ArticlePDF Available

Deccan Continental Flood Basalt Eruption Terminated Indian Dinosaurs before the Cretaceous-Paleogene Boundary

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Abstract : Late Cretaceous-Early Paleogene sediments associated with Deccan Continental Flood Basalt (DCFB) sequences of central and western India record the timing of the introduction and extinction of Late Cretaceous dinosaurs in India based on magnetostratigraphy and magnetic susceptibility stratigraphy. Current taxonomy indicates that only two genera of titanosaurs (e.g., Isisaurus and Jainosaurus), at least four species of large-bodied abelisauridae theropods (e.g., Rajasaurus narmadensis, Rahiolisaurus gujaratensis, Indosuchus matleyi and Indosaurus raptorius) and a small-bodied theropod Laevisuchus inhabited India during the Maastrichtian. Their stratigraphic and geographic distribution suggests that these dinosaurs were dominated by titanosauriforme and abelisauridae that first appeared before the advent of Deccan volcanism in the magnetochron C30n and were well established with the acme of breeding and nesting during C30n to maastrichtian C29r. Their decline in diversity and abundance coincides with initiation of DCFB eruptions when most of the early taxa were terminated and only a few titanosauriforme sauropods survived becoming extinct at about 350 kyr before the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary (KPB).Dinosaur extinction in India is thus directly tied to Deccan volcanism with no evidence of an asteroid impact.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Deccan Continental Flood Basalt Eruption Terminated
Indian Dinosaurs before the Cretaceous-Paleogene Boundary
DHANANJAY M. MOHABEY1 and BANDANA SAMANT2
1Geological Survey of India, Nagpur - 440 001
2Department of Geology, RTM Nagpur University, Nagpur - 440 001
E-mail: dinomohabey@yahoo.com, bandanabhu@gmail.com
Abstract : Late Cretaceous-Early Paleogene sediments associated with Deccan Continental Flood Basalt (DCFB) sequences of
central and western India record the timing of the introduction and extinction of Late Cretaceous dinosaurs in India based on
magnetostratigraphy and magnetic susceptibility stratigraphy. Current taxonomy indicates that only two genera of titanosaurs
(e.g., Isisaurus and Jainosaurus), at least four species of large-bodied abelisauridae theropods (e.g., Rajasaurus narmadensis,
Rahiolisaurus gujaratensis, Indosuchus matleyi and Indosaurus raptorius) and a small-bodied theropod Laevisuchus inhabited
India during the Maastrichtian. Their stratigraphic and geographic distribution suggests that these dinosaurs were dominated by
titanosauriforme and abelisauridae that first appeared before the advent of Deccan volcanism in the magnetochron C30n and
were well established with the acme of breeding and nesting during C30n to maastrichtian C29r. Their decline in diversity and
abundance coincides with initiation of DCFB eruptions when most of the early taxa were terminated and only a few
titanosauriforme sauropods survived becoming extinct at about 350 kyr before the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary (KPB).
Dinosaur extinction in India is thus directly tied to Deccan volcanism with no evidence of an asteroid impact.
Key Words: Late Cretaceous, Indian Dinosaurs, Extinction, Deccan basalts.
GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF INDIA SPECIAL PUBLICATION
No. 1, 2013, pp.260-267
INTRODUCTION
Late Cretaceous dinosaur fossil are found in the Lameta
Formation underlying the Deccan Traps and intertrappean beds
at different stratigraphic levels in the Deccan Continental Flood
Basalt (DCFB) sequence. The history of Indian dinosaurs from
their first appearance to their extinction is recorded in these
sediments. Dinosaur remains from the Lameta and intertrappean
sediments from geographically separated DCFB sequences of
central and western India were studied. These studies were
supplemented with time-series analysis of the associated
sediments applying magnetostratigraphy and Milankovitch
st ra tigraphy to es ti ma te th e ag e o f ap pe ar ance an d
disappearance of dinosaurs from different stratigraphic levels.
The first dinosaur fossil from the Indian subcontinent
was discovered by W.H. Sleeman in 1828 from the Lameta
sediments of Jabalpur (Sleeman, 1844). This fossil was
eventually described as the first discovery of a Titanosaur
worldwide and established as holotype Titanosaurus indicus
in 1877 (Lydekker, 1877). Subsequent finds of Indian dinosaurs
skeletal remains have mostly come from the Lameta
Formation of Jabalpur in Madhya Pradesh, Pisdura and
Dongargaon in Chandrapur District in Maharashtra and Rahioli
in Kheda District Gujarat (Lydekker, 1877, 1879; Matley 1921,
1924; Von Huene and Matley 1933; Chakravarthi, 1934;
Dwivedi et al., 1982; Mohabey 1983, 1984,1987, 2011; Mathur
and Pant, 1986; Mathur and Srivastava, 1987; Jain and
Bandyopadhyay, 1997; Wilson et al., 2003; Mohabey and
Udhoji, 2000; Hansen et al., 2005). In comparison, reports of
dinosaur remains from intertrappean sediments are few. The
important in situ dinosaur bearing intertrappean localities
include Anjar and Dayapar in Kutch, Gujarat (Ghevariya, 1988;
Bhandari et al., 1995; Bajpai and Prasad, 2000) and Ranipur
in Madhya Pradesh (Sahni and Tripathi, 1990). Occurrences
of isolated dinosaur bones in intertrappean sediments have been
reported from Takli and Rama in Nagpur District, Maharashtra
and Asifabad in Andhra Pradesh (Lydekker, 1879; Prasad and
Khajuria, 1995; Mohabey, 2000; Hansen et al., 2005). The
marine influen ced din osaur bearing sedimen ts of the
Kallankurichi and Kallamedu formations in Ariyalur District
of Tamil Nadu are not associated with DCFB (Kohring et al.,
1996; Yadagiri and Govindan, 1998).
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
DECCAN CONTINENTAL FLOOD BASALT ERUPTION 261
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
STRATIGRAPHY OF LATE CRETACEOUS
DINOSAUR BEARING SEDIMENTS
Dinosaurs in Late Cretaceous sediments of India are
associated with the DCFB sequences, which are presently
considered to span from 69 to 63 Ma (Sheth et al., 2001)
straddling the Creta ceous-Paleogene boundar y (KPB).
However, the placement of the KPB within the DCFB
sequences has remained uncertain. The DCFB sequences
classified as Sahyadri, Amarkantak, Satpura and Malwa groups
occur in geographically separated areas. The DCFB sequences
of Kutch and Saurashtra in Gujarat are still unclassified. Based
on the chemostratigraphy, volcanostratigraphy and palyno-
stratigraphy, attempts have been made recently to establish a
spatio-temporal relationship of the different DCFB sequences
(Jay and Widdowson, 2008; Samant and Mohabey, 2009).
Knowledge of the stratigraphic resolution and duration
of the sedimentary beds associated with the DCFB sequences
remained almost non-existent until the recent time series
analysis by Hansen et al., (2001, 2005) in different volcanic
sectors in India, including the marine shore-line and shelf
sediments at Rajahmundry in the south. The latter represents
the marine sedimentary series associated with the DCFB, which
was identified as spanning the KPB transition based on the
presence of earliest Danian (zone P1a) planktic foraminifers
above the Deccan Traps (Keller et al., 2008). No dinosaur
remains are so far known from the sediments of the Godavari
basin (Rajahmundry area). Recently, Keller et al., (2011)
established the correlation between the exposed lava flows in
Rajahmundry and the subsurface lava flows and intertrappean
sediments from the Krishna-Godavari (K-G) Basin drilled by
ONGC. They identified the KPgB based on lower Danian zone
P1a planktic foraminiferal assemblage in the intertrappean
sediments between the megaflows of phase-2 at the end of
Maastrichtian and phase-3 in the early Danian.
Recent work by Keller and co-workers (Keller et al.,
2009) has resulted in identifying the KPgB transition within
an earliest Paleocene marine incursion based on the presence
of basal Danian zone P1a planktic foraminifers and associated
brackish water ostracods in the intertrappean sediments of
Jhilmili in Chhindwara District of Madhya Pradesh in central
India. This finding is vital and significant because it has
provided the first strong age control for the DCFB associated
sediments of the Amarkantak Group. Below the Jhilmili beds
the sediments of Amarkantak Group are dinosaur bearing at
certain stratigraphic levels in C30n as recorded at the
Mohagaon Kalan Well Section (Kar and Srinivasan, 1998;
Samant and Mohabey, 2009) and C29r at Ranipur (Sahni and
Tripathi, 1990; Hansen et al., 2005).
It is now known that sediment deposition associated with
DCFB was initiated during magnetochron C30n and continued
well after the KPB into the Paleocene (Hansen et al., 2005;
Keller et al., 2008, 2009). The reports of in situ dinosaur
remains are mostly from: i) Lameta sediments of Bara Simla,
Chota Simla and Chui Hills (Von Huene and Matley, 1933;
Mohabey, 2001) and intertrappean beds of Ranipur in Jabalpur
District (Sahni and Tripathi, 1990; Mathur and Sharma, 1990);
ii) Lameta sediments of Kheda and Panchamahals districts
(Mohabey, 2001a) and intertrappean sediments of Anjar and
Dayapar in Kutch District, Gujarat (Ghevariya, 1988); and iii)
La meta sed im en ts Pisdura and Dongarg ao n (Nand-
Dongargaon basin) in Chandrapur District of Maharashtra
(Mohabey et al., 1993) (Fig. 1). Dinosaur eggshells associated
with Maastrichtian palynoflora have also been described from
the intertrappean beds of Mohgaon Kalan Well Section
(MKWS) in the Chhindwara (Kar and Srinivasan, 1998;
Samant and Mohabey, 2009) and Ranipur in Jabalpur area
(Sahni and Tripathi, 1990; Mathur and Sharma, 1990) in
Madhya Pradesh.
LATE CRETACEOUS DINOSAUR DIVERSITY
AND AGE CONSTRAINTS
Beginning with the discovery of the first dinosaur bones
in 1828 almost all the Indian Late Cretaceous collection of
dinosaur remains has come from the Lameta Formation of
Jabalpur, Pisdura-Dongargaon and Kheda (Figs. 1, 2). The
specimens collected from the Jabalpur area have provided a
majority of the Indian specimens. Von Huene and Matley
(1933) described at least twenty dinosaur species representing
five titanosauriforme, thirteen theropods and two ornithopods
from these localities. However, the revised taxonomy considers
a majority of the genera and species (that were not associated
or incomplete) as either nomen dubia or invalid including
Titanosaurus indicus and T. blandfordi (Wilson et al., 2003a,b,
2009; Novas et al., 2004, 2010; Carrano et al., 2010). Presently,
amongst the sauropods only two titanosauriforme genera (viz.
Isisaurus and Jainosaurus), and for the theropods four large-
bodied abelisauridae theropods (viz. Rajasaurus narmadensis,
Ra hiolisaurus guja ra te nsis, Indosuchus ma tleyi and
Indosaurus raptorius) and a small-bodied theropod, Noasaurid
Laevisuchus, are considered valid. No ornithopods are now
considered to have existed in the Late Cretaceous on the Indian
subcontinent. Of the smaller theropod specimens, which are
historically described as Composuchus solus, Laevisuchus
indicus,Jubbulp oria tennuis and ot her und etermined
coelurosaurid, only Laevisuchus indicus is considered valid
having affinity to Masiakasaurus knopfleri from Madagascar.
The duration of sedimentation, age and the stratigraphic
placement and correlation of Late Cretaceous dinosaur bearing
262 D.M. MOHABEY AND BANDANA SAMANT
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
beds are constrained by magnetostratigraphy, Milankovitch
stratigraphy and stable organic carbon isotope studies by
Hansen et al., (2001, 2005). Seventeen sections of the DCFB
associated sediments were analyzed. Of these, nine sections
(Fig. 1, 2) containing dinosaur fossils (bones and/or nests and
eggs) are the focus for establishing the stratigraphic history of
Indian Late Cretaceous dinosaurs. The evidence of the earliest
Late Cretaceous dinosaurs in India consists of a single
reworked titanosaur egg (Megaloolithus, Kohring et al., 1996)
in Upper Campanian-Lower Maastrichtian marine sediments
of the Kallankurichi Formation at Ariyalur (Govindan et al.,
1998).
Sediments of the Lameta Formation at Jabalpur are of
special importance because the early discoveries of dinosaur
skeletons of various affinities were reported from Bara Simla
Hill and Chota Simla (Sleeman, 1844; Von Huene and Matley,
1933) and excavated in the 1930s. Vandamme and Courtillot
Fig.1. Map showing location of sections of Late Cretaceous dinosaur bearing sedimentary beds taken-up for study. The sediments are associated
with Deccan Continental Flood Basalt Sequences in western and central India and are described as sediments of the Lameta Formation
occurring below the Deccan basalts and as intertrappean beds occurring between the Deccan lava flows at different stratigraphic levels.
(1992) identified the lower part of the Lameta Formation at
Chui Hill as C29r and referred the upper part of the profile to
C29n. However, Hansen et al., (2005) demonstrated that the
whole Lameta series and the capping basalt at Chui Hill are
part of C29r (Fig. 2). They also demonstrated that the organic
carbon isotopes at Chui Hill across Cycle-Zero of the
susceptibility curve has corresponding anomalies with the KTB
section at El Kef, Tunisia and North Horn Formation, U.S.A.
The latest dinosaurs in the Jabalpur section appear as nests at
the level estimated around 350 kyr before the KPB (Fig. 2).
The nest at Lameta ghat occurs within the Lower Limestone
at this level. A couple of reworked incomplete and fragmented
eggs, possibly derived from the Lower Limestone, are found
in MNB on northern bank of Narmada River near Sivni Tola.
In the Gaur River at Ranipur the intertrappean lake sediments
(ca. 3 m thick) are exposed with laminated green shales
containing Maastrichtian palynoflora and associated dinosaur
DECCAN CONTINENTAL FLOOD BASALT ERUPTION 263
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
Fig. 2. Sections showing different late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) dinosaurs bearing sedimentary beds at different stratigraphic levels and their
correlation based on magneto-stratigraphy and magnetic susceptibility based on the study by Hansen et al., 2005. Only associated bones
of dinosaurs and their nests, eggs and eggshell debris has been considered as indicating the presence of dinosaurs during the sedimentation.
The period of active sedimentation in the various profiles in India is the pattern of magnetic susceptibility as recorded from North Horn
Formation, Utah, USA after Hansen et al 1996. Note level of appearance and disappearance of Maastrichtian dinosaurs in relation to K-
Pg Boundary. The numbers for the sections corresponds to the localities shown in Figure 1. (Magnetostratigraphy modified after Hansen
et al., 2005). Note that the presence of last dinosaurs in India occur at level around 350 kyr prior to KPB.
264 D.M. MOHABEY AND BANDANA SAMANT
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
(sauropod) pelvis and limb-bones (Sahni and Tripathi, 1990)
overlain by fossiliferous limestone and capping basalts of
the Amarkantak Group. The DCFB se qu ence of the
Amarkantak Group in Chhindwara-Jabalpur-Mandla sector
comprises over 500 m thick lava pile of at least 34 flows.
In Gujarat, western India, the Lameta sediments of
Kheda, which were deposited in C30n, have produced the
largest number of dinosaur skeletal remains and nesting sites
of titanosaurid and abelisaurid dinosaurs in India. The C30n
sediments of Kheda have yielded a unique specimen of a snake,
Sanajeh indicus, predating upon a sauropod hatchling
(Mohabey, 1987; Wilson et al., 2010). A t Anjar th e
intertrappean sediments with an associated partial skeleton of
a titanosauriforme dinosaur (Ghevariya, 1988, Mohabey, 2001)
were deposited during C29r (Hansen et al., 2001). The
sediments are interpreted as belonging to the early part of C29r.
The associated skeleton of titanosaur (Isisaurus?) suggests an
age older than 350 kyr below the KPB (Hansen et al., 2001,
2005) (Fig. 2).
In Bagh valley in the lower reaches of Narmada in Jhabua
and Dhar Districts in Madhya Pradesh, a large number of
sauropod nesting sites within the sandstones of the Lameta
Formation have been found. However, no dinosaur bones are
so far recorded from the Lameta of the Bagh valley. Recently,
one of us (DMM) located dorsal vertebrae, parts of illia and
pelvis and limb-bones of titanosauriforme affinity in the
intertrappean sedime nts associated with Maa strichtian
palynomorphs in a well section at Ukala. Weathered and
fragmented dinosaur bones were also found in the intertrappean
bed at the same stratigraphic level of the adjoining locality at
Nimpura in the Dhar District.
The dinosaur bearing sediments in Bagh valley, north of
Narmada are associated with the Malwa Group of DCFB. The
Malwa Group has more than 38 lava flows constituting a total
thickness of over 618 m. The intertrappean beds are found at
6 stratigraphic levels in the basal part of the Mandleshwar and
Kalisindh formations. The upper formations are devoid of any
intertrappean sedimentary beds. The dinosaur bearing
intertrappean bed at Ukala is in the third intertrappean in
stratigraphic order and is found at 333 m RL in the uppermost
part of the Mandleshwar Formation. The intertrappean
sediments at the lower stratigraphic level in the river section
at Bharadpura has yielded a rich Maastrichtian palynomorph
assemblage, including Aquilapollenites bengalensis and
Gabonisporis vigouraxii (Samant and Mohabey, unpublished
data).
In the Nand-Dongargaon basin at the Dongargaon Hill
section the Lameta sediments are associated with the dinosaur
bones and partially articulated skeleton of the associated bones
of Titanosaurus colberti (= Isisaurus colberti, Jain and
Bandyopadhyay, 1997; Wilson and Upchurch, 2003). The
bones were excavated from the green clays overlying the lake
sediments at Dongargaon Hill from the lower series of the
sediments deposited in C30n. The pattern of magnetic
susceptibility allows placement of Isisaurus around 500 kyr
prior to the KPB. The overlying sandstone at Pavna, Kholdoda
and Umred (Mohabey, 2001a) with sauropod eggs and nest
sites are deposits of C29r. The red clays at Pisdura that have
yielded skeletal remains of titanosaurid sauropods over the
last 150 years are deposits of C29r. The titansaurids described
from Pisdura include the earliest described Titanosaurus
blandfordi, T. indicus and Laplatosaurus madagascariensis
(Hislop, 1860; Hughes, 1877; Lydekker, 1879; Von Huene and
Matley, 1933) which are presently considered nomen dubia
(Wilson and Upchurch., 2003). The Pisdura red clays have
also produced plant bearing coprolites of sauropod (Mohabey,
2001b) and skeletal of chelonia (Pelomedusoid) turtles and a
madtsoia snake (Mohabey et al., 2011).
DISCUSSION
The stratigraphic record of earliest Late Cretaceous
dinosaurs in India is a single sauropod egg collected from the
Late Campanian-Early Maastrichtian marine sediments of
Ariyalur. However, the reworked nature of the egg and absence
of any dinosaur bones in the sediments presently do not permit
deriving any useful information in context to its stratigraphy
and phylogeny. The emerging evidence from the Late
Cretaceous of India and Pakistan suggests that the earliest
titanosauriforme-abelisaurid dinosaurs on the subcontinent
were first introduced during C30n of the Maastrichtian before
the eruption of the DCFB. These were the titanosauriforme
sauropods Isisaurus colberti as recorded from the N-D basin
and the large-bodied abelisurid theropod s Rajasaurus
narmadensis and Rahiolisaurus gujaratensis from Kheda,
Gujarat. There first appearance is registered at the stratigraphic
level ca. 500 kyr before the KPB in the Maastrichtian. Both
sauropods and theropods were well established with acme of
their breeding and nesting as witnessed by a large number of
their nest sites and eggs in Lameta sediments of C30n. Presence
of Isisaurus has also become known from the Late Cretaceous
Pab Formation of Baluchistan in Pakistan (Wilson et al., 2005)
and shows that the species was well dispersed in India during
the Maastrichtian. During the C29r of Maastrichtian the
abelisaurids were represented by Indosaurus matleyi and
Indosuchus raptorius and for the first time small theropods
noasaurid Laevisuchus indicus were introduced as recorded
from Jabalpur. A small noasaurid theropod jaw has been recently
collected from the C29r Lameta sediments of Pisdura in the N-
D basin associated with vertebrae of Madtsoia pisdurensis
DECCAN CONTINENTAL FLOOD BASALT ERUPTION 265
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
(Mohabey et al., 2011), pelomedusoid turtles and titano-
sauriforme bones and coprolites. The C29r Pisdura sediments
are covered by basaltic flows of reverse magnetic polarity.
It is suggested that the DCFB eruption during the
Maastrichtian C29r close to the KPB is responsible for the
termination of Indian dinosaurs. Possibly the initiation of local
volcanic activity and arrival of the first flows played a major
role and created hostile conditions due to atmospheric
deterioration as a direct result of Deccan eruptions and possibly
habitat destruction due to direct contact with lava fronts and
volcanic surges. The strategy for the struggling dinosaurs for
survival could be in fleeing to safer areas away from the active
volcanic field having rapid succession of eruptions and where
the local fissure eruptions were dominating. All but one or
two dinosaur species of titanosauriforme perished. These
survivors were also finally terminated with increasing volcanic
activity. The remains of the survivors are found in the sediments
associated in the basal part of the DCFB sequence as recorded
at Anjar and Ranipur in the sediments of Maastrichtian C29r.
The last dinosaurs are recorded at least 350 kyr below the
KPB closing the history of India’s Late Cretaceous dinosaurs
after a brief rein that may have lasted no more that 150 kyr
(500-350 kyr). Their demise well before the KPB appears
closely linked to the DCFB eruptions. The extinction of
dinosaurs in the Indian subcontinent thus appears unrelated to
the extra-terrestrial impact.
Acknowledgements : The authors extend their sincere
thanks to the Deputy Director General, Geological Survey of
India, Nagpur, for permitting to publish this paper. Discussions
and the joint work on the Indian Cretaceous sections under
MoU involving Prof. H.J. Hansen, Denmark and GSI has
contributed to the scope and objective of the paper. Discussion
with J.A. Wilson and Gerta Keller from time to time has helped
in the preparation of the manuscript. Thanks to the reviewers
for useful suggestions which improvised the manuscript. BS
is thankful to the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research,
New Delhi (Grant no. 24/297/08-EMR-II) for financial
assistance and to the Head, PG Department of Geology, RTM
Nagpur University, Nagpur for providing working facilities.
References
BAJPAI, S. and PRASAD, G.V. R. (2000) Cretaceous age for Ir-rich Deccan
intertrappean deposits: palaeonto-logical evidence from Anjar,
western India. Jour. Geol. Soc. London, v. 157, pp.257-260.
BHANDARI, N., SHUKLA, P. N., GHEVARIYA, Z. G., and SUNDERAM, S. M.
(1995) Impact did not trigger Deccan Volcanism: Evidence from
Anjar K/T boundary intertrappean section. Geophys. Res. Lett.,
1995,v. 22, pp. 433-436.
CARRANO, M.T., WILSON, J. A. and BARRETT, P. M.(2010) The history
of dinosaur collecting in central India 1828 -1947. Geol. Soc.
London, v. 343, pp. 161-173,
CHAKRAVATI, D.K. (1934) On a stegosaurian humerous from the Lameta
beds of Jubbalpore. Quart. Jour. Mineral. Metall. Soc. India, v.
30, pp.75-79.
DWIVEDI G.N., MOHABEY, D.M. and BHANDOPADHYAY, S. (1982) On the
discovery of vertebrate fossils from infratrappean Lameta beds,
Kheda District, Gujarat. Curr. Trends Geol., v.7, pp. 79-87.
GHEVARIYA, Z. G. (1988) Intertrappean dinosaur fossils from Anjar
area, Kachcha District, Gujarat. Curr. Sci., v. 57, pp. 248-251.
GOVINDAN, A., YADAGIRI, K., RAVINDRAN, C.N. and KALYANSUNDAR S.
(1998). A field guide on Cretaceous sequence of Tiruchirapalli
area, Cauvey basin, India. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation,
Chennai, p.73.
KOHRING, R., BANDEL, K. and PARTHASARTHY, S. (1996). Shell structure
of a dinosaur egg from Maastrichtian of Ariyalur. N.Jb. Geol.
Palon. Mh., H1, pp. 48-64.
HANSEN, H. J., MOHABEY, D. M. and TOFT, P. (2001) No K/T boundary
at Anjar, Gujarat, India: Evidence from magnetic susceptibility
and carbon isotopes. Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci. (Earth Planet Sci.),
v. 11, pp. 133-142.
HANSEN, H. J., MOHABEY, D. M., LOJEN, S., TOFT, P. and SARKAR, A.
(2005). Orbital cycles and Stable Carbon isotopes of sediments
associated with Deccan Volcanic Suite, India: Implications for
the stratigraphic correlation and Cretaceous-Tertiary Boundary.
Gond. Geol. Magz., Spl. v. 8, pp.5-28.
HISLOP S. (1860) On the Tertiary deposits associated with trap-rocks
in the East Indies. Quart. Jour. Geol. Soc. London, v. 16, pp.
154-166.
HUGHES, T.W.H. (1877) The Wardha Valley coal field . Mem. Geol.
Surv. India, No. 13, pp. 1-54.
JAI N, S. L. an d BHA NDO PADH YAY, S. (1997 ) New titan osurid
(Dinosauria; Sauropoda) from the Late Cretaceous of Central
India. Jour. Vert. Pal., v. 17(1), pp. 114-136.
JAY, A. E. and WIDDOWSON, M. (2008) Stratigraphy, structure and
volcanology of the SE Deccan Continental flood bas alt
province: implications for eruptive extent and volumes. Jour.
Geol. Soc., v. 165, pp. 177-188.
KAR, R. K. and SRINIVASAN, S. (1998) Late Cretaceous palynofossils
from the Deccan intertrappean beds of Mohgaon Kalan,
Chhindwara District, Madhya Pradesh. Geophytol., 1998, v.
27, pp. 17-22.
KELLER, G., ADATTE, T., GARDIN, S., BARTOLINI, A. and BAJPAI, S. (2008)
Main Deccan Volcanic phase end near the KT boundary:
evidence from the Krishna-Godavari Basin, SE India. Earth
and Planet. Sci. Lett., v. 268, pp. 293-311.
KELLER G., ADATTE, T., BAJPAI, S., MOHABEY, D. M., WIDDOWSON, M.,
KHOSLA, A., SHARMA R., KHOSLA, S.C., GERTSCH, B., FLEITMANN,
D. and SAHNI, A. (2009) K-T transition in Deccan Traps of
Central India marks major marine seaway across India. Earth
and Planet.. Sci. Lett., , v. 282 , pp. 10-23.
266 D.M. MOHABEY AND BANDANA SAMANT
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
KELLER, G., BHOWMICK, P.K., UPADHYAY, H., DAVE, A., REDDY, A.N.,
JAIPRAKASH, B.C., and ADATTE, T. (2011) Deccan volcanism
linked to the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary mass extinction:
new evidence from ONGC wells in the Krishna-Godavari basin.
Jour. Geol. Soc. India, v. 78, pp. 399-428.
KOHRING, R., BANDEL, K., KORTUM, D. and PARTHASARTHY, S. (1996)
Shell structure of dinosaur egg from Ariyalur (southern India).
N. Jh. Geol. Palaont. Mh., H1, pp. 48-64.
LYDEKKER, R. (1877) Notices of new and other vertebrata from Indian
Tertiary and Secondary rocks. Mem. Geol. Surv. India, No.
13, pp. 1-54.
LYDEKKER, R. (1879) Indian pre-Tertiary vertebrata. Fossil Reptilia
and Batrachia. Mem. Geol. Surv. India, Pal. Ind., Ser. (1), pp.
1-35.
MATHUR, U. B. and PANT, S.C. (1986) Sauropod dinosaur humeri from
Lameta Group (Upper Cretaceous Palaeocene?) of Kheda area,
Gujarat. Jour. Pal. Soc. India, 1986, v. 33, pp. 22-25.
MATHUR, U. B. and SRIVASTAVA, S. (1987) Dinosaur teeth from Lameta
Group (Upper Cretaceous) of Kheda District, Gujarat, Jour.
Geol. Soc. India, v.29, pp. 554-566.
MATHUR, N. S. and SHARM A, S. D. (1990) Palynofossil and the
age of the Ranipur intertrappean bed Gaur River Jabalpur,
M.P. In: A. Sahni and A. Jolley (eds) Cretaceous Event
Stratigraphy and the correlation of Indian Non-marine Strata
(eds) Seminar cum workshop IGCP 216 and 245, Chandigarh,
pp. 58-59.
MATLEY C.A. (1921) On the stratigraphy, fossils and geological
relationships of Lameta beds of Jabbalpore. Rec. Geol. Surv.
India, v. 53, pp.142-169.
MATLEY C.A. (1924) Note on the armored dinosaur from the
Lameta beds of Jabbalpore. Rec. Geol. Surv. India, v. 55, pp.
105-109.
MOHABEY, D.M. (1983). On the occurrence of dinosaurian fossil eggs
from Infratrappean Limestone, Kheda District, Gujarat. Curr.
Sci., v. 52(4), pp. 1194-1195.
MOHA BEY , D.M. (1984) The study of din osaurian eggs from
infratrappean limestone in Kheda District, Gujarat. Jour. Geol.
Soc. India, v. 5, pp. 329-337.
MOHABEY, D. M. (1987) Juvenile sauropod dinosaur from Upper
Cretaceous Lameta Formation of Panchmahals District, Gujarat,
India. Jour. Geol. Soc. India, v. 30, pp. 210-216.
MOHABEY, D. M. (2001a) Indian dinosaur eggs: a review. Jour. Geol.
Soc. India, v. 58, pp. 479-508.
MOHABEY, D. M. (2001b) Dinosaur eggs and dung mass (fecal mass)
from Late Cretaceous of central India. Geol. Surv. India, Spl.
Publ., v. 64, pp. 605-615.
MOHABEY D.M. (2011) History of Late Cretaceous dinosaurs finds in
India and current status of their study. Jour. Palaeon. Soc. India,
v. 56 (2), pp.127-135.
MOHABEY, D. M. and UDHOJI, S.G. (2000) Vertebrate fauna of Late
Cretaceous dinosaur-bearing Lameta Formation of Nand-
Dongargaon inland basin, Maharashtra: palaeoenvironment and
K-T boundary implications. Jour. Geol. Soc. India, Mem., v.
46, pp. 295-322.
MOH AB EY, D. M., UD HO JI , S.G. an d V ER MA, K. K. (19 93 )
Palaeontological and sedimentological observations on non-
marine Lameta Formation (Upper Cretaceous) of Maharashtra,
India: their palaeoecological and palaeoenvironmental signi-
ficance. Palaeogeo. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol., v.105, pp.
83-94.
MOHABEY, D. M., HEAD, J. J., and WILSON, J. A. (2011) A new species
of the snake Madtsoia pisdurensis from the Late Cretaceous of
India and its palaobiogeographical implications. Jour. Vert. Pal.,
v. 31(3), pp. 588-595.
NOVAS, F. E., AN GOLIN , F. L., and BHAN DOPADH YAY, S. (2004)
Cretaceous theropods from India: a review of specimens
described by Huene and Matley (1933). Rev. Mus. Argentino
Cienc. Nat., n.s. 6(1): pp. 67-103.
NOVAS , F.E., CHATT ERJ EE, S. , RUD RA, D. K. and DUT TA, P.M.
(2010) Rahiolisaurus gujaratensis, n. gen. n. sp., a new
abelisaurid theropod from the Late Cretaceous of India.
In: S. Bhan dopadhyay (eds) New Aspects of Mesozoic
Biodiversity, Lecture notes in Earth Sciences, 132, DOI
10.1007/978-3-642-10311-7_3, @Springer-verlag berlin
Heidelberg 2010.
PRASAD, G.V. R. and KHAJURIA, C. K. (1995) Implications of the infra-
and inter-trappean biota from from the Deccan India, for the
role of volcanism in Cretaceous-Tertiary Boundary extinction.
Jour. Geol. Soc. London, v. 152, pp. 289-296.
SAHNI, A. and TRIPATHI, A. (1990) Age implication of the Jabalpur
Lameta Formation and intertrappean biota. M.P. In: A.SAHNI
and A. JOLLEY (eds) Cretaceous Event Stratigraphy and the
correlation of Indian Non-marine Staratigarphy Seminar cum
workshop IGCP 216 and 245, Chandigarh, pp. 35-37.
SAMANT, B. and MOHABEY, D. M. (2009) Palynoflora from Deccan
volca no-sedim entar y seq uence (Cret aceou s-Paleog ene
transition) of central India; implications for spatio-temporal
correlation. Jour. Biosci., v. 34(5), pp. 811-823.
SHETH H.C., PANDE KANCHAN and BHUTANI, R. (2001) 40Ar-Ar39 age
of a national monument: the Gilbert Hill basalt, Deccan Trap,
Bombay, Curr. Sci., v. 80, pp. 1437-1440.
SLEEMAN, W.H. (1844) Rambles and recollection of an Indian Official,
I.J. Hatchard and Son, London, 478 p.
WILSON, J. A. and UPCHURCH, P. A. (2003) Revision of Titanosaurus
lydekker (Dinosauria- Sauropoda), the first dinosaur genus with
‘Gondwanan’ distribution. Jour. System. Pal., v. 1(3), pp.
125-160.
WILSON, J. A., PAUL, C. S., SRIVASTAVA, S., BHATT, D. K., KHOSLA, A.
and SAH NI , A. (2 003) A new abelis aurid (Dinos auria ,
Theropo da) fr om the La meta F omation (Cret aceou s,
Maastrichtian) of India. Contrib. Mus. Pal., Uni. Michigan,
31(1), pp.1-42.
WILSON, J. A., MALKANI, S. and GINGERICH, P. D. (2005) A sauropod
brainc ase from the Pab Fo rmation (Upper Cretaceous,
Maastrichtian) of Balochistan, Pakistan. Gond. Geol. Magz.,
v. 8, pp. 101-109.
WILSON, J. A., D’EMIC MICHAEL, D., CURRY ROGERS, K.A., MOHABEY,
D. M. and SEN, S. (2009) Reassessment of sauropod dinosaur
Jainosaurus (=Antarctosaurus)septentrionalis from the Upper
Cretaceous of India. Contribs. Mus. Pal. Uni. Michigan, v. 32
(2), pp. 17-40.
WILSON, J. A., MOHABEY, D. M., PETER, S. E. and HEAD, J. J. (2010)
Predation upon hatchling dinosaurs by a new snake from the
Late Cretaceous of India. PLoS Bio., v. 8(3), pp. 1-10.
DECCAN CONTINENTAL FLOOD BASALT ERUPTION 267
GEOL. SOC. INDIA, SPEC. PUBL. No. 1, 2013
VANDAMME, D. and COURTILLOT, V. (1992) Palaeomagnetic constraints
on the structure of Deccan Traps. Phys. Earth. Planet. Int., v.
74, pp. 241-261.
VON HUENE, F.B. and MATLEY, C.A. (1933) Cretaceous-Saurischia
and Ornithischia of the Central Provinces of India, Geol. Surv.
India, Mem. 1,Pal. India, No. 21, pp. 1-24.
YADAGIRI, K. and GOVINDAN, A. (1998) Cretaceous carbonate platforms
in Cauvery basin: sedimentology, depositional setting and
subsurface signatures. Mem. Geol. Soc. India, No. 46, pp.
323-344.
... Intertrappean beds represent sediments that were deposited during pauses in the volcanic activity and paleosols (red and green boles) that formed after the weathering of the immediately underlying lava flows. Mapping of the lava flows by the Geological Survey of India in the Central and Eastern Deccan Volcanic Province (EDVP, including the Mandla Lobe), which includes some Lameta Formation (Maastrichtian) of the most paleontologically productive intertrappean deposits, has indicated various sources of volcanic eruptions and variance in timing, duration, and intensity of the eruptions in different sectors and provinces (Yedekar et al., 1996;Mohabey and Samant, 2013). Infratrappean beds, sediments usually attributed to the Lameta Formation, are those immediately underlying the lowest lava flows in the province; they include well-documented Maastrichtian dinosaur remains from multiple localities (Mohabey, 1990(Mohabey, , 2005Mohabey and Samant, 2013). ...
... Mapping of the lava flows by the Geological Survey of India in the Central and Eastern Deccan Volcanic Province (EDVP, including the Mandla Lobe), which includes some Lameta Formation (Maastrichtian) of the most paleontologically productive intertrappean deposits, has indicated various sources of volcanic eruptions and variance in timing, duration, and intensity of the eruptions in different sectors and provinces (Yedekar et al., 1996;Mohabey and Samant, 2013). Infratrappean beds, sediments usually attributed to the Lameta Formation, are those immediately underlying the lowest lava flows in the province; they include well-documented Maastrichtian dinosaur remains from multiple localities (Mohabey, 1990(Mohabey, , 2005Mohabey and Samant, 2013). In some basins, Lameta sedimentation terminated with the arrival of the first basaltic flows in the area, and, with increasing volcanism, subsequent intertrappean beds were deposited between the flows during the period of repose, while in other basins, Lameta sedimentation continued when the initiation of the volcanism in the area was relatively late. ...
... In some basins, Lameta sedimentation terminated with the arrival of the first basaltic flows in the area, and, with increasing volcanism, subsequent intertrappean beds were deposited between the flows during the period of repose, while in other basins, Lameta sedimentation continued when the initiation of the volcanism in the area was relatively late. Implicitly, the intertrappean beds of the former are time-equivalent to the continued Lameta sedimentation in latter (Hansen et al., 2005;Mohabey, 2005;Mohabey and Samant, 2013). ...
Article
During the Cretaceous and Paleogene, the Indian subcontinent was isolated as it migrated north from the east coast of Africa to collide with Asia. As it passed over the Reunion hotspot in the late Maastrichtian–early Danian, a series of lava flows extruded, known as the Deccan Traps. Also during this interval, there was a major mass-extinction event at the Cretaceous–Paleogene boundary, punctuated by a meteorite impact at Chicxulub, Mexico. What were the biological implications of these changes in paleogeography and the extensive volcanism in terms of biodiversity, evolution, and biogeography? By combining chronostratigraphic, paleosol, and paleobotanical data, an understanding of how the ecosystems and climates changed and the relative contributions of the Chicxulub impact, Deccan Traps volcanism, and paleogeographic isolation can be gained. Understanding relative ages of paleobotanical localities is crucial to determining floristic changes, and is challenging because different methods (e.g., magnetostratigraphy, radiometric dating, vertebrate and microfossil biostratigraphy) sometimes give conflicting answers, or have not been done for paleobotanical localities. Climatic data can be obtained quantitatively by studying paleosol geochemistry, as well as qualitatively by examining functional traits and nearest living relatives of fossil plants. An additional challenge is revising macrofossil data, which includes some confidently identified taxa and others with uncertain affinities. This is important for understanding ecosystem composition both spatially and temporally, as well as the biogeographic implications of an isolated India.
... Unfortunately, these simplistic age proxies are typically unaccompanied by (and can preclude) deeper investigation of the age of deposition, and in some cases, they can even overturn actual sampling of age data. For example, important dinosaur-bearing infratrappean localities at Rahioli and Bara Simla (Jabalpur) have been considered to be the same age, even though they were deposited in different inland basins during different magnetic polarity chrons (C30n and C29r, respectively; Hansen et al., 1996Hansen et al., , 2005Mohabey and Samant, 2013). Description of Deccanolestes hislopi by Prasad and Sahni (1988) led to more purposeful and intensive sampling for vertebrate microfossils in Deccan Trap-associated sedimentary deposits. ...
... Likewise, the palynoflora is distinct from other definitively older Maastrichtian intertrappean palynofloras (Thakre et al., 2017;Samant et al., 2020a). This would imply that the terrestrial fauna and flora had undergone significant turnover and modifications in community structure prior to the bolide impact at the KPB, as has been suggested previously for India (Samant and Mohabey, 2009;Mohabey and Samant, 2013). This taxonomic pattern contrasts with that from contemporaneous latest Cretaceous (Lancian) vertebrate fossil assemblages from North America, which do show changes in mammalian evenness (Wilson, 2014) and dinosaur relative abundances (Horner et al., 2011) but do not show declining dinosaur richness or major palynofloral turnover in the last hundreds of thousands of years of the Cretaceous (Fastovsky and Bercovici, 2016). ...
... Not only are there infratrappean horizons that are younger than intertrappean horizons, a finer breakdown of DTVP-associated sediments is beginning to emerge. Our results combined with previous work on fossiliferous sites in the DTVP (Hansen et al., 2005;Mohabey and Samant, 2013;Mohabey et al., 2019) suggest the presence of at least six distinct groups of localities: C30N infratrappeans (e.g., Rahioli), 30N intertrappeans (e.g., Mohgaon Kalan, Bagwanya, Bharudpura, Ukala), C30N-C29R infratrappeans (e.g., Dongargaon), C29R Maastrichtian infratrappeans (e.g., Bara Simla), C29R Maastrichtian intertrappeans (e. g., Ranipur, Takli, Anjar), and C29R 'transitional' intertrappeans (e.g., Naskal, Rangapur, ?Kisalpuri, ?Upparhati). These temporally distinct sites and associated biota force reconsideration of simplistic lumping of fossils from infratrappean and intertrappean localities in faunal discriminatory analyses (e.g., Halliday et al., 2018Halliday et al., , 2020. ...
Article
The first Cretaceous mammals described from India were recovered from the Naskal locality, on the southeastern edge of the Deccan Traps Volcanic Province (DTVP), where it is preserved between two basalt flows. Because the DTVP eruptions spanned the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary (KPB), it is often unknown whether trap-associated fossil sites are latest Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) or early Paleocene in age. The Naskal locality accounts for nearly half of published mammal records from DTVP-associated sediments as well as a host of other vertebrate microfossils. Its age takes on singular importance in the context of mammalian evolution in India and the effects of the end-Cretaceous mass extinction and subsequent evolutionary radiation of placentals. Here we describe two new mammal species, Indoclemensia naskalensis gen. et sp. nov. and I. magnus sp. nov., from Naskal and present evidence from ⁴⁰Ar/³⁹Ar geochronology, magnetostratigraphy, and chemostratigraphy of the over- and underlying basalt flows to refine the age of the Naskal locality and nearby Rangapur locality. In conjunction with palynostratigraphy and vertebrate biostratigraphy, these sites can be confidently restricted to a <100 kyr interval spanning the KPB. The most probable ⁴⁰Ar/³⁹Ar age is latest Cretaceous (66.136–66.056 Ma), but an earliest Paleogene age cannot be ruled out. We explore the implications of this age assignment for the Deccan chemostratigraphy and Deccan volcanism, Cretaceous-Paleogene (K/Pg) mass extinction, Indian mammalian faunal evolution, and the timing of the origin of placental mammals.
... Unfortunately, these simplistic age proxies are typically unaccompanied by (and can preclude) deeper investigation of the age of deposition, and in some cases, they can even overturn actual sampling of age data. For example, important dinosaur-bearing infratrappean localities at Rahioli and Bara Simla (Jabalpur) have been considered to be the same age, even though they were deposited in different inland basins during different magnetic polarity chrons (C30n and C29r, respectively; Hansen et al., 1996Hansen et al., , 2005Mohabey and Samant, 2013). Description of Deccanolestes hislopi by Prasad and Sahni (1988) led to more purposeful and intensive sampling for vertebrate microfossils in Deccan Trap-associated sedimentary deposits. ...
... Likewise, the palynoflora is distinct from other definitively older Maastrichtian intertrappean palynofloras (Thakre et al., 2017;Samant et al., 2020a). This would imply that the terrestrial fauna and flora had undergone significant turnover and modifications in community structure prior to the bolide impact at the KPB, as has been suggested previously for India (Samant and Mohabey, 2009;Mohabey and Samant, 2013). This taxonomic pattern contrasts with that from contemporaneous latest Cretaceous (Lancian) vertebrate fossil assemblages from North America, which do show changes in mammalian evenness (Wilson, 2014) and dinosaur relative abundances (Horner et al., 2011) but do not show declining dinosaur richness or major palynofloral turnover in the last hundreds of thousands of years of the Cretaceous (Fastovsky and Bercovici, 2016). ...
... Not only are there infratrappean horizons that are younger than intertrappean horizons, a finer breakdown of DTVP-associated sediments is beginning to emerge. Our results combined with previous work on fossiliferous sites in the DTVP (Hansen et al., 2005;Mohabey and Samant, 2013;Mohabey et al., 2019) suggest the presence of at least six distinct groups of localities: C30N infratrappeans (e.g., Rahioli), 30N intertrappeans (e.g., Mohgaon Kalan, Bagwanya, Bharudpura, Ukala), C30N-C29R infratrappeans (e.g., Dongargaon), C29R Maastrichtian infratrappeans (e.g., Bara Simla), C29R Maastrichtian intertrappeans (e. g., Ranipur, Takli, Anjar), and C29R 'transitional' intertrappeans (e.g., Naskal, Rangapur, ?Kisalpuri, ?Upparhati). These temporally distinct sites and associated biota force reconsideration of simplistic lumping of fossils from infratrappean and intertrappean localities in faunal discriminatory analyses (e.g., Halliday et al., 2018Halliday et al., , 2020. ...
Conference Paper
The first Cretaceous mammals described from India were recovered from the Naskal locality, located near the village of Naskal in the state of Telangana. The Naskal locality is located on the eastern edge of the Deccan Traps Volcanic Province (DTVP), where it is preserved between two basalt flows. Naskal and similarly preserved sites are “intertrappean” in position and are distinguished from “infratrappean” sedimentary exposures, which are positionally below the locally lowest basalt flow. Historically, this field-based designation has been used as a proxy for relative age assignments, with intertrappean sites generally considered to be of similar age to each other, but collectively younger than infratrappean (Lameta Formation) sites. However, the DTVP flow stratigraphy is complex, so this age proxy can be incomplete and misleading. Moreover, because the DTVP eruptions spanned the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary (KPB), it is often unknown whether intertrappean sites, including Naskal, are Cretaceous or Paleogene in age. Naskal accounts for nearly half of published mammal records from DVTP-associated sediments, as well as a host of other microfossils. The age of the Naskal locality takes on singular importance in the context of mammalian evolution in India and the effects of the end-Cretaceous mass extinction and subsequent evolutionary radiation. Here we present evidence from Ar/Ar geochronology, magnetostratigraphy, and chemostratigraphy of the over- and underlying basalt flows to narrow the permissible age of the sediments at the Naskal locality. In conjunction with palynostratigraphy and vertebrate biostratigraphy, this site can be confidently restricted to a <100 ka interval spanning the KPB. The most probable Ar/Ar age is latest Cretaceous, but an earliest Paleogene age cannot be ruled out. We explore the implications of this age assignment, and additionally describe two new mammal species from the same genus from Naskal.
... However, results from these different methods are not congruous. Yedekar (1996) and Mohabey and Samant (2013) Shrivastava et al. (2015) and Kale and Pandey (2022) opined that Mandla basalt sequence is indicative of Danian age. Hence intertrappean sequence at and around Mandla cannot be older than Danian. ...
Article
Sedimentary rocks sandwiched between two successive lava flows in Deccan Volcanic Province (DVP) are known as Deccan intertrappean rocks. Fossils of both plants and invertebrates of uppermost Cretaceous to lowermost Palaeocene are present in some of these intertrappean rocks like that in the village Barga. Among the invertebrate fossils, gastropods dominate and because of their benthic nature, they helped a lot to decipher the palaeoenvironment. Gastropod Stenothyra has not yet been reported from any of the Deccan intertrappean. The present work records the presence of the gastropod Stenothyra for the first time from Barga Deccan intertrappean. Its occurrence points to prevalence of brackish water riverine environment at that time in the study area.
... However, results from these different methods are not congruous. Yedekar (1996) and Mohabey and Samant (2013) Shrivastava et al. (2015) and Kale and Pandey (2022) opined that Mandla basalt sequence is indicative of Danian age. Hence intertrappean sequence at and around Mandla cannot be older than Danian. ...
Article
Full-text available
Sedimentary rocks sandwiched between two successive lava flows in Deccan Volcanic Province (DVP) are known as Deccan intertrappean rocks. Fossils of both plants and invertebrates of uppermost Cretaceous to lowermost Palaeocene are present in some of these intertrappean rocks like that in the village Barga. Among the invertebrate fossils, gastropods dominate and because of their benthic nature, they helped a lot to decipher the palaeoenvironment. Gastropod Stenothyra has not yet been reported from any of the Deccan intertrappean. The present work records the presence of the gastropod Stenothyra for the first time from Barga Deccan intertrappean. Its occurrence points to prevalence of brackish water riverine environment at that time in the study area.
... In general, a time of 0.5 Myr is interpreted from the IMC accretion and start of the non-metal extinction anomaly until the period boundary. Thus, dinosaurs would still be alive after the first Deccan LIP volcanism in the early intertrappean sediments as reported by Courtillot et al. (2000) and Mohabey and Samant (2015). ...
Book
Full-text available
A new property of Earth has been discovered. It is called "Earth's non-metal signature". This is a series of non-meal compounds and noble elements deposited throughout geologic time. All the mass extinctions are related to this. A theory of planetary evolution is formulated to explain this non-metal geologic overprint. The theory roughly explains all supercontinent formation and breakup cycles and why a supercontinent will never form again.
... Sediments that are associated with and positioned below the DCFB are called "infratrappean" while sediments that lie in between the flows and were deposited during breaks in volcanic activ-ity are called "intertrappean". These intertrappean sediments have yielded a variety of fossil assemblages (Kapgate, 2005;Bonde, 2008;Khosla and Verma, 2014;Smith et al., 2015;, including dinosaurs (Mohabey and Samant, 2013) and palynomorphs . Stratigraphic resolution and the duration of the sedimentary units and flows in the Deccan volcanic province are constrained by magnetostratigraphy, Milankovitch stratigraphy and stable organic carbon isotope studies (Hansen et al., 2001(Hansen et al., , 2005Verma and Khosla, 2019). ...
Article
Full-text available
The Deccan Continental Flood Basalt (DCFB) sequence of India includes the volcanic flows of the Deccan Traps and the intertrappean sedimentary lacustrine deposits that lie in between the flows. The well-preserved arcellinidan taxon Centropyxis aculeata and associated diatoms on their tests are described for the first time in India from palaeolake sediments (Maastrichtian) of the Bagwanya Intertrappean sequence in Central India. Laminated shales and clays yielded diatoms, arcellinidans and sponge spicules, whereas other lithofacies composed mainly of black cherts yielded marker palynomorphs of Maastrichtian age. Diatoms isolated from the sediments include the poorly preserved centric diatom Aulacoseira and other pennate diatoms. Sponge spicules are present in this microfossil assemblage and show similarity with the extant genus Corvospongilla. Five diatom taxa, Cyclotella sp. (? meneghiniana); Pantocsekiella sp. (? ocellata); Achnanthes sp. (? brevipes); Diadesmis sp. (? confervacea); and Oricymba sp. (? tianmuensis), found associated with the tests of Centropyxis aculeata have been described. Palaeoecological interpretation of this palaeolake is based on the information derived from lithology, arecllinidans, diatoms and the palynomorphs. Bagwanya Palaeolake was a perennial, warm water, well oxygenated and very low salinity lake, surrounded by tropical to subtropical terrestrial and aquatic plants along its coast and also under shallow waters. The environment in this lake was under stress due to ongoing and extensive volcanism in the region, leading to SO2 and CO2 outgassing. Xenosomes of sand and various species of diatoms on the test of Centropyxis aculeata indicate that the shallow benthic environments of the lake had a sandy substrate.
... Sediments that are associated with and positioned below the DCFB are called "infratrappean" while sediments that lie in between the flows and were deposited during breaks in volcanic activ-ity are called "intertrappean". These intertrappean sediments have yielded a variety of fossil assemblages (Kapgate, 2005;Bonde, 2008;Khosla and Verma, 2014;Smith et al., 2015;, including dinosaurs (Mohabey and Samant, 2013) and palynomorphs . Stratigraphic resolution and the duration of the sedimentary units and flows in the Deccan volcanic province are constrained by magnetostratigraphy, Milankovitch stratigraphy and stable organic carbon isotope studies (Hansen et al., 2001(Hansen et al., , 2005Verma and Khosla, 2019). ...
Article
Full-text available
ABSTRACT The Deccan Continental Flood Basalt (DCFB) sequence of India includes the volcanic flows of the Deccan Traps and the intertrappean sedimentary lacustrine deposits that lie in between the flows. The well-preserved arcellinidan taxon Centropyxis aculeata and associated diatoms on their tests are described for the first time in India from palaeolake sediments (Maastrichtian) of the Bagwanya Intertrappean sequence in Central India. Laminated shales and clays yielded diatoms, arcellinidans and sponge spicules, whereas other lithofacies composed mainly of black cherts yielded marker palynomorphs of Maastrichtian age. Diatoms isolated from the sediments include the poorly preserved centric diatom Aulacoseira and other pennate diatoms. Sponge spicules are present in this microfossil assemblage and show similarity with the extant genus Corvospongilla. Five diatom taxa, Cyclotella sp. (? meneghiniana); Pantocsekiella sp. (? ocellata); Achnanthes sp. (? brevipes); Diadesmis sp. (? confervacea); and Oricymba sp. (? tianmuensis), found associated with the tests of Centropyxis aculeata have been described. Palaeoecological interpretation of this palaeolake is based on the information derived from lithology, arecllinidans, diatoms and the palynomorphs. Bagwanya Palaeolake was a perennial, warm water, well oxygenated and very low salinity lake, surrounded by tropical to subtropical terrestrial and aquatic plants along its coast and also under shallow waters. The environment in this lake was under stress due to ongoing and extensive volcanism in the region, leading to SO2 and CO2 outgassing. Xenosomes of sand and various species of diatoms on the test of Centropyxis aculeata indicate that the shallow benthic environments of the lake had a sandy substrate.
... The sampled eggshells are parataxonomically assigned to oogenus Megaloolithus and oogenus Ellipsoolithus of the oofamily Elongatoolithdae (Mikhailov, 1991;Mohabey, 1998Mohabey, , 2001 and taxonomically belong to sauropods and theropods (Zhao, 1975;Erben et al., 1979;Hirsch and Packard, 1987;Mikhailov, 1991;Chiappe et al., 1998;Loyal et al., 1999;Mohabey, 2005). The taxonomic revision of Late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) Indian dinosaurs has clarified that only Titansauriforme sauropods (Isisaurus, Jainosaurus) and Abelisaurid thereopods (large sized Indosaurus, Indosuchus, Rajasaurus, Rahiolisaurus and small sized Noasaurids Laevisuchus) were present in the Indian subcontinent (Wilson et al., 2003;Wilson and Mohabey, 2006;Novas et al., 2010;Mohabey and Samant, 2013). Some photographs of complete eggshells and their occurrence in clutches were given in one of our earlier publications (Sarkar et al., 1991). ...
Article
Full-text available
The thermal physiology of non-avian dinosaurs, especially the endothermic/ectothermic nature of their metabolism , inferred indirectly using body mass, biophysical modelling, bone histology and growth rate, has long been a matter of debate. Clumped isotope thermometry, based on the thermodynamically driven preference of 13 C-18 O bond in carbonate minerals of fossilized eggshells, yields temperature of egg formation in the oviduct and can delineate the nature of thermoregulation of some extinct dinosaur taxa. In the present study, the clumped isotope thermometry was applied to the eggshells of a few species of modern birds and reptiles to show that it is possible to obtain the body temperatures of these species in most of the cases. We then used this method to the fossil eggshells of Late Cretaceous sauropods and theropods recovered from western and central India. The estimated body temperatures varied between 29 C and 46 C, with an overall average of 37 C, significantly higher than the environmental temperature (about 25 C) of this region during the Late Cretaceous. The results also show that the theropod species with low body masses (~800 kg) had high body temperature (~38 C), while some gigantic (~20000 kg) sauropods had low body temperatures that were comparable to or slightly higher than the environmental temperature. Our analyses suggest that these Late Cretaceous giant species were endowed with a capacity of variable thermoregulation to control their body temperature.
Article
Full-text available
Palynological study of eleven intertrappean beds at ten stratigraphic levels in Betul district, Madhya Pradesh provided new insight into biota, age and depositional environment of Satpura Group. Study indicates presence of monospecific assemblage of dinoflagellate cyst Pierceites deccanensis at Hiradehi intertrappean at lower stratigraphic level. Diverse palynoassemblage represented by 3 genera and 3 species of pteridophytes, one genus and one species of gymnosperms, 8 genera and 10 species of angiosperms and 12 genera and 12 species of fungal spores are recorded from Kanhobagholi intertrappean at higher stratigraphic level. Presence of age marker taxa such as Azolla cretacea, Aquilapollenites bengalensis, Aquilapollenites intertrappeus, Echitricolpites sp., Farabeipollis minutes, Farabeipollis deccanensis sp. nov., Jiangsupollis major suggest Late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) age for this intertrappean. Microflora of intertrappean beds at lower stratigraphic levels (Hiradehi and Topidhana) show deposition in semiarid-arid climate and intertrappean beds at higher stratigraphic levels especially Kanhobagholi in warm humid climatic conditions and freshwater to estuarine depositional environment. Two intertrappean namely, Kanhobagholi, and Hatnajhiri from this part also yielded freshwater ostracodes.
Article
Full-text available
Resumen The Late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) Lameta Formation of central India has yielded dissociated elements of a variety of predatory dinosaurs, most of them coming from a quarry named the "Carnosaur bed." The materials were described by Huene and Matley nearly 70 years ago. They recognized nine theropod species, which they sorted out into the theropod subgroups "Carnosauria" and "Coelurosauria". Huene and Matley also described a considerable amount of theropod hindlimb bones (e.g., femora, tibiae, metatarsals, and pedal phalanges) that they could not refer to any of these species, but vaguely interpreted as corresponding to "allosaurid" or "coelurosaurid" theropods. We reviewed the available collection of Cretaceous theropods from Bara Simla housed at the Geological Survey of India, Calcutta, arriving to the following conclusions: 1) Indosuchus and Indosaurus are abelisaurids, as recognized by previous authors, but available information is not enough to judge whether they are synonyms; 2) Laevisuchus indicus is a small abelisauroid, related to Noasaurus and Masiakasaurus on the basis of their peculiar cervical vertebrae; 3) the controversial taxa " Compsosuchus", " Dryptosauroides", " Ornithomimoides", and " Jubbulpuria" are represented by isolated vertebrae corresponding to different portions of the neck and tail, and also exhibit abelisauroid features; 4) hindlimb bones originally referred to as "allosaurid" and "coelurosaurian" also exhibit abelisauroid characters, and bones of large size are tentatively referred to as corresponding to Indosuchus or Indosaurus, whereas some pedal bones of smaller size may belong to Laevisuchus; 5) two kinds of abelisaurid feet are apparent: one in which the phalanges of digit III and IV are robust, and another type in which the phalanges of digit IV are transversely narrow and dorsoventrally deep. This review demonstrates that all of the theropod elements discovered at the "Carnosaur bed" belong to a single theropod clade, the Abelisauroidea
Article
Theropod and sauropod dinosaur teeth are being described for the first time from Lameta Group (Upper Cretaceous) of Kheda District, Gujarat. Carnosaurian teeth show megalosaurid characters and are placed in Majungasaurus (Megalosaurus) crenatissimus and (?) Megalosaurus. Five morphological types of (?) Megalosaurus teeth have been distinguished which vary from laterally compressed flattened cones to recurved ones having serrations on anterior/posterior margins and directed either at right angles or obliquely to the margins. The sauropod dinosaur teeth are tentatively place in Titanosaurus and described as a new species viz., (?) Titanosaurus rahioliensis. -Authors
Article
The knowledge on the Indian Late Cretaceous dinosaurs is mainly based on the monumental work done prior to independence of India by Richard Lydekker, Charles Alfred Matley and Friedrich von Huene. The early collection of dinosaurs mainly came from the Lameta sediments at Bara Simla and Chhota Simla, Jabalpur in Madhya Pradesh and Pisdura in Maharashtra. The first dinosaur bone in India was discovered by W.H. Sleeman from the Lameta sediments in 1828, but could be identified as of dinosaurs only after 45 years by Lydekker in 1877, who established a new species Titanosaurus indicus for it. A major collection mostly came from the excavation by Matley during his expedition to India in 1917-1924 and 1932-33. Huene and Matley jointly worked on the collection during the first expedition from Bara Simla and published their work in 1933. They described four sauropod and eleven species from the collection. After this, it took over 50 years to make new discovery of Late Cretaceous dinosaurs in the Indian subcontinent. The new finds included the discovery of associated abelisaurid-titanosaurid skeletons and their eggs and nest sites from Lameta of the Kheda area in Gujarat in 1981. The new finds from India and its allied southern Gondwana landmasses and emerging phylogenetic information necessitated the taxonomic revision of the Indian dinosaurs. For the Indian titanosaurifome sauropods, the current review accepts only Isisaurus colberti and Jainosaurus septentrionalis as valid. Amongst theropods presently only three large bodied abelisauridae (Indosuchus raptorius, Indosaurus matleyi and Rajasaurus narmadensis) and small bodied theropod Laevisuchus indicus are recognized. The lack of associated skeletons from the Indian Cretaceous has caused difficulties in establishing phylogenetic relationships amongst the Indian Late Cretaceous dinosaurs. In this context, it becomes important to collect all the missing information on the stratigraphy, horizon and location for the collection made prior to 1933 and removed from India to NMH or AMNH. There is now a need to bring all the collection together and study them for the comparative study amongst the individual and different species for taxonomic study and developing phylogenetic relationships.