ArticlePDF Available

Lean management practices to improve supply chain performance of leather footwear industry

Authors:

Abstract

Leather Industry in India is among the top ten foreign exchange earners and export of footwear contributes to 44 % of the total export of leather and leather products from India. The demand for leather footwear is highly fluctuating leading to bullwhip effect and its price elasticity adds to further complications. Lean management practices are applicable to all sectors. However, suitable models need to be developed for different sectors. The purpose of this paper is to identify the set of lean practices adoptable in footwear sector and to investigate the synergistic effects of lean management practices on supply chain operational performance of footwear sector. Lean concept is not only applicable to production but can also be extended to supply chain to improve the supply chain operational performance. The enhancing attributes of Supply Chain Operational Performance (SCOP) specific to footwear industry has been identified and prioritized. A comprehensive set of lean management practices were scrutinized based on its applicability in the footwear sector and a model is designed to maximize supply chain operational performance of the footwear sector.
Lean Manage
m
Chain Performa
n
Shakila Shobana Theagaraja
n
1
Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation D
CSIR-Central Leather Research Institu
t
Chennai, India
shakilashobana@gmail.com
Abstract - Leather Industr
y
in India is amon
g
t
h
exchange earners and export of footwear cont
r
the total ex
p
ort of leather and leather
p
roduct
s
demand for leather footw ear is hi
g
hl
y
fluct
u
bullwhi
p
effect and its
p
rice elasticit
y
a
complications. Lean management practices ar
e
sectors. However, suitable models need to
b
different sectors. The
p
ur
p
ose of this
p
a
p
er is
t
of lean
p
ractices ado
p
table in footwear sector
a
the synergistic effects of lean management
r
chain o
p
erational
p
erformance of footwear sec
t
is not only a
pp
licable to
p
roduction but can al
su
pp
l
y
chain to im
p
rove the su
pp
l
y
c
h
performance. The enhancin
g
attributes o
f
Operational Performance (SCOP) specific to
f
has been identified and prioritized. A com
p
re
h
mana
g
ement
p
ractices were scrutinized based
o
in the footwear sector and a model is desi
g
su
pp
l
y
chain o
p
erational
p
erformance of the fo
o
Keywords—
L
eather, Footwear, Lean
p
ract
i
performance
I. INTRODUCTION
A. Leather Footwear Industry-Value Chain
Fig. 1. Flow indicating the supply chain
Tanner obtains the raw material i.e. pre
s
hides from raw material supplier and
p
r
o
convert into leather. Leather Footwear M
a
converts leather into Leather Footwear. The
are designed based on the inputs from
manufactured, marketed and sold through
b
directly to Brands (national/international) an
d
consumer through retailer. It involves b
o
support supply chain activities and m
a
throughout the process.
The primary activities of supply chain for
are (a) Inbound Logistics include movement
o
Proceedings of the 2015
I
nternational Con
fe
D
ubai, United Arab Emirates (UAE), Marc
h
978-1-4799-6065-1/15/$31.00 ©2015 IEEE
m
ent Practices to improv
n
ce of Leather Footwear
n
1
epartment,
t
e, Adyar
Hansa Lysander
M
2
Department of Manag
e
College of Engineering, G
u
University, Chenn
a
h
e to
p
ten forei
g
n
r
ibutes to 44 % of
s
from India. The
u
atin
g
leadin
g
to
a
dds to further
e
a
pp
licable to all
b
e develo
p
ed for
t
o identif
y
the set
a
nd to investi
g
ate
actices on su
pp
l
y
t
or. Lean conce
p
t
so be extended to
h
ain operational
f
Su
pp
l
y
Chain
f
ootwear industr
y
h
ensive set of lean
o
n its a
pp
licabilit
y
g
ned to maximize
o
twear sector.
i
ces, su
pp
l
y
chain
s
erved skins and
o
cesses them to
a
nufacturer then
Leather Products
design houses,
b
uying agents or
d
reaches the end
o
th primary and
a
rgin is gained
Leather Industry
o
f raw materials
from suppliers (machinery/chemi
c
leather) for the manufacture of le
a
(b) Operations include manufacturi
n
finished leather. (c) Outbound log
i
finished leather footwear from th
e
through various channels (Buying
h
Marketing, Sales and Service are
chain and value addition takes plac
margin.
B. Supply Chain Management –
Le
Supply chain management (
S
important of the areas that have rec
e
of interest in both industry an
d
considered as an integrating philo
flows of materials, products and in
f
the ultimate customers [2]. Suppl
y
practices associated with moveme
materials stage through to the
p
ractices include sourcing and
scheduling, order processing,
transportation, warehousing and c
u
asserted that for effective SCM,
i
improvement in all functions with
i
and also that the focus of supply
c
from functional and independent
[4].
The change in nature of comp
e
to environmental compliance an
organization to be more efficient
e
concept of supply chain agility a
n
p
aradigm focuses on the eliminati
o
added activities to achieve hig
h
profitability and flexibility [6].
Change is the only thing that i
requirements are dynamic and is
e
possible for SCs to deliver the righ
t
the right quantity in the right condi
t
right time at the right cost. Signific
a
in recent years in the concept of “l
e
wider principles of the “lean ente
lean approach has essentially been
o
or muda. The upsurge of interest in
traced to the Toyota Production Sy
s
reduction and elimination of waste
.
with less. Lean concepts work well
fe
rence on Industrial Engineering and Operations Manag
e
h
3 – 5, 2015
e Supply
Industry
M
anoha
r
2
e
ment Studies,
u
indy (CEG), Anna
a
i, India
c
als/we
t
-blue/crust/finished
a
ther and leather products.
n
g of leather footwear from
i
stics include movement of
e
factory to the consumers
h
ouses/Exporters/Retailers).
involved across the value
e at each step and so is the
e
an Paradigm
S
CM) is one of the most
e
ntly generated a great deal
d
academia [1]. SCM is
sophy to manage the total
f
ormation from suppliers to
y
chain is defined as set of
n
t of goods from the raw
end-user. Some of these
procurement, production
inventory management,
u
stomer services [3]. It is
i
mportant efforts to effect
i
n a firm should be made,
c
hain practices should shift
to general and integrative
e
tition, increasing necessity
d pressing need for the
e
nhance the interest in the
n
d leanness [5]. The Lean
o
n of waste and non-value
h
er levels of efficiency,
s constant. Since customer
e
ver-changing, it is seldom
t
product of right quality in
t
io
n
to the right place at the
a
nt interest has been shown
e
an manufacturing” and the
rprises”. The focus of the
o
n the elimination of waste
lean manufacturing can be
s
tems, with its focus on the
.
Lean is about doing more
where demand is relatively
e
ment
stable and hence predictable and where va
r
Some would state that lean manufacturi
responsiveness (service) to efficiency and p
r
[8]. Lean manufacturing states that all n
o
activities or muda must be eliminated. The
s
b
e as flexible as possible but flexibility is no
t
be lean [9].
Lean production promises significant be
n
increased organizational and supply chain co
m
integration [10]. The core thrust of lean
p
capability of working synergistically to crea
system that produces finished products at the
p
demand with little or no waste [11].
SCM dr
a
the areas of operations management, logisti
and information technology, and strives f
o
approach [12].
The past studies enunciate that customer
dynamic and ever-changing and fast respo
n
and cost efficiency in supply chain is the key
opportunities in an industry. The presen
t
developing a model of lean supply chai
n
footwear industry to enhance the operationa
l
the industry along the supply chain. The
m
using HOQ and QFD tools to identify the L
e
Practices to be practically implemented in t
h
enhance the supply chain operational per
f
sector. The whole scaffold exploits fuzzy l
o
linguistics judgments required for re
l
correlations matrixes into numerical values.
II. METHODOLOGY
Why Fuzzy QFD?
In the present approach, HOQ represent
s
that allows the direct assessment of the
Management Practices (LMPs) on the enhan
c
Supply Chain Operational Performance
(
relationships matrices. It also allows the
possible correlations between different Le
Practices (LMPs). As the functional relations
enhancing attributes of SCOP and LM
P
imprecise or vague, it is difficult to identify t
h
p
ermits consideration of the different mean
i
given to the same linguistic expression [13].
benefit of the fuzzy set theory is
b
ased
o
represent vague data [14]. And because of t
h
approach has been so widely adopted in
d
fields, as witnessed in the numerous literatur
e
[15]. Original approach to show the applica
b
methodology to enhance agility of enterpris
e
[16]. A fuzzy set is a class of objects with
grades of membership. Such a set is ch
a
membership function, which assigns a grad
e
ranging between 0 and 1 to each object [1
7
QFD is adopted to express the impact of L
M
attributes of SCOP.
Proposed Methodology
The step-wise description of Fuzzy QF
D
the impact of LMPs on enhancing attributes o
r
iety is low [7].
ng subordinates
r
oductivity (cost)
o
n-value adding
s
upply chain will
t
a prerequisite to
n
efits in terms of
m
munication and
p
roduction is the
a
te a high-quality
p
ace of customer
a
ws heavily from
cs, procurement,
o
r an integrated
requirements are
n
siveness, quality
to avail business
t
study aims at
n
appropriate to
l
performance of
m
odel is designed
e
an Management
h
e sector so as to
f
ormance of the
o
gic, to translate
l
ationships and
s
a practical tool
impact of Lean
c
ing attributes of
(
SCOP) through
identification of
an Management
hips between the
P
s are typically
h
em. Fuzzy logic
i
ngs that may be
Thus, the major
o
n its ability to
h
is benefit, fuzzy
d
ifferent research
es on the subject
b
ility of the QFD
e
s was presented
a continuum of
a
racterized by a
e
of membership
7
] [14]. A Fuzzy
M
Ps on enhancing
D
model to study
f SCOP is shown
in Fig.2.
Fig. 2. Schematic representation of algo
r
A. Identification of SCOP enhanci
n
p
rioritization to obtain Priority
In the present work, the exper
t
mainly comprised of managers of
p
and plant o
p
erations of different
chain of leather footwear industry.
were lead time, flexibility, cost, s
e
reliability, information, product v
a
technology, profit, forecasting, p
knowledge and market demand [9]
footwear sector were then give
n
attributes specific to leather footw
e
to indicate its importance in ter
m
winners as per their expectation fr
o
their satisfaction and improve the
i
performance. Then those supply c
h
order winners as per the experts
w
attributes of Supply Chain O
p
erati
Then they were solicited to distri
b
order winners – higher points for
important role among them. The w
e
was calculated and considered fo
r
‘Voice of the Customers’ of QFD t
o
B. Identification of LMPs
The lean model requires les
movement of materials, less time
smaller workforce, fewer compute
r
technology [18]. Consequently, le
a
focus on waste reduction, helping f
i
adding activities related to exce
s
r
ith
m
followed for research study
n
g attributes and its
Weights (
W
i
)
t
team was formed, which
p
urchase, marketing & sales
partners across the value
T
he supply chain attributes
e
rvice level, quality, speed,
a
riety, capacity, inventory,
roduct life cycle, market
[24].The experts of leather
n
a list of supply chain
ar industry and were asked
m
s of order qualifiers/order
o
m their suppliers to fulfill
i
r supply chain operational
h
ain attributes that are rated
w
ere selected as enhancing
o
nal Performance (SCOP).
b
ute the 100 points among
criteria that play the most
e
ighted average of the same
r
priority weights (W
i
) in
o
ol.
s stock, less space, less
to set up the machiner
y
,
r
systems and more frugal
a
n supply chains strategies
i
rms to eliminate non-value
s
s time, labor, equipment,
space and inventories across the supply chain [19]. Such
strategies enable firms to improve quality, reduce costs and
improve service to customers [20].
The experts brainstormed on various Lean Management
Practices (LMPs) including Information technology (IT)
integrated LMPs for its importance and applicability in
Footwear sector. The LMPs listed by the experts and that
collated from the literature review were then integrated.
The experts were then given a questionnaire on the
integrated lean management practices and were asked to give
rating on a 5 point likert scale based on its importance and
practical applicability in leather footwear sector. Lean
management practices were shortlisted based on the experts’
opinion on its importance and applicability and considered for
further study.
C. Determination of Interrelationship between LMPs and
SCOP enhancing attributes () and Correlation among
LMPs ()
While linking the enhancing attributes of SCOP and
LMPs, most measures were described subjectively using
linguistic terms that cannot be handled effectively using
conventional approaches. However, fuzzy logic provides an
effective means of dealing with problems involving imprecise
and vague phenomena [13]. It was exploited to translate
linguistic judgments required for relative importance of LMPs,
relationships and correlations matrices into numerical values.
In this step, the degree of relationship between enhancing
attributes of SCOP and LMPs was stated by the corresponding
TFNs and placed in the HOQ matrix. Moreover, the degree of
correlation between LMPs was then expressed by TFNs in the
fuzzy HOQ. Both of these correspondences are shown
in Table 1 and Table 2.
TABLE I. FUZZY NUMBERSa FOR DEGREE OF RELATIONSHIPS
Degree of relationship Fuzzy number
Strong (S) (0.7; 1; 1)
Medium (M) (0.3; 0.5; 0.7)
Weak (W) (0; 0; 0.3)
aSource: adapted from Ref.[23].
TABLE II. FUZZY NUMBERSa FOR DEGREE OF CORRELATIONS
Degree of correlation Fuzzy number
Strong positive (SP) (0.7; 1; 1)
Positive (P) (0.5; 0.7; 1)
Negative (N) (0; 0.3; 0.5)
Strong negative (SN) (0; 0; 0.3)
aSource: adapted from Ref. [15]
Triangular Fuzzy Number (TFN)
The TFN can be denoted as a triplet (a, b, c) as shown
in Fig.3, where a b c. When a = b = c, it is a non-fuzzy
number by convention. The membership function can be
defined as per [21] [22]:



,
,
: 


,
,
0  (1)
A fuzzy set N in a universe of discourse X is shown by a
membership function which associates a real number in
the interval [0,1] with each element x in X as shown in Fig. 3.
Fig. 3. Triangular Fuzzy Number (TFN)
If M = (a1, b1, c1) and N = (a2, b2, c2) represent two TFNs,
then the required fuzzy calculations are performed as below
[23].
Fuzzy Addition: MN= (a1+a2, b1+b2, c1+c2) (2)
Fuzzy Multiplication: MN= (a1×a2, b1×b2, c1×c2) (3)
Fuzzy Division: M 1/N = (a1/c2, b1/b2, c1/a2) (4)
Fuzzy and natural number multiplication: rM=(r.a,r.b,r.c)
(5)
D. Calculation of the relative importance (RIj) and priority
weights of LMPs (RIj
)
The aim of computing these two parameters was to
determine which LMP has the most effect on enhancing
SCOP. RIj was computed by fuzzy multiplication of Wi to Rij.

1
 1, … . ,  6




 1, … . ,  7
 was shown in the roof part of HOQ. The mentioned
parameters are shown in Fig.3. Furthermore, normalization
was performed by dividing each

by the highest one
according to the fuzzy set algebra [22]. Then, in order to rank
the LMPs, the normalized scores of

were de-fuzzified.
Suppose M (a, b, c) is a TFN; then, the de-fuzzified value is
computed as (a+2b+c)/4 (8)
LMPs with high crisp values indicate that they can be
usefully exploited to enhance SCOP. Thus, such LMPs must
be selected for implementation.
III. RESULTS AND DISCUS
S
Enhancing attributes of Supply Ch
a
Performance (SCOP) identified by Experts w
e
the Voice of the Customer of QFD tool a
n
Table III along with its priority weights (W
i
).
capacity utilization and Inventory managem
e
lean attributes that contribute to efficiency an
d
importance followed by lead time, qua
l
flexibility, delivery speed, delivery reliabili
t
responsiveness.
TABLE III. VOICE OF THE CUS
T
Lean Management Practices (LMPs) s
h
experts
b
ased on its importance and applic
a
Footwear Industry are shown in Table IV.
TABLE IV. MATRIX OF L
M
LMP 1 Organized Work Environment (5 S methodo
LMP 2 Throughput Improvement (Bottleneck Anal
y
LMP 3 Level Scheduling method
LMP 4 Semi-Automation
LMP 5 Just In Tim e Inventor y (J IT)
LMP 6 Continuous Improvement (KAIZEN)
LMP 7 KANBAN Pull Production system
LMP 8 Zero Defects ( POKA YOKE Error Proofin
g
LMP 9 Set up time reduction
LMP 10 Takt Time
LMP 11 Total Preventive Maintenance (TPM)
LMP 12 Value Stream Mapping
LMP 13 Long term contract with suppliers (Supplier
Management)
LMP 14 Centralized/Collaborative Planning of Prod
u
LMP 15 Systematic Information sharing through ED
Data Interchange) across all Supply chain p
a
LMP 16 ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) imple
m
LMP 17 Customer Relationship Managemen
t
implementation
LMP 18 Workforce Management including multi-s
k
and cross functional teams
The Relative importance of LMPs (
)
weights (
) are calculated with
p
riority
w
enhancing attributes, Interrelationship bet
w
SCOP enhancing attributes and Correlatio
n
using (6) and (7). Then normalization of
and 
values were obtained. The cri
obtained using (a+2b+c)/4
SCOP enhancing Attributes Priority
W
Lead Time
0
Quality Consistency
0
Flexibility
0
Supply Chain Operations Cost
0
Delivery Speed
0
Delivery Reliability
0
Customer Responsiveness
0
Information Accuracy
0
Capacity Utilization
0
Inventory Management
0
Technology Adaptability
0
S
ION
a
in Operational
e
re considered as
n
d are shown in
Operations cost,
e
nt are the prime
d
are given equal
l
ity consistency,
t
y and customer
T
OME
R
S
h
ortlisted by the
a
bility in Leather
M
Ps
logy)
y
sis)
g
technique )
Relationship
u
ctio
n
I (Electronic
a
rtners
m
entatio
n
t
(CRM)
k
illed labour
)
and its priority
w
eights of SCOP
w
een LMPs and
n
among LMPs
was performed
sp values were
(8)
The Fuzzy QFD model depi
c
between the enhancing attributes o
f
correlation among the LMPs in nu
m
Fig.4.
Fig. 4. A Fuzzy QFD based Lean Suppl
y
IV. CONC
L
Lean Management Practices
values has to be practically imple
m
sector so as to enhance the
S
Performance of Leather Footwear I
of their crisp values are listed in Ta
b
TABLE V. LMPs IN THE ORD
To conclude, 11 enhancing att
r
identified through scientifically
d
soliciting inputs from experts. L
M
followed and widely accepted by
t
have been chosen. The interrelati
o
W
eights (Wi)
0
.09
0
.09
0
.09
0
.10
0
.09
0
.09
0
.09
0
.08
0
.10
0
.10
0
.08
1 Systematic Information s
h
Data Interchange) across a
l
2 Takt Time
3 Just In Time Inventory (JI
T
4 Customer Relationship Ma
n
5 Workforce Management i
n
cross functional teams
6 Level Scheduling method
7 ERP (Enterprise Resource
P
8 Centralized/Collaborative
P
9 Throughput Improvement
(
10 Semi-Automation
11 KANBAN Pull Production
12 Long term contract with
Management)
13 Continuous Improvement (
K
14 Zero Defects ( POKA YO
K
15 Organized Work Environ
m
16 Total Preventive Maintena
n
17 Set up time reduction
18 Value Stream Mapping
c
ting the interrelationship
f
SCOP and LMPs and the
m
erical values is shown in
y
Chain Model
L
USION
(LMPs) with high crisp
m
ented in leather footwear
S
upply Chain Operational
n
dustry. LMPs in the order
b
le V.
E
R OF THEIR CRISP VALUES
r
ibutes of SCOP have been
d
esigned methodology of
M
Ps that are predominantly
t
he industry numbering 18
o
nship between enhancing
h
aring through EDI (Electronic
l
l Supply chain partners
T
)
n
agement (CRM) implementatio
n
n
cluding multi-skilled labour and
P
lanning) implementatio
n
P
lanning of Productio
n
(
Bottleneck Analysis)
system
suppliers (Supplier Relationship
K
AIZEN)
K
E Error Proofing technique )
m
ent (5 S methodology)
n
ce (TPM)
attributes of SCOP and LMPs to indicate the appropriate LMP
tool to attain the objectives of each enhancing attribute have
been derived as a model of QFD. Correlations among the
LMPs have also been deduced. LMPs accordingly have been
prioritized based on crisp values. With the developed model,
the footwear industry may opt for LMP tools that would be
appropriate to their own organization to maximize the output
with minimum inputs along the supply chain.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The Research Work is part of the doctoral programme (PhD)
of author and the co-author is her guide for the doctoral
programme.
REFERENCES
[1] Singh R, Sharma HO, Garg SK., “Interpretive structural modelling for
selection of best supply chain practices,” International Journal of
Business Performance and Supply Chain Modelling , 2010b;2(3/4):237
57.
[2] Ellram L, Copper M., “Characteristics of supply chain management and
the implications for purchasing and logistics strategy,” International
Journal of Logistics Management, 1993;4(2):1–10.
[3] Quinn FJ., “What’s the buzz?” Logistics Management, 1997; 36(2):43–
7.
[4] Dawe RL.,“An investigation of the pace and determination of
information technology use in the manufacturing materials logistics
system,” Journal of Business Logistics,1994;15(1):229–58.
[5] Mistry J., “Supply chain management: a case study of an integrated
Lean and agile model,” Qualitative Research in Accounting and
Management, 2005;2 (2):193–215.
[6] G. Anand, Rambabu Kodali, “Benchmarking the benchmarking
models”, Benchmarking: An International Journal, Vol. 15 Iss: 3,
(2008) pp.257 – 291
[7] Ashish Agarwal, Ravi Shank ar, M K Tiwari, “Mod eling the metrics of
lean, agile and leagile supply chain: An ANP-based approach” ,
European Journal of Operational Research, Volume 173, Issue 1, 2006,
Pages 211-225
[8] Vazquez-Bustelo, D., Avella, L., Fernandez, E., “Agility drivers,
enablers and outcomes”’ International Journal of Operations and
Production Management,2007, 27 (12), 1303–1332.
[9] J.B. Naylor, M.M. Naim, D. Berry, “Leagility: Integrating the lean and
agile manufacturing paradigms in the total supply chain”, International
Journal of Production Economics, 62 (1999), pp. 107–118
[10] Scherrer-Rathje, M., Boyle, T.A., Deflorin, P., “Lean, take two!
Reflections from the second attempt at lean implementation”, Business
Horizons, 2009, 52, 79–88.
[11] R. Shah, P.T. Ward, “Lean manufacturing: context, practice bundles,
and performance”, Journal of Operations Management, 21 (2003), pp.
129–149
[12] Bartsch, Frank. "Supply Chain Management", Transport BB Handel, BB
handel GmbH, Jun 2013.
[13] M. Dohnal, J. Vystrcil, J. Dohnalova, K. Marecek, M. Kvapilik, P.
Bures, “Fuzzy food engineering,”Journal of Food Engineering, 19 (2)
(1993), pp. 171–201
[14] L.A. Zadeh, “Fuzzy sets,” Information and Control, 8 (1965), pp. 338–
353
[15] E. Bottani, A. Rizzi, “Strategic management of logistics service: A
fuzzy-QFD approach,” International Journal of Production Economics,
103 (2) (2006), pp. 585–599
[16] E. Bottani, “A fuzzy QFD approach to achieve agility,” International
Journal of Production Economics, 119 (2) (2009), pp. 380–391
[17] [17] C. Kahraman, T. Ertay, “A fuzzy optimization model for QFD
planning process using analytic network process,” International Journal
of Production Research, 171 (2006), pp. 390–411
[18] Shahin,A., Janatyan N, “Group Technology and Lean production : a
conceptual model for enhancing productivity” International Business
Research, 2010.
[19] Corbett, C.J. and Klassen, R.D., “Extending the horizons :
environmental excellence as key to improving operations”,
Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2006,Vol.8 No1,
pp.5-22.
[20] Larson, T. and Greenwood, R., “Perfect complements : synergies
between lean production and eco-sustainability initiatives”,
Environmental Quality Management, 2004,Vol.13 No4.pp27-36.
[21] I. Chamodrakas, N. Alexopoulou, D. Martakos, “Customer evaluation
for order acceptance using a novel class of fuzzy methods based on
TOPSIS,” Expert Systems with Applications, 36 (2009), pp. 7409–7415
[22] Zimmermann, H.J., Fuzzy Set Theory and its Applications, second ed.
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston. 1991
[23] C.J. Chien, H.H. Tsai, “Using fuzzy numbers to evaluate perceived
service and quality” Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 116 (2000), pp. 289–300
[24] Cox, A., Chicksand, D. “Aligning Brand and Supply Chain Strategies”.
CPO Agenda, Autumn,2006, pp. 46–50
BIOGRAPHY
Shakila Shobana is a Scientist in Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation
department of CSIR-Central Leather Research Institute at Chennai, a
constituent laboratory of Council of Scientific & Industrial Research,
New Delhi, India. She is a faculty of Leather Technology, Anna
University and has taught courses in TQM, Principles of Production
Management and International Marketing to B Tech students. She
earned Bachelors in Leather Technology & Information Technology as a
dual degree from Anna University, Chennai. She gained Masters in
Marketing Management, part time from Jamnalal Bajaj Institute of
Management Studies (JBIMS), Mumbai University. She is pursuing her
Ph.D. in management from Department of Management Sciences, CEG,
Anna University. She worked as a Senior Executive – Market
Development, Leather Chemicals followed by Business Development
Manager-South for Care Chemicals – Detergents & Formulators at M/s
BASF India Limited (a German based Chemical Company). Her
Research interests include Production & Supply Chain Management,
TQM implementation and Operations.
Hansa Lysander Manohar is currently an Associate Professor in the
Department of Management Studies at College of Engineering (CEG),
Anna University, Chennai. She gained Bachelors in Textile Technology
from Alagappa College of Technology, Anna University in 1985. She
secured her MBA (Masters in Business Administration) in Systems &
Marketing from CEG, Anna University in 1987. She holds her Ph.D. in
Operations & Technology Management from Alagappa College of
Technology, Anna University in 1997.She has taught courses in
Operations and Systems for MBA students of Anna University. Her
Specialization in Research includes Operations, Systems and
Technology Management. She holds membership in MMA (Madras
Management Association) & ISTE (Indian Society for Technical
Education). She guides Ph.D. students in the areas of Operations,
Systems and Technology Management.
... . O foco das práticas de gerenciamento da cadeia de suprimentos deve passar de iniciativas funcionais e independentes a gerais e integrativas (FRAZZON et al., 2015;THEAGARAJAN;MANOHAR, 2015). Devido a uma crescente pressão competitiva por lead times mais baixos, custos mais baixos e melhor qualidade, os princípios da manufatura enxuta (ME) foram incorporados nas abordagens de gerenciamento da cadeia de suprimentos (CUDNEY; ELROD, 2010). ...
... . O foco das práticas de gerenciamento da cadeia de suprimentos deve passar de iniciativas funcionais e independentes a gerais e integrativas (FRAZZON et al., 2015;THEAGARAJAN;MANOHAR, 2015). Devido a uma crescente pressão competitiva por lead times mais baixos, custos mais baixos e melhor qualidade, os princípios da manufatura enxuta (ME) foram incorporados nas abordagens de gerenciamento da cadeia de suprimentos (CUDNEY; ELROD, 2010). ...
... Assim, a integração de fornecedores e clientes surge como um elemento importante para melhorar a competitividade além dos limites organizacionais (FLYNN et al., 2010;FRAZZON et al., 2015). Este conceito está perfeitamente alinhado com as definições clássicas de gerenciamento da cadeia de suprimentos, uma vez que compreende o fluxo de produtos do fornecedor através de cadeias de fabricação e distribuição até o usuário final (POWER, 2005 MANOHAR, 2015). A abordagem do CSE afasta-se da atual "mentalidade de negociação", na qual os objetivos de lucro são de curto prazo e altamente dependentes dos preços de mercado e da capacidade de negociar fortemente com fornecedores ou clientes, com uma estratégia baseada em um compromisso de longo prazo com os parceiros da cadeia de suprimentos, com uma eliminação sistemática e cooperativa de resíduos ao longo da cadeia (YUSUF et al., 2004;AGARWAL et al., 2006). ...
Article
Um estudo exploratório sobre as relações entre as práticas lean na implementação de uma cadeia de suprimentos enxuta A pressão competitiva por redução do tempo de processamento, de custos e melhoria na qualidade tem promovido a implementação dos princípios da manufatura enxuta também no gerenciamento da cadeia de suprimentos. O objetivo deste trabalho é identificar empiricamente as relações entre as práticas de gerenciamento da cadeia de suprimentos enxuta durante projetos de implementação desta abordagem na cadeia de suprimentos. Por meio de uma survey com 113 empresas os resulta-dos foram analisados por meio de técnicas multivariadas de dados. Os resultados apresentam que a relação entre as práticas pode não ser sempre sinérgica, pois existem pares de práticas que, ao serem implementadas simultaneamente, tendem a entrar em conflito, dificultando seus benefícios. A pesquisa realizada também fornece argumentos aos gestores e profissionais para compreender melhor como as práticas interagem umas com as outras em contextos específicos. Palavras-chave: Enxuta. Práticas. Melhoria de processo. Correlação parcial.
... Supply chain management (SCM) comprises the flow of goods from supplier through manufacturing and distribution chains until the end user (Power, 2005). The focus of SCM practices must shift from functional and independent to general and integrative initiatives (Frazzon et al., 2015;Theagarajan and Manohar, 2015). Due to an increasing competitive pressure for shorter lead times, lower costs and better quality, the principles of lean manufacturing (LM) have been incorporated into the supply chain integrative approaches (Cudney and Elrod, 2010). ...
... This concept is perfectly aligned with classical SCM definitions, since it comprises the flow of goods from supplier through manufacturing and distribution chains until the end user (Power, 2005). In this sense, the focus of SCM practices must shift from functional and independent to general and integrative initiatives (Theagarajan and Manohar, 2015). The LSC approach moves away from the current "trading mentality," in which profit targets are short term and highly dependent on market prices and the ability to negotiate strongly with suppliers or customers, to a strategy based on a long-term commitment to supply chain partners, with a cooperative and systematic waste elimination along the chain (Yusuf et al., 2004;Agarwal et al., 2006). ...
... Research related to the implementation of LSC practices usually neglects the supply chain contexts, or narrowly approach it focusing on a specific industry sector (e.g. Taylor, 2006;Theagarajan and Manohar, 2015). Due to this investigation gap, the evidence on the relationship of LSC practices does not allow a holistic perspective of the problem, hindering the establishment of generalizable assumptions or further deepening. ...
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to empirically investigate the relationships among the implementation of LSC practices. Particularly, the authors examine the adoption level of 27 LSC practices, which were identified in a literature review, within 113 manufacturing companies from different sectors located in Southern Brazil. Design/methodology/approach Data collected were analyzed by means of multivariate techniques (partial correlation analysis) and two control variables were used: level of onshore suppliers and company’s experience on lean manufacturing implementation. Findings The results showed that the relationship among practices may not always be synergic, since there are pairs of practices that, when concurrently implemented they tend to conflict, hindering their benefits. Originality/value The use of partial correlations between pairs of LSC practices provides means to better understand specific associations, disregarding the implementation effect of the whole set of practices. The research also provides managers and practitioners arguments to better comprehend how practices interact with each other under specific contexts.
... Nowadays, environmental protection has attracted increasing attention. A variety of closed-loop supply chains have been designed for recycling, such as the recycling of plastic products, tires [31], and leather products [32]. However, the design of the CLSC network for different industries and different scenarios will bring burden on manpower and material resources, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises. ...
Article
Full-text available
The closed-loop supply chain (CLSC) plays an important role in sustainable development and can help to increase the economic benefits of enterprises. The optimization for the CLSC network is a complicated problem, since it often has a large problem scale and involves multiple constraints. This paper proposes a general CLSC model to maximize the profits of enterprises by determining the transportation route and delivery volume. Due to the complexity of the multi-constrained and large-scale model, a genetic algorithm with two-step rank-based encoding (GA-TRE) is developed to solve the problem. Firstly, a two-step rank-based encoding is designed to handle the constraints and increase the algorithm efficiency, and the encoding scheme is also used to improve the genetic operators, including crossover and mutation. The first step of encoding is to plan the routes and predict their feasibility according to relevant constraints, and the second step is to set the delivery volume based on the feasible routes using a rank-based method to achieve greedy solutions. Besides, a new mutation operator and an adaptive population disturbance mechanism are designed to increase the diversity of the population. To validate the efficiency of the proposed algorithm, six heuristic algorithms are compared with GA-TRE by using different instances with three problem scales. The results show that GA-TRE can obtain better solutions than the competitors, especially on large-scale instances.
... The focus of SCM practices must shift from functional and independent to general and integrative initiatives (Theagarajan and Manohar, 2015), which favors the integration of Lean principles and practices into the SCM (Cudney and Elrod, 2010). Knowledge about the integration of Lean with external customers and suppliers is considered to be one of the new frontiers of research in this area. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose Modern supply chains are at risk as a result of increasing disturbance. The use of Lean and Six Sigma’'s values, methods and tools can be one option to analyze, prevent and mitigate risks. The purpose of this study is to investigate whether a combined Lean Six Sigma philosophy can support the awareness and management of supply-chain risk. Design/methodology/approach The methodology followed in the study is based on a literature review and multiple case study, performed by means of qualitative methods of data collection, such as observations on-site, face-to-face interviews and document analysis. Case selection includes the results of research conducted in seven large Swedish companies. Findings It has been indicated that Lean and Six Sigma values, methods and tools can be very effective in companies’ efforts to control the supply-chain risks and that they improve the companies’ ability to handle variability and risk management. Lean Six Sigma supports a risk-management culture in the focal companies, but they must involve customers and companies in the supply chain if they wish to create a risk-management culture in the entire supply chain. In order to do this, they can use the Six Sigma training structure, but they need to include more risk tools and methods developed for the supply chain management. It has also been indicated in the literature that if more people involve in 6S projects, the financial results will be better, and the innovation of processes will increase. Research limitations/implications These include suggestions for how the companies can use the Six sigma training structure to collaborate in the supply chain. Practical implications This study gives practical suggestions for how the companies in supply chain can collaborate and use the Six Sigma training structure for creating a more holistic view of supply chain, which also decrease risks in supply chain. Originality/value This study indicates that Lean Six Sigma supports risk awareness and management in the focal companies of the supply chains, which improves companies’ ability to handle variability and risk management. It has also been demonstrated that the companies should use the Six Sigma framework, especially training, as a foundation, and they should create common projects for better collaboration in the supply chain, which will decrease the risks in the entire supply chain.
Article
Gıda üretimi, topraktan toplanan ham maddelerin işlenmesi ile başlar. Kaynakların verimli kullanılması, üretilen gıdaların paketlenmesinde ve dağıtımında en önemli husus, verimliliği artırmak ve hataları en aza indirmektir. Bu, yalnızca tedarik zinciri yönetimi sürecine yalın ilkelerin uygulanmasıyla elde edilebilir. Bu çalışmanın temel amacı, öncelikle Yalın Tedarik Zinciri Yönetimi söz konusu olduğunda dikkate alınması gereken kesin uygulamaları ve ilkeleri tanımlamaktır. İkincisi, yalın tedarik zinciri yönetimi ilkeleri ile gıda sektörüne dayalı tedarik zinciri yönetimi performansı farklarını ve ilişkilerini ortaya koymaktır. Yalın Tedarik Zinciri Yönetiminin sistematik olarak uygulanmasının arka planı ve sonuçları ile tedarik zinciri yönetimi performans değerlendirmesi hakkında çok fazla çalışma yoktur. Bu nedenle yalın tedarik zinciri yönetimi ve tedarik zinciri yönetimi ilkelerinin performansı nasıl etkilediğini göstermek çok önemlidir ve makalenin temel amacı da budur. Gıda sektörü düşünülerek yürütülen çalışma, yalın tedarik zinciri yönetimi ile tedarik zinciri yönetimi arasındaki temel performans göstergelerini ölçmek üzerine planlanmıştır. Çalışmada ilk olarak gıda tedarik zinciri yönetimi ve gıda yalın tedarik zinciri yönetimindeki temel performans ölçütleri belirlenmiştir ve literatür araştırması ile birleştirilmiştir. Daha sonra nihai puanı elde etmek ve her boyut için performans indeksini hesaplamak üzere DEMATEL yöntemi uygulanmıştır.
Chapter
Today the role of industry 4.0 plays a very important role in enhancing any supply chain network, as the Industry 4.0 supply chain uses advanced analytics and Big Data for information and visibility of product. Latest data information is available to support real-time decision-making and bring visibility to the entire supply chain, both within and outside the organizations. The main focus of the paper is to identify various Lean supply chain management enablers (LSCMEs) in automobile industry sector with the help of literature review and experts opinion. Thereafter with the help of (AHP) Analytical Hierarchy Process to find the rankings of the enablers by calculating their weightage. This paper has identified 28 key LSCMEs and developed an integrated model, which is very helpful to identify and classify the important enablers as per their ranking obtained and will help understanding and exploring the direct and indirect effects of each enabler on the LSCM implementation.
Article
Full-text available
Lean Six Sigma (LSS) enables supply chains to become more efficient and effective in sustaining continuous improvement. The speed, service quality, and the cost of operations impact the supply chain performance. One most popular approach for providing faster responses, improving quality and reducing cost in SCM, is LSS as it combines strengths of both Lean and Six Sigma. LSS is not just about doing things better, it is a way of doing better things. Research establishes complementary relationship of Lean and Six Sigma; summarizes benefits of LSS in SCM and develops various frameworks such as S-V framework and O-T-S framework to emphasize the role of LSS in enhancing efficiency and effectiveness of SCM processes. As a strategic management tool, LSS deployment in SCM is considered to be an important management philosophy, supporting organizations in their efforts to enhance efficiency and effectiveness of operations, satisfy customers and enhance competitive advantages.
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to identify the mediating effect of lean management (LM) dimensions on the relationship between flexible manufacturing systems (FMS) dimensions and operational performance metrics. Design/methodology/approach A survey questionnaire was developed based on previous literature and interviews conducted at the automotive facilities visited that identified 28 lean dimensions, 15 flexibility dimensions and 8 operational performance metrics. The survey was presented to 175 North American automotive manufacturing managers through interviews conducted at 64 automotive facilities. A total of 164 usable responses were studied. Findings Lean and FMS are multi-dimensional philosophies, the results demonstrate that the automotive industry in North America has implemented many dimensions of both philosophies. Each dimension is categorized based on specific organizational metrics. The 64 facilities studied use common dimensions identified by this study for lean and flexibility. Data analysis indicates a direct link between lean, flexibility and operational metrics. It shows that LM plays a critical role in improving the impact of flexibility on performance metrics. The results also indicate that specific lean and FMS dimensions or categories have higher significant roles than others in the relationship between LM, FMS and operational performance metrics. Research limitations/implications Since the sample size only considered automotive manufacturing facilities, the results need to be considered with caution. Originality/value This research empirically develops a framework linking FMS and LM to operational performance metrics. This research addresses an area within which there is little consensus on the relationship between LM, FMS and their impact on operational performance metrics. The study is unique due to the depth and breadth of the investigation that far exceeds previous literature conducted. In addition, this research highlights the LM and FMS practices on which managers should focus on when attempting to improve operational performance metrics at their facility.
Article
Full-text available
The concepts of a supply chain and supply chain management are receiving increased attention as means of becoming or remaining competitive in a globally challenging environment. What distinguishes supply chain management from other channel relationships? This paper presents a framework for differentiating between traditional systems and supply chain management systems. These characteristics are then related to the process of establishing and managing a supply chain. A particular focus of this paper is on the implications of supply chain management for purchasing and logistics.
Chapter
The supply chain management (SCM) focuses on the optimization opportunities in the value-added chain. Customers, retailers, producers, suppliers, and subcontractors set up a cooperative network. The primary objective is the replacement of inventory by communication. This objective is achieved by increasing the exchanged planning and controlling information. After introducing the subject of supply chain management in general (Chapter 7.1 to 7.2) three SCM-reference models, which focus on different aspects of the supply chain management, are introduced. The Advanced Logistic Partnership model, which was developed at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, points out the key management requirements (Chapter 7.4). Next, the PRO-Net reference model describes the business processes for strategic production networks (Chapter 7.5). The SCOR model finally focuses on SCM best practices and controlling metrics (Chapter 7.6). While in general supply chain management is associated to the make-to-stock production type or at least the large-scale manufacturing, the plant construction business was not yet analyzed for SCM opportunities. Chapter 7.7 presents a research project conducted at the German Fraunhofer Institute for Factory Operation and Automation (IFF), which aim is the development of SCM concepts for the plant construction industry. Afterwards, an introduction into available SCMsoftware systems and their functionality is given. The case of a supply chain management in German textile industry concludes this section.
Article
Purpose A review of benchmarking literature revealed that there are different types of benchmarking and a plethora of benchmarking process models. In some cases, a model has been uniquely developed for performing a particular type of benchmarking. This poses the following problems: it can create confusion among the users as to whether they should use only the unique benchmarking model that has been developed for particular type or they can use any model for any type of benchmarking; a user may find it difficult when it becomes necessary to choose a best model from the available models, as each model varies in terms of the number of phases involved, number of steps involved, application, etc. Hence, this paper aims to question the fundamental classification scheme of benchmarking and thereby the unique benchmarking models that are developed for each type of benchmarking. Further it aims to propose a universal benchmarking model, which can be applied for all types of benchmarking. Design/methodology/approach The fundamental benchmarking model developed by Camp has been used to benchmark the existing models, irrespective of the type of benchmarking, to identify the best practices in benchmarking. Findings Benchmarking the benchmarking models revealed about 71 steps in which around 13 steps have been addressed by many researchers. The remaining unique steps were considered to be the best practices in benchmarking. Research limitations/implications The proposed model is highly conceptual and it requires validation by implementing the same in an organization to understand its effectiveness. Originality/value Though some of the methodologies used in this paper are already available in the literature, their context of application in the field of benchmarking is new. For example, utilizing the benchmarking process itself to improve the existing benchmarking process is an original concept.
Article
The Supply Chain Management (SCM) concept has received much attention as a method for achieving improved customer service, better inventory management, and better overall channel management. Keiretsu, a type of Japanese business network shares many of the goals of SCM, yet is implemented much differently. This paper explores the similarities and differences between SCM and Keiretsu approaches. It also discusses broad changes that are required to make SCM a more viable competitive alternative among western firms.
Article
Purpose Despite the fact that agile manufacturing has been frequently promoted as a means of improving business competitiveness, little empirical evidence exists in the literature validating its positive link with business performance. The purpose of this research paper is to analyse agile manufacturing in Spain and study whether it is a critical factor for success in different industries. Design/methodology/approach A conceptual model is drawn up, based on the literature and a previous case study, to relate turbulence in the environment with agile manufacturing practices and business performance. The model is tested on a large sample of Spanish manufacturers using a survey methodology to obtain information and a structural equation model to analyse the data. Findings The results obtained show that, in turbulent environments, the integrated use of agile manufacturing practices promotes manufacturing competitive strength, leading to better operational, market and financial performance. Research limitations/implications This study has two main limitations. First, it is difficult to determine the most suitable unit of analysis when studying agile manufacturing. Second, single respondent bias may be considered a limitation. Practical implications Managers should consider the integrated implementation of agile manufacturing practices in order to develop manufacturing strength and to outperform competitors in turbulent business environments. Originality/value This study adopts a systematic approach to the analysis of agile manufacturing, considering various agility practices or enablers in an integrated way and relating them not only to environmental characteristics but also to business performance. This approach is especially interesting because most of the literature on agile manufacturing deals with agility strategies or techniques in an isolated way. The study also tests the suitability of agile manufacturing in real organisations – for the first time in the Spanish context.