (ed.), Cereal stem borers in Africa: Economic importance,
Taxonomy, Natural enemies and Control. International Institute of
Entomology, CAB International, Wallingford, UK, 530 p.
Midega C.A.O., Khan Z.R., van den Berg J., Ogol C.K.P.O. 2005.
Habitat management and its impact on maize stemborer colonisation
and crop damage levels in Kenya and South Africa. African Entomology
13: 333-340.
Ndemah R., Gounou S., Schulthess F. 2002. e role of wild grasses in
the management of Lepidopterous stem-borers on maize in the humid
tropics of western Africa. Bulletin of Entomological Research 92: 507-519.
Potting R.P.J., Perry J.N., Powell W. 2005. Insect behavioural ecology
and other factors aff ecting the control effi cacy of agroecosystem
diversifi cation strategies. Ecological Modelling 182: 199-216.
Renswick J.A.A., Chew F.S. 1994. Oviposition behavior in Lepidoptera.
Annual Review of Entomology 39: 377-400.
Shelton A.M., Nault B.A. 2004. Dead-end trap cropping: a technique
to improvemanagement of diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella
(Lepidoptera: Plutellidae). Crop Protection 23: 497-503.
Seshu Reddy K.V. 1990. Cultural control of Chilo spp. in graminaceous
crops. Insect Science and its Application 11: 703-712.
Seshu Reddy K.V., Lubega M.C., Sum K.O.S. 1990. Population patterns
of Chilospp. in sorghum, maize and millets. Insect Science and its
Application 11: 549-554.
Shangwen C. 1999. Insects on Vetiver hedges. e Vetiver Newsletter 23:
17-18.
Singh G., Sandhu G.S. 1978. Oviposition behaviour of maize borer, Chilo
partellus (Swinhoe) in the fi eld. Indian Journal of Agriculture 40: 191–196.
ompson J.N. 1988. Evolutionary ecology of the relationship between
oviposition preference and performance of off spring in phytophagous
insects. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 47: 23-14.
Truong P.N.V. 2005a. Report on the visit to Vietnam, 2-22 January 2005.
Vetiverim 32: 2-9.
Truong P.N.V. 2005b. Photographs of the Report on the visit to Vietnam,
January 2005. Vetiverim 33: 9.
454
J.   B
Van den Berg J. 2006. Oviposition preference and larval survival of
Chilo partellus (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) on Napier grass (Pennisetum
purpureum) trap crops. International Journal of Pest Management 52:
39-44.
Van den Berg J., van der Westhuizen M.C. 1997. Chilo partellus
(Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) moth and larval response to levels of
antixenosis and antibiosis in sorghum inbred lines under laboratory
conditions. Bulletin of Entomological Research 87: 541-545.
Van den Berg J., Rebe M., de Bruyn J., van Hamburg H. 2001.
Developing habitat management systems for graminaceous stem borers
in South Africa. Insect Science and its Application 21: 381-388.
Van den Berg J., De Bruyn A.J.M., van Hamburg H. Oviposition
preference andsurvival of the maize stem borer, Busseola fusca
(Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) on Napier grasses (Pennisetum spp.) and
maize. African Entomology. (in press).
Van Rensburg J.B.J., Walters M.C., Giliomee J.H. 1989. Selective
oviposition by the maize stalk borer, Busseola fusca (Fuller) (Lepidoptera:
Noctuidae). Journal of the Entomological Society of southern Africa 52:
105-108.
Xinbao Z. 1992. Vetiver grass in P.R. China. Vetiver Newsletter 8: 134-138.
Zisong W. 1991. Excerpts from the experiments and popularization of
Vetiver grass, Nanpang Prefecture, Fujian Province, China. Vetiver
Newsletter 6: 105-108.
... Chilo partellus infestation patterns in wild and cultivated host plants have been studied by Rebe et al. (2004a, b). Behavioural responses of moths to resistant and susceptible sorghum varieties , vetiver grass (Berg, 2006a), napier grass (Berg, 2006b) and Mutyambai et al. (2015). Electrophysiological studies have been conducted on the sensory biology of larvae (Waladde et al., 1990) and moths (Waladde, 1993;Birkett et al., 2006). ...
... The push-pull system developed in Kenya has been shown to not only contribute to reduced pest infestation levels but also to improve crop system health (Khan et al., 1997;Khan and Pickett, 2003;Midega et al., 2005;Hailu et al., 2018). Vetiver grass, which is highly preferred by moths for oviposition, is also used a trap crop for other Chilo spp. in China (Berg et al., 2003;Berg, 2006a;Lu et al., 2015;. Trap cropping was also investigated as a management tool in India (Jindal et al., 2012). ...
Article
This datasheet on Chilo partellus covers Identity, Overview, Distribution, Dispersal, Hosts/Species Affected, Diagnosis, Biology & Ecology, Environmental Requirements, Natural Enemies, Impacts, Uses, Prevention/Control, Further Information.
... These border crops and intercrops may serve as habitats to rodent pests that are also potential reservoirs of infectious bacteria. For instance, hedges of vetiver grass (Vetiveria zizanoides), which serve as a trap crop for cereal stem borers (van den Berg 2006), are considered by some as shelters for rodents, while others consider they are repellent for both rodents and snakes (Grimshaw and Faiz 1995). ...
... Benefits other than mere limitation of soil water erosion were reported by Ratnadass et al. (2012b), who indicated significant reduction in pollution levels of run-off water in conservation agriculture systems in Madagascar (Ratnadass et al., 2012b). Another example of the additional benefits of PSD in terms of limiting soil erosion and providing pest management services is that by Van den Berg (2006) and Van den Berg et al. (2003), who suggested the planting of Vetiver grass (Chrysopogon zizanioides) (Poaceae), which is commonly used as soil erosion management measure, for managing corn and rice stem borers. ...
Article
It has been suggested that increasing plant species diversity (PSD) in agroecosystems at different spatiotemporal scales reduces the impacts of crop pests and diseases as well as the dependence on synthetic plant protection products. This principle was applied to a range of tropical case studies. These studies involved various pests and pathogens with contrasting life history traits, different cropping systems (a cereal crop in conservation agriculture, vegetable crops in rotational and trap cropping systems, perennial crops in agroforestry) and various spatial scales of PSD deployment (field and farmscape). Here we review the outcomes of these studies, and discuss the lessons learned regarding synergies and tradeoffs associated with regulation effects provided by PSD. The major points are: 1) results contributed to solve local crop pest and disease problems such as bacterial wilt on tomato in Martinique, scarab beetles and witchweed on upland rice in Madagascar, fruitworms on tomato in Martinique and okra in Niger, fruit flies on cucurbit vegetables in Reunion, mirid bugs and black pod rot on cocoa in Cameroon, berry borer and leaf rust on coffee in Costa Rica; 2) the importance of cross-cutting issues regarding green manure, cover crops or companion plants across case studies at the field scale involving below-ground and aerial processes, were highlighted, particularly that of the within-species genetic variation of these plants; 3) based on the fruitworm/tomato case study, a dynamic and spatially-explicit individual-based model was developed as a generic tool to improve understanding of system functioning by assessing infestation patterns in response to main crop/trap crop relative attractiveness, spatiotemporal deployment of the main crop/trap crop and insect behavioral traits; 4) tradeoffs were highlighted regarding pest and disease complex management, single-option pest and disease control via several pathways based on a single PSD-deployment measure and other ecosystem services and disservices at various scales.
Article
Full-text available
This review describes global rice stemborer assemblages based on published species distributions, apparent host preferences, and reported shifts in assemblage composition in response to environmental factors. At least 56 moth (Lepidoptera: Crambidae, Pyralidae, Noctuidae) and fly (Diptera: Diopsidae, Chloropidae) species have been associated with rice; however, only 21 species are of potential, large-scale economic importance with a further 2 species of localized concern; most of the remaining species’ associations with rice are based on dubious records without economic impacts on rice production. A list of stemborer–host associations indicates that rice stemborers are largely oligophagous on grasses (Poaceae), but a few species are polyphagous (also attacking Cyperaceae, Typhaceae, and some Eudicotyledon plants). Total stemborer abundance is determined by rice cropping patterns and management. Assemblage species richness is determined by geographical location, surrounding habitat (particularly as regards secondary and occasional species), and season. Evidence suggests that stemborer assemblage structure is largely determined through conditional interspecific competition. Regional assemblages typically include a single dominant lepidopteran species (primary species) that is largely restricted to rice and for which the climate is optimal; one or more secondary species that vary based on the age of rice attacked, rice anatomy, and the proximity to other habitats (including other crops); and occasional species that probably spill over from adjacent grasslands. The co-occurrence of lepidopteran with dipteran rice stemborers requires further research attention.
Article
Full-text available
Land pollution at gold mine dumps requires sustainable rehabilitation. A study was conducted at Muriel gold mine, Zimbabwe to investigate the integrated effects of dump age, topographic position and soil depth on chemical degradation, and vetiver grass (Vetiveria zizanioides) performance. The triplicated experiment was set up as a split–split plot, where dump age (fresh dump, old dump and reference site) was the main treatment; topographic position (upper, middle, lower) was the sub treatment and soil layer (0–20 cm, 20–50 cm) was the sub–subtreatment. Samples collected from soil layers were analysed for total lead (Pb), zinc (Zn) and iron (Fe), pH, and salinity. Irrigated vetiver growth was monitored over 12 weeks through measuring changes in height, rooting depth, and shoot numbers. The old dump was acidic (pH = 4.30 ± 0.207); fresh dump alkaline (pH = 8.32 ± 0.142) and reference site slightly alkaline (pH = 7.9 ± 0.09). Salinity was highest in the 20–50 cm layers on old dump lower slopes due to salt concentrating processes of: evaporation, metal dissolution, and translocation of cyanidation effluents. Total Pb, Zn, and Fe concentrations were highest (p < 0.05) at the old dump; lower (p < 0.05) in the 0–20 cm layers and differed (p < 0.05) in the order: upper < middle < lower slope. Soil Zn and Pb concentrations exceeded safe limits at lower slope positions of both dumps. Vetiver growth parameters were 1.5–3 times higher (p < 0.05) on the reference site compared with the dumps. Sterilisation of gold dumps was determined by chemical transformation and translocation processes on the landscape. Expeditious biological rehabilitation of dumps is recommended to evade unsuitable conditions created by rapid acidification.
Article
Full-text available
Achieving food security remains a pressing challenge for small-scale farmers, especially in sub-Saharan Africa and Latin America. Ongoing climate change, invasive noxious weeds, and crop pests further exacerbate the situation. Optimizing traditional cropping systems for sustainable yields and climate-resilient production is imperative in order to address this challenge. The pre-Columbian milpa system of intercropping maize with companion crops such as beans ( Phaseolus vulgaris ) and squash ( Cucurbita spp.) is one effective system that has been shown to produce outstanding yields per unit area compared to monoculture systems. The Push-Pull Technology developed in East Africa, based on the use of repellent and trap companion plants intercropped with maize (and to a lesser extent sorghum), is seen to be similarly effective in minimizing the impact of major pests on yields, including striga weed ( Striga spp.), maize stemborers, and the fall armyworm ( Spodoptera frugiperda ). Although both systems have the potential to compensate for each other’s limitations, there has been no cross-system learning between the Mesoamerican milpa and the East African Push-Pull Technology. Here, we review both systems and present the advantages likely to be obtained by combining these technologies in small-scale farming. The proposed milpa push-pull system could adapt to different gradients of altitude, rainfall, and soil nutrient levels, in addition to controlling pests, and therefore has the potential to become a fundamental cropping technique in Latin America and sub-Saharan Africa.
Preprint
Full-text available
Land pollution at gold mine dumps requires sustainable rehabilitation. A study was conducted at Muriel gold mine, Zimbabwe to investigate the integrated effects of dump age, topographic position and soil depth on chemical degradation and vetiver grass ( Vetiveria zizanoides ) performance. The triplicated experiment was set up as a split-split plot, where the fresh dump, old dump and reference site were the main treatments; topographic position (upper, middle, lower) was the sub treatment and soil layer (0-20cm, 20-50cm) was the sub-sub treatment. Samples collected from soil layers were analysed for total lead(Pb), zinc(Zn) and iron(Fe), pH and salinity. Irrigated vetiver growth was monitored over 12 weeks through measuring changes in height, rooting depth and shoot numbers. The old dump was acidic (pH = 4.30 ± 0.207); fresh dump alkaline (pH = 8.32 ± 0.142) and reference site was neutral (pH = 7.9 ± 0.09). Salinity was highest in the 20-50cm layers on old dump lower slopes due to salt concentrating processes of: evaporation, metal dissolution and translocation of cyanidation effluents. Total Pb, Zn and Fe concentrations were highest (p < 0.05) at the old dump; lower (p < 0.05) in the 0-20cm layers and differed (p < 0.05) in the order: upper < middle < lower slope. Soil Zn and Pb concentrations exceeded safe limits at lower slope positions of both dumps. Vetiver growth parameters were 1.5-3 times higher (p < 0.05) on the reference site compared with the dumps. Sterilisation of gold dumps was determined by chemical transformation and translocation processes on the landscape. Expeditious biological rehabilitation of dumps is recommended to evade unsuitable conditions created by rapid acidification.
Article
Full-text available
Possibilities to combine augmentative biological control using Trichogramma spp. egg parasitoids and conservation biological control through habitat manipulation, for the management of rice leaffolder and rice stemborer pests have received only cursory mention in the literature. We reviewed information on the use of Trichogramma releases and on habitat manipulation to manage leaffolders and stemborers in rice. Stemborers have become a priority for biological control since the 1990s with research focusing mainly on Chilo suppressalis in China and Iran, Scirpophaga incertulas in South and Southeast Asia, and Chilo agamemnon in Egypt. In most cases, 100 K wasps (T. japonicum or T. chilonis) released over 30–100 release points ha−1 at least once during early crop stages, resulted in good control (>50% reduction in damage). Despite positive results accumulated over decades, larger scale releases in rice have only been conducted very recently. Research on conservation biological control of stemborers has focused on manipulating rice field habitat, particularly along rice bunds (levees). Several studies reported higher Trichogramma densities or greater egg parasitism in rice fields with flowering plants on bunds compared to control fields (without bund vegetation and usually with insecticides). These trends have mainly been attributed to nectar as a supplementary food for the adult wasps, although evidence for this mechanism is weak. Trap plants, such as vetiver grass (Chrysopogon zizanioides) attract ovipositing stemborers, but suppress larval development. Repellent and banker plants have not yet been identified for rice stemborers or leaffolders. We outline the opportunities and challenges for combining augmentative and conservation biological control of leaffolders and stemborers in rice.
Article
Full-text available
Une revue bibliographique récente montre que les pratiques de protection agroécologique des cultures (PAEC) contre les ravageurs, pathogènes et adventices, réduisent généralement les risques zoonotiques viraux en santé publique et vétérinaire, alors que les pratiques conventionnelles (à base agrochimique) tendent à les augmenter. Nous avons analysé la littérature scientifique pour déterminer si ces conclusions pouvaient être élargies aux infections bactériennes, avec focus sur les agroécosystèmes tropicaux. En santé publique et vétérinaire, les principales infections bactériennes impactées par des pratiques de protection des cultures sont celles ayant pour réservoirs des rongeurs (avec arthropodes vecteurs, comme la peste, ou pas, comme la leptospirose), et les maladies à entérobactéries ( e.g. , Salmonella ) et autres bactéries opportunistes ( e.g. , Pseudomonas ). La problématique d’antibiorésistance en santé publique est peu affectée par les pratiques de protection des cultures conventionnelles. Des pratiques relevant de la substitution aux intrants de synthèse (variétés résistantes aux attaques de rongeurs ou à la colonisation par des entérobactéries ; pesticides minéraux; solarisation) peuvent se traduire par une réduction plus importante du risque sanitaire que certaines pratiques relevant de la reconception des agroécosystèmes (push-pull ; intégration agriculture-élevage). Toutefois, vu ses effets vertueux en termes de réduction des pollutions, conservation de la biodiversité et résilience climatique, la PAEC, basée sur la reconception, contribue, à des échelles spatiotemporelles supérieures, à la réduction du risque sanitaire lié aux infections bactériennes. Les impacts des pratiques de protection des cultures, basées sur l’amélioration de l’efficience des pratiques conventionnelles, sur la substitution ou sur la reconception, sur les risques d’infection bactérienne en santé publique et vétérinaire, sont sensiblement différents de ceux observés avec les risques zoonotiques viraux. Des recherches sont encore nécessaires pour concilier, dans une perspective « Une seule santé », les trois types de pratiques, afin de réduire les risques sanitaires liés aux maladies infectieuses autant à bactéries qu’à virus, parasites (protozoaires et vers) ou champignons.
Article
Full-text available
Use of non-glossy collards as a trap crop for control of the diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella (L.), in commercial fields of cabbage in New York was unsuccessful because it neither reduced the number of larvae on cabbage nor concentrated the insects on collards. In laboratory and outdoor screenhouse experiments, P. xylostella preferentially laid its eggs on the glossy-type Barbarea vulgaris, a common biennial weed, when compared with broccoli and cabbage. Ovipositional preference in the screenhouse trials varied from 24 to 66 fold for B. vulgaris. However, no larvae were able to develop on B. vulgaris. More importantly, cabbage plants in screenhouses with B. vulgaris had fewer eggs laid on them than cabbage plants in screenhouses without B. vulgaris. We therefore suggest that B. vulgaris, or another plant species that is highly attractive for egg laying, but on which P. xylostella larvae do not survive, may serve as a ‘dead-end’ trap crop and be more successful than trap crop types that may only have increased oviposition. However, candidate dead-end trap crops must also be evaluated for their effects on other insects, diseases and weed management before such plants can be recommended in an overall pest management program.
Article
Full-text available
Napier grass, Pennisetum purpureum, is used successfully as a trap crop for lepidopterous stem borers in Africa. This paper reports on the evaluation of the suitability of Napier grass varieties as trap crops for Busseola fusca (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). This was done through oviposition preference tests and evaluation of larval survival on different varieties. Napier grass varieties were collected from the wild, from research institutions and farmers growing them as forage crops. In multiple-choice tests with the different Napier grass varieties, differences in oviposition preference were observed. Results from two-choice tests with Napier grass and maize plants indicated B. fusca moths have no marked difference in oviposition preference. However, compared to maize, larval survival on Napier grasses was low and a rapid decline in larval numbers was observed over the first week after inoculation on the grasses. A scanning electron microscope study of trichomes on Napier grass and maize leaves was conducted and the relationship between trichome number and larval survival determined. Significant negative correlations (P < 0.03) were observed between trichome numbers and larval survival.
Article
Full-text available
We carried out an assessment of the impact of a diversionary maize stemborer management system on pest colonization, crop damage levels and crop yields. In this system, ovipositing moths are repelled by an intercrop and subsequently attracted to a discard perimeter crop. Studies were conducted at two sites in western Kenya and one site in South Africa. Treatments comprised two fields of maize intercropped with desmodium, and a Napier grass perimeter ('push-pull' system) and two fields of maize monocrop. Treatments were laid out in a completely randomized design at each site. Maize stemborer colonization, oviposition preference and incidence of stemborer larvae and pupae were significantly lower in 'push-pull' plots than maize monocrop plots at all sites. Similarly, the various crop damage levels were for most part significantly higher in maize monocrop than 'push-pull' plots. Maize yield per plant and per plot were mostly significantly higher in 'push-pull' than maize monocrop plots.
Article
Full-text available
The paper summarizes research results and field observations of the use of vetiver grass, Vetiveria zizanioides, and indicates its use as an important and effective vegetative hedge that when grown on the contour significantly reduces the flow of sediment from eroding sites and reduces runoff, both simultaneously, and at a low cost, compared to more traditional engineered practices. Vetiver grass has unique characteristics. The paper also sets out evidence that vetiver grass grows over a wide range of site conditions; is non competitive with adjacent crops; is not a weed; is resistant to pests and diseases; is used as a fodder for livestock; is used for stabilizing earth embankments, drainage lines, roads etc.; is fire resistant and is known to repel rodents; and needs minimum maintenance. The main impediment to extending its use and application is because of poor technology transfer systems, and the lack of training of farmers and technicians.
Article
Full-text available
The stemborers Busseola fusca (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) and Chilo partellus (Lepidoptera: Crambidae) are important pests of maize and sorghum in South Africa. A habitat management system for these pests is being developed in the Northern Province of South Africa. This management system is similar to the one used in eastern Africa, where host and non-host plants of stemborers are used to repel moths away from the main crop and attract them to highly attractive trap plants. To identify possible trap crops, a survey of wild host plants of stemborers was undertaken in the Northern Province of South Africa and several new host plants were recorded. As a possible trap crop for stemborers, various Napier grass (Pennisetum purpureum) varieties were evaluated for oviposition preference by Ch. partellus moths and subsequent larval survival on those varieties. Few larvae survived longer than 15 days after inoculation onto Napier grass plants. A survey was conducted of farming practices that would affect the adoption of habitat management strategies. The high usage of tractors for ploughing may have a negative effect on adoption of perennial intercrops in a habitat management system. The common practice of free grazing animals also reduced the fodder value and benefit of trap crops. The value of Napier grass does not only lie in its use as trap crop but also as a measure to limit soil erosion and as animal feed.
Article
Recent research on the genetics, distribution, and taxonomy of vetiver grass (Chrysopogon zizanioides (L.) Roberty; syn. Vetiveria zizanioides (L.) Nash) provides a context for clarifying its origins and diversity. Current evidence helps us begin to unravel the genesis of nonfertile vetivers, while their ancient diaspora ensures they are a heritage common to us all. Vetiver technology itself is in the public domain, which yields another fundamental advantage to users. While proprietary opportunities exist, our principal of sharing benefits the public good, and continuation of this tradition is encouraged.
Article
The paper reviews the work done on the population patterns of Chilo spp. in relation to the phenological stages of sorghum, maize and millets. The stem borer Chilo partellus entered sorghum and maize crops at 2–3 weeks after emergence and continued till harvest. There were 3–4 peaks of larval population during a cropping season. Such studies not only reveal the relationship between the larval population density and the phenological stage of the plants at infestation time, but are also helpful in scheduling and timing pest management strategies.
Article
Living grass barriers can effectively reduce soil erosion on hillsides under cassava [Manihot esculenta Crantz]. Competition below ground in barrier-crop systems is, however, poorly understood. The objectives of this study were, therefore, (i) to describe rooting patterns and spatial root distribution of cassava and of grasses commonly used as live barriers in soil conservation, and (ii) to determine root growth dynamics over time, using direct observation and quantitative methods. Field research was carried out near Santander de Quilichao, Colombia, on a Typic Dystropept soil where average annual precipitation is 1799 mm. Single 20-m rows of vetiver grass [Vetiveria zizanioides (L.) Nash], lemon grass [Cymbopogon citratus (DC. ex Nees) Stapf] and guatemala grass [Tripsacum andersonii J.R. Gray] were grown on a 13% slope. Cassava was planted in rows on either side of the grass barriers. Observation pits were dug in the cassava-grass plots and perspex sheets fitted closely to exposed walls. These pits allowed periodic tracing of roots. Root length was recorded in metres either per total of an exposed surface measuring 0.8 (depth) and 1.2 m (width) or measuring 0.2 (depth) × 1.2 m (width). Because of their vertical growth and their weak tendency to branch, the roots of vetiver grass rarely mixed with cassava roots, signifying a largely separate soil exploration by the two plants. In contrast, the profuse vertical and horizontal spread of guatemala grass and cassava roots indicated a joint exploration of soil volume. The cassava-lemon grass system revealed an intermediate pattern. The longest roots per exposed area of 0.2 × 1.2 m were observed for cassava growing on both sides of the vetiver grass barrier, and increasing from 6.0 m in the 0–20 cm profile segment to 7.3 m in the 20–40 cm segment. In contrast, roots of cassava with guatemala grass shortened from 5.4 m in the uppermost profile segment to 3.6 m in the 20–40 cm segment. Vetiver grass exhibited the slowest and steadiest root growth and guatemala grass the fastest. Final total root lengths obtained from the entire exposed soil profile were 7 m for vetiver grass, 16 m for guatemala grass and 17 m for lemon grass. Cassava root growth was very slow initially, but increased 25–28 weeks after grass planting when grass root growth temporarily slowed down as a result of cutback. Final total cassava root lengths obtained from the exposed soil profile were 17, 10 and 10 m in association with the three grasses, respectively. The differences in rooting pattern, root growth dynamics and final root lengths suggest that different degrees of root interaction may have occurred, with possible consequences for soil exploration, and nutrient and water uptake.
Article
Through repeated sampling in maize planted on different dates over different seasons in South Africa, it was shown that damage by Busseola fusca (Fuller) to plant parts other than the whorl had an important influence on yield. Damage to plants in the period after tasselling was shown to be important. The number of larvae in the plant was a weak estimator of expected yield losses.