ArticlePDF Available

A Global Model of Climate Change Impacts on Timber Markets

Authors:
Roger Sedjo at Resources for the Future
Roger Sedjo
Brent Sohngen at The Ohio State University
Brent Sohngen
Robert Mendelsohn at Yale University
Robert Mendelsohn
Download full-text PDFDownload full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

Several papers have now estimated the impact of climate change on national timber markets, but few studies have measured impacts globally. Further, the literature on impacts has focused heavily on changes in productivity and has not integrated movements of biomes as well. Here, a dynamic model of ecological change and economic change is developed to capture the impact of climate change on world timber markets. Climate change is predicted to increase global timber production as producers in low-mid latitude forests react quickly with more productive short-rotation plantations, driving down timber prices. Producers in mid-high latitude forests, in contrast, are likely to be hurt by the lower prices, dieback, and slower productivity increases because of long-rotation species. Consumers in all regions benefit from the lower prices, and the overall impacts of climate change in timber markets are expected to be beneficial, increasing welfare in those markets from 2% to 8%.
Figures - uploaded by Robert Mendelsohn
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Robert Mendelsohn
Content may be subject to copyright.
YaleFES-000002
77.pdf
Content uploaded by Robert Mendelsohn
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Robert Mendelsohn
Content may be subject to copyright.
A Global Model of Climate Change Impacts on Timber Marke
ts.pdf
Available via license: CC BY-NC
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Finally, another model that can be classified under the tag of a FSM is the forward-looking dynamic Model of Global Timber Markets (Sohngen et al. 1999, Sohngen at al. 2001, also called Global Timber Model (Sohngen & Mendelsohn 2003), which is based on control theory. ...
The Colombian Forest Sector Model – An Analysis of Forest Plantation Policy in Colombia
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Jul 2023
An economic model for the Colombian forest sector (Colombian Forest Sector Model – CFSM) is developed and used to analyse Colombia´s commercial forest plantation policy covering the 2018 – 2038 horizon (PFCm policy). The CFSM is a structural partial equilibrium econometric model that forecasts quantities and prices for the Colombian forest product markets using the neoclassical theory of competitive markets. Phase I of the CFSM (CFSM-I), developed in detail in this dissertation, includes a simulator of growth and yield for the Colombian forest plantations and two market (sub)models: for Unprocessed Wood and for Manufactured Wood Products. Using the CFSM-I, two PFCm policy goals were simulated to unveil their impacts on the Colombian forest sector. Simulations of an expansion of Colombia’s forest plantation current area (0.3 million hectares, Mha, on Dec 2015) to 1.5 Mha by 2025 indicate that Colombia would increase the 2015-2047 volume available of industrial wood in plantations by 5 times (annually 20.8 million cubic meters of underbark roundwood, on average). In monetary values, this expansion would importantly impact the unprocessed wood market. Supply and exports of wood would multiply by 2.5 and 14.5 times in the next 25 years meanwhile its price of supply would drop by 24%, respectively, and on average, compared to the scenario of no expansion of the current plantations. Simulations of a 2023-2038 5.5-times expansion of the current (2022) production capacity of Colombia’s manufactured wood forest products industry show that on average in the next 25 years and compared to the no expansion scenario, consumption of unprocessed wood and manufactured wood products of the pulp and paper industry would increase by 8% each, and the imports of the latter and of manufactured products of the furniture industry would decrease by 35% and 25%, respectively. Alternative policies of plantation area expansion (0.45 Mha, 0.765 Mha, and 2.0 Mha under sustained rotation, and 0.3 Mha harvested without replanting) also simulated enrich the set of information for policy makers and other stakeholders in preparation for the first round of the PFCm policy evaluation, scheduled for 2023 after the completion of its first implementation period in December 2022.
View
... Many ecological models forecast repercussions that include more significant disturbances, including forest fires, insect infestations, changes in the distribution of various tree species, changes in species' growth rates, and droughts [1]. Such alterations would have significant ecological and economic repercussions, ranging from altered ecosystem-service flows to diminished economic value [2]. ...
A Cost Assessment of Tree Plantation Failure under Extreme Drought Events in France: What Role for Insurance?
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2023
Research Highlights: We analyze the costs of plantation failure and evaluate the distribution of replantation costs and risk sharing between the forestry company and the forest owner in France. Background and Objectives: Due to the lack of a clear definition of drought, forestry companies are increasingly considered as liable for plantation failure, increasing their costs and leading to financial instability. In this context, this paper aims to address the following questions. In the case of plantation failure, is it less costly to replant, not replant, or restart the whole plantation? What is the impact of changing the liability scheme between the company and the forest owner in terms of replantation costs and risk sharing? Materials and Methods: We performed a cost assessment of different itineraries of plantations as a function of different mortality rates. The breakdown of the replantation costs between the company and the forest owner was also investigated. Results: No replanting is the least expensive option for the forest owner, followed by replanting and then by starting the whole plantation anew. Reducing the company’s liability is an interesting option to reduce its exposure to risk. Conclusions: Modifications of the company’s liability allows for the inclusion of private insurance contracts against plantation failure.
View
... The change in forestry consumer and producer surplus (as a share of total income) Economic damages estimated as the average of the estimates by Perez-Garcia et al. (1995) and Sohngen et al. (2001). ...
Accounting for Biodiversity Costs from Climate Change in Integrated Assessment Models
Article
  • Jan 2023
Climate change will have a major negative impact on global biodiversity. Our review of integrated assessment models (IAMs) show that biodiversity damage costs are not included or incompletely captured. We provide improved damage cost estimates of species loss based on (i) a recent global biophysical assessment of impacts on species, (ii) transfer of economic values from a global Delphi contingent valuation study of households’ willingness-to-pay, and (iii) benefit transfer techniques. The new damage cost estimates are implemented in FUND 3.9. The numerical simulations suggest that both the expected physical global species loss and the associated damage costs are higher than initially predicted. Hence, IAMs with incomplete assessment and valuation of species loss could greatly underestimate the social cost of carbon, and lead to underinvestment in greenhouse gas mitigation measures. Even if the knowledge is incomplete, IAMs should include nonmarket environmental damage costs scenarios to better inform climate policy designs.
View
... Therefore, revealing the internal relationship between climate change and vegetation productivity in the Altay Mountains has important practical significance for improving the quality and productivity of forest land in the Altay Mountains, improving the management level of forest land, and promoting the healthy development of forest land [15,16]. Due to the close relationship between forests and climate, climate change will inevitably have a certain impact on forests [17][18][19]. ...
Dynamics of Vegetation Productivity in Relation to Surface Meteorological Factors in the Altay Mountains in Northwest China
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2022
Vegetation productivity, as the basis of the material cycle and energy flow in an ecosystem, directly reflects the information of vegetation change. At the ecosystem level, the gross primary productivity (GPP) refers to the amount of organic carbon fixed by plant bodies. How to accurately estimate the spatiotemporal variation of vegetation productivity of the forest ecosystem in the Altay Mountains in northwest China has become a critical issue to be addressed. The Altay Mountains, with rich forest resources, are located in a semi-arid climate zone and are sensitive to global climate changes, which will inevitably have serious impacts on the function and structure of forest ecosystems in northwest China. In this paper, to reveal the variation trends of vegetation gross primary productivity (GPP) and its response to surface meteorological factors in the Altay Mountains in northwest China, daily temperature and precipitation data from the period of 2000–2017 were collected from seven meteorological stations in Altay prefecture and its surrounding areas; the data were analyzed by using the MODIS GPP model, moving average trend analysis, linear regression analysis and the climate tendency rate method. The results show that: (1) The spatial distribution pattern of GPP in the whole year was almost the same as that in the growing season of vegetation in the Altay Mountains. In the whole mountain range, the proportion of the area which had a GPP value of 400–600 g c/m2 had the highest value; the proportion of the annual and growing season of this area was 41.10% and 40.88%, respectively, which was mainly distributed in the middle and west alpine areas of the Altay Mountains. (2) There was a big gap in the GPP value in the different stages of the vegetation growing season (April to September), which reached the highest value in July, the area with a GPP of 100–150 g c/m2 was the highest, with 36.15%. (3) The GPP of the Altay Mountains showed an overall increasing trend, but the annual fluctuation was relatively large. In 2003, 2008, 2009 and 2014, the GPP showed lower values, which were 385.18 g c/m2, 384.90 g c/m2, 384.49 g c/m2 and 393.10 g c/m2, respectively. In 2007, 2011 and 2016, the GPP showed higher values, which were 428.49 g c/m2, 428.18 g c/m2 and 446.61 g c/m2. (4) In 64.85% of the area of the Altay Mountains, the GPP was positively correlated with annual average temperature, and in 36.56% of the area, the correlation coefficient between temperature and GPP ranged from −0.2 to 0. In 71.61% of the area of the Altay Mountains, the GPP was positively correlated with annual accumulated precipitation, and in 28.39% of the area, the GPP was negatively correlated with annual accumulated precipitation. Under the scenario of global climate change, our study has quantitatively analyzed the long-term dynamics of vegetation GPP and its responses to meteorological factors in the Altay Mountains, which would be helpful for evaluating and estimating the variation trends of forest ecosystems in China, and has important guiding significance for policy formulation to protect forest resources and improve the local ecological environment.
View
Weather variability risks slow climate adaptation: An empirical analysis of forestry
Article
Full-text available
  • May 2024
  • J ENVIRON ECON MANAG
The timing of climate adaptation decisions can have substantial consequences for the assessment of climate damages. Since weather variability can create risks for natural resource management that differ across adaptation choices, such variability has the potential to alter the speed of climate adaptation. This paper estimates the effect of weather variability on the timing of adaptation decisions of forest landowners in the Eastern United States. A discrete-choice econometric model of forest management is estimated and used in a bio-economic simulation that shows how variability in cold temperatures can significantly slow the rate of adapting from cold-tolerant natural hardwood forests to cold-sensitive, but highly valuable pine plantations. The range of weather variability in climate projections and across the landscape generates large differences in adaptation timing. Ignoring projected future decreases in weather variability results in a large downward bias in estimating future paths of climate adaptation. Since pine plantations produce fewer non-market ecosystem services than natural hardwood forests, an important source of future conservation uncertainty is the economic response of private forest landowners to changing weather variability.
View
Climate Change and Wood Production
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2024
In this article, we investigate the direct (i.e. natural disasters) and indirect (i.e. temperature change) impact of climate change on wood production. To do so, we use wood production data from 166 countries over the period 1995-2020. Our results show that the wood production is sensitive to climate change. While temperature change reduces wood production by 4.1%, an increase in the number of natural disasters leads to an increase in wood production of around 1.1%. We also observe that following a natural disaster, industrial and energy wood production increases by 1.9% and 0.9% respectively. Similarly, products from both stages of wood processing, such as paper, cardboard, and pulp, also benefit from this increase in production. Furthermore, we find that wood production’s exposure to climate change varies according to industry characteristics, location, and type of natural disasters.
View
"Climate Change & NTFP- livelihood implications for the tribal" A project supported by the
Book
Full-text available
  • Aug 2015
Likewise other tribal areas, the community in Kanker, Hazaribagh and Koraput have also been facing challenges emerged due to climate variability and change. While rainfed agriculture in small and marginal land is the main livelihood practice, the NTFPs provides subsistent food, nutrition and income security round the year. The fluctuation in rainfall pattern over the year and during monsoon season, higher summer temperature and long dry period are impacting the livelihood resources, hence the food security. Any agricultural stress leads to over exploitation of NTFPs for the forest. The study records the availability of nearly 30 NTFPs from the study area. The tribal of Kanker and Hazaribagh collects good quantity of MFPs namely, tendupatta, mahua, ber, harar, bamboo, sal seed, lac, tamarind etc. The tribals of Koraput collect wild mango tubers, siali leaves, mushroom and broom grass in large quantity.
View
View
Mitigation of greenhouse gases
Chapter
  • Oct 2007
Bringing together many of the world's leading experts, this volume is a comprehensive, state-of-the-art review of climate change science, impacts, mitigation, adaptation, and policy. It provides an integrated assessment of research on the key topics that underlie current controversial policy questions. The first part of the book addresses recent topics and findings related to the physical-biological earth system. The next part of the book surveys estimates of the impacts of climate change for different sectors and regions. The third part examines current topics related to mitigation of greenhouse gases and explores the potential roles of various technological options. The last part focuses on policy design under uncertainty. Dealing with the scientific, economic and policy questions at the forefront of the climate change issue, this book will be invaluable for graduate students, researchers and policymakers interested in all aspects of climate change and the issues that surround it.
View
Impacts and adaptation
Chapter
  • Oct 2007
Bringing together many of the world's leading experts, this volume is a comprehensive, state-of-the-art review of climate change science, impacts, mitigation, adaptation, and policy. It provides an integrated assessment of research on the key topics that underlie current controversial policy questions. The first part of the book addresses recent topics and findings related to the physical-biological earth system. The next part of the book surveys estimates of the impacts of climate change for different sectors and regions. The third part examines current topics related to mitigation of greenhouse gases and explores the potential roles of various technological options. The last part focuses on policy design under uncertainty. Dealing with the scientific, economic and policy questions at the forefront of the climate change issue, this book will be invaluable for graduate students, researchers and policymakers interested in all aspects of climate change and the issues that surround it.
View
View
View
A Case Study of the Effects of CO2-Induced Climatic Warming on Forest Growth and the Forest Sector: B. Economic Effects on the World’s Forest Sector
Article
  • Jan 1988
This section quantifies some of the economic effects of productivity changes using an economic model of the global forest sector. The model projects production, consumption, prices and trade of 16 forest products in 18 regions which comprise the globe. Ecological effects associated with changes of climate enter the model through the forest growth and timber supply components. The model computes partial market equilibrium solutions for each of the ten 5-year periods covering 1980 to 2030, the latter date assumed to be the date at which double CO2 levels are reached. The absolute values of the results are highly speculative, however, three results seem fairly robust: 1) The primary benefits of the increased supply will accrue to the consumers of forest products. 2) While some producers, both in the directly affected regions as well as in other regions, are likely to benefit from the increased timber supply, others in directly affected regions where the increase in supply is small may actually be hurt by climate warming. 3) Climate warming imposes significant costs on regions where productive capacity is currently marginal and where large investments have been made to grow trees. -from Editors
View
Forest Sector Impacts from Changes in Forest Productivity Under Climate Change
Article
  • Jul 1995
The consequences of elevated carbon dioxide and climate change on forest systems and the role that economics could play in timber harvest and vegetation change have not been addressed together. A framework was developed to link climate change scenarios, an ecosystem model, a forest sector model and a carbon accounting model. Four climate scenarios were used to estimate net primary productivity (NPP) for forests in the United States. Changes in NPP were estimated using TEM, the Terrestrial Ecosystem Model which uses spatially referenced information on climate, soils and vegetation so estimate important carbon and nitrogen fluxes and pool sizes within ecosystems at the continental scale. Changes in NPP under climate change were used to modify timber growth within the Aggregate Timberland Assessment Model (ATLAS), which is a part of the forest sector model (TAMM-ATLAS) used by the Forest Service to examine timber policy questions. The changes in timber inventories were then translated into changes in the amount of carbon stored on private timberlands using a national carbon model (FORCARB). Regional changes in productivity filter through the forest sector and result in changes in land use and timber consumption. Long-term changes in carbon storage indicate that these private timberlands will be a source of carbon dioxide for all but the most optimistic climate change scenario.
View
The Science of Climate Change
Article
  • Jun 1996
Climate Change 1995--The Science of Climate Change is the most comprehensive assessment available of current scientific understanding of human influences on past, present and future climate. Prepared under the auspices of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), each chapter is written by teams of lead authors and contributors recognized internationally as leading experts in their field. Climate Change 1995 is the first full sequel to the original 1990 IPCC scientific assessment, bringing us completely up to date on the full range of scientific aspects of climate change. This assessment forms the standard scientific reference for all those concerned with climate change and its consequences, including policy makers in governments and industry worldwide, and researchers and senior-level students in environmental science, meteorology, climatology, biology, ecology and atmospheric chemistry.
View
BIOME3: An equilibrium terrestrial biosphere model based on ecophysiological constraints, resource availability, and competition among plant functional types
Article
  • Dec 1996
The equilibrium terrestrial biosphere model BIOME3 simulates vegetation distribution and biogeochemistry, and couples vegetation distribution directly to biogeochemistry. Model inputs consist of latitude, soil texture class, and monthly climate (temperature, precipitation, and sunshine) data on a 0.5° grid. Ecophysiological constraints determine which plant functional types (PFTs) may potentially occur. A coupled carbon and water flux model is then used to calculate, for each PFT, the leaf area index (LAI) that maximizes net primary production (NPP), subject to the constraint that NPP must be sufficient to maintain this LAI. Competition between PFTs is simulated by using the optimal NPP of each PFT as an index of competitiveness, with additional rules to approximate the dynamic equilibrium between natural disturbance and succession driven by light competition. Model output consists of a quantitative vegetation state description in terms of the dominant PFT, secondary PFTs present, and the total LAI and NPP for the ecosystem. Canopy conductance is treated as a function of the calculated optimal photosynthetic rate and water stress. Regional evapotranspiration is calculated as a function of canopy conductance, equilibrium evapotranspiration rate, and soil moisture using a simple planetary boundary layer parameterization. This scheme results in a two-way coupling of the carbon and water fluxes through canopy conductance, allowing simulation of the response of photosynthesis, stomatal conductance, and leaf area to environmental factors including atmospheric CO2. Comparison with the mapped distribution of global vegetation shows that the model successfully reproduces the broad-scale patterns in potential natural vegetation distribution. Comparison with NPP measurements, and with an FPAR (fractional absorbed photosynthetically active radiation) climatology based on remotely sensed greenness measurements, provides further checks on the model's internal logic. The model is envisaged as a tool for integrated analysis of the impacts of changes in climate and CO2 on ecosystem structure and function.
View
Reflections on Volatile Substance Dependency Treatment
Article
  • Apr 1999
  • J SUBST ABUSE TREAT
A brief review of the causal and treatment literature relating to volatile substance dependency suggests the interaction between individual and system requires careful attention and understanding. A model is tentatively and provisionally adumbrated to help clarify the main factors involved from a dynamic biopsychosocial perspective. Ego boundary disturbances emerge from and reciprocally influence behaviour and social interactions. These disturbances can be avoided temporarily, although inevitably deepened in the long-term, by substance dependence. Two case examples, selected because they differ in many respects, including relative treatment effectiveness, illustrate this integrative perspective. The discussion focuses on explaining the differing outcomes in terms of the extent to which the inner-outer boundary is open to modification and how far it can be successfully negotiated and clarified. A major factor in differentiating between inside and outside is thought to be causal perceptions or “attributions.” Successful differentiation tends to facilitate change, as opposed to reinforcing maladaptive homeostasis. Key issues for therapists overlap with addictions treatment in general, including emotional blocks or barriers in patients, difficulty engaging systems in a strategic manner, and countertransference problems. It is argued that these difficulties in therapy might respond to integrative psychotherapeutic responses, provided the differences in perspective are sufficiently understood.
View
Transient Response of Forests to CO2-Induced Climate Change: Simulation Modeling Experiments in Eastern North America
Article
  • Mar 1986
  • OECOLOGIA
The temporal response of forests to CO2-induced climate changes was examined for eastern North America. A forest stand simulation model was used with the assumption that climate will change at a constant rate as atmospheric CO2 doubles, and then as CO2 doubles again. Before being used to project future vegetation trends, the simulation model FORENA was verified by its ability to reproduce long, temporal sequences of plant community change recorded by fossil pollen and by its ability to reproduce today's vegetation. The simulated effects of changing monthly temperature and precipitation included a distinctive dieback of extant trees at most locations, with only partial recovery of biomass in areas of today's temperate deciduous forest. In the southern portion of today's deciduous-coniferous transition forests the simulated dieback was indistinct and recovery by deciduous tree species was rapid. In more northerly transition areas, the dieback not only was clearly expressed, but occurred twice, when new dominant species replaced extant conifers, then were themselves replaced, as climate change continued. Boreal conifers also underwent diebacks and were replaced by deciduous hardwoods more slowly in the north than in the south. Transient responses in species composition and carbon storage continued as much as 300 years after simulated climate changes ceased.
View
Emanuel WR, Shugart HH, and Stevenson MP. Climate change and the broad-scale distribution of terrestrial ecosystem complexes. Climatic Change
Article
  • Mar 1985
  • CLIMATIC CHANGE
The broad-scale distribution of terrestrial ecosystem complexes is determined in large part by climate and can be altered by climatic change due to natural causes or due to human activities such as those leading to increasing atmospheric CO2 concentration. Classifications that recognize the dependence of natural vegetation on climate provide one means of constructing maps to display the impact of climatic change on the geography of major vegetation zones. A world map of the Holdridge Life-Zone Classification, developed from approximately 8,000 meteorological records, is compared with a Holdridge Map with average temperature increments simulated by a. model of climate under elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration. The largest changes are indicated at high latitudes, where the simulated temperature increase is largest and the temperature intervals defining life zones are smallest. Boreal Forest Zones are replaced by either Cool Temperate Forest or Cool Temperate Steppe, depending on average precipitation. Changes in the tropics are smaller; however, in some regions, Subtropical Moist Forest is replaced by Tropical Dry Forest.
View
A global perspective of regional vegetation and hydrologic sensitivities from climatic change
Article
  • Oct 1994
  • J VEG SCI
. A biogeographic model, MAPSS (Mapped Atmosphere-Plant-Soil System), predicts changes in vegetation leaf area index (LAI), site water balance and runoff, as well as changes in biome boundaries. Potential scenarios of global and regional equilibrium changes in LAI and terrestrial water balance under 2 x CO2 climate from five different general circulation models (GCMs) are presented. Regional patterns of vegetation change and annual runoff are surprisingly consistent among the five GCM scenarios, given the general lack of consistency in predicted changes in regional precipitation patterns. Two factors contribute to the consistency among the GCMs of the regional ecological impacts of climatic change: (1) regional, temperature-induced increases in potential evapo-transpiration (PET) tend to more than offset regional increases in precipitation; and (2) the interplay between the general circulation and the continental margins and mountain ranges produces a fairly stable pattern of regionally specific sensitivity to climatic change. Two areas exhibiting among the greatest sensitivity to drought-induced forest decline are eastern North America and eastern Europe to western Russia. Regional runoff patterns exhibit much greater spatial variation in the sign of the response than do the LAI changes, even though they are deterministically linked in the model. Uncertainties with respect to PET or vegetation water use efficiency calculations can alter the simulated sign of regional responses, but the relative responses of adjacent regions appear to be largely a function of the background climate, rather than the vagaries of the GCMs, and are intrinsic to the landscape. Thus, spatial uncertainty maps can be drawn even under the current generation of GCMs.
View