ArticlePDF Available

Making the quantum leap: Lessons from physics on studying spirituality and religion in organizations

Authors:
Charles J. Fornaciari
Charles J. Fornaciari
Charles J. Fornaciari
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Kathy Lund Dean at Gustavus Adolphus College
Kathy Lund Dean
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

The emerging research on spirituality, religion and work (SRW) poses concerns for all social scientists. Specifically, the paradigm currently employed for social scientific research, including measurement techniques, data analysis, and even accepted language, is inadequate for scholarship in the emerging inquiry stream. This paper discusses the current positivist model under which scholarly work derives legitimacy, and explores where the model fails to address the needs of SRW researchers from both conceptual and moral standpoints. Taking lessons from the natural sciences, we show how inquiry, modeling, and knowledge made critical leaps utilizing a post-positivist creativity within a discipline that struggled with many of the same issues we currently face in the SRW research agenda. The paper concludes with implications for a new research methods paradigm and language that would better serve our understanding of the holistic human experience in organizations, including a discussion of the inherently moral underpinning of our work.
Content uploaded by Kathy Lund Dean
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Kathy Lund Dean on Oct 25, 2023
Content may be subject to copyright.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Making the quantum leap: Lessons from physics on studying spirituality and r...
Charles J Fornaciari; Kathy Lund Dean
Journal of Organizational Change Management; 2001; 14, 4; ProQuest Psychology Journals
pg. 335
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... As alternative ways of understanding spirituality and chaplaincy are needed (Bell 2008;Driscoll and Wiebe 2007;Fornaciari and Lund Dean 2001), essential characteristics of a critical and a positive workplace spirituality are elaborated in this paper and discussed in the context of workplace chaplaincy. Within our empirical study, a practical model of workplace chaplaincy is comprehensively examined through a combination of different ways of qualitative data collection. ...
New insights into workplace chaplaincy
Article
Full-text available
  • May 2022
Workplace chaplaincy, a concrete manifestation of workplace spirituality, is defined as pastoral care serving the specific needs of people in workplaces. While scientific publications have so far emphasized its beneficial implications, scrutiny of the possible instrumentalization of workplace chaplaincy by the management has been neglected. Workplace chaplaincy can signify a real integration of spirituality implying a debate on the meaning of life and work, as well as a critical analysis of organizational structures and management (critical workplace spirituality). Just as well, it can be instrumentalized as a management technique to impel employees to achieve improved organizational results (positive workplace spirituality). This paper contributes to the management literature by elaborating decisive characteristics of a critical and positive workplace spirituality and discussing those characteristics that pertain to workplace chaplaincy. Furthermore, we provide a qualitative study on workplace chaplaincy illustrating a critical thought-provoking model facing different challenges, allegiances and logics in the secular working world. The elaborated characteristics and the qualitative study extend our understanding of workplace spirituality and chaplaincy as they provide a view beyond traditional management perspectives. Moreover, this paper contributes to the discussion what kind of spirituality and chaplaincy we are referring to in management theory and practice.
View
... Possible answers to address these kinds of concerns include challenging accepted language, measurement techniques, and data analysis (Fornaciari & Lund Dean, 2001), and advancing pedagogical innovations balancing reason and emotions, such as whole-person learning (Barbera et al., 2015;Eriksen, 2009;Kolb & Kolb, 2005), positive management education (Karakas, 2011), and pedagogies that embed reflexivity (Sinclair, 2007), deep listening (Senge et al., 2004), consciousness (Mirvis, 2008), and heart and soul (Waddock & Lozano, 2013). While these important contributions lay out a generic foundation of an alternate vision, how the essential aspects of spiritual traditions might inform such a management education pedagogy remains surprisingly underexplored. ...
Spiritual Practice and Management Education Pedagogy: Exploring the Philosophical Foundations of Three Spiritual Traditions
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 2020
  • J Manag Educ
Can the philosophical foundations of spiritual practices inform management education pedagogy and in the long-run support emotional development and more ethical and responsible business practice? In this article, we introduce the essential aspects of three different spiritual traditions—Daoist inner work, Buddhist mindful reflexivity, and Quaker discernment—and lay out some foundations between these essential aspects and management education pedagogy. We offer examples of utilizing these concepts in teaching business ethics in order to offer a foundational discussion for future elaboration. Our experiences also illuminate that instructor preparation is a key ingredient if the kinds of teaching we advance are to gain traction and contribute to the repeated calls for pedagogical innovations that challenge dominant paradigms. We offer some concluding remarks, pathways for future research and indicate a list of resources that can support potential instructors.
View
... Possible answers to address these kinds of concerns include challenging accepted language, measurement techniques, and data analysis (Fornaciari & Lund Dean, 2001), and advancing pedagogical innovations balancing reason and emotions, such as whole-person learning (Barbera et al., 2015;Eriksen, 2009;Kolb & Kolb, 2005), positive management education (Karakas, 2011), and pedagogies that embed reflexivity (Sinclair, 2007), deep listening (Senge et al., 2004), consciousness (Mirvis, 2008), and heart and soul (Waddock & Lozano, 2013). While these important contributions lay out a generic foundation of an alternate vision, how the essential aspects of spiritual traditions might inform such a management education pedagogy remains surprisingly underexplored. ...
SPIRITUAL PRACTICE AND MANAGEMENT EDUCATION PEDAGOGY: EXPLORING THE PHILOSOPHICAL FOUNDATIONS OF THREE SPIRITUAL TRADITIONS
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 2020
Can the philosophical foundations of spiritual practices inform management education pedagogy and in the long-run support emotional development and more ethical and responsible business practice? In this paper, we introduce the essential aspects of three different spiritual traditions – Daoist inner work, Buddhist mindful reflexivity, and Quaker discernment - and lay out some foundations between these essential aspects and management education pedagogy. We offer examples of utilizing these essential aspects in teaching business ethics in order to offer a foundational discussion for future elaboration. Our experiences also illuminate that instructor preparation is a key ingredient if the kinds of teaching we advance are to gain traction and contribute to the repeated calls for pedagogical innovations that challenge dominant paradigms. We offer some concluding remarks, pathways for future research and indicate a list of resources that can support potential instructors
View
Integrating Workplace and Organizational Spirituality with Sustainability for Organizational Success
Chapter
  • Apr 2024
In this chapter I propose that the combination of workplace spirituality and sustainability are beneficial for business and organizational success. Existing literature will be synthesized to demonstrate the benefits, along with interviews to assist with practical application of workplace spirituality and sustainability on a business/organizational level. I included a comment in Chapter 12 concerning the intuitive sense that spirituality and sustainability would contribute to the success of an individual, which nonetheless would require a theoretical foundation or framework which can be researched and proven to be considered scientifically valid.
View
Epilogue: The Synthesis of Spirituality and Sustainability for Success
Chapter
  • Apr 2024
In this text, the author has examined two seemingly unrelated, yet mutually intertwined topics, presenting the case for both to be characteristics of, and tools for both individual and organizational success. The underlying framework of both topics is the interconnectedness and oneness of everyone and everything on the planet. In this concluding chapter, I will summarize the key principles of the preceding chapters, as well as identify future recommendations, trends, and applications relevant to the application of spirituality and/or sustainability for success at both the individual and organizational level.
View
Workplace and Organizational Spirituality for Organizational Success
Chapter
  • Apr 2024
In line with the broad, interdisciplinary, and non-religious framework of the text, the business and organizational benefits of workplace spirituality from a secular perspective will be examined in this chapter. The characteristics and development of spiritual organizations, workplace spirituality programs, demonstrated benefits, and methods of implementation will also be explored. Moreover, the potential risks, challenges and controversies surrounding both spiritual organizations and workplace spirituality will be discussed. Spiritual intelligence is briefly examined because the development of organizational spiritual capabilities is an antecedent to the development of successful triple bottom line strategies. Finally, the Spiritual Incorporated Argument (SIA) is introduced as a method of providing intrinsic justification for the incorporation of spirituality into business management. Existing literature will be synthesized to demonstrate the benefits, and a case study to assist with practical application of workplace spirituality on a business/organizational level concludes the chapter.
View
A systematic literature review of spiritual leadership within African Management Philosophies
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2024
Orientation: Spiritual leadership has been proposed as an alternative to lead a generation where personal values and beliefs are central to employee contentment and organisational success. Research purpose: To critically analyse organisational spiritual leadership (SpL) from an African Management Philosophies (AMP) perspective and whether these are secular or nonsecular. Motivation for the study: Knowledge would be drawn from two bodies of scholarly literature, namely SpL and AMP. Research design, approach and method: Literature will be systematically reviewed, focusing on three aspects of the body on knowledge, namely concepts, definitions and typologies (elements). Main findings: The concept of SpL seems empirically much more operationalised than AMP. Central to organisational spiritual leadership are the leader’s values, attitudes and behaviours that intrinsically motivate followers to have a sense of spiritual survival through membership and calling, while AMP emphasise traditionalism, communalism, co-operative teamwork and mythologies. Practical/managerial implications: The research seeks to highlight the existing gaps in literature of a contextualised African measure of SpL. Contribution or value add: A secular and non-secular approach to spirituality emerges, which looks at AMP as emboldened by Ubuntu ideality that is contrary to extant literature on organisational spiritual leadership. Keywords: spiritual leadership; African management philosophies; leadership models, spiritual, spirituality, African, organisation, employee contentment
View
Mixed Methods Research Online:
Chapter
  • Jan 2015
Contributing to the ongoing debate in research on sensitive issues such as business ethics, this chapter provides a discussion of mixed methods research design, examining the processes and challenges of developing and deploying an online survey tool using technology within an interpretive mixed methods design. This chapter provides pointers on how to deploy this approach through technology to research business ethics using the example of researching ethical mindsets and its components, including spirituality and aesthetics. It is found that mixed methods research is an effective approach because it allows often sensitive issues (i.e. business ethics, aesthetics, spirituality) relating to questioning individuals’ inner values and ethical propensities, which are usually subtle and difficult to measure and analyze constructs. While this tool was developed in the Australian context, it has the potential to form a foundation for wider examination and research in business ethics. The chapter contributes to the collective discussion of research methods using a framework that has both practical relevance and theoretical rigor.
View
Computational Approach for Human Bioenergy Field Imaging and Analysis for Human Wellness
Article
  • Jul 2020
Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) researchers' committee stated a term called Biofield in 1994. The previous study shows the substantial evidence of its existence and its impact on the health and thought process of an individual. Due to the lack of its scientific documentation and examination, usage and belief of biofield in various domains are not very popular. The biofield is an extremely weak electromagnetic bio-information field, which is very hard to measure and visualize. It is a field of energy around every seen and unseen, living and non-living, holds a higher order of dynamic information within itself. CAM practitioners challenge that this bioenergy has mind-like properties reflecting ones' physiological thought process, inner qualities, wellness, organ coordination, and others. Due to its invisibility (through naked eyes) and weak strength, scientific measurements, analysis and belief of its existence is questionable. This research article highlights a method for the visualization, analysis, and medical benefits of biofield measurement. Current research also highlights the applications of biofield study in the future, i.e., and its further study will open up new gateways for investigation and bring remarkable changes in society.
View
Le retour de la spiritualité: De quelle manière la Responsabilité Sociale de l’Entreprise exprime-t-elle un retour hyper moderne du vieux concept de spiritualité au sein du milieu du travail ?
Article
  • May 2015
Back to spirituality supported by vector of corporate social responsibility Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is one of the major concerns of companies trying to enroll in a sustainable strategy. Indeed, several environmental, social and financial scandals legitimize the role of CSR in the fight against social dangerousness. Therefore, several studies have focused on organizational practices that lead employees to engage in CSR. However, only few studies have examined the effect of intrinsic dimension in individual social commitment. In this perspective, spirituality represents an intrinsic dimension that may influence the organizational behavior of employees. This paper is based on a qualitative exploratory study conducted in a one company that is engaged in CSR and relying on semi-structured interviews. These interviews show that spirituality accelerates socially responsible behavior, and leads to various other kinds of employee commitment to CSR. Finally it also appears that the spiritual approach differs generational membership.
View
View
View
View
Building theories from case study research
Article
  • Jan 2002
- This paper describes the process of inducting theory using case studies from specifying the research questions to reaching closure. Some features of the process, such as problem definition and construct validation, are similar to hypothesis-testing research. Others, such as within-case analysis and replication logic, are unique to the inductive, case-oriented process. Overall, the process described here is highly iterative and tightly linked to data. This research approach is especially appropriate in new topic areas. The resultant theory is often novel, testable, and empirically valid. Finally, framebreaking insights, the tests of good theory (e.g., parsimony, logical coherence), and convincing grounding in the evidence are the key criteria for evaluating this type of research.
View
View
View
In The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
Book
Scitation is the online home of leading journals and conference proceedings from AIP Publishing and AIP Member Societies
View
Past Postmodernism? Reflections and Tentative Directions
Article
  • Oct 1999
In this article we first reflect on the significant and positive impact of postmodernism for organizational theorizing during the past decade. Through several examples we point to contributions that poststructuralist perspectives have brought to the field. Finally, we consider four contemporary theoretical tendencies-feminist poststructuralist theorizing, postcolonial analyses, actor-network theory, and narrative approaches to knowledge-as heirs (apparent) of the postmodern turn for organizational theorizing past postmodernism.
View
Application of Complexity Theory to Organization Science
Article
  • Mar 1999
  • ORGAN SCI
This special issue originated with the 1996 Organization Science Winter Conference (OSWC), which set out to explore the implications of the science of complexity for the field of organization studies. Following the OSWC, a formal program organized by the Organization Science section of INFORMS took place in Atlanta. The vast potential for complexity theory to inform and transform research in organization studies became evident from the discussions of 22 papers that were presented at that meeting. In response to the call for papers issued after the Atlanta meeting, 56 papers were submitted to Organization Science, of which seven make up this issue. Interest in complexity has grown dramatically since the 1996 OSWC first explored this idea. The purpose of this special issue is not to declare that a new era in organization studies and strategic management is at hand, but to explore the boundaries and links between the science of complexity—with its origin in evolution and biology—and the field of strategy and organization. The issue explores the implications of complexity research for organization studies in the context of new ways of modeling dynamic, nonlinear complex systems for advancing theoretical and empirical research in organization studies (e.g., theorizing within coevolutionary frameworks, decomposition of nested phenomena, multidirectional causalities).
View
View