Content uploaded by Safaet Alam
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Safaet Alam on Mar 31, 2023
Content may be subject to copyright.
Molecules2023,28,3149.https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules28073149www.mdpi.com/journal/molecules
Review
Papaverine:AMiraculousAlkaloidfromOpiumandIts
MultimedicinalApplication
SaniaAshrafi
1
,SafaetAlam
1,2,
*,ArifaSultana
1
,AsefRaj
1
,NazimUddinEmon
3,4
,FahmidaTasnimRichi
1
,
TasnuvaSharmin
1
,MyunghanMoon
5
,MoonNyeoPark
5
andBongleeKim
5,
*
1
DepartmentofPharmaceuticalChemistry,UniversityofDhaka,Dhaka1000,Bangladesh
2
DrugsandToxinsResearchDivision,BCSIRLaboratoriesRajshahi,BangladeshCouncilofScientificand
IndustrialResearch,Rajshahi6206,Bangladesh
3
DepartmentofPharmacy,FacultyofScienceandEngineering,InternationalIslamicUniversityChiagong,
Chiagong4318,Bangladesh
4
DepartmentofChemistryandBiochemistry,CellandMolecularBiologyProgram,UniversityofArkansas,
Fayeeville,AR72701,USA
5
DepartmentofPathology,CollegeofKoreanMedicine,KyungHeeUniversity,
Seoul02447,RepublicofKorea
*Correspondence:safaet.du@gmail.com(S.A.);bongleekim@khu.ac.kr(B.K.)
Abstract:Thepharmacologicalactionsofbenzylisoquinolinealkaloidsarequitesubstantial,and
haverecentlyaractedmuchaention.Oneoftheprinciplebenzylisoquinolinealkaloidshasbeen
foundintheunripeseedcapsulesofPapaversomniferumL.Althoughitlacksanalgesiceffectsandis
unrelatedtothecompoundsinthemorphineclass,itisaperipheralvasodilatorandhasadirect
effectonvessels.Itisreportedtoinhibitthecyclicadenosinemonophosphate(cAMP)andcyclic
guanosinemonophosphate(cGMP)phosphodiesteraseinsmoothmuscles,andithasbeenobserved
toincreaseintracellularlevelsofcAMPandcGMP.Itinducescoronary,cerebral,andpulmonary
arterydilatationandhelpstolowercerebralvascularresistanceandenhancecerebralbloodflow.
Currentpharmacologicalresearchhasrevealedthatpapaverinedemonstratesavarietyofbiological
activities,includingactivityagainsterectiledysfunction,postoperativevasospasms,andpulmonary
vasoconstriction,aswellasantiviral,cardioprotective,anti-inflammatory,anticancer,neuroprotec-
tive,andgestationalactions.Itwasrecentlydemonstratedthatpapaverinehasthepotentialtocon-
trolSARS-CoV-2bypreventingitscytopathiceffect.Theseexperimentswerecarriedoutbothin
vitroandinvivoandrequireanextensiveunderstandingofthemechanismsofaction.Withits
multiplemechanisms,papaverinecanbeconsideredasanaturalcompoundthatisusedtodevelop
therapeuticdrugs.Tovalidateitsapplications,additionalresearchisrequiredintoitsprecisether-
apeuticmechanismsaswellasitsacuteandchronictoxicities.Therefore,thegoalofthisreviewis
todiscussthemajorstudiesandreportedclinicalstudieslookingintothepharmacologicaleffects
ofpapaverineandthemechanismsofactionunderneaththeseeffects.Additionally,itisrecom-
mendedtoconductfurtherresearchviasignificantpharmacodynamicandpharmacokineticstudies.
Keywords:Papaversomniferum;opium;benzylisoquinoline;papaverine;alkaloid;antiviral;anti-
cancer;SARS-CoV-2;
1.Introduction
Sinceancienttimes,medicinalplantshaveplayedakeyroleintraditionalmedicine
systems.Phytochemicalsarebeingminedmorefrequentlytofindnovelleadsinthedrug
discoveryprocessortofindbeeralternativestoexistingones[1–5].Around75%ofthe
globalpopulation,mostlyfromdevelopingcountries,dependprimarilyontraditional
herbalmedicinesduetotheiraffordabilityandenvironmentallybeneficialqualities[6].
Citation:Ashrafi,S.;Alam,S.;
Sultana,A.;Raj,A.;Emon,N.U.;
Richi,F.T.;Sharmin,T.;Moon,M.;
Park,M.N.;Kim,B.Papaverine:A
MiraculousAlkaloidfromOpium
andItsMultimedicinalApplication.
M
olecules2023,28,3149.hps://
doi.org/10.3390/molecules28073149
AcademicEditors:GiovanniLentini,
MariaMaddalenaCavalluzziand
SolomonHabtemariam
Received:13March2023
Revised:28March2023
Accepted:29March2023
Published:31March2023
Copyright:©2023bytheauthors.Li-
censeeMDPI,Basel,Swierland.
Thisarticleisanopenaccessarticle
distributedunderthetermsandcon-
ditionsoftheCreativeCommonsAt-
tribution(CCBY)license(hps://cre-
ativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Molecules2023,28,31496of22
Accordingtoestimates,20%ofplantspeciesproduce12,000alkaloidscombined,
manyofwhichhavebeenusedinbothtraditionalandmodern-daymedicineforcenturies.
Amongthese,about2500ofthesubstancesaremembersofastructurallydiverseclassof
metabolitesknownasbenzylisoquinolinealkaloids(BIAs),whichalsoincludestheopiate
drugsmorphineandcodeine.Additionally,thebenzylisoquinolinealkaloidfamilyisa
prominentclassofplant-derivedchemicalsthathasshownawiderangeofpharmacolog-
icalactivity,includingantibacterial,antitussive,antispasmodic,andanticancerproperties
[7,8].
Aprominentbenzylisoquinolinealkaloidispapaverine,whichcanbeobtainedfrom
PapaverinesomniferumL.(opiumpoppy).Theopiumalkaloidsincludepapaverine,mor-
phine,codeine,thebaine,noscapine,andnarceine,aswellasasmallpercentageofsome
othercompounds.Variouspiecesoftraditionalresearchevidencehavedemonstrated
opiumalkaloidsinChineseandIndianherbalmedicinetobeeffectiveattreatingavariety
ofailments,includingchroniccough,rectumprolapse,diarrhea,dysentery,andgastroin-
testinalissues.Inaddition,papaverinehasalsobeenincorporatedintherapeuticseings
totreaterectiledysfunction,smoothmusclespasms,andspasmsassociatedwithgastro-
intestinalproblems.Scientistshavealsofoundpapaverineasanonselectivephos-
phodiesterase(PDE)inhibitorinmammals,boostingtheamountofcAMPandcGMP
availableforcellsignaling[9].Hence,thissecondarymetabolitedemandsfurtherexplo-
rationandrequirespharmacologicalresearchinvestigations.Therefore,thecurrentstudy
focusesonthemolecularmechanismsofpapaverine’spharmacologicalpotentialasthey
havebeeninvestigatedindiverseexperimentalmodels.
2.NaturalSourceofPapaverine
Duetotheirphytochemicalcomposition,membersofthegenusPapaver(family:Pa-
paveraceae)arerecognizedfortheirtherapeuticbenefits.ThemostsignificantPapaverspe-
ciesthatcontributesphytochemicalsfordrugdevelopmentisPapaversomniferumL.
(opiumpoppy),whichishighlyproducedincountriessuchasAfghanistan,Myanmar,
Mexico,Laos,Turkey,Czechia,andSpain.OthercommonlycultivatedPapaverspeciesin-
cludeP.bracteatumLindl.(Persianpoppy),P.rhoeasL.(commonpoppyorcornpoppy),
P.dubiumL.,P.pseudo‐orientaleMedw.,andP.orientaleL.,whicharegrownathighalti-
tudesinnorthandnorthwestIran,Russia,theCaucasiaregion,Europe,andAmerica[10].
P.somniferumL.producespapaverinenaturallyinitsunripeseedcapsules.Atotalof40
alkaloidshavebeenfoundintheplant;however,morphine(10–15%),noscapine(4–5%),
codeine(1–3%),papaverine(1–3%),andthebaine(1–3%)arethefiveprimaryalkaloids.
TheprevalenceofpapaverineinIndianspeciesrangesfrom0.5%to3%[11].
3.ChemistryofPapaverine
Benzylisoquinolinealkaloidsholdaprominentplaceinalkaloidchemistryasthey
serveasinvivoprecursorstomanyothernaturallyoccurringisoquinolines.Theyareei-
ther1,2,3,4-tetrahydro,asincoclaurineandN-nororientaline,orfullyaromatic,asinpa-
paverine,palaudine,andescholamine.RingAinthebenzylisoquinolinealkaloidsmay
possesstwoorthreeoxygenatedsubstituents,whileringChasonlyoneortwosubstitu-
ents[12].
Papaverine,alsoknownbyitsIUPACnomenclature1-[(3,4-dimethoxyphenyl)me-
thyl]-6,7-dimethoxyisoquinoline,isoneoftheprincipalbenzylisoquinolinealkaloids
foundinP.somniferum[13,14].Naturally,itisproducedasabyproductofmorphine,co-
deine,andnarcotinesynthesis.Itsm/zratiowasdeterminedtobe340.15417[15].Itisa
neutralsolidthatonlyslightlydissolvesinwater[16].Therearefourmethoxygroupsin
papaverine.EvenifthemoleculelacksaTV-methylgroup,itstillfunctionsasatertiary
base.Itisconsideredapyridinederivativebecauseitmaybereducedtoasecondary
aminebyaddingfourhydrogenatoms,withtheheterocyclicringfusedtoabenzenering
[12](Figure1).
Molecules2023,28,31497of22
Figure1.Structureofpapaverine.
GuidoGoldschmiedtfirstillustratedthestructureofthepapaverinebetweenthe
yearsof1885and1898.Byformingmethiodideanddemonstratingthepresenceoffour
methoxygroupspermole,heestablishedtheexistenceofatertiarynitrogenatom.Under
differentconditions,thebasewasoxidizedwithpotassiumpermanganatetoproducevar-
iousrelatedcompounds(Figure2).
Figure2.Similarcompoundsofpapaverinehelpedtoelucidatethestructureofpapaverine.
Thecurrentstructurewasrecognizedaspapaverinebasedontheevidencemen-
tionedaboveandotherrelevantdata.Followingthesuccessfulsynthesisofpapaverinein
1909,PictetandGamsvalidatedthemolecularstructure[14].
4.BiosynthesisofPapaverine
Twounitsoftyrosinecontributeastheprecursorsforthebiosynthesisofpapaverine,
andtheintermediateproductsinclude(S)-norcoclaurine,laudanine,norlaudanine,retic-
uline,norreticuline,tetrahydropapaverine,anddihydropapaverine.Recentinvestigations
revealedthattheprimarypathwayofpapaverinebiosynthesisintheopiumpoppyhas
beenidentifiedbysystematicsilencingofbenzylisoquinolinealkaloidbiosyntheticgenes.
Therearetwosuggestedmetabolicpathwaysfor(S)-norcoclaurine.Oneinvolves
onlyN-demethylatedintermediates(theNHpathway),whereastheotherinvolves(S)-
reticulineandinvolvesanumberofN-methylatedintermediates(theNCH
3
pathway)
[13,17,18].TheNHrouteadvancesvia(S)-norreticuline[13,19,20](Figure3),whereasthe
NCH
3
routeinvolves(S)-reticuline[13,15,20,21](Figure4).
Molecules2023,28,31497of22
Figure3.TheNHpathwayofpapaverinesynthesis.TYDC=tyrosinedecarboxylase,TyrAT=L-tyrosineaminotransferase,4HPPDC=4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate
decarboxylase,3OHase=tyramine3-hydroxylase,NCS=norcoclaurinesynthase,6OMT=norcoclaurine-6-O-methyltransferase,3’OHase=3’hydroxylase,3’OMT
=3′-O-methyltransferase,4’OMT=3′-hydroxy-N-methylcoclaurine4′-O-methyltransferase,7OMT=norreticuline7-O-methyltransferase,DBOX=dihydrobenzo-
phenanthridineoxidase.
Molecules2023,28,31498of22
Figure4.TheNCH
3
pathwayofpapaverinesynthesis.6OMT=norcoclaurine-6-O-methyltransferase,CNMT=coclaurine-N-methyltransferase,NMCH=(S)-N-
methylcoclaurine3′-hydroxylase,4’OMT=4′-O-methyltransferase,7OMT=reticuline7-O-methyltransferase,3’OMT=3′-O-methyltransferase,LNdeMT=lauda-
nosineN-demethylase,DBOX=dihydrobenzophenanthridineoxidase.
Molecules2023,28,31499of22
ThefirststepinpapaverinebiosynthesisisthecondensationoftwoL-tyrosinederiv-
atives,4-hydroxyphenylacetaldehyde(4HPAA)anddopamine,whichisaccomplished
throughdecarboxylation,meta-hydroxylation,andtransaminationtoproducetheprecur-
sortoallotherbenzylisoquinolinealkaloids,(S)-norcoclaurine.Tyrosinedecarboxylase
(TYDC)andtyramine3-hydroxylase(3OHase)transformL-tyrosineintotyramineand
dopamine,respectively.L-tyrosinecanbetransaminatedbyL-tyrosineaminotransferase
(TyrAT)intheproductionof4HPAA,andthendecarboxylatedbyanenzymeidentified
as4-hydroxyphenylpyruvatedecarboxylase(4HPPDC).Norcoclaurinesynthase(NCS)is
theenzymethatcatalyzesthecondensationof(S)-norcoclaurinefrom4HPAAanddopa-
mine.
Norcoclaurine-6-O-methyltransferase(6OMT)firsttransforms(S)-norcoclaurineinto
(S)-coclaurine.IntheNHpathway,(S)-coclaurinefirstundergoes3′hydroxylationby3′
hydroxylase(3′OHase)andthenisconvertedto(S)-norreticulineby3′-O-methyltransfer-
ase(3′OMT).Ontheotherhand,intheNCH3pathway,(S)-coclaurineistakenupbycoc-
laurineN-methyltransferase(CNMT)toyield(S)-N-methylcoclaurine.(S)-N-methylcoc-
laurineishydroxylatedto3′-hydroxy-N-methylcoclaurineby(S)-N-methylcoclaurine3′-
hydroxylase(NMCH),whichisthentransformedinto(S)-reticulineby3′-hydroxy-N-
Methylcoclaurine4′-O-methyltransferase(4′OMT).Itisinterestingtonotethatonly
NMCHhasbeenreportedtoexhibitstrictstereoisomerandsubstratespecificity,accepting
only(S)-N-methylcoclaurineandrejectingeitherthecorresponding(R)-N-methylcoclau-
rineorN-desmethylcompounds.Asadistinction,theO-andN-methyltransferasesoften
acceptawiderangeof(R)-and(S)-tetrahydroisoquinolines[19].Theenzymereticuline7-
O-methyltransferase(7OMT)canfurthermethylatereticulinetoproducelaudanine,
whichcanthenbefullyO-methylatedtolaudanosineby3′-O-methyltransferase.
ThefinalstepsinpapaverinebiosynthesiscomprisetheoxidationofthefullyO-
methylatedandN-desmethylmoleculetetrahydropapaverinebydihydrobenzophenan-
thridineoxidase(DBOX).
Advancedquantumchemicaldensityfunctionaltheory(DFT)calculations,aswellas
diffusereflectance(Ds),experimentalelectronicabsorption(EAs),matrix-associatedlaser
desorptionionization(MALDI)coupledwithOrbitrapimagingmassspectrometry(MS),
fluorescencespectroscopy(Fs),andcirculardichroic(CD)havebeenusedfortheoretical
andexperimentalelucidationofthepapaverinebiosyntheticpathwayvia(S)-reticuline
(theNCH3pathway)[19,20,22].
5.MechanismofActionofPapaverine
Papaverineisrecognizedasthemosteffectivesmoothmusclerelaxant,asitactsdi-
rectlyonsmoothmusclebyexertingastrongvasodilatingeffect.Ithasbeenobservedto
boostintracellularlevelsofcAMPandcGMPbyblockingthecAMPandcGMPphos-
phodiesteraseinsmoothmuscles(Figure5)[23–27].Inhibitingthereleaseofcalciumfrom
theintracellularspaceandobstructingcalciumionchannelsinthecellmembranearetwo
otherwaysthatpapaverinemaywork[28].
Molecules2023,28,314910of22
Figure5.Mechanismofactionofpapaverineinsmoothmusclerelaxation.Smoothmusclecontrac-
tionrequiresfivesteps:AftertheincreaseinintracellularCa
2+
concentrationfromtheextracellular
fluid,theseionsbindtoaproteincalledcalmodulin(CaM).Thiscomplexactivatesaproteincalled
myosinlight-chainkinase(MLCK)(papaverineinhibitsthisstep),whichsubsequentlyphosphory-
lateslightchainsofmyosinheads,increasingthemyosinATPaseactivity.Finally,activemyosin
cross-bridgesslidealongactinandcreatemuscletensiontocontractthecell.
6.PharmacologicalPropertiesofPapaverine
PapaverinehasbeendemonstratedtobeaparticularPDE
10
Aphosphodiesterasein-
hibitor,whichismostlyfoundinthestriatumofthebrain.Thechronicinjectionofitinto
miceresultedinmotorandcognitivedeficitsaswellaselevatedanxiety.Otherstudies
havesuggestedthatitmayalsohaveanantipsychoticeffect.However,notallresearch
hassupportedthistheory[29,30].Nevertheless,papaverinehasbeenapprovedforthe
treatmentofGIT,bileduct,andureterspasmolyticdisorders[31].
6.1.ActivityagainstErectileDysfunction(ED)
PDE
5
inhibitorsareusedasthefirst-linetherapyforED[32].Asapopularvasodila-
tor,theirusagehasbeenobservedtoimprovepenileimpotence[33].ItsabilitytotreatED
andimpotencehasbeenknownforalongtime.Byfar,thelargestnumberofstudieshave
beenpublisheddemonstratingtheeffectivenessofpapaverineintreatingerectiledysfunc-
tion(ED)andimpotence[34].Threesimultaneousandsynergisticprocessesworkto-
gethertomaintainnormalerectilefunction:(1)relaxationofthecavernosalsmoothmus-
cle,(2)anincreaseinpenilearterialinflowcausedbyneurologicalactivity,and(3)are-
strictionofvenousoutflowfromthepenis.Theseprocessesoccurduetothefollowing:(1)
theactivationofcGMP-dependentproteinkinaseG(PKG);(2)theactivationofcGMP-
dependentionchannelsthatreduceintracellularCa
2+
byCa
2+
sequestrationand/orextru-
sion;(3)theopeningofK
+
channels,causingthehyperpolarizationofcorpuscavernosum
smoothmusclecells;and(4)theactivationofmyosinlight-chainphosphatases.Theobjec-
tiveofEDpharmacotherapyistodevelopnovelpharmacologicaltargetsthatinhibitthe
contractilesystems(α-adrenoceptorantagonists)andactivate(e.g.,prostaglandinE
1
(PGE
1
),NO-donors,andforskolin)oraugment(e.g.,PDEinhibitorsandgenetherapy)the
vasodilatorysystemstoproducegreatertrabecularsmoothmusclerelaxationofthecor-
poracavernosa[35–37](Figure6).
Molecules2023,28,314911of22
Figure6.Mechanismofactionofpapaverineinrelaxationofcavernosalsmoothmuscle.Papaverine
blockscAMPandcGMPphosphodiesterasetoraisetheconcentrationofcAMPandcGMP,which
furtherreleasesMLCPthatdephosphorylatesmyosin,resultinginsmoothmusclerelaxationand
increasedcGMPthatactivatesPKGandleadstosmoothmusclerelaxation(1).ActivatedPKGlow-
ersCa
2+
influx.Ca
2+
activatesMLCK,whichcontractssmoothmuscleviamyosinphosphorylation
(2).PapaverineinduceseffluxofK+withsubsequenthyperpolarizationandrelaxationofcorpora
cavernosasmoothmusclecells.
Intracavernouspapaverinewasfoundtoplayavitalroleinthemanagementofmale
erectilefailureinastudyon48patientswithpsychogenicimpotence.Intracavernouspa-
paverineinduceserectionbyseveralmechanisms.Itrelaxesthesmoothmusclesofsinus-
oidsandincreasesthearterialflowtothecorpora.Theuseofpapaverinehasalsobeen
linkedtoincreasedvenousoutflowresistance[34,38].Researchconductedon17menwith
organicimpotencerevealedpapaverinegeltocauseanoticeablylargercavernousartery
diameter[39].Althoughitsuseasamonotherapytotreatimpotencewasinitiallyques-
tionedduetopriapismbeingasignificantsideeffect(whichoccursin15–18%ofpatients),
physicianssoondiscoveredthatthissideeffectwasdose-dependentandonlyoccursin
patientswithneurogenicimpotence[40,41].Tolessentoxicityandpriapism,papaverine
wascombinedwithphentolamineandPGE
1
[35].Byraisingtheamountofintracellular
cyclicadenosinemonophosphate,relaxingthesmoothmuscleofthecavernousbodyand
helicinearteries,andinhibitingtheenzymephosphodiesterase,papaverineandphentola-
minewereabletosignificantlyincreaseerectionsinvariousexperiments[42,43].Ithas
beenobservedthatpapaverine’seffectivenessisequaltothatoforalsildenafilinadiffer-
enttrialthatinvolved31malepatientswhohadEDinjuriesandwereintheearlystages
ofparaplegia[44].Recently,itwasdiscoveredthatanewtopicalformulationusinglyo-
tropicliquidcrystal(LLC)systemsandpapaverine-HClwasasuitableandefficientsub-
stitutefortheinjectableformulationinthetreatmentofED[34].Accordingtoastudy
conductedinvitro,thesubstanceincreasesthemotilityofpost-thawsperm[34].
6.2.ActivityagainstPulmonaryVas o c o n s t r i c tion
Theprotectiveeffectsofpapaverineonthelungshavebeendemonstratedthrough
variousmechanisms.Inamodelofpulmonaryembolismcausedbyautologousblood
clotsinrabbitlungsthatwereisolatedandperfused,papaverinewasdiscoveredtolessen
pulmonaryvasoconstrictionandedema.Inthepulmonaryvascularbed,papaverinecan
diminishthevasoconstrictorresponsetoET-1,TxA
2
,andserotoninwithoutalteringtheir
Molecules2023,28,314912of22
release.ItisgenerallyknownthatPDEinhibitorsalsohaveantiplateleteffectsduetotheir
abilitytoraisecAMPlevels.Papaverine,inparticular,hasbeendemonstratedtoreduce
plateletaggregationbroughtonbyADPaswell.Suchanoutcomemighthavecontributed
tothebeerresultsobservedinthepapaverine-treatedgroupin[45].Itwasdiscovered
thatitinhibitsvoltage-gatedCa2+channelsinaconcentration-dependentmanner,result-
ingintherelaxationoftrachealsmoothmuscle[46].Papaverinewithnifedipineeffectively
decreasedthepulmonaryarteryvasoconstrictionbroughtonbyECS(Euro-Collinssolu-
tion).TheelevationincAMPcausedbypapaverinemayimprovelungpreservation.Ad-
ditionally,ithasbeennotedtoreduceCa2+influxviacellmembranes[34].
6.3.PostoperativeVas o s p a s m
Tosignificantlyminimizepostoperativevasospasmsandmaintainregularvascular
morphologythroughoutantispasmodictherapy,papaverine-loadedelectrospunfibrous
membranesweredeveloped[47].Inarabbitmodel,itwasdiscoveredthattheintra-arte-
rialrouteismoreeffectiveforloweringautologousblood-inducedcerebralvasospasms
[48].Foraverylongtime,papaverinehasbeenusedtopreventvasospasmsinducedby
subarachnoidhemorrhage[49].Innumerousinvestigations,includinginpatientswho
hadaneurysmalsubarachnoidhemorrhages,theeffectivenessofpapaverineinavoiding
vasospasmswasvalidated.Papaverinecanbegiveneitheronitsownorinconjunction
withtransluminalballoonangioplasty.Inthesecircumstances,papaverinehasbeenfound
toimprovecerebraloxygenation,increasetheangiographicvesseldiameter,decreasethe
extendedcerebralcirculationtime,andboostcerebralbloodflowinanefforttoprevent
cerebralinfarction.Here,asignificantbarrieristheshort-livednatureofpapaverine[50–
53].Asustained-releaseformulationthatcanbeimplantedintracraniallymightminimize
this,anditwouldalsolowerthelikelihoodofhypotensionduringsurgery[54].Neverthe-
less,adifferenttrialinvolving31patientswithasubarachnoidhemorrhage-relatedvaso-
spasmfoundnoadditionalbenefitsfrompapaverinewhencomparedtothemedicaltreat-
mentofvasospasmsalone.Theauthorscametotheconclusionthatchangingthetimeor
indicationsfortherapeuticinterventioncouldbeadvantageous[49].Anotherretrospec-
tivestudyonnineconsecutivepatientswithacutelarge-arteryocclusiontreatedwitha
stentretrieverandintra-arterialpapaverinedemonstratedanincreaseinthecaliberand
flowoftheinfusedarteries,suggestingasafeandeffectivemethodoftreatingcerebral
vasospasmsfollowingmechanicalthrombectomyinacuteischemicstroke[55].Another
investigationof27patientswithasubarachnoidhemorrhage-relatedsymptomaticvaso-
spasmdiscoveredthatintra-arterialpapaverineconsistentlyreducescerebralcirculation
time[56].Followingintra-arterialinfusionofpapaverine,individualswithsymptomatic
vasospasmsshowedanimprovementincerebraloxygenationaswellasareductionin
cerebrallacticacidosis[57].
6.4.AntiviralProperties
Papaverineisalsorecognizedforitsantiviralactivitiesagainstdifferenthumanvi-
rusesandthemurineretrovirus,MSV-Harvey.Ithasbeenhypothesizedthat,atleastfor
themeaslesvirus,interferencewithcellularDNAsynthesisdirectly,competitiveandre-
versiblebindingtotheDNAmolecule,oranincreaseinendogenouscAMPwillimpede
viralRNAsynthesisandthephosphorylationofviralproteins[58].Inastudy,papaverine
suppressedtheviralgrowthofmeaslesinneuroblastomacellsbyinhibitingthesynthesis
ofviralRNAsinadose-dependentandreversiblemanner[59].Itwasreportedtoshow
effectiveantiviralactivitybyinhibitingthereplicationoftheCMVvirus.Themechanism
ofactionunderlyingtherelaxingeffectofthesedrugsonsmoothmusclemaypreventat
leasttheinitialcellrounding,anditispossiblethatacriticalphysiologicevent(s)(e.g.,the
riseinintracellularfreeCa2+)maybeimportanttobothearlycellularresponsesandCMV
replication[60].PapaverineinhibitedthereplicationofHIVinH9celllinesbyblocking
theRTactivityandp24expression.Italsoshowedinhibitingactivityintheperipheral
bloodmononuclearcell(PBMC)culturebyinfluencingtheviralmarkersRTandp24
Molecules2023,28,314913of22
[58,61].Itinhibitedthereplicationofthemeaslesvirusinneuralcells[62].Papaverine
showedadose-dependentinhibitionofmultiplestrainsofinfluenzaviruswhen
A/WSN/33(H1N1),A/Udorn/72(H3N2),andB/Lee/40wereusedinastudy[63].Inavery
recentstudy,papaverinerevealeditsabilitytoinhibittheSARS-CoV-2cytopathicityin
thehumanepithelialcolorectaladenocarcinomacellline,Caco-2[64](Table1).
Tab l e 1.Antiviralpropertiesofpapaverine.
MoleculeActivity
Against
Experimental
ApproachesKeyResultMechanism
ofActionReference
Papaverine
hydrochlo‐
ride
HIV
Determinationofviral
replicationbyliquid
competitionradioim-
munoassayinH9cell
lineandinperipheral
bloodmononuclearcell
(PBMC)culture.
-Thedrugatacon-
centrationof10
µg/mLresultedin
noreversetran-
scriptaseactivityor
p24expression-spe-
cificviralmarkersin
thesupernatantand
novirusantigende-
tectionatthecellu-
larlevel.
-Thedrugaffected
thesynthesisofthe
envprecursorpro-
teingpl60.
-Amarkeddecrease
intheexpressionof
theviralproteins
wasalsoobserved
aftertreatmentwith
papaverine.
-InterferewithDNAsyn-
thesisthroughcompeti-
tiveandreversiblebind-
ingtotheDNAmolecule.
-Fromthedata,theau-
thorsconcludedthatpa-
paverineseemstoaffect
thelatestepsofHIVrep-
lication.Infact,theselec-
tiveeffectsondifferent
proteinssuggestthatpa-
paverineactsafterre-
versetranscription.
[58]
Determinationofviral
replicationinMT4cell
lineandinperipheral
bloodmononuclearcell
(PBMC)culture.Exami-
nationofT-celllym-
phocytes.
Papaverinesignifi-
cantlyinhibitedHIV
replicationbymore
than99%atdosesof
30µMwithanCD50
andED50of32µM
and5.8µM,respec-
tively.
Thedrugmightaffectcel-
lularDNAsynthesisand
reversetranscription,in-
directlyinhibitingHIV
replication.
[61]
PapaverineMeaslesvirus
Determinationofviral
replicationinneural
andnon-neuralcells.
Analysisofmechanism
fortheinhibitionofvi-
ralreplication.
Suppressionofvi-
rusgrowthwas
mostprominentin
neuroblastomacells,
followedbythatin
epidermoidcarci-
nomaandglioblas-
tomacells.
-SynthesisofviralRNAs,
includinggenomicRNA
andmRNA,wasinhib-
ited.
-Phosphorylationofthe
viralproteinswasinhib-
ited.
[59]
PapaverineCMV
Assaysforinhibitionof
infectiousCMVyields
onhumanembryo
skin-muscle(SM)cells.
Assaysfortherateof
Inhibitionofthe
multiplicationof
CMV.Papaverine
wasthemostpotent
ofthethreedrugs
-Relaxingeffectofpapa-
verineonsmoothmuscle
mayatleastpreventthe
initialcellrounding.
[60]
Molecules2023,28,314914of22
cellDNAsynthesisby
measuringtheincorpo-
rationof[methyl3H]
thymidineintocell
DNA.
(papaverine,vera-
pamilandsodium
nitroprusside);ata
concentrationof30
µg/m(80µM)the
CMVyieldwasin-
hibitedby5.21log10
at120hrpostinfec-
tion(PI).
-Thegreaterpotencyof
papaverinerelativetoni-
troprussidemayhavere-
sultedfromincreasedlev-
elsofbothcyclicAMP
(cAMP)andcyclicGMP
(cGMP)ratherthanfrom
cGMPalone.
-Itispossiblethatacriti-
calphysiologicevent(s)
(e.g.,theriseinintracellu-
larfreeCa2+)maybeim-
portanttobothearlycel-
lularresponsesandCMV
replication.
Papaverine
Variousstrainsofin-
fluenzavirusaswell
astheparamyxovi-
rusesparainfluenza
virus5(PIV5),human
parainfluenzavirus3
(HPIV3),andrespira-
torysyncytialvirus
(RSV)
Determinationofanti-
viralactivitybyplaque
reductionneutraliza-
tiontest(PRNT).
Dose-dependentin-
hibitionofinfluenza
virusstrains.
-Kineticstudiesdemon-
stratedthatpapaverine
inhibitedinfluenzavirus
infectionatalatestagein
theviruslifecycle
throughthesuppression
ofnuclearexportof
vRNP,andalsointerfered
withthehostcellular
cAMPandMEK/ERKcas-
cadepathways.
[63]
PapaverineSARS-CoV-2Cytopathicityassays.
InhibitSARS-CoV-2
cytopathicityinthe
humanepithelial
colorectaladenocar-
cinomacellline,
Caco-2,withIC50
valueof1.1±0.39.
Additionalstudiesre-
quired.[64]
6.5.CardiovascularActivity
Papaverineexhibitedpotentcardioprotectiveeffectsbydiversemechanisms.Itdi-
rectlystimulatedthesinusrateandatrialcontractilitybydemonstratingpositivechrono-
tropicandinotropiceffectsonanisolatedatrialpreparationfromadog,whichagain
pointstotheinhibitionofPDEandaccumulatedcAMP.Additionally,papaverinemay
partiallytriggerthereleaseofcatecholaminesfromadrenergicnervefibersandmayin-
terferewiththeprocessofadenosineuptake.Itishypothesizedthatpapaverinemaydi-
rectlystimulateatrialcontractilityandSAnodalpacemakeractivity[65].Similareffects
werefoundinanotherstudywherepapaverinedisplayedpositiveinotropiceffectson
atrialpreparation,whereasinventricularpreparation,itdidnotaffecttheforceofcon-
tractionsignificantly[66].PapaverineinhibitsbothhKv1.5andnativehKv1.5channelsin
aconcentration,voltage,state,andtime-dependentmanner.Thisinteractionshowsthat
papaverinemaychangecardiacexcitabilityinvivo[67].
Molecules2023,28,314915of22
6.6.Anti‐InflammatoryActivity
ThroughthecAMP/PKAandMEK/Erkpathways,papaverinereducedtheexpres-
sionofproinflammatoryfactorsandinhibitedtheactivationofprimaryretinalmicroglia
causedbyLPS,andtheMEK/ErkpathwaymaybepartiallyregulatedbycAMP/PKA,
whichcanprovidetheoreticalandexperimentalsupportforitsprotectionofthecentral
nervoussystem[68].Yoshikawaetal.firstnoticedthatpapaverinecouldpreventthere-
leaseofTNF-αandIL-1βinLPS-inducedBV2cells[69].Similaractivitieswerereported
inanotherstudywherepapaverinepreventedtheproductionofnitricoxideandproin-
flammatorycytokinesinLPS-stimulatedmicroglia[31].Furthermore,itappearedtohave
anti-inflammatoryeffectsinmousemodelsbyinhibitinghighmobilitygroupbox1-me-
diatedinflammatoryresponses[70].SimilareffectsweredemonstratedinLPS-stimulated
macrophagesandmicrogliawherepapaverinesuppressedTNF-α[68,71],IL1β,andthe
NF-κBsignalingpathway[72],thusprovingitspotentialtotreatneurodegenerativedis-
eases.
6.7.AnticancerActivity
Itwasfoundthatpapaverineeffectivelyinducedamorphologicalchangeandinhib-
itedproliferationandtheinvasivepotentialofhumanprostatecelllinesPC-3,DU145,and
LNCaPprimarilythroughitsPDE-inhibitingcapability,whichresultedinraisedcAMP
levels[73].SimilareffectswerereportedontheLNCaPcelllineduetoasynergisticeffect
inducedbyacombinationofpapaverineandprostaglandinE2(PGE2)[74]andonPC-3by
inducingapoptosisandcellcyclearrestalongwiththedownregulationofNFkBandthe
PI3K/Aktsignalingpathway[75].Thephytochemicalhasbeenreportedtoexhibitcyto-
toxiceffectsoncancerousHT29,T47D,andHT1080celllineswithoutaffectingthenon-
cancerousmouseNIH3T3celllineascomparedtodoxorubicin,awidelyusedanticancer
drug.ThemechanismbehinditwasselectiveDNAdamageandtheinductionofapoptosis
oncancerouscelllines[76].Itexpressedacytotoxiceffectagainstcancerstemcells,espe-
ciallyhumanbreastcancercelllineMCF-7,byarrestingthecellcycleintheG1phaseand
inducingapoptosis[77].Antiproliferativeactivityofthecompoundwasreportedonhepa-
tocarcinomacelllineHepG-2asitaffectedthetelomeraseactivity[78].Ithasbeenproven
tobeaneffectiveradiosensitizingagentthatreducestherateofoxygenconsumption
throughtheinhibitionofmitochondrialcomplexI.Thus,thecompoundwasfoundtoim-
provetheresponsetoradiationtherapyandisapotentialcandidatefortumorhypoxia
treatment[9].Papaverineisfoundtopreventcellmigrationanddelayzebrafishdevelop-
mentbysuppressingthekit-signalingpathway[79].Thecompoundsignificantlyinhib-
itedtheproliferationofhumanglioblastomacelllinesU87MGandT98Gandthetumor
volumeintheU87MGxenograftmousemodel[80,81].Thepapaverine–Au(III)complex
wasreportedtohavebeercytotoxicactivitiesagainsthumanbreastcancerMCF-7cells
andhepatocellularcarcinomaHepG-2cellsthanpapaverineitself,andtheinhibitingabil-
itywashigherthanthatofcisplatinagainstMCF-7[16].Caroverine,whichisonederiva-
tiveofpapaverine,preventedtheexpressionofVEGF,whichisawell-knowntumor-pro-
motingfactor[82].Inanotherstudy,apapaverineoxidationproductthatisa6a,12a-di-
azadibenzo-[a,g]fluorenyliumderivativeinhibitedtheMCF-7celllinebyblockingthe
G0/G1phaseofthecellcycleandtelomeraseactivity[83].AninvestigationinvolvingS.
cerevisiaeanddockingandmoleculardynamicsimulationstudiesshowedevidencethat
papaverineinducesROS-mediatedapoptosisandinhibitsBcr-Abldownstreamsignaling
[84](Table2).
Molecules2023,28,314916of22
Tab l e 2.Anticancerpropertiesofpapaverine.
MoleculeCellLineCellTypeSignificantBenefit
AchievedReference
PapaverinePC-3,DU145,and
LNCaPProstatecancer
Inducedmorphologic
changeandalsoraised
intracellularcyclic
AMPlevelsinLNCaP
cells.
[73]
Papaverinecombined
withprostaglandinE2
(PGE2)
LNCaPProstatecancer
Decreasedproliferation
andmalignancyof
LNCaPcellsand
causedthesuppression
oftheexpressionofon-
cogenessuchasc-myc
andBcl-2indifferenti-
atedLNCaPcells.
[74]
PapaverinePC-3Prostatecancer
Showedcytotoxicef-
fectsbyinducingearly
andlateapoptosis
alongwithinducing
sub-G1cellcyclearrest,
andcausedthedown-
regulationofBlc-2,
Bax,andNF-kBpro-
teinsandPI3Kand
phospho-Aktexpres-
sion.
[75]
PapaverineHT29,T47D,and
HT1080
Colorectalcancer,
breastcancer,andfi-
brosarcomacells
Showedcytotoxicef-
fectsbyselectiveDNA
damageandinduction
ofapoptosis.
[76]
PapaverineMCF-7andMDA-MB-
231Breastcancer
Showedcytotoxicef-
fectsbyarrestingcell
cycleinG0/G1phase
andinducingapopto-
sis.
[77]
PapaverineHepG-2Hepatocarcinoma
Inducedantiprolifera-
tiveactivitybyinhibit-
ingtelomerasethrough
downregulationof
hTERTgene.
[78]
Papaverinecombined
withtemozolomideU87MGandT98GGlioblastoma
Significantlyinhibited
theclonogenicityofthe
celllines,delayedtu-
morgrowth,andin-
creasedtheradiosensi-
tivityofT98Gcells.
[80,81]
Papaverine–Au(III)
complexMCF-7andHepG-2
Breastcancerand
hepatocellularcarci-
noma
Showedsignificantcy-
totoxicactivityagainst
theexaminedcelllines.
[16]
Molecules2023,28,314917of22
Additionally,theAu
complexshowedanti-
canceractivityagainst
thebreastcancerMCF-
7cellsbetterthanthat
ofcisplatin.
Papaverine
HCT15(colon),A549
(lung),HeLa(cervical),
K562(Bcr-Ablpositive
CML),andRAW264.7
Colon,lung,cervical,
andlymphoblastcan-
cers
InducedROS-mediated
apoptosisandinhibited
Bcr-Abldownstream
signaling.
[84]
Caroverine,derivative
ofpapaverineLT97andSW480ColorectalcancerInhibitionofexpres-
sionofVEGF.[82]
6a,12a‐diazadibenzo‐
[a,g]fluorenylium,de‐
rivativeofpapaverine
MCF-7Breastcancer
InhibitionofMCF-7
celllinebyblocking
G0/G1phaseofthecell
cycleandtelomerase
activity.
[83]
6.8.NeuroprotectiveEffect
Papaverinemayalsoexertneuroprotectiveeffectstotreatneuropsychiatricdiseases
suchasschizophreniaanddepression[85,86].Inaclinicaltrialinvolvingthreefemalepa-
tientswithtardivedyskinesia,itwasrevealedthatdaily300to600mgdosesofpapaverine
improvedthedyskinesiaconditionwithoutshowinganysideeffects.Theauthorscon-
cludedthattheeffectswereduetotheinhibitionofthedopaminepathway,whichmight
bethereasonfordyskineticmovements[87].Thestudywasagainconductedwithalarger
numberofpatientsviatheoraladministrationofsustained-release150mgpapaverine
capsules.Twooutofninepatientsshowedclinicalimprovements[88].Oro-facialdyski-
nesiawasimprovedinanotherclinicaltrialconductedon150patients[89].Papaverine
wasalsofoundtopotentiatenervegrowthfactor(NGF)-inducedneuriteoutgrowthin
PC12cellsinaconcentration-dependentmanner[90].Bysignificantlyraisingthelevelsof
BDNF,synapsin-IIa,DCX,pCREB,IL-10,andGSHinvariousbrainregionswhilesignifi-
cantlyloweringthelevelsofTNF-α,IL-6,andTBARS,thedrugwasfoundtorestorethe
basicbehavioralphenotypeinautismspectrumdisorder[9].Anotherstudyrevealedthat
thesubstancemaybeusefulinreducingtheischemicinfarctvolume,suggestingthatit
maybeusedtotreatcerebralischemiainclinicalpractice[91].BymodifyingtheNF-Band
CREBsignalingpathways,itpreventstheactivationoftheNLRP3inflammasome,which
reducesmicroglialactivationandneuronalcelldeath.Asaresult,itcouldbeapromising
treatmentforParkinson’sdisease,whichisexacerbatedbysystemicinflammation[92].In
thesubacuteMPTP/PanimalmodelofParkinson’sdisease,thedatarevealedthatpapa-
verinereducesneuroinflammationandMMP-3production,whichpreventsdopaminergic
neuronalcelldeathandα-synucleinaggregation.Inlightofthis,itmightbeaviablemed-
icationforthemanagementofParkinson’sdisease[93].Papaverineenhancedcognitive
functioninamousemodelwithHuntington’sdiseasebyinhibitingPDE10,resultingin
cAMP-responsiveelement-bindingprotein(CREB)phosphorylationandGluA1[94].It
alsoprovidedefficientprotectiontothespinalcordduringdescendingthoracicandthora-
coabdominalaorticaneurysmrepairsurgerybyperfusingthespinalcord[1].Inanother
study,papaverinerevealeditsdirecteffectonsynapticvesicles,whichwasexhibitedvia
theincreaseinnorepinephrineanddopamine-β-hydroxylasefromisolatedperfusedcat
spleen[95].Furthermore,papaverinetemporarilyincreasedsublingualmicrocirculatory
bloodflowinsepticshockpatientswhoneededvasoconstrictorstomaintainbloodpres-
sureduringfluidresuscitationwithoutaffectingsystemichemodynamics[96].
Molecules2023,28,314918of22
6.9.GestationalActivity
Inthe1990s,researchonpapaverineanditsderivativesrevealedthattheycould
shortenthetimeneededforthefirststageoflabor.AspecificinhibitorofPDE4,drotaver-
inehydrochloride,isahomologofpapaverine.Becauseofitsabilitytorelaxsmoothmus-
cles,itwasfoundtobebeneficialinacceleratingcervicaldilation[97].Madhuetal.found
thatwomenwhoweretreatedwithdrotaverinethroughthelatentphaseoflaborhada
significantlyshortertimebetweentheadministrationofthemedicationandthedelivery
ofthefetuscomparedtowomenwhoweretreatedwithaplacebo.Thestudyinvolved146
womenwhogavebirthvaginally(182mincomparedto245minwithaplacebo)[98].An-
otherretrospectivecomparativeinvestigationof498pregnantwomenindicatedthat
short-termprenatalexposuretopapaverineadjustedforindicationwasnotlinkedtopre-
termbirths,cesareanbirth,reducedbirthweight,smallgestationalage,orperinataldeath
[99].Additionally,itwasclaimedthatthemedicationworkedwelltolowerpre-eclamptic
patients’bloodpressure[100].
6.10.OtherActivities
Papaverinehydrochlorideisequallyaseffectiveassodiumdiclofenacfortheshort-
termreliefofacuterenalcolicpain,anditmaybeadvantageousinpatientswithcontra-
indicationsaccordingtoaprospective,single-blindclinicalstudythatinvolved86patients
withacuterenalcolicwhoweregiven120mgintravenouspapaverinehydrochloride
[101].Anotherstudyfoundthattheinjectionofalprostadilandpapaverineintothesper-
maticcordprotectedagainstischemia/reperfusioninjuryfollowingright-sidetestestor-
sionandreducedhistologicalalterationsfollowingtesticularischemia-reperfusioninjury
[102].
7.LimitationsoftheStudy
Executinganidealdrugdiscoveryanddevelopmentprocessisoneoftheprimary
challengesforthepharmaceuticalresearchcommunity.ADMEisacriticalstepinthedrug
designprocessthatinvestigatesthefateofadrugmoleculeafteringestion.Notably,drug
metabolismstudiesarecriticalprocessesforoptimizingtheleadcompoundswithoptimal
PK/PDfeatures,identifyingnewchemicalentitiesbasedonthediscoveryofactivemetab-
olites,minimizingpotentialsafetyliabilitiesduetothedevelopmentofreactiveortoxic
metabolites,comparingpreclinicalmetabolisminanimalswithhumanstoguaranteethat
animalsusedinexperimentshavethepotentialtoadequatelycoverhumanmetabolites
andsupporthumandosepredictions,andsoon[103].However,ADMEandthePK/PD
parametersofpapaverinewerenotevidentinthisreview.Whenitcomestodrugarition
duringtheclinicalstageofdevelopment,compoundfailureratesbecauseofthetoxicity
priortohumantestingarerelativelyhigh,andtheymayaccountforupto30%oftheloss.
Inordertoestablishananticipatedsafedoserangeandtogatherknowledgeondrugdis-
tribution,organ-specifictoxicity,andmetabolism,toxicologystudiesinatleasttwonon-
humanspeciesaretypicallyutilized[104].Thetoxicologicalparametersofpapaverine
werenotdefinedinthisreview.Propertranslationanddeterminationofthemaximum
recommendedstartingdoseinhumansisacriticaltaskinnewdrugdevelopmentand
research[105].Nospecificdoseofpapaverinewasstudiedinthisreview.Moreover,study
dataarenotavailableforuseinlactatingmothersandpediatricandgeriatricpatients.The
three-dimensionalityofmoleculesisintimatelyrelatedtotheclinicalsuccessofdrugcan-
didates[106],whichwasnotelaboratedoninthisreview.Theefficacyoftraditionalmed-
icinesisfrequentlytheconsequenceofasynergisticinteractionbetweennumerouscom-
ponents,targets,andpathways[107].Thisreviewdidnotincludethepositiveornegative
synergisticeffectsofpossibleanalogsofpapaverinefoundinopium.Possiblesideeffects
ofpapaverineincludepriapism,penilefibrosis,andarrythmia[108].Nostudieshavebeen
Molecules2023,28,314919of22
conductedonwhetherthesesideeffectscanbeutilizedasasecondaryusageviarepur-
posing;e.g.,metforministhefirst-linetherapyoftypeIIdiabetes,anditcanberepurposed
asanantiobesitydrugforbothdiabeticandnondiabeticpatients[109,110].
8.DiscussionandFutureRecommendations
Papaverinehasbeenproventobeahigh-valueopioidalkaloidinthefieldofthera-
peuticseitherinsolitudeorincombinationwithothermetabolites/molecules[9].Itwas
approvedbytheFoodandDrugAdministration(FDA)oftheUnitedStatesasavasodila-
tortobepredominantlyusedinthetreatmentofcerebralvasospasmsandcoronarycircu-
lation[108].Severalpreclinicalandclinicalstudiesalsodemonstrateditspotentialefficacy
againstpulmonaryvasoconstriction,erectiledysfunction,postoperativevasospasms,
someparticularviralinfections,inflammation,cardiacexcitability,carcinoma,neurologi-
caldisturbances,gestationaldifficulties,pre-eclampsia,acuterenalcolicpain,andische-
mia-reperfusioninjury,aswellasothermusclespasm-orientedcomplications
[87,88,91,101].Someofthenotablemechanismsunderlyingthedifferentpharmacological
actionsincludevasodilation,theactivationofcGMPandcAMP-dependentbiomolecules,
theinhibitionofvasoconstrictorresponsestobiomolecules,interferencewithcertainviral
nucleicacids,theinhibitionofcytokinerelease(suchasTNF-α,IL-1β,andNF-κB),the
apoptosisofdiseasedcells,thepotentiationofneuriteoutgrowth,thealterationofdiffer-
entbiomolecularsignalingpathways,etc.,whicharediscussedthroughoutthisreview.
Asaconsequence,themultiplebioactivecapabilitiesofpapaverinesuggestthatitmay
alsobeaneffectivenaturalphytoconstituentindiseasemanagement.Moreover,synthetic
drugsconsistofseveraldrawbacks,suchasalackofbioavailability,cost-effectiveissues,
drugresistanceissues,unexpectedadverseeffects,etc.[111].Tocombatthesedrawbacks,
thereisaneedtosearchforleadcompoundsamongthenaturalsubstances[112].Plants
areapresentfromtheEarththathavebeenprovidingusvitalphytochemicalsforthou-
sandsofyears[113,114].Bioactivephytochemicalsfromnaturalsourcesplaypivotalroles
indrugdiscoveryanddevelopment.Almost80%ofallcurrentlyavailabledrugsareeither
directlyderivedfromplantorareamodifiedversion[115,116].Alkaloidsareaveryim-
portantclassofbioactivephytochemicalsthatplayasignificantroleindrugdiscovery
[117].Thus,papaverineisapotentialnaturaldrugcandidatethatmaybeutilizedinthe
nearfuture.Researchersshouldcarryoutseveralstudiesonthepapaverinealkaloid,in-
cludingbystudyingthedeterminationandrevisionofitsPK/PDparameters,thethera-
peuticindex,safetyandtoxicologicalprofiles,dosage,drug–druginteractions,drug-food
interactions,andotherimportantparameters.Consideringallthesefactors,papaverine
shouldbesubjectedtoextensiveresearchtoestablishitasanoveldrugand/orleadcom-
pound.Thisreviewwillprovidefutureresearcherswithimportantinsightsforfurther
studiesonthisconspicuousalkaloid.
9.Conclusions
Themajorityofthealkaloidsisolatedfromtheopiumpoppyseed,suchasmorphine
andcodeine,haveanalgesicproperties;nevertheless,papaverinevariesfromtheopium
groupofalkaloidsbothchemicallyandtherapeutically.Whilethemajorityoftheprimary
alkaloidchemicalsderivedfromtheopiumpoppyarenarcoticandhaveananalgesicef-
fect,themajorityofpapaverine’spharmacologicalusageisasanon-narcotic,non-analge-
sicsmoothmusclerelaxantandvasodilator.Papaverineisarecognizedinhibitorofphos-
phodiesterases.PapaverineisFDA-approvedandisalreadyinclinicaluseasavasodila-
tor.Itisgainingmoreandmoreaentionforuseinotherbiologicalactivities.Withinthe
scopeofthiswork,wedescribedmultiplebioactivepropertiesofpapaverineinaddition
tothemolecularmechanismsbehindsuchactivities.Bothinvitroandinvivoaswellas
clinicalstudiesshowedthatpapaverinepossessedconsiderablepharmacologicalproper-
tiesbesidesitsvasodilatoreffects.Asaresult,itisavitalpotentialcandidatebothforthe
discoveryofnoveldrugsandthedevelopmentoftheexistingdrug.Asamaeroffact,its
Molecules2023,28,314920of22
antiviralandanticanceractionsbothexhibituniquemechanismsofactionthatshowcon-
siderablepotentialfortreatingtheirrespectiveillnesses,whichdemonstratesthatpapa-
verineisaprominentcandidateforuseintheresearchanddevelopmentofnewantiviral
andanticancermedications.Inaddition,toxicologicalresearchmustbecarriedouttoes-
tablishthesubstance’ssafetyforuseinotherpharmaceuticalapplications.
Aut h orContributions:Conceptualization,S.A.(SaniaAshrafi),S.A.(SafaetAlam),A.S.,A.R.and
B.K.;investigation,S.A.(SaniaAshrafi),S.A.(SafaetAlam),A.S.,A.R.,N.U.E.,F.T.R.,M.M.and
M.N.P.;writing—originaldraftpreparation,S.A.(SaniaAshrafi),S.A.(SafaetAlam),A.S.,A.R.,
N.U.E.,F.T.R.andT.S.;writing—reviewandediting,S.A.(SaniaAshrafi),S.A.(SafaetAlam),N.U.E.,
T.S.andB.K.;visualization,S.A.(SaniaAshrafi)andB.K.Allauthorshavereadandagreedtothe
publishedversionofthemanuscript.
Funding:ThisresearchwassupportedbyBasicScienceResearchProgramthroughtheNational
ResearchFoundationofKorea(NRF)fundedbytheMinistryofEducation(NRF-
2020R1I1A2066868),theNationalResearchFoundationofKorea(NRF)grantfundedbytheKorea
government(MSIT)(No.2020R1A5A2019413),agrantoftheKoreaHealthTechnologyR&DProject
throughtheKoreaHealthIndustryDevelopmentInstitute(KHIDI),fundedbytheMinistryof
Health&Welfare,RepublicofKorea(grantnumber:HF20C0038),andtheinnovationnetworksup-
portProgramthroughtheINNOPOLISfundedbyMinistryofScienceandICT(2022-IT-RD-0205-
01-101).
InstitutionalReviewBoardStatement:Notapplicable.
InformedConsentStatement:Notapplicable.
DataAvailabilityStatement:Notapplicable.
Acknowledgments:SaniaAshrafiisgratefultoRummanAdibforhiscontinuoussupportandmo-
tivationthroughoutthework.
ConflictsofInterest:Therearenoknownfinancialorresearch-basedconflictsofinterestamongthe
authorsofthisresearchworkandarticle.
SampleAvailability:Notapplicable.
References
1. Arora,L.;Hosn,M.A.SpinalCordPerfusionProtectionforThoraco-AbdominalAorticAneurysmSurgery.Curr.Opin.
Anaesthesiol.2019,32,72–79.https://doi.org/10.1097/ACO.0000000000000670.
2. Grdina,D.J.;Murley,J.S.;Kataoka,Y.Radioprotectants:CurrentStatusandNewDirections.Oncology2002,63,2–10.
https://doi.org/10.1159/000067146.
3. Weiss,J.F.;Landauer,M.R.ProtectionagainstIonizingRadiationbyAntioxidantNutrientsandPhytochemicals.Toxicology2003,
189,1–20.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0300-483X(03)00149-5.
4. Alam,S.;Emon,N.;Shahriar,S.;Richi,F.;Haque,M.;Islam,M.;Sakib,S.;Ganguly,A.PharmacologicalandComputer-Aided
StudiesProvideNewInsightsintoMillettiaPeguensisAli(Fabaceae).SaudiPharm.J.2020,28,1777–1790.
5. Ashrafi,S.;Alam,S.;Emon,N.;Ahsan,M.Isolation,CharacterizationandPharmacologicalInvestigationsofaNewPhenolic
CompoundalongwithFourOthersFirstlyReportedPhytochemicalsfromGlycosmis.Molecules2022,27,5972.
https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules27185972.
6. Amin,M.N.;Emdadul,M.;Mukul,H.;Millat,M.S.;Saif,M.;Rashed,U.PhytochemicalNatureandPharmacologicalEvaluation
ofChloroformExtractofPandanusFascicularisL.(Fruits):AninVivoStudyOpenAccess.Artic.J.Bioanal.Biomed.2017,9,4.
https://doi.org/10.4172/1948-593X.1000183.
7. Pyne,M.E.;Narcross,L.;Fossati,E.;Bourgeois,L.;Burton,E.;Gold,N.D.;Martin,V.J.J.ReconstitutingPlantSecondary
MetabolisminSaccharomycesCerevisiaeforProductionofHigh-ValueBenzylisoquinolineAlkaloids.MethodsEnzymol.2016,
575,195–224.https://doi.org/10.1016/BS.MIE.2016.02.011.
8. Ziegler,J.;Facchini,P.J.AlkaloidBiosynthesis:MetabolismandTrafficking.Annu.Rev.PlantBiol.2008,59,735–769.
https://doi.org/10.1146/ANNUREV.ARPLANT.59.032607.092730.
9. Benej,M.;Hong,X.;Vibhute,S.;Scott,S.;Wu,J.;Graves,E.;Le,Q.T.;Koong,A.C.;Giaccia,A.J.;Yu,B.;etal.PapaverineandIts
DerivativesRadiosensitizeSolidTumorsbyInhibitingMitochondrialMetabolism.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA2018,115,10756–
10761.https://doi.org/10.1073/PNAS.1808945115.
10. Butnariu,M.;Quispe,C.;Herrera-Bravo,J.J.;Pentea,M.;Sarac,I.;Küşümler,A.;Özçelik,B.;Painuli,S.;Semwal,P.;Imran,M.;
etal.PapaverPlants:CurrentInsightsonPhytochemicalandNutritionalCompositionAlongwithBiotechnological
Applications.Oxid.Med.Cell.Longev.2022,2022,2041769.
Molecules2023,28,314921of22
11. Peter,K.VHandbookofHerbsandSpices;Elsevier:Amsterdam,TheNetherlands,2012;ISBN0857095684.
12. Shamma,M.TheIsoquinolineAlkaloidsChemistryandPharmacology;Elsevier:Amsterdam,TheNetherlands,2012.
13. Desgagné-Penix,I.;Facchini,P.J.SystematicSilencingofBenzylisoquinolineAlkaloidBiosyntheticGenesRevealstheMajor
RoutetoPapaverineinOpiumPoppy.PlantJ.2012,72,331–344.https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1365-313X.2012.05084.X.
14. Yan,J.;Mi,J.Q.;He,J.T.;Guo,Z.Q.;Zhao,M.P.;Chang,W.B.DevelopmentofanIndirectCompetitiveELISAforthe
DeterminationofPapaverine.Talanta2005,66,1005–1011.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.talanta.2005.01.001.
15. Han,X.;Lamshöft,M.;Grobe,N.;Ren,X.;Fist,A.;Kutchan,T.;Spiteller,M.;Zenk,M.TheBiosynthesisofPapaverineProceeds
via(S)-Reticuline.Phytochemistry2010,71,1305–1312.
16. Gaber,A.;Alsanie,W.F.;Kumar,D.N.;Refat,M.S.;Saied,E.M.NovelPapaverineMetalComplexeswithPotentialAnticancer
Activities.Molecules2020,25,5447.
17. Srivastava,A.;Agrawal,L.;Raj,R.;Jaidi,M.;Raj,S.K.;Gupta,S.;Dixit,R.;Singh,P.C.;Tripathi,T.;Sidhu,O.P.;etal.Ageratum
EnationVirusInfectionInducesProgrammedCellDeathandAltersMetaboliteBiosynthesisinPapaverSomniferum.Front.
PlantSci.2017,8,1172.https://doi.org/10.3389/FPLS.2017.01172/FULL.
18. Agarwal,P.;Pathak,S.;Kumar,R.S.;Dhar,Y.V.;Pandey,A.;Shukla,S.;Trivedi,P.K.3′O-Methyltransferase,Ps3′OMT,from
OpiumPoppy:InvolvementinPapaverineBiosynthesis.PlantCellRep.2019,38,1235–1248.https://doi.org/10.1007/S00299-019-
02439-5.
19. Beaudoin,G.A.W.;Facchini,P.J.BenzylisoquinolineAlkaloidBiosynthesisinOpiumPoppy.Planta2014,240,19–32.
20. Ivanova,B.;Spiteller,M.OntheBiosyntheticPathwayofPapaverinevia(S)-Reticuline—Theoreticalvs.ExperimentalStudy.
Nat.Prod.Commun.2012,7,581–586.https://doi.org/10.1177/1934578X1200700508.
21. Pathak,S.;Lakhwani,D.;Gupta,P.;Mishra,B.K.;Shukla,S.;Asif,M.H.;Trivedi,P.K.ComparativeTranscriptomeAnalysis
UsingHighPapaverineMutantofPapaverSomniferumRevealsPathwayandUncharacterizedStepsofPapaverine
Biosynthesis.PLoSONE2013,8,e65622.https://doi.org/10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0065622.
22. Pienkny,S.;Brandt,W.;Schmidt,J.;Kramell,R.;Ziegler,J.FunctionalCharacterizationofaNovelBenzylisoquinolineO-
methyltransferaseSuggestsItsInvolvementinPapaverineBiosynthesisinOpiumPoppy(PapaverSomniferumL).PlantJ.2009,
60,56–67.
23. Abusnina,A.;Lugnier,C.TherapeuticPotentialsofNaturalCompoundsActingonCyclicNucleotidePhosphodiesterase
Families.Cell.Signal.2017,39,55–65.https://doi.org/10.1016/J.CELLSIG.2017.07.018.
24. Debnath,B.;Singh,W.;Das,M.;Goswami,S.;Singh,M.;Maiti,D.;Manna,K.RoleofPlantAlkaloidsonHumanHealth:A
ReviewofBiologicalActivities.Mater.TodayChem.2018,9,56–72.
25. Dong,H.H.;Guang,Y.B.;Tae,K.Y.;Byung,S.S.;Yong,G.K.;Chul,J.K.TheEffectofPapaverineonIonChannelsinRatBasilar
SmoothMuscleCells.Neurol.Res.2007,29,544–550.https://doi.org/10.1179/016164107X191021.
26. Gomes,D.;Joubert,A.;Visagie,M.InVitroEffectsofPapaverineonCellProliferation,ReactiveOxygenSpecies,andCellCycle
ProgressioninCancerCells.Molecules2021,26,6388.https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules26216388.
27. Shimizu,K.;Yoshihara,E.;Takahashi,M.;Gotoh,K.;Orita,S.;Urakawa,N.;Nakajyo,S.MechanismofRelaxantResponseto
PapaverineontheSmoothMuscleofNon-PregnantRatUterus.J.SmoothMuscleRes.2000,36,83–91.
28. Liu,J.K.;Couldwell,W.T.Intra-ArterialPapaverineInfusionsfortheTreatmentofCerebralVasospasmInducedbyAneurysmal
SubarachnoidHemorrhage.Neurocrit.Care2005,2,124–132.https://doi.org/10.1385/NCC:2:2:124.
29. Hebb,A.L.O.;Robertson,H.A.;Denovan-Wright,E.M.Phosphodiesterase10AInhibitionIsAssociatedwithLocomotorand
CognitiveDeficitsandIncreasedAnxietyinMice.Eur.Neuropsychopharmacol.2008,18,339–363.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euroneuro.2007.08.002.
30. Weber,M.;Breier,M.;Ko,D.;Thangaraj,N.;Marzan,D.E.;Swerdlow,N.R.EvaluatingtheAntipsychoticProfileofthe
PreferentialPDE10AInhibitor,Papaverine.Psychopharmacology2009,203,723–735.https://doi.org/10.1007/s00213-008-1419-x.
31. Lee,Y.-Y.;Park,J.-S.;Leem,Y.-H.;Park,J.-E.;Kim,D.-Y.;Choi,Y.-H.;Park,E.-M.;Kang,J.L.;Kim,H.-S.ThePhosphodiesterase
10InhibitorPapaverineExertsAnti-InflammatoryandNeuroprotectiveEffectsviathePKASignalingPathwayin
NeuroinflammationandParkinson’sDiseaseMouseModels.J.Neuroinflamm.2019,16,1–17.https://doi.org/10.1186/s12974-019-
1649-3.
32. Bakr,A.M.;El-Sakka,A.A.;El-Sakka,A.I.ConsiderationsforPrescribingPharmacotherapyfortheTreatmentofErectile
Dysfunction.ExpertOpin.Pharmacother.2020,22,821–834.https://doi.org/10.1080/14656566.2020.1851365.
33. Fusi,F.;Manetti,F.;Durante,M.;Sgaragli,G.;Saponara,S.TheVasodilatorPapaverineStimulatesL-TypeCa2+CurrentinRat
TailArteryMyocytesviaaPKA-DependentMechanism.Vascul.Pharmacol.2016,76,53–61.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vph.2015.11.041.
34. Berkó,S.;Zsikó,S.;Deák,G.;Gácsi,A.;Kovács,A.;Budai-Szűcs,M.;Pajor,L.;Bajory,Z.;Csányi,E.PapaverineHydrochloride
ContainingNanostructuredLyotropicLiquidCrystalFormulationasaPotentialDrugDeliverySystemfortheTreatmentof
ErectileDysfunction.DrugDes.Devel.Ther.2018,12,12–2923.https://doi.org/10.2147/DDDT.S168218.
35. Bivalacqua,T.J.;Champion,H.C.;Hellstrom,W.J.G.;Kadowitz,P.J.PharmacotherapyforErectileDysfunction.TrendsPharmacol.
Sci.2000,21,484–489.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-6147(00)01587-X.
36. Mcmahon,C.G.NarrativeReviewCurrentDiagnosisandManagementofErectileDysfunction.MJA2019,210,469–476.
https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.50167.
37. Padma-Nathan,H.;Christ,G.;Adaikan,G.;Becher,E.;Brock,G.;Carrier,S.;Carson,C.;Corbin,J.;Francis,S.;Debusk,R.;etal.
PharmacotherapyforErectileDysfunction.J.Sex.Med.2010,7,524–540.https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1743-6109.2009.01627.X.
Molecules2023,28,314922of22
38. Usta,M.;Erdoğru,T.;Tefekil,A.;Köksal,T.;Yücel,B.;Kadioğlu,A.HoneymoonImpotence:PsychogenicorOrganicinOrigin?
Urology2001,57,758–762.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0090-4295(00)01057-8.
39. Wen,M.;El-Kamel,A.;Khalil,S.SystemicEnhancementofPapaverineTransdermalGelforErectileDysfunction.DrugDev.Ind.
Pharm.2012,38,912–922.https://doi.org/10.3109/03639045.2011.633262.
40. Kilic,M.;Serefoglu,E.C.;Ozdemir,A.T.;Balbay,M.D.TheActualIncidenceofPapaverine-InducedPriapisminPatientswith
ErectileDysfunctionFollowingPenileColourDopplerUltrasonography.Andrologia2010,42,1–4.https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1439-
0272.2009.00940.X.
41. Hatzimouratidis,K.;Hatzichristou,D.G.AComparativeReviewoftheOptionsforTreatmentofErectileDysfunction:Which
TreatmentforWhichPatient?Drugs2005,65,1621–1650.https://doi.org/10.2165/00003495-200565120-00003.
42. Bella,A.J.;Brock,G.B.IntracavernousPharmacotherapyforErectileDysfunction.Endocrine2004,23,149–155.
https://doi.org/10.1385/ENDO:23:2-3:149.
43. Claro,J.;Aboim,J.;Maríngolo,M.;Andrade,E.;Aguiar,W.;Nogueira,M.;NardozzaJunior,A.;Srougi,M.Intracavernous
InjectionintheTreatmentofErectileDysfunctionafterRadicalProstatectomy:AnObservationalStudy.SaoPauloMed.J.2001,
119,135–137.
44. Yildiz,N.;Gokkaya,N.K.O.;Koseoglu,F.;Gokkaya,S.;Comert,D.EfficaciesofPapaverineandSildenafilintheTreatmentof
ErectileDysfunctioninEarly-StageParaplegicMen.Int.J.Rehabil.Res.2011,34,44–52.
https://doi.org/10.1097/MRR.0b013e32833d6cb2.
45. Trejo,H.E.;Urich,D.;Pezzulo,A.A.;Caraballo,J.C.;Gutiérrez,J.;Castro,I.J.;Centeno,G.R.;SánchezDeLeón,R.Beneficial
EffectsofHydrocortisoneandPapaverineonaModelofPulmonaryEmbolismInducedbyAutologousBloodClotsinIsolated
andPerfusedRabbitLungs.Respirology2007,12,799–806.https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1440-1843.2007.01177.x.
46. Iguchi,M.;Nakajima,T.;Hisada,T.;Sugimoto,T.;Kurachi,Y.OntheMechanismofPapaverineInhibitionoftheVoltage-
DependentCa++CurrentinIsolatedSmoothMuscleCellsfromtheGuineaPigTrachea.J.Pharmacol.Exp.Ther.1992,263,194–
200.
47. Zhu,W.;Liu,S.;Zhao,J.;Liu,S.;Jiang,S.;Li,B.;Yang,H.;Fan,C.;Cui,W.HighlyFlexibleandRapidlyDegradablePapaverine-
LoadedElectrospunFibrousMembranesforPreventingVasospasmandRepairingVascularTissue.ActaBiomater.2014,10,
3018–3028.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actbio.2014.03.023.
48. Liu,H.-M.;Tu,Y.-K.TheEfficacyofPapaverineAdministrationbyDifferentRoutesfortheTreatmentofExperimentalAcute
CerebralVasospasm.J.Clin.Neurosci.2002,9,561–565.https://doi.org/10.1054/jocn.2001.1036.
49. Biondi,A.;Ricciardi,G.K.;Puybasset,L.;Abdennour,L.;Longo,M.;Chiras,J.;VanEffenterre,R.Intra-ArterialNimodipinefor
theTreatmentofSymptomaticCerebralVasospasmafterAneurysmalSubarachnoidHemorrhage:PreliminaryResults.Am.J.
Neuroradiol.2004,25,1067–1076.
50. Firlik,K.;Kaufmann,A.;Firlik,A.;Jungreis,C.;Yonas,H.Intra-ArterialPapaverinefortheTreatmentofCerebralVasospasm
FollowingAneurysmalSubarachnoidHemorrhage.Surg.Neurol.1999,51,66–74.
51. Sayama,C.M.;Liu,J.K.;Couldwell,W.T.UpdateonEndovascularTherapiesforCerebralVasospasmInducedbyAneurysmal
SubarachnoidHemorrhage.Neurosurg.Focus2006,21,1–11.https://doi.org/10.3171/foc.2006.21.3.12.
52. Kerz,T.;Boor,S.;Beyer,C.;Welschehold,S.;Schuessler,A.;Oertel,J.EffectofIntraarterialPapaverineorNimodipineonVessel
DiameterinPatientswithCerebralVasospasmafterSubarachnoidHemorrhage.Br.J.Neurosurg.2012,26,517–524.
https://doi.org/10.3109/02688697.2011.650737.
53. Kim,J.H.;Yi,H.-J.;Ko,Y.;Kim,Y.-S.;Kim,D.-W.;Kim,J.-M.EffectivenessofPapaverineCisternalIrrigationforCerebral
VasospasmafterAneurysmalSubarachnoidHemorrhageandMeasurementofBiomarkers.Neurol.Sci.2014,35,715–722.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10072-013-1589-0.
54. Vajkoczy,P.;Horn,P.;Bauhuf,C.;Munch,E.;HubnerIng,U.;Thome,C.;Poeckler-Schoeninger,C.;Roth,H.;Schmiedek,P.
EffectofIntra-ArterialPapaverineonRegionalCerebralBloodFlowinHemodynamicallyRelevantCerebralVasospasm.Stroke
2001,32,498–505.https://doi.org/10.1161/01.STR.32.2.498.
55. Baltsavias,G.;Yella,S.;AlShameri,R.A.;Luft,A.;Valavanis,A.Intra-ArterialAdministrationofPapaverineduringMechanical
ThrombectomyforAcuteIschemicStroke.J.StrokeCerebrovasc.Dis.2015,24,41–47.
https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JSTROKECEREBROVASDIS.2014.07.052.
56. Dabus,G.;Nogueira,R.CurrentOptionsfortheManagementofAneurysmalSubarachnoidHemorrhage-InducedCerebral
Vasospasm:AComprehensiveReviewoftheLiterature.Interv.Neurol.2013,2,30–51.
57. Badjatia,N.;Topcuoglu,M.A.;Pryor,J.C.;Rabinov,J.D.;Ogilvy,C.S.;Carter,B.S.;Rordorf,G.A.PreliminaryExperiencewith
Intra-ArterialNicardipineasaTreatmentforCerebralVasospasm.Am.J.Neuroradiol.2004,25,819–826.
58. Yu,D.;Morris-Natschke,S.;Lee,K.NewDevelopmentsinNaturalProducts-basedAnti-AIDSResearch.Med.Res.Rev.2007,27,
108–132.https://doi.org/10.1002/med.20075.
59. Rima,B.;Duprex,W.MolecularMechanismsofMeaslesVirusPersistence.VirusRes.2005,111,132–147.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.virusres.2005.04.005.
60. Hudson,J.B.AntiviralCompoundsfromPlants;CRCPress:BocaRaton,FL,USA,2018;ISBN9781351078177.
61. Dereli,F.;Ilhan,M.;Belwal,T.NovelDrugTargetsWithTraditionalHerbalMedicines:ScientificandClinicalEvidence;Springer
Nature:Berlin/Heidelberg,Germany,2022.
62. Griffin,D.E.;Lin,W.H.;Pan,C.H.MeaslesVirus,ImmuneControl,andPersistence.FEMSMicrobiol.Rev.2012,36,649–662.
https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1574-6976.2012.00330.X.
Molecules2023,28,314923of22
63. Aggarwal,M.;Leser,G.P.;Lamb,R.A.RepurposingPapaverineasanAntiviralAgentagainstInfluenzaVirusesand
Paramyxoviruses.J.Virol.2020,94,e01888-19.
64. Ellinger,B.;Bojkova,D.;Zaliani,A.;Cinatl,J.;Claussen,C.;Westhaus,S.;Keminer,O.;Reinshagen,J.;Kuzikov,M.;Wolf,M.;
etal.ASARS-CoV-2CytopathicityDatasetGeneratedbyHigh-ContentScreeningofaLargeDrugRepurposingCollection.Sci.
Data2021,8,70.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-021-00848-4.
65. Pluta,R.;Hansen-Schwartz,J.;Dreier,J.;Vajkoczy,P.;Macdonald,R.;Nishizawa,S.;Kasuya,H.;Wellman,G.;Keller,E.;Zauner,
A.;etal.CerebralVasospasmFollowingSubarachnoidHemorrhage:TimeforaNewWorldofThought.Neurol.Res.2009,31,
151–158.
66. Polur,H.;Joshi,T.;Workman,C.T.;Lavekar,G.;Kouskoumvekaki,I.BacktotheRoots:PredictionofBiologicallyActiveNatural
ProductsfromAyurvedaTraditionalMedicine.Mol.Inform.2011,30,181–187.https://doi.org/10.1002/minf.201000163.
67. Choe,H.;Lee,Y.K.;Lee,Y.T.;Choe,H.;Ko,S.H.;Joo,C.U.;Kim,M.H.;Kim,G.S.;Eun,J.S.;Kim,J.H.;etal.PapaverineBlocks
HKv1.5ChannelCurrentandHumanAtrialUltrarapidDelayedRectifierK+Currents.J.Pharmacol.Exp.Ther.2003,304,706–
712.https://doi.org/10.1124/JPET.102.042770.
68. Zhou,T.;Zhu,Y.CascadeSignalsofPapaverineInhibitingLPS-InducedRetinalMicroglialActivation.J.Mol.Neurosci.2019,68,
111–119.https://doi.org/10.1007/S12031-019-01289-W/FIGURES/7.
69. Yoshikawa,M.;Suzumura,A.;Tamaru,T.;Takayanagi,T.;Sawada,M.EffectsofPhosphodiesteraseInhibitorsonCytokine
ProductionbyMicroglia.Mult.Scler.J.1999,5,126–133.https://doi.org/10.1177/135245859900500210.
70. Tamada,K.;Nakajima,S.;Ogawa,N.;Inada,M.;Shibasaki,H.;Sato,A.;Takasawa,R.;Yoshimori,A.;Suzuki,Y.;Watanabe,N.;
etal.PapaverineIdentifiedasanInhibitorofHighMobilityGroupBox1/ReceptorforAdvancedGlycationEnd-Products
InteractionSuppressesHighMobilityGroupBox1-MediatedInflammatoryResponses.Biochem.Biophys.Res.Commun.2019,
511,665–670.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbrc.2019.01.136.
71. Yamazaki,Y.;Kawano,Y.InhibitoryEffectsofHerbalAlkaloidsontheTumorNecrosisFactor-.ALPHA.andNitricOxide
ProductioninLipopolysaccharide-StimulatedRAW264Macrophages.Chem.Pharm.Bull.2011,59,388–391.
https://doi.org/10.1248/cpb.59.388.
72. Dang,Y.;Mu,Y.;Wang,K.;Xu,K.;Yang,J.;Zhu,Y.;Luo,B.PapaverineInhibitsLipopolysaccharide-InducedMicroglial
ActivationbySuppressingNF-ΚBSignalingPathway.DrugDes.Devel.Ther.2016,10,851.https://doi.org/10.2147/DDDT.S97380.
73. Gomes,D.;Joubert,A.;Visagie,M.InVitroEffectsofPapaverineonCellMigrationandVascularEndothelialGrowthFactorin
CancerCellLines.Int.J.Mol.Sci.2022,23,4654.https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms23094654.
74. Shimizu,T.;Ohta,Y.;Ozawa,H.;Matsushima,H.;Takeda,K.PapaverineCombinedwithProstaglandinE2Synergistically
InducesNeuron-likeMorphologicalChangesandDecreaseofMalignancyinHumanProstaticCancerLNCaPCells.Anticancer
Res.2000,20,761–767.
75. Huang,H.;Li,L.-J.;Zhang,H.-B.;Wei,A.-Y.PapaverineSelectivelyInhibitsHumanProstateCancerCell(PC-3)Growthby
InducingMitochondrialMediatedApoptosis,CellCycleArrestandDownregulationofNF-ΚB/PI3K/AktSignallingPathway.
J.BUON2017,22,112–118.
76. Afzali,M.;Ghaeli,P.;Khanavi,M.;Parsa,M.;Montazeri,H.;Ghahremani,M.H.;Ostad,S.N.Non-AddictiveOpiumAlkaloids
SelectivelyInduceApoptosisinCancerCellsComparedtoNormalCells.DARUJ.Pharm.Sci.2015,23,1–8.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40199-015-0101-1.
77. Sajadian,S.;Vatankhah,M.;Majdzadeh,M.;Kouhsari,S.M.;Ghahremani,M.H.;Ostad,S.N.CellCycleArrestandApoptogenic
PropertiesofOpiumAlkaloidsNoscapineandPapaverineonBreastCancerStemCells.Toxicol.Mech.Methods2015,25,388–
395.https://doi.org/10.3109/15376516.2015.1045656.
78. Noureini,S.K.;Wink,M.AntiproliferativeEffectoftheIsoquinolineAlkaloidPapaverineinHepatocarcinomaHepG-2Cells—
InhibitionofTelomeraseandInductionofSenescence.Molecules2014,19,11846–11859.
https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules190811846.
79. Hultman,K.A.;Scott,A.W.;Johnson,S.L.SmallMoleculeModifierScreenforKit-DependentFunctionsinZebrafishEmbryonic
Melanocytes.Zebrafish2008,5,279–287.https://doi.org/10.1089/zeb.2008.0542.
80. Inada,M.;Sato,A.;Shindo,M.;Yamamoto,Y.;Akasaki,Y.;Ichimura,K.;Tanuma,S.-I.AnticancerNon-NarcoticOpium
AlkaloidPapaverineSuppressesHumanGlioblastomaCellGrowth.AnticancerRes.2019,39,6743–6750.
https://doi.org/10.21873/anticanres.13889.
81. Inada,M.;Shindo,M.;Kobayashi,K.;Sato,A.;Yamamoto,Y.;Akasaki,Y.;Ichimura,K.;Tanuma,S.AnticancerEffectsofaNon-
NarcoticOpiumAlkaloidMedicine,Papaverine,inHumanGlioblastomaCells.PLoSONE2019,14,e0216358.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0216358.
82. Nohl,H.;Rohr-Udilova,N.;Gille,L.;Bieberschulte,W.;Jurek,D.;Marian,B.;Schulte-Hermann,R.Ubiquinolandthe
PapaverineDerivativeCaroverinePreventtheExpressionofTumour-PromotingFactorsinAdenomaandCarcinomaColon
CancerCellsInducedbyDietaryFat.BioFactors2005,25,87–95.https://doi.org/10.1002/biof.5520250110.
83. Rubis,B.;Kaczmarek,M.;Szymanowska,N.;Galezowska,E.;Czyrski,A.;Juskowiak,B.;Hermann,T.;Rybczynska,M.The
BiologicalActivityofG-QuadruplexDNABindingPapaverine-DerivedLigandinBreastCancerCells.Investig.NewDrugs2009,
27,289–296.https://doi.org/10.1007/s10637-008-9173-9.
84. Parcha,P.K.;Sarvagalla,S.;Ashok,C.;Sudharshan,S.J.;Dyavaiah,M.;Coumar,M.S.;Rajasekaran,B.Repositioning
AntispasmodicDrugPapaverinefortheTreatmentofChronicMyeloidLeukemia.Pharmacol.Rep.2021,73,615–628.
https://doi.org/10.1007/S43440-020-00196-X.
Molecules2023,28,314924of22
85. So,H.;Chau,C.;Chiu,W.;Ho,K.;Lo,C.;Yim,S.;Sham,P.AnalysisofGenome-WideAssociationDataHighlightsCandidates
forDrugRepositioninginPsychiatry.Nat.Neurosci.2017,20,1342–1349.
86. Siuciak,J.A.;Strick,C.A.TreatingNeuropsychiatricDisorderswithPDE10AInhibitors.DrugDiscov.TodayTher.Strateg.2006,
3,527–532.https://doi.org/10.1016/J.DDSTR.2006.10.012.
87. Gardos,G.;Granacher,R.P.;Cole,J.O.;Sniffin,C.TheEffectsofPapaverineinTardiveDyskinesia.Prog.Neuropsychopharmacol.
1979,3,543–550.https://doi.org/10.1016/0364-7722(79)90008-0.
88. El-Sayeh,H.G.;LyradaSilva,J.P.;Rathbone,J.;Soares-Weiser,K.Non-NeurolepticCatecholaminergicDrugsforNeuroleptic-
InducedTardiveDyskinesia.CochraneDatabaseSyst.Rev.2006,1.https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD000458.PUB2/ABSTRACT.
89. Soares-Weiser,K.;Rathbone,J.;Ogawa,Y.;Shinohara,K.;Bergman,H.MiscellaneousTreatmentsforAntipsychotic-Induced
TardiveDyskinesia.CochraneDatabaseSyst.Rev.2018,3.https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD000208.PUB2/ABSTRACT.
90. Itoh,K.;Ishima,T.;Kehler,J.;Hashimoto,K.PotentiationofNGF-InducedNeuriteOutgrowthinPC12CellsbyPapaverine:
RolePlayedbyPLC-γ,IP3Receptors.BrainRes.2011,1377,32–40.https://doi.org/10.1016/J.BRAINRES.2010.12.075.
91. Guan,S.;Liu,Q.;Gu,H.;Zhang,Y.;Wei,P.lu;Qi,Y.fei;Liu,J.;Wang,Z.PluripotentAnti-InflammatoryImmunomodulatory
EffectsofPapaverineagainstCerebralIschemic-ReperfusionInjury.J.Pharmacol.Sci.2020,144,69–75.
https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JPHS.2020.07.008.
92. Leem,Y.H.;Park,J.S.;Park,J.E.;Kim,D.Y.;Kim,H.S.PapaverineExertsNeuroprotectiveEffectbyInhibitingNLRP3
InflammasomeActivationinanMPTP-InducedMicroglialPrimingMouseModelChallengedwithLPS.Biomol.Ther.2021,29,
295.https://doi.org/10.4062/BIOMOLTHER.2021.039.
93. Leem,Y.H.;Park,J.S.;Park,J.E.;Kim,D.Y.;Kang,J.L.;Kim,H.S.PapaverineInhibitsα-SynucleinAggregationbyModulating
NeuroinflammationandMatrixMetalloproteinase-3ExpressionintheSubacuteMPTP/PMouseModelofParkinson’sDisease.
Biomed.Pharmacother.2020,130,110576.https://doi.org/10.1016/J.BIOPHA.2020.110576.
94. Giralt,A.;Saavedra,A.;Carretón,O.;Arumí,H.;Tyebji,S.;Alberch,J.;Pérez-Navarro,E.PDE10InhibitionIncreasesGluA1
andCREBPhosphorylationandImprovesSpatialandRecognitionMemoriesinaHuntington’sDiseaseMouseModel.
Hippocampus2013,23,684–695.https://doi.org/10.1002/HIPO.22128.
95. Otto,C.Heartbeat:ImprovingDiagnosisandManagementofAorticValveDisease.Heart2018,104,1809.
https://doi.org/10.1136/heartjnl-2018-314232.
96. Li,H.;Zhu,X.;Yao,G.;Wang,Z.PapaverineImprovesSublingualBloodFlowinPatientswithSepticShock.J.Surg.Res.2015,
195,271–276.https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JSS.2015.01.016.
97. Saravala,H.InstrumentalandAnalyticalStudyofActivePharmaceuticalIngredientsandBioActiveMolecules.Ph.D.Thesis,
SaurashtraUniversity,Rajkot,India,2011.
98. Madhu,C.;Mahavarkar,S.;Bhave,S.ARandomisedControlledStudyComparingDrotaverineHydrochlorideand
ValethamateBromideintheAugmentationofLabour.Arch.Gynecol.Obstet.2010,282,11–15.https://doi.org/10.1007/S00404-
009-1188-8/TABLES/4.
99. Gueta,I.;Braun,A.;Gilan,A.;Berlin,M.;Kohn,E.;Barchel,D.;Markovits,N.;Berkovitch,M.;Loebstein,R.PregnancyOutcomes
FollowingGestationalExposuretoPapaverine:AnObservationalComparativeStudy.Br.J.Clin.Pharmacol.2021,87,3910–3915.
https://doi.org/10.1111/BCP.14809.
100. Kublickiene,K.;Lindblom,B.;Krüger,K.;Nisell,H.Preeclampsia:EvidenceforImpairedShearStress–MediatedNitricOxide
ReleaseinUterineCirculation.Am.J.Obstet.Gynecol.2000,183,160–166.
101. Snir,N.;Moskovitz,B.;Nativ,O.;Margel,D.;Sandovski,U.;Sulkes,J.;Livne,P.M.;Lifshitz,D.A.PapaverineHydrochloride
fortheTreatmentofRenalColic:AnOldDrugRevisited.AProspective,RandomizedStudy.J.Urol.2008,179,1411–1414.
https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JURO.2007.11.053.
102. Karagoz,M.A.;Doluoglu,O.G.;Ünverdi,H.;Resorlu,B.;Sunay,M.M.;Demirbas,A.;Karakan,T.;Aydin,A.TheProtective
EffectofPapaverineandAlprostadilinRatTestesafterIschemiaandReperfusionInjury.Int.Braz.J.Urol.2018,44,617–622.
https://doi.org/10.1590/S1677-5538.IBJU.2017.0600.
103. Zhang,Z.;Tang,W.DrugMetabolisminDrugDiscoveryandDevelopment.ActaPharm.Sin.B2018,8,721–732.
104. Mohs,R.;Greig,N.DrugDiscoveryandDevelopment:RoleofBasicBiologicalResearch.Transl.Res.Clin.Interv.2017,3,651–
657.
105. Nair,A.;AlyMorsy,M.;Jacob,S.DoseTranslationbetweenLaboratoryAnimalsandHumaninPreclinicalandClinicalPhases
ofDrugDevelopment.DrugDev.Res.2018,79,373–382.https://doi.org/10.1002/ddr.21461.
106. Davison,E.K.;Brimble,M.A.NaturalProductDerivedPrivilegedScaffoldsinDrugDiscovery.Curr.Opin.Chem.Biol.2019,52,
1–8.https://doi.org/10.1016/J.CBPA.2018.12.007.
107. Yuan,H.;Ma,Q.;Cui,H.;Liu,G.;Zhao,X.;Li,W.;Piao,G.HowCanSynergismofTraditionalMedicinesBenefitfromNetwork
Pharmacology?Molecules2017,22,1135.https://doi.org/10.3390/MOLECULES22071135.
108. Gomes,D.;Joubert,A.;Visagie,M.TheBiologicalRelevanceofPapaverineinCancerCells.Cells2022,11,3385.
109. Yerevanian,A.;Soukas,A.A.Metformin:MechanismsinHumanObesityandWeightLoss.Curr.Obes.Rep.2019,8,156–164.
https://doi.org/10.1007/S13679-019-00335-3/FIGURES/1.
110. Ziqubu,K.;Mazibuko-Mbeje,S.E.;Mthembu,S.X.H.;Mabhida,S.E.;Jack,B.U.;Nyambuya,T.M.;Nkambule,B.B.;Basson,A.K.;
Tiano,L.;Dludla,P.V.Anti-ObesityEffectsofMetformin:AScopingReviewEvaluatingtheFeasibilityofBrownAdiposeTissue
asaTherapeuticTarget.Int.J.Mol.Sci.2023,24,2227.https://doi.org/10.3390/IJMS24032227/S1.
Molecules2023,28,314925of22
111. Emon,N.;Rudra,S.;Alam,S.;AlHaidar,I.;Paul,S.;Richi,F.;Shahriar,S.;Sayeed,M.;Tumpa,N.;Ganguly,A.Chemical,
BiologicalandProtein-ReceptorBindingProfilingofBauhiniaScandensL.StemsProvideNewInsightsintotheManagement
ofPain,Inflammation.Biomed.Pharmacother.2021,143,112185.
112. Ashrafi,S.;Rahman,M.;Ahmed,P.;Alam,S.;Hossain,M.A.ProspectiveAsianPlantswithCorroboratedAntiviralPotentials:
PositionStandinginRecentYears.Beni‐SuefUniv.J.BasicAppl.Sci.2022,11,1–26.https://doi.org/10.1186/S43088-022-00218-Y.
113. Choo,T.M.NigellaSativaTeaMitigatesType-2DiabetesandEdema:ACaseReport.Adv.Tradit.Med.2023,1–6.
https://doi.org/10.1007/S13596-022-00678-8.
114. Akinloye,O.A.;Sulaimon,L.A.;Ogunbiyi,O.E.;Odubiyi,A.E.;Adewale,A.A.;Toriola,M.A.;Salami,O.A.;Boyenle,I.D.
AmaranthusSpinosus(SpinyPigweed)MethanolLeafExtractAlleviatesOxidativeandInflammationInducedbyDoxorubicin
inMaleSpragueDawleyRats.Adv.Tradit.Med.2023,1–8.https://doi.org/10.1007/S13596-022-00677-9.
115. Alam,S.;Rashid,M.A.;Sarker,M.M.R.;Emon,N.U.;Arman,M.;Mohamed,I.N.;Haque,M.R.Antidiarrheal,Antimicrobialand
AntioxidantPotentialsofMethanolExtractofColocasiaGiganteaHook.f.Leaves:EvidencedfrominVivoandinVitroStudies
alongwithComputer-AidedApproaches.BMCComplement.Med.Ther.2021,21,1–12.https://doi.org/10.1186/S12906-021-03290-
6.
116. Alam,S.;Sarker,M.M.R.;Afrin,S.;Richi,F.T.;Zhao,C.;Zhou,J.R.;Mohamed,I.N.TraditionalHerbalMedicines,Bioactive
Metabolites,andPlantProductsAgainstCOVID-19:UpdateonClinicalTrialsandMechanismofActions.Front.Pharmacol.2021,
12,671498.https://doi.org/10.3389/FPHAR.2021.671498/FULL.
117. Alam,S.;Sarker,M.;Sultana,T.;Chowdhury,M.;Rashid,M.;Chaity,N.;Zhao,C.;Xiao,J.;Hafez,E.;Khan,S.;etal.Antidiabetic
PhytochemicalsfromMedicinalPlants:ProspectiveCandidatesforNewDrugDiscoveryandDevelopment.Front.Endocrinol.
2022,13,800714.
Disclaimer/Publisher’sNote:Thestatements,opinionsanddatacontainedinallpublicationsaresolelythoseoftheindividualau-
thor(s)andcontributor(s)andnotofMDPIand/ortheeditor(s).MDPIand/ortheeditor(s)disclaimresponsibilityforanyinjuryto
peopleorpropertyresultingfromanyideas,methods,instructionsorproductsreferredtointhecontent.