ArticlePDF Available

Knowledge Sharing in a Co-Opetitive Environment: The Case of Business Clusters

World Scientific
Journal of Information & Knowledge Management
Authors:
María GABRIELA Molina Molina at Universidad Técnica de Manabí (UTM)
María GABRIELA Molina Molina
Pak Yoong at Victoria University of Wellington
Pak Yoong
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

This paper reports preliminary results from a study that examines factors influencing knowledge sharing among members of business clusters based in Wellington, New Zealand. Business clusters are local concentrations of competitive firms in related industries that do business with each other. Earthquake Engineering, Creative Capital, Natural Hazards, Optics and Software are examples of clusters stu-died in this paper. However, some of the companies in many business clusters are direct competitors in the local arena and they are often expected to co-operate and share business knowledge with each other when they are considering bidding for international projects or contracts. This knowledge may be considered to have provided each company with a competitive advantage. Therefore, trying to successfully operate in this mixed environment of "co-operation" and "competition" can pose a dilemma for many members of business clusters. For this study, a three-stage data collection strategy was used: a focus group, online voting exercise and individual interviews. Representatives from seven business clusters in the Wellington region took part in this study. Analysis of the data revealed that several factors do influence knowledge sharing in business clusters, such as: sharing a common understanding and commitment to the cluster idea; initial respect and trust between cluster members; and having strong, charismatic cluster champions/leaders. These factors will be explored and the implications for practice and research will also be discussed.
Content uploaded by Pak Yoong
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Pak Yoong
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
A preview of this full-text is provided by World Scientific.
Content available from Journal of Information & Knowledge Management 
This content is subject to copyright.
... Un estudio más reciente en donde la cultura desempeña un papel importante en la constitución y funcionamiento de redes empresariales de cooperación es el realizado por Molina (2003). Utilizando tres métodos de investigación (grupos focales, ejercicios de voto en línea y entrevistas individuales) en siete clusters 6 representativos de la región de Wellington, Nueva Zelanda -en donde algunas de las compañías en gran cantidad de clusters son competidores locales directos que a menudo están a la expectativa para cooperar y compartir conocimiento empresarial, cuando consideran la posibilidad de ofrecer proyectos o contratos internacionales-, encontró que existe una serie de factores de influencia sobre el conocimiento compartido, tales como: el compartir entendimiento y compromiso hacia la idea del cluster; respeto y confianza entre los miembros; un fuerte carisma por parte de los líderes; frecuente interac-5 La cultura nacional es un conjunto de valores, actitudes, ideas y normas que comparte la mayoría de los habitantes de un país. ...
... Estos atributos, al igual que la capacidad innovadora y de adaptación contextual incluidos en la esfera de la equidad propuesta por Throsby (2001), implican la existencia de rasgos de personalidad empresarial, derivados de los elementos culturales que fungen como facilitadores para la construcción de esquemas de cooperación de carácter informal y, por tanto, con un coste mínimo de reproducción y mantenimiento, en donde cada integrante obtiene beneficios con un grado de seguridad razonable sobre el comportamiento de los otros (Molina, 2003). ...
Factores subyacentes de cultura y personalidad empresarial que influyen en la intención de invertir
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2018
El objetivo del trabajo es hacer una caracterización de la personalidad empresarial de los inversionistas que operan en la región Centro-Occidente de México. A diferencia de la gran mayoría de trabajos que existen sobre este tema, la caracterización se hace desde la perspectiva de la Psicología Económica, que incorpora elementos de carácter psicológico a partir de rasgos de cultura y personalidad. Este estudio tiene implicaciones importantes porque permitirá identificar factores subyacentes a la toma de decisiones en la intención de invertir.
View
... The knowledge spillover resulting from being part of a manufacturing cluster makes it feasible for small¯rms to acquire knowledge about intricacies of the business, about new products and new manufacturing techniques that may not be possible to be acquired that easily through market forces. Some of the¯rms in clusters though are competitors in local market and they may be required to cooperate and share business knowledge while bidding for international projects or contracts (Molina and Yoong, 2003). Therefore, trying to successfully operate in this mixed environment of \co-operation" and \competition" can pose a dilemma for many members of business clusters. ...
Impact of Knowledge Management Processes for Sustainability of Small Family Businesses: Evidences from the Brassware Sector of Moradabad (India)
Article
Full-text available
In this research paper, we have studied the role and process of knowledge management in small family businesses at different stages of its growth: startup, business consolidation and succession. We intend to study if in family run MSME clusters education of firm owner gives any edge in the sustainability of the business. There is lack of availability of literature on study of Indian MSME with family business perspective. Our study encompasses factors that stimulate innovation, technology acquisition and business growth and sustainability. Evidences have been drawn from brass manufacturing cluster of Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh, India. The research is based on cross-case analysis of six brassware manufacturing units of Moradabad. We attempted to build on existing literature reviews on knowledge management process in family firms and assess how these theories fit in case of small family run export oriented enterprises, which are highly competitive. It was found family relationship, attitude to learn, critical thinking and social capital are keys in determining sustainability of these firms. A theoretical model has been curved out of the study.
View
... Redes sociais é um assunto discutido com frequência em estudos organizacionais (GIGLIO; HERNANDEZ, 2012). Os temas abordados incluem, por exemplo, assimetria de informação (BERTOLIN; SANTOS; LIMA; BRAGA, 2008), fluxos de informação (Molina & Yoong, 2003), governança e poder (LARSON, 1992). A perspectiva das redes sociais já se mostra relevante para o estudo das organizações há décadas, pois é cada vez mais aceito na comunidade acadêmica que todas as organizações estão inseridas em importantes aspectos de redes sociais e precisam ser abordadas e analisadas como tal (NOHRIA, 1992). ...
UMA NOVA DANÇA DAS CADEIRAS: COMO A FORMALIDADE E INFORMALIDADE DA REDE MUDAM A POSIÇÃO DOS ATORES CENTRAIS EM REDES INTRAORGANIZACIONAIS
Article
Full-text available
  • Oct 2015
Neste trabalho buscamos identificar como formalidade e informalidade da rede muda a posição dos atores centrais em uma rede intraorganizacional. Formalidade em nosso estudo abrange desde a necessidade de aprovações formais entre os membros da gerência e direção da empresa às comunicações relativas ao trabalho entre todos os colaboradores da organização. Realizamos a pesquisa empírica em um grupo do setor de treinamento e desenvolvimento de pessoas, este grupo tem mais de 50 anos e 106 colaboradores. Além disso, possui escritórios em São Paulo, Brasília, Porto Alegre e Rio de Janeiro. Com base em questionários aplicados construímos quatro redes da empresa estudada. Ao analisar estas redes percebemos que os atores centrais mudavam conforme o grau de formalidade da rede, embora isto não acontecesse de forma tão sensível em relação ao seu formato e os atores periféricos. Deste modo, nosso trabalho contribuiu para a teoria ao mostrar as possibilidades que se abrem aos gestores ao analisar as redes informais e, por outro lado, permite que os funcionários que ocupam as posições mais rasas na hierarquia da empresa ganhem espaço ao ocupar o centro da rede informal. Palavras-chave: Redes intraorganizacionais. Centros e periferias de redes. Redes Formais. Redes Informais.
View
... This is conceded through an analytical approach with respect to cluster theory. Molina and Yoong (2003) investigate the knowledge sharing parameter of industrial clusters, to extract a favourable condition of symbiotic and synergistic strategies from at first conflicting interests as well as the impact of shared culture and effective leadership. Skokan and Zotyková (2014) investigate industrial clusters from a business lifecycle perspective, with respect to performance indicators. ...
A Hybrid SWOT Analysis Methodology for Maritime Clusters
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Aug 2015
Agglomeration economies do present themselves as a vessel of strategic competitiveness, for they hold many factors that may render them as the backbone of a propitious niche; their analytical potential surfaces as a very inviting eventuality for strategic management. It would not be out of place to conjecture that a SWOT analysis venture could be proposed whence analyzing these particular economies, for said instrument harbors a methodology that appertains to couplings of conflicting parameters, striking a balance between scientific validity and inclusive practical coherence and materiality. Whilst adhering to this benchmark, this work proposes a novel methodology with respect to SWOT analysis that originates from a critical review of strategic factors concerning maritime clusters and the extraction of an inventory compiled from said review. From this inventory a contingency table is constructed and pertinent statistics calculated. Through this methodology, analytics can be generated and utilized with respect to maritime cluster strategic analysis; by extension, effective policy and/or strategy formulation may be fabricated. In addition, the methodology of inventory formulation and crosstabulation can be applied in other cases of study, thus expanding the scope and applicability of said SWOT analysis.
View
Rethinking cluster under coopetition strategy: an integrative literature review and research agenda
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2024
This study aimed to integrate the dimensions and elements of intra-cluster coopetition, identify the emergence of a complementary theoretical perspective to cluster theory and create an integrative research agenda to support the rethinking cluster approach based on coopetition. It is an integrative Systematic Literature Review that generates insights to move the topic forward. Results showed coopetition as context, process, or outcome. The research focus was grouped into six dimensions of intra-cluster coopetition: Strategic Adjustment, Perceived Benefits, Mediated Coopetition, Social Interaction, Coopetitive Orientation, and Temporality of Coopetition. Four hundred eighty-six elements used by scholars created a second-order coding to represent the variables of coopetition in clusters. From the integrative literature overview, a theoretical framework emerges with four dimensions: Conditional factors, Policies, Market commonality, and Formal supporting structure. These dimensions act as drivers, markets, or intensifiers of the intra-cluster coopetition strategy. At the same time, the dimensions suffer the influence of external, internal, and ecosystem contexts. Our literature review builds theory to advance cluster coopetition research and complement the Porterian perspective. The framework suggests the main elements to manage clusters under the coopetition strategy. These findings rethink cluster theory and deliver the business co-evolution perspective, considering the cluster as a business ecosystem with an open system based on coopetition. Findings offer an inductive-deductive pattern system to further research that represents the evolutionary trend of the topic itself.
View
View
View
Online Networks can Support the Rise of Virtual Leaders
Chapter
  • Jan 2010
The actor network theory (ANT) as first proponed by Latour (1984) describes the emergence of socio-technical systems through interaction patterns between network participants as a means of harnessing technological and human factors. This research extended ANT to investigate how self-selected leaders spontaneously emerged in a virtual environment, using the online medium to gain legitimacy and coverage. Thematic analysis of online postings and interviews outlined how participants: 1) tested and developed virtual leadership competencies for the first time; 2) seized the opportunity to raise their personal profile even when geographically isolated; 3) made purposeful process and content contributions and; 4) developed online networking competencies. Since emergent leadership is simultaneously enabling of and enabled by acts of virtual communication, it is important for organisations to learn to identify virtual leaders. Virtual leaders may rise and contribute to the organisation through communication channels other than those typically used by conventional leaders – hence potentially requiring a different set of communication and network building skills.
View
Mapping micro small and medium enterprises from the resource-based view and dynamic capability theory perspectives and innovation classification
Article
  • Jan 2015
The concept of resource-based view (RBV) and dynamic capabilities theory (DCT) and its role in generation of competitive advantage (CA) and securing sustainable competitive advantage (SCA) had been endorsed in literature. In this research, the authors have analysed and mapped Indian MSMEs from the RBV and DCT perspectives for understanding their position for innovation, cluster functionality and cluster activities. Qualitative research was carried by in-depth interview personally administered with MSME owners and senior managers. The data collected was thematically content analysed. The findings of the study reflected on the type of RENT innovation done by Indian MSMEs, state of the MSME cluster layer and its activity types. Further, this research also classified the MSME firms from a RBV typology. This study was carried out in central India. This research confirmed the theoretical footprints of presence of three cluster layers, six collaborative activities, RBV and DCV and kind of RENT innovation.
View
Opportunities and the spread of information and communication technologies: evidence from the Indian clusters of small- and medium-sized enterprises
Article
  • Jan 2008
The wide spread of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) characterising the recent competitive scenario is giving rise to the great interest of researchers and practitioners. Many studies are addressed to give answers to different questions concerning, for example, the impact of ICTs on organisations, the role of ICTs in economic development, the opportunities given by ICT adoption in Small- and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) and its performance measurement. In this paper, the opportunities provided by the adoption and implementation of ICT solutions in a particular SME-intensive productive environment, the geographical cluster, are examined. To this end, first, the ICT capabilities and their effects on the value-creating processes characterising a generic supply chain are analysed. Successively, the analysis is contextualised to the geographical clusters in order to identify the more appropriate ICTs for the clusters of SMEs. Finally, the actual ICTs' spread within the Indian clusters of SMEs is examined.
View
View
View
View
Endogenous Technological Change
Article
  • Oct 1990
Growth in this model is driven by technological change that arises from intentional investment decisions made by profit-maximizing agents. The distinguishing feature of the technology as an input is that it is neither a conventional good nor a public good; it is a nonrival, partially excludable good. Because of the nonconvexity introduced by a nonrival good, price-taking competition cannot be supported. Instead, the equilibrium is one with monopolistic competition. The main conclusions are that the stock of human capital determines the rate of growth, that too little human capital is devoted to research in equilibrium, that integration into world markets will increase growth rates, and that having a large population is not sufficient to generate growth.
View
The Competitive Advantage Of Nations
Book
  • Oct 1990
  • HARVARD BUS REV
With the publication of his best-selling books "Competitive Strategy (1980) and "Competitive Advantage (1985), Michael E. Porter of the Harvard Business School established himself as the world's leading authority on competitive advantage. Now, at a time when economic performance rather than military might will be the index of national strength, Porter builds on the seminal ideas of his earlier works to explore what makes a nation's firms and industries competitive in global markets and propels a whole nation's economy. In so doing, he presents a brilliant new paradigm which, in addition to its practical applications, may well supplant the 200-year-old concept of "comparative advantage" in economic analysis of international competitiveness. To write this important new work, Porter and his associates conducted in-country research in ten leading nations, closely studying the patterns of industry success as well as the company strategies and national policies that achieved it. The nations are Britain, Denmark, Germany, Italy, Japan, Korea, Singapore, Sweden, Switzerland, and the United States. The three leading industrial powers are included, as well as other nations intentionally varied in size, government policy toward industry, social philosophy, and geography. Porter's research identifies the fundamental determinants of national competitive advantage in an industry, and how they work together as a system. He explains the important phenomenon of "clustering," in which related groups of successful firms and industries emerge in one nation to gain leading positions in the world market. Among the over 100 industries examined are the German chemical and printing industries, Swisstextile equipment and pharmaceuticals, Swedish mining equipment and truck manufacturing, Italian fabric and home appliances, and American computer software and movies. Building on his theory of national advantage in industries and clusters, Porter identifies the stages of competitive development through which entire national economies advance and decline. Porter's finding are rich in implications for both firms and governments. He describes how a company can tap and extend its nation's advantages in international competition. He provides a blueprint for government policy to enhance national competitive advantage and also outlines the agendas in the years ahead for the nations studied. This is a work which will become the standard for all further discussions of global competition and the sources of the new wealth of nations.
View
View
The Added Value of the Industry Cluster Approach to Economic Analysis, Strategy Development, and Service Delivery
Article
  • Feb 2000
Economic development always has been a moving target. Not surprisingly, there is growing evidence that the shape of economic policy and practice is changing significantly in many American states on the eve of the 21st century. This new approach has public officials addressing new issues, using new tools, and beginning to experience new types of results. It is called cluster-based economic analysis and strategy development. This article reviews key literature and events that point to a new phase emerging in state economic development. Then, using Arizona as a case study, it presents practical evidence of the benefits from this new approach. For example, Arizona uses clusters as a tool for better understanding the economy, getting key industry stakeholders together to address common problems, and providing high-value specialized services to key industries.
View
View
View
How Does Knowledge Flow? Inter-firm Patterns in the Semiconductor Industry
Article
  • Dec 1996
Although knowledge spillovers between firms play a critical role in the evolution of technology, we know little about such spillovers. How does knowledge flow across company boundaries? How do industry characteristics and national institutions shape knowledge diffusion? To what extent do companies direct knowledge flows? This study seeks answers to these questions by examining knowledge sharing patterns in the semiconductor industry. The research shows that public sources of technical data play a larger role in knowledge diffusion in Japan than in the United States and in semiconductors relative to steel. By understanding the mechanisms and determinants of knowledge flows, company managers and public policy makers can influence knowledge diffusion more effectively.
View