ArticlePDF Available

The Biology of Culpability:: Pathological Identity and Crime Control in a Biological Culture

February 2000
Theoretical Criminology 4(1):5-34

February 2000
4(1):5-34

Authors:

University College London

This article considers the impact of the new biological criminology on control strategies. Biocriminology does not purport to have a general explanation for crime, but draws upon contemporary human genetics and neurobiology to account for what is represented as a growing social problem of violent and anti-social conduct. Jurisprudential notions of free will and responsibility are not being displaced by genetic essentialism in the courtroom, where the tendency is for an increased emphasis upon moral responsibility of all offenders for their actions. However, in other areas of the criminal justice system, we are seeing the emergence of new conceptions of the individual `genetically at risk' of offending, and the development of crime prevention strategies based upon a rationale of public health. This is not a new eugenics, but a control strategy that aims to identify, treat and control individuals predisposed to impulsive or aggressive conduct. The implications of the new biological criminology may be seen in the form of genetic discrimination, genetic screening in risk assessments and the use of quasi-consensual `treatment' for supposed biological tendencies, as conditions for a non-custodial sentence, loss of employment or denial of insurance or other benefits. The search for biological dispositions may also play a part in the increased use of preventive detention and other pre-emptive interventions for `the protection of the public' against those whose conduct seems to show wanton disregard for the moral constraints on the conduct of free individuals in a liberal society.

Content uploaded by Nikolas Rose

Content may be subject to copyright.

http://tcr.sagepub.com

Theoretical Criminology

DOI: 10.1177/1362480600004001001

2000; 4; 5 Theoretical Criminology

NIKOLAS ROSE

in a Biological Culture

The Biology of Culpability:: Pathological Identity and Crime Control

http://tcr.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/4/1/5

The online version of this article can be found at:

Published by:

http://www.sagepublications.com

can be found at:Theoretical Criminology Additional services and information for

http://tcr.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Email Alerts:

http://tcr.sagepub.com/subscriptions Subscriptions:

http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navReprints:

http://www.sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.navPermissions:

http://tcr.sagepub.com/cgi/content/refs/4/1/5 Citations

at SAGE Publications on December 16, 2009 http://tcr.sagepub.comDownloaded from

CORPOS RELACIONAIS, «BIOFAMÍLIA» E SUSPEIÇÃO POR ASSOCIAÇÃO: O CASO DA PESQUISA FAMILIAR EM GENÉTICA FORENSE

Chapter

Full-text available

Aug 2021

Biology and Criminology: Data Practices and the Creation of Anatomic and Genomic Body ‘Types’

Article

Full-text available

Oct 2023
Crit Criminol

The use of biometrics for the creation of visual ‘body types’ needs continued criminological engagement. This article discusses Lombroso’s practice of typing ‘born criminals’ vis-à-vis genomic phenotyping used to identify potential suspects. Both are prevalent examples of scientizing police and legal work. While Lombroso draws on anatomy to explain causes of criminal behavior, phenotyping is based on genomic and physiognomic correlation to help identify suspects. Despite these differences, both forms of visualizing bodies, we argue, are also a practice of marking. Especially in the context of crime and crime control, marking is a sensitive and political practice. Since typing is embedded in criminology, our analysis is also a critical engagement with criminology itself.

Psychedelics and Desistance From Crime: Lessons From the Concord Prison Experiment

Article

Full-text available

Nov 2022

Logan Neitzke-Spruill

Recent investigations of naturalistic psychedelic use purport that psychedelic therapies may be useful in criminal justice contexts for reducing recidivism. The present study applies interactionist theories of desistance to critically explore how psychedelic therapies could facilitate agentic self-transformation to support desistance from crime. Psychedelic experience reports written by inmates as part of the “Concord Prison Experiment” (CPE) were collected from the New York Public Library. Reports from 29 participants were then analyzed using a qualitative content analysis that employed both conventional and directed approaches. Participants frequently reported on changes in emotion and sense perception, interactions with other participants, and self-knowledge. Reports of self-knowledge often emerged from cognitive shifts that led to reflexive thought and novel insights regarding crime and criminality. These findings demonstrate how psychedelics can facilitate cognitive shifts in meaning conducive to inspiring desistance from crime. However, shortcomings of the CPE indicate that the social environment can hinder integration, by constraining the potential to enact changes in one’s life or realize meaningful insights through prosocial relationships. The combination of potentially harmful prison environments and the vulnerable states of consciousness generated by psychedelics should preclude investigations among actively incarcerated participants. Without addressing common social and structural barriers to successful reentry such as housing and employment, the efficacy of psychedelic-assisted therapy as a recidivism reducing intervention will be limited. Alternative approaches might explore how psychedelic therapy can address the psychological impacts of incarceration.

Genetic Surveillance and Crime Control: Social, Cultural, and Political Perspectives

Book

Full-text available

Oct 2021

Genetic Surveillance and Crime Control presents a new empirical and conceptual framework for understanding trends of genetic surveillance in different countries in Europe and in other jurisdictions around the world. The use of DNA or genome for state-level surveillance for crime governance is becoming the norm in democratic societies. In the post-DNA, contemporary modes of criminal identification are gradually changing through the increasing expansion of transnational sharing of DNA data, along with the development of highly controversial genetic technologies that pose acute challenges to privacy and generate fears of discrimination, racism and stigmatization. Some questions that guide this book are: How is genetic surveillance in the governance of crime intertwined with society, ethics, culture, and politics? What are the views and expectations of diverse stakeholders -scientists, police agencies, and non-governmental organizations? How can social sciences research about genetic surveillance accommodate socio-cultural and historical differences, and be sensitive to specificities of post-authoritarian societies in Europe? Taking an interdisciplinary approach focused on challenges to genetic privacy, human rights and citizenship in contemporary societies , this book will be of interest to students and scholars of social studies of science and technology, sociology, criminology, law and policing, international relations and forensic sciences.

Фронтир биологии и горизонты юриспруденции: влияние исследования природы человеческой агрессии на развитие уголовной юстиции

Article

Mar 2024

Dmitry Vadimovich Bakharev

Стремительный рывок, произошедший за последние десятилетия в области нейробиологии и молекулярной генетики, актуализировал проблему познания нейронных и генетических основ социально значимого поведения. В результате все больше ученых в области социальных и поведенческих наук начинает проявлять интерес к подобным исследованиям с целью сверки и корректировки результатов своих работ в данном направлении. Юриспруденция и в первую очередь уголовно-правовые науки, не являются в данном случае исключением. В кругу их специалистов уже давно циркулирует мнение о том, что методики исследований, реализуемые в науках естественно-научного цикла, и добываемые посредством их данные имеет смысл последовательно внедрять в практику правоохранительной деятельности. В статье содержатся результаты анализа ключевых тенденций в области использования нейробиологической и генетической информации в рамках уголовного судопроизводства США по делам о тяжких насильственных преступлениях. К ним следует отнести: последовательный рост числа рассматриваемых уголовных дел, включающих данные нейробиологических исследований; отсутствие у нейробиологических доказательств постоянного «смягчающего» эффекта; более благожелательное восприятие судом и присяжными нейроданных, представляемых стороной защиты по делам о преступлениях несовершеннолетних; увеличение доли апелляционных жалоб обвиняемых на игнорирование либо неэффективное использование их защитниками нейробиологической информации (в рамках «стандарта Стрикленда») и при этом непропорционально большой процент их удовлетворения; фактическое требование судом от адвокатов постоянного мониторинга новейших исследований в данной области, при одновременном применении аналогичного стандарта качества профессиональной деятельности и по отношению к самому себе. Отмечая расхождение этих правоприменительных тенденций с положениями традиционных социологических теорий, объясняющих природу происхождения социальных девиаций, автор формулирует ряд полемических тезисов, научное и практическое обсуждение которых, по его мнению, способно определить перспективы использования достижений биологической науки для развития отечественной сферы уголовной юстиции.

(Ir-)Responsibilisierung, Genetik und Neurowissenschaften

Chapter

Feb 2024

Thomas Biebricher

Drogas de Desempenho: a Ritalina e o transtorno do déficit de atenção/hiperatividade (TDAH)

Chapter

Jan 2012

Luciana Caliman

Psicólogos, enfermeiros, assistentes sociais, médicos, terapeutas ocupacionais, nutricionistas: ao todo, 28 autores com variados perfis e experiências produziram os 16 capítulos deste livro, cujas análises, muitas vezes, põem em xeque o senso comum. “Senso comum que insiste em tingir com alarmismo apocalíptico as drogas, investindo-as de um caráter metafísico maléfico que estão longe de possuir”, escreve o médico psiquiatra e doutor em saúde pública Sergio Alarcon, organizador da coletânea juntamente com o também médico psiquiatra e doutor em saúde pública Marco Aurélio Soares Jorge. O livro é resultado do Curso de Atualização para a Atenção ao Uso Abusivo de Álcool e Outras Drogas, oferecido anualmente pela Escola Politécnica da Fiocruz. Contudo, a obra se dirige não só aos trabalhadores da saúde e da saúde mental, mas a qualquer pessoa interessada pelo assunto: afinal, as drogas, por seu crescente consumo e pelas tentativas frustradas de combatê-lo, ocupam hoje o centro das preocupações da sociedade.

The War on Terror and the Normalisation of Urban Security

Book

Sep 2021

Jon Coaffee

Crime e tecnologia: desafios culturais e políticos para a Europa

Book

Full-text available

Aug 2021

Este livro aborda as relações entre ciência, cultura e política a partir do olhar sociológico sobre as implicações societais e éticas da presença da genética forense na prevenção da criminalidade e terrorismo na União Europeia. As contingências, controvérsias e expectativas dirigidas à genética forense num contexto híbrido, em que se cruzam agendas securitárias dos Estados-Nação e práticas de cientistas, de agentes policiais e mensagens dos meios de comunicação social, são retratadas neste livro coletivo em jeito de diagnóstico das turbulências com que se confronta a ciência quando é convocada para fora do seu habitat tradicional. O ponto nevrálgico desta obra é a análise da dimensão pública da genética forense quando este domínio de saber científico, sob a égide da neutralidade, é convocado para produzir conhecimento que possa ser prático e útil na identificação criminal. No contexto de uma sociedade rendida à aura simbólica da genética e à vertente benéfica da ciência no contributo para a proteção e segurança da sociedade, esta obra assume a função de desconstruir a dimensão distópica da ciência associada a processos de vigilância estatal e policial, que ameaçam liberdades civis e sujeitam populações vulneráveis a processos insidiosos de racismo, discriminação e estigmatização.

Automation, Knowledge, and Power: How Does Automation Change Social Control and the Balance of Power?

Chapter

Aug 2021

The chapter’s central thesis is that the use of automation tools in social control and politics, erodes some of the basic concepts of the rule of law and changes the knowledge that counts as relevant for policymakers. The authors provide a historical overview of how both the theory and practice of crime and social control have relied on contemporary developments in science, be it psychology, biology, or artificial intelligence. They show how the contemporary attempts at objectification and reliance on novel emerging types of knowledge and tools—“data science”, big data, and AI—are nothing but a persistent feature of the “criminological endeavour”. Reliance on science offers those exerting social control a useful way to objectivise their goals and actions. The chapter then narrows down its focus and examines how, today, a mathematics and “data science” have come to be regarded as the most “objective” and “value-free” knowledge that can inform and legitimise interventions in social control and democratic political realm. In the last part, the chapter focuses on the domain of elections and shows how political groups have been able to rely on high-tech automation tools both online and in the real world, which has enabled them to pick their voters and not vice versa. The authors conclude that a sceptical and critical analysis of so-called intelligent solutions used in social control domain and democratic processes, such as elections, is required lest we risk further disintegration of fundamental cornerstones of liberal democracies.

.Genetic linkage between X chromosome markers and bipolar affective illness

Article

Full-text available

Mar 1987
NATURE

A pedigree study shows close linkage of bipolar affective illness (manic depression) to the X-chromosome markers colour blindness and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency. The maximum lod score ranges from 7.52 (assuming homogeneity) to 9.17 (assuming heterogeneity); that is, the odds in favour of linkage range between 3 X 10(7) to 1 and 10(9) to 1. These results provide confirmation that a major psychiatric disorder can be caused by a single genetic defect. As a possible first step in characterizing the primary genetic abnormality, this finding may have important implications for the aetiology, nosology, pathophysiology and, possibly, prevention and treatment of bipolar affective disorder. It also provides a means for identifying and characterizing homogeneous populations of patients and may help in clarifying aetiological heterogeneity.

News from the field

Article

Sep 1996
PSYCHIAT GENET

Reflections on Wye Woods: Crime, Biology, and Self-Interest

Article

Mar 1996

Evan Balaban

Reflections on Wye Woods: Crime, Biology, and Self-Interest - Volume 15 Issue 1 - Evan Balaban

Heredity versus environment: A reconsideration of charles goring's THE english CONVICT (1913)

Article

Jun 1988

Piers Beirne

In the history of criminology few texts have commanded such gargantuan esteem as Charles Goring's The English Convict (1913). This paper examines the influence on Goring's text of the British movements in statistics and eugenics, and in so doing reconsiders the merits of his critical engagement with Lombrosianism. It is suggested that Goring's labours must be considered a partial failure. In refuting certain aspects of the notion of "born criminality", and in lending support to others, The English Convict advanced an ambiguous position not in opposition to Lombrosianism but in parallel to it. © 1988 The Institute for the Study and Treatment of Delinquency.

Mental deficiency and crime

Article

E.H. Sutherland

Allelic Association of Human Dopamine D2 Receptor Gene in Alcoholism

Article

Apr 1990

Kenneth Blum

In a blinded experiment, we report the first allelic association of the dopamine D2 receptor gene in alcoholism. From 70 brain samples of alcoholics and nonalcoholics, DNA was digested with restriction endonucleases and probed with a clone that contained the entire 3' coding exon, the polyadenylation signal, and approximately 16.4 kilobases of noncoding 3' sequence of the human dopamine D2 receptor gene (λhD2G1). In the present samples, the presence of A1 allele of the dopamine D2 receptor gene correctly classified 77% of alcoholics, and its absence classified 72% of nonalcoholics. The polymorphic pattern of this receptor gene suggests that a gene that confers susceptibility to at least one form of alcoholism is located on the q22-q23 region of chromosome 11.

Sexual Violence, Victim Advocacy, and Republican Criminology: Washington State's Community Protection Act

Article

Jan 1994

This article focuses on the Community Protection Act (CPA), the State of Washington's legislative effort to control sexual violence, and on the victim advocacy groups that played a prominent role in this effort. It is argued by some, most recently by republican criminologists, that victim advocates serve democratic ideals and introduce into criminal process important values and interests that are neglected by professionals. Others argue that victim advocacy tends to promote punitive policies that empower the state, jeopardize constitutional rights, and divert attention from causes to symptoms. The evidence gathered in this research lends credence to the critics of republican criminology. Victim advocates were not reliable carriers of republican values in their strenuous support of the CPA, the central provisions of which reduce civil liberties and promote exclusion rather than reintegration.

Forensic Science and Expert Evidence

Article

Mar 1994

Peter Alldridge

The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice was set up in order to investigate a very serious series of cases in which terrible miscarriages of justice had been exposed. In some of those cases (notably Ward,' Maguire,2 and McIlkenny3), the evidence upon which the convictions had been obtained was that of forensic scientists. In the Birmingham Six case, the questioning which led to the confessions and alleged confessions did not begin until the police officers concerned had been convinced by the forensic scientist that the men were guilty. This is slightly unusual in that the more 'standard' deployment of scientific evidence is that the police will formulate a view as to who it is that is guilty and then generate scientific evidence to support that hypothesis: it is much less common for scientific evidence to lead to persons who were hitherto unsuspected.4 Yet, few of the 352 recommendations which the Royal Commission produced could conceivably be interpreted as being ones which would do anything about miscarriages of justice. The major recommendation, so far as concerns forensic science, is for the establishment of a body concerned with its oversight, and many substantive problems are postponed pending enquiry by that body. The guiding precept does appear to be one of efficiency, and the majority of proposals are claimed to be neutral as between prosecution and defence.5 The report gives the impression that the recommendations were 352 responses to individual problems - isolated dooms which have little or nothing to do one with one another. That is not to claim that they are internally inconsistent, simply that they do not flow

Throwing Down the Gauntlet: A Challenge to the Relevance of Sociology for the Etiology of Criminal Behavior

Article

Mar 1987

The Genetics of Manic Depressive Illness

Article

Oct 1989

Miron Baron

The Biology of Culpability:: Pathological Identity and Crime Control in a Biological Culture

Abstract

Recommended publications

Nacionalinės kriminologinės informacinės sistemos modelis, daktaro disertacijos santrauka

Crime and Security in Asia: Diversity and Development

The Division of Labour in Crime Prevention: Crime Science, Criminology and Criminal Justice

Preventing crime: What works, what doesn't, what's promising: A report to the United States Congress