ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

The aim of this study was to assess escapement success of silver eels, Anguilla anguilla (L.), in a lowland river while passing a reservoir and a hydropower station. It was hypothesized that passage success would be lowest at the hydropower station and that survival and migration speed would be highest in the free‐flowing river section upstream the reservoir. Forty‐five female silver eels 56–86 cm in length were tagged with acoustic transmitters and released in November 2006. Their migration was monitored via automatic listening stations (ALS) in various sections of the river, covering a total migration distance of 64 km. Survival and progression rate of downstream migration was highest in the upstream river section and significantly lower in the reservoir. The eels apparently had trouble finding their way past the turbines and spent between 1.5 and 35 h in the forebay. The results show that within the study period, only 23% of the tagged eels reached the tidal limit, mainly due to difficulties in passing the hydropower dam. With such high loss‐rates, the escapement goals set in the management plan cannot be achieved.
Loss of European silver eel passing a hydropower station
By M. I. Pedersen
1
, N. Jepsen
1
, K. Aarestrup
1
, A. Koed
1
, S. Pedersen
1
and F. Økland
2
1
DTU-Aqua, Section for Freshwater Fisheries Ecology, Silkeborg, Denmark;
2
Norwegian Institute for Nature Research, Trondheim,
Norway
Summary
The aim of this study was to assess escapement success of silver
eels, Anguilla anguilla (L.), in a lowland river while passing a
reservoir and a hydropower station. It was hypothesized that
passage success would be lowest at the hydropower station and
that survival and migration speed would be highest in the free-
flowing river section upstream the reservoir. Forty-five female
silver eels 56–86 cm in length were tagged with acoustic
transmitters and released in November 2006. Their migration
was monitored via automatic listening stations (ALS) in
various sections of the river, covering a total migration
distance of 64 km. Survival and progression rate of down-
stream migration was highest in the upstream river section and
significantly lower in the reservoir. The eels apparently had
trouble finding their way past the turbines and spent between
1.5 and 35 h in the forebay. The results show that within the
study period, only 23% of the tagged eels reached the tidal
limit, mainly due to difficulties in passing the hydropower dam.
With such high loss-rates, the escapement goals set in the
management plan cannot be achieved.
Introduction
The European eel population (Anguilla anguilla L.) has
declined considerably over the past decades. The present
recruitment of glass eels is only about 1–9% of the late-1970s
level, indicating a historically low spawning stock in the
Sargasso Sea (ICES, 2009). Consequently, the International
Council for the Exploitation of the Sea (ICES) stated that the
eel stock was beyond safe biological limits and recommended
that anthropogenic activities affecting the stock be reduced as
much as possible (ICES, 2001). This led to a proposed EU
recovery plan for the eel populations (EU, 2007). As part of
this plan, management measures must be implemented to meet
a target of 40% silver eel escapement from individual river
basins or eel management units.
Silver eel river migrations occur mainly during autumn, but
some migration activity is also observed in the spring
(Aarestrup et al., 2008). The timing of silver eel runs has been
related to the increases in water discharge (Haraldstad et al.,
1984; Vøllestad et al., 1986), lunar phases, and water temper-
ature (Vøllestad et al., 1986; Tesch, 2003). Migration activity
is, in general, nocturnal (Tesch, 2003).
To acquire knowledge on the behaviour and escapement of
migrating silver eels, a series of studies was conducted in the
River Gudenaa, Denmark. Previous studies investigated
behaviour and survival in the lower river and estuary (Aarest-
rup et al., 2008, 2010). The present study focuses on the middle
part of the river where downstream-migrating fish have to pass
free-flowing river sections, a reservoir and a hydropower
station.
The behaviour of downstream migrating eels at hydropower
stations has been the subject of a number of studies (i.e. Haro
et al., 2000; Behrmann-Godel and Eckmann, 2003; Durif
et al., 2003; Gosset et al., 2005; Boube
´e and Williams, 2006;
Calles et al., 2010). The general finding is that A. anguilla
approaching a power station often hesitate to continue their
migration, and only after repeated attempts may pass the
hydropower station either through the turbines, spillways or
the bypass passages. The two principal direct causes of
mortality at hydropower stations are turbine-related mortal-
ities and impingement on the screens (Monten, 1985; Calles
et al., 2010). Carr and Whoriskey (2008) found 100% mortal-
ity of American eels (Anguilla rostrata) descending through
turbines at a hydropower station. Winter et al. (2006) demon-
strated that fishing and hydropower were the main causes for
mortality of migrating eel in the River Meuse. Breteler et al.
(2007) found that only 23% of silver eels had successfully
migrated through the lower 300 km of the Rhine River.
The objective of this study was to assess overall escapement
success of silver eels migrating through regular river sections, a
reservoir and a hydropower station. For future eel manage-
ment it is imperative that knowledge on escapement is
available. It was hypothesized that passage success would be
lowest at the hydropower station and that survival and
migration speed would be highest in the free-flowing river
section upstream the reservoir.
Materials and methods
The River Gudenaa (55
o
52¢N, 9
o
33¢E) is a lowland stream
160 km long with a catchment area of 2631 km
2
and a mean
annual discharge of 32 m
3
s
)1
. The river system is strongly
influenced by human activities, including canalization, nutrient
loading from agriculture, hydropower damming, and develop-
ment. There are seven small hydropower stations on the River
Gudenaa. The largest and lowermost is the Tange Hydro-
power station (Fig. 1) with a catchment of 1699 km
2
(65% of
the total catchment) and a mean annual discharge of 21 m
3
s
)1
at the station. The station is situated 35 km from the tidal limit
and has three Francis turbines. The reservoir, Lake Tange, has
a surface area of 537 ha, length of 8.5 km and with a depth of
<8 m.
To protect migrating fish, Danish legislation requires
physical screens with a maximum bar distance of 10 mm to
be installed in front of hydroelectric turbines. This is also the
case at the Tange hydropower station, with 10 mm screens that
should keep silver eels from entering the turbines. There are
J. Appl. Ichthyol. 28 (2012), 189–193
2011 Blackwell Verlag, Berlin
ISSN 0175–8659
Received: April 4, 2011
Accepted: September 13, 2011
doi: 10.1111/j.1439-0426.2011.01913.x
U.S. Copyright Clearance Centre Code Statement: 0175–8659/2012/2802–0189$15.00/0
Applied Ichthyology
Journal of
two fish bypass facilities (Fig. 2), one is a Denil type fish ladder
with resting pools and with an entrance situated approximately
200 m upstream the turbines (Fig. 2). The other bypass system
consists of three (30 cm Ø) tube bypasses installed to help
downstream-migrating fish, especially salmonid smolts, to
bypass the turbines. One tube bypass is placed in each of the
three turbine screens approximately 0.5 m below the water
surface. Water discharge in the two different bypass systems
fluctuates with the number of turbines in use. The bypass flow
from each turbine in use is 150 L s
)1
. In the fish ladder there is
a constant flow of 150 L s
)1
. When all three turbines are in
use, the maximum discharge in the bypasses is 600 L s
)1
,
<3% of the mean total discharge. A light fence is installed to
guide eels to the fish ladder entrance (Fig. 1), but the effect of
this has never been evaluated.
In the study area there is one commercial fisherman
operating in the Tange reservoir using pound nets. Cormo-
rants Phalacrocorax carbo sinensis can be observed foraging in
the reservoir. The birds are possibly from a colony with 50–200
nests approximately 15 km from the reservoir.
The studied river stretch is 63.5 km. The study area was
divided into five sections (Fig. 1). The first section covers a
Fig. 1. Map of study area showing lower and middle part of River Gudenaa, Denmark. Automatic detection stations installed at all Sites 0–5.
River width varies from 15 to 30 m. Mean annual discharge at Site 3 was 21 m
3
s
)1
Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of Tange hydropower station with position of fish ladder and bypass in the deflecting screens in front of the three
Francis turbines
190 M. I. Pedersen et al.
distance of 4.1 km of free flowing river. The second section is
14.2 km of river and ends at the inlet of the reservoir. The third
section is the reservoir including the power canal (8.5 km). The
fourth section is the area from the end of the inlet canal to the
listening station 3.5 km downstream of the hydropower
station. The fifth section goes to the tidal limit and is
33.3 km long.
Forty-five downstream migrating silver eels were captured in
the autumn of 2006 in a permanent eel trap at the Vestbirk
hydropower station approximately 30 km upstream the release
site. Eels caught in the trap were kept in net-pens in the river
for 1–7 days before tagging. Eels were transferred to the
laboratory of DTU Aqua on 1–2 November and tagged by
surgical implanting with THELMA Ltd., Norway, LP-9
acoustic transmitters (9 ·34 mm, weight in air of 5.3 g,
weight in water of 3.3 g, guaranteed life time of 148 days)
using the method described by Aarestrup et al. (1999). The
tags had a programmed random interval range between
transmitted signals. Mean body length of the tagged fish was
66.3 ± 7.2 cm (SD) (range 56–86 cm), mean body mass
551 ± 213 g (range 303–1309 g). After tagging the eels were
kept in recovery tanks, from 1 to 8 h and by dusk released in a
small tributary approximately 300 m upstream the confluence
with the River Gudenaa. All tagged eels were released on 1–2
November.
Twelve hydrophone buoys (ALS, VR2; VEMCO Ltd.,
Canada) were placed pairwise at six sites (detection stations)
in the river (Fig. 1). These were continuously in operation
from 15 October 2006 to 25 March 2007. At each site, two
hydrophones were moored in the river approximately 25 m
apart. The ability of the VR2 to detect acoustic signals in a
range wider than the river was tested on all stations. In the
power-channel of the hydropower station significant acoustic
noise occurs as a consequence of the turbines. Four VR2s were
placed to cover the entire water column: two close to the
surface and two at the bottom. A single VR2 was placed to
detect upstream migration following release (Site 0, Fig. 1) and
one VR2 was placed at the tidal limit (Site 5).
Migration (progression) speed was calculated as the time
between first detection at site tand first detection at site t+1
divided by distance (d).
Statistical analysis
To test whether progression speed in the river section 1
between the detection station 1–2 could explain survival of the
eel to the tidal limit, a logistic regression with survived dead
as the dependent variable and progression speed in river
section 1 as the predictor variable was performed, and body
length and body weight were entered in the model as
covariates.
Progression speed was compared between two river sections
and the reservoir by repeated-measures
ANOVAANOVA
(r-m
ANOVAANOVA
)
with one within-subject factor (compartment). R-m
ANOVAANOVA
was
preferred to a profile analysis (
MANOVAMANOVA
) that has lower
statistical power (Maxwell and Delaney, 1990; Potvin et al.,
1990). To compensate for violation of the sphericity assump-
tion, the degrees of freedom were decreased by multiplication
by the Huynh-Feldt epsilon, which is a less conservative
adjustment than Greenhouse-Geisser and is recommended
when sample sizes are small (Von Ende, 1993; SPSS, 1997).
The data was log (X+ 1) transformed to meet the require-
ments of parametric analysis (i.e. normality and homoscedas-
ticity). Tests of within-subjects contrasts were achieved by a
repeated design and Bonferroni adjusted (Von Ende, 1993).
Results
Two of the 45 tagged eels were not detected after release at any
of the detection stations. Their fate is unknown and they are
therefore omitted from further analyses.
Forty-three eels resumed downstream migration after
release. Of these, 10 eels were detected at the tidal limit
(Fig. 1, Table 1). Thus, during the study period (1 November
2006–25 March 2007), the observed overall passage success of
tagged eels entering the first station to the estuary is 23%. Eels
were lost in the reservoir (n = 5) and in the last section of the
river (n = 6), but the major loss occurred between Sites 3 and
4 where the eels had to pass the Tange Hydropower station.
Here, 38 eels were detected in the inlet, but only 16 eels were
detected at the next downstream station during the study
period. Thus, 22 eels did not pass the power station and
subsequently the loss was considerably higher at the station
than at all other sections.
Following release, the tagged eels (n = 43) moved down-
stream after 0–38 days (mean 9.2 days). No tagged eels were
detected at the upstream detection station Site 0. Seventeen
eels quickly resumed migration and were detected at Site 1
within 24 h. One eel migrated on day two. Fourteen eels were
detected between 7 and 12 days post release, and between days
12 and 38 the remaining 11 eels were detected at Site 1. Once
having resumed migration, most eels (n = 40) moved quickly
downstream to the reservoir at a mean speed of 3.4 km h
)1
range (0.8–5.9 km h
)1
). The majority of eels reached the
reservoir within the same night as they resumed their migra-
tion. Three eels, however, spent 6, 10 and 14 days before they
reached the reservoir (Site 2).
After arriving in the reservoir the migrants spent an average
8.2 days (range 0.2–34.8 days) (n = 38) before entering the
power canal (Site 3). Most of the eels approached the station
several times over several days before entering, and seven of
the 38 eels detected in the canal reversed their direction of
migration and passed back and forth between the inlet and the
outlet of the reservoir (Sites 2 and 3), a distance of 8.5 km.
After arriving at the power canal the second time, three
individuals finally passed the hydropower station.
The eels clearly had problems locating entering the bypass
facilities, illustrated by the fact that they spent much more time
passing the detection station in the canal than they did at the
other stations (Table 1).
The 16 eels that succeeded in passing the hydropower station
spent from 2 h to 63 days with a mean of 11 days 5 h before
passing. The last 33.1 km to reach the tidal limit (Site 4–5)
were completed on average in 1.3 days (range 0.42–6.35 days).
The logistic regression showed no effect of the progression
rate in the river section between Sites 1 and 2, body length or
body weight on the loss of eels (P > 0.228).
The r-m
ANOVAANOVA
revealed that the progression speed differed
among the three sections Sites 1–2, 2–3 and 3–4 (P < 0.0001).
Progression speed was not statistically dependent on body
length or body weight (P > 0.857). None of the interaction
terms was statistically significant (P > 0.868). The Within-
Subjects contrast test showed that there was a significant
difference between sections Sites 1–2 and 2–3 (P < 0.0001),
and no significant difference between sections Sites 2–3 and
3–4, respectively (P = 0.132).
Loss of European silver eels 191
Discussion
Overall escapement to the tidal limit from the investigated
63.5 km river stretch was 23% in the autumn winter 2006. This
does not necessarily mean that the remaining 77% of the tagged
eels died. It is a well-known fact that some silver eels halt their
autumn migration and resume it the following spring or autumn
(Winter et al., 2007;Aarestrup et al., 2008;Simon and Fladung,
2009). Own (unpublished) results from PIT-tagged eels in the
Gudenaa show that approximately 10% resume migration the
following spring. However, the observed 58% loss of silver eels
during hydropower station passage is substantial, and in
combination with other causes of loss, constitutes a major
problem for the eel. Aarestrup et al. (2008, 2010) and found a
60–80% loss of A. anguilla moving through the Gudenaa
estuary, presumably caused by fishing. The combination of
hydropower station passage and estuarine fishing leaves very
little chance for silver eels from the upper or middle Gudenaa
catchment to reach the sea. The probability of reaching the
estuary was not related to initial progression speeds observed at
the first upriver section (Site 1–2). Progression speeds between
sections varied and were found to be significantly different
between river Site 1–2, the reservoir (Site 2–3), and the power
station (Site 3–4). The differences in progression speeds were not
related to size of the fish (length or weight); this is in contrast to
movement monitored through the estuary where the larger eels
did move faster (Aarestrup et al., 2010). Progression in the river
was relatively fast, but slow through the reservoir. The delay at
the reservoir and the hydropower station may increase the risk
of predation from fishermen and cormorants and are likely
causes of loss in the reservoir. The tags and tagging method used
in this study have proven reliable in a number of studies already
cited herein, but it cannot be ruled out that the adverse effects of
capture, handling and tagging or transmitter malfunction could
be reasons for the loss of some eels. However, earlier experience
with the tags and studies of tagging effects (Baras and Jeandrain,
1998; Winter et al., 2005) gives reason to believe that it is not a
problem.
A considerable number of eels (n = 22) did not pass the
power station, suggesting that migrating silver eels have
problems in locating the bypass openings. All eels spend a
long time in the area in front of the entrance (power canal), as
seen in the recordings from the station at Site 3 (Table 1). A
number of eels (14) moved in and out of the power canal
several times over a course of days - weeks before finally
passing or disappearing. The opening of the bypass is at the
surface, whereas silver eels migrate in midwater or near the
bottom (Tesch, 2003). Consequently, the eels have to approach
the surface to find the bypass. Haro et al. (2000) observed eels
occupying a deep portion of a forebay, down to 10 m, but the
eels made frequent excursions to the surface. Despite the fact
that eels are known to be bottom-oriented, their vertical
searching behaviour makes it possible for eels to locate and
bypass hydroelectric stations through a surface bypass
and spillway (Durif et al., 2003; Gosset et al., 2005; Watene
and Boube
´e, 2005). The 10 mm bar spacing at the Tange
power station prevents silver eels (down to approximately
35 cm length) from being sucked into the turbines. However,
they can often be found impinged on the turbine screens; the
proportion of eels that suffer this fate can be high (Calles et al.,
2010). Gosset et al. (2005) found impingement to be related to
the flow rate, and suggested a water velocity of less than
0.3 m s
)1
to prevent impingement on 20 mm bar spacing on
racks. The risk of impingement probably depends on the water
Table 1
Number of acoustic tagged silver eels (Anguilla anguilla) detected at downstream sections (Fig. 1), time spent and progression rate of downstream migration in each River Gudena
˚section. Mean length of time
(minutes) spent within range of each detection station is given
River section Release Site 1 Site 1–2 Site 2–3 Site 3–4 Site 4–5
Habitat River River Reservoir Power station River
No. of eels detected 43 (100%) 43 (100%) 38 (88%) 16 (37%) 10 (23%)
Mean time (h) (range; SD) 226 (4–918; 263) 21 (2–335; 65) 220 (5–881;224) 512 (25–1680; 545) 32 (10–152;43)
Mean progression rate (km h
)1
) (range; SD) 0.24 (0.95–0.00; 0.3) 3.71 (5.25–0.04; 1.4) 0.16 (1.68–0.01; 0.3) 0.04 (0.14–0.00; 0.1) 1.05 (3.26–0.22; 1.1)
Distance from release site (km) 4.1 18.2 26.7 30.2 63.5
Mean time (min) for passing each detection station (range) 4.7 (1–22) 22.9 (1–260) 1179.5 (108–5760) 39.6 (1–600) 2.5 (1–6)
192 M. I. Pedersen et al.
temperature, eels being less likely to escape at low tempera-
tures. Measurement of water velocity in front of the racks at
Tange during low to moderate flow, showed values ranging
from 0.26 to 0.48 m s
)1
. During high flow, when eels are
typically moving, values of up to 1 m s
)1
can be expected. Eels
that impinge on the turbine screens at Tange are subsequently
removed (often dead or severely damaged) from the water with
an automatic debris cleaner. Workers at the power station may
spot eels among debris and subsequently release them down-
stream, or the eels will be trashed with the debris and die. Such
releases of injured eels from the power plant may explain the
relatively large proportion of eels (n = 6) lost in the last river
section.
Combining the results from river loss in the present study
with the loss in the estuary (Aarestrup et al., 2010) demon-
strates a large loss of migrating silver eels in the Gudenaa
system. The loss may be cumulative, with 10% or fewer
A. anguilla reaching the sea. EU management goals for eels are
thus not met in this system and action is required.
References
Aarestrup, K.; Jepsen, N.; Økland, F.; Rasmussen, G., 1999:
Movements of two strains of radio-tagged Atlantic salmon,
Salmo salar L., smolts through a reservoir. Fish. Mgmt. Ecol. 6,
97–107.
Aarestrup, K.; Thorstad, E. B.; Koed, A.; Jepsen, N.; Svendsen, J. C.;
Pedersen, M. I.; Skov, C.; Økland, F., 2008: Survival and
behavior of European silver eel during spring migration in late
freshwater and early marine phase. Fish. Mgmt. Ecol. 15, 435–
440.
Aarestrup, K.; Thorstad, E. B.; Koed, A.; Jepsen, N.; Svendsen, J. C.;
Pedersen, M. I.; Skov, C.; Økland, F., 2010: Survival and
progression rates of large European silver eel Anguilla anguilla
in late freshwater and early marine phase. Aquat. Biol. 9, 263–
270.
Baras, E.; Jeandrain, D., 1998: Evaluation of surgery procedures for
tagging eel Anguilla anguilla (L.) with biotelemetry transmitters.
Hydrobiologica 371 372,107–111.
Behrmann-Godel, J.; Eckmann, R., 2003: A preliminary telemetry
study of the migration of silver European eel (Anguilla anguilla L.)
in the River Mosel, Germany. Ecol. Freshw. Fish. 12, 196–202.
Boube
´e, J. A. T.; Williams, E. K., 2006: Downstream passage of silver
eels at a small hydroelectric facility. Fish. Mgmt. Ecol. 13(3),165–
176.
Breteler, J. K.; Vriese, T.; Borcherding, J.; Breukelaar, A.; Jo
¨rgensen,
L.; Staas, S.; Laak, G.; Ingedahl, D., 2007: Assessment of
population size and migration routes of silver eel in the River
Rhine based on a 2-year combined mark-recapture and telemetry
study. ICES J. Mar. Sci. 64, 1450–1456.
Calles, O.; Olsson, I. C.; Comoglio, C.; Kemp, P. S.; Blunden, L.;
Schmitz, M.; Greenberg, L. A., 2010: The implication of size-
dependent mortality and decreasing densities of silver eels in
regulated rivers. Freshw. Biol. 55, 2167–2180.
Carr, J. W.; Whoriskey, F. G., 2008: Migration of silver American eels
past a hydroelectric dam and through a coastal zone. Fish. Mgmt.
Ecol. 15, 393–400.
Durif, C.; Elie, P.; Gosset, C.; Rives, J.; Travade, F., 2003: Behavioral
study of downstream migrating eels by radio telemetry at a small
hydroelectric power plant. Am. Fish. Soc. Symp. 33, 343–356.
EU, 2007: Council Regulation (EC) No 1100 2007 of 18 September
2007 establishing measures for the recovery of the stock of
European eel. Off. J. E. U. L 248, 17–22.
Gosset, C.; Travade, F.; Durif, C.; Rives, J.; Elie, P., 2005: Test of two
types of bypass for downstream migration of eels at a small
hydroelectric power plant. River Res. Appl. 21, 1095–1105.
Haraldstad, Ø.; Vøllestad, L. A.; Jonsson, B., 1984: Descent of
European silver eels, Anguilla anguilla L. in a Norwegian
watercourse. J. Fish Biol. 26, 37–41.
Haro, A.; Castro-Santos, T.; Boube
´e, J., 2000: Behavior and passage of
silver phase American eels at a small hydroelectric facility. Dana
12, 33–42.
ICES, 2001: Report of the EIFAC ICES Working Group on Eels.
ICES, CM 2001 ACFM:03, Copenhagen , 87 p.
ICES, 2009: Report of the 2009 session of the Joint EIFAC ICES
Working Group on Eels. EIFAC Occasional Paper. No. 45. ICES
CM 2009 ACOM:15.ICES, Rome, FAO Copenhagen 2010.540
p. (Online).
Maxwell, S. E.; Delaney, H. D., 1990: Designing Experiments and
Analyzing Data: A Model Comparison Perspective. International
Student Ed, Wadsworth, Belmont, Canada.
Monten, E., 1985: Fish and turbines. Fish injury during passage
through power station turbines. Vattenfall, Stockholm.
Potvin, C.; Lechowich, M. J.; Bell, G.; Schoen, D., 1990: The statistical
analysis of ecophysiological response curves obtained from
experiments involving repeated measures. Ecology 71, 1389–1400.
Simon, J.; Fladung, E., 2009: Untersuchungen zur Blankaalabwande-
rung aus Oberhavel, Rhein und Mittelelbe. Fisch. Teichwirt. 60,
288–289.
SPSS, 1997: SPSS Advanced Statistics 7.5, SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA.
Tesch, F. W., 2003: The Eel, Blackwell Science, Oxford, UK.
Vøllestad, L. A.; Jonsson, B.; Hvidsten, N. A.; Næsje, T. F.;
Haraldstad, Ø.; Ruud-Hansen, J., 1986: Environmental factors
regulation the seaward migration of European silver eels (Anguilla
anguilla). Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 43, 1909–1916.
Von Ende, C. N., 1993: Repeated measures analysis: growth and other
time-dependent measures. In: Design and Analysis of Ecological
Experiments. S. M. Scheiner, J. Gurevitch (Eds), Chapman &
Hall, London, pp. 113–137.
Watene, E. M.; Boube
´e, J. A. T., 2005: Selective opening of
hydroelectric dam spillway gates for downstream migrant eels in
New Zealand. Fish. Mgmt. Ecol. 12, 69–75.
Winter, H. V.; Jansen, H. M.; Adam, B.; Schwevers, U., 2005:
Behaviour effects of surgically implanting transponders in Euro-
pean eel. Anguilla anguilla. In: Aquatic telemetry: advances and
applications. M. T. Spedicato, G. Marmulla, G. Lembo (Eds),
COISPA technoloia & ricerca, Rome, Italy, pp. 1–9.
Winter, H. V.; Jansen, H. M.; Bruijs, M. C. M., 2006: Assessing the
impact of hydropower and fisheries on downstream migration
silver eel, Anguilla anguilla, by telemetry in the River Meuse. Ecol.
Freshw. Fish. 15, 221–228.
Winter, H. V.; Jansen, H. M.; Breukelaar, A. W., 2007: Silver eel
mortality during downstream migration in the River Meuse, from
a population perspective. ICES J. Mar. Sci. 64, 1444–1449.
AuthorÕs address: Michael I. Pedersen, DTU-Aqua, Section for
Freshwater Fisheries Ecology, Vejlsøvej 39, DK-
8600 Silkeborg, Denmark.
E-mail: mip@aqua.dtu.dk
Loss of European silver eels 193
... Additionally, turbine-induced mortality effects are cumulative if an eel encounters multiple facilities as they migrate back to the marine environment (Eyler, Welsh, Smith, & Rockey, 2016;MacGregor et al., 2015;McCleave, 2001;Sweka et al., 2014;Verreault & Dumont, 2003). To help conserve the population, the European Union (EU) implemented a policy that requires measures executed to ensure at least 40% of European eels (Anguilla anguilla) biomass relative to pristine conditions have the ability to reach the sea (Pedersen et al., 2012). At the very least, cumulative survival for out-migrating eels should be greater than 33% (Sweka et al., 2014) to make facilitating upstream passage sustainable. ...
... A threshold for upstream movement determined that a cumulative survival of at least 33% was required for upstream passage to be beneficial (Sweka et al., 2014). Furthermore, EU requires at least 40% survival of pristine biomass (Pedersen et al., 2012). Indeed, much higher survival may be required for upstream passage for the St. Lawrence/Lake Ontario population to be beneficial and not act as a sink (McLaughlin et al., 2013). ...
Article
American eels (Anguilla rostrata) are vulnerable to turbine-induced mortality during outmigration along regulated rivers. Turbine-induced mortality is cumulative when multiple facilities are encountered along the route. This level of mortality may be unsustainable such that facilitating upstream movement ostensibly for recovery purposes, may in fact be detrimental to the population or an ecological trap. The objectives of this study were to estimate a theoretical threshold for facilitating upstream movement passed hydroelectric facilities and estimating cumulative turbine mortality within waterbodies across American eel's historical range within Ontario, Canada. A stage-structured model was used to estimate mortality thresholds parameterized by published life stage survival probabilities using a maternal effect and altering silver eel survival to mimic turbine mortality. The threshold was exceeded when population growth (λ) declined below 1.0. Site mortality was estimated based on the generating station characteristics including turbine type, size, proportion of flow through turbines, and sluice gate height. Cumulative mortality within a waterbody was projected using a Bayesian network (i.e., conditional probability) and the calculated site-specific mortality. The survival required for a stable population using the stage-structured model was 0.75; (0.65–0.85) therefore, annual mortality greater than 0.25 (0.15–0.35) would result in population decline (λ < 1). The effects of turbine mortality increased with additional hydroelectric facilities encountered along the route. Across Ontario, there was no eel habitat deemed to be safe in terms of levels of cumulative turbine mortality during outmigration. Moreover, 89.1% of eel habitat was considered to be within the cautionary range of turbine mortality, whereas 10.9% of eel habitat was considered to be above the threshold for sustainable passage during outmigration. Lake Ontario accounted for 98.2% of the area within the cautionary range, whereas most of the tributaries and watersheds associated with the Ottawa River and Lake Ontario were above the threshold.
... These long stays stand out, especially when contrasted with the average duration for further migration into the lake after passing the weir. Fish migration studies often observed that downstream movements were delayed once fish arrived at impounded sections (Giorgi et al., 1988;Venditti et al., 2000;Gosset et al., 2005;Scruton et al., 2005;Pedersen et al., 2012;Nyqvist et al., 2017). Deviation from the natural migratory route and disorientation because of changing hydrological conditions are associated explanations for these behavioural responses (Coutant & Whitney, 2000;Schilt, 2007). ...
... River infrastructure has been identified as a key contributor to the decline of several species including the critically endangered European eel (Feunteun, 2002;Dekker et al., 2007;Verhelst et al., 2018b;Pike et al., 2020). These structures have been reported to cause injuries (Bruijs and Durif, 2009), direct mortality Pedersen et al., 2012) and migration delay or failure (Besson et al., 2016;Trancart et al., 2018) of eel. In addition, due to the long elongated body morphology and low swimming capabilities of eel it is particularly susceptible to injury and mortality (Boubée and Williams, 2006;Calles et al., 2010;Russon et al., 2010;Radinger et al., 2021). ...
Thesis
River infrastructure such as dams, weirs and hydropower facilities can reduce habitat connectivity and lead to direct mortality of fish species. Physical devices (e.g. screens or fish passes) designed to mitigate these negative impacts are not wholly effective and can be costly. Behavioural stimuli such as electric fields offer an alternative or enhancement to traditional physical devices. This thesis addresses the response of fish to electric fields through experimental studies conducted under both static and flowing water conditions. Assessing the response of European eel to electric fields has received limited attention. Threshold field strengths (i.e. electrosensitivity) of key physiological responses (twitch, loss of orientation and tetany) were quantified with respect to pulse frequency and width, for the critically endangered European eel (Anguilla anguilla) under static water conditions. Lower field strengths were required to elicit tetany under a higher pulse frequency and longer pulse widths. Research into eel guidance systems has largely focused on downstream migrating adult (silver-phase) using light and acoustics with mixed success. To gain insights into the potential effectiveness of electric fields for guidance, the behavioural responses of three life-stages of European eel (glass, yellow- and silver-phase) were assessed under flowing water conditions. All life-stages showed avoidance to electric fields, with largely more occurring under higher field strengths for juvenile (glass) eel. Avoidance in downstream migrating adults was reduced under a higher water velocity (1.0 ms-1 ) and yellow-phase eel were more likely to respond when travelling upstream. Evidence of any successful guidance by electric fields was only observed for upstream migrating juvenile (glass) eel and efficiency was improved under lower frequencies (2 Hz) and higher field strengths. Ensuring species selective guidance systems is the next challenge for fisheries management in areas where desirable and invasive species co-exist. A direct comparison of electrosensitivity between two known invasive cyprinids, grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) and common carp (Cyprinus carpio), and adult eel was performed. Adult eel had a higher electrosensitivity than both cyprinids indicating the potential for electric fields to provide a species selective fish guidance system. The research presented in this thesis has advanced scientific knowledge of both fundamental physiological and behavioural responses of fish to electric fields with respect to parameters tested. This research will guide future work to optimise parameters of the electric field to translate avoidance behaviours more effectively into reliable guidance for fisheries management.
... The range of silver eels escapement from a hydropower station is very large, with a lot of adapted structures with low impact, as for instance in Behrmann-Godel and Eckmann (2003, 78% of escapement), in Brown et al. (2009, 90% of escapement) and Piper et al. (2013, 76 and 65% in two successive years with 5 different blocking structures). On the other hand, some hydropower structures enable very low escapement down to 23%, as for instance Pedersen et al. (2012). In the present study, the escapement from the tidal powerplant, defined as the ratio of tagged eels observed in station S5 versus the number of tagged eels observed in stations 6 & 7 was 75%, as classically reported. ...
Article
Very few tidal power plants exist in the world. The first one was built in the Rance estuary (Brittany, France) in 1966 and the second one in South Korea. However, with the increasing demand in renewable energy, other tidal power plant projects are being studied. These power plants are larger than unidirectional fluvial hydropower plants and strongly modify the natural tidal cycle in estuarine systems. As such, their effect on megafaunal movements might strongly differ from those caused by unidirectional fluvial hydropower plants and should be specifically considered and studied before the development of similar constructions. In this study, an acoustic telemetry array was deployed to track 25 silver eels released 16 km upstream of the Rance tidal power dam. Only 1/3 of the tagged eels passed the dam and reached the sea. Data suggested that eels interrupted their migration up to 5 km upstream of the dam. We assume that the noise and tidal disturbance generated by the dam could lead to a disruption of a high proportion of silver eels’ reproductive migration.
... Dams can block the movement of fish both upstream and downstream in different ways. The image of the adult salmon swimming upstream and running into a concrete wall is well-established in the public imagination, but, equally important are the problems of downstream migrants, who may pass through hydroelectric turbines, whose blades may kill them, as documented for seaward migrating adult European eels (Anguilla anguilla) by Pedersen et al. [11], a source of mortality that has contributed to the loss of nearly three quarters of this population in recent decades. Moreover, while upstream migrants tend to be adults of stronger swimming species, downstream migrants include eggs and larvae that passively drift downstream [9]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Dams are essential to society, yet have tremendous environmental impacts, for which there is an increasing interest in mitigation. At the same time, sedimentation threatens the sustainability of reservoir storage and reservoir functions. We use the term dam renovation to encompass a wide range of measures, including dam rehabilitation, a term commonly used for structural retrofits, typically of the dam structure or spillway, fishway retrofits for migratory fish passage, reservoir reoperation, which involves modifying dam operations to improve flow regimes for ecological purposes, and sustainable sediment management, which includes measures to pass sediment through or around dams, as well as other mechanical measures to restore sediment connectivity. Compared to dam renovation, an inordinate amount of literature has been published on the topic of dam removal. While in some cases dam removal is a practical way to improve river condition and to resolve the safety problems of aging dams, the reality is that most dams in existence today will remain for the foreseeable future, provided they do not fill with sediment, or their structures deteriorate to the point of failure. Thus, it is imperative that we understand the options available to renovate dams with poor environmental performance or whose sustainability is threatened.
... Field sites which necessitate fish guidance technologies to reduce injuries or mortalities (e.g. hydropower dams or weirs) are generally dominated by high-level background noise intensities (Miyamoto et al., 1989;Schilt, 2007;Pedersen et al., 2012;Johnson et al., 2014), acting as a crucial constraint to acoustic signal transmission, and the subsequent response of a targeted species (Wiley, 1994). Understanding how fish respond to acoustic signals under masked noise conditions will assist in the development of more effective behavioural guidance systems and aid in conservation efforts to reduce the impacts of anthropogenic noise. ...
Thesis
Rising levels of anthropogenic underwater sound may have negative consequences on freshwater ecosystems. Additionally, the biological relevance of sound to fish and observed responses to human-generated noise promote the use of acoustics in behavioural guidance technologies that are deployed to control the movement of fish. For instance, acoustic stimuli may be used to prevent the spread of invasive fishes or facilitate the passage of vulnerable native species at man-made obstructions. However, a strong understanding of fish response to acoustics is needed for it to be effectively deployed as a fisheries management tool, but such information is lacking. Therefore, this thesis investigated the group behavioural responses of cyprinids to acoustic stimuli. A quantitative meta-analysis and experimental studies conducted in a small-tank or large open-channel flume were used to address key knowledge gaps that are necessary to improve the sustainability of acoustic deterrent technologies, and assist in conservation efforts to reduce the negative impacts of anthropogenic noise. Current understanding on the impact of anthropogenic noise on fishes (marine, freshwater and euryhaline species) was quantified. The impact of man-made sound is greatest for fish experiencing anatomical damage, for adult and juveniles compared to earlier life-stages, and for fish occupying freshwater environments. These findings suggest a review of the current legislation covering aquatic noise mitigation which commonly focus on marine-centric strategies, thereby undervaluing the susceptibility of freshwater fish to the rising levels of anthropogenic sound. Limitations and knowledge gaps within the literature were also identified, including: 1) group behavioural responses to sound, 2) the response of fish to different fundamental acoustic properties of sound, 3) system longevity (e.g. habituation to a repeated sound exposure), and 4) site-specific constraints. Fish movement and space use were quantified using fine-scale behavioural metrics (e.g. swimming speed, shoal distribution, cohesion, orientation, rate of tolerance and signal detection theory) and their collective response to acoustics assessed using two approaches. First, a still-water small tank set-up allowed for the careful control of confounding factors while investigating cyprinid group response to fundamental acoustic properties of sound (e.g. complexity, pulse repetition rate, signal-to-noise ratio). Second, a large open-channel flume enabled the ability of a shoal to detect and respond to acoustic signals to be quantified under different water velocities. Shoals of European minnow (Phoxinus phoxinus), common carp (Cyprinus carpio) and roach (Rutilus rutilus) altered their swimming behaviour (e.g. increased group cohesion) in response to a simple low frequency tonal stimulus. The pulse repetition rate of a signal was observed to influence the long-term behavioural recovery of minnow to an acoustic stimulus. Furthermore, signal detection theory was deployed to quantify the impact of background masking noise on the group behavioural response of carp to a tonal stimulus, and investigate how higher water velocities commonly experienced by fish in the wild may influence the response of roach to an acoustic stimulus. Fine-scale behavioural responses were observed the higher the signal-to-noise ratio, and discriminability of an acoustic signal and the efficacy at which fish were deterred from an insonified channel was greatest under higher water velocities. The information presented in this thesis significantly enhances our understanding of fish group responses to man-made underwater sound, and has direct applications in freshwater conservation, fish passage and invasive species management.<br/
... Research on turbine mortality rates for American Eel may be suitable for modelling the adverse effects of facilities in Ontario; however, the regulation appears to require site-specific monitoring. The European Eel (Anguilla anguilla) has a similar biology and is also negatively affected by hydropower (McCarthy et al. 2008;Pedersen et al. 2012), so studies of this congener may also be useful. Eel turbine injury/mortality and other adverse effects have been modelled for many facilities (Electrical Power Research Institute (EPRI) 2001), including at facilities located within the same region as those in the present study (Great Lakes Fishery Commission (GLFC) 2005;Heisey et al. 2019). ...
Article
Full-text available
American Eel (Anguilla rostrata) were used as a case study to assess whether Ontario’s Endangered Species Act proponent-driven regulatory approach resulted in successful imperilled species management outcomes. American Eel observation databases and proponent-prepared mitigation plans and monitoring data were used to assess whether: (i) facilities within the distribution range were registered, (ii) effects monitoring protocols were adequate to evaluate adverse effects of facilities, (iii) proponents implemented mitigation actions that followed best management practices (BMPs), and (iv) effectiveness monitoring designs were adequate to evaluate effectiveness of mitigation actions. Less than half of the facilities (8 of 17) within the extant species range were registered. Few eels were observed at each facility, precluding proponents from effectively evaluating the facilities’ effects. Mitigation actions following BMPs were only implemented for eel out-migration at three facilities. Half of the registered facilities implemented effectiveness monitoring, but experimental designs did not follow best practices and standards. To improve this proponent-driven approach, regulators could reduce ambiguity in regulation language and provide clearer, quantitative requirements for facility registration, effects monitoring, mitigation actions, and effectiveness monitoring. Proponents could improve monitoring efforts to establish species occurrence and generate baseline data to measure facility effects and mitigation action effectiveness.
Article
Full-text available
The European eel is critically endangered due to heavy impact of anthropogenic factors, such as habitat fragmentation, overexploitation and climate change. During downstream migration, silver eels may encounter hydropower plants, which often result in delay or mortality from impingement on trash-racks or turbine passage. These problems can be mitigated with downstream passage solutions, such as angled racks that guide downstream-migrating eels to safe passage routes. The importance of bar spacing and phenotypic diversity for passage performance is, however, largely unknown. In this study, we investigated how morphological parameters (body mass, eye and fin indices) and behavioral score (open field test) influenced passage rate at an experimental intake equipped with a bypass and angled racks with either 15 or 30 mm bar spacing. Both racks were efficient in guiding eels into a bypass. There was a strong positive effect of body mass and a weak positive effect of open field test score on passage rate. Other factors such as eye and fin indices played a minor role. These results demonstrate the performance of angled racks with bypasses and form a useful starting point for further research regarding the relationships between individual variation in behavior, morphology and passage solutions for silver eels.
Article
Full-text available
River damming has brought great benefits to flood mitigation, energy and food production, and will continue to play a significant role in global energy supply, particularly in Asia, Africa, and South America. However, dams have extensively altered global river dynamics, including riverine connectivity, hydrological, thermal, sediment and solute regimes, and the channel morphology. These alterations have detrimental effects on the quality and quantity of fish habitat and associated impacts on aquatic life. Indeed, dams have been implicated in the decline of numerous fishes, emphasizing the need for effective conservation measures. Here, we present a global synthesis of critical issues concerning the impacts of river damming on physical fish habitats, with a particular focus on key fish species across continents. We also consider current fish conservation measures and their applicability in different contexts. Finally, we identify future research needs. The information presented herein will help support sustainable dam operation under the constraints of future climate change and human needs.
Article
Full-text available
Anguillid eels are near globally distributed catadromous fishes with marine spawning areas and inshore and inland growth areas in both lotic (rivers, estuaries) and lentic (lakes, ponds, lagoons) water bodies. As predators, anguillid eels play an important ecological role in both marine and freshwater systems, and several species are harvested commercially for food. However, some of the more widely distributed species have undergone severe declines in recruitment and their population status is now of significant concern. Given the multiple and lengthy migrations undertaken by anguillid eels, understanding of the drivers of movement is fundamental for species conservation and management. Yet, despite the importance of lentic systems to their ecology, most studies on anguillid eel movement have been conducted in lotic systems. Given that key influences on eel migration in lotic water bodies, such as fluctuations in flow and water temperature, may be minimised in lentic environments, the transferability of findings between lotic and lentic systems cannot be assumed. A systematic map was constructed to synthesise current knowledge on the extrinsic and intrinsic drivers of anguillid eel movement in lentic systems. The current state of knowledge of the drivers of eel movement in lentic systems is presented and compared to the relatively well-understood drivers of movement in lotic systems. We also discuss current knowledge gaps and limitations, and identify key future research requirements to inform the management and conservation of anguillid eels in understudied lentic systems. Graphical abstract
Article
Full-text available
Erste Untersuchungen zur Blankaalabwanderung aus dem Einzugsgebiet der Oberhavel und dem Rhin weisen auf hohe individuelle Unterschiede hinsichtlich der Abwanderungsgeschwindigkeit hin. Bei einem Teil des Blankaalbestandes wurden Unterbrechungen der Wanderung von mehreren Monaten registriert. Über eine Analyse des Rückfangs markierter Aale konnten erste Anhaltspunkte für die Fängigkeit von Geräten der Erwerbsfischerei sowie die Menge abwandernder Blankaale gewonnen werden. Diese Daten fließen in ein Modell zur Bestandsdynamik des Aals im Einzugs-gebiet der Elbe ein. Theoretische Modellierungen der Blankaalabwanderung für das gesamte Elbeeinzugsgebiet ergaben mit jährlich 4-9 Blankaalen pro ha für den Zeitraum 2005-08 eine größenordnungsmäßig gute Übereinstimmung mit den Ergebnissen des Blankaalmonitorings in der Mittelelbe. Um Wanderzeiten, -geschwindigkeiten und Verluste während der Abwanderung besser beziffern zu können, wurde neben der hier beschriebenen Farbmarkierung auch mit der Besenderung von Blankaalen begonnen. Die in die Bauchhöhle der Tiere implantierten Sender (Abb. 3) werden bei der Passage von Kontrollpunkten entlang der Havel registriert und sollen uns zukünftig weitere Einblicke in die Abwanderung von Blankaalen geben, über die wir an dieser Stelle berichten werden.
Article
Full-text available
Downstream migrant cds were monitored near a small (51 MW) hydroelectric facility on the Connecti cut River (Massachusetts, USA) for two seasons using acoustic and radio telemetry. Eels frequently made several attempts over periods of one to several days to pass the station. Did activity of eels was variable, although most movements occurred at night. Eels occupied a variety of depths in the forebay area, but spent the greater proportion of time at or near the bottom (10 m), occasionally venturing to the surface. Horizontal movements usually spanned across the entire width of the forebay. There was no significant relationship between duration of forebay presence and either flow or light intensity. Although ali telemetered eels passed via the turbines, some migrant eels did use a surface bypass.
Chapter
Full-text available
Eels, because of their size and life cycle, are among the most vulnerable species regarding the presence of obstacles on waterways. During a study of the efficiency of two types of fish passes, the behavior of migrating European eels Anguilla anguilla was investigated using telemetry and trapping at a small hydroelectric power plant (southwest of France). Radio-tracking was conducted manually and by stationary receivers in the turbine area and downstream and upstream from the power plant. Sixteen eels were tagged by surgical implantation of transmitters and released upstream of the power station. Results provide insight on eel behavior during the downstream run (swimming rates and delayed migration) as well as behavior in front of both exits to the trap. Almost all tagged individuals moved upstream after the release. Most of these eels migrated downstream after a heavy rainfall, avoiding the power station by crossing the overflowing dam. They were tracked down to the estuary (16 km) over several days during which time several periods of nonmovement occurred. Descending nontagged eels transiting through either of the two tested forebay bypasses were trapped. Daily catches corresponded to movements of radio-tagged individuals. Environmental parameters were recorded and compared to the downstream run. Results clearly showed that silver eel migration was closely linked to certain environmental parameters (flow rate, turbidity, and luminosity) and that downstream migration is inhibited if favorable environmental conditions are not met, such as during daytime when turbidity is low. Direct comparison of daily catches through the bottom and surface bypasses as well as observations of radio-tagged eels in the forebay both suggest that a bottom bypass may be appropriate for safely transiting downstream migrating eels.
Book
A strong demand for an English version of the third German Edition of this extremely important book paved the way for this excellent new translation, which contains much new information from over 500 publications, not covered by the previous English language edition. The Eel is the standard work on the species with chapters in the book covering body structure and functions, developmental stages and distribution of the eel species, post-larval ecology and behaviour, harvest and environmental relationships, fishing methods, eel culture, diseases, parasites and bodily damage, the world trade in eels and eel processing. Contributions are included from several world authorities including new information concerning genetic diversity in eel populations and the consequences for their management. Written by Friedrich-Wilhelm Tesch, one of the foremost world authorities on eels and carefully edited by Professor Thorpe, well known for his work in fish biology, writing and editing, The Eel is an essential purchase for all those working with the species, including fish biologists, physiologists and ecologists, aquatic and environmental scientists, fisheries managers and fish farm personnel. Copies of this landmark publication should be available in the libraries of all research establishments and universities where these subjects are studied or taught. The Fisheries Society of the British Isles provided generous financial support enabling the translation and publication of this book.
Article
Externally attached telemetry transmitters are unsuitable to tag yellow eels Anguilla anguilla (L.), in streams where they exhibit cryptic life habits and hide in narrow cavities between rocks. We evaluated the adequacy of surgical implantation and closing procedures for tagging eels with biotelemetry transmitters. Epoxy dummy transmitters (18 × 8 mm, 1.6–1.7 g) were implanted in eels anaesthetised with 2-phenoxy-ethanol (0.9 ml l-1), through a 20 mm mid ventral incision made in the posterior quarter of their body cavity. The incision was either left open, or closed in different ways: stitches (absorbable or non absorbable suture material) or commercial-grade cyanoacrilate adhesive (LoctiteTM). Fish were stocked in a 4 m2 flow through tank (15–17 °C), controlled daily for mortality and weekly for evaluating the healing process. No transmitter was expelled over a 12-week period, even in eels with unclosed incisions, of which 50% healed within 28 days (t 50). Regardless of the nature of the filament, suturing induced skin and muscle necrosis, caused significantly higher mortality rates (60% after 10 weeks) and paradoxically slowed down the healing rate (40 and 45 d, respectively). Cyanoacrilate suppressed the inflammatory response and granted higher survival rate (90%), but did not permit to speed up the closing process (t_50 = 52 d), as eels actively bit and removed the adhesive within hours. This behaviour was suppressed when we applied a freshly cut fragment of the eel dorsal fin as a biological bandage over the drying cyanoacrilate. The adhesive remained in place for one to two days and permitted to substantially increase the healing rate (t 50 = 15 d). These results substantiate the efficiency of surgery techniques for tagging eels with radio transmitters, at least for units of small weight and bulk.
Article
The population of European silver eel Anguilla anguilla has declined tremendously in the last decades. The cause of this decline is unknown, and it is necessary to investigate the migratory behaviour and survival rates of silver eels during the reproductive migration in order to understand if the decline is related to factors acting during that migration. We estimated survival and progression rates of European silver eel migrating in the lower part of the River Gudenaa and during the first phase of the marine migration in the Randers Fjord in Denmark. Fifty migrating silver eel (total body length: 56 to 84 cm) were captured, and each was equipped with an acoustic transmitter. Their migration was subsequently monitored using an array of automatic listening stations, and progression rate and mortality in the river, inner part of the fjord and outer part of the fjord were estimated. Survival was high in fresh water. However, 60% of eels were lost in the inner and outer fjord, supporting the hypothesis that mortality is large in the early phase of the marine migration and that fishing may be a major cause of mortality of silver eels. There was no indication that the slowest-migrating individuals were more prone to fishing mortality than the faster-migrating individuals. Progression rate increased as the eels proceeded downriver and out of the fjord. The migration was predominantly nocturnal, both in the river and fjord. Based on the available evidence, a considerable increase in eel survival in the river-fjord system will be needed in order to fulfil the goals in the European Union recovery plan for eels.