ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Trusses are structural systems commonly used in projects, being employed mainly in roof structures, present in most rural buildings. The design of trusses, as well as other structural systems, requires the determination of displacements, strains and stresses. However, the project is developed from an ideal model of calculation, considering free rotation between the elements of a connection. This paper presents a computer program for the analysis of bidimensional wooden trusses with connections formed with two screws per node. The formulation is based on the flexibility method, taking into account the influence of the effect of semi-rigid connections formed by two screws. An example of a structure is presented and analyzed by the program developed here, highlighting the importance of behavior analysis on semi-rigid connections.
Content may be subject to copyright.
TECHNICAL PAPER
____________________________________
1 Dr., Departamento de Engenharia Mecânica, Universidade Federal de São João del-Rei (UFSJ), Praça Frei Orlando 170, Centro,
São João del-Rei - MG, alchristoforo@ufsj.edu.br.
2 Departamento de Engenharia de Estruturas, Escola de Engenharia de São Carlos, Universidade de São Paulo, Av. Trabalhador
Sancarlense, 400, São Carlos - SP, giulianoromanholo@hotmail.com.
3 Dr., Departamento de Engenharia Mecânica, Universidade Federal de São João del-Rei (UFSJ), Praça Frei Orlando 170, Centro,
São João del-Rei - MG, tuliopanzera@ufsj.edu.br.
4 Dr., Departamento de Engenharia de Produção Civil, Centro Federal Tecnológico de Minas Gerais (CEFET-MG), Av. Amazonas,
7675, Nova Gameleira, Belo Horizonte - MG, pborges@civil.cefetmg.br.
5 Dr., Departamento de Engenharia de Estruturas, Laboratório de Estruturas de Madeira, Escola de Engenharia de São Carlos,
Universidade de São Paulo, Av. Trabalhador Sancarlense, 400, São Carlos - SP, frocco@sc.usp.br.
Recebido pelo Conselho Editorial em: 25-1-2011
Aprovado pelo Conselho Editorial em: 6-6-2011 Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
INFLUENCE OF STIFFNESS IN BOLTED CONNECTIONS IN WOODEN PLANE
STRUCTURE OF TRUSS TYPE
ANDRÉ L. CHRISTOFORO1, GIULIANO A. ROMANHOLO2, TÚLIO H. PANZERA3,
PAULO H. R. BORGES4, FRANCISCO A. R. LAHR5
ABSTRACT: Trusses are structural systems commonly used in projects, being employed mainly in
roof structures, present in most rural buildings. The design of trusses, as well as other structural
systems, requires the determination of displacements, strains and stresses. However, the project is
developed from an ideal model of calculation, considering free rotation between the elements of a
connection. This paper presents a computer program for the analysis of bidimensional wooden
trusses with connections formed with two screws per node. The formulation is based on the
flexibility method, taking into account the influence of the effect of semi-rigid connections formed
by two screws. An example of a structure is presented and analyzed by the program developed here,
highlighting the importance of behavior analysis on semi-rigid connections.
KEYWORDS: trusses, semi-rigid connections, flexibility method, rural buildings.
INFLUÊNCIA DA RIGIDEZ DE LIGAÇÕES PARAFUSADAS EM ESTRUTURAS
PLANAS DE MADEIRA DO TIPO TRELIÇA
RESUMO: Treliças são sistemas estruturais comumente utilizados em projetos, empregadas
principalmente em estruturas de cobertura, presentes na maioria das construções rurais. O
dimensionamento de treliças, assim como o de outros sistemas estruturais, requer a determinação
dos deslocamentos, esforços, tensões e deformações atuantes em seus elementos constituintes. O
cálculo é desenvolvido com base em um modelo ideal, considerando-se o giro livre entre os
elementos componentes de uma ligação. Este trabalho objetiva apresentar um programa
computacional destinado à análise de treliças planas de madeira com ligações formadas com dois
parafusos por nó. A formulação é fundamentada no Método da Flexibilidade, levando-se em
consideração a influência do efeito semirrígido das ligações formadas por dois parafusos. Um
exemplo de estrutura auxiliar de cobertura é apresentado e analisado pelo programa desenvolvido,
evidenciando-se a importância da análise do comportamento semirrígido sobre as ligações.
PALAVRAS-CHAVE: estruturas de cobertura, ligações semirrígidas, método da flexibilidade,
construções rurais.
Influence of stiffness in bolted connections in wooden plane structure of truss type
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
999
INTRODUCTION
The use of wood as a structural element in Brazil has grown over the past few years because
of the research carried out in order to make it more competitive than other construction materials.
In the case of structures, wood can be used in temporary works, such as anchors and forms, or
as a structural element, such as beams, columns, poles, trusses and more. Wood is widely used in
structures of truss-type roofs, as those found in sheds and diverse rural buildings.
The flat design of roof structures is usually done through ideal calculation models, in which
the links are considered as perfectly flexible in rotation (trusses), i.e., transmitting only normal
forces among their structural components.
In practice, flat connections in wooden structures are designed in different ways, and
especially among them, the use of bolted connections. However, the existence of two or more
screws forms a semi-rigid effect of these connections.
The semi-rigid effect of connections lies between two ideal calculating models: the free
rotating (truss) and the perfectly rigid (porch) models.
According to RIBEIRO (1997), the study of connections began in England in the early
nineteenth century, with the study of the riveted beam-column type, which the moment-rotation
relationship was evaluated.
A work of great importance is that by JOHNSTON & MOUNT (1942), which analyzed
frames with semi-rigid connections. Later, SHOROCHNIKOFF (1950) reported the influence of
forces by the wind in semi-rigid connections for the same type of structure.
For metal structures, LOTHERS (1951) proposed equations to represent the elastic constraint
of semi-rigid connections. KRISHNAMURTHY et al. (1979) applied the Finite Element Method
(FEM) to obtain moment-rotation curves of connections with steel sheets, and JONES et al. (1983)
studied the influence of semi-rigid connections in steel columns.
In the case of studies of connections in wooden structures, the work by OLIVEIRA & DIAS
(2001) evaluated through the analysis of experimental results, the criterion for the design of the
metal pin connections, proposed by the technical standard NBR 7190/97 (Design of wooden
structures). Other relevant works involving the study of links and numerical methods applied to
wooden structures are the following: SANTANA & MASCIA (2009), SOUZA JUNIOR &
GESUALDO (2007), SOUZA JUNIOR & GESUALDO (2006), STAMATO & CALIL (2002),
CARVALHO (2002), GESUALDO (2001), SERAPHIM & FRANCO (2001), EMERSON &
FRIDLEY (1996), GROOM (1996) among others.
The present work aims at developing a computer program PS-R (Semi-Rigid Porch),
developed from the foundations of the flexibility method, to evaluate the effect of semi-rigid
connections formed by two screws in wooden plane structures of truss type. A roof structure is
evaluated by the PS-R program in order to verify the importance of this analysis.
METHODS
The modified stiffness matrix
0
M
[S ]
that accounts for the semi-rigid effect of the rotational
component for each element of the structure is developed according to the method of flexibility, as
expressed by Equation 1. Further details on obtaining the modified stiffness matrix can be found in
the work by WEAVER & GERE (1986).
André L. Christoforo, Giuliano A. Romanholo, Túlio H. Panzera et al.
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
1000
Rij Rj2 Rij Ri2
0
M
AE AE
0 0 - 0 0
LL
0 6Ce 3CLe 0 -6Ce 3CLe
0
[S ] =
22
Rj2 Rj3 Rj2
Rij Rj2
3CLe 2CL e 0 -3CLe CL
AE AE
- 0 0 0 0
LL
0 -6Ce -3CLe Rij Ri2
22
Ri2 Ri2 Ri3
0 6Ce -3CLe
0 3CLe CL 0 -3CLe 2CL e













((1
)
where,
A - cross-sectional area of the structural element;
E - longitudinal modulus of elasticity or Young's modulus;
L - length of the structural element;
I - moment of inertia of cross section;
C - coefficient of flexibility, obtained by:
3Rij Ri Rj
2EI
CL 4e 3 4e e 1



, and
eRij ; eRi; eRj - dimensionless parameters of flexibility.
The coefficients of flexibility contained in the modified stiffness matrix element of the beam,
allow assessing the structural behavior through three different forms of analysis: the first form
accounts for the effect of semi-rigid connection, the second one considers the structure as a porch
and the third one considers it as a truss. To analyze the behavior of semi-rigid connections via the
software developed in FORTRAN language, it is necessary to know the coefficients of flexibility
that make the modified stiffness matrix (equation 1) in a stiffness matrix for porch beam and in a
stiffness matrix for truss beam, respectively.
The determination (calibration) of the coefficient of flexibility responsible for transforming
the stiffness matrix in the modified stiffness matrix for a porch beam is performed according to the
structural model of a beam embedded in their edges with a concentrated force of intensity F, applied
in mid-span, as illustrated in Figure 1.
For the structural variables were assigned the following numeric values: F = -5 kN ; A = 50 cm2 ; I = 467.67 cm4 ; E = 2000
kN/cm2 ; L = 200 cm
FIGURE 1. Bi-clamped beam.
Several attempts were made to find the rotational coefficient of semi-stiffness, which aims to
transform the stiffness matrix into the modified stiffness matrix of a beam porch element. It was
found that for a coefficient of 1.0 × 109, the values of the transverse displacements at the point of
Influence of stiffness in bolted connections in wooden plane structure of truss type
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
1001
application of force as well as the relative rotations at the ends of the beam converged to the results
provided by commercial software SAP 2000. For values above 1.0 × 109, the results for the
displacements with the use of these programs, PS-R and SAP 2000, remained constant.
To determine the coefficient of rotational semi-stiffness that represents the structure as bolted,
the same tests (variation of rotational stiffness) were carried out; however, the structure considered
in SAP 2000 was bi-clamped (hinged). The coefficient of semi-rigid rotation found for this case was
1.0 × 10-9.
It is important to note that the rotational coefficients of semi-rigidity herein determined are
independent of the geometrical and physical parameters used in numerical simulations and that the
axial stiffness was kept constant over the whole data analysis, varying only the rotational stiffness.
In addition to analyzing the effect of semi-rigid connections, the PS-R program also allows
evaluating the structure as a porch or a truss.
In the case of the connection formed by two screws, the standards adopted for the calculation
and the respective provisions were established by the normative NBR 8800/1986 (Project and
execution of steel structures in buildings), replaced by the current version NBR 8800/2008, to
quantify the forces acting on the screws of the connection. The removal of the screws (Figure 2)
confers the presence of a moment of resistance in the connection.
FIGURE 2. Detail of bolted connection.
The shear resistance force of the screws FR and the resistance moment MR of the connection
are expressed by Equations 2 and 3, respectively:
R V NV
F=ΦR
,
uPNV fAR 42,0
(2)
pRR eFM
(3)
where,
p
e
- spacing between screws;
P
A
- gross area, based on the nominal diameter “dp” of the screw;
u
f
- tensile strength of the screw material;
RNV - nominal shear strength, and
V
Φ
- weighting coefficient of the shear resistant strength.
André L. Christoforo, Giuliano A. Romanholo, Túlio H. Panzera et al.
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
1002
According to the version of the normative document NBR 8800/1986, the weighting values
for bolts ASTM A325 and ASTM A490 equals to 0.65 and the minimum distance between their
centers should not be less than
p
3d
(constructive disposition).
Table 1 indicates, according to the specifications of the material, the shear resistance of the
screw according to their diameter.
TABLE 1. Materials used on screws.
Specification
Resistance (kN cm-2)
Nominal Diameter “dp” (mm)
ASTM A325
82.50
12,7 dp 25,4
72.50
25,40 dp 38,10
ASTM A490
103.50
12,7 dp 38,10
The analysis of the behavior of semi-rigid connections formed by two screws through the
program PS-R is carried out according to the correction of rigid connections, which is due to an
iterative process. This correction is made only when the resistance moment of the connection
becomes lower than that of the applicant. To determine in advance the strains on the structure, the
connections are considered to be perfectly rigid, and soon after this consideration, the bending
stresses acting on the connection are compared in module with the resistance that it presents.
The calculation of the resistance moment of the connection by the PS-R program is conducted
as a function of the spacing and diameter of the screws, being equal for all nodes of the structure
and constant throughout the analysis (equation 3). Attention should be paid for the minimum
dimension of the screws provided by the normative, to not impair the reliability of the results.
After calculating the bolted moment and the resistance moment of the connections, the
program compares these two values. If the bolted moment is less than or equal to the resistance
moment, the connections are considered rigid and the value of the moment acting on the connection
is the bolted moment. If the bolted moment in a connection is greater than the resistance moment,
the program recalculates the whole structure so that it finds a new equilibrium configuration. This
procedure is incremental and iterative and, for the bolted connections beyond their resistance, the
value of the coefficient of semi-rigid rotational connection was successively decreased in 1% and
all strains in the structure (redistribution of the surplus moment) were recalculated.
EXAMPLE OF APPLICATION AND RESULTS
Figure 3 illustrates the structure analyzed by the PS-R program.
FIGURE 3. Type-A structure.
The identification of nodes and elements of the components of type A structure are illustrated
in Figure 4.
Influence of stiffness in bolted connections in wooden plane structure of truss type
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
1003
In the analysis of the type-A structure, the following values of structural variables are used: F = 50
kN ; A = 90 cm2 ; I = 1,687.50 cm4 ; E = 2000 kN/cm2 ; L = 200 cm; specification of screw material
= ASTM A325; dp= 1.3 cm ; ep= 4 cm.
FIGURE 4. Discretization of the type-A structure.
The type-A structure is evaluated by three different forms of analysis: first, the displacements
of nodes 2 and 3 (Figure 4) are limited to values less than L/200, according to the NBR 7190/1997
specifications, so to ensure that the structure to be designed is within the linear elastic regime (as
required in the project), in order to verify the influence of the semi-rigid effect under small
displacements; in the second analysis, all structural variables are maintained, with the exception of
force, which is gradually increased in order to verify the intensity responsible for applying two
connections beyond their resistance; the third form of analysis aims to determine the amount of
force necessary to apply four connections of the structure beyond its resistance, allowing to
compare the values of bending moments for both, rigid and semi-rigid connections.
It is important to make clear that the whole structure is designed to withstand the strain and
suffer small displacements, ensuring linear elastic behavior of materials, the designer's task is to
find the best dimensions and arrangements of structural elements as well as choose the most
suitable material. Thus, the second and third forms of analysis aforementioned are presented merely
to verify the stiffness loss of the connections calculated by the program.
Table 2 shows the values of nodal displacements of the type-A structure, expressed in
centimeters, obtained under the three forms of analysis that the PS-R program performs, with a
intensity force F = 50 KN.
TABLE 2. Values of nodal displacements for the type-A structure.
Node
Flexible (truss)
Semi- Rigid
Rigid (porch)
Displ. (x)
(cm)
Displ. (y)
(cm)
Displ. (x)
(cm)
Displ. (y)
(cm)
Displ. (x)
(cm)
Displ. (y)
(cm)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0.00235
-0.36612
0.00248
-0.36150
0.00248
-0.36150
3
-0.00235
-0.36612
-0.00248
-0.36150
-0.00248
-0.36150
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
-0.02484
-0.36025
-0.02456
-0.35602
-0.02456
-0.35602
6
0.0248
-0.36025
0.02456
-0.35602
0.02456
-0.35602
where: Displ. (x) - nodal displacement of the element in direction of x-axis; Displ. (y) nodal
displacement of the element in direction of y-axis.
According to the PS-R program, no connection was required beyond their capacity limits, i.e.,
the calculated acting moments were all less active to the resistance moment, of intensity
André L. Christoforo, Giuliano A. Romanholo, Túlio H. Panzera et al.
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
1004
105.60 kN cm, noting that this value was calculated by the program and was the same for three
analysis presented. This result is observed in Table 2, where displacement values for the structure
with rigid and semi-rigid connections are exactly the same.
For the second form of analysis, the intensity of the force responsible for applying the first
two connections beyond their resistance limits equals to 75 kN. Table 3 shows values of bending
moments acting on the structure nodes, expressed in kN cm, considering semi-rigid and rigid
connections.
TABLE 3. Values of bending moments acting on type-A structure by a force of 75 kN.
Rigid (porch)
Semi-Rigid
Connectivity
Bending moment
(kN cm)
Bending moment
(kN.cm)
Element
Node (i)
Node (j)
Node (i)
Node (j)
Node (i)
Node (j)
1
1
2
-24.01698
-121.53668
-23.6591
-120.17243
2
2
3
36.96272
-36.962762
36.64768
-36.64786
3
3
4
121.53668
24.01690
120.17243
23.65691
4
1
5
24.01690
-63.12227
23.65691
-63.27271
5
2
5
28.97094
29.16207
28.39852
28.96128
6
2
6
55.60302
3.19366
55.12605
2.89919
7
3
5
-55.60302
-3.19366
-55.12605
-2.89919
8
3
6
-28.97094
-29.16277
-28.39852
-28.96128
9
6
4
63.12227
-24.01690
63.27271
-23.65691
10
5
6
37.15385
-37.15385
37.21062
-37.21062
According to the program, nodes 2 and 3 (Figure 4) were applied beyond their resistance
capacities and, for the redistribution of the residual bending moment to the entire structure, 465
iterations were necessary.
For the third form of analysis, the intensity of the force responsible for applying the first four
connections beyond their limits of resistance is equal to 372 kN. Table 4 shows the values of
bending moments acting on the nodes of the structure, expressed in kN cm, considering the semi-
rigid and rigid connections.
TABLE 4. Values of bending moments acting on the type-A structure by a force of 372 kN.
Rigid (porch)
Semi-Rigid
Connectivity
Bending moment
(kN.cm)
Bending moment
(kN.cm)
Element
Node (i)
Node (j)
Node (i)
Element
Node (i)
Node (j)
1
1
2
-119.12384
-602.82193
-56.83838
-120.08168
2
2
3
183.33508
-183.33508
68.54579
-68.54579
3
3
4
602.82193
119.12384
120.08168
56.83838
4
1
5
119.12384
-313.08645
56.83838
-120.13901
5
2
5
143.69586
144.64384
-31.55450
-7.31987
6
2
6
275.79100
15.84055
83.09039
-32.70217
7
3
5
-275.79100
-15.84055
-83.09039
32.70217
8
3
6
-143.69586
-144.64389
31.55450
7.31987
9
6
4
313.08645
-119.12384
120.13901
-56.83838
10
5
6
184.28311
-184.28311
94.75671
-94.75671
Influence of stiffness in bolted connections in wooden plane structure of truss type
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
1005
According to the program, nodes 2, 3, 5 and 6 (Figure 4) were applied beyond their resistance
capabilities and, for the redistribution of residual bending moments to the entire structure 1,135
iterations were necessary.
CONCLUSIONS
The force value of 50 kN responsible for causing small displacements (L/200) in the structure
originated applying moments on the connections for both, rigid and semi-rigid calculation models,
lower than the resistance moment (105.60 kN cm). The displacements values shown in Table 2
indicate great similarity in terms of displacement between the flexible (truss), the rigid and the
semi-rigid models. For design conditions in which the applicant moment is lower than the resistance
moment, the truss model represents as a good calculation alternative, since it does not require the
use of iterative processes, contrary to what happens with the PS-R program, which does consider
the effect of semi-rigid connections.
The use of the PS-R program allowed finding values of the forces responsible for applying
some connections beyond their respective resistances, which represents an alternative calculation
tool for the analysis of truss displacements and stresses. However, it should be noted that the
rigidity of the connection is usually greater than that of the beam elements, resulting in failure of the
wood before the occurrence of maximum application to the connection. Studies involving the
consideration of non-linear physics to the wood allow a more precise analysis of this effect, being
the subject of interest for the development of future work.
REFERENCES
ASSOCIAÇÃO BRASILEIRA DE NORMAS TÉNICAS. NBR7190 - Projeto de estruturas de
madeira. Rio de Janeiro: ABNT, 1997.
ASSOCIAÇÃO BRASILEIRA DE NORMAS TÉNICAS. NBR 8800 - Projeto e execução de
estruturas de aço em edifícios. Rio de Janeiro: ABNT,1986.
ASSOCIAÇÃO BRASILEIRA DE NORMAS TÉNICAS. NBR 8800 - Projeto e execução de
estruturas de aço em edifícios. Rio de Janeiro: ABNT, 2008.
CARVALHO, J.S. Contribuição para a definição de critérios para o dimensionamento da ligação
entre peças de madeira por chapas metálicas com dentes estampados. 2002. 75 f. Dissertação
(Mestrado em Engenharia de Estruturas) - Universidade de São Paulo, 2002.
EMERSON, R.N.; FRIDLEY, K.J. Resistance of metal-plate-connected trussjoints to dynamic
loading. Forest Products Journal, Madson, v.46, n.12, p.83-90, 1996.
GESUALDO, F.A.R. Modelo para análise global de estruturas de madeira com avaliação de forças
localizadas em pinos deformáveis. Madeira, São Carlos, v.4, p.1-7, 2001.
GROOM, L.H. Effect of moisture cycling on truss-plate joint beahavior. Forest Products Journal,
Madison, v.44, n.1, p.21-28, 1996.
JOHNSTON, B.G.; MOUNT, E.H. Analysis of building frames with semi-rigid connections.
Transactions of the American Society Civil Enginners, v.107, p.993-1019, 1942.
JONES, S.W.; KIRBY, P.A.; NETHERCOT, D.A. The analysis of frames with semi-rigid
connections - A state-of-the-art-report. Journal of Constructional Steel Research, London, v.3, n.2,
p.2-13, 1983.
KRISHNAMURTHY, N.; HUANG, H.T.; JEFFREY, P.K. Analytical M-ø curves for end-plate
connections. Journal of Structural Division, New York, n.105, p.133-145, 1979.
LOTHERS, J.E. Elastic restrain equations for semi-rigid connections. Transactions of the American
Society Civil Enginners, Reston, v.116, p.480-494, 1951.
André L. Christoforo, Giuliano A. Romanholo, Túlio H. Panzera et al.
Eng. Agríc., Jaboticabal, v.31, n.5, p.998-1006, set./out. 2011
1006
OLIVEIRA, M.A.M.; DIAS, A.A. Ligações com pinos metálicos em estruturas de madeira. Revista
Madeira (CD-Rom), São Carlos, v.2, n.6, 2001.
RIBEIRO, L.F.L. Comportamento estrutural de ligações viga-coluna com chapa de topo: análise
teórica experimental. Monografia (Trabalho de Graduação de Engenharia Civil) - Escola de
Engenharia de São Carlos, Universidade de São Paulo, São Carlos, 1997.
SANTANA, C.L.O.; MASCIA, N.T. Wooden framed structures with semi-rigid connections:
quantitative approach focused on design needs. Structural Engineering and Mechanics, Fayon,
v.31, p.315-331, 2009.
SERAPHIM, J.H.C.; FRANCO, N. Ligações de peças de madeira de eucalipto com o uso de chapas
metálicas de dentes estampados. Téchne, São Paulo, n.51, p.50-54, 2001.
SHOROCHNIKOFF, B. Wind stresses in semi-rigid connections of steel framework. Transactions
of the ASCE, v.115, p.382-395, 1950.
STAMATO, G.C.; CALIL JR., C. Rigidez de de pórtico em estruturas de seção composta
pregada utilizando chapas de compensado. Revista Madeira Arquitetura e Engenharia, São Carlos,
2002. CD-ROM.
SOUZA JÚNIOR, D.A.; GESUALDO, F.A.R. Aplicação do método dos algoritmos genéticos na
minimização do consumo de madeira de estruturas espaciais com barras cruzadas para coberturas.
Revista Madeira, Curitiba, v. 1, p.1-15, 2006. CD-ROM.
SOUZA JÚNIOR, D.A.; GESUALDO, F.A.R. Distribuição de montantes e diagonais baseada na
minimização do volume de madeira de treliças planas. Revista Madeira, Curitiba, v.21, p.1-13,
2007.
WEAVER, W.W.; GERE, J.M. Matrix analysis of framed structures. New York: Van Nostrand
Reinhold Company, 1986, 492 p.
... The study concluded that, under design conditions where the applied moment is smaller than the resistance moment, the truss model proves to be a viable calculation alternative. This is because it does not require the use of iterative processes, unlike when considering the effect of semi-rigid connections (Christoforo et al., 2011). in the cross-sectional areas of the chords, around 50%. ...
... In the study conducted byChristoforo et al. (2011), the behavior and stiffness of connections in a flat wooden truss were investigated. Differentiating from the traditional truss model, where connections are considered as completely pinned joints, the proposed analysis considered the semi-rigid effect of connections formed by two screws.Figure 1illustrates the configuration of the analyzed timber structure, depicting this approach.REVISTA CADERNO PEDAGÓGICO -Studies Publicações Ltda.ISSN: 1983-0882Page 7 REVISTA CADERNO PEDAGÓGICO -Studies Publicações e Editora Ltda., Curitiba, v.21, n.6, p. 01-21. ...
... Detailing of the analyzed timber structure Source: Adapted fromChristoforo et al. (2011) ...
Article
The diversity of applications of wood in civil construction is remarkable, covering various structural systems. Such utilization is motivated by the growing concern for sustainability and the progressive industrialization of construction processes, coupled with its reduced carbon footprint compared to conventional materials such as concrete and steel. Wood is valued for its excellent mechanical properties, toughness, and high strength-to-density ratio, justifying its extensive use in buildings worldwide, also driven by its aesthetic and organic appeal, characteristic of timber structures. In this regard, this research aims to provide precise data for a rational approach to the use of wood as a structural system, with a particular focus on round timber spatial frames. It is observed that the type of connection between the elements of a frame (hinged, rigid, or semi-rigid) ultimately influences the design of the timber pieces, requiring an assessment of these influences. Thus, this study aims to develop numerical models based on the Finite Element Method (FEM), in accordance with current design codes. To achieve this goal, a computational tool in Python was developed, focused on design with linear elastic processing, whose validation was performed in conjunction with SAP2000® software. With a significant percentage difference between the two idealized models (hinged and fixed), it can be stated that the models designed for the connections exert a substantial influence on the design process of timber profiles, especially when analyzing spatial frame structures. Compared to the hinged model, the fixed model achieved a 27% reduction in the volume of consumed wood, implying a 33% increase in the volume of wood for the hinged model compared to the fixed one, highlighting the significant discrepancy.
... Quando se pretende projetar e construir uma estrutura espacial de madeira, há diversos fatores que fazem o comportamento da estrutura divergir entre o modelo teórico e a estrutura real. Estes fatores podem ser, além da heterogeneidade da madeira, erros construtivos e a falta de conhecimento do comportamento preciso das ligações, muitas vezes são consideradas ligações totalmente rígidas quando na verdade não transmitem toda a rigidez (Christoforo et al, 2011). ...
... A Figura 6 ilustra os resultados experimentais dos deslocamentos verticais medidos pelos transdutores de deslocamentos (LVDT) nos nós de 1 a 5, considerando-se os dois ciclos de carregamento. Da Figura 7, assim como esperado, o real comportamento da ligação da estrutura é semirrígido (Christoforo et al, 2011), variando entre os modelos ideais rotulados e engastados. Nota-se ainda que os valores dos deslocamentos experimentais são mais próximos dos deslocamentos provenientes do modelo simulado considerando ligações rotuladas entre os elementos de barra da grelha. ...
Article
Full-text available
A grelha lamelar em madeira permite a construção de grandes vãos com uso de madeira serrada em dimensões comerciais. O sistema é caracterizado pela geometria das barras, em que cada nó reúne o centro de uma barra (contínua ou não) com as extremidades de duas outras, cada uma destas barras representando uma lamela. Dependendo da concepção das ligações definidas entre as lamelas, a transmissão dos momentos de torção pode ou não ser levada em consideração, e tal condição pode impactar significativamente no desempenho mecânico da estrutura lamelar a ser projetada (maior ou menor rigidez frente à ação das cargas). O objetivo deste trabalho é analisar modelos numéricos de estruturas de grelha lamelar variando a vinculação entre as barras, contribuindo assim para o desenvolvimento de projetos estruturais baseados em simulações mais realistas de estruturas lamelares de madeira. Os elementos de barra podem ou não transmitir momentos de torção em suas extremidades. Portanto, são comparados os resultados de modelos numéricos à evidências experimentais, oriundas de um protótipo de grelha lamelar plana feito com madeira de Pinus spp. A variável utilizada para as comparações é o deslocamento vertical em vários pontos da estrutura. O modelo numérico é elaborado e analisado no software SAP2000. Mantém-se a estrutura em condições tais que não ultrapassem o estado limite de utilização. As ligações entre as lamelas foram feitas com chapas metálicas que envolvem lateralmente a lamela, fixadas às barras de madeira por parafusos auto atarraxantes. Pelos resultados obtidos, o modelo considerando articulação perfeita forneceu deslocamentos nodais mais próximos dos deslocamentos obtidos experimentalmente, indicando ser pequena a torção transmitida entre as barras.
... In other words, only 19% of the models did not present any type of problem. It is worth mentioning that it was considered that the connections remain integral, assuming that the failure occurs only in the timber bars (Christoforo, Romanholo, Panzera, Borges, & Lahr, 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
The Brazilian standard ABNT NBR 7190 (Associação Brasileira de Normas Técnicas [ABNT], 1997) recommends adopting the mean value of the modulus of elasticity to compression in the direction parallel to the grain (Ec0,m) in the calculation of displacements. The values of wood stiffness vary considerably, and they can generate displacements above the limit (L 200-1, where L is the span) established by the referred standard, which contributes to the appearance of pathologies in the structure. To evaluate the influence of the adoption of Ec0,m in the calculation of displacements, mechanical properties of wood species were obtained experimentally. With the aid of numerical models and experimental values, ten types of trusses were analyzed (Porch, Inclined Chord, Top Inclined Chord, Parallel Chord, Bowstring, Fink, Howe, K Truss, Pratt, Scissor), three spans (5, 10, and 20 m) and two species (Hymenolobium petraum Ducke e Hymenolobium sp). Initially, adopting Ec0,m for all members and performing a linear analysis, the maximum loads for the displacement L 200-1 were determined. Subsequently, experimental stiffness values were randomly assigned to each bar, and the maximum displacements were determined through nonlinear geometric analyses. Based on 1260 numerical simulations, deflections of approximately 17% (span of 5 m), 30% (span of 10 m), and 34% (span of 20 m) were observed to be higher than the result considering Ec0,m. This problem can be overcome by using non-destructive methods in the pre-classification of the structure bars, positioning the elements rationally in the regions of the highest demand.
... Ademais, verificou-se que trabalhos que analisam o comportamento e rigidez de ligações em estruturas de madeira geralmente se restringem a variáveis como carga crítica de ruptura; ductibilidade; deslocamentos; deformações; comportamento não linear etc. (CHRISTOFORO et al., 2011;DORN;DE BORST;EBERHARDSTEINER, 2013;FRONTINI;SIEM;RENMAELMO, 2018;TENORIO, 2017;TENORIO et al., 2018). Ou seja, há uma escassez de pesquisas que tratam da influência que os modelos exercem no dimensionamento das peças de madeira, considerando análise linear-elástica requerida em projetos de coberturas. ...
Article
Full-text available
p class="Normal1"> Devido às suas vantagens, a madeira tem sido amplamente utilizada como elemento estrutural ao redor do mundo, principalmente em países do Hemisfério Norte. Entretanto, no Brasil, apesar de sua expressiva diversidade florestal, muito pouco deste potencial é utilizado devido a preconceitos inerentes ao material. Todavia, ainda há uma evidente recorrência em estruturas treliçadas de telhados. Uma das problemáticas que envolvem o projeto de estruturas de cobertura é aquela referente aos modelos idealizados de análise. Engenheiros projetistas costumam adotar o modelo clássico de treliça na concepção estrutural. Entretanto, ao se considerar outras modelagens, diferenças significativas podem ser observadas nas dimensões finais das peças. Sendo assim, primando a avaliação dessas influências, uma ferramenta computacional foi desenvolvida com base no método dos elementos finitos (MEF) e nas rotinas de dimensionamento prescritas pela revisão da ABNT NBR 7190 (2020). Os valores de deslocamentos e esforços solicitantes foram aferidos com o software SAP2000 <sup>®</sup>, resultando em notória confiabilidade. Mediante fixação da espessura, o critério de dimensionamento utilizado foi o de altura mínima dos perfis. Após simulação de três modelos idealizados, os resultados evidenciaram que os perfis realmente sofrem consideráveis mudanças em função do modelo empregado, atingindo dimensões inferiores a 50% em modelos que conferem rigidez perfeita. </p
... Wood is one of the main materials used in the construction industry, either as a structural element (Almeida & Dias, 2016;Cavalheiro et al., 2016;Garcia et al., 2017), cover structures and roofs (truss) (Christoforo et al., 2011;Palludo et al., 2017) or as a support material for construction (shores, scaffolding, and formworks) (Calil Junior & Molina et al., 2010). ...
Article
Full-text available
Wood is one of the main materials used in the constructing of covering structures (roofs) because of its versatility. Under this situation, due to solar radiation incidence, the temperature can exceed 60 °C and, such as other environmental conditions, influence the mechanical properties of the wood in use. The aim of this research was to study the influence of exposure time of the wood of four different hardwood species at a temperature of 60 °C on the shear strength parallel to fibers. The wood of the following species was used: Cupiúba (Goupia glabra), Eucalyptus (Eucalyptus saligna), Garapeira (Apuleia leiocarpa), and Jatobá Tamarindo (Hymenaea sp.). In order to investigate the effect of exposure time (0, 168, 456, 720, and 2160 hours) of the wood species in an oven (60 °C) on the values of shear strength in the direction parallel to fibers, an analysis of variance (ANOVA) was carried out at 5% significance level. According to the results, the time the wood was exposed to the operating temperature significantly influenced the shear strength in the direction parallel to fibers. In addition, all species showed a decrease in shear strength after 456 hours of exposure at a constant temperature of 60 °C.
... Bracing is a structural subsystem of flat structures locking in order to maintain the elements stability that compose it [4,5]. This subsystem ensures that the structure works according to stability criteria considered in design for each constituent structure element, an aspect that will be directly reflected in the functions for which environments are constructed. ...
Article
Full-text available
This research analyzes the forces in bracing members of timber trusses through numerical modeling using the computational system Strap, considering the three-dimensional structure behavior. The values obtained are compared to values set by the Brazilian standard ABNT NBR 7190 (1997), which considers the side instability of the bracing elements. The results were also compared with the values proposed by the methods of the European standard EUROCODE 5, the South African Standard SABS 0163 (1994) and with the work developed by Underwood (2000). The computer models represent industrial sheds with 12 to 24 meters spam, 24 to 96 meters long with heights of pillars 3, 4 and 6 meters. The structural models analyzed were the Pratt and Howe truss types, considering wood provide from C30 and C40 strength classes. The results show that the forces acting on the bracing of the three-dimensional models are higher than the values obtained by the method of ABNT NBR 7190 (1997), and the values obtained by the methods proposed by EUROCODE 5 and Underwood (2000) are more reliable in the overall behavior of the structure.
... Moreover, factors such as the presence of node, opening cracks during drying and fiber inclinations promote great variations in physical and mechanical properties[5] [6] [7]. According to[1], the mechanical properties of wood are dependent on the density, percentage of juvenile wood, the width of the rings, the angle of the micro fibrils, the amount of extractives, moisture content, the intensity of insect attack, the type and location and number of nodes, among other factors, making it difficult to obtain all their elastic parameters to be used in structural projects[8] [9]. ...
Article
Full-text available
For the anisotropy presented by wood, the established positions of the specimens in the bending test can significantly alter the properties of strength and stiffness. This study aimed to evaluate, with the aid of the Brazilian standard ABNT NBR 7190:1997, the influence of the wood specimens position to determine the bending modulus of elasticity. The wood species used in the trials (three point static bending) were Corymbia citriodora and Pinus elliottii, and used six specimens per species. Each piece gave rise to four experiments, performed with a non-destructive form, differentiated only by the position of the specimen in the bending test(sides: A -lowest; B; C; D -higher value), providing four values of elastic modulus per specimens. The experiments were considered non-destructive for the largest displacement value in trials does not exceed the measure L/200 (L-usable length of the specimen), ensuring physical and geometriclinearity fo r the woods tested, as established by the Brazilian standard. The results of analyses of variance showed statistical equivalency between the modulus of elasticity of both wood species, resulting in independence of the specimen position to determine the bending stiffness. Ho wever, by the orthotropic behaviour of wood, the results obtainedcannot be extrapolated to other woods of the same or different species, thereby justifying the change of the specimenposition in the bending test, allowing evaluate the equivalence or not between the modulus of elasticity.
... According to[1], the mechanical properties of wood are dependent on the density, the percentage of juvenile wood, the width of the rings, the angle of the microfibrils, the amount of extract ives, moisture content, the intensity of insect attack, the type and location and number of nodes, among other factors, making it difficult to obtain need all their elastic parameters to be used in structural projects[8] [9]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The obtaining the modulus of elasticity in compression of the wood with the use of dial gauges, fixed on opposite faces of the specimens, may lead to deformation values and consequently to different elastic modulus as a function of the faces chosen for its attachment, being the timber an anisotropic material. This study aimed to evaluate the influence of two distinct positions for setting the dial gauges (A and B) in wood specimens tested in compression, using the assumptions of the test methods and calculation of the Brazilian standard ABNT NBR 7190: 1997. The woods evaluated in trials were the Pinus elliottii and Corymbia citriodora, being used seven specimens per species. A specimen was taken to the rupture, obtained the values of the ma ximu m stress and strain (references) needed to obtain the elastic moduli of the six remaining specimens per species, certain non-destructively (two tests per piece). The results of analysis of variance revealed the equivalence between modules elasticity in compression parallel to the grain for both wood species investigated, resulting not significantly arrangement of dial gaugesto determine the properties of stiffness. However, the anisotropy of wood, these results cannot be extrapolated to other woods of the same or d ifferent species, justifying the setting of dial gauges in two different positions, allo wing for judging whether or not the equivalence between the modulus of elasticity.
Article
Full-text available
p align="left">El objetivo de esta investigación fue ilustrar sobre la posibilidad de aplicación de variables participativas en la evaluación de proyectos relacionados con edificaciones rurales como herramienta de desarrollo socioeconómico en la región de la Mata del sur (PE). La metodología adoptada en este trabajo consistió en investigación bibliográfica en artículos científicos, libros e internet sobre los territorios rurales, desarrollo y / o análisis de proyectos de edificaciones a partir de variables socioeconómicas. Los resultados demostraron que aún son poco utilizadas herramientas que permiten participación de los actores involucrados en la construcción de territorio y en los proyectos de edificaciones rurales, a diferencia de otras áreas agrarias como el desarrollo rural que ya las incorporan. Aun así es importante la inclusión de este tipo de variables para desarrollar proyectos en el marco de desarrollo local, la sustentabilidad y justicia social. Por lo tanto se concluye que los proyectos de edificaciones rurales deben incentivar reflexiones académicas sobre herramientas que permitan conciliar diversos intereses de los actores, lo cual es clave en la variabilidad socioeconómica de los proyectos</p
Article
Full-text available
Wood is a renewable source of structural material with high relative strength/weight, low energy production, which kidnaps and stores carbon in its production. The large use of wood is due to its special qualities as raw material for other products manufactured in residential construction or major works such as bridges, has been widely used in roofing for industrial and commercial buildings. Commercially there are limitations on the length of the wood, resulting from the extraction of tree trunks, thus requiring the adoption of binding elements is the use of self-tapping screws efforts required by side and which can be axial, shear, tensile or compression. Whereas in Brazil does not yet exist and the promising future of the product, this research aims to study the behavior of self-tapping screws together with Brazilian reforestation species of Pinus oocarpa and Lyptus (softwood and hardwood). Rothoblaas self-tapping screws had a good penetration in both woods without requiring pre-drilling, the species of Lyptus wood showed the highest values of strength and the inclination of the screws, at 45 degrees showed the best results on either species of wood.
Article
Full-text available
O crescimento da população urbana, bem como as diferenças sociais brasileiras, têm causado significativa degradação nas condições de vida e de moradia em nosso país. Tal fato vem referenciar a necessidade de se intensificar as pesquisas que tenham como objetivos a produção de alternativas tecnológicas para solucionar-se tais problemas. Não é ainda comun no Brasil o uso de chapas com dentes estampados para se fazer a conexão de peças estruturais de madeira, apesar dessas se apresentarem como uma ótima alternativa estrutural e econômica para tal. A norma brasileira, NBR 7190/97 - Projeto de Estruturas de Madeira, não apresenta um método com os critérios de dimensionamento para tais tipos de ligação. Baseado em estudos teóricos e experimentais desenvolvidos no Laboratório de Madeira e Estruturas de Madeira (LaMEM, do departamento de Engenharia de Estruturas da Escola de Engenharia de São Carlos, Universidade de São Paulo, são apresentados neste trabalho contribuições para o desenvolvimento de tais critérios para o dimensionamento destas ligações. O presente estudo foi desenvolvido para atender as especificações de espécies tropicais nativas e de reflorestamento encontradas em território nacional. Dissertação (Mestrado).
Article
The restraining effects of semi-rigid, girder-column connections have received considerable attention within recent years in both the United States and Great Britain. Excellent literature on the subject is now' available, and methods of analyses which take into account the restraining effects of these connections have been proposed. On the whole, these proposed methods would be conducive to economy in metal structures except for one fact.
Article
The behavior of metal-plate-connected (MPC) joints has been thoroughly researched under various static loading scenarios; however, little research has been performed on MPC joints subjected to dynamic loading. This research investigates the effects of dynamic loading on MPC joints. This investigation follows procedures similar to those used for studies of nailed connections due to the similarities of the two types of connections. Six configurations of MPC truss joints were tes ted under static and dynamic loading. Static tests were performed to obtain maximum static strength and static stiffness values for the different configurations. Each configuration was then subjected to dynamic loading and then statically loaded to failure. An accepted model of the load-slip behavior of MPC joints was fit to the data acquired from static tests before and after dynamic loading. The residual effects of the applied dynamic loading on the tested MPC joints were quite minimal. The tested MPC joints developed similar static load properties before and after dynamic loading. While the dynamically loaded connections generally developed less initial static stiffness than their static-load-only counterparts, they maintained most of their static load resistance. This resistance to residual effects of dynamic loading makes these MPC joints suitable for use in structures situated in high seismic or wind zones.
Article
Much has been written on wind stresses in general and also on stresses in semi-rigid framework. Some disagreement remains, however, on how to combine the stresses due to gravity loads with those due to wind in the connections of semi-rigid framework, particularly when the connections are stressed beyond the yield point in bending. As the semi-rigid connections are often allowed to work beyond the yield point, this question is of importance. This paper presents a theoretical discussion of stresses under these conditions, and derives general conclusions applicable to rectangular framework.
Article
Analytical methodology has been developed and validated, to determine moment-rotation curves and equations for steel bolted end-plate connections. A parameter study was conducted on 168 connections for 559 loading conditions, by two-dimensional finite element analysis. Special features of the computer program and modeling are described. From the results, a prediction equation has been generated by regression analysis, to give the connection rotation as a function of the beam and plate dimensions, bolt sizes and location, and material properties. Comparison of predicted and experimentally observed results is presented for a typical case. Practical applications of the findings are covered.
Article
Mechanical connections are recognized as extremely important elements in the aspect of strength and structural safety. However, classical structural model does not consider the connection stiffness properties, and are based on models with pinned or rigid joints only. In fact, mechanical connections are deformable and behave not linearly, affecting the whole structure and inducing nonlinear behavior as well. The quantification of this effect, however, depends on the description of the working of the connectors and the wood response under embedment. The theoretical modeling of wood structures with semi-rigid connections involves not only the structural analysis, but also the modeling of both single and grouped moment resisting connectors and the study of the wood properties under embedment. The proposal of this paper is to approach these aspects, and to quantitatively study the influence of the moment resistant connection in wooden framed structures. Comparisons between rigid and semi-rigid connections and between linear and nonlinear analysis lead to quantitative results.
Article
The history of research into the behaviour of steel beam-to-column connections is traced starting from early developments in 1917. Attention is focussed on moment-rotation characteristics as this is the most important influence on the response of either individual members or complete frames. The nonlinear nature of this characteristic is identified and methods of representing moment-rotation curves for subsequent use in analytical procedures are discussed. A review is made of all available test data; this may be used as a starting point for both further studies of connection behaviour and as the basis for investigations of the effects of semi-rigid connections on structural response.
Article
A construção de estruturas de madeira usualmente requer ligações entre as peças que as compõem. Estas uniões devem ser compatíveis com as solicitações mecânicas avaliadas, garantindo durabilidade e segurança à estrutura. Atualmente, a normalização brasileira referente ao uso estrutural da madeira, NBR 7190/97- Projeto de estruturas de madeira, aborda os critérios de dimensionamento para as ligações por meio de pinos metálicos, ligações coladas, cavilhas ou conectores. O critério da NBR 7190/97 para o dimensionamento das ligações por pinos metálicos conduz ao aumento do número de elementos nas ligações, em relação ao observado na norma anterior. Dentro deste contexto, o objetivo deste trabalho é avaliar o critério de dimensionamento da NBR 7190/97 por meio de análise de resultados experimentais. Dissertação (Mestrado).
Effect of moisture cycling on truss-plate joint beahavior
  • GROOM L.H.
GROOM, L.H. Effect of moisture cycling on truss-plate joint beahavior. Forest Products Journal, Madison, v.44, n.1, p.21-28, 1996