ArticlePublisher preview available

The adaptive pattern of families with a leukemic child

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Studied 10 families with leukemic children (aged 4 yrs 7 mo to 13 yrs 4 mo) by means of semistructured interviews to evaluate their family structure and, thus, propose clear psychotherapeutic goals. All families had a similar pattern of organization, including tendency to enmeshment and the inclusion of the ill child within the parental subsystem and consequently his/her elimination from the sibling subsystem. There was also an alteration in the familial capacity to express in a clear and direct form the feelings and fears of each member, which represented an important limitation in the mechanisms used for the solution of their conflicts. It is possible that this pattern might be present in any other type of family in which there exists disease that represents a serious threat to a child's life. The rigidity in this adaptive pattern seems to depend on the type of familial structure present before the illness. Psychotherapeutic goals should be directed toward the avoidance of the rigidity in the adaptive pattern. (5 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
The Adaptive Pattern of Families
With a Leukemic Child
Maria Luisa Velasco de Parr a, Ph.D.,
Sandra Ddvila de Cortazar, Psyc,
and Gilberto Covarrubias-Espinoza, M.D.
Ten families with leukemic children (six boys and four girls) were studied
by means of semi-structured interviews in order to evaluate their family
structure and, thus, propose clear psychotherapeutic goals. All families had
a similar pattern of organization including: a) tendency to enmeshment;
b) the inclusion of the ill child within the parental subsystem and con-
sequently his elimination from the sibling subsystem; c) a rigid alliance
between the mother and the leukemic child associated to the peripheral
position of the father and siblings; d) tendency to include the maternal
grandmother and/or a parental daughter within the parental subsystem.
Besides, there was an alteration in the familial capacity to express in a clear
and direct form the feelings and fears of each member, which represented
an important limitation in the mechanisms used for the solution of their
conflicts. It is possible that this pattern might be present in any other type
of family in which there exists a disease which represents a serious threat
to a child's life. The rigidity in this adaptive pattern seems to depend on
the type of familial structure present before the illness.
A family with a child with leukemia has to face basically three problems: a) the
fear and sadness secondary to the suffering and the possibility of death of the child;
b) the family's limited possibilities for satisfying all of the patient's needs; and c) the
guilty feelings caused in each member of the family in connection with the disease (1).
Since the affected child demands a great deal of attention, his or her mother places
her duties in relation to the rest of the family members on a rather secondary level.
As a consequence, a rigid mother-child alliance is established which interferes with
her spouse role and the father, in turn, adopts a rigid attitude, becomes careless, and
remains isolated from his wife. Inasmuch as their life as a couple is completely blocked,
they find it difficult to communicate their real feelings to one another (4). On the other
Maria Luisa Velasco de Parra, Ph.D., is at the Department of Psychiatry, Hospital Infantil de Mexico.
Sandra Davila de Cortazar, Psyc, is a member of
the
faculty of the Universidad de las Americas. Gilberto
Covarrubias-Espinoza, M.D., is at the Department of Oncology, Hospital Infantil de Mexico.
The authors are indebted to Dr. Adalberto Parra and Mrs. Susan Dick for their correction of the
manuscript and to Ms. Esperanza Cardenas for her secretarial assistance.
30
... Specific aspects of the interpersonal context require keen attention. The family's unique cultural and religious beliefs and attitudes may play a prominent role in the illness and treatment process (32). In addition, structural and functional aspects of the family (22) may either promote or constrain the child's pursuit of mastery. ...
Article
Full-text available
Describes a protocol for pediatric health care teams to respond efficiently to children with severe psychosocial symptoms, and to their families. The orienting ideas of the protocol include loss of mastery as the heart of psychosocial symptoms shown by seriously ill children, the requirement of motivation to cope effectively, futility of controlling the naturally occurring emotions that are the facets of illness, and importance of supportive relationships. Six steps for constructing solutions are offered: conducting a developmentally focused comprehensive assessment; problem definitions that include the ill child, parents and members of the health care team; problem definitions to generate creative strategies; developing creative strategies; building collaborative relationships; and focusing on competence. This protocol offers the pediatric team a lifeline for working safely and effectively under stressful circumstances. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
... Although the majority of children with cancer in the United States are Caucasian, the literature has neglected cultural and racial differences in coping and adaptation. Studies of Black and Hispanic families with children with cancer show potentially adaptive patterns (i.e., extreme closeness, mother-child alliances) that differ from those usually associated with positive adjustment (Baskin, Forehand, & Saylor, 1985;de Parra, de Cortazar, & Covarrubias-Espinoza, 1983). Anglo and Hispanic children with cancer were found to have similar amounts of procedure-related pain and showed similar behavioral responses to pain, although parental responses to the child's distress differed (Pfefferbaum, Adams, & Aceves, 1990). ...
Article
Full-text available
Discusses select research articles on adjustment to childhood cancer and organizes them within a social ecological framework, including consideration of social systems larger than the family. Using childhood cancers as an example, family research agendas relevant to cancer and other childhood chronic diseases are presented. Research questions including the ill child, siblings, parents, families, social support networks, education and health care systems, and policy and societal attitudes are organized. Recommendations for research are suggested and the importance of considering normalcy, family development, and methodology in research on ill children and their families are also discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
... The closeness and the special feelings that develop between the parents and the ill teenagers serve as a coping mechanism rather than as a coalition that is dysfunctional. Mental-health professionals may view such structural changes (12,13,16,17) and bonds that develop in response to the illness (2, 7) as pathological and may try to change them, but that may not be in the best interest of the clients. It is important for professionals working with families that have a chronically ill individual to be careful to respect their clients' experiences and learn from them. ...
Article
Full-text available
Interviewed 5 families in a phenomenological study of the impact of thalassemia, a serious hereditary blood disease, on the life of the affected teenager and the parents. Six adolescents (aged 14–19 yrs) and their family members were interviewed separately for a maximum of 1 hr each. Ss shared their views on the impact of the illness on their everyday lives, their relationships with each other, relationships with friends, and their perception of themselves and the future. Coping and adaptive processes are identified, including suppression, anticipation, sublimation, humor, and hope. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
... From the moment the diagnosis of oncological disease is made, family defense mechanisms are activated in a desperate attempt to circumscribe or encapsulate this foreign body in the hope of neutralizing it (1,2,9,14,21). The family polarizes in a search for ways of reinforcing its defense cordon, and risks changing its principal objective from living to surviving (16). ...
Article
Full-text available
Investigated 15 families with children suffering from oncological disease who were in the process of recovery. The organization of family defense mechanisms was examined at the moment of diagnosis, during the long medical treatment, and during the gradual destructuring of these adaptive mechanisms in the recovery process. To formulate both the organization and the destructuring of these mechanisms, the alteration of the time-space parameters that define a family is taken into account to identify the various transformational processes that first led toward rigidity in relational patterns and the possible onset of psychiatric symptoms in the individual, and then toward flexibility and the normal resumption of the life cycle. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Chapter
The complex interactions in patients’ family systems, and in the therapeutic system that includes the family and the clinician, have been extensively described and analyzed in the literature (1–9). Less attention has been devoted to How issues related to the clinician’s nuclear family (10,11) and family of origin (12–14) influence health care and medical education. As the sketch on page 194 shows, every clinical interaction involves the family backgrounds of the clinician and the patient, even though both parties are seldom aware of these dynamics.
Article
Full-text available
Objectives: A systematic review was conducted to (1) investigate family resilience in the context of pediatric cancer, and (2) examine theoretical, methodological, and statistical issues in this literature. Family resilience was operationalized as competent family functioning after exposure to a significant risk. METHODS: Following guidelines for systematic reviews, searches were performed using Web of Science, Pubmed, Cochrane, PsycInfo, and Embase. After screening 5,563 articles, 85 fulfilled inclusion criteria and were extracted for review. RESULTS: Findings indicated that most families are resilient, adapting well to the crisis of cancer diagnosis. However, a subset still experiences difficulties. Methodological issues in the current literature hamper strong nuanced conclusions. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest future research with a greater focus on family resilience and factors predicting it, based on available theory, and conducted with attention toward unit of measurement and use of appropriate statistical analyses. Improvements in research are needed to best inform family-based clinical efforts.
Article
The Leukaemia Foundation of Queensland, in collaboration with the Queensland University of Technology's Centre for Public Health Research, has recently undertaken the exciting initiative of establishing a permanent Australian infrastructure for psychosocial research on leukaemia and associated haematological disorders. The description of this program will be set in the context of an understanding of the dearth of psychosocial material accessible on these diagnostic groups. A summary of the psyehosoeial research that is available on leukaemia will be presented as a reference point for medical social work practitioners who have an interest in this area. The indications are that patients and their families from these diagnostic groups are vulnerable to the stress of extraordinary demands from both the disease and the therapeutic regimens developed to treat it.
Article
Full-text available
Presents a case study in which a physician–therapist team applied a family approach to the assessment of a 42-yr-old female with Huntington's disease. The S's behavior (violent flailing) disturbed and angered the nursing home staff; the S's children (2 females aged 12 and 14 yrs) became more and more depressed and withdrawn each time they visited their mother. The case illustrates the value of a family orientation in understanding the dynamics that can occur with genetically linked chronic illness. (16 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
This article examines and clarifies controversies about the concept of illness in the field of family therapy. We contend that illness, as traditionally understood in all cultures, is a relational, transactional concept that is highly congruent with core principles of present-day family theories. Family therapists need not buy into a biotechnical, reductionistic reframing of illness as disease. Rather, it is more appropriate to conceptualize and work with illness as a narrative placed in a biopsychosocial context. Such a narrative includes how shared responsibility for coping and for finding solutions can take place, without becoming involved in disputes about causal models.
Article
This experimental study compared the effectiveness of behavior therapy with client-centered therapy when these approaches were used in a treatment program designed to reduce overprotection as a coping behavior in parents of leukemic children.The methodology involved using these two treatment modalities with a population of 16 subjects who were matched and randomly assigned to two groups. Prior to initiating any therapy, baseline data were collected for 14 consecutive days. Each parent was then seen individually for eight 30-min sessions during regular clinic visits. These were followed by another 14-day period of data collection, and the data before and after treatment were compared to determine if there was a significant difference in the behavioral changes occuring within the two groups.The statistical analysis of these data demonstrated that the difference between the groups was insignificant. However, evaluation forms completed by the parents of both treatment groups did indicate some significant differences. The parents who experienced the behavioral intervention were better able to conceptualize the problems their families were coping with, and they could define in more specific terms than the parents in the client-centered group, the benefits they received by participating in the study.
The psychosocial adjustment of siblings of children with chronic illness
  • V V Lavigne
  • M Ryan
Lavigne, V. V., & Ryan, M. The psychosocial adjustment of siblings of children with chronic illness. Pediatrics, 1979, 63, 616-627.
Communication patterns in families dealing with life-threatening illness
  • J J Spinetta
Spinetta, J. J. Communication patterns in families dealing with life-threatening illness. In O. J. Sahler (Ed.), The child and death. St. Louis, MO: C. V. Mosby, 1978.