Available via license: CC BY-NC-ND
Content may be subject to copyright.
Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research. 2014 Sep, Vol-8(9): AC07-AC09 77
DOI: 10.7860/JCDR/2014/10402.4885 Original Article
Keywords: Anencephaly, Cleft palate, Clubbed foot, Spina bifida
INTRODUCTION
Failure of closure of the cranial neuropore during the fourth week of
development results in the abnormal vascularisation of the embryonic
exencephalic brain [1]. The nervous tissue subsequently undergoes
degeneration and brain remains as a spongy vascular mass with
some hind brain structures [2]. Previously called as anencephaly
(without brain), it is now called as Meroanencephaly as some
functioning neural tissue is always present [3]. As Meroanencephaly
is a lethal malformation the research on presence of other associated
malformations has largely remained restricted. Ballantyne (1904)
[4] as well as David and Illingworth [5] associated diapharagmatic
hernia with anencephaly. British Perinatal Mortality Survey [6] of
1958 first stressed on registering the associated malformation in
anencephalics. T.J.David [7] tabulated the associated malformations
and found spina bifida to be the most common. Many researchers
found that the most common associated malformations differed
according to the geographical location [8,9]. According to David TJ
cardiovascular defects were common in Lancashire while urinary
tract defects were common in the Bristol [10]. Apart from CNS
malformations gastrointestinal and skeletal abnormalities were the
most common according to C Pandurang [11] in a study conducted
in India.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted between January 2013 to March 2014
in Lokmanya Tilak Municipal Medical College and general hospital
which is a major tertiary care hospital for obstetrics in western India.
Ethical clearance was obtained by the institutional ethical committee.
Twenty anencephalic fetuses were dissected in the Anatomy
department of the institute after obtaining informed consent.
The cases originated from still birth, spontaneous abortion and
therapeutic abortion. The gestational age was in the range of 16 to
34 weeks. There was no history of diabetes, obesity and infections
in the mothers. There was no exposure to any teratogenic drugs.
All mothers had received the recommended 0.5mg of folic acid
supplementation. The findings were done by external examination,
photography and internal examination. Internal examination was
done for abdominal and genitourinary viscera only.
Anatomy Section
Anencephaly and its
Associated Malformations
ABSTRACT
Introduction: Anencephaly is a serious neural tube defect in
which parts of the brain and skull are not developed. But apart
from this it is also associated with other malformations which
are not related to neural tube in development.
Aim: The present study was undertaken to find the associated
congenital malformations in western region of India and
establish a aetiological correlation.
Materials and Methods: The study was conducted using 20
anencephalic fetuses.
Results: Nearly 80% of fetuses had associated malformations.
Spina bifida was seen in 9 fetuses and cleft palate in 8.
Female fetus with cleft palate had other severe associated
gastrointestinal and skeletal malformation.
Conclusion: In cases of anencephaly other associated malfor-
mations like spina bifida and cleft palate are commonly seen.
The results were recorded according to the following parameters.
Facial features: - Cleft lip, cleft palate.
CNS: - Spina bifida.
GIT: - Absence or underdeveloped organ.
Genito urinary system: - Hypospadias, penile hypoplasia, renal
agenesis.
Skeletal system: - Clubbed foot, clubbed hands.
RESULTS
Associated malformations were seen in 16 out of 20 fetuses. There
were 12 female and 8 male fetuses. Spina bifida was the most
common anomaly followed by facial anomalies which included cleft
lip and cleft palate. The details are given in [Table/Fig-1].
DISCUSSION
Anencephaly is associated with anomalies of not only central
nervous system but other systems as well. Previous studies have
mentioned a wide range for the percentage of fetus with associated
malformation. Tan et al., [12] recorded 9.4 % while David TJ
[10] recorded 84%. The present study recorded 80% fetus with
associated malformations. There were more number of female
fetuses (12 cases) as compared to males (8 cases). The percentage
RAVIKIRAN ASHOK GOLE1, PRITEE MADAN MESHRAM2, SHANTA SUNIL HATTANGDI3
Anomaly No of
cases
Percentage Remarks
Spina bifida 9 45 Cervical region 7 cases
Lumbar region 1 case.
Cleft Palate 8 40 7 male
1 female
Cleft lip 5 25 All has associated cleft palate
Clubbed foot and clubbed
hands
7 35 5 males
2 females
Genital abnormalities 2 cases 10 2 males has Hypospadias
No abnormality in females
Gastrointestinal system 2 cases 10 1 case gastroschisis. 1 case
omphalocele.
[Table/Fig-1]: Showing the distribution of number of cases for different anamoly
Ravikiran Ashok Gole et al., Anencephaly and its Associated Malformations www.jcdr.net
Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research. 2014 Sep, Vol-8(9): AC07-AC09
88
of female fetuses was 60%. All the previous studies have proved
that the females outnumber males in cases of anencephaly. The
female preponderance noticed by previous authors were David TJ
[10] at 66%, Panduranga [11] at 56% Aruna [13] recorded 55%.
In the present study the commonest anomaly associated with
anencephaly was spina bifida (9 cases). Associated malformations
were more common in cases with spina bifida. Even though spina
bifida is more common in lumbar region in general population,
craniospinal rachischisis [Table/Fig-2] of the cervical region was
found to be commoner in anencephalic fetuse [14]. Craniospinal
rachischisis is the most severe form of spina bifida cystica. In this
defect the spine lies widely open and the neural plate has spread
out on to the surface [15]. The thoracolumbar type spina bifida
[Table/Fig-3] was seen in only one case.
Facial abnormalities like cleft palate were seen in 8 cases of which 7
were males and one female. Suggesting a correlation between cleft
palate and male sex. Earlier studies have also reported cleft lip and
palate to be more common in male anencephalic fetus [10,11,13].
Cleft lip was found in 5 cases in association with cleft palate.
The genital abnormalities were seen in two male cases in the form
of Hypospadias. The remaining genital development was normal.
There was no genital abnormality detected in females. Studies done
by Tan et al.,[12], Nielsen et al.,[16] and Golalipour et al.,[9] did not
find any abnormality in the genital system. David et al found 0.6%
cases with abnormalities in the genital system and that too in male
fetuses only. One female fetus which had marked deformities such
as cleft lip, cleft palate, gastroschisis, clubbed feet and hands also
showed normal genital development [Table/Fig-4]. One case of
omphalocele was seen [Table/Fig-5]. No abnormality was detected
in the urinary system.
Skeletal deformities like clubbed hands and clubbed feet were
present in 5 males and 2 female fetuses. All the 5 male cases had
associated cleft palate. Skeletal abnormalities found in previous
studies were in the range of 1.7% by David TJ [10], 14.5% Vare
et al.,[17] to 20 % by Tan et al.,[12]. The present study recorded a
higher number of skeletal abnormalities at 35%.
The cause of anencephaly is still a disputed entity but the defect is
failure of closure of rostral neuropore. Anencephaly, even though a
defect of the neural tube can affect many other systems selectively
[18]. The intake of 0.5mg of folic acid [19] during the course of
pregnancy reduces the risk of anencephaly but does it have a similar
effects on other anomalies is poorly understood. The presence
of spina bifida can be correlated embryologically to the defect in
closure of the neuropore. Cleft palate and lip might occur due to the
defective neural crest cells. MTHFR gene has been associated with
anencephaly and orofacial defects [20] but its increased frequency
in males is poorly understood. Many studies have tried to find the
genetic association of anencephaly. LD Botto [21] reported MTHFR
gene located on chromosome 1 to be associated with neural tube
defects. But EC Melvin [22] failed to reach a consensus on the
involvement of p53, PAX3 and MTHFR gene in neural tube defects.
CONCLUSION
Anencephaly is common in females. Associated abnormalities were
seen in 80% of cases in the present study. Commonest abnormality
was spina bifida. Describing the associated malformations in
anencephaly as described in present study is not only of academic
and research interest but also helpful to radiologists for correct
interpretation and diagnosis. The strong association between cleft
palate and male fetus should be considered during the diagnosis.
The presence of associated abnormality like spina bifida, cleft
palate, clubbed foot, clubbed hands and gastroschisis points to the
fact that anenchepaly consists of more than one aetiological entity.
Studies are required at molecular level to find its association with
other anomalies.
REFERENCES
[1] Botto LD, Moore CA, Khoury MJ, Erickson JD. Neural-tube defects. N Engl J
Med. 1999;341(20):1509-19.
[2] Trenouth MJ. Craniofacial shape in the anencephalic human fetus. Journal of
anatomy. 1989;165:215-24.
[3] Moore LK, Persaud TV. Editors. The developing Human. Philadelphia: Saunders;
1998. 478-79.
[4] Ballantyne JW. Manual of Antenatal Pathology and Hygiene. Edinburgh: William
Green and Sons; 1904. pp.347-48.
[5] David TJ, Illingworth CA. Diaphragmatic hernia in the south-west of England.
Journal of Medical Genetics. 1976;13:253-62.
[6] Butler NR, Alberman ED. Perinatal Problems. The Second Report of the 1958
British Perinatal Mortality Survey, Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone; 1969:304.
[7] David TJ, McCrae FC, Bound JP. Congenital malformations associated with
anencephaly in the Fylde peninsula of Lancashire. J Med Genet. 1983;20(5):338-
41.
[8] Loncarek K. Prevalence of anencephaly in the region of Rijeka, Croatia. Eur J
Epidemiol. 2001;17(3):241-44.
[9] Golalipour MJ, Najafi L, Keshtkar AA. Prevalence of Anencephaly in Gorgan,
northern Iran. Arch Iran Med. 2010;13:34-37.
[10] David TJ, Nixon A. Congenital malformation associated with anencephaly and
inencephaly. J Med Gen. 1976;13:263-65.
[11] Panduranga C, Kangle R, Suranagi W, Pilli GS, Patil PV. Anencephaly: A
pathological study of 41 cases. J Sci Soc. 2012;39:81-84.
[12] Tan KB, Tan SH, Tan KH,Yeo GS. Anencephaly in Singapore: a ten year series
1993 -2002. Singapore Med J. 2007;48:12-15.
[13] Aruna E, Ranga R, Diddi, Anencephaly: A 3 year study. Journal of dental and
Medical Sciences.2013;12:12-15.
[14] Horowitz I, Mc Donald AD. Anencephaly and spina bifida in the province of
Quebec. Can Med Assoc J. 1969;100(16):748-55.
[15] Sadlerr T.W.; langman’s Medical Embryology. Central Nervous System, 11th
Edition. Lippincott Wilkins Philadelphia London. 2009. p.302 -16.
[16] Nielsen LA, Maroun LL, BroholmH, LaursenH, Graem N. Neural tube defects and
associated anomaliesin a fetal and perinatal autopsy series. Acta patho Microbiol
Immunol Scand. 2006;114:239-46.
[Table/Fig-2]: Fetus with craniospinal rachischisis and kyphosis of thoracic spine [Table/Fig-3]: Fetus with thoracolumbar spina bifida [Table/Fig-4]: Fetus with gastroschisis,
cleft palate, cleft lip and clubbed feet [Table/Fig-5]: Fetus with omphalocele
www.jcdr.net Ravikiran Ashok Gole et al., Anencephaly and its Associated Malformations
Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research. 2014 Sep, Vol-8(9): AC07-AC09 99
PARTICULARS OF CONTRIBUTORS:
1. Assistant Professor, Department of Anatomy, L.T.Medical College & General Hospital, College Building, 3rd Floor, LTMMC & GH, Sion Hospital, Sion, Mumbai, India.
2. Assistant Professor, Department of Anatomy, L.T.Medical College & General Hospital, College Building, 3rd Floor, LTMMC & GH, Sion Hospital, Sion, Mumbai, India.
3. Professor and Head, Department of Anatomy, L.T.Medical College & General Hospital, College Building, 3rd Floor, LTMMC & GH, Sion Hospital, Sion, Mumbai, India.
NAME, ADDRESS, E-MAIL ID OF THE CORRESPONDING AUTHOR:
Dr. Ravikiran Ashok Gole,
Assistant Professor, Department of Anatomy, College Building, 3rd Floor, LTMMC&GH,
Sion Hospital, Sion, Mumbai-400022, India.
Phone : 09769200508, E-mail : ravikiran.gole@gmail.com
FINANCIAL OR OTHER COMPETING INTERESTS: None.
Date of Submission: Jun 20, 2014
Date of Peer Review: Jul 17, 2014
Date of Acceptance: Jul 21, 2014
Date of Publishing: Sep 20, 2014
[17] Vare AM, Bansal PC. Anencephaly: An anatomical study of 41 anencephalics.
Indian J Pediatr. 1971;38:301-05.
[18] Myrianthopoulos NC, Melnick M. Studies in neural tube defects: Epidemiologic
and etiologic aspects. Am J Med Genet. 1987;26:783-96.
[19] Hibbard ED, Smithells RM. Folic acid metabolism and human embryopathy.
Lancet. 1965;i:1254-56.
[20] Butali, Azeez. Folic Acid Supplementation Use and the MTHFR C677T
Polymorphism in Orofacial Clefts Etiology: An Individual Participant Data Pooled-
Analysis. Clinical and Molecular Teratology. 2013;97(8):509-14.
[21] Botto LD, Yang Q. 5,10-Methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase gene variants and
congenital anomalies: a HuGE review. Am J Epidemiol. 2000;151(9):862-77.
[22] Melvin EC, et al. Genetic Studies in Neural Tube Defects. Pediatr Neurosurg.
2000;32:1–9.