Ants are a very successful group among insects, but the course of evolution of their biodiversity is still unclear. In this study, light is shed on the ant diversification during the Eocene. The analysis of the ant taphocoenosis of the fossil site Grube Messel, Germany, 47 Ma, yielded three poneromorph subfamilies and 22 new species in six genera of which four genera are new (Pseudectatomma gen. nov., Cephalopone gen. nov., Cyrtopone gen. nov., Messelepone gen. nov.). Only one extant genus, Pachycondyla, is present in the taphocoenosis from Messel. The high diversity of poneromorph ants from Messel is very conspicuous in comparison with the middle to late Eocene European ambers. In the ambers, a significant lower portion of species could be assigned to poneromorph ants, and even compared in absolute numbers, fewer poneromorph species are known from European ambers than from Messel. A possible gradual decline of the diversity of poneromorphs from the Eocene to the Miocene seems to be detectable worldwide. These insights are discussed in the context of the morphology and ecology of Poneromorpha and Formicomorpha. The proportion of ant castes in amber seems to indicate that already during the Eocene, poneromorphs inhabited preferably litter and soil, whereas formicomorphs preferred the arboreal realm. The “ponerine paradox” of having only a primitive social organization, yet being an old phylogenetic line with global distribution is discussed with emphasis on the paleontological data basis, but still remains unsolved. The evolutionary history of Myrmicinae is discussed. With the new available paleontological data, the timing and the dynamics of predominance of different subgroups of the ants can be traced more precisely than before.