This action research aims to investigate the determinants of asynchronous interaction among students, interaction between students and instructors, and interaction with course content in an online learning environment. The study involves fifteen graduate students from a state university as participants. The research employed multiple data collection instruments, including commission meeting reports, focus-group sessions, semi-structured interviews, observation forms, emails, video recordings, researchers' diaries, and system log records. The content analysis method was employed for data analysis. The findings revealed that in learner-learner interaction, instructional method, notifications, technical issues, and individual problems exert discernible effects. For learner-instructor interaction, feedback, instructional methods, and the utilization of diverse communication channels were identified as influential factors. Moreover, technical problems, time constraints, and system usability emerged as key elements shaping learner-content interaction. Notably, learners' personal preferences, encompassing attitudes toward the online course and time management, manifested both positive and negative effects across all interaction types. The study has concluded that assignments with open access, star-based scoring, and mobile notifications enhance learner-learner interaction. Instant feedback from instructors and notifications initiated by instructors enhances learner-instructor interaction. Overall, optimal system usability and minimal technical issues contribute substantively to augmenting learner-content interaction. Highlights What is already known about this topic: • In the existing literature, it is noted that asynchronous interactions often result in limited and brief discussion periods. However, research in this area is scarce. • Additionally, it has been stated that material usage, group size, and information density can influence asynchronous interaction. What this paper contributes: • In this study, factors influencing asynchronous interaction have been examined through action research. • Providing assignments with open access tasks to everyone, sending mobile application notifications, rating with stars, and commenting on tasks have been shown to enhance asynchronous interaction. Implications for theory, practice and/or policy: • The instructional method, notifications, technical issues, and individual factors have been noted to affect student-student interaction. • Moreover, feedback, instructional methods, and communication channels influence student-teacher interaction, while technical issues, time constraints, and system usability impact student-content interaction.