ArticlePDF Available

Monoclonal antibody-purged bone marrow transplantation therapy for multiple myeloma

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Forty patients with plasma cell dyscrasias underwent high-dose chemoradiotherapy and either anti-B-cell monoclonal antibody (MoAb)-treated autologous, anti-T-cell MoAb-treated HLA-matched sibling allogeneic or syngeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). The majority of patients had advanced Durie-Salmon stage myeloma at diagnosis, all were pretreated with chemotherapy, and 17 had received prior radiotherapy. At the time of BMT, all patients demonstrated good performance status with Karnofsky score of 80% or greater and had less than 10% marrow tumor cells; 34 patients had residual monoclonal marrow plasma cells and 38 patients had paraprotein. Following high-dose chemoradiotherapy, there were 18 complete responses (CR), 18 partial responses, one non-responder, and three toxic deaths. Granulocytes greater than 500/microL and untransfused platelets greater than 20,000/microL were noted at a median of 23 (range, 12 to 46) and 25 (range, 10 to 175) days posttransplant (PT), respectively, in 24 of the 26 patients who underwent autografting. In the 14 patients who received allogeneic or syngeneic grafts, granulocytes greater than 500/microL and untransfused platelets greater than 20,000/microL were noted at a median of 19 (range, 12 to 24) and 16 (range, 5 to 32) days PT, respectively. With 24 months median follow-up for survival after autologous BMT, 16 of 26 patients are alive free from progression at 2+ to 55+ months PT; of these, 5 patients remain in CR at 6+ to 55+ months PT. With 24 months median follow-up for survival after allogeneic and syngeneic BMT, 8 of 14 patients are alive free from progression at 8+ to 34+ months PT; of these, 5 patients remain in CR at 8+ to 34+ months PT. This therapy has achieved high response rates and prolonged progression-free survival in some patients and proven to have acceptable toxicity. However, relapses post-BMT, coupled with slow engraftment post-BMT in heavily pretreated patients, suggest that such treatment strategies should be used earlier in the disease course. To define the role of BMT in the treatment of myeloma, its efficacy should be compared with that of conventional chemotherapy in a randomized trial.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Monoclonal Antibody-Purged Bone Marrow Transplantation
Therapy for Multiple Myeloma
By
Kenneth
C.
Anderson, Janet Andersen, Robert Soiffer, Arnold
S.
Freedman, Susan N. Rabinowe, Michael J. Robertson,
Neil
Spector,
Kelly
Blake, Christine Murray, Andrea Freeman, Felice Coral, Karen
C.
Marcus,
Peter Mauch,
Lee
M.
Nadler, and Jerome Ritz
Forty
patients with plasma cell dyscrasias underwent
high-dose chemoradiotherapy and either anti-B-cell mono-
clonal antibody (MoAb)-treated autologous, anti-T-cell
MoAb-treated HLA-matched sibling allogeneic or synge-
neic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). The majority of
patients had advanced Durie-Salmon stage myeloma at
diagnosis, all were pretreated with chemotherapy, and 17
had received prior radiotherapy. At the time of BMT, all
patients demonstrated good performance status with Kar-
nofsky score of 80% or greater and had less than
10%
marrow tumor cells; 34 patients had residual monoclonal
marrow plasma cells and 38 patients had paraprotein.
Fol-
lowing high-dose chemoradiotherapy, there were
18
com-
plete responses
(CR),
18 partial responses, one non-re-
sponder, and three toxic deaths. Granulocytes greater than
500/pL and untransfused platelets greater than 20,00O/pL
were noted at a median of 23 (range, 12 to 46) and 25
(range,
10
to 175) days posttransplant (PT), respectively,
in
24
of the 26 patients who underwent autografting. In
the
14
patients who received allogeneic or syngeneic
grafts, granulocytes greater than 500/pL and untransfused
ULTIPLE MYELOMA remains an incurable malig-
M
nancy with
a
median survival at best of only 48
months when conventional therapies are used. Such conven-
tional treatments (ie, melphalan and prednisone or combi-
nation chemotherapy) have been associated with a 50%
to
60%
probability of transient disease regression.’ Although
several reports have suggested improved survival after treat-
ment with combination chemotherapy than after melpha-
Ian with or without prednisone:-’ this remains controver-
~ial.~,~ a2b interferon (IFN) has recently been used to treat
patients during initial and/or as a maintenance therapy&I4;
although requiring confirmation, those patients with either
near complete or complete response (CR) to chemotherapy
in some studies appear to have prolonged survival with IFN
maintenance treatment. Disease inevitably recurs, and al-
though several effective salvage chemotherapy regimens
achieve response rates of up to 50% to 75%,l5-I7 these re-
sponses are rarely complete and durable. To date, therefore,
From the Divisions
of
Tumor Immunology and Biostatistics,
Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, and the Departments
of
Medicine
and Radiation Therapy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Submitted February 2, 1993; accepted June
18,
1993.
Supported by National Institutes
of
Health Grants No. CAS0947
and CA06516.
Address reprint requests to Kenneth C. Anderson, MD, Division
of
Tumor Immunology, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, 44 Binney St.
Boston, MA 02115.
The publication costs ofthis article were defrayed in part by page
charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked
“advertisement”
in accordance with
18
U.S.C.
section 1734 solely to
indicate this fact.
0
I993
by
The American Society
of
Hematology.
0006-49 71 /93/8208-0028$3.00/0
platelets greater than 20,00O/pL were noted at a median
of
19
(range, 12 to 24) and 16 (range, 5 to 32) days PT,
respectively. With
24
months median follow-up for sur-
vival after autologous BMT,
1
6 of 26 patients are alive free
from progression at
2+
to 55+ months PT; of these,
5
patients remain in
CR
at 6+ to 55+ months PT. With
24
months median follow-up for survival after allogeneic and
syngeneic BMT,
8
of
14
patients are alive free from pro-
gression at
8+
to 34+ months PT; of these, 5 patients
remain in
CR
at
8+
to
34+
months PT. This therapy has
achieved high response rates and prolonged progression-
free survival
in
some patients and proven to have accept-
able toxicity. However, relapses post-BMT, coupled
with
slow engraftment post-BMT
in
heavily pretreated pa-
tients, suggest that such treatment strategies should be
used earlier in the disease course. To define the role of
BMT in the treatment of myeloma, its efficacy should be
compared with that of conventional chemotherapy in a ran-
domized trial.
0
1993
by The American Society
of
Hematology.
no therapies have achieved prolonged disease-free survival
or cure.
A promising treatment approach for multiple myeloma
stems from reports of CR after the administration ofalkylat-
ing agents (melphalan, cyclophosphamide, busulfan) in
higher than conventional doses, with or without total body
irradiation, followed by transplantation of syngeneic, alloge-
neic, or autologous bone marrow (BM),
or
of autologous
peripheral blood stem cells (PBSC).’8-39 Reduction in tumor
mass in
some
cases has been dramatic, with CR rates rang-
ing up to 50% to
60%.
Moreover, there are now relapse-free
survivors as long as
14
years,
6
to 7 years, and 5 years post-
syngeneic, allogeneic, and autologous grafting, respectively.
In the European Bone Marrow Transplant Group
median relapse-free survival for 37 of90 (41%) patients who
entered CR was 48 months; however, it remains unclear as
to whether a plateau in the survival curve has yet been
achieved in this and all other studies. Those patients who
have sensitive disease and who are less heavily pretreated
achieve the highest response rates and prolonged progres-
sion-free survival. More recent studies have therefore used
high-dose alkylating agents, with or without radiotherapy,
followed by transplantation
of
allogeneic BM or autologous
BM and/or PBSC as initial therapy for patients with my-
e10ma.’8,28~37.38 Although response rates are high, their dura-
tion and the relative efficacy of these approaches compared
with conventional initial therapies remains to be deter-
mined.
In the present study, we report the results of treatment
with high-dose chemoradiotherapy and bone marrow trans-
plantation (BMT) in 40 patients with responsive multiple
myeloma. Thirteen patients less than 55 years of age with
related histocompatible siblings received allografts, and
a
single patient underwent syngeneic BMT. Twenty-six pa-
2568
Blood,
Vol82,
No
8
(October
15),
1993:
pp
2568-2576
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
MoAE-PURGED BMT
FOR
MYELOMA
2569
tients less than
60
years of age, including those less than
55
years
of
age without related histocompatible siblings,
re-
ceived autografts.
T
cells were depleted from allografts and
tumor cells from autografts, using in vitro lysis with mono-
clonal antibodies (MoAbs) and complement. The majority
of patients were heavily pretreated and underwent BMT at
the time of sensitive relapse. Although this therapy has
achieved high response rates and prolonged progression-
free survival in some patients and proven to have acceptable
toxicity, relapses post-BMT support the view that such
treatment strategies should
be
used earlier in the disease
course and their efficacy compared with that of conven-
tional chemotherapy.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Selection ofpatients and treatment protocol.
Patients were eligi-
ble for autologous BMT if they were less than 60 years of age; pa-
tients less than
55
years of age who had histocompatible sibling
donors underwent allogeneic BMT. All patients had multiple my-
eloma," as well
as
reactivity of tumor cells with anti-plasma cell
associated-
1
(PCA-
I)
MOA^.^'
All original laboratory parameters
were reviewed to establish a proper Dune-Salmon stage at diagno-
sis. Patients must have achieved a minimal tumor burden, defined
as less than
10%
BM tumor cells (regardless of serum paraprotein)
before BMT. Pretransplant therapy was administered to achieve
maximum cytoreduction either at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute
(DFCI) or, under its supervision, administered at local institutions.
Sites of bony disease received additional radiation therapy before
BMT. Additional criteria for entry included the absence of comor-
bid disease of the heart, kidney, lung, and liver, and a Karnovsky
score above 80%. Patients whose prior radiotherapy obviated the
ability to deliver full-dose total body irradiation (TBI) received ab-
lative therapy with chemotherapy only. In patients less than
55
years of age who had HLA identical mixed lymphocyte culture
(MLC) nonreactive sibling donors, allogeneic grafting was per-
formed in preference to autologous BMT; autologous grafting was
done for patients less than 60 years of age, including those less than
55
years of age who did not have histocompatible sibling donors.
Written informed consent was obtained from all patients for treat-
ment protocols approved by the Human Protection Committee at
DFCI.
Preparative therapy for patients undergoing autologous BMT in-
cluded melphalan 70 mg/m2 of body weight, infused
on
each of 2
consecutive days before 1,200 cGy TBI in 20 patients; and cyclo-
phosphamide 60 mg/kg ofbody weight, infused
on
each of 2 consec-
utive days before TBI ( 1,200
cGy
in one patient and 1,400
cGy
in
five patients). The initial
11
patients who received melphalan 70
mg/m2
on
2 consecutive days followed by 1,200 cGy TBI were
evaluated for toxicity in a phase
I
study." Ablative therapy included
cyclophosphamide 60 mg/kg of body weight, infused on each of 2
consecutive days before 1,400 cGy TBI in
1
1
recipients of allografts
and the sole recipient of syngeneic marrow; and busulfan
1
mg/kg
of body weight orally every 6 hours for 16 doses over 4 consecutive
days before cyclophosphamide 60 mg/kg of body weight infused
on
2
consecutive days in two allotransplant patients who had received
prior radiotherapy which precluded TBI. Within 18 hours of the
completion of radiotherapy, either
(
1)
cryopreserved autologous
BM that had been previously treated in vitro with anti-CD10, anti-
CD20, and anti-PCA-1 MoAbs and rabbit complement to deplete
tumor cells was thawed rapidly and reinfused; or (2) allogeneic
marrow that had been treated with anti-CD6 MoAb and rabbit
complement to deplete T cells was reinfused fresh. Marrows were
administered through a central venous catheter.
Collection, processing,
and
infusion of marrow.
Bone marrow
mononuclear cells (BMMCs) were obtained from the iliac crests,
collected in RPMI-1640 medium with preservative-free heparin,
filtered through stainless-steel mesh, and then washed and concen-
trated using a COBE 2991 cell washer (COBE Laboratories, Lake-
wood, CO). Ex vivo treatment of autologous BM was based
on
previously reported methods developed at the Dana-Farber Cancer
Institute that reproducibly deplete two to three logs of antigen (Ag)
positive-cells without depleting hematopoietic stem
cell^."^
Specifi-
cally, anti-PCA-1 MoAb and complement in vitro can lyse two to
three logs of the RPMI 8226 myeloma cell line. Mononuclear cells
were isolated
on
Ficoll-Hypaque gradients and resuspended in
RPMI-I 640 at a concentration of 2
X
lo7 cells/mL. These cells were
subjected to three treatments, each consisting of a 30-minute incu-
bation with MoAb at 20°C followed by incubation for 30 minutes
at 37°C with rabbit complement (Pel Freeze, Brown Deer, WI).
Marrow cells were treated with MoAbs directed at three Ags, in-
cluding CALLA (CD
lo),
which detects the common acute lympho-
blastic leukemia Ag43; B1 (CD20), a pan-B cell AgU; and PCA-1,
which detects a plasma-cell-associated Ag:' This MoAb cocktail
was
used
to target cells in the malignant clone from the pre-B-cell
to the plasma stage.45 Before in vitro marrow treatment, phenotypic
analysis demonstrated less than 10% of cells bearing the CALLA,
B1, or PCA-1 Ags; after treatment, repeat analysis showed absence
ofcells bearing these Ags. Cells were then cryopreserved in medium
containing
10%
dimethyl sulfoxide and 90% autologous serum at
-196°C in the vapor phase of liquid nitrogen. Before infusion, the
cryopreserved marrow cells were rapidly thawed and diluted in me-
dium containing
25
IU DNase/mL to minimize clumping. The
median number of reinfused marrow cells was
2.1
X
lo9
(range, 1.4
to 5.2
X
IO9),
or
a median of 3.1
X
107/kg (range, 1.8 to 7.8
X
107/kg), with 85% to 95% viability
as
measured by Trypan blue
exclusion.
For allogeneic BMT, BM was harvested from histocompatible
sibling donors under general anesthesia using standard techniques.
Marrow was anticoagulated with preservative-free heparin in
RPMI 1640. After BM harvest, marrow cells were washed free of
the anticoagulant and plasma proteins and concentrated into a
50
to 100 mL bufFy-coat fraction using a COBE 299
1
blood-cell proces-
sor. Bone marrow mononuclear cells were isolated from the bufFy-
coat fraction
on
discontinuous gradients of Ficoll-Hypaque.
Mono-
nuclear cells were placed at a cell concentration of 2
X
107/mL and
were incubated with anti-T12 (CD6) MoAb (IgM isotype) for 15
minutes at 20°C followed by the addition of rabbit complement at a
ratio of 1:s or 1:lO final dilution for further incubation at 37°C for
45 minutes. Our method for in vitro treatment of marrow with
anti-T 12 MoAb to abrogate graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) was
described previously.46 Incubation with anti-TI 2 and complement
was repeated twice. After completion of treatment, marrow cells
were combined and washed five times to remove both MoAb and
complement, and were then resuspended in
50
mL media that con-
tained 10% human AB serum. After T12 treatment, patients re-
ceived a median of 6.3
x
IO9
(range, 2.5 to 10
x
lo9)
or a median of
7.4
X
lo7
(range, 2.7 to 13
x
10') cells/kg.
The single patient who underwent syngeneic BMT received
non-
purged marrow with 82.5
x
IO9
total cells, or 101.2
x
IO7
cells/kg.
Supportive care.
Patients were treated in reverse-isolation
rooms until they were discharged. Discharge was permitted if the
absolute granulocyte count was stable at greater than 5OO/pL, and
no
fever had occurred in the absence of antibiotics for 24 to 48
hours.
Trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole
or ciprofloxacin prophy-
laxis was begun in all patients when chemotherapy was initiated,
but was discontinued if intravenous broad-spectrum antibiotics
were required. Patients received prophylactic acyclovir
(5
mg/kg
or
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
2570 ANDERSON ET AL
400 mg orally every
8
hours) for Herpes simplex infections. Prophy-
laxis with
trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole
or pentamidine inhaler
was instituted at the time ofdischarge and continued for 12 months
to prevent
Pneumocystis carinii
pneumonia. Patients were also
treated with acyclovir to prevent Herpes zoster infection during the
first
I2
months posttransplant. Cytomegalovirus-negative blood
products were used in all patients, regardless of prior exposure to
the virus. Blood products were irradiated (2,500 cGy) to prevent
transfusion-related GVHD.
Clinical evaluation.
Before treatment, all patients were evalu-
ated as follows: physical examination, blood chemistry profile,
complete blood count, serum and urinary protein immunoelectro-
phoresis and immunofixation, human immunodeficiency virus
se-
rology, bone survey, bilateral BM biopsies and phenotypic analysis
of
BMMCs, pulmonary function tests, and ventriculogram. Criteria
for CR included, for at least 3 months, both
(1)
the absence
of
serum
paraprotein and Bence Jones proteinuria by immunoelectro-
phoresis and immunofixation; and (2) fewer than
5%
polyclonal
plasma cells, as demonstrated by immunoperoxidase staining of
BM biopsy specimens for Ig heavy and light chains.
A
50% decrease
in measurable protein sustained for at least
1
month constituted a
partial response. Follow-up evaluations included serum protein
studies monthly and BM aspiration and biopsy at 3-month inter-
vals
for
the first year PT; protein studies at 3-month intervals and
BM aspiration and biopsy at 6-month intervals for the second year
PT; and protein studies at 3-month intervals thereafter. Radio-
graphic bone surveys were performed at 12 month intervals.
a
26
IFN
maintenancetherapy.
For patients treated since 1990,
01
2b
IFN
therapy, 3
X
IO6
U
subcutaneously 3 times weekly, has
been used beginning at 3 months
PT
and continued for at least 9
months PT in an attempt to prolong the duration of responses
achieved.
IFN
was not used in patients who did not achieve transfu-
sion independence with granulocytes
2
1,50O/pL and PLTs
2
lOO,OOO/fiL by 3 months
IT.
Statistical methods.
Survival and failure-free survival (FFS)
were calculated from date
of
BMT. Cases were censored for
FFS
if
alive and disease free at analysis. Three patients who underwent
autologous BMT died free from progression at 2,6, and 19 months,
and are considered failures
for
this analysis. This underestimates
FFS,
but perhaps better reflects the experience
of
the patients.
RESULTS
Twenty-five patients with my-
eloma and
1
patient with recurrent extramedullary plasma-
cytomas underwent autologous BMT between February
1987 and November 1992 (Table
1).
There were
16
men
Patient characteristics.
and
10
women with
a
median age of 47 (35 to 59) years,
including 2,4, 13, and
6
patients with Durie-Salmon stages
IA, IIA, IIIA, and IIIB disease, respectively,
at
time of diag-
nosis. Serum
p2
microglobulin and BM labeling indices
were not routinely performed. Patients received
a
median of
three (two
to
four) treatment regimens over
a
period of 23 (8
to 52) months before BMT. Fourteen patients had received
radiotherapy before BMT. At the time of autologous BMT,
all patients had sensitive disease in that they had achieved
minimal disease status, defined as less than
10%
BM plasma
cells. Three patients had polyclonal plasma cells evident on
bilateral bone marrow biopsy;
1
of these also had no serum
and/or urine monoclonal protein and was therefore the only
patient in complete remission. The remaining patients dem-
onstrated both monoclonal marrow plasma cells and mono-
clonal paraprotein at the time of autologous BMT.
Thirteen patients with multiple myeloma underwent allo-
geneic BMT between February 1990 and November 1992
(Table
1).
There were 9 men and 4 women with
a
median
age of 43 (37 to 52) years, including 2, 3,
6,
and 2 patients
with Durie-Salmon stages IA, IIA, IIIA, and IIIB disease,
respectively, at the time
of
diagnosis. Serum
p2
microglobu-
lin and BM-labeling indices were not routinely performed.
Patients received a median
of
two (one to four) treatment
regimens over a period
of
a median of 25 (9
to
48) months
before BMT. Three patients had received radiotherapy be-
fore BMT. At the time of allogeneic BMT, all patients again
had sensitive disease and achieved minimal disease status,
defined as less than
10%
BM plasma cells. Three patients
had polyclonal plasma cells evident on bilateral bone
marrow biopsy;
1
of these also had no serum and/or urine
monoclonal protein and was therefore the only patient in
complete remission. The remaining patients demonstrated
both monoclonal marrow plasma cells and monoclonal par-
aprotein at the time of allogeneic BMT.
A 44-year-old man with stage IIIB myeloma received che-
motherapy without radiotherapy and achieved less than
10% monoclonal marrow cells, with persistent serum para-
protein (Table
1).
After ablative chemoradiotherapy, he re-
ceived nonpurged syngeneic marrow.
Hematologic engraftment.
Engraftment post-autolo-
gous BMT with granulocytes greater than
500/pL
was noted
Table
1.
Characteristics of Patients Undergoing
BMT
for Myeloma
No.
of
No.
of
No.
of
No.
of
Patients: Patients Patients Patients
No.
of With
(+)
or Median With
(+)
or With
(+)
or
No.
of
ChemoRx Without
(-)
Interval Without
(-1
Without
(-)
Source Median Patients:
No.
of Regimens RadioRx Diagnosis Monoclonal Monoclonal
of Stem
No.
of Age (yr) Stage at Patients: Before Before to Transplant Plasma Cells Protein at
Cells Patients (rangel Sex Diagnosis lsotype Transplant Transplant
(mo)
(range)
at
Transplant Transplant
~~~
Purged autologous 26 47 (35-59) 16
M
2:IA 16:lgG 7:2 14+ 23 (8-52)
23+
25+
marrow 10 F 4:llA 7:lgA 11.3 12- 3- 1-
13:lllA 3:Kor
X
8:4
6:lllB
T
depleted allogeneic 13 43 (37-52)
9
M
2:IA 7:lgG 1:l 3+ 25 (9-48) 1
o+
12+
marrow 4F 3:llA 2:lgA 7:2 10- 3- 1-
6:lllA 4:K 3:3
2:MB 2:4
- -
Syngeneic marrow 1 44 1
M
IllB
IgG 1:l
8
+
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
MoAB-PURGED BMT FOR MYELOMA
257
1
at a median of 23 (range, 12 to 46) days
PT
in 25 patients
and untransfused platelets greater than 20,00O/pL at a me-
dian of 25 (range,
IO
to 175) days PT in 24 ofthe 26 patients
(Table 2).
A
median of 9
U
(range, 4 to 30
U)
of red blood
cells (RBCs) and 56
U
(range, 4 to 329
U)
of platelets were
transfused. Patients were discharged from the hospital at a
median of 3 1 (range, 24 to 67) days
PT.
A single patient who
was heavily pretreated with chemotherapy including nitro-
sourea developed pneumonia, typhlitis, and refractory
thrombocytopenia and succumbed of a central nervous sys-
tem hemorrhage at day 67
PT.
She did not engraft and re-
quired 29
U
of RBCs and 329
U
of platelet transfusion
support during her 67-day hospitalization. Another patient
remained platelet transfusion dependent until his death at 6
months
PT.
Engraftment post-allogeneic BMT with granulocytes
greater than
500/pL
was noted at a median of 19 (range, 12
to 24) days
PT
and untransfused platelets greater than
20,0OO/pL at a median of 16 (range,
5
to 32) days
PT
(Table
2).
A
median of
8
U
(range, 4 to 23
U)
of RBCs and 45
U
(
17
to 307
U)
of platelets were transfused.
A
single patient re-
quired 307 units of platelet transfusion support in the set-
ting of venocclusive disease (VOD). Patients were dis-
charged from the hospital at a median of 3
1
(27 to 52) days
PT.
The single patient who underwent syngeneic BMT
achieved granulocytes >500/pL and untransfused platelets
greater than 20,00O/pL at I9 and 25 days PT, respectively
(Table 2). He required 6
U
of RBCs and 76
U
of platelets
during a 33-day hospitalization.
Acute and chronic toxicity.
Of the 26 patients who un-
derwent autologous grafting, all developed fevers
(>
10
1
OF)
while leukopenic, but only 3 patients had positive blood
cultures: Staphylococcus epidermidis in 2 patients and
a
hemolytic streptococcus in a single patient (Table 2). Eigh-
teen patients developed mucositis. Herpes zoster and ve-
nous thrombosis occurred in 4 and
l
patient, respectively.
Three patients developed hypothyroidism and a single pa-
tient hypoparathyroidism PT.
As noted above, there was
1
acute in-hospital treatment-
related death. This death occurred in a 50-year-old woman
who presented with plasmacytoma of the proximal left fe-
mur necessitating total hip replacement, associated with
Durie-Salmon stage IIIB multiple myeloma. Over the next 2
years she received therapy with four combination chemo-
therapy regimens (total dose of 90 mg carmustine). After
melphalan and TBI-ablative therapy, she received 2.9
X
lo7
cells/kg body weight marrow infusion. Fever without source
was noted on
day
5
PT and leukocytes reappeared as ex-
pected on day 10 PT. Her hospital course was complicated
by pneumonia (day 11
PT),
a diffuse rash thought to
be
drug-related (day 30 PT), and clinical and radiographic find-
ings consistent with typhlitis (day
50
PT).
BM aspirate at
day 41 PT was hypocellular, but without evidence of my-
eloma, and leukocyte count peaked on day 48
PT
at 800/pL
with 40% granulocytes. Despite aggressive antibiotic and
transfusion support, the patient became alloimmunized
and refractory even to HLA-matched platelet transfusions
and succumbed with a central nervous system hemorrhage
on day 67 PT. Postmortem examination showed numerous
petecchial and ecchymotic lesions of the skin and serosal
surfaces of the peritoneum, pleura, and pericardium,
as
well
as hemorrhage of the respiratory, gastrointestinal, and uro-
thelial mucosa. The BM was hypocellular but all cell lines
were recovering; immunoperoxidase studies of marrow in-
dicated that the scattered plasma cells were of a polyclonal
nature.
Of the 13 patients who underwent allogeneic grafting,
1 1
developed fever
(>
101
OF)
while leukopenic (Table 2).
Blood cultures were positive in 3 patients: Staphylococcus
Table
2.
Hematologic Engraftment and Toxicity After
BMT
for Myeloma
Median
Median Days Median Units
of
Median
PT With Median Days Units
of
RBCs
Platelets Days in
Source
of
No.
of
Granulocytes PT to Platelets Transfused Transfused Hospital
No.
of
Patients:
Stem Cells Patients
>500/rL
(range)
>2O,OOO/pL
(range) (range) (range) (range) Complication
Purged autologous
26 23 (12-46)’ 25 (10-175)’ 9 (4-30) 56 (4-329) 31 (24-67) 26:
Fever
marrow
3:
Bacteremia
18:
Mucositis
4:
Herpes zoster
1
:
Venous thrombosis
3:
Hypothyroidism
1
:
Hypoparathyroidism
T-depleted allogeneic
13 19 (1 2-24) 16 (5-32)
8
(4-23) 45
(1
7-307) 3
1
(27-52)
1 1
:
Fever
marrow
3:
Bacteremia
6:
GVH disease
(4
grade
I,
1
grade
II,
1
grade
111)
1
:
Chronic GVH disease
2:
Venocclusive disease
1
:
Graft failure
Syngeneic marrow
1
19 25 6 76 33 1:
Fever
Abbreviation: PT, posttransplant.
One patient did not achieve greater than
500
granulocytes/pL and
2
patients did not achieve untransfused platelets greater than
2O,OOO/pL.
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
2572
ANDERSON ET
AL
epidermidis,
Escherichia coli,
and enterobacter in
1
patient
each. Six of the 13 patients developed acute GVHD: grade
I
in 4 patients, grade
I1
in
1
patient, and grade
111
in
I
patient.
Acute GVHD resolved in 3 patients with topical and/or oral
corticosteroid therapy, and in
2
patients without treatment.
A
single patient developed chronic GVHD and was treated
with corticosteroids and cyclosporine for
4
months, and has
required no therapy thereafter.
Two patients developed VOD characterized by weight
gain, ascites, and liver function test abnormalities in the first
month PT. In the first patient, total bilirubin peaked at 4.3
mg/dL on day
I5
PT;
treatment with pentoxyphylline led to
resolution of VOD and discharge at day 33 PT. The other
patient developed clinical VOD and rising total bilirubin on
day
11
PT; despite treatment with tissue plasminogen acti-
vator, heparin, pentoxyphylline, and prostaglandin
E
1,
he
expired on day 40
PT
with total bilirubin of
40
mg/dL. At
postmortem examination, the liver showed signs of pro-
found venous congestion and biliary stasis and ascites was
present. Characteristic signs of GVHD in the gastrointesti-
nal tract, skin, and liver were not present, nor was there any
evidence of residual myeloma in marrow.
A third patient engrafted promptly, with granulocytes
greater than
5OO/pL
and platelets greater than
20,00O/pL
at
days 17 and 19 PT, respectively. The marrow donor was her
brother who was both HLA and AB0 compatible. On day
2
1
PT, the patient was begun on Bactrim therapy for a uri-
nary tract infection; by day 49 PT she had developed pro-
found pancytopenia, with fewer than
100
lymphocytes/pL,
all of which were of her own type. No evidence of viral or
other infection was documented, and a trial of granulocyte
colony stimulating factor did not increase her leukocyte
counts. She therefore underwent a second allograft with her
brother’s non-T-cell depleted marrow, after preparation
with cyclophosphamide
50
mg/kg on 4 consecutive days
and antithymocyte globulin. Although she engrafted
promptly with greater than
500
granulocytes/pL and un-
transfused platelets greater than
2O,OOO/pL
on days
1
1
and
14
PT, respectively, she died in the setting of GVHD, which
was refractory to immunosuppressive therapy including cor-
ticosteroids and cyclosporine as well as IL-
I
receptor antago-
nist.
Therapeutic results.
Among the patients who under-
went autografting, there were
11
complete and 14 partial
responders, and
1
toxic death. All responding patients
achieved pathologically normal marrows with less than
5%
marrow plasma cells; in complete responders, monoclonal
proteins were
also
absent in serum and urine, and marrow
plasma cells were polyclonal on immunoperoxidase stain-
ing. Staging marrow biopsies routinely performed during
the first 24 months PT confirmed the presence of less than
5%
polyclonal plasma cells in
2
1
patients
(1
I
complete and
10 partial responders) at a median of 3 (range, 3 to 10)
months PT. Monoclonal proteins disappeared in the
1
1
pa-
tients with CR at a median of
3
(range, 2 to
19)
months PT.
Of the
1
1
complete responders to autologous BMT, normal
levels of IgG, IgA, and
IgM
were noted in
5,8,
and 9 patients
at
9
(range, 6 to I3),
5
(range,
1
to lo), and 6 (range,
1
to
10)
months PT, respectively. Of the
I4
partial responders, nor-
mal levels of IgG,
IgA,
and
IgM
were noted in 2, 6, and
I2
patients at
1
and 24,9 (range,
5
to
I2),
and
4
(range,
I
to
12)
months PT, respectively. One patient had free
X
light chains
in serum and urine before BMT and recurred with IgG
X
after BMT. Another patient had
IgA
X
myeloma before
BMT and recurred with IgA
X
as well as IgG
X
monoclonal
proteins.
As of November 1,
1992
with 24 months median follow-
up,
21
of the 26 patients who underwent autografting are
alive at
2+
to 68+ months PT, and 16 patients remain alive
free from progression at
2+
to
55+
months
PT
(Fig
1);
of
these, five patients remain in CR at 6+ to
55+
months PT.
Three patients died free from progression at 2, 6, and 19
months
PT.
Seven patients relapsed at 3 to 36 months PT;
of these,
5
patients remain alive at
22+
to 68+ months PT,
and 2 patients died at
14
and 27 months PT. The median
progression-free survival is 36 months and median overall
survival has not yet been reached.
Among the 14 patients who received either allogeneic or
syngeneic grafts, there were 7 complete responders,
4
partial
responders,
1
non-responder, and
2
toxic deaths. Again, all
responding patients achieved pathologically normal
marrows with less than
5%
marrow plasma cells; in com-
plete responders, monoclonal proteins were also absent in
serum and urine, and monoclonal plasma cells were polyclo-
nal on immunoperoxidase staining. On staging marrow
biopsies performed routinely during the first
24
months PT,
the presence
of
less than
5%
polyclonal plasma cells was
confirmed in
11
patients (7 complete and
4
partial re-
sponders) at a median of
4
(2 to
8)
months
PT.
In
2
of the 7
complete responders, monoclonal plasma cells have re-
turned at 6 and 7 months PT. Monoclonal proteins disap-
peared in the
7
patients with CR at a median of 3 (1 to
4)
months PT; in 2 of the
7
complete responders, monoclonal
protein also returned at 6 and
7
months PT. Of the 7 com-
plete responders to allogeneic BMT, normal levels of IgG,
IgA,
and IgM were noted in 5,6, and 7 patients at
5
(range, 2
to 12),
5
(range,
2
to
14),
and
5
(range,
1
to 6) months PT,
respectively. Of the 4 partial responders, normal levels
of
the uninvolved IgG,
IgA,
and IgM were noted in
4,
1, and
1
patient at 5,2, and 3 (range,
2
to
5)
months PT, respectively.
Polyclonal elevation of IgG and monoclonal IgG protein
have each been noted in a single patient at 14 and 9 months
PT, respectively.
As of November
1,
1992
with
24
months median follow-
up, 9 of the
14
patients who received either allogeneic or
syngeneic grafts are alive and
8
patients remain alive free
from progression at
8+
to 34+ months PT (Fig
2);
ofthese,
5
patients remain in CR at
8-t
to 34+ months PT. Two pa-
tients died free of relapse from VOD and graft failure at
l
and
4
months PT, respectively. Four patients relapsed at 2,
6, 7, and
17
months PT; of these,
1
patient remains alive at
24 months
PT
and
3
patients have died at
4,
9,
and 13
months
PT.
The median progression-free and overall sur-
vival have not yet been reached.
Of the 26 patients who underwent
autologous BMT, 13 patients received
IFN:
3
patients pre-
BMT,
3
patients at the time of relapse post-BMT, 6 patients
(Y
2b
IFN
therapy.
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
MoAB-PURGED BMT
FOR
MYELOMA
2573
1
.O
0.8
..............................................................................................
I
0.0
I
I
0
I
2
3
4
5
6
Years
Time Interval
Group
0-1
1-2 2-3 3-4 4-5 5-6
FFS
5/26 3/13 2fl
OD
O/I
OD
Fig
,
.
MM
autologous
trans-
....................
Survival
2/26
2/16
1/10
0/6
OB
011
plant.
(#
eventsl#
at
risk)
as maintenance therapy post-BMT, and
1
patient both be-
fore BMT and as maintenance therapy post-BMT. Five pa-
tients did not receive maintenance
IFN
post-BMT because
of
low counts;
of
those receiving maintenance therapy, dose
reduction
(1
patient) or discontinuation
(1
patient) was re-
quired due to pancytopenia;
IF"
was discontinued in an
additional patient due
to
the development
of
pulmonary
infiltrates. One of the
6
patients on maintenance
IF"
ther-
apy has progressed.
Of the
14
patients who underwent allogeneic or syngeneic
BMT,
10
patients received
IFN
therapy:
1
patient pre-BMT,
2
patients at the time
of
relapse post-BMT, and
7
patients as
maintenance therapy post-BMT. Two patients did not re-
ceive
IFN
post-BMT because of low counts; discontinua-
1
.O
0.8
0.6
0.4
I
1
0.2
1
0.0
0.5
1
.o
1.5
2.0 2.5 3
.O
Years
Time Interval
Group
0-0.5
0.5-1
1-1.5 1.5-2 2-2.5 2.5-3
FFS
5/14
Of9
lfl
0/5
0/4
OB
Survival 3/14
1/11
1/8
016
0/4
013
....................
Fig
2.
MM
allogeneic trans-
(I
event#
at
risk)
plant.
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
2574
ANDERSON
ET
AL
tion of maintenance
IFN
post-BMT was required in 3 pa-
tients due to the development of thrombocytopenia and fa-
tigue. One of the 7 patients on maintenance
IFN
post-BMT
has progressed.
DISCUSSION
In this study, we report the results of 40 patients with
multiple myeloma who underwent high-dose chemora-
diotherapy and either anti-B-cell MoAb-treated autologous
BMT
or
anti-T-cell MoAb-treated allogeneic BMT. The
majority of patients had advanced Dune-Salmon stage my-
eloma, had sensitive relapsed myeloma and were heavily
pretreated with chemotherapy; 17 had received prior radio-
therapy. At the time of BMT, all patients demonstrated
good performance status with Karnofsky score of 80%
or
greater and had less than 10% marrow tumor cells; 34 pa-
tients had residual monoclonal marrow plasma cells and 38
patients had paraprotein. There were 18 CRs, 18 partial
responses,
1
nonresponse, and 3 toxic deaths. Less than 5%
polyclonal marrow plasma cells were noted in all responders
after BMT. As of November 1, 1992 with 24 months me-
dian follow-up for survival among the autologous BMT
cases, 16 of 26 patients are alive free from progression at 2+
to 55+ months PT; of these, 5 patients remain in CR at 6+
to 55+ months PT. With 24 months median follow-up for
survival among the allogeneic and syngeneic BMT cases,
8
of 14 patients are alive free from progression at 8+ to 34+
months PT; of these, 5 patients remain in CR
at
8+ to 34+
months PT. Although this therapy has achieved high re-
sponse rates and prolonged progression-free survival in
some patients and proven to have acceptable toxicity, re-
lapses post-BMT suggest that such treatment strategies
should be used earlier in the disease course and their efficacy
compared with that of conventional chemotherapy in a ran-
domized trial.
Melphalan and prednisone therapy can result in response
rates of 50% to 60% and
a
median survival of 48 months;
and to date it remains controversial as to whether combina-
tion chemotherapy programs have improved on this out-
~ome.',~,~ Once patients become refractory to initial thera-
pies, salvage therapies such as vincristine, doxorubicin, and
dexamethasone" can achieve response rates of
50%
to 75%;
however, these responses are uncommonly either complete
or durable. High-dose melphalan with or without total body
irradiation and hematopoietic stem cell support was ini-
tially used by McElwain et al.27328 This strategy has achieved
responses even in the setting of patients refractory to initial
However, in most studies, significant relapse-
free survival was noted only in
a
minority of patients with
sensitive disease, and those patients with resistant relapse
or
with a combination of risk factors (ie, advanced tumor bur-
den, absence of IgG i~otype)~' did particularly poorly. None-
theless, as is true in B-cell non-Hodgkin's lymphomas
(NHL), high-dose therapy followed by autologous BMT is
the only strategy to have achieved significant relapse-free
survival. For example,
at
our
institute, MoAb-purged autol-
ogous BMT for patients with relapsed
B-
and T-cell NHL
sensitive to chemotherapy has resulted in 40% to
50%
re-
lapse-free survival at
2
to
3
years.'"-49 Although follow-up is
short and long-term outcome remains to be determined, the
current study of either MoAb-purged autologous or alloge-
neic BMT in myeloma sensitive
to
therapy has achieved
significant overall and relapse-free survivals (Figs
1
and 2).
However, only 5 of 26 patients undergoing autologous
BMT and 5 of 14 patients undergoing allogeneic BMT re-
main in CR at 6+ to 55+ and 8+ to 34+ months PT, respec-
tively. In the largest reported series to date of high-dose ther-
apy followed by allogeneic BMT in myeloma, median
relapse-free survival for 37 of 90 (4
1
%)
patients who entered
complete remission was 48 months.23 In this study, those
patients with sensitive disease and who were less heavily
pretreated achieved the highest response rates and pro-
longed progression-free survival. These studies suggest, as
has occurred in leukemias and lymphomas, that high-dose
approaches should be evaluated earlier in the disease, before
the emergence of drug resistance and refractory disease.
An additional impetus for using high-dose approaches ear-
lier in the disease course, now that toxicities of such ap-
proaches have proven to be tolerable, relates to the quality
of autologous hematopoietic stem cells and related speed
and completeness of hematologic recovery after high-dose
therapies.
For
example, Jagannath et a1 have attempted
PBSC collection in 75 previously treated patients with
myeloma after the administration of high-dose cyclo-
phosphamide with
or
without granulocyte-macrophage col-
ony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF).39 Among 72 patients
undergoing PBSC apheresis, good mobilization (>50 col-
ony-forming units GM per lo5 mononuclear cells) was
achieved when prior chemotherapy did not exceed
1
year
and when GM-CSF was used post-high-dose cyclophospha-
mide; similarly, rapid platelet recovery (to
50,00O/pL)
was
associated with good PBSC mobilization. In the present
study of high-dose chemoradiotherapy followed by autolo-
gous
BMT in heavily pretreated patients with myeloma, de-
layed engraftment was also noted; greater than
500
granulo-
cytes/pL and greater than 20,00O/pL platelets were noted as
long as 46 days and 175 days PT, respectively, and
2
pa-
tients did not achieve platelet transfusion independence at
the time of their deaths at
2
and 6 months
PT.
Moreover, it
was not possible to treat all patients with
IFN
post-BMT due
to related myelosuppression. Treatment of patients with
high-dose approaches earlier in their disease course may
therefore be useful not only for the avoidance of drug resis-
tance, but
also
to assure preservation of sufficient hemato-
poietic stem cells to permit rapid hematologic recovery and
low treatment-related morbidity and mortality.
Several investigators have used intensive treatment of
multiple myeloma supported by autologous BM and/or
PBSC transplantation as initial therapy in myel~ma.'**~*-~~~~~
For example, Gore et
a1
treated 50 patients with myeloma
with repeated cycles of 4-day infusions with vincristine,
doxorubicin, and methylprednisolone followed by high-
dose melphalan, with autologous BMT where possible.**
The overall response rate was 74%, with 50% complete he-
matologic and biochemical remissions. More recently, these
investigators have demonstrated that patients who receive
maintenance
IFN
post-autologous BMT have prolonged
median progression-free survival (39 months) compared
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
MOAB-PURGED
BMT
FOR
MYELOMA
2575
with those patients who are not treated with
IFN
(27
months)
(P
<
.025).” Attal et al recently treated
35
patients
with myeloma with repeated cycles of either vincristine,
doxorubicin, and dexamethasone, or vincristine, melpha-
lan, cyclophosphamide, and prednisone until plateau phase
was a~hieved.~’ High-dose melphalan, and TBI followed by
autologous BMT and maintenance
IFN
resulted in 43% and
40% complete and partial responses, respectively. The
33-
month post-BMT probability of progression-free survival
was
85%
for patients in complete and 24% for patients in
partial response. The 42-month post-diagnosis probability
of survival was
8
1
%.
These and other similar studies3’
sug-
gest that high-dose approaches early in the disease course
can achieve high response rates and that therapeutic inter-
ventions post-BMT, such as
IFN
maintenance, may be bet-
ter tolerated by such patients than in more heavily pre-
treated patients. They provide the basis on which a
randomized trial comparing high-dose versus conventional-
dose chemoradiotherapy for patients with untreated my-
eloma can be based.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
We are indebted to the house staff of the Brigham and Women’s
Hospital and Beth Israel Hospital, the fellows of the Dana-Farber
Cancer Institute, as well as the nurses and social workers of the
Dana-Farber Cancer Institute for their excellent care of these pa-
tients. We also thank Barbara Barrett and co-workers of the Blood
Component Laboratory, and the technicians of the Clinical Immu-
nology Laboratory (DFCI) for processing of the BM; the oncologic
surgeons of the Brigham and Women’s Hospital and New England
Deaconess Hospital for their surgical assistance; and Drs William
Kaplan and Robert Finberg and staffs in their respective depart-
ments of Radiology, Nuclear Medicine, and Infectious Disease for
their excellent assistance in patient care. We also thank Bernadette
Miner for preparation of the manuscript. The authors are especially
grateful to the many physicians who referred patients for these stud-
ies.
REFERENCES
1.
Kyle
RA:
Newer approaches to the therapy of multiple my-
eloma. Blood 76:1678, 1990
2. Salmon SE, Haut A, Bonnet JO, Amare M, Weick JK, Dune
BGM, Dixon DO: Alternating combination chemotherapy and le-
vamisole improves survival in multiple myeloma: A Southwest
On-
cology Group study. J Clin Oncol 1:453, 1983
3. Dune BGM, Dixon DO, Carter
S,
Stephens R, Rivkin
S,
Bon-
net J, Salmon SE, Dabich L, Files JC, Costanzi JJ: Improved sur-
vival duration with combination chemotherapy induction for multi-
ple myeloma:
A
Southwest Oncology Group study. J Clin Oncol
4:1227, 1986
4. MacLennan ICM, Kelly K, Crockson
RA,
Cooper EH, Cu-
zick J, Chapman
C
Results of the MRC myelomatosis trials for
patients entered since 1980. Hematol Oncol6:145, 1988
5. MacLennan ICM, Chapman C, Dunn J, Kelly
K:
Combined
chemotherapy with ABCM versus melphalan for treatment of mye-
lomatosis. Lancet
1
:200, 1992
6. Bergsagel DE:
Is
aggressive chemotherapy more effective in
the treatment of plasma cell myeloma? Eur
J
Cancer Clin Oncol
25:159, 1989
7.
Gregory WM, Richards MA, Malpas JS: Combination chemo-
therapy versus melphalan and prednisolone in the treatment of mul-
tiple myeloma: An overview of published trials.
J
Clin Oncol
10:334, 1992
8.
Mandelli F, Avvisati G, Amadori
S,
Boccadoro M, Gernone
A, Lauta VM, Marmont
F,
Petrucci MT, Tribalto M, Vegna ML,
Dammacco F, Pileri A: Maintenance treatment with recombinant
interferon alfa-2b in patients with multiple myeloma responding to
conventional induction chemotherapy. N Engl J Med 322: 1430,
1990
9. Mandelli
F
Interferon maintenance treatment in multiple my-
eloma: Update of the Italian study, in Pileri A (ed): Proceedings of
the 111 International Workshop on Multiple Myeloma. Torino,
Italy, University of Torino, 199
1,
p
1
1
1
10.
Osterborg A, Bjorkholm M, Bjoreman B, Brenning G, Carl-
son K, Celsing F, Gahrton G, Grimfors G, Gyllenhammer
H,
Hast
R, Johansson B, Juliusson G, Jarnmark M, Kimby
E,
Lerner R,
Linder
0,
Merk K, Nilsson B, Ohrling M, Paul C, Simonsson B,
Smedmyr B, Smedmyr
E,
Stalfelt A-M, Strander
H,
Uden A-M,
Osby E, Mellstedt H: Natural interferon-a in combination with
melphalan/prednisone versus melphalan/prednisone in the treat-
ment of multiple myeloma stages I1 and 111: A randomized trial
from Myeloma Group of Central Sweden. Blood 81:1428, 1993
I
1. Westin J, Cortelezzi A, Hjorth M, Rodjer
S,
Turesson
I,
Za-
dor G: Interferon therapy during the plateau phase of multiple my-
eloma: An update of a Swedish Multicenter Study, in Pileri
A
(ed):
Proceedings of the
I11
International Workshop
on
Multiple My-
eloma. Torino, Italy, University of Torino, 199
1,
p 1 13
12. Oken MM, Kyle
RA,
Griepp PR, Kay NE, Tsiatis A, O’Con-
nell MJ: Possible survival benefit with chemotherapy plus inter-
feron (RIFN alpha 2)
in
the treatment of multiple myeloma. Proc
Am SOC Clin Oncol 11:358, 1992 (abstr)
13. Salmon SE, Crowley J: Impact of glucocorticoids (GC) and
interferon
(IFN)
on outcome in multiple myeloma. Proc Am SOC
Clin Oncol 11:316, 1992
14. Cooper MR, Dear K, McIntyre
OR,
Ozer H, Ellerton J, Can-
ellos G, Bernhardt B, Duggan D, Faragher D, Schiffer C A random-
ized clinical trial comparing melphalan/prednisone with or without
interferon alfa-2b in newly diagnosed patients with multiple my-
eloma:
A
Cancer and Leukemia Group B study. J Clin Oncol
11:155, 1993
15. Barlogie B, Smith L, Alexanian
R
Effective treatment of
advanced multiple myeloma refractory to alkylating agents.
N
Engl
J Med 310:1353, 1984
16.
Buzaid AC, Dune BGM: Management of refractory my-
eloma:
A
review. J Clin Oncol6:889, 1988
17. Barlogie B, Velasquez WS, Alexanian R, Cabanillas
F
Eto-
poside, dexamethasone, cytarabine, and cisplatin in vicristine, dox-
orubicin, and dexamethasone-refractory myeloma. J Clin Oncol
7:1514, 1989
18. Barlogie B, Gahrton G: Bone marrow transplantation in mul-
tiple myeloma. Bone Marrow Transplant 7:71, 1991
19. Osserman EF, DiRe LB, Sherman WH, Hersman JA, Storb
R: Identical twin marrow transplantation in multiple myeloma.
Act Haematol68:215, 1982
20. Fefer A: Current status of syngeneic marrow transplantation
and its relevance to autografting. Clin Haematol 15:49, 1986
2
1.
Wolff
SH,
McCurley TL, Giannone
L
High dose chemora-
diotherapy with syngeneic bone marrow transplantation for multi-
ple myeloma:
A
case report and literature review. Am J Hematol
26:191, 1987
22. Copelan EA, Tutschka PJ: Marrow transplantation follow-
ing busulfan and cyclophosphamide
in
multiple myeloma. Bone
Marrow Transplant 3:363, 1988
23. Gahrton G, Tura
S,
Ljungman
P,
Belanger C, Brandt
L,
Cavo M, Facon T, Granena A, Gore M, Gratwohl A, Lowenberg B,
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
2576
ANDERSON ET AL
Nikoskelainen J, Reiffers JJ, Samson D, Verdonck L, Volin
L
Allo-
geneic bone marrow transplantation in multiple myeloma. N Engl
J
Med 325:1267, 1991
24. Bensinger WI, Buckner CD, Clift
RA,
Petersen
FB,
Bianco
JA, Singer JW, Appelbaum FR, Dalton W, Beatty P, Fefer A, Storb
R, Thomas ED, Hansen JA: Phase
I
study of busulfan and cyclo-
phosphamide in preparation for allogeneic marrow transplant for
patients with multiple myeloma. J Clin Oncol
10:
1492, 1992
25. Barologie B, Hall R, Zander A, Dicke K, Alexanian R: High
dose melphalan with autologous bone marrow transplantation for
multiple myeloma. Blood 67: 1298, 1986
26. Barlogie B, Alexanian R, Dicke
KA,
Zagars G, Spitzer G,
Jagannath
S,
Horwitz
L
High-dose chemoradiotherapy and autolo-
gous bone marrow transplantation for resistant multiple myeloma.
Blood 70:869, 1987
27. Selby P, Zulian
G,
Forgeson
G,
Nandi A, Milan
S,
Meldrum
M, Viner C, Osborne R, Malpas JS, McElwain TJ: The develop-
ment of high dose melphalan and autologous bone marrow trans-
plantation in the treatment of multiple myeloma: Royal Marsden
and St. Bartholomew’s Hospital studies. Hematol Oncol 6: 173,
1988
28. Gore ME, Selby PJ, Viner C, Clark PI, Meldrum M, Millar
B, Bell J, Maitland JA, Milan
S,
Judson IR, Zuiable A, Tillyer C,
Slevin M, Malpas JS, McElwain TJ: Intensive treatment of multiple
myeloma and criteria for complete remission. Lancet 22379, 1989
29. Gobbi M, Cavo M, Tazzari PL, Dinota A, Tassi C, Bontadini
A, Albertazzi L, Miggiano C, Rizzi
S,
Rosti G, Bolognesi A, Stirpe
F, Tura
S:
Autologous bone marrow transplantation with immuno-
toxin-purged marrow for advanced multiple myeloma. Eur J Hae-
matol 43:176, 1989
30. Barlogie B, Jagannath
S,
Dixon DO, Cheson B, Smallwood
L, Hendrickson A, Purvis JD, Bonnem E, Alexanian R: High-dose
melphalan and granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor
for refractory multiple myeloma. Blood 76:677, 1990
31. Jagannath
S,
Barlogie B, Dicke K, Alexanian R,
Zagars
G,
Cheson B, Lemaistre FC, Smallwood L, Pruitt K, Dixon DO: Autol-
ogous bone marrow transplantation in multiple myeloma: Identifi-
cation of prognostic factors. Blood 76: 1860, 1990
32. Anderson KC, Barut BA, Ritz J, Freedman AS, Takvorian
T, Rabinowe SN, Soiffer R, Heflin L, Coral F, Dear K, Mauch P,
Nadler LM: Monoclonal antibody-purged autologous bone
marrow transplantation therapy for multiple myeloma. Blood
77:712, 1991
33. Mansi J,
da
Costa F, Viner C, Judson I, Gore M, Cun-
ningham
D
High-dose busulfan in patients with myeloma. J Clin
Oncol 10:1569, 1992
34. Lokhorst HM, Muewissen OJATh, Verdonck LF, Dekker
AW: High-risk multiple myeloma treated with highdose melpha-
Ian. J Clin Oncol 10:47, 1992
35. Fernand JP, Levy
Y,
Gerata J, Benbunan M, Cosset JM,
Castaigne
S,
Seligman M, Brouet JC: Treatment ofaggressive multi-
ple myeloma by high dose chemotherapy and total body irradiation
followed by blood stem cell autologous graft. Blood 73:20, 1989
36. Reiffers J, Marit
G,
Boiron JM: Autologous blood stem cell
transplantation in high risk myeloma. Br J Haematol72:296, 1989
37. Harousseau JL, Milpied
N,
Laporte JP, Collombat P, Facon
T, Tigaud JD, Casassus P, Guilhot F, Ifrah N, Gandhour C: Dou-
ble-intensive therapy in high-risk multiple myeloma. Blood
79:2827, 1992
38. Attal M, Huguet F, Schlaifer D, Payen C, Laroche
M,
Four-
nie B, Mazieres B, Pris J, Laurent
G:
Intensive combined therapy
for previously untreated aggressive myeloma. Blood 79:
1
130, I992
39. Jagannath
S,
Vesole DH, Glenn
L,
Crowley J, Barlogie B:
Low-risk intensive therapy for multiple myeloma with combined
autologous bone marrow and blood stem cell support. Blood
80:1666, 1992
40. Dune BG, Salmon SE: A clinical staging system for multiple
myeloma. Cancer 36:842, 1975
4
1.
Anderson KC, Park
EK,
Bates MP, Leonard RCF, Hardy R,
Schlossman SF, Nadler LM: Antigens
on
human plasma cells iden-
tified by monoclonal antibodies. J Immunol 130:
I
132, 1983
42. Anderson KC, Nadler LM, Takvorian T, Freedman AS,
Canellos GP, Schlossman
SF,
Ritz J: Monoclonal antibodies: Their
use
in
bone marrow transplantation, in Brown E (ed): Progress in
Hematology. Philadelphia, PA, Grune
&
Stratton, 1987, p 137
43. Ritz J, Pesando JM, Notis-McConarty J, Lazarus H, Schloss-
man SF:
A
monoclonal antibody to human acute lymphoblastic
leukaemia antigen. Nature 283:583, 1980
44. Nadler LM, Stashenko P, Ritz J, Hardy R, Pesando JM,
Schlossman SF:
A
unique cell surface antigen identifying lymphoid
malignancies of B cell origin. J Clin Invest 67: 134, 198
I
45. Anderson KC, Bates MP, Slaughenhoupt BL, Pinkus
GS,
Schlossman SF, Nadler LM: Expression of human B cell-associated
antigens on leukemias and lymphomas: A model of human B cell
differentiation. Blood 63: 1424, 1984
46. Soiffer
RJ,
Murray C, Mauch P, Anderson KC, Freedman
AS, Rabinowe SN, Takvorian T, Robertson
MJ,
Spector N, Gonin
R, Miller
KB,
Rudders
RA,
Freeman A, Blake K, Coral F, Nadler
LM, Ritz J: Prevention of graft-versus-host disease by selective de-
pletion ofCD6-positive T lymphocytes from donor bone marrow.
J
Clin Oncol
10:
1
I9
I,
I992
47. Freedman AS, Takvorian T, Anderson KC, Mauch P, Ra-
binowe SN, Blake
K,
Yeap B, Soiffer R, Coral
F,
Heflin L, Ritz J,
Nadler LM: Autologous bone marrow transplantation in B-cell
non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma: Very low treatment-related mortality
in
100
patients in sensitive relapse. J Clin Oncol 8:784, 1990
48. Anderson KC, Soiffer
R,
DeLage R, Takvorian T, Freedman
AS, Rabinowe
SN,
Nadler LM, Dear K, Heflin L, Mauch P, Ritz J:
T-cell-depleted autologous bone marrow transplantation therapy:
Analysis of immune deficiency and late complications. Blood
76:235, 1990
49. Freedman AS, Ritz J, Neuberg D, Anderson KC, Rabinowe
SN, Mauch P, Takvorian T, Soiffer R, Blake K, Yeap B, Coral F,
Nadler LM: Autologous bone marrow transplantation in 69 pa-
tients with a history of low-grade B-cell non-Hodgkm’s lymphoma.
Blood 77:2524, 1991
50.
Cunningham D, Powles R, Malpas JS, Milan
S,
Meldrum M,
Viner
C,
Montes A, Hickish
T,
Nicolson
M,
Johnson
P,
Mansi
J,
Treleaven J, Raymond
J,
Gore ME: A randomized trial of mainte-
nance therapy with Intron-A following high
dose
melphalan and
ABMTinmyeloma.ProcAm SocClinOncol12:1232, 1993(abstr)
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
1993 82: 2568-2576
Blake, C Murray and A Freeman
KC Anderson, J Andersen, R Soiffer, AS Freedman, SN Rabinowe, MJ Robertson, N Spector, K
multiple myeloma
Monoclonal antibody-purged bone marrow transplantation therapy for
http://www.bloodjournal.org/content/82/8/2568.full.html
Updated information and services can be found at:
Articles on similar topics can be found in the following Blood collections
http://www.bloodjournal.org/site/misc/rights.xhtml#repub_requests
Information about reproducing this article in parts or in its entirety may be found online at:
http://www.bloodjournal.org/site/misc/rights.xhtml#reprints
Information about ordering reprints may be found online at:
http://www.bloodjournal.org/site/subscriptions/index.xhtml
Information about subscriptions and ASH membership may be found online at:
Copyright 2011 by The American Society of Hematology; all rights reserved.
Society of Hematology, 2021 L St, NW, Suite 900, Washington DC 20036.
Blood (print ISSN 0006-4971, online ISSN 1528-0020), is published weekly by the American
For personal use only.on June 19, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom
... Subsequently, others reported high response rates in patients with resistant MM using melphalan at 90 to 200 mg/m 2 with or without TBI, 19 making it the most widely used high-dose regimen. A variety of other regimens have been used, including busulfan (BU) alone 20 or with CY 2,20 or thiotepa, 21 and TBI with CY. 22 Response rates of 60% to 90% have been reported with true CR rates of 20% to 50%, which are generally higher in patients offered transplant as first-line therapy. In 1995, approximately 400 autologous transplants for MM were reported to the North American Bone Marrow Transplant Registry. ...
... Investigators at Dana-Farber Cancer Center transplanted 21 patients with chemotherapy-responsive disease. 22,44 The preparative regimen was CY and TBI for all but two patients. Marrow was T-cell depleted with an anti-CD6 monoclonal antibody and complement, which removed 1.5 logs of T cells. ...
... The use of selective T-cell depletion using an anti-CD6 monoclonal antibody technique is intriguing. In a report by Anderson et al, 22 only 2 (10%) of 21 patients developed severe GVHD, with no deaths attributable to GVHD. This very good outcome may be related to patient selection. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Multiple myeloma (MM) is a malignant plasma cell disorder with a median survival of three years. Despite the development of numerous conventional chemotherapy regimens and interferons, there has been little progress in improving the survival of patients with MM. Very high-dose chemoradiotherapy and autologous or allogeneic hematopoetic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) can result in high complete remission rates, even in patients with advanced disease. Methods A prospective, randomized study has shown that autologous HSCT results in superior response rates, progression-free survival, and disease-free survival compared with conventional chemotherapy. This is the first real advance in the treatment of this disease in 30 years. Unfortunately, few, if any, patients with MM who receive autologous HSCT are cured. Results Allogeneic HSCT can be curative for a fraction of patients with MM. However, very high transplant-related morbidity and mortality limit the application of allografts to younger patients with compatible donors. Conclusions Challenges for the future include the development of less intensive or more disease-specific chemotherapy regimens that preserve the antitumor activity but are less toxic, improvement in the control of graft-vs-host disease in the case of allografts and, for autologous graft recipients, the development of vaccines and cytotoxic lymphocytes to augment a graft vs myeloma effect.
Article
Full-text available
The development of new resources for a more accurate diagnosis and response assessment in multiple myeloma has been a long process for decades, mainly since the middle of the 20th century. During this time, the succession of technical advances has run parallel to the better knowledge of disease biology and the availability of novel therapeutic strategies. The cornerstone of standardized criteria to uniformly evaluate the disease response in myeloma dates back to the 1990s when the key role of complete remission was established. Since then, different updates have been implemented according to available scientific evidences not always without certain controversies. The progressive improvements in survival results of myeloma patients and the growing quality of responses due to the novel therapies have led to the need of developing new tools for better monitoring of tumor burden. In this way, the concept of minimal residual disease and its key value based on the prognostic significance and the clinical relevance has been consolidated during the last years, overcoming the value of conventional response criteria or classical adverse prognosis markers. Nevertheless, its precise role in the clinical management of myeloma patients to detect early treatment failure and trigger early rescue strategies is still pending to be defined. In this review, we revisit the major milestones in the understanding of tumor reduction in multiple myeloma until the most recent imaging techniques or liquid biopsy approaches, including a critical view of conventional response criteria, whose backbone has remained unchanged during the last 20 years.
Article
We report the development of a potent anti-CD38 immunotoxin capable of killing human myeloma and lymphoma cell lines. The immunotoxin is composed of an anti-CD38 antibody HB7 conjugated to a chemically modified ricin molecule wherein the binding sites of the B chain have been blocked by covalent attachment of affinity ligands (blocked ricin). Conjugation of blocked ricin to the HB7 antibody has minimal effect on the apparent affinity of the antibody and no effect on the ribosome-inactivating activity of the ricin A-chain moiety. Four to six logs of CD38+ tumor cell line kill was achieved at concentrations of HB7-blocked ricin in the range of 0.1 to 3 nmol/L. Low level of toxicity for normal bone marrow (BM) granulocyte-macrophage colony- forming units (CFU-GM), burst-forming units-erythroid (BFU-E), colony- forming units-granulocyte/erythroid/monocyte/macrophage (CFU-GEMM) cells was observed. Greater than two logs of CD38+ multiple myeloma cells were depleted from a 10-fold excess of normal BM mononuclear cells (BMMCs) after an exposure to HB7-blocked ricin under conditions (0.3 nmol/L) that were not very toxic for the normal BM precursors. HB7- blocked ricin was tested for its ability to inhibit protein synthesis in fresh patients' multiple myeloma cells and in normal BMMCs isolated from two healthy volunteers; tumor cells from four of five patients were 100-fold to 500-fold more sensitive to the inhibitory effect of HB7-blocked ricin than the normal BM cells. HB7 antibody does not activate normal resting peripheral blood lymphocytes, and HB7-blocked ricin is not cytotoxic toward these cells at concentrations of up to 1 nmol/L. The potent killing of antigen-bearing tumor cells coupled with a lack of effects on peripheral blood T cells or on hematopoietic progenitor cells suggests that HB7-blocked ricin may have clinical utility for the in vivo or in vitro purging of human multiple myeloma cells.
Article
We report the development of a potent anti-CD38 immunotoxin capable of killing human myeloma and lymphoma cell lines. The immunotoxin is composed of an anti-CD38 antibody HB7 conjugated to a chemically modified ricin molecule wherein the binding sites of the B chain have been blocked by covalent attachment of affinity ligands (blocked ricin). Conjugation of blocked ricin to the HB7 antibody has minimal effect on the apparent affinity of the antibody and no effect on the ribosome-inactivating activity of the ricin A-chain moiety. Four to six logs of CD38+ tumor cell line kill was achieved at concentrations of HB7-blocked ricin in the range of 0.1 to 3 nmol/L. Low level of toxicity for normal bone marrow (BM) granulocyte-macrophage colony- forming units (CFU-GM), burst-forming units-erythroid (BFU-E), colony- forming units-granulocyte/erythroid/monocyte/macrophage (CFU-GEMM) cells was observed. Greater than two logs of CD38+ multiple myeloma cells were depleted from a 10-fold excess of normal BM mononuclear cells (BMMCs) after an exposure to HB7-blocked ricin under conditions (0.3 nmol/L) that were not very toxic for the normal BM precursors. HB7- blocked ricin was tested for its ability to inhibit protein synthesis in fresh patients' multiple myeloma cells and in normal BMMCs isolated from two healthy volunteers; tumor cells from four of five patients were 100-fold to 500-fold more sensitive to the inhibitory effect of HB7-blocked ricin than the normal BM cells. HB7 antibody does not activate normal resting peripheral blood lymphocytes, and HB7-blocked ricin is not cytotoxic toward these cells at concentrations of up to 1 nmol/L. The potent killing of antigen-bearing tumor cells coupled with a lack of effects on peripheral blood T cells or on hematopoietic progenitor cells suggests that HB7-blocked ricin may have clinical utility for the in vivo or in vitro purging of human multiple myeloma cells.
Chapter
Marrow transplantation from sibling donors for patients with advanced leukemia or bone marrow failure conditions proved considerably more challenging than transplantation for immunodeficiency diseases. The knowledge that hematopoietic cells are present in circulating blood, the arrival of cloned growth factors such as the granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF) and the availability of apheresis techniques allowed the wide application of collection methods for blood-derived grafts for allogeneic HCT. Continued studies in the dog model showed the characteristic spectrum of complications, as well as favorable events following allogeneic marrow grafting, including primary graft failure and secondary graft rejection. The concept of storing autologous hematopoietic cells while patients are being exposed to high doses of irradiation and/or high dose cancer drugs with subsequent cell reinfusion was developed over half a century ago. Initially, high dose chemotherapy and autologous transplantation was tested in women who had stage IV breast cancer.
Chapter
The goal of targeted therapy is to kill cells bearing specific receptors. This is in contradistinction to cytotoxic chemotherapy, which depends on biochemical differences between normal and target cells. Many types of malignant cells, including those resistant to cytotoxic chemotherapy, display unique proteins on the cell surface, making such cells potentially sensitive to targeted therapy. Unlike small chemotherapeutic agents, which enter the cell by passing though the membrane, targeted therapy must enter through the specific receptors or antigens on the cell surface. Because such sites number only thousands per cell, the targeted agent must be extremely potent. Typically, protein toxins are used since they kill cells by catalytic mechanisms. In fact, it has been shown with both bacterial and plant toxins that only one molecule in the cytoplasm of cells is sufficient to kill the cell (CARRASCO et al. 1975; YAMAIZUMI et al. 1978; WILLINGHAM, FITZGERALD and PASTAN unpublished data).
Chapter
To reduce the incidence of severe graft versus host disease (GvHD) and lower the treatment related mortality(TRM) in allogeneic stem cell transplantation from HLA-identical siblings patients with multiple myeloma, we incorporated anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG, Fa Fresenius, Bad Homburg, Germany) in the conditioning regimen of 12 patients. The conditioning regimen consisted of modified total body irradiation, busulfan and cyclophoshamide (n=9) or busulfan and cyclophoshamide (n=3). The median age was 44 years (range, 29–53) and the median time from diagnosis to transplant was 12 months (range, 6 to 56). The stem cell source was bone marrow in 10, and peripheral blood stem cells in 2 patients. Grade II-IV acute GvHD occurred in 3 patients (27% percent). Severe grade III and IV GvHD developed in only 1 patient. Major toxicity was mucositis. Grad II according the Bearman score was noted in 10 patients, whereas 2 patients experienced grade III, requiring prophylactic intubation. One patient died of severe GvHD grade IV and one patient developed multi-organ failure on day +13, resulting in a TRM of 17%. A complete response in surviving patients after allogeneic transplantation was seen in 4 (40%), and PR in 6 (60%) patients. Two of the patients with PR received a donor lymphocyte infusion (DLI) for further tumor reduction 8 and 14 months after stem cell transplantation, and converted to CR, which increased the rate of CR up to 60%. After a median follow-up of 25 months (range, 5–62), no patient with CR after allogeneic transplantation relapsed during follow-up, while 3 out of 4 patients with PR. experienced progress within 3 years (p=0.07). The estimated overall survival at three years for all patients is 83 percent (CI 95%: 68%–98%). The estimated progression-free survival at three years is 61 percent (CI 95%: 32%–90%). These results suggest that the incorporation of anti-thymocyte globulin may prevent severe GvHD without obvious increase of relapse. DLI should be administered for patients with incomplete response after transplantation to enhance the rate of complete remission, which results in long term freedom of disease.
Chapter
Despite the success of the use of combination chemotherapy for the treatment of advanced-stage malignancies, the majority of these patients die of their disease. In an attempt to overcome drug resistance, there has been increasing use of high-dose therapy (HDT) with a curative attempt both in patients with previously relapsed disease and increasingly as consolidation therapy in first complete remission. The myeloablation induced by HDT can be reversed by autologous or allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (autoHCT and alloHCT, respectively). Autologous cells have several potential advantages over allogeneic cells for HCT. Autologous HCT overcomes the need for an human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-identical donor, eliminates the risk of graft-vs-host-disease (GVHD) and has, therefore, enabled the use of chemotherapy dose escalation for a large number of patients with hematologic and solid tumors (1–4).
Article
The desire to remove tumor cells from autologous grafts is strong and commitments to this approach for ASCT have reached religious proportions. There is a general 'feeling' by many investigators, the public and some private companies that grafts should be purged 'if it does no harm and could do some good'. However, it can be concluded after more than a decade of intensive research, that no current purging technology is standard of care for patients receiving ASCT. In-vitro demonstration of tumor cell removal from the graft is not an acceptable criterium for judging efficacy of purging as all techniques could be harmful to the patient by altering the hematologic and/or immunologic function of the graft. Purging technologies should not be utilized clinically in a non-research setting until documented to be safe and effective in randomized trials.
Article
Multiple myeloma (MM) is an incurable plasma cell neoplasm characterized by the accumulation of malignant plasma cells in the bone marrow. In the vast majority of cases, this neoplastic proliferation of plasma cells produces a monoclonal protein or immunoglobulin fragment that can be detected in the blood, urine, or both. Signs and symptoms of MM can be related to the location of these cells as well as the excessive production of irrelevant monoclonal immunoglobulin. As the malignant plasma cells expand in the marrow, normal surrounding bone can dissolve as a result of stimulation of osteoclasts by a variety of cytokines. Damage to the bone can lead to pain, pathologic fractures, and hypercalcemia. Furthermore, normal bone marrow can be suppressed, in particular, erythropoiesis. Impairment of the immune system leads to decreased humoral immunity with increased risk of infection, particularly encapsulated organisms. The paraprotein itself can lead to problems, including hyperviscosity, amyloid, and renal damage. This disease typically occurs in individuals in the sixth or seventh decades, but can also be seen in younger people. Systemic therapy is palliative. For decades, chemotherapy was based on single agents or combinations of alkylating agents and steroids. Despite great enthusiasm, dose intensification is not curative in the majority of cases, but can prolong overall survival (OS) and event-free survival (EFS). Newer drugs, based on antiangiogenesis approaches and targeting cytokine pathways, have generated a great deal of interest.
Article
Full-text available
A high remission rate is achieved with high-dose melphalan (HDM) in multiple myeloma (MM), and autologous transplantation of hematopoietic stem cells allows a prompt hematologic recovery after high-dose therapy. We treated 97 patients with high-risk MM (group 1:44 advanced MM including 14 primary resistances and 30 relapses; group 2: 53 newly diagnosed MM) with a first course of HDM. For responding patients a second course of high-dose therapy with hematopoietic stem cell support was proposed. After the first HDM, the overall response and complete remission rates were 71% and 25% with no significant difference between the two groups. The median durations of neutropenia and thrombocytopenia were significantly longer in group 1 (29.5 days and 32 days, respectively) than in group 2 (23 days and 17 days, respectively). This severe myelosuppression led to eight toxic deaths and the fact that only 38 of the 69 responders could proceed to the second course (three allogenic and 35 autologous transplantations). Among the 35 patients undergoing autologous transplantation (10 in group 1, 25 in group 2), 31 received their marrow unpurged collected after the first HDM, and four received peripheral blood stem cells. The median durations of neutropenia and thrombocytopenia after autologous transplantation were 24 days and 49 days, respectively. Two toxic deaths and nine prolonged thrombocytopenias were observed. The median survival for the 97 patients was 24 months (17 months in group 1, 37 months in group 2) and the median duration of response was 20 months. The only parameters that have a significant impact on the survival are the age (+/- 50 years) and the response to HDM. The median survival of the 35 patients undergoing autologous transplantation is 41 months, but the median duration of remission is 28 months with no plateau of the remission duration curve. Patients responding to HDM may have prolonged survival, but even a second course of high-dose therapy probably cannot eradicate the malignant clone.
Article
Eleven patients with plasma cell dyscrasias underwent high-dose chemoradiotherapy and anti-B-cell monoclonal antibody (MoAb)-treated autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT). The majority of patients had advanced Durie-Salmon stage myeloma at diagnosis, all were pretreated with chemotherapy, and six had received prior radiotherapy. At the time of ABMT, all patients demonstrated good performance status with Karnofsky score of 80% or greater and had less than 10% marrow tumor cells. Eight patients had residual monoclonal marrow plasma cells and 10 patients had paraprotein. Following high-dose melphalan and total body irradiation (TBI) there were seven complete responses, three partial responses, and one toxic death. Granulocytes greater than 500/mm3 were noted at a median of 21 (range 12 to 46) days posttransplant (PT) and untransfused platelets greater than 20,000/mm3 were noted at a median of 23 (12 to 53) days PT in 10 of the 11 patients. Natural killer cells and cytotoxic/suppressor T cells predominated early PT, with return of B cells at 3 months PT and normalization of T4:T8 ratio at 1 year PT. Less than 5% polyclonal marrow plasma cells were noted in all patients after transplant. Three of the seven complete responders have had return of paraprotein, two with myeloma, and have subsequently responded to alpha 2 interferon therapy. Eight patients are alive at 18.9 (8.9 to 43.1) months PT and four remain disease-free at 12.3, 17.5, 18.9, and 29 months PT. This preliminary study confirms that high-dose melphalan and TBI can achieve high response rates without unexpected toxicity in patients who have sensitive disease, and that MoAb-based purging techniques do not inhibit engraftment. Although the follow-up is short- and long-term outcome to be determined, relapses post-ABMT in these heavily pretreated patients suggest that ABMT or alternative treatment strategies should be evaluated earlier in the disease course.
Article
To improve the safety of autotransplantation for myeloma, peripheral blood stem cell (PBSC) collection was attempted in 75 previously treated patients after the administration of high-dose cyclophosphamide (HD-CTX; 6 g/m2) with or without granulocyte-macrophage colony- stimulating factor (GM-CSF). Sixty patients subsequently received melphalan 200 mg/m2 (57 patients) or melphalan 140 mg/m2 and total body irradiation (850 cGy) (3 patients) supported by both autologous bone marrow and PBSC; 38 patients received GM-CSF posttransplantation. Among 72 patients undergoing PBSC apheresis, “good” mobilization (greater than 50 colony-forming units granulocyte-macrophage [CFU-GM] per 10(5) mononuclear cells) was achieved when prior chemotherapy did not exceed 1 year and when GM-CSF was used post-HD-CTX; similarly, rapid platelet recovery to 50,000/microL within 2 weeks was associated with “good” PBSC mobilization. These same variables also predicted for rapid engraftment after autotransplantation, so that hematologic recovery (granulocytes greater than 500/microL and platelets greater than 50,000/microL) proceeded within 2 weeks among the 37 patients with “good” PBSC collection. As a result of rapid neutrophil recovery (greater than 500/microL) within a median of 2 weeks, infectious complications both post-HD-CTX and posttransplant were readily manageable, resulting in only one treatment-related death post-HD-CTX. The cumulative response rate (greater than or equal to 75% cytoreduction) for all 75 patients was 68%, with 12-month event-free and overall survival projections of about 85%. Using both bone marrow and PBSC together with GM-CSF, autotransplants are safe and appear effective in myeloma, especially when prior therapy had been limited to less than 1 year. More than 80% of transplanted patients achieved complete hematologic recovery within a median of 1 month posttransplant (granulocytes greater than 1,500/microL; platelets greater than 100,000/microL; hemoglobin greater than 10 g%), thus providing sufficient hematopoietic reserve for further chemotherapy in the event of posttransplant relapse.
Article
Both melphalan and cyclophosphamide increase life expectancy in patients with myelomatosis, but few large randomised studies have compared combination chemotherapy regimens with these single agents. In the Vth MRC myelomatosis trial, the survival of 314 patients randomised to receive ABCM (adriamycin, BCNU, cyclophosphamide, and melphalan) as first-line treatment was significantly longer than that of 316 patients given intermittent melphalan (M7) (p=0·0003). The 75%, median, and 25% survivals were 7, 24, and 42 months, respectively, with M7 and 10, 32, and 56 months, respectively, with ABCM. Stable disease with few symptoms (plateau) was achieved by 61% of patients given ABCM and 49% of those given M7 (p = 0·004). Myelotoxicity was comparable between regimens. Cross-trial analysis suggests that M7 is comparable to melphalan and prednisone or melphalan, prednisone, and vincristine; that the efficacy of ABCM in the Vth trial and Vlth M RC trials is comparable; and that ABCM gave better survival than intermittent melphalan regimens in the prognostic groups analysed. The results indicate that ABCM is an acceptable regimen that is more effective than melphalan, with or without prednisone, for first-line treatment of myelomatosis.
Article
A multicentre clinical trial was carried out in order to evaluate the effect of interferon (IFN) in patients with multiple myeloma. Patients (n = 120) who had shown response to conventional intermittent melphalan-prednisone induction therapy, and achieved a plateau phase, were randomized at that point to receive either interferon alfa-2b in a dose of 5 million units (MU) three times per week or no therapy. This report presents the results of an interim analysis, performed when the patients had been followed for a median of 20 months. The duration of the plateau phase was significantly longer in the IFN arm (59 weeks), compared to the no therapy arm (26 weeks). A total of 34 deaths have occurred, 13 in the IFN arm and 21 in the no therapy arm. In spite of the high median age of the patients studied (70 years), most patients were able to tolerate a full or only slightly reduced IFN dose.
Article
50 previously untreated patients with multiple myeloma received two-phase treatment: repeated cycles of 4 day infusion with vincristine, doxorubicin, and methylprednisolone (VAMP) followed by high-dose melphalan (HDM), with autologous bone marrow transplantation where possible. The overall response rate was 74% (37/50), with 25 patients (50%) achieving complete haematological and biochemical remission. These remissions were associated with a good quality of life as measured by performance status, pain grade, and the reversal of humoral immunosuppression. 6 patients died during the VAMP phase and there was 1 death related to HDM. The achievement of complete remission, as defined here, in such a high proportion of patients is exeptional and may represent a useful advance in the management of myeloma.
Article
The presenting clinical features of 71 patients with multiple myeloma were correlated with myeloma cell mass (myeloma cells X 10(12)/m2 of body surface area) determined from measurements of monoclonal immunoglobulin (M-component) synthesis and metabolism. Bivariate correlation and multivariate regression analyses showed that myeloma cell mass could be accurately predicted from A) extent of bone lesions, B) hemoglobin level, C) serum calcium level, and D) M-component levels in serum and urine. Analyses of response to chemotherapy and survival indicated significant correlation with measured myeloma cell burden. The results were synthesized to produce a very reliable and useful clinical staging system with three tumor cell mass levels (Table 7). For clinical research purposes, multivariate regression equations were developed to predict optimally the exact myeloma cell mass. Thus, initial staging can be quantitatively related to followup using tumor cell mass changes calculated from changes in M-component production. Use of the clinical staging system sould provide better initial assessment and followup of individual patients, and should lead to improved study design and analysis in large clinical trials of therapy for multiple myeloma.
Article
To improve the safety of autotransplantation for myeloma, peripheral blood stem cell (PBSC) collection was attempted in 75 previously treated patients after the administration of high-dose cyclophosphamide (HD-CTX; 6 g/m2) with or without granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF). Sixty patients subsequently received melphalan 200 mg/m2 (57 patients) or melphalan 140 mg/m2 and total body irradiation (850 cGy) (3 patients) supported by both autologous bone marrow and PBSC; 38 patients received GM-CSF posttransplantation. Among 72 patients undergoing PBSC apheresis, "good" mobilization (>50 colony-forming units granulocyte-macrophage [CFU-GM] per 105 mononuclear cells) was achieved when prior chemotherapy did not exceed 1 year and when GM-CSF was used post-HD-CTX; similarly, rapid platelet recovery to 50,000/μL within 2 weeks was associated with "good" PBSC mobilization. These same variables also predicted for rapid engraftment after autotransplantation, so that hematologic recovery (granulocytes >500/μL and platelets >50,000/μL) proceeded within 2 weeks among the 37 patients with "good" PBSC collection. As a result of rapid neutrophil recovery (>500/μL) within a median of 2 weeks, infectious complications both post-HD-CTX and posttransplant were readily manageable, resulting in only one treatment-related death post-HD-CTX. The cumulative response rate (≥75% cytoreduction) for all 75 patients was 68%, with 12-month event-free and overall survival projections of about 85%. Using both bone marrow and PBSC together with GM-CSF, autotransplants are safe and appear effective in myeloma, especially when prior therapy had been limited to less than 1 year. More than 80% of transplanted patients achieved complete hematologic recovery within a median of 1 month posttransplant (granulocytes >1,500/μL; platelets >100,000/μL; hemoglobin >10 g%), thus providing sufficient hematopoietic reserve for further chemotherapy in the event of posttransplant relapse.
Article
To evaluate the use of high-dose busulfan (HDB) with autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT) in patients with myeloma. Fifteen patients received HDB (16 mg/kg), eight of whom received high-dose melphalan (HDM) but had experienced a short remission or progression-free interval. Two patients had received HDM on two previous occasions, one had no response to low-dose melphalan, and four had impaired renal function (edathamil clearance < 40 mL/min). All patients received induction chemotherapy before HDB. Two patients were in complete remission (CR) after induction chemotherapy before HDB. Of the remaining 13 patients, four (31%) achieved CR and two (15%) achieved a partial remission for an overall response rate of 46%. There were three treatment-related deaths, but the toxicity was otherwise predictable and manageable. In heavily pretreated patients, HDB results in a relatively high response rate. It can also be used safely in patients with renal impairment who are not suitable for HDM.
Article
To study the toxicity and potential efficacy of busulfan (BU) and cyclophosphamide (CY) as a conditioning regimen before allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (ABMT) in patients with multiple myeloma (MM). Twenty patients with MM underwent conditioning, which was followed by ABMT from 16 HLA-identical donors, three one-antigen-mismatched donors, and one HLA A, B, D-identical unrelated donor. Four levels of BU plus CY were evaluated. Severe regimen-related toxicity occurred in two of five patients who received BU 16 mg/kg and CY 120 mg/kg, in none of the four patients who received BU 14 mg/kg and CY 120 mg/kg, in one of eight patients who received BU 14 mg/kg and CY 147 mg/kg, and in two of three patients who received BU 14 mg/kg and CY 174 mg/kg. Twelve of 15 (80%) assessable patients achieved a complete remission with the disappearance of M-protein and the return of normal marrow morphology. Ten patients died of complications related to the ABMT, and two patients died of progressive or relapsed MM. Overall, eight of 20 patients were alive; seven (35%) were in complete remission 190 to 1,271 days after ABMT. The maximum-tolerable dose given in this setting was BU 14 mg/kg and CY 147 kg/mg. These results suggest that this regimen may have significant antimyeloma activity. Further phase II studies are warranted.