Conference PaperPDF Available

Enhanced distributed resource allocation and interference management in LTE femtocell networks

Authors:

Abstract

Femto cells have been integrated into 4G Long Term Evolution (LTE) cellular network architecture to efficiently address the coverage and capacity issues faced in indoors and at hotspots. Though spectral efficiency increases through frequency reuse one at Femtos, it could lead to co-tier interference and cause higher interference for cell edge User Equipments (UEs). This problem is more severe in enterprise and hotspot Femto deployments due to dense placement of Femtos. Existing co-tier interference management techniques do not solve this problem completely. Hence, in this paper, we propose a Variable Radius (VR) algorithm which dynamically increases or decreases the cell edge/non-cell edge region of Femtos and efficiently allocates the radio resources among cell edge/non-cell edge region of Femtos so that the co-tier interference between neighboring Femtos can be avoided. We implemented the proposed VR algorithm on top of Proportional Fair (PF) scheduling algorithm in NS-3 simulator. In our experiments, for 90 UEs the proposed technique (VR + PF) achieved 29% and 38% improvement in average throughput for static and mobile scenarios, respectively when compared to classic PF algorithm without any interference management.
Enhanced Distributed Resource Allocation and
Interference Management in LTE Femtocell
Networks
Vanlin Sathya, Harsha Vardhan Gudivada, Hemanth Narayanam, Bala Murali Krishna and Bheemarjuna Reddy Tamma
Department of Computer Science and Engineering
Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad, India
Email: [cs11p1003, cs09b011, cs09b024, bala, tbr]@iith.ac.in
Abstract—Femto cells have been integrated into 4G Long
Term Evolution (LTE) cellular network architecture to efficiently
address the coverage and capacity issues faced in indoors and at
hotspots. Though spectral efficiency increases through frequency
reuse one at Femtos, it could lead to co-tier interference and
cause higher interference for cell edge User Equipments (UEs).
This problem is more severe in enterprise and hotspot Femto
deployments due to dense placement of Femtos. Existing co-tier
interference management techniques do not solve this problem
completely. Hence, in this paper, we propose a Variable Radius
(VR) algorithm which dynamically increases or decreases the cell
edge/non-cell edge region of Femtos and efficiently allocates the
radio resources among cell edge/non-cell edge region of Femtos so
that the co-tier interference between neighboring Femtos can be
avoided. We implemented the proposed VR algorithm on top of
Proportional Fair (PF) scheduling algorithm in NS-3 simulator.
In our experiments, for 90 UEs the proposed technique (VR +
PF) achieved 29% and 38% improvement in average throughput
for static and mobile scenarios, respectively when compared to
classic PF algorithm without any interference management.
Index Terms—LTE; Femto Cells; Interference Management;
Spectral efficiency
I. INTRODUCTION
Due to popularity of smart phones and tablets, there is
an exponential increase in the demand for higher data rates.
To provide higher data rates, 3GPP proposed 4G Long Term
Evolution (LTE) standard. As per traffic statistics given by
Huawei and Nokia-Siemens [1], [2], 60% of the voice and
video traffic in cellular networks come from indoor environ-
ments. The indoor users typically get low data rates because
of poor cellular network coverage inside buildings. Into the
LTE standard [3], Femto Base Stations (Home eNB/Enterprise
eNB) are introduced to provide good coverage and high data
rates for the indoor User Equipments (UEs). These Femtos are
installed by end users who have broadband wire-line Internet
connections. In enterprise Femto networks, a large number of
Femtos are deployed in places such as office buildings and
hotspot areas. These Femtos can serve 15 to 25 UEs and
have coverage of 60 to 70 meters [4]. LTE system comprising
of legacy macro BSs and Femto BSs is called as two-tier
Heterogeneous Network (HetNet).
Different types of Femto access are defined namely open,
closed and hybrid. In open access, all UEs of a given cellular
(mobile) network operator are allowed to connect to Femto
BS, but in closed access, only authorized UEs are allowed
to connect. In hybrid access, both authorized UEs and a
limited number of other UEs can connect in a prioritized
manner. In case of enterprise networks and hotspots, Femtos
are commonly configured for open access. Fig. 1 shows the
architecture of LTE Femtocell network, where Femtos are
connected to broadband network (Internet) and then eventually
connected to Femto Gateway (F-GW) via S1 interface.
P−GW
Internet
X2
E−eNB
E−eNB
E−eNB
E−eNBX2
MME/S−GW
S1
F−GW
S1
X2
S1
X2
X2
S1
S1
S1
S1
Fig. 1. Architecture of Enterprise LTE Femtocell Network
Interference results in packet loss and low data rates [5].
Two types of interference is possible between macro and
Femto BSs of two-tier LTE HetNets namely cross-tier in-
terference and co-tier interference [5]. Cross-tier interference
occurs between macro and Femto BSs. It occurs especially
when same bandwidth (RB) is allocated to the UEs of both
macro and Femto BSs. Co-tier interference occurs when all
Femto BSs (also true for macro BSs) share the same spectrum
resources through frequency reuse one. Due to high UE den-
sity, enterprise Femto BSs experience high co-tier and cross-
2013 IEEE 9th International Conference on Wireless and Mobile Computing, Networking and Communications (WiMob)
978-1-4799-0428-0/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE 553
tier interference when compared to Femto BSs used in home
environments. In [6], three cross-tier interference management
schemes are proposed. First scheme divides spectrum between
macros and Femtos, but as number of Femtos increases the
spectrum allocated to macros decreases considerably. Second
scheme allocates the whole spectrum to both macros and Fem-
tos which can lead to high interference. In third scheme, some
part of the spectrum is shared by Femtos and macros. The
remaining spectrum is divided between macros and Femtos.
But, this scheme is efficient only if UEs count is low.
In this paper, we propose a Variable Radius (VR) algorithm
which dynamically increases or decreases the cell edge region
of Femtos logically and efficiently allocates radio Resource
Blocks (RBs) among cell edge/non-cell edge region of Femtos
so that the co-tier interference between neighboring Femtos
can be avoided in enterprise deployments. Rest of the paper
is organized as follows: Section II describes the related work.
Proposed VR algorithm is discussed in Section III. The sim-
ulation methodology and results are presented in Section IV.
Finally, Section V contains concluding remarks.
II. RELATED WORK
In this section, we review existing works addressing the
interference issues due to incorporation of Femtos into LTE
systems. In Release 8 [7], X2 interface avoids the interference
at the cell edge of two neighboring macro BSs. In this case,
eNBs share the information of RBs assigned to cell edge
UEs.In Release 11 [7], X2 interface is introduced between
Femtos of enterprise femtocell networks to avoid interference
and directly route the data and signaling messages among
Femtos, thereby reducing the load on Mobility Management
Entity (MME) of LTE core network and offers better coordi-
nation among Femtos. Two types of interference is possible in
two-tier cellular network i.e cross-tier and co-tier. Cross-tier
interference can be avoided by dividing the spectrum between
macro and Femto cells orthogonally [8], [9]. In their schemes
resources are shared between Femtos in a distributed manner
by using F-ALOHA scheme, which introduces slotting and
contention amongst Femtos. But, in this scheme spectrum can
not be reused unlike proposed VR algorithm.
Two types of frequency reuse techniques can be applied
to reduce co-tier interference. Fractional Frequency Reuse
(FFR) [10] has frequency reuse three, which means that only
one third of the spectrum is used in a particular cell and
therefore leads to inefficient usage of spectrum resource. The
other approach is Soft Frequency Reuse (SFR) [11], [12].
In SFR, the cell area is divided logically into two regions
based on spectrum allocation: an inner region where major
portion of spectrum is available and a cell edge area where a
small fraction of the spectrum is available. Since the Shannon
capacity at cell edge may be very low, it can be increased
by allocating higher power carriers to UEs in this region,
where as lower power carriers are allocated to UEs in the inner
region. But, SFR was studied only for macros. To improve the
spectrum efficiency and throughput for the indoor UEs, SFR
technique can also be adapted to enterprise Femto networks.
But the drawback of implementing SFR in Femtos is that
it can lead to high interference due to overlap of coverage
regions of Femtos. Hence, we propose an efficient interfer-
ence management technique (VR: Variable Radius algorithm)
which dynamically increases or decreases the width of cell
edge region inside the Femto coverage area to overcome the
drawback of SFR for Femtos.
III. PROPOSED WORK
In this work, we consider a two-tier HetNet comprising of
macro and Femto BSs in a LTE system. Inside the enterprise
buildings we assume that, a large number of Femtos are
deployed and configured for open access. We rely on Position
Reference Signal (PRS) [13] to get the positions of UEs
inside the buildings without GPS. We also assume that the
available spectrum is divided between macros and Femtos to
avoid cross-tier interference. But, co-tier interference can exist
among Femtos due to reuse factor one and overlap of coverage
regions. To reduce this co-tier interference in enterprise Femto
networks, two logical regions namely inner and outer region
are assumed inside the Femto coverage area as shown in
Fig. 2. The radius of inner region (and hence the width of
outer region) changes dynamically. These regions are created
logically due to changes in the power transmitted and the
average CQI values, but only created virtually by the Femtos
in the proposed VR algorithm.
F
Outer region (Cell Edge)
Inner region
Fig. 2. Regions inside Femto coverage area
Every Femto communicates about the RBs allocated to its
cell edge UEs with neighboring Femtos through X2 interface.
Femto allocates RBs to its UEs in outer region such that same
RBs are not allocated in the outer regions of its neighboring
Femtos, thus avoiding the interference. Such an allocation is
known as restricted RB allocation. But, since the delay to get
the required number of RBs increases, the average throughput
for cell edge UEs decrease. For the UEs of inner region, there
is no such restriction on RB allocation, unlike cell edge users.
Any free RB can be allocated to them.
Let us consider an enterprise Femto deployment scenario
with six Femtos namely F1-F6 and randomly placed UEs as
shown in Fig. 3 for describing the proposed VR algorithm.
The two scenarios of it are given below.
Interference Scenario 1: Initially the width of outer region
is zero. In this case, interference occurs if the cell edge
UEs in overlapping regions of neighboring Femtos use the
554
same RBs. This results in decrement of data rate and CQI
due to poor signal-to-interference-to-noise ratio (SINR) value.
According to 3GPP TS [36.301], the CQI values vary from 1
to 15. Active UEs provide CQI feedback to Femto at regular
intervals. Femto transmits data with higher modulation scheme
like 64-QAM if the UE has higher CQI value. In consummate
circumstances caused by very high interference, CQI value
becomes zero and the UE may not able to transmit any data.
To reduce this interference, the radius of the inner region
is decreased which inturn increases the width of the outer
region as shown in Fig. 3. To determine the average CQI
of an UE at a distance dfrom the Femto center, firstly an
inner and an outer circle are drawn with the radius as (d-
δ) and (d+δ), respectively as shown in Fig. 4. The width
of the resultant strip is 2δ(in our experiments, δis taken as
0.5 m). Secondly, the average of the CQI of all UEs within
this strip is calculated and this value is assigned to the UE
at distance d. The average CQI is calculated and assigned
similarly to every UE at any distance from the Femto within
the radius of inner region. Thirdly, the average CQI of all
UEs is sorted in increasing order. Fourthly, the first UE whose
average CQI value is greater than a threshold CQI value is
identified (in our experiments, the threshold CQI is set as
4). The distance of this identified UE from the Femto is the
threshold distance and is named γ. Finally, bisection method
is used to calculate the mean of the inner region radius rand
the threshold distance γas r=(r+γ)/2.
This mean value (r) is the radius of the inner region. By
using X2 interface the interference is avoided in the outer
region by exchanging signaling messages between neighboring
Femtos for restricted RB allocation. Bisection method is used
in general to find the roots of a polynomial. Here Bisection
method is used to find the approximate radius value for which
the average CQI value at the given radius is equivalent to
threshold value.
Using mean value helps us to decrease the effective inner
radius from R (cell radius) to r. The advantage of calculating
the mean over considering the threshold distance γ, as radius,
is that when the threshold distance is very small, a large
number of UEs reside in outer region which may lead to
unfair allocation of RBs to the cell edge UEs, as very less
amount of RBs are catered to cell edge UEs, due to restricted
allocation. The threshold CQI value for contraction is the
CQI used for indoor data traffic handover i.e., less than -3 dB
in terms of SINR. [14] gives the mapping of SINR to CQI.
Interference Scenario 2: When the number of UEs in the
outer region increases drastically, due to restricted RB allo-
cation, many RB requests from UEs of the outer region may
not get satisfied. This leads to dramatic decrease in the system
throughput. In order to overcome this problem, the inner region
has to be expanded to accommodate the excess UEs of the
outer region as shown in Fig. 5.
Depending upon the fail ratio (FR) the radius increases,
where FR is defined as, FR =RejectedRequests(RR)
AcceptedRequests(AR), where
RR is the number of unsatisfied requests coming from outer
Outer Region (−−−) : High TX Power
Inner Region(white) : Low TX power
***
*
*
*
*
*
**
*
*
**
**
**
*
**
*
*
*
*
***
*
*
*
*
*
*
**
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
**
F1
F4
F6
F7
F3
*: User
x2
x2
x2 F2
*x2
x2
x2
x2
x2
F5 *
x2
x2
: E−eNB
Fig. 3. Reducing the inner regions of Femtos
 

 
Fig. 4. Calculating Avg CQI value in the strip
***
*
*
*
*
*
**
*
*
**
**
**
*
**
*
*
*
*
***
*
*
*
*
*
*
**
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
**
F1
F4
F6
F7
F3
: E−eNB
*: User
x2
x2
x2 F2
*x2
x2
x2
x2
x2
F5 *
x2
x2
Fig. 5. Increasing the Inner regions of Femtos
region due to restricted RB allocation and AR is the number
of requests coming from outer region that can be satisfied in
some subframe. Due to unavailability of RBs certain requests
cannot be satisfied in a particular subframe and these requests
555
are excluded in AR. The radius of inner region will remain the
same if FR is less than or equal to the threshold value and this
value can be set by the network operator. If FR is greater than
threshold value, the radius of inner region is increased. The
radius is incremented by δsuch that RR(AR/2) unsatisfied
UEs from outer region are brought into the inner region. Thus,
the excess UEs of outer region are brought into the inner
region and the FR reduces below FR Threshold. Hence,
the UE load in the outer region reduces and the throughput
increases. The proposed VR algorithm (refer Algorithm 1) will
therefore reduces the interference efficiently in a large scale
deployment of Femto networks.
Algorithm 1 Variable Radius Algorithm
Input CQI Threshold :Handover CQI threshold
Input FR Threshold :Threshold Fail Ratio
Input R:Radius of Femto
0: rR{Initialize Radius of Inner Region}
while true do
CQI CalculateCQIInnerRegion(); {Calculates
average CQI for a given inner region }
if ( CQI <CQI Threshold )then
DecreaseRadius true;
else
DecreaseRadius false;
end if
FR Cal culateF RU EsOuterReg ion(); {Calculates
Fail Ratio of UEs in cell edge region }
if (FR>FR Threshold )then
IncreaseRadius true;
else
IncreaseRadius false;
end if
if ((IncreaseRadius) && (DecreaseRadius)) || ((!In-
creaseRadius) && (!DecreaseRadius)) then
Continue;
else
if ( DecreaseRadius && !IncreaseRadius ) then
CQI array Sort(CQI inner region)
γSearch(CQI array){finds threshold distance
γof the first UE whose AVG CQI along circumfer-
ence of circle with radius d>CQI Threshold }
r(r+γ)/2;{(where δis the width of the region
containing users whose AVG CQI <CQI T hreshold)}
PFScheduling(); {Proportional Fair Algorithm}
else
rr+δ;{(where δwill bring RR-(AR/2)
unsatisfied users of outer region nearest to the boundary
between inner and outer regions into inner region)}
PFScheduling();
end if
end if
end while
end
TABLE I
SIMULATION PARAMETERS
Parameters Values
Number of Femto cells 6
Number of UEs per Femto 10, 15
UE Deployment Random
Femto coverage range 70 m
Femto BandWidth 5 MHz (25 RBs)
Duplexing Mode FDD
Scheduling Algorithm PF, VR+PF
Simulated Traffic Downlink (Video)
Mobility of Mobile UEs 1m/s
Mobility of Static UEs 0.1m/s
Mobility Model Building Mobility Model
Application Data Rate 4 Mbps
Frame Duration 10 ms
TTI 1ms
1020
1040
1060
1080
1100
1120
1140
1160
1180
1200
1220
900 950 1000 1050 1100 1150 1200 1250
Position in Y-axis
Position in X-axis
F3
F5
F6
F1
F4
F2
Femto(F)
Users
Fig. 6. Positions of six Femtos with 90 UEs
IV. SIMULATION METHODOLOGY AND RESULTS
In NS-3 simulator six apartment buildings scenario is cre-
ated and in each apartment one Femto is placed randomly.
Simulation parameters are given in the Table 1. The VR
algorithm is implemented in NS-3 on top of the Proportional
Fair (PF) scheduling algorithm to ensure fairness to all the
UEs. We modified the building mobility model in NS-3 to
introduce limited mobility for indoor UEs. We restrict the users
from entering into the other room, as we are not dealing with
handovers in this work. In real life, even static users will have
some mobility. In order to replicate the same scenario in the
simulator, we assigned the mobility rate as 0.1 m/s even for
the static users. Each UE has single downlink flow from its
connected Femto. The CQI Threshold is the CQI value used
for indoor data traffic handover. It varies between 4 and 6 and
it is less than -3db in terms of SINR. The FR Threshold
is set as 0.5. The metrics used for performance evaluation
are area spectrum efficiency in b/s/hz/m*m and throughput in
Mbps. The results shown in this work are the averaged values
after running simulations for 10 different seed values. Fig. 6
shows the positions of 90 indoor UEs (6 Femtos and 15 UEs
in each Femto).
556
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
CDF interms of Users
Throughput in Mbps
PF With No VR & No Mobility 60 users
VR+PF With No Mobility 60 users
FFR With No Mobility 60 user
Fig. 7. Throughput for 60 static UEs inside the building
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
CDF interms of Users
Throughput in Mbps
PF With No VR & No Mobility 90 users
VR+PF With No Mobility 90 users
FFR With No Mobility 90 user
Fig. 8. Throughput of 90 static UEs inside the building
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
CDF interms of Users
Throughput in Mbps
PF With No VR & Mobility 60 users
VR+PF With Mobility 60 users
FFR With Mobility 60 user
Fig. 9. Throughput of 60 mobile UEs inside the building
1. Throughput Results: In Figs. 7 and 8, average throughput
of VR+PF algorithm is compared against classic PF scheduling
and FFR for 60 and 90 static UEs (i.e., one flow per UE),
respectively. Average throughput for 60 static UEs is increased
by 27% when VR algorithm is employed in PF. For 90 static
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8
CDF interms of Users
Throughput in Mbps
PF With No VR & Mobility 90 users
VR+PF With Mobility 90 users
FFR With Mobility 90 user
Fig. 10. Throughput of 90 mobile UEs inside the building
0
2e-06
4e-06
6e-06
8e-06
1e-05
1.2e-05
1.4e-05
1.6e-05
1.8e-05
1 2 3 4 5 6
Area Spectral Efficiency in b/s/hz/m*m
Femto ID
VR+PF With No Mobility 60 users
PF With No VR & No Mobility 60 users
FFR With No Mobility 60 user
Fig. 11. Area Spectrum Efficiency of Femtos with 60 static UEs
indoor UEs, the average throughput is increased by 29%
when VR algorithm is employed in PF. In Figs. 9 and 10,
achieved throughput of VR+PF algorithm is compared against
PF and FFR for 60 and 90 mobile UEs, respectively. Average
throughput for 60 mobile UEs is increased by 37% when
VR+PF algorithm is used. For 90 UEs the average throughput
is increased by 38% when VR+PF algorithm is used. Since
the inner region radius changes dynamically more number of
UEs can be served by the inner region and thus it increases
the average throughput. Bisection method makes sure that UEs
who are supposed to be in the outer region will come inside
the inner region, even though they have interference with
neighboring Femtos. It is observed that proposed VR algorithm
also performs better in mobile scenarios because UEs mobility
there is enough potential for interference management and load
balancing in outer regions and the average CQI values of UEs
with high mobility vary at much faster rate when compared
to UEs with low mobility.
2. Area Spectrum Efficiency Results: In Figs. 11 and 12,
area spectral efficiency of VR+PF, PF and FFR are compared
for 60 and 90 static UEs, respectively. In Figs. 13 and 14,
area spectral efficiency of VR+PF and PF are compared for
557
1e-06
2e-06
3e-06
4e-06
5e-06
6e-06
7e-06
8e-06
9e-06
1 2 3 4 5 6
Area Spectral Efficiency in b/s/hz/m*m
Femto ID
VR+PF With No Mobility 90 users
PF With No VR & No Mobility 90 users
FFR With No Mobility 90 user
Fig. 12. Area Spectrum Efficiency of Femtos with 90 static UEs
0
2e-06
4e-06
6e-06
8e-06
1e-05
1.2e-05
1.4e-05
1.6e-05
1.8e-05
1 2 3 4 5 6
Area Spectral Efficiency in b/s/hz/m*m
Femto ID
VR+PF With Mobility 60 users
PF With No VR & Mobility 60 users
FFR With Mobility 60 user
Fig. 13. Area Spectrum Efficiency of Femtos with 60 mobile UEs
1e-06
2e-06
3e-06
4e-06
5e-06
6e-06
7e-06
8e-06
9e-06
1e-05
1.1e-05
1 2 3 4 5 6
Area Spectral Efficiency in b/s/hz/m*m
Femto ID
VR+PF With Mobility 90 users
PF With No VR & Mobility 90 users
FFR With Mobility 90 user
Fig. 14. Area Spectrum Efficiency of Femtos with 90 mobile UEs
60 and 90 mobile UEs, respectively. In order to be more
precise, area spectral efficiency of each of six Femto is plotted
separately in the graphs. Area spectral efficiency of Femtos
has increased considerably as the interference is avoided in
the outer overlapping regions of Femtos by restricted RB
allocation with the help of communication over X2 interface.
V. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK
The proposed VR algorithm dynamically increases or de-
creases the radius of inner regions to avoid co-tier interference
among Femto BSs. All Femtos need not increase/decrease
their inner region radius by same amount at the same time
as VR algorithm depends on the user count and overlap with
neighboring Femtos. In VR, using FR the radius of inner
region is increased. We intend to determine the optimal value
of FR in our future work. We also have to define a function to
vary δbased on UE density. Also, the proposed VR needs to
be modified to include the cases of handovers between Femtos.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This work was supported by the Deity, Govt of India (Grant
No. 13(6)/2010CC&BT).
REFERENCES
[1] S. Nielsen, “Lte evolving towards local area in release 12 and beyond.”
Future Radio in 3GPP, Nokia Corporation, 2012.
[2] “Views on rel-12 and onwards for lte and umts.” Future Radio in 3GPP,
Huawei Technologies, 2012.
[3] “Small Cells Forum.” http://smallcellforum.org/smallcellforum.
[4] “Enterprise multi-femtocell deployment guidelines.” Qualcomm Inc.,
2011.
[5] N. Saquib, E. Hossain, L. B. Le, and D. I. Kim, “Interference man-
agement in ofdma femtocell networks: Issues and approaches,” IEEE
Wireless Communications, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 86–95, 2012.
[6] M. Andrews, V. Capdevielle, A. Feki, and P. Gupta, “Autonomous
spectrum sharing for mixed lte femto and macro cells deployments,” in
IEEE INFOCOM Conference on Computer Communications Workshops,
2010, pp. 1–5, 2010.
[7] “3GPP Releases.” http://www.3gpp.org/releases.
[8] V. Chandrasekhar and J. Andrews, “Spectrum allocation in tiered cellular
networks,” IEEE Transactions on Communications, vol. 57, no. 10,
pp. 3059–3068, 2009.
[9] J. Yoon, M. Y. Arslan, K. Sundaresan, S. V. Krishnamurthy, and
S. Banerjee, “A distributed resource management framework for inter-
ference mitigation in ofdma femtocell networks,” in ACM MOBIHOC
2012, pp. 233–242, 2012.
[10] P. Lee, T. Lee, J. Jeong, and J. Shin, “Interference management in lte
femtocell systems using fractional frequency reuse,” in The 12th Inter-
national Conference on Advanced Communication Technology (ICACT
2010), vol. 2, pp. 1047–1051, IEEE, 2010.
[11] Y. Yu, E. Dutkiewicz, X. Huang, M. Mueck, and G. Fang, “Performance
analysis of soft frequency reuse for inter-cell interference coordination
in lte networks,” in International Symposium on Communications and
Information Technologies (ISCIT 2010), pp. 504–509, 2010.
[12] M. Al-Shalash, F. Khafizov, and Z. Chao, “Interference constrained soft
frequency reuse for uplink icic in lte networks,” in IEEE PIMRC 2010,
pp. 1882–1887, 2010.
[13] J. A. del Peral-Rosado, J. A. L´
opez-Salcedo, G. Seco-Granados,
F. Zanier, and M. Crisci, “Joint channel and time delay estimation for
lte positioning reference signals,” in 6th ESA Workshop on NAVITEC
2012, pp. 1–8, 2012.
[14] M. T. Kawser, N. I. B. Hamid, M. N. Hasan, M. S. Alam, and M. M.
Rahman, “Downlink snr to cqi mapping for different multiple antenna
techniques in lte,” in International Conference on Future Information
Technology (ICFIT 2010), 2010.
558
... The Variable Radius algorithm (VRA) proposed in [40] overcomes the shortcomings of SFR scheme in non-sectorized enterprise Femto networks scenarios where UE count is very low. In this scheme the region covered by a FBS has been divided into two virtual regions, viz., inner and outer. ...
... The VRA proposed in [40] is applicable only to nonsectorized Femtos, and an extension of VRA that is equipped to deal with higher order sectorization will certainly increase the capacity of dense LTE HetNets. We extend the VRA for sectorized FBS, and call it Sectorized VRA (SVRA). ...
... FFR-FI with the mentioned constraint reduces the intrasector interference in the AE. The proposed SVRA uses these interference management techniques in AE and OAE scenarios in combination combined with the baseline VRA [40] for the sectorized FBS. ...
Article
Full-text available
Femto Cells offer higher data rates to users within closed spaces. Dense deployment of small cells is a characteristic of pre-5G/LTE-Advanced Pro (LTE-A Pro) networks and is a precursor to the future 5G cellular networks. Combined with a Frequency Reuse Factor (FRF) of one, the dense small cell systems result in high co-tier interference which is undesirable. High interference Optimized scheduling decisions and interference management techniques are required to guarantee certain minimum data rates to the users at the cell-edge and increase the overall throughput of the system. This work presents a centralized scheduling approach that mitigates the detrimental impact of interference, thereby maximizing the overall throughput of the system. In doing so, we make use of concepts from Social theory and incorporate these ideas in the solution design. The centralized approach uses optimized scheduling algorithm (RAPTA) which takes feedback from the indoor users of all Femtos as the input and formulates a Mixed Integer Non-Linear Programming (MINLP) problem. Thereafter, the MINLP problem is relaxed and its solution carries out the Resource Block allocation and ensures optimal power transmission for every allocated resource block in all Femtos. We implement the proposed OPT algorithm on top of Proportional Fair (PF) in the Vienna Simulator. Since the RAPTA is NP-Hard and takes a considerably long time to solve the MINLP problem, we derive from it a polynomial time Heuristic algorithm (RAPTAP) which performs Resource Block allocation and sub-optimal Power transmission quite close to the RAPTA algorithm in terms of performance. RAPTAP is a two-stage approach each of which is inspired by ideas from two different strands of Sociological theory. We demonstrate through experiments that the proposed RAPTA + PF achieves 60.67% improvement in the services offered to the mobile users when compared to the classic PF algorithm with Soft Fractional Frequency Reuse (SFFR) interference management technique in the built environment. The Socio-inspired RAPTAP performs almost as well as the RAPTA + PF algorithm, with only a marginal 4% drop in the overall system throughput as compared to the latter. Further, we evaluate the RAPTAP heuristic in scenarios involving mobile users and demonstrate 14.52% improvement when compared to classic PF algorithm with Fractional Frequency Reuse-Full Isolation (FFR-FI) interference management. Finally, we compare the proposed Socio-inspired RAPTAP + PF with two state-of-the-art algorithms, viz., a Genetic Algorithm approach to resource allocation (NSGA-UDN) and a recent work on LTE-Unlicensed (LTE-U) + PF. Proposed Socio-inspired solution outperforms the LTE-U + PF and NSGA-UDN by 28.26% and 31.41%, respectively, in terms of throughput.
... Moreover, users association with an FBS can also change with time based on the access mode implemented at the FBS. Various solutions have been presented in literatures to address the CCI issue including the fractional frequency reuse (FFR) [2,3], where fixed orthogonal frequency bands are assigned to macrocell and femtocell users, soft frequency reuse where different frequency bands are used in the inner and outer regions of macro/femto cells [4][5][6], dynamic frequency reuse where resource allocated to macro and femto networks changes dynamically to cope CCI [7,8], and access control where strongly interfering macro users are transferred to femto network to avoid CCI [1,9]. Several other CCI mitigation schemes are also presented in literatures such as time division multiple access (TDMA) based approach to share same spectrum in time, power control on femto base station to reduce CCI [10,11], interference cancellation using multiple-input-multiple-output (MIMO) techniques [12,13], Q-learning based approach for self organization [14], interference decoding [15,16] and cognitive radios (CR) for sharing of spectrum by regarding femtocell user as secondary user. ...
... Resource sharing among FBSs is in underlay mode and are deployed in open access mode. The radius of the inner region also affects the CCI and overall system performance of the multi-region cellular designs as has been studied in [4,5], but optimizing the size of the inner region of macrocell is beyond the scope of this research and therefore without loss of generality an inner region with size of 0.7r M is considered for the study as per [3]. ...
... In this section, the performance of the proposed scheme is verified by simulations under LTE system parameters [5,38]. The detailed simulation parameters are given in Table 1. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, we propose a novel resource allocation scheme for co-channel interference avoidance in LTE heterogeneous networks with universal spectrum reuse where both macro users (MUs) and cognitive femto base stations (FBSs) within the same macrocell coverage can dynamically reuse whole spectrum. Specifically, resource blocks (RBs) are shared between cognitive FBSs in underlay mode while the resource sharing among FBSs and MUs is in overlay mode. The macrocell is divided into inner and outer regions with the inner region further divided into three sectors. The proposed scheme addresses co-channel interference (CCI) by employing fractional frequency reuse (FFR) for RB allocation in the outer region of the macrocell and increase the distance of users that reuse the same RB within the macrocell. Part of RBs are allocated to the outer region of the macrocell with a FFR factor of 1/3, while the remaining RBs are dynamically allocated to each sector in the inner region of macrocell based on MUs demand to efficiently utilize the available spectrum. A basic macro base station (MBS) assistance is required by the FBS in selection of suitable RB to avoid interference with MU in each sector. With the proposed solution, both macro and femto users can dynamically access the whole spectrum while having minimum bandwidth guarantee even under fully congested scenarios. Moreover, the proposed scheme practically eliminates the cross-tier interference and the CCI problem in heterogeneous network reduces to inter-femtocell interference. The throughput and outage performances of the proposed scheme are validated through extensive simulations under LTE network parameters. Simulation results show that the proposed scheme achieves a performance gain of more than 1.5 dB in terms of SINRs of both macro user and femto user compared to traditional cognitive and non-cognitive schemes without bandwidth guarantee for femtocells.
... This can be avoided by using the Frequency Division Duplex (FDD) mode. In [28], the authors proposed a Variable Radius algorithm for the enhanced distribution of resources and interference management in a LTE femtocell network. The scenario considered the femtocell's open access mode, where all users are authorized to connect to the femtocell network. ...
... When testing the performance of MLICOS1 and MLICOS2, it was compared with that of the Proportional Fair (PF), Variable Radius + Proportional Fair (VR+PF) [28], and a Cognitive Approach (CA) [23]. The performance was assessed in terms of QoS parameter throughput, delay and PLR. ...
Article
Full-text available
The exponential demand for multimedia services is one reason behind the substantial growth of mobile data traffic. Video traffic patterns have significantly changed in the past two years due to the coronavirus disease (COVID-19). The worldwide pandemic has caused many individuals to work from home and use various online video platforms (e.g., Zoom, Google Meet, and Microsoft Teams). As a result, overloaded macrocells are unable to ensure high Quality of Experience (QoE) to all users. Heterogeneous Networks (HetNets) consisting of small cells (femtocells) and macrocells are a promising solution to mitigate this problem. A critical challenge with the deployment of femtocells in HetNets is the interference management between Macro Base Stations (MBSs), Femto Base Stations (FBSs), and between FBS and FBS. Indeed, the dynamic deployment of femtocells can lead to co-tier interference. With the rolling out of the 5G mobile network, it becomes imperative for mobile operators to maintain network capacity and manage different types of interference. Machine Learning (ML) is considered a promising solution to many challenges in 5G HetNets. In this paper, we propose a Machine Learning Interference Classification and Offloading Scheme (MLICOS) to address the problem of co-tier interference between femtocells for video delivery. Two versions of MLICOS, namely, MLICOS1 and MLICOS2, are proposed. The former uses conventional ML classifiers while the latter employs advanced ML algorithms. Both versions of MLICOS are compared with the classic Proportional Fair (PF) scheduling algorithm, Variable Radius and Proportional Fair scheduling (VR+PF) algorithm, and a Cognitive Approach (CA). The ML models are assessed based on the prediction accuracy, precision, recall and F-measure. Simulation results show that MLICOS outperforms the other schemes by providing the highest throughput and the lowest delay and packet loss ratio. A statistical analysis was also carried out to depict the degree of interference faced by users when different schemes are employed.
... As a result, decisions regarding channel selection may be delayed or inaccurate. To solve this problem, we propose to use supervised learning as a tool to model the complex interactions between PHY and MAC layers based on factors such as the power and PHY rate of a neighboring Wi-Fi link [130][131][132][133]. -Efficient Radio Resource Allocation Using Reinforcement Learning In the fifth generation (5G) of mobile broadband band systems, Radio Resources Management (RRM) has reached unprecedented levels of complexity. ...
Article
Full-text available
With the exponential increase in mobile users, mobile data demand has grown tremendously. To meet these demands, cellular operators are constantly innovating to enhance the capacity of cellular systems. Consequently, operators have been reusing the licensed spectrum “spatially,” by deploying 4G/Long-term Evolution (LTE) small cells (e.g., Femto Cells) in the past. However, despite the use of small cells, the licensed spectrum will be unable to meet the consistently rising data traffic because of data-intensive applications such as augmented reality/virtual reality (AR/VR) and on-the-go high-definition video streaming. Applications such as AR/VR and online gaming not only place extreme data demands on the network but are also latency-critical. To meet the QoS guarantees, cellular operators have begun leveraging the unlicensed spectrum by coexisting with Wi-Fi in the 5 GHz band. The standardizing body Third Generation Partnership Project, has prescribed cellular standards for fair unlicensed coexistence with Wi-Fi, namely LTE Licensed Assisted Access (LAA), New Radio in unlicensed (NR-U), and NR in Millimeter. The rapid roll-out of LAA deployments in developed nations like the USA offers an opportunity to study and analyze the performance of unlicensed coexistence networks through real-world ground truth. Thus, this paper presents a high-level overview of past, present, and future of research in small cell and unlicensed coexistence communication technologies. It outlines the vision for future research work in the recently allocated unlicensed spectrum: The 6 GHz band, where the latest Wi-Fi standard, IEEE 802.11ax, will coexist with the latest cellular technology, 5G New Radio in unlicensed. At the end, we present a comparison of the performance between standards ranging from LTE to NR-U based on realistic assumptions.
... The overall performance of MLICOS is is compared to PF, VR + PF [23], and CA [24] schemes in terms of QoE, estimated using PSNR and SSIM metrics. PSNR examines frames of the received video with respect to a reference video by computing signal-to-noise-ratio-value. ...
... A heterogeneous network (HetNet) consists of a Macro cell augmented with various types of small cells to address the challenge of enhancing system capacity and coverage. Examples of small cells are micro cell, pico cell, relay, Remote Radio Head (RRH), Femto, Licensed Assisted Access (LAA), New Radio in Unlicensed (NR-U), and Femto cell [3,4] as shown in Fig. 1. Table 1 shows characteristics of various types of cells. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
To boost the capacity of the cellular system, the operators have started to reuse the same licensed spectrum by deploying 4G LTE small cells (Femto Cells) in the past. But in time, these small cell licensed spectrum is not sufficient to satisfy future applications like augmented reality (AR)and virtual reality (VR). Hence, cellular operators look for alternate unlicensed spectrum in Wi-Fi 5 GHz band, later 3GPP named as LTE Licensed Assisted Access (LAA). The recent and current rollout of LAA deployments (in developed nations like the US) provides an opportunity to understand coexistence profound ground truth. This paper discusses a high-level overview of my past, present, and future research works in the direction of small cell benefits. In the future, we shift the focus onto the latest unlicensed band: 6 GHz, where the latest Wi-Fi version, 802.11ax, will coexist with the latest cellular technology, 5G New Radio(NR) in unlicensed
... where , , and ∆f are the Femto-cell transmission power, transmitter gain, and the frequency shift, respectively. Aside from that, [16] proposed to divide the Femto-cell coverage area into two regions namely inner and outer, whereby initially the outer region width equals to zero until the Channel Quality Identifier (CQI) level degrades below the CQIT hreshold. Users send frequent CQI readings to the FBS, the FBS later assigns higher modulation scheme to users bearing CQI levels. ...
Article
Full-text available
Future cellular communication will relentlessly and incessantly hinge upon heterogeneous network due to its’ capabilities in maintaining lofty capacity figures. It also strengthens the voice quality, accelerate data transmission, and optimize the users’ battery onsumption. However, its performance is often debatable due to the interference that may accompany its service. This paper focuses on studying the interference that affixes Femto-cells as an entity of eterogeneous networks due to its appealing functionalities and performance qualities. Moreover, the paper categorizes the types of interference based on the network platform and its source, discusses different contributions related to the topic based on schemes’ efficiencies and complexity levels, and presents the most decent and stable scheme from the authors’ prospective of view.
... The effectiveness of SCN architecture and SCGM has been verified through simulation results. In this study, FBSs are assumed to provide resources over a shared spectrum and operate in an open subscriber group (OSG) mode [5]. Randomly deployed and turned on and off by users, FBSs are characterized by a high level of randomness. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
With the exponential increase in mobile users, the mobile data demand has grown tremendously. To meet these demands, cellular operators are constantly innovating to enhance the capacity of cellular systems. Consequently, operators have been reusing the licensed spectrum spatially, by deploying 4G/LTE small cells (e.g., Femto Cells) in the past. However, despite the use of small cells, licensed spectrum will be unable to meet the consistently rising data traffic because of data-intensive applications such as augmented reality or virtual reality (AR/VR) and on-the-go high-definition video streaming. Applications such AR/VR and online gaming not only place extreme data demands on the network, but are also latency-critical. To meet the QoS guarantees, cellular operators have begun leveraging the unlicensed spectrum by coexisting with Wi-Fi in the 5 GHz band. The standardizing body 3GPP, has prescribed cellular standards for fair unlicensed coexistence with Wi-Fi, namely LTE Licensed Assisted Access (LAA), New Radio in unlicensed (NR-U), and NR in Millimeter. The rapid roll-out of LAA deployments in developed nations like the US, offers an opportunity to study and analyze the performance of unlicensed coexistence networks through real-world ground truth. Thus, this paper presents a high-level overview of past, present, and future of the research in small cell and unlicensed coexistence communication technologies. It outlines the vision for future research work in the recently allocated unlicensed spectrum: The 6 GHz band, where the latest Wi-Fi standard, IEEE 802.11ax, will coexist with the latest cellular technology, 5G New Radio (NR) in unlicensed.
Chapter
Driven by the continuous growth of wireless and mobile communication users, Long Term Evolution (LTE) and Long Term evolution-Advanced (LTE-A) have taken up densification of network as a new paradigm to meet the growing capacity demands. Small cells come with the advantage of enhanced coverage in indoor and hard reach areas and offer traffic offloading capacity in hotspots. However, there are challenges of interference management and self-adaptability with the overlaying macro cellular network since most small cell base stations are user deployed and do not have centralized control on their configuration and operation. The purpose of this chapter is to elaborate the concept of heterogeneous network and Self Organization Network (SON) in LTE-A. The various use cases of SON that can benefit the heterogeneous network have been discussed laying emphasis on interference management use case. Further the current trend of research in this field has been highlighted. It provides a holistic picture of the heterogeneous network and SON in LTE-A and upcoming mobile communication generations.
Article
Full-text available
One of the effective techniques of improving the coverage and enhancing the capacity and data rate in cellular wireless networks is to reduce the cell size (i.e., cell splitting) and transmission distances. Therefore, the concept of deploying femtocells over macrocell has recently attracted growing interests in academia, industry, and standardization forums. Various technical challenges towards mass deployment of femtocells have been addressed in recent literature. Interference mitigation between neighboring femtocells and between the femtocell and macrocell is considered to be one of the major challenges in femtocell networks because femtocells share the same licensed frequency spectrum with macrocell. Further, the conventional radio resource management techniques for hierarchical cellular system is not suitable for femtocell networks since the positions of the femtocells are random depending on the users' service requirement. In this article, we provide a survey of the different state-of-the-art approaches for interference and resource management in orthogonal frequency-division multiple access (OFDMA)-based femtocell networks. A qualitative comparison among the different approaches is provided. To this end, open challenges in designing interference management schemes for OFDMA femtocell networks are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
Next generation wireless networks (i.e., WiMAX, LTE) provide higher bandwidth and spectrum efficiency leveraging smaller (femto) cells with orthogonal frequency division multiple access (OFDMA). The uncoordinated, dense deployments of femtocells however, pose several unique challenges relating to interference and resource management in these networks. Towards addressing these challenges, we propose RADION, a distributed resource management framework that effectively manages interference across femtocells. RADION's core building blocks enable femtocells to opportunistically find the available resources in a completely distributed and efficient manner. Further, RADION's modular nature paves the way for different resource management solutions to be incorporated in the framework. We implement RADION on a real WiMAX femtocell testbed deployed in a typical indoor setting. We extensively evaluate two solutions integrated with RADION, both via prototype implementation and simulations and quantify their performance in terms of quick and efficient self-organization.
Article
Full-text available
Long Term Evolution (LTE) is a step towards the 4th generation (4G) of radio technologies designed to increase the capacity and speed of mobile wireless access. In Release 8, LTE was standardized by 3GPP as the successor of the Universal Mobile Telecommunication System (UMTS).Before full commercial deployment of LTE, downlink SNR to CQI mapping for different multiple antenna techniques can be of enormous significance for the operators. Such vital RF parameters should be tuned before full-fledged commercial launch. In LTE, Adaptive Modulation and Coding (AMC) has to ensure a BLER value smaller than 10%. The SNR-to-CQI mapping is required to achieve this goal. In this paper, Downlink SNR to CQI Mapping for LTE has been performed for Flat Rayleigh channel in fast fading in different transmission modes considering HARQ.
Conference Paper
The ranging performance of the Long Term Evolution (LTE) positioning reference signal (PRS) is enhanced with respect to traditional correlation-based approaches in multipath channels. For that purpose, a joint maximum likelihood (ML) channel and time delay estimation is introduced for the PRS signal. The estimation can be implemented by using the least-squares (LS) criterion that benefits from the multicarrier flexible waveform. Preliminary results are shown with a comparison of the root-mean-square error (RMSE) of this ML estimator and the corresponding Cramér-Rao Bound (CRB) expression for a specific urban pedestrian channel model.
Article
Two-tier networks, comprising a conventional cellular network overlaid with shorter range hotspots (e.g. femtocells, distributed antennas, or wired relays), offer an economically viable way to improve cellular system capacity. The capacity-limiting factor in such networks is interference. The cross-tier interference between macrocells and femtocells can suffocate the capacity due to the near-far problem, so in practice hotspots should use a different frequency channel than the potentially nearby high-power macrocell users. Centralized or coordinated frequency planning, which is difficult and inefficient even in conventional cellular networks, is all but impossible in a two-tier network. This paper proposes and analyzes an optimum decentralized spectrum allocation policy for two-tier networks that employ frequency division multiple access (including OFDMA). The proposed allocation is optimal in terms of area spectral efficiency (ASE), and is subjected to a sensible quality of service (QoS) requirement, which guarantees that both macrocell and femtocell users attain at least a prescribed data rate. Results show the dependence of this allocation on the QoS requirement, hotspot density and the co-channel interference from the macrocell and femtocells. Design interpretations are provided.
Conference Paper
Careful management of inter-cell interference is important in OFDMA based systems such as LTE. In this paper, we study an uplink ICIC (Inter-cell Interference Coordination) mechanism, which fully utilizes the flexibility of frequency selective scheduling and rate adaptation, while dynamically limiting the interference experienced by the neighboring cells. This technique can be seen as an extension of soft frequency reuse SFR, which has been widely studied for the downlink. The proposed technique provides a flexible and efficient way of sharing resources between the cell-edge and cell-center users, without the need to strictly classify each UE into one of these categories. It avoids the loss of trunking efficiency inherent in static classification of users according to their geographical location within the serving cell. We analyze the proposed method, and evaluate its performance using system level simulations. The simulation results illustrate the effectiveness of our method.
Conference Paper
Due to the requirement of high spectrum efficiency, the frequency reuse of one is targeted for next generation OFDMA-based cellular networks. Such a frequency planning strategy can lead to unacceptable inter-cell interference levels experienced especially by users located at the cell edge area. Soft frequency reuse (SFR) is considered as an effective frequency reuse scheme for inter-cell interference coordination as well as maintaining spectrum efficiency. In this paper, we investigate the performance of SFR for LTE downlink transmission by considering issues of various traffic loads and different power ratio configurations. In addition to the cell-edge user performance, the overall cell performance and the cell-center user performance are both evaluated in terms of throughput estimation. Using simulation studies, the advantages and limitations of SFR are comprehensively examined and compared against the classical frequency reuse of one scheme.
Conference Paper
We consider the problem of sharing spectrum between different base stations in an OFDM network where some cells have a small radius. Such scenarios will become increasingly common in fourth generation networks where the need for ubiquitous high-speed coverage will lead to an increased use of small cells as well as indoor femtocells. Our aim is to devise autonomous algorithms for small cells and femtocells to choose spectrum so that they can achieve high data rates without causing interference to users in the traditional macro cells. We present a number of algorithms that perform combinations of frequency and time sharing based on the channel conditions reported by the mobile users. Our schemes bear some resemblance to the traditional 802.11 MAC algorithms. However, they differ in the fact that they are able to use better information about channel conditions from the mobiles and they are allowed to adjust the amount of spectrum that they are using. We evaluate our schemes using a platform that combines a physical-layer ray-tracing tool for indoor and outdoor environments with an upper layer OFDM simulation tool. We believe that this type of simulation capability will become increasingly important as cellular networks target the provision of high-speed performance in dense urban environments. Our results suggest that user channel quality measurements can be used to set the level of sharing between femtocells and macrocells and that finding the correct level of sharing is important for optimal network performance.
Conference Paper
Recently, Long Term Evolution (LTE) has developed a femtocell for indoor coverage extension. However, interference problem between the femtocell and the macrocell should be solved in advance. In this paper, we propose an interference management scheme in the LTE femtocell systems using Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR). Under the macrocell allocating frequency band by the FFR, the femtocell chooses sub-bands which are not used in the macrocell sub-area to avoid interference. Simulation results show that proposed scheme enhances total/edge throughputs and reduces the outage probability in overall network, especially for the cell edge users.
Lte evolving towards local area in release 12 and beyond
  • S Nielsen
S. Nielsen, "Lte evolving towards local area in release 12 and beyond." Future Radio in 3GPP, Nokia Corporation, 2012.