Content uploaded by Lawrence Leung
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Lawrence Leung on Aug 29, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
BMJ Case Reports 2011; doi:10.1136/bcr.07.2011.4492 1 of 4
BACKGROUND
Painless soft tissue masses on the scalp are commonly
encountered in clinical practice. The most likely diag-
noses still remain as epidermoid cysts, sebaceous cysts and
benign lipomas. However, clinicians should be cognisant
of other possible, though uncommon, pathologies as dif-
ferential diagnoses. We hereby present a case of soft scalp
mass which was mis-diagnosed as benign lipoma until
clarifi ed by histological confi rmation to be trichilemmal
cyst, a relatively common condition known to carry prolif-
erative and malignant potential in rare cases.
CASE PRESENTATION
A 56-year-old patient with learning disability presented
with a lump at top of his head. Due to problems in com-
munication, history was obtained from his mother who
had been living together with the patient since his birth.
The lump appeared when patient was in his late teens, and
had never been painful, infected or bled. It remained the
size of a cherry and it had increased in size in the last 6
months. Patient was unaware of the lump until someone
commented on it. Despite repeated assurance from his
mother, patient became nervous with frequent agitation,
thinking that it is a punishment from God and he would
soon meet his demise. He had no history of trauma or
developmental defect to his head and he takes losartan
and hydrochlorothiazide for his hypertension. He had no
personal or family history of solid tumours. On examina-
tion, there is a solitary 4×4 cm spherical mass arising from
the vertex of his skull. The mass is soft and fl uctuant and
partially trans-illuminable. The surface consisted of normal
looking skin of the near-alopecic scalp with no discoloura-
tion, cicatration or punctum. The mass was non-pulsatile
and non-tender on palpation ( fi gure 1 ). A provisional diag-
nosis of lipoma was made and when the benign nature of
the lesion was explained to the patient; his mother elected
to observe the lesion. Two weeks later, patient returned
in an extremely distressed state and pleaded for an opera-
tion to prevent ‘his brains from sticking out’. In view of
the patient’s inability to comprehend the situation, it was
decided that the mass be removed in the best interests of
the patient. The patient was offered the choice between
Reminder of important clinical lesson
Differential diagnosis of soft scalp lumps
Lawrence K Leung
Department of Family Medicine, Queen’s University, Kingston, Canada
Correspondence to Dr Lawrence K Leung, leungl@queensu.ca
Summary
A 56-year-old man presented with a painless cyst on the top of his head which has been increasing in size in the last 6 months. Due to his
learning disability, he could not be dissuaded from his belief that the lump was a sign of brain prolapse which led to increasing agitation in the
next 2 weeks. A provisional diagnosis of benign lipoma was made and prompt excision was performed in his best interests. The lesion was
more cystic and fl uctuant than that of a lipoma and hence it was sent for histological diagnosis. The report came back as a trichilemmal cyst
with no signs of proliferation. Cosmetic outcome was reasonable at follow-up after 3 months. The patient was scheduled for regular review
every 6 months.
Figure 1 Soft fl uctuant cystis mass measuring 4×4 cm arising
from the vertex of the scalp.
Figure 2 Elliptical excision of skin marked out to facilitate better
wound closure.
BMJ Case Reports 2011; doi:10.1136/bcr.07.2011.4492
2 of 4
a plastic surgery procedure (guaranteed cosmesis), or an
offi ce procedure (possible cicatration). Due to the long
waiting time (up to 12 months) for plastics referral, patient
opted for the latter.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Differential diagnosis of trichilemmal cysts includes epi-
dermoid cysts, benign lipomas, spindle cell lipoma, hiber-
nomas and liposcarcoma. Epidermoid cysts broadly refer
to cystic lesions that rise from invagination of the epi-
dermis into deeper layers either accidentally or iatrogeni-
cally, as a complication of hair transplantation.
1 Though
considered benign and slow-growing, epidermoid cysts
of the scalp are known to be associated with perforation
of the skull
2 and even the dura and the brain.
3 Sebaceous
cysts arise from cystic dilatation of the secretory glands
of the hair follicles and in fact should be distinct from
epidermoid cysts. However, in our medical literature,
epidermoid cysts are often used synonymously and inter-
changeably with sebaceous cysts. Due to the semisolid
contents, both epidermoid cysts and sebaceous cysts are
often fi rmer to touch and less spherical in shape then
truly fl uid fi lled cysts. Due to the intrinsic anatomy of
the scalp and face, benign lipomas are relatively uncom-
mon with a case prevalence of 2%–14%.
4 They are usu-
ally slow-growing and often ellipsoid rather than round
on the scalp. Spindle cell lipoma is a variant of common
lipomas which consists of signifi cant fi brous tissue com-
posing of spindle cells among the mature adipocytes.
5
Most spindle cell lipomas are under 5 cm in diameter but
can exceed 40 cm.
6 Hibernomas are rare tumours thought
to arise from the developmental remnants of brown
adipose tissues. They often present as non-tender slow-
growing masses with increased localised temperature.
7
Hibernomas can grow to sizes of 5–10 cm in diameters
with a preferred site at the thighs, interscapular area, the
neck and the scalp.
8
9 Although rare, liposarcomas of the
scalp have been reported which were mostly the myxoid
subtypes.
10
11 They can mimic infected benign sebaceous
cysts with their rapid growth and possible tissue necrosis.
Diagnosis with fi ne-needle aspiration or local biopsy is
known to be diffi cult as well-differentiated liposarcomas
may look similar to benign lipomas.
12
13
TREATMENT
The lesion was infi ltrated with 2% lidocaine containing
1:10 000 norepinephrine. Due to ballooning effect of the
lesion, an elliptical strip of skin was excised as the cyst was
removed en bloc ( fi gures 2 and 3 ). There was moderate
tethering of the base to the underlying fascia which upon
separation, led to profuse bleeding initially. Using elec-
trodessication from a hyfrecator and subsequent prompt
suturing, adequate haemostasis was eventually achieved.
There was moderate tissue and cutaneous swelling when
the suture was complete ( fi gure 4 ). The wound was given
a light dressing, and patient was observed in the waiting
room for an hour before being sent home.
OUTCOME AND FOLLOW-UP
Sutures were removed after 10 days with satisfactory heal-
ing of the wound. When reviewed after 3 months, there
was mild degree of cicatration at the site of excision ( fi gure
5 ). Nevertheless, patient was not concerned by the cos-
metic effects and repeatedly expressed gratitude to us for
‘putting his brains back in’! Given the cystic nature of the
lesion and the obvious lack of lobulation in appearance, the
author queried the diagnosis of lipoma, hence the lesion
was sent off for histology. Indeed, histology report con-
fi rmed the diagnosis of trichilemmal cyst with no signs of
active cell proliferation. In view of the low risks of malig-
nancy for this patient, no further action was considered
necessary. Patient was scheduled for routine review every
6-months thereafter.
DISCUSSION
Trichilemmal (pilar) cysts and the commoner epidermoid
(sebaceous) cysts are the two types of cutaneous cysts
found in the hair bearing area that arise from different parts
of the hair follicle unit, with a prevalence ratio of 1:4.
14 In
earlier days, all cutaneous cysts were erroneously referred
to as sebaceous cysts until Pinkus
15 pointed out in 1969 that
trichilemmal cysts arise from the outer root sheath of the
isthmus of the follicle, whereas sebaceous cysts arise from
the follicular infundibulum and hence are distinct entities.
Trichilemmal cysts usually occur in the hair bearing areas
with a predisposition for the scalp, neck, trunk and gluteal
Figure 3 Cystic mass removed en bloc with the ellipse of skin. Figure 4 Wound closed with adequate haemostasis albeit
moderate degree of cutaneous oedema.
BMJ Case Reports 2011; doi:10.1136/bcr.07.2011.4492 3 of 4
region. They have a female dominance and with an age
preponderance of over 60 years
16 and occasionally reached
extreme sizes of over 8 cm in diameter.
17
18 Trichilemmal
cysts are usually solitary lesions and can increase in size
over time. They may partially rupture leading to low-grade
infl ammation due to the cystic contents. Though rare, pro-
liferative forms of trichilemmal cysts have been reported
which mimic squamous cell carcinomas histologically
19
20
and may eventually progress to true local malignancy
20
–
22
and even metastases.
23
24 Some studies even suggested that
the metastatic potential of proliferative trichilemmal cysts
may even exceed that of squamous cell carcinomas.
14
25 In
our case, whether the preoperative diagnosis was a lipoma
or trichilemmal cyst would in fact make no difference in
our surgical management of excision. However, it would
be necessary to confi rm if there is a proliferative or malig-
nant potential if it is turns out to be a trichilemmal cyst, as
it would affect the postoperative management and overall
prognosis.
Learning points
▶ Soft tissue masses of the head and neck are
commonly encountered in general practice.
Benign lipomas, epidermoid cysts and sebaceous
▶
cysts remain as the most common diagnoses.
Excision of lesions from the scalp can lead to profuse
▶
bleeding and adequate haemostasis must be ensured.
Trichilemmal cyst usually presents as a slow-growing
▶
painless lump with cystic fl uctuant consistency.
Though rare, proliferative forms of trichilemmal cysts
▶
have been reported which mimic squamous cell
carcinomas.
Practising clinicians should be aware of trichilemmal
▶
cysts as a possible differential diagnosis when
approaching soft tissue masses of the head and neck,
and to exclude malignant potential which will affect
prognosis and management.
Competing interests None.
Patient consent Obtained.
REFERENCES
1 . Whiting DA, Stough DB . Posttransplant epidermoid cysts secondary to small
graft hair transplantation. Dermatol Surg 1995 ; 21 : 863 – 6 .
2 . Ambo M, Kumakiri M, Chohno Y . Epidermoid cyst with perforation of the skull.
J Am Acad Dermatol 2003 ; 49 : 934 – 6 .
3 . Cho JH, Jung TY, Kim IY, et al . A giant intradiploic epidermoid cyst with
perforation of the dura and brain parenchymal involvement. Clin Neurol
Neurosurg 2007 ; 109 : 368 – 73 .
4 . Truhan AP, Garden JM, Caro WA, et al . Facial and scalp lipomas: case
reports and study of prevalence. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 1985 ; 11 : 981 – 4 .
5 . Haas AF, Fromer ES, Bricca GM . Spindle cell lipoma of the scalp: a case
report and review. Dermatol Surg 1999 ; 25 : 68 – 71 .
6 . Eryilmaz M, Yigit T, Ozturk G, et al . Giant spindle cell lipoma of the posterior
neck. Dermatol Surg 2007 ; 33 : 1258 – 61 .
7 . Lawson W, Biller HF . Cervical hibernoma. Laryngoscope 1976 ; 86 : 1258 – 67 .
8 . Furlong MA, Fanburg-Smith JC, Miettinen M . The morphologic spectrum
of hibernoma: a clinicopathologic study of 170 cases. Am J Surg Pathol
2001 ; 25 : 809 – 14 .
9 . Naik R, Pai MR . Hibernoma of scalp: case report and review of literature.
Indian J Cancer 1996 ; 33 : 116 – 8 .
10. Newlands SD, Divi V, Stewart CM . Mixed myxoid/round cell liposarcoma of
the scalp. Am J Otolaryngol 2003 ; 24 : 121 – 7 .
11. Herman O, Ariely D . Myxoid liposarcoma of the scalp: case report and
literature review. Plast Reconstr Surg 1997 ; 100 : 84 – 5 .
12. Collins BT, Gossner G, Martin DS, et al . Fine needle aspiration biopsy of well-
differentiated liposarcoma of the neck in a young female. A case report. Acta
Cytol 1999 ; 43 : 452 – 6 .
13. Dey P . Fine needle aspiration cytology of well-differentiated liposarcoma. A
report of two cases. Acta Cytol 2000 ; 44 : 459 – 62 .
14. Sau P, Graham JH, Helwig EB . Proliferating epithelial cysts. Clinicopathological
analysis of 96 cases. J Cutan Pathol 1995 ; 22 : 394 – 406 .
15. Pinkus H . “Sebaceous cysts” are trichilemmal cysts. Arch Dermatol
1969 ; 99 : 544 – 55 .
16. Leppard BJ, Sanderson KV . The natural history of trichilemmal cysts. Br J
Dermatol 1976 ; 94 : 379 – 90 .
17. Karaman E, Duman C, Yagiz C . Giant trichilemmal cyst at the neck region. J
Craniofac Surg 2009 ; 20 : 961 – 2 .
18. Karaca S, Kulac M, Dilek FH, et al . Giant proliferating trichilemmal tumor of
the gluteal region. Dermatol Surg 2005 ; 31 : 1734 – 6 .
19. Brownstein MH, Arluk DJ . Proliferating trichilemmal cyst: a simulant of
squamous cell carcinoma. Cancer 1981 ; 48 : 1207 – 14 .
20. Satyaprakash AK, Sheehan DJ, Sangüeza OP . Proliferating trichilemmal
tumors: a review of the literature. Dermatol Surg 2007 ; 33 : 1102 – 8 .
21. Sethi S, Singh UR . Proliferating trichilemmal cyst: report of two cases, one
benign and the other malignant. J Dermatol 2002 ; 29 : 214 – 20 .
22. Garg PK, Dangi A, Khurana N, et al . Malignant proliferating trichilemmal cyst:
a case report with review of literature. Malays J Pathol 2009 ; 31 : 71 – 6 .
23. Amaral AL, Nascimento AG, Goellner JR . Proliferating pilar (trichilemmal)
cyst. Report of two cases, one with carcinomatous transformation and one
with distant metastases. Arch Pathol Lab Med 1984 ; 108 : 808 – 10 .
24. Eskander A, Ghazarian D, Bray P, et al . Squamous cell carcinoma arising in
a proliferating pilar (trichilemmal) cyst with nodal and distant metastases. J
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2010 ; 39 : E63 – 7 .
25. Y e J , Nappi O, Swanson PE, et al . Proliferating pilar tumors: a clinicopathologic
study of 76 cases with a proposal for defi nition of benign and malignant
variants. Am J Clin Pathol 2004 ; 122 : 566 – 74 .
Figure 5 Review of patient after 3 months with mild cicatration
at site of cyst excision.