ArticlePDF Available

Toxicity and risks with T-2 and HT-2 toxins in cereals

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The trichothecenes T-2 and HT-2 toxins have during recent years been found frequently in cereals grown in Europe. They are mainly produced by Fusarium langsethiae. High concentrations of the toxins are most commonly found in oats, but they are also detected frequently at lower concentrations in barley. Wheat is only rarely contaminated. Yearly surveys of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in oats from Northern Europe have shown that the occurrence and levels have increased from 2002, with very high levels in 2005-2007, followed by a decrease in 2008-2009.Raw oats delivered to mills for processing to food have also been highly contaminated with T-2 and HT-2 toxins during the period 2006-2009. The processing of oats in the mills by sorting-sieving and dehulling reduce the toxin concentrations in the final food products, flakes and meals, with more than 80% even at high levels in the raw oat. The concentrations of the toxins in the by-products from the process are instead increased. The by-products are mainly used as feed components.The toxic effects of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in animals and the toxicological information used in the risk evaluations are briefly described. Risk evaluations of the toxins in cereals for human consumption have been conducted by both EU-Scientific Committee on Food and by JECFA in 2001. Both evaluations resulted in the same temporary tolerable daily intake (t-TDI) for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxins. The group TDI for T-2 and HT-2 toxins, alone or in combination, became 60 ng/kg bw and day.The intake of T-2 and HT-2 toxins through oats is calculated from median concentrations in oat products and median consumption data from Norway. The intake was found to be 1.5-5.4% of the t-TDI.The toxic effects studied or expected in farm animals, horses and ruminants, consuming high amounts of oat in their feed are described and discussed.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
TOXICITY AND RISKS WITH T-2 AND HT-2 TOXINS IN CEREALS
Pettersson, H.
Department of Animal Nutrition and Management, Swedish University of Agricultural
Sciences, P. O. Box 7024, SE-750 07 Uppsala, Sweden
The trichothecenes T-2 and HT-2 toxins have during recent years been found frequently
in cereals grown in Europe. They are mainly produced by Fusarium langsethiae. High
concentrations of the toxins are most commonly found in oats, but they are also detected
frequently at lower concentrations in barley. Wheat is only rarely contaminated with the
toxins and then at low levels. Yearly surveys of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in oats from
Northern Europe have shown that the occurrence and levels have increased from 2002,
with very high levels in 2005-2007, followed by a decrease in 2008-2009.
Raw oats delivered to mills for processing to food have also been highly contaminated
with T-2 and HT-2 toxins during the period 2006-2009. The decrease during the last
years can also be seen. The processing of oats in the mills by sorting-sieving and
dehulling reduce the toxin concentrations in the final food products, flakes and meals,
with more than 80 % even at high levels in the raw oat. The concentrations of the toxins
in the by-products from the process are instead increased. The by-products are mainly
used as feed components. The concentrations of T-2 and HT-2 in oats and oat products
will be summarized.
The toxic effects of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in animals and the toxicological information
used in the risk evaluations will be briefly described. Risk evaluations of the toxins in
cereals for human consumption have been conducted by both EU-Scientific Committee
on Food and by JECFA in 2001. Both evaluations resulted in the same tolerable daily
intake (TDI) for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxins. The group TDI for T-2 and HT-2
toxins, alone or in combination, became 60 ng/kg bw and day.
The intake of T-2 and HT-2 toxins through oats is calculated from median
concentrations in oat products and consumption by exposed population. Intake by
normal and high consumers of oat are compared with the TDI.
The toxic effects studied or expected in farm animals, horses and ruminants, consuming
high amounts of oat in their feed are described and discussed.
Key words: T-2 toxin, HT-2 toxin, Fusarium langsethiae, oats, toxin contamination,
toxicity, risk
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Introduction
Cereal plants are worldwide infected with different Fusarium species and some of them
e.g. F. graminearum, F. culmorum are associated with plant diseases like Fusarium head
blight and grain contamination with toxins. Other Fusarium species e.g. F. poae, F.
langsethiae do not produced clear pathogenic symptoms but may still produce toxins.
The trichothecene deoxynivalenol mainly produced by F. graminearum is the most
frequently found fusarium toxin and present at the highest concentrations in especially
wheat. The more toxic trichothecenes T-2 and HT-2 toxins have during recent years
been found also frequently in cereals grown in Europe (Edwards et al. 2009, Pettersson
et al. 2008). They are mainly associated with F. langsethiae, but may be produced also
by F. sporotrichioides in cereals from East and South Europe. T-2 and HT-2 toxins have
most frequently been found at highest concentrations in oats followed by barley. Wheat
is much less contaminated.
Tricothecenes in cereals were risk evaluated by the EU Scientific Committee on Food
(SCF 2001) and JECFA (Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives) in
2001. A combined provisional tolerable daily intake (p-TDI) of 0.06 µg/kg body weight
and day was established for T-2 and HT-2 toxins, since T-2 toxin is readably converted
into HT-2 toxin after consumption.
The European Union has introduced maximal tolerable levels of deoxynivalenol in
cereals intended for food and recommendation on guidance levels in feed (EC 2006a,b).
There are currently no legal limits for T-2 and HT-2 toxins in food or feed, although the
intention to introduce such is indicated in the legislation. The time table for introduction
has been prolonged, partly due to the high occurrence of the toxins in oats.
This paper will give a review of the occurrence of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in European
cereals, effect of processing, their toxicity and risks for human and animals.
Occurrence
Surveys of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in European cereals during the 1990-ties as reported by
SCOOP 2003 and JECFA 2001 showed that the toxins occurred most frequently in oats
followed by barley and maize. Wheat was much less contaminated. The mean levels for
the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxins were generally relatively low (< 100 µg/kg) although
some max values in certain oat samples exceeded 1000 µg T-2+HT-2/kg. The surveys of
trichothecenes in cereals continued in Scandinavia and started in UK during the period
2000 to 2009. Results from the surveys of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in oats are presented in
table 1. High and increasing levels of T-2 and HT-2 toxins were found in oats from
Scandinavia and UK in 2002 to 2006. Thirty-three to 44 % of the samples from UK,
Finland, and Sweden exceeded 500 µg T-2+HT-2/kg during at least one year. Median
levels above 200 µg/kg were recorded and max concentrations up to 9990 µg/kg were
found. The levels decreased in oats from all survey countries during the period 2007-
2009.
The European Breakfast Cereal Association (CEEREAL) has analyzed T-2 and HT-2
toxins in 235 samples of raw oats delivered to their mills during 2006-2009 (Pettersson
2010). The overall median level was only 44 µg T-2+HT-2/kg with a max value of
841µg/kg in 20006. The decrease in the levels during 2008-2009 compared to 2006-
2007 was clear.
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Barley and wheat have also been analyzed for T-2 and HT-2 toxins in Scandinavia, UK
and France during several years in the period 2000-2009. Concentrations above 50 µg T-
2+HT-2/kg have only rarely been detected in wheat. Barley samples above that level
occurred more frequently, but most positive samples had a concentration below. In the
French surveys of spring barley such low levels were frequently detected (Orlando et al.
2010). The adjusted mean concentrations for the years 2006-2008 were between 19 and
22 µg T-2+HT-2/kg. The toxins were much less frequently detected in winter barley
although fewer samples had been analyzed.
All oats for human consumption are processed in mills. Oats are cleaned by screening,
dehulled, sorted and flaked or milled. T-2 and HT-2 toxin concentration in the final
products used for food are reduced by an average of 80% during especially the dehulling
step. The effect of processing on the toxin levels in oats from UK mills are in detail
described by Scudamore et al. 2007. The toxin levels in the by-products (husks, debris,
small kernels) often used for feed will instead increase by on an average up to 3 times
compared to the raw oats.
The CEEREAL has also analyzed T-2 and HT-2 toxins in the oat-flakes and oat by-
products obtained in their mills during 2005-2009 (Pettersson 2010). The concentrations
in the raw oats, oat-flakes and oat by-products from the mills are given in table 2. The
mean and median concentrations in oat-flakes decrease by 81 and 73 % respectively
compared to raw oats and increased by 307 and 345 % in the oat-byproducts.
Toxicity
T-2 and HT-2 toxins exhibit their toxicity mainly by inhibiting DNA, RNA and protein
synthesis, the latter at the ribosomal level. The toxins are therefore highly cytotoxic and
more toxic compared to the other trichothecenes partly due to their more lipophilic
character and membrane permeability. T-2 toxin is rapidly converted into HT-2 toxin
after ingestion by animals. The toxicity of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in animals is thus
considered to be similar.
Several studies in mice and rats show that T-2 toxin causes cytotoxicity and proliferative
changes in the oesophagus- and forestomach epithelium. Several tests for genotoxicity in
vitro and in rodents in vivo, especially for clastogenic effects, were positive for T-2 and
HT-2. There is, however, limited evidence for carcinogenicity in experimental animals.
It induced hepatocellular- and pulmonary adenomas in male mouse (Schiefer et al.
1987).
The most important toxicity studies identified by the EU Scientific Committee on Food
(SCF, 2001) and the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA,
2001) in their evaluation of T-2 and HT-2 toxicity are given in table 3. The LOAEL
(Lowest observed adverse effect levels) or NOAEL (No observed adverse effect levels)
are given for the critical effects. Both Committees, the JECFA and the SCF, used the
haematotoxicity and immunotoxicity of T-2 toxin in the subacute toxicity study by Rafai
et al. 1995a as the bases for their safety assessment. There are deficiencies in the toxicity
studies, e.g study duration, pair feeding of control animals, comparative studies on
metabolism and toxicokinetics. To account for this and the use of a LOAEL, the
Committes included an extra uncertainty factor of 5, giving an overall uncertainty factor
of 500. A temporary or provisional maximal Tolerable Daily Intake (t-TDI or PMTDI)
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
of 0.06 µg/ kg bodyweight and day was thus established for the sum of T-2 and HT-2
toxins.
The toxicity of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in farm animals was evaluated by Eriksen and
Pettersson 2004. The lowest effect level in feed for certain toxic effects in major feeding
studies with pigs and chickens are given in table 4. Guidance values for the highest T-2
and HT-2 concentrations in feed for pigs and chicken was suggested to 0.2 and 0.5
µg/kg respectively.
There are hardly any reports on toxic effects in ruminants fed T-2 and HT-2 toxins in
controlled studies. This may be due to that trichothecenes including T-2 and HT-2 toxins
are rapidly degraded and detoxified by microorganisms in the rumen. They are
deacetylated and de-epoxidated. The removal of the epoxide is the main detoxification
of trichothecenes. De-epoxidation activities have also been found in faeces from pigs
and horses (Eriksen et al. 2002; Pettersson et al. 2008), but it is unclear if this reaction
in the lower part of the gastro-intestinal tract may have an influence on the eventual
toxic effects.
Horses may be highly exposed to T-2 and HT-2 toxins but there are only few case
reports on their eventual toxic effects in horses. Most cases are from East Europe but T-
2 toxin has also been the cause of bean-hull poisoning of horses in Japan. Toxic effects
described are CNS toxicity, muscle contraction, tachycardia and colic. The exposure of
trotter horse to T-2 and HT-2 toxins through oats has been studied in Sweden (Pettersson
et al. 2007). Horses consuming an average of 2.6 mg T-2+HT-2 per day were compared
with a group consuming 0.7 mg toxins per day. No clear effects were seen on health and
performance of the horses.
Risks
Estimation of human intake of T-2 and HT-2 toxins through oats and comparison with
the established t-TDI can provide information on the risks with the toxins in food oats.
JECFA (2001) made intake calculations for the trichothecenes based on the toxin
database available for each cereal at that time and different cereal consumption
information. The calculated intakes were high for many population groups and the intake
for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxins exceeded the combined t-TDI in most high cereal
consumption groups. The toxin portion from oats was about 50% of the intake. The
mean concentration used for oats in the calculations was a weight mean (21 µg T-2/kg,
35 µg HT-2/kg) of all European analysis on unprocessed oats. This is not an appropriate
concentration value to use in the calculations since unprocessed oats are not consumed
and processing decrease the toxin concentrations with more than 80%.
The median concentration of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in oat-flakes for the year 2005-2009
from the study by CEEREAL are more correct to use. This concentration has been used
together with the detailed Norwegian oat consumption data for the calculation of intake
in table 5. Oat consumption in Norway is relatively high and a median consumption has
been used in the calculations. The intake of T-2 and HT-2 toxins from oats is then 1.5-5
% of the t-TDI depending on groups and much lower than in the JECFA calculations. If
the intake is calculated for high oat consumers (95th percentile consumption) and high
toxin concentration (90th percentile) in the oat-flakes, the toxin intake will become 48-77
% of the t-TDI.
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
About 75 % of the European oat crop is used in animal feed. Oats are mainly used in
feed for ruminants and horses. It is less popular in feeds for pigs and poultry due to the
relative high fiber content and low energy value. Oat by-products are only used in horse
and ruminant feed.
Oats with median T-2 and HT-2 toxin concentrations (Survey mean 90 µg/kg,
CEEREAL 42 µg/kg) can be used in feed to pigs and poultry without restrictions due to
toxin content and risk for exceeding feed guidance levels. The oat component in their
feeds rarely exceeds 50% of the diet. Oats containing high toxin levels equal to the 90th
percentile (208 µg/kg) in the CEEREAL study could also be used, but oats with
concentrations above 1000 µg T-2+HT-2/kg may cause adverse effects.
In adult ruminants even the highest T-2 and HT-2 toxin concentrations in oats are
expected to be degraded and detoxified by the rumen microbes. The highest toxin
concentrations may have a local contact effect causing erosions on the muzzle and in the
mouth. This has however not been described.
Athletic or working horses may be fed up to 6 kg oats per day in addition to the
roughage. If oats with a median toxin concentration (90 or 42 µg/kg) is used the daily
intake will be only 0.25-0.54 mg/day or calculated on a body weight of 500kg give 0.5-
1.1 µg/kg b.w. and day. The lowest adverse effect level of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in horses
is not known, but this daily amount will probably not cause adverse effects. Oats with T-
2 and HT-2 concentrations above 1000 µg/kg will give a daily consumption of more
than 6 mg/day or more than 12 µg/ kg b.w. and day. These amounts are expected to
cause toxic effects in the horses, although it was not noticed in the study on trotter
horses in Sweden. An explanation could be the degradation of trichothecenes in
intestinal and feces content of horses fed oats. A local cytotoxic contact effects caused
by high toxin concentrations could also be expected in the muzzel, mouth, stomach and
upper intestine of the horses. T-2 and HT-2 toxins are highly cytotoxic and cause cell
death at concentrations from 0.3-20 ng/ml in cell culture studies.
References
Clasen, P-E. 2006, 2008, 2009, 2010. Personal communications.
EC, European Commission. 2006a. Commission Regulation (EC) No. 1881/2006 setting
maximum levels of certain contaminants in food-stuffs. Off. J. Eur. Union L364:5-24.
EC, European Commission. 2006b. Commission Recommendation (EC) No. 206/2006
on the presence of deoxynivalenol, zearalenone, ochratoxin A, T-2 and HT-2 and
fumonisins in products intended for animal feeding. Off. J. Eur. Union L229:7-9.
Edwards, S. 2006. Personal communication.
Edwards, S. 2007. Investigations of Fusarium mycotoxins in UK barley and oat
production. HGCA, London, UK. Report 415, 72 pp.
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Edwards, S.G. 2009. Fusarium mycotoxin content of UK organic and conventional oats.
Food Add. Contam. 26:1063-1069.
Edwards, S.G., B. Barrier-Guillot, P.E. Clasen, V. Hietaniemi, and H. Pettersson. 2009.
Emerging issues of HT-2 and T-2 toxins in European cereal production. World
Mycotox. J. 2:173-179.
Eriksen, G.S., H. Pettersson, K. Johnsen, and J.E. Lindberg. 2002. Transformation of
trichothecenes in ileal digesta and faeces from pigs. Arch. Tierernahr. 56:263-274.
Eriksen, G.S., and H. Pettersson. 2004. Toxicological evaluation of trichothecenes in
animal feed. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 114:205-239.
Hietaniemi, V. 2006, 2010. Personal communication.
Friend, D.W., B.K. Thompson, H.L. Trenholm, H.J. Boermans, K.E. Hartin, and P.L.
Panich. 1992. Toxicity of T-2 toxin and its interaction with deoxynivalenol when fed to
young pigs. Can. J. Anim. Sci. 72:703-711.
JECFA, Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives. 2001. Safety evaluation
of certain mycotoxins in food. T-2 and HT-2 toxins. FAO Food and Nutrition Paper
74:557-680.
Orlando, B., B. Barrier-Guillot, E. Gourdain and C. Maumene. 2010. Identification of
agronomic factors that influence the levels of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in barley grown in
France. World Mycotox. J. 3:169-174.
Rafai, P., A. Bata, A. Vanyi, Z. Papp, E. Brydl, L. Jakab, S. Tuboly, and E. Tury. 1995a.
Effect of various levels of T-2 toxin on the clinical status, performance and metabolism
of growing pigs. Vet. Rec. 136:485-489.
Rafai, P., S. Tuboly, A. Bata, P. Tilly, A. Vanyi, Z. Papp, L. Jakab, and E. Tury. 1995b.
Effect of various levels of T-2 toxin in the immune system of growing pigs. Vet. Rec.
136:511-514.
Rousseaux, C.G., and H.B. Schiefer. 1987. Maternal toxicity, embryolethality and
abnormal fetal development in CD-1 mice following one oral dose of T-2 toxin. J. Appl.
Toxicol. 7:281-288.
Rukmini, C., J.S. Prasad, and K. Rao. 1980. Effects of feeding t-2-toxin to rats and
monkeys. Food Cosm. Toxicol. 18:267-269.
Ohtsubo, K., and M. Saito. 1977. Chronic effects of trichothecene toxins. In: Rodricks,
J.V., Hesseltine, C.W., Mehlman, M.A. (Eds.), Mycotoxins in Human and Animal
Health. Phatotox Publishers, Park Forest South, Illinois, pp. 255-262.
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Pettersson, H., J. Nyman, A. Jansson and J-E. Lindberg. 2007. T-2 and HT-2 toxins in
oats and the effects in horses. Proc. 30th Mycotoxin Work-shop, Waegening
Pettersson, H., T. Borjesson, L. Persson, C. Lerenius, G. Berg, and G. Gustafsson. 2008.
T-2 and HT-2 toxins in oats grown in Northern Europe. Cereal Res. Comm. 36:591-592.
Pettersson, H. 2010. T-2 and HT-2 toxins in oats and oat products. Presentation at 7th
Fusarium toxin Forum, Brussels
SCF Scientific Committee on Food. 2001. Opinion on Fusarium toxins. Part 5: T-2 and
HT-2toxin. http://www.europa.eu.int/comm/food/fs/sc/scf/out88.en.pdf
Schiefer, H.B., C.G. Rousseaux, D.S. Hancock, and B.R. Blakley. 1987. Effects of low-
level long-term oral-exposure to t-2 toxin in cd-1 mice. Food Chem. Toxicol. 25:593-
601.
SCOOP 2003. Task 3.2.10. Collection of occurrence data of fusarium toxins in food and
assessment of dietary intake by the population of EU member states. Brussels: European
Commission.
Scudamore, K.A., H. Baillie, S. Patel, and S.G. Edwards. 2007. Occurrence and fate of
Fusarium mycotoxins during commercial processing of oats in the UK. Food Add.
Contam. 24:1374-1385.
Sirkka, U., S.A. Nieminen, and P. Ylitalo. 1992. Acute neurobehavioral toxicity of
trichothecene t-2 toxin in the rat. Pharmacol. Toxicol. 70:111-114.
Schlatter, J. 2004. Toxicity data relevant for hazard characterization. Toxicol. Letters
153:83-89.
Smith, B.J., S.D. Holladay, and B.L. Blaylock. 1994. Hematopoietic alterations after
exposure to T-2 mycotoxin. Toxicon 32:1115-1123.
Weaver, G.A., H.J. Kurtz, F.Y. Bates, M.S. Chi, C.J. Mirocha, J.C. Behrens, and T.S.
Robison. 1978. Acute and chronic toxicity of T-2 mycotoxin in swine. Vet. Rec.
103:531-5.
Wyatt, R.D., B.A. Weeks, P.B. Hamilton, and H.R. Burmeister. 1972. Severe oral
lesions in chickens caused by ingestion of dietary fusariotoxin T-2. Appl. Microbiol.
24:251-257.
Wyatt, R.D., W.M. Colwell, P.B. Hamilton, and H.R. Burmeister. 1973. Neural
disturbances in chickens caused by dietary T-2 toxin. Appl. Microbiol. 26:757-761.
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Table 1. T-2 and HT-2 toxins in surveys of oats 2000-2009. (after Pettersson 2010)
Year Country Mean Median Max Reference
>50ppb >500ppb (µg/kg) (µg/kg) (µg/kg)
2000 Finland 25 36 8137 25 1369 Hietaniemi 2006
Norway 22 73 586 53 564 SCOOP 2003
2001 Finland 37 27 059 25 273 Hietaniemi 2006
Norway 24 0 0 10 10 10 SCOOP 2003
2002 Finland 30 37 078 38 427 Hietaniemi 2006
UK 92 70 16 311 106 4844 Edwards 2006
2003 Finland 30 63 13 305 116 1647 Hietaniemi 2006
UK 104 69 33 727 204 9990 Edwards 2006
2004 Finland 30 57 10 282 104 2850 Hietaniemi 2006
Norway 56 70 0106 86 334 Clasen 2006
UK 128 80 24 500 202 6997 Edwards 2006
2005 Finland 60 63 33 440 186 3500 Hietaniemi 2006
Sweden 41 61 17 255 90 1165 Pettersson 2006
Norway 126 87 13 283 180 2041 Clasen 2006
Denmark 18 94 6312 221 2560 Biselli 2006
UK 134 88 44 694 403 3188 Edwards 2006
2006 Finland 59 53 5163 47 1283 Hietaniemi 2007
Sweden 71 90 44 465 376 1416 Pettersson 2007
Norway 102 78 9218 145 1675 Clasen 2006
UK 100 96 43 795 404 6261 Edwards 2007
2007 Finland 80 53 5121 64 863 Hietaniemi 2007
Sweden 58 91 10 255 90 1165 Pettersson 2008
Norway 32 94 6217 177 980 Clasen 2008
UK 103 77 18 438 169 8399 Edwards 2008
2008 Finland 80 38 5100 32 1932 Hietaniemi 2009
Sweden 70 34 057 34 493 Pettersson 2009
Norway 33 64 062 55 145 Clasen 2009
UK 90 7120 47 1190 Edwards 2009
2009 Finland 80 39 485 25 1020 Hietaniemi 2010
Sweden 27 33 482 35 886 Pettersson 2010
Norway 30 67 6134 73 763 Clasen 2010
Number
of
Samples
Percentage of Samples
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Table 2. T-2 and HT-2 toxins in oats and oat products from European mills in the
CEEREAL study 2005-2009. (after Pettersson 2010).
Product Number Mean Median 90th % ile Max
of Samples (µg/kg) (µg/kg) (µg/kg) (µg/kg)
Oats raw 235 96 44 212 841
Oat flakes 435 18 12 41 197
Oat by-product 208 295 152 663 1711
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Table 3. Critical Toxicology studies on T-2 toxin identified by SCF in 2001. (after
Slatter 2004)
Critical effect
NOAEL/LOAEL
Reference
(mg/kg b.w./day)
Pulmonary adenomas
0.23 (NOAEL)
Schiefer et al. 1987
Hepatocellular adenomas
0.23 (NOAEL)
Forestomach epithelial
hyperplasi
0.23 (NOAEL)
Forestomach epithelial
hyperplasi
0.5 (NOAEL)
Ohtsubo and Saito 1977
Thymus athrophy,
decreased number of T- and
B-cells
0.75 (LOAEL)
Smith et al. 1994
Reduced number of
leukocytes, lymphocytes
and antibody production
against horse globulin.
Decrease in size of thymus
and spleen
0.03 (LOAEL)
Rafai et al. 1995
Leukopenia
0.1 (LOAEL)
Rukimini et al. 1980
No dose showing effect
Embryo- or foetotoxicity
0.45 (NOAEL)
Rosseaux and Schiefer
1987
Neurotoxicity
0.4 (NOAEL)
Sirkka et al. 1992
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Table 4. Lowest effect level of T-2 toxin in feed for pigs and chicken.
Animal
Lowest
Effect level
Toxic Effect
Reference
(mg/kg feed)
Pig
0.5
Reduced immunedefence
Rafai et al. 1995b
1-2
Reduced growth and feed
intake
Rafai et al. 1995a, Friend
et al. 1992, Weaver et al.
1978
Chicken
0.4-1
Mucosa erosion
Wyatt et al. 1972, 1973
2
Reduced feed
consumption and growth
Wyatt et al. 1972, 1973
Manuscript
Proc. 11th European Fusarium Seminar, 20-23September 2010, Radzikow, Poland
Table 5. Intake of T-2 and HT-2 toxins from oats calculated on consumption data from
Norway. Median consumption and median toxin concentration from CEEREAL study.
Population
Body
Median
Toxin
conc.
Median Consumption
group
weight
Grain
Toxin intake
% of TDI
(kg)
(µg/kg)
(g/person
per day)
(ng/person
, day)
(ng/kg
b.w., day)
6 years
23
12
6.2
74.4
3.23
5.4
10 years
35
12
8.2
98.4
2.81
4.7
Males
16-29 years
75
12
7.5
90
1.20
2.0
30-59 years
83
12
7.6
91.2
1.10
1.8
60-79 years
79
12
6.5
78
0.99
1.6
Females
16-29 years
63
12
6.3
75.6
1.20
2.0
30-59 years
65
12
5.8
69.6
1.07
1.8
60-79 years
69
12
5.1
61.2
0.89
1.5
... Cereal plants can become infected by different Fusarium species, such as F. graminearum and F. culmorum, which are the main causative agents of the Fusarium head blight (FHB) disease, and the contamination with toxins in small-grain cereals (Pettersson, 2011). Oat (Avena sativa L.) is generally less susceptible to FHB than wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) and barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) because its long pedicels between spikelets prevent the spread of fungal mycelia throughout the panicle (Tekauz et al., 2008). ...
... T-2 toxin is the most toxic trichothecene mycotoxin, as it has several harmful effects on humans and animals on the cardio-cerebrovascular system, central nervous system, gastrointestinal tract, skin and other important organs (Janik et al., 2021). HT-2 toxin is considered as toxic as T-2 toxin because T-2 toxin is rapidly converted into HT-2 toxin after ingestion by animals (Pettersson, 2011). Nordic European countries and the United Kingdom are currently the countries with the highest type A trichothecene contamination levels in this cereal. ...
... The detection of HT-2 toxin in two pasta samples was unexpected. HT-2 toxin has been shown to cause toxicity by inhibiting DNA and RNA function and, ultimately, protein synthesis (Pettersson, 2011). Like DON, it can cause nausea, vomiting, and other unpleasant GI side effects (Bennett & Klich, 2003). ...
... HT-2 toxin is often considered together with T-2 toxin, which can be rapidly converted to HT-2 after ingestion. Both appear interchangeable and have similar effects on mammals (Pettersson, 2011). T-2 toxin and HT-2 toxin are believed to be more toxic than DON, and their cytotoxic effects can cause immunosuppression and decreased resistance to infectious microbes (Bennett & Klich, 2003). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
BACKGROUND: The incidence of pediatric Crohn’s disease (CD) has increased over the past few decades. The etiology of CD has not yet been elucidated. Still, researchers have identified variables associated with the disease process, including genetic predisposition, environmental triggers like a poor-quality diet, air pollution, water pollution, and a dysbiotic microbiome with increased fungal diversity as predisposing factors. Fungal mycotoxin contamination in the food supply from toxicants like Deoxynivalenol (DON), a highly prevalent gastrointestinal irritant, has largely been ignored as a potential factor influencing the fungal dysbiosis and symptoms associated with the disease process. It is hypothesized that global and intermittent exposure to mycotoxins like DON may negatively affect the gastrointestinal health of pediatric CD patients. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this two-part project was to: 1) Gather evidence of mycotoxin contamination in the food supply, 2) Given the evidence then, to test local food commodities for mycotoxins for the development of a low-mycotoxin diet as a potential treatment modality for pediatric CD. METHODS: An integrative review of studies measuring global DON prevalence was conducted. With evidence that wheat and corn crops are routinely contaminated with mycotoxins, flours containing these ingredients were directly tested for DON using lateral flow screening technology. Wheat bread and pasta samples were also analyzed and sent to Trilogy laboratory for liquid chromatography, mass spectrometry-mass spectrometry mycotoxin testing. RESULTS: Results of the integrative review showed that globally, wheat, corn, bakery products, pasta, and mothers’ milk were routinely contaminated with DON. There was also sufficient evidence to suggest that other grain-based crops, soy, coffee, tea, dried spices, nuts, certain seed oils, animal milk, and various water reservoirs are intermittently contaminated. The direct measurement of foods in a typical child’s diet, such as pasta, bread, and raw ingredients such as wheat- and corn-based flours, also demonstrated routine contamination with DON. Some pasta samples were also contaminated with HT-2 toxin. Contamination rates were significantly higher in 2021 than in 2019, showing the problem may be escalating. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: Universally, due to their increased intake of cereal-based foods relative to their lower body weight it would appear children are at higher risk for exposures to DON than adults. A review of the literature suggests that mycotoxin contamination in the food supply is common. The cumulative effects of multiple mycotoxin exposures by pediatric CD patients may pose serious health risks. Further investigation into the role mycotoxin contamination plays in the disease process, microbial perturbations, and fungal dysbiosis inherent in CD is needed. The information obtained here demonstrates a need to develop a “Low Mycotoxin Diet” for pediatric CD patients to help mitigate the common occurrence of these biohazards. KEYWORDS: Crohn’s disease, Pediatrics, Deoxynivalenol, Diet, and Mycotoxin
... Among the mycotoxins not yet subject to regulatory limits, which however object of attention and study by the European Commission, T-2 and HT-2 toxins assume particular importance due to the high degree of toxicity assessed, the resistance to degradation and, consequently, the tendency to remain in the raw materials and in the processed products [22]. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this study, biogas and biomethane production during mesophilic anaerobic digestion of wheat substrates coming from national crops and naturally contaminated with deoxynivalenol (DON) and/or T-2/HT-2 toxins was investigated. Biochemical methane potential (BMP) tests of both wholewheat flour and of the main milling fractions were carried out to assess the effect on the concentration of mycotoxins on the anaerobic biological process and their residual presence in the final digestate. The good methane average production achieved (337.0 ± 24.5 NL CH4/kg VS) was substantially comparable with the yields gained from similar biomasses at mesophilic conditions. Moreover, an effective reduction (60.7–100%) of DON concentration was obtained in all the tested substrates (range of contamination in the samples, 368–12,916 μg/kg) whereas the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxin levels in digestates was always <LOQ in all substrates analyzed (range of contamination in the samples, 5–65 μg/kg). The results supported an alternative exploitation of “non-compliant” lots of cereals destined for human consumption and/or animal feed which could represent a concrete benefit for agricultural producers. Anaerobic digestion could be employed as an effective tool to recover large amounts of trichothecene-contaminated cereals in an environmentally and economically sustainable way.
... The hydrolysis of the corresponding glucosides into T-2 or HT-2 in the GI tract can induce serious toxic effects in humans and animals primarily caused by the inhibition of DNA, RNA, and protein synthesis. 21 Hence, the EFSA Panel on Contaminants in the Food Chain (CONTAM) proposed to establish a group TDI and acute reference dose (ARfD) for T-2 and HT-2, including their modified forms as well. 4 Because more data are required for a better understanding of the intestinal metabolism of the modified mycotoxins T-2 and HT-2 glucosides in α and β configuration, this comparative study deals with their intestinal metabolism in the pig cecum model ( Figure 1). ...
Article
The type A trichothecene mycotoxins T-2 and HT 2 toxin are fungal secondary metabolites produced by Fusarium fungi which contaminate food and feed worldwide. Especially due to the high toxicity of T 2 toxin and their occurrence together with glucosylated forms in cereal crops, these mycotoxins are of human health concern. Particularly, it is unknown whether and how these modified mycotoxins are metabolized in the gastrointestinal tract and thus contribute to the overall toxicity. Therefore, the comparative intestinal metabolism of T 2 toxin and HT 2 toxin glucosides in α and β configuration was investigated using the ex vivo pig cecum model which mimics the human intestinal metabolism. Regardless its configuration, the C 3 glycosidic bond was hydrolyzed within 10 20 min releasing T 2 and HT 2 toxin which were further metabolized to HT 2 toxin and T 2 triol, respectively. We conclude that T 2 and HT 2 toxin should be evaluated together with their modified forms for risk assessment.
... In Italy, the pathogen incidence is higher in Centre and Southern than in Northern regions being related to climate conditions characterized by high temperature and scarce rain fallings during the wheat flowering [16]. The toxins T2 and HT2 produced by F. langsethiae present high toxicity probably due to their lipophilicity and are consequently likely to penetrate the cells [19]. Their toxic effects regard the inhibition of synthesis of DNA and RNA and proteins and the reduction of lymphocytes and immune defenses [15]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Fusarium langsethiae is amongst the most recently discovered pathogens of small grains cereals. F. langsethiae is the main producer, in Europe, of T2 and HT-toxins in small grain cereals, albeit often asymptomatic; this makes its control challenging. The European Union (EU) is pushing hard on the use of biocontrol agents to minimize the use of fungicides and pesticides, which are detrimental to the environment and responsible for serious pollution of the soil and superficial water. In line with EU directives (e.g., 128/2009), here we report the use of protein fractions, purified from the culture filtrate of the basidiomycete Trametes versicolor, for controlling F. langsethiae. T. versicolor, a so-called medicinal mushroom which is applied as a co-adjuvant in oncology and other pathologies as a producer of biological response modifiers. In this study, the exo-proteome of T. versicolor proved highly efficient in inhibiting the growth of F. langsethiae and the biosynthesis of the T2 toxin. Results are promising for its future use as a sustainable product to control F. langsethiae infection in cereals under field conditions.
... Several studies report the incidence of T-2 and HT-2 mainly in oats, but also in other grains including barley, wheat, maize, rice and soybean, as well as in cereal-based products [1][2][3][4]. Being potent inhibitors of DNA, RNA and protein synthesis, T-2 and HT-2 can cause several adverse effects in both humans and animals [3,5]. Due to their toxicity and co-occurrence, the Panel on Contaminants in the Food Chain (CONTAM Panel) of the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) established a group tolerable daily intake (TDI) of 100 ng/kg body weight per day for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 [3]. ...
Article
Full-text available
T-2 and HT-2 toxins and their main modified forms (T-2 glucoside and HT-2 glucoside) may co-occur in cereals and cereal-based products. A fluorescence polarization immunoassay (FPIA) was developed for the simultaneous determination of T-2 toxin, HT-2 toxin and relevant glucosides, expressed as sum. The developed FPIA, using a HT-2-specific antibody, showed high sensitivity (IC50 = 2.0 ng/mL) and high cross-reactivity (100% for T-2 toxin and 80% for T-2 and HT-2 glucosides). The FPIA has been used to develop two rapid and easy-to-use methods using two different extraction protocols, based on the use of organic (methanol/water, 90:10, v/v) and non-organic (water) solvents, for the determination of these toxins in wheat. The two proposed methods showed analytical performances in terms of sensitivity (LOD 10 µg/kg) recovery (92–97%) and precision (relative standard deviations ≤13%), fulfilling the criteria for acceptability of an analytical method for the quantitative determination of T-2 and HT-2 toxins established by the European Union. Furthermore, the methods were then validated in accordance with the harmonized guidelines for the validation of screening methods included in the Regulation (EU) No. 519/2014. The satisfactory analytical performances, in terms of intermediate precision (≤25%), cut-off level (80 and 96 µg/kg for the two methods) and rate of false positives (<0.1%) confirmed the applicability of the proposed methods as screening method for assessing the content of these toxins in wheat at the EU indicative levels reported for T-2 and HT-2 toxins.
... Main producers of these toxic secondary metabolites are Fusarium sporotrichioides, F. poae, and F. langsethiae (Thrane et al. 2004). Ingestion of food derived from moldy grain that is contaminated with T2 and HT2 can cause toxic effects in humans and animals mainly by the inhibition of DNA, RNA, and protein synthesis (Ueno 1984;Pettersson 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
Plant-derived phase II metabolites of T-2 toxin (T2) and HT-2 toxin (HT2) were first described in 2011 and further characterized in the following years. Since then, some efforts have been made to understand their biosynthesis, occurrence, toxicity, toxicokinetics, and finally relevance for consumers. Thus, the probably most important question is whether and how these metabolites contribute to toxicity upon hydrolysis either during food processing or the gastrointestinal passage. To answer this question, firstly, knowledge on the correct stereochemistry of T2 and HT2 glucosides is important as this affects hydrolysis and chemical behavior. So far, contradictory results have been published concerning the number and anomericity of occurring glucosides. For this reason, we set up different strategies for the synthesis of mg-amounts of T2, HT2, and T2 triol glucosides in both α and ß configuration. All synthesized glucosides were fully characterized by NMR spectroscopy as well as mass spectrometry and used as references for the analysis of naturally contaminated food samples to validate or invalidate their natural occurrence. Generally, 3-O-glucosylation was observed with two anomers of HT2 glucoside being present in contaminated oats. In contrast, only one anomer of T2 glucoside was found. The second aspect of this study addresses the stability of the glucosides during thermal food processing. Oat flour was artificially contaminated with T2 and HT2 glucosides individually and extruded at varying initial moisture content and temperature. All four glucosides appear to be more stable during food extrusion than the parent compounds with the glucosidic bond not being hydrolyzed.
... T-2 toxin is one of the most potent of the TCEs and it is produced by F. acuminatum, F. equiseti, F. poae and F. sporotrichoides. The highest concentrations of T-2 toxin tend to be found in oats and barley [8] and in some countries in maize [36]; wheat is typically less contaminated than these grains [37]. Following consumption, T-2 is rapidly de-acetylated to hydroxy-T-2. ...
Chapter
Trichothecene (TCE) contamination of common agricultural grains such as wheat, barley and maize is an increasingly common problem for the livestock industry because it can cause mycotoxicosis in animals affecting their production and survival. Many questions remain as to how TCE are metabolized by different livestock species, what their effects on health and production are, and what levels of intake are tolerable to ruminants without affecting health and productivity. The following TCEs: T-2, deoxynivalenol (DON), nivalenol (NIV), fusarenon-X (FUS-X), diacetoxyscirpenol (DAS) and neosolaniol (NEO) are reviewed herein to assess their effects on livestock health and production. These TCEs commonly affect the immune system, reproduction, and feed intake and weight gain across species. However, further research investigating the effects of these TCEs needs to be conducted in ruminants. Research on the combined effects of mixed-TCE exposure is especially necessary since this type of exposure typically occurs in nature.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of study was to detect the fungal and mycotoxins contamination of grain samples of oat, wheat and barley grown in four regions of Ural region (Kurgan, Sverdlovsk, Tyumen, Chelyabinsk) in 2017–2018. Methods. The infection of grain with fungi was analyzed using traditional mycological methods; the content of fungal DNA was determined by quantitative PCR; the presence and amounts of toxic secondary metabolites of fungi in the grain was detected by high performance liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry. Results. In the analyzed grain samples at least 10 species of Fusarium fungi were identified, among which F. sporotrichioides, F. avenaceum sensu lato and F. poae were found to be prevailing. The areas of Fusarium species that are atypical for the territory of Ural region were specified. F. graminearum was found in 14 % of the analyzed grain samples, and F. langsethiae was detected in three grain samples from the Sverdlovsk region. The DNA of F. poae was found in 48 % of grain samples, F. avenaceum DNA – in 39 %, F. sporotrichioides DNA – in 30 %, and F. graminearum DNA – in 29 % of analyzed grain samples. The content of mycotoxins in the grain samples ranged significantly depending on the crop and the geographical origin of the samples. One to seven mycotoxins were present in each contaminated grain sample. T-2 and HT-2 toxins were most common and were detected in 59 % of samples. Following to them beauvericin and deoxynivalenol were found in 34 % and 25 % of the grain samples, respectively. The excess of the maximum permissible level of T-2 toxin in 26 times was detected in grain of barley from the Chelyabinsk region Scientific novelty. For the first time, the information about the occurrence and the amounts of moniliformin and beauvericin, which are rarely analyzed in the grain, is provided. The significant connection between the content of DNA of dominant Fusarium species and the amount of the main mycotoxins produced by them in the grain were revealed.
Chapter
Full-text available
This chapter presents an overview of current chemometric tools utilized for the evaluation of several mycotoxins often found in foodstuff, such as cereals, peanuts, pistachio nuts and condiments. Mycotoxins are compounds produced as a result of the secondary metabolism of fungus, such as Aspergillus, Fusarium and Pénicillium. Because of their harmful effect in animals and humans, their levels in food are strictly controlled. Discussions are focused on the analysis of first and second-order data generated through several techniques such as near infrared spectroscopy, fluorescence spectroscopy and high performance liquid chromatography with diode array detector. This review manuscript describes the algorithms frequently used to model this type of data, including Partial Least Squares (PLS) regression, Parallel Factor Analysis (PARAFAC) and Multivariate Curve Resolution Alternating Least Squares (MCR-ALS). These multivariate calibration methods allow the quantification of multiple analytes in complex food samples with the application of minimum pre-treatment techniques. Another important chemometric tool commented in this review is the Response Surface Method (RSM), commonly applied in the optimization of experimental procedures and chemical measurements. This chapter discusses the different strategies implemented for the analysis of a wide spectrum of mycotoxins, as well as their advantages and disadvantages.
Article
Full-text available
This is the final report of a four year project which started in July 2002. The project was sponsored by the HGCA (£46,217, Project No. RD-2002-2706) and the Food Standards Agency (£285,947, Projects No CO4033 and CO4034), making a total of £332,164. The Home-Grown Cereals Authority (HGCA) has provided funding for this project but has not conducted the research or written this report. While the authors have worked on the best information available to them, neither HGCA nor the authors shall in any event be liable for any loss, damage or injury howsoever suffered directly or indirectly in relation to the report or the research on which it is based. Reference herein to trade names and proprietary products without stating that they are protected does not imply that they may be regarded as unprotected and thus free for general use. No endorsement of named products is intended nor is it any criticism implied of other alternative, but unnamed, products.
Article
Full-text available
The trichothecenes T-2 and HT-2 toxins have been found at much higher levels in oats from Sweden and N. Europe in 2005-2007 compared to surveys during 1990-ties. High portions (13-44%) of the samples were above the suggested EU max level (500 mu g/kg) for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxins in raw oats. Factors behind these high toxin levels have been studied. Variations due to oat variety have been found in trials, but no or small effects of fungicides. Processing of oats, cleaning and dehulling, have reduced the toxins often by more than 90%. Sortex equipment to remove discolored kernels from the dehulled kernel fraction reduced the toxins further. Oat by-products from the milling process were 3-6 times higher in HT-2 + T-2 toxins compared to original oats.
Article
The European Commission has considered the appropriateness of setting a maximum level for T-2 and HT-2 toxins in cereals and cereal products in future. Occurrence studies show that oats, and to a lesser extent barley, seem to accumulate higher levels of these toxins than other cereals. Consequently, ARVALIS - Institut du vegetal has conducted a field survey in collaboration with different French partners (cooperatives and merchants, agro industries and research institutes). The agronomic factors identified to reduce the risk of T-2 and HT-2 toxins on barley are different from those identified for deoxynivalenol (DON). They are, in decreasing order of importance: sowing date, rotation (number of small grain cereals in the last 2 years), tillage (with a smaller impact than for DON), and possibly varietal susceptibility and fungicide protection. Finally, this field survey shows that DON, and T-2 and HT-2 toxins seem to be opposed, which probably means a different risk management for these different mycotoxins.
Article
HT-2 and T-2 toxins are two of the most potent trichothecenes; they have a combined (HT-2+T-2) temporary Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) of 0.06 mu g/kg body weight/day. The distribution of HT-2 and T-2 appears to be largely restricted to Europe. Of the cereal species, HT-2 and T-2 usually have higher incidences and concentrations on oats followed by barley and then wheat, however, this can vary between countries. Survey data from Nordic countries have indicated that these mycotoxins have increased in recent years, reaching concentrations of >1000 mu g/kg HT-2+T-2 in some samples. HT-2 and T-2 have also been detected in malting barley in France, and in particular in spring sown varieties. A newly identified species, Fusarium langsethiae, has been implicated as a producer of HT-2 and T-2 in European cereals. There is limited data available regarding this species' pathogenicity and mycotoxin production. The impact of agronomy on the concentration of HT-2 and T-2 in cereals has not been clearly identified, but it is evident that it is different to the impact of agronomy on deoxynivalenol. Processing of cereals can have a major impact on the HT-2 and T-2 content of cereals. Oats are de-hulled during processing for human consumption; de-hulling reduces the mycotoxin content of oats by more than 90%. During the malting and brewing of barley the concentration of HT-2 and T-2 increases and decreases within various stages of the processes and the final mycotoxin load of beers will depend on the individual processes tied by each maltster and brewer. Whether these mycotoxins are an issue for human health cannot be determined until a full TDI is calculated based on more long-term exposure studies, and human exposure levels are calculated from surveys of retail products using new, highly sensitive assays.
Article
Trichothecenes are mycotoxins commonly found in cereals world-wide. Fusarium fungi are the main producers of trichothecenes in cereals. Trichothecenes are rapidly excreted from animals and residues of trichothecenes in animal-derived food products are not considered to pose any threat to consumers. The toxins are toxic to all tested species, but the sensitivity varies considerably between toxins and between species. Available feeding studies with the trichothecenes deoxynivalenol (DON), nivalenol (NIV) and T-2 toxin in feed to production animals have been reviewed. There are not sufficient available data about the effects of trichothecenes in ruminant feed to allow a scientifically-based risk assessment. The available studies of the metabolism of trichothecenes in cattle indicate that trichothecenes to a large extent are transformed to the much less toxic de-epoxide metabolite in the rumen before absorption. Furthermore, no effect has been found on milk production, feed intake or other parameters measured at levels used in the studies. It is concluded that trichothecenes are not likely to cause any harm in ruminants unless fed visibly damaged feed and no guideline value is probably needed.