SUMMARY
The present study aimed to evaluate the relative toxicological safety of certain non-conventional insecticides, i.e. imidacloprid, neem oil, mineral oil and a commercial product of the entomopathogenic fungi, Beauvaria bassiana (all compared to chlorpyrifos and cypermethrin). In this respect, acute and subchronic studies on Japanese quail, Coturnix coturnix japonica and Bolti fish, Tilapia nilotica were conducted. For subchronic studies, sublethal daily doses (or concentrations) each of 1/50 or 1/100 LD50 (or LC50) were used for 30 days.
1. Acute toxicity studies:
Against Japanese quail birds, the insecticides could be comparatively classified as follows: chlorpyrifos and imidacloprid are extremely toxic (LD50’s: 8.8 and 25 mg/kg b.w, respectively); cypermethrin moderately toxic (LD50’s 1247 mg/kg); neem oil and mineral oil, relatively non-toxic (LD50’s: > 10000 and 20000 mg/kg, respectively).
Dermally, chlorpyrifos is classified as very toxic (LD50: 155.78 mg/kg), imidacloprid as moderately toxic (LD50: 1757.9 mg/kg), cypermethrin, neem or mineral oil as relatively non-toxic (LD50’s: 8957.4, > 50000 mg/kg, respectively). The entomopathogenic fungi showed low acute oral or dermal toxicity to quail (LD¬50’s: 6 x 108 and > 30 x 108 conidia/kg b.w. equivalent to 20 and 100 ml of the liquid formulation/kg b.w., respectively).
Against fingerlings of Bolti fish and using static methods, the tested insecticides could be classified as follows: chlorpyrifos and chypermethrin, extremely toxic (LC50’s: 0.06 and 0.028 ppm, respectively; imidacloprid moderately toxic (LC50: 13 ppm); neem oil and mineral oil, relatively non-toxic (LC50’s: 150 and 120 ppm, respectively).
2. Subchronic toxicities:
2.1. Against quail birds:
Quail birds were treated orally with single daily doses (each of 1/50 or 1/100 LD50) for 30 days. LD50’s of neem and mineral oils were supposed to be 10000 and 20000 mg/kg b.w, respectively. No clinical signs of toxicity could be observed throughout the experimental period. Birds treated with mineral oil or cypermethrin showed no deaths within test period. Birds treated with 1/50 LD50 of chorpyrifos, neem oil or the entomopathogenic fungi showed 13.3, 20 and 33.3% mortalities, respectively. At 1/100 LD50 the toxicity was less powerful (mortalities were nearly 6.6%). Except for the entomopathogenic fungi, all the tested toxicants caused significant reduction in red blood cells count, Hemoglobin content and hematocrit values, whereas white blood cells were increased. The effects were less powerful for the dose 1/100 LD50. Chlorpyrifos was the only insecticide that significantly decreased the specific activity of AChE which was determined in brains of birds. Chlorpyrifos, imidacloprid, neem oil and the fungal product significantly reduced the activity of non-specific esterases at 1/50 LD50 but were of no effect at 1/100 LD50. Cypermethrin and mineral oil exhibited no effect on esterase activity at the two tested doses.
The mineral oil and the fungal product caused no significant alterations in the activities of alkaline phosphatase, alanine amino transferase; total protein, bilirubin concentration and albumin at the two tested doses. Chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin, imidacloprid and neem oil significantly elevated alkaline phosphatase, transaminases, total bilibrubin, albumin whereas reduced cholesterol and total lipids. The effect was more remarkable for the conventional insecticides, chlorpyrifos and cypermethrin. It could be concluded that alterations caused in the tested biochemical measurements due to chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin, imidacloprid and neem oil might indicate the liver dysfunction. The effect was more pronounced in chlorpyrifos and cypermethrin and generally less powerful at the dose 1/100 LD50. This was emphasized by the histopathological examination where livers of birds treated with mineral oil or the entomopathogenic fungi showed no histological changes and seemed to be normal. In contrary, livers of birds treated with chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin, imidacloprid and neem oil showed similar histopathological reactions differ in severity and generally appeared as vacoular degeneration of hepatocytes, necrosis, infiltration, congestion and others.
Concerning the effect on kidney function, it was found that the mineral oil and the fungal product exhibited no significant effect on urea and creatinine concentrations. Chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin, imidacloprid and neem oil showed significant increase of these parameters. It is concluded that chlorpyrifos might be severely nephrotoxic while cypermethrin, imidacloprid and neem oil might be less powerfull. The entomopathogenic product and the tested mineral oil might be relatively of no-renal toxicity.
For the effect on blood sugar content results showed that only the tested conventional insecticides (i.e. chlorpyrifos and cypermethrin) were found to elevate glucose concentration at the two tested doses.
2.2. Bolti fish, Tilapia nilotica:
Bolti fish fingerlings were continuously exposed to freshly prepared concentrations (1/50 or 1/100 LC50) of the insecticides for 30 days. Few number of fish died throughout the test period (3.33-10%). The highest mortalities were observed for neem and mineral oils (10%). At the concentration, 1/100 LC50, chlorpyrifos, imidacloprid and the fungal product caused no deaths.
Chlorpyrifos was the only toxicant that significantly decreased the activity of brain AChE. Concerning the effect on brain total esterase, chlorpyrifos, imidacloprid and neem oil significantly decreased the activities of this enzyme while cypermethrin, mineral oil and the fungal product were of no effect.
For the effect on liver function, chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin and neem oil were found to significantly alternate the activities of alkaline phosphatase, transaminases and other biochemical measurements. All the non-conventional insecticides showed no effects on bilirubin concentrations. It is generally noticed that results of the effects on biochemical markers in fish are in parallel with those obtained on quail birds with the exception of imidacloprid that showed no significant biochemical lesions in fish and this could be explained on the basis of photodegradation of imidacloprid in water. It thus obvious that biochemical markers of liver function of Bolti fish have not been adversely affected by the tested non-conventional insecticides unlike chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin and neem oil that showed liver dysfunction. The harmful effects were less pronounced at the concentration, 1/100 LC50. However, dysfunction might be reversible and curable after non-exposure period to the toxicants.
All the tested non-conventional insecticides showed no significant alterations in levels of creatinine and urea. However, imidacloprid and the mineral oil were found to elevate creatinine at 1/50 LC50 chlorpyrifos and cypermethrin were the most dangerous ones since they affected urea and creatinine levels at the two tested concentrations. Cypermethrin is less powerful than chlorpyrifos being of no effect on urea level at 1/100 lC50. It could be concluded that chlorpyrifos might be nephrotoxic and the rest of materials especially neem oil and the fungal product might be of low renal toxicity.
Concerning the effect on sugar content, none of the conventional insecticides was of significant effect on glucose level in viscera of fish homogenates.
In general, the study suggests that the biorational insecticides especially the mineral oil and the entomopathogenic fungal product might be toxicologically safer than the conventional synthetic ones. Comprehensive toxicological and ecotoxicological studies on different animal and avian species are further needed to verify the overall impact of these biorationals and possibly their chemical constituents on ecosystem using more realistic exposure conditions especially for fish and other marine organisms.